The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About02 Certificates of AppropriatenessITEM #2 ,--_ KY p•!1 __.~_~- DATE: JUNE 23, 2009 ~ ~ t ~ (' - C O rp ~~~5~~ , TO: PLANNING COMMISSION FROM: COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT SUBJECT: CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS REPORT Attached for the Planning Commission's information are copies of Certificates of Appropriateness, indicating the addresses and types of Old Town projects approved by the Community Development Department from December 9, 2008, through June 23, 2009. Elizabeth A. Binsack Community Development Director S:\Cdd\PCREPORl12008\CertificateApp 6-23-09.doc Community Develop .Went Department CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS MAY S, 2008 560 EL CAMINO REAL TUSTIN HIS f~l RY BUILDING OUR FUTURE HONORING OUR PAST PROPOSAL: The property is improved with a "C" rated Industrial style structure per the Tustin Historical Resources Survey. The proposed project involves the installation of two (2) blade signs on the exterior of the building, in compliance with City Council Resolution No. 09-15. In accordance with Ordinance No. 1001 which was adopted June 20, 1988, by the Tustin City Council, the Community Development Director has the authority to approve, approve with conditions, or deny Certificates of Appropriateness for improvements requiring a City building permit for property located within a Cultural Resource District. The Community Development Department finds and determines as follows: A. The proposed work will not detrimentally alter, destroy or adversely affect the structure in that the signs are designed in a style that is compatible with the industrial style of the building and will be installed so that they could be removed in the future without altering the structure of the building. B. The proposed work does not adversely affect the character of the District or Designated Guttural Resources within the District in that the signs are designed to complement the building and are similar to signs historically seen within the Cultural Resources District. C. The proposed modifications will retain the essential elements which make the structure culturally significant in that the proposed signs are an addi'tfon to the exterior of the building and do not after the appearance of the building other than through the addition of the two blade signs. The proposed work is hereby approved, subject to the following conditions: 1. Prior to the start of any work, the applicant shall obtain any applicable building, electrical, or other necessary permits and pay all applicable plan check and permit fees. 2. Replacement or repair of any part of the existing structure shall match the existing exterior materials, finish, and colors of the existing structure. 3. The property shall be subject to final building inspection to ensure consistency with plans approved and on file with the Ciiy. `~ Elizabeth A. Binsack Community Development Director S ~Cdd\Can\Cullural Resources, Old Town~Certficale o-Appropriateriess1580 dCamino Real.doC ~(lU C.entennial Way, Tustin, C.A')27RU • I' f71-~) 573-3I11O • F: (i 14) 573-3113 • wwwtustinca.urg r~. ~~ to r~ ~~~ ~~~, ~f -~• r :,:: } ~ - ! ~~ r..., r... 00 - f~i - d t ~~;~•.. -g g r r .. ~`~' ~~` E ~; _. .~ _~ ~~~~ ; r _ ~ --_ __ __ a 0 a o~ = U d ~ W ~ ~r 0 z Z 0 W a ~¢ U O ~ O Z ,----- - ~ c °` qqq~~~~ $ E ~ ~g ~ ~Sd 9~~~8 ~A :u o~ g z ~ NXS~.~~ ~y~~ OS n~m~~~`~~o ~' s ~- ~~ ~ .~ ~~~ n~~ ~~~~~.~ ~ 0 ~ ~ ~~ ~a o ~ ~ ~ °~° ~ ~ ~ g ° # L a m a S Y I ~ y ~ 9 ~~g~~~ ~~~ ~~~ Asa '~~~~~~~ ~~~ ~a m _ m c aZ ~~ ~o Z O ~w Q ~ a ~- z w U U Q U 4 ~ W ~ H W J (OJ ~ Q i ~ ~ ~~" J L u7~Jd OB JY . J Q ~ O N ~ a m ~ zz N ~ ~ a~o ~ Q Q Z O _~ J ~S a ~ W F ~ ~ ~ = f n M m 6. Z d~ ~ - Q' N ~..~` r ] ~, z m J ~ ~ } Q wad ~v ~~N ~~ v ~ ~ a w Z o j 1~`. ~ ~~ ~ ~ - J 1-- U C1 . ' ~ \ ~_ .. W E- W 7i o ~+ o 4 0 (V W i w ~m W 7 F- ~ CJ Z wv>Duv~, fV jmN ~ ~ p ~ ~ ~ ~ d r _ 1 ~ ti j "- LLZ °w z ~ ~ m ~ ? J ~ ~ ¢ d °~a ~ Sa D ~ m . ~"~Z WS`d ~N y~ r z - -9Z~~ ~ ~ ~a o~~ >~a ~~~ ~~~ '~ O ~ ~ R ~ n c LL ~ ~ m oh O d A O ~ ~ ~ m D L T m S 'a m 7 c ~~ ~~ ~~ ~~~~~ ~~~88 '~~~~~~ ~ ~ ~~3~g~ Q `v Q ~ ~. = Z 1 ~~ ~o ~. a Q ~ w ~~ - a <~ ,i . s a ~~ J WSd - -9Z~~ ~ ~ . 0•.9 .vn a-,~ __ T ~ a ~ t~ s ~mc g H &~ w ` ~ ~c"i ~o ~ g 7 ~~~ ~ ~ ~ o ~~ a~~ oo"~4t4 Z =U' z~m ~& ~ LL~ ~m ~~ `d ~7a 2 0 ~ ~ w ~ -a ~ ~ ~ ~ rn ~ ~g R z o U ~ U K W .U Lt ~ K y F O 2 a ~ ~ ~ ~ 3 ~~ ~~ ~ ~' a ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~~ ° ~ a ~ ~ S ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~LL ~ _ ~ $ ff ~ e aq ~ W r'l ~ 3 3 W ~- W Z J J W W J Z ~ Z ,` Fw- T 2=2 ~ U m G ~r~ e zi< < a_ z m 9 0 tV W H u~~' N X N Q ui ~~ 'o~ rm1 LJ *~ ~ r..r '' _ w ~ J 1- Z ~zLL a ~W~ ?~ d. Z ~ ~°~ r - ~ r J ~~ ui a a~ ~ "'Fa m ' ~a a o ~~ m ~ '9° ~~ d o ~ 8 ~ B 0 9 T m i R v F _ A S c a ~~ ~~~~~ ~~~ ~~~~~ ~~~ ~¢ nt a = = Z ] U F- ~ o Z O ~ _ J N ., ., Commtulity Development Department CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS APRIL 23, 2009 555 W. MAIN STREET HIJIURY BUILDING OUR FUTURE HONORING OUR PAST The property is improved with an "A" rated church structure in the Victorian Gothic Church style per the City of Tustin Historical Resources Survey (1990) and has a NRHP Status Code: 3S per the Update to the Tustin Historical Resources Survey (2003). The Surveys note that the First Advent Church is the oldest continuously active Protestant church in Orange County and the oldest church in Tustin built in 1881. The proposed work involves the repair of the existing patio area along with electrical upgrades to the facility and wood fence replacement. The concrete steps along Main Street will be rebuilt and incorporate wrought iron handrails in context with the building. Lamp post lanterns in a historical style consistent with the building will be added to the patio area. The wood fence replacement is along the rear and interior property lines and will match the existing wood fence. Aground mounted floodlight will be placed within the landscaped area to illuminate the existing flag pole. The floodlight shall be positioned to confine all direct rays to the project site and ensure that there will be no spillover to adjacent properties or into the public right-of-way. Existing pavement throughout the site will be replaced as needed due to damage. There are no exterior improvements to the building being proposed. In accordance with Ordinance No. 1001 which was adopted June 20, 1988, by the Tustin City Council, the Community Development Director has the authority to approve, approve with conditions, or deny Certificates of Appropriateness for improvements requiring a City building permit for property located within a Cultural Resource District. The Community Development Department finds and determines as follows: A. The proposed work conforms to the Municipal Code and any applicable design standards in that the proposed project meets zoning code and building code requirements. The majority of the proposed work will repair and replace already existing features of the project site. B. The proposed work does not adversely affect the character of the District or Designated Cultural Resources within the District in that: the proposed repair work will improve the overall aesthetics of the property and is within the historical context of the site. 300 Centennial Way, Tustin, CA 92780 • P: (714) 573-3100 • F: (71~) 573-31 13 • www.tustinca.org TUSTIN Certificate of Appropriateness 555 W. Main St. April 23, 2009 C. The proposed work is harmonious with existing surroundings in that the proposed repairs and additions will enhance the appearance and functionality of the site while still maintaining the historical context. The proposed work would not cause a substantial change in the visual appearance of the site as the majority of work is repair work or upgrades to existing elements. The proposed work is hereby approved, subject to the following conditions: 1. Prior to the start of any work, the applicant shall obtain a building permit and pay all applicable plan check and permit fees. 2. All new utilities shall be placed underground. 3. The floodlight shall be positioned to confine all direct rays to the project site and ensure that there will be no spillover to adjacent properties or into the public right-of-way. 4. Prior to project final and occupancy, field inspection shall be conducted to verify consistency with the approved set of plans. ~= . c Elizabeth A. Binsack Community Development Director \\Cot-second\cdd-rda\Cdd\Ryan\Certificate of Appropriateness\555 W. Main St.doc ._ ._ ._.....~, ..Q,,..,a, x 1't~N EMtIQANCE t0 I~f3'dW oa Q (E~ OFFICE (E) HALL (E) KITCHEN ~~ `~ ~,` (E) 81lB PArEI. 'A' ~ b' MD ffNCE ~i c P ~--~---.r-.~_~.- _ -~-- o-~ __,, ~ ~ (E) CC ~r,~cc LAWN ~ ~ ~ ' ao~scc i ~ MATCH (E) CC WALKWAY --- ,~ ec (EJ 81!73 PMEI. 'C' TO CE taP GRADED (E) BTApe'B LA!~ING • ' l (E) RESIDENTIAL HOUSE aoncc loo.~cc) t. ~ p. ' ~ B ~ LArbHG ' ~ aivoc ex, (E) t3ARACaE SANCTUARY ~wl~lcca . ,,,, , 1.10` e H ~~ t~ A t: A ~ ~ ~~ roc har. ~` ~ . ~ roov ` ~ ~ ~ O ~ ~ ~ W O ~~ TO t+~MAi o 99.94TC TEMP. t'1ARK TER 7B (IOOD+CC) 114TER M@tSt T E~411Ct1T LME PROTEG' Ga?e:cY 7y o ~. PI ED _, Ini'.ia', _ 71QA~G S E 8 B PR7IECTEp „~cFL't9G Date; ~ „~ t; I Mit y FIRJ< Date; ~ ~' ~/ inkial: ~ y `,/.~ ~tlIIDING D2te• ~ r -----W.- MAIN STREET ---------------------------- coNSULrarr ate-- ' a ~ --- Date:. -- ~ ,: SITE PLAN ~-nr ~1 a ___ 0 _-- ~ u~ ~n ~~ ~~ ~~S ~a ~~~ ____,~ 9 a~ 4~ ~~ a.. >~ W ~ J W ~~~. Community Development Department CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS APRIL 1, 2009 435 PACIFIC STREET TUSTIN PROPOSAL: The property is improved with a "D" rated Penod Revival style structure per the Tustin Historical Resources Survey. The proposed project involves demolition of a utility room, storage room, patio cover, and laundry room, and construction of a 1,110 square foot addition and kitchen remodel. In accordance with Ordinance No. 1001 which was adopted June 20, 1988, by the Tustin City Council, the Community Development Director has the authority to approve, approve with conditions, or deny Certificates of Appropriateness for improvements requiring a City building permit for property located within a Guttural Resource District. The Community Development Department finds and determines as follows.: A_ The proposed work will not detrimentally alter, destroy or adversely affect the resource in that structures to be removed are for accessory uses, are not visible from the street, and have not acquired significance on their own, and the proposed addition is compatible to the main structure, clearly delineated from the main structure, and is not visible from the street. B. The proposed work does not adversely affect the character of the District or Designated Cultural Resources within the District in that no work is proposed in any area visible from the street and the street view of the house will remain unaltered. C. The proposed modifications will retain the essential elements which make the structure, site or feature culturally significant in that the proposed work is not visible from the public rdght-of way, the addition is designed in a style consistent with the historic structure, and the addition is clearly distinguished from the main structure. All of the elements that make the main structure and site significant will be maintained. The proposed work is hereby approved, subject to the following conditions: Prior to the start of any work, the applicant shall obtain any applicable building, plumbing, electrical, or other necessary permits and pay all applicable plan check and permit fees. 2. Replacement or repair of any part of the existing structure shall match the existing exterior materials, finish, and colors of the existing structure. 3. The property shall be subject to final building inspection to ensure consistency with plans approved and on file with the City. C~ ~>~ ~~~_~~~~ Elizabeth A. Binsack Community Development Director S:1CddlCanlCulhir~ Resouroes, Oid TownlCefificatff ;,: Appropriateneas'A35 PxiflC.doC _ 300 Centennial Way, Tustin, CA 92780 • P: (714) 573-3100 • F: (714) 573-31 13 • www.tustinca.org BUILDING OUR FUTURE HONORING OUR PAST r-" lJ -' -x„~_„?~~-- o to -- - - - -- _ - 3-i oc ~. __- 1 a- ._ ~ HS og ~" 3 - - C95 8'1b9 4~' r ~ - - ~ H = _ w _• .~} = _ ~ (~ -~ it ~ O ~ fl 43 Q 8_ g -a - _ f r~ - ~ ~_ - "' ~` ~ - - Q~ - ~ -o :- "°j ~_ 3 ° ~ ~ $ -_ 06 ~ ~ 3 J u IO <O ~ _ ~ a ~ ~~ ~~ d53 .9"905 ~H '~ .~; ~ _ _ ~ - _, u- ~~~ 4 ~ - ~° n M U- _ A ~ _ _, ~ ~ ~ r` ~ t3 ~W~S~p ~ ; f O O f ~ A ~"~~ ~ ~ ~~~ i ~ h ^ _• O __ t- _. o ,, ~ p „i ~, ~ r a w ~ ~ ~ \ ~ ~~~ ~ ~ ~ 3 ~ ~ I~ ~ ~ o _J - Q ~ V ~ ~ v =it ~ ~ r p _~ ~_ - __ . ~~ . o x~~ 111 ~n 4 ~ D 3° ~~ ~~ ~~ ~_ m ~ w X ~~ ~~- -~ ~ 3 4,% a 2 O ~4 =Q f t0 ~F --~~~" ~~ ~_ 3 ~r~ ~~ 3 N 7x~ ~ 1 W Z '~ 0 Z _~ ~~ U ~ Z ~~ ~~