Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout15 ATS WIRELESS MASTER PLAN PROPOSAL 08-04-09~-~ ---~ ` AGENDA REPORT ~. ~, MEETING DATE: AUGUST 4, 2009 TO: WILLIAM A. HUSTON, CITY MANAGER FROM: REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY SUBJECT: WIRELESS COMMUNICATIONS MASTER PLAN SUMMARY: Agenda Item 15 Reviewed: City Manager Finance Director A~ This report is to inform the City Council that the Wireless Master Plan (WMP) as contracted with ATS Communications (ATS) has been completed. RECOMMENDATION: Receive and file the Wireless Communications Master Plan. FISCAL IMPACT: With the completion of the Wireless Master Plan, the Consultant, ATS Communications, will begin procuring carriers on selected City-owned properties. As currently estimated, gross revenues per license site might range from $21,600 to $28,000 annually depending on the location, the investment required of the carrier in the construction of the facility, and the number of antennas. The City will not incur costs for the installation of the carrier's facilities; all costs of construction, maintenance and operation will be the responsibility of the carrier. ATS will receive twenty-five percent (25%) of gross revenues from each license as compensation for procuring carriers, processing carrier applications, inspecting the installation of new facilities, inspecting the maintenance of existing wireless facilities under the new licenses, and related issues impacting the terms and conditions of the license agreement as directed by the City. In addition, ATS will be responsible for updating the WMP, as requested by the City. All license agreements for proposed wireless facilities on City-owned properties will be submitted to the City Council for consideration. BACKGROUND/DISCUSSION: In November 2007, the City entered into an agreement with ATS Communications to develop and implement a Wireless Communications Master Plan (WMP) for the City and to act as the City's agent in procuring qualified wireless carriers wanting to locate facilities on City-owned property. ATS Communications completed the Wireless Master Plan in June 2009. The WMP does the following: 1) identifies adequacy of existing City Council Report Wireless Master Plan August 4, 2009 Page 2 wireless infrastructure citywide including the identification of existing wireless carriers on both City-owned properties and private properties, 2) identifies potential industry, regulatory and technology changes impacting future development of the City's wireless infrastructure, 3) evaluates the City's existing wireless ordinance, 4) provides design standards for future wireless facilities, 5) identifies City-owned properties that have the greatest potential for licensing, and, 6) provides an application and review process for wireless carriers interested in locating on City-owned properties including the inclusion of a standard form license. Over 35 wireless facilities are located or being considered for location throughout the City, on both private and publicly owned property. As a result of feedback from City departments no changes are recommended to the existing ordinance. During the preparation of the WMP, permitting of wireless facilities has continued on private property. The Wireless Master Plan identified four (4) potential City-owned sites for future potential facility installations although no specific facilities have yet been proposed or recommended by carriers as follows: 1. 13602 Parkcenter Lane (Camino Real Park) 2. 11385 Pioneer Road (Cedar Grove Park) 3. 10250 Pioneer Road (Pioneer Park) 4. Tustin Sports Park (There is an existing carrier facility on the site). Other sites will be considered in the future, as development occurs, including City- owned sites within the Tustin Legacy community and a future parking structure located at the MetroLink station adjacent to Edinger and Jamboree. All qualified proposals and Licensing Agreements for wireless facilities on City-owned property in the future will be brought forward by the Agency to the City Council for consideration. w ~'~../ Christine A. Shingleto Assistant City Manag Jo n A. Buchanan edevelopment Program Manager S:\RDAWohn BWTS Communications\CC Report adoption of WMP (Aug 2009)\AgendaReport 8-4-09 - WMP.docx i~ i~ City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study Table of Contents Executive Summary ............................................................................................1 Wireless Master Plan Introduction ....................................................................3 Goals ........................................................................................... .............................................. 3 Methodo%gy ............................................................................... .............................................. 3 Findings ...................................................................................... .............................................. 4 Background ................................................................... ......................................5 Wireless Infrastructure -Existing ............................................................................................ 5 Wireless Networks and Cell Sites .............................................. ............................................ 12 Site Se%ction .............................................................................. ............................................ 13 Se%tion Criteria ......................................................................... ............................................ 14 Wireless Technology Background ............................................. ............................................16 Evolution of Wire%ss Techno%gies ............................................ ............................................ 17 DAS Networks ............................................................................. ............................................ 18 Mergers and Acquisitions and Name Changes ............................ ............................................ 19 Regulatory Issues ........................................................................ ............................................ 21 Federal ........................................................................................ ............................................ 21 State ........................................................................................... ............................................ 21 Local ........................................................................................... ............................................ 2 2 Radio Frequency Emissions ........................................................ ............................................ 22 Analysis ......................................................................... ....................................24 Wireless Infrastructure -Existing and Proposed ..................... ............................................ 24 AT&T Wire%ss ............................................................................ ............................................ 25 Ne x te l .......................................................................................... ............................................ 3 0 Sprint PCS ................................................................................... ............................................ 35 T-Mobile ...................................................................................... ............................................ 4 0 I/erizon Wire%ss ......................................................................... ............................................ 45 Metro PCS ................................................................................... ............................................ 50 Radio Frequency Engineering Methodologies ......................... ............................................ 55 Inventory of City Property ........................................................... ............................................ 60 Map of City Properties ................................................................ ............................................ 62 City Property Evaluation &Marketing ......................................... ............................................ 62 Recommendations ........................................................ .................................... 63 Design Standards ........................................................................ ............................................ 63 General Types of Cell Sites ......................................................... ............................................ 63 Proposed Design Standards ........................................................ ............................................ 64 Design Considerations ................................................................ ............................................ 70 Implementation ............................................................................ ............................................ 74 WMPApprova/ Process ............................................................... ............................................ 74 Promotion &Marketing ............................................................... ............................................ 74 Application Process ..................................................................... ............................................ 74 Site Deve%pment Process .......................................................... ............................................ 75 Expiration ofArchitectural Elements and Design Standards ...... ............................................ 76 Suggested License Agreement .................................................. ............................................ 77 Wireless Communication Facility Site Application .............................................................. 86 Appendix "A" ................................................................ ....................................88 Inventory of Wireless Communications Facilities ................................................................ 88 Appendix "B" ................................................................ ..................................129 Glossary .................................................................................................................................. 129 City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study Executive Summa Executive Summary Over the last several years, three major factors have impacted the wireless landscape: 1) More people use cellular phones as their primary means of communication; 2) Cell phone usage is increasing as the price declines; and 3) New services and capabilities, requiring greater bandwidths, are exhausting current cell site (wireless network infrastructure) capacities. Cities have the opportunity, right, and obligation to be apart of the solution to this growing dilemma. There are concerns with the deployment of new towers, which are occurring in densely populated areas where additional bandwidth in needed due to high usage. Previously antennas were placed on commercial properties, existing towers, and non-residential areas, but the majority of these properties are currently occupied and carriers are looking for alternatives. Due to the Telecommunications Act of 1996 carriers have the authority to place sites in the public right of way without City approval. This creates tension between carriers and cities, due to the fact that local ordinances, zoning, and planning objectives are neglected. The WMP is the process created by ATS to rationalize the placement of new sites to meet the need. In 2002, ATS Communications (ATS) recognized the growing need for reliable, efficient wireless planning. Wireless planning, which involves collecting accurate data to create information, has been rationalized by ATS and assembled in the Wireless Master Plan (WMP). The WMP is a working document created by ATS in order to provide information to manage the growth and evolution of wireless communications infrastructure within cities. The goal of the WMP can be summated in one sentence; to facilitate future network expansion while maximizing City revenue and decrease blight. Before this goal can be achieved, the information that comprises the WMP must be collected and analyzed. The process begins by completing an inventory of all existing cell sites, both public and private, in the City. In the field, while conducting the inventory, the longitude and latitude, the build, and the carrier of each site is determined. This information is used to conduct a radio frequency analysis in order to find the potential need for future sites. The geo-coded location of future sites are cross referenced with the location of City properties, and the potential future sites are identified. This study indentified 6 potential cell site locations with six different carriers. The carriers that are currently in the marketplace are Verizon, AT&T, T-Mobile, MetroPCS, Sprint PCS, and Nextel. Each carrier has their own network deployed in the field, but some companies are running on different bandwidth frequency. There is more information in the pages that follow regarding the methodologies of the radio frequency engineering analysis, the individual wireless carriers, and their coverage. City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study Executive Summa The radio frequency analysis produces maps that show each individual carriers' coverage in the City. The maps included in the WMP can be compared to show the existing coverage and the future coverage. The future coverage is determined by overlaying the existing coverage with the coverage of the proposed sites. There are also maps that show the location of each carriers' sites amongst the other existing sites. For each site identified there is additional due diligence that must take place to determine if the location is a viable candidate. Both the wireless carriers and the City have determining factors that contribute to this conclusion. For example, zoning, soil condition, cost of rent, etc. Once the site is determined viable the carrier goes through a site development process, which includes soil testing, drawings and photo simulations, approvals and permits, and executing the lease. The WMP incorporates the design standards recommended for the City's approval. The design standards review the general types of cell sites antennas and equipment enclosures. Each antenna has recommended locations for usage and design specifications. For example, with a monopalm there are specifics regarding the color of the fronds and the bark cladding, the concealment of the antenna and cables, and the height of the tower, which will make it possible for co-location. Also included in the WMP is background information regarding the evolution of the telecommunications industry and its regulations at different levels of government. 2 City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study Introduction Wireless Master Plan Introduction Goa/s The goals and objectives for the City 's wireless facilities deployment are: 1) Facilitate future network development through a proactive approach; implementing the WMP; 2) Mitigate the visual impact of towers and antennas by employing "stealth" technology into design standards; 3) Reduce the number of cell sites through a coordinated co-location process; and 4) Maximize the economic benefit to the City This process will reduce the time expended by both the city and the wireless carriers in the application and site development process. Pre-approved locations and designs on city-owned property creates incentives for the wireless companies to enhance their networks, while the city benefits with an additional revenue stream. Thus, both the city and the carrier will experience greater efficiency throughout the wireless network enhancement projects. Methodo%gy Detailed information about each wireless existing site is collected and field verified to determine current wireless network infrastructure. ATS identifies each major wireless carrier's (Cingular, AT&T, Metro PCS, Nextel, Sprint, T-Mobile and Verizon) present locations and the corresponding signal coverage. This information is analyzed, using radio frequency engineering signal propagation and coverage prediction modeling software, to generate existing coverage maps for each of the major carrier's networks. The city's population densities, traffic patterns and physical terrain are taken into account during the analysis. The compilation of this information enables ATS to view each carrier's existing coverage or "footprint" and predict the locations for future sites. Each existing city sites is considered as a candidate for future co-location, which is placing multiple carriers at one site. Design recommendations, height requirements and other considerations will be discussed for each future location. This process minimizes the time required by staff to handle cell site applications and review development design proposals. The site-specific design standards will be acceptable to the City, while meeting the wireless carriers' needs. The carrier, the city, and ATS work together negotiating and executing the leases and entitlements. City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study Introduction Findings The following chart shows the 6 city-owned properties that could meet the needs of various wireless service providers. Table 1 Site ID Lat Lon Address Site - # of Carriers TUS021 33.730489 -117.803915 13602 Parkcenter Ln 3 TUS033 33.751236 -117.769605 11385 Pioneer Road Cedar Grove Park 5 TUS034 33.767251 -117.761297 10250 Pioneer Road Pioneer Road Park 6 TUS035 33.733994 -117.785102 Tustin S orts Park 2 While the entire inventory of city-owned properly was considered, 39 cell sites currently exist on public and private property throughout the city. Depending on the location and design of the existing sites, the placement of a site on city-owned properly in close proximity to an existing site may be unnecessary. While this study aims to identify new cell site locations for future wireless sites on city- owned property, does not preclude wireless carriers from targeting private property sites for network deployment. 4 City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study Existing Coverage Background Wireless Infrastructure -Existing ATS identified 39 active cell sites at 33 locations throughout Tustin. Of the 39 existing cell sites, T-Mobile has the most facilities, possessing 11 locations. Sprint PCS, Nextel, and AT&T each have 7 sites. While Verizon and Metro PCS possess 5 and 2, respectively. Analysts observe eight different antenna structure styles, the most common is a stealth roof mount. The maps below present the coverage that currently exists in Tustin. These maps also show the strength of the coverage provided by each site located within the City. The legend provided on each map will enable the user to see the outdoor coverage versus the indoor coverage by carrier. A map is provided for each carrier that services the City. City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study Existing Coverage Map 1 AT&T Ex~Stlnq GOVeraQe .. k m . ~ ~ ... " ~ _ ~- ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ,~..~.. ~~-:~~~ ~ m ~ E ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~`~~ ~ ~ ~ o E ~ ~ ~ Ot ~ ~ ~ ~ N wbva''', ..; ~ a ~. "- :'.. ~~ ~ ~.. ~ ~ r Sr ... ~, f 4, ~y ~ ~ ~ ~ ar .` 0 ~ ty ~ ~ ~ U d p o ~ ~' ~ ~ ~ t / ~ n. ~ ~ (a ~ C D ._ a ... 6 City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study Existing Coverage Map 2 nextei txistina coverage 7 City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study Existing Coverage Map 3 Sprint PCS Existing Coverage 8 City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study Existing Coverage Map 4 i~ T-MOb~le Existing Govera4e a ~~ _ ~~ ~; ~ ~. ~° ~' m U ~ `- ~ ~ '' 4 ~ a° ~ ::<.a .ate ~ ~ ~,_ ~ _ t ~ ~° < ~ - .a ~_ ~ 'o ~ n" ~C ~ ~ ~ d.a . i .,,.~,y-~,,~,, <, ~ aroma ~ ,,, g ~ te` .~ '6-.~~~~ ,~ ' ^ ~ r ~ ~. ~° ~ ~,~, ~~a ., _~ t ~, g } H = ~~. o ~# f - ~ ,a_ P -~ ~~ - ~~ - ~~~~ it r~ ~ ~~.,.~ ; , , ~ ~a ° , ~~~s1 ~~`r~ ~ -~ ~~ _.,w» ~ a+'' , .O ~ ~~= G ,, ~~ ~ -€ ~~ . ~ u ~ ~~ w af .. ~ ~ ' ' ~ ~ w ~ ,r' ' ~ ~N~ _ w ~, F ~'` ,~ ~ _ ~ _ ._ ~% f f °. ~ . ~ C i T '. e ~ ~. .~ _ ~ - ! t ,, e_...t ~ e ~ `f S .. ~, r„ t" ~ ~ n ... ._ ~ ~ ~ ~ - .S ~~ A .. , ,q~''.by L~ ~ ~ .. .. ~~ '~ `""` ," ~ m ~ ~ v ~ ~ m „ ~ F`~ q~ ~y.~~ $ ~" ~ ~~ p' ^ ~ D ~ O Via'' ../'~^• ~ 's.... ; CJ ` ~ ~ e. . ~~ `"w,. ~ ~ > ~ ~ ~~ r§ ~ ~ ~ U ~ ~ ~ ~* 'E7 U C ~ q ~~~ U C '~ A ~ ~~ ~ ~~ 9 City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study Existing Coverage Map 5 verizon wireless txisting coverage ~~- r; a a 1 10 i~ City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study EXIStIng COV@fag@ Map 6 Metro Pc5 Existin covera e ~., c "r.~.~"" "~ ^%~ ~ ~ e ....~ ! ~~~ M.,.ey'~~t° ~,/,,,~ p F m ~ ~ .^~`. „ ~ v m m .. -~ ,n ~ E , , .~ , ~:. m o ~ CII '^~ -~.,~ A ~ @ W ~ ..i C4 ~ r C!S ~ `, ~ d ~. ~ ~ ~ ~ j } ~ i !;,` 9 `", c ~~ '`~~~ .~` ~ G ~ ~; .~ ~ _ __ ,, ,~ ~ t.- c ~ ~, b '`; c ~Ci~ygr ~b / ,~ ~~ a ~, ..~._ .. x R ~~m ~°~~~ ` a ~~` ~o, ^ f ~, ~ ~ ,~, ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ w~ ~ _' ~~ s- ~F -gam' '-:~_,~, ~ `°~~ "S'„ ,.~A. 11 City of Tustin ' wireless Master Plan Study Wireless Networks Wireless Networks and Cell Sites Cellular and Personal Communications Systems (PCS), which are commonly referred to as "cell ~ phones," are integral to our daily lives. As consumers become more reliant on these devices, the need for additional antennas, or "cell sites", to support these customers also increases. The Cellular Telecommunication Industry Association (CTIA) reports that when they began their semi-annual survey of the industry in June 1985, there were an estimated 203,600 domestic cellular subscribers. By 2007, that number grew to over 250,000,000 customers. Currently, '~ the corresponding wireless infrastructure that services over 250 million subscribers is estimated _ at approximately 230,000 cell sites. The Federal Communications Commission (FCC) has issued, through public auction, a limited number of licensed frequencies to wireless services providers, such as Verizon Wireless, T- Mobile, Sprint/Nextel, AT&T Mobility (a.k.a. Cingular and Cricket carriers). For the carriers to receive these frequency licenses, the FCC mandates that they must provide seamless coverage throughout the licensed market area assigned for those frequencies. In order to fully understand cellular service, an explanation of "cellular" and "cell site" concepts is necessary. In the first years of mobile wireless communications, carriers needed to provide subscriber coverage. To do so effectively, they limited their frequencies. Frequency spectrum .. reuse is accomplished by allocating a set number of frequencies to each wireless communications facility. (These frequencies are represented as hexagonal "cells" [shown ., below], which represent geographical areas.) Each cell utilizes a different frequency set than its neighboring cells. However, the next cell over (the adjacent shaded cell) can reuse the same frequencies as the original (shaded) cell. This pattern repeats throughout the geographical market area, creating a wireless communications network of cells, which are called "cell sites." Hence, because of this cell network, the term "cellular" communications is appropriate. Figure 1 Wireless communications networks develop using two underlying objectives that govern cell site placement: to provide coverage and to provide capacity. Together, these two objectives contribute to a network's overall customer Quality of Service. ~ The first and main objective, is to provide coverage throughout the carrier's licensed market area. This is accomplished by locating new cell sites in areas where existing coverage is either 1 unavailable or unreliable. These locations can be on the market area's periphery (where new population growth occurs), in newly-licensed markets (in which the carrier has no existing 12 City of Tustin Wireless MasferPlan Sfudy Wireless Networks network infrastructure) or within an existing network (in which technical issues, such as topographical constraints, cause service interruptions or gaps). These gaps, or areas known as "holes,"cause dropped calls. The other objective, network capacity, critically affects a wireless network's viability. Capacity is driven by demand, and a cell site can only handle a finite number of calls to meet this demand. As more customers use the network, greater demands are placed upon this limited frequency capacity, or bandwidth, of the cell site. When a cell site's bandwidth reaches its maximum capacity, customer call blocking and dropped calls result. Ultimately, maximization of bandwidth causes poor Quality of Service. A carrier attempts to minimize or eliminate insufficient capacity issues by dividing a cell; in other words, it introduces a new cell site between existing cells to off-load customer call volume. Site Se%ction All wireless carriers constantly seek to improve their Quality of Service by enhancing their wireless network infrastructures. This process begins when Radio Frequency (RF) engineers collect data on network performance. RF engineers pinpoint the networks' coverage problem areas by reviewing the recorded number of dropped calls or missed calls over the networks. The RF engineering team visits the areas of concern to determine the best technical locations for new cell sites. Then, the RF engineer issues "search rings," or maps of the general areas where new cell sites are needed. Typically, focal areas have less than one-quarter mile radii, but they may be even smaller, depending on environmental constraints such as terrain, vegetation and buildings. The next step in the process is performed by a Site Acquisition Specialist. The Site Acquisition Specialist uses an RF engineer's search map to identify the general locations of suitable properties that are cell site development candidates. However, the criteria that are employed at this stage often contradict the RF engineer's desired criteria. The site acquisition criteria for a geographically suitable property must be "leasable," "zonable" and "buildable," but it still must be viable from an RF engineering perspective. Hence, the carrier and the landowner must agree on business terms, the site must possess a reasonable likelihood of obtaining all necessary entitlements (permits), the site must be constructed within a reasonable budget and meet RF engineering objectives. Higher elevation properties prove to be the best cell site locations because they allow clear lines-of-sight for radio-transmitted signals. Yet, this fact presents a siting dilemma since, in many instances -and especially in established communities -the desired locations (to provide the best radio coverage) lie within residential areas. Carriers typically select commercial property cell site options to avoid or minimize controversial zoning and land use issues. However, as network infrastructure continues to expand, viable options for cell sites become increasingly limited. This trend has forced carriers to seek sites within residential areas, school properties, parks and the city's other public rights-of-way. Siting issues compound as the wireless service providers compete for both customers and suitable new cell site locations. The onus rests on local governments to manage and coordinate cell site proliferation throughout their communities. Local control and coordination are necessary because independent wireless services companies do not generally benefit from 13 City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study Wireless Networks collaboration. In fact, an industry effort to coordinate network facility co-location is contrary to the spirit of business competition and raise concerns over collusion, monopoly and other regulatory issues. It is apparent that a process that coordinates and manages cell site growth is necessary and prudent to future wireless network infrastructures in any well-planned community. Therefore, the creation of a Wireless Master Plan provides a means to facilitate wireless network growth that meets both wireless companies' and subscribers' needs. Se%tion Criteria Managing or coordinating future cell site development requires the City to adopt certain cell site design standards. Each property possesses distinct characteristic that require unique cell site development approaches. A carrier must consider the following cell site selection criteria: • Topography • Coverage area • Tower design or type • Antenna height • Antenna array or antenna selection • Antenna orientation • Cable run (distance from the base station equipment to the antennas) • Surrounding vegetation and/or structures • Proximity to electrical power and telephone services • Access to the public right-of-way • Equipment and tower space limitations • Soil composition • Site development costs • Rent Simultaneously, alocal government considers the following cell site selection criteria: • Site location • Tower design or type • Structure height • Area zoning (residential, open space, commercial, industrial or institutional) • Screening and integration • View impact • Landscaping • Access • Co-location These two set of criteria sometimes present conflicting objectives. Wireless service providers seek sites that maximize coverage area at minimum cost. These goals, from the carriers' perspectives, correspond to building towers high enough to overcome topographical limitations and possible vegetation or structural interference, while also including space for a full array of antennas (typically 12 antennas divided into three arrays, or "sectors," and a microwave dish). Furthermore, the carriers seek locations possessing close proximities to power, telephone and 14 City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study Wireless Networks street access, adequate space for equipment shelters and generator space. The preceding criteria foster basic cell tower sites that are not aesthetically attractive, and would not be welcome in suburban/ residential settings. 15 City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study Wireless Communications Background Wireless Technology Background "Wireless telecommunications" generally describes those services known to the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) as Commercial Mobile Radio Services (CMRS). Currently, the majority of CMRS is encompassed within the radio telephony segment: Cellular Telephone Services (800 to 900 MHz range), Personal Communications Services (PCS) (1800 to 1900 MHz range), and Specialized Mobile Radio (SMR). By the end of 2003, 97% of U.S. residents had access to three or more providers of these services, and more than 160 million people subscribed to these services. Nationwide, over 54% of the population use CMRS services, and in Southern California, over 61% utilize CMRS services. During 2003, radio telephony generated over $88 billion in revenue. These facts prove that CMRS, and especially radio telephony, are major factors in the majority of the United States population's daily lives. Modern radiotelephony began with analog Cellular Telephone Service. While AT&T originally developed cellular technology in 1958, it did not become commercially available until the FCC began licensing cellular providers in 1982. Cellular licenses are allocated in two bands (A & B) within the 800 MHz area of the radio spectrum. Since 1991, two carriers have been licensed in each of the nation's 734 Cellular Market Areas. During the 1990s, most cellular service was transitioned from analog to digital signal transmission. Although cellular operators must retain analog service availability until 2008, digital service greatly improved reception for cellular customers. In addition to Cellular Telephone Service, first generation services also include Specialized Mobile Radio (SMR), whose best known provider in Southern California is Nextel. In 1979, the FCC began licensing SMR in both the 800 MHz and 900 MHz bands and, since that time, the FCC has also auctioned off spectrum for SMR services. To date, 1900 MHz of exclusive spectrum and 7.5 GHz of shared spectrum are allocated to SMR. SMR provides for both one-on-one and simultaneous group communications through "dispatch mode" operations. It also provides radiotelephony through "interconnected mode" operations, which connect the radios to the regular land line telephone network. Due to various interference issues between SMR and public safety radio systems, the federal government requires SMR providers to relocate from the 800 MHz band to the 1900 MHz band. In 1995, the second generation of radiotelephony services was introduced with the advent of Broadband PCS. PCS integrates cellular telephony with additional services, such as paging and text messaging. Digital signals in the 1850-1990 MHz bands deliver all PCS services. Unlike cellular, whose spectrum was allocated by the FCC through traditional regulatory licensing, Broadband PCS spectrum was allocated through auctions. The A and B blocks of the Broadband PCS spectrum, both of which are 30 MHz wide, were auctioned on the basis of 51 Major Trading Areas (MTAs). The remaining blocks (the 30 MHz C block and the 10 MHz D, E and F blocks) were auctioned based on 493 Basic Trading Areas (BTAs). The third generation of radio telephony, commonly called "3G," is generally implemented as a Broadband PCS enhancement. 3G technology requires high-speed digital transmission to support various multimedia applications, including email and Internet access. The FCC also plans to auction an additional 90 MHz of spectrum, in the 1710-1755 MHz and 2110-2155 MHz bands, specifically for advanced wireless services like 3G and 4G. Fourth generation, known as 16 City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study Wireless Communications Background "4G" or "beyond 3G," will provide high-speed advanced wireless communication services, including comprehensive IP solutions that deliver voice data and multimedia to users at any location and/or time. In addition to radiotelephony, CMRS includes two other elements: paging and Narrowband PCS. Licensees in these spectrum bands provide paging and both one- and two-way text messaging services. While these services may seem outdated, companies continue to find new market niches that need or desire these services. Evo/ution of Wire%ss Techno%gies Current cellular technology provides users with access to television broadcasts and live streaming video. The future of wireless technology promises an utterly ubiquitous wireless environment that offers even greater global high-speed data service access for a wide variety of devices. The emergence of the 802.16 (WiMAX) standard adds a new opportunity to provide high-speed data access to a new wave of Internet users. As the successor to 802.11a/g aimed at consumer applications that require very high throughput (like HDTV and streaming video), 802.11n possesses a fourfold increase in bandwidth to support increasing demands of high volume data networks over the next few years. These technologies will continue to evolve and cross-pollinate with both licensed and unlicensed bands, including PCS and VoIP (voice-carrying) networks. Hence, there is a common opinion throughout academia, industry and business that the current wireless technology fulfills neither current nor future demands," according to those behind the Wireless Gigabit with Advanced Multimedia (WIGWAM) project. WIGWAM is seen as an early version of the next generation of 802.11n looking for Gbps speeds, which is the interactive speed and bandwidth necessary for the next generation of wireless services envisioned. These new technologies and services entice both youth and adult markets. However, the majority of marketing dollars are spent on the youth market -with an age range of 12 to 24 years old -even though they do not make up the majority of the population. Wireless companies promote new cell phones, such as Helio and Amp'd Mobile, to provide these services. Helio's commercial, which states, "It's not a phone," accurately captures the new direction in which these devices are moving. As a result, many more cell sites are necessary to provide future services. Over the next few years, the landscape of wireless technology, new devices and the bandwidth necessary to meet the demands of the consumer will be dynamic. As wireless technology evolves, its supporting infrastructure will change in order to keep pace with new consumer needs. Technological evolution cannot occur if the infrastructure necessary to support it does not exist, and analysts anticipate that the number of existing cell sites, for any given area, will double or triple in order to provide the bandwidth needed for these services. Many industry analysts also expect that devices like PDAs, iPods, cameras, video cameras, and even wallets will be replaced by multiple-feature cell phones. Unlike Europe, Asia and South America, the United States has been slow to embrace these new technologies and services, but a growing number of companies believe that the American consumer is finally ready. 17 City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study Wireless Communications Background DAS Networks Carriers often face poor signal quality in areas that are topographically isolated or in high- density urban environments. Moreover, when trying to improve their Quality of Service (QoS) by constructing new towers, they face opposition from local communities. These issues couple with the needed bandwidth for today's mobile data communications services, requires a new approach to efficiently develop network infrastructure. The Distributed Antenna Systems (DAS) network is an emerging phenomenon in wireless network deployments. While DAS is not new technology, it possesses a new application with outdoor open network usage. Traditionally, DAS networks were utilized in indoor environments like subways, tunnels, sports complexes, airports and convention centers. DAS networks typically use existing infrastructure, such as telephone poles and streetlights, to expand carrier networks. They deploy small antennas distributed throughout a geographic area. The antenna locations, referred to as 'nodes," are interconnected by fiber optic cables to a central hub location. One remarkable aspect of a DAS network is its usage of shared infrastructure to support multiple wireless carriers within defined geographical areas. This network solution promises to address many of the carriers' coverage and capacity needs, while also minimizing the aesthetic and zoning issues that concern local governments. However, DAS network deployments are still relatively unused when compared to the overall scheme of carrier deployments nationwide. 18 City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study Wireless Communications Background Mergers and Acquisitions and Name Changes Over the 15 years that wireless companies have been active, a number of mergers, name changes, and partnerships have occurred. The following table sorts out the various players: Table 1 Current Wireless Com an Transactions Cingular Wireless (the new AT&T Wireless Renamed from Pac Bell Wireless Purchased AT&T Wireless who urchased LA Cellular Partnered with T-Mobile Sold a portion of its combined network to T-Mobile, dissolvin artnershi Purchased s strum ri hts from NextWave Telecom Rebranded to AT&T Com leted 2007 Nextel (Nextel) Provided Boost Mobile with prepaid services through 'oint venture with an Australian com an Merged with Sprint PCS, though it appears Nextel may remain active as S rint's business service cite Currently required to relocate its spectrum to eliminate Public Safe Radio S stem interference issues S rint PCS S rint Renamed from MCI Ac uired Cox PCS service Mer ed with Nextel Partnered with Virgin Group LLC to form Virgin Mobile re aid services T-Mobile Deutsche Telecom Partnered with Cin ular Wireless Purchased a portion of Cingular Wireless' network and certain s estrum ri hts as artnershi dissolved Partnered with Western Wireless Verizon Wireless Verizon Purchased Airtouch Cellular Ac uired PacTel Cellular T-Mobile and Cricket are relatively new players in the wireless industry; they previously shared their network with Cingular. However, the acquisition of AT&T Wireless required Cingular to divest part of its wireless network, so it chose to sell its former Pacific Bell locations to T-Mobile. As part of this transition, each carrier is in the process of moving their customers to separate networks in order to give each company time to fill in coverage holes. In addition, two new wireless companies joined the Southern California market, Metro PCS (dba Royal Street Communications) and Modeo. While Metro PCS competes head-on with the other 19 City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study Wireless Communications Background major wireless carriers, Modeo is a subsidiary of one of the major tower companies and is expected to use its infrastructure to develop its network. 20 City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study Regulatory Issues Federa/ U18tOrV (SSU2S Three principal Acts allow Congress to provide a comprehensive federal regulatory scheme over wireless telecommunications, thereby preempting State and local regulations. The first Act is the Communications Act of 1934. This Act created the Federal Communications Commission (FCC), giving it regulatory responsibility for interstate communications, both wired and wireless. Second, the 1993 Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act eliminates States' abilities to regulate wireless providers' entries and rates. Finally, the Telecommunications Act of 1996 overhauls the 1934 Act, focusing on creating a competitive telecommunications market by eliminating the barriers to entry and the "public utility model" monopolies that were the telecommunications industry's principal features under the 1934 Act. The major exception to federal preemption under the 1996 Act is local zoning authority, which is specifically reserved for State and local governments. Under the 1934 and 1996 Acts, the FCC exercises regulatory authority over wireless communication providers, including spectrum allocation (through traditional public interest allocations or auctions), carrier licensing, and the design, manufacture and operations of equipment. In addition, the FCC enforces comprehensive radio frequency exposure regulations to protect the public from dangerous radio frequency emission levels. Aside from the 1934 and 1996 Acts, wireless telecommunications providers may fall under a number of additional federal regulations. In order to avoid being hazardous to air navigation, wireless facilities must comply with Federal Aviation Administration regulations with regards to height and proximity to airport facilities. Projects in certain federal priority areas, including federal property, wilderness areas, wildlife preserves, endangered species habitats, historical sites, Native American religious sites, flood plains and wetlands may require environmental assessments under the National Environmental Protection Act. Wireless facilities that contain backup battery and generator systems may also be subject to federal regulations under the Clean Air Act, Clean Water Act, Resource Conservation and Recovery Act, and the Emergency Planning and Community Right-to-Know Act. State Due to federal preemption, the State plays a limited role in wireless telecommunications' regulatory issues beyond the Labor, Tax and similar Acts applicable to all business enterprises in the State. The zoning exception, however, does provide an opportunity for State regulation. Since the State generally delegates land use authority to local government, State regulation is generally limited to those special cases when the State retains zoning authority. Such cases include the Coastal Zone, where the Coastal Commission exercises regulatory authority, and hospital sites, where the Office of Statewide Health and Planning Development exercises 21 City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study Regulatory Issues authority. In addition, wireless facilities must meet the requirements of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA). Loca/ The 1996 Act's exception for zoning regulation causes local governments to have the most direct impacts on wireless facility locations and their visual appearances (with respect to placement, construction, and modification). However, this authority is limited. Local governments may not "unreasonably discriminate among providers of functionally equivalent services," enact regulations that prohibit wireless facilities, or prohibit facilities based on the concern of radio frequency emissions, for which the FCC sets regulations. Further, local governments are required to act in a timely manner on a wireless placement permission request. If a request is rejected, it must be placed in a written record that is supported by substantial evidence. Applicants who are denied authorization for facility placement may file actions in court that challenge the denial, and they are then entitled to expedited hearings in court. If a denial is based on radio frequency emission, the applicant may appeal that denial to the FCC instead of the court. The Telecommunications Act of 1996 (TCA) allows state and local governments to enact ordinances governing the placement of wireless telecommunications facilities [§TCA Section 332 (c)(7)]. Nonetheless, local governments become increasingly embroiled in lawsuits filed by the common carriers over restrictive local ordinances, violating Section 253(a) of the TCA [§ 253(a)- (e)(1994 & Supp. II 1996)) (hereinafter °removing barriers']. Recently, the courts have struck down restrictive ordinances or ordinances that are '~so onerous" that they restrict wireless network development, as in the following case: Sprint Te%phony PCS, L.P. v. County of San Diego, Nos. 05-56076, 05-56435 (9th Cir. June 13, 2007). Local governments regulate, but cannot prohibit, wireless communication facility placement on sites like schools, in residential zones and in public rights-of-way. Furthermore, according to the TCA §' 332 (c)(7)(B), "Limitations (iv) - No State or local government or instrumenta/ity thereof may regu/ate the placement, construction, and modification of personal wire%ss service facilities on the basis of the environmental effects of radio frequency emissions to the extent that such facilities comply with the commission's regulations concerning such emissions " Radio Frequency Emissions Wireless site emissions cannot be directly regulated by the City. The Telecommunications Act of 1996, 704 Section B, states that State or local governments may not regulate wireless facilities on the basis of environmental effects of radio frequency emissions if the applicant demonstrates compliance with FCC regulations. It is important to understand the guidelines under which such sites are regulated. The government bases the Maximum Permissible Exposure (MPE) levels upon National ANSI, IEEE and international standards. The FCC established these health and radio emission standards, and the guidelines for. measuring and analyzing RF Emissions were created by the FCC's Office of Engineering and Technology (OET) 65. This Office writes a periodic bulletin called "Evaluating 22 City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study Regulatory Issues Compliance with FCC Guidelines for Human Exposure to Radiofrequency Electromagnetic Fields." This bulletin aids engineers and other qualified persons, guiding them toward correct determinations about whether specific sites meet emission requirements. Typical cellular tower transmissions are relatively low in power, so FCC-outlined emissions rarely present issues. The distance from a transmitting antenna to the nearest structure is usually greater than the FCC requirement, and emissions fall well below the MPE threshold. Another excellent FCC-oridyced reference is entitled, "A Loca/ Governments 0>"ficia/s Guide to RF Emission Antenna Safety."Rules, Procedures and Practical Guidance are available on the FCC's RF safety web page at www.fcc.gov/oet/rfsafety. 23 City of Tustin Wire%ss MasterP/an Study Wireless Infrastructure Analysis Wireless Infrastructure -Existing and Proposed ATS identified 39 active cell sites at 33 locations throughout Tustin. Of the 39 existing cell sites, T- Mobile has the most facilities, possessing 11 locations. Sprint PCS, Nextel, and AT&T each have 7 sites. While Verizon and Metro PCS possess 5 and 2, respectively. Analysts observe eight different antenna structure styles, the most common is a stealth roof mount. The proposed sites were developed using the radio frequency engineering analysis. These sites were identified by locating the carrier's absent coverage areas and plotting the findings on city property. These identified sites serve as probable areas for future development, meaning they are the closest approximation to the carrier's coverage gaps. But these selected locations do not necessarily fit the City's desires for placement or the carrier's coverage and capacity goals. The maps below present three different pictures to the City: the coverage that currently exists, the additional coverage that is needed (proposed coverage), and the final picture of what exists and what is proposed, which shows the future deployment in the City. The maps provided are shown for each of the major carriers that service the City. These maps also show the strength of the coverage provided by each site located within the City. The legend provided on each map will enable the user to see the outdoor coverage versus the indoor coverage by carrier. The goal of the wireless carriers is to attain indoor coverage for their users. This will enable individuals to have cellular reception in their home and office. By attaining this coverage the carriers will greatly reduce the coverage holes that are located in the City. 24 City of Tustin Wire%ss Master Plan Study Wireless Infrastructure AT&T Wire%ss AT&T is the largest carrier in the Unites States based on subscribers, it serves 70.1 million individuals. AT&T has the largest digital voice and data network in the network, which is referred to as the ALLOVER network. The ALLOVER network covers the top 100 U.S. markets. AT&T claims to be the leading innovator in the wireless industry, introducing many of the newest technologies including GSM/GPRS, the Apple iPhone, and the Blackberry. Consumers can access high quality videos and music from these new phones, which require greater bandwidth capabilities. With this technology, AT&T has captured some of the fastest growing wireless segments, including youths and Hispanics. The following table lists locations that satisfy AT&T's future needs: Table 1 Pro osed forAT&T Wire%ss Site ID Site Address TUS033 11385 Pioneer Road TUS034 10250 Pioneer Road 25 City of Tustin Wire%ss Master P/an Study Wireless Infrastructure Map 1 AT&T Additional Proposed Coverage i; 26 City of Tustin Wire%ssMasterP/an Study Wireless Infrastructure Map 2 AT&T Existin Covera e / ~ fi, .., i v Wes. M _ ~ .Q ~ E ~~ro~ 27 i~ City of Tustin Wire%ss Master Plan Study Map 3 Wireless Infrastructure nT~T Future coverage 28 i~ City of Tustin ,~ Wire%ss Master Plan Study Map 4 i~ Wireless Infrastructure AT&T Existing Sites and City Pro ~~'` fY ~~ ,~, a, ~ ~- 1 =x c~ Q ~. ' ~ ~, ~, ~ ~~ ~~ f~ ~ 1 ~ ~ ~ V ` r ' ` ~ t ^ , M \ ~ ~ ^ ` ~ ~ ~ ~ v .~._ '~-.= ., ~~ i ~ .. . ? ~ J~ _ t~ ^ -... ,; .. 1 ..- ..._. ~ _ ~ f r T. f y "~ / 29 City of Tustin Wire%ss Master Plan Study Wireless Infrastructure Nexte/ Unlike the Cingular/AT&T merger, Sprint and Nextel remain separate entities. It is unclear if Nextel will brand itself as the merged companies' business focus or target another market segment; nevertheless, they combined their build plans for efficiency. While each build plan is shown separately, Sprint and Nextel will likely co-locate on one another's sites as part of their network enhancements. They will also combine their new site acquisitions through Sprint's name, which is part of their already-underway Synergy network enhancement plan. Table 2 Proposed for Nexte/ Site ID Site,Name TUS033 11385 Pioneer Road TUS034 10250 Pioneer Road 30 City of Tustin Wire%ss Master Plan Map 5 Wireless Infrastructure nextei Aaaitionai Nroaosea covera4e 31 i~ City of Tustin Wire%ss Master Plan Map 6 Wireless Infrastructure Nextel Exlstinq Covera4e R ~ ~ I 3: i~ City of Tustin Wire%ssMasterP/an Study Wireless Infrastructure Map 7 i~ Nextei Future coverage 33 i~ t t City of Tustin Wire%ss MasterP/an Study Wireless Infrastructure Map 8 34 City of Tustin Wire%ssMasterP/an Study Wireless Infrastructure Sprint PCS Sprint PCS recently announced its plans to develop and deploy the first fourth generation (4G) nationwide mobile network. As a large community in the nation's primary mobile market, Sprint PCS will likely enhance its network throughout Orange. It is probable that Sprint PCS will employ clauses in the Nextel's agreements, enhancing its networks within those facilities' bounds. Even so, the higher frequency ranges needed to facilitate 4G technology require additional sites. In 2006 and 2007 Sprint added thousands of cell sites and enhancements to its national wireless network, spending approximately $13 billion dollars. Sprint is aiming to have both networks, Sprint and Nextel, performing at optimum levels with fewer dropped and blocked call while their consumers are using new technology features. The chart below shows locations identified as potential candidates for Sprint's build. We anticipate that, with Nextel's frequency change and Sprint's aggressive live sports video marketing, site demand may exceed this analysis. Table 3 Proposed for Sprint Site ID Site Name TUS021 13602 Parkcenter Lane TUS033 11385 Pioneer Road TUS034 10250 Pioneer Road 35 City of Tustin Wire%ss MasterP/an Study Wireless Infrastructure i; Map 9 Sprint Additional Proposed Coverage 36 i; City of Tustin Wire%ss MasterP/an Study Wireless Infrastructure Map 10 3 City of Tustin Wire%ss Master Plan Study Map 11 Wireless Infrastructure Sprint Future Coverage -. f f/ f m s s, `~- Qj f E ~~~,® ,,.N,,~* ~ ~- _; ~ ,,j.,,,: b ~, `~.,,, d,,..... „.;.~ .,.... ~ .E ~ r, ~ ~ ~/ ~~ - 5; _~.~ ~': s Q a ~ ~~~s`~ _ ?~~ r v ~'.o~ C9~ ~. 4 n 38 ~~ City of Tustin Wipe%ssMaste~P/an Study Wireless Infrastructure Map 12 39 i~ City of Tustin Wire%ss Master Plan T-Mobi/e Wireless Infrastructure T-Mobile is a subsidiary of the German company Deutsche Telekom AG. It entered Southern California's market in 2003, sharing its network with Cingular. As part of Cingular's acquisition of AT&T Wireless (currently AT&T), it sold the portions of its network that were sites acquired from its Pacific Bell acquisition. In order to transition its customers from AT&T (Cingular) sites, T-Mobile plans to enhance its network using an aggressive build plan. T-Mobile's Radio Frequency engineers indicate that its three-year build plan calls for approximately 1,700 sites each year within the Southern California region. With a steady increase in customers from 2006, T-Mobile will need to continue their expansion of sites in order to maintain their awarded achievement of °2007 Highest in Overall Customer Satisfaction with Wireless Retail Service". Table 4 Proposed for T-Mobi/e Site_ID Site Name TUS021 13602 Parkcenter Lane TUS033 11385 Pioneer Road 40 City of Tustin Wire%ss Master P/an Study Wireless Infrastructure i~ Map 13 T-MOUiile Additiional Proposed Coverage 41 City of Tustin Wipe%ss Master Plan Study Map 14 Wireless Infrastructure i -rioni~e txistina c;overaae City of Tustin Wire%ss Master Plan Study Map 15 Wireless Infrastructure T-MOnue Future coverage 43 !R' City of Tustin Wire%ss Master Plan Study Map 16 Wireless Infrastructure and .. i, City of Tustin Wire%ss MasterP/an Study Wireless Infrastructure Verizon Wire/ess Headquartered in Basking Ridge, New Jersey, Verizon Wireless is a joint venture of Verizon Communications and Vodafone. With 54 million customers across the country, Verizon Wireless is second in subscribers only to AT&T. In this market, Verizon is transitioning from the cellular network (800 to 900 MHz) to the PCS network (1800 to 1900 MHz) to prepare for the next generation of products and services. Verizon operates in both the cellular and PCS frequency ranges, the cellular (850 MHz) range reaches further than the higher PCS (1900 MHz) range. For Verizon Wireless to maintain its customer base, especially with new competitors entering the market, it is expected that its build plan will increase dramatically over the following years. In order to compete with other wireless carriers' new services, Verizon Wireless must move to the PCS range, which allows for greater data bandwidths services like streaming video, games and mobile phone Internet access. Table 5 Proposed for Verizon Site IQ__ Site Name..... TUS034 10250 Pioneer Road TUS035 Tustin S orts Park 45 City of Tustin Wire%ss Master Plan Study Wireless Infrastructure Map 17 Verizon Additional Proposed Coverage i~ 46 i~ City of Tustin Wire%ss Master Plan Study Map 18 Wireless Infrastructure verizon Existina coveraae 4; City of Tustin Wire%ss MasterP/an Study Wireless Infrastructure Map 19 verizon ruture coverage 48 b City of Tustin Wire%ss Master Plan Study Map 20 Wireless Infrastructure verizon Existm Sites and G~ ~~ Jr, ~ ~~~ %~. - r ,' ,. f ~.. ~ ~ x ,. _.. ~r ~,. ___ ~:_ , ~ ~. ~,~ ~.~ _, ~,,, ,1 ~ ^' _ -~_ ~~ ~..~ l Y/t ri it .. a. s -. ~ ~ ~~ r ~ ___ _ __._ ~„y C ,, ''~ 'n'~` ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ v N ~ 4A act, ° .~ J ? C ~ r ~ _ ~ ~ CY ~ -. Y .~ a ~.~ ~ ,r- ~~ -~ t~ f'~ ~(} ~;,,; l~ T ~ ~` ~'~, ~ ~ , ~ :;mac:. ~ ~p ., r w.,+ i ~ ~f~..a ` `~/,tn ~, ~ v `~~ : I ~" ~~~ r /per ~ ~. ^.. ~,~~ ~<'~ 0 ty~ ] „~,..c,.~ ~ r~~e ,.~ ( ara~ J _ p~ i,~~ _. \~'1 ~ 'Ed, .~. L f ~ ~ p d T ,~ P t s~ / ~ ~~ y . ~' ~ ~f x .. ~ ~ i ~ ~.~ `> ~ ~.,,~ .„ i a~ ~ i .. rho -~ ;m ul % 1 .~ ~~~ ,. t .. .. _ 1 ._ t ~, ^~ ~ - ~ ~i. tea. '`~ ...,. s ;~ , ,. _ ;:.. ., . N ~..., d ~:.;.. ae. .«. rn N :< r 49 City of Tustin Wire%ss Master Plan Study Wireless Infrastructure Metro PCS Metro PCS offers PSC, or broadband personal communication services, to consumers with no long term contract, a flat rate, and unlimited usage in regards to minutes. Metro PSC has been around since 2002, and it the fastest growing PCS providers in the United States. They provide service to 14 of the 25 large metropolitan cities and their surroundings areas in the country. In 2007 there was widespread news of a merger between Metro PCS and Leap Wireless International. MetroPCS withdrew from the merger in order to focus on realizing it's stand-alone growth opportunities. In 2007 there was a service launch in Los Angeles, and its expected that there will be continued launches by late 2008 or early 2009. Table 6 Proposed for Metro PCS Site ID Site Name TUS021 13602 Parkcenter Lane TUS034 10250 Pioneer Road TUS035 Tustin S orts Park 50 City of Tustin Wire/ess MasterP/an Study Wireless Infrastructure Map 21 Metro PCS Additional Proposed Coverage 5., ,:. r a .~k ~y d ~ ~ i' ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~&' ~ r ~fx~` r e ~ G ~~a~i~ t .air ~ ~ ~ ~ .~" lti 1. .+w+. ~,,. r 51 City of Tustin Wire%ss MasterP/an Study Wireless Infrastructure Map 22 r. „~ k «. ~N Aa s `~ ~t ~ V ~$ ~ /~ 'A ~ ~ s ~ ~ ~ i ~ ~ p f. ~ y { q { f V C igi ~ ~ ~ ($ w-_ ~ m`~ f ~ `~ ~ '4 d~ y¢¢ 7~ " ,1 $ ~ .~ f l t ~.~~.~ ~ + . $ ~, 1) ).z .~~ 8F gY t ~~ r. ~^" >> iw g w t ~ ~~~ ~ # + i i ~ t ~ i ~ d y d ~ h»~^ ^.2~ ~~~ + 7 I` ~" ~ F- § S 7 ~ P ~ 4 } A k_ t } 4 jay ~ 7 ~ 4 ~ ~4 ~~'Tn~ ~ ~ ~ tta3 ~iS+:Y~ t g tk,~ ~`~~ ''`~ S ~ ~ ~ 7 "€-~r i ~~ _ 1 ~ s ~.- { "~ i 1 r t $ "r rtrt~ ~ ~ r i ~ ~ x ~~_ s~ ~-. -. a t y ~ ~. ~ r ~ } }~a ~,~ ~ ~ <._ ~~ ~ 3.~..~ ... 4~ a.-,. , ~ .--i u f P W S j E ~ 9l,ii u ~ a t 'i { r b s~ ~ ~ ~ se 5. •+ 4 C .„„,,,,a ~ ! 3 It ; }i~ # i tt,, ~ F ~ F 1 .~. ~ ~~ ~ ~~~' .{ ~ t i x~ _ ~ ,~.~ } 52 City of Tustin Wire%ss Master Plan Study Map 23 Wireless Infrastructure metro Pcs Future coverage .~ - ,~ t ~ ~; ~fi '~ ~.1 '' ~ ~_~ ,- ' ~ ~ s ` } ~` t y} ~ "~ y . € a ~ '~ ~ 1^i $ ~.. ~ „1 ~~ C ~~ S ~. ~ ~ A t '" ~ ~ .p~~-- ~ 3 ~ ' ' ~ ~ ~ ~ i , ~ E 3 . ^ t ~¢ 1. ... y, ~ ~ [ F 1 p ~ t ~ ~ ~ ~ , eS ~ E7 ~ ~ ~ E j ~ ~ t i ~ € f V '~ a - t~ ~. ~r^Y t ~ ~ ~ ~ i t f ~ 9 ,~i: , t ~ ~ ~ ~~ i 4 F .k ,. . f ~ "~ ~ ~ va ~-~ ~~ . . ~ { ~~ ~ G City of Tustin Wire%ss Master Plan Study Wireless Infrastructure Map 24 54 City of Tustin Wire%ss MasterP/an Study Radio Frequency Analysis Radio Frequency Engineering Methodologies To model and calculate existing carrier coverage, RF engineers used the following assumptions and data: 1. Structure heights are either known or estimated at fifty feet 2. Field-verified Latitudes and Longitudes 3. Carrier antenna orientations are not taken into account during the initial study 4. A theoretical Isotropic (perfectly round globe) 10dBd Omni antenna is used for all propagations 5. Thirty-meter (1 arc sec) terrain elevation data is used for propagation predictions 6. One- and two-meter Satellite Aerial Imagery is used, and thirty-meter (1 arc sec) terrain is used to overlay Aerial Imagery 7. No Clutter data is included as part of the propagation calculations 8. The Longley Rice model is used, with the percentage of time set to 70%, the percentage of location set to 85%, and the margin set at 18 as a conservative correction factor 9. Electrical or mechanical down tilt, sectorization, directional or high gain antennas are not used for this output 10. Signal strength thresholds for the color propagation levels are set to -75dBm Green, -85dBm Blue, -90dBm Yellow, -98dBm Brown and -104dBm Red 11. Receiver threshold limit is set at -104dBm 12. Full transmit power (ERP) is set to twenty Watts at all of the sites' hatch plates, after which typical cable loss is inserted base on structure height to closer model the real life signal losses occurred for each site. 7/8 inch cable was used for the loss calculations with a total of 12ft of 1/2 inch for jumpers 13. Duplexers, surge suppressors and any other connector line are inserted at .8 dB total loss. Total ERPs for all sites ranged between 96 and 141 Watts, with heights ranging from 8 feet to 100 feet 14. Cellular and SMR frequencies are set to 875MHz and PCS at 1960MHz As part of the initial comprehensive cursory analysis, engineers produced propagations for each carrier's on-air site. This study aims to determine the highest probability of each network's reliable coverage, in conjunction with each carrier's ability to pursue its short and long term growth strategies. Since each carrier's actual RF engineered settings were not entered and reproduced, the methods used here generate common predictions for overall systems by using relaxed modeling. Sectorization, directional antennas, downtilts and power were not directly estimated in the modeling per each carrier's actual settings, so this output represents a 'perfect" antenna of equal signal gain of 10 dB. Due to this propagation method, growth strategies should still reflect the probability of areas where carriers may need additional sites for better overall footprint coverage and/or to address capacity issues. However, this data does not confirm areas that have coverage that may not really exist, and vice versa. 55 City of Tustin Wire%ss MasterP/an Study Radio Frequency Analysis Map 1 Traffic Maq, used to consider traffic counts and flow: _- ~.: ~, - ., ~s a ~ .: .:.. ~~ ., ~~ ` ~ -~ ~ i~ j ri - >~ ~ ~ ~~ 000. n ~` ~I a, I l ~ ~ ~ ~ ! ~ itfi t 1 r ~ ,. ~ r ~ ~ ~ ~/~ 1 J~ J ~ ~' = o:a.~~ ~ ~ ~~I (y . ~_ ~' ~ :~ ~ '- ~< o ~ ~ ~ OS~ ~~I W ° ~ ~ " ~ ~'~ ' t .~ ( ~ T `. ,:.,~ - t }., . S ~ -~ irt! ~ ~ r A {.. 4 ~~ .. ~.r~~ - .,.~~ ~`~~. ~ ,Fr i~ ~~ J .`n. ,~~, .. ~b v ] ~ ~ ~a , h b. I ~ 1 k ~~`•: dr ~>> ", M .M ~ y ~' ~ ~ ~p~1,31 °w~, ~ v. N . ~r ~/''`~I ~ ~'I ~~ "t N ~~j'* y~ ~ 5 t='t , ~ j j t`~ t ` _. ~2~v ~lb,• ^~~ ~ ~ ~ ~1 ~ ~ 1 ~ 'Mq ,.\ `r +~l ~ _, I + ~ n9b tf yn A~a 7 q •.~ ~ ~xl Q j/'~ cm ~:yJG W ~ ~ %L rl ~L..,.;_!!!' ~I ~Y '"~ ~i ~ ~ ~ 1 -~lrj F .- i ) O t- t ,~, ..~ <.,~.ii ~ I 1 ~N ~ ~I ~~ r f ,`°d'~ CZ ~I ~ . I si[ ~4t~ ~ ~ ° x 4~ y i S ~ ~1 yr, LlS'!~ ~ ~ ~ Xjl~ l ~~ ,. ~l ~i ,, y s~ ' ~- I v a ~ '~ ~~ ~ N 1.1 ~ ~ Wi ~d > ~<'' ~ ~ y ~3f c ,i L1 _ ~.~.~ -- f ' _ _ ' ~'1-~y- j ~ ~ J y j ~ ~ ~ l rl~ ~a ~~ c0 dll. ~~y ~ . H .: ~ .d'~ ,~ ~ c0~ ~ ~m P ` r `~ I ~~~ I XI-! j S Or N ' ' ~I /I ,'~I TI ~~~I a`c~ ~ ~ ~- ~ ~~` MI Z ,~ i ti` ~ id 4 '~ ~I ~NIMI~I I ~ " ~ `~~5: [ .-- ~.- ~~~ . ~ ~ I ~ W - a..L-L. ~ m - -- ~~-~ ~i ~ _ ~ ~ r w -_ ... ~ _r tn: _a W. 1~7 ~ iQ I 1_ ~i ~' } ~ e w w - ~ , - _ ~ Z - - g i x W~. ~ _ i-'9 r !per °21~ ~ , TI Q~!y ~ ~Q~ ~ y ~- ~, r... _. L ~'f ~~ q`+~, li - j "` I ' ` ~ I.~ 1 y _ . ~..7 LA ~ ~~~ ~~~ ~ ~ {_ ~~i. ~ f ~~~ i 222 N r ~ t 1 f (A r 1 F .. f..". , O~ , , ' L ~ -~ - ~ ~ O 1a~ti ~ ~ .~.:_ ~ ~ ~ - - w ~ ~ i ~ -- ` ~p~ " N _p~. , ; -~` ~ ___s_ `''-i" ~ ~ ~`~`mm~' 7 i..,.. 1~ ~ ~ I ~ b T ~ - ~- ~ k. .,r~ 1~_ ~ ~' _ 4 ~ ~~ ~~f,~~~ `~ fi ~ ` - ~ L " T~ ~ ~ ~ ar~ } N ' moo ~` ___ .- a~ --: O , tip. ; ; !. i . i ., ~ _ -O. _~ ~ ~ ~ __ 38i006,~,/t ~ i O i _~ d ' _'. I_l. LL . ~'~ ~ ftft £~LZyk£ 7 - - r ~- ~ -. 1 +-+ + - ~~t- i-- - j}'{j 11 7(1 t, - i 1+1~ ~ _ ~ ~ g _- ~ { ~ .. T iL~ TI 2Sr 3$-- ~ ~ ~ - ~ - ~ __;,. ~ IL 96 y f ~~i~ tin ~~ N ..: ~-. - -~ ~ ~ i ~~ ~. _. ~.~ ~.. ~~ ~~... "~-. 89 : ~ I s 6Z rn ' _~ ~ - ~ .~ -_ ;~ ~ ~ a , ~~ ~ rDi - _ ~ j~ I ~ --- ~ ~ -- ~---~'- '~ ~-~tII~~- C 1 _ .-_ .. 7_ Q ~ 09 ~- -_ r f,R~ :1 . _._~.~: . - _ ~; . m . ~ .~.i ~ ~ ~ -- i ~ t -a 1-. .. -~ _i ~ 39 000 ~ ~ ` 1 t -~ ~ -- I ' ~ F ~ _ t -- i ~~ r-~ -i i E ~ . a - -11 -~ .._ ; r , ~~ ~. 'r City of Tustin Wire%ssMasterP/an Study Radio Frequency Analysis Map 2 57 City of Tustin Wire%ss Master Plan Study Map 3 Radio Freauencv Analysis 58 City of Tustin Wire%ssMasterP/an Study Radio Frequency Analysis Map 4 Land tvoe man to evaluate land usage for capacity and coverage: City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study Inventory of City Property Inventory of City Property The following table lists all city-owned properties. All properties are initially evaluated as possible wireless facility location candidates. However, parcels are removed from consideration if they exhibit development limitations and can not be considered viable sites to place support structures for wireless antennas and accompanying telecommunications equipment. City properties that are within aquarter-mile of identified coverage gaps are typically proposed as properties to target for development. But this does not prohibited carriers from targeting adjacent private properties that better accommodate coverage needs, leasing terms, or build area. Table 1 Site ID Site Address. Lat Lon TUS001 1472 Service Road 33.723275 -117.826888 TUS002 235 E. Main Street 33.742362 -117.821840 TUS003 245 E. Main Street 33.742091 -117.821683 TUS004 275 E. Main Street 33.742422 -117.821233 TUS005 335 Pros ect Avenue 33.742700 -117.822132 TUS006 18001 Beneta Wa 33.751158 -117.818589 TUS007 14632 Pros ect Avenue 33.750906 -117.821764 TUS010 11921 Simon Ranch Road 33.751360 -117.785758 TUS012 17575 Vandenbur Well 33.758167 -117.825397 TUS014 13161 Yorba Street 33.770879 -117.827082 TUS015 18602 E. 17th Street 33.759124 -117.808717 TUS017 11301 New ort Avenue 33.769138 -117.793548 TUS018 11811 Outlook Lane 33.752229 -117.783083 TUS019 13333 Foothill Blvd. 33.768865 -117.796945 TUS020 13331 Foothill Blvd. 33.768865 -117.796945 TUS021 13602 Park Center Lane 33.730489 -117.803915 TUS022 14722 Devonshire Avenue 33.722062 -117.819263 TUS023 14712 Pros ect Avenue 33.749092 -117.821568 TUS024 1400 Mitchell Avenue 33.732334 -117.818645 TUS025 2350 Kinsman Circle 33.734442 -117.795360 TUS026 13301 M ord Road 33.730628 -117.793438 TUS027 2274 Fi Tree Drive 33.719594 -117.812721 TUS028 McFadden & Pasadena 33.734081 -117.832082 TUS029 230 W. 1st Street 33.745034 -117.825522 TUS030 1402 B an Avenue 33.739328 -117.811208 TUS031 300 Centennial Wa 33.743391 -117.819724 TUS032 200 S. C Street 33.746518 -117.834126 TUS033 11385 Pioneer Road 33.751236 -117.769605 TUS034 10250 Pioneer Road 33.767251 -117.761297 TUS035 12850 Robinson Drive 33.733994 -117.785102 TUS036 18500 E. 17th Street 33.759324 -117.809034 TUS037 14702 N. Pros ect Avenue 33.749766 -117.821746 60 City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study Inventory of City Property Site ID site Address l:at Lon TUS038 14652 N. Pros ect Avenue 33.750402 -117.821761 TUS039 240 E. 3rd Street 33.742831 -117.821615 TUSO40 285 E. Main Street 33.742391 -117.820978 TUSO41 Beneta Wa 33.751311 -117.819444 61 City of Tustin Wire%ss Master Plan Study Inventory of City Property Map 1 Map of City Properties <~ ..., ~'1 ~ . ,.. ~ .. k F... 1 ~ ~ . t _ , _. .. r j ., ' ._ ..~. I ,, ~' ~ ,_ ~ ~ ~ .; .. ' _. m ..... . ~.~ i ~ ' ...: . - p~ ,• , 1 F othdl T §ti ~ ~ u n o s , T : .~ ~ f t ~ ' ~ ~~ ~ J r ~ ~ ~ 4 ~ c~ ~ ~ ~` ~ h a C . . ~ @ 7 1 Yt y P `~` ~ 1yy s. `, ~ ~$ ~ ~,. t N . .~ ~ e , to ,. na ~; ~ ~ ' e ~° `~'crt e , -r~ ~ ~ ~ -~ Tust t Y~ l~r` .. k ' 4 a ~, . '`~ f ~, ,~ , a ~ iq y ~b a < . r r ~ ~ Ml ; ~ ~, ~ q; ' a e . } r. . r s ~ yr~ _ r ~~ t .. , ~ ~~ ~. ;: _ ,~ ~ I ~ i ,. ,-,A.~. ~ .4,~.. „"7 F'~ Be S Y d ~44 i~ fY f ~ ~ .., r ~ ~ .- _W_____ a r i m ~,fAe ~~ l s _. ~ •~ ~~' .. itir)SX.wecf City SitM ~,. City Property Eva/nation & Marketing In order to evaluate city-owned property, all parcels are geo-coded. This information is the minimum profile necessary for initial property marketing. The list of geo-coded properties is immediately available to the carriers for review and enhancement to their wireless network. When evaluating and marketing properties to wireless carriers several factors need to be considered, 1. The ground height's relationship with the surrounding area, the ASML, 2. Suitable height for antennas according to the City's zoning standards, and 3. The carrier's coverage, capacity objectives, customer usage and newly available wireless services 62 City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study Recommendations Design Standards Desian Standards The cell site design standards are presented below with a brief description of the appearance and its typical use. Genera/ Types of Ce//Sites Antennas and Mounting Systems: • Whip antenna -a thin, metal/fiberglass pole that serves as a receiving and transmitting device. Typically, this antenna measures 18 inches to ten feet in length and one-half inch to four inches in diameter. This is typically installed on fire department buildings, police department buildings and city maintenance facilities. • Light standard with flush-mounted antennas -usually found at sports fields with ballpark lighting. The antenna panels are mounted near the pole and under the lights. However, antennas can also be placed within a "stealth" cylinder on top of a light standard. • Flagpole antenna- a slim line monopole with a flag attached. It has a thicker diameter than a typical flagpole. • Monopole - a tall pole topped with a triangular structure to mount the antenna array. This one of the earlier design types used for wireless communications facilities. • Slim-line monopole - a slender pole mounted with afour- to six-foot high radome that has an 18- to 24-inch diameter to conceal the antennas. • Lattice power line towers - a design takes advantage of the existing lattice tower power transmission used by the utility companies. • Water tank - uses apre-existing, above-ground structure to attach antennas. • Monopine - similar to a monopole design pole with simulated bark covering, in addition to simulated branches and pine needles. • Monopalm - covers a monopole design with palm fronds and a growth pod as a means to hide the cell site's antennas. • Monobroadleaf - mimics a broadleaf tree to hide antennas, using the same monopole structure. • Lollypop -consists of a thin pole that holds a panel antenna. It is employed in open space or below the ridgeline in canyons or areas of hilly terrain. Sometimes the antenna is blended with faux or natural vegetation. • Building facade mounted antenna -installed by flush-mounting the antenna to the building's facade and painting it to match the wall's color and texture. In some cases, the antenna is incorporated into or hidden by one of the structure's design elements. • "Stealth" installations - A "stealth" installation include monuments, faux chimney, rooftop parapet, rooftop screen walls, steeple, clock tower, faux rocks, faux water tanks 63 City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study Design Standards Proposed Design Standards We recommend that the City adopt the following design standards into all cell site development guidelines: Antenna Mounting Systems: Whip Antennas • Antennas 18 inches or less in length should be allowed on any existing structure and zone. • Antennas 60 inches or less in length should be allowed on any commercial or industrial building provided that the antenna does not exceed the roof line by more than ten feet • A whip antenna's base should be set back from the roof's edge by a distance equal to its height. Lioht Standards • Allowed in all zones with low profile/flush-mounted antennas and up to 35 feet high • Antennas should be painted to match the light standard and all cables should be concealed within the light standard. • The radome should not exceed 18 inches in diameter and 6.5 feet in height. • New ball field light standards should be subject to conditional use permits, as long as they do not exceed 65 feet in height. Flagpoles • If the pole does not exceed 55 feet in height, and the antenna is concealed inside the pole, they should be allowed in any zone. • The radome must not exceed an 18-inch diameter. • The poles must be able to fly flags. If the flags are U.S. flags that are not removed every day at sunset, the flagpoles must be lit. • The pole diameters should be the minimum necessary to meet engineering requirements to accompany and conceal the inner coaxial cabling. • Different carriers' antennas should be distributed on multiple light poles to minimize the poles' overall diameters. Monopoles • Not allowed, except as'~slim-line" monopoles. • New antenna co-location on existing sites should only be permitted by a conditional use permit . Slim-line monopoles • Antennas and cables should be mounted inside the structures and the radomes exceeding an 18-inch diameter should not be allowed. • The structures' colorings should be light grey, olive green or light blue to better blend in with their backgrounds. Lollypop antenna • Approved only when other "stealth" installation types are more intrusive, such as on steep slopes or hillsides where they attract more attention. • Installed below ridgelines wherever possible to stop the antennas' profiles from appearing above a slope top. • Cross braces between individual antenna poles add additional bulk to the installation, and should be discouraged. 64 City of Tustin wireless Master Plan Study Design Standards • Antennas and their support poles must be painted the appropriate colors that match the surrounding environment. • In cases where irrigation is available, natural shrubs must be planted behind lollypop antennas. • In cases where irrigation is unavailable or impractical, faux shrubs (subject to staff review) are installed to conceal antenna arrays. • All coaxial cables that connect the antennas to their accompanying telecommunications equipment cabinet are run underground. • The antennas' heights from the base do not exceed 15 feet. Building facade mount • Patch (usually 12 inches high) antennas and antennas less than 1.5 square feet in surface area that are mounted to a building facade are covered and painted to match existing facade's color and texture. They are also mounted flush to the building or with low-profile brackets, as well as skirted. The antennas' profile does not extend more than 12 inches from the building facade's face. • Antennas with surface areas greater than 1.5 square feet that are mounted any commercial building's facade are fully screened using materials that match the existing facade's color and texture. • Antenna screening systems must be architecturally integrated to the greatest possible extent. • Antenna screens must be fully enclosed to prevent birds from nesting in the screen structures. • The facade mounted antennas and screening must not exceed 18 inches from the existing building's face and must be designed to the minimum feasible depth. • The structure's walls, conduits, chases or concealment type devices that are integrated into the building's architecture must hide all coaxial cables to the greatest possible extent. All exposed cable is painted to match the underlying surface. Lattice towers • No new types of lattice towers should be allowed. Power line towers • Co-location on existing power line towers should be allowed. • Antennas should be mounted to the vertical portion of the structure, using low- profile mounting brackets. • All pipe-mounts must be concealed behind the antenna. The accompanying coaxial cables should be run on the tower structure's inside. • Accompanying telecommunications equipment should be located under or close to the tower structure. The equipment should be enclosed by a screen. Water tanks • Antennas mounted on the top of the structure should be concealed behind screening that does not exceed six feet. • Antennas, coaxial cables, and screening should be painted to match the color of the structure. 65 City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study Desian Standards Faux tree design specifications: Monopine • Designed for a minimum of two carriers. • Has 3.1 branches per foot for full-density coverage, limiting spacing between the branches. Seventy percent of the branches should be eight feet or longer. • Branch dispersal is random, with intermingled long and short branches, to appear natural. • Branches extend beyond all antennas by at least 12 inches in length. • Branches begin 15 feet above the ground. • A five foot minimum space exists between the top of the antenna and the top of the faux tree. • Branch foliage is multicolored with greens and browns, and matching those of a natural pine tree. The foliage is extruded (made from plastic) in these colors instead of painted. A sample is submitted for City approval prior to fabrication. • A bark cladding sample with custom color is submitted for City approval prior to fabrication. • "Pine needle antenna socks" that match the approved foliage colors cover all antennas. • Antennas are mounted using "stand-off mounts" (horizontal, frame-type mounts are unacceptable). Antennas support pipe mounts, which are painted a darker shade of green or black with a "flat" paint finish that reduces reflection and mounting visibility. • Coaxial cables access the structure through the base. Raised ice bridges or cable trays are unacceptable. • Monopine structure height is forty feet, unless a greater height is authorized. Monopalm • Structure is designed for a minimum of two carriers if possible. • The monopalm structure possesses sufficient palm fronds to simulate a natural palm tree. • The growth pod and/or the monopalm trunk conceals the antennas. • A minimum space of five feet exists between the top of the antenna and the top of the faux tree's palm fronds. • Frond foliage color varies in olive green shades to simulate palm tree colors. A sample palm frond is submitted for City approval prior to fabrication. • Acustom-colored sample of bark cladding is submitted for City approval prior to fabrication. • The tower (trunk) conceals all coaxial cables, which access the structure through the base. Raised ice bridges or cable trays are unacceptable. • The monopalm structure's height is forty feet (tower portion), unless a greater height is authorized. Monobreadleaf • Designed for a minimum of two carriers. • The monobroadleaf structure possesses a sufficient branch count to conceal all antennas. • Branch dispersal is random, with intermingled long and short branches, to appear natural. • Branches exceed all antennas by at least 12 inches. • Branches begin 15 feet above the ground. 66 City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study ian Standards • A minimum space of five feet appears between the top of the antenna and the top of the faux tree. • Branch foliage (leaves) possess varying colored "leaves" to mimic a real broadleaf tree. The foliage is extruded in these colors instead of painted. A sample branch with foliage must be submitted for City approval prior to fabrication. • Acustom-colored sample of bark cladding is submitted for City approval prior to fabrication. • "Leafed antenna socks" that match the approved foliage color must cover all antennas. • Antennas are mounted using "stand-off mounts" (horizontal, frame-type mounts are unacceptable). Antennas conceal support pipe mounts and must be painted a darker shade of green or black with a "flat" paint finish that reduces reflection and mounting visibility. • The tower conceals all coaxial cables, which access the structure through the base. Raised ice bridges or cable trays are unacceptable. • The monobroadleaf structure's height is forty feet, unless a greater height is authorized. "Stealth" antenna Monument • Designed to coincide with environmental conditions. • Installation height allowed for two carriers , or a minimum of 38 feet Faux chimney • Should be allowed, depending upon the extent of the site integration with the existing building's architecture. • The antenna's number, height, width and depth must balance with structure's bulk and scale. • Must not exceed ten feet above the maximum roof height for all buildings. • Must not exceed the maximum roof height of apeak-roofed building. Rooftopparapet application's the existing level-roofed • Installation must be screened, all around, to match existin4 color and texture of parapet • A parapet extension must not exceed five feet above the existing parapet and integrate architectural with the existing building. Rooftop screen wall • Do not exceed ten feet above the maximum roof height for level-roofed buildings. • Walls are screened on all sides. • Walls are set back at least three feet from the roof's edge. • Walls match or complement the building facade's color and texture. Steeple Antennas mounted inside existing steeples can utilize the full space, Must be match the existing structure's color and texture and be fully screened. Any modification to the steeple's outward appearance requires that it be integrated with the overall structural design. 67 City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study Design Standards • New steeple construction on an existing structure is consistent with the current architectural design up to 45 feet (regardless of the zone's underlying height limit). Clock tower • A clock tower installation must be appropriate for the location, • It must be designed for a minimum of two carriers, • The installation is allowed, up to 45 feet in height, depending upon the surrounding environment. • The design is consistent with the environmental setting. Equipment location & screening systems: • All equipment installation types require all coaxial, telephone and electrical cables/wires to be concealed. Equipment vault • Below ground equipment vaults are encouraged for all wireless installations at park facilities, parking lots and wireless facilities in the public right-of-way. Tenant improvement • Tenant improvement is encouraged for all wireless installations on existing buildings, where sufficient space is available within the building's interior. If sufficient space is not available within the existing building structure, equipment room additions are allowed subject to standard building codes. Equipment room addition design is consistent with the existing building's architecture and must be effectively mitigated with the required landscape setbacks. Prefabricated equipment shelter • These shelters are discouraged for most wireless installation applications. Prefabricated equipment shelters can be utilized in commercial areas where the shelter is not visible to any public view. Site constructed equipment shelter • These shelters are encouraged, provided that they are architecturally integrated into the surrounding environment. Equipment shelter heights must not exceed that which is consistent with the adjacent building. Air conditioning condensing units (A/C units) must be located on the ground adjacent to the structure or mounted in the roof. A/C units must be fully screened, and they must not exceed any applicable noise ordinances. Landscape standards also apply. Outdoor telecommunications equipment cabinet • These cabinets must be located within equipment enclosures (except telecommunications equipment in the public right-of-way), with sufficiently high walls that completely conceal the equipment cabinets from public view. Equipment enclosures must have lattice-type covering to prevent unauthorized access. All city screening and mitigation requirements also apply. Rooftop equipment platform • These platforms must be fully screened and, if possible, integrated with a rooftop antenna installation. Equipment screening height must not exceed ten feet above the maximum roof height or level-roofed buildings and others are subject to staff review. 68 City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study Design Standards In evaluating the appropriate design for a particular property, existing uses of the property, landscaping and optimal location of the facility must be considered. As the wireless industry and its services evolve, its equipment will change as well. The WMP will need periodic updates to incorporate the wireless industry's changing environment and the progress made toward "stealthing"antennas and equipment. 69 City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study Proposed Design Considerations Design Considerations In evaluating the identified locations, each of the proposed wireless facilities designs were based the appropriateness to the particular property and the surround environment. This approach seeks to balance designing wireless communication facilities that blend with its surroundings while still providing the necessary locations to provide the needed radio coverage. ATS Communications reviewed each of the targeted City-owned locations proposed for wireless communications facilities. The following pages show the sites along with a brief description as to the suitability of the site based on City staff input and ATS Communications personnel evaluation. 70 City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study Proposed Design Considerations Cedar Grove Park The monopine is an example of a proposed wireless facility that might be considered by the City for Cedar Grove Park. Each site will be evaluated by the City during the design review process for the appropriate application that corresponds to the size and uses on the site and impacts on adjacent property. Before After 71 City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study Proposed Design Considerations Camino Real Park The monopine is an example of a proposed wireless facility that might be considered by the City for Camino Real Park. Other applications may be more appropriate. Each site will be evaluated by the City during the design review process for the appropriate application that corresponds to the size and uses on the site and impacts on adjacent property. Before After 72 City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study Proposed Design Considerations Tustin Sports Park The flush mounted panel antennas are an example of proposed wireless facilities that might be considered in Tustin Sports Park. As stated on page 76, each site will be evaluated by the City during the design review process for the appropriate application that corresponds to the size and uses on the site and impacts on adjacent properly. After 73 City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study Implementation WMP Approva/Process ~ 171p1@C11@tltatlOll Once the City's agencies review and refine the WMP, it is presented to the Planning Commission and City Council for review and approval. Upon approval, the WMP enters its full implementation phase. One of the plan's stated goals is to streamline the City's process for wireless communications facility development. Currently, representatives of the carrier visit the subject site to prepare the submittal application for the city. Once this application is prepared and submitted, the staff compiles their response, including recommendations and/or requests for modifications. The information in the WMP allows the City to control the approval process with the wireless companies and specify criteria for location and design. Promotion & Marketing ATS will take the lead in promoting the City-owned sites depicted within the master plan to the various wireless carriers. As the Wireless Industry continues to evolve, there will be the need to periodically update the WMP. ATS will present this list of City-owned properties to the wireless service providers for their consideration of potential candidates for their future builds. This WMP will be used as a tool to market these properties to the Carriers. Each of the Carriers uses subcontractors to continue the development of their networks. Often these subcontractors come and go. Therefore, a continuous marketing effort is needed to ensure this WMP is implemented and additional City-owned properties are considered for future Master Plan updates. Representatives from the various wireless service providers will use the City's WMP as a guide and submit their proposals in accordance with the City's Zoning Ordinance Section 17.28.070, Antennas on City properlyfor projects subject to the WMP. App/ication Process The process for permit applications meeting the pre-approved design concepts for City properties indentified in the WMP is as follows: • Applicant consults with Planning Staff for conceptual review of project and determination of appropriate permit application. Additional information regarding permit requirements for antennas on City property can be found in the Municipal Code. • Applicant submits required permit application (City Antenna Permit (CAP) or Conditional Use Permit (CUP), application fees, and appropriate exhibits to Community Development Department. In lieu of the application fee, the Planning Division may establish a deposit 74 City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study Implementation account from the applicant to cover the actual cost of staff time to review and analyze the City Antenna Permit application. • Application is reviewed for completeness and identification of issues. • If application is complete, processing begins. Application is then reviewed by all appropriate departments and comments are provided to the applicant. If not complete, application is returned to applicant for resubmission at later date. • The Planning Commission's Design Review Subcommittee shall consider and provide comments on staffs review, analysis and recommendation. • CEQA review is performed by Planning Department (once application is complete). Thirty (30) day review period is provided for comments on environmental documentation, if applicable. • Based upon comments from reviewing departments and Design Review Subcommittee, a recommendation is made to approve with conditions or deny the requested project permit. Refer to the Municipal Code for findings required prior to approval. • Applications consistent with the pre-approved design concepts for City properties indentified in the WMP shall be considered by the City Manager for approval (with conditions) or denial. Project applications not consistent with the pre-approved design concepts for City properties indentified in the WMP shall be considered by the Planning Commission for approval (with conditions) or denial. • Once all applicable appeal periods have expired and no appeals have been filed, or the appeals have been resolved, the applicant may apply for other permits or licenses. • Lease agreement for applicant use of City property is drafted by City Staff. • City Council review and approval/denial of lease agreement. Site Deve%pment Process The next step after marketing the proposed properties to the carrier involves inspecting the site and developing the plans for the build, if the carrier continues to hold an interest in that location. ATS works with the Site Acquisitions personnel from the wireless company and assists them in the feasibility and due diligence process. The Site Acquisition Specialist works on a package to present to the wireless carrier, which is referred to as Site Candidate Information Package, SCIP. Other tasks of ATS during the development process include scheduling and facilitating meetings with the City, communicating with the carrier's RF engineers, and negotiating the terms of the lease on behalf on the City. After the affirmative decision to proceed with a site is concluded the carrier will have site plans and equipment plans drawn up for review by the parties involved. This is formally completed with the documentation of a building application to the City. ATS will review the application 75 City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study Implementation from the carrier for its completion after it is submitted to the City. The application will then go through the standard process review by the City and its departments. Being that the City has control over the execution of the lease as well as the issuance of permits, these steps can be completed simultaneously. There is a concentrated effort by all parties towards the procurement of an executed lease. The due diligence that takes place at this time, which can differ slightly by each carrier, includes ordering a Preliminary Title Report which documents the legal description of the property, receiving a Letter of Intent, and creating a draft lease for review and revisions by the all involved parties. There are a number of items that all parties involved should be aware of when signing the lease. Before this time the lessee and lessor should be acquainted with each other in order to determine that the contract that will be completed without breech. The lease agreement should define the uses of the land; these terms are broadly stated due to the changes in technology and site capacity issues. The rental amount is the greatest variable during negotiations, typically an amount between $1,800 and $2,400 can be received for use of a site, but it varies based on access to alternative sites, current market rates, and geographic locations. The term of the lease is of concern to the carrier and the City for opposing reasons, but should only be considered by the client if the term exceeds 20 years. Other information that should be careful reviewed and negotiated is yearly rent adjustments, access and improvements to the properly, and termination. Expiration ofArchitectura/ E/ementsand Design Standards Wireless facilities have gone through many changes over the last few years. The size of antennas, height necessary for transmission, concealment and other attributes of the operational aspects of the industry have changed. The design and size of equipment will continue to change over the next few years. Taking this into consideration, the design standards discussed and recommended in this document are the most recent concepts offered to date. It is anticipated that this document will evolve over time as the wireless industry changes and that new concepts and design standards will be incorporated as well. In addition, as the demand for more services taking more bandwidth evolves, the design of each wireless carrier's network will change too. The number of cell sites, the height for the antennas, the related equipment and network characteristics will all change. A review of the current "stealthing" technology will occur on an on-going basis. ATS will provide supplemental updates to the WMP every six months or when sufficient changes in technology warrant a change in the WMP. The radio frequency engineering will be updated every 18-24 months based on the new sites deployed throughout the City and the City's property. 76 City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study License Agreement Suggested License Agreement COMMUNICATIONS SITE LICENSE AGREEMENT This License Agreement is made this _ day of 20_ by and between the City of Tustin (hereinafter ""City"), and (hereinafter "Licensee"). 1. GRANT OF LICENSE. City hereby grants a license to Licensee for the purpose of installing and maintaining certain communications equipment consisting of antenna support structure, cable runs, and associated equipment ("Licensee's facilities") together with the non-exclusive right for ingress and egress from and to the nearest public right-of-way, seven (7) days a week, twenty-four (24) hours a day, subject to any restrictions stated herein, on foot or motor vehicle, including trucks, and for the installation and maintenance of utility wires, poles, cables, conduits, and pipes over, under, or along a twelve (12') foot wide right-of-way extending from the nearest public right-of-way, Licensee shall be responsible for installing and maintaining access as required by the City, subject to the limitations set forth in this agreement on that certain real property (the "Premises") owned by City, and more particularly described as follows: 2. TERM. The term of this License Agreement shall be for a term of years commencing upon the date herein above written. 3. LICENSE FEE AND SECURITY DEPOSIT. Licensee shall pay a monthly license fee of $ per month payable to the City of Tustin on the first of each month. The licensee fee shall commence upon the issuance of a building permit, or sixty (60) days after the effective date of the Agreement, whichever occurs first. If the monthly fee is not paid within fifteen (15) days after the due date, and provided Licensee has complied with all applicable notice and cure provisions herein, Licensee agrees to pay a late charge of ten percent (10%) of the then-current monthly fee. Monthly fee amounts attributable to partial months shall be prorated on a daily basis. Monthly fees and deposits shall be made payable to the City of Tustin, c/o Licensee shall post anon-refundable deposit equal to the license fee for three (3) months at the time of the City Council's approval of the Agreement. This non-refundable deposit shall be retained by the City even if the Licensee fails to commence construction of the facility. 4. ANNUAL RENTAL INCREASES. Monthly payments shall be subject to an annual rental increase of four percent (4%) per year, to be increased on each anniversary of the effective date of this Agreement year for the initial term of the agreement (which should not exceed ten or fifteen years). Any succeeding term needs to go through the re-evaluation of value suggested in comments to Section 5 below. 5. LICENSE AGREEMENT EXTENSIONS. This License Agreement may be extended by the City Manager or the City Manager's designee at its discretion upon terms and conditions mutually agreeable to the parties to this Agreement. Licensee shall have the option of extending this license for _ period(s) for terms of _ years. The monthly licensee fee shall be the greater of the then market value for comparable fees for wireless facilities as may be reasonably determined by the City Manager or the City Manager's designee or the existing licensee fee as adjusted on an annual basis as described in Section 4 of this license. 6. GOVERNMENTAL APPROVALS. It is understood and agreed that Licensee's ability to use the Premises is contingent upon its obtaining all of the certificates, permits and other approvals (collectively the "Governmental Approvals") that may be required to comply with Federal and State Building and Safety Codes including but not limited to the California Building Code and International 77 City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study License Agreement Construction Codes, and City zoning and building codes as appropriate, including any applicable discretionary land use permits such as site plan or use permit requirements. The Licensee may be required by the City to provide other information in the planning process such as site plans, design concepts and photo simulations of the structural plans. Licensee shall have the right (but not the obligation) to enter the Premises for the purpose of making necessary inspections and engineering surveys (and soil tests where applicable) and other reasonably necessary tests (collectively "Tests") to determine the suitability of the Premises for Licensee's Facilities and for the purpose of preparing for the construction of Licensee's facilities. In the event that any of such applications for such Governmental Approvals should not be approved or any Governmental Approval issued to Licensee is canceled, expires, lapses, or is otherwise withdrawn or terminated by the governmental authority are found to be unsatisfactory so that Licensee will be unable to use the Premises for its intended purposes, Licensee and agents representing the Licensee shall have the right to terminate this Agreement. Notice of Licensee's exercise of its right to terminate shall be given to City in writing by personal service, or first class mail, and if mailed, shall be effective upon the mailing of such notice by Licensee. All monthly licensee fees including security deposit paid prior to said termination date shall be retained by the City. Upon such termination, this Agreement shall become null and void and all the Parties shall have no further obligations, including the payment of money, to each other. 7. LICENSEE'S USE OF PREMISES. Following City's approval of Licensee's facilities plans and specifications, Licensee may use the Premises for mobile/wireless communications services, including transmission and reception of radio communication signals on various frequencies providing there is no conflict with the_primary purpose of the City-owned property or City communication activities including, but not limited to, emergency service responders serving the City (e.g., the City's Police communication system, the Orange County Fire Authority communication system, and other emergency communication systems). Accordingly, Licensee shall have the responsibility to construct, maintain, install, repair, and operate on the Premises radio communications facilities, including but not limited to, radio frequency transmitting and receiving equipment, batteries, utility lines, transmission lines, radio frequency transmitting and receiving antennas and supporting structures and improvements. Notwithstanding the foregoing, once the initial improvements are installed, Licensee shall, as is necessary, replace, substitute, upgrade and expand its equipment, cables and antennas which comprise Licensee's Facilities in the repair and upgrading the physical structure or communications capabilities of the facilities, so long as the equipment, cables or antennas remain within the original physical parameters of the Premises and are consistent with City approved building permit plans and specifications. Licensee with be responsible for notifying the City as described in this Section prior to entering the premises. Licensee shall be responsible for the cost of any and all damage to City-owned property including but not limited to turf, concrete and/or asphalt, buildings and/or apprentices caused by Licensee regardless of negligence. The City at its discretion may require Licensee to repair and/or replace said damages or contract for said services and invoice Licensee. Licensee invoices must be paid within thirty (30) days of receipt of the invoice from the City. Invoices not paid within thirty (30) days of receipt will be subject to a interest cost of 1.50% per month on the outstanding balance. The Security Deposit shall not be used by the Licensee as a repair reserve fund. Licensee shall install any warning signs on or about the Premises required by federal, state or local law, subject to prior notice to and consent of City, which consent shall not be unreasonably withheld. Licensee shall provide notification to the City five (5) days prior to any work on the Licensee's Facilities conducted by the Licensee or its agents. Said work and work hours are subject to approval by the City. Any work or repair of an emergency nature will require the Licensee to provide notification by telephone the City of Tustin, Police Department's Watch Commander at 714.573.3200. Licensee in providing regular maintenance to the facility shall provide twenty-four (24) hour notice to the City prior to commencing any maintenance that would interfere with the use of City facilities or scheduled events. Said maintenance and work hours shall be subject to review and approval by the City. 78 City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study License Agreement 8. INDEMNITY. To the maximum extent permitted by law, Licensee shall defend, with counsel acceptable to Licensor, indemnify, and save harmless Licensor and its officers, employees, and agents from, and shall pay all costs, expenses and reasonable attorney's fees for all trial and appellate levels and post judgment proceedings in connection with, any and all claims and demands, actions, proceedings, losses, liens, costs and judgments of any kind and nature whatsoever, including expenses incurred in defending against legal actions, for death or injury to persons or damage to property and for civil fines and penalties to the extent arising out of the occupation or use of the Premises by Licensee, its employees, agents, servants, guests, invitees, contractors, or sublessees, including the following: a. Any dangerous, hazardous, unsafe or defective condition, in or on the Premises, of any nature whatsoever, which may exist by reason of any act, omission, neglect, or any use or occupation of the Premises by Licensee, its officers, agents, employees, sublessees, licensees or invitees from commencement of the term of the License; b. Any operation conducted upon or any use or occupation of the Premises by Licensee, its officers, agents, employees, sublessees, licensees or invitees under or pursuant to the provisions of this License or otherwise; c. Any act, omission, or negligence of Licensee its officers, agents, employees; d. The loss of, or damage to any property of Licensee by theft or otherwise; e. Any failure of Licensee, its officers, agents, employees or sublessees to comply with the terms or conditions of this License or any applicable federal, state, regional or municipal law, ordinance, rule or regulation related to the use or occupancy of the Premises. 9. INSURANCE. Licensee shall provide, or cause its member(s) or contractor(s) to provide, and maintain at its own expense during the term of the work the following insurance covering all work under this License. Such insurance shall be provided with insurers authorized to do insurance business in the State of California, with a rating of at least A, VII or better or A-, X (if offered by a surplus line carrier) according to the latest Best's Key Rating Guide, except that the City will accept Workers Compensation Insurance rated B-VIII or better or from the State Compensation Fund. Evidence of such insurance in the form of Certificates and signed Insurer Endorsements shall be delivered to the Licensor prior to commencing with work. The signed Insurer Endorsements (or a copy of the policy binder, if applicable) shall specifically identify the work and shall provide that (1) said insurance shall not be cancelled, except if Licensor is given at least thirty (30) days advance written notice of any cancellation or termination of insurance; (2) commercial general liability insurance shall be primary to and not contributing with any other insurance maintained by Licensor, and shall name Licensee and any subcontractors, the City and any related entity of the City, as appropriate, as additional insureds, and shall provide that all losses shall be payable notwithstanding any act or failure to act or negligence of Licensor, or any other person; (3) shall contain a provision that the insurer waives any right of subrogation against the City insured parties which may arise by reason of any payments made under a policy; and (4) if Licensee is self insured for Workers Compensation, Licensee shall submit to Licensor a copy of its certification of self insurance. All insurance shall be maintained on an occurrence basis and shall include the following: a. Commercial General Liability Insurance. Commercial general liability and property damage insurance covering the Premises, including automobile liability insurance, contractual, broad form property damage, and bodily injury or death, with a combined single limit of not less than $1,000,000 per occurrence with respect to personal injury or death, and $1,000,000 per occurrence with respect to property damage. b. Workers' Compensation Insurance. To the extent that Licensee has employees, workers' compensation insurance in an amount and form meeting all applicable requirements of the California Labor Code, covering all employees of Licensee and all risks to such persons. 79 City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study License Agreement c. Deductibles. All insurance limits shall be without deduction, provided that the City may permit a deductible amount in those costs where, in its judgment, such a deduction is justified. d. Subcontractors. Licensee shall include all of its subcontractors as insured under its policies or shall furnish separate certificates and endorsements for insurance maintained by each subcontractor. All coverages for subcontractors shall be subject to all of the requirements stated herein. e. Verification of Coverage. The insurer endorsements required herein are to be signed by a person authorized by that insurer to bind coverage on its behalf. All endorsements are to be received and approved by City before Licensee execution of the Agreement. f. Vehicle Insurance. Licensee shall maintain sufficient automobile liability insurance on any vehicle accessing the Licensed premises and such insurance shall be in the amount of $1,000,000 per accident for bodily injury and property damage. 10. CITY'S USE OF PREMISES. Notwithstanding this grant of License right to Licensee, City shall have the right to conduct City Business on the Premises. Nothing in the Agreement shall impair or impact the ability of the City or the public to use any area adjacent or near the Premises for any lawful purpose. "City Business" shall include, but not be limited to the following: maintenance, landscaping, construction, concessionaires, and City sponsored events, located on or near the Premises, so long as the City Business does not interfere with or impair the operation of Licensee's Facilities. 11. MISCELLANEOUS LICENSEE RESPONSIBILITIES. A. Licensee shall comply with all present and future laws, orders and regulations relating to Maximum Permissible Exposure ("MPE") and other related health issues directly applicable to its operation of Licensee's Facilities, as well as the American National Standards Institute (ANSI) standards. Without limiting the provisions of Licensee's indemnity contained herein, Licensee, on behalf of itself and its successors and assigns, shall indemnify City, its officials, officers, and employees from and against all claims of personal injuries due to violation of MPE to the extent such personal injuries are actually caused by Licensee's Facilities on the Premises. B. Licensee shall maintain its Facilities and shall make all repairs to the Premises necessitated to keep the Premises clean, safe, and a condition that approximates the initially installed Facilities including landscaping and exterior finishes. City may require Licensee to make repairs to and/or replace damaged equipment of Licensee's Facilities and/or any parts thereto regardless of fault (including but not limited to damage caused by vandalism or acts of god not later than one (1) week after said damage is reported to Licensee, except for damage cause by City, its employees, agents, contractors or volunteers. This time period may be extended with written authorization from the City. In the event such authorization is not given and repairs are not made in one week, City may cause such repairs to be made including making said repairs and/or hiring a contractor to make said repairs. City may charge Licensee for the cost of said services. Damage caused by graffiti shall be removed within forty-eight (48) hours notification to Licensee by City. If said graffiti is not removed within the 48-hour period, City may remove said graffiti and bill Licensee for the cost of services. C. Licensee is responsible for all personal property taxes assessed directly against its property including equipment. D. Licensee shall obtain, at its expense, utilities for the operation of its Facilities. Licensee will install a separate meter for the measurement of its power and will pay for utilities used by the Licensee. E. Licensee shall not interfere or cause to interfere with activities on adjacent City-owned sites including sports activities and cultural events. Licensee shall notice the City pursuant to Section 7 of this Agreement regarding maintenance, repair and installation work. 80 City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Sfudy License Agreement 12. EMERGENCY USE OF SITE. In cases of emergency, Licensee shall make available to the City police, fire and emergency services a location for City's communication equipment on Licensee's facilities at no cost to City. The City is responsible for maintaining its own equipment. The space to be made available will not create interference with Licensee's communications operations. The City entities will be afforded 24- hour access to its equipment at the Premises. In addition, the City will be provided "power backup" by Licensee at the Premises. 13. INTEGRATION. It is agreed and understood that this Agreement contains all agreements, promises and' understandings between the City and Licensee and that no verbal or oral agreements, promises or understandings shall be binding upon either the City or Licensee in any dispute, controversy or proceeding at law, and any addition, variation or modification to this Agreement shall be void and ineffective unless made in writing and signed by the Parties. In the event any provision of the Agreement is found to be invalid or unenforceable, such finding shall not affect the validity and enforceability of the remaining provisions of this Agreement. The failure of either Party to insist upon strict performance of any of the terms or conditions of this Agreement or to exercise any of its rights under the Agreement shall not waive such rights and such Party shall have the right to enforce such rights at any time and take such action as may be lawful and authorized under this Agreement, either in law or in equity. 14. GOVERNING LAW. This Agreement and the performance thereof shall be governed, interpreted, construed, and regulated by the laws of the State of California, with venue in Orange County. 15. ATTORNEYS' FEES. The substantially prevailing party in any legal action or lawsuit arising hereunder shall be entitled to its reasonable attorneys' fees and court costs, including appeals, if any. 16. ASSIGNMENT. Licensee shall not assign, transfer or sub-let any right or interest in this Agreement without written approval of the City Manager or the City_Manager's designee, which such approval shall not be unreasonably be withheld provided, however, that Licensee may assign its interest to its parent company, any subsidiary or affiliate of it or its parent company or to any successor-in-interest or entity acquiring more than fifty percent (50%) of its stock or assets, subject to any financing entity's interest, if any, in this License. Upon assignment, Licensee shall be relieved of all future performance, liabilities, and obligations under this License Agreement, provided that the assignee assumes all of Licensee's obligations herein. 17. NOTICES. Any notice required to be given under this Agreement may be provided by personal service or first class mail, postage prepaid, as follows: To City: City Manager City of Tustin To Licensee: 81 City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study License Agreement 18. DEFAULT. In the event there is a default by Licensee respect to any of the provisions of this Agreement or its obligations under it, including the payment of the monthly license fee, the City shall give the defaulting party written notice of such default. After receipt of such written notice, the Licensee shall have ten (10) days in which to cure any monetary default and thirty (30) days in which to cure any non-monetary default. The City, at its sole discretion, will grant an extension of time on the cure period if the nature of the cure is such that it reasonably requires more than thirty (30) days and the Licensee commences to cure within the thirty (30) day period and thereafter continuously and diligently pursues the cure to completion to the satisfaction of the City. If the City commences an action against the Licensee arising out of or in connection with this Agreement, the City, if found to be the prevailing party shall be entitled to have and recover from the losing party reasonable attorney's fees and costs of suit. 19. LICENSEE'S COMPLIANCE WITH ENVIRONMENTAL LAWS. A. Licensee shall not bring any Hazardous Materials onto the Premises, except for those contained in its back-up power batteries and common materials used in telecommunications operations. "Hazardous Materials" shall mean any substance, chemical or waste identified as hazardous, toxic or dangerous in any applicable federal, state or local law or regulation, including petroleum and asbestos. Licensee will treat and dispose of any Hazardous Materials brought onto the Premises/Property by it in accordance with all federal, state and local laws and regulations. B. Licensee will be responsible for all obligations of compliance with any and all environmental and industrial hygiene laws, including any regulations, guidelines, standards, or policies of any governmental authorities regulating or imposing standards of liability or standards of conduct with regard to any environmental or industrial hygiene conditions or concerns as may now or at any time hereafter be in effect, that are or were in any way related to activity now conducted in, on, or in any way related to the Premises. 20. CASUALTY. In the event of damage by fire or other casualty to the Premises that cannot reasonably be expected to be repaired within sixty (60) days following same or, if the Property is damaged by fire or other casualty so that such damage may reasonably be expected to disrupt Licensee's operations at the Premises for more than sixty (60) days, then Licensee may at any time following such fire or other casualty, provided City has not commenced -the restoration required to permit Licensee to resume its operation at the Premises, terminate this Agreement upon twenty (20) days written notice to the City. Any such notice of termination shall cause this Agreement to expire with the same force and effect as though the date set forth in such notice were the date originally set as the expiration date of this Agreement and the parties shall make an appropriate adjustment, as of such termination date, with respect to payments due to the other under this Agreement. If Licensee decides not to terminate this Agreement, Rent shall be abated proportionally to the reduction of use. 21. SURVIVAL. The provisions of the Agreement relating to indemnification from one Party to the other Party shall survive any termination or expiration of this Agreement. Additionally, any provisions of this Agreement, which require performance subsequent to the termination, or expiration of this Agreement shall also survive such termination or expiration. 22. TERMINATION. A. Compelled Termination. If, during the license term, there is a determination made pursuant to an unappealable order of a county, state, or national governmental health agency having proper jurisdiction over Licensee's operations that Licensee's use of the Premises poses a human health hazard which cannot be remedied and that Licensee must cease all operations on the Premises, then Licensee shall immediately cease all operations on the Premises and this Agreement shall terminate as of the date of such order. In the event the Federal Communications Commission, or any successor agency, makes a determination which is final and non-appealable or which is affirmed and becomes final after the exhaustion of all available appeals concluding that Licensee's use as set forth in this Agreement presents a material risk to the public health or safety and that Licensee must cease all operations on the Premises, City may terminate this Agreement upon fourteen (14) days notice to Licensee. 82 City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study License Agreement B. Termination by Licensee. Licensee may terminate this Agreement by notice to City if (i) Licensee does not obtain all permits, consents, easements, non-disturbance agreements or other approvals (collectively "approval") reasonably desired by Licensee or required from any. governmental authority or any third party related to or reasonably necessary to operate, install, maintain, replace, or remove Licensee's Facilities, or if any such approval is canceled, expires or is withdrawn or terminated without any fault of Licensee, or (ii) the Property or Licensee's Facilities are, or become, unacceptable under Licensee's design or engineering specifications for Licensee's Facilities or the communications system to which Licensee's Facilities belong, so long as Licensee pays City a termination fee equal to six (6) months rent or (iii) Licensee fails to cure a default. Upon termination, all prepaid rent shall be retained by City. C. Termination by City. City may terminate this Agreement if Licensee fails to: 1) perform any of its obligations pursuant to this Agreement and the City has followed the default provisions in Section 18 or 2) Licensee has failed to obtain required permits for operating the facilities or 3) the City and Licensee fail to agreement upon a Relocation Site in accord with Section 23 of this Agreement. City may terminate this Agreement upon fourteen (14) days notice to Licensee. 23. RELOCATION RIGHT. A. Anytime after the expiration of the original term, the City shall have the right to relocate Licensee's Facilities to alternate space; to be performed by Licensee or its agents, at the Licensee's sole cost, to be done in accordance with subsections B and C below. Upon relocation of Licensee's Facilities, the access and utility rights-of-way will be relocated as required, in the sole discretion of City, to operate and maintain Licensee's Facilities. Any relocation of the Licensee's facilities shall be consistent the California Public Utilities Code Section 7901 and other sections of the Public Utilities Code as applicable. B. City shall exercise its relocation right under subsection A above by (and only by) delivering written notice (the "Notice") to Licensee. In the Notice, City shall propose an alternate site within or on the Property to which Licensee may relocate Licensee's Facilities. Licensee shall have sixty (60) days from the date it receives the Notice to evaluate City's proposed relocation site, during which period Licensee shall have the right to conduct tests to determine the technological feasibility of the proposed relocation site. If Licensee fails to approve of such proposed relocation site in writing within the sixty-day period, Licensee shall be deemed to have disapproved such proposed relocation site. If Licensee disapproves such relocation site, then City may thereafter propose another relocation site by Notice to Licensee in the manner set forth above. If the City and Licensee fail to find an alternative site for relocation within twelve (12) months of the Notice being delivered by the City, the License shall be terminated pursuant Section 22, Termination. Licensee shall have a period of not more than twelve (12) months after execution of a written agreement between the parties concerning the location and dimensions of the Relocation Site to relocate Licensee's Facilities to the Relocation Site. Upon relocation of Licensee's Facilities to the Relocation Site, all references to the Premises herein shall be deemed to be references to the Relocation Site. City and Licensee agree that the Relocation Site (including the access and utility right of way) may be surveyed by a licensed surveyor at the sole cost of Licensee, and such survey will then replace Exhibit "B" and become a part hereof and will control or describe the Premises. Except as expressly provided, City and Licensee hereby agree that in no event will the relocation of Licensee's Facilities, or any part thereof, under subsection A above, affect, alter, modify or otherwise change any of the terms and conditions of this Agreement. 24. CONDITION OF PREMISES AT TIME OF TERMINATION. Upon termination of this Agreement, Licensee shall within thirty (30) days remove all of its facilities and all personal property and restore the licensed premises, as defined in this Agreement, to a condition satisfactory to the City. City acknowledges that all of the equipment and personal property of Licensee shall remain the personal property of Licensee and shall not be deemed fixtures, and Licensee shall have the right to remove such facilities. City may, at its sole discretion, agree to provide reasonable additional time to remove facilities. In such event, Licensee shall pay the monthly license fee as adjusted upward by one-hundred percent 83 City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study License Agreement (100%) until such time as the facilities and personal property are removed. In the event, the Licensee fails to remove the facilities and personal property as requested by the City, the City may remove the facilities and personal property at the cost of the Licensee. 25. NON-INTERFERENCE WITH PUBLIC COMMUNICATIONS SYSTEMS. A. Non-Interference with Public Safety Communication Systems: Before activating Licensee's facility, the Licensee shall submit to apost-installation test to confirm that the "planning and frequency coordination" of the facility was successful in not interfering with the City of Tustin's Public and Safety radio equipment. The test will be conducted by the Communications Division of the Orange County Sheriff-Coroner Department or aDivision-approved contractor at the expense of the applicant. This post-installation testing process shall be repeated for every proposed frequency addition and/or change to confirm the intent of the "frequency planning" process has been met. Licensee shall provide a 24-hour phone number to which interference problems may be reported. To ensure continuity on all interference issues the name, telephone number, fax number, and a-mail address of a "single point of contact" in its Engineering and Maintenance Departments shall be provided to the City's designated representative upon activation of the facility." B. Notes to be Added to Licensee's Submitted Plans: "Licensee recognizes that the frequencies used by the wireless facility located at are close to the frequencies used the City of by Tustin for public safety. This proximity will require extraordinary "comprehensive advanced planning and frequency coordination" engineering measures to prevent interference, especially in the choice of frequencies and radio ancillary hardware. This is encouraged in the "Best Practices Guide" published by the Association of Public-Safety Communication Officials-International, Inc. (APCO) and as endorsed by the Federal Communications Commission (FCC). Prior to the issuance of any permits to install the facility, Licensee shall meet in good faith to coordinate the use of frequencies and equipment with the Communications Division of the Orange County Sheriff-Coroner Department to minimize, to the greatest extent possible, any interference with the Public Safety 800 MHz countywide Coordinated Communications System (CCCS). Similar consideration shall be given to any other existing or proposed wireless communications facility that may be located on the subject property. The Licensee shall provide a 24-hour phone number to which interference problems may be reported. To ensure continuity on all interference issues the name, telephone number, fax number, and a-mail address of a "single point of contact" in its Engineering and Maintenance Departments shall be provided to the City's designated representative upon activation of the facility." 26. MISCELLANEOUS PROVISIONS. A. Each undersigned represents and warrants that its signature herein below has the power, authority and right to bind their respective parties to each of the terms of this Agreement, and each party shall indemnify the other fully, including reasonable costs and attorney's fees, for any injuries or damages incurred in the event that such authority or power is not, in fact, held by the signatory or is withdrawn. B. City shall have the right to inspect Licensee's facilities by providing at least 24 hours advance notice to Licensee, except in cases of emergency. C. To the extent any possessory interest taxes are imposed with respect to the use of the Premises herein, Licensee shall have the sole responsibility to pay such taxes. D. Time is of the essence with respect to any act to be performed under this Agreement. 84 City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study License Agreement IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have executed this Agreement the date and year first above written. ATTEST: By: City Clerk APPROVED AS TO FORM: By: City Attorney LICENSEE: By: CITY OF TUSTIN By: Mayor 85 City of Tustin wireless Master Plan Study Site Application Wireless Communication Facility Site Application WIRELESS TELECOMMUNICATION APPLICATION Required for all New/ Existing Wireless Telecommunication Facilities The purpose of this form is to ensure that the goals and objectives outlined in the City's Wireless Master Plan Study dated April 2007 will be met with each submitted project. Specifically, this form shall be used to ensure each application for installation of or modification to wireless communication infrastructure within the City demonstrates that reasonable design and site location alternatives have been explored and evidence of such is presented to the approving authority prior to the final tower, location, and design being approved. An application shall not be deemed complete nor processed until the entire application is submitted in full and accepted by the City staff. Any requisite Public Hearing will be scheduled only after acceptance of the application as complete. Location: Proposed Cell Carrier: Existing Cell Carrier(s): New Build: Property Owner: Cell Site Design: Modified Build: Height: Material: Color: Antenna Diameter: Height of adjacent building, structures, and trees: Parabolic/ Microwave dish (Y/N): Aesthetic mitigation measures: 86 City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study Site Application Proposed site co-locatable (Y/N): Explain: Describe site access to antennas: Alternative cell site design(s): Explain why the proposed design is preferred over the alternative design: Equipment: Location of the proposed equipment (and existing equipment, if applicable): Size: Enclosure material: Proposed screening material: Site access to equipment: Aesthetic mitigation measures: Height of enclosure: Applicant Signature Tony Ingegneri ATS Communications Square Feet: Interior/ Exterior: Date Date 87 City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study Existing Inventory Appendix "A" Inventory of Wireless Communications Facilities Table 1 Pa a Site # Address Carrier T e of build 100 TUS-01 36 Auto Center Dr. Nextel Mono ole 101 TUS-02 14861 Franklin Ave. Nextel Mono alm 102 TUS-03 14711 Sinclair Circle S rint PCS Mono alm 103 TUS-04 14451 M ord Road T-Mobile Mono ole 104 TUS-05 2721 Michelle Dr Verizon Mono ole 105 TUS-06 2631 Michelle Dr. AT&T Mono ole 106 TUS-07 12850 Robinson Dr. AT&T Li ht Standard 107 TUS-08 12850 Robinson Dr. T-Mobile Li ht Standard 108 TUS-09 12850 Robinson Dr. S rint PCS Li ht Standard 109 TUS-10 1452 Edin er Ave. T-Mobile Roof Mount -Stealth 110 TUS-11 1452 Edin er Ave. Nextel Roof Mount 111 TUS-12 15201 Woodlawn Ave. S rint PCS Mono ine 112 TUS-13 15201 Woodlawn Ave. Metro PCS Mono ine 113 TUS-14 320 W.6th St. AT&T Mono ole 114 TUS-15 600 W. 6th St. T-Mobile Mono ole 115 TUS-16 550 W. 6th St. Nextel Mono alm 116 TUS-17 18231 Irvine Blvd. Nextel Roof Mount -Stealth 117 TUS-18 18062 Irvine Blvd. T-Mobile Roof Mount 118 TUS-19 1171 EI Camino Real Verizon Mono ole 119 TUS-20 1450 EI Camino Real T-Mobile Si n Mount -Stealth 120 TUS-21 17821 17th St. T-Mobile Roof Mount -Stealth 121 TUS-22 17821 17th St. S rint PCS Roof Mount -Stealth 122 TUS-23 12711 New ort Ave. Metro PCS Roof Mount -Stealth 123 TUS-24 730 EI Camino Wa S rint PCS Roof Mount -Stealth 124 TUS-25 900 W. 1st St. S rint PCS Si n Mount -Stealth 125 TUS-26 13931 Carroll Wa T-Mobile Fa ade Mount 126 TUS-27 13931 Carroll Wa Verizon Roof Mount 127 TUS-28 14081 Yorba St. AT&T Roof Mount -Stealth 128 TUS-29 17592 17th St. Nextel Roof Mount -Stealth 129 TUS-30 1671 EI Camino Real S rint PCS Ke Inn Tower -Stealth 130 TUS-31 3097 Edin er Ave. T-Mobile Clock Tower -Stealth 131 TUS-32 3057 Edin er Ave. AT&T Roof Mount -Stealth 132 TUS-33 1421 Edin er Ave. AT&T Roof Mount -Stealth 133 TUS-34 15101 Red Hill Ave. Verizon Roof Mount -Stealth 134 TUS-35 11010 Jamboree Road Verizon Li ht Standard 135 TUS-36 10200 Pioneer Road T-Mobile Li ht Standard 136 TUS-37 13814 Red Hill Ave AT&T Mono ole 137 TUS-38 15991 Red Hill Ave. Nextel Roof Mount -Stealth 88 City of Tustin wireless Master Plan Study Existing Inventory 138 TUS-39 14642 New ort Ave. T-Mobile Fa ade Mount 225 W. Main St. Metro PCS Pendin A 3057 Edin er Ave. Metro PCS Pendin A Jamboree Rd. & Portola Pk Verizon Pendin A 11385 Pioneer Road Metro PCS Pendin A 300 Centennial Wa Verizon Pendin A 14712 Pros ect Ave. Verizon Pendin A 89 City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study Existing Inventory 36 Auto Center Dr. .~ r Last Update: January 2008 Site Name: Peters Canyon Site Number: TUS-01 Coordinates: Lat:33.725895 Long: -117.802942 Coord. System: ^ NAD83 Site Address: 36 Auto Center Drive Tustin, CA. 92782 Site County: Orange Property Type: Commercial Elevation: 79' (AMSL) Structure Ht: 50' (AGL) Tower Type: Monopole Existing Carrier : Nextel RAD Height: 50' Line of Sight: Yes - 360 degrees Connectivity: Telco - Pac Bell 90 Site View Aerial view City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study 14861 Franklin Ave. Existing Invento Last Update: February 2008 Site Name: Public Storage Site Number: TUS-02 Coordinates: Lat:33.713128 Long: -117.812478 Coord. System: ^ NAD83 Site Address: 14861 Franklin Avenue Tustin, CA. 92780 Site County: Orange Property Type: Storage Facility Elevation: 55' (AMSL) Structure Ht: 50' (AGL) Tower Type: Monopalm Existing Carrier: Nextel RAD Height: 50' Line of Sight: Yes - 360 degrees Connectivity: Telco - Pac Bell Aerial view 91 Site View City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study Existing Inventory 14711 Sinclair Road Last Update: January 2008 Site Name: Ario Site Number: TUS-03 Coordinates: Lat:33.713726 Long: -117.806585 Coord. System: ^ NAD83 Site Address: 14711 Sinclair Circle Tustin, CA. 92780 Site County: Orange Property Type: Commercial Elevation: 62' (AMSL) Structure Ht: 50' (AGL) Tower Type: Monopalm Existing Carrier: Sprint PCS RAD Height: 50' Line of Sight: Yes - 360 degrees Connectivity: Telco - Pac Bell Aerial view 92 Site View City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study Existing Inventory 14451 Myford Road rti. ,_ Last Update: January 2008 Site Name: AT&T III Site Number: TUS-04 Coordinates: Lat:33.716614 Long: -117.803462 Coord. System: ^ NAD83 Site Address: 14451 Myford Road Tustin, CA. 92780 Site County: Orange Property Type: Commercial Elevation: 66' (AMSL) Structure Ht: 40' (AGL) Tower Type: Monopole Existing Carrier : T-Mobile RAD Height: 40' Line of Sight: Yes - 360 degrees Connectivity: Telco - Pac Bell Aerial view 93 Site View City of Tustin wireless Master Plan Study Existing Inventory 2721 Michelle Dr. Last Update: January 2008 Site Name: Allied Site Number: TUS-O5 Coordinates: Lat:33.720571 Long: -117.799499 Coord. System: ^ NAD83 Site Address: 2721 Michelle Drive Tustin, CA. 92780 Site County: Orange Property Type: Commercial Elevation: 72' (AMSL) Structure Ht: 50' (AGL) Tower Type: Monopole Existing Carrier: Verizon Wireless RAD Height: 50' Line of Sight: Yes - 360 degrees Connectivity: Telco - Pac Bell Aerial view 94 City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study 2631 Michelle Drive Existin4 Inve Last Update: January 2008 Site Name: Storage Site Number: TUS-06 Coordinates: Lat:33.722214 Long: -117.800213 Coord. System: ^ NAD83 Site Address: 2631 Michelle Drive Tustin, CA. 92780 Site County: Orange Property Type: Commercial Elevation: 74' (AMSL) Structure Ht: 50' (AGL) Tower Type: Monopole Existing Carrier: AT&T Wireless RAD Height: 50' Line of Sight: Yes - 360 degrees Connectivity: Telco - Pac Bell Aerial view 95 City of Tustin wireless Master Plan Study Existing Inventory 12850 Robinson Drive I Last Update: January 2008 Site Name: Robinson Park I Site Number: TUS-07 Coordinates: Lat:33.733467 Long: -117.783698 Coord. System: ^ NAD83 Site Address: 12850 Robinson Drive Tustin, CA. 92782 Site County: Orange Property Type: Park Elevation: 138' (AMSL) Structure Ht: 60' (AGL) Tower Type: Light Standard Existing Carrier: ATBT Wireless RAD Height: 50' Line of Sight: Yes - 360 degrees Connectivity: Telco - Pac Bell Aerial view 96 Site View City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study Existing Inventory 12850 Robinson Drive II Site View Last Update: January 2008 Site Name: Robinson II Site Number: TUS-08 Coordinates: Lat:33.73354 Long: -117.784241 Coord. System: ^ NAD83 Site Address: 12850 Robinson Drive Tustin, CA. 92782 Site County: Orange Property Type: Park Elevation: 137' (AMSL) Structure Ht: 60' (AGL) Tower Type: Light Standard Existing Carrier : T-Mobile RAD Height: 50' Line of Sight: Yes - 360 degrees Connectivity: Telco - Pac Bell Aerial view 97 City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study Existing Inventory 12850 Robinson Park III Last Update: January 2008 Site Name: Robinson Park III Site Number: TUS-09 Coordinates: Lat:33.73354 Long: -117.784241 Coord. System: ^ NAD83 Site Address: 12850 Robinson Drive Tustin, CA. 92782 Site County: Orange Property Type: Park Elevation: 137' (AMSL) Structure Ht: 60' (AGL) Tower Type: Light Standard Existing Carrier: Sprint PCS RAD Height: 50' Line of Sight: Yes - 360 degrees Connectivity: Telco - Pac Bell ss Aerial view City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study Existing Inventory 1452 Edinger Ave. I Last Update: January 2008 Site Name: ATBT I Site Number: TUS-10 Coordinates: Lat:33.721093 Long: -117.829661 Coord. System: ^ NAD83 Site Address: 1452 Edinger Avenue Tustin, CA. 92780 Site County: Orange Property Type: AT&T Elevation: 72' (AMSL) Structure Ht: 40' (AGL) Tower Type: Roof Mount -Stealth Existing Carrier: T-Mobile RAD Height: 40' Line of Sight: Yes - 360 degrees Connectivity: Telco - Pac Bell Aerial view 99 City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study 1452 Edinger Ave II Existing I Last Update: January 2008 Site Name: AT&T II Site Number: TUS-11 Coordinates: Lat:33.721093 Long: -117.829661 Coord. System: ^ NAD83 Site Address: 1452 Edinger Avenue Tustin, CA. 92780 Site County: Orange Property Type: AT&T Elevation: 72' (AMSL) Structure Ht: 40' (AGL) Tower Type: Roof Mount Existing Carrier: Nextel RAD Height: 40' Line of Sight: Yes - 360 degrees Connectivity: Telco - Pac Bell Aerial view 100 Site View ~..,,,,~k ,.., a ~. `t~'~~h City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study Existing Inventory 15201 Woodlawn Ave 1 Last Update: January 2008 Site Name: Woodlawn I Site Number: TUS-12 Coordinates: Lat:33.720899 Long: -117.833503 Coord. System: ^ NAD83 Site Address: 15201 Woodlawn Avenue Tustin, CA. 92780 Site County: Orange Property Type: Business Park Elevation: 70' (AMSL) Structure Ht: 40' (AGL) Tower Type: Monopine Existing Carrier : Sprint PCS RAD Height: 40' Line of Sight: Yes - 360 degrees Connectivity: Telco - Pac Bell Aerial view 101 Site View City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study 15201 Woodlawn Ave II Existing Inve Last Update: January 2008 Site Name: Woodlawn II Site Number: TUS-13 Coordinates: Lat:33.720899 Long: -117.833503 Coord. System: ^ NAD83 Site Address: 15201 Woodlawn Avenue Tustin, CA. 92780 Site County: Orange Property Type: Business Park Elevation: 70' (AMSL) Structure Ht: 40' (AGL) Tower Type: Monopine Existing Carrier : Metro PCS RAD Height: 35' Line of Sight: Yes - 360 degrees Connectivity: Telco - Pac Bell Aerial view 102 Site View City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study Existing Inventory 320 W. 6th St. Last Update: January 2008 Site Name: 320 W. 6th Site Number: TUS-14 Coordinates: Lat:33.739637 Long: -117.826517 Coord. System: ^ NAD83 Site Address: 320 W. 61h Street Tustin, CA. 92780 Site County: Orange Property Type: Commercial Elevation: 102' (AMSL) Structure Ht: 40' (AGL) Tower Type: Monopole Existing Carrier: AT&T Wireless RAD Height: 40' Line of Sight: Yes - 360 degrees Connectivity: Telco - Pac Bell Aerial view 103 Site View City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study Existing Inventory 600 W. 6th Street Last Update: January 2008 Site Name: Larry Johnson Site Number: TUS-15 Coordinates: Lat:33.740052 Long: -117.830881 Coord. System: ^ NAD83 Site Address: 600 W. 6~h Street Tustin, CA. 92780 Site County: Orange Property Type: Church Elevation: 105' (AMSL) Structure Ht: 50' (AGL) Tower Type: Monopole Existing Carrier: T-Mobile RAD Height: 50' Line of Sight: Yes - 360 degrees Connectivity: Telco - Pac Bell Aerial view 104 Site View City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study Existing Inventory 550 W. 6t" Street Last Update: January 2008 Site Name: Tustin Self Storage Site Number: TUS-16 Coordinates: Lat:33.739181 Long: -117.828601 Coord. System: ^ NAD83 Site Address: 550 W. 6~h Street Tustin, CA. 92780 Site County: Orange Property Type: Storage Facility Elevation: 103' (AMSL) Structure Ht: 55' (AGL) Tower Type: Monopalm Existing Carrier: Nextel RAD Height: 55' Line of Sight: Yes - 360 degrees Connectivity: Telco - Pac Bell Aerial view 105 Site View City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan study Existing Inventory 18231 Irvine Blvd Last Update: January 2008 Site Name: 18231 Irvine Blvd Site Number: TUS-17 Coordinates: Lat:33.748585 Long: -117.814764 Coord. System: ^ NAD83 Site Address: 18231 Irvine Boulevard Tustin, CA. 92780 Site County: Orange Property Type: Commercial Elevation: 133' (AMSL) Structure Ht: 40' (AGL) Tower Type: Roof Mount -Stealth Existing Carrier: Nextel RAD Height: 40' Line of Sight: Yes - 360 degrees Connectivity: Telco - Pac Bell Aerial view 106 Site View City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study 18062 Irvine Blvd Existing Invento Last Update: January 2008 Site Name: 18062 Irvine Blvd Site Number: TUS-18 Coordinates: Lat:33.748135 Long: -117.817464 Coord. System: ^ NAD83 Site Address: 18062 Irvine Boulevard Tustin, CA. 92780 Site County: Orange Property Type: Commercial Elevation: 122' (AMSL) Structure Ht: 40' (AGL) Tower Type: Roof Mount Existing Carrier: T-Mobile RAD Height: 40' Line of Sight: Yes - 360 degrees Connectivity: Telco - Pac Bell Aerial view ~ o~ City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study Existing Inventory 1171 EI Camino Real Last Update: January 2008 Site Name: Tustin High School Site Number: TUS-19 Coordinates: Lat:33.735547 Long: -117.814733 Coord. System: ^ NAD83 Site Address: 1771 EI Camino Real Tustin, CA. 92780 Site County: Orange Property Type: School Elevation: 98' (AMSL) Structure Ht: 50' (AGL) Tower Type: Monopole Existing Carrier: Verizon Wireless RAD Height: 50' Line of Sight: Yes - 360 degrees Connectivity: Telco - Pac Bell Aerial view Site View City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study Existing Inventory 1450 EI Camino Real Last Update: January 2008 Site Name: Subway Site Number: TUS-20 Coordinates: Lat:33.734618 Long: -117.815857 Coord. System: ^ NAD83 Site Address: 1450 EI Camino Real Tustin, CA. 92780 Site County: Orange Property Type: Commercial Elevation: 111' (AMSL) Structure Ht: 50' (AGL) Tower Type: Sign Mount -Stealth Existing Carrier: T-Mobile RAD Height: 50' Line of Sight: Yes - 360 degrees Connectivity: Telco - Pac Bell Aerial view 109 City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study 17821 17t" St. I S Existing Invento Last Update: January 2008 Site Name: Pacific West I Site Number: TUS-21 Coordinates: Lat:33.760428 Long: -117.821555 Coord. System: ^ NAD83 Site Address: 17821 17~h Street Tustin, CA. 92780 Site County: Orange Property Type: Commercial Elevation: 179' (AMSL) Structure Ht: 35' (AGL) Tower Type: Roof Mount -Stealth Existing Carrier: T-Mobile RAD Height: 35' Line of Sight: Yes - 360 degrees Connectivity: Telco - Pac Bell Aerial view 110 City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study Existing Inventory 17821 17t" St. II Last Update: January 2008 Site Name: Pacific West 11 Site Number: TUS-22 Coordinates: Lat:33.760428 Long: -117.821555 Coord. System: ^ NAD83 Site Address: 17821 17~" Street Tustin, CA. 92780 Site County: Orange Property Type: Commercial Elevation: 179' (AMSL) Structure Ht: 35' (AGL) Tower Type: Roof Mount -Stealth Existing Carrier: Sprint PCS RAD Height: 35' Line of Sight: Yes - 360 degrees Connectivity: Telco - Pac Bell Aerial view 111 Site View City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study 12711 Newport Ave. Site View Existina Inve Last Update: February 2008 Site Name: 12711 Newport Site Number: TUS-23 Coordinates: Lat:33.752578 Long: -117.808273 Coord. System: ^ NAD83 Site Address: 12711 Newport Avenue Tustin, CA. 92780 Site County: Orange Property Type: Commercial Elevation: 164' (AMSL) Structure Ht: 35' (AGL) Tower Type: Roof Mount -Stealth Existing Carrier: Metro PCS RAD Height: 35' Line of Sight: Yes - 360 degrees Connectivity: Telco - Pac Bell Aerial view 112 City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study Existing Inventory 730 EI Camino Way Last Update: January 2008 Site Name: 730 EI Camino Way Site Number: TUS-24 Coordinates: Lat:33.738035 Long: -117.824027 Coord. System: ^ NAD83 Site Address: 730 EI Camino Way Tustin, CA. 92780 Site County: Orange Property Type: Commercial Elevation: 121' (AMSL) Structure Ht: 35' (AGL) Tower Type: Roof Mount -Stealth Existing Carrier: Sprint PCS RAD Height: 35' Line of Sight: Yes - 360 degrees Connectivity: Telco - Pac Bell Aerial view 113 Site View City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study 900 W. 1St Street Existing Invento Last Update: January 2008 Site Name: 900 W. 1st Site Number: TUS-25 Coordinates: Lat:33.745501 Long: -117.833849 Coord. System: ^ NAD83 Site Address: 900 W. 1s~ Street Tustin, CA. 92780 Site County: Orange Property Type: Commercial Elevation: 135' (AMSL) Structure Ht: 70' (AGL) Tower Type: Sign Mount -Stealth Existing Carrier : Sprint PCS RAD Height: 70' Line of Sight: Yes - 360 degrees Connectivity: Telco - Pac Bell Aerial view 114 Site View City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study Existing Inve 13931 Carroll Way Last Update: January 2008 Site Name: Jewelry Mart I Site Number: TUS-26 Coordinates: Lat:33.760964 Long: •117.830293 Coord. System: ^ NAD83 Site Address: 13931 Carroll Way Tustin, CA. 92780 Site County: Orange Property Type: Commercial Elevation: 168' (AMSL) Structure Ht: 35' (AGL) Tower Type: Facade Mount Existing Carrier: T-Mobile RAD Height: 35' Line of Sight: Yes - 360 degrees Connectivity: Telco - Pac Bell Aerial view 115 Site View City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study Existing Inventory 13931 Carroll Way Last Update: January 2008 Site Name: Jewelry Mart II Site Number: TUS-27 Coordinates: Lat:33.760964 Long: -117.830293 Coord. System: ^ NAD83 Site Address: 13931 Carroll Way Tustin, CA. 92780 Site County: Orange Property Type: Commercial Elevation: 168' (AMSL) Structure Ht: 35' (AGL) Tower Type: Roof Mount Existing Carrier : Verizon Wireless RAD Height: 35' Line of Sight: Yes - 360 degrees Connectivity: Telco - Pac Bell Aerial view 116 Site View City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study Existing Inventory 14081 Yorba Street Last Update: January 2008 Site Name: Allan Site Number: TUS-28 Coordinates: Lat:33.758282 Long: -117.830152 Coord. System: ^ NAD83 Site Address: 14081 Yorba Street Tustin, CA. 92780 Site County: Orange Property Type: Commercial Elevation: 164' (AMSL) Structure Ht: 35' (AGL) Tower Type: Roof Mount -Stealth Existing Carrier: AT&T RAD Height: 35' Line of Sight: Yes - 360 degrees Connectivity: Telco - Pac Bell Aerial view 117 Site View City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study Existing Inventory 17592 17th Street Last Update: January 2008 Site Name: Fidelity Site Number: TUS-29 Coordinates: Lat:33.758475 Long: -117.825396 Coord. System: ^ NAD83 Site Address: 1759217~h Street Tustin, CA. 92780 Site County: Orange Property Type: Commercial Elevation: 169' (AMSL) Structure Ht: 45' (AGL) Tower Type: Roof Mount -Stealth Existing Carrier: Nextel RAD Height: 45' Line of Sight: Yes - 360 degrees Connectivity: Telco - Pac Bell 118 Site View Aerial view City of Tustin wireless Master Plan Study Existing Inventory 1671 EI Camino Real Last Update: January 2008 Site Name: Key Inn Site Number: TUS-30 Coordinates: Lat:33.732442 Long: -117.812678 Coord. System: ^ NAD83 Site Address: 1671 EI Camino Real Tustin, CA. 92780 Site County: Orange Property Type: Motel Elevation: 102' (AMSL) Structure Ht: 40' (AGL) Tower Type: Key Inn Tower -Stealth Existing Carrier : Sprint PCS RAD Height: 40' Line of Sight: Yes - 360 degrees Connectivity: Telco - Pac Bell Aerial view 119 Site View City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study Existing Inventory 3097 Edinger Ave. Last Update: January 2008 Site Name: Just Tires Site Number: TUS-31 Coordinates: Lat:33.705542 Long: -117.80562 Coord. System: ^ NAD83 Site Address: 3097 Edinger Avenue Tustin, CA. 92780 Site County: Orange Property Type: Commercial Elevation: 55' (AMSL) Structure Ht: 50' (AGL) Tower Type: Clock Tower -Stealth Existing Carrier: T-Mobile RAD Height: 50" Line of Sight: Yes - 360 degrees Connectivity: Telco - Pac Bell Aerial view 120 Site View City of Tustin wireless Master Plan Study Existing Inventory 3057 Edinger Ave. Last Update: January 2008 Site Name: 3057 Edinger Site Number: TUS-32 Coordinates: Lat:33.706318 Long: -117.806229 Coord. System: ^ NAD83 Site Address: 3057 Edinger Avenue Tustin, CA. 92780 Site County: Orange Property Type: Commercial Elevation: 55' (AMSL) Structure Ht: 45' (AGL) Tower Type: Roof Mount -Stealth Existing Carrier: ATBT WIRELESS RAD Height: 45' Line of Sight: Yes - 360 degrees Connectivity: Telco - Pac Bell Aerial view 121 Site View City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study Existing Inventory 1421 Edinger Ave. Last Update: January 2008 Site Name: 1421 Edinger Site Number: TUS-33 Coordinates: Lat:33.722865 Long: -117.828194 Coord. System: ^ NAD83 Site Address: 1421 Edinger Avenue Tustin, CA. 92780 Site County: Orange Property Type: Business Park Elevation: 83' (AMSL) Structure Ht: 50' (AGL) Tower Type: Roof Mount -Stealth Existing Carrier : AT&T Wireless RAD Height: 50' Line of Sight: Yes - 360 degrees Connectivity: Telco - Pac Bell 122 Aerial view City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study 15101 Red Hill Ave. Site View Existina Inve Last Update: January 2008 Site Name: 15101 Red Hill Site Number: TUS-34 Coordinates: Lat:33.720016 Long: -117.829569 Coord. System: ^ NAD83 Site Address: 15101 Red Hill Avenue Tustin, CA. 92780 Site County: Orange Property Type: Commercial Elevation: 78' (AMSL) Structure Ht: 40' (AGL) Tower Type: Roof Mount -Stealth Existing Carrier : Metro PCS RAD Height: 40' Line of Sight: Yes - 360 degrees Connectivity: Telco - Pac Bell Aerial view 123 City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study Existing Inventory 11010 Jamboree Road Last Update: January 2008 Site Name: OC Fire Site Number: TUS-35 Coordinates: Lat:33.748772 Long: -117.766802 Coord. System: ^ NAD83 Site Address: 11010 Jamboree Road Tustin, CA. 92780 Site County: Orange Property Type: Right of Way Elevation: 272' (AMSL) Structure Ht: 25' (AGL) Tower Type: Light Standard Existing Carrier: Verizon Wireless RAD Height: 25' Line of Sight: Yes - 360 degrees Connectivity: Telco - Pac Bell 124 Aerial view City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study Existing Inventory 10200 Pioneer Road Last Update: January 2008 Site Name: Salvation Army Site Number: TUS-36 Coordinates: Lat:33.765491 Long: -117.760513 Coord. System: ^ NAD83 Site Address: 10200 Pioneer Road Tustin, CA. 92782 Site County: Orange Property Type: Salvation Army/Church Elevation: 468' (AMSL) Structure Ht: 20' (AGL) Tower Type: Light Standard Existing Carrier : T-Mobile RAD Height: 20' Line of Sight: Yes - 360 degrees Connectivity: Telco - Pac Bell Aerial view 125 City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study Existing Inventory 13814 Red Hill Ave. Last Update: January 2008 Site Name: 13814 Red Hill Site Number: TUS-37 Coordinates: Lat:33.735141 Long: -117.812009 Coord. System: ^ NAD83 Site Address: 13814 Red Hill Avenue Tustin, CA. 92780 Site County: Orange Property Type: Commercial Elevation: 105' (AMSL) Structure Ht: 50' (AGL) Tower Type: Monopole Existing Carrier: AT&T Wireless RAD Height: 50' Line of Sight: Yes - 360 degrees Connectivity: Telco - Pac Bell Aerial view 126 Site View City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study Existing Inventory 15991 Red Hill Ave. Site View Last Update: January 2008 Site Name: 15991 Red Hill Site Number: TUS-38 Coordinates: Lat:33.712093 Long: -117.837773 Coord. System: ^ NAD83 Site Address: 15991 Red Hill Avenue Tustin, CA. 92780 Site County: Orange Property Type: Business Park Elevation: 64' (AMSL) Structure Ht: 40' (AGL) Tower Type: Roof Mount -Stealth Existing Carrier: Nextel RAD Height: 40' Line of Sight: Yes - 360 degrees Connectivity: Telco - Pac Bell 127 Aerial view City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study 14642 Newport Ave. Site View q xso- r l !( ~~ >/` ~... Existina Inve Last Update: January 2008 Site Name: Tustin Medical Center Site Number: TUS-39 Coordinates: Lat:33.730127 Long: -117.829502 Coord. System: ^ NAD83 Site Address: 14642 Newport Avenue Tustin, CA. 92780 Site County: Orange Property Type: Medical Center Elevation: 100' (AMSL) Structure Ht: 35' (AGL) Tower Type: Fayade Mount Existing Carrier: T-Mobile RAD Height: 35' Line of Sight: Yes - 360 degrees Connectivity: Telco - Pac Bell 128 Aerial view City of Tustin wireless Master Plan Study Appendix "B" Appendix "B" Glossary Above Means Sea Level (AMSL) -refers to the elevation (on the ground) or altitude (in the air) of any object relative to the average sea level datum. This measurement is used extensively in radio, broadcasting, aviation, and telecommunications by engineers to determine the coverage area a station will be able to reach. Antenna - a device for transmitting and receiving radiofrequency (RF) signals. Often camouflaged on existing buildings, trees, water towers or other tall structures, the size and shape of antennas are generally determined by the frequency of the signal they manage. Base station - the central radio transmitter/receiver that communicates with mobile telephones within a given range (typically a cell site). Bluetooth - a technological standard (a communications protocol) that enables mobile devices equipped with a special chip to send and receive information wirelessly. Broadband - a transmission facility having a bandwidth (capacity) sufficient to carry multiple voice, video or data channels simultaneously. Broadband is generally equated with the delivery of increased speeds and advanced capabilities. Carrier - a service provider or operator; a communications company that provides customers service for their wireless phones. Cell -the basic geographic unit of wireless coverage. A region is divided into smaller "cells," each equipped with aloes-powered radio transmitter/receiver. The radio frequencies assigned to one cell can be limited to the boundaries of that cell. As a wireless call moves from one cell to another, a computer at the Mobile Telephone Switching Office (MTSO) monitors the call and at the proper time, transfers the phone call to the new cell and new radio frequency. The handoff is performed so quickly that it's not noticeable to the callers. Cellular network - a radio network made up of a number of cells served by a fixed transmitter - a cell site or a base station. Cell site -the location where a wireless antenna and network communications equipment is placed in order to provide wireless service in a geographic area. Cell splitting - a means of increasing the capacity of a wireless system by subdividing one cell into two or more smaller cells. Competitive Local Exchange Carrier (CLEC) - a telecommunication provider company that competes with other established carriers, generally the incumbent local exchange carrier (ILEC). 129 City of Tustin wireless Master Plan Study Appendix "B" Code Division Multiple Access (CDMA) - a technology used to transmit wireless calls by assigning them codes to a range of channels. The codes allow numerous calls to travel on the same frequency and guides calls to the correct receiving phone. Co-location -placement of multiple antennas at a cell site location Commercial Mobile Radio Service Providers (CMRS) - an FCC designation for any wireless carrier or license owner whose wireless service is connected to the public switched telephone network and/or is operated for profit. DSL - a digital line connecting the subscriber's terminal to the serving company's central office, providing multiple communications channels able to carry both voice and data communications simultaneously. Dual Band - a wireless handset that works on more than one spectrum frequency, e.g., in the 800 MHz frequency and 1900 MHz frequency bands. Frequency Division Multiple Access (FDMA) -access technology that is used by radio systems to share spectrum by allocating individual frequencies for each signal within the band Global System for Mobile communications (GSM) -the most popular standard for mobile phones; also referenced as a cellular network, which connects mobile phones to cell sites in a vicinity. GSM networks operate in four different frequency ranges - 850 MHz, 900 MHz, 1800 MHz, and 1900 MHz. Handoff -the process of when a wireless network automatically switches a mobile call to an adjacent cell site. iDEN - a specialized mobile technology that combines two-way radio, telephone, text messaging and data transmission into one digital network, giving user access to information on a single device. Incumbent Local Exchange Carrier (ILEC) - a local telephone company that was in existence at the time of the break up of AT&T into the Regional Bell Operating Companies. Interconnection -connecting one wireless network to another, such as linking a wireless carrier's network with a local telephone company's network. Local Area Network (LAN) - a small data network covering a limited area, such as a building or group of buildings. Most LANs connect workstations or personal computers, allowing users to share devices, such as printers and data. MegaheHz - a unit of frequency equal to one million hertz or cycles per second. Wireless mobile communications within the United States generally occur in the 800 MHz, 900MHz and 1900MHz spectrum frequency bands. Mobile phone - a short range, portable device used for voice or data communication over a network of specialized base stations 130 City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study Appendix "B" Mobile Telephone Switching Office (MTSO) - a computer that monitors a mobile phone call transfers the phone call to the new cell and radio frequency when the call can no longer be handled by a distance cell. Multimedia Messaging Service (MMS) - an extension of the SMS standard; allows for longer messages and multimedia objects, such as images, audio, video, and rich text, to be sent. Personal Communication Services (PCS) -abroad family of wireless services, commonly viewed as including two-way digital voice, messaging and data services. POPS -refers to the number of people in a specific area where wireless services are available (the population). Radio Frequency - a frequency or rate of oscillation within the range of 3Hz to 300 GHz Reception -the action of an electronic receiver; a signal Roaming - a fundamental of mobility management procedures which allows for cellular customers to access cellular services outside their home network geographical coverage area Short Message Service (SMS) - a communication protocol allowing the interchange of short text messages between mobile telecommunication devices Smart phone -wireless phones with advanced data features and often keyboards. Spectrum allocation -process where the federal government designates frequencies for specific uses, such as personal communications services and public safety. Spectrum assignment -Federal government authorization for the use of specific frequencies within a given spectrum allocation, usually in a specific geographic location. Mobile communications assignments are granted to both private users and commercial providers. Subscriber Identity Module (SIM card) - a microchip that stores the phone configuration data by the use of a unique numerical identifier Telecommunication Act of 1996 -the first major overhaul of the US telecommunications law in 62 years, approved on January 3, 1996. The Act created deregulation and new regulation. Third-Generation (3G) - a general term that refers to technologies which offer increased capacity and capabilities delivered over digital wireless networks. Voice over Internet Protocol (VoiP) -technology capable of delivering voice and accommodating two-way video conferencing and application over Internet protocol Voice recognition -the capability for wireless phones, computers and other devices to be activated and controlled by voice commands. 131 City of Tustin Wireless Master Plan Study Appendix "B" Wide Area Network (WAN) -refers to a large network spanning a country or around the world, the Internet or a PCS network Wi-Max - a wireless technology based on the standard providing metropolitan area network connectivity for fixed wireless access at broadband speeds. Wireless Fidelity (WiFi) -provides wireless connectivity over unlicensed spectrum to local area connectivity to WiFi-enabled computers, generally in the 2.4 and 5 GHz radio bands. Wireless communications -the transfer of information over a distance with electromagnetic waves rather than electrical conductors or "wires"; a branch of telecommunications. Wireless Internet -using wireless services to access the Internet, a-mail and/or the World Wide Web. Wireless Local Area Network (WEAN) -using radio frequency (RF) technology to transmit and receive data wirelessly in a small area without physically connecting each computer with cords or wires. 132