Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutPC Minutes 06-09-09MINUTES REGULAR MEETING TUSTIN PLANNING COMMISSION JUNE 9, 2009 7:00 p.m. CALL TO ORDER Given INVOCATION AND PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE ROLL CALL Present: Chair Puckett Chair Pro Tem Kozak Commissioners Kasalek, Murray, Thompson Staff present Elizabeth A. Binsack, Community Development Director David Kendig, Assistant City Attorney Dana Ogdon, Assistant Community Development Director Terry Lutz, Principal Engineer Jerry Craig, Redevelopment Program Manager Lt. Tom Tarpley, Tustin Police Department Justina Willkom, Principal Planner Scott Reekstin, Senior Planner Amy Thomas, Senior Planner Gordon Margulies, Tustin Police Department Khaya Breskin, Tustin Police Department Edmelynne Huffer, Associate Planner Reina Kapadia, Associate Planner George Wiesinger, Code Enforcement Officer Eloise Harris, Recording Secretary Given PRESENTATION: PowerPoint presentation by Amy Thomas, Senior Planner, on the City of Tustin's Anti- Graffiti Coordination. Murray Complimented the Tustin Police Department (TPD) and Community Development Department for this collaborative, pro-active approach to this quality of life issue. Thompson Indicated he liked the feature allowing residents to a-mail photos to the website. Kozak Thanked staff for the presentation; and, asked if the stickers on street signs, buildings, windows, and also letters that can be purchased at hardware stores are a part of the vandalism trend; questioned how Minutes -Planning Commission June 9, 2009 -Page 1 that can be addressed and how many of the criminals are caught and sanctioned or punished. Tarpley Indicated that stickers are considered vandalism; taggers realize that spray painting takes longer; placing a moniker on a sticker can be pasted on quickly with less risk of detection; abating this type of vandalism takes more resources and time; the coordinated efforts of the gang units, the special enforcement detail, and the Neighborhood Improvement Task Force (NITF) have resulted in tremendous progress toward identifying the organized tagging crews and reducing the blight. Kozak Stated he appreciated that information; it is gratifying to see the results of these resources. Regarding the no boundaries issue, he heard that the Santa Ana City Council has directed city attorney staff to draft another ordinance that will hold the individuals and the parents of juveniles responsible far penalties. Thanked staff for their hard work; and, noted that he is a frequent caller; both the TPD and Code Enforcement are very responsive. Murray Asked if any outreach efforts are in place to educate stores regarding selling spray paint. Tarpley Indicated that outreach took place in the early phase of addressing the problem; the North Area impact officer is in the process of drafting an ordinance to take to the City Council to make it a crime to possess graffiti tools; the California Penal Code requires the intent must be proved; the draft ordinance will make possession of graffiti tools illegal and restrict possession. Puckett Stated his hope that the proposed ordinance will become law. None PUBLIC CONCERNS CONSENT CALENDAR Approved, with 1. APPROVAL OF MINUTES -APRIL 28, 2009, PLANNING one minor COMMISSION MEETING. correction Murray Requested a modification to his comment on page 4 to read as follows: "Thanked the City for the opportunity to attend the historic preservation training in Palm Springs." Minutes -Planning Commission June 9, 2009 -Page 2 It was moved by Murray, seconded by Kasalek, to approve the Consent Calendar. Motion carried 4-0. Thompson abstained. PUBLIC HEARINGS Adopted 2. CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT 09-010 A REQUEST FOR Resolution No. AUTHORIZATION TO ESTABLISH A PAWNBROKER 4115 BUSINESS IN CONJUNCTION WITH A RETAIL ESTABLISHMENT SPECIALIZING IN ANTIQUE AND ESTATE GOODS LOCATED AT 17390 EAST 17T" STREET, SUITE D. THIS PROJECT IS LOCATED IN THE PLANNED COMMUNITY COMMERCIAL (PC COMM) ZONING DISTRICT. RECOMMENDATION: That the Planning Commission adopt Resolution No. 4115 approving Conditional Use Permit 09-010. 7:24 p.m. The Public Hearing opened. Huffer Presented the staff report. Murray Asked if there would be any video surveillance installed on-site. Huffer Responded that issue was not addressed. Murray Asked how many other pawn brokers there are in the City. Huffer Replied that she did not have that information; however, there is another pawn broker in another jewelry store in Enderle Center. Thompson Asked what sort of investigation the TPD undertakes for these types of businesses. Huffer Requested that the TPD respond to that question. Tarpley Indicated that the North Area Commander, Lt. Steve Lewis, was not available to attend this meeting; his adjutant, Officer Breskin, has researched this and should be able to address any questions. Breskin Stated that a pawn license required fingerprinting that is processed through the Department of Justice; if there is any criminal history, the request would be rejected; the applicant's prior history is researched regarding problems with any other agencies or cities. Minutes -Planning Commission June 9, 2009 -Page 3 Kasalek Asked if the TPD has any requirements regarding video surveillance. Breskin Answered in the negative. Murray Asked if there are requirements for inspection at any time by the Community Development regarding public safety. Breskin Stated that requirement exists in the conditional use permit. Puckett Asked if there have been any problems with the applicant's other location in La Fayette Plaza. Breskin Answered in the negative; this applicant does not accept what might be considered ordinary pawn items but specializes in estate goods. Murray Asked staff to comment on his question regarding inspection. Director Replied that Condition 1.8 allows for an annual review in the event there may be any issue and to add mitigating conditions of approval if mitigating conditions are not effective. Puckett Asked if the applicant wished to speak. AI Enderle, property Welcomed the Verdults to Enderle Center; it is anticipated this will be owner a good store for the center; the merchandise will be collectibles, not typical pawnshop items. Puckett Asked if anyone else wished to speak. 7:34 The Public Hearing closed. Thompson Stated his appreciation of staff s work on the evaluation required for due diligence. Murray Stated he supports staffs recommendation; and, welcomed the applicants to the new location in Enderle Center. It was moved by Thompson, seconded by Kasalek, to adopt Resolution No. 4115. Motion carried 5-0. Puckett Mentioned that Mr. Enderle was recently selected as the 2009 Tustin Man of the Year. Mr. Enderle Thanked the Chair, accepted a round of applause, and added that there are video cameras at Enderle Center. Minutes -Planning Commission June 9, 2009 -Page 4 ,, Adopted 3. AMENDMENT TO CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT CUP 94-021 Resolution No. TO INCREASE THE MAXIMUM ALLOWABLE SQUARE 4117; adopted FOOTAGE OF OFFICE SPACE FROM 115,500 SQUARE Resolution No. FEET TO 142,900 SQUARE FEET WITHIN THE EXISTING 4118, with minor BUILDINGS AT THE TUSTIN BUSINESS CENTER. THIS modifications PROJECT IS LOCATED AT 1542 EDINGER AVENUE-1652 presented by EDINGER AVENUE; 1541-1582 PARKWAY LOOP, 15011- staff 15042 PARKWAY LOOP; AND 15012-15102 RED HILL AVENUE IN THE INDUSTRIAL (M) ZONING DISTRICT. RECOMMENDATION: That the Planning Commission: a. Adopt Resolution No. 4117 adopting the Final Negative Declaration as adequate for an Amendment to Conditional Use Permit 94-021 to increase the maximum allowable square footage of office space. b. Adopt Resolution No. 4118 approving an Amendment to Conditional Use Permit 94-021, authorizing an increase in the maximum allowable square footage of office space from 115,500 square feet to 142,900 square feet within the existing buildings at the Tustin Business Center located at the southerly corner of Red Hill Avenue and Edinger Avenue. 7:36 p.m. The Public Hearing opened. Reekstin Presented the staff report and explained the minor corrections to Conditions 1.2 and 1.7 that were presented at the dais. Thompson Asked why two resolutions were necessary. Reekstin Indicated that one resolution pertained to the adoption of the Mitigated Negative Declaration and one to the Conditional Use Permit. Thompson Asked the traffic engineer to further clarify the statistics that were contained in the traffic study. Lutz Indicated that the level of service was based on future traffic projections; it was felt the study presented by Austin-Foust was acceptable; the streets are private; there is concern regarding safety features; however, the streets are 36 feet wide and the parallel parking on one side would be safe. Minutes -Planning Commission June 9, 2009 -Page 5 Thompson Suggested the report indicates that 606 spaces would be adequate to park the site and be in compliance with the Code. Lutz Answered that would be correct. Murray Asked for verification that the width is 36 feet on those private streets. Lutz Replied that it is 36 feet from curb to curb. Murray Asked for further verification that the parking spaces will be nine feet wide and, due to sight distance concerns, if the provision of additional striping would promote better safety. Lutz Replied that Public Works can work with the applicant regarding striping enhancements. Kozak Asked if these spaces being dispersed throughout the development would be unassigned and added to the total inventory of spaces or designated to the new uses. Reekstin Stated his understanding that the spaces would be unassigned. Puckett Invited the applicant to come forward. Pam Sapetto, Thanked the City staff; stated the Sapetto Group was representing representing ScanlanKemperBard, supports staffs recommendation, and agrees ScanlanKemperBard to the conditions of approval. 7:50 p.m. The Public Hearing closed. Thompson Mentioned that he had spoken with Ms. Sapetto by telephone earlier in the day; this application seems consistent with the evolution of land uses in that area, going from industrial/manufacturing to office use; the Legacy project has been a key catalyst in transforming that area; it is good to see the parking has been addressed. Moved approval of the resolutions as presented. Puckett Asked if both resolutions could be moved at the same time. Kendig Answered in the affirmative. The motion was seconded by Murray. Motion carried 5-0. Minutes -Planning Commission June 9, 2009 -Page 6 Murray Added that he agreed that the applicant should work with traffic engineering regarding the striping and the sight distance issues at the entries and exits. Kasalek Noted that there are significant parking spaces available, but the striping would clarify the location of the spaces. REGULAR BUSINESS Adopted 4. DESIGN REVIEW 08-009 A REQUEST TO AUTHORIZE Resolution No. THE DEMOLITION OF AN EXISTING 1,757 SQUARE 4116, as FOOT ONE-STORY COMMERCIAL BUILDING AND modified OTHER SITE IMPROVEMENTS, AND THE DEVELOPMENT OF A 5,331 SQUARE FOOT TWO- STORY COMMERCIAL BUILDING SUITABLE FOR RETAIL AND MEDICAUDENTAL OFFICE USES, INCLUDING ASSOCIATED SITE IMPROVEMENTS, LOCATED AT 740 EL CAMINO REAL. THIS PROJECT IS LOCATED AT 740 EL CAMINO REAL IN THE CENTRAL COMMERCIAL WITH COMBINING PARKING OVERLAY (C-2 P) ZONING DISTRICT. RECOMMENDATION: That the Planning Commission adopt Resolution No. 4116 approving Design Review 08-009. Kapadia Presented the staff report. Thompson Applauded the revisions to the application; the proposed architecture is a wonderful enhancement to that corner; since this proposal is very different from the original request, he questioned why the plan does not include any retail on the ground floor. Director Replied that the City Council recommended approval with the dental or general office uses on the ground floor being acceptable; the only Planning Commission determination this evening is the design review; the City Council was concerned about the architectural treatment of all four sides of the building and wanted to ensure the design would come before the Planning Commission; the proposed retail on the ground floor and office use on the second story would be in keeping with the C-2 District. Thompson Questioned whether or not the applicant could, for example, build a high rise because of the action taken by the City Council with a variable of no retail use on the ground floor. Minutes -Planning Commission June 9, 2009 -Page 7 Director Reiterated that the City Council allowed for office uses on the ground floor; if another conditionally permitted use were requested at this location, the applicant would need to go through the applicable process. Thompson Stated his concern that the square footage has tripled; this appears to be a very different project; what he understands is that the boundaries established by the action of the City Council provided that flexibility. Director Indicated that Commission Thompson's understanding was correct; the applicant meets all of the development standards and the parking requirements for each kind of use that would be permitted in the building. Thompson Noted that a lot of the vegetation has been removed; many of the trees that provided a good screening for the freeway also have been removed; perhaps additional conditions could be added regarding the landscaping along the back side of the lot, including trees of a reasonable height. Murray Stated he likes the project and would like to hear from the applicant before making additional comments. Kozak Asked if from all four sides the roof-mounted equipment will be fully screened. Kapadia Replied that the equipment is shown on the proposed plans a minimum of six inches below the parapet wall; the parapet wall has been designed with a sufficient height to screen the equipment. Puckett Invited the applicant to the lectern. Dr. Mehta, applicant Stated that he has been working with staff for more than a year to reach the design before the Planning Commission and will continue to do so; and, added that his architect was also available for questions. Kozak Asked how the site can be graded while preserving one interior wall. Raj Patel, architect Answered the wall will not be a structure wall, but a wall with two supporting columns on each side. Kozak Questioned how the pad can be graded without removing the wall Mr. Patel Indicated that the wall is inside the building. Minutes -Planning Commission June 9, 2009 -Page 8 Kozak Asked if the plan was to maintain the existing foundation. Mr. Patel Responded only that portion under the wall. Thompson Reiterated that the architecture is an improvement; and, recommended that Resolution No. 4116, Condition 4.1, be amended to require additional screening with trees at the back of the lot. Murray Restated that he likes the project; the theme seems consistent with the building located at 100 West Main Street and complements the existing architecture in Old Town; other important factors are the two street exits and entries and the parking. Kasalek Noted that she parked across the street from this location for the Chili Cook-Off; compared to the current building, the proposed project is outstanding; she especially likes the proposed building's articulation. Questioned where Commissioner Thompson wants the trees. Thompson Replied that his suggestion was for trees to replace those that formerly screened the freeway. Kozak Added his thanks to the applicant and staff for working to produce and propose a lovely Old Town themed building; this is what the Commission was striving for when the application came before the Commission a year ago; the materials, articulation, etc. can become a poster child for commercial guidelines in Old Town. Stated there is a cinder block wall on the southwest comer separating this property from the property to the south; the edge of that wall has been damaged, and it is his hope that this wall will not remain at the completion of this project. Suggested that pavers be added at the new driveway to replicate the existing pavers at other portions of the sidewalk. Puckett Echoed the comments of the other Commissioners; this is a tremendous improvement of the previous application; this proposed structure is in a class with the building on the southwest corner of EI Camino Real and Main Street and will be a great addition to Old Town. It was moved by Thompson to approve Resolution No. 4116, with the modifications suggested. Puckett Suggested staff discretion for those changes. Minutes -Planning Commission June 9, 2009 -Page 9 Director Indicated that Condition 4.1, third bullet point, would accommodate the suggestion regarding the trees. The first bullet point could be modified as follows: "A revised site plan as well as include in landscape drawings the installation of decorative pavers at the main building entrance and at the drive approach on EI Camino Way, subject to review and approval by the Director of Public Works." Murray seconded the motion. Motion carried 5-0. Received and 5. PROJECT SUMMARY filed The summary focuses on the status of projects that the Planning Commission, Zoning Administrator, or Community Development Director approved, major improvement projects, and other items of interest. RECOMMENDATION: That the Planning Commission receive and file this report. Willkom Presented the staff report. Thompson Suggested that the Legacy summary seems to state there is very little residential construction underway. Director Stated that the Villages of Columbus represent all the residential construction occurring at this time; almost everything is completed at The District Thompson Referenced 20 units. Director Stated that about 25 building permits have been issued, so there will be more activity soon. Murray Thanked staff for the update. Kasalek Asked if there are future plans for alteration to the left-turn lane entrance off Warner; when leaving The District, traffic backs up into the regular traffic lanes. Lutz Answered there are no plans at this time, but Public Works will look into the problem. Kasalek Suggested that the situation is more of a problem on the weekends. Minutes -Planning Commission June 9, 2009 -Page 10 Lutz Pointed out that the completion of Tustin Ranch Road should alleviate some of the traffic problems. Kozak Thanked staff for the Summary of Projects; the information is always indicative of the partnership between the City and business in Tustin; a lot of projects are underway, even given the difficult economic times. Asked for the status of the Larwin Square reroofing project, especially the side that faces Centennial Way. Willkom Replied that the simple remodel was complicated by problems in the roof; the project is taking longer than usual; the project is ongoing; there are revisions being submitted for plancheck. Kozak Referred to the design review on page 3 for a significant remodel of the existing building and suggested adding language to include: "...application for demolition of the existing building and construction of a two-story dental office and retail on the ground floor." Puckett Emphasized that even in the bad economy there is a lot going on in Tustin for which to be thankful. Received and 6. ECONOMIC STIMULUS filed At a previous Planning Commission meeting, Commissioner Kozak identified available economic stimulus funds. This report provides the Commission with a broad view of the City's efforts in applying for and obtaining available funds. RECOMMENDATION: That the Planning Commission receive and file this report. Kozak Thanked staff for the information in response to his question; it is clear that City staff is working diligently to access available funds for various projects, including the Tustin Ranch Road extension, Newport Avenue, Rawlings Reservoir, etc. Mentioned SB 238 which was introduced in January, "Build America Bonds Act of 2009 (BABS)," a $50 billion package for transportation projects; and, noted that the language suggests assistance with the Tustin Ranch Road extension, the parking structure at the train station, the grade separations at Red Hill and Newport; the bill reads: "The purpose of this bill is to provide $50 billion in new transportation infrastructure funding through bonding to empower states and local Minutes -Planning Commission June 9, 2009 -Page 11 governments to complete significant infrastructure projects across all modes of transportation including roads, bridges, rail transport, transit, ports, inland waterways, and other purposes." Received and 7. OLD TOWN TUSTIN WORK PLAN filed At a previous Planning Commission meeting, Commissioner Kozak inquired as to the work plan for Old Town. This report identifies in-house projects for Fiscal Year 2009-2010. RECOMMENDATION: That the Planning Commission receive and file this report. Kozak Thanked staff for the response; he understands the separation of the projects into those that staff believes can be accomplished and those that cannot; the CLG grant application is not marked as one that staff would be working on; perhaps the Mills Act brochure or the workshop should come first. Director Indicated that the CLG grant requires a General Fund matching obligation; that is the reason it was pulled and the City did not file an application; staff is proposing that staff prepare a brochure, develop the Mills Act workshop, etc. as staff works around other projects that will not require outside consultants. Thompson Stated he thought the report provided a good overview; perhaps during the next fiscal year this list could be updated; and, added that he would be more than happy to participate as an example in the Mills Act workshop. Murray Indicated he felt the six selections chosen were content-rich and appropriate. Kasalek Added that she was especially pleased to see the brochure and website listed. STAFF CONCERNS 8. REPORT OF ACTIONS TAKEN AT THE MAY 5, MAY 19, AND JUNE 2, 2009, CITY COUNCIL MEETINGS. Director reported The City Council took action on the Mitigated Negative Declaration on the Tustin Avenue Well project; the City is working on that project i even though it is in the City of Santa Ana; this project will alleviate some of the City's water concerns. Minutes -Planning Commission June 9, 2009 -Page 12 Director continued The Community Development Block Grant Recovery funds will benefit the Tustin Area Senior Center which will receive about $217,000 for new flooring, wall coverings, and some energy-efficient HVAC safety systems for the facility. The HCD made comments on the draft revised Housing Element; staff is working diligently to respond to those comments; a certification letter is expected shortly; a final draft will then be taken to the City Council. The City Council held a Budget Workshop, detailed in the minutes included in the Planning Commission packets and making clear the impact on the City's coffers and what the state will be doing to the City. COMMISSION CONCERNS Thompson Stated that he attended the Orange County Business Council Infrastructure Committee meeting; there was an update regarding the John Wayne Airport (JWA) operations and expansion; there has been a 17 percent reduction in the number of flights due to the economy, but a recovery is expected; in 2015, agreements expire; at present there are caps on the number of passengers; a $550 million expansion is planned, expanding from 14 to 20 gates with a new terminal; JWA is known for having the largest through-put of any gate in the country; this is good for business but not so good for those under the flight path; it is important to remain vigilant regarding the airport's growth. Indicated he attended the last Citizens Advisory Committee workshop with the OCTA for the; it was necessary to reduce bus operations and adjust the budget due to the income reduction experienced; OCTA revenues are lower because sales tax receipts are down but are even lower because the state is taking more; this reduction impacts lower-income people. Stated he attended the State of the City address; although the news is somber, we can be proud that Tustin was ranked 21St in the country by Forbes as places to live, work, and play. Offered congratulations to Lou Bone who received the Key to the City Award, well deserved for his work on the City Council and proof that a retired person can invest much in the community; it is sad to see him leave Tustin. Minutes -Planning Commission June 9, 2009 -Page 13 Thompson continued Noted that he did not attend the Chili Cook-Off due to family conflicts; however, he is well aware of the process of preparing for, holding, and cleaning up this event; he thanked everyone involved for their hard work. Stated that he and his son, Luke, attended a sleepover on the USS Midway in San Diego; this is a phenomenal restoration project; it reminded him of the efforts of Old Town Tustin; as staff continues to receive applications for the historic plaque program, he would like recommendations from staff for stricter guidelines for the names of these historic structures; history does not change but homeowners do; the plaque program is intended to commemorate the history of Old Town, and it is important not to lose track of that history. Requested that staff provide updates during Planning Commission meetings regarding the Zoning Administrator actions that are provided to the Planning Commission by mail. Puckett Stated that he toured the USS Midway, the first ship too large to pass through the Panama Canal; and, encouraged everyone to to on the tour. Murray Noted that he has scheduled a motorcycle trip with some of his colleagues to visit the USS Midway. Stated he attended the I-5 Self Storage Grand Opening. Indicated he met with Assemblyman Jeff Miller and Councilmember John Nielsen to discuss Tustin issues and the Tustin Chamber when Mr. Miller visited the City. Stated that he attended the Tustin Foundation Awards ceremony and was very pleased to see the various grants presented; Erin Nielsen does a wonderful job at the Foundation. Offered congratulations to Mayor Davert who was re-elected as the Chair of the Sanitation District and will have additional tenure on the Orange County Fire Authority Board. Stated he was asked to sit on the Advisory Board of the Tustin Community Foundation. Noted he attended the Pat Nixon Scholarship luncheon at the Tustin Ranch Golf Course. Minutes -Planning Commission June 9, 2009 -Page 14 Murray continued Indicated he also attended the ground-breaking of the new quad project at the Tustin High School; Mayor Davert and Councilmember Nielsen were also in attendance. Stated that he attended the State of the City luncheon where he appreciated the tribute to Lou Bone for all his great work to the City. Indicated he worked with Marilyn Esposito on some of the contests at the Chili Cook-Off; Mayor Davert was in the dunk tank more than once, a charity event for Tustin baseball teams. Thanked his colleagues for their support of the Juvenile Diabetes fundraiser for the Padre Foundation in which his daughter is involved. Complimented the Tustin Police Department and Community Development staff for the graffiti presentation. Kasalek Stated that she also attended the Tustin Community Foundation luncheon, an outstanding event; it was exciting to see the number of non-profits involved. Indicated she attended the Teacher of the Year dinner. Noted she also attended the State of the City luncheon last week; and, offered her personal congratulations to Lou Bone; she served on the Commission with him many years ago; it is sad to know he will be leaving Tustin; he will be missed. Indicated that she also saw Mayor Pro Tem Amante getting dunked at the Chili Cook-Off. Noted that the Tustin Preservation Conservancy Tea and Tour takes place this Saturday; the Police Department Open House takes place on June 20. Offered her congratulations to AI Murray for his role in the City of Irvine's being the largest safe city again this year. Kozak Reminded everyone that Concerts in the Park begin June 24 and continue through August 12. Noted the staff projects with partners in the community: The Foundation, graffiti project, Chili Cook-Off; these are all reasons that Tustin ranks in the top 25 best cities to live well in the United States. F Minutes -Planning Commission June 9, 2009 -Page 15 Kozak continued Thanked staff for the opportunity to attend the Second Annual Orange County Water Summit in Anaheim; the topics included the "water wars" between north and south, agricultural and urban interests, ways to revitalize the Delta and bring more fresh water to central and southern California, haw businesses can work with water- saving projects in order to remain sustainable and vibrant, relying on local water resources such as Tustin's ground water replenishment system that has become a model for other communities, etc. Stated he attended the State of the City address and luncheon; he, too, served with Lou Bone on the Planning Commission; Lou is a wonderful person and citizen. Noted the City of Tustin/Lions/Chamber Food Drive for the Orange County Rescue Mission and Blind Children's Learning Center runs May through August; information is available from the Chamber; there are a dozen places where goods can be delivered. Commented that the Memorial between EI Camino Real and EI Camino Way is in need of repair or replacement. Murray Reminded everyone that the Tustin Chamber holds its 52"d Annual Chamber Gala installation of officers and Tustin business of the year awards on June 26 at the Tustin Ranch Golf Course. Puckett Commented that Lou Bone had a tremendous impact on the City and is now moving out of town; Commissioner Puckett is an ex-mayor who stayed and will continue to do so. Stated that he already noted the wonderful Planning staff and would be remiss not to mention the equally wonderful City Council. Noted that he and Commissioner Kasalek were both in Stockholm, Sweden, on May 19~'; however, their paths did not cross; Commissioner Puckett and his wife boarded a cruise ship in London that toured the Baltic capita Is. Congratulated AI Enderle and Kim Bass who were the 2009 Man and Woman of the Year recipients. Indicated that the Tustin Foundation presented checks to about 20 non-profits. Stated he enjoyed the Chili Cook-Off and State of the City address Minutes -Planning Commission June 9, 2009 -Page 16 Puckett continued Noted that he completed the Hope University golf marathon; thanks to everyone's support, he was the top fundraiser at $5,000. 9:03 p.m. ADJOURNMENT Murray Adjourned the meeting on behalf of Councilwoman Beth Krom, City of Irvine, due to the untimely loss of his son, Noah, over the weekend. The next regular meeting of the Planning Commission is scheduled for Tuesday, June 23, 2009, at 7:00 p.m. in the City Council Chamber at 300 Centennial Way. Charles E. Puckett Chairperson Elizabeth A. Binsack Planning Commission Secretary Minutes -Planning Commission June 9, 2009 -Page 17