Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutATTACHMENT A - COVENTRY COURT REPORTReport to the Planning Commission ITEM #2 TUSTIN DATE: MARCH 23, 2010 SUBJECT: CONTINUED ITEM CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT 09-024 DESIGN REVIEW 09-024 AMENDMENT TO TRACT MAP 16581 AMENDMENT TO CONCEPT PLAN 03-003 APPLICANT: LENNAR HOMES OF CALIFORNIA MANAGING MEMBER OF TUSTIN COVENTRY, LLC C/O DONNA KELLY 25 ENTERPRISE ALISO VIEJO, CA 92656 PROPERTY OWNER: TUSTIN COVENTRY, LLC C/O DONNA KELLY 25 ENTERPRISE ( ALISO VIEJO, CA 92656 DEVELOPER/ FUTURE PROPERTY OWNER: TUSTIN COVENTRY SENIORS, LLC PROJECT/PROPERTY MANAGER: META HOUSING CORPORATION 1640 S. SEPULVEDA BLVD., SUITE 425 LOS ANGELES, CA 90025 LOCATION: COVENTRY COURT AT COLUMBUS SQUARE LOT 265 OF TRACT 16581 ZONING: MCAS TUSTIN SPECIFIC PLAN (MCAS -SP 1) PLANNING AREAS 4 AND 5 REU$g DISPOSITION PARCELS 23 AND 24 GENERAL PLAN: MCAS TUSTIN SPECIFIC PLAN ENVIRONMENTAL STATUS: THE PROJECT IS EXEMPT FROM FURTHER CEQA REVIEW PURSUANT TO SECTION 65457 OF THE CALIFORNIA GOVERNMENT CODE Planning Commission Report March 23, 2010 CUP 09-024, DR 09-024, et al. Page 2 REQUEST: TO DEVELOP 240 SENIOR APARTMENT HOMES, AGE - RESTRICTED FOR PERSONS 55 YEARS OR OLDER, FOR RENTAL TENURE, WITH A PARKING STANDARD OF 1.7 SPACES PER UNIT, INCLUDING 153 AFFORDABLE UNITS, RECREATION CENTER, AND ASSOCIATED SITE AND INFRASTRUCTURE IMPROVEMENTS AT LOT 265 OF TRACT 16581, ALSO REFERRED TO AS COVENTRY COURT IN COLUMBUS SQUARE AT TUSTIN LEGACY RECOMMENDATION That the Planning Commission adopt: 1. Resolution No. 4134 recommending that the City Council approve Conditional Use Permit 09-024 and Design Review 09-024 authorizing the development of a 240 -unit senior apartment residential complex, age restricted to persons of 55 years or older, for rental tenure, with a parking standard of 1.7 spaces per unit, including 153 affordable units, recreation center, and associated infrastructure and site improvements on Lot 265 of Tract 16581; 2. Resolution No. 4136 recommending that the City Council approve Amendment to Resolution No. 3951, which approved Concept Plan 03-003, to reflect a ohange in tenure from ownership to rental for the proposed 240 -unit age -restricted senior housing complex on Lot 265 of Tract 16581; 3. Resolution No. 4137 recommending that the City Council approve Amendment to Resolution No. 05-40, which approved Tentative Tract Map 16581, to reflect a change in tenure from ownership to rental for the proposed 240 -unit age - restricted senior housing. complex on Lot 265 of Tract 16581. BACKGROUND The item has been continued from the January 26, 2010, and December 8, 2009, Planning Commission meetings. Due to the .feedback received at the December 8, 2009, public hearing from Columbus Square homeowners, the Planning Commission continued the item to the January 26, 2010, meeting to allow the applicant (Lerinar) and the proposed housing provider (Meta Housing) an opportunity to meet with the Community Association to address some of their concerns. At the January 26, 2010., Planning Commission meeting, several Columbus Square homeowners and residents spoke in opposition to the project and various items of concern were discussed. As a result, the Planning Commission continued the item for sixty (60) days for staff to conduct further research and for the applicant and community members to engage in further dialogue. 7� Planning Commission Report March 23, 2010 CUP 09-024, DR 09-024, et al. Page 3 The major issues raised at the January 26th public hearing which the Planning Commission requested further information on relate to: 1. Disclosure/notification documents, 2. Master Community Association dues and membership and voting rights within the master Community Association, 3. Occupancy limits for the proposed units, 4. Age restriction requirements, and , 5. Property transfers or assignments. 6. Parking (email received from an individual following the last public hearing) This Report to the Planning Commission will address only new information relative to the above -listed issues. For full project -specific details and discussion, please reference the Planning Commission Reports dated December 8, 2009, and January 26, 2010 (Attachment A). Project Proposal ' The project proposal is to develop a 240 -unit age -restricted senior community for rental tenure including 153 affordable units, recreation center, and associated site and infrastructure improvements, at a parking standard of 1.7 spaces per unit, located on Lot 265 of Tract 16581, also known as Coventry Court at Columbus Square. The `.f project was originally approved in 2005 and. 2006, but since the project was not completed, entitlements and building permits expired. At this time the applicant is requesting approval for the same plans as previously approved, with a change from ownership tenure (as was previously approved) to rental tenure for the 240 units. In summary, the project proposal involves the following new or amended entitlements: 1. DR 09-024: New design review for the development of a 240 -unit senior housing project, including associated recreational facilities and site and building improvements. 2. CUP 09-024: New conditional use permit for age -restricted apartments utilizing a parking ratio of .1.7 parking spaces per unit. Pursuant to Sections 3.4.2.A and 3.4.5.A of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan, multiple family dwelling units (apartments) are conditionally permitted in Planning Areas 4 and 5. 3. Amendment to Tract Map 16581: Due to the proposed change from ownership to rental tenure, an amendment to TM 16581 will be required to be documented in a resolution. 4. Amendment to Concept Plan 03-003: Due to the proposed change to rental tenure, an amendment to the Concept Plan is also required to be documented in a resolution. Planning Commission Report March 23, 2010 CUP 09-024, DR 09-024, et al. Page 4 Public Input since the January 26th Planning Commission Hearing Since the January 26th Planning Commission meeting, staff has received written correspondence from two individuals who own/reside in Columbus Square regarding the project (see Attachment B). In summary: Mr. Eric Higuchi submitted a letter via email on the subject of parking; Ms. Colleen Tierney submitted an email to the City Council expressing opposition to the proposed project, citing decreased property values, increased HOA fees, and potential for a higher crime rate due to a lack of community policing by Tustin P.D. in Columbus Square. DISCUSSION 1. DISCLOSURE/NOTIFICATION DOCUMENTS Homebuyer Notification Document Condition 10.1 of Resolution No. 05-40 (City Council approval of Tentative Tract Map 16581) required the subdivider to submit a homebuyer notification document for review and approval by the Community Development Department to include notification to all homebuyers of certain characteristics which may affect the community such as roadway and train noise, public use of park sites, affordable units located within the community, assessment districts, etc. Section H of Condition 10.1 required the homebuyer notification to include "a notice stating that all development within the site is approved for ownership tenure only per Chapter 3.9.3J5 of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan." The "Columbus Square Homebuyer Notification" (herein referred to as Notification) (Attachment C) is a document separate from the "Columbus Square Homebuyer Disclosure Statement" (herein referred to as Disclosure)' (Attachment D): The Notification is a document that was required as a condition of approval on Tentative Tract Map 16581. The Notification is a document that is not to be amended without prior review and approval from the City. The City is not aware of any amendments to this document. The original version of the Notification, dated 3/6/06, includes a section, "SALE AND OWNERSHIP PER MCAS TUSTIN SPECIFIC PLAN," which states, "Development within the Community is approved for sale and ownership tenure only in accordance with Chapter 3.9.3J5 of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan. If the project is approved and necessitates any amendments to the Notification, the applicant shall be responsible for providing an amendment or addendum for City review and approval, and then for distributing to existing and future homebuyers in the Community. Planning Commission Report March 23, 2010 CUP 09-024, DR 09-024, et al. Page 5 Homebuyer Disclosure Document The Columbus Square Homebuyer Disclosure Statement is a document regarding the Community prepared and provided by the Master Developer or Neighborhood Builders directly to each homebuyer in the Community to "describe various matters which might affect [a homebuyer's] decision to purchase." This document is neither required nor approved by the City. This document is prepared by and for the purposes of the Developer. At the January 26, 2010, public hearing, attention was drawn to the fact that there was more than one version of this Disclosure document and homeowners who purchased at various stages of the Columbus Square development were, given, different versions of the documents from the homebuilders which contain varying language, specifically regarding rentals within the Community. Since the meeting, Lennar has provided City staff with what they have stated to be all versions (five in total) of the Columbus Square Homebuyer Disclosure Statement. A summary of the various versions is provided in Table 1 and a more detailed comparison is provided in Table 2. Attachment D contains copies of the versions provided to the City by Lennar, which include highlighted changes and handwritten annotation made by a representative of Lennar. The sections of the Disclosure document addressed in this Report pertain to items that are relevant to the subject project only (i.e. ownership or rental language, mention of senior housing, or specific reference to Lot 265). Items outside of the scope of the subject project that may have been changed in different versions of the document are not discussed herein. Table 1. Summary of versions of Developer's Homebuyer Disclosure Statement DATE Changes as they relate to the subject project 6/13/06 First version of the document 8/11/06 First appearance of language that Neighborhood Builders may rename, sell, or not build the listed neighborhoods at all 3/1/07 Substantially the same as prior version 9/25/08 First appearance of "rental" language at the Active Adult neighborhood (Coventry Court) 11/16/09 Also contains rental language Applicable sections of the Disclosure are quoted and compared in Table 2. At the January 26, 2010, public hearing, it was questioned when speck rental language was added to the Developer's Disclosure document. It appears that such language first appears in the September 25, 2008, version of the document. So, homebuyers who purchased prior to this date would have likely been provided a Disclosure Statement that did not disclose the possibility of rentals at the Active Adult neighborhood in express terms. Covenants, Conditions, and Restrictions (CC&Rs) The Master Declaration of Covenants, Conditions, Restrictions and Reservation of Easements for Columbus Square (CC&Rs) was recorded on March 7, 2006 (Attachment E). Article XVII, Section 17.2 RIGHTS states, "Declarant and the Neighborhood Builders have the following rights. Nothing in the Community Association Governing Documents limits and no Owner or the Community Association will interfere with Declarant's or any Neighborhood Builder's exercise of these rights." Section 17.2.2 goes on to specify, "Sales. To sell and rent any portion of the Covered Property directly or through agents and representatives." A First Amendment to the CC&Rs document was recorded on August 2, 2006. It does not appear to contain any changes relative to the subject project. 2. MASTER COMMUNITY ASSOCIATION DUES AND MEMBERSHIP AND VOTING RIGHTS The issues of dues and voting rights within the Columbus Square Community Association remain topics of concern. As proposed, the applicant indicated that the change from ownership to rental tenure would result in the 240 -unit senior community being annexed into the master association at a rate of 2:1 assessments and voting rights. Therefore, the owner of the senior project would pay assessments at a rate of .5 assessments per unit, instead of the 1 assessment per unit which was envisioned when the association was formed and operating budget was prepared. As a result, all other homeowners outside of the senior project (835 homes) in the master association would be reassessed to make up the shortfall for 120 assessments over the life of the project. The owner 240 -unit senior project would also be allotted a total of 120 of the total 955 votes (12.5 percent) in the -association. Staff has surveyed a sample of management companies who represent homeowners associations in nearby communities which may experience similar scenarios to that which is proposed at Columbus Square (master homeowners associations with a mix of rental and ownership members). The responses are summarized in Table 2 below. Table 3. Summary of responses received from other homeowners associations COMPANY COMMUNITIES RESPONSE .REPRESENTED' • Apartment communities in Tustin Ranch are not a part of. The Irvine Company Tustin Ranch master associations. 9 Therefore,' not subject to'master association dues. CD N O O -Oh CL rt CD N 3 N O v 0 a CD N O 3 CD a c a O N C� O N C �D CD M O C7 c CD Z ( o 0 o s 0 0 m 3 a= o Q W IV O C ' eM O CL z Q N m Ol CQ m a -' c . $ C S O) O O H CL v m 3 (� O °crtmm rt rt rt rt -n oGN. o<07 p m m Q. m D tpZD O , yQ * <N _ O O O CD CL N m m Q < (D N= OjfOCN O ortS sN"� <(7 0 - ° m D s D < Ul O O � O rt <° 3 O c pNyOO' FD p • ,.r m :3 N ID Q o 3 Nn ° rt p C p C_7n CD O m NCD 7 O ( 7 O w OnQ CD m Q 3 O Dq N O m Q O C �< m O N m O ° O (D —D - - <- < n n OO � Qn"= CL O N <p ° NO m< m m z ° °= O Qm v \O1 m N m 3 rt m O — S, p p LncD O O S DV O O_ C °' o W Q< (D p r) O S S vmi 3° m N �. N O= m p O n O "O N N D o M O 2 _S p °. m (D S a .N-' O 7 00 3 G m d n O N< < o O (D in O O j' W n M '+ w N m (D O O -. m 's O -O m m cn O rt s m p '••' Q O C N m ° Q - o m r m" N -0 p n m N "O O S m D1 3 O frtD n O ? m .v' a' 3 N Q 3 O Q ° o rt N m o< °- m m 0q m ° ° p O N n Z O < H c 7 m o m D p m (D n n Q v CD W O v O ° N '* N Q 2 Q Dq' rOy Q p Q O fi N rD n Q m K a m '"' 3 s ° 2 3. 7 7 O m ^' S Cr C L, f1 m O- ° -< O M N a N cu K ° ri _ — _S O (D O rt m N S< m FD'fD �' p fll H i `G (D Q Vf o ri 0 C W O m p n d z n° (D 00CD S 'a n `_'• n S O m m• H N Os p O O o 'o O) a4 (� N- o o M ((D S p Q Q s m CL o ° mCL c o C. o Q n m o N S m o n 'oCL C+ S o S m p o o o m (° 0- a� o om CL m Q zv z o p n 3 n m `D N oS) opo mm � m N 011 < `�° o 0 ° C S C D- S N N M vOi ° (D N N N T. (D p D D z m a '•r m C- N 7 'N•r O ° On ro N D O W_ O M 3 Q � m �3j' S n 0 - ;' nmi N u'i cn• m O 5- — N S m D 7 m C N D rt N =' A U7 C p (�'1 9�1 m rt W yj n N w N cu 3 c m m a m 0 a o Q o o< ° D=q X ID Q 0• N'} M CD N n o n O N Q N aj rt 0: ON `< o N 7 r! �:,' ° v Ort m .n. a 7 C N n v C ° m °rt' a m s m '* w D m p o o 0010 m Q (D m ° m N m m H °m D 3 v < o m ZN • " 'o O O S (D O O ( D H O_ m vmi s 3 '*. m m m w m m m '-' Q- N X v c° ° m D m° c< D m d4 rt e° o �b m O < �. CL N o_ x w Q m m OJ N 7 Ln o Dq u= n+ Cr 3 m n vc m r<D m c vm ° cn ° _0 00 oq O Q (�D N m O < D= m rt _. Q Q rt _ 02 t< O O Q .-i n rt n fll W -O S m p Oq 3r m p rL N S m m N c 3 M �' m O n 'm+ Cl 3 N q� Q c rt <� (D M O '•r N m rt S '+ ? O m p 3 S 0) a O N OQ 3° 7 S n m N N. Q _s Q 00 m or - => N N O � N Q rt O ; N N _ vv -< y z o 0 3 ° \m N Qq 0 m =r �< < DJ O! 00 D 27�_ 00 NO m ID C v Oq � N S O 0) v O < G rt' Oq Q N 4 N rD O �V N N 3 M CD N O O -Oh CL rt CD N 3 N O v 0 a CD N O 3 CD a c a O N C� O N C �D CD M O C7 c CD n9:9 c°v ,o =r 2. JC,OIV3 W A0-3 X03 O vNi o 0 AC (D O. O DI � v D o m 3 V CL 3 � N O N to A o = C 0 S. v3Ui Oc C n mn' 1 N o h C � O Dhl 3 M m O N p m m N Z �. O0 O^ N C -i NN < A ('f M O 0 < — M Ln 3 p�j Q w Q m �w � m CL .NW.. � 3 oED m� CL K CL D o a m (D C" 3 O O O) Er in '< N O Zi ri O Vii O (D O M n ° 3-< Q C w D) S u O W 0 C O p S .G 0 7 m (D (D O = -°Q (D rt 0 CQi N N S N cm y '*j !L v N 7 Q C_ -VN (D O ti+ S �. O' ° C_ of W N N O S$ f7 O (D Q 7 Q (D Z s m° 3 3 o�0 3° �` C C C OQ C �' m o 0 3 N --� o o n — < Qy (D — 7 vi, O (D X Q sIn 03 0 O N in (D (D v d X Z Z O O A S Pf S Ol N 7 DA C (D N 00 N N Q1 Z O O n S M S v N 7 ((DD m V O C O O °° O Vf 'B < S 7 W BN S S 3 7 - (D 3CU ooo p 3 aon aQ CL M 3 O O -N � N H � �N — � O ar O 0 O'" 3 i' (D M M a 0 3 m " =. CL c - C_ =rm ao 7 m 7 n (D O) S K ? c 3 00 o n '. 3 S 00 (, j �. ° n m vdi o a m , m N _ S (D cu m m 0 0 d ori Deo D (D m w n9:9 c°v ,o =r 2. JC,OIV3 W A0-3 X03 O vNi o 0 AC (D O. O DI � Planning Commission Report March 23, 2010 CUP 09-024, DR 09-024, et al. Page 9 COMPANY COMMUNITIES REPRESENTED RESPONSE • Apartment units represent 1300 of a total 8100 units (16 Anaheim Hills percent) in Ladera Ranch Planned Community Anaheim Hills • There are 3 separate active adult (55+) communities Association (portion of) within Ladera Ranch. They' are part of the master (AHPCA) association. Merit Property . These communities are assessed at a rate of 3:1. Management/Ladera Ladera Ranch Ranch Maintenance . Voting rights are proportionately allotted (3:1) and are Corp. (LRMC) granted to the owner of the complex (not renters). . At 3:1 ratio, apartments represent 433 of 7233 total votes (6 percent) in the master association. • Interviewee comment: While this is not near a majority, it can be enough to swing an election because of the rate of voter turnout in association elections. . WVA consists of 1,096 apartment units and 7,685 single family, or condo units (=12% apartments). • In CCBRs, HOA membership is at two levels Class A: single family or condominium owners; Class B: apartment complex owners. • Class A: 1 voting right per assessment. • Class B: Assessment-- Base ssessment=Base assessment based og net acreage of site x 7.24 + supplemental declaration which is a percentage of the Woodbridge Village Woodbridge Class A assessment. Association (WVA) Village (in Irvine) (Each apartment complex negotiated the supplemental declaration amount with the HOA upon annexation into the master; varies but can be around 60-75% of Class A assessment). • Voting right for Class B is based on their base assessment only (varies by community), so voting rights:assessments are < 1:1 ratio. • Interviewee comment: Even within such a large association, apartments do constitute a large voting percentage and do have the possibility of swaying an election. . AHPCA represents the largest of 5 master associations in the Anaheim Hills area (2273 homes). Anaheim Hills • Rental projects are not included in master associations. 1 Planned Community Anaheim Hills association features only 1 type of housing product (i.e. Association (portion of) condos, single family). (AHPCA) . Voting is not based on a straightforward ratio but members elect delegates to represent them in the association. Each delegate represents between 10 - 212 homeowners. . WVA consists of 1,096 apartment units and 7,685 single family, or condo units (=12% apartments). • In CCBRs, HOA membership is at two levels Class A: single family or condominium owners; Class B: apartment complex owners. • Class A: 1 voting right per assessment. • Class B: Assessment-- Base ssessment=Base assessment based og net acreage of site x 7.24 + supplemental declaration which is a percentage of the Woodbridge Village Woodbridge Class A assessment. Association (WVA) Village (in Irvine) (Each apartment complex negotiated the supplemental declaration amount with the HOA upon annexation into the master; varies but can be around 60-75% of Class A assessment). • Voting right for Class B is based on their base assessment only (varies by community), so voting rights:assessments are < 1:1 ratio. • Interviewee comment: Even within such a large association, apartments do constitute a large voting percentage and do have the possibility of swaying an election. Planning Commission Report March 23, 2010 CUP 09-024, DR 09-024, et al. Page 10 I COMPANY COMMUNITIES RESPONSE REPRESENTED • All projects in Orange County that feature apartment communities were developed as such since the initial phases, so no changes in dues or representation have occurred. • The makeup within each association varies. • When apartments units are part of such master Numeroassociations, the rate of assessment for each apartment The Irvine Company communities in unit is approximately 75% of that paid per home (though it Irvine varies by project). • The assessment rate for rental units is less than for ownership units based on the assumption that dedicated amenities are provided in the rental community, so those residents would not be as likely to utilize the master association amenities. • Voting rights also vary, but in many cases are approximately 1:1 on a per unit basis. Staff was not able to locate a community with a circumstance very similar to that proposed at Columbus Square where within a homeowners association that features both ownership and rental units, apartment units constitute approximately 22 percent of the total units. Additionally, none of the communities surveyed had experienced a conversion of condominiums to apartments or vice versa; all had been planned since inception. However, amongst the communities surveyed, it appears that when rental units are part of the same association as ownership units, a distinction is made in the amount of assessments paid. Voting rights are, allotted in some cases proportionate to the assessment rate, in other cases on a 1:1 basis; and in some other cases using an alternate formula. The applicant (Lennar) indicated they have been examining different alternatives to resolve the issues of association dues and voting rights for the subject project. In preliminary discussions with City staff, the applicant indicated they were considering not annexing the subject property into the, master association and alternatively utilizing a recorded agreement between the Columbus Square Master Community Association (CSMCA) and the property owner of Lot 265. The applicant has indicated that the purpose of such an agreement is that the bottom line would result in the future owner of the 240 apartment complex paying full assessments while ensuring rights and commitments, and that such an agreement should result in a no -net -change for other - homeowners in Columbus Square. The applicant submitted.a "Summary of Rental Proposal' (Attachment F) just prior to the completion of this Report. Upon review of the Summary, it is consistent with what is discussed in the "Homeowner Association Dues" section of this Report. However, no details on this proposal have been submitted to the City. Condition 2.1 of Resolution No. 4134 requires the applicant to secure an agreement to this effect, for review and approval by the City. Planning Commission Report March 23, 2010 CUP 09-024, DR 09-024, et al. Page 11 3. OCCUPANCY LIMITS Federal and State agencies offer guidelines for occupancy requirements. In a reasonable effort to allocate scarce financial resources for affordable housing, housing programs typically use occupancy standards that allow for up to "two persons per bedroom plus one" (e.g., five person in a two-bedroom unit). The California Health and Safety Code standard, applicable for housing receiving financial assistance from Redevelopment Housing Set -Aside Fund, is one person per bedroom plus one (e.g., three persons in a two-bedroom unit). The City in this case utilizes the federal and State agencies occupancy guidelines of two persons per bedroom plus one. This is reflected in the First Amendment to the Housing Agreement in which the applicant would need to execute as part of the condition of approval of the project (see Attachment G - Section 3.3.3 on Page 4 of the Regulatory Agreement and Declaration of Restrictive Covenants). 4. AGE RESTRICTION The Fair Housing Act protects all citizens from discrimination on the basis of race, color, national origin, religion, sex, handicap, or familial status. In 1995 the Act was amended ("Housing for Older Persons Act of 1995") to provide an exemption with respect to housing intendedand operated for occupancy by persons 55 years of age or older, ., where 4t least 80 percent of the occupied units are occupied by at least one person who is 55 years of age or older. Accordingly, if approved, each unit must be occupied by at least one person who is 55 years of age or older. To ensure that the project remain as a senior development, proposed Condition No. 1.11 of Resolution No. 4134 requires an age -restrictive covenant to be recorded on the property. 5. PROPERTY TRANSFER AND/OR ASSIGNMENT The question of length of ownership and ability of the future property owner (proposed to be Tustin Coventry Seniors, LLC to transfer or assign ownership of the property were also raised at the January 26t Planning Commission meeting. At the hearing, Shaun Bradley of Meta Housing indicated that it was not the intention of Meta to build and ultimately sell the property because of the type of financing options they are pursuing. In benefitting from public tax finance credits and tax-exempt bonds, their compliance period would be minimum 15 years. As previously mentioned, the proposed project necessitates an amendment to the existing Housing Agreement and Affordable Housing Plan and .inclusion of a Regulatory Agreement to reflect the change in tenure and implement new rental language and terms of affordability. Section 6 of the Regulatory Agreement states that the developer is not to sell, transfer, or otherwise dispose of the property without obtaining written approval from the City (Attachment G). Section 6 also states that that the provision is to terminate at the end of one year following the expiration of the Qualified Project Period, which is specified as 55 years. Section 8 of the Regulatory Agreement also states that the covenants and restrictions of the Regulatory Agreement shall run with the land and Planning Commission Report March 23, 2010 CUP 09-024, DR 09-024, et al. Page 12 are enforceable upon the Developer, its successors and assigns. Consequently, the City will have the authority to approve all transfers, sales, and assignments of the subject property (and associated obligations) for a period of up to 56 years. If a successor or assign to any portion of the property is approved, that party will be subject to all covenants and restrictions thereof. 6. PARKING A topic discussed by several Columbus Square residents who contacted staff and spoke at the prior hearings were current and future , parking impacts within the community, Mr. Eric Higuchi submitted an email to the City (Attachment C) outlining concerns he holds regarding the proposed 1.7 spaces/unit parking ratio as discussed in the January 26, 2010, staff report. Mr. Higuchi states his challenges to the parking study: 1. The proposed project is for an "active adult" not "assisted living" community for individuals who are typically still employed and require two cars. 2. The proposed project is neither urban nor a desert gated community. 3. No Orange County senior communities were surveyed in the parking study. 4. The project is the highest density residential 'in Tustin with the most relaxed parking requirement. Staff maintains that the parking issue was fully addressed in the "Parking" section of the January 26th Report. The parking study justifying a 1.7 spaces/unit parking has been previously reviewed 'and accepted by City staff, the Planning Commission, and the City Council. The City's Traffic Engineer re -visited the study in conjunction with the subject application and determined the change in tenure to be negligible upon parking. As Commissioner Thompson summarized at the January 26, 2010, Planning Commission meeting, a technical study was completed, staff has verified that the proposed project does not involve significant variation and merits no necessity to' update the study, and that the existing parking situation in the community, while it may be a valid issue to be resolved, is not particular to the proposed project. CONCLUSION Staff recommends that the Planning Commission adopt Resolution Nos. 4134, 4136, and 4137, recommending that the City Council approve. CUP 09-024, DR .09-024, Amendment to CP 03-003, and Amendment to Tract Map 16561, with drafted findings and recommended conditions of approval. The draft resolutions also include stipulations (Condition 2.2 of Reso. 4134, Condition 1.3 of Reso. 4136, and Condition 1.6 of Reso. 4137), that if the project as apartments/for rental tenure is not instituted for any reason, the approval is to remain valid for ownership tenure (240 senior condominium units), as was originally intended and approved for the project site. Planning Commission Report March 23, 2010 CUP 09-024, DR 09-024, et al. Page 13 �� iA49�94 Reina Kapadia Associate Planner Elizabeth A. Binsack Community Development Director Attachments: A. Report to the Planning Commission, December 8, 2009 and Report to the Planning Commission, January 26, 2010 B. Public Input - emails received from residents C. Columbus Square Homebuyer Notification Statement D. Columbus Square Homebuyer Disclosure Statement (5 versions) E. Master Declaration of CC&Rs and First Amendment to Master Declaration of CC&Rs F. "Summary of Rental Proposal' submitted by applicant G. First Amendment to Housing Agreement and Regulatory Agreement (draft) . H. Planning Commission Resolution Nos. 4134, 4136, and 4137 i ATTACHMENT A Report to the Planning Commission, December 8, 2009 and Report to.the Planning Commission, January 26, 2010 Report to the Planning Commission DATE: JANUARY 26, 2010 ITEM #4 SUBJECT: CONTINUED ITEM CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT 09-024 DESIGN REVIEW 09-024 AMENDMENT TO TRACT MAP 16581 AMENDMENT TO CONCEPT PLAN 03-003 TUSTIN APPLICANT: LENNAR HOMES OF CALIFORNIA MANAGING MEMBER OF TUSTIN COVENTRY, LLC C/O DONNA KELLY 25 ENTERPRISE ALISO VIEJO, CA 92656 PROPERTY OWNER: TUSTIN COVENTRY, LLC C/O DONNA KELLY 25 ENTERPRISE ALISO VIEJO, CA 92656 DEVELOPER/ FUTURE PROPERTY OWNER: TUSTIN COVENTRY SENIORS, LLC PROJECT/PROPERTY MANAGER: META HOUSING CORPORATION 1640 S. SEPULVEDA BLVD., SUITE 425 LOS ANGELES, CA 90025 LOCATION: COVENTRY COURT AT COLUMBUS SQUARE LOT 265 OF TRACT 16581 ZONING: MCAS TUSTIN SPECIFIC PLAN (MCAS -SP 1) PLANNING AREAS 4 AND 5 REUSE DISPOSITION PARCELS 23 AND 24 GENERAL PLAN: MCAS TUSTIN SPECIFIC PLAN ENVIRONMENTAL STATUS: THE PROJECT IS EXEMPT FROM FURTHER CEQA REVIEW PURSUANT TO SECTION 65457 OF THE CALIFORNIA GOVERNMENT CODE Planning Commission Report January 26, 2010 CUP 09-024, DR 09-024, et al. Page 2 REQUEST: TO DEVELOP 240 SENIOR APARTMENT HOMES (AGE - RESTRICTED FOR PERSONS 55 YEARS OR OLDER FOR RENTAL TENURE) INCLUDING 153 AFFORDABLE UNITS, WITH A PARKING STANDARD OF 1.7 SPACES PER UNIT, RECREATION CENTER, AND ASSOCIATED SITE AND INFRASTRUCTURE IMPROVEMENTS AT LOT 265 OF TRACT 16581, ALSO REFERRED TO AS COVENTRY COURT IN COLUMBUS SQUARE AT TUSTIN LEGACY RECOMMENDATION That the Planning Commission: 1. Adopt Resolution No. 4134 recommending that the City Council approve Conditional Use Permit 09-024 and Design Review 09-024 authorizing the development of a 240 -unit senior apartment residential complex (age restricted to persons of 55 years or older for rental tenure) including 153 affordable units, with a parking standard of 1.7 spaces per unit, recreation center, and associated infrastructure and site improvements on Lot 265 of Tract 16581; 2. Adopt Resolution No. 4136 recommending that the City Council approve Amendment to Resolution No. 3951, which approved Concept Plan 03-003, to reflect a change in tenure from ownership to rental for the proposed 240 -unit age -restricted senior housing complex on Lot 265 of Tract 16581; 3. Adopt Resolution No. 4137 recommending that the City Council approve Amendment to Resolution No. 05-40, which approved Tentative Tract Map 16581, to reflect a change in tenure from ownership to rental for the proposed 240 -unit age -restricted senior housing complex on Lot 265 of Tract 16581. BACKGROUND The item is continued from the December 8, 2009, Planning Commission meeting. Due to the feedback received at the public hearing, the Planning Commission continued the item to the January 26, 2010 meeting to allow the applicant (Lennar) and the proposed housing provider (Meta Housing) an opportunity to meet with the Community Association to address some of their concerns. Project Proposal The project proposal is to develop a 240 -unit age -restricted senior community for rental tenure including 153 affordable units, recreation center, and associated site and infrastructure improvements, at a parking standard of 1.7 spaces per unit, located on Lot 265.of Tract 16581, also known as Coventry Court at Columbus Square. The project was originally approved in 2005 and 2006, but since the project was not completed, Planning Commission Report January 26, 2010 CUP 09-024, DR 09-024, et al. Page 3 entitlements and building permits expired. At this time the applicant is requesting approval for the same plans as previously approved, with a change from ownership tenure (as was previously approved) to rental tenure for the 240 units. In summary, the project proposal involves the following new or amended entitlements: 1. DR 09-024: New design review for the development of an age -restricted 240 -unit senior housing project, including associated recreational facilities and site and building improvements. 2. CUP 09-024: New conditional use permit for age -restricted apartments utilizing a parking ratio of 1.7 parking spaces per unit. Pursuant to Sections 3.4.2.A and 3.4.5.A of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan, multiple family dwelling units (apartments) are conditionally permitted in Planning Areas 4 and 5. 3. Amendment to Tract Map 16581: Due to the proposed change from ownership to rental tenure, an amendment to TM 16581 will be required to be documented in a resolution. (An amendment or Certificate of Correction to be recorded on FTM 16581 will be required prior to issuance of a building permit, for review and approval by the Public Works Department). 4. Amendment to Concept Plan 03-003: Due to. the proposed change to rental tenure, an amendment to the Concept Plan is also required to be documented in a resolution. Public Input Prior to the Planning Commission Hearing Prior to the December 8, 2009, Planning Commission hearing, City staff was contacted by three (3) individuals who expressed questions and concerns regarding the proposed project. 1. Mr. Paul Mobley, property owner and resident in Columbus Square, had questions and concerns regarding HOA facility access, parking, and the 55 -year age restriction. 2. Mr. Tab Johnson, property owner and resident in Columbus Square, had questions and concerns regarding the proposed parking ratio, the parking effect on an already -impacted situation in the community, and the guarantee that the property will remain for seniors. 3. Mr. Eric Higuchi, property owner and resident in Columbus Square, expressed his opinion that: • Property values will be negatively affected if 25 percent of the units in the specific plan are for rental; • Lennar is a homebuilder and not experienced or qualified to operate as a property manager for the project; The parking provided is insufficient; the senior community will have a greater demand than what will be provided, parking is already impacted in the community, and the 240 -unit project will add to the impact. Planning Commission Report January 26, 2010 CUP 09-024, DR 09-024, et al. Page 4 Responses to these concerns were addressed at the public hearing on December 8, 2009, and are discussed further in this staff report. For full project -specific details, please refer to the staff report dated December 8, 2009 (Attachment A). Planning Commission Hearing of December -8, 2009 On December 8, 2009, the Planning Commission conducted a public hearing on the subject items. The hearing was attended by many residents and property owners from the Columbus Square community including seven (7) speakers who expressed concern with the proposed project. Due to the feedback received at the hearing, the Planning Commission continued the item to the January 26, 2010, meeting to allow the applicant (Lennar) and the proposed housing provider (Meta Housing) an opportunity to meet with the Community Association to address their concerns. The major issues raised at the December 8"' public hearing included: • Lack of prior notification of the proposed project from the applicant to the community residents and association • Rental tenure in an otherwise ownership community • Parking • Homeowners' Association (HOA) dues and representation and Community Facility District (CFD) fees At the December 8, 2009, Planning Commission meeting, Lennar also submitted a letter requesting amendments be made to Conditions 1.9 and 4.9 of proposed Resolution No. 4134, Condition 1.5 of proposed Resolution No. 4136, and Condition 1.8 of proposed Resolution No. 4137 (Attachment B). Public Input Following the Planning Commission Hearing Since the December 8t' Planning Commission meeting, staff has been contacted by several individuals who own/reside in Columbus Square regarding the project (see Attachment C). In summary: Mr. Carlos Cuyugan submitted a letter requesting a copy of 'the Commission letter addressed to the HOA but delivered to Lennar instead." It is not clear exactly what Mr. Cuyugan is referring. to, but staff believes he is requesting a copy of the Official Notice of Public Hearing, which was mailed to the Columbus Square Community Association at Lennar's address as explained in the "Notification of Project" section of this report. • Mr. Paul Mobley, Mr. Tab Johnson, and Mr. Lee Whiteley raised concerns regarding the resulting increase in association dues for non -Coventry homeowners and voting rights in the community association allotted to the apartment community. Mr. Mobley also expressed concern with what he perceived to be a decrease in association revenue and steady or rising association maintenance costs. Planning Commission Report January 26, 2010 CUP 09-024, DR 09-024, et al. Page 5 Mr. Eric Higuchi submitted an additional letter on behalf of the Camden Place Neighborhood Homeowners in opposition to the potential increase of HOA assessments. • Ms. Stephanie Yang, owner and resident in Columbus Square, via email voiced objection to "Section 8 apartments in our community." • Mr. Jeffrey Enes via email questioned if the proposed project could be considered a "taking"; if renters would be allowed to use community facilities and its impact on maintenance of these facilities; if the landlord would be responsible for CFD taxes associated with the project, impacts on noise, pedestrian, and vehicular traffic, age restriction; and, if non -age restricted ownership tenure could be considered as a land use alternative. • "Stop Coventry Rentals," a community group, submitted a letter in opposition to the proposed project changes, arguing that the approval of a CUP for rental apartments will be detrimental to the general welfare of the residents of Columbus Square in terms of additional fees and loss of control of the association board. • A "Petition against Converting Coventry Court from Ownership Tenure to Rental Tenure" was submitted to the Community Development Department on January 19, 2010. The petition comes from homeowners in Columbus Square and has a total of 361 signatures. (Signatures have not been verified). • A letter from Lee and Wanda Whiteley states the opinion that the proposed project will only be beneficial to Lennar, META Housing, and the City of Tustin, not to the residents of Columbus Square due to the changes in HOA fees, voting rights, and quality of life and general welfare of the community. Meeting with Community Association At the December 8, 2009, meeting, the Planning Commission continued the item to allow sufficient time for the applicant to meet with the Community Association (HOA). Subsequently, representatives from Lennar and Meta Housing attended the December 16, 2009, meeting of the Columbus Square Community Association. Ms. Donna Kelly of Lennar provided a letter to the Community Development Department summarizing the events of that meeting (Attachment D). DISCUSSION In general, the issues raised regarding the subject project that are discussed in this report are: 1. Notification of the project 2. Parking 3. Community Association facilities, dues, and voting rights Planning Commission Report January 26, 2010 CUP 09-024, DR 09-024, et al. Page 6 4. Community Facilities District (CFD) fees 5. For sale vs. rental units 6. Occupancy by seniors 7. Developer qualifications 8. Request for amendments to proposed conditions of approval by the applicant It should be noted that some of the items (i.e. Community Facility District fees, community association fees, and voting rights) are discussed in this report for informational purposes only due to the number of inquiries received on the topics. The City is not the regulatory agency for such entities. Notification of Project Speakers at the December 8, 2009, public hearing raised the issue of the lack of advance communication regarding the subject project. Many residents were upset with the fact that the developer of the entire community (Lennar) had planned on converting the 240 -unit project from ownership to rental but had not informed or extended the conversation to include the existing homeowners in the community or the Homeowners Association. Staff Response: Pursuant to the California Government Code, prior to consideration of certain discretionary actions, a public hearing must be conducted with advance public notice mailed to all property owners within 300 feet of the proposed site's boundaries, as listed on the County Assessor tax roll, a minimum of ten (10) days prior to the hearing. In accordance with the state law, City staff prepared an Official Notice of Public Hearing which was mailed to all property owners within a 300 foot radius of the subject property, including . the Columbus Square Community Association, ten (10) days prior to the scheduled public hearing. As the developer (Lennar) still holds seats on the Community Association board and Lennar's address is listed on the Assessor tax roll, so the Notice of Public Hearing addressed to the Columbus Square Community Association was mailed to the Lennar address, as required per state law. Additionally, the Official Notice was published in the Tustin News on November 26, 2009, posted on the public notice board located outside City Hall, and staff posted two (2) staked "Notice of Public Hearing" placards on the site more than ten (10) days before the December 8t' hearing. In addition, the Planning Commission agendas are available on the City's website. At the Planning Commission hearing, the Lennar representative stated that the lack of notification to the community had been an oversight. Following the Planning Commission. meeting, Lennar provided an additional address, c/o Merit Property Management, for communications with the association. Future notices from the City will be sent to both the address appearing on the Assessor tax roll (currently Lennar) and to the Merit Property Management addresses. For the January 26, 2010, public hearing, additional public notices were not mailed or published in the newspaper because it is a continued public hearing and the date of the continuation was announced at the December 8, 2009, meeting. City staff did post public notice placards on the subject site (two) and in front of the Village Conservatory (one). Additionally, Lennar indicated that Merit Property Management (property management Planning Commission Report January 26, 2010 CUP 09-024, DR 09-024, et al. Page 7 company for the association) would distribute and email to all owners within Columbus Square of the upcoming hearings for the Coventry Court project. Parking A topic discussed by several Columbus Square residents who contacted staff and spoke at the hearing were current and future parking impacts within the community. Mr. Eric Higuchi suggested to Lennar (see Attachment C) that the overall parking ratio for the project be further reduced from 1.7 to 1.58, spaces per unit to eliminate the use of 28 parking spaces located on Charleston Street (a private street) by the senior community. (In the previously approved parking study, 28 spaces on Charleston Street are identified as part of the total spaces provided by the project). Staff Response: When the Villages of Columbus were considered by the Planning Commission and the City Council in 2005, they were envisioned and approved as a complete community. The 240 -unit senior housing project approval in 2006 included a conditional use permit which authorized a parking ratio of 1.7 spaces per unit, based on a parking study prepared by a registered traffic engineer. The proposed project involves no change to the previously approved project and site design, including the amount and location of parking provided. The City's traffic engineer re -reviewed the previously approved parking demand analysis in conjunction with the subject application for 240 senior rental apartments and determined that there would be no difference in parking demand between a senior condominium (for sale) and senior apartment (for lease) project; thus, the 1.7 spaces/unit ratio can remain applicable to the Coventry Court project as proposed for rental tenure. However, in order to address concerns expressed by the community, staff has proposed additional conditions addressing parking to be added to the project. Proposed Conditions 8.2 and 8.3 of Planning Commission Resolution No. 4134 (see Attachment H) specify the minimum amount and type of parking spaces to be maintained through the life of the project and require the applicant to submit a Parking Management Plan for review and approval by the Community Development Department. In response to the suggested 1.58 parking ratio, a revised parking study would need to be completed to determine the feasibility of the proposed ratio and a change in the parking of the community could be considered a significant change in the project. A reduction in parking for this site would negate the argument that is being made (that the proposed parking is insufficient) and would bifurcate this community from the rest of the Columbus Square community. When the Villages of Columbus project was approved, the master developer was granted a series of incentives in return for the production of affordable housing. One of the concessions was the allowance of up to 100 percent of required guest parking to be fulfilled on -street (the MCAS Specific Plan allows for no more than 50 percent of the guest spaces required to be fulfilled on -street) in all Planning Areas within the Villages of Columbus. Based on the methodology in the submitted parking supply evaluation and the Planning Commission Report January 26, 2010 CUP 09-024, DR 09-024, et al. Page 8 Urban Land Institute Shared Parking Report which it references, guest parking should be provided at the rate of .15 spaces per dwelling unit. At 240 units, Coventry Court is required to provide 36 guest spaces. Twenty-eight (28) of the 36 spaces, or 78 percent, are proposed to be accommodated on -street. Therefore, the fulfillment of 28 guest spaces on -street for the Coventry Court project is permissible and consistent with the other communities in the Villages of Columbus. As originally planned, all residents within the Columbus Square community — including the future residents of the affordable senior housing project at Coventry Court — share the benefit of using these on -street spaces. Community Association Facilities, Dues, Voting Rights, and Community Facilities District Fees Concerns were expressed regarding the direct financial impact the 240 -unit community as rentals would have upon community -interest property, specifically: a) If renters will have access to use the community association facilities, would the renters be required to pay into homeowner association fees to maintain these facilities? Staff Response: Coventry Court will be part of the Master Association and their residents/tenants will be allowed to utilize the community facilities within Columbus Square that are outside of the Coventry Court development. Accordingly, Coventry Court will be subject to the Master Community Association assessment. However, many of these amenities including a club house/recreation center, pool, and spa are also provided within the Coventry Court complex. b) The impact on the Community Association's funds and fees paid by other members of the Association. Staff Response: According to the applicant, the Coventry Court sub -association would not be formed if the project becomes an apartment community, .but the 240 - unit community would be annexed into the master Columbus Square Community Association at a proposed assessment rate of 2:1. Therefore, each unit at Coventry Court would pay 50 percent of the community association dues paid by non -Coventry Court units. Currently, the Columbus Square Master Community Association (HOA) is operating under the Department of Real Estate (DRE) budget which is to expire in September 2010 when the budget will then be based upon actual costs and could decrease or increase, depending upon the actual costs. The HOA assesses each unit at the same rate, including the affordable units. The monthly assessments are currently at $126.00 per month (this is with 705 homes units paying assessments). At build -out, the current budget will assess each unit $113.00 per month based upon a total of 1075 homes. with Coventry assessed at one-half assessment per unit, the total number of units subjected to the Community Association assessment would effectively be 955. This would have each unit within the Columbus Square Community Association assessed at Planning Commission Report January 26, 2010 CUP 09-024, DR 09-024, et al. Page 9 $127.20 per month and represents an increase of eleven to twelve (11-12) percent over the previously projected $113.00 per month. However, this estimate does not account for any increase or decrease in the updated budget in September 2010. Pursuant to California Civil Code Section 1366 under the purview of the Department of Real Estate (DRE), if an assessment increase does not exceed twenty (20) percent, no approval of owners or board of directors is required. While this information is being provided in an effort to respond to questions raised by the community about the project, it should be noted that the City itself does not play a role in establishing, adjusting, or enforcing HOA dues. c) Voting rights within the association (individuals expressed that there may be an imbalance of voting rights if 120 voting rights are given to one entity [Tustin Coventry Seniors, LLC]). Staff Response: Currently, each unit represents one (1) vote in the Community Association. With the change to rental tenure, the proposed representation (voting rights) rate of the rental community would be 2:1 in correlation with the 2:1 assessment rate. As proposed, Coventry Court would. have 12.0 votes or 11 i percent of the total voting rights within the Columbus Square Community Association. Coventry Court's representation within the Master Community Association at various ownership scenarios . Representation Rate Total votes Total Units Percentage 1:1 (240 condominium owners) 1/owner 1,075 0.1% 240 total 1,075 22% 2:1 (1 owner, 240 rental units) 120 1,075 11% Again, this information is reported for informational purposes, and is based on the City's understanding of the CC&Rs applicable in the Community Association. The City generally does not establish, amend nor enforce CC&Rs. d) Will the project would result in an increase of the Community, Facility District (Mello Roos) fees? Staff Response: Based upon the approved Community Facility District (CFD) assessment, the change in tenure type to rental does not affect the applicable assessment since the project would remain as a senior affordable housing development. Planning Commission Report January 26, 2010 CUP 09-024, DR 09-024, et al. Page 10 For Sale vs. Rental Units Some individuals stated that when they purchased their units, they were assured that all units within the community would be for sale only. One individual questioned if such change in tenure would be considered a "taking" from current homeowner community property rights and if the change in tenure type would have impacts upon the community's noise, pedestrian and vehicular traffic, and lighting. Some property owners in Columbus Square expressed their concerns about the characteristics of an apartment community and rental tenants and the qualifications of the proposed housing provider to manage such a property. A concern was raised that a Section 8 apartment complex would be built in lieu of a senior housing. Others have stated that they thought the project as rental units might be beneficial to the greater community in that it would move this and other projects forward to completion of construction. Staff Response: Lennar states that notification of the possibility that rental housing could be located in Coventry Court was given in the Master Disclosure and Master Declaration of Covenants, Conditions, Restrictions, and Reservation of Easements for Columbus Square, provided by the homebuilder and required to be signed and acknowledged by each purchaser as part of the escrow documents. The applicable excerpt from each of these documents are attached for reference (Attachment E). The adopted MCAS Tustin Specific plan allows for up to 25 percent rental units in the Tustin Specific Plan area. The proposed project is within that limit—the 240 units constitute less than 16 percent of the 1,540 total units in the Villages of Columbus and approximately 5.3 percent of the total projected residential units in the MCAS Specific Plan area. The applicant for the project is Lennar as the managing member of Tustin Coventry, LLC (property owner). The City in this case is the regulatory agency responsible for land use under the provision of the City's codes and regulations. The City's action in granting or denying use permits is limited to determining whether or not the project would be detrimental to the health, safety, morals, comfort, or general welfare of the persons residing or working in the neighborhood, nor be injurious or detrimental to the property and improvements in the neighborhood of the subject property, or to the general welfare of the City of Tustin. This action is within the legal authority granted by State Law to the City to cant' out and implement its general plan through actions including, but not limited to, the administration of specific plans and zoning and subdivision ordinances. The project does not propose any changes to the previously approved plans (including site design, architecture, landscaping, lighting, parking, access, etc.). The submitted plans are consistent with the plans previously approved by the Planning .Commission in Design Review and by staff in plan check. The project will remain as an affordable, senior, multi- family development, as previously approved. The project, regardless if it is for ownership or rental, would implement the City's Housing Element by providing affordable units and by Planning Commission Report January 26, 2010 CUP 09-024, DR 09-024, et al. Page 11 meeting the needs of the senior population. No additional noise, pedestrian and vehicular traffic, and lighting impacts are anticipated. The project, regardless of `tenure type, is required to provide 153 affordable units. These units must be made available to qualified seniors (Very. Low, Low,. and Moderate Income Senior's). Should the conversion to rental housing be approved, the provision of the First Amendment to the Housing Agreement requires the developer to use its best efforts to fill vacancies of the affordable units. While the City does not require that all affordable units be rented to Section 8; Certificate or Voucher holders, a provision is included in the First. Amendment to the Housing Agreement that no affordable units designated for rent to a Senior Citizen in a Very Low Income Household or Low Income Household shall be refused for leasing to a holder of a certificate or voucher under 24 CFR Part 982 Section 8 Rental Certificate'Program or Section 8 Rental Voucher Program or to the holder of a comparable document evidencing participation in a HOME tenant -based assistance program. Additionaily, all property owners within the Villages of Columbus were provided a "Homebuyer Notification" which identified that affordable units would be located throughout the communities; each buyer is required to sign the acknowledgement prior to the close of escrow. An example of the Columbus Square Homebuyer Notification is attached for reference (Attachment F). Appropriate findings have been proposed in Resolution Nos. 4134, 4136, and 4137 f (Attachment H) outlining reasons why the change to rental tenure would not be detrimental to the health, safety, morals, comfort, or general welfare of the persons residing or working in the neighborhood, -nor be injurious or detrimental. to the property and improvements in the neighborhood of the subject property, or to the .general welfare of the City of Tustin. There, could be advantages to the other property owners in Columbus Square and the Community Association to coordinate with a single property owner and --a single property management company as opposed to 240 individual owners in terms of property maintenance, collaboration, etc. It should also be noted that most homeowners (except affordable units) in the remainder of Columbus Square are not precluded from renting out their unit on an individual basis. Senior Occupancy A concern was expressed as to the terms of senior occupancy of the. project and whether the project will ever be converted to allow residents other than seniors. In addition, an individual questioned if non age -restricted ownership tenure could be considered as a land use alternative if the current project is no longer economically feasible for the developer. Staff Response: The Coventry Court project was approved as part of the overall Villages of Columbus project. At the time of the approval, the master developer requested and the City granted a density bonus in return for the production of affordable housing which included incentives such as, density bonus, density averaging, concentration of affordable units in the seniorproduct, parkland credit; and transfer of affordable units. The project, was also approved with reduced parking .due to the nature of the project as a senior affordable development. For these reasons, the project will need to remain as a senior Planning Commission Report January 26, 2010 CUP 09-024, DR 09-024, et al. Page 12 housing development for persons of fifty-five (55) years or older regardless of tenure type. However, the term of affordability is limited to a period of fifty-five (55) years; upon conclusion, affordable units would no longer be required. In addition, but excluding the affordability restriction, conversion of the project from an age - restricted to non age -restricted complex is prohibited per proposed Condition 1.11 of Resolution No. 4134 for the following reasons: 1) The project would need to comply with all the provisions and development standards for multiple family dwellings, including parking requirements, as prescribed in the MCAS Specific Plan. Due to the senior occupancy and affordable components, the applicant submitted justification (parking study) to support a reduction in parking requirements (from 2.25 spaces/unit to 1.7 spaces/unit). Should these components no longer be a part of the project, parking would need to be provided at the ratio of 2.25 spaces/unit. As the project is currently designed, no excess spaces are provided and no room exists on the site to add additional parking spaces to meet this requirement. Also, additional environmental reviews would need to be conducted to address any potential impacts related to the project. 2) As part of the interconnected elements of the master developer incentives, many of the affordable housing units were allowed to be concentrated in the senior product. If the product is no longer specifically for seniors, the location of .so many of the affordable units in one development would be considered a concentration and alternative locations would need to be provided to avoid the over -concentration. As the remainder of the units in the Villages of Columbus have been, sold and built out, finding an alternate location for most of these affordable units would likely be very difficult. 3) As mentioned, the developer was granted a parkland credit in lieu fees in exchange for providing affordable housing. Should the affordability no longer be part of the development, the developer would need to the pay applicable parkland credit to the City. Developer Qualification Mr. Higuchi expressed his concern regarding Lennar's experience in developing and running senior housing project. Staff Response: The applicant has indicated that a new entity, Tustin Coventry Seniors, LLC, will be the ultimate owner of Coventry Court. Tustin Coventry Seniors, LLC will acquire the property following the approval of the requested entitlements, and plans to contract with Meta Housing Corporation as the property manager and senior housing provider, and Tustin Coventry Seniors, LLC will remain as owner for the senior complex. The applicant also has submitted a copy of Meta Housing portfolio describing the Meta Housing Corporation team, experience, and a list of projects which includes family and Planning Commission Report January 26, 2010 CUP 09-024, DR 09-024, et al. Page 13 senior housing developments (Attachment G). Based upon the submitted portfolio, it appears that the Meta Housing Corporation has experience and knowledge of operating approximately seventeen (17) senior housing complexes. Request for Amendments to Proposed Conditions of Approval Lennar, as a member of Tustin Coventry, LLC requested amendments be made to Conditions 1.9 and 4.9 of proposed Resolution No. 4134, Condition 1.5 of proposed Resolution No. 4136, and Condition 1.8 of proposed Resolution No. 4137 (see Attachment B). Staff Response: Proposed Condition 1.9 of Resolution No. 4134 has been amended to reflect future owners) obligation under the Housing Agreement and its associated Regulatory Agreement for the project. However, Condition 4.9 of proposed Resolution No. 4134, Condition 1.5 of proposed Resolution No. 4136, and Condition 1.6 (formerly Condition 1.8) of proposed Resolution No. 4137 remain the same since the obligation to the Fair Share Contribution to the Tustin Legacy Backbone Infrastructure Program including the adjusted fees as approved by the City Council on April 3, 2006, and September 2, 2008, and along with future increases are applicable to all affected parties including future owner(s). At the December 8, 2009, Planning Commission meeting, Lennar indicated their agreement to the conditions imposed. CONCLUSION Staffs recommendation that the Planning Commission recommend approval of the subject project to the City Council remains unchanged. Additional conditions have been added to address some concerns expressed by members of the public and the Community Association was given the opportunity to meet directly with the project proponents. The findings to support approval are as outlined in Planning Commission Resolution Nos. 4134, 4136, 4137. Reina Kapadia Elizabeth A. Binsack Associate Planner Community Development Director Attachments: A. Report to the Planning Commission, December 8, 2009 B. Letter from Lennar dated December 8, 2009 requesting amendments to conditions of approval C. Public Input - emails and letters received from residents D. Letter from Lennar "RE: Summary of Coventry Court Presentation to Columbus Square Community Association Meeting on December 16th" E. Master Disclosure statement and Master Declaration of CC&Rs (excerpts) F. Columbus Square Homebuyer Notification statement G. Meta Housing Corporation Portfolio H. Planning Commission Resolution Nos. 4134, 4136, and 4137 ATTACHMENT A Report to the Planning Commission, December 8, 2009 Report to the Planning Commission DATE: DECEMBER 8, 2009 ITEM #3 SUBJECT: CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT 09-024 DESIGN REVIEW 09-024 AMENDMENT TO TRACT MAP 16581 AMENDMENT TO CONCEPT PLAN 03-003 TUSTIN APPLICANT: LENNAR HOMES OF CALIFORNIA MANAGING MEMBER OF TUSTIN COVENTRY, LLC C/O DONNA KELLY 25 ENTERPRISE ALISO VIEJO, CA 92656 PROPERTY OWNER: TUSTIN COVENTRY, LLC C/O DONNA KELLY 25 ENTERPRISE ALISO VIEJO, CA 92656 FUTURE PROPERTY OWNER: TUSTIN COVENTRY SENIORS, LLC DEVELOPER: META HOUSING CORPORATION 1640 S. SEPULVEDA BLVD., SUITE 425 LOS ANGELES, CA 90026 LOCATION: COVENTRY COURT AT COLUMBUS SQUARE LOT 265 OF TRACT 16681 ZONING: MCAS TUSTIN SPECIFIC PLAN (MCAS -SP 1) PLANNING AREAS.4 AND 6 REUSE DISPOSITION PARCELS 23 AND 24 GENERAL PLAN: MCAS TUSTIN SPECIFIC PLAN ENVIRONMENTAL STATUS: THE PROJECT IS EXEMPT FROM FURTHER CEQA REVIEW PURSUANT TO SECTION 65457 OF THE CALIFORNIA GOVERNMENT CODE REQUEST: TO DEVELOP 240 SENIOR APARTMENT HOMES (AGE - RESTRICTED FOR PERSONS 55 YEARS OR OLDER FOR RENTAL TENURE) INCLUDING 153 AFFORDABLE Planning Commission Report December 8, 2009 CUP 09-024, DR 09-024 Page 2 UNITS, WITH A PARKING STANDARD OF 1.7 SPACES PER UNIT, RECREATION CENTER, AND ASSOCIATED SITE AND INFRASTRUCTURE IMPROVEMENTS AT LOT 265 OF TRACT 16581, ALSO REFERRED TO AS COVENTRY COURT IN COLUMBUS SQUARE AT TUSTIN LEGACY RECOMMENDATION That the Planning Commission: 1. Adopt Resolution No. 4134 recommending that the City Council approve Conditional Use Permit 09-024 and Design Review 09-024 authorizing the development of a 240 -unit senior apartment residential complex (age restricted to persons of 55 years or older for rental tenure) including 153 affordable units, with a parking standard of 1.7 spaces per unit, recreation center, and associated infrastructure and site improvements on Lot 265 of Tract 16581; 2. Adopt Resolution No. 4136 recommending that the City Council approve Amendment to Resolution No. 3951, which approved Concept Plan 03-003, to reflect a change in tenure from ownership to -rental for the proposed 240 -unit age -restricted senior housing complex on Lot 266: of Tract 16581; 3. Adopt Resolution No. 4137 recommending that. the City Council approve Amendment to Resolution No. 05-40, which approved Tentative Tract Map 16581, to reflect a change in tenure from. ownership to rental for the proposed 240 -unit age -restricted senior housing complex on Lot 265 of Tract 16581. BACKGROUND Coventry Court is a neighborhood within the community of Columbus Square at Tustin Legacy. In 2005, the developments of Columbus Grove and Columbus Square (collectively known as the "Villages of Columbus's were reviewed and approved by the Planning Commission ,and City Council. On February 14, 2005, the Planning Commission adopted: 1) Resolution No. 3950 recommending that the City Council approve Zone Change 04-003 to allow for the development of detached carriage way units and amended the minimum requirement for a development site from 10 acres to 8 acres; 2) Resolution No. 3951 approving Concept Plan 03-003; Resolution No. 3952 recommending that the City Council approve Tentative Tract Map 16581, a density bonus, and affordable unit transfer; and 3) Resolution No. 3953 approving Design Review 04-006 for development of 1,077 residential units for Planning Area 4 and 5 of MCAS Tustin Specific Plan known as Columbus Square (Attachment C). It should be noted that the 1,077 units, including 242 senior units, approved in Columbus Square were later reduced to 1,075 and 240 units respectively due to the redesign of the senior project. On February 22, 2005, the City Council adopted Resolution No. 05-40 approving the Tentative Tract Map 16581 (amended on March 7, 2005 to reflect parkland credits) and Ordinance No. 1297 approving Zone Change 04-003 (Attachment D). Final Tract Map 16581 was approved Planning Commission Report December 8, 2009 CUP 09-024, DR 09-024 Page 3 with the adoption of Resolution No. 06-17 by the City Council on February 6, 2006 (Attachment D). The approved project included a. density bonus and affordable unit transfer and required 266 affordable units including 153 units provided in a senior housing project to be approved under separate Design Review. Subsequently, on January 23, 2006, the Planning Commission adopted Resolution No. 401.4 (Attachment C) approving Design Review 05-019 which authorized the development of a 240 -unit senior residential project including the required 153 affordable units and Conditional Use Permit 05-037 authorizing a parking ratio of 1.7 parking spaces per unit. Since approval, only one (1) of the project's ten (10) 24 -unit buildings has been completed (see Figure 1). The remaining units have since been suspended due to the economic downturn. Recently, the applicant informed the City that they wish to resume the development of the Coventry, Court. The applicant has indicated that a new entity, Tustin Coventry Seniors, LLC will be the ultimate owner for Coventry Court. Tustin Coventry Seniors, LLC will acquire the property following the approval,of the requested entitlements, contract with Meta Housing Corporation as a fee builder to develop the property as proposed, and Tustin Coventry Seniors, LLC will remain as owner and property manager for the senior complex. Figure 1. Constructed building at Coventry Court Condition 1.3 of Resolution No. 4014 specifies that "the subject projectapproval shall become null and void unless permits for the proposed project are issued and substantial construction is underway within 24 months." While some building permits were applied for, approved, and issued, due to the economic downturn, the developer did not progress with. permitting and construction of the project beyond the first building. Consequently, Design Review 05-019 and CUP 05-037 for Coventry Court have expired; thus the applicant has submitted new design review and conditional use permit applications (DR 09-024 and CUP 09-024) for the entitlement While the developer has requested approval to resume the development as previously approved, the developer is requesting authorization to modify *the project's prior requirement for ownership tenure only. The developer is now proposing that the 240 units Planning Commission Report December 8, 2009 CUP 09-024, DR 09-024 Page 4 be provided for rental tenure. Pursuant to Sections 3.4.2.A and 3.4.5.A of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan, "multiple -family residential (apartments)" are a conditionally permitted use in Planning Areas 4 and 5. Since resolutions of approval for Concept Plan 03-003 and Tentative Tract Map 1658.1 specified that senior housing developed at Columbus Square would be "for ownership tenure," the proposed project necessitates amendments to Planning Commission Resolution No. 3951 and City Council Resolution No. 05-40. The changes are for consistency purposes and do not constitute a significant change from the intent of the original approvals. Lot 265 of Final Tract Map 16581 is specified "for condominium purposes"; an amendment or a Certificate of Correction to the recorded map will be necessary, as conditioned in Condition 1.6 of proposed Resolution No. 4137. In summary, the project proposal involves the following new or amended entitlements: 1. DR 09-024: New design review for the development of an age -restricted 240 -unit senior housing project including associated recreational facilities and site and building improvements. 2. CUP 09-024: New conditional use permit for age -restricted apartments utilizing a parking ratio of 1.7 parking spaces per unit. Pursuant to Sections 3.4.2.A and 3A.5.A of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan, multiple family dwelling units (apartments) are conditionally permitted in Planning Areas 4 and 5. 3. Amendment to Tract Map 16581: Due to the proposed change from ownership to rental tenure, an amendment to TM 16581 will be required to be documented in a resolution. (An amendment or Certificate of Correction to be recorded on FTM 16581 will be required prior to issuance of a building permit, for review and approval by the Public Works Department). 4. Amendment to Concept Plan 03=003: Due to the proposed change to rental tenure, an amendment to the Concept Plan is also required to be documented in a resolution. Due to the comprehensive naturee of the requests, the Planning Commission is being asked to consider the proposals and make a recommendation to the City Council. The Council will be responsible for taking action on the proposed new and modified entitlements, as well as the amendments to the Housing Agreement and Affordable Housing Plan to reflect the change to rental tenure. DISCUSSION Site and Surroundings The project site is Lot 265 of Tract 16581 (Columbus Square). It is also considered part of Planning Areas 4 and 5 (the site traverses the boundary) and Reuse Plan Disposition Parcels 23 and 24 of the MCAS Tustin Speck Plan. Columbus Square is a community of 1,075 homes' generally bounded by Edinger Avenue to the north, Valencia Avenue to the south, the future fire station site and Kensington Park Drive (formerly West Connector Road) to the east, and Severyns Road to the west. Within Columbus Square, Coventry Total approved number of units, including approved density bonus. Not all units have been constructed. Planning Commission Report December 8, 2009 CUP 09-024, DR 09-024 Page 5 Court is located in the northeast corner along Edinger Avenue, contiguous to the future fire station site, and directly adjacent to the Verandas and Cambridge Lane communities (see Figure 2 — Location Map). Figure 2. Location Map Project Proposal, Site Design and Architecture The project proposal involves the development of 240 units (24 units constructed, 216 remaining) on an approximately nine (g) acre site, including a recreation center and associated infrastructure and site improvements with a parking standard of 1.7 spaces per unit. No changes to the previously -approved plans (including site design, architecture, landscaping, parking, etc.) are proposed. The submitted plans are consistent with the plans previously approved by the Planning Commission in Design Review and by staff in plan check. The only change proposed from the previously -approved project is the requested modification to the housing tenure type from ownership to rental. The 240 units are divided into ten (10) three-story cluster buildings. The buildings are designed as U-shaped clusters containing twenty-four (24) units and are separated by either a minimum of twenty-six (26) feet of open space or a two-way drive with landscaping, parking, and sidewalks (See Figure 3 — Building Layout). Each cluster includes twenty (20) single car garage spaces and four (4) residential units on the ground floor and twenty (20) units on the second and third floors. The units feature six different plan types, either one (1) or two (2) bedroom, ranging from about 660 — 1750 square feet (see Attachment B — Submitted Plans for further details). For safety and convenience, the garages are designed with an interior access to the main corridors. Fourteen (14) of the garages take vehicular access from an interior courtyard and six (6) from the private streets. The main lobby, elevator, and trash chutes are located at the center of the building and within a reasonable distance from all units. In addition to the trash chutes, recycling bins are located on the ground floor of each building. Planning Commission Report December 8, 2009 CUP 09-024, DR 09-024 Page 6 MNOM n rr w Ne.ra r e o n. — 1L1 1 4 •. _rl Z IMblpirll 4 ��-«• - X , j_ jr ILI Ir I a il. it -rr rl .•l. 4Yi...... w1 w� � I . Figure 3. Building Layout The main entry leading to the lobby includes a small veranda that is separated from the street with an ornate wrought iron gate. The elevator tower is designed with decorative brackets and capped with a decorative cupola that is the focal point of the building. This element is also duplicated in the design of the pool building and the recreation center. The buildings are designed with stucco and brick veneer on the first and second floors and wood siding on the third. floor. The doors and windows are enhanced with wood shutters and Fypon millwork moldings. The balconies and ground floor patios include wrought iron railings that are compatible with the Colonial and Georgian architectural styles of other residential buildings in Columbus Square (see Figure 4 — Elevations). ■ w a __ a aft J1 r .�i A, i =[ c� S —.-_.— m ■fir. •,�.� - . . _ � _.w_ ■ v ��.�'=�I ��I �� `tel �1�• i LO `; tt _I I - N AUG i 5i CIammov mt Elevetion! KW Figure 4. Elevations Planning Commission Report December 8, 2009 CUP 09-024, DR 09-024 Page 7 Ownership Tenure Pursuant to Sections 3.4.2.A and 3.4.5.A of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan, development in Planning Area 4 and 5 of apartments is a discretionary action requiring approval of a conditional use permit. Section 3.4.2.H.4 (Special Development Requirements) states that consideration of a conditional use permit should include the City's preference for ownership tenure, and in any event, no more than 25 percent of the total number of units permitted within the Tustin portion of the Specific Plan area may be approved for apartments. The applicant (Lennar) has requested a change in the housing tenure from ownership to rental due to their forecast of the housing market. The applicant has justified the request by noting that: 1) Approval of the request will accelerate the construction and delivery of the required 153 affordable units within Coventry Court. For the project to remain as for -sale units, the current market and construction schedule would place the delivery of the affordable homes beyond mid -2012. If allowed as rental, the affordable apartments would be available in the marketplace with the completion of the project. 2) Construction of Coventry Court as a rental project allows the remaining market products within Columbus Square to comply with phasing schedules that require complementary delivery of market -rate and affordable products. 3) Coventry Court is located on a prominent perimeter parcel of Columbus Square; the completion of the project would demonstrate completion of a significant portion of Tustin Legacy. 4) The change in tenure does not necessitate a major change to the proposed plans. Additionally, approval of the subject 240 units for rental would remain within the 25 percent limit on apartments in the Specific Plan area. The project should be viewed in context of the greater master plan for the reuse of WAS Tustin and considered as part of the overall development of the Villages of Columbus (Columbus Square and Columbus Grove), in which it is the only rental project built or anticipated. The 240 rental units out of a total of 1,540 units in the Villages of Columbus constitute less than 16 percent and represents also 5.7 percent of the total WAS Tustin projected residential units. The Columbus Square development included a density bonus and the Columbus Grove development included an affordable unit transfer for some affordable units from Columbus Square. Parking Condition 2.2 of Resolution No. 05-40 adopted for Tentative Tract Map 16581 stated that [for the subsequent senior development proposal, any deviation from the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan parking standards for the senior housing would require approval of a conditional use permit which would include submittal of a parking analysis that would justify reduction in the number of required parking spaces, subject to review and approval of the City's Traffic Engineer. Previously -approved CUP 05-037 permitted a parking deviation from the parking standard in the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan (which does not Planning Commission Report December 8, 2009 CUP 09-024, DR 09-024 Page 8 differentiate senior multiple family units from other multiple family units) from the required 2.25 spaces per unit to a proposed 1.7 spaces per unit to accommodate the proposed senior housing development. The application for the deviation included a traffic study prepared by KAKU Associates, Inc., which drew examples from senior, market -rate, and affordable projects in several cities across the Southern California. with respect to the proposed project, the City's Public Works -Engineering Division re- reviewed the parking demand analysis approved under CUP 05-037 in conjunction with the subject application for 240 senior rental apartments. The City's Traffic Engineer determined that the difference in parking demand between a senior condominium (for sale) and senior apartment (for lease) project would be negligible; thus, the 1.7 spaces/unit ratio can remain applicable to the Coventry Court project as proposed for rental tenure (CUP 09-024). Affordable Housing Per the adopted Affordable Housing Agreement and Housing Plan for Planning Area 4 and 5 (Columbus Square) at Tustin Legacy, 153 of the 240 senior units proposed at the Coventry Court site are designated as affordable housing units. The project as proposed includes the same number of affordable units (with 87 units anticipated to be rented at market rate) at identical locations, unit size, bedroom counts and income designations as the previously approved Housing Agreement and Housing Plan. However, the proposed changes in the project's tenure necessitate amendments to the Housing Agreement Affordable and Housing Plan. The amendments implement new rental language, terms of affordability, and regulatory agreements. The amendments to the Housing Agreement and — Affordable Housing Plan will be considered by the City Council along with the other project entitlements; the draft document is included as Attachment E to this report strictly as an informational item for the Planning Commission. The Housing Element (adopted June 2009) of the City's General Plan identifies the aging and elderly as a growing population with special needs. The Coventry Court project has been identified in the Housing Element as an approved project to be implemented to meet the City's housing projections and goals. If approved, the Coventry Court for -rental apartments will contribute to meeting these goals (at an accelerated rate). The type of tenure does not alter the original intent of serving the housing needs of the target population. PriorApproval and Conditions of Approval The project's site layout, design, and architecture are consistent with the plans that were previously approved by the City during the plan check process; however, since the applicant suspended construction after completion of the first building and did not obtain further permits, the plan checks have since expired. To continue the development of the project, new plan check submittals will be required and minor changes to the construction plans may be necessary due to the adoption of the latest California codes in 2007. Since the senior housing development was originally approved as a part of Tract Map 16581 for the entire Columbus Square community, the previously adopted conditions of Planning Commission Report December 8, 2009 CUP 09-024, DR 09-024 Page 9 approval of that project would still apply. As a result, staff is recommending that a general condition of approval (proposed Condition 1.10 of Resolution No. 4134) on DR 09-024 and CUP 09-024 be included to clarify that all applicable conditions of City Council Resolution No. 05-40 (Tentative Tract Map approval) remain applicable. Additional recommended conditions of approval for DR 09-024, CUP 09-024, Amendment to Tract Map 16581, and Amendment to Concept Plan 03-003 have been included in proposed Resolution Nos. 4134, 4136, and 4137. Concept Plan and Tract Map The development now known as Columbus Square (or Tract 16581) was authorized by Concept Plan (CP) 03-003 (approved by Planning Commission Resolution No. 3951 on February 14, 2005), and Tentative Tract Map (TTM) 16581 (approved by City Council Resolution No. 05-40 on February 22, 2005). Both CP 03-003 and TTM 16581 approvals authorized the following: to subdivide 105.5 acres for the purpose of developing 1,077 residential units (later reduced to 1,075) including 84 Single Family Detached (SFD), 181 Carriage Way SFD, 72 Multiple Family Attached (senior housing -- for ownership tenure) for a total of 337 units at an average density of 8.62 du/acre in Planning Area 4 (Parcel 23), and 18 carriage way units, 552 Multiple Family Attached (MFR), 170 Multiple Family Attached (senior housing — for ownership tenure) for a total of 740 units at an Average density 17.53 du/acre for Planning Area 5 (Parcel 24) of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan. The Concept Plan and Tentative Tract Map approvals specified that the future senior housing was to be for ownership tenure. The proposed senior apartment development necessitates amendments to the CP 03-003 and TTM 16581. The amendments would include the change in tenure type and additional conditions specifically related to the proposed senior apartments. Resolution -Nos. 4136 and 4137 reflects the amendments to CP 03-003 and TTM 16581. ENVIRONMENTAL ANALYSIS California Government Code Title 7, Division 1, Chapter 3, Article 8 addresses the California Environmental Quality Act (.CEQA) in relation to Speck Plans. Section 65457 provides that once the EIR has been certified and the specific plan adopted, any residential development project that is undertaken to implement and is consistent with the speck plan is exempt from additional CEQA review. The exemption does not apply if after the adoption of.the specific plan, substantial changes in the project or circumstances under which the project is being undertaken requiring major revisions in the project, or if new information becomes available which was not known at the time the EIR was certified. The development of Coventry Court at Columbus Square is a residential development project that is consistent with and is being undertaken to implement the MCAS Tustin Speck Plana No substantial changes in the project nor circumstances under which it is being undertaken have occurred and no new information which was not known at the time the EIR was certified (or amended) has become available. Therefore, the proposed project is exempt from additional environrhental review under CEQA. Planning Commission Report December 8, 2009 CUP 09-024, DR 09-024 Page 10 FINDINGS A. That pursuant to the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan and Section 9272 of the Tustin City Code, the location, size, architectural features, and general appearance of the proposed development will not impair the orderly and harmonious development of the area, the present or future development therein, or the occupancy as a whole, in that: 1. The proposed senior residential apartment development is a permitted use in Planning Areas 4 and 5 of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan, subject to approval of a conditional use permit; 2. As conditioned,. the proposed project is consistent with the development standards and design guidelines of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan; 3. As conditioned, conformance with all other applicable development standards, including current California building codes, will be verified by staff during plan check review; 4. The proposed site and building improvements are substantially consistent with plans previously approved by the Planning Commission and Community Development Department; 5. The location, size, architectural features and general appearance of the _ proposed development are consistent with and will not impair the orderly and harmonious development of the area, the present or future development therein, the occupancy thereof, or the community as a whole. B. That pursuant to Tustin City Code Section 9291, the proposed senior apartment development with a parking ratio of 1.7 spaces per unit will not be detrimental to the health, safety, morals, comfort, or general welfare of the persons residing or working in the neighborhood, nor be injurious or detrimental to the property and improvements in the neighborhood of the subject property, or to the general welfare of the City of Tustin, in that: 1. Mufti -family residential apartment housing is a permitted use in Planning Areas 4 and 5 of the WAS Tustin Specific Plan, subject to approval of a conditional use permit; 2. The 240 -unit senior apartment project is in conformance with the MCAS Specific Plan, including the limitation of rental units to a maximum 25 percent of the total number of units permitted in the Tustin portion of the Specific Plan; 3. The change from ownership to rental tenure will not result in a change in the design, operational characteristics, or intent of the project as previously considered and approved; Planning Commission Report December 8, 2009 CUP 09-024, DR 09-024 Page 11 4. The aging and elderly are identified in the Housing Element of the City's General Plan as a growing special needs population in the City. The Housing Element identified the Coventry Court project as an implementation project to meet the City's housing projections and goals; 5. The project as proposed remains an age -restricted senior project and will benefit the target population as originally intended; 6. The 153 affordable housing units will be provided just as originally approved in terms of number, location, size, bedroom counts and income level, in conformance with the approved Housing Agreement and Affordable Housing Plan for Columbus Square; 7. Approval of the project for rental tenure will allow for the project to progress and deliver the affordable housing units to the market in a more timely manner and in conformance with the requirement for reasonable proportionality in development of market -rate and affordable housing units; 8. A parking demand analysis utilizing a parking ratio of 1.7 spaces per unit was previously approved for age -restricted senior condominiums as CUP 05-037 by Resolution No. 4014, has been re -reviewed by the City's Traffic Engineer in conjunction with the subject project, and has been determined to be satisfactory, adequate and applicable to the project as proposed for age= restricted senior apartments. C. That the subdivision of 105.5 acres and development of 1,075 residential units at the Columbus Square site, including 240 multiple family attached senior housing units for ownership tenure was approved under Concept Plan (CP) 03-003 by Planning Commission Resolution No. 3951 and under Tentative Tract Map (TTM) 16581 by City Council Resolution No. 05-40 and Final Tract Map 16581 by City Council Resolution No. 06-17. The project as proposed also necessitates text amendments to Resolution No. 3951 (CP 03-003), Resolution No. 0540 (TTM 16581), and FTM 16581 to ensure consistency of the approved housing tenure type from ownership to rental senior units, and that the necessary amendments are determined to be consistent with the intent of the approved Concept Plan and Tract Map. bSL Reina Kapadia Elizabeth A. Binsack Associate Planner Community Development Director Attachments: A. Location Map B. Submitted Plans and Approved Parking Analysis C. Planning Commission Resolution Nos. 3950, 3951, 3952, 3953, and 4014 D. City Council Resolution Nos. 05-40 and 06-17 and Ordinance No. 1297 E. First Amendment to Housing Agreement for Columbus Square F. Planning Commission Resolution Nos. 4134, 4136, and 4137 Attachment A Location Map LOCATION MAP ADDRESS: LOT 265 OF TRACT 16581 COVENTRY COURT AT COLUMBUS SQUARE PROJECT NO.: CUP 09-024, DR 09-024 DEVELOPMENT'OF 240 SENIOR APARTMENT HOMES � ,I Attachment B Submitted Plans and, Approved Parking Analysis 1 n N p t m 110/ 0 r C cn cn L �a pm z cn a m z 0 G r r a n m n. 0 n m c a r Ell I --4 m r a z a� J � SIB A 00 x� q6 gF MINOR NV a i 7u i S 3<Atas .p e— ! n ll# y + i u X C� an LL + o N m U N U 0 0 ar .� 0 �, 1 1 - tta , o o ° b ` U .UJ V m _ a� G n c� go . it Y m El r Ci by m V _ IN N . it Y o 0,4 No L C� CY c dCo I ! j A C, i i cm L� IE 1 is LLA y W r N � O jh L 0 a r� u _tea �= 0 s� �- - iIIiiIS "%IiiWii.i iilI, ,t';` .i i ,111111 I A all Ci IL Mll Not J,; art k <_6 X9.9 — ai 38 �. 1 l� Wu i ' Z- x <_ Jtl �i t 3<iSs� is S � Z l�0 S e u w a O � 73'f w Eb�yy ..7 'b a I � � x 04 U IL in Fr 00 • N U �..........—_..01-:91-.._...._ i _ FAL to r---� r----------- 7.11 C fli I U 1p ? -- -1 --------------- --- I. N L---------- J ------ .Ih -..'— <_6 X9.9 — ai 38 �. 1 l� Wu i ' Z- x <_ Jtl �i t 3<iSs� Z 3 n ills I r6� 4 ti� 3 3� iS 2 9 Iii .� HU a �:m t � I � ,I i i4 y •� �"rte `�� - � • � ` lilt til! n 11 I .� HU U Fo + 4,= t }5 I 1 s FE�liz I � yy( 4 1 ll, I t l� f U Fo LA � . � 7 ! ] .CIO : � - » _ R� >» eV DUPLICATE. 33 SHEET I'w LB ` OF LOT& "° '�°'' TRACT NO 16581' � AM �ia AX M NUMMERm: 383' Y I AJ� II LETTERM M2 LOTS 1 THROUGH 15 OF TRACT t4O. 54 IN THE CITY OF AREA - 106.471 ACRES GROSS TUSTIN. COUNTY OF ORANGE. STATE OF CALIFORNIA, AS allE AREA 727 ACRES NET SHOWN ON THE MAP RECORDED IN BOOK 80, PAGES41 THROUGH TWE DATE OF SUR%t"f FEB. 14. 2005 44. INCLUSIVE, IN THE OFFICE OF THE COUNTY RECORDER OF warMAlolr ORANGE COUNTY' !Aa 411 IN THE CITY OF TUSTW, COUNTY OF ORANGE, STATE OF CALIFORNIA mu KY -+m ' ^ Li MICHAEL SWW4 P1S 6034 TAIT k ASSOCIATE$ INC. W (`,L) OWNERSHIP CERTIFICATE TDM" I DALE OF SURVEY: FEBRUARY 14. 2005 [oM 2q•25i,f$4-3617ANV 3WW301 AV44W'S`AQRCf71toMft4MACA!L'W3 WL 11L � INNM M ALL PMICS HMO MY I== TALE lomm N THEV, K SAD MAK LI W OMMIMPI K PW*MUNML Me OWNERSHIP CERTIFICATElCONTIMM WE HMW DMICA E m M CITY OF TLMK AS MOM MOM16 [pY ►pY �) POM71N1W ar MVMRYM M015,LM1211tJ11IILIII11M 6010 MD VIO! LOIWdiN. �4 AK C CLDY m 121 OF ® AMYL•WYI►aZ7ZMAl 0It3 MWAW"iOTRAP[ QMNN M MU".AT To {p- IgIRi11EADdq p�I�p�, WC. NO MN NK.0 w- NO ANtlW10. E COMWEM 11E OOWf, 600 i, ZA ANS 2N AT NOLTI T0[. TI!>r fYIR�! ML iA016i MRf p TM6 FADPOIIOI M WONR MR-SEXIMI O, LADS(AJPM AID NAENOYY M PUMMEL ' Al WOOD POR NOME OXMINNT AND I INIOMMCE AMPOM L M IMI®' WG1M aF M CUEMM ON1Nt OF M MP-13W(LOT 12 M EjHDMD FOR PIRJP UK AND KOM AMM PI PMM D1NL IDM ND t0► 131 NO W IA 1T AO IDf 16) M[ICOS PLIMME I ACWIOIRm0O1 M4,4114 231. LOM MF AD Ai URN W.N.P. N.T, Y AD X. TWAT R ONY M MMS Collum NOOK POWM COYPLIOM OF naltm m �pp0 pgppA�p��_� _ _ MOEOMON WON R WINK UK SAD PPACELS ME m K COMM m LDW►IR. Y. MM M I M�IIpp0. IDIS . TX00W0N0 O�7 QMCIMCC YOIFiiT LtAO0W6 MR116714 YC NRl M01 DII�WIO A161 AMgNi. . L.OM u TINU m, LAM FA IIMMJ IDIS Pq LLi16 Ik TMU OK U03114% THRI NO AND IDM N TMX1 0. NCIDEM M NOM[ IOMK AN AMU EMMMM JON MM SERVICE VENLTSM ftl NO MMS,LHISIMU MPCD 1MANNOOM MOrOM Aro PUDIC MM OWN IDM IN TMM CJ. MCLLAW , RDL LCOgIt10ND aFFICfJ1 . WE ALM NMOY POEM[ AND N UMUK ALL VVM=M AOCIM 1011103 NOTARY A.CKNOMMEDGMENT: m ONWm AMK PM K FMTM CP'MVW MU ROW VAUMMA HINM too► ItAAD NRI WINT wWLRTOR, evcwr AT Wfl RLfNOEI.TINM APO 2 MPRMYM AR21M LWJWW M. COUNfY WBi,Y�LSO WE AM NNW OmIGWE M FCUDMD M NEW IOEpY 2eAMMMMMcaE1oRN oowMn WM WOM AM0c mR1 FOR LAND- S. ® N =1 EM0w MOM ��7p�MM yp�p{p��2TMMP�gX� ON nW . so= IIF PENEONMLY APMAMM IMMLAIMYME�Ig1 1sfLM tMC1 FAiDNi ��- AAW LLM A'd JSLT TO 7M M0! �NOy AM GOWN RIM{ M AR� ylpyOL EL TSS am M M Nom Ic CAI MOdCE) m t PPMWNNM IM�YE(>q M ONMINf fEOaROM 11i. 1 Lof AS IIItF. 11p. 61•p7M11ff,, s11LC1AL s�IpS V */AM N!� IOM WILLM MONA6R M AO MOWEC A m IR TIW 4MMNW COMMAND M A� CIDTfNIL TIME N/ TOM MALL M PLM1M N 3,W IMIVMM/DlO' OLpOm M "It N IMMWVMM M0400021) CVACIIV(!S) AM1 Amm � w11 wx MNYm co -- r AM TIN HMIs wililm wit IWfNCf. 11NT d Iq/la/OOI WIOIN7IMETW) ON M MmAoR M FOIMFI(Wj. ON M �. A PETE M' 6011 A ARIq +• WIN tMNIN► T6 TIO IIOIRORIMN MNCMLM EMILY LM01 bMif a MSCJI' M MIOON(� ACRD. OQDLRED M s EMILIM f. Far. LOE A1D ruwa ACCMF FU POW ITS MI Mlle A MAIMt LMim UVIRM COW NY. WIII!>s - /�yy Wn UMM MCM W CA/CMK NC.. A UMWOMM OMIPOROgK =AM 7P I MY PNNCJPIL PLACE W NJM45W m iM WI - =AMY PI WE A1D f1711[ ■ N �� or, EW6IAYr�y EAOA- W COISWDM Comm PONE WYAL .] ��'ofts: NNFIm) mE VIlf_ ullM NOTARY ACIQIONaEDOAIENT: . ar CEFOMM► 2M IIOFFID IIfA00W5 A OOAWAIE Ulm I IMM CQ~AS OWNER AND AND IOIDICIMY URJL 7RIJSf NmOMOm .RET• 2W. 7006 M WIST. IIO.Yi 2000000508M 20000000sOSN. 200E0006s1076 AD 100600Ms1JM SPMOMMEWim, P MN ML LM A OO/MIM Ulm LMM OONPAM'. W. TAM MILL43 W INI� LLC. A _MUVMW Wim LIIWIY COIPW .. LMR WOMB HMM OF CAOOMK MIC. A CM10MM OOKORMION, iPMM Y NYE, •II,�f PIi, tacr,�a WTl 0, Tl --,I .:-rsr+�T OIN.MMWNI LLr, A CN/OMM UINm U AMM CM~, si: OM NL>DOOINXF' ULiLG L NYlSRNRS L .LP. A CM0CMM LMM PARRJCRlIR. R;' ISO ACAM. F UC, A. DELMVE LMM WMRY CM~. m IIMIDN mm L6, A ODIIWIE WED UUMJIY COLPAY, SY: - PMIf WYE WI.NOUMM PMMM L V. A GLFOIMM UWM PA M AW n: IM NOUMD NIIHDEIEIR K LIC. A CNNOEM.LMM WMJIV MN,1'AITY. LIE OEINLW YAR11611 WM�Y 'WJMA NM'WJMAMM R. UC, A NNNNON LMM UMMM 00~. NP., NEYEM, M KALI' W.T110M Pit. A WASHMOM COMPIMI ON. Ar— Rh PMM NME PMR MME: ON TME wom M' EMILY LP01 BOWL OF MWCn' M PO wMOs W wom NONI{K MOOM PLMM N AND FOR SAD SPATE (LULL POMO CWFOIMWI 2__ t. ON nM� . MFOE PEFAMW W40 ICI OOIIAILY m 70 LIE (at PWAD1010 ME m M M MAS01[(6) NIOM WNW[W) NR AND ACIOXIMIDM m ME nN NOV"M WRONOZD CAMCITVCM AND II•, SMSRRRNf M M1O011(f� OR M �'AF1M ON.1Rm M ►mMRR71Y. PERSONMLY APPV"M MOVALY MD1M1 m YE (OR Pomm m LIE M WE MPEM01(>h WH Ort AM ACANOMIOOMD m LE 1NAT N1NIdt AUMONOm CAPACOMM AND wrom w NAM NONA7INE MY PNXl•1L sL smse NMM FIWD N MD WW WAD sm O M COMM W COIs0M10M OPMft DULL PIMM) - NOTARY ACIMNAADGMENT, STATE or cotim Or ON TIM �IT�=�• . 6VO(E LE. __ " YiL1.M '..PERIOWLLY APPLA ED DrlabfWMAANR---'- - - -I momELY GLOM To LE (WR•TRMAm=.w IWI<IfE NOCAID m M wom SEIMRND AD TO K T7ma 1M�Oq/nNR movAl (O ON M mmom DR im POM01L(S), OR M ETm IMON WDULF OF WHICH M POW" W= EX m m M NNMJIENf. WIIIlSW W IWDI . NOM1nJM[fL W PMNCM PLACE OF MINIMIZE!NOONY PU C iLOR MAD STNS ■ N o01MIM w oPno(L•a!-� OWL rtr+lm) SEE NRT 2 FOR MW% AgOoomma mm OOIMIY TMFANMER-ux OOULLSon CDTKIOW[. WIONMuIL OLINWIONR s0111RYO11Y ANONR, COLN" sunEYa1YW SfAE110R, C11Y O1WE1Ff117 WfATOIEMf IND CIN' 12Dtl1'S CmfsICATL SHEET.2 OF III (ALL Of "° '°'' Numm O"um'""� TRACT NO 6581 NUMBERED: IiFM LOTS 1 THROUGH 1a OF Tf ACT NO. IN TFE • 10&4471 ACNES GEM CITY OF TUSTIN, COUNTY OF ORANGE, STATE OF CALIFORNIA. As AREA ; • 727 ACRES NET SHOYIM ON THE MAP RECORD IN BOOK M, PAGES 41 THROUGH 44, DATE OF SLRVEr FES. 14, 2006 INCLUSIVE, IN THE OFFICE OF THE COUNTY RECORDER OF ORANGE COUNTY IN THE CITY OF TUSTIN, COUNTY OF ORANGE, STATE OF CALIFORNIA ' MICHAEL SMON, PLS 0064 TNT t ASSO.CIA7S, INC. DAZE CF'WR". FEIIRUARY 141 2006 .. 4079 W-LNE; 29-n*AND 771-�"r/MOWBASATIT Q7MIOa1L1 //f,R/G�i� COUNTY TREASURER -TM COLLECTOR'S CERTIFICATE: Wn .01 fI67aR0k , 11Eldw-cOFIW TINT AD=" W M Nm0606 w W OFFICE, mm AK NO UJEIMA�WNYWW M IAD COWIIED M THE MW ON NM MRI THOW FOR �1D/II•' 8TAAE DO, MPAL IFECOR LWA VM OR iPNCK ORL llA DOPF TA WD OR VVCM'A1aNOR! C011D7® M OF . ,TAM MYET PaAtL AND 00 CWW TO INE WD:ONppt OF OMI K CLNIY TWT M MOMIOIB OF TME SUIll MN MAP, ACT INK !NI COMPLIED NR AMWW DUMIS W swm P+D M TJyQ%w OF Ti117} ON�WWK A=US MR 0MLO ED AE UM ON DAM TI�Of TR� 200/. AOM M.N., MOOIWAOM' . CDNIIY TFALM1EKR-TAR uuR:TOR NOTARY ACKNOVREDGMENT: . I= or C4001100 t� . DDWWm a�tl WTM dlNe%aF'1"a ME. AFFIMm Glia-- - � PDISOWLY 1000 W W (0*4RMiii?It O[EIMIMmW MWNOW KAM. DM'AOD". TW0 [MM W M NNMNi1R�D M� NI M D/INY LrW ND,WE OF: rAECM M PtWSM* AMM DRCURD M NENRNAW, wymns �. 9BNDUA w PLACE OF lIINiS6 ARY PIA11C R AID Fon SAD AAtE e.N•�w!mIr ea r L. Id"rq'rIA�. w DolNmat OPBOSV�l.7 OI" PWNFm) NOTARY ACIWONILEDGMENr , $TALE O GIUOMA D - cotmw Of .. THS SXlfN P N&WIi PDMNWLY APRAWm ON T1[ LATS OF SAYArACMW LVDDM�1bf 0To 001K I DION W W (011 •INA W M POlgl(>q NDE W FUME(!) M/A,Ht 71MELY� W M N11N NNNNQR rd AOCgMmOm W 1 v HHD'. +BI/+rA/Oa,NOMTIEE(S) Ol 1K NNMNOR� 11®PER1011(Ji OR im DRAY Vdl lDIMP NEN M PEIBON(lq'AMM DOARm M NSN►NOR. NOMOS w IW4 ,��� ,�// SMNWIK�Wi'!-yyl�I�JN6� W PIN OF EUMN{SE NMW PDX N AND FOR SW ANC M N 06URY 1:+L�w1 ITPMAlA NIMIm) W C0IRMMOI CPEO 009 (IMINE . NOTARY ACKNOWLEDGMENT' ANE O CMRpMN.) CCIlRY O D -►- 9A ,n,rW McD.J&.-,s PE0.TOi+(LY APPEMm rEn>Q-l�-ra S.awAh : PUMNYLY Wow W ME (OW-PM.[M-TYNE K TW 5/AA&S1M0C1IM� lHE OWN WFIDRMDW A A ONW ME TW w4vw41RY CVRD M FILE N M/IO(/AIOt NA01®. CNAOIY(IF* AND MAT N /EE/11MAfDNW SD/LATYEji) O/ M' NSIBWpf M PfAON{!J 06 M Nn(Y iR011,ECWF N N►LW M PDL7011{h AC7FD. DECUIm M IISIIIIDEIIf. NTINa w SWONAIUK - W FIJI=1_O_lIYNOS NIDTAWY' NAD 7 ND !WAVE M N L tlO1MlY 1 D. #dA►�.S w uNRoaoN DaAND� 99Ja�B OWE PIMRm) c h..•t 1µ65311c sNGNATURE OMIN)SIOFIB: rom" ' W THE PROM M OF Sw m MOM mm O Dr aWDMEDN AW ACT, M PoUOMID TWWW= MW !DF COIWIIY OF DIWIOC IINDEII OM WDOR PON PMPgINL AgODN, WOCODD YARCN'11, HSN N 5001[ 011/1 ►BOE 771 OF D®l kMYiN91. pP1N7� p" amp A {allow ,A'Lr aV9 AS J2VSPXA MWr Z a bOUECEt AWrvA.o JM S7+%v, ou�u�.r 3V TIES MAP W FlOWIW w M OI L"m W aW.TOI AND R MEO UPON A MCONFORMAlICK OROMI �W OF ACF AND IDGLK MMWNEC= LLC., N FCWJW 200E. I NOM/Y SpA TNT ALL IFORMON! AIE O M CIYIIICM AM OCMIF M PWIIOM NOCTmI OR T10 TEY WL R DI N ■PCN POERDI* AID YWR LTD NOMNOIR AW l FPK3W W DUM M SU W W K ([DNpD. 1 MF u SWE DW TNR FN11 NV pAETAMYLLY CW~ W M WIDRIONNLY APPWM IDRWM W►. mom SMOK P AFAOMTON DPND 06/SO/07 �LWulr E!N COUNTY SURVEYOR'S STATEMENT: w I wm ANL aw I FUME DMNMD TIK MN AND fwm MAT ALL WPPNO PIICRNNM O M S MOM MAP ALT IYNE SM COMPLIED NM AND I AN SKFAFPD ID4�0 W R 1EL�CHNICILLYCOMM MU1M W %a JSW N+/ BUND f. WO TOJ—DO Or Ng" 2001. 4j4cAt. l- zvurr NAYMOD L MATE LL 0106 R OWRQ DPEo 03/31/04 * ►M.OMAN IRBM + CITY ENGINEER'S STA I MW ANE TNT I W9 DfNMRD THIS MAP AND FOIL O W O SLMDNIWLY N CMVM MIC[ WM M IMM MO. P ROUMMU M FLIED NNL AM= AND APPWM N M C11Y CMU:L TIAT AL MDMIDWG O M MIRDAOWCII LW ACF AND DnY NIeoA1F1N MOHAA0IN ALAN OP2N COW= UM AND M MM It 7ECHOGMLY COMET N ALL' W TWIT NO SG17m W IN.M COMP SINIIMIOL DAIm THS +r Otl' OrAgwL. 2007. .. OIY ENONMEN OF Mcrrf INS REMMOM DPMD 06/.10/00 A� CITY CLERK'S CERTIFICATE: SHOE OF CAIOEM COMIY OF OMIM2E s 1 WWW CO MY 7W 7W MAP VRA PWWMD FOR API OL W M COY COl�1�O M CW O K A KRAM MWW TIOImF IOD ON M DIIF O 2006. AD 1060 7NOW OII NPD COIODI OiD. N'A7fJMMOM NMM1Em �D11OMD. APMOK SAC MN. AND DO ALSO ACCWf ON HCWI O M COY OF =Me ® AAT =WRWNN�NMM I.M)�M 1WN 11 TW an f TON N MML14 W DOW. ® M EASEMW FOR SDENICA LA40SWM AND MAMDWM R ONi 10 M /MOOR FOR NWAL =APMINT AND 1W MV= PIW"M ® M CAEFIOR FT KIVIX IME AMD NOW ACC{4S FSNFO/D, M U LOM 2061 206. 371. IDR AAI AM HMA UM B4O.RILS.T, U AD7L M ACCDS FA1DOR FOR DIDODI.Y VEHCIl ACCOO. PUBLIC SE M:E RAW ►IMIW AND FORF7l. AND PANIC Mm 01101 LCR A TW Y. LOU M DW AQUA SATIM IC LCR CA DOLI O. LM IDIS G TDI t T W L. � AFIMaOi GA m WIML 01l IDIi NA MW L AIM PCR M iHN M AOCM LL70OFI MR FUNIC lD111C[ VEI►CIIIAR N06LSS ND !>711fSS. ASIPWORDIIIIIIIS D AND PLWUC'uM11Ns oyVl1 LORE G IIID 0L NCUINL VROMM A�MC{LM WW= TO CWNMN AVNOE. FMAC T'06T10N OF SOMM � .�IDWTN LOW MID AND WEST C"WIIM, M WNAAMD ® POW WW OF MMM* WWAD. VALLIOA WMR LWF PAW AND WEST CONNLC,011. AND DID ALSO APROK SURALT MAP FUMWVR W M PRWMDNM O 1D^1DN N436(SX3M O M NW MMN MAP ALT.�,-•-, DOW IM DAY O O S{1lQJODL 2006. FAMBA SUCIIIIIIIVI CM CLDN cm Of TUNA i� 1977 DUPLINT9 35 SHEET 3 OF 18 — -- ( NU IU TENTATIVE TRACT N0. 16581) TRACT NO. 6581 NUMBER OF LOTS: BE NUMRED: 363 LE71ERDk 162 LOTS 1 THROUGH 15 OF TRACT NO. N1 THE AREA . 105.471 ACRES GROW CITY OF TUSTIN. COUNTY OF ORANGE. STATE OF CAUFORWk. AS AREA 72:7 ACRES NET SHOWN ON THE MAP RECORDED IN BOOK 868, PAGES 41 THROUGH M, DATE OF S1RVEr: FEB. 14, 2005 INCLUSIM IN THE OFFICE OF THE COUNTY RECORDER OF ORANGE COUNTY IN THE CITY OF T USTIN, COUNTY OF ORANGE, STATE OF CALIFORNIA MICHAEL SBNNL P.L.S. 6034 TAIT t ASSOCIATES, WC. DATE OF SURVEY: FEBRUARY 14. 2005 Lo71P ncs-29st, 2!1-s0 MD 332-3W IAC 600 MR CWOQWN•IMfGRh79R6 CE ,TIWATE OF ACCEPTANCE . IRVINE RAN^.H WATER DISTRICT t LME 6allo M(L swMEr W aE 7W 6OMb OF aE MI, ar wwft 1MMof CGWADd6REC1 bD M9:>tr const 11NT M WldEfts W RUL PROFe" a01M11 Ar 0E)1W1011 ON THIS SUMNA gN'MW AK'NWM ACIVM M . TfE WCOMIRM OTIM ON. SUWF W 11E 6oM6 W OSIOOIaI - W WANE Amm Mao, Ownwr mmom R to A mom om"Aw w N=wnoN Ift 1s71-111 OF TN[ BMW ar.aecel m ADww am Nmww a 1e7c w:.k�: ` sElylElARr ar 1f1aME IEweN 1D17a D1SDtlCl ANO iK SDAf1D DF OfSD01aRS DfDEOF NOTARY ACKNON4EDOAIFM: srA1E OF au►owM 22 omm or4S� I'M ON .fI .1Mr � 1E.�^"'F ^"'��POWORMLY APPEWIM . OM US -MM ar fMa/ASIORY PumKfw now TO ME (all rmm W ba 4 TO t 7NE PE 1S MW MERE wm" ==I—,* /�C SIwM71wm W M MW MML% 1R MO ALIOCMMM A 1f< 71W 6t/>lf��e+���[—,* 1NE SME N ISIHDl, *M AMlMORM &PACNtV" AND T" wovi " ON M NSIEAEMr 1ME M= all 11E INIM P'E71EONp1 ACRD, E7wL- M Pw111U1rNr. MA11D: MDNA7W „'Or � NfoESS fA7rARF w ue N POR SMD STAR 1S N AIN! 171tA w aaNnEgM aawo Plrilm) . r '9f *01100 ccs 1104 0 �o es o 00o s Lf Now Ito e)' Cw� a A "n B 1H3HS ass \ iwu OF WAS * 1 ro \ E aw�rl � 1 S � L] I. � � °R1 11 NOlf)NMI8IIM G I . (I R I [� T C0 19 LottAM Am AM m' (oil AM AW JA I k MPI ■ I � `J R 1 � z��•� I I � >� � q�� � � m -- .� AM L*, 1 A� I M�.{T — 1 � la ' I , C�1Rt .M.t{• 7.KX/M— anp OM 70• i�M bRif _$1. �► ..� �" � � Tf4 133HS 33S �p -- --+��------=---- --- -- " rw� err 1 q { , � f Amn AM I 1 $ s too Ul ttrr � too co cogj t Ico�,. o��� 1 - m h fI /I I p wrmr AI - d .LOl 1 O �i I I s rkw W \ l AVM iMLLS NOLONLAGO yl iol m q I W L�n es+ 1 a�J07 _ ^�AYM�NIOOIf7�_��1�� r ., $ a 133H8 338 Oh 31VOndna tce E OL LSMHS ass /h 31d�lld(10 GLS . f. M4 rim la R as 1= "101- �w I /h 31d�lld(10 GLS . 67-7 DUPUC i'E. 4"? SEPT 10 OF 18 - `OF NUhIw w wm "'"""°'°' TRACT NO. 16581 303 LETmIAJIIBEIIE� 1ER0 1G2 IN THE CRY OF TUSH COUNTY OF ORANGE, STATE OF CALIFORNIA AREA AREA � 106.4T ES ACR48065 NCMAEL MWP.L.S 0034 TNT t ASSOOIATES, INC. AREA x'72:7 ACM NET DATE OF S1 MM FEBRUARY 14, 2006 DATE OF WRVE1: FEB. 14. 2006 LOM 110-1p. 214-M M& 332-M NMAWA fat OM Ommm Kwam 0 20 100 100 100 SEE SHEET 4 FOR MOMAUT NOTES, 2PNE I% w REOM DATA RUM= SURIEYWS NOTE, BASS OF BEMNGS, DARN STATEWW t OM*' RMP NOTE, DEDICATION AND -EAS: IT ROTES �( e SEE Sh1E7 8 / 1 129' I 124 fLor aoo _N 1 I I . i 128: 1 W 1126 1126. I II � I I II i-;--4 LOT E k - rlrar lax R aw 182 163. 184 185 186 �m w OC. "A Af10RNWAYy �Vll 4W W20,111 200 18Y 1>E w I 00 W — av W >t NreSrr ow � LOONGTON STREET 204 205 .200 207 206 --wa2rrti .nn. 715--=Lj4ffBAa7r— NA o2rati 228 222. 221, 220 218 ' — A Nr2r" bras LOT G '11,1 327 I . • I 1 SEE SHEET 16 0 c 0 2f17 � Nor. ,-ar*-�s•r.� r -•ate-; asr.-arra rc ��-rac-*-as-r• a r•:'as�-: ar•r-'arlr-a Cis �2222L i•'i ["*'"�rz"i r s o � fs;.-i.-a r•-r-� s-ra r;r. as:z"arr-aroma I wro-�--- LOT U h 316 ( I I 2" SEE SHEET 17 a rx "' 71vul101lu �rr�Ir�d��lllltlllti W� 1210dN3AV0 Noo m,7' sh monaaa uo I . I k". a ig Gil off * 11VOndna Uo 8L 133HS 33S (iI III � I L L 13HNS 338 x J •I I _es r A A I 4� � I r Lob g r RE " W H o o zb « J N U n�Q I N bib 11, +�€ o, fin �, fi Nil 91Vanana "ll m i bib 11, +�€ o, fin �, fi Nil 91Vanana "ll °y I.IYOndna uD rrr ,Poole Gtr PARKING SUPPLY EVALUATION FOR COLUMBUS SQUARE SENIOR VILLAGE Tustin, California REVISED NOVEMBER 2005 PREPARED FOR LENNAR HOMES - ORANGE COAST LAND PREPARED BY M� MA&%CiATES PARKING SUPPLY EVALUATION FOR COLUMBUS SQUARE SENIOR VILLAGE Tustin, California Revised November 2005 Prepared for. LENNAR HOMES — ORANGE COAST LAND Prepared by: KAKU ASSOCIATES, INC. 201 Santa Monica Boulevard, Suite 500, Santa Monica, California 90401 (310) 45&9916 Ref: 1968 TABLE OF CONTENTS I. Introduction................................................................................................................. 1 II. Parking Code Requirements........................................................................................... 4 City Codes, — Market Rate Housing.................................................................... 4 CityCodes — Senior Housing ................................................. 6 Institute of Transportation Engineers Parking Generation Manual .................... 6 Urban Land Institute Shared Parking Study ....................................................... 9 Affordable Housing Parking Demand................................................................. 10 Summary............................................................................................................. 10 III. Parking Field Data........................................................................................................... 11 Southern California Experience.......................................................................... 11 San Francisco Affordable Housing Surveys ................................. I.................... 14 Valencia Senior Housing Survey........................................................................ 16 Summary.............................................................................................................. 16 IV. Conclusions................................................................................................................. 17 f Appendix I LIST OF FIGURES NO. 1 Project Site Plan......................................................................................................... 2 2 Parking Supply and Demand Survey.......................................................................... 12 LIST OF TABLES 1 Parking Rates for Market Rate Housing........................................................................ 5 2 Parking Rates for Senior Housing................................................................................ 7 3 Data for Residential Parking Demand — Institute of Transportation Engineers Parking Generation Manual ................ 8 4 Southern California Coastal Zone Residential Parking Survey .................................. 13 5 Parking Occupancy Count Results — Residential Developments in San Diego, California ....................................... 15 1. INTRODUCTION Lennar Homes — Orange Coast Land proposes to construct a residential pro in Tustin ft California. The project, Columbus Square Senior Village, would include 24 units that would be restricted to seniors. The project would also incl de a recreation or center the use of which would be limited to residents of the project. A total of 64% of the project dwelling units (du) would be allocated as affordable units. Figure 1 shows the site plan for the proposed project. The project, located on the west side of Edinger Avenue between Red Hill Avenue and Jamboree Road just north of West Connector, proposes to supply a total of 409 parking spaces (sp) to serve the 240 dwelling units in the following format: Covered Garage 200 sp Carport 40 sp On-site uncovered 130 sp On -street 28 sp Disabled 10 sp Disabled Van 160 Total 409 sp The proposed parking supply equates to 1.7 sp/du (409 sp/240 du = 1.70 sp/du).' City staff is concerned that the proposed parking supply may not be adequate to meet the overall parking demand of the project. This report investigates the parking demand patterns at residential projects, concentrating on parking at condominiums and affordable units. Where available, the parking demand patterns at condominiums and affordable units focused on seniors are discussed. ( ' Approximately five parking spaces would be allocated to staff of the Recreation Center during the weekday, daytime hours. At all other times these spaces would be available for use by residential guests. 1 T W W I-- 55 -55 �U LL W i O w The report is divided into discussions of parking code requirements and parking demand studies. 3 II. PARKING CODE REQUIREMENTS Senior and affordable residential projects typically have lower parking demand ratios than comparably sized market rate housing developments that serve a mixture of tenants including families. The number of occupants per du is typically lower at senior housing developments than at market rate projects where families may occupy a portion of the units. The reduced occupancies often lead to a reduction in the number of automobiles per unit, resulting in a lower overall parking demand ratio. Surveys have shown that 5-10% of the units in a senior housing development have no automobile at all, further reducing the overall parking demand requirements. CITY CODES - MARKET RATE HOUSING Many cities and counties recognize the difference between market rate housing and senior and/or affordable units by reducing -the amount of parking required for these types of developments. Table 1 shows a summary of parking ratios and required parking supplies for a sample market rate development of 100 du made up of 10 studios, 40 one -bedroom units, 40 two-bedroom units, and 10 three-bedroom units. The required parking for the development would range from 125 to 325 spaces, with the City of Tustin requiring 225 spaces. As can be seen, Tustin is near the top of the list in terms, of the most stringent requirements. The parking rates shown in Table 1 apply to market rate developments with no discounts for seniors or for affordable housing. r z Parking Study at Valencia Senior Resldentlal Projad, Korve Engineering, City of Burbank Community Development Staff Report, June 2001 4 ALI c 7 p y 2to O� _ CL CNcM1�1-1`0Q m O �pNM1-1-1-0)0)0)()00T 1A04ALAIAOtAtA0000NM tnMMGOtC) 00000TCMMcON T T T T T V� T.: T-: T N N N N N N N CV tM O O M M 10 09 to to co 8p 8p N M UA M M GO W) TMCMCMN N N N N N N N N M Or �? .O `) N N N N N N N N M NMN .0 000000000 V OOCD, c Z Z Z T CI M C to 0 N m � E l6 m N N N N N N N N N M N M N N N m et 0 G M T CV CV cV c m m a.�N���NNNNNNNNNNN C4 C4m Rl 0• c Ix > 0 m �;to wwww "Itian T T T N T N N N N T T T T T T T T T T c� E 'L. 0 7 to Lo LO Lq T T T T T T T N T N T N N N N co U v�tg� ��� a 1 U Um mVE0 em�`a 0 0: CM 0 N c�o2m=m.00�4 d c �.�Q: 78 c 70 = �v •- O U ca m •'C.. N ,C C C C 0 C ?. c C y C 0 C x Uto C ca J Zi>uoJ�cod. coOcoo 1—= CO [1 C m M _O .0 C O m N N CA C ' C y O CO _ CO T M. V a` 0 0 Z IA .4 O OC C R '0 N y a ` o C '� Q � f-- �' w - CL U � 00 n a� ami _ co D CITY CODES — SENIOR HOUSING Table 2 shows parking requirements for the same 100 -unit development constructed as senior housing., The five cities listed recognize that senior residential units generate a lower parking demand than market rate housing and thus reduce the senior parking requirements by 19-56%. The average reduction for senior housing parking requirements is approximately 40% when compared to market rate housing requirements. The proposed ratio of 1.7 sp/du for the Columbus Square Senior Village project would exceed all five of the City senior parking ratios for the six cities listed in Table 2. This does not even take into account the fact that 64% of the proposed Columbus Square Senior Village project is affordable units, which would tend to reduce the parking ratio even further. The Cities of Burbank and Berkeley reduce the market rate parking requirements by 25% for senior housing projects, consistent with the data shown in Table 2. The City of Santa Monica requires a parking ratio of 1.45 sp/du for senior housing that is limited to low-income seniors, (and 0.45 sp/du for downtown low-income senior housing), indicating that the combination of the two factors yields a substantial discount in on-site parking requirements. ,. INSTITUTE OF TRANSPORTATION ENGINEERS PARKING GENERATION MANUAL The Institute of Transportation Engineers (ITE) has just published the Third Edition of Parking Generation,' a national compilation of measured parking occupancy studies at various land uses. This edition has many new land use categories, including Senior Housing, and is based on a much more extensive set of data than the Second Edition. Table 3 shows the relevant data from the publication. The data indicates that the actual parking demand for market rate residential ranges between 1.04 and 1.96 sp/occupied du. Parking Generation recommends the use of the 8e percentile data point as the appropriate planning level for new projects. In the case of the market rate housing, the 85'" percentile ( 3 Parking Generation, Third Edition, Institute of Transportation Engineers, Ransford McCourt Editor, Washington D.C., 2004 .11 TABLE 2 PARKING RATES FOR SENIOR HOUSING City Hypothetical 100 -unit Market Development Hypothetical 100 -unit Senior Development Percent Reduction for Senior Development Total Spaces per Total Spaces per Spaces Unit SNOBS Unit Cathedral City 125 125 100 1.00 20% Anaheim 238 2.38 150 1.50 58% San Clemente 213 2.13 122 1.22 43% Ventura (County) 185 1.85 150 1.50 19% West Hol cod 195 1.95 60 0.60 38% Hypothetical Development fused on 10 studios, 401 -BR units, 40 2 -BR units, and 10 3 -BR units Source: Southern Califomia Association for Non -Profit Housing, 2004 See Appendix for full report �. TABLE 3 DATA FOR RESIDENTIAL PARKING DEMAND INSTITUTE OF TRANSPORTATION ENGINEERS PARKING GENERATION MANUAL Land Use Category Number of Sites Surveyed Peak Parking Demand Measured in Field Low High Average 85th Percentile Market Rate Condominium 8 1.04 1.96 1.46 1.68 Senior Housing 2 0.34 0.5 Source: Parking Generation, Third Edition, Institute of Transportation Engineers, 2004 parking demand was measured at 1.68 sp/du, exactly the supply level proposed for the Columbus Square Senior Village project. The market rate housing data was based on counts at eight developments, five of which were in Southern California. Data is also presented for two senior housing developments in Huntington' Beach, California where the peak parking demand was found to be 0.50 sp/du. This field data verifies the parking code reductions for senior housing discussed above and shown in Table 2. URBAN LAND INSTITUTE SHARED PARKING STUDY The Urban Land Institute (ULI) is in the process of updating the 1980 study entitled Shared Parking. The Second Edition of Shared Parking recommends the use of 1.85 sp/du for multifamily condominiums. This ratio is broken into 1.7 sp/du for tenants and 0.15 sp/du for visitor parking. The ULI Shared Parking report does not include senior housing as a separate land use and therefore it does not recommend a specific parking ratio for senior housing. The report does explain, however, that parking ratios for land uses not included in the study should be added to the Shared Parking considerations based on the parking characteristics of that individual land use. With 1.85 sp/du recommended for market rate housing, it is clear that a parking analysis using the ULI methodology would begin with a parking ratio of at most 1.67 sp/du even if only a 10% reduction for senior housing was applied (1.85 sp/du x 90% = 1.67 sp/du). Shared Parking, Second Edition, Urban Land Institute, 2005 OJ AFFORDABLE HOUSING PARKING DEMAND The Appendix to this report includes Parking Requirements Guide for Affordable Housing Developers° The report speaks to the rationale for providing less parking for affordable housing than for market rate housing, and it cites examples of cities that recognize parking reductions for senior and/or affordable housing. iC yt Market Rate Requirement Affordable Project Requirement Los Angeles 1.3 sp/du 1.25 spidu 1.05 spidu (near transit) Long Beach 1.95 sp/du 0.75 sp/du Santa Barbara 1.98 sp/du 1.00 sp/du Santa Monica 1.90 sp/du 1.45 sp/du SUMMARY The parking ratio proposed for the Columbus Square Senior Village residential project is consistent with the ULI study and it exceeds the parking ratios recommended by ITE. It exceeds the required parking ratios for all of the cites shown In Table 2 that have a specific requirement for senior housing and it exceeds the parking ratios for affordable housing projects for the cities that recognize this land use category. 'Parking Requirements Guide for Affordable Housing Developers, Southern California Association of Non -Profit Housing, 2004 10 Ili. PARKING FIELD DATA While the comparison of the proposed parking ratio to parking rates required by other cities is informative, the City of Tustin Is Interested in the actual parking demand field experience at other similar developments. Data for condominiums reserved for seniors (with a portion allocated to affordable units) is limited, but the field data summarized below has application to the proposed Columbus Square Senior Village project. SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA EXPERIENCE In 2001, Kaku Associates, Inc. conducted a parking demand study for residential developments in Souther California urban residential developments. This study was submitted to the California Coastal Commission in support of a City of Long Beach approval of a parking supply Cthat was below the 2.16 sp/du required in the City's Local Coastal Plan for projects along Ocean Boulevard. The parking demand study measured the peak residential parking demand at 11 residential projects spread among downtown/waterfront Long Beach, Marina del Rey, downtown/waterfront San Diego and downtown/waterfront Santa Monica. The peak parking demand at these 11 sites averaged from 0.66 to 1.59 sp/du. Figure 2 and Table 4 show the results of the parking demand study. Since the City of Tustin -Is interested In the parking demand at condominium projects, the counts at condos have been highlighted. While these projects were not necessarily senior housing projects, they were primarily non -family., units. Their location along the coast and/or in urban centers made them high cost units that were primarily occupied by senior "empty nesters" or young urban professionals. The auto ownership patters and the income levels at the surveyed condo sites can be expected to be higher than at the proposed Columbus Square Senior Village project. 11 8 $ i N CV r r. C C np i zaavag 16ul4+wd t G ii t- 4uup Od- C oMN�Nvi�W C � C T- v � TZ v 1- C Q i AN �p �l��t�ttiRA � J Nr-NNN�` CL C a. n �O N �pp pp $ Z F �O N18412iDig r cl a..05vNi�ic��ir7Pf W g �A w a N w mmmo sem°AS oo°g �- �- •- UN O a�RaRa��aRaR��e ae � O z� sell O W m ZN AN N�LO 2 CO O (/1 a' Oi5 , ppb optQ �C O 3 m 5 VlAAsss ?} 1— OCU�UU�OC�UU� W N The study results show that the condo developments studied had parking demand rates well below the 1.7 sp/du proposed for the Columbus Square Senior Village project. The parking studies showed a range of actual parking demand of 0.93 to 1.43 sp/du with an average peak parking demand of 1.31 sp/du, or 22% less than the parking ratio proposed by the Columbus Square Senior Village project The remaining six sites measured were rental projects in the same geographic areas and the same financial level as the condo projects. The rental projects had peak parking demands ranging from 0.66 to 1.59 sp/du with an overall average of 1.07 sp/du. In 1996, Darnell & Associates measured the peak parking demand at seven residential sites in the University City area of San Diego. These sites were all rental projects. Table 5 shows the peak residential parking demand at the seven sites ranged between 1.15 and 1.52 sp/du. All 18 of the studies cited above have higher income levels (and higher auto ownership) than is expected in the Columbus Square Senior Village project The proposed project would be expected to have a lower parking demand than the studies cited because of the expected lower auto ownership levels. Of the 18 sites surveyed above, not one location had a parking demand that exceeded the 1.7 sp/du parking supply proposed in the Columbus Square Senior Village project. SAN FRANCISCO AFFORDABLE HOUSING SURVEYS A parking study of 12 low-income projects In San Francisco showed that the parking demand never filled the one space per unit parking supply required by the City zoning code. A Palo Alto low-income residential project was approved in 1989 with 1.6 spaces per unit (25% below the City's market rate zoning code requirements). The project was required to set aside a landscape reserve that could be converted to additional on-site parking supply d needed. After 15 years, the landscape reserve area is still dedicated to open space, not parking. 14 �I cc J n W F— 100 J V Q Q t- a v O z 2 tY IL 3 V O W_ O z N F— z W a 0 W O J g z W O N W ix ZQF—a �iNa�o M� LO IL W 0 Z CO W IVa' 00LO0MN co �aU t`cocotovv v CL y 0 � a O � � ao I- M CO Na. Q� r N V r r N r co COZ LL X O v N CO N M W M O O) co co co �- I a�Ga.. N e- CDcoinco co aZCa LL co OF•- LO 00 CO V- iT-o °r° 0z Z CDLacACIO MM M �-- W _CL Ixw0:woc0: 0: .o H to aN O C l0 5 lQ 'C lCd N En E a� 'cv L a� 0 co y 4) Z 3 F— > 'X .J J co m m E w a m E cU CL co cQ it o > � Q Q oif E c w n 13 til OC Z co VALENCIA SENIOR HOUSING SURVEY As part of a 2001 consideration of a senior housing application, the City of Burbank retained Korve Engineering to survey the parking demand at a 169 -unit senior housing development in Valencia, California. Parking occupancy surveys conducted throughout the day showed that the peak parking demand for the project occurred at 6 a.m. when 124 spaces were occupied. The resulting peak parking demand ratio was 0.73 spaces per du — approximately one-half of the parking ratio proposed for the Columbus Square Senior Village project. SUMMARY The field studies of both rental and condominium units showed that the peak parking demand at the surveyed sites were less than the proposed panting ratio at the Columbus Square Senior Village project In over 32 parking occupancy studies, the peak parking demand never reached or exceeded the 1.7 sp/du proposed for the project. 16 IV. CONCLUSIONS o� q�grthAC' The proposed Columbus Square Senior Village project will construct 240 senio&88 64% of which will be reserved as low-income units. The project prorking supply of 409 spaces to serve the project. The parking supply would provide one garage or carport reserved space per unit with the remainder in an unreserved parking lot configuration. The review of parking Zoning Code requirements in California cities.showed that many cities recognize the fact that auto ownership and unit occupancy rates are lower for senior units and low-income units than for comparable rental or condominium market rate units. Thus, many cities lower their required parking supplies for senior and low-income units. Surveys of peak parking demand occupancy rates at condominium and rental projects measured the peak parking demand at comparable projects. The field data showed that the measured demand at these projects was considerably below the proposed 1.7 sp/du parking supply at the Columbus Square Senior Village project. 11dw Based on the results of the survey data, we believe that the proposed parking supply of 409 parking spaces (1.7 spaces per dwelling units) will be adequate to serve the proposed Columbus Square Senior Village project. 17 APPIENDIX Parking Requirements Guide For Affordable Housing Developers Southern California Association of Non -Profit Housing 3345 Wilshire Blvd. Suite 1005 Los Angeles, CA 90010 www.scanph.org 03.,7.04 Table of Contents Parking Requirements Fact Sheet page 3 List of Relevant Resources 4 Best Practices Policies 6 Example Best Practices Policy - Los Angeles 7 Sample Southern Callfornla Minimum Parking Requirements a Related Newspaper Articles 11 "Rethinking Residential Parking: Myth 3 Facts" Appendix A Report by the Non -Profit Housing Association of Northern Calfornia Soud a Ca1Monda Asumladm of Non-Pro1H Houshp 3345 Wilshire Blvd. Suite 1005, Los Angeles, CA 90010 PH: 213-480.1249 www.scarnh.ora -2- ( Parking Requirements and the Cost to Affordable Housing Fear of traffic congestion and overcrowded street parking has led many cities to establish minimum parking requirements calling for developments to provide often excessive amounts of off-street parking. Aside from creating excess parking and adding to congestion by encouraging automobile usage, parking requirements have a tremendous negative impact on development of all kinds, especially affordable housing. Problems for Affordable Housing Developers • ina Costs - Parking requirements drive up the cost of development, resulting in less units of housing. Needing to spend more on parking means less funds available to provide housing. Some developments end up having more space for cars than for people. • Redumm the Potential for other AmenNies and Uses. Wastes Land - Parking requirements also mean that less money and land is available for other purposes. Childcare facilities, community rooms, and play areas may all be sacrificed in order to accommodate parking. The possibility for mixed-use, such as ground - floor retall, are also reduced, leaving other community needs unmet in the name of parking. • Less Attractive Desiata - Meeting parking requirements becomes a focal. point .MW in the design process and eliminates opportunities to incorporate open space. With less parking to consider, a building can be designed that more reflects a neighborhood's context and needs. Is All This Parking Needed? No. Parking requirements have largely been arbitrarily determined and do not usually reflect the verifiable parking needs of the people who will make use of a development. • Parking requirements have often been set using a "one -size fits ail" approach using information gathered during peak periods at developments with ample parking in areas with few public transit options. • The likely residents of affordable housing do not require a great deal of parking. Studies show that the correlation between income and vehicle ownership is strong, with the likelihood of owning more than one vehicle increasing with southern Calffm a Assooiadon of HonWroiit Housing 3345 Wilshire Blvd. Wte 1005, Los Angeles, CA 90010 PH: 213-480-1249 www.scarph.ora -3- income. Low-income families, seniors, and special needs populations are less likely to require the use of more than one parking space, if that at all. The need for parking also decreases for residents in dense areas near transit. Southern California Association of Non-ProOt Homing 3345 Wilshire Blvd. Suite 1005, Los Angeles. CA 90010 PH: 213-480-1249 www.sconoh.ora -4- Resources Planning for Resldenflal Parking: A Guide for Housing Developers and Planners. Website created by NPH to help developers be more effective in arguing for reduced parking. Contains data, recommendations, and a model for determining the amount of parking needed by a specific site. htt •/p /dcrp ced berkelev edu/studentshrusso/parking//Develol2er%2OManualAn de . tm Donald Shoup Professor, Urban Planning. UCLA. Has written numerous reports regarding parking requirements. Argues for reduced parking requirements for numerous developments, including affordable housing. shoupOuclo.edu Reports Parking Requirement Impacts on Housing Affordability Todd Litman, Victoria Transport Policy Institute. Victoria, B.C., Canada, 1999. www.vtpi.orq/park-hou.pdf Pavement Busters Guide: Why and How to Reduce the Amount of Land Paved for Roads and Parking FaclNffes Todd Litman, Victoria Transport Policy Institute. Victoria, B.C., Canada, 2000. www.vtDi.org/pav-bust.Ddf Smart Growth Zoning Codes: A Resource Guide Local Government Commission. Sacramento, 2003. To order a copy, visit www.loc.ora Travel Characteristics of Transif-Odented Development to California Hollie Lund (CSU Poly, Pomona), Robert Cervero (UC Berkeley), Richard Wilson (CSU Poly, Pomona). California, 2004. Please contact SCANPH for a copy. Rethinking Residenflal Parking: Myth 3 Facts Southern Cailronda Association or Non -Profit Mousing 3345 WllsHre Blvd. Suite 1005, Los Angeles, CA 90010 PH: 213-480-1249 wwwscorwh.ora `.. -5- .. Non -Profit Housing Association of Northern California (NPH). San Francisco, 2001. www nonprofithousinq ora/actioncenter/toolbox/porkina/mvthsandfacts odf Reducing Housing Costs by Rethinking Parking Requirements San Francisco Planning and Urban Research Association (SPUR). San Francisco, 1998. www.spur.ora/documents/spurhsapkamdf Reports, cont" Buying 71me at fhe Curb Donald Shoup, UCLA Department of Urban Planning. Los Angeles, 2003. www.sppsr.ucla.edu/up/webfiles/bLWnatime.Wf The High Cost of free Parking Donald Shoup, UCLA Department of Urban Planning. Los Angeles, 1997. www.sppsr.uclo.edu//dup/people/facultv/ShoupToMPub%204.r)df In lieu of Required Parking Donald Shoup, UCLA Department of Urban Planning. Los Angeles, 1999. .... www.sppsr.ucla.edu//dup/people/faculty/Shoup%2OPub%202.r>d The Trouble With Minimum Parking Requirements Donald Shoup, UCLA Department of Urban Planning. Los Angeles, 1999. www.soc)sr.uclo.edu//­d­ur)/De�ople/focu#Y/Shovp%2OPub%203mdt Housing Shortage/Parking Surplus: Slllcon Voley's Opportunity to Address Housing Needs and Tronspodatlon Problems wflh InnovaBve Parking Policies Transportation and Land Use Coalition. San Jose, 2002. vwvw.transcoolition.ora/reports/housing s/housina shortage home.html Southern California Association of Non -Profit Housing 3345 Wilshire Blvd Suite 1005, Los Angeles, CA 90010 PH: 213.480-1249 www.sconvh.orc -6- Best Practice Policies Here is a quick list of jurisdictions and practices that can be used as examples: Combined Reductions in City of Los Angeles See Next Page Parking Requirements for Affordable Housing arking Lots Unassigned Parking Unassig Parking requirements reduced by .25 spaces and Proximity to Transit City of San Diego per dwelling unit for Transit Area or Very Low Sunnyvale spaces per unit lower than developments Income housing (Municipal Code 142.05) P0r#ri1'. Code 19.46.0501 Riq.l 4 blr3 ReNtl [" S4ota-Monica hetIt Affli 3345 Wilshire Blvd Sulte 1005, Los Angeles, CA 90010 s Using Square Feet In R4 district, parking requirements are I per Rather Than Bedrooms 1,000 it of gross floor area. This reduces the for Parking City of Berkeley penalty that minimum parking requirements Requirements typically have on smaller units. (Section 230.40.0801 For 1 bedrooms and studios only, San Jose has Parking Son Jose a 0.5 spaces per unit reduction in MPRs when "Ab "One RequireLower menfor a facility is Open Parking" vs. -Car" or "Two arking Lots Unassigned Parking Unassig -Car Garage" (Municipal Code 20.12.215) versus Assigned Parking If open let, parking requirements are 0.3 to 0.4 Spaces Sunnyvale spaces per unit lower than developments using one4ully enclosed garage. (Municipal Code 19.46.0501 Allowing Residentlal Santo Clara County - Pass Is between $20 and $00 per year per Southern California Association of Mon -Profit Mousing 3345 Wilshire Blvd Sulte 1005, Los Angeles, CA 90010 PH: 213-480-1249 www.sconph.ora •7. I Deuelvpmerst MiyMWO V011" Transportatfm Peraor►'depa Ih9 on develop Mnt *o and to PuMs hOwArrOw AutOWTesidentidt:. lecaftm Trarwif piit WO M Eco-Pase ; Resideft lot: d Discount One-fifth the regular parking requirement for housing specifically designed for and "BY -right" reductions in San Francisco occupied by senior citizens or physically parking requirements for handicapped persons. (Article 1.5. Section Senior and disabled housing 25% reduction of parking requirement for Berkeley housing exclusively for persons over the age of sbdy-two (62). One space per 5 residents for nursing homes. (Section 23D.QQ80) 11 - W,.W f t 'i Southern CaUrm a Association of Mon -Profit Housing 3345 Wtlshlre Blvd. Suite 1005, Los Angeles, CA 90010 PH: 213-4801249 www.sconoh.ora -8- ( City of Los Angeles Municipal Code Chapter 1, General Provisions a Zoning Section 12.22 A* 25 (d) 25. Affordable Housing Incentives/Density Bonuses. (d) Affordable Housing 'Production Incentives. Notwithstanding any provisions of this article to the contrary, density bonus projects, and other development projects with any restricted affordable units or any affordable accessible units, shall be granted the following incentives: (1) In calculating dwelling units or guest rooms, density shall be rounded upwards from fractions of one-half (1 /2) and more from that permitted by the applicable zone to allow one additional dwelling unit or guest room. (2) Parking requirements for each restricted affordable unit only shall be as follows: For a project located 1.00 parking space per within 1,500 feet of a mass dwell-ing unit, regardless transit station or major bus of the number of route habitable rooms For a project containing 1 1.00 parking space per or 2 habitable rooms and dwell-ing unit not to -sated within 1,500 feet of a transit station or major bus route For a project containing 3 1.50 parking spaces per or more habitable rooms dwelling unit and not located within 1,500 feet of a transit station or major bus route For any project containing 0.50 parking space per units designed for senior dwelling unit or guest citizens and/or disabled room persons For a single -room 0.25 parking space per occupancy hotel dwellming unit or guest room, with a minimum of 5 parking stalls per facility soa>twe CaM r"Im AsawlaUon of NotiPro/l! MemMq 3345 Vftfte Blvd suite 1005, Los Angeles, CA 90010 PH: 213-480-1249 www.scanoh.ora -9- a Sample of Southern California Minimum Parking Requirements Below is a' table of many Southern California cities' minimum parking requirements (MPR) for multi -family housing. For comparison purposes, the required off-street parking spaces, including guest. parking, was calculated for a hypothetical 100 unit development consisting of. 10 studios, 40 one bedroom units. 40 two bedroom units. and 10 three bedroom units. The municipalities are Isted from the lowest required spaces to the highest. Cathedrd CRY"' ` "' 1 li `' 1.5 125 Los Angeles 11 1 iJ 2 130 r Irvine 1 1.4 VA 2 T X44' 175 L16 Riverside (City) 14' 1.5 2 2 tilt 175 r1s Ventura (City) 1 1 2 2 EY 175 Santa Monica ) 1.5 2? 2 190 Long Beach 1 1.5 2w 2 `' 195 West Hollywood 1>. 1.5 2; 195 Santa Barbara 1.0� 1.5 2` 2 198 Pasadena 2z 2 200 7 t a. :ry San Bernardino 1$ 1.5 2' 25 200 Icily) City of Orange fa -1.7 22 202 y.. Son 1.5 2 2.5 213 Clemente"1„ Oxnard 1 1 2. 2 215 Tustin 2. 2 2' 2 t 225 `. lot Huntington Park 2 2 2:. 2 1 .; . 233 , Anaheim 1M... 2 2.26 3 Q 238 2. Santa Ana' 2' 2 3 4 r 325 3, Note: These are merely the timber of required parking spaces. This fist does not include the additional regulations cities impose such as requiring that at least one space per unit be covered. These additional requirements may hither Impede development. Soudwn California Association of Non -Profit Housing 3345 Wilshire Blvd. Suite 1005, Los Angeles, CA 90010 PH: 213-480-1249 www.scanoh.orn -10- c� • Santa Ana recently changed their MPRs to more reasonable ratios. Santa Ana's municipal code still reflects these requirements as of 9/16/03. " San Clemente may also use net floor area to determine MPRs. Whichever method yields the larger amount will be employed. Breakdown is as follows: To 900 sq. ft — 1.5 spaces To 1800 sq. ft — 2.0 spaces To 2700 sq. ft — 2.5 spaces Over 2700 sq. it – 3.0 spaces Southern Callifornla A=wwA tion of Non -P *N Housing 3345 Wilshire Blvd. Suite 1005, Los Angeles, CA 90010 PH: 213-480-1249 www.scanph.ora Sample of Alternative Minimum Parking Requirements Below is a table of alternative minimum parking requirements for various types of multi -family developments. Various cities have recognized that the standard requirements may not be fitting for every population, such as low income families or seniors, and have developed more reasonable requirements for sites serving to these groups. For comparison purposes, the same hypothetical development has been employed. Cathedral City - senior 100 Long Beach - - Special Needs U at 75 Senior U WW Southern California Association of Mon -Profit Homing 3345 Wilshire Blvd. Suite 1005, Los Angeles, CA 90010 (J PH: 213480-1249 www.scarmh.ora -12- 125 ( 105 Los Angeles Affordable 1 1.5 if near fro ulfjtransit) nea + San Clemente i ' ' 122 — Senior Santa Barbara 1 ; 1 1 1 100 — 100%Affordable '. Santa Monica- 1r 1.: 1.5 145 Affordable Ventura County - Low k 1 1.. 2 f` 180 Income or Senior West Hollywood - 0:5- OS Off 0.5 1 pxiyl"'t 60 Senior WW Southern California Association of Mon -Profit Homing 3345 Wilshire Blvd. Suite 1005, Los Angeles, CA 90010 (J PH: 213480-1249 www.scarmh.ora -12- Reftrences Access municipal code language for all cities listed via the internet. City Section W0bsit0 Anaheim 1.8.06.050 htto://www.amleool.com/anaheim ca/ Cathedral City9.58.020.F hf l2e//ordlhk com/codes/cafhedral/index htm Huntington Park 9-3.804 , hfto://ordlink com/codes/huntlnatonAndex htm Irvine 4-34 httc):/Iwww.ci.h4rie-ca.us/dents/cd/plgnnbX=rpANes/zor*la •. •.J S1. Long Beach 21.41.216 h D:/Lci.l�ng-beach.ca-us/cityckftlibmc/­iffie-21 /frame, I him Los Angeles1 • b.m.w o. 11 •, • 1 t RiversideCity of Orange] 7�34!060 http://bpg.iseryer.net/codestmnoelindex,htm Pasadena 17.68.030 h-tty.1/www.cLposadeno.c(3.usicityi6left/municode.as 19.74.0106hffr):/twww.ci.riverside.ca.us/municipoI••- • Son Bemwdho 10M 19.24D40 hfto*/Avwwci.ZjD- • ' • • ,l • • t t I11 D _ = o• • 11 = 1 •d• : 41 1 ► 1 tl Son Clemente 17.64.050hffQ:/hNwwbp!gnet.com/codes/mnc[emente/­ Santa Ana 4-1322 [,'TIAL •: �,■ u. s . • u ./ •., .•I u • _• - ■ -- • ■� ■ u .. i Santa Barbara 28.90.100 ww&i w dAgnt¢ bqdXgISLcaL /deoartmentr/adrrkthtroHw ■ tD&a&/aity chrkhru.+z-fi +l rQdW Santa Monica 9.04.10.08.040 httod/oencfsonfe- monico.cats/munlcode/codwnaster/Adicle 9/04/10.0&W0.htmi Tustin 9226 htto://Mvepubllsh rt?unica4 e-com/LvePtMish/neworginecocles.aso?lntobase-11307 Ventura (City) 24.415.030 hitn://W&mA2Mrnuricode.com/3/Inaxt/diff-tema at sifn=mairt- Ltm3vid=10135 West Hollywood 19.28.040 htto://www.weho.ora/index.cfm?fuseacfiion=nov&navid=24&mode=Web 8outbofrn CalHb►nla Association of Nott•Profit Housing 3345 Wilshire Blvd Suite 1005, Los Angeles, CA 90010 PH: 213-480-1249 www.scanph.orn -13- Making a House Call Less Downtown Parking Is Part of Proposal to Streamline Home Building by Jason Mandell, Los Angeles Downtown News The city's restrictive building codes have caused many developers to shy away from tackling much-needed housing in the Central City. But a plan released last week by a business advocacy group hopes to make the prospect more attractive to residential builders by streamlining the process. It states that revising certain codes and zoning laws could reduce construction costs by $20,000 to $30,000 per unit. A major focus of the pian, authored by the Central City Association, is to create more high-density housing by cutting back on open space requirements and steering development toward pubic transportation spots. It also has the controversial aspect of aiming to reduce the number of parking spaces required for a project. The 19 -page "white paper;' which was unveiled last Tuesday at the Subway Terminal Building, has won the support of Mayor James Hahn and Ninth District Councilwoman Jan Perry. The plan states.what most Angelenos already know — L.A. is in the midst of a housing crisis. According to the CCA, the city has a net deficit of between 8,000 and 10,000 housing units. Additionally, about 15% of all units are considered substandard, and 30% of the units are overcrowded, according to the report. Developer Greg Vilkin, who heads CCA's housing production committee and oversaw the white paper, said the idea is to curb what residents consider their right to private open space and a parking spot for every car. "L.A. needs to grow up;" said Vilkin, whose company Forest City Residential West is developing several Downtown projects, including the 277 -unit Subway Terminal Building. Vilkin said the CCA plan's ultimate goal is to force people to live near where they work, use public transit or rideshare, and use neighborhood parks rather than backyards. Vilkin admitted that lowering the requirements for parking spaces for new projects would negatively impact Downtown, whose lack of affordable parking has long deterred visitors and potential residents. 'There will be some short-term pain;' said Vilkin. However, he said that in the long run, cutting down on parking spaces will transform the area's lifestyle. soathens CallMrnla Am"lattow of NomProlrt Housing 3345 WIMre Blvd. Suite 1005, los Angeles. CA 90010 PH: 213480.1249 www.scarroh.ora -14- 4 Hahn said the high cost of meeting the current parking requirements drives away developers. He said that if more housing is constructed near bus and subway stops, the need for parking spaces will diminish. Making a Howse Call, conn A potentially controversial measure of the CCA pian is the elimination of prevailing wage requirements for pubic and private housing projects. The plan states that wage restrictions often deter developers from taking on projects because of high labor costs. The report also calls for the city to abandon certain policies that require developers to include affordable housing in market -rote projects. The plan suggests providing better incentives and subsidies for mixed -income housing. Among the plan's additional recommendations -are: • Create a housing advisory committee to help developers meet code requirements. • Change building codes and zoning laws to cut costs and increase the speed of the approval and construction processes. C • Develop a workforce housing campaign and offer financial assistance to "critical employees" such as police, fire, nurses and teachers. • Step up lobbying efforts for state and federal funds for market -rate and low-income housing. As part of the effort to encourage residential development, Hahn announced during the press conference that his business team is being renamed the Los Angeles Housing and Business Team. He said the CCA plan offers real solutions for building housing quickly and at lower costs. Hahn said he does not endorse every component of the initiative, and pians to further examine it. He expressed hesitation about the proposal to reduce open space requirements in development projects. "I'm not an advocate of that yet," said Hahn. Perry praised the report for seeking to entice developers to tackle projects. "I like the fact that this paper provides incentives, not punitive measures:' southern Calffends AsamMUon of Mon-ProfH NeusMs 3345 Wilshire Blvd. Suite 1005, Los Angeles, CA 90010 PH: 213-480-1249 www.scanoh.oro �' - 15 - z l + Perry said the plan provides a blueprint for the city's effort to increase housing production.'1'm looking forward to using this paper as a measure of our success as we move forward." Attachment C Planning Commission Resolution Nos. 3950,3951, 3952, 3953, and 4014 RESOLUTION NO. 3950 A RESOLUTION OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF TUSTIN, CALIFORNIA, RECOMMENDING THAT THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF TUSTIN APPROVE ZONE CHANGE 04003 TO PERMIT THE DEVELOPMENT OF DETACHED CARRIAGE WAY SINGLE FAMILY DWELLING UNITS IN PLANNING AREA 4 AND 5 AND ESTABLISH RELATED DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS AND AMEND THE REQUIREMENT FOR A 10 -ACRE MINIMUM DEVELOPMENT SITE FOR CONDOMINIUMS AND MULTIPLE FAMILY DWELLINGS IN PLANNING AREA 4 The Planning Commission of the City of Tustin does hereby resolve as follows: I. The Planning Commission finds and determines as follows: A. That Marble Mountain Partners LLC submitted a proper application for Specific Plan Amendment/Zone Change 04-003 to allow development of detached carriage way units within Planning Area 4 and 5 for the purpose of providing an alternative to the traditional single family detached product without compromising the density and development standards and to allow development of condominium projects on development sites that are less than ten (10) acres (senior housing — for ownership tenure). B. That a public hearing was duly called, noticed, and held on said application on January 24, 2005, and continued to February 14, 2005, by the Planning Commission. C. That Zone Change 04-003 would apply to Planning Area 4 and Planning Area 5 of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan within the City of Tustin. D. That the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan does not set forth standards for "carriage way units" and the standards for carriage way units are proposed as an aftemative to the traditional singlefamily detached product and is accessed from a rear alley instead of a street, which provides for a neo -traditional streetscape of residences with garages to the rear of the residences. These types of single family detached units should be permitted within Planning Areas 4 and 5 since the development standards would be identical to those for single family detached units, with the exception of the minimum rear yard setback, which would be reduced from ten (10) feet to seven (7) feet for living space and three (3) feet for garage space since access to the garage for these units would be located at the rear of the property. Resolution No. 3950 Page 2 E. That the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan sets forth a minimum development site size of ten (10) acres for condominiums and multiple family dwellings. However, it is appropriate to allow condominiums and multiple family developments to contain numerous lots or sites and be designated as a development unit on a tentative map with a minimum development unit size of eight (8) acres. A development unit, as defined by the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan, consists 'of all building sites, their ' private open space, common recreation and open space areas, and public and/or private streets serving the project. A minimum of eight (8) acres in a development unit would ensure that these types of products are located in developments of substantial size and will result in orderly, rather than fragmented, development. F. The proposed. zone change supports and is consistent with the Tustin General Plan. The Land Use Element includes the City's goals and policies for the long-term growth, development, and revitalization of Tustin. Based on the summary of issues, needs, opportunities, and constraints described in the Tustin Land Use Element, ten goals are identified which include the following: 1. Achieve balanced development. 2. Ensure that compatible and complementary development occurs. 3. Revitalize older commercial, industrial, and residential development. 4. Improve citywide urban design. 5. Promote economic expansion and diversification. 6. Coordinate development with provision of adequate public facilities and services. T. Implement a reuse plan for MCAS Tustin which maximizes the appeal of the site as a mixed-use, master planned development. These goals establish the framework for policies related to allocation of land use in the City and the implementation policies reflect the direction and image the City seeks for the future. The proposed Zone Change support several General Plan goals and policies, including the following: 1. The project will implement policies under the goal to achieve balanced development including: -- Resolution No. 3950 Page 3 a. Policy 1.10 — Ensure that the distribution and intensity of land uses are consistent with the Land Use Plan and classification system. b. Policy 6.2 — Encourage and promote high quality design and physical appearance in all development projects. C.. Policy 6.4 — Preserve and enhance the City's special residential character and "small town" quality by encouraging and maintaining Tustin's low density residential, neighborhoods through enforcement of existing land use and property development standards and the harmonious blending of buildings and landscape. 2. The project will implement Housing Elements Goals and policies such as: a. Policy 1.8 — Utilize Planned Community Districts and Specific Plans to authorize and promote a variety of lot sizes and housing types. b. Policy 1.13 — Encourage the design and occupancy of housing for senior citizens and the disabled. Promote the construction or rehabilitation and adoption of dwelling units accessible to seniors and/ or the disabled. 3. The project will implement policies under the goal and policies for future development of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan including: a. Policy 13.2 — Encourage a development pattern that offers a connectedness between buildings and uses and has a strong sense of place through architectural styles and creative landscape design. b. Policy 13.5 — Promote high quality architecture, landscaping, signage, open space design, circulation patterns, and landscape patterns distinct from surrounding areas. The Planning Commission hereby recommends that the City Council approve Specific Plan Amendment/Zone change 04-003 to allow development of "Carriage Way" units within Planning Area 4 and 5 and development of a condominium project (senior housing -- for ownership tenure) on parcels less than 10 acres if they are proposed as part of a tentative tract map over 10 acres as noted in Exhibit A attached hereto. Resolution No. 3950 Page 4 PASSED AND ADOPTED at a regular meeting of the Tustin Planning Commission held on the 10 day of February, 2005. N NIELSEN Chairperson ELIZABETH A. BINSACK Planning Commission Secretary STATE OF CALIFORNIA ) COUNTY OF ORANGE ) CITY OF TUSTIN ) 1, ELIZABETH A. BINSACK, the undersigned, hereby certify that I am the Planning Commission Secretary of the Planning Commission of the City of Tustin, California; that Resolution No. 3950 was duly passed and adopted at a regular meeting of the Tustin Planning Commission, held on the 14"' day February, 2005. ELIZABETH A. BINSACK Planning Commission Secretary �- EXHIBIT A TO RESOLUTION NO. 13950 ZONE CHANGE, 04-003 The following changes to the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan shown in underlined text represent the proposed amendment in Zone Change 04-003: 3.1.1 Planning Area 4 - Low Density Residential A. Permitted and Conditionally Permitted Uses The following uses shall be permitted by right where the symbol "P" occurs or by conditional use permit where the symbol "C" occurs. Community care facilities for six or fewer persons P • Condominiums and cooperatives P • Family care home, foster home or group home, for six or P fewer persons Large family day care for seven to twelve children on P single family detached lots in accordance with the Tustin City Code • Multiple -family dwelling units (apartments) in C accordance with tenure provisions in Section 3.4.2.G • Residential care facility for elderly, for six or fewer P Pins • Single-family attached dwelling units and duplexes P . Single-family detached dwelling units P Sime family detached carriage way units P • Small family day care for less than seven children on P single family detached lots B. Accessory Uses and Structures Accessory uses and structures are permitted when customarily associated with and subordinate to a permitted use on the same site and would include: • Carports • Garages • Home occupations subject to provisions of the City Code • Patio covers/trellises • Swimming pools, spas, jacuzzis • Tennis courts, basketball courts and other multi-purpose courts, recreation and community buildings C. Unlisted Uses _ Those uses not specifically listed are subject to a determination by the Community Development Director as either permitted, permitted subject to a conditional use permit or prohibited consistent with the purpose of the land designation of this planning area and the Specific Plan. Decisions of the Director are appealable to the Planning Commission. D. Site Development Standards - Single Family Detached 1. Maximum dwelling units - 7 dwelling units per acre 2. Minimum lot area - 3,000 square feet 3. Minimum lot width - 35 feet 4. Maximum building height - 35 feet 5. Maximum lot coverage . - 50 percent of lot area. Covered areas shall include all areas under roof except trellis areas, roof overhangs, and covered porches outside the exterior wall. 6. Minimum building setbacks) a) Edinger Avenue - 40 feet b) Local public street -10 feet c) Private street or private drive - 5 feet d) Interior side yard - 3 feet minimum with aggregate requirement of 10 feet for both side yards e) Rear yard - 10 feet 7. Landscape setbac& a) Edinger Avenue -30 feet 8. Landscaping a) Areas not devoted to buildings, parking areas, hardscape, and roads, shall be landscaped. b) Compliance with the City of Tustin Landscape and Irrigation Guidelines c) Compliance with the Landscape Design Guidelines in Section 2.17 of this Specific Plan 9. Bicycle and pedestrian circulation facilities shall provide connections within the Planning Area, to adjacent Planning Areas, and to citywide bicycle trails where applicable. 10. Fences and Walls a) Compliance with General Regulations Section 3.11. b) A masonry block wall shall be maintained and/or constructed along the western perimeter of the Planning Area in accordance with the General Development Regulations. 11. Other General Development Regulations (refer to Section 3.11 as applicable) 12. Signage (refer to Section 3.12 as applicable) 13. Off-street parking (refer to Section 3.13 as applicable) Landscape setbacks are measured from the back of the curb and are a combination of parkway, sidewalk, and — - planting areas. Building setbacks are measured from future right-of-way. Non -conforming landscape and building setbacks will be permitted to remain to accommodate existing walls or buildings not in future right- of-way. E. Site Development Standards — Carriage Way Unita Definition: A tvne of single family detached product that is located on a minimum thirty six (36) foot wide Raved street with a ten (10) foot parkway on both sides of the paved portions of the street with a garage that is located to the rear of the residence and takes access from a rear two-way alley that is a minimum of twenty-four (24) feet wide. 1. Maximum dwelUng units - 7 dwelling units ver acre 2. Mmimum lot area - 3.000 square feet 3. Minimum lot width - 35 feet 4. Maximum building height - 35 feet 5. mwdmum lot coverage - 50 percent of lot area. Covered areas shall include all areas under roof except trellis areas. roof overhangs. and 6. covered Nfinimum l building a) b) Local public street -10 feet c) Private street or private drive - 5 feet d) Intaior jide yard feet for both 3 feet minimum with aggregate moturement of e) 10 side Rrar yard — 3 feet Yards for garage and 7 feet for living areas including livi= areas above garage _ h) Building to building setback- 30 feet minimum Mlicable to units space 7. Landscam nting a vaseo%pen setb &O a) Edinger Avenue - 30 feet S. Landscaping a) not devoted to buildings Barking areas hardscane and b) roads, shall be landscaved. Compliance with the City of Tustin Landscape and Irrigation c) Guidelines Q=Wiance with the Landscape Design Guidelines in Section 2.17 9. Bicycle of this Specific Plan and pedestrian circulation facilities shall provide connections within the Planning Arm to ejacent Planning Areas, and to citywide bicycle trails where applicable. 10. Fences and Walls a) Compliance with General Regulations Section 3.11. b) A masonry block wall shall be maintained and/or constructed along the western perimeter of the Planning -Area in accordance with the General Development Regulations. _.... _ 2 Landscape setbacks are measured Stom the back of the curb and are a combination of parkway, sidewalk, and planting areas. Building setbacks are measured from future right-of-way. Non - 'conforming landscape and building setbacks will be permitted to remain to accommodate odsting walls or buildings not in future right-of-way. 11. Homes that side -on to a local road shall incorporate architectural enhancements on the side and front view of the unit as seen from the local EWL 12. End units — a minimum back up space of three (3) feet in addition to the width of the drive WMach. 13. Other General Develo ent gulations (refer to Section 3.11 as applicable) 14. Signarie (refer to Section 3.12 as agplicable) 15. Off-street parkin¢ (refer to Section 3.13 as applicable to Single Family Detached) , F. Site Development Standards - Single Family Attached 1. Maximum dwelling units - 7 dwelling units per acre 2. Minimum lot area per family unit - 3,000 square feet 3. Minimum lot width - no minimum 4. Maximum building height - 35 feet 5. Maximum lot coverage - 100 percent less required setbacks and open space areas 6. Common open space - 400 square feet per dwelling unit located within common, designated recreational areas. Private attached ground level patios may be credited if open on three sides. Areas not available for open space credit include all structures, streets, driveways, landscape setbacks, and parking lots. 7. Private outdoor open space - minimum private outdoor open space shall be increased to 400 square feet for existing units. 8. Minimum gross floor area per dwelling unit, excluding the Page. a) Bachelor - 450 square feet b) 1 Bedroom - 550 square feet c) 1 Bedroom with den - 700 square feet d) 2 Bedrooms - 750 square feet e) 2 Bedrooms or more with den - 900 square feet 9. Minimum building setbacia? a) Edinger Avenue - 40 feet b) Local public street - 10 feet c) Private street or private drive - 5 feet d) Interior side yard - 3 feet minimum with aggregate requirement of 10 feet for both side yards e) Rear yard -10 feet 10. Landscape setbacke 3 Building setbacks are measured from future right-of-way. Non -conforming landscape and building setbacks will be permitted to remain to accommodate existing walls or buildings not in future right-of-way. ' Landscape setbacks are measured from the back of the curb and am a combination of parkway, sidewalk, and planting areas. Non -conforming landscape and building setbacks will be permitted to remain to accommodate existing walls or buildings not in titre right-of-way. I a) 'Edinger Avenue - 30 feet 11. Landscaping a) Areas not devoted to buildings, parking areas, hardscape, and roads, shall be landscaped. b) Compliance with the City of Tustin Landscape and Irrigation Guidelines c) Compliance with the Landscape Design Guidelines in Section 2.17 of this Specific Plan 12. Bicycle and pedestrian circulation facilities shall provide connections within the Planning Area, to adjacent Planning Areas, and to citywide bicycle trails where applicable. 13. Fences and Walls a) Compliance with General Regulations Section 3.11. b) A masonry block wall shall be maintained and/or constructed along the western perimeter of the Planning Area in accordance with the General Development Regulations. 14. Other General Development Regulations (refer to Section 3.11 as applicable) 15. Signage (refer to Section 3.12 as applicable) 16. Off-street parking (refer to Section 3.13 as applicable) G. Site Development Standards - Condominiums and Multiple Family Dwellings 1. Maximum dwelling units - 7 dwelling units per acre 2. Minimum develonment site - 8 acres 3. Maximum building height - 40 feet 4. Maximum lot coverage - 65 percent, less the required building and landscape setbacks 5. Common open space - 400 square feet per dwelling unit located within common, designated recreational areas. Private attached ground level patios may be credited if open on three sides. Areas not available for open space credit include all structures, streets, driveways, landscape setbacks, and parking lots. 6. Private outdoor open space - minimum private outdoor open space shall be increased to 400 square feet for existing units. 7. Minimum gross floor area per dwelling unit, excluding the garage a) Bachelor - 450 square feet b) 1 Bedroom - 550 square feet c) 1 Bedroom with den - 700 square feet d) 2 Bedrooms - 750 square feet e) 2 Bedrooms or more with den - 850 square feet S. Minimum building setbackss a) Edinger Avenue - 40 feet b) Local public street -10 feet . c) Private street or private drive - 5 feet d) Interior side yard - 3 feet minimum with aggregate requirement of 10 feet for both side yards e) Rear yard -10 feet 9. Landscape setbacks a) Edinger Avenue - 30 feet 10. Landscaping a) Areas not devoted to buildings, parking areas, hardscape, and roads, shall be landscaped. b) Compliance with the . City of Tustin Landscape and Irrigation Guidelines c) Compliance with the Landscape Design Guidelines in Section 2.17 of this Specific Plan 11. Bicycle and pedestrian circulation facilities shall provide connections within the Planning Area, to adjacent Planning Areas, and to citywide bicycle trails where applicable. 12. Fences and Walls a) Compliance with General Regulations Section 3.11. b) A masonry block wall shall be maintained and/or constructed along the western perimeter of the Planning Area in accordance with the General Development Regulations. - 13. Other General Development Regulations (refer to Section 3.11 as applicable) 14. Signage (refer to Section 3.12 as applicable) 15. Off-street parldng (refer to Section 3..13 as applicable) H. Special Development or Reuse Requirements 1. Concept plan approval shall be required for Planning Area 4 prior to reuse or development (refer to Section 4.2.1 of this Specific Plan). 2. Development unit - Planning Area 4 shall be developed or redeveloped as a single development unit. 3. Affordability - The following minimum affordable housing production objectives are intended to reflect the intention of the City to create a redevelopment project area (Community Redevelopment Law; section 33000) and as needed to meet Regional Housing Allocation needs as identified in the Housing Element of the General Plan through the provision of s Landscape setbacks are measured from the bark of the curb and are a combination of parkway, — sidewalk, and planting areas. Building setbacks are measured from future right-of-way. Non- conforming landscape and building setbacks will be permitted to remain to accommodate existing walls or buildings not in future right-of-way. — housing for households at very 'low, low, and moderate -- incomes levels. Specific housing requirements for redevelopment and Housing Element compliance will be established at the time of development project approval to ensure uniformity with the Housing Element of the General Plan and other applicable provisions of California Law and to achieve the following: a) " At least 15% of units for initial occupancy by very low income to moderate income households for redevelopment, with 6% (or 40%) of units affordable to very low income households. b) At least 38 additional units for occupancy by low income households. c) At least 15 additional units for occupancy by moderate income households. d) Restricted affordable housing. units shall be reasonably dispersed throughout the project and shall be compatible with the design and use of market rate units in appearance, use of materials, and finished quality. Restricted units shall be affordable for at least the minimum period of time required by state law, or longer if required by a construction or mortgage financing assistance program. err e) Prior to issuance of a certificate of use and occupancy, a developer shall enterinto a legally binding agreement with the City of Tustin or its Redevelopment Agency, and agree to deed restrictions on targeted affordable housing units that are binding on property upon sale or transfer. Said agreements shall address the following: 1) Number of units by type, location, bedroom count 2) Standards for qualifying income and maximum rents or sales prices 3) Parties responsible for sales prices and incomes f) The City of Tustin reserves the right to negotiate transfer of a developer's obligation pursuant to this section off- site as a credit for affordable units which cannot be reasonably feasible to provide on-site which shall be at the City's sole and absolute discretion. To ensure comparable equivalent value of an off-site option or exchange for not providing on-site affordable units, a financial affordability gap analysis will be conducted by the City, at developer's cost, to compare the value of the off-site option and the affordability gap cost of providing on-site affordable housing. 4. Tenure - Retiwidevelopment in Planning Area 4 shall be - preferably ownership tenure, Development of apartments is a discretionary action requiring approval of a conditional use permit. Consideration of a conditional use permit should include the City's preference for ownership tenure, and in any event, no more than 25 percent of the total number of units permitted within the City of Tustin portion of the Specific Plan may be approved for apartments. 5. Existing structures to be reused shall be brought into conformance with applicable provisions of the. Uniform Building Code as amended by the City, State of California Title 24 Access Compliance (handicapped provisions), and requirements of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). 6. Utility metering modifications and/or provision of independent utility services shall be committed to by agreement between the City of Tustin and those agencies receiving property in the PA 4 prior to use and occupancy of existing buildings and/or new development. Said agreement shall identify required capital/infrastructure improvements and environmental impact report mitigations. 1. Development or Reuse Guidelines 1. Existing housing units shall be aesthetically upgraded through architectural and landscape improvements to appear consistent in quality with private market housing in the surrounding neighborhoods of Tustin and Irvine. Such improvements shall be completed prior to issuance of use and occupancy permits. The improvements may include, but are not limited to, the following: a) Upgraded facade treatments, including use of plaster or stucco, wood siding, brick, stone, and other approved materials b) Upgraded window types and treatments (i.e. trim) e) Upgraded roofing materials and extension of roof overhangs d) Updated color scheme for buildings and walls e) Enhancement of private patios and balconies f) Upgraded appearance of unit entrances, including doorways, walkways, decorative paving g) Improved landscape design of front yards and common areas h) Consistent landscape treatment along local roads i) Extensive planting of trees and shrubs throughout the site j) Decorative treatment of all exposed site walls k) Upgraded driveways 1) Decorative paving and other hardscape amenities for pedestrian paths in common areas m) Improvements to common recreational area including provision of shelters, lighting, and refurbishing of facilities n) Creation of project entryways through signage and landscape design o) Upgraded and consistent signage, including project identification, addressing, and directional signs P) Enhanced lighting scheme for units, common areas, paw, and parking areas q) Application of defensible space techniques in landscaping and lighting 2. The existing boundary wall along Edinger Avenue shall be aesthetically improved with stucco or other facade treatment, color, and a decorative wall cap, as shown in the example below. MAAAr viA"4!5' ! - S+vPvD� .4s&Alb. UAICL _/ftTw a WA" f� * Aral ~..t 3. In the event that infill development shall occur, the following guidelines shall apply: a) Consistency with scale massing, and setbacks of existing structures. b) Compliance with re -use guidelines that pertain to the surrounding structures. c) Compliance with appropriate landscape and parking standards. 4. Demolition of structures may be as required by Tustin to be undertaken under the following conditions: 1) where information determines the need for demolition to eliminate public health and safety risks, 2) to improve the appearance of the Planning Area, 3) to accommodate the completion of major roadway improvements, and 4) to properly implement the land use intent of this Planning Area. A summary of the key design guidelines for the Low Density Residential Planning Area is provided in Figure 3-4. 3.1.1 Planning Area 5 - Medium Density Residential A. Permitted and Conditionally Permitted Uses The following uses shall be permitted by right where the symbol "P" occurs or by conditional use permit where the symbol "C" occurs. • Churches and other religious institutions C • Community care facilities for six or fewer persons P • Condominiums and cooperatives P • Convalescent hospital C • Family care home, foster home or group home, for six or P fewer persons • Large family day care for seven to twelve children on P single family detached lots in accordance with the. Tustin City Code • Multiple -family dwelling units (apartments) in C accordance with tenure provisions in Section 3.4.3.H • Patio homes P • Private school C • Public or private preschools C • Fire Station P • Public/ovate utility building facility C • Residential care facility for elderly, for six or fewer P persons • Single-family attached dwelling units and duplexes P • Single-family detached dwelling units P • Carriage Way units P • Small family day care for less than seven children on P single family detached lots B. Accessory Uses and Structures Accessory uses and structures are permitted when customarily associated with and subordinate to a permitted use on the same site and would include: • Carports • Garages • Home occupations subject to provisions of the City Code • Patio covers/trellises • Swimming pools, spas, jacuzzis • Tennis courts, basketball courts and other multi-purpose courts, recreation and community buildings C. Unlisted Uses Those uses not specifically listed are subject to a determination by the Community Development Director as either permitted, permitted subject to a conditional use permit or prohibited consistent with the purpose of the land designation of this — planning area and the Specific Plan. Decisions of the Director are appealable to the Planning Commission. D. Site Development Standards - Single Family Detached 1. Maximurn dwelling units -15 dwelling units per acre 2. Minimum lot arta - 3,000 square feet 3. Minimum lot width - 35 feet 4. Maximum building height - 35 feet 5. Maximum lot coverage - 50 percent of lot area. Covered areas shall include all areas under roof except trellis areas, roof overhangs, and covered porches outside the exterior wall. 6. Minimum building setbacks' a) North Loop Road - 25 feet b) West Connector - 20 feet c) Local public street - 10 feet d) Private street or private drive - 5 feet e) Interior side yard - 3 feet minimum with aggregate requirement of 10 feet for both side yards f) Rear yard - 10 feet 7. Landscape setbacks' a) North Loop Road - 30 feet b) West Connector - 20 feet -- 8. Landscaping a) Compliance with the City of Tustin Landscape and Irrigation Guidelines `•-Now b) Compliance with the Landscape Design Guidelines in Section 2.17 of this Specific Plan 9. Bicycle and pedestrian circulation facilities shall provide connections within the Planning Area, to adjacent Planning Areas, and to citywide bicycle trails -where applicable. 10. A corner triangular-shaped setback of 60 feet, measured from the intersection of the curb lines at North Loop Road. and Armstrong Avenue shall be provided for a secondary community intersection treatment (see Section 2.17 for landscape guidelines). 11. A portal intersection tteatmem shall be provided at Edinger Avenue and West Connector (see Section 2.17 for landscape guidelines). 12. Other General Development Regulations (refer to Section 3.11 as applicable) 13. Signage (refer to Section 3.12 as applicable) 14. Off-street parking (refer to Section 3.13 as applicable) L Site Development Standards – Carriage Way Units Definition: A type of single family detached product that is located on a minimum thirty-six (36) foot wide paved street with a ten (10) foot parkw on both sides of the Raved portions of the street with a garage that is located to the rear of the Landscape setbacks are measured from the back of the curb and are a combination of parkway, sidewak and planting anis. Non -conforming landscape and building setbacks will be permitted to remain to accommodate existing walls or buildings not in nrture right-of-way. Building setbacks are measured from future right-of-way. 1. m • dwcIfing unitsdwelfin uniti1'1agn 2. Minimum • area - 3.000-Samam feet Minimum3. . • h - 35 feet 4. Maximum building height z1 5. Maximum lot covema1 Ra= of • SKS. Covaed -ii' shall include- area under r2of exclo tmilis areas. roof ovedmigs. and covered Rgrchcs outside theWr } 1 feet, Privaft satet • _ • } - d _t i •. • 4e !}_.t It mit with aggregatereguirement of 1 fed for both sideyards i._' above fronting a ! y •m! space 7. Landscape setbacks4 a) Edinger Avenue - 30 feet Landscaping b) Areag not devoted to buildings larking areas hardscaye and roads. shall be landMed. c) C=Iia ce with the City of Tustin Landscape and Irrigation Guidelines d) Co liance with the La-n&o a Design Guidelines in Section 2.17 of this Specific'Plan 8. Bicycle and pedestrian circulation facilities shall provide connections within the planning Area, to adiacent Plaiming Areas. and to citywide bicycle trails where applicable. 9. Fences and Walls a) Complia*icr with General Regulations Section 3.11. b) A masonry block wall shall be maintained and/or conswctcd along the western perimeter of the Planning Area in accordance with the General DevelgMent RM9ations. 11. Homes that side -on to a local road shall incorporate architectural enbancements on the side and front view of the unit, as seen from the local road. 12 End units a minimum back upspace of three (3) feet in addition to the width of the drive approac . 13 Other General Development Regulations (refer to Section 3.11 as auplicable) 14 Signage (refer to Section 3.12 as applicable) 2 Landscape setbacks are measured from the back of the curb and art a combination of parkway, sidewalk, and planting areas. Building setbacks are measured from future right-of-way. Non -conforming landscape and building setbacks will be permitted to remain to accommodate existing walls or buildings not in future right-of-way. 15. Of -street marking (refer to Section 3.13 as applicable to Single Family -.. Detached) F. Site Development Standards - Single Family Attached 1. Maximum dwelling units -15 dwelling units per acre 2. Minimum lot area per family unit - 3,000 square feet 3. Minimum lot width - no minimum 4. Maximum building height - 35 feet 5. Maximum lot coverage - 100 percent less required setbacks and open space J Building setbacks are measured from future rigbt-of-way. Non -conforming landscape and building setbacks will be permitted to remain to accommodate existing walls or buildings not in future right-of-way. 4 Landscape setbacks are measured from the back of the curb and are a combination of parkway, sidewalk, and planting areas. Nonconforming landscape and building setbacks will be permitted to remain to accommodate existing walls or buildings not in future right-of-way. areas 6. Common open space - 400 square feet per dwelling unit located within common, designated recreational areas. Private attached ground level patios may be credited if open on three sides. Areas not available for open space credit include all structures, streets, driveways, landscape setbacks, and pig lots. 7. Minimum gross floor area per dwelling unit, excluding the garage: a) Bachelor - 450 square feet b) 1 Bedroom - 550 square feet c) I Bedroom with den- 700 square feet d) 2 Bedrooms - 750 square feet e) 2 Bedrooms or more with den - 900 square feet 8. Minimum building setbacks; a) North Loop Road - 25 feet b) West Connector - 20 feet c) Local public street - 10 fret d) Private street or private drive - 5 feet e) Interior side yard - 3 feet minimum with aggregate requirement of 10 feet for both side yards f) Rear yard - 10 feet 9. Landscape setbacks4 a) North Loop Road - 30 feet b) West Connector - 20 feet 10. Landscaping a) Compliance with the City of Tustin Landscape and Irrigation Guidelines b) Compliance with the Landscape Design Guidelines in Section 2.17 of this Specific Pian 11. Bicycle and pedestrian circulation facilities shall provide connections within the Planning Area, to adjacent Planning Areas, and to citywide bicycle trails where applicable. 12. A comer triangular-shaped setback of 60 feet, measured from the intersection of the curb lines at North Loop Road and Armstrong Avenue shall be J Building setbacks are measured from future rigbt-of-way. Non -conforming landscape and building setbacks will be permitted to remain to accommodate existing walls or buildings not in future right-of-way. 4 Landscape setbacks are measured from the back of the curb and are a combination of parkway, sidewalk, and planting areas. Nonconforming landscape and building setbacks will be permitted to remain to accommodate existing walls or buildings not in future right-of-way. provided "for a secondary community intersection treatment (see Section 2.17 for landscape guidelines). 13. A portal intersection treatment shall be provided at Edinger Avenue and West Connector (see Section 2.17 for landscape guidelines). 14. Other General Development Regulations (refer to Section 3.11 as applicable) 15. • Signage (refer to Section 3.12 as applicable) 16. Off-street parking (refer to Section 3.13 as applicable) G. Site Development Standards - Condominiums and Multiple Family Dwellings 1. Maximum dwelling units - IS dwelling units per acre 2. Minimum lot area - none, refer to Section 3.4.3.G. 3. Maximum building height - 40 feet 4. Maximum lot coverage - 65 percent, less the required building and landscape setbacks 5. Common open space - 400 square feet per dwelling unit located within common, designated recreational areas. Private attached ground level patios may be credited if open on three sides. Areas not available for open space credit include all structures, struts, driveways, landscape setbacks, and parking lots. 6. * Minimum gross floor area per dwelling unit, excluding the garage a) Bachelor - 450 square feet b) 1 Bedroom - 550 square feet c) 1 Bedroom with den - 700 square feet d) 2 Bedrooms - 750 square feet e) 2 Bedrooms or more with den - 850 square feet 7. Minimum building setbacks S a) North Loop Road - 25 feet b) West Connector - 20 feet c) Local public street -10 feet d) Private street or private drive - 5 feet e) Interior side yard - 3 feet minimum with aggregate requirement of 10 feet for both side yards f) Rear yard - 10 feet 8. Landscape setbacks'' a) North Loop Road - 30 feet b) West Connector - 20 feet 9. Landscaping a) Compliance with the City of Tustin Landscape and Irrigation Guidelines b) Compliance with the Landscape Design Guidelines in Section 2.17 of this Specific Plan 10. Bicycle and pedestrian circulation facilities shall provide connections within the Planning Area, to adjacent Planning Areas, and to citywide bicycle trails where applicable. s Lmdscape setbacks are measured from the back of the curb and are a. combination of parkway, sidewalk, and planting areas. Building setbacks aro measured from future right-of-way. Non -conforming landscape and building setbacks will be permitted to remain to accommodate existing walls or buildings not in future right-of-way. 11. A corner triangular-shaped setback of 60 feet, measured from the intersection -. of the curb lines at North Loop Road and Armstrong Avenue shall be provided for a secondary community intersection treatment (see Section 2.17 for landscape guidelines). 12. A portal intersection treatment shall be provided at Edinger Avenue and West Connector (see Section 2.17 for landscape guidelines). 13. Other General Development Regulations (refer to Section 3.11 as applicable) 14. Signage (refer to Section 3.12 as applicable) 15. Off-street parking (refer to Section 3.13 as applicable) H. Site Development Standards - Patio Homes 1. Maximum dwelling units -15 dwelling units per acre 2. Minimum lot area - none, refer to Subsection 3.4.3.H: below 3. Building site requirements - patio home subdivisions shall be designated as a 'development unit on a tentative map. 4. Maximum building height - 35 feet 5. Maximum lot coverage - 100 percent, less required building and landscape setbacks 6. Common open space - 400 square feet per dwelling unit located within common, designated recreational areas. A minimum of 150 square feet may be for private use if located on ground level and open on three sides. Areas not available for open space credit include all structures, streets, driveways, landscape setbacks, and parking lots. 7. Minimum gross floor area per dwelling unit, excluding the garage - 900 square feet t� 8. Maximum number of four bedroom units - 30 percent 9. Minimum building setbackO a) North Loop Road - 25 feet b) West Connector - 20 feet c) Local public or private street - The minimum building setback shall be 10 feet from a public or private street. An attached or detached garage may be setback a minimum of 5 feet. from a public or private street. If living areas are provided above garages, garage setbacks shall apply provided that no more than 75 percent of the units along the street frontage have living space over a garage with less than a 10 foot setback. All units located along both sides of a street segment shall be included when calculating the above 75 percent determination, regardless of whether they front, side, or rear load on that section of a street. A garage shall not be setback between 9 feet and 19 feet from the right-of-way line. Garages setback 9 feet or less shall be equipped with an automatic garage opener. d) Private drives and courts - The minimum building setback shall be 7 feet in a private court or on a private drive not located within a court. An attached or detached garage may be setback a minimum of 3 feet 6 Building setbacks are measured from future right-of-way. Non -conforming landscape and building setbacks will be permitted to remain to accommodate existing walla or buildings not in future right-of-way. provided that no more than 50 percent of the length of the building frontage over the total length of the drive or court is setback less than 7 feet. In calculating the total length of the drive or court and the length of building frontage, the length of building and street frontage on both sides of the drive or court shall be used. If living areas are provided above garages, garage setback shall apply. The minimum 3 foot garage setback shall be increased where necessary to accommodate required sidewalks. A garage shall not be setback between 9 feet and 19 feet from the right-of-way line. Garages setback 9 feet or less shall be equipped with an automatic garage opener. A minimum distance of 40 feet shall be maintained between ground floor living area on units across from each other in a court, on a drive, or on a shared driveway. e) Minimum distance between buildings - The minimum horizontal distance between adjacent buildings shall be 10 feet. The minimum distance between buildings may be reduced to 6 feet for no more than a maximum length of 25 feet of a building elevation, provided that there are no windows on one elevation for that portion of the. building elevation with less than a 10 foot setback. If living areas are provided above garages, garage setbacks shall apply. f) Tract boundary - The minimum building setback from any tract boundary shall be 10 feet. If the tract boundary is adjacent to a park or other permanent open space, the minimum building setback shall be 5 feet, 10. Landscape setbacks' a) North Loop - 30 feet b) West Connector - 20 feet 11. Landscaping a) Compliance with the City of Tustin Landscape and Irrigation Guidelines b) Compliance with the Landscape Design Guidelines in Section 2.17 of this Specific Plan 12. Bicycle and pedestrian circulation facilities shall provide connections within the Planning Area, to adjacent Planning Areas, and to citywide bicycle trails where applicable. 13. A corner triangular-shaped setback of 60 feet, measured from the intersection of the curb' lines at North Loop Road and Armstrong Avenue shall be provided for a secondary community intersection treatment (see Section 2.17 for landscape guidelines). 14. A portal intersection treatment shall be provided at Edinger Avenue and West Connector (see Section 2.17 for landscape guidelines). 15. Other General Development Regulations (refer to Section 3.11 as applicable) 16. Signage (refer to Section 3.12 as applicable) 17. Off-street parking (refer to Section 3.13 as applicable) Landscape setbacks are measured from the back of the curb and are a combination of parkway, sidewalk, and planting areas. Nonconforming landscape and building setbacks will be permitted to remain to accommodate existing wails or buildings not in fixture right-of-way. I. Special Development Requirements 1. Concept plan approval shall be required for Planning Area 5 prior to development (refer to Section 4.2.1 of this Specific Plan). 2. Affordability — The following minimum affordable housing production objectives are intended to reflect the intention of the City to create a redevelopment project area (Community Redevelopment Law, section 33000) and as needed to meet Regional Housing Allocation needs as identified in the Housing Element of the General Plan through the provisions of housing for households at very low, low and moderate income levels. Specific housing requirements for redevelopment and Housing Element compliance will be established at the time of development project approval to ensure uniformity with the Housing Element of the General Plan and other applicable provisions of California Law and to achieve the following: a) At least 15% of units for initial occupancy by very low income to moderate income households for redevelopment, with 6% (or 40"/0) of units affordable to very low income households. b) At least 38 additional units for occupancy by low income households. c) At least 16 additional units for occupancy by moderate income households. d) Restricted affordable housing units shall be reasonably dispersed throughout the project and shall be compatible with the design and use of market rate units in appearance, use of materials, and finished quality. Restricted units shall be affordable for at least the minimum period of time required by state law, or longer if required by a construction or mortgage financing assistance program. e) Prior to issuance of a certificate of use and occupancy, a developer shall enter into a legally binding agreement with the City of Tustin or its Redevelopment Agency, and agree to deed restrictions on targeted affordable housing units that are binding on property upon sale or transfer. Said agreements shall address the following: 1) Number of units by type, location, bedroom count 2) Standards for qualifying income and maximum rents or sales prices 3) Parties responsible for sales prices and incomes f) The City of Tustin reserves the right to negotiate transfer of a developer's obligation pursuant to this section off-site as a credit for affordable units which cannot be reasonably feasible to provide on-site which shall be at the City's sole and absolute discretion. To ensure comparable equivalent value of an off-site option or exchange for not providing on-site affordable units, a financial affordability gap analysis will be conducted by the City, at developer's cost, to compare the value of the off-site option and the affordability gap cost of providing on-site affordable housing. 3. Tenure - Development in Planning Area 5 of apartments is a discretionary action requiring approval of a conditional use permit. In considering a conditional use permit, no more than 25 percent of the total number of units permitted within the Tustin portion of the Specific Plan area may be approved for apartments. 4. Condominiums and multiple family development may contain numerous lots, but shall be designated as a development unit on a tentative map. The minimum size for a development unit shall be 10 acres. J. Development Guidelines 1. Buildings should be staggered along North Loop Road to provide variety along the streetscape. 2. The use of sound walls should be minimized through building site location. 3. Demolition of structures may be required by Tustin to be undertaken under the following conditions: 1) where information determines the need for demolition to eliminate public health and safety risks, 2) to improve the appearance of the Planning Area, 3) to accommodate the completion of major roadway improvements, and 4) to properly implement the land use intent of this Planning Area A summary of the key design guidelines for the Medium Density Residential Planning Area is provided in Figure 3-4. V RESOLUTION NO. 3951 A RESOLUTION OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION APPROVING CONCEPT PLAN 03-003 TO SUBDIVIDE 105.5 ACRES (GROSS) AND DEVELOP 1,077 RESIDENTIAL UNITS BOUNDED BY EDINGER AVENUE ON THE NORTH, VALENCIA NORTH LOOP ROAD ON THE SOUTH, AN INDUSTRIAL BUSINESS PARK AND SEVERYNS ROAD ON THE WEST, AND WEST CONNECTOR ROAD ON THE EAST WITHIN PLANNING AREA 4 AND PLANNING AREA 5 OF THE MCAS- TUSTIN SPECIFIC PLAN (PARCEL 23 AND PARCEL 24) The Planning Commission of the City of Tustin does hereby resolve as follows: I. The Planning Commission finds and determines as follows: A. That Marble Mountain Partners LLC submitted a proper application for Concept Plan 03-003 to subdivide 105.5 acres for the purpose of developing 1,077 residential units including 84 Single Family Detached (SFD), 181 Carriage Way SFD, 72 Multiple Family Attached (senior housing -- for ownership tenure) for a total of 337 units at an average density of 8.62 du/acre in Planning Area 4 (Parcel 23) and 18 carriage way units, 552 Multiple Family Attached (MFR), 170 Multiple Family Attached (senior housing — for ownership tenure) for a total of 740 units at an Average density 17.53 du/acre for Planning Area 5 (Parcel 24) of the MCAS Tustin Speck Plan; B. That pursuant to Section 4.2.1 of the MCAS Tustin Speck Plan, submittal of a concept plan for development of planning areas is required prior to or concurrent with an Initial subdivision application; C. That Marble Mountain Partners LLC has submitted concurrent development applications identified as Tentative Tract Map 16581, Design Review 04-006, Specific Plan Amendment/Zone Change 04-003, and a request for incentives for the provision of affordable housing and a request to transfer affordable housing units from Planning Area 4 to Planning Area 5; and, D. With development of this site, the applicant has requested a density bonus, density averaging, and an affordable housing plan for transfer of lower income and moderate income units from Planning Area 4 to Planning Area 5, which will be binding with execution of a Housing Agreement. Resolution No. 3951 Page 2 E . That Concept Plan 03-003 is in conformance with the Tustin Area — General Plan and MCAS Tustin Specific Plan and approval of Concept Plan 03-003, subject to conditions contained in Resolution Nos. 3952, 3953, and 3954, would achieve the development concepts set forth by the MCAS Tustin Spec Plan, including: 1. Ensuring the continuity and adequacy of all circulation systems, such as: roadways, access points, trails, pedestrian ways, and other infrastructure systems needed to serve the project; 2. Ensuring the continuity and design quality of architecture, landscape, and hardscape themes and treatments; 3. Providing urban design features as per Chapters 2 and 3 of the WAS Tustin Specific Plan; 4. Ensuring conformity with the Non -Residential Land Use Trip Budget; and, 5. Ensuring compliance with all applicable provisions of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan. II. The Planning Commission hereby approves Concept Plan 03-003 for the development of 1,077 residential units, subject to the conditions of approval attached hereto. PASSED AND ADOPTED at a regularymeeting n � `uAin Planning Commission held on the 14w da of Februa , A JQMN NIELSEN Chairperson ELIZABETH A. INSACK Planning Commission Secretary STATE OF CALIFORNIA ) COUNTY OF ORANGE ) CITY OF TUSTIN ) I, ELIZABETH A. BINSACK, the undersigned, hereby certify that I am the Planning Commission Secretary of the Planning Commission of the City of Tustin, California; that Resolution No. 3951 was duly passed and adopted at a regular meeting of the Tustin Planning Commission, held on the 14"' day February, 2005. ELIZABETH A. B NSACK Planning Commission Secretary (1) (1) (1) 1.1 EXHIBIT A — CONCEPT PLAN 03-003 RESOLUTION NO. 3951 CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL Concept Plan 03-003 is approved for development of 1,077 residential units in Planning Area 4 and Planning Area 5 as follows: Planning Area 4 (Parcel 23) 84 Single Family Detached (SFD) 181 Carriage Way SFD 72 Multiple Family Attached (Senior Housing — for ownership tenure) Total: 337 units Average density of 8.62 du/ace (Parcel 24) 18 Carriage Way units 552 Multiple Family Attached (MFR) 170 Multiple Family Attached (Senior Housing — for ownership tenure) Total: 740 units Average density 17.53 du/acre 1.2 The approved concept plan is subject to execution of a Housing Agreement between Marble Mountain Partners LLC and City of Tustin In conformance with the requirements of the density bonus application and as approved by the City Council. All entitlements of Concept Plan 03-003 will become null and void in case of any default of terms and conditions of the Housing Incentive Agreement. 1.3 Resolution No. 3951 shall become null and void in the event that Resolution Nos. 3950, 3952 approving Spec Plan Amendment/ Zone Change 04-003, Design Review 04-006, and the Affordable Housing Plan and Density Bonus Application, which includes the transfer of required affordable housing units from Planning Area 4 to Planning Area 5, are not approved by the City Council. (1) 1.4 Approval of Concept Plan 03-003 shall be contingent upon all conditions of approval contained within Resolution Nos. 3949, 3950, 3952, and 3953. — - RESOLUTION NO. 3952 A RESOLUTION OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF TUSTIN RECOMMENDING THAT THE CITY COUNCIL APPROVE TENTATIVE TRACT MAP 16581 TO SUBDIVIDE 105.5 ACRES BOUNDED BY EDINGER AVENUE ON THE NORTH, VALENCIA NORTH LOOP ROAD ON THE SOUTH, AN INDUSTRIAL BUSINESS PARK AND SEVERYNS ROAD ON THE WEST, AND WEST CONNECTOR ROAD ON THE EAST FOR THE PURPOSE OF DEVELOPING 1,077 RESIDENTIAL UNITS WITHIN PLANNING AREA 4 AND PLANNING AREA S OF THE MCAS-TUSTIN SPECIFIC PLAN (REUSE PLAN DISPOSAL PARCEL 23 AND PARCEL 24) The Planning Commission of the City of Tustin does hereby resolve as follows: 1. The Planning Commission finds and determines as follows: A. That a proper application for Tentative Tract Map No. 16581 was submitted by Marble Mountain Partners LLC requesting subdivision of a 105.5 acre site, into 386 numbered lots and 186 lettered lots for the purpose of development of 1,077 residential units; including 84 Single Family Detached (SFD), 181 Carriage Way SFD, 72 Multiple Family Attached (Senior Housing — for ownership tenure) for a total of 337 units at an average density of 8.62 du/acre in Planning Area 4 (Parcel 23) and 570 Multiple Family Attached (MFR), 170 Multiple Family Attached (Senior Housing — for ownership tenure) for a total of 740 units at an Average density 17.53 du/acre for Planning Area 5 (Parcel 24) of the MCAS -Tustin Specific Plan, generally bounded by Edinger Avenue on the north, West Connector Road to the east, an industrial office park to the west, and Valencia/North Loop Road to the south; B. That a public hearing was duly called, noticed, and held for said map on January 24, 2005. and continued to February 14, 2005, by the Planning Commission, and the density bonus and transfer of affordable units was considered concurrently with the development applications; C. As conditioned, the proposed subdivision will be in conformance with the Tustin Area General Plan, MCAS Tustin Speck Plan as proposed to be amended by Zone Change 04-003, State Subdivision Map Act and the City's Subdivision Code; D. That the proposed subdivision is In conformance with the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan as amended by Resolution No. 3950 for approval of Specific Plan Amendment/Zone Change 04-003; E. That the site Is located in Planning Area 4 of the MCAS Tustin Spec Plan, which is designated for Low Density Residential (1-7 Resolution No. 3952 TTM 16581 Page 2 units/acre) and Planning Area 5 of MCAS Tustin Specific Plan which is designated for Medium Density Residential (8-15 unitstacre) and that the development as conditioned will be physically suitable for the type of development and proposed density of development; F. The applicant will be required to provide funding towards the projects fair share 'of Tustin Legacy Backbone Infrastructure Program, which includes improvements that are required to serve new development at MCAS -Tustin, including but not limited to roadway improvements; traffic and circulation mitigation to support development at the former MCAS -Tustin project; domestic and reclaimed water; sewer, telemetry systems; storm drains and flood control channels; retention and detention systems, open space and public recreational facilities and; utility backbone systems. G. That the proposed subdivision would not have an impact on school district facilities within the Tustin Unified School District in that school impacts for development were considered in the MCAS Reuse Plan which identified school facility sites that will be conveyed to the Tustin Unified School District by the Federal Department of Education or the City of Tustin to serve development of property at the former MCAS Tustin. The MCAS Tustin Specific Plan, and the Final Joint Program Environmental Impact Statement/Environmental Impact Report (FEIS/EIR) and conditions of approval of the proposed subdivision also require proof of payment of appropriate school fees as adopted by the Tustin Unified School District prior to issuance of certificates of use and occupancy, which will be collected prior to issuance of building permits in accordance with the City's procedures; H. That the design of the subdivision or the proposed improvements are not likely to cause substantial environmental damage or substantially and avoidably injure fish or wildlife in their habitat; I. The proposed subdivision Is not located within a 100 -year flood plain according to the Federal Emergency Management Agency map for the area dated August 9, 2002. J. That development of the site will require the developer to dedicate in fee title property to the City of Tustin including portions of Severyns Road to the City of Tustin for public roadways and utility purposes as shown on the Tentative Tract Map 16581. _ K. To ensure there is adequate infrastructure to support buildout of the project, construction of all public infrastructure and in tract private streets and utility systems is required within the initial phase of Resolution No. 3952 TTM 16581 Page 3 development. In addition, to ensure orderly development and the systematic provision of required affordable housing, construction phasing of affordable units will be required to be reasonably proportionate to market rate units. L. That the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan requires the provision of affordable housing affordable to very low, low, and moderate income level persons. The applicant has submitted a request for incentives for the development of affordable housing (i.e., density bonus) in Planning Areas 4 and 5 and has requested the transfer of 22 affordable units (8 Very Low and 14 Moderate income) from Planning Area 4 and Planning Area 21 to Planning Area 5 and 25 (8 Very Low and 15 Low income) from Planning Area 21 to Planning Area 5. in accordance with Section 3.9.4.1.3.f of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan, which provides for the transfer of affordable housing unit obligations to an off-site location at the City's sole discretion, the transfer of these units is appropriate in that they are proposed to be located in condominium units (including senior housing — for ownership tenure) project in Planning Area 5, which will offer equivalent housing opportunities. The applicant will be required to enter into a Housing Incentive Agreement to ensure the provision of affordable housing. M. That the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan process included public conveyance of City parks and an Urban Regional Park and -" Individual developers were relieved of the requirement to dedicate land for park purposes; however, the developer is required to provide funding toward the project fair share of Tustin Legacy Open Space and Recreational facilities including payment of a parkland dedication in -lieu fee subject to the provisions of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan and the City's parkland dedication ordinance (Section 9331 of the Tustin City Code), which permits a credit for public recreational open space if affordable housing is being provided. The subdivider is providing 4.9 acres of private parkland in the proposed subdivision and has requested a waiver of parkland dedication fees pursuant to Section 9931 d(1)(c) of the Tustin City Code for the 241 affordable housing units to be provided in the subdivision and a credit for 3.66 acres private parkland that will be provided and accessible to the public on the park site through public easements on the development site. It is appropriate to waive a portion of the fees since affordable housing units will be provided within Planning Area 4 and 5 and provide a credit for a portion of the park areas that will be accessible to the public. N. With development of this site, the applicant has requested a density bonus, density averaging, and an affordable housing plan for transfer of lower Income and moderate Income units from Planning Resolution No. 3952 TTM 16581 Page 4 Area 4 and Planning Area 21 to Planning Area 5, which will be binding with execution of a Housing Incentive Agreement. Since 63 percent of the affordable units required for the project site are located in the senior housing project (for ownership tenure), no portions of the project shall be subdivided until design, phasing, and tenure of the senior housing project is completed to satisfaction of Community Development Department. In addition, to ensure orderly development and the systematic provision of required affordable housing, construction phasing of affordable units will be required to be reasonably proportionate to market rate units. O. Section 9121 of the Tustin City Code requires the granting of a density bonus of twenty-five (25) percent of the total units and at least once concession or incentive when an applicant agrees to provide at least twenty (20) percent of the total units (excluding the density bonus) of the housing development as target units affordable to lower income households (i.e., Target Units). The applicant is providing 186 target units and requested a density bonus for construction of 182 units in Planning Area 4 and 5. No financial incentive has been requested. P. That the Building Official has considered and approved deviations to the Private Improvement Standard to allow turning radii of less than 25 feet for private drives when acceptable turning radii for a forty (40) foot long by eight (8) feet wide moving truck is demonstrated on the Circulation Plan. 0. That a Final Environmental Impact Statement/Environmental Impact Report for the MCAS Tustin Reuse Plan and Specific Plan (FEISIEIR) was prepared and certified, which considered the development of low density development within Planning Area 4 and medium density development within Planning Area 5. A checklist was prepared that finds all potential impacts of the project were addressed by the certified FEIS/EIR and no additional impacts have been identified; all applicable mitigation measures in the FEIS/EIR have been included as conditions of approval. The Planning Commission has adopted Resolution No. 3949 recommending that the City Council find that the FEIS/EIR for the MCAS Tustin Reuse Plan and Specific Plan adequately addressed all potential Impacts related to the subdivision. The Planning Commission hereby recommends that the City Council approve Tentative Tract Map 16561 for the subdivision of 105.5 (gross) acre site into 386 numbered lots and 186 lettered lots for the purpose of developing 1,077 residential units; including 337 units within Planning Area 4 and 740 units in Planning Area 5 (Parcel 23 and Parcel 24), subject to the conditions contained in Exhibit A attached hereto. Resolution No. 3952 TTM 16581 Page 5 PASSED AND ADOPTED at a regular meeting of the Tustin Planning Commission held on the 141h day of February, 2005--1 (1 NIELSEN ELIZABETH A. BINSACK Planning Commission Secretary STATE OF CALIFORNIA ) COUNTY OF ORANGE ) CITY OF TUSTIN ) I, ELIZABETH A. BINSACK, the undersigned, hereby certify that I am the Planning Commission Secretary of the Planning Commission of the City of Tustin, California; that Resolution No. 3952 duly passed and adopted at a regular meeting of the Tustin Planning Commission, held on the 14"' day of February, 2005. ELIZABETH A. BINSACK Planning Commission Secretary EXHIBIT A - TENTATIVE TRACT MAP 16581 RESOLUTION NO. 3952 CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL GENERAL (1) 1.1 Within 24 months from tentative map approval, the subdivider shall record with appropriate agencies, a final map prepared in accordance with subdivision requirements of the Tustin Municipal Code, the State Subdivision Map Act, and applicable conditions contained herein unless an extension is granted pursuant to Section 9335.08 of the Tustin Municipal Code. Prior to submittal for initial City review, all corrections noted herein shall be made. A revised tentative tract map that includes all corrections contained herein shall be submitted prior to the issuance of any permits or submittal of the first final tract map, whichever occurs first. If multiple final maps are proposed, each map shall comply with all requirements herein and the requirements for phasing set forth in Condition 2.1. (1) 1.2 Resolution No. 3952 shall become null and void in the event that Resolution Nos. 3950, 3951, 3953 approving Concept Plan 03- 003, Specific Plan Amendment/Zone Change 04-003, Design Review 04-006, and the Affordable Housing Plan and Density Bonus Application, which includes the transfer of required affordable housing units from Planning Area 4 and 21 to Planning Area 5 is not approved by the City Council. (1) 1.3 Approval of Resolution No. 3952 Is contingent upon the applicant retuming to the Community Development Department a notarized "Agreement to Conditions Imposed" form and the property owner signing and recording with the County Clerk -Recorder a notarized "Notice of Discretionary Permit Approval and Conditions of Approvar form. The forms shall be established by the Director of Community Development, and evidence of recordation shall be provided to the Community Development Department. SOURCE CODES (1) STANDARD CONDITION (5) RESPONSIBLE AGENCY REQUIREMENT (2) CEQA MITIGATION (6) LANDSCAPING GUIDELINES (3) UNIFORM BUILDING CODES (7) PC/CC POLICY (4) DESIGN REVIEW "' EXCEPTION — Exhibit A Resolution No. 3952 TTM 16581 Page 2 (1) 1.4 The final tract map(s) shall be developed in accordance with Resolution Nos. 3949, 3950, 3951, and 3953 approving Concept Plan 03-003, Specific Plan Amendment/Zone Change 04-003, Design Review 04-006, and the Affordable Housing Plan and Density Bonus Application, which includes the transfer of forty- seven (47) required affordable housing units from Planning Area 21 and Planning Area 4 to Planning Area 5. All conditions of approval herein, as applicable, shall be satisfied prior to recordation of a final map or as specified herein. (1) 1.5 The subdivider shall comply with all applicable requirements of the State Subdivision Map Act, the City's Subdivision Ordinance, the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan, applicable mitigation measures identified in the certified FEIS/EIR, and other agreements with the City of Tustin, unless otherwise modified by this Resolution or Resolution Nos. 3949, 3950, 3951, and 3953. (5) 1.6 Prior to recordation of the first final map, the subdivider shall be required to execute bonds or pay fees for grading permits, Quimby Act obligations, and Tustin Legacy Backbone Infrastructure Program improvements as determined by the City Council, required to be made by the developer pursuant to City procedures. (1) 1.7 Prior to recordation of the final map, the subdivider shall execute a , subdivision and monumentation agreement and furnish the improvement and 'monumentation bonds as required by the City Engineer. (1) 1.8 Prior to final map approval by the City Council, the subdivider shall execute a hold -harmless agreement and provide a Certificate of Insurance pursuant to Section 9325 of the Tustin City Code. (1) 1.9 The subdivider shall not oppose any future creation of a landscape and lighting district for maintenance within the public right-of-way or of public parkland, or community facilities district for funding of Tustin Legacy backbone infrastructure or municipal service provision to the project site, or a future community facilities district for school purposes. (1) 1.10 Prior to final map approval, the subdivider shall submit: A. A current title report; and, - B. A duplicate mylar of the Final Map, or 8% inch by 11 inch transparency of each map sheet prior to final map approval and "as built" grading, landscape, and improvement plans prior to Certificate of Acceptance. Exhibit A Resolution No. 3952 TTM 16581 Page 3 (1) 1.11 Upon recordation of any final map or submittal of an application for building permits, the applicant shall obtain new addresses from the Engineering Division. (1) 1.12 As a condition of approval of Tentative Tract Map 16581, the applicant shall agree, at its sole cost and expense, to defend, indemnify, and hold harmless the City, its officers, employees, agents, and consultants, from any claim, action, or proceeding brought by a third party against the City, its officers, agents, and employees, which seeks to attack, set aside, challenge, void, or annul an approval of the City Council, the Planning Commission, or any other decision-making body, including staff, concerning this project or from any potential flooding impacts. The City agrees to promptly notify the applicant of any such claim or action filed against the City and to cooperate in the defense of any such action. The City may, at its sole cost and expense, elect to participate in defense of any such action under this condition. (1) 1.13 As required by Amendment No. 1 to the Joint Cooperative Agreement between the City, the County of Orange, and the Orange County Flood Control District (OCFCD), the applicant shall indemnify and defend the City, County of Orange ("County") and the Orange County Flood Control District ("District") against any claims, loss, liability or damages arising from damage to property or injury to persons resulting from flooding and/or erosion within Tract 16581. The applicant shall ensure that it has adequate assets in existence to fund this obligation until completion of future widening and Peters Canyon Channel improvements. These defense and indemnify obligations do not extend to any loss, liability, or damages established by a court of competent jurisdiction to be cause by the County's or District's negligence or willful misconduct in the design or maintenance of existing flood control Improvements in the Peters Canyon Channel, provided the failure to improve Peter's Canyon Channel adjacent to Parcels in the City of Tustin and City of Irvine will not constitute negligence or willful misconduct on the part of the District or County. (1) 1.14 The applicant is required to prepare and record a final subdivision map. (1) 1.15 Unless otherwise agreed by the City in its sole discretion, the Developer Parcel, the property within the tract or any street or sidewalk or alleyway thereon shall not be privately gated; provided however, that any swimming pool and/or spa facility within the - Common Area and any indoor Common Area Improvement, Exhibit A Resolution No. 3952 TTM 16581 Page 4 including any clubhouse and bathrooms, may be gated or locked and made available solely to residents of the Project and their guests. PROJECT PHASING (*) 2.1 Construction phasing of products types and units (including affordable units) on individual multiple family product planning areas within the tract (i.e., PA 5-1, PA 5-2, PA 5-4, PA 5-5, PA 5-6, and PA 5-7) shall occur concurrently as shown on Sheet CP -8 (Phasing Pian) and as noted for in the conditions of approval contained herein with the exception of the senior housing project that requires submittal of a separate design review application and any associated required applications and a separate affordability production monitoring as identified in condition 2.2. (*) 2.2 The senior housing shown on the tentative tract map is provided for general location and number of units purposes and does not represent final City approval except that 153 affordable units shall be provided at this site including 36 Very Low, 61 Low, and 56 Moderate Income units. A design review application for the senior housing including a site plan delineating adequate access non - intrusive to low density residential units, adequate parking, landscaping, fire access, architectural floor plans, elevations, materials and colors for the housing units and the recreational building, and a phasing plan for the construction of the affordable units along with the market rate units in the senior housing shall be submitted and approved prior to issuance of building permits for the first production unit of the entire Columbus Square project. A production unit is defined as a unit included in phase I and subsequent phases of the Phasing Plan (not including initial phase or model homes). Any deviation from the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan parking standards for the senior housing would require approval of a conditional use permit which would include submittal of a parking analysis that would justify reduction in number of required parking spaces, subject to review and approval of the City's traffic engineer. If the developer is not able to justify the reduction in parking and/or the conditional use permit is not approved, the developer agrees to a proportionate reduction in the number of units. Except in no case, shall the number of affordable units approved herein for the senior housing project be reduced. Prior to issuance of the 4201' building permit for the production units of the entire Columbus Square project, building permits for the senior housing shall have been issued and the first footing inspection for the senior housing shall have been completed. In addition, construction of the recreation building and park facilities Exhibit A Resolution No. 3952 TTM 16581 Page 5 shall be completed prior to the issuance of the 420'h building permit (50% of non -restricted). (*) 2.3 The developer shall develop, market and sell Very Low, Low, and Moderate income ("affordable units") in the individual multiple family product planning areas ( i.e., PA 5-1, PA 5-2, PA 5-4, PA 5- 5, PA 5-6, and PA -5-7) as shown on Sheet CP -8 and shall construct and market and sell , such units in equal proportion to the market rate units as shown on the Phasing Plan for each individual multiple family planning area and as per the conditions of approval contained herein including Condition 2.1. If there is any deviation from provisions contained herein for the individual multiple family product planning areas and as required in Condition 2.1 as determined by the Community Development Department upon written notice to the applicant or applicable vertical home builder responsible for development of the planning area, no additional building permits shall be issued by the Community Development Department for additional units on subsequent phases in a planning area .(PA) until compliance with said provisions has been demonstrated to the satisfaction of the Director of Community Development. in reviewing compliance, the Director shall utilize objective information such as the number of market rate and affordable units constructed to date in the 1� planning area based on the approved Phasing Plan and Building Division records and data on the number of market rate and affordable units sold in an individual phase which shall be provided by the developer upon written request of the Director. The requirements of this Condition shall be disclosed by the applicant to all vertical home builders and with each final conveyance map. (*) 2.4 Prior to recordation of the first final map including a conveyance map, or first building permit, whichever occurs first, the applicant shall enter into a Housing Agreement with the City to insure Implementation of the Affordable Housing requirements of the Specific Plan, the City's Density Bonus Ordinance, the City approved "Affordable Housing Plan, Density Bonus Application, and the City's Affordable Housing Policy and compliance with California Health and Safety Code Section 33413(b)(2). The development shall include 266 affordable units in Planning Areas 4 5 including twenty-five (25) affordable units transferred from Planning Area 21 to Planning Area 5. (1) 2.5 Design and construction of all on-site and off-site developer -- required public infrastructure and in -tract private streets and utility systems shall be constructed within the initial phase of development and shall be completed prior to the issuance of Exhibit A Resolution No. 3952 TTM 16581 Page 6 building permits for any Phase 1 unit as identified on Sheet CP -8 (Phasing Plan). Model units may be constructed prior to completion of infrastructure if adequate ingress and egress is provided to the satisfaction of the Building Official and Orange County Fire Authority. Project infrastructure (i.e., drives within condominium projects) and utilities shall be constructed at the time of project development. (') 2.6 The developer shall submit to the City an Affordable Housing Purchaser Selection and Criteria Plan for Redevelopment Agency ("agency") review and approval 30 days prior to approval of a final map or issuance of a building permit, whichever occurs first. The agency will approve or disapprove the Affordable Housing Purchaser Selection and Criteria Pian within 20 calendar days. The developer shall initiate marketing and sales of the Affordable Housing units after agency's approval of Developer's Affordable Housing Purchaser Selection and Criteria Plan. Sale of Affordable Housing units can begin after final map recordation and all necessary California Department of Real Estate approvals. The developer shall also submit to agency individual escrow instructions for buyers of Affordable Housing units and all other related documents at least 20 calendar days prior to close of escrow of individual Affordable Housing units and with submission of individual escrow instructions and related items by developer to agency. The agency shall approve or disapprove individual escrow instructions and related items for buyers of Affordable Housing units within 10 calendar days of following submission by developer. GENERAL CONDITIONS FOR ALL NON -BACKBONE INFRASTRUCTURE IMPROVEMENTS The following general conditions apply to Tustin Legacy Non -Backbone Infrastructure Improvements, as specified in each condition to ensure coordinated design, construction, and operation of all on- and off-site infrastructure and utility systems. (1) 3.1 Separate 24" by 36" street improvement plans for all Tustin Legacy Non -Backbone Infrastructure Improvements identified in the following Conditions and other public improvements, as prepared by a California Registered Civil Engineer, shall be required for all design and construction within the public right-of-way including but not limited to the following: Exhibit A Resolution No. 3952 TTM 16581 Page 7 A. Full width improvements on Severyns Road, project entries at Valencia North Loop Road/Lot P and West Connector Road/Lot T; B. Sidewalk, including curb ramps for the physically disabled, on both sides of Severyns Road, the south side of Edinger Avenue, the north side of Valencia North Loop Road, and the west side of West Connector Road: The project shall comply with City of Tustin Standard Plan No. 204 for construction of meandering sidewalks and shall comply with ADA accessibility requirements for all proposed sidewalk grades on public streets. All public sidewalks, paseos, and trail facilities shall comply with the provisions of the American with Disabilities Act; C. Catch basins/storm drain laterals/connections to the existing storm drain system along Valencia North Loop Road, Severyns Road, and West Connector Road with approval of City of Tustin; D. Domestic water facilities and reclaimed water facilities: The domestic water system shall be designed and installed to the standards of the Irvine Ranch Water District. Improvement plans shall also be reviewed and approved by the Orange County Fire Authority for fire protection purposes. The adequacy and reliability of water system design and distribution of fire hydrants will be evaluated. The water distribution system and appurtenances shall also conform to the applicable laws and adopted regulations enforced by the Orange County Health Department. Any required reclaimed water system shall meet the standards as required by the Irvine Ranch Water District; E. Sanitary sewer facilities: All sanitary sewer facilities must be submitted as required by the City Engineer and Irvine Ranch Water District (IRWD). These facilities shall include a gravity flow system per the standard of the Irvine Ranch Water District; F. Landscape/irrigation on both sides of Severyns Road subject to Navy approval within the LIFOC areas, on the south side of Edinger Avenue and the median on Edinger Avenue adjacent to the project site, the median on Edinger Avenue from 1400 feet of Red Hill Avenue to West Connector Road, both sides of Valencia North Loop Road adjacent to the project site, and the west side of West Connector road adjacent to the project site; G. Underground utility connections: All utility lines shall be placed underground by the developer; H. Fire hydrants; Exhibit A Resolution No. 3952 TTM 16581 Page 8 I. Demolition and removal of any abandoned utilities at the entire site including within the current proposed roadway sections. J. Traffic signals at Lot PNalencia North Loop and Lot T/West Connector Road; and, K. Storm drain facilities on Severyns Road per City's Run-off Management Plan for Tustin Legacy. All public access easements outside of the existing or proposed street rights-of-way shall be clearly shown and labeled on the plans and street sections and design and placement of utilities such as light poles, street furniture, traffic lights, etc. will be subject to design parameters established by the City. In addition, a 24" by 36" reproducible construction area traffic control plan, as prepared by a California Registered Traffic Engineer or Civil Engineer experienced in this type of plan preparation, shall be required. (5) 3.2 All public improvements, including, but not limited to, water supply, sanitary sewer facilities, reclaimed water supply, storm water drainage, electrical service, gas service, and other facilities and utilities shall comply with the City of Tustin General Plan, the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan, City development standards and guidelines, and all conditions contained herein, including, but not limited to, the following: A. The project shall comply with City of Tustin Standard Plan No. 204 for construction of a meandering sidewalk and ADA accessibility requirements for all proposed sidewalk grades on public streets. B. All landscape setbacks shall be consistent with the City of Tustin MCAS Specific Plan. C. Adequate horizontal and vertical intersection sight lines shall be provided and shown on the grading plan and landscape plan. A minimum 25 foot by 25 foot limited use area triangle shall be provided to ensure adequate sight lines at all driveways and the applicant shall comply with the City of Tustin's Standard Drawings and Design Standards for Public Works Construction No. 510 for all public and private intersection sight distances and limited use area requirements for the project's streets. Exhibit A Resolution No. 3952 TTM 16581 Page 9 (1) 3.3 Prior to any final map recordation, the development applicant shall enter into an agreement with the City of Tustin and any appropriate regional utility agencies, districts, and providers, as applicable, to dedicate all easement, rights-of-way, or other land determined necessary to construct adequate utility infrastructure and facilities to serve the project, Including but not limited to, the following: IRWD, SCE, SBC, The Gas Company, Cox Communications, etc. (1) 3.4 A complete hydrology study and hydraulic calculations shall be submitted to the City for review and approval. (1) 3.5 The minimum pipe diameter for all public storm drains shall be 24 - inch. (5) 3.6 All storm drains to be constructed within or adjacent to the development shall be designed per the applicable OCFCD and City of Tustin standards. (1) 3.7 The proposed private and public drainage collection systems shall be designed for a minimum 25 -year storm frequency and a 100 - year storm frequency for regional facilities. The applicant shall submit hydrology studies for the existing and proposed drainage conditions for both the 25 -year and 100 -year storm events for the City's and County's review and approval and provide mitigation to maintain storm water discharges for the proposed condition that is consistent with the existing condition discharges for the site. (1) 3.8 A detailed hydrology and hydraulic analysis for 25 -year and 100 - year storm frequencies shall be provided for both the existing and proposed conditions to determine any requirements for on-site storm water retention/detention and facility sizing. The applicant shall also be required to accept upstream storm water that would historically cross the property and detain/retain on the property such upstream water so that the release of said water into downstream regional flood control systems does not exceed historical flow rates or the downstream capacity of such systems. (1) 3.9 All proposed utilities and storm drain lines shall be labeled as being either private or public, subject to approval by the Public Works Director and applicable utility providers. (1) 3.10 The minimum grade on gutter flow lines shall be 0.4 percent (including the flow line grades in street tapers and horizontal curves). Construction of catch basins, storm drain laterals and junction structures shall be required to eliminate the need for cross gutters on public streets. Exhibit A Resolution No. 3952 TTM 16581 Page 10 (1) 3.11 Prior to issuance of an encroachment permit, the applicant shall prepare a sedimentation and erosion control plan for all work related to this development. (1) 3.12 Preparation and submittal of a final grading plan shall be provided showing all pertinent elevations as they pertain to the public right- of-way along with delineating the following information: A. Final street elevations at key locations; B. Final pad/'finished floor elevations and key elevations for all site grading as established by the approved hydrology report and elevations provided by the OCFCD; and, C. All flood hazards of record. (1) 3.13 Prior to the recordation of the first final map, the applicant shall be required to enter into a landscape maintenance agreement with the City of Tustin for all parkway improvements within public right- of-way along Edinger Avenue, West Connector Road, Valencia North Loop Road, and the public portion of Severyns Road. (1) 3.14 In addition to the normal full size plan submittal process, all final development plans including, but not limited to: tract maps, parcel maps, right-of-way maps, records of survey, public works improvements, private Infrastructure improvements, final grading plans, and site plans are also required to be submitted to the Public Works Department/Engineering Division in computer aided design and drafting (CADD) format. The standard file format is AutoCAD Release 2004 having the extension DWG. Likewise, layering and line" conventions are AutoCAD -based (latest version available upon request from the Engineering Division). In order to interchangeably utilize the data contained in the infrastructure mapping system, CADD drawings must be in AutoCAD "DWG" format (i.e., produced using AutoCAD or AutoCAD compatible CADD software). The most current version of AutoCAD is Release 2000. Drawings created in AutoCAD Release 2000 are compatible and acceptable. The CADD files shall be submitted to the City at the time the plans are approved and updated CADD files reflecting the "as built" conditions shall be submitted once all construction has been completed. The subdivision bonds will not be released until the "as built" CADD files have been submitted. Exhibit A Resolution No. 3952 TTM 16581 Page 11 TUSTIN LEGACY BACKBONE INFRASTRUCTURE PROGRAM (1) 4.1 This Subdivision necessitates the construction of certain infrastructure improvements as outlined in the Tustin Legacy Backbone Infrastructure Program for the former MCAS Tustin. The applicant shall fund its Fair Share Contribution to the Tustin Legacy Backbone Infrastructure and shall provide security satisfactory to City to insure that the entire Fair Share Contribution is paid to the City including amounts due for the Government Parcels within the City of Irvine as required in the Cooperative Agreement between the City of Tustin and Marble Mountain Partners LLC, dated February 7, 2005. (1) 4.2 The applicant shall design and construct the traffic signal at West ConnectorNalencia North Loop Road, in the first phase of development of Tentative Tract Map 16581. For all design and construction within the public right-of-way, separate plans shall be provided, which include all plans and specifications and estimates necessary to conduct a public bid process. PRIVATE IN -TRACT IMPROVEMENTS (3) 5.1 Prior to the issuance of precise grading permits, infrastructure construction plans, as prepared by a California Registered Civil Engineer, shall be required for all private, on-site construction. All design and construction of improvement work shall incorporate applicable conditions contained within Resolution No. 3947 and, shall be designed and performed in accordance with the applicable portions of the City of Tustin's "Grading Manual" and "Construction Standards for Private Streets, Storm Drain and On -Site Private Improvements," revised April 1989, or as subsequently amended. Said plans shall include, but not be limited to, the following: A. Curbs and gutters on all streets; B. Sidewalks on all streets, including curb ramps for the physically disabled; all sidewalks, pathways, paseos, and trails shall comply with the provisions of the American with Disabilities Act; C. Drive aprons; D. Signing/striping plan; — E. Street and drive aisle paving; all private streets, drive aisles, and curb return radius shall be consistent with the City's Exhibit A Resolution No. 3952 TTM 16581 Page 12 design standards for private street improvements, unless otherwise approved by the Building Official, and all roadway and driveway widths and parking area widths (and lengths where appropriate) shall be dimensioned on the plans; F. Catch basin/storm drain laterals/connections to the public storm drain system with approval of the City of Tustin; G. Domestic water facilities and reclaimed water facilities: The domestic water system shall be designed and installed to the standards of the Irvine Ranch Water District. Improvement plans shall also be reviewed and approved by the Orange County Fire Authority for fire protection purposes. The adequacy and reliability of the water system design and the distribution of fire hydrants will be evaluated. The water distribution system and appurtenances shall also conform to the applicable laws and adopted regulations enforced by the Orange County Health Department. Any required reclaimed water system shall meet the standards as required by the Irvine Ranch Water District (IRWD); H. Sanitary sewer facilities: All sanitary sewer facilities must be submitted as required by the Building Official and IRWD. These facilities shall be consistent with the standards of the Irvine Ranch Water District; I. Underground utility connections: All utility lines shall be placed underground by the developer, J. Fire hydrants; K. Demolition/removal of utilities in accordance with the demolition/severance plan as required herein; L. Telecommunications facilities including, but not limited to, telephone and cable television facilities. Developer is required to coordinate design and construction of cable television facilities with a City -franchised system operator and shall not place an undue burden upon said operator for the provision of these facilities. (3) 5.2 Prior to the issuance of building permits, construction plans, as prepared by a California Registered Civil Engineer, shall be required for the following private improvements: Exhibit A Resolution No. 3952 TTM 16581 Page 13 A. Street lighting: The private street lighting system shall be reviewed and approved by the City of Tustin and Southern California Edison; B. Landscaperrrigation; C. Trash facilities: The applicant shall provide commercial trash collection and obtain approval from the Engineering Division for the location, size, and trash enclosures. (1) 5.3 All improvement work shall be performed in accordance with the applicable portions of the City of Tustin's "Grading Manual° and "Construction Standards for Private Streets, Storm Drain and On - Site Private Improvements," revised April 1989. COORDINATION WITH AFFECTED PROPERTY OWNERS AND AGENCIES (1) 6.1 The applicant shall obtain permission from and coordinate with affected property owners, jurisdictions, and resource agencies for all public and private improvements, including, but not limited to, the following: A. Prior to any . work in the public right-of-way, an >� Encroachment Permit shall be obtained and applicable fees paid to the Public Works Department. B. The applicant shall obtain permission from affected property owners for any work located on adjacent properties or on LIFOC parcels, including the property owned by the Department of Navy. C. The applicant shall obtain all approvals and permits from the applicable property owners and agencies for work within the City limits. D. The applicant shall coordinate the design and construction of the bus stop locations with the Orange County Transportation Authority. E. The applicant shall obtain written approval and/or permits from the applicable utility companies. F. The applicant shall obtain permission from property owners for any work located on adjacent properties. Exhibit A Resolution No. 3952 TTM 16581 Page 14 CONSTRUCTION (1) 7.1 Any damage done to existing street improvements and utilities shall be repaired before acceptance of the tract within the subdivision to the satisfaction of the City Engineer. (1) 7.2 The applicant shall comply with all waste diversion requirements. The City of Tustin is required to comply with the recycling requirements contained in the California Integrated Waste Management Act of 1989. To facilitate City compliance with this law, the applicant is required to comply with Section 4327 of the Tustin City Code which details the requirements for developing and implementing a Waste Management Plan. GRANTS IN FEE AND DEDICATION (1) 8.1 The applicant and subdivider shall satisfy dedication and/or reservation requirements as applicable, including but not limited to dedication of parts of Severyns Road and West Connector Road, traffic signal equipment and maintenance easements of Valencia North Loop Road/Lot P and West Connector Road/Lot T, drainage and flood control right-of-way easements for acceptance and conveyance of existing flows from the adjacent business park westerly of Planning Area 4, pedestrian and vehicular access rights, utility easements and public parks, defined and approved as ` to speck locations by the City Engineer and other agencies, for this project. Reciprocal ingress, egress, parking, utility and pedestrian access easements may need to be provided between and across certain privately own and maintained lots and within the lettered lots. (1) 8.2 The applicant shall identify the easements for public use of privately owned parks and related public access easements on the final map. (1) 8.3 The applicant shall dedicate in fee title to the City of Tustin portions of Severyns Road for public roadways and utility purposes as shown on the Tentative Tract Map 16581. (1) 8.4 All dedication and/or offers of dedication shall also state that the City of Tustin shall be permitted to obtain, at no cost, a right -of - entry and temporary construction easement for all on-site joins when the ultimate street improvements are constructed. The right - of -entry and temporary construction easement shall terminate on the date that the Notice of Completion is recorded at the Orange County Recorder's office. Exhibit A Resolution No. 3952 TTM 16581 Page 15 — (1) 8.5 The applicant shall provide an ingress/egress easement on lots "P," 'T,", "R," "U," and "X," for Department of Navy to access IRP - 16. (1) 8.6 The applicant shall dedicate public access and maintenance easements to the City of Tustin fro sidewalk along Valencia North Loop Road and West Connector Road. CC_ (1) 9.1 All organizational documents for the project including any covenants, conditions, and restrictions (CC&Rs) shall be submitted to and approved by the Community Development Department, City Attorney's Office, and Special Counsel. Costs for such review shall be bome by the subdivider. The approved CC&Rs shall be recorded with County Recorder's Office at the same time as recordation of the final map. A copy of the final documents shall be submitted to the Community Development Department after recordation. No dwelling unit in the development shall be sold or a Certificate of Occupancy issued, unless a homeowners association has been legally formed with the right to assess all these properties which are jointly owned or benefited to operate and maintain all other mutually available features of the development including, but not limited to, open space, amenities, landscaping, or slope maintenance landscaping, private streets, and utilities. No dwelling unit shall be sold unless all approved and required open space, amenities, landscaping, or other improvements, or approved phases thereof, have been completed or completion is assured by a - development agreement or financing guarantee method approved by the City. The CC&Rs shall include, but not be limited to, the following provisions: A. The City shall be included as a party to the CC&Rs for enforcement purposes of those CC&R provisions in which the City has interest as reflected in the following provisions. However, the City shall not be obligated to enforce the CC&Rs. B. The requirement that association bylaws be established. C. Provisions for effective establishment, operation, management, use, repair, and maintenance of all common areas and facilities including recreational buildings and amenities, landscaped areas and lots, walls and fences, Exhibit A Resolution No. 3952 TTM 16581 Page 16 private roadways (i.e., walks, sidewalks, trails), parkland facilities and bikeways, and open space areas. D. Membership in the homeowners association shall be inseparable from ownership in individual units. E. Architectural controls shall be provided and may include, but not be limited to, provisions regulating exterior finishes, roof materials, fences and walls, accessory structures such as patios, sunshades, trellises, gazebos, awnings, exterior mechanical equipment, television and radio antenna, consistent with the Tustin City Code and the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan. F. Maintenance standards shall be provided for applicable items listed in Section C above in CC&As. Examples of maintenance standards are shown below. 1. All common area landscaping and private areas visible from any public way shall be properly maintained such that they are evenly cut, evenly edged, free of bare or brown spots, debris, and weeds. All trees and shrubs shall be trimmed so they do not impede vehicular or pedestrian traffic. Trees shall be pruned so they do not intrude into neighboring properties and shall be maintained so they do not have droppings or create other nuisances to neighboring properties. All trees shall also be root pruned to eliminate exposed surface roots and damage to sidewalks, driveways, and structures. 2. All private roadways, sidewalks, and open space areas shall be maintained so that they are safe for users. Significant pavement cracks, pavement distress, excessive slab settlement, abrupt vertical variations, and debris on travel ways should be removed or repaired promptly. I Common areas shall be maintained in such a manner as to avoid the reasonable determination of a duly authorized official of the City that a public nuisance has been created by the absence of adequate maintenance such as to be detrimental to public health, safety, or general welfare. Exhibit A Resolution No. 3952 TTM 16581 Page 17 G. Homeowners association approval of exterior improvements requiring a building permit shall be obtained prior to requesting a building permit from the City of Tustin Community Development Department. All plans for exterior improvements shall conform to requirements set forth by the City and the CC&Rs. H. Private open space areas within the common area shall be illustrated on a "Private Open Space Exhibit" and shall be made part of the CC&Rs and shall specify those portions of the common open space area that are allocated for private use and public use and access rights in perpetuity. The CC&Rs shall include a separate 81h inch by 11 inch dimensioned site plan for each unit that is allocated private open space. 1. The approved site plan showing the public portion of the park site and associated public easements that will be accessible to the public and provisions for maintenance of these areas by the Homeowners Association. J The approved "Parking and Circulation Exhibit" shall be made part of the CC&Rs and shall be enforced by the homeowners association. In addition to the exhibit, provisions regarding parking shall be included in the CC&Rs, including the following: 1. All units are required to maintain a two -car garage. 2. A minimum of 562 unassigned guest parking spaces shall be permanently maintained in locations shown on the "Parking and Circulation Exhibit" and have a minimum length of twenty-two (22) feet per stall for on street parking. 3. Residents shall not store or park any non -motorized vehicles, trailers or motorized vehicles that exceed 7 feet high, 7 feet wide, and 19 feet long in any parking space, driveway, or private street area except for the purpose of loading, unloading, making deliveries or emergency repairs except that the homeowners association may adopt rules and regulations to authorize exceptions. 4. Residents shall park vehicles in garage spaces. Storage of personal items may occur in the garages Exhibit A Resolution No. 3952 TTM 16581 Page 18 only to the extent that vehicles may still be parked within the required garage spaces. 5. The homeowners association shall be responsible for monitoring and enforcing all parking and traffic regulations on private streets. The proposed CC&Rs shall include provisions requiring the association to develop and adopt an enforcement program for parking and traffic regulations within the development which may include measures for fire access and enforcement by a private security company. K. Provisions for enforcing individual trash bin placement at designated curb areas as shown on the approved "Curbside Trash Pick-up Exhibilr no earlier than noon on the day before scheduled collections and removed within twelve (12) hours of collection. L. Maintenance of lettered and numbered Lots (including but not limited to Lots 264, 265, 297,335 and 369 Lots A -m, P- u, X -Y, CA -CF, DA -DJ, FA -FD, AA -AR, BA -BC, EA -EG, GA - GH, HA -HO, IA -IL AAA-AAJ, BBA -BAF, BBA-BBZ, CCA- CCO, DAA, DDA-DDZ), containing all common areas, public and private park areas, streets, alleys, paseos, etc., shall be by the homeowners association. M. Television and radio antennas shall be installed in accordance with the requirements of the Tustin City Code. N. All utility services serving the site shall be installed and maintained underground. O. The homeowners association shall be required to file the names, addresses, and telephone numbers of at least one member of the homeowners association Board and, where applicable, a manager of the project before January 1st of each year with the City of Tustin Community Development Department for the purpose of contacting the association in the case of emergency or in those cases where the City has an interest in CC&R violations. P. The homeowners association shall be responsible' for —'- establishing and following procedures for providing access to public utilities for maintenance of their facilities within the project area, subject to those agencies' approval. Exhibit A Resolution No. 3952 TTM 16581 Page 19 Q. No amendment to alter, modify, terminate, or change the homeowners association's obligation to maintain the common areas and the project perimeter wall or other CC&R provisions In which the City has an interest, as noted above, or to alter, modify, terminate, or change the City's right to enforce maintenance of the common areas and maintenance of the project perimeter wall, shall be permitted without the prior written approval of the City of Tustin Community Development Department. R. No delivery and or moving trucks larger than 40 feet shall be permitted on the private drives of the condominium projects with less than 25 foot radius turns. HOMEBUYER NOTIFICATION (1) 10.1 Prior to recordation of the final map, the subdivider shall submit to the Community Development Department for review and approval a homebuyer notification document that includes the notifications listed below. The notification document shall be signed by each homebuyer prior to final inspection and occupancy, and a copy of the signed notification shall be provided to the Community Development Department prior to final inspection and/or issuance �. of each Certificate of Occupancy. A. A notice for roadway, trail, and train noise that may impact the subdivision, including roadway noise associated with, Edinger Avenue, North Loop Road, West Connector Road, and train noise associated with the rail corridor north of the project. The notice shall indicate the current number of trains per day (59) and the estimated to increase to over 100 trains on a 24 hour basis by the year 2020. The notice shall indicate that additional building upgrades may be necessary for noise attenuation. This determination is to be made as architectural drawings become available and/or where field-testing determines inadequate noise insulation. B. A notice, to be reviewed by the City of Tustin and the Tustin Unified School District, regarding the location of existing and proposed elementary, middle, and high schools which will serve the subdivision (text and map) and advice to homebuyers that proposed school sites may never be constructed. C. A notice regarding units that are adjacent to aboveground utilities or structures (such as light standards and fire Exhibit A Resolution No. 3952 TTM 16581 Page 20 hydrants) identifying the type of structure and their locations. D. A notice indicating that any use of a residence for a business shall be subject to the City's Home Occupation Ordinance and may require zoning clearance and a business license. E. A notice indicating that public use of a minimum one (1) acre or more portion of the park site, to be maintained by the homeowners association, will be allowed and noting public ingress and egress through the subdivision will be provided for access to the park. F. A notice explaining the easements, facilities, amenities, and dedications that will be provided on lettered lots and indicating all on-site streets, alleys, paseos, and common areas are to be maintained by the homeowners association. G. A notice, to be approved by the City Attorney, indicating that neither the site, nor the project nor any part thereof any street or sidewalk, alleyway, or paseo thereon shall be privately gated, ' provided however that any swimming pool and/or spa facility within the common area and any indoor common area improvements, Including any clubhouse and bathrooms, may be gated or locked and made available solely to residents of the project and their guests. H. A notice stating that - all development within the site is approved for ownership tenure only per Chapter 3.9.3J5 of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan. A notice stating trash bins shall be placed in designated curb areas as shown on the approved "Curbside Trash Pick-up Exhibit" no earlier than noon on the day before scheduled collections and removed within twelve (12) hours of collection. J. A notice indicating that surrounding properties may be developed in accordance with City ordinances in a manner which may partially or totally obstruct views from the owner's unit and that the City of Tustin makes no claim, - warranty, or guarantee that views from any unit will be preserved as development of surrounding properties occurs. Exhibit A Resolution No. 3952 TTM 16581 Page 21 K. A notice indicating the minimum building setbacks and that construction of patio covers, . trellises, etc. may not be allowed. L. A notice explaining and providing a copy of a "Private Open Space Exhibit" and separate 8% inch by 11 inch dimensioned site plan for each unit that is allocated private open space within the common area. M. A notice explaining and providing a copy of the approved "Parking and Circulation Exhibit" and related CUR provisions. N. A notice explaining that 241 affordable housing units will be dispersed throughout the site. These units will remain affordable for a period of forty-five (45) years or longer. O. A notice explaining the phasing of construction within the subdivision and that activity may be disruptive. P. The developer shall notify all homebuyers that future Assessment/Maintenance Districts may affect the property. k- Q. The project is located adjacent to a future fire station site at � the southwest comer of Edinger Avenue and West Connector Road that will be operating 24 hours. ENVIRONMENTAL MITIGATION (1) 11.1 All mitigation measures related to the tentative tract map required by the adopted Mitigation Monitoring Program for the MCAS Tustin Reuse Plan/Specific Plan FEIS/EIR that are required by the Mitigation Monitoring Program for the project, identified in this exhibit and in other project entitlements, shall be implemented. (1) 11.2 As part of the final design process and to comply with the Final EIR/EIS requirements for the Disposal and Reuse of MCAS Tustin, the applicant shall submit detailed hydrology calculations of 100 - year storm events for the existing pre -project condition and for the project condition. As part of the study, the project's contribution to the overall increase in stormwater runoff from the redevelopment of MCAS Tustin shall be estimated and the potential design and construction costs to mitigate the Increase storm water discharge - contribution from the project shall be determined. Exhibit A Resolution No. 3952 TTM 16581 Page 22 PARKS AND RECREATION (1) 12.1 The applicant shall at its sole cost and expense comply with the Quimby Act, California Government Code Section 66477, and shall as a condition precedent to issuance of building permits for the vertical improvements or any portion thereof, pay for and provide a performance bond complying with City Code Section 9931(d), in favor of the City, with the Surety and informed and substance acceptable to the City in its sole discretion covering the developer's Quimby fee obligations in the amount of cash payment for the net required parkland requirements in the tract equal to a net acreage of 1.85 acres minus the approved improvement cost for the development of on-site parkland approved for parkland credit in an amount based on actual improvement plans and cost approved in writing by the Director of Parks and Recreation Department not to exceed $675,000 per acre times an appraised value of land for the tract as approved by the City pursuant to City Code Section 2.7 and 3.11.18 of the MCAS Tustin Specific Pian and a performance bond equal to 5.33 acres times an appraised value of land in the tract as approved by _.._ the City pursuant to City Code Section 9931(d), which performance bond shall be decreased upon compliance by the applicant with the provisions of clauses (A) and (B) below. A) As part of the initial phase of the project and concurrently with construction of the required horizontal improvements and as part of the common area improvements, the applicant shall construct within the common area certain contiguous, landscaped, open space facilities of not less than one acre in area in the location as depicted on the preliminary plan and the approved project pians and Including improvements as required by the Tustin Code to quality for Quimby Fee waiver (park facilities) that shall be open and accessible to the public. Upon completion of the park facilities and as a condition precedent to issuance of any partial or final certificate of compliance the developer shall execute and record a perpetual easement or other dedication agreement in favor of the City and its successors and assigns, inform and subject acceptable to the City in its sole discretion upon final map and the acceptance of conditions, covenants, and restrictions (CC&Rs) for the benefit of the public providing in perpetuity and at no cost to the City: (i) the right of the public to access and use the Park Facilities; (ii) public access to and from said Park Facilities along and across public and private streets within the site; and (iii) maintenance of the Park Facilities by the Exhibit A Resolution No. 3952 TTM 16581 Page 23 Developer and its successor and assigns, in each case subject only to reasonable and non-discriminatory rules and regulations. Upon (x) completion of such Regulations applicable thereto, and (y) recordation of an easement or dedication agreement approved by the City, the City shall provide a credit to the developer against its obligation to pay Quimby Act Fees in the amount of 3.66 acres times an appraised value of the land for the tract. . B) Waiver for Affordable Housing. The developer shall receive a credit against Quimby Act fees otherwise due and payable by it as permitted by the City Code Section 9931 in connection with construction of not to exceed 241 Affordable Housing Units in this tract in an amount not to exceed 1.97 acres times an appraised value of land; provided, however, that the benefit of such waiver shall apply with respect to each Affordable Housing Unit only upon Completion of all Affordable Housing Units in the Phase in which such Unit is located. (1) 12.2 The Developer shall accommodate, at various locations on the _ Developer Parcel as approved by Community Development, pedestrian and bicycle connections to the regional bike trail to be constructed in the future along Edinger Avenue, Valencia Avenue, and the West Connector and Class II bicycle trails as depicted on the Preliminary Plan. The final tract map shall include a perpetual easement in favor of the City, its successors and assigns, in form and substance acceptable to the City in its sole discretion and at no cost to the City, providing pedestrian and bicycle access to the public upon and across the full length of any foregoing pedestrian and bicycle connections on the Developer Parcel as they connect to adjoining bike paths. Notwithstanding the foregoing, the Developer and its successors and assigns shall retain responsibility for maintenance and repair of the foregoing pedestrian and bicycle connections constructed on the Developer Parcel. FEES (1) 13.1 The applicant shall submit to the City of Tustin any additional CC&R Review fee required at the time of submittal. The CC&R Review fee includes one initial check and recheck of the document. If subsequent review is required, an hourly fee of $150 — per hour (or rate in effect at the time of submittal) for the City Attorney and $50 per hour (or rate in effect at the time of submittal) for the Planning Staff Is required. Exhibit A Resolution No. 3952 TTM 16581 Page 24 (1) 13.2 Prior to issuance of the first building permit, the subdivider shall submit in -lieu parkland dedication fees in an amount and form as required by the Director of the Parks and Recreation Department. (1) 13.3 The applicant shall submit all fees required by the City and other agencies as identified in Resolution No. 3953. RESOLUTION NO. 3953 A RESOLUTION OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF TUSTIN APPROVING DESIGN REVIEW 04-006 AUTHORIZING THE DEVELOPMENT OF 1,077 RESIDENTIAL UNITS ON A 105.5 ACRE (GROSS) SITE BOUNDED BY EDINGER AVENUE ON THE NORTH, AN OFFICE INDUSTRIAL BUILDING AND SEVERYNS ROAD ON THE WEST, VALENCIA NORTH LOOP ROAD ON THE SOUTH AND WEST CONNECTOR ROAD ON THE EAST WITHIN PLANNING AREA 4 AND PLANNING AREA 5 OF THE MCAS TUSTIN SPECIFIC PLAN (PARCEL 23 AND PARCEL 24) The Planning Commission of the City of Tustin does hereby resolve as follows: I. The Planning Commission finds and determines as follows: A. That a proper application for Design Review. 04-006 was submitted by Marble Mountain Partners LLC for development of 1,077 residential units including 84 Single Family Detached (SFD), 181 Carriage Way (SFD), 72 condominium units (senior housing -- for ownership tenure) for a total of 337 units at an average density of 8.62 du/acre in Planning Area 4 (Parcel 23) and 18 Carriage Way units (SFD), 552 Condominium units (Multiple Family Residential), and 170 condominium units (senior housing — for ownership tenure) t for a total of 740 units at an average density 17.53 du/acre for Planning Area 5 (Parcel 24) of the MCAS -Tustin Specific Plan on a 105.5 -acre site within Planning Area 4 and Planning Area 5 of the MCAS -Tustin Specific Plan (Parcel 23 and 24); B. That a public hearing was duly called, noticed, and held for said application on January 24, 2005 and continued to February 14, 2005, by the Planning Commission; C. That the site is located in the "MCAS -Tustin Specific Plan" land use designation of the General Plan, which provides for residential development, and in Planning Areas 4 and 5 of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan, which is designated for Low Density Residential and Medium Density Residential on MCAS Tustin Reuse Plan Disposal Parcel 23 and Parcel 24; D. That, as conditioned, the proposed subdivision will be in conformance with the Tustin Area General Plan, MCAS Tustin Specific Plan, as amended by Zone Change 04-003, State Subdivision Map Act and the City's Subdivision Code; Resolution 3953 DR 04-006 Page 2 E. Pursuant to the MCAS Tustin Specific Pian and Section 9272 of the Tustin Municipal Code, the Planning Commission finds that the location, size, architectural features, and general appearance of the proposed development will not impair the orderly and harmonious development of the area, the present or future development therein, or the occupancy as a whole. In making such findings, the Commission has considered at least the following items: 1. Height, bulk, and area of buildings. 2. Setbacks and site planning. 3. Exterior materials and colors. 4. Type and pitch of roofs. 5. Size and spacing of windows, doors, and other openings. 6. Towers, chimneys, roof structures, flagpoles, radio and television antennae. 7. Location, height, and standards of exterior illumination. 8. Landscaping, parking area design, and traffic circulation. 9. Location and appearance of equipment located outside an enclosed structure. 10. Location and method of refuse storage. 11. Physical relationship of proposed structures to existing structures in the neighborhood. 12. Appearance and design relationship of proposed structures to existing structures and possible future structures in the neighborhood and public thoroughfares. 13. Proposed signage. 14. Development Guidelines and criteria as adopted by the City Council. F. That the applicant has requested approval of Tentative Tract Map 16581 ('The Map") in conjunction with the applications for Design Review 04-006, and findings and conditions of approval related to site design, street design, open space and park site design, dedication of necessary rights-of-way and provision of necessary infrastructure improvements have been included in Resolution No. 3952 recommending approval of The Map. G. That a Final Environmental Impact Statement/Environmental Impact Report for the Disposal and Reuse of MCAS Tustin (FEISIEIR) was prepared and certified, which considered the potential development of low density residential units and that the proposed project includes 1,077 units. A checklist was prepared that finds all potential impacts of the project were addressed by the certified FEIS/EIR and no additional impacts have been identified; all applicable mitigation measures in the FEIS/EIR have been included as conditions of approval. The Planning Commission has Resolution 3953 DR 04-006 Page 3 adopted Resolution No. 3949 finding that the FEIS/EIR adequately addressed all potential impacts related to the project. 11. The Planning Commission hereby approves Design Review 04-006 for development of 1,077 residential units on a 105.5 -acre site (Parcel 23 and Parcel 24) within Planning Area 4 and Planning Area 5 of the MCAS - Tustin Specific Plan, subject to the conditions contained in Exhibit A attached hereto. PASSED AND ADOPTED at a regular meeting of th Tustin Planning Commission held on the 14!' day of February, 2005. J A LSEN Chairperson ELI ETH A. BINSACK Planning Commission Secretary STATE OF CALIFORNIA ) COUNTY OF ORANGE ) CITY OF TUSTIN ) I, ELIZABETH A. BINSACK, the undersigned, hereby certify that I am the Planning Commission Secretary of the Planning Commission of the City of Tustin, California; that Resolution No. 3953 duly passed and adopted at a regular meeting of the Tustin Planning Commission, held on the 14th day of February, 2005. c6n�,*' xoto��� ELI BETH A. BINSACK ' 6 Pla ning Commission Secretary EXHIBIT A DESIGN REVIEW 04-006 RESOLUTION NO. 3953 CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL GENERAL (1) 1.1 The proposed project shall conform with the Tustin City Code and Tustin guidelines and standards and be consistent with submitted plans for the project date stamped February 14, 2005, on file with the Community Development Department, except as herein modified, or as modified by the Director of Community Development in accordance with this Exhibit. The Director of Community Development may also approve minor modifications to plans during plan check if such modifications are consistent with the provisions of the Tustin City Code, and other applicable codes. (1) 1.2 Unless otherwise specified, the conditions contained in this Exhibit shall be compiled with as specified or prior to the issuance of any building permits for the project, subject to review and approval by the Community Development Department (1) 1.3 Resolution No. 3953 shall become null and void in the event that Resolution Nos. 3950, 3951, and 3952 approving Specific Plan Amendment/Zone Change 04-003, Concept Plan 03-003, Tentative Tract Map 16581, and the Affordable Housing Plan and Density Bonus Application, which incudes 182 additional density bonus units and transfer of 8 Very Low income and 17 Low income units from Planning Area 21 to Planning Area 5 and transfer 8 Low Income units and 14 Moderate Income units from Planning Area 4 to Planning Area 5, are not approved by the City Council. (1) 1.4 The subject project approval shall become null and void unless permits for the proposed project are issued and substantial construction is underway within 24 months. All time extensions may be. considered N a written request is within thirty (30) days prior to expiration date. (1) 1.5 The development of the project described in Design Review 04-006 shall be designed and constructed in accordance with Specific Plan Amendment/Zone Change 04-003, Concept Plan 03-003, Tentative Tract Map 16581, and density bonus application as approved by Resolution Nos. 3950, 3951, 3952, and 3946 which are incorporated herein by reference. SOURCE CODES (1) STANDARD CONDITION (5) RESPONSIBLE AGENCY REQUIREMENT (2) CEQA MITIGATION (0) LANDSCAPING GUIDELINES (3) UNIFORM BUILDING CODES (7) PCICC POLICY (4) DESIGN REVIEW "" EXCEPTION Resolution 3953 DR 04-006 Page 2 (1) 1.6 Approval of Design Review 04-006 is contingent upon the applicant returning to the Community Development Department a notarized "Agreement to Conditions Imposed" form and the property owner signing and recording with the County Clerk -Recorder a notarized "Notice of Discretionary Permit Approval and Conditions of Approval" form. The forms shalt be established by the Director of Community Development, and evidence of recordation shall be provided to the Community Development Department. (1) 1.7 The development of the project described in Design Review 04-006 shall be in accordance with Concept Plan 03-003 and Tentative Tract Map 16581 approved by Resolution Nos. 3951, and 3952 which are incorporated herein by reference. (1) 1.8 As a condition of approval of Design Review 04-006, the applicant shall agree, at its sole cost and expense, to defend, indemnify, and hold harmless the City, its officers, employees, agents, and consultants, from any claim, action, or proceeding brought by a third party against the City, its officers, agents, and employees, which seeks to attack, set aside, challenge, void, or annul an approval of the City Council, the Planning Commission, or any other decision-making body, including staff, concerning this project. The City agrees to promptly notify the applicant of any such claim or action filed against the City and to fully cooperate in the defense of any such action. The City may, at its sole cost and expense, elect to participate in defense of any such action under this condition. (5) 1.9 The applicant shall implement an affordable housing program in compliance with all applicable provisions of MCAS Tustin Specific Plan and comply with related conditions contained in the housing incentive agreement as required by Resolution No. 3952t. (5) 1.10 Project phasing shall be in accordance with the phasing set forth in Resolution No. 3952. GRADING PLAN SUBMITTAL (1) 2.1 Prior to issuance of a grading permit all requirements related to private infrastructure contained within Resolution No. 3946 shall be met. (1) 2.2 Four (4) sets of final grading plans, including a site plan, and consistent with the landscaping plans, as prepared by a registered civil engineer, shall be submitted and shall include the following: A. Technical details and plans for all utility installations including telephone, gas, water, and electricity. Resolution 3953 DR 04-006 Page 3 B. Three (3) copies of a precise soils report provided by a civil engineer and less than one (1) year old. Expanded information regarding the levels of hydrocarbons and ground water contamination found on-site shall be provided in the soil report. All pavement "R" values shall be in accordance with applicable City of Tustin standards. C. Information demonstrating that all site drainage shall be handled on-site and shall not be permitted to drain onto adjacent properties. D. Information demonstrating that drainage, vegetation, circulation, street sections, curbs, gutters, sidewalks, and storm drains shall comply with the City of Tustin's "Construction Standards for Private Streets, Storm Drain and On -Site Private Improvements," revised April 1989. E. Two (2) copies of a hydrology report. F. Information demonstrating that vehicle parking, primary entrance to the building, primary paths of travel, sanitary facilities, drinking fountain, and public telephones for the recreation building shall be accessible to persons with disabilities. G. Building and landscape setback dimensions and dimensions for all drive aisles, back up areas, each covered parking stall, and open parking stalls. H. Details indicating that a maximum streetlight spacing of 200 feet staggered from side to side along the street shall be used for on-site street lighting (per City standards for local private residential streets) and placement of streetlights in relation to the intersection locations and other driver decision points for safe pedestrian access through the site. (1) 2.3 The engineer of record must submit a final compaction report to the Building Division for review and approval prior to the issuance of a building permit. (1) 2.4 The engineer of record must submit a pad certification to the Building Division for review and approval prior to the issuance of a building permit. (1) 2.5 Prior to issuance of a grading permit, the applicant shall be required to provide a performance bond to assure grading work is completed in accordance with approved plans. The engineer's estimated cost shall be submitted to the Building Official for determination of the bond amount. Resolution 3953 DR 04-006 Page 4 (1) 2.6 A note shall be provided on the final plans indicating that a six (6) foot high chain link fence shall be installed around the site prior to grading. A nylon fabric or mesh shall be attached to the temporary construction fencing. Gated entrances shall be permitted along the perimeter of the site for construction vehicles. BUILDING PLAN SUBMITTAL (3) 3.1 At the time of building permit application, the plans shall comply with the 2001 California Building Code (CBC), 2001 California Mechanical Code (CMC), 2001 California Plumbing Codes (CPC), 2001 California Electrical Code (CEC), California Title 24 Accessibility Regulations, Title 24 Energy Regulations, City Ordinances, and State and Federal laws and regulations. (3) 3.2 Ouilding plan check submittal shall include the following: • Seven (7) sets of construction plans, including drawings for mechanical, plumbing, and electrical. • Structural calculations, two (2) copies. - • Title 24 energy calculations, two (2) copies. • Elevations that include all proposed dimensions, materials, colors, finishes, and partial outlines of adjacent buildings on-site and off-site where applicable • Details for the proposed windows and doors. • Roofing material shall be fire rated class "B" or better. • The location of any utility vents or other equipment shall be provided on the roof plan. • Details of all proposed lighting fixtures and a photometric study showing the location and anticipated pattern of light distribution of all proposed fixtures. All new light fixtures shall be consistent with the architecture of the building. All exterior lighting shall be designed and arranged as not to direct light or glare onto adjacent properties, including the adjacent streets. Wall - mounted factures shall be directed at a 90 -degree angle directly toward the ground. All lighting shall be developed to provide a minimum of one (1) foot-candle of light coverage, in accordance with the City's Security Ordinance. A note shall be provided on the plans that "All parking areas shall be illuminated with a minimum of one (1) foot-candle of light, and lighting shall not produce light, glare, or have a - - negative impact on adjacent properties." • Cross-section details showing the installation of the proposed rooftop equipment. Rooftop equipment shall be installed and maintained so as not to be visible from the public right-of-way. An elevation showing rooftop equipment Installation related to the height of the parapet and proposed equipment must be identified at plan check submittal and all equipment must be six Resolution 3953 DR 04-006 Page 5 (6) inches below the top of the parapet, subject to the approval of the Community Development Director. • Noise attenuation features as required by Conditions 14.1 through 14.3 of this Resolution. • Note on plans that no field changes shall be made without prior approval from the Building Official and architect or engineer of record. (1) 3.3 Sufficiently sized concrete pad in front of mailbox structures shall be provided to allow mail carrier to place mail and homeowner to retrieve mail without standing in the street or landscape area. (3) 3.4 Vehicle parking, primary entrance to the pool and recreational building, the primary path of travel, sanitary facilities, drinking fountains, and public telephones shall be accessible to persons with disabilities as per State of California Accessibility Standards (Title 24). Parking for disabled persons shall be provided with an additional five (5) foot loading area with striping and ramp; disabled persons shall be able to park and access the building without passing behind another car. At least one (1) accessible space shall be van accessible served by a minimum 96 inch wide loading area. (3) 3.5 Prior to issuance of any permit, Irvine Ranch Water District (IRWD) intent to serve and approval of the water/ sewer plans are required. (3) 3.6 Two (2) exits are required from the third floor of residential occupancy when, the floor area of the third floor exceeds 500 square feet. (3) 3.7 Provide area analysis for all buildings (residences and garages), and show compliance with allowable floor areas based on 2001 California Building Code Chapter 5, Table 5-B. (3) 3.8 Escape or rescue windows shall be provided in all sleeping rooms, in accordance with the 2001 California Building Code (Section 310.4). (3) 3.9 Dwelling units shall be provided with heating facilities capable of maintaining a temperature of 70 degrees at a point three (3) feet above the floor in all habitable rooms in accordance with the 2001 California Building Code (Section 310.11). (1) 3.10 The clear and unobstructed interior garage dimensions for each parking space shall be a minimum of nine (9) feet in width and twenty (20) feet in length and shall be shown on the plans. (4) 3.11 Information to ensure compliance with requirements of the Orange County f=ire Authority shall be submitted including fire flow and installation of fire hydrants subject to approval of the City of Tustin Public Works and/or Irvine Ranch Water District. Resolution 3853 DR 04-006 Page 6 (1) 3.12 No structures shall be permitted to be developed over active pipelines, abandoned lines, or utility easements, except where approved by the City Engineer and/or Building Official. (1) 3.13 Footings for all retaining walls shall be located within the tract boundary. (1) 3.14 If determined feasible by the Building Official, the applicant shall implement one or more of the following control measures, if not already required by the SCAQMD under Rule 403 during construction as follows: a) Apply water twice daily, or chemical soil stabilizers according to manufacturers' specifications, to all unpaved parking or staging areas or unpaved road surfaces at all actively disturbed sites. b) Develop a construction traffic management plan that includes, but is not limited to, rerouting construction trucks off congested streets, consolidating truck deliveries, and providing dedicated tum lanes for movement of construction trucks and equipment on-site and off-site. c) Use electricity from power poles rather than temporary diesel or gasoline -powered generators. ® d) Reduce traffic speeds on all unpaved roads to 15 mph or less. e) Pave construction roads that have a traffic volume of more than 50 daily trips by construction equipment or 150 total daily trips for all vehicles. f) Apply approved chemical soil stabilizers according to manufacturers' specifications to all inactive construction areas (previously graded areas inactive for four days or more). g) Enclose, cover, water twice daily, or apply approved soil binders according to manufacturers' specifications to exposed piles of gravel, sand, or dirt. h) Cover all trucks hauling dirt, sand, soil, or other loose materials, and maintain at least two (2) feet of freeboard (i.e., minimum vertical distance between top of the load and top of the trailer). i) Sweep streets at the end of the day if visible soil material is carried over to adjacent roads (use water sweepers with reclaimed water when feasible). j) Install wheel washers where vehicles enter and exit unpaved roads onto paved roads or wash off trucks and any equipment leaving the site each trip. k) Use low VOC architectural coatings for all interior and exterior painting operations. Resolution 3953 DR 04-006 Page 7 3.15 According to the submitted report the water table is as low as eight (8) feet in some areas. Units with basements or grade difference that would be affected by the water table shall require special construction techniques subject to review and approval of the Community Development Department. (1) 3.16 Add notes that all utilities placed under private streets are located a minimum of 36 inches below grade and revise street cross sections accordingly. PUBLIC/PRIVATE INFRASTRUCTURE IMPROVEMENTS (1) 4.1 All conditions of Resolution No. 3952 related to private on-site infrastructure shall be implemented. WATER QUALITY (1) 5.1 The applicant shall comply with the following conditions pertaining to the requirement for a Water Quality Management Plan: A. Prior to issuance of any permit, the applicant shall submit for - approval by the Community Development and Public Works Departments, a Water Quality Management Plan (WQMP) specifically identifying Best Management Practices (BMPs) that will be used on-site to control predictable pollutant run-off. This WQMP shall Identify the structural and non-structural measures specified detailing implementation of BMPs whenever they are applicable to the project; the assignment of long-term maintenance responsibilities (specifying the developer, parcel owner, maintenance association, lessee, etc.); and, reference to the location(s) of structural BMPs. B. Prior to submittal of a Water Quality Management Plan (WQMP), the applicant shall submit a deposit of $5,000.00 for the estimated cost of review of the WQMP to the Building Division. The actual costs shall be deducted from the deposit, and the applicant shall be responsible for any additional review cost that exceeded the deposit prior to issuance of grading permits. Any unused portion of the deposit shall be refunded to the applicant. C. Prior to issuance of any permits, the property owner shall record a Notice of Water Quality Management Plan (WQMP) with the County Clerk Recorder on a form provided by the Community Development Department to inform future property owners of the requirement to implement the approved WQMP. Resolution 3953 DR 04.006 Page 8 D. The Community Development and Public Works Departments shall determine whether any change in use requires an amendment to an approved Water Quality Management Plan. (1) 5.2 Prior to issuance of grading permits, the applicant shall submit a copy of the Notice of Intent (NOI) indicating that coverage has been obtained under the National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) State General Permit for Storm. Water Discharges Associated with Construction Activity from the State Water Resources Control Board. Evidence that the NOI has been obtained shall be submitted to the Building Official. In addition, the applicant shall include notes on the grading plans indicating that the project will be implemented in compliance with the Statewide Permit for General Construction Activities. (1) 5.3 The following requirements shall be defined on permit plan cover sheets as either general or special notes and the project shall be implemented in accordance with the notes: A. Construction sites shall be maintained in such a condition that an anticipated storm does not carry wastes or pollutants off the site. �► B. Discharges of material other than stormwater are allowed only when necessary for performance and completion of construction practices and where they do not cause or contribute to a violation of any water quality standard; cause or threaten to cause pollution, contamination, or nuisance; or, contain a hazardous substance in a quantity reportable under Federal Regulations 40 CFR Parts 117 and 302. C. Potential pollutants include, but are not limited to, solid or liquid chemical spills; wastes from paints, stains, sealants, glues, limes, pesticides, herbicides, wood preservatives, and solvents; asbestos fibers, paint flake or stucco fragments; fuels, oils, lubricants, and hydraulic, radiator or battery fluids; fertilizers, vehicle/equipment wash water and concrete wash water, concrete, detergent or floatable wastes; wastes from any engine equipment steam cleaning or chemical degreasing; and chlorinated potable water line flushing. During construction, disposal of such materials shall occur in a specified and controlled temporary area on-site, physically separated from potential storm water run-off, with ultimate disposal in accordance with local, State, and Federal requirements. D. Dewatering of contaminated groundwater or discharging contaminated soils via surface erosion is prohibited. Resolution 3953 DR 04-006 Page 9 Dewatering of non -contaminated groundwater requires a National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System Permit from the California State Regional Water Quality Control Board. MODEL HOME PLAN AND CONSTRUCTION PHASING (1) 6.1 A site plan, street improvement plan, and striping plan for the model home complex shall be submitted as one submittal for all product models for review and approval of the Community Development Department, in accordance with the phasing requirements for the project contained within Resolution 3952. All required improvements for streets, landscaping, ADA compliance, emergency access, security lighting, etc. shall be installed prior to final inspection for the model homes and the sales office. (1) 6.2 Temporary construction fencing shall be permitted to encroach into required travelways of private streets or drives once constructed and shall be removed prior to issuance of Certificate of Occupancy for the model homes. (1) 6.3 The developer shall close and convert the model homes to occupancy within 90 days from the last home sale of the same style home. Prior to issuance of building permits for the model homes, the developer shall submit a bond to ensure the conversion. ARCHITECTURE (1) 7.1 All carriage way product shall meet the development standards adopted by Resolution No. 3950. (1) 7.2 Architectural elevations of the Carriage way product shall be revised to incorporate a cohesive architectural style and adequate articulation on the side and rear elevations subject to review and approval of the Community Development Department. (4) 7.3 Building elevations visible from Edinger Avenue, West Connector Road, and Valencia North Loop Road shall be designed in accordance with the Urban Design Guidelines contained in the MCAS Tustin Specific Pian with respect to mass, variety of color and material, architectural articulation in form of off sets, pop -outs, overhangs, window trim, fascia molding, planter boxes, etc. to the satisfaction of the Community Development Department. (4) 7.4 The design of the recreational building shall incorporate the character defining features of the residential products within the subdivision subject to review and approval by the Community Development Department. Resolution 3953 DR 04006 Page 10 (4) 7.5 Window trims, surrounds, and mullions shall be provided on all elevations consistent with the architectural treatment and of the buildings subject to final approval of the Community Development Department. (4) 7.6 All roof materials shall be subject to final approval by the Community Development Department. (4) 7.7 All exterior doors and windows, glass, and frame color shall be subject to final approval of the Community Development Department. (4) 7.8 All exterior colors and textures shall be submitted to review and approval of the Community Development Department. Colors, materials, and textures shall be coordinated with the architectural styles and noted in construction plans. (4) 7.9 All mechanical and electrical fixtures and equipment shall be adequately and decoratively screened. The screen shall be included as an element of the overall design of the project and blend with architectural design of the building. All telephone and electrical boxes shall be identified on the construction plans. Electrical transformers shall be located toward the interior of the project to minimize visual impacts from Harvard Avenue and Moffett Avenue screened by adequate landscaping or other effective screening devices. (1) 7.10 All portions of the first, second, and third floor living areas of the multiple family products shall be located a minimum of five (5) feet from the private drives. LANDSCAPING/HARDSCAPE (1) 8.1 Submit at plan check complete detailed landscaping and irrigation plans for all landscaping areas, including the model complex, consistent with adopted City of Tustin Landscaping requirements. The plans shall include the following: • Include a summary table identifying plan materials. The plant table shall list botanical and common names, sizes, spacing, location, and quantity of the plant materials proposed. ■ Show planting and berming details, soil preparation, staking, etc. The irrigation plan shall show location and control of backflow prevention devices, pipe size, sprinkler type, spacing, and coverage. Details for all equipment must be provided. Resolution 3953 DR 04-006 Page 11 (1) ■ Show all property lines on the landscaping and irrigation plans, public right-of-way areas, sidewalk widths, parkway areas, and wall locations. ■ The Community Development Department may request minor substitutions of plant materials or request additional sizing or quantity of materials during plan check. ■ Add a note that coverage of landscaping and irrigation materials is subject to inspection at project completion by the Community Development Department. • Turf is unacceptable for grades over 25 percent. A combination of planting materials shall be used. On large areas, ground cover alone is not acceptable. ■ Shrubs shall be a minimum of five (5) gallon size and shall be placed a maximum of five (5) feet on center. ■ Ground cover shall be planted eight (8) to twelve (12) inches on center. ■ Fences, wall, and equipment areas shall be screened with walls, vines, and/or trees. ■ All plant materials shall be installed in a healthy vigorous condition typical to the species and shall be maintained in a neat and healthy condition. Maintenance includes, but is not limited to, trimming, weeding, removal of litter, fertilizing, regular watering, and replacement of diseased or dead plants. ■ Major points of entry to the project, private streets, and private drives and Internal circulation shall receive specimen trees to create an identifying theme. ■ Landscape adjacent to the right-of-way shall be in compliance with the requirements of MCAS Tustin Specific Plan. Perimeter walls should be treated with vines to relieve large expanse walls with greenery and color. Vines shall be Informally grouped and installed with training devices. 8.2 An opaque screen consisting of one or a combination of berms, masonry walls, and landscaping Integrated into an aesthetic pattern shall be installed along site boundaries where residential uses abut arterial or secondary highways, with the aggregate height of berms and walls not to exceed six (6) feet, eight (8) inches, or higher as may be required and approved to mitigate noise impacts. Screening Resolution 3953 DR 04.006 Page 12 - shall consist of one or any combination of the following components: • Walls, including retaining walls, shall consist of concrete, stone, brick, tile, or similar masonry material. • Berms shall be constructed of earthen materials and shall be landscaped according to an approved plan. • Evergreen or deciduous trees or shrubs consistent with landscape guidelines contained in the Specific Plan. Trees shall vary in size (minimum 24 -inch box) and species to provide smaller broad dome trees and upright vertical trees along the street right-of-ways consistent with the requirements of the Urban Design Guidelines Section 2.17 of MCAS Tustin Specific Plan and subject to final approval of the Community Development Department. • Landscaping/screening at intersections shall be designed and maintained to not restrict vehicular sight distance in accordance with the current City of Tustin and Irvine standards. (4) 8.3 On-site walls and fences shall be noted on the plans with specific materials, colors, and decorative treatments. Interior wall/fences shall be made of durable materials subject to review and approval of the Community Development Department. (4) 8.4 Major points of entry to the project, private streets, and private drives and internal circulation shall receive specimen trees to create an identifying theme. (4y 8.5 Perimeter tract walls shall be constructed of high quality materials and matching architecture subject to final approval of the Community Development Department. (4) 8.6 The main entries to the project at West Connector Road and Valencia North Loop Road shall Include hardscape treatments that are consistent with Section 2.17 of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan and shall be subject to final approval of the Community Development Department. (1) 8.7 Trees in the landscape setbacks adjacent to public rights-of-way shall be provided in a variety of sizes to ensure initial maturity along project perimeter. (1) 8.8 A portal design for the intersection of Edinger Avenue and West shall be provided for review and approval of the Community Development Department and installed by the applicant. Resolution 3953 DR 04-006 Page 13 USE RESTRICTIONS (5) 9.1 The project shall include 1,077 units, including 84 Single Family Detached (SFD), 181 Carriage Way SFD, 72 condominium units (Senior Housing) for a total of 337 units at an average density of 8.62 du/acre in Planning Area 4 (Parcel 23) and 570 condominium units (Multiple Family Residential), and 170 condominium units (Senior Housing) for a total of 740 units at an Average density 17.53 du/acre for Planning Area 5 (Parcel 24) of the MCAS -Tustin Specific Plan with 266 on-site units (241 required and 25 transferred from Planning Area 21) required to be offered as affordable units, as identified in Condition 10.1. (1) 9.2 A separate "Private Open Space Exhibit" shall be submitted at plan check. Any changes to the allocation of private open space Identified on the site plan shall be reviewed and approved by the Director of Community Development. (4) 9.3 Parallel guest parking spaces, guest parking stalls, and driveway parking spaces shall be maintained as shown on the approved "Parking and Circulation Exhibit." Any changes to the number, location, or size of parking spaces shall be reviewed and approved --- by the Director of Community Development. (5) 9.5 Individual trash can service may be provided on the site. Trashcans shall be placed only in the locations identified on the approved "Curbside Trash Pick-up Exhibit' up to twelve (12) hours prior to regularly scheduled trash collection and shall be removed within twelve (12) hours of trash collection. (1) 9.6 No outdoor storage shall be permitted during grading or building stages, except as approved by the Tustin Community Development Director. (1) 9.7 During construction, permission from adjacent property owners shall be required for any work located on adjacent properties. AFFORDABLE HOUSING (1) 10.1 The subdivider shall comply with the obligations contained in Resolution No. 3952 regarding affordable housing units. SENIOR HOUSING PROJECT (') 11.1 The senior housing shown on the tentative tract map is provided for general location and number of units purposes and does not represent final City approval except that 153 affordable units shall be provided at this site including 36 Very Low, 61 Low, and 56 Moderate Income units. A design review application for the senior Resolution 3953 DR 04-006 Page 14 — housing including a site plan delineating adequate access non - intrusive to low density residential units, adequate parking, landscaping, fire access, architectural floor plans, elevations, materials and colors for the housing units and the recreational building, and a phasing plan for the construction of the affordable units along with the market rate units shall be submitted and approved prior to Issuance of building permits for the first production unit of the entire Columbus Square project. A production unit is defined as a unit included in phase I and subsequent phases of the Phasing Plan (not including initial phase or model homes). Any deviation from the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan parking standards for the senior housing would require approval of a conditional use permit which would include submittal of a parking analysis that would justify reduction in number of required parking spaces, subject to review and approval of the City's traffic engineer. If the developer is not able to justify the reduction in parking and/or the conditional use permit is not approved, the developer agrees to a proportionate reduction in the number of units. Except in no case, shall the number of affordable units approved herein be reduced. Prior to issuance of the 420"' building permit for the production units of the entire Columbus Square project, building permits for the senior housing shall have been issued and the first footing inspection for the senior housing shall have been completed. In addition, construction of the recreation building and park facilities shall be completed prior to the issuance of the 420th building permit (50% of non -restricted). (1) - 11.2 The design,. massing, and color/materials of the senior housing project shall be of high quality construction and compatible with other products within Columbus Square to minimize the institutional appearance of this product. ORANGE COUNTY FIRE AUTHORITY (5) 12.1 Prior to the issuance of any grading or building permits, the applicant shall submit a Fire Master Plan to the Fire Chief for review and approval. This plan submittal shall include fire department access, fire hydrants, fire lane markings, water availability for fire flow reports, blue reflective pavement markers, and laddering exhibits for rescue windows on multi -story dwelling units. (5) 12.2 Prior to the issuance of a building permit, the applicant shall submit plans for any required automatic fire sprinkler system in any structure larger than 5,500 square feet, multi -family housing or dwellings that do not meet fire department access to the Fire Chief for review and approval. Resolution 3953 DR 04006 Page 15 (5) 12.3 Prior to the issuance of a building permit for combustible construction, the builder shall submit a letter on company letterhead stating that water for fire -fighting purposes and all-weather fire protection access roads shall be in place and operational before any combustible material is placed on site. Building permits will not be issued without OCFA approval obtained as a result of an on-site inspection. Please contact the OCFA at (714) 573-6100 to obtain a copy of the standard combustible construction letter. (5) 12.4 Prior to the issuance of a building permit, the applicant shall submit architectural plans for the review and approval of the Fire Chief if required per the "Orange County Fire Authority Plan Submittal Criteria Form." Please contact the OCFA at (714) 573-6100 for a copy of the Site/Architectural Notes to be placed on the plans prior to submittal. (5) 12.5 Prior to the. issuance of a building permit, plans for the fire alarm system shall be submitted to the Fire Chief for review and approval. The requirement for fire alarms applies to Group R Division 1 occupancies as defined by the 2001 California Fire Code; when a building is at least three stories in height and contains 16 or more dwelling units. The requirement for fire sprinkler monitoring applies to a structure when it contains 100 or more fire sprinkler heads. NOISE (1) 13.1 Plans for noise attenuation of residential units located near arterial highways, which ensure that interior and exterior noise levels (including balconies) do not exceed State and local requirements of the City of Tustin shall be submitted for review and approval prior to Issuance of building permit or recordation of the final map, whichever occurs first. (1) 13.2 In accordance with the noise analysis, all units along Edinger Avenue, West Connector Road, and Valencia North Loop Road that are required to include air conditioning units to achieve the minimum interior noise level standards shall have these units installed prior to issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy. Prior to final inspection and issuance of certificates of use and occupancy, the developer shall provide an independent noise analysis verifying that interior noise levels comply with Title 25 and City noise requirements. (1) 13.3 The applicant shall submit additional information to the City showing the construction details, materials and finish, and height of the proposed sound walls along Edinger Avenue for review and approval of Community Development Director. Resolution 3953 DR 04-006 Page 16 -- ENVIRONMENTAL (1) 14.1 Additional measures related to development of this project as noted in the adopted EIS/EIR and are not previously identified in this exhibit as a condition of approval are required as follows: A. The developer shall enter into an agreement with the City of Tustin to establish a fair -share mechanism to provide needed Tustin Legacy Backbone Infrastructure program. B. Prior to issuance of any permits, the developer shall retain a County -certified archaeologist. If buried resources are found during grading within the reuse plan area, a qualified archaeologist would need to assess the site significance and perform the appropriate mitigation. The Native American viewpoint shall be considered during this process. This could include testing or data recovery. Native American consultation shall also be initiated during this process. C. The developer shall comply with the requirements established in a Palentological Resource Management Plan (PRMP) prepared for the site, which details the methods to be used for surveillance of construction grading, assessing finds, and actions to be taken in the event that unique paleontological resources are found. D. Prior to the issuance of any permit, the applicant shall provide written evidence to the Community Development Department that a County -certified paleontologist has been retained to conduct salvage excavation of unique paleontological resources if they are found. E. Prior to issuance of any permit, the developer shall provide traffic operations and control plans that would minimize the traffic impacts of proposed construction activity. The plans shall address roadway and lane closures, truck hours and routes, and notification procedures for planned short-term or interim changes in traffic patterns. Such plans shall minimize anticipated delays at major intersections. Prior to approval, the City of Tustin or the City of Irvine, as applicable, shall review the proposed traffic control and operations plans with any affected jurisdiction. FEES (1)(5) 15.1 Prior to issuance of any building permits, payment shall be made of all applicable fees, including but not limited to, the following. Payment shall be required based upon those rates in effect at the time of payment and are subject to change. Resolution 3953 DR 04-006 Page 17 a. Building plan check and permit fees to the Community Development Department based on the most current schedule at the time of permit issuance. b. Engineering plan check and permit fees to the Public Works Department based on the most current schedule at the time of permit issuance. C. Orange County Fire Authority plan check and inspection fees to the Community Development Department based upon the most current schedule at the time of permit issuance. d. Major Thoroughfare and Bridge Fees to the Tustin Public Works Department based on the most current schedule at the time of permit issuance. The current fee is $2,910 per single-family unit and $1,694 per multiple family unit. e. Transportation System Improvement Program (TSIP), Benefit Area "B" fees in the amount of $3.31 per square foot of new or added gross square floor area of construction or improvements to the Community Development Department. f. Water and sewer connection fees to the Irvine Ranch Water District. g. New development tax is $350.00 per unit. h. School facilities fee in the amount as required by Tustin Unified School District. Other applicable parkland in -lieu fees and Tustin Legacy Backbone Infrastructure Program fees as required by Resolution No. 3952. (1) 15.2 Within forty-eight (48) hours of final approval of the project, the applicant shall deliver to the Community Development Department, a CASHIER'S CHECK payable to the County Clerk in the amount of forty-three dollars ($43.00) to enable the City to file the appropriate environmental documentation for the project. If within such forty-eight (48) hour period that applicant has not delivered to the Community Development Department the above -noted check, the statute of limitations for any interested party to challenge the environmental determination under the provisions of the California Environmental Quality Act could be significantly lengthened. RESOLUTION NO. 4014 A RESOLUTION OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF TUSTIN APPROVING DESIGN REVIEW 05-019 AND CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT 05-037 AUTHORIZING THE DEVELOPMENT OF A 240 SENIOR RESIDENTIAL PROJECT WITH A NEW PARKING STANDARD OF 1.7 PARKING SPACE PER UNIT ON A NINE (9) - ACRE SITE BOUNDED BY EDINGER AVENUE ON THE NORTH, THE FIRE STATION SITE AND WEST CONNECTOR ROAD ON THE EAST, AND OTHER RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT ON THE WEST AND SOUTH WITHIN PLANNING AREA 4 AND PLANNING AREA 5 OF THE MCAS TUSTIN SPECIFIC PLAN (PARCEL 265 OF TRACT 16581) The Planning Commission of the City of Tustin does hereby resolve as follows: 1. The Planning Commission finds and determines as follows: A. That a proper application for Design Review 05-019 and Conditional Use Permit 05-037 was submitted by Lennar Homes for development of a 240 unit senior housing project with a new parking ratio of 1.7 parking spaces per unit for a nine (9) acre site within Columbus Square within Planning Area 4 and Planning Area 5 of the MCAS -Tustin Specific Plan (Lot 265 of Tract 16581); B. That a public hearing was duly called, noticed, and held for said Imw application on January 23, 2006, by the Planning Commission; C. That the site is located within Tract 16581 previously approved for development of 1,077 residential units including 242 senior housing units within Planning Areas 4 and 5 of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan, which is designated for Low Density Residential and Medium Density Residential; D. That the Columbus Square project included 266 affordable units including 153 affordable housing units (36 Very Low, 61 Low, and 56 Moderate Income units) in the senior housing project as required by Resolution No. 05-40 for approval of Tentative Tract Map 16581; E. In accordance with Condition 2.2 of Resolution No. 05-40 for approval of Tentative Tract Map 16581, a design review and conditional use permit application for site/architectural design and the parking standard for the senior housing project was submitted; F. Pursuant to the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan and Section 9272 of the Tustin Municipal Code, the Planning Commission finds that the location, size, architectural features, and general appearance of the Resolution 4014 DR 05-019, CUP 05-037 Page 2 proposed development will not impair the orderly and harmonious development of the area; the present or future development therein, or the occupancy as a whole. In making such findings, the Commission has considered at least the following items: 1. Height, bulk, and area of buildings. 2. Setbacks and site planning. 3. Exterior materials and colors. 4. Type and pitch of roofs. 5. Size and spacing of windows, doors, and other openings. 6. Towers, chimneys, roof stnx:tures, flagpoles, radio and television antennae. 7. Location, height, and standards of exterior illumination. 8. Landscaping, parking area design, and traffic circulation. 9. Location and appearance of equipment located outside an enclosed structure. 10. Location and method of refuse storage. 11. Physical relationship of proposed structures to existing structures in the neighborhood. 12. Appearance and design relationship of proposed structures to existing structures and possible future structures in the neighborhood and public thoroughfares. — 13. Proposed signage. 14. Development Guidelines and criteria as adopted by the City Council. . E. That the proposed parking ratio of 1.7 parking space per unit for senior housing development will not be detrimental to the health, safety, morals, comfort, or general welfare of the persons residing or working in the neighborhood, nor be injurious or detrimental to the property and improvements in the neighborhood of the subject property, or to the general welfare of the City of Tustin, in that: 1. in accordance with the submitted parking study affordable senior housing projects have lower parking demand in comparison with the family housing and market rate units that can be accommodated with the proposed 1.7 parking spaces per unit. 2. The Traffic Engineer has determined that the parking analysis contains sufficient technical data to support the conclusion that the proposed parking supply is adequate to serve the proposed development. r-- 3. The proposed ratio of 1.7 parking space per unit was considered to be consistent with the recommendations of the Resolution 4014 DR 05-019, CUP 05-037 Page 3 Urban Land Institute (ULI) and exceeds the recommended ratio by the Institute of Transportation Engineers (ITE). F. On January 16, 2001, the City of Tustin certified the Program Final Environmental Impact Statement/Environmental Impact Report for the Reuse and Disposal of MCAS Tustin (FEIS/EIR). In addition, the City Council certified a separate environmental check list for the Columbus Square project with approval of Tentative Tract Map 16581 which considered the senior housing site and noted that no additional impacts were. anticipated. II. The Planning Commission hereby approves Design Review 05-019 and Conditional Use Permit 05-037 for development of a 240 unit senior housing project on a nine (9) acre site and establish parking standards within Planning Area 4 and Planning Area 5 of the MCAS -Tustin Specific Pian (Lot 265 of Tract 16581), subject to the conditions contained in Exhibit A attached hereto. PASSED AND ADOPTED at a regular meeting of the Tustin Planning Commission held on the 23rd day of January, 2006. JO NI LSEN Chairperson Gju , ELIZABETH A. BINSACK Planning Commission Secretary STATE OF CALIFORNIA ) COUNTY OF ORANGE ) CITY OF TUSTIN ) I, ELIZABETH A. BINSACK, the undersigned, hereby certify that I am the Planning Commission Secretary of the Planning Commission of the City of Tustin, California; that Resolution No. 4014 duly passed and adopted at a regular meeting of the Tustin Planning Commission, held on the 23rd day of January, 2006. ELIZABETH A. BINSACK Planning Commission Secretary EXHIBIT A DESIGN REVIEW 05-019 AND CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT 05-037 RESOLUTION NO. 4014 CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL GENERAL The proposed project shall conform with the Tustin City Code and Tustin guidelines and standards and be consistent with submitted plans for the project date stamped January 23, 2006, on file with the Community Development Department, except as herein modified, or as modified by the Director of Community Development in accordance with this Exhibit. The Director of Community Development may also approve minor modifications to plans during plan check if such modifications are consistent with the provisions of the Tustin City Code, and other applicable codes. (1) 1.2 Unless otherwise specified, the conditions contained in this Exhibit shall be complied with as specified or prior to the issuance of any building permits for the project, subject to review and approval by the Community Development Department. (1) 1.3 The subject project approval shall become null and void unless permits for the proposed project are issued and substantial construction is underway within 24 months. All time extensions may be considered if a written request is received within thirty (30) days prior to expiration date. s (1) 1.4 Approval of Design Review 05-019 and Conditional Use Permit 05037 is contingent upon the applicant returning to the Community Development Department a notarized "Agreement to Conditions Imposed" form and the property owner signing and recording with the County Clerk -Recorder a notarized "Notice of Discretionary Permit Approval and Conditions of Approval" form. The forms shall be established by the Director of Community Development, and evidence of recordation shall be provided to the Community Development Department. (1) 1.5 As a condition of approval of Design Review 05-019 and Conditional Use Permit 05-037, the applicant shall agree, at its sole cost and. expense, to defend, indemnify, and hold harmless the City, its officers, employees, agents, and consultants, from any claim, action, or proceeding brought by a third party against the City, its officers, agents, and employees, which seeks to attack, set aside, challenge, void, or annul an approval of the City Council, the Planning Commission, or any other decision-making body, including staff, concerning this project. The City agrees to promptly notify SOURCE CODES (1) STANDARD CONDITION (5) RESPONSIBLE AGENCY REQUIREMENT (2) CEGA MITIGATION (6) LANDSCAPING GUIDELINES (3) UNIFORM BUILDING CODES (7) PC/CC POLICY (4) DESIGN REVIEW "' EXCEPTION Resolution 4014 DR 05-019, CUP 05-037 Page 2 the applicant of any such claim or action filed against the City and to fully cooperate in the defense of any such action. The City may, at its sole cost and expense, elect to participate in defense of any such action under this condition. (•) 1.6 As required by ' Resolution No. 05-40, prior to issuance of the 42011' building permit for the production units of the entire Columbus Square project, building permits for the senior housing shall have been issued and the first footing inspection for the senior housing shall have been completed. ") 1.7 All conditions of Resolution No. 05-40 related to private on-site infrastructure shall be Implemented. (") 1.8 The "Affordable Housing Plan and Density Bonus Application" approved for the Columbus Square and Columbus Grove developments shall be amended to include the revised design and location of the affordable housing units provided in the senior housing project. GRADING PLAN SUBMITTAL (1) 2.1 Four (4) sets of final grading plans, Including a site plan, and consistent with the landscaping plans, as prepared by a registered civil engineer, shall be submitted and shall include the following: A. Technical details and plans for all utility installations including telephone, gas. water, and electricity. B. Three (3) copies of a precise soils report provided by a civil engineer and less than one (1) year old. Expanded information regarding the levels of hydrocarbons and ground water contamination found on-site shall be provided in the soil report. All pavement "R" values shall be in accordance with applicable City of Tustin standards. C. Information demonstrating that all site drainage shall be handled on-site and shall not be permitted to drain onto adjacent properties. D. Information demonstrating that drainage, vegetation, circulation, street sections, curbs, gutters, sidewalks, and storm drains shall comply with the City of Tustin's "Construction Standards for Private Streets, Storm Drain and On -Site Private Improvements," revised April 1989. E. Two (2) copies of a hydrology report. F. Information demonstrating that vehicle parking, primary entrance to the building, primary paths of travel, sanitary facilities, drinking fountain, and public telephones for the recreation building shall be accessible to persons with disabilities. G. Building and landscape setback dimensions and dimensions for all drive aisles, back up areas, each covered parking stall, and open parking stalls. Resolution 4014 DR 05-019, CUP 05-037 Page 3 (1) 2.2 The engineer of record must submit a final compaction report to the Building Division for review and approval prior to the issuance of a building permit. (1) 2.3 The engineer of record must submit a pad certification to the Building Division for review and approval prior to the issuance of a building permit. (1) 2.4 Prior to issuance of a grading permit, the applicant shall be required to provide a performance bond to assure grading work is completed in accordance with approved plans. The engineer's estimated cost shall be submitted to the Building Official for determination of the bond amount. (1) 2.5 A note shall be provided on the final plans indicating that a six (6) foot high chain link fence shall be installed around the site prior to grading. A nylon fabric or mesh shall be attached to the temporary construction fencing. Gated entrances shall be permitted along the perimeter of the site for construction vehicles. BUILDING PLAN SUBMITTAL (3) 3.1 At the time of building permit application, the plans shall comply with the --- 2001 California Building Code (CBC), 2001 California Mechanical Code (CMC), 2001 California Plumbing Codes (CPC), 2001 California Electrical Code (CEC), California Title 24 Accessibility Regulations, Title 24 Energy Regulations, City Ordinances, and State and Federal laws and regulations. (3) 3.2 Building plan check submittal shall include the following: • Seven (7) sets of construction plans, including drawings for mechanical, plumbing, and electrical. • Structural calculations, two (2) copies. • Title 24 energy calculations, two (2) copies. • Elevations that include all proposed dimensions, materials, colors, finishes, and partial outlines of adjacent buildings on-site and off-site where applicable • Details for the proposed windows and doors. • Roofing material shall be fire rated class "B" or better. • The location of any utility vents or other equipment shall be provided. on the roof plan. • Details of all proposed lighting fixtures and a photometric study showing the location and anticipated pattern of light distribution of all proposed fixtures. All new light fixtures shall be consistent with the architecture of the building. All exterior lighting shall be designed and _ arranged as not to direct light or glare onto adjacent properties, including the adjacent streets. Wall- mounted fixtures shall be directed at a 90 -degree angle directly toward the ground. All lighting shall be Resolution 4014 DR 05-019, CUP 05-037 Page 4 developed to provide a minimum of one (1) foot-candle of light coverage, in accordance with the City's Security Ordinance. A note shall be provided on the plans that "All parking areas shall be illuminated with a minimum of one (1) foot-candle of light, and lighting shall not produce light, glare, or have a negative impact on adjacent properties." Cross-section details showing the installation of the proposed rooftop equipment. Rooftop equipment shall be installed and maintained so as not to be visible from the public right-of-way. An elevation showing rooftop equipment installation related to the height of the parapet and proposed equipment must be Identified at plan check submittal and all equipment must be six (6) inches below the top of the parapet, subject to the approval of the Community Development Director. Noise attenuation features as required by Conditions 14.1 through 14.3 of this Resolution. Note on plans that no field changes shall be made without prior approval from the Building Official and architect or engineer of record. (1) 3.3 Sufficiently sized concrete pad in front of mailbox structures shall be provided to allow mail carrier to place mail and homeowner to retrieve mail without standing in the street or landscape area. (3) 3.4 Vehicle parking, primary entrance to the pool and recreational building, the t primary path of travel, sanitary facilities, drinking fountains, and public w telephones shall be accessible to persons with disabilities as per State of California Accessibility Standards (Title 24). Parking for disabled persons shag be provided with an additional five (5) foot loading area with striping and ramp; disabled persons shag be able to park and access the building without passing behind another car. At least one (1) accessible space shall be van accessible served by a minimum 96 inch wide loading area. (3) 3.5 Provide area analysis for all buildings (residences and garages), and show compliance with allowable floor areas based on 2001 California Building Code Chapter 5, Table 5-B. (3) 3.6 Escape or rescue windows shall be provided in all sleeping rooms, in accordance with the 2001 California Building Code (Section 310.4). (3) 3.7 Dwelling units shall be provided with heating facilities capable of maintaining a temperature of 70 degrees at a point three (3) feet above the floor in all habitable rooms in accordance with the 2001 California Building Code (Section 310.11). (1) 3.8 The clear and unobstructed interior garage dimensions for each parking space shall be a minimum of ten (10) feet in width and twenty (20) feet in length and shall be shown on the plans. (4) 3.9 Information to ensure compliance with requirements of the Orange County Resolution 4014 DR 05-019, CUP 05-037 Page 5 Fire Authority shall be submitted including fire flow and installation of fire hydrants subject to approval of the City of Tustin Public Works and/or Irvine Ranch Water District. (1) 3.10 If determined feasible by the Building Official, the applicant shall implement one or more of the following control measures, if not already required by the SCAQMD under Rule 403 during construction as follows: a) Apply water twice daily, or chemical soil stabilizers according to manufacturers' specifications, to all unpaved parking or staging areas or unpaved road surfaces at all actively disturbed sites. b) Develop a construction traffic management plan that includes, but is not limited to, rerouting construction trucks off congested streets, consolidating truck deliveries, and providing dedicated turn lanes for movement of construction trucks and equipment on-site and off-site. c) Use electricity from power poles rather than temporary diesel or gasoline -powered generators. d) Reduce traffic speeds on all unpaved roads to 15 mph or less. e) Pave construction roads that have a traffic volume of more than 50 -- daily trips by construction equipment or 150 total daily trips for all vehicles. Q Apply approved chemical soil stabilizers according to manufacturers' specifications to all inactive construction areas (previously graded areas inactive for four days or more). g) Enclose, cover, water twice daily, or apply approved soil binders according to manufacturers' specifications to exposed piles of gravel, sand, or dirt. h) Cover all trucks hauling dirt, sand, soil, or other loose materials, and maintain at least two (2) feet of freeboard (i.e., minimum vertical distance between top of the load and top of the trailer). i) Sweep streets at the end of the day if visible soil material is carried over to adjacent roads (use water sweepers with reclaimed water when feasible). j) Install wheel washers where vehicles enter and exit unpaved roads onto paved roads or wash off trucks and any equipment leaving the site each trip. k) Use low VOC architectural coatings for all interior and exterior painting —. operations. Resolution 4014 DR 05-019, CUP 05-037 Page 6 (1) 3.11 Add notes that all utilities placed under private streets are located a minimum of 36 inches below grade and revise street cross sections accordingly. PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT (1) 4.1 A separate 24" x 36" street improvement plan, as prepared by a California Registered Civil Engineer, shall be required for all construction within the public right-of-way along Edinger Avenue and West Connector Road. Construction and/or replacement of any missing or damaged public improvements will be required adjacent to this development. Said plan shall include, but not be limited to the following: a) Curb and Gutter b) Sidewalk c) Drive aprons d) Catch basin/storm drain laterals/ connection to existing storm drain system e) Domestic water facilities f) Reclaimed water facilities - - g) Sanitary sewer facilities h) Underground utility connections 1 In addition, a 24' x 36" reproducible construction area traffic control plan, as prepared by a California Registered Traffic Engineer or Civil Engineer experienced in this type of plan preparation may be required. (1) 4.2 Preparation of plans for and construction of: a. All sanitary sewer facilities shall be submitted as required by the City Engineer and Irvine Ranch Water District b. A domestic water system shall be designed and installed to the standards of the Irvine Ranch Water District. The adequacy and reliability of the water system design and the distribution of fire hydrants shall be evaluated. The water distribution system and appurtenances shall also conform to the applicable laws and adopted regulations enforced by the Orange County Health Department. Any required reclaimed water system shall meet the standards as required by the Irvine Ranch Water District. (1) 4.3 Prior to any work in the public right-of-way, an Encroachment Permit shall be obtained from and applicable fees paid to the Public Works Department. (1) 4.4 Any damage done to existing street improvements and utilities shall be repaired before issuance of a certificate of Occupancy. Resolution 4014 DR 05-019, CUP 05-037 Page 7 (1) 4.5 A complete hydrology study and hydraulic calculations shall be submitted for review and approval by the City. (1) 4.6 in addition to the normal full size plan submittal process, all final development plans including, but not limited to: tract maps, parcel maps, right-of-way maps, records of survey, public works improvements, private infrastructure improvements, final grading plans, and site plans are also required to be submitted to the Public Works Department/Engineering Division in computer aided design and drafting (CADD) format. The standard file format is AutoCAD Release 14 or 2000 having the extension DWG. Likewise, layering and linetype conventions are AutoCAD -based (latest version available upon request from the Engineering Division). In order to interchangeably utilize the data contained in the infrastructure mapping system, CADD drawings must be in AutoCAD "DWG" format (i.e., produced using AutoCAD or AutoCAD compatible CADD software). The most current version of AutoCAD is Release 2000. Drawings created in AutoCAD Release 14 are compatible and acceptable. The CADD files shall be submitted to the City at the time the plans are approved and updated CADD files reflecting "as built" conditions shall be submitted once all construction has been completed. The subdivision bonds will not be released until the was built" CADD files have been -- submitted. (1) 4.7 This development shall comply with all applicable provisions of the City of Tustin Water Quality Ordinance and all Federal, State and Regional Water Quality Control Board rules and regulations. Multi -Family Recycling a. The Applicant, Property Owner and/or tenant(s) are required to participate in the City's recycling program. b. Prior to issuance of a building permit, a solid waste recycling plan identifying planned source separate and recycling programs shall be submitted and approved by the City of Tustin Public Works Department. WATER QUALITY (1) 5.1 The applicant shall comply with the following conditions pertaining to the requirement for a Water Quality Management Plan: A. Prior to issuance of any permit, the applicant shall submit for approval by the Community Development and Public Works Departments, a Water Quality Management Plan (WQMP) specifically identifying Best Management Practices (BMPs) that will be used on-site to control predictable pollutant run-off. This WQMP Resolution 4014 DR 05-019, CUP 05-037 Page 8 shall identify the structural and non-structural measures specified detailing implementation of BMPs whenever they are applicable to the project; the assignment of long-term maintenance responsibilities (specifying the developer, parcel owner, maintenance association, lessee, etc.); and, reference to the location(s) of structural BMPs. B. Prior to submittal of a Water Quality Management Plan (WQMP), the applicant shall submit a deposit of $5,000.00 for the estimated cost of review of the WQMP to the Building Division. The actual costs shall be deducted from the deposit, and the applicant shall be responsible for any additional review cost that exceeded the deposit prior to issuance of grading permits. Any unused portion of the deposit shall be refunded to the applicant. C. Prior to issuance of any permits, the property owner shall record a Notice of Water Quality Management Plan (WQMP) with the County Clerk Recorder on a form provided by the Community Development Department to inform future property owners of the requirement to implement the approved WQMP. - D. The Community Development and Public Works Departments shall determine whether any change in use requires an amendment to t an approved Water Quality Management Plan. .rte (1) 5.2 Prior to issuance of grading permits, the applicant shall submit a copy of the Notice of Intent (NOI) indicating that coverage has been obtained under the National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) State General Permit for Storm Water Discharges Associated with Construction Activity from the State Water Resources Control Board. Evidence that the NOI has been obtained shall be submitted to the Building Official. In addition, the applicant shall include notes on the grading plans indicating that the project will be implemented in compliance with the Statewide Permit for General Construction Activities. (1) 5.3 The following requirements shall be defined on permit plan cover sheets as either general or special notes and the project shall be implemented in accordance with the notes: A. Construction sites shall be maintained in such a condition that an anticipated storm does not cavy wastes or pollutants off the site. B. Discharges of material other than stormwater are allowed only when necessary for performance and completion of construction practices and where they do not cause or contribute to a violation of any water quality standard; cause or threaten to cause pollution, contamination, or nuisance; or, contain a hazardous substance in a quantity reportable under Federal Regulations 40 CFR Parts 117 Resolution 4014 OR 05-019, CUP 05-037 Page 9 and 302. C. Potential pollutants include, but are not limited to, solid or liquid chemical spills; wastes from paints, stains, sealants, glues, limes, pesticides, herbicides, wood preservatives, and solvents; asbestos fibers, paint flake or stucco fragments; fuels, oils, lubricants, and hydraulic, radiator or battery fluids; fertilizers, vehicle/equipment wash water and concrete wash water, concrete, detergent or floatable wastes; wastes from any engine equipment steam cleaning or chemical degreasing; and chlorinated potable water line flushing. During construction, disposal of such materials shall occur in a specified and controlled temporary area on-site, physically separated from potential storm water run-off, with ultimate disposal in accordance with local, State, and Federal requirements. D. Dewatering of contaminated groundwater or discharging contaminated soils via surface erosion is prohibited. Dewatering of non -contaminated groundwater requires a National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System Permit from the California State Regional Water Quality Control Board. -- MODEL HOME PLAN AND CONSTRUCTION PHASING (1) 6.1 A site and striping plan for the model home complex shall be submitted for the model homes site shall be submitted for review and approval of the Community Development Department. All required improvements for streets, landscaping, ADA compliance, emergency access, security lighting, etc. shall be installed prior to final inspection for the model homes and the sales office. (1) 6.2 The developer shall close and convert the model homes to occupancy within 90 days from the last home sale of the same style home. Prior to issuance of building permits for the model homes, the developer shall submit a bond to ensure the conversion. LANDSCAPING/HARDSCAPE (1) 7.1 Submit at plan check complete detailed landscaping and irrigation plans for all landscaping areas, including the model complex, consistent with adopted City of Tustin Landscaping requirements. The plans shall include the following: Include a summary table identifying plan materials. The plant table shall list botanical and common names, sizes, spacing, location, and quantity of the plant materials proposed. Resolution 4014 DR 05-019, CUP 05-037 Page 10 ■ Show planting and berming details, soil preparation, staking, etc. The irrigation plan shall show location and control of backflow prevention devices, pipe size, sprinkler type, spacing, and coverage. Details for all equipment must be provided. • Show ail property lines on the landscaping and irrigation plans, public right-of-way areas, sidewalk widths, parkway areas, and wall locations. ■ The Community Development Department may request minor substitutions of plant materials or request additional sizing or quantity of materials during plan check. • Add a note that coverage of landscaping and irrigation materials is subject to inspection at project completion by the Community Development Department. ■ Turf is unacceptable for grades over 25 percent. A combination of planting materials shall be used. On large areas, ground cover alone is not acceptable. • Shrubs shall be a minimum of five (5) gallon size and shall be { placed a maximum of five (5) feet on center. ■ Fences; wall, and equipment areas shall be screened with walls, vines, and/or trees. ■ All plant materials shall be installed in a healthy vigorous condition typical to the species and shall be maintained in a neat and healthy condition. Maintenance includes, but is not limited to, trimming, weeding, removal of litter, fertilizing, regular watering, and replacement of diseased or dead plants. ■ Landscape adjacent to the right-of-way shall be in compliance with the requirements of MCAS Tustin Specific Plan. Perimeter walls should be treated with vines to relieve large expanse walls with greenery and color. Vines shall be informally grouped and installed with training devices. (4) 7.2 On-site walls and fences shall be noted on the plans with specific materials, colors, and decorative treatments. Interior wall/fences shall be made of durable materials subject to review and approval of the Community Development Department. AFFORDABLE HOUSING (1) 8.1 The subdivider shall comply with the obligations contained in Resolution Resolution 4014 DR 05-019, CUP 05-037 Page 11 No. 05-40 regarding affordable housing units. The senior housing project shall contain a minimum of 153 affordable units including 36 Very Low, 61 Low, and 56 Moderate Income units and at locations depicted on the submitted plans approved on January 23, 2006. PARKING (*) 9.1 The approved parking ratio of 1.7 parking spaces per unit is contingent on the property remaining a condominium senior housing complex for persons of 55. years and older with 153 affordable units. A minimum of 200 one -car garage spaces and 40 carports shall be provided. The project site shall also include a minimum of 130 open guest parking stalls and 28 parallel street parking and six (6) parking spaces assigned for exclusive use of the recreation center staff for a total of 169 open parking spaces. ORANGE COUNTY FIRE AUTHORITY (5) 10.1 Prior to the issuance of any grading, the applicant shall submit a fire hydrant location plan to the Fire Chief for review and approval. (5) 10.2 Prior to the issuance of a building permit, the applicant shall submit evidence of the on-site fire hydrant system to the Fire Chief and indicate — whether it is public or private. If the system is private, it shall be reviewed and approved by the Fire Chief prior to building permit issuance, and the applicant shall make provisions for the repair and maintenance of the system in a manner meeting the approval of the Fire Chief. Please contact the OCFA at (714) 573-6100 or visit the OCFA website for a copy of the "Guidelines for Private Fire Hydrant Wor Sprinkler Underground Piping." (5) 10.3 Prior to the issuance of any certificate of occupancy, all fire hydrants shall have a blue reflective pavement marker indicating the hydrant location on the street as approved by the Fire Chief, and must be maintained in good condition by the property owner. Please contact the OCFA at (714) 573- 6100 or visit the OCFA website for a copy of the "Guideline for Installation of Blue Dot Hydrant Markers." (5) 10.4 Prior to the issuance of any grading, the applicant shall provide evidence of adequate fire flow. The "Orange County Fire Authority Water Availability for Fire Protection" form shall be signed by the applicable water district and submitted to the Fire Chief for approval. If sufficient water to meet fire flow requirements is not available an automatic fire extinguishing system may be required in each structure affected. (5) 10.5 Prior to the issuance of building permits, a note shall be placed on the plans stating that all residential structures (R-1 occupancies) and any structure exceeding 6,000 square feet (per amendment) shall be protected by an automatic fire sprinkler system in a manner meeting the approval of the Fire Chief. Resolution 4014 DR 05-019, CUP 05-037 Page 12 (5) 10.6 Prior to the issuance of a building permit, the applicant shall submit plans for any required automatic fire sprinkler system in any structure to the Fire Chief for review and approval. Please contact the OCFA at (714) 573- 6100 for additional information. (5) 10.7 Prior to the Issuance of a certificate of occupancy, this system shall be operational in a manner meeting the approval of the Fire Chief. (5) 10.8 Prior to the issuance of any grading or building permits, the applicant shall obtain approval of the Fire Chief for all fire protection access roads to within 150 feet of all portions of the exterior of every structure on site. Please contact the OCFA at (714) 573-6100 or visit the OCFA website to obtain a copy of the "Guidelines for Emergency Access, or Bulletin number 08-99, "Fire Department Access Requirements for A Single Family Residence." (5) 10.9 Prior to the issuance of a precise grading permit or building permit, the applicant shall submit and obtain approval of the Fire Chief and City Staff of plans for all public or private access roads, streets and courts. The plans shall include plan and sectional views and indicate the grade and width of the access road measured flow4ine to flow4ine. When a dead- end street exceeds 150 feet or when otherwise required, a dearly marked fire apparatus access turnaround must be provided and approved by the Fire Chief. Applicable CC&R'S or other approved documents shall contain provisions which prohibit obstructions such as speed bumps/humps, control gates or other modifications within said easement or access road unless prior approval of the Fire Chief is granted. Please contact the OCFA at (714) 573-6100 or visit the OCFA website to obtain a copy of the "Guidelines for Emergency Access." (5) 10.10 A note shall be placed on the fire protection access easement plan indicating that all street/road signs shall be designed and maintained to be either intemally or externally illuminated in a manner meeting approval of the Fire Chief. (5) 10.11 Prior to the issuance of any grading or building permits, the applicant shall submit plans and obtain approval from the Fire Chief for fire lanes on required fire access roads less than 36 feet in width. The plans shall indicate the locations of red curbs and signage and include a detail of the proposed signage including the height, stroke and colors of the lettering and its contrasting background. Please contact the OCFA at (714) 573- 6100 or visit the OCFA website to obtain a copy of the "Guidelines for Emergency Access Roadways and Fire Lane Requirements," or Bulletin 06-99, "Fire Lane Requirements on Private & Public Streets Within Residential Developments." Resolution 4014 DR 05-019, CUP 05-037 Page 13 (5) 10.12 Prior to the issuance of any certificate of occupancy, the fire lanes shall be installed in accordance with the approved fire lane plan. The CC&R'S or other approved documents shall contain a fire lane map, provisions ` prohibiting parking in the fire lanes, and an enforcement method. (5) 10.13 Prior to the issuance of any grading permits, the applicant shall obtain the approval from the Fire Chief for the construction of any gate across required fire department access roads. Please contact the OCFA at (714) 573-6100 or visit the OCFA website to obtain a copy of the "Guidelines for Design and Installation of Emergency Access Gates and Barriers." (5) 10.14 Prior to the issuance of a building permit for combustible construction, the builder shall submit a letter on company letterhead stating that water for fire -fighting purposes and all-weather fire protection access roads shall be in place and operational before any combustible material is placed on site. Building permits will not be issued without OCFA approval obtained as a result of an on-site inspection. Please contact the OCFA at (714) 573- 6100 to obtain a copy of the standard combustible construction letter. (5) 10.15 Prior to the issuance of a building permit, the applicant shall submit architectural plans for the review and approval of the Fire Chief if required per the "Orange County Fire Authority Plan Submittal Criteria Form." r-- Please contact the OCFA at (714) 573-6100 for a copy of the Site/Architectural Notes to be placed on the plans prior to submittal. (5) 10.16 Prior to the issuance of a building permit, plans for the fire alarm system shall be submitted to the Fire Chief for review and approval. Please contact the OCFA at (714) 573-6100 or visit the OCFA website to obtain a copy of the "Guideline for New and Existing Fire Alarm Systems." (5) 10.17 This system shall be operational prior to the issuance of a certificate of occupancy. NOISE (1) 11.1 Noise attenuation measures as recommended by the noise analysis shall be included with the construction drawings for plan check, which ensure a minimum outdoor -indoor transmission Gass (OITC) of 37. The interior and exterior noise levels (including balconies of six feet in width) shall comply with City of Tustin noise requirements. (1) 11.2 in accordance with the noise analysis, all units are required to include air conditioning units or fresh air intake systems to achieve the minimum interior noise level standards shall have these units installed prior to issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy. Prior to final inspection and issuance of certificates of use and occupancy, the developer shall provide an independent noise analysis verifying that interior noise levels comply with Title 25 and City noise requirements. Resolution 4014 DR 05-019, CUP 05-037 Page 14 (1) 11.3 The perimeter sound walls are included as part of the master wall plans for Columbus Square currently under review. ENVIRONMENTAL (1) 12.1 Additional measures related to development of this project as noted in the adopted EIS/EIR and are not previously identified in this exhibit as a condition of approval are required as follows: A. Prior to issuance of any permits, the developer shall retain a County -certified archaeologist. If buried resources are found during grading within the reuse plan area, a qualifled archaeologist would need to assess the site significance and perform the appropriate mitigation. The Native American viewpoint shall be considered during this process. This could include testing or data recovery. Native American consultation shall also be initiated during this process. C. The developer shall comply with the requirements established in a Palentological Resource Management Plan (PRMP) prepared for the site, which details the methods to be used for surveillance of construction grading, assessing finds, and actions to be taken in the event that unique paleontological resources are found. D. Prior to the issuance of any permit, the applicant shall provide written evidence to the Community Development Department that a County -certified paleontologist has been retained to conduct salvage excavation of unique paleontological resources if they are found. E. Prior to issuance of any permit, the developer shall provide traffic operations and control plans that would minimize the traffic impacts of proposed construction activity. The plans shall address roadway and lane closures, truck hours and routes, and notification procedures for planned short-term or interim changes in traffic patterns. Such plans shall minimize anticipated delays at major intersections. Prior to approval, the City of Tustin or the City of Irvine, as applicable, shall review the proposed traffic control and operations plans with any affected jurisdiction. FEES (1 x5) 13.1 Prior to issuance of any building permits, payment shall be made of all applicable fees, including but not limited to, the following. Payment shall be required based upon those rates In effect at the time of payment and are subject to change. Resolution 4014 DR 05-019, CUP 05-037 Page 15 a. Building plan check and permit fees to the Community Development Department based on the most current schedule at the time of permit issuance. b. Engineering plan check and permit fees to the Public Works Department based on the most current schedule at the time of permit issuance. C. Orange County Fire Authority plan check and inspection fees to the Community Development Department based upon the most current schedule at the time of permit issuance. d. Major Thoroughfare and Bridge Fees to the Tustin Public Works Department based on the most current schedule at the time of permit issuance. e. Transportation System Improvement Program (TSIP), Benefit Area "B" fees in the amount of $3.31 per square foot of new or added gross square floor area of construction or improvements to the Community Development Department. f. Water and sewer connection fees to the Irvine Ranch Water District. g. New development tax is $350.00 per un1L h. School facilities fee in the amount as required by Tustin Unified School District. i. Other applicable parkland in4leu fees and Tustin Legacy Backbone Infrastructure Program fees as required by Resolution No. 05-40. (1) 13.2 Within forty-eight (48) hours of final approval of the project, the applicant shall deliver to the Community Development Department, a CASHIER'S CHECK payable to the County Clerk in the amount of forty-three dollars ($43.00) to enable the City to file the appropriate environmental documentation for the project. If within such forty-eight (48) hour period that applicant has not delivered to the Community Development Department the above -noted check, the statute of limitations for any interested party to challenge the environmental determination under the provisions of the California Environmental Quality Act could be significantly lengthened. Attachment D City Council Resolution Nos. 05-40 and 06-17 and Ordinance No. 1297 AMENDED ON 3/7/05 RESOLUTION NO. 0540 A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF TUSTIN APPROVING TENTATIVE TRACT MAP 16581 TO SUBDIVIDE 105.5 ACRES BOUNDED BY EDINGER AVENUE ON THE NORTH, VALENCIA NORTH LOOP ROAD ON THE SOUTH, AN INDUSTRIAL BUSINESS PARK AND SEVERYNS ROAD ON THE WEST, AND WEST CONNECTOR ROAD ON THE EAST FOR THE PURPOSE OF DEVELOPING 1,077 RESIDENTIAL UNITS WITHIN PLANNING AREA 4 AND PLANNING AREA 5 OF THE MCAS-TUSTIN SPECIFIC PLAN (REUSE PLAN DISPOSAL PARCEL 23 AND PARCEL 24) The City Council of the City of Tustin does hereby resolve as follows: The City Council finds and determines as follows: A. That a proper application for Tentative Tract Map No. 16581 was submitted by Moffett Meadows Partners, LLC requesting subdivision of a 105.5 acre site into 386 numbered lots and 186 lettered lots for the -- purpose of development of 1,077 residential units, including 84 Single Family Detached (SFD), 181 Carriage Way SFD, 72 Multiple Family Attached (Senior Housing — for ownership tenure) for a total of 337 units at an average density of 8.62 du/acre in Planning Area 4 (Parcel 23) and 570 Multiple Family Attached (MFR), 170 Multiple Family Attached (Senior Housing for ownership tenure) for a total of 740 units at an Average density 17.53 du/acre for Planning Area 5 (Parcel 24) of the MCAS -Tustin Specific Plan, generally bounded by Edinger Avenue on the north, West Connector Road to the east, an industrial. office park to the west, and Valencia/North Loop Road to the south, B. That a public hearing was duly called, noticed, and held for said map on January 24, 2005, and continued to February 14, 2005, by the Planning Commission, and the density bonus and transfer of affordable units was considered concurrently with the development applications; C. As conditioned, the proposed subdivision will be in conformance with the Tustin Area General Plan, MCAS Tustin Specific Plan as proposed to be amended by Zone Change 04-003, State Subdivision Map Act, and the City's Subdivision Code; D. That the proposed subdivision is in conformance with the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan as amended by Resolution No. 3950 for approval of Specific Plan Amendment/Zone Change 04-003; Resolution No. 05-40 Page 1 of 27 E. That the site is located in Planning Area 4 of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan, which is designated for Low Density Residential (1-7 units/acre) and Planning Area 5 of MCAS Tustin Specific Plan which is designated for Medium Density Residential (8-15 units/acre) and that the development as conditioned will be physically suitable for the type of development and proposed density of development; F. The applicant will be required to provide funding towards the project's fair share of Tustin Legacy Backbone Infrastructure Program, which includes improvements that are required to serve new development at MCAS - Tustin, including but not limited to roadway improvements; traffic and circulation mitigation to support development at the former MCAS -Tustin project; domestic and reclaimed water, sewer; telemetry systems; storm drains and flood control channels; retention and detention systems, open space and public recreational facilities; and, utility backbone systems. G. That the proposed subdivision would not have an impact on school district facilities within the Tustin Unified School District in that school impacts for development were considered in the MCAS Reuse Plan which identified school facility sites that will be conveyed to the Tustin Unified School District by the Federal Department of Education or the City of Tustin to serve development of property at the former MCAS Tustin. The WAS Tustin Specific Plan, and the Final Joint Program Environmental Impact Statement/Environmental Impact Report (FEIS/EIR) and conditions of approval of the proposed subdivision also require proof of payment of appropriate school fees as adopted by the Tustin Unified School District prior to issuance of certificates of use and occupancy, which will be collected prior to issuance of building permits in accordance with the City's procedures; H. That the design of the subdivision or the proposed improvements are not likely to cause substantial environmental damage or substantially and avoidably injure fish or wildlife in their habitat; 1. The proposed subdivision is not located within a 100 -year flood plain according to the Federal Emergency Management Agency map for the area dated August 9, 2002. J. That development of the site will require the developer to dedicate in fee title property to the City of Tustin including portions of Severyns Road to the City of Tustin for public roadways and utility purposes as shown on the Tentative Tract Map 16581. K. To ensure there is adequate infrastructure to support buildout of the project, construction of all public infrastructure and in -tract private streets and utility systems is required within the initial phase of development. In Resolution No. 05-40 Page 2 of 27 addition, to ensure orderly development and the systematic provision of required affordable housing, construction phasing of affordable units will be required to be reasonably proportionate to market rate units. �. That the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan requires the provision of affordable housing affordable to very low, low, and moderate income level persons. The applicant has submitted a request for incentives for the development of affordable housing (i.e., density bonus) in Planning Areas 4 and 5 and has requested the transfer of 22 affordable units (8 Very Low and 14 Moderate income) from Planning Area 4 and Planning Area 21 to Planning Area 5 and 25 (8 Very Low and 15 Low income) from Planning Area 21 to Planning Area 5. In accordance with Section 3.9.4.1.3.f of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan, which provides for the transfer of affordable housing unit obligations to an off-site location at the City's sole discretion, the transfer of these units is appropriate in that they are proposed to be located in condominium units (including senior housing — for ownership tenure) project in Planning Area 5, which will offer equivalent housing opportunities. The applicant will be required to enter into a Housing Incentive Agreement to ensure the provision of affordable housing. M. That the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan process included public conveyance of City parks and an Urban Regional Park and individual developers were relieved of the requirement to dedicate land for park purposes; however, the developer is required to provide funding toward the project fair share of Tustin Legacy Open Space and Recreational facilities including payment of a parkland dedication in -lieu fee subject to the provisions of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan and the City's parkland dedication ordinance (Section 9331 of the Tustin City Code), which permits a credit for public recreational open space if affordable housing is being provided. The subdivider is providing 4.9 acres of private parkland in the proposed subdivision and has requested a waiver of parkland dedication fees pursuant to Section 9931d(1)(c) of the Tustin City Code for the 241 affordable housing units to be provided in the subdivision and a credit for 3.66 acres private parkland that will be provided and accessible to the public on the park site through public easements on the development site. It is appropriate to waive a portion of the fees since affordable housing units will be provided within Planning Areas 4 and 5 and provide a credit for a portion of the park areas that will be accessible to the public. N. With development of this site, the applicant has requested a density bonus, density averaging, and an affordable housing plan for transfer of lower income and moderate income units from Planning Area 4 and Planning Area 21 to Planning Area 5, which will be binding with execution _ of a Housing Incentive Agreement. Since 63 percent of the affordable units required for the project site are located in the senior housing project (for ownership tenure), no portions of the project shall be subdivided until Resolution No. 05-40 Page 3 of 27 design, phasing, and tenure of the senior housing project is completed to the satisfaction of Community Development Department. In addition, to ensure orderly development and the systematic provision of required affordable housing, construction phasing of affordable units will be required to be reasonably proportionate to market rate units. O. Section 9121 of the Tustin City Code requires the granting of a density bonus of twenty-five (25) percent of the total units and at least one concession or incentive when an applicant agrees to provide at least twenty (20) percent of the total units (excluding the density bonus) of the housing development as target units affordable to lower income households (i.e., Target Units). The applicant is providing 186 target units and requested a density bonus for construction of 182 units in Planning Areas 4 and 5. No financial Incentive has been requested. P. That the Building Official has considered and approved deviations to the Private Improvement Standard to allow turning radii of less than 25 feet for private drives when acceptable turning radii for a forty (40) foot long by eight (8) feet wide moving truck is demonstrated on the Circulation Plan. Q. That a Final Environmental Impact Statement/Environmental Impact Report for the MCAS Tustin Reuse Plan and Specific Plan (FEIS/EIR) was prepared and certified, which considered the development of low density development within Planning Area 4 and medium density development within Planning Area 5. A checklist was prepared that finds all potential t impacts of the project were addressed by the certified FEIS/EIR and no additional impacts have been identified; all applicable mitigation measures in the FEISIEIR have been included as conditions of approval. The Planning Commission has adopted Resolution No. 3949 recommending that the City Council find that the FEIS/EIR for the MCAS Tustin Reuse Plan and Specific Plan adequately addressed all potential impacts related to the subdivision. The Planning Commission hereby recommends that the City Council approve Tentative Tract Map 16581 for the subdivision of 105.5 (gross) acre site into 386 numbered lots and 186 lettered lots for the purpose of developing 1,077 residential units, including 337 units within Planning Area 4 and 740 units in Planning Area 5' (Parcel 23 and Parcel 24), subject to the conditions contained in Exhibit A attached hereto. PASSED AND ADOPTED at a regular meeting of the Tustin City Council held on the 22nd day of February, 2005. 2 LOU BONE Mayor Resolution No. 0540 Page 4 of 27 STATE OF CALIFORNIA ) COUNTY OF ORANGE ) SS CITY OF TUSTIN ) I, Pamela Stoker, City Clerk and ex -officio Clerk of the City Council of the City of Tustin, California, do hereby certify that the whole number of the members of the City Council of the City of Tustin is five; that the above and foregoing Resolution No. 05-40 was duly passed and adopted at a regular meeting of the Tustin City Council, held on the 7°t day of March, 2005, by the following vote: COUNCILMEMBER AYES: COUNCILMEMBER NOES: COUNCILMEMBER ABSTAINED: COUNCILMEMBER ABSENT: 400"1 "s City Clerk BONE, DAVERT, AMANTE, HAGEN, KAWASHIMA (5) NONE (0) NONE (p) Resolution No. 05-40 Page 5 of 27 EXHIBIT A - TENTATIVE TRACT MAP 16581 RESOLUTION NO. 05-40 CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL GENERAL (1) 1.1 Within 24 months from tentative map approval, the subdivider shall record with appropriate agencies, a final map prepared in accordance with subdivision requirements of the Tustin Municipal Code, the State Subdivision Map Act, and applicable conditions contained herein unless an extension is granted pursuant to Section 9335.08 of the Tustin Municipal Code. Prior to submittal for initial City review, all corrections noted herein shall be made. A revised tentative tract map that includes all corrections contained herein shall be submitted prior to the Issuance of any permits or submittal of the first final tract map, whichever occurs first. If multiple final maps are proposed, each map shall comply with all requirements herein and the requirements for phasing set forth in Condition 2.1. (1) 1.2 Resolution No. 05-40 shall become null and void in the event that Resolution Nos. 3949, 3951, 3953 approving Concept Plan 03-003 as applicable, and which were approved by the Planning Commission, Specific Plan Amendment/Zone Change 04-003, Design Review 04-006, and the Affordable Housing Plan and Density Bonus Application, which includes the transfer of required affordable housing units from Planning Areas 4 and 21 to Planning Area 5 is not approved by the City Council. (1) 1.3 Approval of Resolution No. 05-40 is contingent upon the applicant returning to the Community Development Department a notarized "Agreement to Conditions Imposed" form and the property owner signing and recording with the County Clerk -Recorder a notarized "Notice of Discretionary Permit Approval and Conditions of Approval" form. The forms shall be established by the Director of Community Development, and evidence of recordation shall be provided to the Community Development Department. SOURCE CODES (1) STANDARD CONDITION (5) RESPONSIBLE AGENCY REQUIREMENT (2) CEQA MITIGATION (6) LANDSCAPING GUIDELINES (3) UNIFORM BUILDING CODE/S (7) PC/CC POLICY (4) DESIGN REVIEW `•* EXCEPTION Resolution No. 05-40 Page 6 of 27 {1 j 1.4 The final tract map(s) shall be developed in accordance with Resolution Nos. 3951, and 3953 approving Concept Plan 03-003, Design Review 04- 006, and Resolutions 05-38, 05-39 approving Specific Plan Amendment/Zone Change 04-003, and the Affordable Housing Plan and agreement and Density Bonus Application. All conditions of approval herein, as applicable, shall be satisfied prior to recordation of a final map or as specified herein. (1) 1.5 The subdivider shall comply with all applicable requirements of the State Subdivision Map Act, the City's Subdivision Ordinance, the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan, applicable mitigation measures identified in the certified FEIS/EIR, and other agreements with the City of Tustin, unless otherwise modified by this Resolution or Resolution Nos. , 05-38, 05-39, 3951, and 3953. (5) 1.6 Prior to recordation of the first final map, the subdivider shall be required to execute bonds or pay fees for grading permits, Quimby Act obligations, and Tustin Legacy Backbone Infrastructure Program improvements as determined by the City Council, required to be made by the developer pursuant to City procedures. (1) 1.7 Prior to recordation of the final map, the subdivider shall execute a subdivision and monumentation agreement and furnish the improvement and monumentation bonds as required by the City Engineer. (1) 1.8 Prior to final map approval by the City Council, the subdivider shall execute a hold -harmless agreement and provide a Certificate of Insurance pursuant to Section 9325 of the Tustin City Code. (1) 1.9 The subdivider shall not oppose any future creation of a landscape and lighting district for maintenance within the public right-of-way or of public parkland, or community facilities district for funding of Tustin Legacy backbone infrastructure or municipal service provision to the project site, or a future community facilities district for school purposes and shall comply with the following: 1.9.1 Prior to recordation of a final subdivision map creating building sites ("B Map"), a mutually acceptable "Mitigation Agreement" shall be entered into with the Tustin Unified School District. (1) 1.10 Prior to final map approval, the subdivider shall submit: A. A current title report; and, B. A duplicate mylar of the Final Map, or 8%2 inch by 11 inch transparency of each map sheet prior to final map approval and "as built" grading, landscape, and improvement plans prior to Certificate of Acceptance. Resolution No. 05-40 Page 7 of 27 (1) 1.11 Upon recordation of any final map or submittal of an application for building permits, the applicant shall obtain new addresses from the Engineering Division. (1) 1.12 As a condition of approval of Tentative Tract Map 16581, the applicant shall agree, at its sole cost and expense, to defend, indemnify, and hold harmless the City, its officers, employees, agents, and consultants, from any claim, action, or proceeding brought by a third party against the City, Its officers, agents, and employees, which seeks to attack, set aside, challenge, void, or annul an approval of the City Council, the Planning Commission, or any other decision-making body, including staff, concerning this project or from any potential flooding Impacts. The City agrees to promptly notify the applicant of any such claim or action filed against the City and to cooperate in the defense of any such action. The City may, at its sole cost and expense, elect to participate in defense of any such action under this condition. (1) 1.13 As required by Amendment No. 1 to the Joint Cooperative Agreement between the City, the County of Orange, and the Orange County Flood Control District (OCFCD), the applicant shall indemnify and defend the City, County of Orange ("County") and the Orange County Flood Control District ("District") against any claims, loss, liability or damages arising from damage to property or injury to persons resulting from flooding and/or erosion within Tract 16581. The applicant shall ensure that it has adequate assets in existence to fund this obligation until completion of future widening and Peters Canyon Channel improvements. These defense and indemnify obligations do not extend to any loss, liability, or damages established by a court of competent jurisdiction to be cause by the County's or District's negligence or willful misconduct in the design or maintenance of existing flood control Improvements in the Peters Canyon Channel, provided the failure to improve Peters Canyon Channel adjacent to Parcels in the City of Tustin and City of Irvine will not constitute negligence or willful misconduct on the part of the District or County. (1) 1.14 The applicant is required to prepare and record a final subdivision map. (1) 1.15 Unless otherwise agreed by the City in its sole discretion, the Developer Parcel, the property within the tract or any street or sidewalk or alleyway thereon shall not be privately gated, provided however, that any swimming pool and/or spa facility within the Common Area and any indoor Common Area Improvement, including any clubhouse and bathrooms, may be gated or locked and made available solely to residents of the Project and their guests. Resolution No. 05-40 Page 8 of 27 (*) 1.16 Approval of Tentative Tract Map 16581 shall be contingent upon conditions of approval contained within Planning Commission Resolutions 3949, 3950, 3951, 3952, and 3953, as applicable. PROJECT PHASING (*} 2.1 Construction phasing of product types and units (including affordable units) on individual multiple family product planning areas within the tract (i.e., PA 5-1, PA 5-2, PA 5-4, PA 5-5, PA 5-6, and PA 5-7) shall occur concurrently as shown on Sheet CP -8 (Phasing Plan) and as noted in the conditions of approval contained herein with the exception of the senior housing project that requires submittal of a separate design review application and any associated required applications and separate affordability production monitoring as Identified in Condition 2.2. (') 2.2 The senior housing shown on the tentative tract map is provided for general location and number of units and does not represent final City approval except that 153 affordable units shall be provided at this site including 36 Very Low, 61 Low, and 56 Moderate income units. A complete design review application for the senior housing including a site plan delineating adequate access non intrusive to low density residential units, adequate parking, landscaping, fire access, architectural floor plans, elevations, materials and colors for the housing units and the recreational building, and a phasing plan for the construction of the affordable units along with the market rate units in the senior housing shall be submitted and approved prior to issuance of building permits for the first production -Awl unit of the entire Columbus Square project. A production unit Is defined as a unit included in Phase I and subsequent phases of the Phasing Plan (not including initial phase or model homes). Any deviation from the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan parking standards for the senior housing would require approval of a conditional use permit which would include submittal of a parking analysis that would justify reduction in the number of required parking spaces, subject to review and approval of the City's traffic engineer. If the developer is not able to justify the reduction in parking and/or the conditional use permit is not approved, the developer agrees to a proportionate reduction in the number of units. Except in no case, shall the number of affordable units approved herein for the senior housing project be reduced. Prior to issuance of the 100th building permit for the production units of the entire Columbus Square project, building permits for the senior housing shall have been issued and the first footing inspection for the senior housing shall have been completed. In addition, construction of the recreation building and park facilities shall be completed prior to the issuance of the 420th building permit (50 percent of non -restricted). (') 2.3 The developer shall develop, market and sell Very Low, Low, and Moderate income ("affordable units") in the individual multiple family Resolution No. 05-40 Page 9 of 27 product planning areas (i.e., PA 5-1, PA 5-2, PA 5-4, PA 5-5, PA 5-6, and PA -5-7) as shown on Sheet CP -8 and shall construct and market and sell such units in equal proportion to the market rate units as shown on the Phasing Plan for each individual multiple family planning area and as per the conditions of approval contained herein including Condition 2.1. If there is any deviation from provisions contained herein for the individual multiple family product planning areas and as required in Condition 2.1 as determined by the Community Development Department upon written notice to the applicant or applicable vertical home builder responsible for development of the planning area, no additional building permits shall be issued by the Community Development Department for additional units on subsequent phases in a planning area (PA) untjl compliance with said provisions has been demonstrated to the satisfaction of the Director of Community Development. In reviewing compliance, the Director shall utilize objective information such as the number of market rate and affordable units constructed to date in the planning area based on the approved Phasing Plan and Building Division records and data on the number of market rate and affordable units sold in an individual phase which shall be provided by the developer upon written request of the Director. The requirements of this Condition shall be disclosed by the applicant to all vertical home builders and with each final conveyance map. (") 2.4 Prior to recordation of the first final map including a conveyance map, or first building permit, whichever occurs first, the applicant shall enter into a Housing Agreement with the City to ensure implementation of the Affordable Housing requirements of the Specific Plan, the City's Density Bonus Ordinance, the City approved "Affordable Housing Plan, Density Bonus Application, and the City's Affordable Housing Policy and compliance with California Health and Safety Code Section 33413(b)(2). The development shall include 266 affordable units in Planning Areas 4 and 5 including twenty-five (25) affordable units transferred from Planning Area 21 to Planning Area 5. (+) 2.5 Design and construction of all public infrastructure and in4ract private streets and utility systems shall be constructed within the initial phase of development and shall be completed prior to the issuance of building permits for any Phase 1 unit as identified on Sheet CP -7 (Phasing Plan), unless a modified phasing plan for in -tract private streets and utility systems only Is reviewed and approved by the Building Official and the Orange County Fire Authority in compliance with all applicable codes and standards including the California Fire Code for access and water supply during construction and occupancy of production units. However, said modified phasing plan for in -tract private street and utility improvements only shall not impact any other condition contained herein or any other City approval. Model units may be constructed prior to completion of Resolution No. 0540 Page 10 of 27 infrastructure if adequate ingress and egress is provided to the satisfaction of the Building Official and Orange County Fire Authority. Project infrastructure (i.e., drives within condominium projects) and utilities shall be constructed at the time of project development. (') 2.6 The developer shall submit to the City an Affordable Housing Purchaser Selection and Criteria Plan for Redevelopment Agency ("agency") review and approval 30 days prior to approval of a final map or issuance of a building permit, whichever occurs first. The agency will approve or disapprove the Affordable Housing Purchaser Selection and Criteria Plan within 20 calendar days. The developer shall initiate marketing and sales of the Affordable Housing units after the agency's approval of the Developer's Affordable Housing Purchaser Selection and Criteria Plan. Sale of Affordable Housing units can begin after final map recordation and all necessary California Department of Real Estate approvals. The developer shall also submit to agency individual escrow instructions for buyers of Affordable Housing units and all other related documents at least 20 calendar days prior to close of escrow of individual Affordable Housing units and with submission of individual escrow instructions and related items by the developer to the agency. The agency shall approve or disapprove individual escrow instructions and related items for buyers of Affordable Housing units within 10 calendar days following submission by developer. GENERAL CONDITIONS FOR ALL NQN-BACKBONE INFRASTRUCTURE IMPROVEMENTS Ai - The following general conditions apply to Tustin Legacy Non -Backbone Infrastructure improvements, as specified in each condition to ensure coordinated design, construction, and operation of all on- and off-site infrastructure and utility systems. (1) 3.1 Separate 24" by 36" street improvement plans for all Tustin Legacy Non - Backbone Infrastructure Improvements identified in the following Conditions and other public improvements, as prepared by a California Registered Civil Engineer, shall be required for all design and construction within the public right-of-way including but not limited to the following: A. Full width improvements on Severyns Road, project entries at Valencia North Loop Road/Lot P and West Connector Road/Lot T; B. Sidewalk, including curb ramps for the physically disabled, on both sides of Severyns Road, the south side of Edinger Avenue, the north side of Valencia North Loop Road, and the west side of West Connector Road: The project shall comply with City of Tustin Standard Plan No. 204 for construction of meandering sidewalks and shall comply with ADA accessibility requirements for all proposed sidewalk grades on public Resolution No. 05-40 Page 11 of 27 streets. All public sidewalks, paseos, and trail facilities shall comply with the provisions of the American with Disabilities Act; C. Catch basins/storm drain laterals/connections to the existing storm drain system along Valencia North Loop Road, Severyns Road, and West Connector Road with approval of City of Tustin; D. Domestic water facilities and reclaimed water facilities: The domestic water system shall be designed and installed to the standards of the Irvine Ranch Water District. Improvement plans shall also be reviewed and approved by the Orange County Fire Authority for fire protection purposes. The adequacy and reliability of water system design and distribution of fire hydrants will be evaluated. The water distribution system and appurtenances shall also conform to the applicable laws and adopted regulations enforced by the Orange County Health Department. Any required reclaimed water system shall meet the standards as required by the Irvine Ranch Water District; E. Sanitary sewer facilities: All sanitary sewer facilities must be submitted as required by the City Engineer and Irvine Ranch Water District (IRWD). These facilities shall include a gravity flow system per the standard of the Irvine Ranch Water District; F. Landscape/irrigation on both sides of Severyns Road subject to Navy approval within the LIFOC areas, on the south side of Edinger Avenue and the median on Edinger Avenue adjacent to the project site, the median on Edinger Avenue from 1400 feet of Red Hill Avenue to West Connector Road, both sides of Valencia North Loop Road adjacent to the project site, and the west side of West Connector road adjacent to the project site; G. Underground utility connections: All utility lines shall be placed underground by the developer; H. Fire hydrants; Demolition and removal of any abandoned utilities at the entire site including within the current proposed roadway sections. J. Traffic signals at Lot Palencia North Loop and Lot T/West Connector Road; and, K. Storm drain facilities on Severyns Road per City's Run-off Management Plan for Tustin Legacy. All public access easements outside of the existing or proposed street rights-of-way shall be clearly shown and labeled on the plans and street Resolution No. 05-40 Page 12 of 27 sections and design and placement of utilities such as light poles, street furniture, traffic lights, etc. will be subject to design parameters established by the City. In addition, a 24" by 36" reproducible construction area traffic control plan, as prepared by a California Registered Traffic Engineer or Civil Engineer experienced in this type of plan preparation, shall be required. (5) 3.2 All public improvements, including, but not limited to, water supply, sanitary sewer facilities, reclaimed water supply, storm water drainage, electrical service, gas service, and other facilities and utilities shall comply with the City of Tustin General Plan, the MCAS Tustin Specific Pian, City development standards and guidelines, and all conditions contained herein, including, but not limited to, the following: A. The project shall comply with City of Tustin Standard Plan No. 204 for construction of a meandering sidewalk and ADA accessibility requirements for all proposed sidewalk grades on public streets. B. All landscape setbacks shall be consistent with the City of Tustin MCAS Specific Pian. C. Adequate horizontal and vertical intersection sight lines shall be provided and shown on the grading plan and landscape plan. A minimum 25 foot by 25 foot limited use area triangle shall be provided to ensure adequate sight lines at all driveways and the applicant shall comply with the City of -dw Tustin's Standard Drawings and Design Standards for Public Works Construction No. 510 for all public and private intersection sight distances and limited use area requirements for the project's streets. (1) 3.3 Prior to any final map recordation, the development applicant shall enter into an agreement with the City of Tustin and any appropriate regional utility agencies, districts, and providers, as applicable, to dedicate all easement, rights-of-way, or other land determined necessary to construct adequate utility infrastructure and facilities to serve the project, including but not limited to the following: IRWD, SCE, SBC, The Gas Company, Cox Communications, etc. (1) 3.4 A complete hydrology study and hydraulic calculations shall be submitted to the City for review and approval. (1) 3.5 The minimum pipe diameter for all public storm drains shall be 24 inches. (5) 3.6 All storm drains to be constructed within or adjacent to the development shall be designed per the applicable OCFCD and City of Tustin standards. Resolution No. 0540 Page 13 of 27 (1) 3.7 The proposed private and public drainage collection systems shall be designed for a minimum 25 -year storm frequency and a 100 -year storm frequency for regional facilities. The applicant shall submit hydrology studies for the existing and proposed drainage conditions for both the 25 - year and 100 -year storm events for the City's and County's review and approval and provide mitigation to maintain storm water discharges for the proposed condition that is consistent with the existing condition discharges for the site. (1) 3.8 A detailed hydrology and hydraulic analysis for 25 -year and 100 -year storm frequencies shall be provided for both the existing and proposed conditions to determine any requirements for on-site storm water retention/detention and facility sizing. The applicant shall also be required to accept upstream storm water that would historically cross the property and detain/retain on the property such upstream water so that the release of said water into downstream regional flood control systems does not exceed historical flow rates or the downstream capacity of such systems. (1) 3.9 All proposed utilities and storm drain lines shall be labeled as being either private or public, subject to approval by the Public Works Director and applicable utility providers. (1) 3.10 The minimum grade on gutter flow lines shall be 0.4 percent (including the flow line grades in street tapers and horizontal curves). Construction of catch basins, storm drain laterals, and junction structures shall be required to eliminate the need for cross gutters on public streets. (1) 3.11 Prior to issuance of an encroachment permit, the applicant shall prepare a sedimentation and erosion control plan for all work related to this development. (1) 3.12 Preparation and submittal of a final grading plan shall be provided showing all pertinent elevations as they pertain to the public right-of-way along with delineating the following information: A. Final street elevations at key locations; B. Final pad/finished floor elevations and key elevations for all site grading as established by the approved hydrology report and elevations provided by the OCFCD; and, C. All flood hazards of record. (1) 3.13 Prior to the recordation of the first final map, the applicant shall be required to enter into a landscape maintenance agreement with the City of Tustin for all parkway improvements within public right-of-way along Edinger Avenue, West Connector Road, Valencia North Loop Road, and the public portion of Severyns Road. Resolution No. 0540 Page 14 of 27 (1) 3.14 In addition to the normal full size plan submittal process, all final development plans including, but not limited to: tract maps, parcel maps, right-of-way maps, records of survey, public works improvements, private infrastructure improvements, final grading plans, and site plans are also required to be submitted to the Public Works Department/Engineering Division in computer aided design and drafting (CADD) format. The standard file format is AutoCAD Release 2004 having the extension DWG. Likewise, layering and linetype conventions are AutoCAD -based (latest version available upon request from the Engineering Division). In order to Interchangeably utilize the data contained in the infrastructure mapping system, CADD drawings must be in AutoCAD "DWG" format (i.e., produced using AutoCAD or AutoCAD compatible CADD software). The most current version of AutoCAD is Release 2000. Drawings created in AutoCAD Release 2000 are compatible and acceptable. The CADD files shall be submitted to the City at the time the plans are approved and updated CADD files reflecting the "as built" conditions shall be submitted once all construction has been completed. The subdivision bonds will not be released until the "as built" CADD files have been submitted. TUSTIN LEGACY BACKBONE INFRASTRUCTURE PROGRAM (1) 4.1 This Subdivision necessitates the construction of certain infrastructure improvements as outlined in the Tustin Legacy Backbone Infrastructure Program for the former MCAS Tustin. The applicant shall fund its Fair Share Contribution to the Tustin Legacy Backbone Infrastructure and shall provide security satisfactory to the City to insure that the entire Fair Share Contribution is paid to the City, including amounts due for the Government Parcels within the City of Irvine as required in the Cooperative Agreement between the City of Tustin and Marble Mountain Partners LLC, dated February 7, 2005. Where the applicant is required to design and construct Legacy Backbone Infrastructure as a condition of approval, the applicant shall be reimbursed pursuant to the cooperative agreement. (1) 4.2 The applicant shall design and construct the traffic signal at West ConnectorNalencia North Loop Road in the first phase of development of Tentative Tract Map 16581. For all design and construction within the public right-of-way, separate plans shall be provided, which include all plans and specifications and estimates necessary to conduct a public bid process. (*) 4.3 In the event that the February 7, 2005, award of contract for the Valencia/Armstrong project is set aside by a court of competent jurisdiction, or the City is otherwise enjoined from performing that contract, or the construction of backbone Infrastructure containing water, sewer, or Resolution No. 05-40 Page 15 of 27 other utilities (the "Backbone Utilities") necessary to serve the project is delayed for these or other reasons such that the Backbone Utilities are not available at time of building permit issuance, no building permit shall be issued (unless OCFA approves an alternative for firefighting water) until such Backbone Utilities are available to the project. In the event said Backbone Utilities are not constructed because the award of contract for the Valencia/Armstrong project is set aside by a court of competent jurisdiction, or the City is otherwise enjoined from performing the contract, the developer may construct the Backbone Utilities, subject to review and approval of the Director of Public Works and Community Development Director. In any event, no certificate of use or occupancy shall be issued unless such Backbone utilities are available to the project. PRIVATE IN -TRACT IMPROVEMENTS (3) 5.1 Prior to the issuance of precise grading permits, infrastructure construction plans, as prepared by a California Registered Civil Engineer, shall be required for all private, on-site construction. All design and construction of improvement work shall incorporate applicable conditions contained within Resolution No. 3953 and shall be designed and performed in accordance with the applicable portions of the City of Tustin's "Grading Manual" and Construction Standards for Private Streets, Storm Drain and On -Site Private Improvements," revised April 1989, or as subsequently amended. Said plans shall include, but not be limited to, the following; A. Curbs and gutters on all streets; B. Sidewalks on all streets, including curb ramps for the physically disabled; all sidewalks, pathways, paseos, and trails shall comply with the provisions of the American with Disabilities Act; C. Drive aprons; D. Signing/striping plan; E. Street and drive aisle paving; all private streets, drive aisles, and curb return radius shall. be consistent with the City's design standards for private street improvements, unless otherwise approved by the Building Official, and all roadway and driveway widths and parking area widths (and lengths where appropriate) shall be dimensioned on the plans; F. Catch basin/storm drain laterals/connections to the public storm drain system with approval of the City of Tustin; G. Domestic water facilities and reclaimed water facilities: The domestic water system shall be designed and installed to the standards of the Irvine Resolution No. 05-40 Page 16 of 27 Ranch Water District. Improvement plans shall also be reviewed and approved by the Orange County Fire Authority for fire protection purposes. The adequacy and reliability of the water system design and the distribution of fire hydrants will be evaluated. The water distribution system and appurtenances shall also conform to the applicable laws and adopted regulations enforced by the Orange County Health Department. Any required reclaimed water system shall meet the standards as required by the Irvine Ranch Water District (IRWD); H. Sanitary sewer facilities: All sanitary sewer facilities must be submitted as required by the Building Official and IRWD. These facilities shall be consistent with the standards of the Irvine Ranch Water District; I. Underground utility connections: All utility lines shall be placed underground by the developer, J. Fire hydrants; K. Demolition/removal of utilities in accordance with the demolition/severance plan as required herein; L. Telecommunications facilities including, but not limited to, telephone and cable television facilities. Developer is required to coordinate design and construction of cable television facilities with a City -franchised system operator and shall not place an undue burden upon said operator for the provision of these facilities. (3) 5.2 Prior to the issuance of building permits, construction plans, as prepared by a California Registered Civil Engineer, shall be required for the following private improvements: . A. Street lighting: The private street lighting system shall be reviewed and approved by the City of Tustin and SouthemfCalifomia Edison; B. Landscaperrrigation; C. Trash facilities: The applicant shall provide commercial trash collection and obtain approval from the Engineering Division for the location, size, and trash enclosures. (1) 5.3 All improvement work shall be performed in accordance with the applicable portions of the City of Tustin's "Grading Manual" and "Construction Standards for Private Streets, Storm Drain and On -Site Private Improvements," revised April 1989. Resolution No. 05-40 Page 17 of 27 COORDINATION WITH AFFECTED PROPERTY OWNERS AND AGENCIES (1) 6.1 The applicant shall obtain permission from and coordinate with affected property owners, jurisdictions, and resource agencies for all public and private improvements, Including, but not limited to, the following: A. Prior to any work in the public right-of-way, an Encroachment Permit shall be obtained and applicable fees paid to the Public Works Department. B. The applicant shall obtain permission from affected property owners for any work located on adjacent properties or on LIFOC parcels, including the property owned by the Department of Navy. C. The applicant shall obtain all approvals and permits from the applicable property owners and agencies for work within the City limits. D. The applicant shall coordinate the design and construction of the bus stop locations with the Orange County Transportation Authority. E. The applicant shall obtain written approval and/or permits from the applicable utility companies. F. The applicant shall obtain permission from property owners for any work located on adjacent properties. CONSTRUCTION (1) 7.1 Any damage done to existing street improvements and utilities shall be repaired before acceptance of the tract within the subdivision to the satisfaction of the City Engineer. (1) 7.2 The applicant shall comply with all waste diversion requirements. The City of Tustin is required to comply with the recycling requirements contained in the California Integrated Waste Management Act of 1989. To facilitate City compliance with this law, the applicant is required to comply with Section 4327 of the Tustin City Code which details the requirements for developing and implementing a Waste Management Plan. GRANTS IN FEE AND DEDICATIONS (1) 8.1 The applicant and subdivider shall satisfy dedication and/or reservation requirements as applicable, including but not limited to dedication of parts of Severyns Road and West Connector Road, traffic signal equipment and maintenance easements of Valencia North Loop Road/Lot P and West Connector Road/Lot T, drainage and flood control right-of-way easements for acceptance and conveyance of existing flows from the adjacent Resolution No. 05-40 Page 18 of 27 business park westerly of Planning Area 4, pedestrian and vehicular access rights, utility easements and public parks, defined and approved as to specific locations by the City Engineer and other agencies, for this project. Reciprocal Ingress, egress, parking, utility and pedestrian access easements may need to be provided between and across certain privately own and maintained lots and within the lettered lots. (1) 8.2 The applicant shalt identify the easements for public use of privately owned parks and related public access easements on the final map. (1) 8.3 The applicant shall dedicate in fee title to the City of Tustin portions of Severyns Road for public roadways and utility purposes as shown on the Tentative Tract Map 16581. (1) 8.4 All dedication and/or offers of dedication shall also state that the City of Tustin shall be permitted to obtain, at no cost, a right -of -entry and temporary construction easement for all on-site joins when the ultimate street Improvements are constructed. The right -of -entry and temporary construction easement shall terminate on the date that the Notice of Completion is recorded at the Orange County Recorder's office. (1) 8.5 The applicant shall provide an ingress/egress easement on lots "P," "T," "R," "U" and "X" for Department of Navy to access IRP -16. (1) 8.6 The applicant shall dedicate public access and maintenance easements to the City of Tustin fro sidewalk along Valencia North Loop Road and West Connector Road. CC&R (1) 9.1 All organizational documents for the project including any covenants, conditions, and restrictions (CC&Rs) shall be submitted to and approved by the Community Development Department, City Attorney's Office, and Special Counsel. Costs for such review shall be borne by the subdivider. The approved CC&Rs shall be recorded with County Recorder's Office at the same time as recordation of the final map. A copy of the final documents shall be submitted to the Community Development Department after recordation. No dwelling unit in the development shall be sold or a Certificate of Occupancy issued, unless a homeowners association has been legally formed with the right to assess all these properties which are jointly owned or benefited to operate and maintain all other mutually available features of the development including, but not limited to, open space, amenities, landscaping, or slope maintenance landscaping, private streets, and utilities. No dwelling unit shall be sold unless all approved and required open space, amenities, landscaping, or other improvements, or approved Resolution No. 05-40 Page 19 of 27 a phases thereof, have been completed or completion is assured by a development agreement or financing guarantee method approved by the City. The CC&Rs shall include, but not be limited to, the following provisions: A. The City shall be included as a party to the CC&Rs for enforcement purposes of those CC&R provisions in which the City has interest as reflected in the following provisions. However, the City shall not be obligated to enforce the CC&Rs. B. The requirement that association bylaws be established C. Provisions for effective establishment, operation, management, use, repair, and maintenance of all common areas and facilities including recreational buildings and amenities, landscaped areas and lots, walls and fences, private roadways (i.e., walks, sidewalks, trails), parkland facilities and bikeways, and open space areas. D. Membership in the homeowners association shall be inseparable from ownership in individual units. E. Architectural controls shall be provided and may include, but not be limited to, provisions regulating exterior finishes, roof materials, fences and walls, accessory structures such as patios, sunshades, trellises, gazebos, awnings, exterior mechanical equipment, television and radio antenna, �. consistent with the Tustin City Code and the MCAS Tustin Specific Pian. F. Maintenance standards shall be provided for applicable items listed in Section C above in CC&Rs. Examples of maintenance standards are shown below. 1. All common area landscaping and private areas visible from any public way shall be properly maintained such that they are evenly cut, evenly edged, free of bare or brown spots, debris, and weeds. All trees and shrubs shall be trimmed so they do not impede vehicular or pedestrian traffic. Trees shall be pruned so they do not Intrude into neighboring properties and shall be maintained so they do not have droppings or create other nuisances to neighboring properties. All trees shall also be root pruned to eliminate exposed surface roots and damage to sidewalks, driveways, and structures. 2. All private roadways, sidewalks, and open space areas shall be maintained so that they are safe for users. Significant pavement cracks, pavement distress, excessive slab settlement, abrupt vertical variations, and debris on travel ways should be removed or repaired promptly. Resolution No. 05-40 Page 20 of 27 3. Common areas shall be maintained in such a manner as to avoid the reasonable determination of a duly authorized official of the City that a public nuisance has been created by the absence of adequate maintenance such as to be detrimental to public health, safety, or general welfare. G. Homeowners association approval of exterior improvements requiring a building permit shall be obtained prior to requesting a building permit from the City of Tustin Community Development Department. All plans for exterior improvements shall conform to requirements set forth by the City and the CC&Rs. H. Private open space areas within the common area shall be illustrated on a "Private Open Space Exhibit" and shall be made part of the CC&Rs and shall specify those portions of the common open space area that are allocated for private use and public use and access rights in perpetuity. The CC&Rs, shall include a separate 8% inch by 11 inch dimensioned site plan for each unit that is allocated private open space. I. The approved site plan showing the public portion of the park site and associated public easements that will be accessible to the public and provisions for maintenance of these areas by the Homeowners Association. J The approved "Parking and Circulation Exhibit" shall be made part of the CC&Rs and shall be enforced by the homeowners association. In addition to the exhibit, provisions regarding parking shall be included in the CC&Rs, including the following: 1. . All units are required to maintain the required number of garage spaces based on Table 34 of MCAS Tustin Specific Plan. 2. A minimum of 562 unassigned guest parking spaces shall be permanently maintained in locations shown on the "Parking and Circulation Exhibit" and have a minimum length of twenty-two (22) feet per stall for on street parking. 3. Residents shall not store or park any non -motorized vehicles, trailers or motorized vehicles that exceed 7 feet high, 7 feet wide, and 19 feet long in any parking space, driveway, or private street area except for the purpose of loading, unloading, making deliveries or emergency repairs except that the homeowners association may adopt rules and regulations to authorize exceptions. 4. Residents shall park vehicles in garage spaces. Storage of Resolution No. 05-40 Page 21 of 27 personal items may occur in the garages only to the extent that vehicles may still be parked within the required garage spaces. 5. The homeowners association shall be responsible for monitoring and enforcing all parking and traffic regulations on private streets. The proposed CC&Rs shall include provisions requiring the association to develop and adopt an enforcement program for parking and traffic regulations within the development which may include measures for fire access and enforcement by a private security company. K. Provisions for enforcing individual trash bin placement at designated curb areas as shown on the approved "Curbside Trash Pick-up Exhibit' no earlier than noon on the day before scheduled collections and removed within twelve (12) hours of collection. L. Maintenance of lettered and numbered Lots (including but not limited to Lots 264, 265, 297, 335 and 369 Lots A -m, P -u, X -Y, CA -CF, DA -DJ, FA - FD, AA -AR, BA -BC, EA -EG, GA -GH, HA -HO, IA -11- AAA-AAJ, BBA -BAF, BBA-BBZ, CCA-CCO, DAA, DDA-DDZ), containing all common areas, public and private park areas, streets, alleys, paseos, etc., shall be by the homeowners association. M. Television and radio antennas shall be installed in accordance with the requirements of the Tustin City Code. Y N. All utility services serving the site shall be installed and maintained underground. O. The homeowners association shall be required to file the names, addresses, and telephone numbers of at least one member of the homeowners association Board and, where applicable, a manager of the project before January 1st of each year with the City of Tustin Community Development Department for the purpose of contacting the association in the case of emergency or in those cases where the City has an interest in CC&R violations. P. The homeowners association shall be responsible for establishing and following procedures for providing access to public utilities for maintenance of their facilities within the project area, subject to those agencies' approval. Q. No amendment to alter, modify, terminate, or change the homeowners association's obligation to maintain the common areas and the project perimeter wall or other CC&R provisions in which the City has an interest, as noted above, or to alter, modify, terminate, or change the City's right to enforce maintenance of the common areas and maintenance of the Resolution No. 0540 Page 22 of 27 project perimeter wall, shall be permitted without the prior written approval of the City of Tustin Community Development Department. R. No delivery and or moving trucks larger than 40 feet shall be permitted on the private drives of the condominium projects with less than 25 foot radius turns. HOMEBUYER NOTIFICATION (1) 10.1 Prior to recordation of the final map, the subdivider shall submit to the Community Development Department for review and approval a homebuyer notification document that includes the notifications listed below. The notification document shall be signed by each homebuyer prior to final inspection and occupancy, and a copy of the signed notification shall be provided to the Community Development Department prior to final inspection and/or issuance of each Certificate of Occupancy. A. A notice for roadway, trail, and train noise that may impact the subdivision, including roadway noise associated with, Edinger Avenue, North Loop Road, West Connector Road, and train noise associated with the rail corridor north of the project. The notice shall indicate the current number of trains per day (59) and the estimated to increase to over 100 trains on a 24 hour basis by the year 2020. The notice shall indicate that additional building upgrades may be necessary for noise attenuation. This determination is to be made as architectural drawings become available and/or where field-testing determines inadequate noise insulation. B. A notice, to be reviewed by the City of Tustin and the Tustin Unified School District, regarding the location of. existing and proposed elementary, middle, and high schools which will serve the subdivision (text and map) and advice to homebuyers that proposed school sites may never be constructed. C. A notice regarding units that are adjacent to aboveground utilities or structures (such as light standards and fire hydrants) identifying the type of structure and their locations. D. A notice indicating that any use of a residence for a business shall be subject to the City's. Home Occupation Ordinance and may require zoning clearance and a business license. E. A notice indicating that public use of a minimum one (1) acre or more portion of the park site, to be maintained by the homeowners association, will be allowed and noting public ingress and egress through the subdivision will be provided for access to the park. Resolution No. 05-40 Page 23 of 27 F. A notice explaining the easements, facilities, amenities, and dedications that will be provided on lettered lots and indicating all on-site streets, alleys, paseos, and common areas are to be maintained by the homeowners association. G. A notice, to be approved by the City Attorney, indicating that neither the site, nor the project nor any part thereof any street or sidewalk, .alleyway, or paseo thereon shall be privately gated, provided however that any swimming pool and/or spa facility within the common area and any indoor common area improvements, including any clubhouse and bathrooms, may be gated or locked and made available solely to residents of the project and their guests. H. A notice stating that all development within the site is approved for ownership tenure only per Chapter 3.9.3J5 of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan. A notice stating trash bins shall be placed in designated curb areas as shown on the approved "Curbside Trash Pick-up Exhibit" no earlier than noon on the day before scheduled collections and removed within twelve (12) hours of collection. J. A notice indicating that surrounding properties may be developed In accordance with City ordinances in a manner which may partially or totally obstruct views from the owner's unit and that the City of Tustin makes no t, -moor claim, warranty, or guarantee that views from any unit will be preserved as development of surrounding properties occurs. K. A notice indicating the minimum building setbacks and that construction of patio covers, trellises, etc. may not be allowed. L. A notice explaining and providing a copy of a "Private Open Space Exhibit" and separate 8% inch by 11 inch dimensioned site plan for each unit that is allocated private open space within the common area. M. A notice explaining and providing a copy of the approved "Parking and Circulation Exhibit" and related CC&R provisions. N. A notice explaining that 241 affordable housing units will be dispersed throughout the site. These units will remain affordable for a period of forty- five (45) years or longer. O. A notice explaining the phasing of construction within the subdivision and that activity may be disruptive. P. The developer shall notify all homebuyers that future Resolution No. 05-40 Page 24 of 27 Assessment/Maintenance Districts may affect the property. Q. The project is located adjacent to a future fire station site at the southwest corner of Edinger Avenue and West Connector Road that will be operating 24 hours. ENVIRONMENTAL MITIGATION (1) 11.1 All mitigation measures related to the tentative tract map required by the adopted Mitigation Monitoring Program for the MCAS Tustin Reuse Plan/Specific Plan FEIS/EIR that are required by the Mitigation Monitoring Program for the project, identified in this exhibit and in other project entitlements, shall be implemented. (1) 11.2 As part of the final design process and to comply with the Final EIR/EIS requirements for the Disposal and Reuse of MCAS Tustin, the applicant shall submit detailed hydrology calculations of 100 -year storm events for the existing pre -project condition and for the project condition. As part of the study, the projects contribution to the overall increase in stormwater runoff from the redevelopment of MCAS Tustin shall be estimated and the potential design and construction costs to mitigate the increase storm water discharge contribution from the project shall be determined. PARKS AND RECREATION (1) 12.1 The applicant shall at its sole cost and expense comply with the Quimby Act, California Government Code Section 66477 and shall as a condition precedent to issuance of building permits for the vertical improvements or any portion thereof. Developer's Quimby Act fee obligations shall be in the amount of a cash payment for the net required parkland requirements in the tract equal to a net acreage of 3.20 acres, or as adjusted by approved final map, times an appraised value of land for the tract as approved by the City pursuant to City Code Section 2.7 and 3.11.18 of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan minus . the improvement cost for the development of on-site private parkland approved for parkland credit in an amount based on improvement plans and cost approved in writing by the Director of Parks and Recreation Department not to exceed $675,000 per acre. In order to secure developer's obligations pursuant to the Quimby Act, developer shall be required to post a performance bond complying with City Code Section 9931(d) in favor of the City, with the Surety in a form and substance acceptable to the City Attorney equal to total of 8.83 acres times an appraised value of land in the tract as approved by the City pursuant to City Code Section 9931(d), which performance bond shall be decreased upon compliance by the applicant with the provisions of clauses (A) and (B) below. Resolution No. 05-40 Page 25 of 27 A) As part of the initial phase of the project and concurrently with construction of the required horizontal improvements and as part of the common area improvements, the applicant shall construct within the common area certain contiguous, landscaped, open space facilities of not less than one acre in area in the location as depicted on the preliminary plan and the approved project plans and including improvements as required by the Tustin Code to quality for Quimby Fee waiver (park facilities) that shall be open and accessible to the public. Upon completion of the park facilities and as a condition precedent to issuance of any partial or final certificate of compliance the developer shall execute and record a perpetual easement or other dedication agreement in favor of the City and its successors and assigns, inform and subject acceptable to the City in its sole discretion upon final map and the acceptance of conditions, covenants, and restrictions (CCBRs) for the benefit of the public providing in perpetuity and at no cost to the City. (i) the right of the public to access and use the Park Facilities; (ii) public access to and from said Park Facilities along and across public and private streets within the site; and (Iii) maintenance of the Park Facilities by the Developer and its successor and assigns, in each case subject only to reasonable and non- discriminatory rules and regulations. Upon (x) completion of such Regulations applicable thereto, and (y) recordation of an easement or dedication agreement approved by the City, the City shall provide a credit to the developer against its obligation to pay Quimby Act Fees in the amount of 3.66 acres times an appraised value of the land for the tract. klmw B) Waiver for Affordable Housing. The developer shall receive a credit against Quimby Act fees otherwise due and payable by it as permitted by the City Code Section 9931 in connection with construction of not to exceed 241 Affordable Housing Units in this tract in an amount not to exceed 1.97 acres times an appraised value of land; provided, however, that the benefit of such waiver shall apply with respect to each Affordable Housing Unit only upon Completion of all Affordable Housing Units in the Phase in which such Unit is located. (1) 12.2 The Developer shall accommodate, at various locations on the Developer Parcel as approved by Community Development, pedestrian and bicycle connections to the regional bike trail to be constructed in the future along Edinger Avenue, Valencia Avenue, and the West Connector and Class II bicycle trails as depicted on the Preliminary Plan. The final tract map shall include a perpetual easement in favor of the City, its successors and assigns, in form and substance acceptable to the City in its sole discretion and at no cost to the City, providing pedestrian and bicycle access to the public upon and across the full length of any foregoing pedestrian and bicycle connections on the Developer Parcel as they connect to adjoining bike paths. Notwithstanding the foregoing, the Developer and its successors and assigns shall retain responsibility for maintenance and Resolution No. 0540 Page 26 of 27 repair of the foregoing pedestrian and bicycle connections constructed on the Developer Parcel. FEES (1) 13.1 The applicant shall submit to the City of Tustin any additional CCBR Review fee required at the time of submittal. The CC&R Review fee Includes one initial check and recheck of the document. If subsequent review is required, an hourly fee of $150 per hour (or rate in effect at the time of submittal) for the City Attorney and $50 per hour (or rate in effect at the time of submittal) for the Planning Staff is required. (1) 13.2 Prior to issuance of the first building permit, the subdivider shall submit in - lieu parkland dedication fees in an amount and form as required by the Director of the Parks and Recreation Department. (1) 13.3 The applicant shall submit all fees required by the City and other agencies as identified in Planning Commission Resolution No. 3953. Resolution No. 05-40 Page 27 of 27 RESOLUTION NO. 06-17 A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF TUSTIN APPROVING FINAL TRACT MAP 16581 TO SUBDIVIDE 105,5 ACRES INTO 383 NUMBERED LOTS AND 192 LETTERED LOTS FOR DEVELOPMENT OF 1,077 RESIDENTIAL UNITS The City Council of the City of Tustin does hereby resolve as follows: I. The City Council finds and determines as follows: A. Final Tract Map 16581 was submitted by Moffett Meadows Partners LLC requesting subdivision of a 105,5 acre site into 383 numbered lots and 192 lettered lots for developing 1,077 residential units within Planning Areas 4 and 5 of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan; B. The Planning Commission recommended that the City Council approve Tentative Tract 16581 on February 14, 2005, and the City Council approved Tentative Tract 16581 on February 22,2005; -- C. The City Engineer has determined that Final Map 16581 is in substantial conformance with the requirements of the Tustin General Plan, MCAS Tustin Specific Plan, State Subdivision Map Act, the City's Subdivision Code, and has been determined to be consistent with the Air Quality Sub - Element; D. The site is located in Planning Areas 4 and 5 of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan, which is designated for Low Density and Medium Density Residential use; E. The City Council finds that requiring the developer to include a separate exhibit for each unit that is allocated private open space in the homebuyer notification is in substantial compliance with Condition 9,1 (H) of Resolution No, 05-40 of Tentative Map approval. F. Final subdivision maps are statutorily exempt pursuant to Section 15268 of California Code of Regulations, Title 14, and the City Council has adopted Resolution No, 05-38 finding that the potential environmental impacts of Tentative Tract Map 16581 have been adequately addressed with FEIS/EIR for the MCAS Tustin Reuse Plan and Specific Plan, II. The City Council hereby approves Final Tract Map 16581 for the subdivision of a 105,5 -acre site into 383 numbered lots and 192 lettered lots for development of 1,077 residential units, subject to final approval by the City Engineer prior to recordation, Resolution No. 06-17 Page 1 of 2 PASSED AND ADOPTED at a regular meeting of the City Council of the City of Tustin held on the 6th day of February 2006. A ATTEST: R -1 PMLA STOKER, City Clerk STATE OF CALIFORNIA ) COUNTY OF ORANGE ) SS CITY OF TUSTIN ) I, Pamela Stoker, City Clerk and ex -officio Clerk of the City Council of the City of Tustin, California, do hereby certify that the whole number of the members of the City Council of the City of Tustin Is five; that the above and foregoing Resolution No. 06-17 was duly passed and adopted at a regular meeting of the Tustin City Council, held on the 6t' day of February, 2006 by the following vote: COUNCILMEMBER AYES: DAVERT, HACEN, AMANTE, BONE, KAWASHIMA (5) COUNCILMEMBER NOES: Dtna,� rn, COUNCILMEMBER ABSTAINED: rni COUNCILMEMBER ABSENT: NONE (0) wmdl PAMELA STOKER, City Clerk Resolution No. 06-17 Page 2 of 2 ORDINANCE NO. 1297 AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF TUSTIN, ADOPTING ZONE CHANGE 04-003 TO PERMIT THE DEVELOPMENT OF DETACHED CARRIAGE WAY SINGLE FAMILY DWELLING UNITS IN PLANNING AREAS 4 AND 5 AND ESTABLISH RELATED DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS AND AMEND THE REQUIREMENT FOR A 10 -ACRE MINIMUM DEVELOPMENT SITE FOR CONDOMINIUMS AND MULTIPLE FAMILY DWELLINGS IN MCAS TUSTIN PLANNING AREA 4 The City Council of the City of Tustin does hereby resolve as follows: Section 1. FINDINGS The City Council finds and determines as follows: A. That Moffett Meadows Partners, LLC submitted a proper application for Specific Plan Amendment/Zone Change 04-003 to allow development of detached carriage way single family dwelling units within Planning Areas 4 and 5 for the purpose of providing an alternative to the traditional single family detached product without compromising the density and development standards for single family residences and to allow development of condominium projects on development sites that are less than ten (10) acres. B. That a public hearing was duly called, noticed, and held on said application on January 24, 2005, and continued to February 14, 2005, by the Planning Commission. C. That a public hearing was duly called, noticed, and held on said application on February 7, 2005, and continued to February 22, 2005, by the City Council. D. That Zone Change 04003 would apply to Planning Areas 4 and 5 of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan within the City of Tustin. E. That the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan does not set forth standards for "carriage way units" and the standards for carriage way units are proposed as an alternative to the traditional single family detached product and are accessed from a rear alley instead of a street, which provides for a neo- traditional streetscape of residences with garages to the rear of the residences. These types of single family detached units should be permitted Ordinance No. 1297 Page 1 of 24 within Planning Areas 4 and 5 since the development standards would be identical to those for single family detached units, with the exception of the minimum rear yard setback, which would be reduced from ten (10) feet to seven (7) feet for living space and three (3) feet for garage space since access to the garage for these units would be located at the rear of the property. F. That the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan sets forth a minimum development site size of ten (10) acres for condominiums and multiple family dwellings. However, it is appropriate to allow condominiums and multiple family developments to contain numerous lots or sites and be designated as a development unit on a tentative map with a minimum development unit size of eight (8) acres. A development unit, as defined by the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan, consists of all building sites, their private open space, common recreation and open space areas, and public and/or private streets serving the project. A minimum of eight (8) acres in a development unit would ensure that these types of products are located in developments of substantial size and will result in orderly, rather than fragmented, development. G. The proposed zone change supports and is consistent with the Tustin General Plan. The Land Use Element includes the City's goals and policies for the long-term growth, development, and revitalization of Tustin. Based on the summary of issues, needs, opportunities, and constraints described in the Tustin Land Use Element, ten goals are identified which Include the following: 1. Achieve balanced development. 2. Ensure that compatible and complementary development occurs. 3. Revitalize older commercial, industrial, and residential development. 4. Improve City-wide urban design. 5. Promote economic expansion and diversification. 6. Coordinate development with provision of adequate public facilities and services. 7. Implement a reuse plan for MCAS Tustin which maximizes the appeal of the site as a mixed-use, master planned development. These goals establish the framework for policies related to allocation of land use in the City and the implementation policies reflect the direction and image the City seeks for the future. The proposed Zone Change supports several General Plan goals and policies, including the following: 1. The project will implement policies under the goal to achieve balanced development including: Ordinance No. 1297 Page 2 of 24 a. Policy 1.10 — Ensure that the distribution and intensity of land uses are consistent with the Land Use Plan and classification system. b. Policy 6.2 — Encourage and promote high quality design and physical appearance in all development projects. C. Policy 6.4 — Preserve and enhance the City's, Special residential character and "small town" quality by encouraging and maintaining Tustin's low density residential neighborhoods through enforcement of existing land use and property development standards and the harmonious blending of buildings and landscape. 2. The project will implement policies under the goals and policies for future development of MCAS Tustin Specific Plan including: a. Policy 13.2 — Encourage a development pattern that offers a connectedness between buildings and uses, and has a strong sense of place through architectural styles and creative landscape design. b. Policy 13.5 — Promote high quality architecture, landscaping, signage, open space design, circulation patterns, and landscape patterns distinct from surrounding areas. Section 2. The City Council hereby adopts Zone Change (MCAS Tustin Specific l Plan Amendment) 04-003 ("Zone Change") to amend Sections 3.4.2 and 3.4.3 of the MCAS Tustin Speck Plan to establish new development standards for carriage way units in Planning Areas 4 and 5 and minimum development site for condominium units in Planning Area 4 of MCAS Tustin Specific Plan. Section 3. SEVERABILITY All of the provisions of this ordinance shall be construed together to accomplish the purpose of the regulations. If any provision of this part is held by a court to be invalid or unconstitutional, such invalidity or unconstitutionality shall apply only to the particular facts, or if a provision is declared to be invalid or unconstitutional as applied to all facts, all of the remaining provisions of this ordinance shall continue to be fully effective. PASSED AND ADOPTED by the City Council of the City of Tustin, at a regular meeting on the 7th day of March , 2005. LOU BONE Mayor Ordinance No. 1297 Page 3 of 24 ATTEST: W(fflu 11010"� pm 10107r, 04 at", a r_ eKERCity Clerk STATE OF CALIFORNIA ) COUNTY OF ORANGE ) SS CITY OF TUSTIN ) I, Pamela Stoker, City Clerk of the City of Tustin, California hereby certify that the foregoing is a full, true and correct copy of the Ordinance introduced at a regular meeting of the City Council of the City of Tustin duly held on February 22, 2005, of which meeting all of the members of said City Council had due notice and at which a majority thereof were present; and was finally passed and adopted not less than five days thereafter on March 7, 2005, by the following vote: COUNCILMEMBER AYES: COUNCILMEMBER NOES: COUNCILMEMBER ABSTAINED: COUNCILMEMBER ABSENT: ia"a A I FOWN"I'llp-15-•• City Clerk Ordinance No. 1297 Page 4 of 24 BONE, DAVERT, AMANTE, HAGEN, KAWASHIMA (5) NONE NODE. (0 ) NONE (0) EXHIBIT A Ordinance No. 1297 Page 5 of 24 EXHIBIT A TO ORDINANCE NO. 1297 ZONE CHANGE 04-003 The following changes to the WAS Tustin Specific Plan shown in underlined text represent the proposed amendment in Zone Change 04-003: 3.1.1 Planning Area 4 - Loa Density Residential A. Permitted and Conditionally Permitted Uses The following uses shall be permitted by right where the symbol "P" occurs or by conditional use permit where the symbol "C" occurs. • Community care facilities for six or fewer persons P • Condominiums and cooperatives P Family caro home, foster home or group home, for six or P fewer persons • Large family day care for seven to twelve children on P single family detached lots in accordance with the Tustin City Code • Multiple -family dwelling units (apartments) in C accordance with tenure provisions in Section 3.4.2.0 • Residential care facility for elderly, for six or fewer P Paws • Single-family attached dwelling units and duplexes P • Single-family detached dwelling units P • Single family detached carriage way units E • Small family day care for less than seven children on P single family detached lots B. Accessory Uses and Structures Accessory uses and structures are permitted when customarily associated with and subordinate to a permitted use on the same site and would include: • Carports • 0aragcs • Home occupations subject to provisions of the. City Code • Patio covers/trellises • Swimming pools, spas, jacuzzis • Tennis courts, basketball courts and other multipurpose courts, recreation and community buildings C. Unlisted Uses Those uses not specifically listed are subject to a determination by the Community Development Director as either permitted, permitted subject to a conditional use permit or prohibited consistent with the purpose of the land Ordinance No. 1297 . Page 6. of 24 0 designation of this planning area and the Specific Plan. Decisions of the Director are appealable to the Planning Commission. D. Site Development Standards - Single Family Detached 1. Maximum dwelling units - 7 dwelling units per acre 2. Minimum lot area - 3,000 square feet 3. Minimum lot width - 35 feet 4. Maximum building height - 35 feet S. Maximum lot coverage - 50 percent of lot ani. Covered areas shall include all. areas under roof .except trellis areas, roof overhangs, and covered porches outside the exterior wall. 6. Minimum building setbackst a) Edinger Avenue - 40 feet b) Local public scrod -10 feet c) Private strut or private drive - S fed d) Interior side yard , 3 fat minimum with aggregate requirement of 10 feet for both side yards e) Rear yard - 10 feet 7. Landscape setbaclaO a) Edinger Avenue - 30 feet S. Landscaping a) Areas not devoted to buildings, parking areas, hardscape, and roads, shall be landscaped. b) Compliance with the City of Tustin Landscape and Irrigation Guidelines c) Compliance with the Landscape Design Guidelines in Section 2.17 of this Specific Plan 9. Bicycle and pedestrian circulation facilities shall provide connections within the Planning Area, to adjacent Planning Areas, and to citywide bicycle trails where applicable. 10. Fences and Walls a)_ Compliance with Oenetal.Regulations Section 3.11. b) A masonry block wall shall be maintained and/or constructed slang the western perimeter of the Planning Area in accordance with the General Development Regulations. 11. Other General Development Regulations (refer to Section 3.11 as applicable) 12. Signage (refer to Section 3.12 as applicable) 13. Off-street parking (refer to Section 3.13 as applicable) LwAscape setbacb we masutod from the back of the curb asd aro a combination of parkway, sidewalk. and plasdna arae. Suildiss setba b are mastred Som fen ftld- f -way. Non-caadormina'landscW sad builclina ndmb will be parndtled to menain to mommodsle a ishan wells or boildkW not In firtwe right- of-way. Ordinance No. 1297 Pape 7 of 24 E. Site Development Standards — Carriage Way Units !! } }! !!! 1ITT=1' r -- 4. Maximum building heiW9 - 35 fat 5. !! 1} lot cMMM 1 .WM 1 1 am, 1XMMd gmas shall iftcludc_ WMA undcrroof excaut WES ffeas.roof 1 1 } j: }1 6. hfi1 11 1! 1 '1 1 e .' Edinger Avenue 1 Net ') Local yublic sum 1 feet Prhmte•'i.l or 4f 'll ♦5 fed X11' Li_►' 1 Int9dor side'mud N }.. 1! J'! with AgWgggmuircment1 10 feet for both 1,- 33ah livinga) Rear 33W — 3 feet for &=a -and 7 feet for 113dag area including labove ungg = Luxtu apa aatbacb aro mcuumd fmm the bads of dw mb and am a eambinadw of parkway, $Www k and plaatiog arem Building utbadw aro mmaumd ftom famm ril;Wof-way. Noll- ¢aafbrming laadteape and bulMing setbacks will be Permitted to remain to aecooallodate axiaa'slg wrllb or building aot in Ntuea righaof•way. Ordinance No. 1297 Page 8 of 24 11. Homes that side -on to a local road shall incorporate arc itectuml ad a wmr nts on the side and front view of the unit s seen from the lel fes. - — 12. End units — a nrttnimum back un mace of ftu (31 fet_f_ in addition to the width of the drive Unroach. 13. Qhf er General Develon=_ Regulations (refer to Section 3.11 as apolicablel 14. Sitmaae (_dtto Section 3.12 as gpp i le) 15. Off-street narkina (refer to Section 3.13 am atmlicahle to Cinalp FAms1w F. Site Development Standards - Single Family Attached I. Maximum dwelling units - 7 dwelling units per acre 2. Minimum lot area per family unit - 3,000 square feet 3. Minimum lot width - no minimum 4. Maximum building height - 35 feet 5. Maximum lot coverage - 100 percent less required setbacks and open space areas 6. Common open space - 400 square feet per dwelling unit located within common, designated recreational areas. Private attached ground level patios may be credited if open on throe sides. Areas not available for open space credit include all structures, streets, driveways, landscape setbacks, and parking lots. 7. Private outdoor open space - minimum private outdoor open space shall be increased to 400 square feet for existing units. S. Minimum gross floor area per dwelling unit, excluding the gam: a) Bachelor - 450 square feet b) 1 Bedroom - 550 square feet c) 1 Bedroom with den - 700 square feet d) 2 Bedrooms - 750 square feet e) 2 Bedroom or more with den - 900 square feet 9. Minimum building setbacks3 a) Edinger Avenue - 40 feat b) Local public atreet -10 feat c) Private street or private drive - 5 feet d) Interior side yard - 3 feet minimum with aggregate requirement of 10 feet for both side yards e) Rear yard -10 feet 10. Landscape setbacw Buildit Xd do are nraasored Isom future ri;hhof-way. Non-omformins Imdiape and building setimb will be permiteed to remain to accoauoodde cdsfts walls or buildings not in famm rig "&way. ` LandseW setbacks arc measured from the back of the nub and are a combiturice of parkway. silk and planthag area:. Non.00nfixminl; landxape and building setbacb will be permitted to remain to aaommodate existing walls or buildir gs not In !inure righkW-way. Ordinance No. 1297 _Page _?of 24 a) Edinger Avenue - 30 feet 11. Landscaping a) Areas not devoted to buildings, parking areas, bardwape, and roads, shall be landscaped. b) Compliance with the City of Tustin Landscape and Irrigation Guidelines C) Compliance with the Landscape Design Guidelines in Section 2.17 of this Specific Flan 12- Bicycle and pedestrian circulation facilities shall provide connections within the Planning Area, to adjacent Planning Areas, and to citywide bicycle trails where applicable. 13. Fences and Walls a) Compliance with General Regulations Section 3.11. b) A masonry block wall sha11 be maintained and/or constructed along the western perimeter of the Planning Area in accordance with the General Development Regulations. 14. Other General Developn►ent Regulations (refer to Section 3.11 as applicable) 15. Signage (refer to Section 3.12 as applicable) 16. Off-street packing (refer to Section 3.13 as applicable) G. Site Development Standards - Condominiums and Multiple Family Dwellings 1. Maximum dwelling units - 7 dwelling units per acre 2. Minimum development site — g acres (minimnm heal lot size) 3. Maximum building height - 40 fat 4• Maximum lalpoet �e - 65 percent, less the required building 5. Common open space - 400 square feet per dwelling unit located within common, designated recreational areas. private attached ground level patios may be credited if open on three sides. Areas not available for open space credit include all structures, streets, driveways, landscape setbacks, and parking lots. 6. Private outdoor open space minimum private outdoor open space shall be increased to 400 square feet for existing units. 7. Minimum grass floor area per dwelling unit, excluding the PM90 a) Bachelor - 450 square feet b) 1 Bedroom - 550 square feet c) 1 Bedroom with den - 700 square feet d) 2 Bedrooms - 750 square feet e) 2 Bedrooms or more with den - 850 square feet Ordinance No. 1297 Page 10 of 24 8. Minimum building setbackss a) Edinger Avenue - 40 feet b) Local public street - 10 feet c) Private street or private drive - S feet d) Interior side yard - 3 feet minimum with aggregate requirement of 10 feet for both side yards e) Rear yard -10 feet 9. Landscape setbacks? a) Edinger Avenue - 30 fat 10. Landscaping a) Area not devoted to buildings, parking areas, hardscape, and roads, shall be landscaped. b) Compliance with the City of Tustin Landscape and Irrigation Guidelines c) Compliance with the Landscape Design Guidelines in Section 2.17 of this Specific Plan ll. Bicycle and pedestrian circulation facilities shall provide connections within the Planning Area, to adjacent Planning Areas, and to citywide bicycle trails where applicable. 12. Fences and Walls a) Compliance with General Regulations Section 3.11. b) A masonry block wall shall be maintained and/or constructed along the western perimeter of the Planning Area in accordance with the General Development Regulations. 13. Other General Development Regulations (refer to Section 3.11 4 w ' as applicable) 14. Signage (refer to Section 3.12 as applicable) 15. Off -stmt parking (refry to Section 3.13 as applicable) , IL Special Development or Reuse Requirements I - Concept plan approval shall be required for Planning Arca 4 prior to reuse or development (refer to Section 4.2.1 of this Specific Plan). 2. Development unit - Planting Area 4 shall be developed or redeveloped as a single development unit. 3. Affordability - The following minimum affordable housing production objectives are intended to reflect the intention of the City to create a redevelopment project area (Community Redevelopment Law, section 33000) and as needed to meet Regional Housing Allocation needs as identified in the Housing Element of the General Plan through the provision of S Lanndsape setbaeks aro meaairad f m the back of the curb and are a combination of parkway, sidewalk and planting areas. Buil ft setbacks am meanned fhom future right -0f -way. Non. conforating landscw and building se&wb will be permitted to remain to weammodwe existi ft walls or buildinp not is fipm , right -of -array. Ordinance No. 1297 Page 11 of 24 housing for households at very low, low, and moderate incomes levels. Specific housing requirements for redevelopment and Housing Element compliance will be established at the time of development project approval to ensure uniformity with the Housing Element of the General Plan and other applicable provisions of California Law and to achieve the following: a) At least 15% of units for initial occupancy by very low income to moderate income households for redevelopment, with 6% (or 401/6) of units affordable to very low income households. b) At least 38 additional units for occupancy by low income households. C) At least 15 additional units for occupancy by moderate income households. d) Restricted affordable housing units shall be reasonably dispersed throughout the project and shall be compatible with the design and use of market rate units in appearance, use of materials, and finished quality. Restricted units shalt be affordable for at least the minimum period of time required by state law, or longer if required by a construction or mortgage financing assistance program. C) Prior to issuance of a certificate of use and occupancy, a developer shall enter into a legally binding. agreement with the City of Tustin or its Redevelopment Agency, and agree to deed restrictions on targeted affordable housing units that aro binding on property upon sale or transfer. Said agreements shall address die following: 1) Number of units by type, location, bedroom count 2) Standards for qualif�dng income and maximum rents or sales prices 3) Parties responsible for sales prices and incomes f) The City of Tustin reserves the right to negotiate transfer of a developer's obligation pursuant to this section off- site as a credit for affordable units which cannot be reasonably feasible to provide on-site which shall be at the City's sole and absolute discretion. To earsure comparable equivalent value of an off-site option or exchange for not providing on-site affordable units, a financial affordability gap analysis will be conducted by the City, at developer's cost, to compare the value of the off-site option and the affordability gap cost of providing on-site affordable housing. Ordinance No. 1297 Page 12 of 24 4. Tenure - Reuse/development in Planning Area 4 shall be preferably ownership tenure. Development of apartments is a discretionary action :squiring approval of a conditional use permit. Consideration of a conditional use permit should include the Cites preference for ownership tenure, and in any event, nd more than 25 percent of the total number of units permitted within the City of Tustin portion of the Specific Plan may be approved for apartments. 5. Existing 3UW= to be reused shall be brought into conformance with applicable provisions of the Uniform Building Code as amended by the City, State of California Title 24 Access Compliance (handicapped provisions), and requirements of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). 6. Utility metering modifications and/or provision of independent utility services shall be committed to by agreement between the City of Tustin and those agencies receiving property in the PA 4 prior to use and occupancy of existing buildings and/or new development. Said agreement shall identify required capital/infrastructure improvements and environmental impact report mitigations. [. Development or Reuse Galdanes 1. Existing housing units shall be aesthetically upgraded through architectural and landscape improvements to appear consistent m quality with private market housing in the surrounding neighborhoods of Tustin and Irvine. Such improvements shall be completed prior to issuance of use and occupancy permits. The improvements may include, but are not limited to, the following: a) Upgraded facade treatments, including use of plaster or stucco, wood siding, brick, stone, and other approved materials b) Upgraded window types and treaunents (i.e. trim) C) Upgraded roofing materials and extension of roof overhangs d) Updated color scheme for buildings and walls e) Enhancement of private patios and balconies 0 Upgraded appearance of unit entrances, including doorways, walkways, decorative paving g) Improved landscape design of front yards and common areas h) Consistent landscape treatment along local roads i) Extensive planting of trees and shrubs throughout the site j) Decorative treatment of all exposed site walls k) Upgraded driveways Ordinance No. 1297 Page 13 of 24 1) Decorative paving and other bardscape amenities for Pedestrian paths in common areas M) Improvements to common recreational areas including provision of shelters, lighting, and refurbishing of facilities n) Creation of project entryways through signage and landscape design o) Upgraded and consistent signage, including project identification, addressing, and directional signs P) Enhanced lighting scheme for units, common areas, Pte, and Parldng areas q) Application of defensible space techniques in landscaping and lighting 2. The existing boundary wall along Edinger Avenue shall be aesthetically improved with stucco or other facade treatment, color, and a decorative wall cap, as shown in the example below. wr.�.✓swMrs % - iA1►vd+'! •��Nw. u+�tt • -J. 3. In the event that infill development shall occur, the following guidelines shall apply: a) Consistency with scale massing, and setbacks of existing structures. b) Compliance with reuse guidelines that pertain to the surrounding structures. c) Compliance with appropriate landscape and parking . standards. 4. Demolition of shucmm may be as required by Tustin to be undertaken under the following conditions: 1) when information determines the need for demolition to eliminate public health and safety risks, 2) to improve the appearance of the Planning Area, 3) to accommodate the completion of major roadway improvements, and 4) to properly implement the land use intent of this Planning Area. Ordinance No. 1297 Page 14 of 24 A sununary of the key design guidelines for the Low Density Residential Planing Area is provided in Figure 3-4. Ordinance No. 1297 Page 15 of 24 3.1.1 Planning Area S - Mediam Density Residential A. Permitted and Conditionally Permitted Uses The following uses shall be permitted by right where the symbol "P" occurs or by conditional use permit where the symbol "C" occurs. • Churches and other religious institutions C • Community care facilities for six or fewer persons P • Condominiums and cooperatives P • Convalescent hospital C • Family care home, foster home or group home, for six or P fewer persons • Large family day care for seven to twelve children on P single family detached lots in accordance with the Tustin City Code • Multiple -family dwelling units (apartments) in C accordance with tenure provisions in Section 3.4.3.H • Patio homes P • Private school C • Public or private preschools C • Fire Station P • Publictprivate utility building facility C • Residential care facility for elderly, for six or fewer P Persons • Single-family attached dwelling units and duplexes P • Single-family detached dwelling units P • CarriaQe Way units E -.01 • Small family day care for less than seven children on P single family detached lots B. Accessory Uses and Structures Accessory uses and structures are permitted when customarily associated with and subordinate to a permitted use on the same site and would include: • Carports • Garages • Home occupations subject to provisions of the City Code • Patio covers/trellises • Swimming pools, spas, jacuzzis Tennis courts, basketball courts and other multi-purpose courts, recreation and community buildings C. Unlisted Uses Those uses not specifically listed are subject to a determination by the Community Development Director as either permitted, permitted subject to a conditional use Ordinance No. 1297 Page 16 of 24 permit or prohibited consistent with the purpose of the land designation of this planning area and the Specific Plan. Decisions of the Director are appealable to the Planning Commission. D. Site Development Standards - Single Family Detached I. Maximum dwelling units - IS dwelling units per acre 2. Minimum lot area - 3,000 square feet 3. Minimum lot width - 35 feet 4. Maximum building height - 35 feet 5. Maximum lot coverage - 50 percent of lot area. Covered areas shall include all areas under roof except trellis areas, roof overhangs,' and covered porches outside the exterior wall. 6. Minimum building setbacksl a) North Loop Road - 25 feet b) West Connector - 20 feet c) Local public street -10 feet d) Private street or private drive - 5 feet e) Interior side yard - 3 feet minimum with aggregate requirement of 10 feet for both side yards f) Rear yard -10 feet 7. Landscape setbacks' a) North Loop Road - 30 feet b) West Connector - 20 feet 8. Landscaping a) Compliance with the City of Tustin Landscape and Irrigation Guidelines b) Compliance with the Landscape Design Guidelines in Section 2.17 of this Specific Plan 9. Bicycle and pedestrian circulation facilities shall provide connections within the Planning Area, to adjacent Planning Areas, and to citywide bicycle trails where applicable. 10. A corner triangular-shaped setback of 60 feet, measured from the intersection of the curb lines at North Loop Road and Armstrong Avenue shall be provided for a secondary community intersection treatment (see Section 2.17 for landscape guidelines). 11. A portal intersection treatment shall be provided at Edinger Avenue and West Connector (see Section 2.17 for landscape guidelines). 12. Other General Development Regulations (refer to Section 3.11 as applicable) 13. Signage (refer to Section 3.12 as applicable) 14. Off-street parking (refer to Section 3.13 as applicable) E. Site Development Standards — Carriage Way Units Definition: A type of singjs family detac,�W pgg t that is loc&ftd on a miin,,.�, thirty-six (36) foot wide paved street with a ten (101foot parkway on both aides of the Raved portions of the street with a stage that is located to the rear of the Feed seO&W aro meaaued bom dw back of the curb and are a oomwmdoa of planting smae. Non-eoafonaLtg landscape and buiM ft setbacks will be permiaed to raneW to aoa►mpodaoe exisdag wells or buildiup not in huure righ"t-way. BWWWS setbacb are meaatred from fuhn right-of-wgY. Ordinance No. 1297 Page 17 of 24 residence and takes access from a reu two-way alley that is a minimum of twetm►- four (24Zfed wide. 1. Maximum dwelliniz units - 7 dwelUniz units per acre 2. Minimum lot ams3.000 aguare fed 3. „ } m _}} _ 4. Maximum buildim } t:t 5. Maximum lot covem2c - 50 2m= of 121 AM, Covaed AM shall jWude WI areas under i4• exceRl treflis areas. roof • -111.:. } `.. and covaed, 2grehes 6. Mini building setbw� b) Local Mjbfic sbvd - 10 fed • Interior nW feet minimum with ag=nte mguim=tgj 10 1 for both side yards e) Rear XW — 3 feet for gMgj and 7 feet for living areas including living amas •.• t 1 fronting 1: '.:Qm1•. i ' LmWsmpe sabaoks at: meaaued fan the bade of the cub and are a combisr tion of pwkW, skkwWk. W piauind areas SuIldlar setbaeb are mmnmd fora 6mm rldht.o6wsy. Non-wntormbn; landuape and bulUft sabacks will be parmioted to rumin to aarommodaw existiad walk or bufl&p oot In More rISM-o! way. Ordinance No. 1297 Page 18 of 24 _ _.. all �1.� •:i r. .!.' 1 �'l/ • : V• IMF• i. c.ii.. F. Site Development Standards - Single Family Attached 1. Maximum dwelling units -15 dwelling units per acre 2. Minimum lot area per family unit - 3,000 square feet 3. Minimum lot width - no minimum 4. Maximum building height - 35 feet 5. Maximum lot coverage - 100 percent less required setbacks and open space areas 6. Common open space - 400 square feet per dwelling unit located within common, designated recreational areas. Private attached ground level patios may be credited if open on three sides. Areas not available for open space credit include all structures, streets, driveways, landscape setbacks, and pwking lots. 7. Minimum gross floor area per dwelling unit, excluding the garage: a) Bachelor - 450 square feet b) l Bedroom - 550 square feet c) 1 Bedroom with den- 700 square feet d) 2 Bedrooms - 750 square feet e) 2 Bedrooms or more with den - 900 square feet 8. Minimum building setbacks a) North Loop Road - 25 feet b) West Connector - 20 feet c) Local public street -10 feet d) Private street or private drive - 5 feet e) Interior side yard - 3 feet minimum with aggregate requirement of 10 feet for both side yards f) Rear yard -10 feet 9. Landscape setbacks A) North Loop Road - 30 feet b) West Connector - 20 feet 10. Landscaping a) Compliance with the City of Tustin Landscape and Irrigation Guidelines b) Compliance with the Landscape Design Guidelines in Section 2.17 of this Specific Plan 11. Bicycle and pedestrian circulation facilities shall provide connections within the Planning Area, to adjacent Planning Areas, and to citywide bicycle trails where applicable. 12. A comer triangular-shaped setback of 60 feet, measured from the intersection of the curb lines at North Loop Road and Armstrong Avenue shall be Building setbacks aro maasttred Brom fhU n right-cf-way. Nonconforming landscape and building setback will be permitted to remain to accommodate existing walk or buikiinp not in future right-ofwny. Landscape sdbwb aro measured Crean dw back of the ewb and are a eombinatim of parkww, sidewalk, No plenums area Noweoml6rmima kndseape and buildim setbacb win be permitted to mnwo to memmmodw existing walk or beildinp not in lbonre right-of-way. Ordinance No. 1297 Pape 19 of 24 provided for a secondary community intersection treatment (see Section 2.17 for landscape guidelines). 13. A portal intersection treatment shall be provided at Edinger Avenue and West Connector (see Section 2.17 for landscape guidelines). 14. Other General Development Regulations (refer to Section 3.11 as applicable) 15. Signage (refer'to Section 3.12 as applicable) 16. Off-street parking (refer to Section 3.13 as applicable) G. Site Development Standards - Condominiums and Multiple Family Dwellings 1. Maximum dwelling units -15 dwelling units per acre 2. Minimum lot area - none, refer to Section 3.4.3.G. 3. Maximum building height - 40 feet 4. Maximum lot coverage - 65 percent, leas the required building and landscape setbacks 5. Common open spate - 400 square feet per dwelling unit located within common, designated recreational areas. Private attached ground level patios may be credited if open on three sides. Areas not available for open space credit include all structures, strew, driveways, landscape setbacks, and parking lots. 6. Minimum gross floor area per dwelling unit, excluding the garage a) Bachelor - 450 square feet b) 1 Bedroom - 550 square feet c) 1 Bedroom with den - 700 square feet d) 2 Bedrooms - 750 square feet e) 2 Bedrooms or more with den - 850 square feet 7. Minimum building setbacks' a) North Loop Road - 25 feet b) West Connector - 20 feet c) Local public street -10 feet d) Private street or private drive - 5 feet e) Interior side yard - 3 feet minimum with aggregate requirement of 10 feet for both side yards f) Rear yard -10 feet 8. Landscape setbacks" a) North Loop Road - 30 feet b) West Connector - 20 feet 9. Landscaping a) Compliance with the City of Tustin Landscape and Irrigation Guidelines b) Compliance with the Landscape Design Guidelines in Section 2.17 of this Specific Plan 10. Bicycle and pedestrian circulation facilities shall provide connections within the Planning Area, to adjacent Planning Areas, and to citywide bicycle trails when applicable. s LandsaWc sot mb am moanuad from the bock of the curb and are a combination of parkway, sidewalk. and plaming areas. Building setbacks am measured from future right.of--way. Nontordorming landscape and building setbacks will be permitted to remain to acooromodara mbftg walls or buildings not in R*m right-of-way. Ordinance No: 1297 Page 20 of 24 I 1. A corner triangular-shaped setback of 60 feet, measamd from the intersection of the curb- lines at North Loop Road and Armstrong Avenue shall be Provided for a secondary community intersection treatamU (see Section 2.17 for landscape guidelines). 12. A portal intersection treshu t shall be provided at Edinger Avenue and West Connector (see Section 2.17 for landscape guidelines). 13. Other General Development Regulations (refer to Section 3.11 as applicable) 14. Signage (refer to Section 3.12 as applicable) 15. Off-street parking (refer to Section 3.13 as applicable) A. Site Development Standards - Patio Homes I - Maximum dwelling units -15 dwelling units per acre 2. Minimum lot area - none, refer to Subsection 3.4.3.11 below 3. Building site requirements - patio home subdivisions shall be designated as a development unit on a tentative map. 4. Maximum building height - 35 feet 5. Maximum lot coverage - 100 percent, less required building and landscape setbacks 6. Common open space - 400 square feet per dwelling unit located within common, designated recreational areas. A minimum of 150 square fed may be for private use if located on ground level and open on three sides. Areas not available for open space credit include all structures, streets, driveways, landscape setbacks, and parking lots. 7. Minimum gross floor area per dwelling unit, excluding the garage - 900 square feet 8. Maximum number of four bedroom units - 30 percent ,loop 9. Minimum building 3etbacks6 a) North Loop Road - 25 feet b) West Connector - 20 fed c) Local public or private street - 'The minimum building setback shall be 10 feet from a public or private strod. An attached or detached garage may be setback a minimum of 5 fed from a public or private street. if living areas are provided above garages, garage setbacks shall apply provided that no more than 75 percent of the units along the street frontage have living space over a garage with less than a 10 foot setback. All units located along both sides of a street segment shall be included when calculating the above 75 percent determination, regardless of whether they fron4 side, or rear load an that section of a street. A garage shall not be setback. between 9 feet and 19 feet from the right-of-way line. Garages setback 9 feet or kss shall be equipped with an automatic garage opener. d) Private drives and courts - The minimum building setback shall be 7 feet in a private court or on a private drive not located within a court An attached or detached garage may be setback a minimum of 3 feet Bundins sefteks are moored tkm ibtum tiSk-ot-wnY• Noa.eonfarming lendacape and bonding setbacks will be Permitted to remain to WMMModate existing wails or buildup not in Amm ritio-of-way. Ordinance No. 1297 Page 21 of 24 provided that no more than 50 percent of the length of the building frontage over the total length of the drive or court is setback less than 7 feet. In calculating the total length of the drive or court and the length of building frontage, the length of building and street fiontage on both sides of the drive or court shall be used. If living areas are provided above garages, garage setback shall apply. The minimum 3 foot garage setback shall be increased where necessary to accommodate required sidewalks. A garage shall not be setback between 9 feet and 19 feet from the right-of-way line. Garages setback 9 feet or less shall be equipped with an automatic garage opener. A minimum distance of 40 feet shall be maintained between ground floor living areas on units across from each other in a court, on a drive, or on a shared driveway. e) Minimum distance between buildings - The minimum horizontal distance between adjacent buildings shall be 10 feet. The minimum distance between buildings may be reduced to 6 feet for no more than a maximum length of 25 feet of a building elevation, provided that there are no windows on one elevation for that portion of the building elevation with less than a 10 foot setback. If living areas are provided above garages, garage setbacks shall apply. f) Tract boundary - The minimum building setback from any tract boundary shall be 10 feet. If the tract boundary is adjacent to a park or other permanent open space, the minimum building setback shall be 5 feet. 10. Landscape setbacks' a) North Loop - 30 fat b) West Connector - 20 feet ll. Landscaping a) Compliance with the City of Tustin Landscape and Irrigation Guidelines b) Compliance with the Landscape Design Guidelines in Section 2.17 of this Specific Plan 12. Bicycle and pedestrian circulation facilities shall provide connections within the Planning Area, to adjacent Planning Areas, and to citywide bicycle trails where applicable. 13. A corner triangular-shaped setback of 60 feet, measured from the intersection of the curb lines at North Loop Road and Armstrong Avenue shall W provided for a secondary community intersection treatment (see Section 2.17 for landscape guidelines). 14. A portal intersection treatment shall be provided at Edinger Avenue and West Connector (see Section 2.17 for landscape guidelines). 15. Other General Development Regulations (refer to Section 3.11 as applicable) 16. Signage (refer to Section 3.12 as applicable) 17. Off-street parking (refer to Section 3.13 as applicable) ' Landscape setbacks are mawred from the back of the curb and we a combination of parkway, sidewalk. trod planting ares. Non-eonfotmimS landscape amd buikaea sedmeb will be permitted to rands to wommmodata c daing walls or buildings not in !haus riaitt-of-way. Ordinance No. 1257 Page 22 of 24 I. Special Development Requirements I. Concept plan approval shall be required for Planning Area 5 prior to development (refer to Section 4.2.1 of this Specific Plan). 2. Affordability — The following minimum affordable housing production objectives are intended to reflect the intention of the City to create a redevelopment project arca (Community Redevelopnlem Law, section 33000) and as needed to meet Regional Housing Allocation needs as identified in the Housing Element of the General Plan through the provisions of housing for households at very low, low and moderate income levels. Specific housing requirements for redevelopment and Housing Element compliance will be established at the time of development project approval to ensure uniformity with the Housing Element of the General Plan and other applicable provisions of California Law and to achieve the following: a) At least 15% of units for initial occupancy by very low income to moderate income households for redevelopment, with 6% (or 40%) of units affordable to very low income households. b) At least 38 additional units for occupancy by low income households. c) At least 16 additional units for occupancy by moderate income households. d) Restricted affordable housing units shall be reasonably dispersed throughout the project and shall be compatible with the design and use of market rate units in appearance, use of materials, and finished quality. Restricted units shall be affordable for at least the minimum period of tine required by state law, or longer if required by a construction or mortgage financing assistance program. e) Prior to issuance of a certificate of use and occupancy, a developer shall enter into a legally binding agreement with the City of Tustin or its Redevelopment Agency, and agree to deed restrictions 'on targeted affordable housing units that are binding on property upon sale or transfer. Said agreements shall address the following: I) Number of units by type, logon, bedroom count 2) Standards for qualifying income and maximum rents or sales prices 3) Parties responsible for sales prices and incomes f) The City of Tustin reserves the right to negotiate transfer of a developer's obligation pursuant to this section off-site as a credit for affordable units which cannot be reasonably feasible to provide on-site which shall be at the City's sole and absolute discretion. To ensue comparable equivalent value of an of -site option or exchange for not providing on-site affordable units, a financial affordability gap analysis will be conducted by the City, at developer's cost, to compare the value of the off-site option and the affordability gap cost of providing on-site affordable.housing. 3. Tenure - Development in Planning Area S of apartments is a discretionary action requiring approval of a conditional use permit. In considering a conditional use permit,. no more than 25 percent of the total number of units Ordinance No. 1297 _Page 23_of.24._ permitted within the Tustin portion of the Specific Pian area may be approved for apartments. 4. Condominiums and multiple family development may contain numerous lots, but shall be designated as a development unit on a tentative map. The minimum size for a development unit shall be 10 acres. J. Development Guidelines 1. Buildings should be staggered along North Loop Road to provide variety along the streetscape. 2. The use of sound walls should be minimized through building site location. 3. Demolition of structures may be required by Tustin to be undertaken under the following conditions: 1) where information determines the need for demolition to eliminate public health and safety risks, 2) to improve the appearance of the Planning Area, 3) to accommodate the completion of major roadway improvements, and 4) to properly implement the land use intent of this Planning Area. A summary of the key design guidelines for the Medium Density Residential Planning Area is provided in Figure 34. Ordinance No. 1297 Page 24 of 24 Attachment E First Amendment to Housing kl- Agreement for Columbus Square FIRST AMENDMENT TO HOUSING AGREEMENT FOR COLUMBUS SQUARE This First Amendment to the Housing Agreement for Columbus Square (the "First Amendment"), is entered into as of , 2009 the ("Effective Date"), by and between the City of Tustin ("City"), a municipal corporation and Moffett Meadows Partners, LLC, a Delaware Limited Liability Company ("Developer"). The Developer and City are collectively referred to herein as the "Parties." Capitalized terms used herein and not otherwise defined shall have the same meanings given to them in the Housing Agreement. RECITALS A. The City and Developer entered into that certain Housing Agreement (Columbus Square) dated as of June 20, 2005 (the "Original Housing Agreement") in order to, among other things, ensure implementation of the Affordable Housing Requirements of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan, the City's Density Bonus Ordinance, the Developer's City -approved "Affordable Housing Plan," the Developer's Density Bonus Application, the City's "Affordable Housing Policy," compliance with California Health and Safety Code Section 33413, subdivision (b)(2), and in accordance with conditions of approval for Tentative Tract Map 16581. B. The City and Developer agreed in the Housing Agreement that all 266 Affordable Housing Units at Columbus Square to be provided by Developer would be "for sale" units and would be owned and occupied only by Owner -Occupiers. C. Assignment Agreements were subsequently approved by the City for assignment and assumption of Developer's duties of performance under the Housing Agreement as follows, (i) an Assignment Agreement entered into by and between Moffett Meadows Partners and Tustin Villas Partners, LLC dated as of August 22, 2005 on Lot 4 of Finance and Conveyance Map No. 16857; (ii) an Assignment Agreement entered into by and between Tustin Villa Partners, LLC and Tustin Coventry, LLC dated as of October 19, 2009 on Lot 4 of Finance and Conveyance Map No. 16857; (iii) an Assignment Agreement entered into between Moffett Meadows Partners, LLC and Lennar Homes of California, Inc dated as of August 22, 2005 on Lots 8, 10 and 12 of Finance and Conveyance Map Tract 16857, and (iv) an Assignment Agreement entered into between Moffett Meadows Partners, LLC and William Lyon Homes, Inc. dated as of August 22, 2005 on Lot 7 of Finance and Conveyance Map No. 16857. D. Section 14 of the Housing Agreement provides that the Housing Agreement can be modified by written amendment if formally approved and executed by the Parties. E. Section 3.4.3 of the WAS Tustin Specific Plan also permits multi -family dwelling units (Apartments) subject to review and City approval of a Conditional Use Permit. The Tustin Planning Commission reviewed and approved Conditional Use Permit _ with adoption of Resolution No. on , 2009 requiring the 240 senior citizen units in the Coventry Court product at Columbus Square to be a multi -family senior citizen apartment project rather than an owner occupied senior citizen multi -family condominium 4- 90087986.1 9/24/09 project. Of the 240 units in the Coventry Court project, 153 units were age and rent restricted to require occupancy by Senior Citizens who are Affordable Households, with the remaining 87 units age restricted for occupancy by Senior Citizens, but not income restricted. F. The Developer has submitted a formal request to the City to modify the Housing Agreement, consistent with the approval of Conditional Use Permit No., to require Developer to make 153 Affordable Housing Units in Coventry Court of the total 266 Affordable Housing Units at Columbus Square identified in the Housing Agreement available as Affordable Housing Units for rental occupancy by Senior Citizens. G. The City Council has found that the conversion of 153 of the 266 Affordable Housing Units from for -sale units into rental units will not result in any adverse impacts on the public health, safety or physical environment. H. Pursuant to Developer's request, the City and Developer hereby amend the Housing Agreement by way of this First Amendment to allow, in the Developer's discretion, for some or all of the 266 Affordable Housing Units to be made available as rental units. NOW, THEREFORE, in consideration of the foregoing Recitals, which are hereby incorporated in the operative provisions of this Amendment by this reference and mutual covenants and agreements set forth herein and other valuable consideration, the receipt and sufficiency of which is hereby acknowledged, the Parties hereto agree as follows: 1. Sections 1.1. 1.2, and 1.3. The definitions for "Affordable Housing Cost for Lower Income Households," "Affordable Housing Cost for Moderate Income Households" and l "Affordable Housing Cost of Very Low Income Households" in Sections 1. 1, 1.2, and 1.3 in the Housing Agreement are hereby amended and restated to read in their entirety as follows: "1.1 'Affordable Housing Cost' shall mean for any Affordable Housing Unit designated for sale as owner -occupied housing a price that does not exceed the Affordable Housing Cost for a Very Low Income Household, a Low Income Household, or a Moderate Income Household, as applicable. The Affordable Housing Cost for an Affordable Housing Unit shall be calculated as of the date of sale or resale of the Unit and shall take into account and include monthly payments for principal and interest on the mortgage loan, mortgage loan insurance, property taxes and assessments, fire and casualty insurance, property maintenance and repairs, homeowner association fees, and a reasonable allowance for utilities and in an amount not in excess of (a) For'Very-Low Income Households,' as more particularly defined in Health and Safety Code Section 50052.5(b)(2) and as generally described herein as a price per unit which results in Monthly Housing Costs for the purchaser which shall not exceed one -twelfth of thirty percent (30%) times fifty percent (50%) of the annual Orange County Median Income, adjusted for family size appropriate for the unit. (b) For 'Low Income Households,' also defined as 'Lower Income Households' as more particularly defined in Health and Safety Code Section 50052.5(b)(3) and as generally described -2- 90087986.1 9/24/09 herein as a price per Unit which results in Monthly Housing Costs for the purchaser which shall not exceed one -twelfth of thirty percent (30%) times seventy percent (70%) of the annual Orange County Median Income, adjusted for family size appropriate for the unit. (c) For 'Moderate Income Households,' as more particularly defined in Health and Safety Code Section 50052.5(b)(4) and as generally described herein as a price per unit which results in the annual Affordable Housing Cost for the purchaser which shall not be less than twenty-eight percent (28%) of the gross annual income of the household, nor exceed the product of thirty-five percent (35%) times one hundred ten percent (110%) of the annual Orange County Median Income, adjusted for family size appropriate for the unit. Notwithstanding the foregoing, in accordance with Health and Safety Code Section 50052.5(b)(4), the City has determined and hereby agrees that, for a Moderate Income Household with annual gross income that exceeds one hundred ten percent (110%) of the annual Orange County Median Income, adjusted for family size appropriate for the unit. 1.2 'Affordable ordable Rent' shall mean for any for -rent Affordable Housing Unit a maximum monthly rental or lease price that does not exceed the Affordable Rent for a Very Low Income Household, a Low Income Household, or a Moderate Income Household, as applicable. The Affordable Rent for a for -rent Affordable Housing Unit shall be calculated as of the date of rent of the unit and shall take into account and include a reasonable allowance for utilities and in an amount not in excess of: (a) For 'Very Low Income Households; as more particularly defined in Health and Safety Code Section 50053(b)(2) and as generally described herein as a monthly rent which does not exceed one -twelfth of thirty percent (30%) times fifty percent (50%) of the annual Orange County Median Income, adjusted for family size appropriate for the unit. (b) For 'Low Income Households,' also defined as 'Lower Income Households; as more particularly defined in Health and Safety Code Section 50053(b)(3) and as generally described herein as applicable to those low income households whose gross incomes exceed the maximum income for very low income households, a monthly rent which does not exceed one - twelfth of thirty percent (30%) times.sixty percent (60%) of the annual Orange County Median Income, adjusted for family size appropriate for the unit. (c) For 'Moderate Income Households,' as more particularly defined in Health and Safety Code Section 50053(b)(4) and as generally described herein as a monthly rent which does not exceed one -twelfth of thirty percent (30%) times one hundred and ten percent (110%) of the annual Orange County Median Income, adjusted for family size. Notwithstanding the foregoing, in accordance with Health and Safety Code Section 50053(b)(4), the City has determined and hereby agrees that, for Moderate Income Households with annual gross incomes that exceed one hundred ten percent (1109/6) of the annual Orange County Median Income, adjusted for family size appropriate for the unit, a maximum monthly rent shall be calculated as not to exceed one - twelfth of thirty percent (30%) times one hundred and twenty percent (120%) of the annual Orange County Median Income, adjusted for family size. -3- 90087986.1 9/24/09 1.3 'Affordable Regulatory Agreement' or the 'Regulatory Agreement' means the Affordable Housing Regulatory Agreement and Declaration of Restrictive Covenants in the form attached hereto as Attachment 9 to be recorded against property containing For -Rent Affordable Housing Units as described in Section 3.5." 2. Section 1.8. Section 1.8 of the Housing Agreement is hereby amended and restated to read in its entirety as follows: "1.8 'Affordable Housing Unit means one of the one hundred thirteen (113) units to be provided by Developer for sale and to be occupied by Owner -Occupiers at an Affordable Housing Cost for Very Low, Lower or Moderate Income Households and the one hundred and fifty-three (153) Units identified by the Developer and approved by the City for rent to Senior Citizens at an Affordable Rent to Very Low Income Households, Low Income Households, and Moderate Income Households, as more specifically set forth in Section 3, collectively the Tor - Rent Affordable Housing Units.'" 3. Section 1.13. The definition of "Lower Income Households" is hereby amended and restated to read in its entirety as follows: "1.13 'Low Income Household,' also defined as 'Lower Income Household' shall mean a Household occupied by persons and families whose gross annual income is greater than fifty percent (50%) but does not exceed eighty percent (80%) of the annual Orange County Median Income, as published by the California Department of Housing and Urban Development, with adjustments for smaller and larger family sizes." 4. Section 1.16. The definition of "Memorandum of Agreement" in Section 1.16 of the Housing Agreement shall be hereby amended and restated to read: 3.9." 1.16 'Memorandum of Agreement' shall have the meaning set forth in Section 5. Section 1.17. The definition of 'Moderate Income Household' in Section 1.17 of the Housing Agreement is hereby amended and restated to read in its entirety as follows: "1.17 'Moderate Income Household' shall mean a Household occupied by persons and families whose gross annual income is greater than eighty percent (80%) but does not exceed one hundred and twenty percent (120%) of the Orange County Median Income, as published by the California Department of Housing and Urban Development, with adjustments for smaller and larger family sizes." 6. Section 1.23. The definition of "Very Low Income Household" in Section 1.23 of the Housing Agreement is hereby amended and restated to read in its entirety as follows: "1.23. 'Very Low Income Household' shall mean a Household occupied by persons and families whose gross annual income does not exceed fifty percent (50%) of the Orange County -4- 90087996.1 9/24/09 Median Income as published by the California Department of Housing and Urban Development, with adjustments for smaller and larger family sizes." 7. Section 1. Section 1 of the Housing Agreement is amended to add the following new Sections 1.24, 1.25, 1.26, 1.27 and 1.28 to read as follows: . " 1.24 'Business Days' shall mean any day on which Tustin City Hall is open for business. 1.25. 'City Program Administrator' shall mean the. Assistant City Manager or other Redevelopment Agency staff member as designated by either the Assistant City Manager or the City Manager. 1.26. 'Qualified Project Period' shall mean the period beginning on the first day on which at least fifty percent (50%) of the residential rental Senior Citizen units in the Coventry Court project are completed and first occupied and ending on the date that is fifty-five (55) years after the date on which at least fifty percent (50%) of the residential rental Senior Citizen units are completed and first occupied. 1.27 'Senior Citizen' means persons age 55 and older. 1.28. 'Verification of Income' shall mean the documentation by the Developer from the Very Low Income Household, Low Income Household, and Moderate Income Households verifying income as described in Section 3.5. 10 hereof or such other form as may from time to time be provided by the City Program Administrator to the Developer." 8. Section 3. The title of Section 3 of the Housing Agreement is hereby amended and restated as follows: "3. Affordable Housing Unit Obligations and Tenure Restrictions 9. Sections 3.1 and 3.2 of the Housing Agreement are hereby deleted in their entirety and new Sections 3.1 and 3.2 are substituted in their place. "3.1. Affordable Housing Unit Obli tions 3.1.1. Developer covenants and agrees for itself, its successors, its assigns and every successor in interest of Developer that no fewer than two hundred sixty-six (266) residential units shall be constructed and available for sale to and/or rental to and occupancy by, Very Low Income Households, Low -Income Households, and Moderate Income Households (the 'Affordable Housing Units), as identified in Attachment No. 2. Of these two hundred and sixty- six (266) Affordable Housing Units: -5- 90087986.1 9/29/09 (a) no fewer than one hundred thirteen (113) of the Affordable Housing Units shall be constructed and shall be made available as for -sale units for occupancy by qualified persons at an Affordable Housing Cost for Very Low, Lower or Moderate Income Households. All for -sale Affordable Housing Units shall be sold to and occupied by Owner -Occupiers. Of these one hundred thirteen (113) units, a minimum of twenty-five (25) units shall be sold to Very Low Income Households, a minimum of sixty-four (64) units shall be sold to Lower Income Households, and a minimum of twenty-four (24) units shall be sold to Moderate Income Households; and (b) no fewer that one hundred fifty-three (153) of the Affordable Housing Units shall be constructed and shall be made available for rental occupancy by Senior Citizens, with a minimum. of thirty-six (36) units rented to 'Very Low Income Households', a minimum of sixty- one (61) units rented to Low Income Households, and fifty-six (56) units rented to Moderate - Income Households. For rent Affordable Housing Units may only be rented to and occupied by Senior Citizens. The proposed general locations of such Affordable Housing Units by specific parcel, tenure (rental or ownership), bedroom count by tenure which shall not be less than the bedroom mix (shown in Table 4 of the Affordable Housing Plan, as amended), shall be in accordance with conditions of approval of Resolution CC 05-40, including Conditions 2.1, 2.2, and 2.3, and in Planning Commission Resolution No. , including Conditions 3.2 Affordable For -Sale Housing Unit Requirements: M@6LetjR& and Required Documents 1 3.2.1 Income QWWfication Standards and Procedures The Developer shall submit to the City's Program Administrator an Affordable Housing Purchaser Selection and Criteria Plan for Redevelopment Agency review and approval thirty (30) days prior to approval of a final map or issuance of a building permit. The City's Program Administrator shall approve or disapprove the Affordable Housing Purchaser Selection and Criteria Plan within twenty (20) calendar days. The Developer shall initiate marketing and sales of the Affordable Housing Units after Program Administrator's approval of Developer's Affordable Housing Purchaser Selection and Criteria Plan. Sale of Affordable Housing Units can only be after final map recordation and all necessary California Department of Real Estate approvals. Prior to execution of a sales contract for an Affordable Housing Unit, Developer shall submit to Program Administrator proposed purchaser's income certification and related income verification materials in a form acceptable to the Program Administrator and in the event that the Program Administrator finds that the provisions of the Agreement have been complied with, Program Administrator shall approve same in writing. The Developer shall submit to Program Administrator individual escrow instructions for buyers of Affordable Housing Units and all other related documents at least twenty (20) calendar days prior to close of escrow of individual Affordable Housing Units and with submission of individual escrow instructions and related items by Developer to Program Administrator. The Program Administrator shall approve or disapprove individual escrow instructions and related items for buyers of Affordable Housing Units within ten (10) calendar days of the following submission by Developer. -6- 90087986.1 9/24/09 3.2.2 Housing Affordable Documents to be Recorded. At the time of closing of each sale of an Affordable Housing Unit to an Owner Occupier, the Developer shall cause to be recorded against such Affordable Housing Unit the applicable 'Affordable Housing Covenant' based on the income level for such Affordable Housing Unit (i.e., Very Low Income, Low Income, or Moderate Income), the applicable 'Affordable Housing Trust Deed, and the "Affordable Housing Option Agreement" . The Developer shall also cause to be executed a promissory note executed by the applicable Owner -Occupier. In addition, Developer shall require the prospective Owner Occupier to execute a 'Reimbursement Agreement' (Exhibit 'E' to each Affordable Housing Covenant), which executed agreement shall be delivered to the City's Program Administrator as a condition of close of escrow on the Unit. In order to enable Developer to meet its continuing housing obligations under State law and as required by the Specific Plan and Housing Agreement, and because the City has facilitated the provision of the Affordable Housing Units through its adoption of the Specific Plan and housing incentives in the Density Bonus Ordinance, and provided that the Affordable Housing Covenant, Affordable Housing Trust Deed and Affordable Housing Option Agreement are recorded concurrently with the closing of the sale of an Affordable Housing Unit, the City agrees to accept the Affordable Housing Note, which Affordable Housing Note shall be in an amount equal to the difference between the appraised fair market value of the unit as if it was a Market Rate Unit and the sales price required to sell the Unit at an Affordable Housing Cost for Very Low Income Households, Low Income Households or an Affordable Housing Cost for Moderate Income Households, as applicable. The Affordable Housing Note shall be in the applicable form attached hereto as Attachment No. 3. Each Affordable Housing Note shall be assigned by the Developer to the City at the time of the closing of the sale of each Affordable Housing Unit, and shall be secured by a deed of trust executed by the purchasing Owner Occupier and recorded against the Unit at the time of the closing of such sale (the 'Affordable Housing Trust Deed) in the applicable form attached hereto as Attachment No. 4. The Affordable Housing Trust Deed shall secure the obligations of the Owner Occupier set forth in the Affordable Housing Covenant, the Reimbursement Agreement and the Affordable Housing Promissory Note and shall be subordinate in priority only to the monetary lien of a purchase money deed of trust also recorded at the time of closing of the sale securing an amount not in excess of the applicable Affordable Housing Cost of the Unit. The Affordable Housing Deed of Trust shall be subordinate in priority only to the monetary lien of a purchase money deed of trust also recorded at the time of closing." 12. Section 3.3. The title of Section 3.3 of the Housing Agreement is amended as restated to read in its entirety as follows: "3.3 Covenant: Affordable For Sale Units." 13. Sections 3.4 and 3.5 are hereby amended and restated to read in their entirety as follows: "3.4. For -Rent Affordable Housing Unit Requirements: Marketing and Required Documents. The 153 required For -Rent Senior Citizen Affordable Housing Units shall -7- 90087986.1 9/24/09 be constructed in the Coventry Court project as depicted in general location in Attachment No. With respect to the Coventry Court Senior Citizen rental apartment project, 36 units shall be rent restricted and occupied by Very Low Income Senior Citizen Households, 61 units shall be rent restricted and occupied by Low Income Senior Citizen Households, and 56 units shall be rent restricted and occupied by Moderate Income Senior Citizen Households, and 87 units shall be rented at market rates. -8- 90087986.1 9/29/09 3.5 Covenant Re: Affordable For -Rent Units. 3.5.1 The Developer covenants and agrees for itself, its successors, its assigns and every successor in interest to property designated to contain For -Rental Senior Citizen Affordable Housing Units to construct the For -Rent Senior Citizen Affordable Housing Units described in Section 3.4 and depicted as to general location on Attachment No. and said units shall be restricted for a period terminating fifty-five (55) years from the issuance of a certificate of occupancy for a rental project and expiration of the Qualified Project Period and according to the following terms: (a) Affordable Housing Units .designated by general parcel location in Attachment No. as being For -Rent to Very Low -Income Households shall only be rented and occupied by Senior Citizens in Very Low -Income Households; (b) Affordable Housing Units designated by general parcel location in Attachment No. as being For -Rent to Low -Income Households shall only be rented and occupied by Senior Citizens in Low -Income Households; and (c) Affordable Housing Units designated by general parcel location in Attachment No. as being For -Rent to Moderate Income Households shall only be rented and occupied by Senior Citizens in Moderate Income Households. 3.5.2 In order to impose upon a parcel the obligations set forth above in Section 3.5.1, prior to issuance by the City's Building -Official of further building permits for the Coventry Court project, there shall be recorded against the Coventry Court project site an 'Affordable Housing Regulatory Agreement and Declaration of Restrictive Covenants,' (hereinafter referred to as the 'Regulatory Agreement') in the form of the Regulatory Agreement and applicable covenants attached hereto as Attachment No. 9. The Developer shall cause the Regulatory Agreement, and all amendments and supplements hereto and thereto, to be recorded and filed in the Official Records and in such other places as the Program Administrator may reasonably request. The Developer shall pay all fees and charges incurred in connection with any such recording. Written evidence of the recorded Regulatory Agreement shall be provided to the Program Administrator. 3.5.3 Renting to Affordable Households. Very Low Income Units, Low Income Units and Moderate Income Units shall be rented to eligible and qualified Senior Citizens in Very Low Income Households, Low Income Households and Moderate Income Households in accordance with the following terms: a) Developer shall use its best efforts to fill vacancies of Very Low Income, Low Income, and Moderate Income Affordable Units as soon as possible following the date the Affordable Housing Unit becomes available for renting, by renting the units to Senior Citizens in Very Low Income Households, Low Income Households, and Moderate Income Households as applicable to such units and as described in Section 3.4.1 and generally depicted on Attachment No. . Developer shall lease available units to eligible Affordable Households on a first-come, first-served, and non-discriminatory basis. Developer shall notify the City Program Administrator of any Affordable Housing Units that either (a) fails to have been leased to a Senior Citizen in a Very Low Income Household, Low Income Household, or Moderate Income Household, as applicable, within thirty (30) days after the issuance of a certificate *of occupancy for the unit (the 'Initial Leasing Period), or (b) becomes available as a result of tenant -9- 90087986.1 9/29/09 vacation of the premises. b) Developer shall create and maintain an 'interest list' which includes all potential tenants who have expressed an interest in leasing a unit within each rental project. The interest list shall clearly designate whether such potential tenant is a Senior Citizen in a Very Low Income Household, Low Income Household, or Moderate Income Household. The interest list shall clearly indicate whether such potential tenant will be receiving rental assistance under the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) Section 8 program (or other federal programs that may replace the Section 8 program). Developer shall use its best efforts to fill vacancies of Very Low Income Units, Low Income Units, and Moderate Income Units as soon as possible following the date the Affordable Housing Units become available for renting, by renting the units to Senior Citizens in Very Low Households, Low Income Households, and Moderate Income Households as applicable to such units. c) An Affordable Housing Unit that either (a) fails to be leased within the Initial Leasing Period to a Senior Citizen in a Very Low Income Household, Low Income Household, or Moderate Income Household, as may be applicable, or (b) becomes available as a result of tenant vacation of the premises, shall be rented to a new eligible and qualified tenant in accordance with the following procedure: (i) Developer shall make a reasonable effort to contact eligible and qualified prospective tenants in the order of priority on the interest list as set forth in this Section 3.5.3 above and, Developer shall lease available units to such eligible tenants on a first- come, first-served, basis; i (ii) Each such eligible and qualified prospective tenant shall have three (3) business days to notify Developer of the prospective tenant's intent to accept the unit, and must thereafter execute a lease for the unit within seven (7) days of such acceptance; (iii) Failure of the eligible and qualified prospective tenant to timely notify Developer of accepting the unit or to thereafter timely execute a lease for the unit shall be deemed rejection of the unit, and Developer may seek other eligible tenants as set forth in this subsection (c) and following. d) In the event the 'interest list' maintained by the Developer does not include a prospective tenant that is eligible and qualified as a tenant of a vacant Affordable Housing Unit, or in the event Developer is unable to lease a vacant Affordable Housing Unit after fully complying with the procedures set forth herein, the Developer may lease the restricted unit to any eligible and qualified Very Low Income Household, Low Income Household, or Moderate Income Household for the appropriate restricted unit. e) Senior Citizens in Low Income Households, Very Low Income Households and Moderate Income Households who occupy Low Income Units, Very Low Income Units and Moderate Income Units at the expiration of the Qualified Project Period and who qualify as Very Low Income Households, Low Income Households, or Moderate Income -10- 90087986.1 9/29/09 Households on such date shall be permitted to continue to occupy those Low Income Units, Very Low Income Units and Moderate Income Units for a period of one (1) year, beginning on the first day after the expiration of the Qualified Project Period; provided, however, that annual rent increases during such one (1) year period shall not exceed an amount equal to the existing rent for such unit plus an amount equal to the greater of (i) five percent (50/6) or (ii) the percentage increase that would have been permitted had the Qualified Project Period not expired. Except as provided in the preceding sentence, upon the expiration of the Qualified Project Period, the Affordable Housing Units shall no longer be subject to the provisions of this Section 3. f) The Developer agrees to provide to Very Low Income Households, Low Income Households, and Moderate Income Households within the rental project sites notice of all rent increases pursuant to applicable Governmental Requirements, including rules and regulations of the State. 3.5.4 Rental Rates. Rental rates for all Affordable Housing Units to which this Agreement and a Regulatory Agreethent are applicable shall not exceed the higher of following: (a) The Affordable Housing Rent as defined in the California Health and Safety Code Section 50054 for Very Low Income Households (Section 50053 (b)(1)), for Low Income Households (Section 50053 (b)(2)), and for Moderate, Income Households (Section 50053 (b)(3)), less the monthly allowance for utilities and services (excluding telephone) to be paid by the household; or (b) If an Affordable Housing Unit designated for rent to a Senior Citize in a Very Low Income Household or Low Income Household receives federal or state rental subsidy, and a Very Low or Low Income tenant pays as a contribution toward rent no more than thirty percent (30%) of the household's adjusted income, then the maximum rent (i.e., tenant contribution plus any rental subsidy) shall be the fair market rent allowable under the federal or state rental subsidy certificate or voucher program. Alternatively, the maximum monthly rent that may be charged to a qualified tenant who is subject to this limitation may be the monthly adjusted income of the qualified tenant multiplied by thirty percent (30%) and divided by 12 and, if applicable, a monthly allowance for any utilities and services (excluding telephone) to be paid by the tenant shall be subtracted. 3.5.5 Voucher Holders. No Affordable Housing Units designated for rent to a Senior Citizen in a Very Low Income Household or Low Income Income Household shall be refused for leasing to a holder of a certificate or voucher under 24 CFR Part 982 Section 8 Rental Certificate Program or Section 8 Rental Voucher Program or to the holder of a comparable document evidencing participation in a HOME tenant -based assistance program because of the status of the prospective Very Low Income Household or Low Income Household as a holder of such certificate of family participation, rental voucher, or comparable tenant -based assistance document. -11- 90087986.1 9/29/09 3.5.6 Rent Schedule and Utility Allowances. The City Program Administrator shall annually review and approve rents proposed by the Developer for the Affordable Housing Units to determine that the Developer has properly applied the rental restrictions contained in this Section 3.5 and shall provide the Developer with a schedule establishing the monthly allowances for utilities and services to be paid by the tenants of the units. The Developer shall re-examine the income of each tenant household living in the Affordable Housing Unit at least annually. The maximum monthly rent shall be recalculated by the Developer and reviewed and approved by the City Program Administrator annually and may change as changes in the applicable gross rent amounts, the income adjustments, or the monthly allowance for utilities and services warrant. The Developer shall not impose on a tenant an increase in rent approved by the City Program Administrator if that increase is not permitted to be imposed under the lease between Developer and the tenant. Developer shall provide not less than thirty (30) days prior written notice to affected tenants before implementing any increase in rents. 3.5.7 Increases in Income (a) If, as a result of the annual re-examination of incomes required pursuant to Section 3.5.6, the Developer determines that a household that qualified as a Very Low Income Household for purposes of paragraph 3.5.3 above, no longer is a Very Low Income Household but instead qualifies as a Low Income Household, then the Developer may require that household to pay the Affordable Rent for Low Income Units, and the Developer shall lease the next available Low Income or Moderate Income Unit to a Senior Citizen in a Very Low Income Household at the rent permitted under Section 3.5.3. (b) If, as a result of the annual re-examination of incomes required pursuant to Section 3.5.6, the Developer determines that a household that qualified as a Very Low Income Household for purposes of paragraph 3.5.3 above, no longer is a Very Low Income Household but instead qualifies as a Moderate Income Household, then the Developer may require that household to pay the Affordable Rent for Moderate Income Units, and the Developer shall lease the next available Low Income Unit or Moderate Income Unit to a Senior Citizen in a Very Low Income Household at the rent permitted under Section 3.5.3. (c) If, as a result of the annual re-examination. of incomes required pursuant to Section 3.5.6, the Developer determines that a household that qualified as a Low Income Household for purposes of paragraph 3.5.3 above, no longer is a Low Income Household but instead qualifies as a Moderate Income Household, then the Developer may require that household to pay the Affordable Rent for Moderate Income Units, and the Developer shall lease the next available Moderate Income Unit to a Senior Citizen in a Low Income Household at the rent permitted under Section 3.5.3. (d) If, as a result of the annual re-examination of incomes required pursuant to Section 3.5.6, the Developer determines that a household that qualified as a Very Low Income Household, Low Income Household, or Moderate Income Household for purposes of paragraph 3.5.3 above, no longer is a Very Low Income Household, Low Income Household, -12- 90087986.1 9/24/09 or Moderate Income Household, then the Developer may require that household to pay fair market rent, and the Developer shall lease the next available apartment unit in the development to a Senior Citizen in a Very Low Income Household, Low Income Household, or Moderate Income Household (whichever class of household that the original Affordable Housing Units was to be leased to) at the affordable rent for such Very Low Income Unit, Low Income Unit, or Moderate Income Unit. Such next available apartment unit shall then be deemed to be a Very Low Income Unit, Low Income Unit, or Moderate Income Unit, subject to the provisions of this Section 3.5, and the previous unit shall no longer be subject to the provisions of this Section 3.5. (e) Notwithstanding the foregoing provisions, it is the intent of this Agreement and the Regulatory Agreement that the number of Very Low Income Units, Low Income Units, and Moderate Income Units be allocated as among the Affordable Housing Units as provided in Section 3.4. In the event the foregoing provisions result in an allocation of Affordable Housing Units different from that provided in Section 3.4, Developer shall lease the next available Affordable Housing Unit to a Senior Citizen in a Very Low Income Household, Low Income Household, or Moderate Income Household, as the case may be, in order to correct the allocation. 3.5.8 Minimum Rents. Notwithstanding the other provisions of this Section 3.5, Developer shall not be required to charge a rent for a Very Low Income Unit, Low Income Unit, or Moderate Income Unit that would be lower than the maximum rent Developer would have been permitted to charge for the Unit had the determination of maximum rent been made on the date the City and Developer entered into the Agreement. 3.5.9 Tenant Protections (a) Rental Agreement. The Rental Agreement (lease) between Developer and the Affordable Household must be for not less than one year, unless the City Program Administrator provides prior written approval, and may not contain any of the following provisions: (i) Any agreement by the tenant to be sued, to admit guilt or to consent to a judgment in favor of the Developer in a lawsuit brought in connection with the lease. (ii) Any agreement by the tenant that the Developer may take, hold, or sell personal property of household members without notice to the tenant and a court decision on the rights of the parties. This prohibition, however, does not apply to an agreement by the tenant concerning disposition of personal property remaining in the Unit after the tenant has moved out of the Unit. The Developer may dispose of this personal property in accordance with applicable state law. (iii) Any agreement by the tenant not to hold the Developer or its agents legally responsible for any action or failure to act, whether intentional or negligent. -13- 90087986.1 9/29/09 (iv) Any agreement of the tenant that the Developer may evict the tenant or household members without notice to the tenant. (v) Any agreement by the tenant that the Developer may evict the tenant or household members without instituting a civil court proceeding in which the tenant has the opportunity to present a defense, or before a court decision on the rights of the parties. (vi) Any agreement by the tenant to waive any right to a trial by jury. (vii) Any agreement by the tenant to waive the tenant's right to appeal, or to otherwise challenge in court, a court decision in connection with the lease. (viii) Any agreement by the household to pay attorney's fees or other legal costs even if the tenant wins in a court proceeding by the Developer against the tenant. The tenant, however, may be obligated to pay costs if the tenant loses. (b) Termination of Tenancy. Developer may not terminate the tenancy or refuse to renew the lease of an affordable housing tenant except for violation of the terms and conditions of the lease; for violation of applicable federal, state, or local law; or for other good cause. Any termination or refusal to renew must be preceded by not less than sixty (60) days by the Developer's service upon the tenant of a written notice specifying the grounds for the action. 3.5.10 Very Low Income, Low Income. and Moderate Income Senior Citizen Tenants: Records and Reports. The Developer hereby represents, warrants and covenants as follows: (a) Within 30 days after the date on which at least ten percent (10%) of the dwelling units in the Project are first occupied, the Developer shall execute and deliver a written notice, in the form provided by the City Program Administrator or otherwise approved by Program Administrator a copy of a certificate identifying said date and the beginning date and earliest ending date of the Qualified Project Period, which certificate shall be in the form provided by Program Administrator or otherwise approved by City's Program Administrator. The Developer shall record a copy of such certificate in the Official Records. (b) The Developer shall obtain, complete and maintain on file Verifications of Income qualification, in the form provided by City's Program Administrator or otherwise approved by City's Program Administrator, from each Very Low Income Household, Low Income Household or Moderate Income Household, including (i) a Verification of Income and age qualification dated immediately prior to the initial occupancy of such Very Low Income Household, Low Income Household or Moderate Income Household and (ii) thereafter, annual Verifications of Income and age qualifications which must be dated as of June 1st of each year, or such other date as may be mutually agreed upon by the City's Program Administrator and the Developer, and in no event less than once in every twelve-month period following each Very -14- 90087986.1 1490087986.1 9/29/09 Low Income Household's, Low Income Household's, or Moderate Income Household's occupancy of a unit in the Project. The Developer will obtain such additional information as may be required in the future by the State or by the City's Program Administrator, due to changes in federal or state law. (c) A copy of the most recent Verification of Income and age qualification for Very Low Income Household, Low Income Household, and Moderate Income Household commencing upon occupation or continuing occupation of a Very Low Income Unit, Low Income Unit, or Moderate Income Unit (and not previously filed) shall be attached to the Certificate of Continuing Program Compliance, in the form provided by City's Program Administrator or otherwise approved by City's Program Administrator which is to be filed with the City's Program Administrator no later than the fifteenth (15`h) day of each month following the receipt by the City's Program Administrator of the Completion Certificate to and including the month in which such report indicates that fifty percent (50%) -of the units in the Coventry Court Project are occupied by Senior Citizens in Very Low Income Households, Low Income Households and Moderate Income Households and, thereafter, no later than the first (I') day of the sixth (6a') month of each calendar year until the end of the Qualified Project Period. (d) The Developer shall make a diligent and good -faith effort to verify that the information provided by an applicant in the Verification of Income and Senior Citizen age qualifications is accurate by taking the following steps, as a part of the verification process: (1) obtain birth certificates for all household members; (2) obtain pay stubs for the most recent one-month period or the last three months bank statements for self-employed individuals, and (3) obtaining income W-2 Wage and Earnings Statements and tax returns for the most recent tax year, alternatively, if determined appropriate for the tenant's situation the following may be obtained: (i) obtain an income verification from the Social Security Administration and/or the California Department of Social Services if the applicant receives assistance from either of such agencies; or (ii) if the applicant is unemployed, does not have income tax returns or is otherwise unable to provide other forms of verification as required above, obtain another form of independent verification satisfactory to the Program Administrator. (e) The Developer shall maintain complete and accurate records pertaining to the Very Low Income Units, Low Income Units, and Moderate Income Units and shall permit any duly authorized representative of the City to inspect the books and records of the Developer pertaining to the Project, including those records pertaining to the occupancy of the Affordable Housing Units. (f) The Developer shall prepare and submit to the City Program Administrator no later than the first (1s') day of the sixth (6`h) month of each calendar .year until the end of the Qualified Project Period, a Certificate of Continuing Program Compliance executed by the Developer with the following information: (i) The number of the dwelling units of the Project which were occupied, pursuant to Section 3.4 above, by Senior Citizens in Very Low Income Households, Low Income Households, and Moderate Income Households during such period and such other -15- 90087986.1 9/24/09 tenant information as may be reasonably required as stated on the form of the Certificate of Continuing Program Compliance acceptable to the Program Administrator; and (ii) A statement either: (a) that no un -remedied default has occurred under the Regulatory Agreement or (b) a default has occurred, in which event the Certificate shall describe the nature of the default in detail and set forth the measures being taken by the Developer to remedy such default. 3.5.11 Each lease or rental agreement for an Affordable Housing Unit shall contain a provision to the effect that the Developer has relied on the Verification of Income Certification and age qualification and supporting information supplied by the Very Low Income Household, Low Income Household, or Moderate Income Household in determining qualification for occupancy of the Very Low Income Units, Low Income Units and Moderate Income Units by Senior Citizens and that any material misstatement in such verification (whether or not intentional) will be cause for immediate termination of such lease or rental agreement. Each such lease or rental agreement shall also provide (and shall so disclose to the tenant) that the tenant's income and age qualification is subject to annual certification in accordance with the terms of the Regulatory Agreement, and that, if upon review of any such verification the tenant's income exceeds the then applicable income limit for a Very Low Income Household, Low Income Household, or Moderate Income Household, such household shall cease to qualify as a Very Low Income Household, Low Income Household, or Moderate Income Household, and, as a consequence, said household's lease shall be subect to termination on such prior notice as the City's Program Administrator deems reasonable. 3.5.12 Termination of For -Rent Affordable Ho—using Covenants The provisions of this Section 3.5 shall remain in full force and effect for the period provided in Section 3.5.1." 14. Section 3.6*is hereby deleted in its entirety and a new Section 3.6 is substituted in its place as follows: "3.6 Puroose of Affordable Housing provisions The City and the Developer hereby agree that the provisions of this Agreement relating to the Affordable Housing Units are entered into in order to achieve a stabilized community of Owner. -Occupied for -sale Affordable Housing Units and for -rent Affordable Housing Units. It is the intention of the City and the Developer that the City and its successors and assigns be empowered to enforce the covenants contained in this Affordable Housing Agreement and all Affordable Housing Covenants, or Regulatory Agreements, that each of the foregoing empower the City and its successors and assigns to enforce the covenants contained herein, and that each of the foregoing should also be construed and interpreted." 15. Section 3 is hereby amended to add the following new Section 3.7: "3.7 Compliance_ with Density Bonus Ordinance Specific Plan and Applicable State -16- 90087986.1 9/29/09 Law. The City and the Developer hereby agree that the provisions of this Agreement comply with the Specific Plan, Density Bonus Ordinance, Government Code Section 65915, and California Health and Safety Code Sections 33413, 33334.3, and 33334.14, and that such provisions fully satisfy the requirements of such code sections." 16. Section 3 is hereby amended to add the following new Section 3.8: "3.8 Other Covenants: Developer covenants and agrees for itself, its successors, its assigns that: 3.8.1 Obligation to Refrain from Discrimination. There shall be no discrimination against or segregation of any person or group of persons, on account of race, color, creed, religion, sex, sexual orientation, marital status, national origin or ancestry in the sale, lease, sublease, transfer, use, occupancy, tenure or enjoyment of the Site or any portion thereof, nor shall Developer itself or any person claiming under or through it (including any tenant) establish or permit any such practice or practices of discrimination or segregation with reference to the selection, location, number, use or occupancy of tenants, lessees, subtenants, sublessees or vendees on the Property or any portion thereof. 3.8.4 Redevelovment Law: Form of Nondiscrimination and Non se re ation Clauses. The Developer itself and any person claiming under or through it shall refrain from restricting the sale of the property on the basis of race, color, creed, religion, sex, sexual orientation, marital status, national origin or ancestry of any person. All deeds, leases or - contracts shall contain or be subject to substantially the following non-discrimination or non - segregation clauses: (a) In Deeds: 'The grantee herein covenants by and for itself, its successors and assigns, and all persons claiming under or through them, that there shall be no discrimination against or segregation of, any person or group of persons on account of race, color, creed, religion, sex, sexual orientation, marital status, national origin or ancestry in the sale, lease, sublease, transfer, use, occupancy, .tenure or enjoyment of the land herein conveyed, nor shall the grantee itself or any person claiming, under or through it, establish or permit any such practice or practices of discrimination or segregation with reference to the selection, location, number, use or occupancy of tenants, lessees, subtenants, sublessees or vendees in the land herein conveyed. The foregoing covenants shall run with the land! (b) In Leases: The lessee herein covenants by and for itself, its successors and assigns, and all persons claiming under or through them, and this lease is made and accepted upon and subject to the following conditions: That there shall be no discrimination against or segregation of, any person or group of persons on account of race, color, creed, religion, sex, sexual orientation, marital status, national origin or ancestry in the sale, lease, sublease, transfer, use, occupancy, tenure or enjoyment of the land herein conveyed, nor shall the grantee itself or any person claiming under or through it, establish or permit any such practice or practices of discrimination or segregation with reference to the -17- 90087986.1 9/29/09 selection, location, number, use or occupancy of tenants, lessees, subtenants, sublessees or vendees in the land herein leased.' (c) In Contracts: There shall be no discrimination against or segregation of, any person or group of persons on account of race, color, creed, religion, sex, sexual orientation, marital status, national origin or ancestry in the sale, lease, sublease, transfer, use, occupancy, tenure or enjoyment of the land herein conveyed, nor shall the grantee itself or any person claiming under or through it, establish or permit any such practice or practices of discrimination or segregation with reference to the selection, location, number, use or occupancy of tenants, lessees, subtenants, sublessees or vendees in the land.' The Developer covenants and agrees for itself, its successors, its assigns and every successor in interest to the Site or any part thereof, there shall be no discrimination against or segregation of any person, or group of persons, on account of race, color, creed, religion, sex, sexual orientation, marital status, national origin or ancestry in the sale, transfer, rental or lease (where permitted), use, occupancy, tenure or enjoyment of the Site nor shall the Developer itself or any person claiming under or through it establish or permit any such practice or practices of discrimination or segregation with reference to the selection, location, number, use or occupancy of purchasers of the Property, or renters or lessees of the Property, or any portion thereof." read: 17. Section 3 of the Housing Agreement is hereby amended to add a new Section 3.9 to "3.9 Memorandum f A Bement. A Memorandum of Agreement, substantially in the form of Attachment 8, attached hereto and incorporated herein by this reference, shall be recorded against the Property upon execution of this Agreement. A Memorandum of any Amendments to the Agreement, shall also be prepared, substantially in the form of Attachment 10, attached hereto and incorporated herein by this reference, and shall be recorded against the Property upon execution of any Amendments to the Agreement." 18. [this is an existing agreement, we are only adding or amending attachment 9 and I01Section 17. Section 17 is hereby amended to add Attachment 9 and Attachment 10 to read as follows: "Attachment No. 1: Legal Description Attachment No. 2: Affordable Housing Units — Number, Location, Bedrooms Attachment No. 3: Affordable Housing Note Attachment No. 4: Affordable Housing Deed of Trust Attachment No. 5: Affordable Housing Covenant 90087966.1 -18- 9/24/09 (Very Low Income) Attachment No. 6: Affordable Housing Covenant Attachment No. 7: Affordable Housing Covenant (Moderate Income) Attachment No. 8: Memorandum of Agreement Attachment No. 9: Regulatory Agreement and Declaration of Restrictive Covenants (Coventry Court Rental Project) Attachment No. 10: Memorandum of First Amendment to the Housing Agreement The new Attachments 9 and 10 to the Housing Agreement will be in the forms attached hereto as Exhibits 'A,' and 'B,'respectively. " 19. Counterparts. This First Amendment may be executed in counterparts. Each counterpart shall be deemed an original, and all counterparts shall be deemed the same instrument with the same effect as if all parties hereto had signed the same signature page. In addition, a copy of this First Amendment executed by a party hereto and telecopied to the other party shall be deemed to constitute delivery of an originally executed copy of this First Amendment to the other party. A facsimile signature shall be enforceable to the same extent as an original signature. [Signatures On Following Page) -19- 90087986.1 9/29/09 IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have executed this First Amendment as of the date above written. "CITY" CIII..�T1Yl "CITY" TUSTIN, ATTEST: a California municipal corporation rporation Pamela Stoker, City Clerk By: William Huston, City Manager or APPROVED AS TO FORM: Christine Shingleton, Assistant City Manager Woodruff, Spradlin & Smart Douglas Holland, City Attorney "DEVELOPER" MARBLE MOUNTAIN PARTNERS, LLC, MOFFETT MEADOWS its sole member, a Delaware limited liability company, PARTNERS, LCC, its administrative member a Delaware limited liability company By. Its: By. Its: ACKNOWLEGMENT AND CONSENT OF ASSIGNEES TO FIRST AMENDMENT The Undersigned, as assignees of portions of the property subject to the Housing Agreement in accordance with the assignment agreements referenced in Recital C hereof, consent to the foregoing amendments and agree to be bound thereby if and the extent such amendments affect the property owned by them. ASSIGNEES: For Lot 4 of Finance and Conveyance Map No. 16857 TUSTIN COVENTRY, LLC, a California Delaware limited liability company -20- 90087986.1 9/24/09 By: Lennar Homes of California, Inc., a California corporation, its managing Member M- Name: Title: For Lots 8,10 and 12 of Finance and Conveyance Map No. 16857 Lennar Homes of California, Inc, a California corporation By: Name: Title: For Lot 7 of Finance and' Conveyance Map No. 16857 William Lyon Homes, Inc., a California corporation By: Name: Title: -21- 90087986.1 9/24/09 s EXHIBIT "A" ATTACHMENT 9 TO HOUSING AGREEMENT AFFORDABLE HOUSING REGULATORY AGREEMENT AND DECLARATION OF COVENANTS 90087986.2 11/18/2009 EXHIBIT "B" ATTACHMENT 10 TO HOUSING AGREEMENT. MEMORANDUM OF AGREEMENT FOR FIRST AMENDMENT TO THE HOUSING AGREEMENT 90087986.2 11/18/2009 MEMORANDUM OF AGREEMENT RECORDING REQUESTED BY AND WHEN RECORDED MAIL TO: City of Tustin 300 Centennial Way Tustin, California 92780 Attention: Assistant City Manager No fee for recording requested purant to Government Code Sections 6103 and 27383 MEMORANDUM OF FIRST AMENDMENT TO THE HOUSING AGREEMENT THIS MEMORANDUM OF THE FIRST AMENDMENT TO THE HOUSING AGREEMENT ("Memorandum of Agreement") is made as of 2009 by and between the CITY OF TUSTIN, a municipal corporation (together with its successors and assigned, the "City"), and MARBLE MOUNTAIN PARTNERS, LLC a Delaware limited liability company (the "Developer") to confine that the City and the Developer have entered into that certain FIRST AMENDMENT TO THE HOUSING AGREEMENT dated as of , 2009 (the "Amended Agreement") affecting the real property described below. The City and the Developer are sometimes referred to herein individually as a "Party" and collectively as the "Parties." Initially capitalized terms used herein and not otherwise defined shall have the meanings ascribed to such terns in the Agreement. 1. Property Affected by the Aaeement. The following described land is subject to the terms, covenants, conditions and restrictions set forth in the Amended Agreement effective as to such land upon the date of acquisition thereof by the Developer: 1.1 The "Property" consisting as of the date hereof of that certain land at the former MCAS Tustin site, legally described on EXHIBIT A attached hereto and incorporated herein by this reference. 1.2 This Memorandum of Agreement has been executed and shall be recorded immediately following the recordation of the Amended Agreement for the Site and the Amended Agreement and this Memorandum of Agreement shall each be binding upon the Site in accordance with its terms. 2. Effect of Agreement. The Amended Agreement imposes certain obligations, agreements, covenants, conditions and restrictions with respect to the Property and Developer's development, use, operation and ultimate disposition thereof of required Affordable Units, that run with the land as further set forth below, including, but not limited to without limitation: (a) The covenants for the development and sale and rent of Affordable Units contained in Sections 3.1. 3.2, and 3.2 of the Amended Agreement; that remain in effect until execution and recordation by the City of a Certificate of Compliance on the Property and certain covenants and restrictions which continue on sold and rented Affordable Units under the terms of Section 3.3 of the Amended Agreement; (b) Certain restrictions on the sale or transfer of the Property contained in Section 6.1. 6.2. and 7 and the assignment of the Amended Agreement contained in Section 3.3 of the Agreement, that terminate upon execution and recordation by the City of a Certificate of Compliance on the Property; (c) The non-discrimination covenants contained in Section 3.4 of the Amended Agreement that remain in effect in perpetuity, (f) The affordable housing covenants contained in Section 3 3 on for -sale Affordable Units and in Section 3.5 on for -rent Affordable Units, that remain in effect for the period specified in the Amended Agreement; 3. Amended Agreement and Memorandum of Agreement Run with the Land. The Amended Agreement and this Memorandum of Agreement, including, without limitation, the provisions recited and set forth above, and all other obligations, agreements, �► covenants, conditions and restrictions set forth in the Amended Agreement and this Memorandum of Agreement, are hereby agreed by the Developer and the City to be covenants running with the land and enforceable as equitable servitudes against the Site, and are hereby declared to be and shall be binding upon the Property and the Developer and the successors and assigns of the Developer owning all or any portion of the Property for the benefit of the City, except that a City approved written assignment by the Vertical Builder/Purchaser shall relieve Developer of its obligations under the Amended Agreement for that portion of the Property. 4. Acknowledgement and Assumption by Developer. The Developer hereby acknowledges and assumes all responsibilities placed upon the Developer under the terms of the Amended Agreement. 5. Public Documents. The documents constituting the Amended Agreement are public documents and may be reviewed at the official offices of the City. 6. Interpretation; Notice. This Memorandum of Agreement is prepared for recordation and notice purposes only and in no way modifies the terms, conditions, provisions and covenants of the Amended Agreement. In the event of any inconsistency between the terms, conditions, provisions and covenants of this Memorandum of Agreement and the Amended Agreement, the terms, conditions, -provisions and covenants of the Agreement shall prevail. 7. Attachments. Exhibit A to this Memorandum of Agreement is hereby incorporated by this reference as though fully set forth in this Section. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties have signed this Memorandum of Agreement as of the date first set forth above CITY: CITY OF TUSTIN Dated: M ATTEST: Pamela Stoker, City Clerk APPROVED AS TO FORM By: Doug Holland, City Attorney Clay Gantz, Special Counsel William A. Huston, City Manager < Additional Signatures follow> "DEVELOPER" MARBLE MOUNTAIN PARTNERS, LLC, MOFFETT MEADOWS its sole member, a Delaware limited liability company, PARTNERS, LCC, administrative member a Delaware limited liability company By: Its: UN Its: ACKNOWLEGMENT AND CONSENT OF ASSIGNEES TO MEMORANDUM OF FIRST AMENDMENT The Undersigned, as assignees of portions of the property subject to the Housing Agreement, as amended by the First Amendment to the Housing Agreement, in accordance with the assignment agreements referenced in Recital C hereof of the First Amendment to the Housing Agreement, have consented to the Amended Agreement and this Memorandum of Agreement and agree to be bound thereby if and the extent such amendments affect the property owned by them. ASSIGNEES: For Lot 4 of Finance and Conveyance Map No. 16857 TUSTIN COVENTRY, LLC, a California Delaware limited liability company By: Lennar Homes of California, Inc., a California corporation, its managing Member By: Name: Title: For Lots 8,10 and 12 of Finance and Conveyance Map No. 16857 Lennar Homes of California, Inc, a California corporation UAA Name: Title: For Lot 7 of Finance and Conveyance Map No. 16857 William Lyon Homes, Inc., a California corporation M Name: Title: Dated: By: STATE OF CALIFORNIA ) COUNTY OF ORANGE )ss.) On before me, Notary Public, personally appeared a who proved to me on the basis of satisfactory evidence to be the subscribed to the within instrument and acknowledged to me that) el he/theyoexecutedse sth same in his/her/their authorized capacity(ies), and that by his/her/their signature(s) on the instrument the person(s), or the entity upon behalf of which the person(s) acted, executed the instrument. I certify under PENALTY OF PERJURY under the laws of the State of California that the foregoing paragraph is true and correct. WITNESS my hand and official seal. Signature (Seal) EXHIBIT A TO MEMORADUM OF AGREEMENT LEGAL DESCRIPTION OF THE PROPERTY ADDENDUM TO HOMEBUYER NOTIFICATION COLUMBUS SQUARE This is an addendum ("Addendum") to the Homebuyer Notification — Columbus Square (the "Homebuyer Notification') executed by the undersigned ("Buyer') dated . concerning the purchase of real property known as Homesite of Tract No. (the "Property") in at Columbus Square (the "Development") located in the City of Tustin, County of Orange, State of California, from a and/or its affiliated companies ("Seller'). The Development is part of a master planned development called "Columbus Square." This Addendum modifies the Homebuyer Notification as set forth below. Unless defined in this Addendum, capitalized terms used in this Addendum have the meanings given them in the Columbus Square Homebuyer Disclosure Statement (the "Master Disclosure"). Buyer acknowledges, understands and accepts the following information: SALE, RENT AND OWNERSHIP PER MCAS TUSTIN SPECIFIC PLAN Development within the Community was originally approved for sale and ownership tenure only in accordance with Chapter 3.9.3J5 of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan. The City of Tustin has recently approved the development of a for -rent project within the Community, as more particularly described below. COVENTRY COURT An "Active Adult" project has been planned for the Community on Lot 265 of Tract No. 16581, which is located on Charleston and Cambridge Streets adjacent to Georgia Street and Kensington Park Drive, and is currently planned to consist of approximately 240 age - restricted apartment units ("Coventry Court'. Originally, Coventry Court was designed as a for -sale project in the Community, however, the current owner of Coventry Court has obtained approval from the City of Tustin to develop Coventry Court as a for -rent project in the Community. Buyer was notified of the possibility that rental housing could be located in Coventry Court in Section 23 of the Master Disclosure. As an Active Adult project, each apartment unit ("Unit") must be occupied by at least one (1) resident who is at least 55 years of age. Coventry Court is required by the City to provide a total of 153 Units with affordability restrictions and 87 market rate Units. Of the 153 affordable Units, Coventry Court is required to have 56 moderate -income restricted Units, 61 low-income restricted Units and 36 very low-income restricted Units. The affordable housing restrictions are governed through entitlements and a housing agreement (which may be amended with City of Tustin approval.) It is currently anticipated that Coventry Court will be annexed into the Community and the owner of the Coventry Court apartment complex will become a member of the Community Association and pay assessments to the Community Association on a 2:1 2544-33253\SAM369\D1SCISR\ 924526.1 10/28/09 ratio. In other words, if annexed, the owner of the Coventry Court apartment complex would pay an amount equivalent to fifty percent (50%) of the monthly Common Assessments currently paid by each Owner of a Home in the Community for each Unit in the apartment complex. Buyer understands and acknowledges that due to the change in design of Coventry Court from a for -sale to a for -rent project, the amount of Common Assessments that Buyer must pay to the Community Association are expected to increase. At this time, it is not expected that the Common Assessments will increase more than twenty percent (20%) over the amount set forth in the current build -out budget for the Community; however, Seller makes no guarantees or warranties concerning this matter. In the event Coventry Court is ever converted from a for -rent to a for -sale project, the owners of the for -sale condominium units shall be responsible for paying the same Common Assessments as all other Owners in the Community. Coventry Court is currently designed to have amenities such as a recreation building and swimming pool for use by Coventry Court owners, residents and their guests. If Coventry Court has its own recreational facilities, then all costs for the maintenance of these recreation facilities are the exclusive responsibility of the owner or residents of Units in Coventry Court. As a result, the recreational facilities located within Coventry Court are not open to other Owners in the Community; provided, however, the owners and residents of the Units in Coventry Court will have the right to use the public recreational facilities located throughout the Community. In addition, if Coventry Court is annexed into the Community as currently anticipated, then the residents of Coventry Court will have the right to use the Community Association's private recreational facilities. This Addendum supplements the disclosures contained in the Homebuyer Notification. The Homebuyer Notification, as modified by this Addendum, is hereby ratified and shall continue in effect. Buyer has read and understands the matters set forth in this Addendum and Buyer has received a copy for Buyer's records. Buyer acknowledges and agrees that Buyer is solely responsible to make certain that Buyer understands the contents of this Addendum and Buyer will take whatever steps are necessary to do so, including without limitation, consulting an attorney, interpreter, or any other person whose advice or assistance may be necessary to fully understand the matters set forth herein. Buyer acknowledges that Seller and Seller's representatives have made no other representations or warranties regarding the matters described above. Buyer acknowledges that Buyer has considered the possible effect of such matters in Buyer's decision to purchase a Home in the Community. ACKNOWLEDGED, UNDERSTOOD AND ACCEPTED: Date: _ . 200 Buyer(s) of Homesite of Tract No. 2 254433253\.SAM369\DISCLSR1924526.1 10/28/09 Print Name Print Name 2544-33253\SAM369\DISCLSR\ 924526.1 10/28/09 Attachment F Resolution Nos. 4134, 4136, and 4737 RESOLUTION NO. 4134 A RESOLUTION OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF TUSTIN RECOMMENDING THAT THE CITY COUNCIL APPROVE DESIGN REVIEW 09-024 AND CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT 09-024, AUTHORIZING THE DEVELOPMENT OF A 240 -UNIT SENIOR APARTMENT RESIDENTIAL COMPLEX (AGE RESTRICTED TO PERSONS OF 55 YEARS OR OLDER) INCLUDING 153 AFFORDABLE UNITS, WITH A PARKING STANDARD OF 1.7 SPACES PER UNIT, RECREATION CENTER, AND ASSOCIATED INFRASTRUCTURE AND SITE IMPROVEMENTS ON LOT 265 OF TRACT 16581 WITHIN PLANNING AREA 4 AND PLANNING AREA 5 OF THE MCAS TUSTIN SPECIFIC PLAN, ALSO REFERRED TO AS COVENTRY COURT IN COLUMBUS SQUARE AT TUSTIN LEGACY The Planning Commission of the City of Tustin does hereby resolve as follows: I. The Planning Commission finds and determines as follows: A. That a proper application for Design Review 09-024 and Conditional Use Permit 09-024, Amendment to Tract Map 16581 and Amendment to Concept Plan 03-003 was submitted by Lennar Corporation for the development of a 240 -unit senior apartment housing project for rental tenure on a nine (9) acre site within Columbus Square within Planning Area 4 and Planning Area 5 of the MCAS -Tustin Specific Plan (Lot 265 of Tract 16581); B. That the site is located in the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan land use designation of the General Plan, which provides for residential development, and on Reuse Disposition Parcels 23 and 24 in Planning Areas 4 and 5 of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan, which is designated for low and medium density residential; C. That a public hearing on the matter was duly called, noticed, and held for said application on December 8, 2009, by the Planning Commission; D. That the site is located within Tract 16581 previously approved by City Council Resolution No. 05-40 and Concept Plan 03-003 approved by Planning Commission Resolution No. 3951 for subdivision of 105.5 acres within Planning Areas 4 and 5 of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan for the purpose of developing 1,075 residential units including 240 senior housing units for ownership tenure of which 153 units are designate as affordable units; PC Resolution No. 4134 DR 09-024 and CUP 09-024 Page 2 E. That pursuant to Condition 2.2 of Resolution No. 05-40 approving TTM 16581, a Conditional Use Permit is required to permit a reduction in the number of on-site parking spaces from the required 2.25 spaces per unit to 1.7 spaces per unit. Conditional Use Permit 05-037 was approved in conjunction with Design Review 05-019, authorizing a parking standard of 1.7 spaces per unit for the senior condominium development; F. That the senior housing project was originally approved by Planning Commission Resolution No. 4014 as Design Review 05-019 and Conditional Use Permit 05-037 authorizing development of 240 age - restricted senior housing units for ownership tenure and a parking ratio of 1.7 spaces per unit; G. That pursuant to Condition 1.2 of Resolution No. 4014, permits must be obtained and substantial construction underway within 24 months; H. That some building permits were applied for, approved, and issued; and one (1) ten -unit building was constructed but the developer chose not to obtain additional permits or continue construction at Coventry Court; I. That since development at Coventry Court was discontinued, Design Review 05-019 and Conditional Use Permit 05-037 for Coventry Court are considered null; J. That the submitted plans are consistent with the plans that were previously approved by the Planning Commission and Community Development Department except for tenure type which is proposed to change from ownership to rental. Pursuant to Sections 3.4.2.A and 3.4.5.A of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan, development in Planning Area 4 and 5 of apartments is a discretionary action requiring approval of a conditional use permit; K. That new applications (DR 09-024, CUP 09-024, and Amendments to TM 16581 and CP 03-003) for continued development of the project and change in tenure type from ownership to rental are proposed; L. That although a new Design Review application is required for the subject project, all applicable conditions from City Council Resolution Nos. 05-40 for approval of Tentative Tract Map 16581 and 06-17 for approval of Final Tract Map 16581 remain applicable to DR 09-024; M. That the City's Traffic Engineer re -reviewed the parking demand analysis approved under CUP 05-037 in conjunction with the proposed project for PC Resolution No. 4134 DR 09-024 and CUP 09-024 Page 3 the development of 240 senior rental apartments and determined that the difference in parking demand between a senior condominium (for sale) and senior apartment (for lease) project would be negligible. Accordingly, the parking ratio of 1.7 spaces per unit approved under CUP 05-037 remains valid and applicable to the subject project (CUP 09- 024); N. That pursuant to the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan and Section 9272 of the Tustin City Code, the location, size, architectural features, and general appearance of the proposed development will not impair the orderly and harmonious development of the area, the present or future development therein, or the occupancy as a whole, in that: 1. The proposed senior residential apartment development is a permitted use in Planning Areas 4 and 5 of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan, subject to approval of a conditional use permit, 2. As conditioned, the proposed project is consistent with the development standards and design guidelines of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan, 3. As conditioned, conformance with all other applicable development standards, including current California building codes, will be verified by staff during plan check review, 4. The proposed site and building improvements are substantially consistent with plans previously approved by the Planning Commission and Community Development Department, 5. The location, size, architectural features and general appearance of the proposed development are consistent with and will not impair the orderly and harmonious development of the area, the present or future development therein, the occupancy thereof, or the community as a whole. In making such findings, the Commission has considered at least the following items: a) Height, bulk, and area of buildings. b) Setbacks and site planning. c) Exterior materials and colors. d) Type and pitch of roofs. e) Size and spacing of windows, doors, and other openings. f) Towers, chimneys, roof structures, flagpoles, radio and television antennae. g) Location, height, and standards of exterior illumination. h) Landscaping, parking area design, and traffic circulation. PC Resolution No. 4134 DR 09-024 and CUP 09-024 Page 4 i) Location and appearance of equipment located outside an enclosed structure. j) Location and method of refuse storage. k) Physical relationship of proposed structures to existing structures in the neighborhood. 1) Appearance and design relationship of proposed structures to existing structures and possible future structures in the neighborhood and public thoroughfares. m) Proposed signage. n) Development Guidelines and criteria as adopted by the City Council. O. That pursuant to Tustin City Code Section 9291, the proposed senior apartment housing development with a parking ratio of 1.7 spaces per unit will not be detrimental to the health, safety, morals, comfort, or general welfare of the persons residing or working in the neighborhood, nor be injurious or detrimental to the property and improvements in the neighborhood of the subject property, or to the general welfare of the City of Tustin, in that: 1. Multi -family residential apartment housing is a permitted use in Planning Areas 4 and 5 of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan, subject to approval of a conditional use permit; 2. The 240 -unit senior apartment project is in conformance with the MCAS Specific Plan, including the limitation of rental units to a maximum 25 percent of the total number of units permitted in the Tustin portion of the Speck Plan; 3. The change from ownership to rental tenure will not result in a change in the design, operational characteristics, or intent of the project as previously considered and approved; 4. The aging and elderly are identified in the Housing Element of the City's General Plan as a growing special needs population in the City. The Housing Element identified Coventry Court as an implementation project to meet the City's housing projections and goals; 5. The project as proposed remains an age -restricted senior project and will benefit the target population as originally intended; 6. The 153 affordable housing units will be provided just as originally approved in terms of number, location, size, bedroom counts and income level, in conformance with the approved Housing Agreement and Affordable Housing Plan for Columbus Square; PC Resolution No. 4134 DR 09-024 and CUP 09-024 Page 5 7. Approval of the project for rental tenure will allow for the project to progress and deliver the affordable housing units to the market in a more timely manner and in conformance with the requirement for reasonable proportionality in development of market -rate and .affordable housing units; 8. A parking demand analysis utilizing a parking ratio of 1.7 spaces per unit was previously approved for senior condominiums as CUP 05- 037 by Resolution No. 4014, has been re -reviewed by the City's Traffic Engineer in conjunction with the subject project, and has been determined to be satisfactory, adequate and applicable to the project as proposed for senior apartments. P. That the subdivision of 105.5 acres and development of 1,075 residential units at the Columbus Square site, including 240 multiple family attached senior housing units for ownership tenure was approved under Concept Plan (CP) 03-003 by Planning Commission Resolution No. 3951, under Tentative Tract Map (TTM) 16581 by City Council Resolution No. 05-40, and Final Tract Map (FTM) 16581 by City Council Resolution No. 06-17. The project proposed as rental units necessitates text amendments to CP 03-003, and TTM 16581 and FTM 16581 to ensure consistency of the approved housing tenure type from ownership to rental senior units, and that the necessary amendments are determined to be consistent with the intent of the approved Concept Plan and Tract Map. Q. That this project is determined to be exempt from additional CEQA review pursuant to California Government Code Section 65457, which provides that once the EIR has been certified and the specific plan adopted, any residential development project that is undertaken to implement and is consistent with the specific plan is exempt from additional CEQA review. On January 16, 2001, the City of Tustin certified the Program Final Environmental Impact Statement/Environmental Impact Report for the Reuse and Disposal of MCAS Tustin (FEIS/EIR), which evaluated the environmental impacts of the reuse and disposal of MCAS -Tustin, in conjunction with the adoption of a Speck Plan. On February 3, 2003, the Tustin City Council adopted Ordinance No. 1257, which adopted the MCAS Tustin Speck Plan. On April 3, 2006, the City Council adopted Resolution No. 06-43 approving an Addendum to the FEIS/EIR for the Disposal and Reuse of MCAS Tustin. The FEIS/EIR and its Addendum considered the potential environmental impacts associated with development on the former Marine Corps Air Station, Tustin. The development of Coventry Court at Columbus Square is a residential PC Resolution No. 4134 DR 09-024 and CUP 09-024 Page 6 development project that is being undertaken to implement and is consistent with the WAS Tustin Specific Plan, as amended. No substantial changes in the project or circumstances under which it is being undertaken have occurred and no new information which was not known at the time the EIR was certified (or amended) has become available. Therefore, the proposed project is exempt from additional environmental review under CEQA. II. The Planning Commission hereby recommends that the City Council approve Design Review 09-024 and Conditional Use Permit 09-024 for development of a 240 -unit senior housing project age restricted for persons of 55 years or older for rental tenure utilizing a parking standard of 1.7 spaces per unit on Lot 265 of Tract 16581, including 153 affordable housing units, recreation center, and associated infrastructure and site improvements, subject to the conditions contained in Exhibit A attached hereto. PASSED AND ADOPTED at a regular meeting of the Tustin Planning Commission held on the 8th day of December, 2009. STEVE KOZAK Chairperson ELIZABETH A. BINSACK Planning Commission Secretary STATE OF CALIFORNIA ) COUNTY OF ORANGE ) CITY OF TUSTIN ) I, ELIZABETH A. BINSACK, the undersigned, hereby certify that I am the Planning Commission Secretary of the Planning Commission of the City of Tustin, California; that Resolution No. 4134 duly passed and adopted at a regular meeting of the Tustin Planning Commission, held on the 8h day of December, 2009. ELIZABETH A. BINSACK Planning Commission Secretary EXHIBIT A RESOLUTION NO. 4134 DESIGN REVIEW 09-024 AND CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT 09-024 CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL GENERAL (1) 1.1 The proposed project shall conform with the Tustin City Code and Tustin guidelines and standards and be consistent with submitted plans for the project date stamped December 8, 2009, on file with the Community Development Department, except as. herein modified, or as modified by the Director of Community Development in accordance with this Exhibit. The Director of Community Development may also approve minor modifications to plans during plan check if such modifications are consistent with the provisions of the Tustin City Code, and other applicable codes. (1) 1.2 Unless otherwise specified, the conditions contained in this Exhibit shall be complied with as specified or prior to the issuance of any building permits for the project, subject to review and approval by the Community Development Department. (1) 1.3 The subject project approval shall become null and void unless permits for the proposed project are issued and substantial construction is underway within twelve (12) months. All time extensions may be considered if a written request is received within thirty (30) days prior to expiration date. (1) 1.4 Approval of Design Review 09-024, Conditional Use Permit 09-024, Amendment to Tract Map 16581, and Amendment to Concept Plan 03-003 is contingent upon the applicant returning to the Community Development Department a notarized "Agreement to Conditions Imposed" form and the property owner signing and recording with the County Clerk -Recorder a notarized "Notice of Discretionary Permit Approval and Conditions of Approval' form. The forms shall be established by the Director . of Community Development, and evidence of recordation shall be provided to the Community Development Department. SOURCE CODES (1) STANDARD CONDITION (5) RESPONSIBLE AGENCY REQUIREMENT (2) CEQA MITIGATION (6) LANDSCAPING GUIDELINES (3) UNIFORM BUILDING CODES (7) PC/CC POLICY (4) DESIGN REVIEW *** EXCEPTION PC Resolution No. 4134 DR 09-024 and CUP 09-024 Page 2 (1) 1.5 As a condition of approval of Design Review 09-024, Conditional Use Permit 09-024, Amendment to Tract Map 16581, and Amendment to Concept Plan 03-003, the applicant shall agree, at its sole cost and expense, to defend, indemnify, and hold harmless the City, its officers, employees, agents, and consultants, from any claim, action, or proceeding brought by a third party against the City, its officers, agents, and employees, which seeks to attack, set aside, challenge, void, or annul an approval of or conditions imposed by the City Council, the Planning Commission, or any other decision-making body, including staff, concerning this project. The City agrees to promptly notify the applicant of any such claim or action filed against the City and to fully cooperate in the defense of any such action.. The City may, at its sole cost and expense, elect to participate in defense of any such action under this condition. (1) 1.6 Any violation of any of the conditions imposed is subject to issuance of an Administrative Citation pursuant to Tustin City Code Section 1162(a). (1) 1.7 The applicant shall be responsible for costs associated with any necessary code enforcement action, including attorney fees, subject to the applicable notice, hearing, and appeal process as established by the City Council by ordinance. (1) 1.8 The project approval is for 240 senior housing units age restricted to persons of 55 years or older for rental tenure utilising a parking ratio of 1.7 spaces per unit, including 153 affordable units, recreation center, and infrastructure and site improvements. Any changes to the project description, scope, or affordable housing plan shall require further review and approval by the City. 1.9 The subject project approval requires the approval and execution of an amendment to the Housing Agreement, including approval and execution of a Regulatory Agreement for the project by Tustin Coventry Seniors, LLC., and Affordable Housing Plan by the City Council in form and content approved by the Redevelopment Agency, City Attorney, and City's Special Real Estate Counsel. Should amendments to the Housing Agreement and Affordable Housing Plan not be approved by the City Council, the subject approval shall become null and void. (*) 1.10 All applicable conditions of City Council Resolution Nos. 05-40 approving TTM 16581 density bonus, and affordable housing transfer and 06-17 approving FTM 16581, and Planning Commission Resolution No. 3953 approving DR 04-006 for the Columbus Square community shall remain applicable to Design Review 09-024, Conditional Use Permit 09-024, Amendment to Tract Map 16581, and Amendment to Concept Plan 03-003 as may be modified herein or in Planning Commission Resolution Nos. 4136 and/or 4137. PC Resolution No. 4134 DR 09-024 and CUP 09-024 Page 3 (') 1.11 The senior apartment development is proposed to be developed strictly as a senior complex with parking concession of 1.7 parking ratio per unit. Accordingly the senior apartment development shall be restricted to seniors of 55 years or older for the life of the project. An age restricted covenant running with the land shall be reviewed and approved by the Community Development Director and shall be recorded by the applicant prior to issuance of a building permit. DESIGN REVIEW (4) 1.12 The applicant shall clearly demonstrate compliance with all. applicable development standards of the WAS Tustin Specific Pian and the Tustin City Code on construction drawings at the time of plan check submittal. (4) 1.13 Architecturally compatible roof screening shall be incorporated into the building design similar and comparable to the roof screens that have been provided at the constructed model building on site. Details of proposed roof screens shall be provided in the construction drawings at the time of plan check submittal. (4) 1.14 Production plans shall incorporate additional chimneys as necessary to be consistent with the approved conceptual roof plans. GRADING PLAN SUBMITTAL (1) 2.1 Four (4) sets of final grading plans, including a site plan, and consistent with the landscaping plans, as prepared by a registered civil engineer, shall be submitted and shall include the following: A. Technical details and plans for all utility installations including telephone, gas, water, and electricity. B. Three (3) copies of a precise soils report provided by a civil engineer and less than one (1) year old. Expanded information regarding the levels of hydrocarbons and ground water contamination found on-site shall be provided in the soil report. All pavement W values shall be in accordance with applicable City of Tustin standards. C. Information demonstrating that all site drainage shall be handled on-site and shall not be permitted to drain onto adjacent properties. D. Information demonstrating that drainage, vegetation, circulation, street sections, curbs, gutters, sidewalks, and storm drains shall comply with the City of Tustin`s "Construction Standards for Private Streets, Storm Drain and On -Site Private Improvements," revised April 1989. E. Two (2) copies of a hydrology report. F. Information demonstrating that vehicle parking, primary entrance to the building, primary paths of travel, sanitary facilities, drinking fountain, and public telephones for the recreation building shall be PC Resolution No. 4134 DR 09-024 and CUP 09-024 Page 4 accessible to persons with disabilities. G. Building and landscape setback dimensions and dimensions for all drive aisles, back up areas, each covered parking stall, and open parking stalls. (1) 2.2 The engineer of record must submit a final compaction report to the Building Division for review and approval prior to the issuance of a building permit. (1) 2.3 The engineer of record must submit a pad certification to the Building Division for review and approval prior to the issuance of a building permit. (1) 2.4 Prior to issuance of a grading permit, the applicant shall be required to provide a performance bond to assure grading work is completed in accordance with approved plans. The engineer's estimated cost shall be submitted to the Building Official for determination of the bond amount. (1) 2.5 A note shall be provided on the final plans indicating that a six (6) foot high chain link fence shall be installed around the site prior to grading. A nylon fabric or mesh shall be attached to the temporary construction fencing. Gated entrances shall be permitted along the perimeter of the site for construction vehicles. BUILDING PLAN SUBMITTAL (3) 3.1 At the time of building permit application, the plans shall comply with the latest applicable codes, City Ordinances, State, Federal laws, and regulations as adopted by the City Council of the City of Tustin. (3) 3.2 Building plan check submittal shall include the following: • Seven (7) sets of construction plans, including drawings for mechanical, plumbing, and electrical. • Structural calculations, two (2) copies. • Title 24 energy calculations, two (2) copies. • Elevations that include all proposed dimensions, materials, colors, finishes, and partial outlines of adjacent buildings on-site and off-site where applicable • Details for the proposed windows and doors. • Roofing material shall be fire rated class "B" or better. • The location of any utility vents or other equipment shall be provided on the roof plan. • Details of all proposed lighting fixtures and a photometric study showing the location and anticipated pattern of light distribution of all proposed fixtures. All new light fixtures shall be consistent with the architecture of the building. All exterior lighting shall be designed and arranged as not to direct light or glare onto adjacent properties, including the adjacent streets. Wall- mounted fixtures shall be directed PC Resolution No. 4134 DR 09-024 and CUP 09-024 Page 5 at a 90 -degree angle directly toward the ground. All lighting shall be developed to provide a minimum of one (1) foot-candle of light coverage, in accordance with the City's Security Ordinance. • A note shall be provided on the plans that "All parking areas shall be illuminated with a minimum of one (1) foot-candle of light, and lighting shall not produce light, glare, or have a negative impact on adjacent properties." • Cross-section details showing the installation of the proposed rooftop equipment. Rooftop equipment shall be installed and maintained so as not to be visible from the public right-of-way. An elevation showing rooftop equipment installation related to the height of the parapet and proposed equipment must be identified at plan check submittal and all equipment must be six (6) inches below the top of the parapet, subject to the approval of the Community Development Director. • Noise attenuation features as required under the "Noise" section of this Resolution. • Note on plans that no field changes shall be made without prior approval from the Building Official and architect or engineer of record. (1) 3.3 Sufficiently sized concrete pad in front of mailbox structures shall be provided to allow mail carrier to place mail and homeowner to retrieve mail without standing. in the street or landscape area. (3) 3.4 Vehicle parking, primary entrance to the pool and recreational building, the primary path of travel, sanitary facilities, drinking fountains, and public telephones shall be accessible to persons with disabilities as per State of California Accessibility Standards (Title 24). Parking for disabled persons shall be provided with an additional five (5) foot loading area with striping and ramp; disabled persons shall be able to park and access the building without passing behind another car. At least one (1) accessible space shall be van accessible served by a minimum 96 inch wide loading area. (3) 3.5 The clear and unobstructed interior garage dimensions for each parking space shall be a minimum of ten (10) feet in width and twenty (20) feet in length and shall be shown on the plans. (4) 3.6 Information to ensure compliance with requirements of the Orange County Fire Authority shall be submitted including fire flow and installation of fire hydrants subject to approval of the City of Tustin Public Works and/or Irvine Ranch Water District. (1) 3.7 If determined feasible by the Building Official, the applicant shall implement one or more of the following control measures, if not already required by the SCAQMD under Rule 403 during construction as follows: a) Apply water twice daily, or chemical soil stabilizers according to manufacturers' specifications, to all unpaved parking or staging areas or unpaved road surfaces at all actively disturbed sites. PC Resolution No. 4134 DR 09-024 and CUP 09-024 Page 6 b) Develop a construction traffic management plan that includes, but is not limited to, rerouting construction trucks off congested streets, consolidating truck deliveries, and providing dedicated turn lanes for movement of construction trucks and equipment on-site and off-site. c) Use electricity from power poles rather than temporary diesel or gasoline -powered generators. d) Reduce traffic speeds on all unpaved roads to 15 mph -or less. e) Pave construction roads that have a traffic volume of more than 50 daily trips by construction equipment or 150 total daily trips for all vehicles. f) Apply approved chemical soil stabilizers according to manufacturers' specifications to all inactive construction areas (previously graded areas inactive for four days or more). g) Enclose, cover, water twice daily, or apply approved soil binders according to manufacturers' specifications to exposed piles of gravel, sand, or dirt. h) Cover all trucks hauling dirt, sand, soil, or other loose materials, and maintain at least two (2) feet of freeboard (i.e., minimum vertical distance between top of the load and top of the trailer). i) Sweep streets at the end of the day if visible soil material is carried over to adjacent roads (use water sweepers with reclaimed water when feasible). j) Install wheel washers where vehicles enter and exit unpaved roads onto paved roads or wash off trucks and any equipment leaving the site each trip. k) Use low VOC architectural coatings for all interior and exterior painting operations. PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT (1) 4.1 A separate 24" x 36" street improvement plan, as prepared by a California Registered Civil Engineer, shall be required for all construction within the public right-of-way along Edinger Avenue and West Connector Road. Construction and/or replacement of any missing or damaged public improvements will be required adjacent to this development. Said plan shall include, but not be limited to the following: a) Curb and Gutter b) Sidewalk c) Drive aprons d) Catch basin/storm drain laterals/ connection to existing storm drain PC Resolution No. 4134 DR 09-024 and CUP 09-024 Page 7 system e) Domestic water facilities f) Reclaimed water facilities g) Sanitary sewer facilities h) Underground utility connections In addition, a 24" x 36" reproducible construction area traffic control plan, as prepared by a California Registered Traffic Engineer or Civil Engineer experienced in this type of plan preparation may be required. (1) 4.2 Preparation of plans for and construction of: a. All sanitary sewer facilities shall be submitted as required by the City Engineer and Irvine Ranch Water District. b. A domestic water system shall be designed and installed to the standards of the Irvine Ranch Water District. The adequacy and reliability of the water system design and the distribution of fire hydrants shall be evaluated. The water distribution system and appurtenances shall also conform to the applicable laws and adopted regulations enforced by the Orange County Health Department. Any required reclaimed water system shall meet the standards as required by the Irvine Ranch Water District. ! (1) 4.3 The applicant shall comply and meet all conditions of Tract Map 16581. (1) 4.4 Prior to any work in the public right-of-way, an Encroachment Permit shall be obtained from and applicable fees paid to the Public Works Department. (1) 4.5 Any damage done to existing street improvements and utilities shall be repaired before issuance of a certificate of Occupancy. (1) 4.6 A complete hydrology study and hydraulic calculations shall be submitted for review and approval by the City. (1) 4.7 In addition to the normal full size map and plan submittal process, all final maps and development plans including, but not limited to: tract maps, parcel maps, right-of-way maps, records of survey, public works improvements, private infrastructure improvements, final grading plans, and site plans are also required to be submitted to the Public Works Department/Engineering Division in computer aided design and drafting (CADD) format. The standard file format is AutoCAD Release 2007, or latest version, having the extension "DWG." All layering and linotype conventions are AutoCAD -based (latest version available upon request from the Public Works Department). The CADD files shall be submitted to the City at the time the plans are approved and updated CADD files reflecting "as built" conditions shall be PC Resolution No. 4134 DR 09-024 and CUP 09-024 Page 8 submitted once all construction has been completed. No project bonds will be released until acceptable "as built" CADD files have been submitted to the City. (1) 4.8 Facility Solid Waste Collection and Recycling Plan a. Prior to approval of a site plan or the issuance of a building permit, whichever occurs first, a Facility Solid Waste Collection and Recycling Plan and a site plan covering the planned use o the facility shall be submitted utilizing the applicable from and approved by the City of Tustin Public Works Department. b. The applicant, property owner, and/or tenant(s) are required to participate in the City's recycling program. c. Waste and Recycling collection facilities shall be equally and readily accessible by the property owner(s) or tenant(s). d. Waste and Recycling collection facilities must be placed in a location that can be easily and safely accessed by the solid waste hauler which utilizing either front loader or side loading equipment. e. Adequate collection capability shall be provided to ensure that collection frequency shall not exceed four times per week for commercial customers. f. All trash enclosures shall utilize the City's standard enclosure designed to accommodate at least two (2) 4 -cubic yard bins, with at least one (1) bin reserved for recyclable materials. g. Prior to the issuance of a building permit, the Public Works Department shall review and approve the number of trash enclosures required to service the project site. 4.9 Condition of approval 4.1 of Resolution 05-40 approving Tentative Tract Map16581, which is incorporated into this approval, requires that the applicant fund its Fair Share Contribution to the Tustin Legacy Backbone Infrastructure Program. The applicant shall fund and provide security for its Fair Share Contribution to the Tustin Legacy Backbone Infrastructure Program as required by Condition of approval 4.1 of Resolution 05-40, including its Fair Share Contribution of the cost estimates of the Tustin Legacy Backbone Infrastructure as adjusted by the Tustin City Council on April 3, 2006, and September 2, 2008, and subject to future increases in the Backbone Infrastructure Program costs and applicant's Fair Share Contribution thereto. PC Resolution No. 4134 DR 09-024 and CUP 09-024 Page 9 WATER QUALITY (1) 5.1 This development shall comply with all applicable provisions of the City of Tustin Water Quality Ordinance and all Federal, State and Regional Water Quality Control Board rules and regulations. (1) 5.2 An updated Water Quality Management Plan (WQMP) shall be submitted and approved prior to issuance of grading permit. The WQMP shall be prepared using the City's WQMP Guidelines. The applicant shall submit a deposit of $2,700.00 for the estimated cost for reviewing WQMP to the City. The actual costs will be deducted from the deposit, and the applicant shall be responsible for any additional review cost that exceeded the deposit prior to issuance of grading permits. Any unused portion of the deposit will be refunded to the applicant. CONSTRUCTION PHASING AND MODEL UNIT PLAN (1) 6.1 The developer shall close and convert the model units (constructed units) to occupancy within 90 days from the last unit rented. (1) 6.2 The applicant shall comply with the submitted phasing plan. LANDSCAPING/HARDSCAPE (1) 7.1 Submit at plan check complete detailed landscaping and irrigation plans for all landscaping areas, including the model complex, consistent with adopted City of Tustin Landscaping requirements. The plans shall include the following: ■ Include a summary table identifying plan materials. The plant table shall list botanical and common names, sizes, spacing, location, and quantity of the plant materials proposed. • Show planting and berming details, soil preparation, staking, etc. The irrigation plan shall show location and control of backflow prevention devices, pipe size, sprinkler type, spacing, and coverage. Details for all equipment must be provided. • Show all property lines on the landscaping and irrigation plans, public right-of-way areas, sidewalk widths, parkway areas, and wall locations. • The Community Development Department may request minor substitutions of plant materials or request additional sizing or quantity of materials during plan check. PC Resolution No. 4134 DR 09-024 and CUP 09-024 Page 10 ■ Add a note that coverage of landscaping and irrigation materials is subject to inspection at project completion by the Community Development Department. • Turf is unacceptable for grades over 25 percent. A combination of planting materials shall be used. On large areas, ground cover alone is not acceptable. ■ Shrubs shall be a minimum of five (5) gallon size and shall be placed a maximum of five (5) feet on center. ■ Fences, wall, and equipment areas shall be screened with walls, vines, and/or trees. ■ All plant materials shall be installed in a healthy vigorous condition typical to the species and shall be maintained in a neat and healthy condition. Maintenance includes, but is not limited to, trimming, weeding, removal of litter, fertilizing, regular watering, and replacement of diseased or dead plants. ■ Landscape adjacent to the right-of-way shall be in compliance with the requirements of MCAS Tustin Speck Plan. Perimeter walls should be treated with vines to relieve large expanse walls with greenery and color. Vines shall be informally grouped and installed with training devices. (4) 7.2 On-site walls and fences shall be noted on the plans with specific materials, colors, and decorative treatments. Interior wall/fences shall be made of durable materials subject to review and approval of the Community Development Department. PARKING (*) 8.1 The approved parking ratio of 1.7 parking spaces per unit is contingent on the property remaining a senior housing complex for persons of 55 years and older. The project shall provide a minimum of 409 parking spaces including a minimum of 200 one -car garage spaces and 40 carports, 130 open guest parking stalls, 28 parallel street parking, 10 ADA accessible parking spaces and 1 ADA van accessible parking space. RENTER NOTIFICATION (1) 9.1 The applicant shall submit to the Community Development Department for review and approval a renter notification document that includes the notifications listed below. The notification document shall be signed by each renter(s) prior to occupancy, and a copy of the signed notification shall be provided to the Community Development Department prior to final inspection and/or issuance of each Certificate of Occupancy. PC Resolution No. 4134 DR 09-024 and CUP 09-024 Page 11 A. A notice for roadway, trail, and train noise that may impact the project, including roadway noise associated with, Edinger Avenue, North Loop Road, Kensington Park Drive, and train noise associated with the rail corridor north of the project. The notice shall indicate the current number of trains per day (59) and the estimated to increase to over 100 trains on a 24 hour basis by the year 2020. The notice shall indicate that additional building upgrades may be necessary for noise attenuation. This determination is to be made as architectural drawings become available and/or where field-testing determines inadequate noise insulation. B. A notice, to be reviewed by the City of Tustin and the Tustin Unified School District, regarding the location of existing. and proposed elementary, middle, and high schools which will serve the subdivision (text and map) and advice to renters that proposed school sites may never be constructed. C. A notice regarding units that are adjacent to aboveground utilities or structures (such as light standards and fire hydrants) identifying the type of structure and their locations. D. A notice indicating that any use of a residence for a business shall be o, subject to the City's Home Occupation Ordinance and may require zoning clearance and a business license. E. A notice indicating that public use of a minimum one (1) acre or more portion of the park site,. to be maintained by the homeowners association, will be allowed and noting public ingress and egress through the subdivision will be provided for access to the park. F. A notice explaining the easements, facilities, amenities, and dedications that will be provided on lettered lots and indicating all on- site streets, alleys, paseos, and common areas are to be maintained by the homeowners association. G. A notice, to be approved by the City Attorney, indicating that neither the site, nor the project nor any part thereof any street or sidewalk, alleyway, or paseo thereon shall be privately gated, provided however that any swimming pool and/or spa facility within the common area and any indoor common area improvements, including any clubhouse and bathrooms, may be gated or locked and made available solely to residents of the project and their guests. H. A notice indicating that surrounding properties may be developed in accordance with City ordinances in a manner which may partially or totally obstruct views from the renter's unit and that the City of Tustin PC Resolution No. 4134 DR 09-024 and CUP 09-024 Page 12 makes no claim, warranty, or guarantee that views from any unit will be preserved as development of surrounding properties occurs. I. A notice explaining that 153 affordable housing units will be dispersed throughout the project site. These units will remain affordable for a period of fifty-five (55) years or longer. J. A notice explaining the phasing of construction within the project site and surrounding subdivison and that activity may be disruptive. K. A notice that the project is located adjacent to a future fire station site at the southwest corner of Edinger Avenue and Kensington Park Drive and that the station will be operating 24 hours. ORANGE COUNTY FIRE AUTHORITY (5) 10.1 Prior to the issuance of any grading, the applicant shall submit a fire hydrant location plan to the Fire Chief for review and approval. (5) 10.2 Prior to the issuance of a building permit, the applicant shall submit evidence of the on-site fire hydrant system to the Fire Chief and indicate whether it is public or private. If the system is private, it shall be reviewed and approved by the Fire Chief prior to building permit issuance, and the applicant shall make provisions for the repair and maintenance of the +- system in a manner meeting the approval of the Fire Chief. Please contact the OCFA at (714) 573-6100 or visit the OCFA website for a copy of the "Guidelines for Private Fire Hydrant Wor Sprinkler Underground Piping." (5) 10.3 Prior to the issuance of any certificate of occupancy, all fire hydrants shall have a blue reflective pavement marker indicating the hydrant location on the street as approved by the Fire Chief, and must be maintained in good condition by the property owner. Please contact the OCFA at (714) 573- 6100 or visit the OCFA website for a copy of the "Guideline for Installation of Blue Dot Hydrant Markers." (5) 10.4 Prior to the issuance of any grading, the applicant shall provide evidence of adequate fire flow. The "Orange County Fire Authority Water Availability for Fire Protection" form shall be signed by the applicable water district and submitted to the Fire Chief for approval. If sufficient water to meet fire flow requirements is not available an automatic fire extinguishing system may be required in each structure affected. (5) 10.5 Prior to the issuance of building permits, a note shall be placed on the plans stating that all residential structures (R-1 occupancies) and any structure exceeding 6,000 square feet (per amendment) shall be protected by an automatic fire sprinkler system in a manner meeting the approval of the Fire Chief. PC Resolution No. 4134 DR 09-024 and CUP 09-024 Page 13 (5) 10.6 Prior to the issuance of a building permit, the applicant shall submit plans for any required automatic fire sprinkler system in any structure to the Fire Chief for review and approval. Please contact the OCFA at (714) 573- 6100 for additional information. (5) 10.7 Prior to the issuance of a certificate of occupancy, this system shall be operational in a manner meeting the approval of the Fire Chief. (5) 10.8 Prior to the issuance of any grading or building permits, the applicant shall obtain approval of the Fire Chief for all fire protection access roads to within 150 feet of all portions of the exterior of every structure on site. Please contact the OCFA at (714) 573-6100 or visit the OCFA website to obtain a copy of the "Guidelines for Emergency Access, or Bulletin number 08-99, "Fire Department Access Requirements for A Single Family Residence." (5) 10.9 Prior to the issuance of a precise grading permit or building permit, the applicant shall submit and obtain approval of the Fire Chief and City Staff of plans for all public or private access roads, streets and courts. The plans shall include plan .and sectional views and indicate the grade and width of the access road measured flow -line to flow -line. When a dead- end street exceeds 150 feet or when otherwise required, a clearly marked C fire apparatus access turnaround must be provided and approved by the Fire Chief. Applicable CC&R'S or other approved documents shall contain provisions which prohibit obstructions such as speed bumps/humps, control gates or other modifications within said easement or access road unless prior approval of the Fire Chief is granted. Please contact the OCFA at (714) 573-6100 or visit the OCFA website to obtain a copy of the "Guidelines for Emergency Access." (5) 10.10 A note shall be placed on the fire protection access easement plan indicating that all streettroad signs shall be designed and maintained to be either internally or externally illuminated in a manner meeting approval of the Fire Chief. (5) 10.11 Prior to the issuance of any grading or building permits, the applicant shall submit plans and obtain approval from the Fire Chief for fire lanes on required fire access roads less than 36 feet in width. The plans shall indicate the locations of red curbs and signage and include a detail of the proposed signage including the height, stroke and colors of the lettering and its contrasting background. Please contact the OCFA at (714) 573- 6100 or visit the OCFA website to obtain a copy of the "Guidelines for Emergency Access Roadways and Fire Lane Requirements," or Bulletin 06-99, "Fire Lane Requirements on Private & Public Streets Within Residential Developments." (5) 10.12 Prior to the issuance of any certificate of occupancy, the fire lanes shall be installed in accordance with the approved fire lane plan. The CC&R'S or PC Resolution No. 4134 DR 09-024 and CUP 09-024 Page 14 other approved documents shall contain • a fire lane map, provisions prohibiting parking in the fire lanes, and an enforcement method. (5) 10.13 Prior to the issuance of any grading permits, the applicant shall obtain the approval from the Fire Chief for the construction of any gate across required fire department access roads. Please contact the OCFA at (714) 573-6100 or visit the OCFA website to obtain a copy of the "Guidelines for Design and Installation of Emergency Access Gates and Barriers." (5) 10.14 Prior to the issuance of a building permit for combustible construction, the builder shall submit a letter on company letterhead stating that water for fire -fighting purposes and all-weather fire protection access roads shall be in place and operational before any combustible material is placed on site. Building permits will not be issued without OCFA approval obtained as a result of an on-site inspection. Please contact the OCFA at (714) 573- 6100 to obtain a copy of the standard combustible construction letter. (5) 10.15 Prior to the issuance of a building permit, the applicant shall submit architectural plans for the review and approval of the Fire Chief if required per the "Orange County Fire Authority Plan Submittal Criteria Form." Please contact the OCFA at (714) 573-6100 for a copy of the Site/Architectural Notes to be placed on the plans prior to submittal. (5) 10.16 Prior to the issuance of a building permit, plans for the fire alarm system shall be submitted to the Fire Chief for review and approval. Please contact the OCFA at (714) 573-6100 or visit the OCFA website to obtain a copy of the "Guideline for New and Existing Fire Alarm Systems." (5) 10.17 This system shall be operational prior to the issuance of a certificate of occupancy. NOISE (1) 11.1 Noise attenuation measures as recommended by the noise analysis shall be included with the construction drawings for plan check, which ensure a minimum outdoor -indoor transmission class (OITC) of 37. The interior and exterior noise levels (including balconies of six feet in width) shall comply with City of Tustin noise requirements. (1) 11.2. In accordance with the noise analysis, all units are required to include air conditioning units or fresh air intake systems to achieve the minimum interior noise level standards shall have these units installed prior to issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy. Prior to final inspection and issuance of certificates of use and occupancy, the developer shall provide an independent noise analysis verifying that interior noise levels comply with Title 25 and City noise requirements. (1) 11.3 The perimeter sound walls are included as part of the master wall plans for Columbus Square currently under review. PC Resolution No. 4134 DR 09-024 and CUP 09-024 Page 15 PUBLIC SAFETY (4) 12.1 Required lighting shall be installed so as not landscaping and possible reduced lighting output. be shown on lighting and landscape plans at submittal. ENVIRONMENTAL to be in conflict with Evidence of such shall the time of plan check (1) 13.1 Additional measures related to development of this project as noted in the adopted EIS/EIR including, but not limited to the following: A. Prior to issuance of a grading permit, the developer shall retain a County -certified archaeologist. If buried resources are found during grading within the reuse plan area, a qualified archaeologist would need to assess the site significance and perform the appropriate mitigation. The Native American viewpoint shall be considered during this process. This could include testing or data recovery. Native American consultation shall also be initiated during this process. B. The developer shall comply with the requirements established in a Palentological Resource Management Plan (PRMP) prepared for the site, which details the methods to be used for surveillance of construction grading, assessing finds, and actions to be taken in the event that unique paleontological resources are found. C. Prior to the issuance of a grading permit, the applicant shall provide written evidence to the Community Development Department that a County -certified paleontologist has been retained to conduct salvage excavation of unique paleontological resources if they are found. D. Prior to issuance of any permit, the developer shall provide traffic operations and control plans that would minimize the traffic impacts of proposed construction activity. The plans shall address roadway and lane closures, truck hours and routes, and notification procedures for planned short-term or interim changes in traffic patterns. Such plans shall minimize anticipated delays at major intersections. Prior to approval, the City of Tustin or the City of Irvine, as applicable, shall review the proposed traffic control and operations plans with any affected jurisdiction. FEES (1)(5) 14.1 Prior to issuance of any building permits, payment shall be made of all PC Resolution No. 4134 DR 09-024 and CUP 09-024 Page 16 (1) applicable fees, including but not limited to, the following. Payment shall be required based upon those rates in effect at the time of payment and are subject to change. a. Building plan check and permit fees to the Community Development Department based on the most current schedule at the time of permit issuance. b. Engineering plan check and permit fees to the Public Works Department based on the most current schedule at the time of permit issuance. C. Orange County Fire Authority plan check and inspection fees to the Community Development Department based upon the most current schedule at the time of permit issuance. d. Major Thoroughfare and Bridge Fees to the Tustin Public Works Department based on the most current schedule at the time of permit issuance. e. Transportation System Improvement Program (TSIP), Benefit Area "B" fees in the amount of $3.31 per square foot of new or added gross square floor area of construction or improvements to the Community Development Department. f. Water and sewer connection fees to the Irvine Ranch Water District. g. New development tax in the amount of $350.00 per unit, plus $100.00 per bedroom over one (1) bedroom in each unit. h. School facilities fee in the amount as required by Tustin Unified School District. is Other applicable parkland in -lieu fees and Tustin Legacy Backbone Infrastructure Program fees as required by Resolution No. 05-40. 14.2 Within forty-eight (48) hours of final approval of the project, the applicant shall deliver to the Community Development Department, a CASHIER'S CHECK payable to the County Clerk in the amount of fifty dollars ($50.00) to enable the City to file the appropriate environmental documentation for the project. If within such forty-eight (48) hour period that applicant has not delivered to the Community Development Department the above -noted check, the statute of limitations for any interested party to challenge the environmental determination under the provisions of the California Environmental Quality Act could be significantly lengthened. t RESOLUTION NO. 4136 A RESOLUTION OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION RECOMMENDING THAT THE CITY COUNCIL APPROVE AMENDMENT TO CONCEPT PLAN 03- 003 TO REFLECT A CHANGE IN TENURE FROM OWNERSHIP TO RENTAL FOR THE PROPOSED 240 -UNIT AGE -RESTRICTED SENIOR HOUSING COMPLEX ON LOT 265 OF TRACT 16581 (COVENTRY COURT IN COLUMBUS SQUARE AT TUSTIN LEGACY) The Planning Commission of the City of Tustin does hereby resolve as follows: I. The Planning Commission finds and determines as follows: A. That a proper application for Design Review 09-024 and Conditional Use Permit 09-024, Amendment to Resolution No, 05- 40 which approved Tract Map 16581 and Amendment to Resolution No, 3951 which approved Concept Plan 03-003 was submitted by Lennar Corporation for the development of a 240 -unit senior apartment housing project for rental tenure on a nine (9) acre site within Columbus Square within Planning Area 4 and Planning Area 5 of the MCAS -Tustin Speck Plan (Lot 265 of Tract 16581); NOW B. That the site is located is located within Tract 16581revi p ously approved by City Council Resolution No. 05-40 in the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan land use designation of the General Plan, which provides for residential development, and on Reuse Disposition Parcels 23 and 24 in Planning Areas 4 and 5 of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan, which is designated for low and medium density residential; C. That a public hearing on the matter was duly called, noticed, and held for said application on December 8, 2009, by the Planning Commission; D. That on February 14, 2005, the Planning Commission adopted Resolution No. 3951 approving Concept Plan 03-003 to subdivide 105.5 acres for the purpose of developing 1,077 residential units including 84 Single Family Detached (SFD), 181 Carriage Way SFD, 72 Multiple Family Attached (senior housing -- for ownership tenure) for a total of 337 units at an average density of 8.62 du/acre in Planning Area 4 (Parcel 23) and 18 carriage way units, 552 Multiple Family Attached (MFR), 170 Multiple Family Attached (senior housing -- for ownership tenure) for a total of 740 units at an Resolution No. 4136 Amendment to Concept Plan 03-003 Page 2 Average density 17.53 du/acre for Planning Area 5 (Parcel 24) of the. WAS Tustin Specific Plan; E. That the submitted plans are consistent with the plans that were previously approved by the Planning Commission and Community Development Department except for tenure type which is proposed to change from ownership to rental; F. That the proposed project necessitates text amendments to Resolution 3951 which approved Concept Plan 03-003; G. That the amendment to Concept Plan 03-003 is in conformance with the Tustin Area General Plan and MCAS Tustin Specific Plan and approval of Concept Plan 03-003, subject to conditions contained in Resolution Nos. 4134 and 4137, would achieve the development concepts set forth by the MCAS Tustin Speck Plan, including: 1. Ensuring the continuity and adequacy of all circulation systems, such as: roadways, access points, trails, pedestrian ways, and other infrastructure systems needed to serve the project; 2. Ensuring the continuity and design quality of architecture, landscape, and hardscape themes and treatments; 3. Providing urban design features as per Chapters 2 and 3 of the WAS Tustin Specific Plan; 4. Ensuring conformity with the Non -Residential Land Use Trip Budget; and, 5. Ensuring compliance with all applicable provisions of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan. II. The Planning Commission hereby recommends that the City Council approve amendment to Concept Plan 03-003 to reflect a change in tenure from ownership to rental for the proposed 240 -unit age -restricted senior apartment housing project on a nine (9) acre site within Columbus Square within Planning Area 4 and Planning Area 5 of the MCAS -Tustin Specific Plan (Lot 265 of Tract 16581), subject to the conditions of approval attached hereto. PASSED AND ADOPTED at a regular meeting of the Tustin Planning Commission held on the 8th day of December, 2009. STEVE KOZAK Chairperson Resolution No. 4136 Amendment to Concept Plan 03-003 Page 2 ELIZABETH A. BINSACK Planning Commission Secretary STATE OF CALIFORNIA ) COUNTY OF ORANGE ) CITY OF TUSTIN ) I, ELIZABETH A. BINSACK, the undersigned, hereby certify that I am the Planning Commission Secretary of the Planning Commission of the City of Tustin, California; that Resolution No. 4136 was duly passed and adopted at a regular meeting of the Tustin Planning Commission, held on the 8t' day December, 2009 ELIZABETH A. BINSACK Planning Commission Secretary (1) EXHIBIT A RESOLUTION NO. 4136 AMENDMENT TO CONCEPT PLAN 03-003 CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL 1.1 Concept Plan 03-003 is approved for development of 1,075 residential units in Planning Area 4 and Planning Area 5 as follows: Planning Area 4 (Parcel 23) 84 Single Family Detached (SFD) 181 Carriage Way SFD 72 Multiple Family Attached (Senior Housing) Total: 337 units Average density of 8.62 du/acre 5 (Parcel 24) 18 Carriage Way units 552 Multiple Family Attached (MFR) 170 Multiple Family Attached (Senior Housing) Total: 740 units Average density 17.53 du/acre 1.2 The amendment to the approved concept plan and Regulatory Agreement is subject to execution of the First Amendment to the Housing Agreement in conformance with the requirements of the density bonus application as approved by - the City Council, Condition 1.9 and 1.10 of Planning Commission Resolution No. 4134, and Condition 2.2 of Resolution No. 4137. (*) 1.3 Resolution No. 4136 shall become null and void in the event that Resolution Nos. 4134 approving Design Review 09-024 and Conditional Use Permit 09-024 and Resolution No. 4137 approving Amendment to the Tract Map 16581 are not approved by the City Council. (1) 1.4 Approval of Amendment to Concept Plan 03-003 shall be contingent upon all conditions of approval contained within Resolution Nos. 4134 and 4137. (***) 1.5 Condition of approval 4.1 of Resolution 05-40 approving Tentative Tract Map16581, which is incorporated into this approval, requires that the applicant fund its Fair Share Contribution to the Tustin Legacy Backbone Infrastructure Program. The applicant shall fund and provide security for its Fair Share Contribution to the Tustin Legacy Backbone Infrastructure Program as required by Condition of approval 4.1 of Resolution 05-40, including its Fair Share Contribution of the cost estimates of the Tustin Legacy Backbone Infrastructure as adjusted by the Tustin City Council on April 3, 2006 and September 2, 2008, and subject to future increases in the Backbone Infrastructure Program costs and applicant's Fair Share Contribution thereto. RESOLUTION NO. 4137 A RESOLUTION OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF TUSTIN RECOMMENDING THAT THE CITY COUNCIL APPROVE AMENDMENT TO RESOLUTION NO. 05-40, WHICH APPROVED TENTATIVE TRACT MAP 16581, TO REFLECT A CHANGE IN TENURE FROM OWNERSHIP TO RENTAL FOR THE PROPOSED 240 -UNIT AGE - RESTRICTED SENIOR HOUSING COMPLEX ON LOT 265 OF TRACT 16581 (COVENTRY COURT IN COLUMBUS SQUARE AT TUSTIN LEGACY) The Planning Commission of the City of Tustin does hereby resolve as follows: I. The Planning Commission finds and determines as follows: A. That a proper application for Design Review 09-024 and Conditional Use Permit 09-024, Amendment to Resolution No. 05-40, which approved Tract Map 16581, and Amendment to Resolution No. 3951, which approved Concept Plan 03-003, was submitted by Lennar Corporation for the development of a 240 -unit senior apartment housing project for rental tenure on a nine (9) acre site within Columbus Square within Planning Area 4 and Planning Area 5 of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan (Lot 265 of Tract 16581); �.. B. That the site is located in the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan land use designation of the General Plan, which provides for residential development, and on Reuse Disposition Parcels 23 and 24 in Planning Areas 4 and 5 of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan, which is designated for low and medium density residential uses; C. That a public hearing on the matter was duly called, noticed, and held for said application on December 8, 2009, by the Planning Commission; D. That the site is located within Tract 16581 previously approved by City Council Resolution Nos. 05-40 and 06-17 for subdivision of 105.5 acres within Planning Areas 4 and 5 of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan for the purpose of developing 1,075 residential units including 240 senior housing units for ownership tenure; E. That the applicant submitted a request to allow a change in tenure from ownership to rental for the proposed 240 -unit age restricted senior housing complex; F. That the request is consistent with the previously -approved project and the text changes are for consistency purposes and do not constitute a significant change from the intent of the original approvals; Resolution No. 4137 Amendment to TTM 16581 Page 2 G. That the proposed project necessitates text amendments to Resolution No. 05-40 which approved Tentative Tract Map 16581; H. That pursuant to the previously -approved Tract Map 16581, density bonus, and transfer of affordable housing units for Columbus Square, the Columbus Square Housing Agreement, and the Affordable Housing Plan for Villages of Columbus, the senior housing project includes 153 affordable housing units (36 Very Low, 61 Low, and 56 Moderate Income units). The proposed project includes the prescribed number of affordable units identical in size, location, bedroom counts, and income levels as to the previously approved plans with the exception of the type of tenure; I. That this project is determined to be exempt from additional CEQA review pursuant to California Government Code Section 65457, which provides that once the EIR has been certified and the speck plan adopted, any residential development project that is undertaken to implement and is consistent with the specific plan is exempt from additional CEQA review; On January 16, 2001, the City of Tustin certified the Program Final Environmental Impact Statement/Environmental Impact Report for the Reuse and Disposal of MCAS Tustin (FEIS/EIR), which evaluated the environmental impacts of the reuse and disposal of MCAS -Tustin, in conjunction with the adoption of a Specific Plan. On February 3, 2003, the Tustin City Council adopted Ordinance No. 1257, which adopted the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan. On April 3, 2006, the City Council adopted Resolution No. 06-43 approving an Addendum to the FEIS/EIR for the Disposal and Reuse of MCAS Tustin. The FEIS/EIR and its Addendum considered the potential environmental impacts associated with development on the former Marine Corps Air Station, Tustin. The development of Coventry Court at Columbus Square is a residential development project that is being undertaken to implement and is consistent with the MCAS Tustin Speck Plan, as amended. No substantial changes in the project or circumstances under which it is being undertaken have occurred and no new information which was not known at the time the EIR was certified (or amended) has become available. Therefore, the proposed project is exempt from' additional environmental review under CEQA. II. The Planning Commission hereby recommends that the City Council approve amendment to Resolution No. 05-40, which approved Tentative Tract Map 16581, to reflect a change in tenure from ownership to rental for the proposed 240 -unit age -restricted senior housing complex on Lot 265 of Tract 16581, subject to the conditions contained in Exhibit A attached hereto. Resolution No. 4137 Amendment to TTM 16581 Page 3 PASSED AND ADOPTED at a regular meeting of the Tustin Planning Commission held on the 8th day of December, 2009. STEVE KOZAK Chairperson ELIZABETH A. BINSACK Planning Commission Secretary STATE OF CALIFORNIA ) COUNTY OF ORANGE ) CITY OF TUSTIN ) I, ELIZABETH A. BINSACK, the undersigned, hereby certify that I am the Planning Commission Secretary of the Planning Commission of the City of Tustin, California; that Resolution No. 4137 duly passed and adopted at a regular meeting of the Tustin Planning Commission, held on the 8th day of December, 2009. ELIZABETH A. BINSACK Planning Commission Secretary EXHIBIT A RESOLUTION NO. 4137 AMENDMENT TO TENTATIVE TRACT MAP 16581 CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL GENERAL (1) 1.1 All applicable conditions of City Council Resolution Nos. 05-40 approving TTM 16581, a density bonus, and affordable housing transfer and 06-17 approving FTM 16581 for the Columbus Square community shall remain applicable, as herein modified. (1) 1.2 Approval of Resolution No. 4137 is contingent upon the applicant returning to the Community Development Department a notarized "Agreement to Conditions Imposed" form and the property owner signing and recording with the County Clerk -Recorder a notarized "Notice of Discretionary Permit Approval and Conditions of Approval" form. The forms shall be established by the Director of Community Development, and evidence of recordation shall be provided to the Community Development Department. (***) 1.3 The senior apartment development shall be restricted to seniors of 55 years or older for the life of the project. An age -restrictive covenant running with the land shall be reviewed and approved by the Community Development Director and shall be recorded by the applicant prior to issuance of a building permit. (***) 1.4 Prior to issuance of a building permit, the applicant shall submit an Addendum to Homebuyer Notification for Columbus Square and a letter that will be sent to all existing homeowners explaining the change in Coventry Court. Proof of mailing of the Addendum to Homebuyer Notification and the letter to existing homeowners shall be submitted to the Community Development prior to final inspection and occupancy. (1) 1.6 The applicant shall submit an amendment to Final Tract Map 16581 or a Certificate of Correction to reflect aged restricted to seniors of 55 years or older, for review and approval. The amended Final Tract Map. or Certificate of Correction shall be recorded prior to issuance of a building permit. SOURCE CODES (1) STANDARD CONDITION (5) RESPONSIBLE AGENCY REQUIREMENT (2) CEQA MITIGATION (6) LANDSCAPING GUIDELINES (3) UNIFORM BUILDING CODE/S (7) PC/CC POLICY (4) DESIGN REVIEW *** EXCEPTION (1) 1.7 Resolution No. 4137 shall become null and void in the event that Exhibit A Resolution No. 4137 TTM 16581 Page 2 Resolution No. 4134 approving Conditional Use Permit 09-024 and Design Review 09-024 and Resolution No. 4136 approving amendment to Resolution No. 3951 which approved Concept Plan 03-003 are not approved by the City Council. 1.8 Condition of approval 4.1 of Resolution 05-40 approving Tentative Tract Map16581,which is incorporated into this approval, requires that the applicant fund its Fair Share Contribution to the Tustin Legacy Backbone Infrastructure Program. The applicant shall fund and provide security for its Fair Share Contribution -to the Tustin Legacy Backbone Infrastructure Program as required by Condition of approval 4.1 of Resolution 05-40, including its Fair Share Contribution of the cost estimates of the Tustin Legacy Backbone Infrastructure as adjusted by the Tustin City Council on April 3, 2006, and September 2, 2008, and subject to future increases in the Backbone Infrastructure Program costs and applicant's Fair Share Contribution thereto. AFFORDABLE HOUSING 2.1 The developer shall comply with the obligations contained in Resolution No. 05-40 regarding affordable housing units. The senior housing project shall contain a minimum of 153 affordable units including 36 Very Low, 61 Low, and 56 Moderate Income units and at locations depicted on the previously approved Affordable Housing Plan. 2.2 The First Amendment to the Housing Agreement shall include a Regulatory Agreement as an exhibit to reflect rental tenure which will be required to be executed by Tustin Coventry Seniors, LLC. (the proposed owner of the project). The First Amendment to the Housing Agreement shall be subject to approval of the Redevelopment Agency, City Attorney, and City's Special Real Estate Counsel as to form and content and shall be executed and recorded prior to issuance of any building permits. Should the First Amendment to the Housing Agreement and Affordable Housing Plan not be approved by the City Council, the subject approval shall become null and void. 2.3 Prior to issuance of any building permits, an Assignment and Assumption Agreement of Tustin Coventry, LLC.'s duties of performance under the Housing Agreement, as amended, shall be executed between Tustin Villas Partners, LLC. and Tustin Coventry Seniors, LLC. on Lot 265 of Tract 16581 in a form and content approved by the Redevelopment Agency, Community Exhibit A Resolution No. 4137 TTM 16581 Page 3 Development Department, City Attorney, and City's Special Real Estate Counsel and the Community Development Department (***) 2.4 The "Affordable Housing Plan and Density Bonus Application" document approved for the Columbus Square shall be amended to reflect the rental tenure and a clean copy of the document shall be provided to the City and Redevelopment Agency for final review and approval, prior to issuance of a building permit. (***) 2.5 The 240 -unit project shall not feature a mix of housing tenure (i.e. ownership and rental) during the term of affordability outlined in the First Amendment to the Housing Agreement and any executed Regulatory Agreement. (***) 2.6 The affordable units in the project shall be available during the qualified project period outlined in the First Amendment to the Housing Agreement which shall be not less than 55 years. (***) 2.7 The affordable units shall comply with the City's adopted Local Workforce Housing Preference Policy by granting current Tustin residents or individuals employed within the city of Tustin preference over an applicant who does not currently reside or is not employed in the City of Tustin. FEES .� (***) 3.1 The applicant shall submit all fees required by the City and other agencies as identified in Resolution No. 4134 including all Attorney and Special Counsel fees associated with the review of the project. ATTACHMENT B Letter from Lennar dated December 8, 2009 requesting amendments to conditions of approval December 8, 2009 VIA HAND DELIVERY Ms. Elizabeth A. Binsack Community Development Director City of Tustin 300 Centennial Way Tustin, CA 92780 Re: Planning Commission Review of CUP 09-024, DR 09-024, Amendment to Tract Map 16581, and Amendment to Concept Plan 03-003 Dear Elizabeth: As you know, Lennar Homes ("Lennar") is a member of Tustin Coventry, LLC (the "LLC'J, which is the applicant for purposes of Conditional Use Permit 09-024, Design Review 09-024, Amendment to Tract Map 16581, and Amendment to Concept Plan 03-003 (collectively, the "Project Approvals"), currently scheduled to go before the City of Tustin's ("City") Planning Commission on December 8, 2009. On behalf of the LLC, we would like to thank City management and staff for working with the LLC to bring this matter to the City's Planning Commission for consideration. Upon our review of the Agenda Report, the draft Resolutions, and conditions of approval for the Project Approvals, we have several concerns and/or matters of clarification we would like to point out for the Planning Commission's consideration at the December 8h meeting. The LLC's requested modifications are reflected in underline and strikethrough formatting below: Resolution No. 4134, Condition No. 1.9 — The LLC requests that the following underlined text be added: "The subject project approval requires the approval and execution of an amendment to the Housing Agreement, including approval and execution of a Regulatory Agreement for the project by Tustin Coventry Seniors, LLC, or other owner of the subject Mrouerty reasonably approved by the City, an Affordable Housing Plan by the City Council in a form and content approved by the Redevelopment Agency, City Attorney, and City's Special Real Estate Counsel. Should amendments to the Housing Agreement and Affordable Housing Plan not be approved by the City Council, the subject approval shall become null and void." • Resolution No. 4134, Condition No. 4.9 — The LLC feels this condition has been added in error. Moffet Meadows Partners, LLC, was the applicant for Tentative Tract Map 16581. Tustin Coventry, LLC was not the applicant for that map, and therefore the condition appears to improperly pass any "Fair Share Contribution" obligations under the City's Backbone Infrastructure Program ("Program") on to Tustin Coventry, LLC, which is not a participant in the Program. In addition, Tustin Coventry, LLC, as the applicant for this project, was never subject to, provided invoices for, or paid fees relating to, any "cost adjustments" under the Program in April 2006 or September 2008, and has never been conditioned to pay any future adjustments for the Program. Therefore, the LLC requests that this condition be removed in its entirety because it is confusing and improper. If, however, the Planning Commission is not willing to remove the condition in its entirety, the LLC requests that the following stricken language be removed from the Condition since the applicant was never subject to any Fair Share Allocation increases under the Program in 2006 or 2008, or any future increases under the Program: "Condition of approval 4.1 of Resolution 05-40 approving Tentative Tract Map 16581, which is incorporated into this approval, requires that the applicant fund its Fair Share Contribution to the Tustin Legacy Backbone Infrastructure Program. The applicant shall fund any provide security for its Fair Share Contribution to the Tustin Legacy Backbone Infrastructure Program as required by Condition of approval 4.1 of Resolution 05-40, ineluding its Pak 916 Couneil en--Ap6l 3, 2806, &Rd September- 2, 2008, Wad themte." If the Planning Commission is not willing to remove the condition in its entirety, or in the alternative, remove the stricken language as reflected above, then the LLC requests that the following sentence be added to the end of Condition No. 4.9: "Nothing herein shall affect or vreiudice the rights of the parties in the pending litiltation of Marble Mountain Partners. LLC v. City of Tustin, et al., Case No. 30-2008- 00116681, filed in Orange _County Suverior Court on December 29, 2008." • Resolution No. 4136, Exhibit A, Condition No. 1.5 — Same comments as for Resolution No. 4134, Condition No. 4.9 above. • Resolution No. 4137, Exhibit A, Condition No. 1.8 — Same comments as for Resolution No. 4134, Condition No. 4.9 above. If the condition regarding payment of Fair Share Allocation under the Backbone Infrastructure Program, or references to the April 2006 and/or September 2008 increases (or future increases) appears anywhere else in the Resolutions or Conditions of Approval for the Project Approvals that we have failed to point out here, we request that the above requests be applied to those references as well. Thank you very much for your consideration. Very y yours, Vt� L onna Kelly Vice President of Community Development cc: Chairman and Members of the Tustin Planning Commission William Huston, City Manager Christine Shingleton, Assistant City Manager ATTACHMENT C Public Input - emails and letters received from residents Willkom, Justina Subject: FW: Columbus Square - Res No. 4129, Dec 8th Meeting From: Eric Higuchi [mailto:ehiguchi@gmail.com] Sent: Monday, December 07, 2009 10:22 PM To: skozak@tustinca.org; amurray@tustinca.org; cpuckett@tustinca.org; mkasalek@tustinca.org; Thompson, Jay Cc: Shingleton, Christine; Amante, Jerry; Nielsen, John; Palmer, Jim; Gavello, Deborah; Davert, Doug; Huston, William; pstoker@tustinca.org; Interim City Clerk Subject: Columbus Square - Res No. 4129, Dec 8th Meeting Eric Higuchi 1408 Mayfield Way Tustin, CA 92782 December 7th, 2009 To the City of Tustin Planning Commission:, My name is Eric Higuchi and I am a current resident and active member of the Columbus Square Community. It has recently been brought to the attention of many members of the community that the Managing Developer (Lennar) of the community of Columbus Square at Tustin Legacy has requested and has received City Staff s recommendation to reflect a change in tenure from ownership to rental for the proposed 240 -unit age -restricted senior housing complex on Lot 265 of Tract 16581. Many residents, if not the majority of residents, of Columbus Square strongly oppose any resolution allowing the Managing Developer to build and occupy the 240 age -restricted units as rentals. Our opposition is based on the following: Our property values and future re -sales will be negatively affected if nearly 25% of the units within the master plan are rentals based on the fact that the product type of the for -rent housing is one of the most dense if not the most dense configurations in the City of Tustin. In addition, it seems apparent that the 240 age restricted units will be occupied last, thus, the Developer's new home sales will not be as affected. 1.7 Parking Spaces per unit, inclusive of guest parking, is grossly insufficient. Many individuals 55 and older still having a living spouse, continue to work, and, therefore, require two vehicles. Furthermore, married retirees will still maintain ownership of two vehicles in addition to having the propensity to invite guests over much more frequently. On -street parking is a growing and divisive issue within our community. When the 240 units are built and occupied, parking will become even more limited and on -street parking will be even more pervasive creating a safety issue for the residents of the community. Lennar is a homebuilder, not a property management company. I believe it is within reason to question Lennar's ability to effectively manage a large rental community as their business is home building. Lennar does not have the experience nor are they appropriately staffed to manage or address the needs of renters, especially seniors, while maintaining the building and it's common area appropriately. If the City of Tustin Planning Commission proceeds with the approval of Resolutions 4134, 4136 and 4137 on December 8th, 2990, the City of Tustin will face significant, organized opposition to the development of the 240 age -restricted -its. The residents of Tustin Legacy have been underrepresented at the City, and if Columbus Square residents are cored on this issue, I believe the City will create a movement that will further delay the development of Tustin Legacy. strongly recommend that Planning Commission reject the aforementioned amendments in order to avoid any further delay of the development of the community. Furthermore, I urge the Planning Commission to reach out to the Columbus Square community and host a charrette at the Columbus Square Community Center in order to discuss alternatives to a 240 unit rental community within our master plan. I recognize that a for -sale, 240 unit senior housing community is not economically viable at this time, however, a community with a density of 24 units to the acre was never appropriate for this community since it was planned. Please feel free to contact me at (949) 290 7510 or ehieuchi@gmail.com. I would be happy to assist the City of Tustin in any way possible. Sincerely, Eric Higuchi Cc: City of Tustin City Council William A. Huston, City Manager t Christine A. Shingleton, Assistant City Manager January 5, 2010 COMM. STEVE KOZAK, Chairperson Planning Commission, City of Tustin 300 Centennial Way, Tustin, Ca 92780 CERTIFIED MAIL WITH RETURN CARD Dear Commissioner Kozak: RECEIVED JAN 0 6 2010 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPT I thought I'd wait until after the holidays before I followed up on my letter dated December 9, 2009 copy of which is attached. I will appreciate receiving the requested documents before the scheduled public hearing on January 26, 2010 with sufficient time to read'and have reasonable understanding of the contents. This is all the more important since Lennar representative Ms. Donna Kelly, when she addressed the Columbus Square HOA on December 16, 2009, failed to produce the Commission letter addressed to the HOA but delivered to Lennar instead. We know there is this letter as its presence was confirmed by the Commission staff at the December a public hearing. I will as well appreciate acknowledgment of this request and either a favorable or unfavorable response to it. Thank you very much. Respectfully yours, —. CARLOS F. CUYUGAN 15201 Providence Way Tustin, CA 92782 c.cuyuRan vahoo.com December 9, 2009 MR STEVE KOZAK, Chairperson City of Tustin Planning Commission 300 Centennial Way, Tustin, CA 92780 Dear Commissioner Kozak: I apologize to you, the other Commissioners, and your staff for my intemperate language at last night's public forum. To help me come to a rational not emotional understanding of the issue and the process involved please send me a copy each of the following: • Lennar's letter requesting modification of requirement from ownership tenure to rental tenure. • The Commission's letter to the Columbus Square HOA delivered to Lennar. • Lennar's letter received by the Commission yesterday or very recently. y'..... • Any and all communication between Lennar and the Commission or staff, transcripts of discussions and or meetings with Lennar. Thank you also for the continuance. Development of Coventry Court at Columbus Square has been discontinued for years, original permits expired, and there is no pressing or urgent need to adopt and recommend approval of the City Council Resolutions nos. 4134, 4136, and 4137. Property owners in Columbus Square must be afforded time and assistance by the Commission. Thank you for your consideration of above requests. 15201 Providence Way Tustin, CA 92782 Kapadia, Reina From: Binsack, Elizabeth Sent: Wednesday, January 13, 2010 3:56 PM To: Willkom, Justina; Kapadia, Reina Subject: FW: CHANGING COVENTRY COURT SENIOR HOUSING IN COLUMBUS SQUARE FROM OWNERSHIP TO RENTAL APARTMENTS IS UNFAIR ACTION AGAINST COLUMBUS SQUARE HOME OWNERS!! Elizabeth A. Binsack Community Development Director City of Tustin 714-573-3031 -----Original Message ----- From: Estrella, Patty Sent: Wednesday, January 13, 2010 2:25 PM To: Deborah Gavello ; Doug Davert; 'Jerry Amante'; 'Jim Palmer'; John Nielsen Cc: Binsack, Elizabeth Subject: FW: CHANGING COVENTRY COURT SENIOR HOUSING IN COLUMBUS SQUARE FROM OWNERSHIP TO RENTAL APARTMENTS IS UNFAIR ACTION AGAINST COLUMBUS SQUARE HOME OWNERS!! -----Original Message ----- From: Stephanie Yang [mailto:syang1029@gmail.com] Sent: Monday, January 11, 2010 11:03 PM To: Amante, Jerry Cc: Nielsen, John; Davert, Doug; Palmer, Jim; Gavello, Deborah Subject: CHANGING COVENTRY COURT SENIOR HOUSING IN COLUMBUS SQUARE FROM OWNERSHIP TO RENTAL APARTMENTS IS UNFAIR ACTION AGAINST COLUMBUS SQUARE HOME OWNERS!! To the City Council of Tustin: First and foremost, I would like to thank each of you for playing such an integral part in the development and quality of our city! It is my pleasure and pride to be a part of the City of Tustin and the Villages of Columbus Communities. I truly -enjoy the quality of life, safety, and life style that our communities provide us. As we all know, the characteristics of our communities is what keeps us here and attracts future homebuyers to our community. Our sole reason for buying in Columbus Square of Tustin was for the higher quality of life that we are all enjoying now and I would love it to stay that way as Tustin Legacy continues its development in the years to come. Onto more URGENT MATTERS! I am going to be very honest and state that I would have never made the final decision to purchase our home in Columbus Square in the city of TUSTIN if I was previously informed that there would be Section 8 Apartments built in our community! It was PROMISED during our the purchase of our properties that our community would not absorb any of the Tustin Legacy mandated apartment populations, and now it will absorb 80%??? How is this fair to our community of home owners? How is this fair to our FAMILIES who intentionally bought in Columbus Square to be a part of HIGHER LIVING STANDARDS? Our family could have gone elsewhere and paid a much less premium for that type of commun: The change of Coventry Court will devalue our homes, our community, and unfairly increase ou. HOA fees by 20%11 1 It is a GREAT CONCERN to my family that Lennar and META will be petitioning to change lventry Court Senior Housing into 240 Rental Apartments with 153 being Section 8 units. Of ,,se 240 Units, each rental tenant will only be required to pay 50% of our HOA fees and the st will fall back onto the home owners of Columbus Square! How is this equitable in any ..ay? WE DO NOT POUR OUR HARD EARNED MONEY AND PAY TAXES FOR OUR HOMES TO BE TURNED AROUND AND GIVEN MORE BURDEN! Not only will we take a hit financially, we will have to face an increase in transitional traffic by rental living in our community that was never properly given notice of when we all decided to purchase in Columbus Square of Tustin. With SUCH a large amount of undeveloped land in the Tustin Legacy project, there are PLENTY of possible planned areas for apartment living. THE CITY OF TUSTIN CAN MAKE A DIFFERENCE for their tax paying home owners and the community of Columbus Square by making sure that our home values are not negatively effected by this unjust move by Lennar Homes and META and DENY the request for rental apartments in Columbus Square. I URGE, BEG, and PRAY that each of you think about this situation as if it were YOUR HOME VALUE, HARD EARNED MONEY, and COMMUNITY where you raise your families. Please take the time to come and see our community and enjoy what we enjoy so you can truly understand why we are so passionately against this proposal by Lennar. With the economy on the low and home values already dropping, no home owner in Tustin should have to face unnecessary devaluation of their homes! Once again... CHANGING COVENTRY COURT SENIOR HOUSING IN COLUMBUS SQUARE FROM OWNERSHIP TO RENTAL APARTMENTS IS UNFAIR ACTION AGAINST COLUMBUS SQUARE HOME OWNERS!! PLEASE take my voice as a Tustin Home Owner and Citizen into great consideration. ,ank you, .OUD COLUMBUS SQUARE HOME OWNER PROUD MEMBER OF THE CITY OF TUSTIN Stephanie Yang and David Lam 1403 Compass Rose Way Tustin, CA 92782 Willkom, Justina Subject: FW: Coventry Court at Columbus Square Attachments: 01-14-10 - Ltr in re Coventry Court.pdf From: Eric Higuchi [mailto:ehiguchi@gmail.com] Sent: Thursday, January 14, 2010 5:00 PM To: skozak@tustinca.org; amurray@tustinca.org; cpuckett@tustinca.org; mkasalek@tustinca.org; Thompson, Jay Cc: Amante, Jerry; Nielsen, John; Palmer, Jim; Gavello, Deborah; Davert, Doug; Huston, William; Shingleton, Christine; pstoker@tustinca.org; Jon Cernok; Renee Morales; Paul Mobley; Mike Fender; Teresa Rooney; James Novella; sbradley@metahousing.com; donna.kelley@lennar.com Subject: Coventry Court at Columbus Square To the City of Tustin Planning Commission: Please find attached a letter from the Camden Place Neighborhood Homeowner Association's Board of Directors in regards to the pending application for approval of a conditional use pemit and amendment to the tract map for the Coventry Court Community at Columbus Square to allow "for -rent" housing. In brief, the Camden Place Board of Directors is in opposition to the aforementioned application on the basis that its approval will result in increased HOA assessments for all homeowners within Columbus Square. Lennar's projected increase in HOA assessments is a consequence of the decision to reduce the HOA assessments for 240 units at Coventry Court by 50% as a condition of sale of the property to a 3rd party apartment builder. The Camden Place Board would like the opportunity to meet with members of the Tustin Planning Commission prior to the January 26th meeting in order to clarify our position and offer our assitance in resolving this issi Feel free to contact me at (949) 290-7510 or ehi ug chi()gmail.com. On behalf of the Camden Place Board of Directors, Eric Higuchi January 14,.2010 City of Tustin, Planning Commission 300 Centennial Way Tustin, CA 92780 In Re: Coventry Court at Columbus Square To the City of Tustin Planning Commission: As the Board of Directors for the Camden Place Neighborhood Association (a sub -association within the Columbus Square Master Plan), we have been entrusted with the duty to maintain the outstanding character of our community as well as protect the fiduciary interests of the 222 households we represent (approximately 21% of the total homes to be built in Columbus Square). Therefore, by unanimous action, the Camden Place Neighborhood Association Board of Directors requests that the City of Tustin deny the pending application for modification to Lot 265 of Tract 16581, also referred to as Coventry Court in Columbus Square at Tustin Legacy on the basis that, if approved as currently proposed, the homeowners of Camden Place would incur long-term financial harm. According to Lennar's documentation filed with the City of Tustin, "the owner of Coventry Court apartment complex would pay an equivalent amount to fifty percent (50%) of the monthly Common Assessments currently paid by each Owner of a Home in the Community for each Unit in the apartment complex."' The master association's assessment revenue would decrease while our obligations to the residents of Coventry Court would remain the same (such as their right to access the Village Conservatory, pool, community parks and association maintained streets). Consequently, this potential reduction in assessment revenue will result in a projected 20% increase in the Master Association Common Assessments for the 222 households that make up Camden Place. ' Py 271-273,Reoort to the Planning Commission in re: Coventry Court dated December 8, 2009, 'Addendum to Homebuyer Notification for Columbus Square' The financial impacts are as follows: Per Individual Homeowner HOA Dues as of Jan 2010 20% Increase Columbus Square HOA Dues (annual) $1,596 $1,915 Negative Annual Impact to Camden Place' Negative Annual Impact to Columbus Square Subsidy to Coventry. Court (proposed)' (50% HOA Assessment Discount) ($70,862) 17% of the Annual Camden Place HOA Budget ($266,532) $191,520 While the Camden Place Board of Directors is not explicitly in opposition to the development of Coventry Court as "for -rent" housing, this application, if approved, will result in financial benefits exclusively limited to Lennar and Meta Housing at the direct expense and long-term harm of all current and future homeowners of Camden Place. Thus, as mentioned above, the Camden Place Board of Directors has the fiduciary responsibility to publicly oppose the approval of this application. In order to move forward with the development of Coventry Court, the Camden Place Neighborhood Association respectfully requests that the City of Tustin revise the proposed resolutions to limit Lennar's ability to burden Columbus Square Homeowners with any increase in Common Assessments associated with the sale of Coventry Court or the change in designation of Coventry Court from a "for -sale" to a "for -rent" project. Furthermore, the Board requests that the owner(s) of the units at Coventry Court be required to pay their fair share of assessments relative to the assessments paid by all households within Columbus Square in perpetuity. The Board of Directors also requests a meeting with members of the Planning Commission, prior to January 26"', 2010, to express our concerns, clarify our position and offer our assistance in order to quickly resolve this Issue. The Camden Place Board appreciates the hard work of the Planning Commissioners and City Staff and thanks you for your time. Please contact Eric Higuchi at (949) 290 — 7510 or ehieuchi@amaii.com should you have any questions or concerns. 2 Calculation based upon current assessment rate ($133/mo). Total impact is equivalent to 20% of the total sum of assessments paid by 222 units within Camden Place annually., 3 Calculation based upon current assessment rate ($133/mo). Total impact Is equivalent to 20% of the total sum of assessments paid by 835 units within Columbus Square annually. 4 Calculation based on the current assessment rate ($133/mo). Si Eric Higucr,sid Camden Place oard of Directors CC: Tustin City Council William Huston, Tustin City Manager Christine Shingleton, Tustin Assistant City Manager Pamela Stoker, Tustin City Clerk Columbus Square Community Association Board of Directors Cambridge Lane Neighborhood Association Board of Directors Meriwether Neighborhood Association Board of Directors Donna Kelly, Lennar of California Shaun Bradley, Meta Housing Corporation Brian Doyle, President, William Lyon Homes Southern California Kapadia, Reina From: Binsack, Elizabeth Sent: Monday, January 18, 2010 10:53 AM To: Willkom, dustina; Kapadia, Reina Subject: FW: Reject Lennar's Proposal to Change 240 Units From Ownership to Rental Tenure EGza6etFiA. Binsack Community Development Director City of Tustin 714-573-3031 From: Sowder, Debra Sent: Monday, January 18, 2010 8:57 AM To: Jerry Amante Cc: Binsack, Elizabeth Subject: FW: Reject Lennar's Proposal to Change 240 Units From Ownership to Rental Tenure From: Jeffrey Enes [mailto:jeffenes@yahoo.coml Sent: Saturday, January 16, 2010 2:22 PM To: Amante, Jerry; jnielson@tustinca.org; Davert, Doug; Palmer, Jim; Gavello, Deborah Subject: Reject Lennar's Proposal to Change 240 Units From Ownership to Rental Tenure Dear Tustin City Council Members, I am a Tustin homeowner in the Columbus Square community (resident for 3 years) and oppose Lennar's request to change the planning for Coventry Court (a nine acre site located on Lot 265 of Tract 16581 with 240 units of senior housing) from ownership to rental tenure. Lennar's request will be discussed at the January 26, 2010, Planning Commission meeting. In my opinion, Lennar should not be allowed to change tenure after disclosing to myself and other current Columbus Square homeowners that all of the housing within Columbus Square would be for -sale. I hope to persuade the Planning Commission and you that Lennar's proposal is the wrong way to go about planning for senior rental housing in our city. There are a number of questions that might be asked by the City Council and Planning Commission regarding Lennar's proposal. Would such a change in tenure be a "taking" from current homeowner community property rights? Would rental tenure mean that renters have use of the community facilities and if so would the renters be required to pay into homeowner association fees to maintain these facilities? Are there community facility district (CFD) taxes associated with this site and if so would the landlord continue to be responsible for this site's fair share of the CFD tax burden? How would the community's noise, pedestrian and vehicular traffic, and lighting change if Coventry Court were a rental project? Would the rental tenure be for a period of time (ie until the for -sale housing market improves) or indefinitely? Will the rental tenure be age -restricted? Could a non age -restricted ownership tenure be considered as a land use alternative if the current zoning is no longer economically feasible for the developer? I hope the questions above are analyzed in detail before the Planning Commission and City Council acts. I believe the answers will indicate that adding a rental tenure project to an existing for -sale housing community will negatively affect the current homeowners. Rental tenure, especially senior affordable housing projects, is an important part of our city's housing planni.__ but residents should be aware of the planning in their community prior to purchasing into that community and be justly compensated for a taking of community property rights. Lennar's proposal will unfairly add more of a burden to the existing homeowners. Please reject Lennar's proposal to change Coventry Court from ownership rental tenure. 'incerely, Jeffrey Enes Tustin Homeowner Columbus Square Community ADMINISTRATION January 16, 2010 Lee and Wanda Whiteley JAN 18 2010 15201 Covington Street RECEIVED Tustin, CA 92782 (714) 323-0074 Honorable Mayor and City Council Members, We are residents of Tustin in the Columbus Square community of Tustin Legacy. We have recently learned that Lennar Homes has requested the City of Tustin to change Coventry Court from ownership to rental per Conditional Use Permit (CUP) 09-024, Design Review (DR) 09-024, and Amendments to the Final Tract Map (FTM) 16581, and Concept Plan (CP) 03-003. It is our understanding atter much research that the purpose of this requested change is to support the sale of Coventry Court from Lennar to META Housing Corporation, and to help Lennar and the City meet and comply with their phasing schedules in this down turned economy. Obviously, this change favors Lennar, the City, and META; however, I'm deeply concerned that it will have a very negative impact on the well being of my family and the entire community of Columbus Square for the following reasons: META, as the owner / manager of the apartment complex will have their share of HOA dues reduced from the now current 240 shares (one share per unit) down to 120 shares. Simply said this is a 50 percent reduction of their HOA fees. The balance of these HOA fees will be redistributed evenly between the actual Homeowners Columbus Square. Based upon a meeting between the homeowners and Lennar at a recent HOA Board meeting held in December it is our understanding this will increase Homeowners HOA fees by approximately 15 percent! The voting rights of the apartment complex owner (now and in the future) will be 120 votes. The control of that many votes by one entity was never contemplated by the drafters of the current HOA documents and/or the CC&R's. One entity with that voting right will effectively control the HOA board, and this is unacceptable to the homeowners of Columbus Square. In addition our quality of life and the general welfare of this community will be jeopardized by this change. We have spoken with virtually all of the homeowners at Columbus Square in regards to their purchase process. We have learned that every single one of them asked if there would be rental properties in this community. The unanimous answer from both Lennar and William Lyon was "NO". Proof of this was a review of the previously approved CUP's specifying ownership through out Columbus Square. As indicated within the Planning Commission Report the applicant, Lennar is stating that this request is primarily due to their forecast of the housing market. It's their opinion that changing from ownership to rental is beneficial to all for the.follow reasons: It will accelerate the construction and delivery of the required 153 affordable units with Coventry Court' . If the project were to remain as for -sale routs, the current market and construction schedule would place delivery of the affordable homes beyond mid -2012, and if allowed as rental, the affordable apartments would be available in the marketplace with the completion of the project. Construction of Coventry Court as a rental project allows the reaming market products within Columbus Square to comply with phasing schedules that require complementary delivery of market -rate and affordable products. Coventry Court is located on a prominent parcel of Columbus Square; the completion of the project would demonstrate completion of a significant portion of Tustin Legacy. The Change in tenure does not necessitate a major change to the proposed plans. Once again while the developers and city will benefit from these justifications it will be the homeowners of Columbus Square that will be adversely affected. As new homeowners within Columbus Square we are already enduring the hardships of a floundering economy and the extreme downturn in the housing market We are carrying massive mortgages based on the over inflated housing prices we paid to live in Columbus Square. Many of our homes cost a million plus dollars before hardscape and landscape improvements. We our paying standard property tax as well as huge mello rocs tax. Our paries and schools are not being built as promised. The parking in Columbus Square is not adequate and we have been working with our HOA for over a year now to find a way to improve it. The value of our homes is Plummeting. Most of us can't sell our homes even if we wanted too, not to mention get out of our mortgages loan right side up. We are stuck here. All that being said, we love where we live, and we believe that in time everything will shake out. That being said, we hope the developers and the city will share this burden with us, by waiting until Coventry Square will work as for -sale units,2012 is not far away! We can't sell our homes so what's the difference for a developer Ince Lenmr that can't build and sell there units, or the t City trying to meet its schedules and quotas in a downturned economy? All we are doing is asking the city to understand our concerns, our hardships and not allow Lennar to add to this already overwhelming negative situation. We understand this request is most likely legal, but it is far from the right thing to dol As homeowners we made the decision to live in Columbus Square, and based on our decision we are staying the course and doing best we can to survive these turbulent times. It's hard enough as is, but this request to change Coventry Court to rental is the straw that will break the camels beck! In closing, the homeowners at this community are educated, articulate, knowledgeable, united and devoted to this cause. We currently have over 1,300 voters in our community, and we are your constituents. We are certain you recognize the proposed use of this application creates an undue hardship and burdens on our families; increases our financial responsibility, and increases our parking problems. We ask of each one of you to deny Lennaes application, and request them to consider a legitimate business solution to the situation. A solution that is fair to us the Residents of Columbus Square. Thank you in advance for irnaking the right decision. Lee and Wanda Whiteley Stop Coventry Court Rentals Residences of Columbus Square Tustin, CA. 92782 949-533-4361 Planning Commission Members, We the residents of Tustin in the Columbus Square community of Tustin Legacy, have recently learned that Lennar Homes has requested the City of Tustin to change Coventry Court from ownership to rental under CUP 09-024. Lennar and the proposed developer, Meta Housing Corp., are contemplating the incentive / condition that Meta, as the owner / manager of the apartment complex will have their share of HOA dues reduced from the now current 240 shares down to 120 shares. The balance of these HOA dues will be redistributed evenly between the balance of the homeowners. This will increase homeowners HOA dues by approximately 15% . This is based upon the homeowner / HOA board meeting with the Lennar representatives in late December of 2009. Also, as part of this deal, the voting rights of the apartment complex owner (now and in the future) will number 120 votes. Control of this many votes by one entity was never contemplated by the drafters of the HOA documents or the CC&R's. One entity with that large of a voting block will effectively control the HOA board. This is unacceptable to the homeowners of Columbus Square. We understand that matters between members of an HOA are not under the purview of the Commission but you must also understand that, at this point in time, our HOA board is still populated with a majority of Lennar and William Lyon members. Any action taken at this point in time is fully under the control of the developer. Our quality of life and the general welfare of this community will be jeopardized by this proposed change. Having this project sit idle is not detrimental to the community. Adding undue economic hardship and the future loss of control of our HOA board will be detrimental. Our economy will rebound, and the sale of these Condominiums will happen. It may take some time, but we, the homeowners of this community, have invested a huge sum of our life savings into Columbus Square. We are not in it for the short run, two to three years goes by quickly, and this project will be standing for 50-75 years if not longer, as will any actions in the future by a board controlled, for the most part, by one entity. Also, parking is at a premium in Columbus Square. We feel that the existing traffic study does not take into account the real issues that have surfaced with the build out of our community. We request that the parking variance not be granted and that a condition be placed on Coventry Court to fully contain all residence parking in the confines of Coventry Court. We request that a separate parking decal program be required to insure that these two projects stay separate and distinct. Per Section 9291 "Use Permits" subsection c, the Planning Commission Decision on any CUP type action must find that the "establishment, maintenance or operation of the use will not be "detrimental to the health, safety, morals, comfort and general welfare of the persons residing or working in the neighborhood of the proposed use". The application before you does not meet that standard It is in fact very detrimental to the general welfare of the residences of Columbus Square. Additional fees being pushed from one parcel owner to another cannot be anything other than detrimental. The potential loss of control of the HOA board by the broad section of homeowners is also another extremely detrimental outcome of the action before you. As such you must deny this application in its present form. We thank you for your consideration in this matter. Sincerely, Tab & Sarah Johnson 1445 Charleston Street Tustin, CA. 92782 Planning Commission Members, I am a resident of Tustin in the Columbus Square community of Tustin Legacy. We recently learned that Lennar Homes has requested the City of Tustin to change Coventry Court from ownership to rental. This will allow 240 apartments to be built and rented. If you aren't aware of the situation you soon will be. Conditional Use Permit (CUP) 09-024, Design Review (DR) 09-024, and Amendments to the Final Tract Map (FTM) 16581, and Concept Plan (CP) 03- 003 to convert Coventry Court from ownership tenure to rental tenure are on the Planning Commission's calendar in the month of January. This deal is being struck between Lennar and the proposed developer, Meta Housing Corp., with the incentive / condition that Meta, as the owner / manager of the apartment complex will have their share of HOA dues reduced from the now current 240 shares down to 120 shares. The balance of these HOA dues will be redistributed evenly between the balance of the homeowners. This will increase Homeowners HOA dues a approximately 15% base upon the homeowner / HOA board meeting with the Lennar representatives in late December. As part of this deal, the voting rights of the apartment complex owner (now and in the future) will number 120 votes. Control of this many votes by one entity was never contemplated by the drafters of the HOA documents or the CC&R's. One entity with that large of a voting block will effectively control the HOA board. Elections do not have a good track record of voter turnout. If a 30% turn out is ever achieved, the apartment owner will have 120 votes of the 243 votes that would be cast. This is unacceptable to the homeowners of Columbus square. Our quality of life and the general welfare of this community will be jeopardized by this change. I've spoken with more than enough homeowners at Columbus Square to learn that most in the process of their home purchase asked a very similar question: "Will there be any rental properties in this community?" The answer each one received from the builders was "NO". This proposed application is unjust and poses additional financial obligations to the existing homeowners in the name of profit for Lennar and Meta The general comfort and welfare of the persons residing in the neighborhood is being put at risk by the potential loss of control of their HOA board. Having this project sit idle is not detrimental to the community. Our economy will rebound, and the sale of these Condominiums will happen. It may take some time, but we, the homeowners of this community, have invested a huge sum of our life savings into Columbus Square. We are not in it for the short run, two to three years goes by quickly, and this project will be standing for 50-60 years, if not longer. I urge you to reflect on the ramifications this proposal has on us, the 760 households / homeowners, who are voters and your constituents. The homeowners of Columbus Square are educated, articulate, knowledgeable, united and devoted to this cause. I ask of each one of you to deny Lennar's application and request them to consider a legitimate business solution to the situation. Sincerely, Columbus Square Zone Petition against Converting Coventry Court from Ownership Tenure to Rental Tenure Conditional Use Permit (CUP) 09-024, Design Review (DR) 09-024, and Amendments to the Final Tract Map (FTM) 16581, and Concept Plan (CP) 03-003 to convert Coventry Court from ownership tenure to rental tenure. Region: Tustin County: Orange Target: Columbus Square Community Background: A 240 unit 55 + resident development, named Coventry Court located in Tustin's Columbus Square community is proposed to be converted from ownership to an Apartment rental complex. 153 of these apartments will be rented as Affordable Housing under the Section 8 Rental Agreement. Of the 153 units 56 will be rented as moderate - income, 61 as low-income, and 36 as very low-income. We urge the Planning Commissioners and City Council Members to deny the proposal for converting Coventry Court to rental tenure. This proposal will create an undue hardship and burdens on our families; increase our financial responsibility, and increase parking problems. 1. META the owner of Coventry Court apartments will have 120 votes at future Columbus Square HOA meetings. This will most likely control of the entire Columbus Square HOA Board and the Direction of the Community. This means the owners of the new apartment complex will be in total control of our community! 2. Our HOA fees will increase approx. 20 percent! 3. Columbus Square will absorb 80 percent of the Tustin Legacy apartment requirements. This is not what we were told when we bought our homes. 4. All of this will have an extreme negative impact on our home values while unjustly enriching the future developers of Tustin Legacy at the expense of Columbus Square home owners. We, the undersigned, ask that the proposed application converting Coventry Court to rental tenure, project developers Lennar and META to be denied. We, the undersigned,. do not wish to have obis t15'eQof-.community built within our current community: iA V v;c 1v4,r 'U l Print name and sig Afure l Print name and siure Print name and signature a"OcAfl J. ,�7 t Homeowner address Iz Homeowner address V,,14 92-1 1Z Homeowner address Petition against Convening Coventry Court from Ownership 1 Tenure to Rental Tenure Conditional Use Permit (CUP) 09-024, Design Review (DR) 09-024, and Amendments to the Final Tract Map (FTM) 16581, and Concept Plan (CP) 03-003 to conven Coventry Court from ownership tenure to rental tenure. Columbus Square Zone Print name and stgna•ur— e — ' S J �i � ���i• ►`/c%Y` ��i.0 IUPC. Print nsig ' a and n re Print name and signature Print anignature n n Pqn' t name nd sig ature Print nameland signature K H t N L,a E�.N nl Print name and signature ' Print name and signature Print name and signature Print name and signature Print name and signature Print name and signature Print name and signature Print name and signature Print name and signature /1SZj! ) c rar4, s ��.�. 23 , ?I" , ('/,d `)6L 1,z Homeowner address Homeowner address 131 e T Homeowner add ss \JG�_ �����:;� Ct�1) Homeowner address / Jz" i / Homeowner address Homeowner address L% Sl -U• ,f= ynij /�-7D i l wy zCA 7,9 79 �? . Homeowner address Homeowner address Homeowner address Homeowner address Homeowner address Homeowner address Homeowner address Homeowner address Homeowner address Petition against Converting Coventry Court from Ownership Tenure to Rental Tenure Conditional Use Permit (CUP) 09-024, Design Review (DR) 09-024, and Amendmcnts to the Final Tract Map (FTM) 16581, and Concept Plan (CP) 03-003 to convert Coventry Court from ownership tenure to rental tenurc. Columbus Square Zone Z -- Petition against Converting Coventry Court from Ownership Tenure to Rental Tenure Conditional Use Permit (CUP) 09-024, Design Review (DR) 09-024, and Amendments to the Final Tract Map (FTM) 16581, and Concept Plan (CP) 03-003 to convert Coventry Court from ownership tenure to rental tenure. Region: Tustin County: Orange Target: Columbus Square Community Background: A 240 unit 55 + resident development, named Coventry Court located in Tustin's Columbus Square community is proposed to be converted from ownership town Apartment rental complex. 153 of these apartments will be rented as Affordable Housing under the Section 8 Rental Agreement. Of the 153 units 56 will be rented as moderate - income, 61 as low-income, and 36 as very low-income. We urge the Planning Commissioners and City Council Members to deny the proposal for converting Coventry Court to rental tenure. This proposal will create an undue hardship and burdens on our families; increase our financial responsibility, and increase parking problems. 1. META the owner of Coventry Court apartments will have 120 votes at future Columbus Square HOA meetings. This will most likely control of the entire Columbus Square HOA Board and the Direction of the Community. This means the owners of the new apartment complex will be in total control of our community! 2. Our HOA fees will increase approx. 20 percent! 3. Columbus Square will absorb 80 percent of the Tustin Legacy apartment requirements. This is not what we were told when we bought our homes. 4. All of this will have an extreme negative impact on our home values while unjustly enriching the future developers of Tustin Legacy at the expense of Columbus Square home owners. We, the undersigned, ask that the proposed application converting Coventry Court to rental tenure, project developers Lennar and META to be denied. We, the undersigned, do not wish to have this type of community built within our current community: Print name and signal re Homeowner address ess Print name and signature Homeowner address C -- Print nameA d signature ,. Homeowner address Petition against Converting Coventry Court from Ownership 1 Tenure to Rental Tenure Conditional Use Permit (CUP) 09-024, Design Review (DR) 09-024, and Amendments to the Final Tract Map (FCM) 16581, and Concept Plan (CP) 03-003 to convert Coventry Court from ownership tenure to rentaltenure. Columbus Square Zone L Priinnt.name and si re Homeowner address Print nanle and signature Homeowner address 01 1 Print name and'signadre Homeowner address 5nFvG v G ►, iY�f� �l .soJ Tom; Print nam:and sia afore Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address 1 Print name an signs ure Homeowner address J Yu !' ' t S' z� ti'AI not name and signature Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address VQ1� ALL l.sz.. t" 1t(1 '�1a��cn St. Print name and signature Homeowner address Print name and signs u.. Homeowner address ?D�L'P_ YUYl4 l�G� Print na eme�nnd signatu Homeowner address P nt name and signature Homeowner address Pr r t name and s'g a _owne # address Ap Print name an signatu Ho er address Aq _ ( `i ,-, •, �t � � � � � � �� � ��t d.� r Shit. I G�- S� Pxinf nameand siekakuwe Homeowner address Petition against Converting Coventry Court from Ownership Tenure to Rental Tenure Conditional Use Permit (CUP) 09-024, Design Review (DR) 09-024, and Amendments to the Final Tract Map (FTM) 16581, and Concept Plan (CP) 03-003 to convert Coventry Court from ownership tenure to rental tenure. Columbus Square Zone Print n rra and signature Sc k-4- F AT.e--J Print name and signature Print name and signs ure � r , Print name and signature � le Print name acid signature Print name and s' ature Prit name and signature Print name p4;9ira Print name and signature Print name and signature Print name and signature Print name and signature Print name and signature Print name and signature Print name and signature 3 SOL -L Homeowner address ...mss �-� ,,J. Homeowner address / Yz! /" ICI n Homeowner address o eowner address t 4 iq� ,/I AJ( S o Homeowner address W7 M6 isyti Homeowner address 1520 se-4er�jVls g . ,C4q 11Z -79G Homeowner address J45q rhA-i 1 33 ST `(VS7'1/\i , i. , {� L-7 -Y 71 Homeowner address ,M4r� (.S -c) AJ� � v J r — Homeowner address Homeowner address Homeowner address Homeowner address Homeowner address Homeowner address Homeowner address Petition against Convcrting Coventry Court from Ownership 3 Tenure to Rental Tenure Conditional Use Permit (CUP) 09-024, Design Review (DR) 09-024, and Amendments to the Final Tract Map (FTM) 16581, and Concept Plan (CP) 03-003 to convert Coventry Court from ownership tenure to rental tenure. ;J Columbus Square Zone Petition against Converting Coventry Court from Ownership Tenure to Rental Tenure Conditional Use Permit (CUP) 09-024, Design Review (DR) 09-024, and Amendments to the Final Tract Map (FTM) 16581, and Concept Plan (CP) 03-003 to convert Coventry Court from ownership tenure to rental tenure. Region: Tustin County: Orange Target: Columbus Square Community Background: A 240 unit 55 + resident development, named Coventry Court located in Tustin's Columbus Square community is proposed to be converted from ownership to an Apartment rental complex. 153 of these apartments will be rented as Affordable Housing under the Section 8 Rental Agreement. Of the 153 units 56 will be rented as moderate - income, 61 as low-income, and 36 as very low-income. We urge the Planning Commissioners and City Council Members to deny the proposal for converting Coventry Court to rental tenure. This proposal will create an undue hardship and burdens on our families; increase our financial responsibility, and increase parking problems. 1. META the owner of Coventry Court apartments will have 120 votes at future Columbus Square HOA meetings. This will most likely control of the entire Columbus Square HOA Board and the Direction of the Community. This ( means the owners of the new apartment complex will be in total control of our community! 2. Our HOA fees will increase approx. 20 percent! 3. Columbus Square will absorb 80 percent of the Tustin Legacy apartment requirements. This is not what we were told when we bought our homes. 4. All of this will have an extreme negative impact on our home values while unjustly enriching the future developers of Tustin Legacy at the expense of Columbus Square home owners. We, the undersigned, ask that the proposed application converting Coventry Court to rental tenure, project developers Lennar and META to be denied. We, the undersigned, do not wt�h to ha s type of community built within our current community: 4_� .`Print name 'signature Homeowner address - 2 4:tY2�i Print name and(_sri I Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Petition against Converting Coventry Court from Ownership 1 Tenure to Rental Tenure Conditional Use Permit (CUP) 09-024, Design Review (DR) 09-024, and Amendments to the Final Tra;t Map (FTM) 16581, and Concept Plan (CP) 03-003 to convert Covcntry Court from ownership tenure to rental tenure. Columbus Square Zone Print name and signature Print name and signature C,'WVmI an�- Print name and signatureti'ur�1.1 Print nanie and signature 7X Print name and signature---,(--,*' Print name and signature yC) Y,, -\I -kw, 5 -t -— Homeowner address I �b 144 [ t0s S Homeowner address D� nd-ison .Sf. Homeowner address C`fb�, I��alt5on�� Homeowner address S7, L4 �.L r i - !- (. a—) Homeowner address omeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address �i�r11S C XJ.L Print name and signature Prinf name and signature Homeown raddress l —�— .14061 ie,-IU4NZ-> <A -- Homeowner address 1407 t&— ffT �s -5t- Print name and signature Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Petition against Converting Coventry Court from Ownership 2 renure to Rental Tenure Conditional Use Permit (CUP) 09-024, Design Review (DR) 09-024, and Amendments to the Final'rract Map (Frm) 16581, and Concept Plan (CP) 03-003 to convert Coventry Court from ownership tenure to rental tenure. Columbus Square "Lone Petition against Converting Coventry Court from Ownership Tenure to Rental Tenure Conditional Use Permit (CUP) 09-024, Design Review (DR) 09-024, and Amendments to the Final Tract Map (FTM) 16581, and Concept Plan (CP) 03-003 to convert Coventry Court from ownership tenure to rental tenure. Region: Tustin County: Orange Target: Columbus Square Community Background: A 240 unit 55 + resident development, named Coventry Court located in Tustin's Columbus Square community is proposed to be converted from ownership to an Apartment rental complex. 153 of these apartments will be rented as Affordable Housing under the Section 8 Rental Agreement. Of the 153 units 56 will be rented as moderate - income, 61 as low-income, and 36 as very low-income. We urge the Planning Commissioners and City Council Members to deny the proposal for converting Coventry Court to rental tenure. This proposal will create an undue hardship and burdens on our families; increase our financial responsibility, and increase parking problems. 1. META the owner of Coventry Court apartments will have 120 votes at future Columbus Square HOA meetings. This will most likely control of the entire Columbus Square HOA Board and the Direction of the Community. This t means the owners of the new apartment complex will be in total control of our community! 2. Our HOA fees will increase approx. 20 percent! 3. Columbus Square will absorb 80 percent of the Tustin Legacy apartment requirements. This is not what we were told when we bought our homes. 4. All of this will have an extreme negative impact on our home values while unjustly enriching the future developers of Tustin Legacy at the expense of Columbus Square home owners. We, the undersigned, ask that he -r posed application converting Coventry Court to rental tenure, project develo rs nar and META to be denied. We, the undersigned, do not wish to have this typ of o munity built within our current community: c v o ,1ti►� \Lt,- �' 15SZv3 leu (c_t� �� -�� s � , (, 0- � Z7�L Print name an signature V Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Print name and sig fiatur --- Homeowner addre s Petition against Converting Coventry Court from Ownership 1 Tenure to Rental Tenure Conditional Use Permit (CUP) 09-024, Design Review (DR) 09-024, and Amendments to the Final Tract Map (FTM) 16581, and Concept Plan (CP) 03-003 to convert Coventry Court from ownership tenure to rental tenure. Columbus Square Zone r -q 77 Print name an si nature Print name and signature Print name and signature ' RUCA71 M6rUYafQ Aa. —A--,—\ Print name and signature J - Print name and signature Print name and signs Print name and signature �)G rN� � Print name and signature MIQH &tt_& DOH n% 11,4,4"C -4p O-, , ® C', Print name and signature Pi -1 name and si ature �c41-4 ��ti� Print name and VOiature Print name and signature Print name and signature Print name and signature CA Homeowner address Homeowner address Homeowner address 1 yZ7 s 1�w,��- (mss ✓1 G� �'Z Homeowner address ,9V address I Zt C)h Homeowner address Homeowner address S`�3z R-�r�s 5L-sT=�--\ CO, Homeowner address 19-7-0 f L Y OTI C S/- -7 Homeowner address tlC3 Ir S4 C:.Z '1 *Z Homeowner address IS- vq ,\- Homeowner address js. Yns - CH Homeowner address Homeowner address Homeowner address Homeowner address Petition against Converting Coventry Court from Ownership 2 Tenure to Rental Tenure Conditional Use Permit (CUP) 09-024, Design Review (DR) 09-024, and Amendments to the Final Tract Map (FTM) 16581, and Concept Plan (CP) 03-003 to convert Coventry Court from oWaurship tenure to rental tenure. Columbus Square Zone Petition against Converting Coventry Court from Ownership Tenure to Rental Tenure Conditional Use Permit (CUP) 09-024, Design Review (DR) 09-024, and Amendments to the Final Tract Map (FTM) 16581, and Concept Plan (CP) 03-003 to convert Coventry Court from ownership tenure to rental tenure. Region: Tustin County: Orange Target: Columbus Square Community Background: A 240 unit 55 + resident development, named Coventry Court located in Tustin's Columbus Square community is proposed to be converted from ownership to an Apartment rental complex. 153 of these apartments will be rented as Affordable Housing under the Section 8 Rental Agreement. Of the 153 units 56 will be rented as moderate - income, 61 as low-income, and 36 as very low-income. We urge the Planning Commissioners and City Council Members to deny the proposal for converting Coventry Court to rental tenure. This proposal will create an undue hardship and burdens on our families, increase our financial responsibility, and increase parking problems. 1. META the owner of Coventry Court apartments will have 120 votes at future Columbus Square HOA meetings. This will most likely control of the entire Columbus Square HOA Board and the Direction of the Community. This means the owners of the new apartment complex will be in total control of _ our community! 2. Our HOA fees will increase approx. 20 percent! 3. Columbus Square will absorb 80 percent of the Tustin Legacy apartment requirements. This isnot what we were told when we bought our homes. 4. All of this will have an extreme negative impact on our home values while unjustly enriching the future developers of Tustin Legacy at the expense of Columbus Square home owners. We, the undersigned, ask that the proposed application converting Coventry Court to rental tenure, projecfdevelopers Lennar and META to be denied. We, the undersigned, do/not wish to have this type of community built within our current community: l�)� � ��" i ri (f' 1 � vl p Print name and si ature Homeowner addresIQ s ' Pri name and signature Jc�.cl�C, i ,1� e L�iCy� Print name and signature Homeowner address � t C �l �S-r 1-� Homeowner address k ",— I , S l �5(I -b Petition against Converting Coventry Court from ownership 1 renure to Rental Tenure Conditional Use Permit (Cull) 09-024. Design Review (DR) 09-024. and Amendments to the Final Tract Map (FTM) 16581. and Concept Plan (CP) 03-003 to convert Coventry Court from ownership tenure to rental tenure. Columbus Square "Lone Print name and signature l i n J L171 Print name and signature Print na and ignature -��lzNs S Print narnel Print name and signature Print name =---40410 Pri na na sigi� l AY`JC D I h ne� 104, Pri�anre �Y- �n625�oo � VjO . Print name and signature -1W, Print name and signature Homeowner address Homeowner address `7'/ �'7 7f 2 - Homeowner address Homeowner address iso r���,�,9�,✓ �- ��� c�- Homeowner address qZ 7� /4t4I 6 A2CE. t� Sr- Y-Q'T►A)CA qZ?eZ Homeowner address 152x,1 Gtsy 1'l 6:M� sS :'[yb, CA 9't--!3 Z Homeowner address r r--Pe�� L, � 1-7�SI7111 . Homeowner address 15J -D3 Co v i h� ,5� CC.. Homeowner addr 152x-:.. cQV,• V�C.7�.L sT, � �)„� �. Homeowner address 1-4 VTJ Homeowner address I ODI LJALtks I u6 KI Homeowner address e/-'57-20:3 LC> IcLvq 5a 4!ce— -z;+,., A,(:k Homeowner address /c52162 � ��TW 0�1 Homeowner address S� D-ykE V,)%y\t4 .J _N:2 -cis (� -k(zxES I�.J Print name and signature Homeowner address n I7,'e ae u- �j Petition against Converting Coventry Court from Ownership 2 Tenure to Rental Tenure Conditional Use Permit (CI1P) 09-024. Design Review (DR) 09-024. and Amendments to the Final Tract Map (FTM) 16581. and Concept Plan (CP) 03-003 to convert Coventr7 Court from ownership tenure to rental tenure. Columbus Square Zone S and signature, Homeowner address � �►"` IS2ol C.VvI,uC>ro►-J STS Tush► -1 Cow— qi2_ Ig? 1tg signature Homeowner address Print'ofilffie and signature Print a and signature '� Print name and signature �15.� Print nam� and signature IML ` 44v'l 'nt name and si t re Kia -'g- Print riamelaVid signature Print name and signature Print name and signature Print name and signature Print name and signature Print name and signature Print name and signature Print name and signature Homeo C er addre , ST TwT 44 � Homeowner address .fin. fis r -�Sp ; CA Homeowner address Homeowner address Homeowner address )5�8 uJACAjt-)QON ST . -1`0sno Otz,-i$Z Homeowner address Homeowner address Homeowner address Homeowner address Homeowner address Homeowner address Homeowner address Homeowner address Petition against Converting Coventry Court from Ownership j Tenure to Rental Tenure Conditional Use Permit (CUP) 09-024. Design Review (DR) 09-024. and Amendments to the Final rract Map (FTM) 16581. and Concept Plan (CP) 03-003 to convert Coventn Court from ownership tenure to rental tenure. Columbus Square Gone Petition against Converting Coventry Court from Ownership Tenure to Rental Tenure Conditional Use Permit (CUP) 09-024, Design Review (DR) 09-024, and Amendments to the Final Tract Map (FTM) 16581, and Concept Plan (CP) 03-003 to convert Coventry Court from ownership tenure to rental tenure. Region: Tustin County: Orange Target: Columbus Square Community Background: A 240 unit 55 + resident development, named Coventry Court located in Tustin's Columbus Square community is proposed to be converted from ownership to an Apartment rental complex. 153 of these apartments will be rented as Affordable Housing under the Section 8 Rental Agreement. Of the 153 units 56 will be rented as moderate - income, 61 as low-income, and 36 as very low-income. We urge the Planning Commissioners and City Council Members to deny the proposal for converting Coventry Court to rental tenure. This proposal will create an undue hardship and burdens on our families; increase our financial responsibility, and increase parking problems. 1. META the owner of Coventry Court apartments will have 120 votes at future Columbus Square HOA meetings. This will most likely control of the entire Columbus Square HOA Board and the Direction of the Community. This t means the owners of the new apartment complex will be in total control of our community! 2. Our HOA fees will increase approx. 20 percent! 3. Columbus Square will absorb 80 percent of the Tustin Legacy apartment requirements. This is not what we were told when we bought our homes. 4. All of this will have an extreme negative impact on our home values while unjustly enriching the future developers of Tustin Legacy at the expense of Columbus Square home owners. We, the undersigned, ask that the proposed application converting Coventry Court to rental tenure, project devglopers Lennar and META to be denied. We, the undersigned, do not wish to have this type community built within ourcurrentcommunity: t Print name and signature } Homeowner address i Print name and signotur,e r Print name and signature •.x Homeowner address Homeowner address Petition against Converting Coventry Court from Ownership 1 Tenure to Rental Tenure Conditional Use Permit (CUP) 09-024, Design Review (DR) 09-024, and Amendments to the Final Tract Map (FTM) 16581, and Concept Plan (CP) 03-003 to convert Coventry Court from ownership tenure to rental tenure. Columbus Square Zone k, Print name and signature Print a and signature Print name and signature 1 ' Print name and signature,. -� Print name and signature - NC ]i A fl) HA Nc A C Print name and signature Print name and sigxtature - Print,name d signature Print name and'signefturey S'I I-, k-,�%t,r c'J 1 •J� 1 V '\i Print name and signature Homeowner address Homeowner,, address Homeowner address Homeowner address Homeowner address Homeowner address Homeowner address I'�-LSI ''{� �. Homeowner address Homeowner address Homeowner address lU�^-�11.Lv`vli' Print name and signature Homeowner address Print name and signature Print mime and s Print name and signatur&,oc' Print name and signature Homeowner address -- -- Homeowner address Homeowner address f iomeorvner afldress Petition against Converting Coventry Court from Ownership Tenure to Rental Tenure Conditional Use Permit (CLP) 09-024, Design Review (DR) 09-024, and Amendments to the Final Tract Map (FTM) 16581, and Conccpt Plan (CP) 03-003 to convert Coventry Court from ownership tenure to rental tenure. Columbus Square Zone Q Z. ciL V t- 142 Zily- 4z�z Print n"e and signature Homeowner address Petition against Convening Coventry Court from Ownership 3 Tenure to Rental Tenure Conditional Use Permit (CUP) 09-024, Design Review (DR) 09-024, and Amendments to the Final Tract Map (FTM) 16581. and Concept Plan (CP) 03-003 to convert Coventry Court from ownership tenure to rental tenure. Print name and sigAature Hor�oer address A t L) �rin 'name ands gn*e Homeowner address 'A Ail I\jA 510 IN C JK - h t C Print name and signature Homeowner address Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Print name and signature Petition against Convening Coventry Court from Ownership 3 Tenure to Rental Tenure Conditional Use Permit (CUP) 09-024, Design Review (DR) 09-024, and Amendments to the Final Tract Map (FTM) 16581. and Concept Plan (CP) 03-003 to convert Coventry Court from ownership tenure to rental tenure. Columbus Square Zone Petition against Converting Coventry Court from Ownership Tenure to Rental Tenure Conditional Use Permit (CUP) 09-024, Design Review (DR) 09-024, and Amendments to the Final Tract Map (FTM) 16581, and Concept Plan (CP) 03-003 to convert Coventry Court from ownership tenure to rental tenure. Region: Tustin County: Orange Target: Columbus Square Community Background: A 240 unit 55 + resident development, named Coventry Court located in Tustin's Columbus Square community is proposed to be converted from ownership to an Apartment rental complex. 153 of these apartments will be rented as Affordable Housing under the Section 8 Rental Agreement. Of the 153 units 56 will be rented as moderate - income, 61 as low-income, and 36 as very low-income. We urge the Planning Commissioners and City Council Members to deny the proposal for converting Coventry Court to rental tenure. This proposal will create an undue hardship and burdens on our families; increase our financial responsibility, and increase parking problems. 1. META the owner of Coventry Court apartments will have 120 votes at future Columbus Square HOA meetings. This will most likely control of the entire Columbus Square HOA Board and the Direction of the Community. This means the owners of the new apartment complex will be in total control of our community! .low 2. Our HOA fees will increase approx. 20 percent! 3. Columbus Square will absorb 80 percent of the Tustin Legacy apartment requirements. This is not what we were told when we bought our homes. 4. All of this will have an extreme negative impact on our home values while unjustly enriching the future developers of Tustin Legacy at the expense of Columbus Square home owners. We, the undersigned, ask that the proposed application converting Coventry Court to rental tenure, project developers Lennar and META to be denied. We, the undersigned, do not wish to have this type of community built within our current community: 1, /-BAR t,€ � nrNO ST yG o. c M Print name and signature Homeowner address P 'ntinamed sign Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Petition against Converting Coventry Court from Ownership 1 Tenure to Rental Tenure Condidonal Use Permit (CUP) 09-024, Design Review (DR) 09-024, and Amendments to the Final Tract Map (FTM) 16581, and Concept Plan (CP) 03-003 to convert Coventry Court from ownership tenure to rental tenure. Columbus Square Zone - %jIi/y � �Ll�w� '(-clntti,St� 11� q,�ntA:(•jyyc ' �i k.u3 N tti iv K; iik%N C 1�a ei oy1 5; . 1 u� hln C'' -1 z`7 RQ - Print name and signature, Homeowner address Print name and signs re , Homeowner ad ress Print name and signature Homeowner add ss H Print nine and signature Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Print name and sign Homeowner dyes ew- Print name and signature Homeowner address P� N►J tE L I `i 4� U� 5 qz,-,Q 2 - Print name and sig tore Homeowner address -f-T NJ- I +L 2 v, S4 , 1,.-�, 0 LCSL 7 ° G - v Print name and signature Homeowner address 3ry k -e �;�c�y ly5t� C lC,15�0V1 41St - C-Pf L.21g2 Print name and signature Homeowner address I CL s 3! , & �,r-t f�� ! 6' ��r� L±Qom? 15-rint name and signature Homeowner addr s L tA Print name anif signature Ho em owner add ess �6y 'ice J J la -7 F2 � Print na and signature �j Homeowner add ss N-- q!50 i y cr — 115i � Print name and signa* Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Petition against Converting Coventry Court from Ownership 2 Tenure to Rental Tenure Conditional Use Permit (CUP) 09-024, Design Review (DR) 09-024, and Amendments to the Final Tract Map (FTM) 16581, and Concept Plan (CP) 03-003 to convert Coventry Court from ownership tenure to rental tenure. Co bus Square Zone Com, l��-li,� , �c i-�r•� rint n e and signature Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address ,Z i y 3 14 3y 07 Print name an siona Homeowner address Y 2 tyke h S; In Print name d signature Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Petition against Converting Coventry Court from Ownership 3 Tenure to Rental Tenure Conditional Use Permit (CUP) 09-024, Design Review (DR) 09-024, and Amendments to the Final Tract Map (FTM) 16581, and Concept Plan (CP) 03-003 to convert Coventry Court from ownership tenure to rental tenure. SZ 1' 1x08 is -to i j ui Columbus Square Zone 6 l s 1 Z, ISl `i {t 5/G Z `E Petition against Converting Coventry Court from Ownership y 2 Z Tenure to Rental Tenure `s 8' zo I Conditional Use Permit (CUP) 09-024, Design Review (DR) 09-024, and Amendments to the Final Tract ` f 5 Map (FTM) 16581, and Concept Plan (CP) 03-003 to convert Coventry Court from ownership tenure to SZCv I ; 2 c/ rental tenure. 1 Region: Tustin County: Orange S Z Za Target: Columbus Square Community $ Z S', 2 1 l S 21 t4 Background: ? 7 Z A 240 units 55 + resident development, named Coventry Court located in Tustin's 15-Z Y f 5Z Columbus Square community is proposed to be converted from ownership to an I .S zad Apartment rental complex. 153 of these apartments will be rented as Affordable Housing +C�� 52, OLo under the Section 8 Rental Agreement. Of the 153 units 56 will be rented as moderate- L S -?- income, 61 as low-income, and 36 as very low-income. 15- Z We urge the Planning Commissioners and City Council Members to deny the proposal � S ZS` Z, 5 3 for converting Coventry Court to rental tenure. This proposal will create an undue hardship and burdens on our families; increase our financial responsibility, and increase I parking problems. S Z --SG a 78 1. META the owner of Coventry Court apartments will have 120 votes at future 15--7, q Columbus Square HOA meetings. This will most likely control of the entire I SZ yY Z Columbus Square HOA Board and the Direction of the Community. This 1 means the owners of the new apartment complex will be in total control of our community. Z 2. Our HOA fees will increase approx. 20 percent! 3 1� 3. Columbus Square will absorb 80 percent of the Tustin Legacy apartment 1 S Z 3 a(, requirements. This is not what we were told when we bought our homes.-Z—�' 15 r` 4. All of this will have an extreme negative impact on our home values while I S Z 3 l unjustly enriching the future developers of Tustin Legacy at the expense of I S -Z L1 7 Columbus Square home owners. We, the undersigned, ask that the proposed application converting Coventry Court to 1 S Z Z 1 ap re project developers Lennar and META to be denied. We the undersigned, 15 r l rental tenure, p � p g ZZS do not wish to have this type of community built ithin our current community: 1S'Z Z 3 Prin n e and si ture Homeowner address ` 15a4 �1aI�,�,�G +'�. �u�n (�► 92$2 Print name and igna re Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Petition against Converting Coventry Court from Ownership 1 Tenure to Rental Tenure Conditional Use Permit (CUP) 09-024, Design Review (DR) 09-024, and Amendments to the Final Tract Map (FTM) 16581, and Concept Plan (CP) 03-003 to convert Coventry Court from ownership tenure to rental tenure. Columbus Square Zone Print name and signature Print name and signature Print n an s' re bu Y � Print name and signature i' -R fm� PI Print name and signature Lavrmn N��►so�Dr�,-t.�� Print name and signaturV-j-- Print name and signa i And � PrintGinWe and Signa re SA.v?D/ZA ;W,+,e 7�✓� Print name and signature %�sRR/ SCHENN w� Imo{ iRrint name and Anatize Clint name and signature I IvM �,", Print na e d signature Print name Ad signature SUPRIVA -7crfk1 Print name and signature 4/ Print name and signature Homeowner address Homeowner address r 3� I -5 -2-1-) S �L�� -5,w� 0-- ?�V- Homeowner address 126`7 Homeowner address /s2YW 0-,n�,r,JM 5L.,- MIS Homeowner addrefi t5�,56 QCAMbn35Z- S4c1'j us n g27Ss Z Homeowner address 1524'Z C4•ti&e/96F 7u Snti 4 Z-7 8Z Homeowner address (-emsim4mf�� Homeowner address /5"�-� 3 ���✓ - di. �� Homeowner address 92 7S- t, is Zyt fK T -a c'z 7I Z Homeowner addr X ) 33 � Homeowner address J Homeowner addres Homeowner address S-.2- -2) Kg -b`$ -i 2'x-82 Homeowner address 9 Q Homeowner addres Petition against Converting Coventry Court from Ownership 2 Tenure to Rental Tenure Conditional Use Permit (CUP) 09-024, Design Review (DR) 09-024, and Amendments to the Final Tract Map (FTM) 16581, and Concept Plan (CP) 03-003 to convert Coventry Court from ownership tenure to rental tenure. , Columbus Square Zone Print name and signature Homeowner address / �/ IS�Ij (lGhl"'%2L► (110° Print name and signature Homeowner address T :;E- /rza%` s- �+, link Print name and sig azure Homeowner addr6is 41" k7i�� -TIJ 927e 2, rint name and ignature Homeowner address Print name and signature n� Homeowner address M Ef (� Pt name and Print name and Prinifaifie and sig a re �5 m(A YY1-r�f- /1" Print name and signature Print name and signatu_rep ^ vlirl�%Ilr�—t'12.n 2�' `-- Print name and gignature ,Tehnia F'W14ot*At4--- Print name and signature �,✓I N (w, Nt vtrstyVA A(" Print name and signature Printnameand'signature 1 VaIp Homeowner address 2 Homeowner address /S�Z)o Law.�,r ,*Jo -e SE )�A',n 9-2782- 14omeowner address j ) 5 a3e C4 o,�[g6 A Homeowner address fj Homeowner address / $-z-,S-B vt Homeowner addres I S as, 3 ^C /;I' I /k- T" 4b Homeowner address ISM Tu�i�c, Homeowner address y 7 Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Petition against Converting Coventry Court from Ownership Tenure to Rental Tenure Conditional Use Permit (CUP) 09-024, Design Review (DR) 09-024, and Amendments to the Final Tract Map (FTM) 16581, and Concept Plan (CP) 03-003 to convert Coventry. Court from ownership tenure to rental tenure. 1 J Columbus Square Zone Print name and signature Homeowner address ', i n Print name and signature Homeowner address vkyj�u.WTKO ��i L3z Cay�lar;d�� -. Tc c CA q7_-jLSZ Print name and signature Homeowner address Mi �� mb�yala l �,S�o� CAaa7�� Print nam and signature ) n ,,omeowner address _ Print name and Print name Print name and IS Low name and si Print name and signature Print name -ILA Pri name and signature &JA - Print name and signature It AAU�4,.IAV W Print name and signature ) q 9,LI�� � t.. rt'�s - cam- z �Z Homeowner address T _ Homeowner address 4.2 -7 IYZ Homeowner addres )Wz Co►a , i .j4/7 Wit-gz �Z Homeowner address Homeowner address 1 SZv 57!Leis � Du�lc!% ;10417 Homeowner address /f zjs-�- Homeowner address L5 5 ym (n ter Homeowner address Z (NDS tr Lli—lI* Homeowner address ��_ 14. Qe.,,.,_r,� ire, T� �- Homeowner address If IZ-1 V�� 6b7g 2, 148q Qe,,a�L/eye.,��st� 1z-702 Homeowner address Petition against Converting Coventry Court from Ownership 4 Tenure to Rental Tenure Conditional Use Permit (CUP) 09-024, Design Review (DR) 09-024, and Amendments to the Final 'Tract Map (FTM) 16581, and Concept Plan (CP) 03-003 to convert Coventry Court from ownership tenure to rental tenure. Columbus Square Zone i � Petition against Converting Coventry Court from Ownership Tenure to Rental Tenure Conditional Use Permit (CUP) 09-024, Design Review (DR) 09-024, and Amendments to the Final Tract Map (FTM) 16581, and Concept Plan (CP) 03-003 to convert Coventry Court from ownership tenure to rental tenure. Region: Tustin County: Orange Target: Columbus Square Community Background: A 240 unit 55 + resident development, named Coventry Court located in Tustin's Columbus Square community is proposed to be converted from ownership to an Apartment rental complex. 153 of these apartments will be rented as Affordable Housing under the Section 8 Rental Agreement. Of the 153 units 56 will be rented as moderate - income, 61 as low-income, and 36 as very low-income. We urge the Planning Commissioners and City Council Members to deny the proposal for converting Coventry Court to rental tenure. This proposal will create an undue hardship and burdens on our families; increase our financial responsibility, and increase parking problems. 1. META the owner of Coventry Court apartments will have 120 votes at future Columbus Square HOA meetings. This will most likely control of the entire Columbus Square HOA Board and the Direction of the Community. This means the owners of the new apartment complex will be in total control of our community! 2. Our HOA fees will increase approx. 20 percent! 3. Columbus Square will absorb 80 percent of the Tustin Legacy apartment requirements. This is not what we were told when we bought our homes. 4. All of this will have an extreme negative impact on our home values while unjustly enriching the future developers of Tustin Legacy at the expense of Columbus Square home owners. We, the undersigned, ask that the proposed application converting Coventry Court to rental tenure, project developers Lennar and META to be denied. We, the undersigned, do not wish to have this type of community built within our current community: Print name and signature , Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address t [, r'... j'47to tJc,)fyGle Print name and signature " Homeowne addr s Petition against Convcrting Coventry Court from Ownership 1 Tenure to Rental Tenure Conditional Use Permit (CUP) 09-024, Design Review (DR) 09-024, and Amendments to the Final Tract Map (FTM) 16581, and Concept Plan (CP) 03-003 to convert Coventry Court from ownership tenure to rental tenure. t ,� Columbus Square Zone 1 ,n; Print name and signature -lt ri,L" �-k i LV 0 c Print name and signature aS 0--s'-w -�P E t Print paTe andsi nature r Print nayrie and signature/ Print name and signature Print name and signature Pri t nam"d suture L-- � t i' -P Y V1 a -K 1443 Print name and signature Print name and signat Print n4he and signature- ;'. `Print name and ignature , '--, ' Print name and signature Print name and signature Print name and signature Print name and signature t16rt# Homeowne' addres (444 Hon �j= Homeowner address Homeowner address Homeowner address (JJI Homeowne address '1S214 � Cc..yA Homeowner address 16D�-j -i Cf\N` ,'?)?,\ l Homeowner address Homeowner address Homeowner ad ress , 1 Homeowner address Homeowner address Homeowner address Homeowner address Homeowner address Homeowner address Petition against Converting Coventry Court from Ownership ; Tenure to Rental Tenure Conditional Use Permit (CUP) 09-024, Design Review (DR) 09-024, and Amendments to the Final Tract Map (FTM) 16581, and Concept Plan (CP) 03-003 to convert Coventry Court from ownership tenure to rental tenure. Columbus Square Zone 10 Petition against Converting Coventry Court from Ownership Tenure to Rental Tenure Conditional Use Permit (CUP) 09-024, Design Review (DR) 09-024, and Amendments to the Final Tract Map (FTM) 16581, and Concept Plan (CP) 03-003 to convert Coventry Court from ownership tenure to rental tenure. Region: Tustin County: Orange Target: Columbus Square Community Background: A 240 unit 55 + resident development, named Coventry Court located in Tustin's Columbus Square community is proposed to be converted from ownership to an Apartment rental complex. 153 of these apartments will be rented as Affordable Housing under the Section 8 Rental Agreement. Of the 153 units 56 will be rented as moderate - income, 61 as low-income, and 36 as very low-income. We urge the Planning Commissioners and City Council Members to deny the proposal for converting Coventry Court to rental tenure. This proposal will create an undue hardship and burdens on our families; increase our financial responsibility, and increase parking problems. 1. META the owner of Coventry Court apartments will have 120 votes at future Columbus Square HOA meetings. This will most likely control of the entire Columbus Square HOA Board and the Direction of the Community. This means the owners of the new apartment complex will be in total control of our community! 2. Our HOA fees will increase approx. 20 percent! 3. Columbus Square will absorb 80 percent of the Tustin Legacy apartment requirements. This is not what we were told when we bought our homes. 4. All of this will have an extreme negative impact on our home values while unjustly enriching the future developers of Tustin Legacy at the expense of Columbus Square home. owners. We, the undersigned, ask that the proposed application converting Coventry Court to rental tenure, project developers Lennar and META to be denied. We, the undersigned, do not wish to have this type of community built within our current community: Print name and signature Homeowner addreAs Print name and si,natu a ------,-Homeowner address rin name an signature Homeowner address Petition against Converting Coventry Court from Ownership 1 Tenure to Rental Tenure Conditional Use Permit (CUP) 09-024, Design Review (DR) 09-024, and Amendments to the Final Tract Map (FTM) 16581, and Concept Plan (CP) 03-003 to convert Coventry Court from ownership tenure to rental tenure. Columbus Square Zone Print name and signature rent n e�signature Print name and signature r Print name and signature and Print name d signature f /j� Print name and signature Print name and signature Print name and signature Print name and signature Print name and signature Print name and signature Print name and signature Print name and signature Print name and signature Homeowner address i— �-TI A Homeowner a dress (5I6 I C -O,,7 Homeowner address / S— Homeowner address l Homeowner address Homeowner address ( meg atgo N Homeowner address Zo 3 cneen \("I . � � ra S � ��•} Homeowner address Homeowner address Homeowner address Homeowner address Homeowner address Homeowner address Homeowner address Homeowner address Petition against Converting Coventry Court from Ownership 2 Tenure to Rental Tenure Conditional Use Permit (CUP) 09-024, Design Review (DR) 09-024, and Amendments to the Final Tract Map (FTM) 16581, and Concept Plan (CP) 03-003 to convert Coventry Court from ownership tenure to rentaltenure. Columbus Square Zone 1_ Petition against Converting Coventry Court from Ownership Tenure to Rental Tenure Conditional Use Permit (CUP) 09-024, Design Review (DR) 09-024, and Amendments to the Final Tract Map (FTM) 16581, and Concept Plan (CP) 03-003 to convert Coventry Court from ownership tenure to rental tenure. Region: Tustin County: Orange Target: Columbus Square Community Background: A 240 unit 55 + resident development, named Coventry Court located in Tustin's Columbus Square community is proposed to be converted from ownership to an Apartment rental complex. 153 of these apartments will be rented as Affordable Housing under the Section 8 Rental Agreement. Of the 153 units 56 will be rented as moderate - income, 61 as low-income, and 36 as very low-income. We urge the Planning Commissioners and City Council Members to deny the proposal for converting Coventry Court to rental tenure. This proposal will create an undue hardship and burdens on our families; increase our financial responsibility, and increase parking problems. 1. META the owner of Coventry Court apartments will have 120 votes at future Columbus Square HOA meetings. This will most likely control of the entire Columbus Square HOA Board and the Direction of the Community. This 11 means the owners of the new apartment complex will be in total control of our community! 2. Our HOA fees will increase approx. 20 percent'. 3. Columbus Square will absorb 80 percent of the Tustin Legacy apartment requirements. This is not what we were told when we bought our homes. 4. All of this will have an extreme negative impact on our home values while unjustly enriching the future developers of Tustin Legacy at the expense of Columbus Square home owners. We, the undersigned, ask that the proposed application converting Coventry Court to rental tenure, project developers Lennar and META to be denied. We, the undersigned, do not wish to have this type of community built within our current community: Print �n^a'me and signaturel` 1 1 e, ��maY Print name and signature �ct1 1�V1 ��1,y [wt Print name and signature "02 iAE--�(Z-p IAy �TvS?11J cA 92--Iqr Homeowner address ts2� ! e 1 tips-ftv� C:� �Z�0Z Homeowner addxcA vL l,�! � 1 �� � Homeowner add Petition against Converting Coventry Court from Ownership 1 Tenure to Rental Tenure Conditional Use Permit (CUP) 09-024, Design Review (DR) 09-024, and Amendments to the Final Tract Map (FTM) 16581, and Concept Plan (CP) 03-003 to convert Coventry Court from ownership tenure to rental tenure. Columbus Square Zone Print name and signatur Print name and signature,,,, Nlu Print name and signature 2`7��� )2— address )- address Homeowner address Print naxfie and Signa urea ' Homeowner address y1 Print Print name and YI.LJ6 <:�:H) vJ -) rZ. Print name andel signature Print name and signature Print name and signature D9 M01110V Print ame and signature ; 0A Print name and signature Print name and signature name and signature Q'fr\-J V(k rint name arid signature t rint name and signature /y60 OttOLIa4 AtF- Homeowner address I y y V, -ta,.c i t Homeowner address r4t6 aokh,,, Ave Homeowner address ^' J. Homeowne r addres �d. 8 omeowner dress aM h(,t� Nw Homeowner address 1 q o 6 Vh,�_6',-e, l-�, w Homeowner addre s Homeowner address Homeowner address Homeowner address 2 2- w Homeowner address Petition against Converting Coventry Court from Ownership Tenure to Rental Tenure Conditional Use Permit (CUP) 09-024, Design Review (DR) 09-024, and Amendments to the Final Tract Map (FTM) 16581, and Concept Plan (CP) 03-003 to convert Coventry Court from ownership tenure to rental tenure. Columbus Square Zone 9 � cv- '-�rvl�- N o- ; I'�� nc: ►�- '' w �f Print name and sig at a Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address ..• Print name and signature Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Petition against Converting Coventry Court from Ownership 3 Tenure to Rental Tenure Conditional Use Permit (CUP) 09-024, Design Review (DR) 09-024, and Amendments to the Final Tract Map (FTM) 16581, and Concept Plan (C P) 03-003 to convert Coventry Court from ownership tenure to rental tenure. 10 Columbus Square Zone i A - Petition against Converting Coventry Court from Ownership Tenure to Rental Tenure Conditional Use Permit (CUP) 09-024, Design Review (DR) 09-024, and Amendments to the Final Tract Map (FTM) 16581, and Concept Plan (CP) 03-003 to convert Coventry Court from ownership tenure to rental tenure. Region: Tustin County: Orange Target: Columbus Square Community Background: A 240 unit 55 + resident development, named Coventry Court located in Tustin's Columbus Square community is proposed to be converted from ownership to an Apartment rental complex. 153 of these apartments will be rented as Affordable Housing under the Section 8 Rental Agreement. Of the 153 units 56 will be rented as moderate - income, 61 as low-income, and 36 as very low-income. We urge the Planning Commissi ners and City Council Members to deny the proposal for converting Coventry Court t ) eQtal tenure. This proposal will create an undue hardship and burdens on our families; -increase our financial responsibility, and increase parking problems. --_----- 1. META the owner of Coventry Court apartments will have 120 votes at future Columbus Square HOA meetings. This will most likely control of the entire Columbus Square HOA Board and the Di ` ction of the Community. This means the owners of the new apartment complex will be in total control of our community! 2. Our HOA fees will increase approx. 20 percent! 3. Columbus Square will absorb 80 percent of the Tustin Legacy apartment requirements. This is not what we were told when we bought our homes. 4. All of this will have an extreme negative impact on our home values while unjustly enriching the future developers of Tustin Legacy at the expense of Columbus Square home owners. We, the undersigned, ask that the proposed application converting Coventry Court to rental tenure, project developers Lennar and META to be denied. We, the undersigned, do not wish to have this type of ity built within our current community: Print name and §ignature '�/, /"I/ Homeowner address 70 ri-,] V y, I U n Print name and sigi RACKI, A$-4 Print name and sil Homeowner address 14(. ✓"(AA "O.WUl---1 TuSf(d CA 12 ?8�L Homeowner address Petition against Converting Coventry Court From Ownership ] Tenure to Rental Tenure Conditional Use Pcrmit (CUP) 09-024, Design Review (DR) 09-024, and Amendments to the Final Tract Map (FTM) 16581, and Concept Plan (CP) 03-003 to convert Coventry Court From ownership tenure to rental tenure. i 1 Columbus Square Lone �- Print name and—signature — Print name and signature Hoieowne address lTomeow �dress [Tint name an =nature Hou�eowner a�•ess Print name and sigiTature Hoi eowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address J Print name and signs re ,, Print name and signature ,/5207 1Ji0tr rt r f= (.c.ta : i? <i Iy -12 73Z Homeowner address I iomeowner address umbras Square Zone Print name and signature Homeowner address Print name and'si`unature Homeowner address Print iiame artd signature Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Print name and signature Print name and signature Print name and signature Print name and signature Homeowner address Homeowner address Homeowner address i-Iomeowner address--------_^--- --- Columbus Square Gone Petition against Converting Coventry Court from Ownership Tenure to Rental Tenure Conditional Use Permit (CUP) 09-024, Design Review (DR) 09-024, and Amendments to the Final Tract Map (FTM) 16581, and Concept Plan (CP) 03-003 to convert Coventry Court from ownership tenure to rental tenure. Region: Tustin County: Orange Target: Columbus Square Community Background: A 240 unit 55 + resident development, named Coventry Court located in Tustin's Columbus Square community is proposed to be converted from ownership to an Apartment rental complex. 153 of these apartments will be rented as Affordable Housing under the Section 8 Rental Agreement. Of the 153 units 56 will be rented as moderate - income, 61 as low-income, and 36 as very low-income. We urge the Planning Commissioners and City Council Members to deny the proposal for converting Coventry Court to rental tenure. This proposal will create an undue hardship and burdens on our families; increase our financial responsibility, and increase parking problems. 1. META the owner of Coventry Court apartments will have 120 votes at future Columbus Square HOA meetings. This will most likely control of the entire Columbus Square HOA Board and the Direction of the Community. This means the owners of the new apartment complex will be in total control of our community! 2. Our HOA fees will increase approx. 20 percent! 3. Columbus Square will absorb 80 percent of the Tustin Legacy apartment requirements. This is not what we were told when we bought our homes. 4. All of this will have an extreme negative impact on our home values while unjustly enriching the future developers of Tustin Legacy at the expense of Columbus Square home owners. We, the undersigned, ask that the proposed application converting Coventry Court to rental tenure, project developers Lennar and META to be denied. We, the undersigned, do not wish to have this type ofcommunity built within our current community: jf E,y ,� t L L Print name and signature Homeowner address Print n and signature Homeowner address Print name and signature J Homeowner address ' T Petition against Convening Coventry Court from Ownership 1 Tenure to Rental Tenure Conditional use Permit (CUP) 09-024, Design Review (DR) 09-024, and Amendments to the Final Tract Map (FTM) 16381, and Concept Plan (CP) 03-003 to convert Coventry Court from ownership tenure to rental tenure. Columbus Square Zone 1-3 P-rjntna=-.ar4 signature Print name and signature Pri 4 A -ahie and siHature Print name and sigrmhure I( d \1 V - Print n and signature4 Print name and signature f7 !v� , Print name and signature 45, Print name and signature Print/name and signature L A,q W Print name and signatPrell-,.- Print name and signatur6 U 11-j Prig rtame,and.sfgnat&e Print name and signature Print name and signature Print name and signature C Homeowner address Homeowner address I SZ I WJEEAUX-W-f C Homeowner address Homeowner address JL3g 1 0�4i v, � !1 Homeowner ad ss Homeowner address_" I tic-; Homeowner address _LH) Homeowner address K -j-03 Homeowner address lybcz /�-UML,,60 9�2'-r3-- Homeowner address wo2- cl-nemzwL v\kq, -Tuct1t, t - cf2-778 71 Homeowner address A 7Z I',-? Homeowner address Homeowner address Homeowner address Homeowner address Petition against Converting Coventry Court from Ownership Tenure to Rental Tenure Conditional Use Permit (CUP) 09-024, Design Review (DR) 09-024, and Amendments to the Final,rract Map (FTM) 16581, and Concept Plan (CP) 03-003 to convert Coventry Court from ownership tenure to rental tenure. Columbus Square Zone Petition against Converting Coventry Court from Ownership Tenure to Rental Tenure Conditional Use Permit (CUP) 09-024, Design Review (DR) 09-024, and Amendments to the Final Tract Map (FTM) 16581, and Concept Plan (CP) 03-003 to convert Coventry Court from ownership tenure to rental tenure. Region: Tustin County: Orange Target: Columbus Square Community Background: A 240 unit 55 + resident development, named Coventry Court located in Tustin's Columbus Square community is proposed to be converted from ownership to an Apartment rental complex. 153 of these apartments will be rented as Affordable Housing under the Section 8 Rental Agreement. Of the 153 units 56 will be rented as moderate - income, 61 as low-income, and 36 as very low-income. We urge the Planning Commissioners and City Council Members to deny the proposal for converting Coventry Court to rental tenure. This proposal will create an undue hardship and burdens on our families; increase our financial responsibility, and increase parking problems. 1. META the owner of Coventry Court apartments will have 120 votes at future Columbus Square HOA meetings. This will most likely control of the entire Columbus Square HOA Board and the Direction of the Community. This means the owners of the new apartment complex will be in total control of our community! 2. Our HOA fees will increase approx. 20 percent! 3. Columbus Square will absorb 80 percent of the Tustin Legacy apartment requirements. This is not what we were told when we bought our homes. 4. All of this will have an extreme negative impact on our home values while unjustly enriching the future developers of Tustin Legacy at the expense of Columbus Square home owners. We, the undersigned, ask that the proposed application converting Coventry Court to. rental tenure, project developers Lennar and META to be denied. We, the undersigned, do not wish to ave this ty e community built within our current community: Print name and signat e Homeowner address .�7 Print! name and signature ,e Print nam nd si ture `-'` Homeowner address 1 5? 16 1, n!p IL) t,�I Homeowner address Petition against Converting Coventry Court from Ownership ] Tenure to Rental Tenure Conditional Use Permit (CUP) 09-024, Design Review (DR) 09-024, and Amendments to the Final Tract Map (FTM) 16581, and Concept Plan (CP) 03-003 to convert Coventry Court from ownership tenure to rental tenure. Columbus Square Zone Print name and signt e � 1 ar E RL�� >�t�u,4 RAe K u .ta—p.4nn -'I • V Print name and signature L Print name and signat Prin name,and signature Print name and sig re �ilM°t�it7.ne'�u K% Print name and sig r J /,T22 Z tvE-SL6Y W&Y Homeowner address 1 5a 14 0 i s LE -'f (-,% A-( Homeowner address 1!57-U., WCStAt--e Homeowner address Homeowner address I S2oCk &U vzfy� ujCL Homeowner address Homeowner address Print name and signature j Homeowner addr ss Print name and signature Homeowner addreess Pri name and signatur na e and >gnature name and signature Print and signature/ Print name an�ure Print name and iignature 14(ay� Print nariYe ansignature N61 Lc'C�0 ON Homeowner address I Homeowner address ' Homeowner address VV H , eowwti address JI nn V'14i Ho em owner address I qO 1p W' I Homeowner address 6 Homeowner address Petition against Converting Coventry Court from Ownership Tenure to Rental Tenure Conditional Use Permit (CUP) 09-024, Design Review (DR) 09-024, and Amendments to the Final Tract Map (FTM) 16581, and Concept Plan (CP) 03-003 to convert Coventry Court from ownership tenure to rental tenure. Columbus Square Zone S,�I .: � ll Print name and signature Print name and signature Print natiWand si ;N fV —i`'( W,- U L� Print name and signature a !(J/)! v✓J'YL47.1i/ Homeowner address iSzaZ Gk-es(e U Homeowner address I Homeowner address fl ,-.) /7-,'t l Homeowner address -- Print name and signatutA omeowner address } V rint name and signature A Homeowner address Print fa. Zvr}�Sig �mMLB�u.-c.�-� Print name and signature j hq✓i t. 2&A M�vn Print name and signature 4�tr Print name and signatur Print name and signature rJ �cL` Print name and signature , : P 7 Print name and signature Print name and signature 51LD O rrem %ayw. Print name and signature \)G Homeowner address Homeowner address I � � Y Vol le- �,c .,4 If o y e - Homeowner address 222 ( A3-�,- L-2 V W�� Homeowner address 1 z Homeowner address Homeowner address Homeowner address 'J64na, Ave - Homeowner address N729 VVL# ml Homeowner address Petition against Converting Coventry Court from Ownership Tenure to Rental Tenure Conditional Use Permit (CUP) 09-024, Design Review (DR) 09-024, and Amendments to the Final Tract Map (FTM) 16581, and Concept Plan (CP) 03-003 to convert Coventry Court from ownership tenure to rental tenure. Columbus Square Zone `ZM Print name andsignature Homeowner addres � t�s{�� C. i27 2- y�1 tDA U �,� ��� Way Print nam ure Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Petition against Converting Coventry Court from Ownership 4 Tenure to Rental Tenure Conditional Use Permit (CUP) 09-024, Design Review (DR) 09-024, and Amendments to the Final Tract Map (ETM) 16581, and Concept Plan (CP) 03-003 to convert Coventry Court from ownership tenure to rental tenure. Columbus Square Zone IS Petition against Converting Coventry Court from Ownership Tenure to Rental Tenure Conditional Use Permit (CUP) 09-024, Design Review (DR) 09-024, and Amendments to the Final Tract Map (FTM) 16581, and Concept Plan (CP) 03-003 to convert Coventry Court from ownership tenure to rental tenure. Region: Tustin County: Orange Target: Columbus Square Community Background: A 240 unit 55 + resident development, named Coventry Court located in Tustin's Columbus Square community is proposed to be converted from ownership to an Apartment rental complex. 153 of these apartments will be rented as Affordable Housing under the Section 8 Rental Agreement. Of the 153 units 56 will be rented as moderate - income, 61 as low-income, and 36 as very low-income. We urge the Planning Commissioners and City Council Members to deny the proposal for converting Coventry Court to rental tenure. This proposal will create an undue hardship and burdens on our families; increase our financial responsibility, and increase parking problems. 1. META the owner of Coventry Court apartments will have 120 votes at future Columbus Square HOA meetings. This will most likely control of the entire Columbus Square HOA Board and the Direction of the Community. This means the owners of the new apartment complex will be in total control of our community! saw 2. Our HOA fees will increase approx. 20 percent! 3. Columbus Square will absorb 80 percent of the Tustin Legacy apartment requirements. This is not what we were told when we bought our homes. 4. All of this will have an extreme negative impact on our home values while unjustly enriching the future developers of Tustin Legacy at the expense of Columbus Square home owners. We, the undersigned, ask that the proposed application converting Coventry Court to rental tenure, project developers Lennar and META to be denied. We, the undersigned, do not wish to have this type of community built within/our current community: Print ngme and signature Homeowner address t t L L ice-- rrr� i✓s'� Homeowner address Homeowner address Petition against Converting Coventry Court from Ownership 1 Tenure to Rental Tenure Conditional Use Permit (CUP) 09-024, Design Review (DR) 09-024, and Amendments to the Final Tract Map (FTM) 16581, and Concept Plan (CP) 03-003 to convert Coventry Court from ownership tenure to rental tenure. Columbus Square Zone Pr` iiame and signature Prktt name aAd signature Print name and signdture ?+'sLt G Print name and signature Print name and signature Print name and signature Print name and signatures Print name and signature Print name and signature ~ Print -name and signatpre 1 4 Print name and signature Print name and signature Print name and sign ure Print name and signature tiny. V,1 j -.f% , T �L Homeowner address lu.� G l o� Homeowner address t41 e � �h iQt eve i�&�'i n Homeowner address Homeowner address r' F ''r 7 Ic-t(J at SIL t L; -i t_- «� C_ lv Homeowner address Homeowner address Homeowner address 11 � Cy Homeowner address Homeowner address Homeowner ddre'ss, •, Homeowner addiess 11"'(j !: i''iE`.7) t� :-✓��.,-/ y� 1, Homeowner address '? r„t C J Homeowner ad rtiss ;` 1 f Homeowner address j Homeowner address Petition against Converting Coventry Court from Ownership 2 Tenure to Rental Tenure Conditional Use Permit (CUP) 09-024, Design Review (DR) 09-024, and Amendments to the Final Tract Map (FTM) 16581, mid Concept Plan (CP) 03-003 to convert Coventry Court from ownership tenure to rentaltenure. Columbus Square Zone S ` l Print name and signature it • i!j Print name end sigrlaturer Print name and signat Print name and sign ture Print name and signature J enni fe* So►,b o Print name and sig ature Print narWe and signature_ Print name Homeowner address' Homeowner address Homeowner address Homeowner address 11 �ycj Pmtu , Ak Homeowner address 157-N/ Soe tiS �-O Homeowner address Homeowner address / S Z78 ja EXVA3 s RD. Homeowner address Homeowner address Pri t ame ana sign a Homeowner address 1 �— Gan,'/' O rl //�/i► /ka* �`�xci,'f/ ST Print name and signatur Homeowner address Ka.f'1 Isan JL�L- Moril0jom Sr rint iame, and sign e Homeowner addre A.*terJ toot j Irl J Print name and ature Homeowner address Print name and ign u e Homeowner addres C,N f - e; tv-- c,J Print name and si nature Homeowner address Petition against Converting Coventry Court from ownership 3 Tenure to Rental Tenure Conditional Use Permit (CUP) 09-024, Design Review (DR) 09-024, and Amendments to the Final Tract Map (FTM.) 16581. and Concept Plan (CP) 03-003 to convert Coventry Court from ownership tenure to rental tenure. Columbus Square Zone Don 1�A✓�o'�,s.R /�_��r-- ISZIi CA�r'�ilo,�-pn (/�ar Print name and signature! Homeowner address Print na r-. nnri -d6thature Homeowner address L l ZZ-2-ci wP, name "anatune Homeowner address Print am JAK?7aV-O� 5�Z0 �A:�A-f 5C� V4t/ Print name and signature Homeowner address Petition against Converting Coventry Court from Ownership 4 Tenure to Rental Tenure Conditional Use Permit (CUP) 09-024, Design Review (DR) 09-024, and Amendments to the Final Tract Map (1•TM) 16581, and Concept Plan (CP) 03-003 to convert Coventry Court from ownership tenure to rentaltenure. Print name and signature Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address t Print name and signature Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Petition against Converting Coventry Court from Ownership 4 Tenure to Rental Tenure Conditional Use Permit (CUP) 09-024, Design Review (DR) 09-024, and Amendments to the Final Tract Map (1•TM) 16581, and Concept Plan (CP) 03-003 to convert Coventry Court from ownership tenure to rentaltenure. I/ Columbus Square Zone /Q Petition against Converting Coventry Court from Ownership Tenure to Rental Tenure Conditional Use Permit (CUP) 09-024, Design Review (DR) 09-024, and Amendments to the Final Tract Map (FTM) 16581, and Concept Plan (CP) 03-003 to convert Coventry Court from ownership tenure to rental tenure. Region: Tustin County: Orange Target: Columbus Square Community Background: A 240 unit 55 + resident development, named Coventry Court located in Tustin's Columbus Square community is proposed to be converted from ownership to an Apartment rental complex. 153 of these apartments will be rented as Affordable Housing under the Section 8 Rental Agreement. Of the 153 units 56 will be rented as moderate - income, 61 as low-income, and 36 as very low-income. We urge the Planning Commissioners and City Council Members to deny the proposal for converting Coventry Court to rental tenure. This proposal will create an undue hardship and burdens on our families; increase our financial responsibility, and increase parking problems. 1. META the owner of Coventry Court apartments will have 120 votes at future Columbus Square HOA meetings. This will most likely control of the entire Columbus Square HOA Board and the Direction of the Community. This means the owners of the new apartment complex will be in total control of our community! 2. Our HOA fees will increase approx. 20 percent! 3. Columbus Square will absorb 80 percent of the Tustin Legacy apartment requirements. This is not what we were told when we bought our homes. 4. All of this will have an extreme negative impact on our home values while unjustly enriching the future developers of Tustin Legacy at the expense of Columbus Square home owners. We, the undersigned, ask that the proposed application converting Coventry Court to rental tenure, project developers Lennar and META to be denied. We, the undersigned, do not wish to have this type of community built within our current community: Print name and signature Print name and signature )2O e Yfl Print name and signature Homeowner add s Homeowner address 2- Homeowner address Petition against Converting Coventry Court from Ownership 1 Tenure to Rental Tenure Conditional Use Permit (CUP) 09-024, Design Review (DR) 09-024, and Amendments to the Final Tract Map (FTM) 16581, and Conccpt Plan (CP) 03-003 to convert Coventry Court from ownership tenure to rental tenure. Columbus Square Zone Print name, ands�i�gnaturp Print nqme, and signature u� Print name and signature 1 li— � Print name and signature SNA Print namq and signature Print nantiland signat Print name and signature �ev C;I Print name and signature Print name and sign e Print name and signature 14-�e-x; ` �'I c %J }"t bus fi .,1 (_ A y 2- jp Homeowner address .� �2. L; j - 1E LSC!{ -Z Homeowner address Homeowner address ' AoAeowner address Homeowner ad ss Homeowner address '> Homeowner address r V11 U Y1�—) Ute. v> Homeowner address Homeowner address Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Print name and signature Homeowner address Print name and signature Print name and signature Homeowner address Homeowner address -e Petition against Converting Coventry Court from Ownership Tenure to Rental Tenure Conditional Use Permit (CUP) 09-024, Design Review (DR) 09-024, and Amendments to the Final Tract Map (FTM) 16581, and Concept Plan (CP) 03-003 to convert Coventry Court from ownership tenure to rental tenure. ATTACHMENT D Letter from Lennar "RE: Summary of Coventry Court Presentation to Columbus Square Community Association Meeting on December 16th" --1 January 5, 2010 Ms. Elizabeth A. Binsack Community Development Director city of Tustin 300 Centennial Way Tustin, CA 92780 RE: Summary of Coventry Court Presentation to Columbus Square Community Association Meeting on December 16"' Dear Ms. Binsadc: The following represents a summary, prepared by me and submitted to the Columbus Square Community Association Board Members as well as Merit for their concurrence that this fairly represented the presentation and discussions that evening. Lennar and Meta Housing representatives presented the proposal we have before the City of Tustin to build Coventry Court as an age -restricted rental community instead of an age -restricted for -sale development on Wednesday evening, December 16th at their regularly scheduled HOA meeting. Approximately 20 residents were in attendance in addition to the Board of Directors. k1 -1W One resident, Eric Higuchi submitted a list of questions prior to the meeting (attached) that he wanted answered. Meta responded to the operational aspects of Coventry Court moving forward. In addition to describing that the built environment was proposed to be exactly the same as a rental community and answering the questions posed by Mr. Higuchl, the following items were discussed: • We shared the reasons for lack of success in selling Coventry that led us to request the change from ownership to rental. • Mello Roos tax assessments would be paid the same as if the community remained as a 'for -sale development' The HOA Assessments could increase due to the proposal as the rental community would pay an amount equivalent to 50°x6 of the monthly Common Assessments. The apartment community would also have voting rights equivalent to 50% of the total units within Coventry Court. We discussed that this was a consistent approach within Master Planned Communities for a rental parcel. It was also acknowledged that consistent with DRE regulations, the increase would require the approval of the residents if the amount of the Increase was more than 20%. The community is currently operating under the initial DRE budget. • Questions were answered relative to when all development might be complete and when Lennar specifically was complete. 25 Enterprise, Suite 200, ANso Viejo, CA 92858 • Phone: (949) 349-8000 • Fax: (949) 349-0798 LENNAR.COM 19 Aside from the obvious concerns with increased HOA Assessments, existing on -street parking within the community and on -street parking within Coventry appeared to be an issue that was concerning the residents relative to the Coventry development regardless if it was rental or for -sate. For some, since the community was initially envisioned as for -sale, there was disappointment that Coventry would not remain for -sale and fear relative to rental in general. There was some mixed support or understanding for the proposal to build Coventry as a rental community. While all would rather that Coventry remain a for -sale community, most of those residents who might be considered supportive appeared to see value in the completion of Columbus Square and did not appear overly concerned that the rental component was detrimental to their community. Lennar committed to bring forward to the Planning Staff, a request by one resident (Mr. Eric Higuchi) that the parking ratio for Coventry be further reduced to 1.58 parking spaces to eliminate the 28 on - street spaces on Charleston. The request would not eliminate any parking on Charleston but is intended to restrict Coventry Court from utilizing these spaces in their parking analysis/allocation. When the Board wanted to close this portion of the meeting, a few residents indicated that they had outstanding questions. When Lennar Indicated they would be willing to answer any remaining questions residents may have for us, they then indicated they would attend the Planning Commission meeting and ask their questions there. In speaking with the Community Activities Director for Villages of Columbus, a Merit Property Management Associate, outside after the presentation portion of the meeting, Meta offered to provide additional marketing materials to her that identify operations and activities that are typical to their seniors communities to further confirm that the seniors have a full range of amenities and activities and function primarily as a stand-alone community within the larger Village of Columbus Square. As was obvious in the Planning Commission Meeting of December 8th, the residents were dearly upset that they had not received advance notice of the plans to change Coventry from for -sale to rental and wanted to be kept informed about future changes and city meetings. While there was not a sign -in sheet at the meeting, Merit committed to distribute an email blast to all owners within Columbus Square, regardless of their distance from Coventry Court as to the upcoming Planning Commission and City Council meetings. This email distribution would notify the great majority of the residents within the community. At the meeting we provided the following dates and have learned since that the target date provided for City Council is incorrect. The construction and occupancy dates we presented are likely aggressive by 3-5 months. January 26th, 2010 - Planning Commission February 23rd, 2010 - City Council (Incorrect Date Provided) February 16th, 2010 - City Council if approved at Planning Commission (Accurate Target Date) June 2010 - Anticipated start of construction prior to continuance at Planning Commission January 2012 - Estimated First Occupancy December 2012 - Estimated to be Fully Leased / Occupied Please let me know if you have any questions. It appears that the community will be well represented at both the Planning Commission and City Council meetings. 25 Enterprise, Suite 200, Aliso Viejo, CA 92858 - Phone: (949) 34948000 - Fax: (949) 349-0798 LENNAR.COM I� Drafted by Eric Higuchi December 15, 2009 General questions 1. What is the current schedule for the senior living neighborhood (Coventry Court)? a. Planning commission approval b. City Council approval c. Start of Construction d. First Occupancy e. Last Delivery 2. What are the estimated rental rates for the affordable and market rate apartments? 3. When does Lennar anticipate selling these as condominiums? 4. Will individuals younger than 55 be able to live in a unit as long as there is an occupant older than 55 in the unit as well? S. How will Lennar enforce a 55+ age restriction? 6. Will occupants at Coventry Court have access to the main Columbus Square Clubhouse? 7. Can you provide the community with a copy of the draft CC&R's for this neighborhood? Will renters be provided a copy of the CC&R's? Entitlements In my opinion, the approved senior living product type is not appealing to Lennar's targeted market due to the Southern California active adult's preferences for: • an SFD home as opposed to an attached home • a single story, on -grade home as opposed to a two-story home or a unit accessible only by stairs or elevator • an attached two car garage Considering all these critical deficiencies in your product's design, I believe it's quite possible that this will not be a successful project for Lennar. Therefore, it seems that the preferable course for Lennar would be to build a lower density product type on the site (Meriwether?) in order to be able sell units at a higher price point. I understand that there are hurdles to be overcome in regards to entitlements, therefore, I would like to know, how can the community can work with Lennar and the City of Tustin to revise the entitlements to allow for a product type that will be best for your bottom line In addition to our community. Alternatively, can Lennar seek approval to increase passive open space and on-site parking by only building the 153 affordable units (7 structures)? Due to the cost of construction of this type of product ($125 psf?) and that the current economic downturn has significantly reduced the gap between the affordable housing rental rate and market rental rate, it seems that there would be negative cost recovery by proceeding with the construction of the market rate units. Parking Questions 1. How will Lennar inform future residents of the rental community that they may only have one car per household? 2. How will Lennar enforce a one carper household rule within the neighborhood's private streets? 3. The current proposed parking permit program does not specifically address renter's residing in developer owned units. Preferably, the master association's parking permit program would not be applicable to the residents of the active adult community, and, therefore, all Coventry renter's would be not be able to park master association streets overnight. However, as approval of the parking program is ultimately up to a developer controlled HOA board, its seems likely that the board would allow Coventry renters to apply for on -street parking permits. If this is the case: 1. Will the residents be required to apply for the permits themselves or can Lennar apply for a permit on behalf of a resident? Will Lennar be able to apply for a permit on behalf of a unit to be used as an incentive for a future resident? 2. Will the permits be approved by a committee made up of resident's only, and not the board itself? 3. Will Lennar adopt the same parking rules and regs for the private, on-site parking spaces at Coventry? ATTACHMENT E Master Disclosure statement 20, Additional Provisions, There may be provisions of various laws, including the Davis -Stirling Common Interest Development Act codified at Sections 1.350 et seq. of the California Civil Code and the Federal Fair Housing Act codified at Title 42 United States Code, Section 3601 et seq., which may supplement or override the Community Association Governing Documents, The Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders and Community Association make no representations or warranties regarding the future enforceability of July portion of the Community Association Governing Documents. COLUMBUS SQUARE DISCLOSURES 21. Charitable Endowment Fee. A recorded Charitable Housing Agreement Imposing Endowment Fee On Transfer (`Agreement") affects your Horne and the other Homes in the Community. The Agreement requires that an "Endowment Fee" equal to one -twentieth of one percent (0.05%) of the total sales price (0.0005 x total sales price) be paid each time a Home in the Community is transferred to a new owner. The Endowment Fee will be paid to Lennar Charitable Housing Foundation, a California nonprofit public benefit corporation ( "Foundation "), to be used for the purposes described in the Agreement. When you close escrow for the purchase of your Horne, you will pay the Endowment Fee to the Foundation. Thereafter, each time your Home is resold, the Endowment Fee must be paid at the close of escrow, but it may be paid either by the new buyer or the then current seller. The Agreement will be in effect for an indefinite period of time. 22. Affordable Housing/Transitional Housing. The City of Tustin has required the Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders to provide two hundred sixty-six (266) units of affordable housing ("Affordable Housing Units'l within the Community. Sixty-three (63) Affordable Housing Units will be located in the Camden Place Neighborhood, fifty (50) Affordable Housing Units will be located in the Cambridge bane Neighborhood, and one hundred fifty-three (153) Affordable Housing Units will be located in an area of the Community that will be designated as housing for seniors (Coventry Court). Certain of these Affordable Housing Units will be offered to persons who qualify as very low, low and moderate income buyers pursuant to guidelines established by the united States Department of Housing and Urban Development for the City. Buyers who qualify as very low, low and moderate income will purchase their Homes subject to resale restrictions, as reflected in a recorded covenant agreement, for a period of forty-five (45) years. If you are interested in the Affordable Housing Units you should consult your sales representative for further information. 23. "Active Adult" Neighborhood. An "Active Adult" Neighborhood, Coventry Court, is proposed for the Community on Lot 26.5 of Tract No. 16581, which is located on Charleston and Cambridge Streets adjacent to Georgia Street and Kensington Park Drive, and is planned to consist of approximately 240 age restricted Homes. As an Active Adult Neighborhood, each Home must be occupied by at least one resident who is at least 55 years of age. If the Active Adult Neighborhood has its own recreational facilities, then all assessments for the maintenance of these recreation facilities are the exclusive responsibility of the residents of the Active Adult Neighborhood. As a result, the recreational facilities located within the Active Adult Neighborhood are not open to other Owners in the Community; provided, however, the residents of the Active Adult Neighborhood will have the right to use the public recreational Buyer 1111681s: .. _(�_ 2544-332531CLP42K)ISCLSRl609965.9 — 9/30108 facilities located throughout the Community. In addition, if the residents of the Active Adult Neighborhood become members of the Community Association and pay assessments to the Community Association, then the residents of the Active Adult Neighborhood, as members of the Community Association, will have the right to use the Community Association's private recreational facilities. Master Developer reserves the right to construct other age restricted communities in other locations in the Community. Neighborhood Builder may also plan and construct other types and number of Homes, including rental, within Lot 265 of Tract No. 16581, with the approval by the City. 24. Home Business Use. Any Home within the Community may be used for home based business purposes, provided that such use is subject to the City of Tustin's Home Occupation Ordinance (if applicable), the provisions in Section 2.1 of the Community Declaration and the Community Guidelines. You are advised that the Community Declaration and the Community Guidelines may contain stricter restrictions than those in the City Ordinance and that such use may require zoning clearance and a business license. You should contact the City for more information regarding business uses in your Home. 15, MCAS Tustin. (a) Prior Use as MCAS Tustin. You are advised that the Community was previously used as the "Tustin Marine Corps Air Station (`WAS Tustin'J. The Marine Corps and the Department of the Navy ("DON') are the responsible agencies for 'the Installation Restoration Program ("IRF' }. The IRP is a comprehensive environmental investigation and cleanup program formed to identify, investigate and clean up chemical and nuclear contamination that has resulted from past land use operations. When MCAS Tustin was an active base, it received a permit from the California Department of Toxic Substances Control ("DTSC"} pursuant to the federal Resources Conservation. and Recovery Act ("RCRA ") (42 U.S.C. 6901 et seq.) to store hazardous waste on portions of the base. One of the conditions of that permit was to perform "corrective action" to clean-up releases of hazardous waste constituents throughout the base. Although the permit has expired., these corrective action obligations continue, and the DON is undertaking environmental investigation and cleanup activities on portions of the former base that are within the Community. (b) Asbestos Containing Material. Hazardous material in the form of asbestos or asbestos -containing materials ("ACM") have been found and are otherwise presumed to exist in buildings and structures previously located in the Community. At such time as demolition of the prior existing buildings on the Community containing ACM was completed, the appropriate governmental regulatory agency confirmed that ACM had been removed fi-om the buildings and any necessary soil remediation had been conducted in accordance with. all applicable federal, state and local laws and regulations. (c) Easement for Environmental Remediation. An easement over the Community granted to the United States of America, acting by and through the Department of the Navy ("DON") in a document entitled "Quitclaim Deed for Marble Mountain Parcel and Buyer lnivals: /_-._.-_._........-__. -1 l- 2544-332531{.1I42WISLLSM 609965.9 r 9/30/08 �, �............... .. .. ..__....._ ........._.. _............ ,...._._....._..... .... i RECORDING REQUESTED BY: NORTH AMERICAN TITLE COMPANY WEEN RECORDED, MAIL TO: MOFFETT MEADOWS PARTNERS, LLC c/o Lennar Homes of California, Inc. Attn: T. Wilson 25 Enterprise, Suite 300 Aliso Viejo, CA 92656 This Document was electronically recorded by North American Recorded in Official Records, Orange County Tom Daly, Clerk -Recorder 11111111111111101 438.00 2006000149773 10:35am 03107/06 203 59 D02 827143 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 428.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 (Space Abovefor Recorder's Use) MASTER DECLARATION OF COVENANTS, CONDITIONS, RESTRICTIONS AND RESERVATION OF EASEMENTS FOR COLUMBUSSQUARE 2544-33253TU429%CCPM 591730.13 2!(106 the Covered Property. Declarant will record an instrument reflecting the fact that the LIFOC Property has been annexed to the Covered Property and will provide the City with a copy of such recorded instrument. ARTICLE XVII DECLARANT AND NEIGHBORHOOD BUILDER RIGHTS AND EXEMPTIONS Declarant reserves various rights in this Article to facilitate the smooth, orderly development of the Covered Property and to accommodate changes in the development plan that inevitably occur as a community the size of the Covered Property grows and matures. 17.1 INTEREST OF DECLARANT. Declarant intends to develop . the Covered Property into a master planned community. Declarant, in cooperation with the City, has created a comprehensive plan for the development of the Covered Property, which includes modern master -planning objectives which have been formulated for the common good in the community. Declarant, the Neighborhood Builders, or their successors or. assigns intend, but are not obligated, to construct Homes and develop all of the Lots in the Covered Property. The completion of that work and sale, resale, rental and other disposal of Lots is essential to the establishment and welfare of the Covered Property as a quality master planned community. Each Owner acknowledges that Declarant has a substantial interest in assuring compliance with, and enforcement of, the covenants, conditions, restrictions and reservations contained in this Master Declaration and any Supplemental Declarations. 17.2 RIGHTS. The provisions of this Article XVII supersede and control over all other provisions of the Community Association Governing Documents as applied to Declarant and the Neighborhood Builders. Declarant and the Neighborhood Builders have the following rights. Nothing in the Community Association Governing Documents limits and no Owner or the Community Association will interfere with Deelarant's or any Neighborhood Builder's exercise of these rights. 172.1 Subdivision. To subdivide and resubdivide any portion of the Covered Property. 17.2.2 Sales. To sell and rent any portion of the Covered Property directly or through agents and representatives. 172.3 Development. To complete excavation, grading, construction of Improvements and other development activities on the Covered Property. 172.4 Construction. To alter construction plans and designs, to modify Improvements and to construct such additional Improvements as Declarant or a Neighborhood Builder deems advisable. 17.2.5 Grading. To cant' on such grading work as may be approved by the Local Governmental Agency having jurisdiction. -81- 2544.33233%CLP42rC= 591730.13 2/1106 ATTACHMENT F Columbus Square Homebuyer Notification statement ' J Columbus Square . HOMEBUYER NOTIFICATION INTRODUCTION You, the undersigned Buyer, are considering the purchase of a new home in the Columbus Square master planned residential community (the "Community') in the City of Tustin (the "City'I. The master developer of the Community will be Moffett Meadows Partners, LLC ( "Master Developer') and the Columbus Square Community Association, a California nonprofit mutual benefit corporation (the "Community Association') will maintain portions of the Community. We want you (the "Buyer') to be an extremely satisfied customer. Part of your satisfaction is in knowing as much as possible about your new home in the master -planned . Community. We offer this Homebuyer Notification ( "Not leation') as a service to .describe to you various matters which might affect your decision to purchase. Please read it carefully, Be aware, however, that (a) much of the information in this Notification has been obtained from other sources (public agencies, public records, etc.), and (b) the information contained in this Notification is not comprehensive. This means that we cannot guarantee the accuracy or completeness of the information disclosed. Because this information is subject to change without notice to us, it also means that we cannot commit to advise you of any changes affecting the information in this Notification. By signing this Notification, you agree to independently verify all information regarding matters of concern to you before the Close of Escrow for your home purchase. As a part of your pre -purchase investigation, we strongly recommend that you visit the Community and the general vicinity surrounding the Community on several different days at several different times to familiarize yourself with the Community, its location and its surroundings. Unless defined in this Notification, capitalized terms used in this Notification have the meanings given them in the Master Declaration of Covenants, Conditions, Restrictions and Reservation of Easements for Columbus Square (the "Master Declaration'). OPEN SPACE/PARK AREAS Master Developer plans to construct three (3) Open Space/Park Areas within the Community. The facilities in these Open Space/Park Areas may include tot lots, basketball courts, barbeques, picnic tables or restrooms or other popular park facilities. There is no guarantee that any of these facilities will be included in the Open Space/Park Areas. Residents living in the areas nearest to the Open Space/Park Areas may experience noise, traffic and parking congestion, light spillage, glare and othor impacts from the ' operation of these Open Space/Park Areas and the events that take place there and may be inconvenienced by these impacts. You are advised that Master Developer has no control over the operation or use of the Open Space/Park Areas after the completion of construction thereof. The Community Association or Neighborhood Association, as applicable, shall maintain the Open Space/Park Areas in accordance with* all City rules and regulations. Some Open Space/Park Areas may be located immediately adjacent to your Lot or Condominium. Those portions of the Open Space/Park Areas which will be open for public use and any associated access or use easements to the public in connection with these Open Space/Park Areas are located approximately as shown on Exhibit "OS" attached to the Master Declaration. Residents ' of the -1- 2544-3325ACLP428TISCLS 591337.9 6/3= Community may experience glare from night -lighted activities at tale Open Space/Park Areas. Additionally, from time to time, balls and other objects may be hit out of the Open Space/Park Areas and into lots and adjacent areas. Residents of the Community may also experience noises originating from the activities at the Open Space/Park Areas, traffic noises from vehicles going to and from the club, and noises from landscaping and other maintenance activities near the Open SpaceJPark Areas. Master Developer has no control over the use, operation or maintenance of the Open Space/Park Areas. RAIL CORRIDOR There is a rail corridor located to the north of the Community. As of the date of this Notification, an estimated fifty-nine (59) trains per day pass through the rail corridor. Master Developer has been informed by the City that this number is estimated to increase to over one hundred (100) trains per day by the year 2020. The impact of this rail corridor may include, without limitation, increased noise, light and vibration levels in the area of the Community. The rail corridor could be an attractive nuisance to children who may play in the vicinity of the rail corridor. Master Developer and the Community Association have no control over the use, maintenance or care of the rail corridor. You should evaluate the impact of this rail corridor on your decision to purchase a Lot or Condominium in the Community. MAJOR THOROUGHFARES Major thoroughfares are located within the vicinity of the Community, which include, among others, Edinger Avenue, North Loop Road and West Connector Road. Master Develo'j= and the Neighborhood Builders have no control over the use, maintenance or care of these streets and thoroughfares. You may experience noise, dust and traffic within and in the vicinity of the Community based on the public's use of some of these streets and thoroughfares. SOUND ATTENUATION Pursuant to a noise analysis conducted by or on behalf ofMaster Developer, Lots or Condominiums that may most likely be susceptible to noise impacts from property uses surrounding the Community are identified as sensitive receptors, as depicted on Exhibit A attached hereto. Approved building plans may contain sound attenuation measures If your Lot or Condominium is improved with any sound attenuation measures, you are prohibited from altering or modifying any such measures and you acknowledge and understand that the indoor sound attenuation measures will only work as intended if the windows and doors remain closed. You further acknowledge that individuals have varying sensitivity to noise, and any sound attenuation measures installed by Master Developer or a Neighborhood Builder may not reduce noise to a level that will satisfy every expectation. Owners of Lots or Condominiums identified as sensitive receptors on Exhibit A and located at the southwest comer of the Community are advised that these Lots and Condominiums are adjacent to an area west of the Community that is currently zoned for commercial and light industrial uses. Owners of Lots or Condominiums in this area of the Community may experience noise, traffic, dust, odors and other impacts from the operation of this commercial and industrial property. By acceptance of a deed to a Lot or a Condomipium, each Owner acknowledges and accepts that Declarant has no control over any commercial or industrial property or its impact on the Owners or the Community. 2544-33253CLP428%DISC 0 7.9 0 6rim -2- AFFORDABLE HOUSING/TRANSITIONAL HOUSING The City has required Master Developer to provide two hundred sixty-six (266) units of affordable housing within the Community. Certain Lots or Condominiums in the Community will be offered to persons who qualify as very low, low and moderate income buyers pursuant to guidelines established by the United States Department of Housing and Urban Development for the City. Buyers who qualify as very low, low and moderate income will purchase their Lots or Condominiums subject to resale restrictions, as reflected in a recorded covenant agreement, for a period of forty-five (45) years. Buyers who are interested in the affordable housing program should consult their sales counselor for further information. UTILITY 110PROVEMENTS 'In addition to utility lines, all of which will be installed underground in the Community, there may be above -ground and subterranean utility Improvements such as transformers, lift stations, water or sewer facilities, fire hydrants, lighting Improvements, telecommunications vaults and other visible Improvements necessary for the delivery of utilities or other services either on or adjacent to each Lot or Condominium. Each Owner understands that the placement of such Improvements is dictated by the needs of the applicable utility or service provider, and the presence of such Improvements in the Community is in accordance with easements created prior to or during the development of the Community. You understand, by accepting a deed to a Lot or Condominium in the Community, that each Lot or Condominium and portions of the Association Property are subject to one (1) .or more such easements for placement of utility Improvements. You may not modify, remove or otherwise interfere with utility Improvements on any Lot or Condominium or other portion of the Community. CODEmENITY FACILITIES DISTRICT AND ASSESSMENT DISTRICTS The Community lies within the boundaries of Special Assessment Districts and Mello -Roos Community Facilities Districts which require the levy of special taxes for the repayment of bonds issued for the purpose of paying the cost of services or capital improvements that have been or are being provided. The amount of the special tax and any other information pertaining to any such district can be obtained from the County Assessor's office. You will be obligated to pay these assessments and taxes in addition the assessments imposed by the Community Association or any Neighborhood Corporation. MAINTENANCE The Community Association shall maintain all completed Improvements on the Association Property it is obligated to maintain (including the Parkways described in Section 9.2.2 of the Master Declaration, Open Space,/Park Areas, streets (i.e., lighting, drainage facilities), alleys and paseos), all in conformance with any Maintenance Guidelines. The Association Property is described in Exhibit "AP" attached to the Master Declaration. Please refer to Section 9.2 of the Master Declaration for further information concerning maintenance by the Community Association. -3- 2544-33253%CLPa28\D1SCLSR\ 581357.9 VMS ACCESS Neither the Community nor any street, sidewalk, alleyway or paseo located within the Community shall be privately gated; provided however, that any swimming pool and/or spa facility within the Association Property and any indoor recreational facilities, such as a clubhouse and bathrooms, may be gated or locked and made available solely to Residents of the Community and their family, invitees and guests. Neither Master Developer nor the Community Association undertake to provide security or privacy for the Community or buyers, nor do they make any representations or warranties concerning the security or privacy of the Community or Residents. HOME BUSINESS USE Any Home within the Community may be used for business purposes, provided such use is subject to City regulations pertaining to allowable home business use and such use may require zoning clearance and a business license. You should contact the City for more information regarding business uses that are allowed in your Home. TRASH For certain Homes in the Community, trash must be kept in -individual and sanitary containers at designated locations, as approximately shown on Exhibit "TC" to the Master Declaration. In accordance with the Community Guidelines, no odor may be permitted to arise therefrom so as to render any portion of the Community offensive or detrimental to any other property in the vicinity thereof or to its occupants. Your trash containers may be exposed to the view of neighboring Homes only when set out for a reasonable period of time (no earlier than 6:00 p.m: on the day before scheduled trash collection times and no later than midnight the day of pickup). VIEWS/SURROUNDING PROPERTIES Properties surrounding the Community may be developed in accordance with City ordinances in a manner which may partially or totally obstruct views from your Lot or Condominium. Master Developer and the City make no claim, warranty or guarantee that views from any Lot or Condominium will be preserved as development of surrounding properties occurs. PARIONG Vehicles may not be parked in the `no parking" zones identified in the Master Declaration or any Supplemental Declarations. Certain of these "no parking" zones will be identified only by signs and winnot be identified with red -painted curbs. Vehicles parked in these "no parking" zones may be towed immediately without advance notice to vehicle owners. The parking and circulation areas in the Community are located approximately as shown on Exhibit "PC" and Exhibit "OS" to the Master Declaration. Vehicle parking in private streets is subject to local. ordinances and Community Association regulations. Please refer to Section 2.4 of the Master Declaration for further restrictions concerning parking of vehicles within the Community. -4- 2544-33233WLP4281D1SCLSR% 581357.9 MAI BUILDING SETBACKS Construction of Improvements in the yard of any Lot or Condominium such as pools, spas, patio covers, BBQ, fountains, trellises, and water features are subject to minimum setback and height restrictions and may not be permitted You should refer to the Community Association Governing Documents and applicable City ordinances for any restrictions concerning the construction of any Improvements to your Lot or Condominium. PHASED CONSTRUCTION AND SALES ACTIVITY Phased Construction and sales activities will be occurring within and in the vicinity of the Community. Sales activity will increase the vehicle and pedestrian traffic within the Community. This may result in inconvenience to residents in the Community, due to increased light, noise and dust from the construction activities and the operation of the model homes and sales office. As a result of construction and sales activities, public and private utilities (water, electrical, cable television, sewers, storm drain, etc.) within the Community, and/or servicing your Home, may be temporarily interrupted and/or adversely affected. You agree to exercise extreme caution and to observe all signs while driving through construction areas and to observe the temporary closure of streets and the rerouting of traffic. SCHOOLS The Community is currently located in the Tustin Unified School District, telephone: (714) 730- 7301 (the "School District'). To obtain further information about the schools serving the Community, including transportation to and from the schools, please contact the School District. You should ipvestigate this matter to your satisfaction prior to purchasing a Lot or Condominium in the Community. FUTURE FIRE STATION SITE The Community is located adjacent to a future fire station site at the corner of Edinger Avenue and West Connector Road. The fine station will operate twenty-four (24) hours a day and seven (7) days a week. Residents in the vicinity of the fire station will notice noise, sirens, light, glare and other impacts from the operation of the fire, station and emergency vehicles. You are advised that Master Developer has no control over the operation or use of the fire station. You should evaluate the impact of the fire station on your decision to purchase a Lot or Condominium in the Community. SALE AND OWNERSHIP PER MCAS TUSTIN SPECIFIC PLAN Development within the Community is approved for sale and ownership tenure only in accordance with Chapter 3.9.3J5 of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan. ENVIRONMENTAL CONDITION The Community is Iocated on a portion of the former Marine Corps Air Station Tustin ("MCAS Tustin') that the United States Government once owned and operated. Certain Lots within the Community are located in areas that were previously used by the U.S. Government to store and wash vehicles and equipment that were used at WAS Tustin. These areas arc designated;1357.9 - -5- 2544-33253\CLP4291D1SCLS 6/3108 13S" and "IRP -13W' on the final subdivision map that was recorded for the Community and are depicted in Exhibit B attached hereto ("Release Areas'l. As a result of these activities, hazardous substances have been released into the groundwater underlying the portions of the Release Areas. Volatile Organic Compounds ("VOC"s), including trichloroetheleyne ("TCB) and 1,2,3 Trichloropropane (11,2,3 TCP'), were found in groundwater at concentrations that could result in adverse effect to human health if this water was extracted from the ground and directly used for domestic purposes such as drinking or bathing. However, groundwater at this location is currently not used for such purposes. Extensive documentation has been prepared that describes the nature and extent of the release of hazardous substances that has occurred at the Release Area and past and ongoing remediation efforts. The following reports are available for public review at either (1) BRACS Environmental Coordinator's Office, Library Building 307, MCAS El Toro, telephone (949) 726-5398 or (2) University of California at Irvine Langson Library, Government Publication Department, Irvine, CA, (949) 8247362 or (949) 824-6836: • Draft Feasibility Study Report For Operable Unit 4B, Former Marine Corps Air Station, Tustin, California, August 2005, Bechtel Environmental, Inc., August 2005. • Final Record of Decision/Remedial Action Plan Operable Unit IA, Former Marine Corps Air Station Tustin, California, Department of Navy, October 2004. • Final Feasibility Study Report, OU -1A, Marine Corps Air Station, Tustin, California, Bechtel Environmental, Inc., August 2003. • Final Environmental Impact Statement/Environmental Impact Report, Disposal and Reuse of MCAS Tustin, California, Department'of Navy and City of Tustin, December, 1999. Each building that is located within the Release Area, depicted on Exhibit B attached hereto, is protected with a vapor control barrier and contains a vapor ventilation system. Any activity that could result in the penetration or alteration of the floor slab of these buildings is subject to the review and approval by the City of Tustin building official and inspection by a qualified engineer. Deed restrictions may also be recorded on all or a portion of lots within the Release Areas that will limit certain activities on such lots. These deed restrictions will identify specific land use restrictions to prevent exposure of future landowners and/or users of the Release Areas to hazardous substances and to maintain the integrity of the remedial action until remediation is complete and remediation goals have been achieved. PROPOSED PARKS. A proposed Urban Regional Park and a proposed Community Park (collectively, the "Parks") may eventually be constructed southwest and west of the Community, respectively. If constructed, the Urban Regional Park will be maintained by the County of Orange and the Community Park will be maintained by the City of Tustin. The MCAS Tustin Specific Plan provides that the following uses may be included in the Urban Regional Park: animal shelter; arboretums and horticultural gardens; Children,. Youth and Family Resource Center; commercial recreation facilities; live performance -6- 2544.33233\CLPa28XDISCLS facility/amphitheater; .museum, cultural center, interpretive center and/or other educational and cultural facility, nature center with live animals; picnic areas; recreation facilities; regional law enforcement training classrooms; park, Regional A.rchaelogieal Curation Center, retail or service commercial uses (other than concessionaire commercial uses); riding and hiking trails and stage areas; sports lighting (where exterior lighting is designed to confine direct rays and, glare to the premises; and theatres. The MCAS Tustin Specific Plan further provides that the following uses may be included in the Community Park: ballfields, courts, playgrounds and other recreation facilities; civic, cultural and community center buildings; nature center with live animals; private recreational facilities; public park; sports field lighting (where lighting is designed to confine direct rays and glare to the premises). Master Developer makes no guarantee that either Park will be constructed, or, if constructed, that it will include any or all of the facilities described in the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan. Residents in the Community can experience increased noise, traffic and glare of lights from activities within the Parks, if constructed. Owners acknowledge that Master Developer and the Master Association have no control over the use, maintenance or care of the Parks, if constructed. By signing below you acknowledge you have received and understand this Notification, and you agree to purchase a Home in the Community subject to it terms. Date: Buyet Signature Name Name Name -7- 2544-33253�W42MI)I5CI.SR\ 581357.9 6/3/08 mv EXHIBIT A DEPICTION OF SENSITWE RECEPTORS 2544-332531CLP4281DWUR% 581357.9 6/3= 11 F'I EXHIBIT B DEPICTION OF RELEASE AREAS 2544-33253\\CLP428\DISCLSR\ 581357.9 650 _0000iloo efl���fla QG© �o 1101 Eo j"Ina 0 o�o�o fo\o �u©oa- Ila - 13 �' �.i� WIN all: am ■ W A-0 ■r:s70 L _ C- ATTACHMENT G �� Meta Housing Corporation Portfolio t t E '{a 7 R $- r: t, 6 , j f� 1 s rc.�.n (_ ._ -� � � ^�� 1"" ., S t � � S� v� :`�.\` Meta Housing Corporation meta\me'-ta�pref. Used with the name of a discipline to designate a new but related discipline designed to deal critically with the original one For nearly 40 years, the team at Meta Housing Corporation has 1)een dedicated to designing and developing exceptional communities for families and seniors across Southern California. As one of the region's most respected, trusted and honored development experts, Meta Housing's mission is to provide the highest quality of life for residents, a process that begins at the inception of each community and continues even after each is completed. Fresh, innovative design concepts; thoughtful amenities, features and spaces designed into each community; and on-site prograris and services all combine to enhance residents' experiences and broaden their opportunities. In addition, Meta Housing is constantly anticipating and exploring new resident needs and expectations as we move through the 21st century, planning and working to meet those needs. As a developer and operator of affordable, family and senior apartment communities throughout Southern California, Meta Housing has accomplished numerous "first achievements" beginning with Valley Village Senior Apartments, the first Southern California project "out of the ground" utilizing state earthquake funding following the 1994 Northridge earthquake. Meta Housing's innovative developments have consistently won national recognition such as the National Association of Home Builders' S0+ Housing Gold Achievement award, PCBC Gold Nugget Award and the SAGE Award. The National Endowment for the Arts has recognized Meta's Burbank Senior Artists Colony as one of the finest examples of incorporation of services, education and activities with architecture. Other award winning developments include The Piedmont Senior Apartments in North Hollywood, its sister development, Park Plaza, The Jasmine at Founders Village, Dorado Senior Apartments in Buena Park, CA, Cortina D'Arroyo in Arroyo Grande, CA, and "The Grove" in Garden Grove, CA. At the same time Meta Housing focuses on quality -of -life issues, we also draw on our team's knowledge of fundamental real estate principles and bottom-line business acumen... a combination that has made us an ideal partner for cities, housing agencies, nonprofits and other developers throughout the region. Our recognized expertise extends across every aspect of the development spectrum. The result? More than 12,000 units delivered by Meta or affiliates since 1976, with hundreds more being planned and built each year. Meta Housing communities have received many of the industry's most coveted national, regional and local awards for design excellence and innovation — a testimony to our commitment and experience. k John M. Huskey President John Huskey is President of Meta Housing Corporation and has successfully pioneered cooperative development among non-profit and for- profit enterprises. Mr. Huskey has been active in the financing, development, construction and management of affordable, family and senior apartment communities since 1969 and has been responsible for the creation of more than 12,000 housing units. Mr. Huskey currently serves on the City of Los Angeles Mixed Income Policy committee under the direction of Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa. In 1996, Mr. Huskey received the Building Industry Association Senior Housing Council as its SAGE award winner for outstanding contributions to senior housing. A frequent speaker, writer and guest lecturer on development and transportation issues at UCLA, USC, Pepperdine University as well as industry groups, Mr. Huskey has served as a technical advisor to the Los Angeles County Housing Authority as well as San Bernardino County. He also served two terms on the Loan and Grant. Committee for the State of California Department of Housing and Community Development. He was an appointee of Mayor James Hahn to the $100 Million Housing Trust Fund Advisory Committee. Previously, Mr. Huskey was President and Chief Executive Officer of Calmark Properties Inc. a nationally recognized builder/developer/operator of residential and commercial properties and a leading producer of affordable non -federally subsidized rental housing for seniors. Under his direction, Mr. Huskey helped create the independent senior housing category with the acclaimed Heritage Park program of apartment communities for active, seniors. More than 6,000 units were built. John Huskey attended the University of Notre Dame and Sophia University in Tokyo. George Russo Chief Financia/ Officer George Russo has been working for Meta Housing Corporation as a consultant since 2003 and officially joined Meta in May 2005. His responsibilities include all aspects of financial, tax and asset management reporting for Meta Housing and its family of affiliated partnerships, limited liability companies and corporations. Russo also oversees relationships with lenders and other financial partners and stakeholders. Russo brings to Meta a broad background spanning 24 years in real estate finance, accounting, and taxation. Prior to joining Meta, he s served as controller of StorageWorld, L.P. In addition he has served as Controller of Kaufman & Broad Multi -Housing Group and Division Controller of Public Storage Inc. Russo earned a Bachelor of Science degree in Business Administration and Accounting from California State University, Los Angeles and holds an NASD Series 28 Registration. k Kasey Burke Senior Vice President k,_� Mr. Burke is responsible for managing all facets of the development process for Meta Housing Corporation's Affordable Housing Division. Since joining the firm in 2001, he has managed significant projects in the areas of site acquisition, entitlement processing, financing, design development, construction, and lease -up. Mr. Burke specializes in securing funds from federal, state and municipal sources and oversees all of Meta Housing's tax credit and bond application processes. These include 9% and 4% federal low-income housing tax credits (CTCAC), bond allocations from the California Debt Limit Allocation Committee (CDLA(,), State of California Multifamily Housing Program (MHP), Federal Home Loan Bank Affordable Housing Program (AHP), Los Angeles Housing Department (LAHD), City of Los Angeles Community Redevelopment Agency (CRA), Housing Authority City of Industry Funds (Industry Funds) and all other local and municipal sources. Mr. Burke graduated from the University of Southern California with an emphasis in Real Estate Finance. Additionally Mr. Burke is a licensed Real Estate Broker with the State of California. Shaun C. Bradley Director ofAcquisilions Mr. Bradley is Director of Acquisitions for Meta Housing Corporation. In this capacity he is responsible for the organization and structure of Meta's conventional age -qualified platform including: identification, acquisition, asset management and disposition of the firm's investments. Mr. Bradley's background includes experience in virtually all facets of the Multi -family industry with over $250 Million in transactions. Prior to Meta, Mr. Bradley pursued development and investment opportunities for a large privately held age -qualified housing developer where he was instrumental in the achievements of the firms first and second funds. Preceding his venture into age -qualified housing, Mr. Bradley held acquisition and development positions for a national affordable housing company utilizing bond/tax credit financing, a regional multi -family owner/operator and started his career with a Los Angeles based brokerage firm. Mr. Bradley is a graduate of Gonzaga University 0 0 • 01 "a C p cn i E > Cc C. J C 'Co CDR 0 4- a oQ CL o c cv Q o0 U o � LVA}—�' � �>► L ca 0 v o >%U 0 4-a0 0 >+ ' V L 'p 0 = 5 c U cn ocn-'-' 0' W cn E c o 0 -J E� o � w ccoo cu o U U L 0 E 0 S >,cn 0 �E C -� c O '�- co 0 L 0 .. 0 _� c U E V c 5 Q ca cn 0 c 'c 0 c' N 0 i ccoo m > coo 0) 0 Q mQ- Z.:) I— :3 a.UUQQJOOf coC C N aO O cu r- � O CL Q �o . . I E U .0 Q O 0 � � O O � N cn O v +� L 0 0 0 co CD ocu E J �U ca ca = Ccn O O co N N V" cu L N C L U U C c� o> O LO p. � N cn N X 0 0 0 >, C Ca co .O O CL co Z Z >- D 0 U w m V♦ M cn 0 (n M CL c NImil, O N 0 N L- � DO M N °D U a C7 0 _ Uca V♦ M cn 0 (n M CL c cu �U c 0 O E cu a N L U N cn cn C O m N a� CD Q 0 0 4-0 5 C: cu0 Cfl O co O N N C U o � CO) 4-0 ° a' 0 0 o a o- 'c co J -0v s o c o O ma) L 0 O LO 'C mp. V - Z Z a- co � !� cu �U c 0 O E cu a N L U N cn cn C O m N a� CD Q 0 0 4-0 5 C: cu0 E _m U O � a0 _ Cl) C, O .O ti C N O ON O O i..� O .L Q N c U O U LL CO -0 L �' O L cu w O >% _N U - m E O .O CU O a) L �- c O �0 C L cp \ O O co cu U V L U- 4- cu Irl,c L N t/1 c to O Q O Q c 0) CU CL (D — L � >% ti O O O >, c co ca O ±:!O O I— -- U- Z }- I— D a.3:UU0Uu- � o U fl. cn > E r_ cc U co W L m N Mccn L W U 0 a Uc CL m L cu Ca U c U U C _O O U Cl) Q N � c 0 Q O N � LO 0 N Mccn L W U 0 a Uc CL m L cu Ca U c U U ,.,now"' L- 0 O O CO C O > M CO � 0) Q 0 U N O Ca -C r O -p c bc (oj LCU E o a C7 .O o u) cu = Z >, U U ai o a o C CL U QN Q Z >- H w C V Q O CO CD C O O N Q L 0 > C Q U o -a 0 L 'c Cl)ca o c�0 0 0 o _� U) N N ccoo a co C � m = U 0 Z o.o 0 U L a)�r- >- 'a N H n o :D L ami L C co CL C N E cn C C E E U cu •L co CD ° �U 0 cu L 0 AW L cu a. c M� W 0 Am CL Q Y C co m cc 0 CM J C 00 0 U Ui cn C 0 :0.-0 0 U) cn o. _ cn 0 0 cn = E Z N v a H U a d�k C ' c� G cu a -0 in M coo o rn Uco L > O -0M cu 0 "2 to N T- > O cu C� O co c �.• c cu � N v a H U a d�k U) c a� E ca QN Q cu P.- 0 0 C U) C Q U O c U E W Cl) c _p Q)_E CO a) O U N > U U LO CU Ccu N CO U C a"' CD �U OJ to 'O Q � J a) > N a) N E Q CU m 0 C QN cca- Q CD Q O > Q Fn LV =_� .0 Z OJ= cr V p N p N W z TUU dao �cc ��Vv�o .cu O O aj a0LQ(� .4" C 3 'O Q V- .— �, CO U rn a. Z D H D CL () o-jw w C �- Q O ca >Co N 5 O CD Q CD .0 (� td j m N to v ON O O Z C V c C Z o 'C a) Cl)L a0oo Vj "a J C Y co m O Ccu cn O > Z��Z) d c coO coo A ti a) 'O v O N ' -0 a� N 4-0L C U 'a'cv c U �- - 213 (D �- cu >E a 0 U— U 0 Z �, CD >- o �� F- cu a c o o U CD Q � o o 'c a)co � Tt E �- O a� 0 c O coCD O 0 c� c 0 O u U C � N 0) N Q E c co N E N _ O CD LO CD cu CD �(n Y. C a r N t6 -p :3 c (/) cn v 0) cu U ' o CD ry u U (n 0 o a) T cu >% � C c rn CO � � :3U � � � c Z � U E Q cd 0 N Cj cn c cn c 0 0 c LO co >°', . c coo 0 0 > > F- a.: U. Q r- >% o T co _ U O cn > U CO)Q cu � 00 c ca o o -v U .o a N tQ _ O � CC O . N co N C O ti U U c O °O zz � Z a A C O C J Icu - U o o An o) CU M •L o o �CD L �CU C m O c O m m CN J J M d�k C J Icu - d�k Awards 2009 Adams & Central Mixed Use Development Gold Nugget Winni;ig Category - Outstanding On -The -Boards Apartment Pi oject - Merit Award NoHo Senior Artists Colony PCBC: Gold Nugget Winning Category - Outstanding On -The -Boards Seniors Community - Merit Award NoHo Senior Artists Colony 50+ Housing Awards - Best of the 50+ Housing Awards Program - Gold Achievement Award for Multifamily Housing Overall Market Rate Rental Community On -The -Boards 2008 Garden Grove "The Grove" Senior Apartments 50+Housing Awards - Multifamily Housing: Overall Community - Gold Award Winner 2007 Garden Grove "The Grove" Senior Apartments 50+Builder Magazine named "Project of the Year" - December 2007 Garden Grove "The Grove" Senior Apartments 50+ Housing Council - Certificate of Merit - Finalist - Project of the Year Cortina D'Arroyo NAHB's Best of 50+ Housing Gold Achievement Award - Overall Community NAHB's Best of 50+ Housing Gold Achievement Award - Common Area Interior Design Dorado Senior Apartments 50+ Housing Council - Project of the Year NAHB's Pillars of the Industry Awards - Most Creative Financing of an Affordable Apartment Community NAHB's Best of 50+ Housing Silver Achievement Award - Overall Community NAHB's Best of 50+ Housing Silver Achievement Award - Common Area Interior Design Burbank Senior Artists Colony NAHB's Pillars of the Industry Awards - Best Clubhouse at a Multifamily Community 2006 Burbank Senior Artists Colony NAHB's Gold Award - Clubhouses - Small (Up to 6,000 sq. ft.) NAHB's Gold Award - Multifamily Housing: Overall Community - Rental Apartments NAHB's Silver Award - Active Adult Housing: Condominium Community (Any Size) National Endowment for the Arts: Creativity and Aging - Best Practices 2005 Burbank Senior Artists Colony - SAGE Awards - Project of the Year The Jasmine at Founders Village - NAHB's Silver Achievement Award - Best Rental Apartments k14qWW 2004 The Jasmine at Founders Village - SAGE Award Certificate of Merit - Project of the Year The Piedmont - NAHB's Platinum Achievement Award- Active Adult Housing Overall Community - Small NAHB's Gold Achievement Award - Multifamily Housing Overall Community - Rental Apartments NAHB's Juror's Innovation Award San Fernando Valley Business Journal's Award for "Most Innovative Senior Community" 2003 Burbank Senior Artists Colony - NAHB/NCOSH Gold Medal for Best of Senior's Housing Design - On the Boards The Piedmont - PCBC - Gold Nugget Award of Merit - Best Apartment Project - 4 or more Stories PCBC - Award of Merit - Best of Seniors Project - Active Adult 2002 Park Plaza - NAHB's Gold Achievement Award - Best Seniors Housing, Most Outstanding Affordable Senior Apartment Project KIIII Park Plaza - PCBC - Award of Merit (Gold Nugget Awards) - Best Senior Project - Active Adult SHC - SAGE Award of Merit ATTACHMENT H Planning Commission Resolution Nos. 4134, 4136, and 4137 RESOLUTION NO. 4134 A RESOLUTION OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF TUSTIN RECOMMENDING THAT THE CITY COUNCIL APPROVE DESIGN REVIEW 09-024 AND CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT 09-024, AUTHORIZING THE DEVELOPMENT OF A 240 -UNIT SENIOR APARTMENT RESIDENTIAL COMPLEX (AGE RESTRICTED TO PERSONS OF 55 YEARS OR OLDER) INCLUDING 153 AFFORDABLE UNITS, WITH A PARKING STANDARD OF 1.7 SPACES PER UNIT, RECREATION CENTER, AND ASSOCIATED INFRASTRUCTURE AND SITE IMPROVEMENTS ON LOT 265 OF TRACT 16581 WITHIN PLANNING AREA 4 AND PLANNING AREA 5 OF THE MCAS TUSTIN SPECIFIC PLAN, ALSO REFERRED TO AS COVENTRY COURT IN COLUMBUS SQUARE AT TUSTIN LEGACY The Planning Commission of the City of Tustin does hereby resolve as follows: 1. The Planning Commission finds and determines as follows: A. That a proper application for Design Review 09-024 and Conditional Use Permit 09-024, Amendment to Tract Map 16581 and Amendment to Concept Plan 03-003 was submitted by Lennar Corporation for the development of a 240 -unit senior apartment housing project for rental tenure on a nine (9) acre site within Columbus Square within Planning Area 4 and Planning Area 5 of the MCAS -Tustin Specific Plan (Lot 265 of Tract 16581); B. That the site is located in the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan land use designation of the General Plan, which provides for residential development, and on Reuse Disposition Parcels 23 and 24 in Planning Areas 4 and 5 of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan, which is designated for low and medium density residential; C. That a public hearing on the matter was duly called, noticed, and held for said application on December 8, 2009, by the Planning Commission; D. That the Planning Commission continued the project to the January 26, 2010, meeting to allow the project proponent to meet directly with the Community Association and any interested members of the community; E. That the project proponents attended the December 16, 2009, meeting of the Columbus Square Community Association; F. That the site is located within Tract 16581 previously approved by City Council Resolution No. 05-40 and Concept Plan 03-003 approved by Planning Commission Resolution No. 3951 for subdivision of 105.5 acres within Planning Areas 4 and 5 of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan for the purpose of developing 1,075 residential units including 240 senior housing PC Resolution No. 4134 DR 09-024 and CUP 09-024 Page 2 units for ownership tenure of which 153 units are designate as affordable units; G. That pursuant to Condition 2.2 of Resolution No. 05-40 approving TTM 16581, a Conditional Use Permit is required to permit a reduction in the number of on-site parking spaces from the required 2.25 spaces per unit to 1.7 spaces per unit. Conditional Use Permit 05-037 was approved in conjunction with Design Review 05-019, authorizing a parking standard of 1.7 spaces per unit for the senior condominium development; H. That the senior housing project was originally approved by Planning Commission Resolution No. 4014 as Design Review 05-019 and Conditional Use Permit 05-037 authorizing development of 240 age -restricted senior housing units for ownership tenure and a parking ratio of 1.7 spaces per unit; I. That pursuant to Condition 1.2 of Resolution No. 4014, permits must be obtained and substantial construction underway within 24 months; J. That some building permits were applied for, approved, and issued; and one (1) ten -unit building was constructed but the developer chose not to obtain additional permits or continue construction at Coventry Court; K. That since development at Coventry Court was discontinued, Design Review 05-019 and Conditional Use Permit 05-037 for Coventry Court are considered null; L. That the submitted plans are consistent with the plans that were previously approved by the Planning Commission and Community Development Department except for tenure type which is proposed to change from ownership to rental. Pursuant to Sections 3.4.2.A and 3.4.5.A of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan, development in Planning Area 4 and 5 of apartments is a discretionary action requiring approval of a conditional use permit; M. That new applications (DR 09-024, CUP 09-024, and Amendments to TM 16581 and CP 03-003) for continued development of the project and change in tenure type from ownership to rental are proposed; N. That although a new Design Review application is required for the subject project, all applicable conditions from City Council Resolution Nos. 05-40 for approval of Tentative Tract Map 16581 and 06-17 for approval of Final Tract Map 16581 remain applicable to DR 09-024; O. That the City's Traffic Engineer re -reviewed the parking demand analysis approved under CUP 05-037 in conjunction with the proposed project for the development of 240 senior rental apartments and determined that the difference PC Resolution No. 4134 DR 09-024 and CUP 09-024 Page 3 in parking demand between a senior condominium (for sale) and senior apartment (for lease) project would be negligible. Accordingly, the parking ratio of 1.7 spaces per unit approved under CUP 05-037 remains valid and applicable to the subject project (CUP 09-024); P. That pursuant to the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan and Section 9272 of the Tustin City Code, the location, size, architectural features, and general appearance of the proposed development will not impair the orderly and harmonious development of the area, the present or future development therein, or the occupancy as a whole, in that: 1. The proposed senior residential apartment development is a permitted use in Planning Areas 4 and 5 of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan, subject to approval of a conditional use permit, 2. As conditioned, the proposed project is consistent with the development standards and design guidelines of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan, 3. As conditioned, conformance with all other applicable development standards, including current California building codes, will be verified by staff during plan check review, 4. The proposed site and building improvements are substantially consistent with plans previously approved by the Planning Commission and Community Development Department, 5. The location, size, architectural features and general appearance of the proposed development are consistent with and will not impair the orderly and harmonious development of the area, the present or future development therein, the occupancy thereof, or the community as a whole. In making such findings, the Commission has considered at least the following items: a) Height, bulk, and area of buildings. b) Setbacks and site planning. c) Exterior materials and colors. d) Type and pitch of roofs. e) Size and spacing of windows, doors, and other openings. f) Towers, chimneys, roof structures, flagpoles, radio and television antennae. g) Location, height, and standards of exterior illumination. h) Landscaping, parking area design, and traffic circulation. i) Location and appearance of equipment located outside an enclosed structure. j) Location and method of refuse storage. k) Physical relationship of proposed structures to existing structures in PC Resolution No. 4134 DR 09-024 and CUP 09-024 Page 4 the neighborhood. 1) Appearance and design relationship of proposed structures to existing structures and possible future structures in the neighborhood and public thoroughfares. m) Proposed signage. n) Development Guidelines and criteria as adopted by the City Council. Q. That pursuant to Tustin City Code Section 9291, the proposed senior apartment housing development with a parking ratio of 1.7 spaces per unit will not be detrimental to the health, safety, morals, comfort, or general welfare of the persons residing or working in the neighborhood, nor be injurious or detrimental to the property and improvements in the neighborhood of the subject property, or to the general welfare of the City of Tustin, in that: 1. Multi -family residential apartment housing is a permitted use in Planning Areas 4 and 5 of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan, subject to approval of a conditional use permit; 2. The 240 -unit senior apartment project is in conformance with the MCAS Specific Plan, including the limitation of rental units to a maximum 25 percent of the total number of units permitted in the Tustin portion of the Specific Plan; 3. The change from ownership to rental tenure will not result in a change in the design, operational characteristics, or intent of the project as previously considered and approved; 4. The aging and elderly are identified in the Housing Element of the City's General Plan as a growing special needs population in the City. The Housing Element identified Coventry Court as an implementation project to meet the City's housing projections and goals; 5. The project as proposed remains an age -restricted senior project and will benefit the target population as originally intended; 6. The 153 affordable housing units will be provided just as originally approved in terms of number, location, size, bedroom counts and income level, in conformance with the approved Housing Agreement and Affordable Housing Plan for Columbus Square; 7. Approval of the project for rental tenure will allow for the project to progress and deliver the affordable housing units to the market in a more timely manner and in conformance with the requirement for reasonable proportionality in development of market -rate and affordable housing units; 8. A parking demand analysis utilizing a parking ratio of 1.7 spaces per unit PC Resolution No. 4134 DR 09-024 and CUP 09-024 Page 5 was previously approved for senior condominiums as CUP 05-037 by Resolution No. 4014, has been re -reviewed by the City's Traffic Engineer in conjunction with the subject project, and has been determined to be satisfactory, adequate and applicable to the project as proposed for senior apartments. R. That the subdivision of 105.5 acres and development of 1,075 residential units at the Columbus Square site, including 240 multiple family attached senior housing units for ownership tenure was. approved under Concept Plan (CP) 03- 003 by Planning Commission Resolution No. 3951, under Tentative Tract Map (TTM) 16581 by City Council Resolution No. 05-40, and Final Tract Map (FTM) 16581 by City Council Resolution No. 06-17. The project proposed as rental units necessitates text amendments to CP 03-003, and TTM 16581 and FTM 16581 to ensure consistency of the approved housing tenure type from ownership to rental senior units, and that the necessary amendments are determined to be consistent with the intent of the approved Concept Plan and Tract Map. S. That this project is determined to be exempt from additional CEQA review pursuant to California Government Code Section 65457, which provides that once the EIR has been certified and the specific plan adopted, any residential development project that is undertaken to implement and is consistent with the specific plan is exempt from additional CEQA review. On January 16, 2001, the City of Tustin certified the Program Final Environmental Impact Statement/Environmental Impact Report for the Reuse and Disposal of MCAS Tustin (FEIS/EIR), which evaluated the environmental impacts of the reuse and disposal of MCAS -Tustin, in conjunction with the adoption of a Specific Plan. On February 3, 2003, the Tustin City Council adopted Ordinance No. 1257, which adopted the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan. On April 3, 2006, the City Council adopted Resolution No. 06-43 approving an Addendum to the FEIS/EIR for the Disposal and Reuse of MCAS Tustin. The FEIS/EIR and its Addendum considered the potential environmental impacts associated with development on the former Marine Corps Air Station, Tustin. The development of Coventry Court at Columbus Square is a residential development project that is being undertaken to implement and is consistent with the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan, as amended. No substantial changes in the project or circumstances under which it is being undertaken have occurred and no new information which was not known at the time the EIR was certified (or amended) has become available. Therefore, the proposed project is exempt from additional environmental review under CEQA. II. The Planning Commission hereby recommends that the City Council approve PC Resolution No. 4134 DR 09-024 and CUP 09-024 Page 6 Design Review 09-024 and Conditional Use Permit 09-024 for development of a 240 -unit senior housing project age restricted for persons of 55 years or older for rental tenure utilizing a parking standard of 1.7 spaces per unit on Lot 265 of Tract 16581, including 153 affordable housing units, recreation center, and associated infrastructure and site improvements, subject to the conditions contained in Exhibit A attached hereto. PASSED AND ADOPTED at a regular meeting of the Tustin Planning Commission held on the 26th day of January, 2010. STEVE KOZAK Chairperson ELIZABETH A. BINSACK Planning Commission Secretary STATE OF CALIFORNIA ) COUNTY OF ORANGE ) CITY OF TUSTIN ) I, ELIZABETH A. BINSACK, the undersigned, hereby certify that I am the Planning Commission Secretary of the Planning Commission of the City of Tustin, California; that Resolution No. 4134 duly passed and adopted at a regular meeting of the Tustin Planning Commission, held on the 26h day of January, 2010. ELIZABETH A. BINSACK Planning Commission Secretary EXHIBIT A RESOLUTION NO. 4134 DESIGN REVIEW 09-024 AND CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT 09-024 CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL GENERAL (1) 1.1 The proposed project shall conform with the Tustin City Code and Tustin guidelines and standards and be consistent with submitted plans for the project date stamped January 26, 2010, on file with the Community Development Department, except as herein modified, or as modified by the Director of Community Development in accordance with this Exhibit. The Director of Community Development may also approve minor modifications to plans during plan check if such modifications are consistent with the provisions of the Tustin City Code, and other applicable codes. (1) 1.2 Unless otherwise specified, the conditions contained in this Exhibit shall be complied with as specified or prior to the issuance of any building permits for the project, subject to review and approval by the Community Development Department. (1) 1.3 The subject project approval shall become null and void unless permits for the proposed project are issued and substantial construction is underway within twelve (12) months. All time extensions may be considered if a written request is received within thirty (30) days prior to expiration date. (1) 1.4 Approval of Design Review 09-024, Conditional Use Permit 09-024, Amendment to Tract Map 16581, and Amendment to Concept Plan 03-003 is contingent upon the applicant retuming to the Community Development Department a notarized "Agreement to Conditions Imposed" form and the property owner signing and recording with the County Clerk -Recorder a notarized "Notice of Discretionary Permit Approval and Conditions of Approval' form. The forms shall be established by the Director of Community Development, and evidence of recordation shall be provided to the Community Development Department. SOURCE CODES (1) STANDARD CONDITION (5) RESPONSIBLE AGENCY REQUIREMENT (2) CEQA MITIGATION (6) LANDSCAPING GUIDELINES (3) UNIFORM BUILDING CODE/S (7) PC/CC POLICY (4) DESIGN REVIEW *** EXCEPTION PC Resolution No. 4134 DR 09-024 and CUP 09-024 Page 2 (1) 1.5 As a condition of approval of Design Review 09-024, Conditional Use Permit 09-024, Amendment to Tract Map 16581, and Amendment to Concept Plan 03-003, the applicant shall agree, at its sole cost and expense, to defend, indemnify, and hold harmless the City, its officers, employees, agents, and consultants, from any claim, action, or proceeding brought by a third party against the City, its officers, agents, and employees, which seeks to attack, set aside, challenge, void, or annul an approval of or conditions imposed by the City Council, the Planning Commission, or any other decision-making body, including staff, concerning this project. The City agrees to promptly notify the applicant of any such claim or action filed against the City and to fully cooperate in the defense of any such action. The City may, at its sole cost and expense, elect to participate in defense of any such action under this condition. (1) 1.6 Any violation of any of the conditions imposed is subject to issuance of an Administrative Citation pursuant to Tustin City Code Section 1162(a). (1) 1.7 The applicant shall be responsible for costs associated with any necessary code enforcement action, including attorney fees, subject to the applicable notice, hearing, and appeal process as established by the City Council by ordinance. (1) 1.8 The project approval is for 240 senior housing units age restricted to persons of 55 years or older for rental tenure utilizing a parking ratio of 1.7 spaces per unit, including 153 affordable units, recreation center, and infrastructure and site improvements. Any changes to the project description, scope, or affordable housing plan shall require further review and approval by the City. (***) 1.9 The subject project approval requires the approval and execution of an amendment to the Housing Agreement and Affordable Housing Plan by the City Council in form and content approved by the Redevelopment Agency, City Attorney, and City's Special Real Estate Counsel. The Amendment shall be approved and executed by all current parties to the Housing Agreement and all successors and assigns of each of the parties. Should amendments to the Housing Agreement and Affordable Housing Plan not be approved by the City Council, the subject approval shall become null and void. (***) 1.10 All applicable conditions of City Council Resolution Nos. 05-40 approving TTM 16581 density bonus, and affordable housing transfer and 06-17 approving FTM 16581, and Planning Commission Resolution No. 3953 approving DR 04-006 for the Columbus Square community shall remain applicable to Design Review 09-024, Conditional Use Permit 09-024, Amendment to Tract Map 16581, and Amendment to Concept Plan 03-003 as may be modified herein or in Planning Commission Resolution Nos. 4136 and/or 4137. PC Resolution No. 4134 DR 09-024 and CUP 09-024 Page 3 The senior apartment development is proposed to be developed strictly as a senior complex with parking concession of 1.7 parking ratio per unit. Accordingly the senior apartment development shall be restricted to seniors of 55 years or older for the life of the project. An age restricted covenant running with the land shall be reviewed and approved by the Community Development Director and shall be recorded by the applicant prior to issuance of a building permit. DESIGN REVIEW (4) 1.12 The applicant shall clearly demonstrate compliance with all applicable development standards of the MCAS Tustin Speck Plan and the Tustin City Code on construction drawings at the time of plan check submittal. (4) 1.13 Architecturally compatible roof screening shall be incorporated into the building design similar and comparable to the roof screens that have been provided at the constructed model building on site. Details of proposed roof screens shall be provided in the construction drawings at the time of plan check submittal. (4) 1.14 Production plans shall incorporate additional chimneys as necessary to be consistent with the approved conceptual roof plans. GRADING PLAN SUBMITTAL (1) 2.1 Four (4) sets of final grading plans, including a site plan, and consistent with the landscaping plans, as prepared by a registered civil engineer, shall be submitted and shall include the following: A. Technical details and plans for all utility installations including telephone, gas, water, and electricity. B. Three (3) copies of a precise soils report provided by a civil engineer and less than one (1) year old. Expanded information regarding the levels of hydrocarbons and ground water contamination found on-site shall be provided in the soil report. All pavement 11" values shall be in accordance with applicable City of Tustin standards. C. Information demonstrating that all site drainage shall be handled on-site and shall not be permitted to drain onto adjacent properties. D. Information demonstrating that drainage, vegetation, circulation, street sections, curbs, gutters, sidewalks, and storm drains shall comply with the City of Tustin's "Construction Standards for Private Streets, Storm Drain and On -Site Private Improvements," revised April 1989. E. Two (2) copies of a hydrology report. F. Information demonstrating that vehicle parking, primary entrance to the building, primary paths of travel, sanitary facilities, drinking fountain, and public telephones for the recreation building shall be PC Resolution No. 4134 DR 09-024 and CUP 09-024 Page 4 accessible to persons with disabilities. G. Building and landscape setback dimensions and dimensions for all drive aisles, back up areas, each covered parking stall, and open parking stalls. (1) 2.2 The engineer of record must submit a final compaction report to the Building Division for review and approval prior to the issuance of a building permit. (1) 2.3 The engineer of record must submit a pad certification to the Building Division for review and approval prior to the issuance of a building permit. (1) 2.4 Prior to issuance of a grading permit, the applicant shall be required to provide a performance bond to assure grading work is completed in accordance with approved plans. The engineer's estimated cost shall be submitted to the Building Official for determination of the bond amount. (1) 2.5 A note shall be provided on the final plans indicating that a six (6) foot high chain link fence shall be installed around the site prior to grading. A nylon fabric or mesh shall be attached to the temporary construction fencing. Gated entrances shall be permitted along the perimeter of the site for construction vehicles. t BUILDING PLAN SUBMITTAL (3) 3.1 At the time of building permit application, the plans shall comply with the latest applicable codes, City Ordinances, State, Federal laws, and regulations as adopted by the City Council of the City of Tustin. (3) 3.2 Building plan check submittal shall include the following: • Seven (7) sets of construction plans, including drawings for mechanical, plumbing, and electrical. • Structural calculations, two (2) copies. • Title 24 energy calculations, two (2) copies. • Elevations that include all proposed dimensions, materials, colors, finishes, and partial outlines of adjacent buildings on-site and off-site where applicable • Details for the proposed windows and doors. • Roofing material shall be fire rated class "B" or better. • The location of any utility vents or other equipment shall be provided on the roof plan. • Details of all proposed lighting fixtures and a photometric study showing the location .and anticipated pattern of light distribution of all proposed fixtures. All new light fixtures shall be consistent with the architecture of the building. All exterior lighting shall be designed and arranged as not to direct light or glare onto adjacent properties, including the adjacent streets. Wall- mounted fixtures shall be directed PC Resolution No. 4134 DR 09-024 and CUP 09-024 Page 5 at a 90 -degree angle directly toward the ground. All lighting shall be developed to provide a minimum of one (1) foot-candle of light coverage, in accordance with the City's Security Ordinance. • A note shall be provided on the plans that "All parking areas shall be illuminated with a minimum of one (1) foot-candle of light, and lighting shall not produce light, glare, or have a negative impact on adjacent properties." • Cross-section details showing the installation of the proposed rooftop equipment. Rooftop equipment shall be installed and maintained so as not to be visible from the public right-of-way. An elevation showing rooftop equipment installation related to the height of the parapet and proposed equipment must be identified at plan check submittal and all equipment must be six (6) inches below the top of the parapet, subject to the approval of the Community Development Director. • Noise attenuation features as required under the "Noise" section of this Resolution. • Note on plans that no field changes shall be made without prior approval from the Building Official and architect or engineer of record. (1) 3.3 Sufficiently sized concrete pad in front of mailbox structures shall be provided to allow mail carrier to place mail and homeowner to retrieve mail without standing in the street or landscape area. (3) 3.4 Vehicle parking, primary entrance to the pool and recreational building, the primary path of travel, sanitary facilities, drinking fountains, and public telephones shall be accessible to persons with disabilities as per State of California Accessibility Standards (Title 24). Parking for disabled persons shall be provided with an additional five (5) foot loading area with striping and ramp; disabled persons shall be able to park and access the building without passing behind another car. At least one (1) accessible space shall be van accessible served by a minimum 96 inch wide loading area. (3) 3.5 The clear and unobstructed interior garage dimensions for each parking space shall be a minimum of ten (10) feet in width and twenty (20) feet in length and shall be shown on the plans. (4) 3.6 Information to ensure compliance with requirements of the Orange County Fire Authority shall be submitted including fire flow and installation of fire hydrants subject to approval of the City of Tustin Public Works and/or Irvine Ranch Water District. (1) 3.7 If determined feasible by the Building Official, the applicant shall implement one or more of the following control measures, if not already required by the SCAQMD under Rule 403 during construction as follows: a) Apply water twice daily, or chemical soil stabilizers according to manufacturers' specifications, to all unpaved parking or staging areas or unpaved road surfaces at all actively disturbed sites. PC Resolution No. 4134 DR 09-024 and CUP 09-024 Page 6 b) Develop a construction traffic management plan that includes, but is not limited to, rerouting construction trucks off congested streets, consolidating truck deliveries, and providing dedicated turn lanes for movement of construction trucks and equipment on-site and off-site. c) Use electricity from power poles rather than temporary diesel or gasoline -powered generators. d) Reduce traffic speeds on all unpaved roads to 15 mph or less. e) Pave construction roads that have a traffic volume of more than 50 daily trips by construction equipment or 150 total daily trips for all vehicles. f) Apply approved chemical soil stabilizers according to manufacturers' specifications to all inactive construction areas (previously graded areas inactive for four days or more). g) Enclose, cover, water twice daily, or apply approved soil binders according to manufacturers' specifications to exposed piles of gravel, sand, or dirt. h) Cover all trucks hauling dirt, sand, soil, or other loose materials, 'and maintain at least two (2) feet of freeboard (i.e., minimum vertical distance between top of the load and top of the trailer). i) Sweep streets at the end of the day if visible soil material is carried over to adjacent roads (use water sweepers with reclaimed water when feasible). j) Install wheel washers where vehicles enter and exit unpaved roads onto paved roads or wash off trucks and any equipment leaving the site each trip. k) Use low VOC architectural coatings for all interior and exterior painting operations. PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT (1) 4.1 A separate 24 x 36" street improvement plan, as prepared by a California Registered Civil Engineer, shall be required for all construction within the public right-of-way along Edinger Avenue and West Connector Road. Construction and/or replacement of any missing or damaged public improvements will be required adjacent to this development. Said plan shall include, but not be limited to the following: a) Curb and Gutter b) Sidewalk c) Drive aprons d) Catch basin/storm drain laterals/ connection to existing storm drain PC Resolution No. 4134 DR 09-024 and CUP 09-024 Page 7 system e) Domestic water facilities f) Reclaimed water facilities g) Sanitary sewer facilities h) Underground utility connections In addition, a 24" x 36" reproducible construction area traffic control plan, as prepared by a California Registered Traffic Engineer or Civil Engineer experienced in this type of plan preparation may be required. (1) 4.2 Preparation of plans for and construction of: a. All sanitary sewer facilities shall be submitted as required by the City Engineer and Irvine Ranch Water District. b. A domestic water system shall be designed and installed to the standards of the Irvine Ranch Water District. The adequacy and reliability of the water system design and the distribution of fire hydrants shall be evaluated. The water distribution system and appurtenances shall also conform to the applicable laws and adopted regulations enforced by the Orange County Health Department. Any required reclaimed water system shall meet the standards as required by the Irvine Ranch Water District. (1) 4.3 The applicant shall comply and meet all conditions of Tract Map 16581. ..1' (1) 4.4 Prior to any work in the public right-of-way, an Encroachment Permit shall be obtained from and applicable fees paid to the Public Works Department. (1) 4.5 Any damage done to existing street improvements and utilities shall be repaired before issuance of a certificate of Occupancy. (1) 4.6 A complete hydrology study and hydraulic calculations shall be submitted for review and approval by the City. (1) 4.7 In addition to the normal full size map and plan submittal process, all final maps and development plans including, but not limited to: tract maps, parcel maps, right-of-way maps, records of survey, public works improvements, private infrastructure improvements, final grading plans, and site plans are also required to be submitted to the Public Works Department/Engineering Division in computer aided design and drafting (CADD) format. The standard file format is AutoCAD Release 2007, or latest version, having the extension "DWG." All layering and linotype conventions are AutoCAD -based (latest version available upon request from the Public Works Department). The CADD files shall be submitted to the City at the time the plans are approved and updated CADD files reflecting "as built" conditions shall be PC Resolution No. 4134 DR 09-024 and CUP 09-024 Page 8 submitted once will be released to the City. all construction has been completed. No project bonds until acceptable "as built" CADD files have been submitted (1) 4.8 Facility Solid Waste Collection and Recycling Plan a. Prior to approval of a site plan or the issuance of a building permit, whichever occurs first, a Facility Solid Waste Collection and Recycling Plan and a site plan covering the planned use o the facility shall be submitted utilizing the applicable from and approved by the City of Tustin Public Works Department. b. The applicant, property owner, and/or tenant(s) are required to participate in the City's recycling program. c. Waste and Recycling collection facilities shall be equally and readily accessible by the property owner(s) or tenant(s). d. Waste and Recycling collection facilities must be placed in a location that can be easily and safely accessed by the solid waste hauler which utilizing either front loader or side loading equipment. e. Adequate collection capability shall be provided to ensure that �. collection frequency shall not exceed four times per week for commercial customers. f. All trash enclosures shall utilize the City's standard enclosure designed to accommodate at least two (2) 4 -cubic yard bins, with at least one (1) bin reserved for recyclable materials. g. Prior to the issuance of a building permit, the Public Works Department shall review and approve the number of trash enclosures required to service the project site. (***) 4.9 Condition of approval 4.1 of Resolution 05-40 approving Tentative Tract Map16581, which is incorporated into this approval, requires that the applicant fund its Fair Share Contribution to the Tustin Legacy Backbone Infrastructure Program. The applicant shall fund and provide security for its Fair Share Contribution to the Tustin Legacy Backbone Infrastructure Program as required by Condition of approval 4.1 of Resolution 05-40, including its Fair Share Contribution of the cost estimates of the Tustin Legacy Backbone Infrastructure as adjusted by the Tustin City Council on April 3, 2006, and September 2, 2008, and subject to future increases in the Backbone Infrastructure Program costs and applicant's Fair Share Contribution thereto. PC Resolution No. 4134 DR 09-024 and CUP 09-024 Page 9 WATER QUALITY (1) 5.1 This development shall comply with all applicable provisions of the City of Tustin Water Quality Ordinance and all Federal, State and Regional Water Quality Control Board rules and regulations. (1) 5.2 An updated Water Quality Management Plan (WQMP) shall be submitted and approved prior to issuance of grading permit. The WQMP shall be prepared using the City's WQMP Guidelines. The applicant shall submit a deposit of $2,700.00 for the estimated cost for reviewing WQMP to the City. The actual costs will be deducted from the deposit, and the applicant shall be responsible for any additional review cost that exceeded the deposit prior to issuance of grading permits. Any unused portion of the deposit will be refunded to the applicant. CONSTRUCTION PHASING AND MODEL UNIT PLAN (1) 6.1 The developer shall close and convert the model units (constructed units) to occupancy within 90 days from the last unit rented. (1) 6.2 The applicant shall comply with the submitted phasing plan. LAN DSCAPING/HARDSCAPE r (1) 7.1 Submit at plan check complete detailed landscaping and irrigation plans for all landscaping areas, including the model complex, consistent with adopted City of Tustin Landscaping requirements. The plans shall include the following: ■ Include a summary table identifying plan materials. The plant table shall list botanical and common names, sizes, spacing, location, and quantity of the plant materials proposed. ■ Show planting and berming details, soil preparation, staking, etc. The irrigation plan shall show location and control of backflow prevention devices, pipe size, sprinkler type, spacing, and coverage. Details for all equipment must be provided. ■ Show all property lines on the landscaping and irrigation plans, public right-of-way areas, sidewalk widths, parkway areas, and wall locations. ■ The Community Development Department may request minor substitutions of plant materials or request additional sizing or quantity of materials during plan check. PC Resolution No. 4134 DR 09-024 and CUP 09-024 Page 10 ■ Add a note that coverage of landscaping and irrigation materials is subject to inspection at project completion by the Community Development Department. ■ Turf is unacceptable for grades over 25 percent. A combination of planting materials shall be used. On large areas, ground cover alone is not acceptable. ■ Shrubs shall be a minimum of five (5) gallon size and shall be placed a maximum of five (5) feet on center. ■ Fences, wall, and equipment areas shall be screened with walls, vines, and/or trees. ■ All plant materials shall be installed in a healthy vigorous condition typical to the species and shall be maintained in a neat and healthy condition. Maintenance includes, but is not limited to, trimming, weeding, removal of litter, fertilizing, regular watering, and replacement of diseased or dead plants. • Landscape adjacent to the right-of-way shall be in compliance with the requirements of MCAS Tustin Specific Plan. Perimeter walls should be treated with vines to relieve large expanse walls with greenery and color. Vines shall be informally grouped and installed with training devices. (4) 7.2 On-site walls and fences shall be noted on the plans with speck materials, colors, and decorative treatments. Interior wall/fences shall be made of durable materials subject to review and approval of the Community Development Department. PARKING (***) 8.1 The approved parking ratio of 1.7 parking spaces per unit is exclusive to the senior community and is contingent on the property remaining a senior housing complex for persons of 55 years and older. The project shall provide a minimum of 409 parking spaces including a minimum of 200 one -car garage spaces and 40 carports, 130 open guest parking stalls, 28 parallel street parking, 10 ADA accessible parking spaces and 1 ADA van accessible parking space. (***) 8.2 The applicant shall submit a Parking Management Plan for review and approval by the Community Development Department prior to issuance of any building permit. The Parking Management Plan shall include, but not be limited to, the following: • Of the 409 parking spaces, thirty-six (36) spaces (0.15 space per unit as recommended by the ULI Shared Parking Study) shall be set aside PC Resolution No. 4134 DR 09-024 and CUP 09-024 Page 11 for guests, six (6) spaces shall be set aside for employees and a maximum of 367 spaces shall be available for residents. In any event, the owner and/or operator of the facility shall not permit residents to own and maintain any more than a total of 367 vehicles on-site at any given time. These restrictions shall be incorporated in any lease and/or rental agreement. • The owner and/or operator of the facility shall ensure that required parking is provided to tenants, employees, and visitors such that off- site or surrounding properties parking are not negatively impacted. This could be accomplished using a decal systems, on-site security and/or manager parking enforcement, etc. • The owner and/or operator shall be responsible for monitoring and enforcing all parking and traffic regulations on the project site. • Any revision to the Parking Management Plan shall be reviewed and approved by the Community Development Department. (***) 8.3 If in the future the City determines that parking or traffic problems exist on the site or in the vicinity, the Community Development Director may require that the property owner prepare an analysis and bear all associated costs. If the study indicates that there is a parking or traffic impact, the applicant/property owner shall provide interim and permanent mitigation measures to alleviate the problem. RENTER NOTIFICATION (1) 9.1 The applicant shall submit to the Community Development Department for review and approval a renter notification document that includes the notifications listed below. The notification document shall be signed by each renter(s) prior to occupancy, and a copy of the signed notification shall be provided to the Community Development Department prior to final inspection and/or issuance of each Certificate of Occupancy. A. A notice for roadway, trail, and train noise that may impact the project, including roadway noise associated with, Edinger Avenue, North Loop Road, Kensington Park Drive, and train noise associated with the rail corridor north of the project. The notice shall indicate the current number of trains per day (59) and the estimated to increase to over 100 trains on a 24 hour basis by the year 2020. The notice shall indicate that additional building upgrades may be necessary for noise attenuation. This determination is to be made as architectural drawings become available and/or where field-testing determines inadequate noise insulation. B. A notice, to be reviewed by the City of Tustin and the Tustin Unified School District, regarding the location of existing and proposed elementary, middle, and high schools which will serve the subdivision (text and map) and advice to renters that proposed school sites may PC Resolution No. 4134 DR 09-024 and CUP 09-024 Page 12 never be constructed. C. A notice regarding units that are adjacent to aboveground utilities or structures (such as light standards and fire hydrants) identifying the type of structure and their locations. D. A notice indicating that any use of a residence for a business shall be subject to the City's Home Occupation Ordinance and may require zoning clearance and a business license. E. A notice indicating that public use of a minimum one (1) acre or more portion of the park site, to be maintained by the homeowners association, will be allowed and noting public ingress and egress through the subdivision will be provided for access to the park. F. A notice explaining the easements, facilities, amenities, and dedications that will be provided on lettered lots and indicating all on- site streets, alleys, paseos, and common areas are to be maintained by the homeowners association. G. A notice, to be approved by the City Attorney, indicating that neither the site, nor the project nor any part thereof any street or sidewalk, alleyway, or paseo thereon shall be privately gated, provided however that any swimming pool and/or spa facility within the common area and any indoor common area improvements, including any clubhouse and bathrooms, may be gated or locked and made available solely to residents of the project and their guests. H. A notice indicating that surrounding properties may be developed in accordance with City ordinances in a manner which may partially or totally obstruct views from the renter's unit and that the City of Tustin makes no claim, warranty, or guarantee that views from any unit will be preserved as development of surrounding properties occurs. I. A notice explaining that 153 affordable housing units will be dispersed throughout the project site. These units will remain affordable for a period of fifty-five (55) years or longer. J. A notice explaining the phasing of construction within the project site and surrounding subdivison and that activity may be disruptive. K. A notice that the project is located adjacent to a future fire station site at the southwest comer of Edinger Avenue and Kensington Park Drive and that the station will be operating 24 hours. ORANGE COUNTY FIRE AUTHORITY' PC Resolution No. 4134 DR 09-024 and CUP 09-024 Page 13 (5) 10.1 Prior to the issuance of any grading, the applicant shall submit a fire hydrant location plan to the Fire Chief for review and approval. (5) 10.2 Prior to the issuance of a building permit, the applicant shall submit evidence of the on-site fire hydrant system to the Fire Chief and indicate whether it is public or private. If the system is private, it shall be reviewed and approved by the Fire Chief prior to building permit issuance, and the applicant shall make provisions for the repair and maintenance of the system in a manner meeting the approval of the Fire Chief. Please contact the OCFA at (714) 573-6100 or visit the OCFA website for a copy of the "Guidelines for Private Fire Hydrant Wor Sprinkler Underground Piping." (5) 10.3 Prior to the issuance of any certificate of occupancy, all fire hydrants shall have a blue reflective pavement marker indicating the hydrant location on the street as approved by the Fire Chief, and must be maintained in good condition by the property owner. Please contact the OCFA at (714) 573- 6100 or visit the OCFA website for a copy of the "Guideline for Installation of Blue Dot Hydrant Markers." (5) 10.4 Prior to the issuance of any grading, the applicant shall provide evidence of adequate fire, flow. The "Orange County Fire Authority Water Availability for Fire Protection" form shall be signed by the applicable water district and submitted to the Fire Chief for approval. If sufficient water to meet fire flow requirements is not available an automatic fire extinguishing system may be required in each structure affected. (5) 10.5 Prior to the issuance of building permits, a note shall be placed on the plans stating that all residential structures (R-1 occupancies) and any structure exceeding 6,000 square feet (per amendment) shall be protected by an automatic fire sprinkler system in a manner meeting the approval of the Fire Chief. (5) 10.6 Prior to the issuance of a building permit, the applicant shall submit plans for any required automatic fire sprinkler system in any structure to the Fire Chief for review and approval. Please contact the OCFA at (714) 573- 6100 for additional information. (5) 10.7 Prior to the issuance of a certificate of occupancy, this system shall be operational in a manner meeting the approval of the Fire Chief. (5) 10.8 Prior to the issuance of any grading or building permits, the applicant shall obtain approval of the Fire Chief for all fire protection access roads to within 150 feet of all portions of the exterior of every structure on site. Please contact the OCFA at (714) 573-6100 or. visit the OCFA website to obtain a copy of the "Guidelines for Emergency Access, or Bulletin number 08-99, "Fire Department Access Requirements for A Single Family Residence." PC Resolution No. 4134 DR 09-024 and CUP 09-024 Page 14 (5) 10.9 Prior to the issuance of a precise grading permit or building permit, the applicant shall submit and obtain approval of the Fire Chief and City Staff of plans for all public or private access roads, streets and courts. The plans shall include plan and sectional views and indicate the grade and width of the access road measured flow -line to flow -line. When a dead- end street exceeds 150 feet or when otherwise required, a clearly marked fire apparatus access turnaround must be provided and approved by the Fire Chief. Applicable CC&R'S or other approved documents shall contain provisions which prohibit obstructions such as speed bumps/humps, control gates or other modifications within said easement or access road unless prior approval of the Fire Chief is granted. Please contact the OCFA at (714) 573-6100 or visit the OCFA website to obtain a copy of the "Guidelines for Emergency Access." (5) 10.10 A note shall be placed on the fire protection access easement plan indicating that all street/road signs shall be designed and maintained to be either internally or externally illuminated in a manner meeting approval of the Fire Chief. (5) 10.11 Prior to the issuance of any grading or building permits, the applicant shall submit plans and obtain approval from the Fire Chief for fire lanes on required fire access roads less than 36 feet in width. The plans shall t indicate the locations of red curbs and signage and include a detail of the proposed signage including the height, stroke and colors of the lettering and its contrasting background. Please contact the OCFA at (714) 573- 6100 or visit the OCFA website to obtain a copy of the "Guidelines for Emergency Access Roadways and Fire Lane Requirements," or Bulletin 06-99, "Fire Lane Requirements on Private & Public Streets Within Residential Developments." (5) 10.12 Prior to the issuance of any certificate of occupancy, the fire lanes shall be installed in accordance with the approved fire lane plan. The CC&R'S or other approved documents shall contain a fire lane map, provisions prohibiting parking in the fire lanes, and an enforcement method. (5) 10.13 Prior to the issuance of any grading permits, the applicant shall obtain the approval from the Fire Chief for the construction of any gate across required fire department access roads. Please contact the OCFA at (714) 573-6100 or visit the OCFA website to obtain a copy of the "Guidelines for Design and Installation of Emergency Access Gates and Barriers." (5) 10.14 Prior to the issuance of a building permit for combustible construction, the builder shall submit a letter on company letterhead stating that water for fire -fighting purposes and all-weather fire protection access roads shall be in place and operational before any combustible material is placed on site. Building permits will not be issued without OCFA approval obtained as a result of an on-site inspection. Please contact the OCFA at (714) 573- 6100 to obtain a copy of the standard combustible construction letter. PC Resolution No. 4134 DR 09-024 and CUP 09-024 Page 15 (5) 10.15 Prior to the issuance of a building permit, the applicant shall submit architectural plans for the review and approval of the Fire Chief if required per the "Orange County Fire Authority Plan Submittal Criteria Form." Please contact the OCFA at (714) 573-6100 for a copy of the Site/Architectural Notes to be placed on the plans prior to submittal. (5) 10.16 Prior to the issuance of a building permit, plans for the fire alarm system shall be submitted to the Fire Chief for review and approval. Please contact the OCFA at (714) 573-6100 or visit the OCFA website to obtain a copy of the "Guideline for New and Existing Fire Alarm Systems." (5) 10.17 This system shall be operational prior to the issuance of a certificate of occupancy. NOISE (1) 11.1 Noise attenuation measures as recommended by the noise analysis shall be included with the construction drawings for plan check, which ensure a minimum outdoor -indoor transmission class (OITC) of 37. The interior and exterior noise levels (including balconies of six feet in width) shall comply with City of Tustin noise requirements. (1) 11.2 In accordance with the noise analysis, all units are required to include air conditioning units or fresh air intake systems to achieve the minimum interior noise level standards shall have these units installed prior to issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy. Prior to final inspection and issuance of certificates of use and occupancy, the developer shall provide an independent noise analysis verifying that interior noise levels comply with Title 25 and City noise requirements. (1) 11.3 The perimeter sound walls are included as part of the master wall plans for Columbus Square currently under review. PUBLIC SAFETY (4) 12.1 Required lighting shall be installed so as not to be in conflict with landscaping and possible reduced lighting output. Evidence of such shall be shown on lighting and landscape plans at the time of plan check submittal. ENVIRONMENTAL (1) 13.1 Additional measures related to development of this project as noted in the adopted EIS/EIR including, but not limited to the following: A. Prior to issuance of a grading permit, the developer shall retain a County -certified archaeologist. If buried resources are found during grading within the reuse plan area, a qualified archaeologist would PC Resolution No. 4134 DR 09-024 and CUP 09-024 Page 16 need to assess the site significance and perform the appropriate mitigation. The Native American viewpoint shall be considered during this process. This could include testing or data recovery. Native American consultation shall also be initiated during this process. B. The developer shall comply with the requirements established in a Palentological Resource Management Plan (PRMP) prepared for the site, which details the methods to be used for surveillance of construction grading, assessing finds, and actions to be taken in the event that unique paleontological resources are found. C. Prior to the issuance of a grading permit, the applicant shall provide written evidence to the Community Development Department that a County -certified paleontologist has been retained to conduct salvage excavation of unique paleontological resources if they are found. D. Prior to issuance of any permit, the developer shall provide traffic operations and control plans that would minimize the traffic impacts of proposed construction activity. The plans shall address roadway and lane closures, truck hours and routes, and notification procedures for planned short-term or interim changes in traffic -New patterns. Such plans shall minimize anticipated delays at major intersections. Prior to approval, the City of Tustin or the City of Irvine, as applicable, shall review the proposed traffic control and operations plans with any affected jurisdiction. FEES (1)(5) 14.1 Prior to issuance of any building permits, payment shall be made of all applicable fees, including but not limited to, the following. Payment shall be required based upon those rates in effect at the time of payment and are subject to change. a. Building plan check and permit fees to the Community Development Department based on the most current schedule at the time of permit issuance. b. Engineering plan check and permit fees to the Public Works Department based on the most current schedule at the time of permit issuance. C. Orange County Fire Authority plan check and inspection fees to the Community Development Department based upon the most current schedule at the time of permit issuance. PC Resolution No. 4134 DR 09-024 and CUP 09-024 Page 17 d. Major Thoroughfare and Bridge Fees to the Tustin Public Works Department based 'on the most current schedule at the time of permit issuance. e. Transportation System Improvement Program (TSIP), Benefit Area "B" fees in the amount of $3.31 per square foot of new or added gross square floor area of construction or improvements to the Community Development Department. f. Water and sewer connection fees to the Irvine Ranch Water District. g. New development tax in the amount of $350.00 per unit, plus $100.00 per bedroom over one (1) bedroom in each unit. h. School facilities fee in the amount as required by Tustin Unified School District. i. Other applicable parkland in -lieu fees and Tustin Legacy Backbone Infrastructure Program fees as required by Resolution No. 05-40. (1) 14.2 Within forty-eight (48) hours of final approval of the project, the applicant shall deliver to the Community Development Department, a CASHIER'S CHECK payable to the County Clerk in the amount of fifty dollars ($50.00) to enable the City to file the appropriate environmental documentation for the project. If within such forty-eight (48) hour period that applicant * has not delivered to the Community Development Department the above -noted check, the statute of limitations for any interested party to challenge the environmental determination under the provisions of the California Environmental Quality Act could be significantly lengthened. RESOLUTION NO. 4136 A RESOLUTION OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION RECOMMENDING THAT THE CITY COUNCIL APPROVE AMENDMENT TO CONCEPT PLAN 03-003 TO REFLECT A CHANGE IN TENURE FROM OWNERSHIP TO RENTAL FOR THE PROPOSED 240 -UNIT AGE -RESTRICTED SENIOR HOUSING COMPLEX ON LOT 265 OF TRACT 16581 (COVENTRY COURT IN COLUMBUS SQUARE AT TUSTIN LEGACY) The Planning Commission of the City of Tustin does hereby resolve as follows: I. The Planning Commission finds and determines as follows: A. That a proper application for Design Review 09-024 and Conditional Use Permit 09-024, Amendment to Resolution No, 05-40 which approved Tract Map 16581 and Amendment to Resolution No, 3951 which approved Concept Plan 03-003 was submitted by Lennar Corporation for the development of a 240 -unit senior apartment housing project for rental tenure on a nine (9) acre site within Columbus Square within Planning Area 4 and Planning Area 5 of the MCAS -Tustin Specific Plan (Lot 265 of Tract 16581); B. That the site is located is located within Tract 16581 previously approved by City Council Resolution No. 05-40 in the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan land use designation of the General Plan, which provides for residential development, and on Reuse Disposition Parcels 23 and 24 in Planning Areas 4 and 5 of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan, which is designated for low and medium density residential; C. That a public hearing on the matter was duly called, noticed, and held for said application on December 8, 2009, by the Planning Commission; D. That the Planning Commission continued the project to the January 26, 2010, meeting to allow the project proponent to meet directly with the Community Association and any interested members of the community; E. That the project proponents attended the December 16, 2009, meeting of the Columbus Square Community Association; F. That on February 14, 2005, the Planning Commission adopted Resolution No. 3951 approving Concept Plan 03-003 to subdivide 105.5 acres for the purpose of developing 1,077 residential units including 84 Single Family Detached (SFD), 181 Carriage Way SFD, 72 Multiple Family Attached (senior housing - for ownership tenure) for a total of 337 units at an Resolution No. 4136 Amendment to Concept Plan 03-003 Page 2 average density of 8.62 du/acre in Planning Area 4 (Parcel 23) and 18 carriage way units, 552 Multiple Family Attached (MFR), 170 Multiple Family Attached (senior housing -- for ownership tenure) for a total of 740 units at an Average density 17.53 du/acre for Planning Area 5 (Parcel 24) of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan; G. That the submitted plans are consistent with the plans that were previously approved by the Planning Commission and Community Development Department except for tenure type which is proposed to change from ownership to rental; H. That the proposed project necessitates text amendments to Resolution 3951 which approved Concept Plan 03-003; That the amendment to Concept Plan 03-003 is in conformance with the Tustin Area General Plan and MCAS Tustin Specific Plan and approval of Concept Plan 03-003, subject to conditions contained in Resolution Nos. 4134 and 4137, would achieve the development concepts set forth by the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan, including: 1. Ensuring the continuity and adequacy of all circulation systems, such as: roadways, access points, trails, pedestrian ways, and other infrastructure systems needed to serve the project; 2. Ensuring the continuity and design quality of architecture, landscape, and hardscape themes and treatments; 3. Providing urban design features as per Chapters 2 and 3 of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan; 4. Ensuring conformity with the Non -Residential Land Use Trip Budget; and, 5. Ensuring compliance with all applicable provisions of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan. II. The Planning Commission hereby recommends that the City Council approve amendment to Concept Plan 03-003 to reflect a change in tenure from ownership to rental for the proposed 240 -unit age -restricted senior apartment housing project on a nine (9) acre site within Columbus Square within Planning Area 4 and Planning Area 5 of the MCAS -Tustin Specific Plan (Lot 265 of Tract 16581), subject to the conditions of approval attached hereto. Resolution No. 4136 Amendment to Concept Plan 03-003 Page 3 PASSED AND ADOPTED at a regular meeting of the Tustin Planning Commission held on the 26th day of January, 2010. STEVE KOZAK Chairperson ELIZABETH A. BINSACK Planning Commission Secretary STATE OF CALIFORNIA ) COUNTY OF ORANGE ) CITY OF TUSTIN ) I, ELIZABETH A. BINSACK, the undersigned, hereby certify that I am the Planning ( Commission Secretary of the Planning Commission of the City of Tustin, California; that Resolution No. 4136 was duly passed and adopted at a regular meeting of the Tustin Planning Commission, held on the 26th day January, 2010. ELIZABETH A. BINSACK Planning Commission Secretary (1) EXHIBIT A RESOLUTION NO. 4136 AMENDMENT TO CONCEPT PLAN 03-003 CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL 1.1 Concept Plan 03-003 is approved for development of 1,075 residential units in Planning Area 4 and Planning Area 5 as follows: Planning Area 4 (Parcel 23) 84 Single Family Detached (SFD) 181 Carriage Way SFD 72 Multiple Family Attached (Senior Housing) Total: 337 units Average density of 8.62 du/acre Planning Area 5 (Parcel 24) 18 Carriage Way units 552 Multiple Family Attached (MFR) 170 Multiple Family Attached (Senior Housing) Total: 740 units Average density 17.53 du/acre 1.2 The amendment to the approved concept plan and Regulatory Agreement is subject to execution of the First Amendment to the Housing Agreement in conformance with the requirements of the density bonus application as approved by the City Council, Condition 1.9 and 1.10 of Planning Commission Resolution No. 4134, and Condition 2.2 of Resolution No. 4137. (*) 1.3 Resolution No. 4136 shall become null and void in the event that Resolution Nos. 4134 approving Design Review 09-024 and Conditional Use Permit 09-024 and Resolution No. 4137 approving Amendment to the Tract Map 16581 are not approved by the City Council. (1) 1.4 Approval of Amendment to Concept Plan 03-003 shall be contingent upon all conditions of approval contained within Resolution Nos. 4134 and 4137. (***) 1.5 Condition of Approval 4.1 of Resolution No. 05-40 approving Tentative Tract Map16581, which is incorporated into this approval, requires that the applicant fund its Fair Share Contribution to the Tustin Legacy Backbone Infrastructure Program. The applicant shall fund and provide security for its Fair Share Contribution to the Tustin Legacy Backbone Infrastructure Program as required by Condition of Approval 4.1 of Resolution No. 05-40, including its Fair Share Contribution of the cost estimates of the Tustin Legacy Backbone Infrastructure as adjusted by the Tustin City Council on April 3, 2006 and September 2, 2008, and subject to future increases in the Backbone Infrastructure Program costs and applicant's Fair Share Contribution thereto. r RESOLUTION NO. 4137 t. A RESOLUTION OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF TUSTIN RECOMMENDING THAT THE CITY COUNCIL APPROVE AMENDMENT TO RESOLUTION NO. 05-40, WHICH APPROVED TENTATIVE TRACT MAP 16581, TO REFLECT A CHANGE IN TENURE FROM OWNERSHIP TO RENTAL FOR THE PROPOSED 240 - UNIT AGE -RESTRICTED SENIOR HOUSING COMPLEX ON LOT 265 OF TRACT 16581 (COVENTRY COURT IN COLUMBUS SQUARE AT TUSTIN LEGACY) The Planning Commission of the City of Tustin does hereby resolve as follows: I. The Planning Commission finds and determines as follows: A. That a proper application for Design Review 09-024 and Conditional Use Permit 09-024, Amendment to Resolution No. 05-40, which approved Tract Map 16581, and Amendment to Resolution No. 3951, which approved Concept Plan 03-003, was submitted by Lennar Corporation for the development of a 240 -unit senior apartment housing project for rental tenure on a nine (9) acre site within Columbus Square within Planning Area 4 and Planning Area 5 of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan (Lot 265 of Tract 16581); B. That the site is located in the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan land use designation of the General Plan, which provides for residential development, and on Reuse Disposition Parcels 23 and 24 in Planning Areas 4 and 5 of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan, which is designated for low and medium density residential uses; C. That a public hearing on the matter was duly called, noticed, and held for said application on December 8, 2009, by the Planning Commission; D. That the Planning Commission continued the project to the January 26, 2010, meeting to allow the project proponent to meet directly with the Community Association and any interested members of the community; E. That the project proponents attended the December 16, 2009, meeting of the Columbus Square Community Association; F. That the site is located within Tract 16581 previously approved by City Council Resolution Nos. 05-40 and 06-17 for subdivision of 105.5 acres within Planning Areas 4 and 5 of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan for the purpose of developing 1,075 residential units including 240 senior housing units for ownership tenure; Resolution No. 4137 Amendment to TTM 16581 Page 2 G. That the applicant submitted a request to allow a change in tenure from ownership to rental for the proposed 240 -unit age restricted senior housing complex; H. That the request is consistent with the previously -approved project and the text changes are for consistency purposes and do not constitute a significant change from the intent of the original approvals; 1. That the proposed project necessitates text amendments to Resolution No. 05-40 which approved Tentative Tract Map 16581; J. That pursuant to the previously -approved Tract Map 16581, density bonus, and transfer of affordable housing units for Columbus Square, the Columbus Square Housing Agreement, and the Affordable Housing Plan for Villages of Columbus, the senior housing project includes 153 affordable housing units (36 Very Low, 61 Low, and 56 Moderate Income units). The proposed project includes the prescribed number of affordable units identical in size, location, bedroom counts, and income levels as to the previously approved plans with the exception of the type of tenure; K. That this project is determined to be exempt from additional CEQA review pursuant to California Government Code Section 65457, which provides that once the EIR has been certified and the speck plan adopted, any residential development project that is undertaken to implement and is consistent with the specific plan is exempt from additional CEQA review; On January 16, 2001, the City of Tustin certified the Program Final Environmental Impact Statement/Environmental Impact Report for the Reuse and Disposal of MCAS Tustin (FEIS/EIR), which evaluated the environmental impacts of the reuse and disposal of MCAS -Tustin, in conjunction with the adoption of a Specific Plan. On February 3, 2003, the Tustin City Council adopted Ordinance No. 1257, which adopted the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan. On April 3, 2006, the City Council adopted Resolution No. 06-43 approving an Addendum to the FEIS/EIR for the Disposal and Reuse of MCAS Tustin. The FEIS/EIR and its Addendum considered the potential environmental impacts associated with development on the former Marine Corps Air Station, Tustin. The development of Coventry Court at Columbus Square is a residential development project that is being undertaken to implement and is consistent with the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan, as amended. No substantial changes in the project or circumstances under which it is being undertaken have occurred and no new information which was not known at the time the EIR was certified (or amended) has become available. Therefore, the proposed project is exempt from additional environmental review under CEQA. Resolution No. 4137 Amendment to TTM 16581 Page 3 II. The Planning Commission hereby recommends that the City Council approve amendment to Resolution No. 05-40, which approved Tentative Tract Map 16581, to reflect a change in tenure from ownership to rental for the proposed 240 -unit age -restricted senior housing complex on Lot 265 of Tract 16581, subject to the conditions contained in Exhibit A attached hereto. PASSED AND ADOPTED at a regular meeting of the Tustin Planning Commission held on the 26th day of January, 2010. STEVE KOZAK Chairperson ELIZABETH A. BINSACK Planning Commission Secretary STATE OF CALIFORNIA ) COUNTY OF ORANGE ) CITY OF TUSTIN ) I, ELIZABETH A. BINSACK, the undersigned, hereby certify that I am the Planning Commission Secretary of the Planning Commission of the City of Tustin, California; that Resolution No. 4137 duly passed and adopted at a regular meeting of the Tustin Planning Commission, held on the 26th day of January, 2010. ELIZABETH A. BINSACK Planning Commission Secretary EXHIBIT A RESOLUTION NO. 4137 AMENDMENT TO TENTATIVE TRACT MAP 16581 CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL GENERAL (1) 1.1 All applicable conditions of City Council Resolution Nos. 05-40 approving TTM 16581, a density bonus, and affordable housing transfer and 06-17 approving FTM 16581 for the Columbus Square community shall remain applicable, as herein modified. (1) 1.2 Approval of Resolution No. 4137 is contingent upon the applicant returning to the Community Development Department a notarized "Agreement to Conditions Imposed" form and the property owner signing and recording with the County Clerk -Recorder a notarized "Notice of Discretionary Permit Approval and Conditions of Approval" form. The forms shall be established by the .Director of Community Development, and evidence of recordation shall be provided to the Community Development Department. (***) 1.3 The senior apartment development shall be restricted to seniors of 55 years or older for the life of the project. An age -restrictive covenant running with the land shall be reviewed and approved by the Community Development Director and shall be recorded by the applicant prior to issuance of a building permit. (***) 1.4 Prior to issuance of a building permit, the applicant shall submit an Addendum to Homebuyer Notification for Columbus Square and a letter that will be sent to all existing homeowners explaining the change in Coventry Court. Proof of mailing of the Addendum to Homebuyer Notification and the letter to existing homeowners shall be submitted to the Community Development prior to final inspection and occupancy. (1) 1.5 The applicant shall submit an amendment to Final Tract Map 16581 or a Certificate of Correction to reflect aged restricted to seniors of 55 years or older, for review and approval. The amended Final Tract Map or Certificate of Correction shall be recorded prior to issuance of a building permit. SOURCE CODES (1) STANDARD CONDITION (5) RESPONSIBLE AGENCY REQUIREMENT (2) CEQA MITIGATION (6) LANDSCAPING GUIDELINES (3) UNIFORM BUILDING CODE/S (7) PC/CC POLICY (4) DESIGN REVIEW *** EXCEPTION Exhibit A Resolution No. 4137 TTM 16581 Page 2 (1) 1.6 Resolution No. 4137 shall become null and void in the event that Resolution No. 4134 approving Conditional Use Permit 09-024 and Design Review 09-024 and Resolution No. 4136 approving amendment to Resolution No. 3951 which approved Concept Plan 03-003 are not approved by the City Council. 1.7 Condition of Approval 4.1 of Resolution No. 05-40 approving Tentative Tract Map16581,which is incorporated into this approval, requires that the applicant fund its Fair Share Contribution to the Tustin Legacy Backbone Infrastructure Program. The applicant shall fund and provide security for its Fair Share Contribution to the Tustin Legacy Backbone Infrastructure Program as required by Condition of Approval 4.1 of Resolution No. 05-40, including its Fair Share Contribution of the cost estimates of the Tustin Legacy Backbone Infrastructure as adjusted by the Tustin City Council on April 3, 2006, and September 2, 2008, and subject to future increases in the Backbone Infrastructure Program costs and applicant's Fair Share Contribution thereto. AFFORDABLE HOUSING (`**) 2.1 The developer shall comply with the obligations contained in �� Resolution No. 05-40 regarding affordable housing units. The senior housing project shall contain a minimum of 153 affordable units including 36 Very Low, 61 Low, and 56 Moderate Income units and at locations depicted on the previously approved Affordable Housing Plan. 2.2 The First Amendment to the Housing Agreement shall include a Regulatory Agreement as an exhibit to reflect rental tenure which will be required to be executed by Tustin Coventry Seniors, LLC. (the proposed owner of the project). The First Amendment to the Housing Agreement shall be subject to approval of the Redevelopment Agency, City Attorney, and City's Special Real Estate Counsel as to form and content and shall be executed and recorded prior to issuance of any building permits. Should the First Amendment to the Housing Agreement and Affordable Housing Plan not be approved by the City Council, the subject approval shall become null and void. (***) 2.3 Prior to issuance of any building permits, an Assignment and Assumption Agreement of Tustin Coventry, LLC.'s duties of performance under the Housing Agreement, as amended, shall be executed between Tustin Villas Partners, LLC. and Tustin Coventry Seniors, LLC. on Lot 265 of Tract 16581 in a form and Exhibit A Resolution No. 4137 TTM 16581 Page 3 content approved by the Redevelopment Agency, Community Development Department, City Attorney, and City's Special Real Estate Counsel and the Community Development Department (***) 2.4 The "Affordable Housing Plan and Density Bonus Application" document approved for the Columbus Square shall be amended to reflect the rental tenure and a clean copy of the document shall be provided to the City and Redevelopment Agency for final review and approval, prior to issuance of a building permit. (***) 2.5 The 240 -unit project shall not feature a mix of housing tenure (i.e. ownership and rental) during the term of affordability outlined in the First Amendment to the Housing Agreement and any executed Regulatory Agreement. (***) 2.6 The affordable units in the project shall be available during the qualified project period outlined in the First Amendment to the Housing Agreement which shall be not less than 55 years. (**") 2.7 The affordable units shall comply with the City's adopted Local Workforce Housing Preference Policy by granting current Tustin residents or individuals employed within the city of Tustin preference over an applicant who does not currently reside or is not employed in the City of Tustin. FEES (***) 3.1. The applicant shall submit all fees required by the City and other agencies as identified in Resolution No. 4134 including all Attorney and Special Counsel fees associated with the review of the project. FI FULL COPIES OF THE DECEMBER 8, 20 , AND JANUARY 26, 2010, REPORTS TO THE PLANNIN COMMISSION, INCLUDING ATTACHMENTS, ARE AILABLE AT THE FOLLOWING LOCATIONS: 1. ON FILE WITH THE C MMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT AT TY HALL, 300 CENTENNIAL WAY, TUSTI N, CA 927 2. ACCESSIB THROUGH "DOCUMENT ARCHIVE" ON THE CITY' WEBSITE: http://www.tustinca.org 3. TWO,,COPIES WILL BE AVAILABLE FOR VIEWING AT TH MARCH 23,2010, PLANNING COMMISSION ETING ATTACHMENT 8 Public Input - emails received from residents Kapadia, Reina aject: FW: Coventry Court - Staff Report & Parking Study From: Eric Higuchi {mailto:ehiguchi@gmail.com] Sent: Thursday, January 28, 2010 10:45 AM To: Binsack, Elizabeth Cc: Kapadia, Reina; Shingleton, Christine; CITY COUNCIL; pstoker@tustinca.org Subject: Coventry Court - Staff Report & Parking Study Dear Director Binsack, I would like to clarify a few issues and report some concerns that I have after having read Staffs Report to planning commission in regards to item 4 on January 26, 2010 Planning Commission Agenda (in re: Coventry court). While I had submitted questions in writing to Donna Kelley of Lennar at the December Columbus Square Board Meeting, I never received a direct response from her or any other Lennar representative. had only learned that my questions had been addressed on the day of the meeting through the PC Staff Report. Regarding the following paragraph on Page 7 of the staff report: �.�., "In response to the suggested 1.58 parking. ratio a revised parking study would need to be completed to determine the feasibility of the proposed ratio and a change in the parking of the community could be considered a significant change in the project. A reduction in parking for this site would negate the argument that is being made that the proposed parking is insufficient and could bifurcate this community from the rest of the Columbus Square community" Staff is correct that my argument is.that the current parking ratio of 1.75 space per unit is grossly insufficient. However, since i was fairly certain that the developer would not concede to increasing the parking ratio, the purpose of reducing the parking ratio was to eliminate Coventry Court's access to on -street master association owned parking stalls thereby containing the potential parking problems within the bounds of the Coventry Court parcel. While eliminating Coventry Court's access to on -street parking could contribute to the bifurcation of the community, the City's and the Developer's actions and intentions have already segmented Coventry Court as a stand alone community through seeking a for -rent designation, age -restrictions, and separate common area facilities. 1 don't see how you can contend that my request would ultimately lead to the bifurcation of the community when the City's own actions have already done so. Furthermore, reducing the parking ratio to 1.58 by eliminating on -street parking has been suggested by the developers themselves who have stated that a 1:1 parking ratio would be sufficient. Furthermore, the parking study by Kaku suggests that a 1.75 parking ratio could be considered over parked. However, let me again reiterate, I do not believe a 1.75:1 parking ratio is anywhere near sufficient as: o this is an "active -adult" community as opposed to an "assisted -living" care facility. Individuals 55+ that do want to remain in orange county (outside of laguna woods) are typically not widowers, typically are still employed and typically require two cars. Even if only one spouse in the household worked, I foresee that individuals living here would typically be related to a young family in the community and would assist two working parents, specifically by driving the children to and from school and activities. o this is not an urban project, nor is it a desert gated community. Urban projects are allowed lower parking ratios because of proximity to mass transit and community services. There is a single bus stop within a 1/4 mile and no community services. Desert, gated communities are self contained lifestyle neighborhoods with golf courses, large rec centers, and even restaurants, Coventry court is NOT a retirement lifestyle community. Yes, many argue that these communities are over parked as all the homes have two car garages, but that's what this demographic still wants in order to have open streets and additional storage space. o this is the densest residential housing type in all of tustin yet it has the most lax parking requirement and was not even required to have a parking management plan in place. it does not make sense from an overall general plan standpoint to suddenly allow urban specifications in a sub -urban city. Regarding the November 2005 Parking Study by Kaku Associates, a new parking study MUST be conducted. Staffs excuses for not requiring a new parking study are no longer valid as, one, planning commission has continued the hearing for 60 days allowing for more than sufficient time to complete a new parking study. Second, according to staffs Dec 8, 2009 report, the parking study was required for the CUP, NOT any environmental approvals. Deviation from the parking standard in the MCAS Tustin Specifc Plan are • allowable if accompanied by a parking study tied to the CUP. Regarding the Kaku Parking Study itself, it is absolutely ridiculous that not a single Orange County senior community was surveyed. Furthermore, Kaku relied on surveys performed by 3rd parry engineering firms that they are not affiliated with as well as an outdated 2001 survey of urban, coastal communities in Los Angeles. I've had the opportunity to actively work on the entitlement and development of an active adult community within orange county and we actually had a traffic engineer provide the city with candidate communities, the city selected applicable communities and the engineer physically went out to the community and tracked the parking utilized in those communities every other day over the course of two weeks. That was at marginal cost and took less than one month. It's not hard to do, it's literally an intern counting cars and snapping a photo. It is incredibly frustrating to see that the city has relied upon a parking study that I believe was completed within literally one day to make a decision allowing an incredibly drastic deviation to their parking code. Please, again, this is the highest density residential housing in all of tustin and the city's drastically reduced parking requirements based upon an incomplete study. We have the time and authority to conduct a new one, the right way. Please do so. Please forward my letter to the members of the planning commission. Eric Higuchi (949) 290 - 7510 Kapadia, Reina bject: FW: Stop Coventry From: Tierney, Colleen ]. [mailto:Colleen.Tierney@aecom.com] Sent: Saturday, February 20, 2010 4:11 PM To: CITY COUNCIL Subject: Stop Coventry To: City of Tustin City Council Councilmember Re: Stop Coventry Date: February 20, 2010 Dear Council Members I am writing as new Cambridge Lane homeowners to voice my concern over Lennar's request to convert Coventry Court to an Apartment. Complex. When I purchased my new townhome in May 2009, my homebuilder, William Lyons, went over every detail the plans for the Columbus Square community and adjacent Tustin Legacy Park. At no time was there any mention either verbally or written that there were plans to build a 200 plus unit apartment building in such close proximity to my home. Had that been communicated to me I would have not elected to buy my new home in Tustin and I feel that I have been defrauded. I moved to Tustin from Irvine last May and I immediately recognized a drop in policing and community services that the City of Tustin provides to its resident. Irvine practices community policing and I have yet to see a Tustin police car patrol the streets of Columbus Square. I fear that with so little police presence, having an apartment building in the area will only contribute to a higher crime rate since there is little, or no, police presence in the community to begin with. addition, are property values will plummet and we will be asked to pay higher HOA dues at a time when just about everyone is iggling to make ends meet. Being a new homeowner 1 will consider the option of walking away from my new home rather than have —.e home devalued to an unsellable price or be forced to sell at a loss. I predict I will not be the only homeowner to contemplate walking away and the city of Tustin will have less property tax for police and fire and other services as a result. It is disheartening to find ourselves in this predicament since we did everything right when we bought our new homes in Columbus Square. Now we are having the rug pulled out from us by a sleazy homebuilder (Lennar) who is simply interested in making money who does not care about one bit about the residents of this fine community. We are all hard working, taxpaying residents and we deserve better than this. Please join us in our fight to STOP COVENTRY! It is in the best interest for the City of Tustin and all of its residents. Thank you. Regards, Colleen Tierney 15243 Cambridge Street Tustin, CA 92782 ATTACHMENT C Columbus Square Homebuyer Notification Statement Columbus Square HOMEBUYER NOTIFICATION INTRODUCTION You, the undersigned Buyer, are considering the purchase of a new home in the Columbus Square master planned residential community (the "Community') in the City of Tustin (the "City"). The master developer of the Community will be Moffett Meadows Partners, LLC ( "Master Developer") and the Columbus Square Community Association, a California nonprofit mutual benefit corporation (the "Community Association') will maintain portions of the Community. We want you (the "Buyer") to be an extremely satisfied customer. Part of your satisfaction is in knowing as much as possible about your new home in the master -planned Community. We offer this Homebuyer Notification ("Notification') as a service to describe to you various matters which might affect your decision to purchase. Please read it carefiallv. Be aware, however, that (a) much of the information in this Notification has been obtained from other sources (public agencies, public records, etc.), and (b) the information contained in this Notification is not comprehensive. This means that we cannot guarantee the accuracy or completeness of the information disclosed. Because this information is subject to change without notice to us, it also means that we cannot commit to advise you of any changes affecting the information in this Notification. By signing this Notification, you agree to independently verify all information regarding matters of. concern to you before the Close of Escrow for your home purchase. As a part of your pre -purchase investigation, we strongly recommend that you visit the Community and the general vicinity surrounding the Community on several different days at several different times to familiarize yourself with the Community, its location and its surroundings._. Unless defined in this Notification, capitalized terms used in this Notification have the meanings given them in the Master Declaration of Covenants, Conditions, Restrictions and Reservation of Easements for Columbus Square (the "Master Declaration'). OPEN SPACE/PARK AREAS Master Developer plans to construct three (3) Open Space/Park Areas within the Community. The facilities in these Open Space/Park Areas may include tot lots, basketball courts, barbeques, picnic tables or restrooms or other popular park facilities. There is no guarantee that any of these facilities will be included in the Open Space/Park Areas. Residents living in the areas nearest to the Open Space/Park Areas may experience noise, traffic and parking congestion, light spillage, glare and other impacts from the operation of these Open Space/Park Areas and the events that take place there and may be inconvenienced by these impacts. You are advised that Master Developer has no control over the operation or use of the Open Space/Park Areas after the completion of construction thereof. The Community Association or Neighborhood Association, as applicable, shall maintain the Open Space/Park Areas in accordance with all City rules and regulations. Some Open Space,/Park Areas may be located immediately adjacent to your Lot or Condominium. Those portions of the Open Space/Park Areas which will be open for public use and any associated access or use easements to the public in connection with these Open Space/Park Areas are located approximately as shown on Exhibit "OS" attached to the Master Declaration. Residents of the -1- 2544-33253\CLP4281DISCISR1591357.8 316106 Community may experience glare from night -lighted activities at the Open Space/Park Areas. Additionally, from time to time, balls and other objects may be hit out of the Open Space/Park Areas and into lots and adjacent areas. Residents of the Community may also experience noises originating from the activities at the Open Space/Park Areas, traffic noises from vehicles going to and from the club, and noises from landscaping and other maintenance activities near the Open Space/Park Areas. Master Developer has no *control over the use, operation or maintenance of the Open Space/Park Areas. RAIL CORRIDOR There is a rail corridor located to the north of the Community. As of the date of this Notification, an estimated fifty-nine (59) trains per day pass through the rail corridor. Master Developer has been informed by the City that this number is estimated to increase to over one hundred (100) trains per day by the year 2020. The impact of this rail corridor may include, without limitation, increased noise, light and vibration levels in the area of the Commumity. The rail corridor could be an attractive nuisance to children who may play in the vicinity of the rail corridor. Master Developer and the Community Association have no control over the use, maintenance or care of the rail corridor. You should evaluate the impact of this rail corridor on your decision to purchase a Lot or Condominium in the Community. MAJOR THOROUGHFARES Major thoroughfares are located within the vicinity of the Community, which include,. among others, Edinger Avenue, North Loop Road and West Connector Road. Master Developer and the Neighborhood Builders have no control over the use, maintenance or care of these streets and thoroughfares. You may experience noise, dust and traffic within and in ,the vicinity of the Community based on the public's use of some of these streets and thoroughfares. SOUND ATTENUATION Pursuant to a noise analysis conducted by or on behalf of Master Developer, Lots or Condominiums that may most likely be susceptible to noise impacts from property uses surrounding the Community are identified as sensitive receptors, as depicted on Exhibit A attached hereto. Approved building plans may contain sound attenuation measures. If your Lot or Condominium is improved with any sound attenuation measures, you are prohibited from ultering or modifying any such measures and you acknowledge and understand that the indoor sound attenuation measures will only work as intended if the windows and doors remain closed. You further acknowledge that individuals have varying sensitivity to noise, and any sound attenuation measures installed by Master Developer or a Neighborhood Builder may not reduce noise to a level that will satisfy every expectation. • Owners -of Lots or Condominiums identified as sensitive receptors on Exhibit A and located at the southwest corner of the Community are advised that these Lots and Condominiums are adjacent to an area west of the Community that is currently zoned for commercial and light industrial uses. Owners of Lots or Condominiums in this area of the Community may experience noise, traffic, dust, odors and other impacts from the operation of this commercial and industrial property. By acceptance of a deed to a Lot or a Condominium, each Owner acknowledges and accepts that Declarant has no control over any commercial or industrial property or its impact on the Owners or the Community. -2- 2544-33253\C1P428\DLSCISR\ 581357.8 3/6/06 t, AFFORDABLE HOUSINGITRANSITIONAL HOUSING The City has required Master Developer to provide two hundred sixty-six (266) units of affordable housing within the Community. Certain Lots or Condominiums in the Community will be offered to persons who qualify as very low, low and moderate income buyers pursuant to guidelines established by the United States Department of Housing and Urban Development for the City. Buyers who qualify as very low, low and moderate income will purchase their Lots or Condominiums subject to resale restrictions, as reflected in a recorded covenant agreement, for a period of forty-five (45) years. Buyers who are interested in the affordable housing program should consult their sales counselor for filrther information. UTILITY Il"ROVEMENTS In addition to utility lines, all of which will be installed underground in the Community, there may be above -ground and subterranean utility Improvements such as transformers, lift stations, water or sewer facilities, fire hydrants, lighting Improvements, telecommunications vaults and other visible Improvements necessary for the delivery of utilities or other services either on or adjacent to each Lot or Condominium. Each Owner understands that the placement of such Improvements is dictated by the needs of the applicable utility or service provider, and the presence of such Improvements in the Community is in accordance with easements created prior to or during the development of the Community. You understand, by accepting a deed to a Lot or Condominium in the Community, that each Lot or Condominium and portions of the Association Property are subject to one (1) or more such easements for placement of utility Improvements. You may not modify, remove or otherwise interfere with utility Improvements on any Lot or Condominium or other portion of the Community. T COMMUNITY FACILITIES DISTRICT AND ASSESSMENT DISTRICTS The Community lies within the boundaries of Special Assessment Districts and Mello -Roos Community Facilities Districts which require the levy of special taxes for the repayment of bonds issued for the purpose of paying the cost of services or capital improvements that have been or are being provided. The amount of the special tax and any other information pertaining to any such district can be obtained from the County Assessor's office. You will be obligated to pay these assessments and taxes in addition the assessments imposed by the Community Association or any Neighborhood Corporation. MAINTENANCE The Community Association shall maintain all completed Improvements on the Association Property it is obligated to. maintain (including the Parkways described in Section 9.2.2 of the Master Declaration, Open Space,/Park Areas, streets (i.e., lighting, drainage facilities), alleys and paseos), all in conformance with any Maintenance Guidelines. The Association Property is described in Exhibit "AP" attached to the Master Declaration. Please refer to Section 9.2 of the Master Declaration for further information concerning maintenance by the Community Association. -3- 2544-33253WU42WISCISM 581357.8 3/6/06 ACCESS Neither the Community nor any street, sidewalk, alleyway or paseo located within the Community shall be privately gated; provided however, that any swimming pool and/or spa facility within the Association Property and any indoor recreational facilities, such as a clubhouse and bathrooms, may be gated or locked and made available solely to Residents of the Community and their family, invitees and guests. Neither Master Developer nor the Community Association undertake to provide security or privacy for the Community or buyers, nor do they make any representations or warranties concerning the security or privacy of the Community or Residents. HOME BUSINESS USE Any Home within the Community may be used for business purposes, provided such use is subject to. City regulations pertaining to allowable home business use and such use may require zoning clearance and a business license. You should contact the City for more information regarding business uses that are allowed in your Home. TRASH For certain Homes in the Community, trash must be kept in individual and sanitary containers at designated locations, as approximately shown on Exhibit "TC" to the Master Declaration. In accordance with the Community Guidelines, no odor may be permitted to arise therefrom so as to render any portion of the Community offensive or detrimental to any other property in the vicinity thereof or to its occupants. Your trash containers may be exposed to the view of neighboring Homes only when set out for a reasonable period of time (no earlier than 6:00 p.m. on the day before scheduled trash collection times and no later than midnight the day of pickup). VIEWS/SURROUNDING PROPERTIES Properties surrounding the Community may be developed in accordance with City ordinances in a manner which may partially or totally obstruct views from your Lot or Condominium. Master Developer and the City make no claim, warranty or guarantee that views from any Lot or Condominium will be preserved as development of surrounding properties occurs. PARIUNNG Vehicles may not be parked in the "no parking" zones identified in the Master Declaration or any Supplemental Declarations. Certain of these "no parking" zones will be identified only by signs and will not be identified with red -painted curbs. Vehicles parked in these "no parking" zones may be towed immediately without advance notice to vehicle owners. The parking and circulation areas in the Community are located approximately as shown on Exhibit "PC" and Exhibit "OS" to the Master Declaration. Vehicle parking in private streets is subject to local ordinances and Community Association regulations. Please refer to Section 2.4 of the Master Declaration for further restrictions concerning parking of vehicles within the Community. -4- 2544-3325MCLP42801SCLSM 581357.8 3/6/06 k BUILDING SETBACKS Construction of Improvements in the yard of any Lot or Condominium such as pools, spas, patio covers, BBQ, fountains, trellises, and water features are subject to minimum setback and height restrictions and may not be permitted. You should refer to the Community Association Governing Documents and applicable City ordinances for any restrictions concerning the construction of any Improvements to your Lot or Condominium. PHASED CONSTRUCTION AND SALES ACTIVITY Phased Construction and sales activities will be occurring within and in the vicinity of the Community. Sales activity will increase the vehicle and pedestrian traffic within the Community. This may result in inconvenience to residents in the Community, due to increased light, noise and dust from the construction activities and the operation of themodel homes and sales office. As a result of construction and sales activities, public and private utilities (water, electrical, cable television, sewers, storm drain, etc.) within the Community, and/or servicing your Home, may be temporarily interrupted and/or adversely affected. You agree to exercise extreme caution and to observe all signs while driving through construction areas and to observe the temporary closure of streets and the rerouting of traffic. SCHOOLS The Community is currently located in the Tustin Unified School District, telephone: (714) 730- 7301 (the "School District'. To obtain further information about the schools serving the Community, including transportation to and from the schools, please contact the School District. r•.. You should investigate this matter to your satisfaction prior to purchasing a Lot or Condominium in the Community. FUTURE FIRE STATION SITE The Community is located adjacent to a future fire station site at the corner of Edinger Avenue and West Connector Road. The fire station will operate twenty-four (24) hours a day and seven (7) days a week. Residents in the vicinity of the fire station will notice noise, sirens, light, glare and other impacts from the operation of the fire station and emergency vehicles. You are advised that Master Developer has no control over the operation or use of the fire station. You should evaluate the impact of the fire station on your decision to purchase a Lot or Condominium in the Community. SALE AND OWNERSHIP PER WAS TUSTIN SPECIFIC PLAN Development within the Community is approved for sale and ownership tenure only in accordance with Chapter 3.9.3J5 of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan. ENVIRONMENTAL CONDITION The Community is located on a portion of the former Marine Corps Air Station Tustin ( "MCAS Tustin') that the United States Government once owned and operated. Certain Lots within the Community are located in areas that were previously used by the U.S. Government to store and wash vehicles and equipment that were used at MCAS Tustin. These areas are designated "IRP- -5- 2544-3325MCLP42801SCLSM 581357.8 3/6/06 13S" and "IRP -13W" on the final subdivision map that was recorded for the Community and are depicted in Exhibit B attached hereto ("Release Areas'j. As a result of these activities, hazardous substances have been released into the groundwater underlying the portions of the Release Areas. Volatile Organic Compounds ("VOC"s), including trichloroetheleyne ("TCE'I and 1,2,3 Trichloropropane ("1,2,3 TCP'j, were found in groundwater at concentrations that could result in adverse effect to human health if this water was extracted from the ground and directly used for domestic purposes such as drinking or bathing. However, groundwater at this location is currently not used for such purposes. Extensive documentation has been prepared that describes the nature and extent of the release of hazardous substances that has occurred at the Release Area and past and ongoing remediation efforts. The following reports are available for public review at either (1) BRACS Environmental Coordinator's Office, Library Building 307, MCAS El Toro, telephone (949) 726-5398 or (2) City of Tustin, Department of Community Development, 300 Centennial Way, Tustin, CA 92780, telephone (714) 573-3100: • Draft Feasibility Study Report For Operable Unit 4B, Former Marine Corps Air Station, Tustin, California, August 2005, Bechtel Environmental, Inc., August 2005. • Final Record of Decision/Remedial Action Plan Operable Unit IA, Former Marine Corps Air Station Tustin, California, Department of Navy, October 2004. • Final Feasibility Study Report, OU -IA, Marine Corps Air Station, Tustin, California, Bechtel Environmental, Inc., August 2003. • Final Environmental Impact Statement/Environmental Impact Report, Disposal and Reuse of MCAS Tustin, California, Department of Navy and City of Tustin, December, 1999. Deed restrictions may also be recorded on all or a portion of lots within the Release Areas that will limit certain activities on such lots. These deed restrictions will identify specific land use restrictions to prevent exposure of future landowners and/or users of the Release Areas to hazardous substances and to maintain the integrity of the remedial action until remediation is complete and remediation goals have been achieved. PROPOSED PARKS. A proposed Urban Regional Park and a proposed Community Park (collectively, the "Parks') may eventually be constructed southwest and west of the Community, respectively. If constructed, the ' Urban Regional Park will be maintained by the County of Orange and the Community Park will be maintained by the City of Tustin. The MCAS Tustin Specific Plan provides that the fbIlowing uses may be included in the Urban Regional Park: animal shelter; arboretums and horticultural gardens.; Children, Youth and Family Resource Center; commercial recreation facilities; live performance facility/amphitheater, museum, cultural center, interpretive center and/or other educational and cultural facility, nature center with live animals; picnic areas; recreation facilities; regional law enforcement training classrooms; park, Regional Archaelogical Curation Center, retail or service commercial uses (other than concessionaire commercial uses); riding and hiking trails and stage areas; sports lighting (where exterior lighting is designed to confine direct rays and glare to the -6- 2544-3325MLP428WISCLSM 581357.8 3/6/06 premises; and theatres. The MCAS Tustin Specific Plan further provides that the following uses may be included in the Community Park: ballfields, courts, playgrounds and other recreation facilities; civic, cultural and community center buildings; nature center with live animals; private recreational facilities; public park; sports field lighting (where lighting is designed to confine direct rays and glare to the premises). Master Developer makes no guarantee that either Park will be constructed, or, if constructed, that it will include any or all of the facilities described in the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan. Residents in the Community can experience increased noise, traffic and glare of lights from activities within the Parks, if constructed. Owners acknowledge that Master Developer and the Master Association have no control over the use, maintenance or care of the Parks, if constructed. By signing below you acknowledge you have received and understand this Notification, and you agree to purchase a Home in the Community subject to it terms. ' Date: Buyer: Signature Signature � Signature Name Name Name -7- 2544-33253WLP42ADISCLSM 581357.8 MUM EXHIBIT A DEPICTION OF SENSITIVE RECEPTORS a 2544-3325MLP428DISCISM 581357.8 3/6/06 EXHIBIT B DEPICTION OF RELEASE AREAS 2544-3325MLP42MISCLSM 581357.8 316/06 _x0000000 NOW -110 acocoa n o ©u.on'© an can ©o :n nm an o .r a,"' can ©o 00 a©a -_ — ���-'poo©o �© 10.5 KW E7, 7" WE' • p;� ' Kai ATTACHMENT D Columbus Square Homebuyer Disclosure Statement (5 versions) Columbus Square HOMEBUYER DISCLOSURE STATEMENT 14i'edwditer i Camden Place The Gables & Astoria + Coventry Court Cambridge Lane • A'ensington Court • [verandas June 2006 Welcome to Columbus Square. We are pleased you are considering the purchase of a new home in Columbus Square. We want you (the "Buyer") to be an extremely satisfied customer. Part of your satisfaction is in knowing as much as possible about your new home in the master -planned community of Columbus Square ("Comrrtunity"� located in the City of Tustin. We offer this Homeowner Disclosure Statement ("Disdosure") as a service to describe to you various matters which might affect your decision to purchase. Please read it carefully. Be aware, however, that (a) much of the information in this Disclosure has been obtained from other sources (public agencies, public records, etc.), and (b) the information contained in this Disclosure is not comprehensive. This means that we cannot guarantee the accuracy or completeness of the information disclosed. Because this information is subject to change without notice to us, it also means that we cannot commit to advise you of any changes affecting the information in this Disclosure. In addition to'this Disclosure, the City of Tustin has required that the Master Developer provide you with a Columbus Square Homebuyer Notification (the "Homebuyer Notification'). The Master Developer prepared the Homebuyer Notification with information provided by the City of Tustin, at the direction of the City of Tustin and do not have the right to alter or update the Homebuyer Notification. To the extent any of the information provided in the Homebuyer Notification is inconsistent with the information provided in this Disclosure, this Disclosure shall supersede that portion of the Homebuyer Notification. By signing this Disclosure, you agree to independently verify all information regarding matters of concern to you before the Close of Escrow for your home purchase. As a part of your pre -purchase investigation, we strongly recommend that you visit the Community and the general vicinity surrounding the Community on several different days at several different times to familiarize yourself with the Community, its location and its surroundings. You will receive many documents in addition to this Disclosure to review, complete and sign before the Close of Escrow for the purchase of your home. These other documents are called the "Purchase Documents" in this Disclosure, and they include documents pertaining to the Community, defined below as the "Community Association Governing Documents". This Disclosure is not intended as a substitute for your review of the Community Association Governing Documents, This Disclosure does not amend, modify or supersede the Community Buyer Initials: _� - (_ 2544-332531Ci.P428\DISCLSR\ a*965.3 6113106 Association Governing Documents. If the Community Association Governing Documents are inconsistent with this Disclosure, the Community Association Governing Documents will supersede this Disclosure. Unless defined in this Disclosure, capitalized terms used in this Disclosure have the meanings given them in the Master Declaration of Covenants, Conditions, Restrictions and Reservation of Easements for Columbus Square ("Community Declaration'). If the Community Declaration gives the same capitalized term a different meaning than this Disclosure, the meaning given in the Community Declaration shall apply. INTRODUCTION TO THE MASTER DEVELOPER Moffett Meadows Partners, LLC, a Delaware limited liability company, is the initial Master Developer of the Columbus Square master -planned community ("Master Developer"). INTRODUCTION TO COLUMBUS SQUARE 1. Location and Master Plan. The Community is east of Interstate 55 near the intersection of Edinger Avenue and Redhill Avenue, in the City of Tustin (the "City"). The master land -use plan approved by the City of Tustin for the Community is called the WAS Tustin Specific Plan (the "Specific Plan") and it contains numerous design standards and development conditions. Such conditions establish, among other things, the number of single family dwellings and condominiums and other development requirements. If developed as approved by the City, Columbus Square will encompass approximately 1075 Homes, which are planned to consist of 283 single family dwellings, 552 condominiums and 240 senior housing condominiums. The actual number of Homes built may increase or decrease subject to approval by the City. All Homes in the Community are planned to be subject to the jurisdiction of the Columbus Square Community Association, a California nonprofit mutual benefit corporation ("Community Association'), as described in the Community Declaration. INTRODUCTION TO COLUMBUS SQUARE'S NEIGHBORHOODS AND NEIGHBORHOOD BUILDERS 2. Neighborhoods. The Community is being developed with Homes in numerous distinct neighborhoods ("Neighborhoods") constructed by various homebuilders ("Neighborhood Builders'). Neighborhood Builders may have owner occupancy restrictions, rental Homesites and Homes (each of which is defined below), and investor-owned Homesites and Homes. You are advised to read the individual Neighborhood Builder disclosures and any other documentation relating to the Neighborhood in which you choose to purchase a Homesite or Home thoroughly. Neighborhood Builder policies may differ from those described in this Disclosure and the Community Declaration and are enforceable by the applicable Neighborhood Builders. The following is a list of the different Neighborhoods to be developed by the Neighborhood Builders in the Community and the approximate number of Homes to be constructed in each Neighborhood: Buyer Initials! / -2- 2544-3325ACLI 428WISCLSM 609965.3 6/13/06 (a) Lennar Homes of California, Inc. • Meriwether 114 Homes • Camden Place 222 Homes • The Gables 84 Homes • Coventry Court 240 Homes (b) William Lyon Homes, Inc. • Astoria 102 Homes • Cambridge Lane 156 Homes • Kensington Court 60 Homes • Verandas 97 Homes 3. Ownership. A residential Lot in the Community is referred to as a "Homesite" in this Disclosure. If you are purchasing a residential Lot in the Community, upon the Close of Escrow, you will receive fee title to a Homesite, which will be improved with a single family dwelling (a "Home'l. If you are purchasing a Condominium in the Community, upon the Close of Escrow, you will receive fee title to a Unit and you will also receive easements for maintenance and use over Exclusive Use Areas (collectively, a "Home'). If you purchase a Homesite, you will not own the mineral, oil, and gas rights under the land below a depth of five hundred (500) feet, or the water rights. The holder of these rights has no right of surface entry. COMMUNITY ASSOCIATION GOVERNING DOCUMENTS Your Home will be subject to the following documents ("Community Association Governing Documents'): (a) The Community Declaration, and any amendments or modifications thereto; (b) The Articles of Incorporation of the Columbus Square Community Association ("CommunhyAssociation'); (c) The Bylaws of the Community Association; (d) The Supplemental Declaration of Covenants, Conditions and Restrictions ("Supplemental Declaration") that is applicable to the Neighborhood in which your Horne is located, and may annex that Neighborhood to the coverage of the Community Declaration; and (e) Any Community Guidelines or Design Guidelines which may be adopted from time to time, respectively, by the Community Association's Board of Directors or the Design Review Committee ("Committee'l pursuant to the Community Declaration. You should carefully review the Community Association Governing Documents in order to understand your specific rights and obligations as an Owner in the Community. The Community Association Governing Documents establish limits and restrictions on the use of the Buyer Initials: / _3_ 2544-33253TU42ADISCLSM 609965.3 6/13/06 Home you are purchasing. You will also be provided with a preliminary title report. The title report will list other recorded documents affecting the use of the Home you are purchasing. You should review the title report and the documents referenced in the report closely prior to your purchase of a Home. SPECIFIC PROVISIONS OF THE COMMUNITY DECLARATION 4. Assessment Obligation. The Community Declaration authorizes the Community Association's Board of Directors to levy a Common Assessment against each Home to meet the Community Association's Common Expenses. The Board of Directors is also authorized to levy various special assessments for specific purposes, in conformance with Articles I and VIII of the Community Declaration. The monthly installment of the Common Assessment will vary as each Phase of the Community is developed. You should review the Budget approved by the California Department of Real Estate and provided to you with the Final Subdivision Public Report for your Home. The Board of Directors' ability to increase the Common Assessments and improve additional special assessments without a vote of the Members is subject to certain limitations set forth in Sections 8.5 and 8.6 of the Community Declaration. The Community Association is obligated to provide you with an annual budget and other financial statements for the Community Association. 5. Use Restrictions. You must comply with all the various use restrictions set forth in the Community Declaration. These restrictions include, among other things, restrictions on non-residential uses of your Home, keeping of animals, improvements to your Homesite and Home, parking of vehicles, etc. The Community Association has the power to enforce the use restrictions set forth in the Community Declaration, as well as the Community Guidelines and the Design Guidelines. 6. Prohibited Dwelling Structures. You may not use your garage as a living area. Further, in accordance with Section 2.7 of the Community Declaration, you may not erect or use any outbuilding, tent, shack, storage shed, trailer, camper, motor home, recreational vehicle or any other vehicle on your Homesite for a living area. 7. Use of Garages. All vehicles owned or operated by or within the control of an Owner and kept in the Community must be parked in the assigned parking space or garage of that Owner; provided that, although storage of personal items may occur in the garage, all Authorized Vehicles must be parked in the garage, in accordance with Section 2.4.3 of the Community Declaration and Exhibit PC -1 attached thereto. Notwithstanding the foregoing, Owners may not park any Authorized Vehicle in the street or in any guest parking spaces. No repair, maintenance or restoration of any vehicle may be conducted within the Community except in an enclosed garage when the garage door is closed; provided, however, that such activity may not be undertaken as a business, and provided further that such activity may be prohibited entirely by the Board if the Board determines that it constitutes a nuisance. 8. Parking of Recreational and Commercial Vehicles. Sections 2.4.1, 2.4.2 and 2.4.3 of the Community Declaration impose limitations and prohibitions on the parking of Authorized Vehicles and Prohibited Vehicles within the Community. In accordance with Section 2.4.6 of the Community Declaration, an Owner may park any Authorized Vehicle that Buyer Initials: / -4_ 2544-33253\CLF428\DISCLSR\ 609965.3 6/13/06 exceeds seven (7) feet high, seven (7) feet wide, and nineteen (19) feet long in the Owner's garage or driveway (as long as the Authorized Vehicle does not extend onto the sidewalk or drive approach area). In addition, no delivery and/or moving trucks larger than forty (40) feet are permitted on any private drive having less than a twenty-five (25) foot radius that is located within a Neighborhood in the Community. You further acknowledge that it is your responsibility to determine whether the parking provided in the Community and your Neighborhood is satisfactory for your purposes and to verify that the standard height and depth, of the garage will provide adequate clearance for your vehicles before the Close of Escrow on your Home. 9. Owner Maintenance Guidelines. As set forth in Section 9.1.1 of the Community Declaration, each Owner must maintain his Home and Homesite in a neat and attractive condition at all times. The maintenance of all areas located within the boundaries of a Homesite is the responsibility of each Owner. The Neighborhood Builders will provide you with important guidelines on the proper maintenance of improvements in your Homesite. Failure to properly maintain interior improvements may cause premature deterioration of important features, finishes or equipment. The Neighborhood Builders are not responsible for failure of equipment or other improvements caused by your failure to properly maintain such improvements. In addition, you acknowledge that some upgraded materials, if any are selected by you, may have specific maintenance requirements. The Neighborhood Builders are not responsible for any damages that may occur to such materials due to your failure to properly maintain them, 10. Insurance. In accordance with Article IX of the Community Declaration, you are solely responsible for determining the type and quality of insurance required to adequately insure your Homesite and Home, your personal property, and your personal liability for ownership of your Homesite and Home. You are solely responsible for determining if natural disaster insurance is required for your Homesite and Home. If any insurance is required by your lender, you are responsible for obtaining that insurance prior to Close of Escrow. 11. Design Review of Improvements and Alterations. You may not build, construct, install or plant any improvements on your Homesite (or alter any improvements located on your Homesite, including your Home), until you have submitted plans and specifications and obtained approval from the Design Review Committee, as set forth in Article V of the Community Declaration. The Design Review Committee will establish Design Guidelines containing rules and guidelines for the submission of plans and specifications. The Design Review Committee may collect a fee to review the plans. All Improvements must comply with any applicable restrictions in the Community Declaration and the Design Guidelines, as well as with all requirements imposed by the City and any other local governmental agency. The Design Guidelines and City and other local governmental agency regulations may change from time to time, and you will be subject to the regulations in effect at the time plans are submitted. After obtaining written approval of the Deesign Review Committee, you must submit the plans and specifications to the appropriate local governmental agencies for any proposed improvements that require the issuance of a building permit, or other approval by the City or any other local governmental agencies, as applicable. You should read Article V of Buyer Initials: / _$_ 2544-33253tC1,1`42WISCLSM 609965.3 6/13/06 the Community Declaration before constructing any Improvements. You may be subject to a Neighborhood Association Design Review Committee if you live in a Condominium project. (a) Landscaping and Irrigation Improvements. All landscape materials and irrigation systems installed by Owners must comply with plans and specifications approved by the Design Review Committee. You may need to install yard drains when installing landscaping and patios. Your landscaping plans are required to conform with the original drainage plan of the Homesite. Changes to drainage and grading require approval of the Design Review Committee and generally require you to obtain a permit from the City, as applicable. The slope areas, if any, located on a Homesite may include drainage facilities and temporary erosion control measures. No modifications to the slope areas shall be undertaken without the prior approval of the Design Review Committee and the City, as applicable. (b) Landscaping Completion Deadline. Section 2.18 of the Community Declaration requires you to install landscaping on any portions of your Homesite that have not been landscaped by a Neighborhood Builder. Landscaping in the front yard of a Homesite must be completed within six (6) months after the Close of Escrow for the purchase of the Homesite and landscaping in the back yard of a Homesite must be completed within one (1) year after the Close of Escrow for the purchase of the Homesite. The time period for the completion of such improvements is set forth in the Community Declaration. (c) . Owner Liability. Any alterations or Improvements made by you to your Homesite, to its drainage pattern or to the Home shall be made at your sole risk. The Neighborhood Builders assume no responsibility for any damage caused by the design, construction, installation, alteration or maintenance by you of any Improvement on the Homesite, or caused by the impact of such an Improvement on the Homesite's drainage pattern. (d) Licensed Professionals. If you wish to alter or install any Improvement on your Homesite, you should obtain the advice of a licensed architect or civil, soil or structural engineer, as applicable, and should design and complete the alteration or installation of the Improvement in accordance with such licensed professional's advice and specifications. 12. Drainage. Section 2.14 of the Community Declaration contains important restrictions concerning drainage of water and water pollution. (a) Surface Water. The Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders have provided for surface and underground drainage of water from all Homesites and Homes in the Community. Your Homesite may have surface "swales" or area drains to carry the water from the rear and sides of the Home to the street or other designated outlet points. The Homesites and Homes are graded in accordance with plans approved by the City and certified by a registered civil engineer. In connection with the preparation of landscape plans for your yard, it is important that you consider any possible harmful effects that such landscaping - and associated Improvements may have on adjacent property and structures as well as your Homesite and Home. Because the Community and your Homesite are located in an Area which may contain expansive soils as more particularly explained in the Paragraph below entitled "Soil Conditions," water may have a detrimental impact upon such soils and the soils of surrounding Homesites and Buyer Initials; ! _6_ 2544-33253TU42ADISCURk 6UM5.3 6/13106 slopes. Existing drainage patterns must be maintained and all drainage systems must be kept free of debris and free flowing. (b) Effect of Improvements and Alterations. Raising the existing grade, constructing planters, changing the drainage pattern and other similar activities may cause damage to your Homesite, adjacent property (including, without limitation, your neighbor's Homesite, adjacent slopes and lower Homesites) and Improvements located thereon, including the Home. It is recommended that you consult with a licensed professional on landscaping and drainage, such as a qualified landscape architect and soils engineer, geotechnical engineer, geologist, civil engineer or other similar specialist, before making any alterations. Any Improvements must be designed and constructed in a manner to prevent any possible damage to your Homesite and to adjacent property. If any obstruction occurs to the drainage on your yard, it may result in obstruction of drainage from adjacent property or cause major problems such as trapped water or flooding which may undermine the foundation of your Home and surrounding Homes or create moisture intrusion or mold and mildew problems. You are solely responsible for any damage to your Homesite and Home or surrounding property and the Improvements located thereon as a result of any alterations you make to the approved existing drainage pattern or failure to maintain proper drainage. The Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders and Community Association shall have no liability or responsibility for any such damage. Any grading or drainage modifications are subject to applicable codes of the City, approval by the Design Review Committee, and the terms of any drainage easements that may be of record. You - acknowledge and understand that if your Homesite or Home does not include area drains, you shall be responsible for installing area drains on your Homesite or Home when installing your landscaping. Your responsibilities for maintaining all grading and other drainage -related features on your Homesite and Home are set forth in Section 2.14.1 of the Community Declaration. (c) Water Quality Management Requirements. The Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders are developing the Community and Neighborhoods in accordance with a water quality management plan (1`Plan') required by the California State Water Quality Control Board. The Plan imposes requirements for the design, implementation and maintenance of Best Management Practices (ITMPs') to eliminate or mitigate all non -storm water discharges into storm drains - during and after construction of the Community and Neighborhoods. The requirements imposed by the Plan are in addition to any local ordinances with regard to discharge of non -storm water into storm drains. The Plan imposes post -construction requirements. This means that after the Close of Escrow, you and your sub -contractors and other agents, are required to comply with all BMPs which are necessary to prevent, without limitation, run-off of soil, sand, sediment, oil, gasoline or other hydrocarbons, paint, fertilizers, pool chemicals and other household chemicals into the storm drains located in your Neighborhood. For example, when fertilizing landscaping, measures must be taken to prevent over -watering the landscaping to ensure that fertilizer and other lawn chemicals do not run into the storm drains. Your Neighborhood Builder will provide you with a Best Management Practices Handbook containing BMP 'recommendations for the prevention of run-off into storm drains from your Homesite and Home. The Plan affirmatively obligates all Owners to take immediate corrective action whenever there is a violation of the Plan as to an Owner's Homesite or Home. Penalties include Buyer lnidals! / -7_ 2544.33253TU42901SCLSM 609965.3 6/13106 significant fines that may be imposed against an Owner for failing to comply with BMPs necessary to prevent non -storm water run-off into storm drains, in violation of the Plan. 13. Utility and Other Easements. Article VII of the Community Declaration contains provisions pertaining to easements which may affect Owners and Homes. Your Homesite and Home may be subject to easements or other rights in favor of utility companies, local governmental agencies and other parties. These easements and rights may include access onto your Homesite or to exterior portions of the Home for purposes of installing, constructing, inspecting, maintaining and repairing facilities which are customary for residential developments (including, but not limited to, water lines, sewer lines, electrical lines and facilities, transformer boxes, natural gas pipelines, street lights, telephone lines and facilities, cable television lines, mailboxes, traffic signs, fire hydrants, etc.). These facilities and structures may be located above ground or below ground. In either case, the foregoing easements, rights and facilities may restrict the use and type of improvements you can make to your Homesite and Horne, and the utility company, local government agency or other parties benefited by such easement or right may have the right to remove improvements made by you on the easement area without any obligation to repair or restore them. You should review the policy of title insurance, the tract map for your Homesite, Article VII of the Community Declaration, and the Supplemental Declaration to determine what easements and other rights, if any, affect your Homesite and Home. Such easements may preclude construction of structures or other improvements or may require an encroachment permit to be obtained. You should not excavate or construct an improvement on any portion of your Homesite, as applicable, until you have consulted with an applicable licensed design professional (for example, an engineer) and located all easements and facilities. A copy of the tract map depicting your Homesite is available for review in the sales office. The location of gas and electric meters, telephone and cable access panels may change from the locations shown in the models. Please ask your sales representative for information concerning the proposed location of utility facilities and structures for your Home. The Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders make no representations or warranties concerning the final location of these facilities or structures for your Home. 14. Pets. Household pets, such as dogs or cats, are limited to reasonable quantities as established in Section 2.5 of the Community Declaration. Buyers shall be liable for any unreasonable noise or damage (including, but not limited to, clean up after such animal(s)) caused by any animal brought or kept upon the Community and Neighborhoods as more fully described in the Community Declaration. 15. Window Coverings. In accordance with Section 2.10 of the Community Declaration, the Design Guidelines and Community Guidelines may prohibit or restrict certain types of window coverings such as paint, foil, reflective tint or other similar materials or substances, and may permit certain types of temporary window coverings pending installation of permanent window coverings. 16. Walls and Fences. Wall and fence heights may vary throughout the Community and your Neighborhood. Walls and fences are subject to change, at any time and without notice to you, from any depiction that may have been provided or shown to you. Section 9.1.4 of the Community Declaration sets forth Owner's wall maintenance responsibilities. Owners are responsible for maintenance of all portions of the walls and fences that border the perimeter of Buyer Initials: / _$. 2544-33253TU428113ISCLSM 609465.3 6fl 3/06 the Homesite, including any pilasters located on an Owner's Homesite, except for those portions that are designated for maintenance by the Community Association or a Neighborhood Association. You should review the Community Association Governing Documents for further information. Community Walls, Neighborhood Walls and/or Party Walls (all as defined in the Community Declaration) may be installed on the property line(s) of your Homesite (collectively, the "Walls'), as shown as Exhibit WM attached to the Community Declaration, Neighborhood Declaration or a Supplemental Declaration. Owners must maintain any portion of the Walls not otherwise maintained by the Community Association or a Neighborhood Association. Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders and the Community Association are not responsible for damage to any Wall on the Homesite if such damage results from your failure to properly maintain the Walls. 17. Solar Energy Systems. Pursuant to Section 2.17 of the Community Declaration, you and all other Owners of Homesites in the Community have the right to place and maintain equipment and facilities related to the installation and maintenance of individual solar energy systems ("System"). The installation and maintenance of any System by you shall be subject to all applicable ordinances and zoning regulations of the City, the Uniform Building Code and associated ordinances. California has a strong public policy in favor of solar energy needs of a neighbor, including but not limited to the location and height of trees on your Homesite. You must obtain written approval from the Design Review Committee prior to installation of a System and you must comply with reasonable restrictions placed on the System by the Design Review Committee, subject to California Civil Code Sections 714 and 714. 1, as the same may be amended from time to time. 18. Satellite Dishes. Satellite dish antennas (or Authorized Antennae, as defined in the Community Declaration) may be installed and used in the Community in accordance with Section 2.11 of the Community Declaration. However, Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders have provided no assurances or guarantees that any satellite dish or other antenna installed within the Community will remain unobstructed or that satellite service will be provided to an Owner after installation of an Authorized Antennae. You should understand that broadcast signals may be obstructed by the installation of additional improvements within and outside of the Community including, without limitation, homes, walls, fences, trees and other landscaping and such obstructions may not allow for acceptable satellite reception. You should also understand that Neighborhood Associations may impose additional restrictions. 19. Amendments to the Community Declaration. Notwithstanding the fact that you have received a copy of the Community Declaration and the Supplemental Declaration for your Phase of Development, these documents may be amended in accordance with their amendment provisions. 20. Additional Provisions. There may be provisions of various laws, including the Davis -Stirling Common Interest Development Act codified at Sections 1350 et seq. of the California Civil Code and the Federal Fair Housing Act codified at Title 42 United States Code, Section 3601 et seq., which may supplement or override the Community Association Governing Documents. The Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders and Community Association make Buyer Initials: / -g- 2544.33253\CLP42801SCLSM 609965.3 6113106 no representations or warranties regarding the future enforceability of any portion of the Community Association Governing Documents. COLUMBUS SQUARE DISCLOSURES 21. Charitable Endowment Fee. A recorded Charitable Housing Agreement Imposing Endowment Fee On Transfer ("Agreement's affects your Home and the other Homes in the Community. The Agreement requires that an "Endowment Fee" equal to one -twentieth of one percent (0.05%) of the total sales price (0.0005 x total sales price) be paid each time a Home in the Community is transferred to a new owner. The Endowment Fee will be paid to Lennar Charitable Housing Foundation, a California nonprofit public benefit corporation ("Foundation'), to be used for the purposes described in the Agreement. When you close escrow for the purchase of your Home, you will pay the Endowment Fee to the Foundation. Thereafter, each time your Home is resold, the Endowment Fee must be paid at the close of escrow, but it may be paid either by the new buyer or the then current seller. The Agreement will be in effect for an indefinite period of time. 22. Affordable Housing/Transitional Housing. The City of Tustin has required the Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders to provide two hundred sixty-six (266) units of affordable housing ("Affordable Hoaxing Units') within the Community. Sixty-three (63) Affordable Housing Units will be located in the Camden Place Neighborhood, fifty (50) Affordable Housing Units will be located in the Cambridge Lane. Neighborhood, and one hundred fifty-three (153) Affordable Housing Units will be located in an area of the Community that will be designated as housing for seniors (Coventry Court). Certain of these Affordable Housing Units will be offered to persons who qualify as very low, low and moderate income buyers pursuant to guidelines established by the United States Department of Housing and Urban Development for the City. Buyers who qualify as very low, low and moderate income will purchase their Homes subject to resale restrictions, as reflected in a recorded covenant agreement, for a period of forty-five (45) years. If you are interested in the Affordable Housing Units you should consult your sales representative for further information. 23. "Active Adult" Neighborhood. An "Active Adult Neighborhood," the Coventry Court, consists of age restricted residences located within the Community. In Coventry Court, each Home must be occupied by at least one resident who is at least 55 years of age. Coventry Court is a community consisting of approximately 240 Homes and has its own recreational facilities and activities. All assessments for the maintenance of these recreation facilities are the exclusive responsibility of the Coventry Court residents. As a result, the recreational facilities located within Coventry Court are not open to other Owners in the Community; provided, however, Coventry Court residents will have the right to use the recreational facilities located throughout the Community. Master Developer reserves the right to construct other age restricted communities in other locations in the Community. 24. Home Business Use. Any Home within the Community may be used for home based business purposes, provided that such use is subject to the City of Tustin's Home Occupation Ordinance (if applicable), the provisions in Section 2.1 of the Community Declaration and the Community Guidelines. You are advised that the Community Declaration and the Community Guidelines may contain stricter restrictions than those in -the City Ordinance Buyer Initials: ! _10- 2544-33253\CLP428\DISCLSR1 609465.3 6/13/06 and that such use may require zoning clearance and a business license. You should contact the City for more information regarding business uses in your Home. 25. MCAS Tustin. (a) Prior Use as MCAS Tustin. You are advised that the Community was previously used as the Tustin Marine Corps Air Station ("MCAS Tustin'). The Marine Corps and the Department of the Navy ("DON'J are the responsible agencies for the Installation Restoration Program (17RP'). The IRP is a comprehensive environmental investigation and cleanup program formed to identify, investigate and clean up chemical and nuclear contamination that has resulted from past land use operations. When MCAS Tustin was an active base, it received a permit from the California Department of Toxic Substances Control ("DTSC") pursuant to the Federal Resources Conservation and Recovery Act ("RCRA'j (42 U.S.C. 6901 et seq.) to store hazardous waste on portions of the base. One of the conditions of that permit was to perform "corrective action" to clean-up releases of hazardous waste constituents throughout the base. Although the permit has expired, these corrective action obligations continue, and the DON is undertaking environmental investigation and cleanup activities on portions of the former base that are within the Community. (b) Asbestos Containing Material. Hazardous material in the form of asbestos or asbestos -containing materials ("ACM') have been found and are otherwise presumed to exist in buildings and structures previously located in the Community. At such time as demolition of the prior existing buildings on the Community containing ACM was completed, the appropriate governmental regulatory agency confirmed that ACM had been removed from the buildings and any necessary soil remediation had been conducted in accordance with all applicable federal, state and local laws and regulations. (c) Easement for Environmental Remediation. An easement over the Community granted to the United States of America, acting by and through the Department of the Navy ("DON') in a document entitled "Quitclaim Deed for Marble Mountain Parcel and Environmental Restriction Pursuant to Civil Code Section 1471," was recorded on March 11, 2003, as Document No. 200300263521. In connection with ongoing' remediation on the DON's property within the Community, it was agreed, as a covenant running with the land, that the DON and its officers, agents, employees, contractors and subcontractors shall have the right, upon reasonable notice, to enter the Community when a response or corrective action is found to be necessary or when such access is necessary to carry out a response action or corrective action. The right for the DON to enter the Community shall include the right to conduct tests, investigations and surveys, including, where necessary, drilling, test -pitting, boring and other similar activities. Such right shall also include the right to construct, operate, maintain or undertake any other response or corrective action as required or necessary, including, but not limited to, monitoring wells, pumping wells, treatment facilities, and the installing of associated utilities. In exercising these rights of access, except in the case of imminent and substantial endangerment to human health or the environment, the DON shall give reasonable notice of any action to be taken related to such Buyer initials: / _ 1 j _ 2544-33253\CLP4281DISCLSR160"65.3 6/13106 remedial or corrective actions on the Community. Further, the DON will make reasonable efforts to minimize interference with the on going use of the Community and act in good faith to minimize any conflict between the necessary environmental investigation and remediation activities and the use of the Community. The DON is not required to restore or repair any Improvements in the Community damaged as a result of this right to access the Community. If any Improvements on Association Property are damaged as a result of the DON's access to the Community, you are advised that any such damaged Improvement may be repaired or replaced by the Community Association and you may be charged a Reconstruction Assessment or Extraordinary Assessment (if applicable). (d) Groundwater Plume. The City Environmental Impact Report (1999) ("EIR"} indicates the presence of subsurface plumes of chlorinated volatile organic compounds ("VOCs'), dissolved trichloroethene ("TCE11 and methyl tertiary -butyl ether ("MTBE' at ground water level in portions of MCAS Tustin located outside the Community. It is presently unknown whether and to what extent these contaminants will migrate towards the Community. According to the EIR, estimated human health risks associated with residential use of groundwater from the plumes are above the acceptable limits of the United States Environmental Protection Agency. Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders make no representations or warranties with respect to the plumes described above. or whether such plumes will migrate into the groundwater under Community. 26. LIFOC PROPERTY/ENVIRONMENTAL CONDITIONS. Due to its prior use as a military base, certain areas within the Community, designated on the map for Tract No. 16581, as "IRP -13S" and "IRP -13W" (collectively, the "LIFOC Property'!, are owned by the United States of America ("U.S. Government") and will ultimately be annexed into the Covered Property pursuant to Section 16.6 of the Community Declaration. (a) Prior Use of the LIFOC Property. That portion of the LIFOC Property identified as IRP -13S is approximately 0.7 acres and was previously used as a "Temporary Storage Area" ("TSA 'I and as a "Miscellaneous Wash Area" ("MWA"). The TSA consisted of two (2) buildings that were used for vehicle maintenance. Cleaning solvents were reportedly used to wash down floors in the buildings and waste solvent was likely released to storm drains, or to. the ground outside the building. The MWA includes an inactive wash pad formerly used for cleaning small generators and other field equipment. Solvents were used in this area and may have been released to the subsurface through cracks in the concrete pad. That portion of the LIFOC Property identified as IRP 13W was previously used as a former disposal area where hydraulic fluid, diesel fuel, leaded gasoline, oil, paint stripper, batter acid and solvent were stored. (b) Release of Volatile Organic Compounds. As a result of the historic use of the LIFOC Property, hazardous substances have been released into the groundwater at the LIFOC Property. Volatile Organic Compounds ("VOCs"), including trichloroethylene ("TCE'l and 1,2,3 Trichloropropane ("1,2,3 TCP'j, were found in groundwater at concentrations that could result in adverse effect to human health if this water was extracted from the ground and directly used for domestic purposes such as drinking or bathing. However, groundwater at this location is currently not used for such purposes. Buyer Initials; ! -12- 2544-33253TU42MISCLSM 669965.3 6!13/66 (c) Remedial Action Plan. As a result of the release of hazardous substances at the LIFOC Property, various remedial activities have occurred at the LIFOC Property and will continue to occur until remediation goals have been achieved. In October 2004, the Department of Navy issued a report entitled "Final Record of Decision/Remedial Action Plan, Operable Unit 1A, Former Marine Corps Air Station, Tustin, California", which describes the specific remedial action plan ("RAP') that has been approved for IRP 13S to address groundwater contamination. In August 2005, the Department of Navy published a report entitled `Draft Feasibility Study Report for Operable Unit 4B [includes IRP 13W], Former Marine Corps Air Station, Tustin, California," ("Feasibility Study") which addresses a range of remedial alternatives to address the VOCs in groundwater. As documented in the Feasibility Study, "no further action was recommended for soil a OU -413 sites... therefore, soil remediation..." was not addressed in the Feasibility Study. A final groundwater remedial action plan has not yet been selected for IRP 13W. (d) Deed Restrictions. Deed restrictions will ultimately be recorded on all or a portion of the Homesites or Homes in the Community lying within the LIFOC Property, and will limit certain activities on such Homesites or Homes. These deed restrictions will identify specific land use restrictions to prevent exposure of future landowners and/or users of the LIFOC Property to hazardous substances and to maintain the integrity of the remedial action until remediation is complete and remediation goals have been achieved. (e) Documentation Relating to the Release and Remediation Activities. Extensive documentation has been prepared that describes the nature and extent of the release of hazardous substances that has occurred at the LIFOC Property. The following reports are available for public review and document the investigation and remediation work that has been or will be performed at the LIFOC Property: (i) Draft Feasibility Study Report For Operable Unit 4B, Former Marine Corps Air Station, Tustin, California, August 2005 (Bechtel Environmental, Inc., August 2005); (ii) Final Record of Decision/Remedial Action Plan Operable Unit IA, Former Marine Corps Air Station, Tustin, California (Department of Navy, October 2004); (iii) Final Feasibility Study Report, OU -IA, Marine Corps Air Station, Tustin, California (Bechtel Environmental, Inc., August 2003); and (iv) Final Environmental Impact Statement/Environmental Impact Report, Disposal and Reuse of MCAS Tustin, California (Department of Navy and City of Tustin, December 1999). You should carefully review these reports before making a decision to buy a Home in the Community. Copies of the reports are available for review at either (1) BRACS Environmental Coordinator's Office, Library Building 307, WAS El Toro, telephone (949) 726-5398 or (2) City of Tustin, Department of Community Development, 300 Centennial Way, Tustin, CA 92780, telephone (714) 573-3100. The Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders make no representations or warranties with respect to the LIFOC Property and the Buyer Initials: / ..13- 2544-3325MCLP42MISCLSM 6D9965.3 6/13M environmental conditions described above or in the reports. Due to the fact that groundwater in the Community has been found at depths of six (6) to twenty-five (25) feet below the ground surface, as described below, you are advised to avoid eating any fruit from trees with deep root systems in the Community or drinking any groundwater, and to keep your children and animals away from such fruit and groundwater. (f) The following items have been indicated in the EIR as affecting portions of MCAS Tustin that are outside of the Community. These items are not expected to impact the Community, and are listed in this Disclosure for your information only. Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders make no representations or warranties as to any future impact these items may have on the Community or Residents using public parks and other areas outside the Community. (i) Former crash drill site area; (ii) Former skeet ranges; (iii) Transformers containing polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs); (iv) Buildings formerly on property containing lead based paint; (v) Moffit Meadow fire fighting trenches and crash crew burn pits; (vi) JP -5 pipeline, currently classified as out of service; and (vii) Petroleum hydrocarbons in subsurface soil. If you have any questions or concerns about environmental activities at MCAS Tustin or the Community, please contact the Local Redevelopment Authority at the City of Tustin or visit the United States Naval Facilities Engineering Command's internet website at www.efdsw.navfac.navy.mil/Environmentanustin.htm. 27. Prior Agricultural Use. The Community is located on or near lands that are or were previously used for agricultural purposes, including farming operations. By reason of such agricultural use, you may be subject to dust, noise and odors and may be exposed to pesticides, herbicides, insecticides and other chemicals. By acceptance of a deed to a Home, you on your own behalf, and on behalf of the members of your family, tenants, lessees, guests and invitees) expressly acknowledge and accept these existing and future impacts and forever waive any and all causes of actions against the Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders and Community Association and their respective directors, officers, employees, agents, representatives and consultants for any damages or injuries which may arise from or relate to any such conditions or risks. 28. Private Recreational Center. The Community is planned to include a private recreational center (the "Center'l. The Center is planned to include swimming and wading pools, spas and recreational building and other recreational facilities. While the Center is planned to be private and only open to Owners and guests in the Community, the public will have access to the open space areas surrounding the Center and some outdoor recreational Buyer Initials: I -14- 2544-3325%CLP428\QISCLSR\ 609965,3 6/13/06 facilities in the Open Space/Park Areas. All persons using the Center are required to use caution and to watch their children at all times to prevent drowning and other injuries. The Community Association may, from time to time, promulgate rules for use and operation of the Center, including reasonable hours of operation. Owners and other residents living in the area of the Center will most likely experience and otherwise be subject to or inconvenienced by noise and pedestrian and vehicular traffic in the areas surrounding the Center. 29. Natural Hazard Zone Disclosures. Your Neighborhood Builder will provide you with a Natural Hazard Disclosure Statement in compliance with Section 1103 of the California Civil Code that discloses whether your Home is located in a seismic hazard zone. (a) Earthquakes. California is subject to a wide range of earthquake activity. California has many known earthquake faults as well as yet undiscovered faults. While the Community is not located in an Alquist Priolo Earthquake Zone, earthquakes are always a possibility. You must evaluate the potential for future seismic activity that may seriously damage your Homesite and Home.. A major earthquake, which some have predicted will occur in our lifetimes, could cause very serious damage to Homes located even many miles from the epicenter of the earthquake. A more moderate earthquake occurring on a more minor fault, or on an as yet undiscovered fault, could also cause substantial damage. For more information, read "The Homeowners Guide to Earthquake Safety" which explains the various geological hazards associated with earthquakes and contains information on planning ahead for earthquakes, as well as what to do during and after an earthquake. Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders make no representations or warranties as to the degree of earthquake risk in the Community. You are advised to consult with the City, County, other public agencies and appropriate experts to evaluate the potential risk. (b) Seismic Hazard Zones. Many portions of California are subject to risks associated with seismic activity. Areas that meet the definition of "Seismic Hazard Zone" in the Seismic Hazards Mapping Act (California Public Resources Code Section 2690, et seq.) are shown on maps that are prepared and released by the California Department of Conservation, Division of Mines and Geology. Such zones may pose an increased risk of damage to property from earthquakes and liquefaction. "Liquefaction" is the process by which water -saturated soils become unstable under heaving shaking and thereby jeopardize foundations and other structures. The Master Developer has been informed that all or a portion of the Community is located within a Seismic Hazard Zone. You are advised to consult with the City, County, other public agencies and appropriate experts to evaluate the potential risk. For more information concerning seismic activity and risks, read "The Homeowner's Guide to Earthquake Safety." (c) Area of Potential Flooding. The Master Developer has been informed that the Community is located within an Area of Potential Flooding (or Dam Inundation Zone) pursuant to applicable maps. The Office of Emergency Services is required to designate areas within which personal injury or death would, in its determination, result from the partial or total failure of any dam. These areas of potential flooding, as defined in the California Emergency Services Act (California Government Code Section 8984.4, etseq.), are shown on maps released by the Office of Emergency Services, copies of which are also on file with the City. These maps are updated periodically, and the Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders and Community Association make no representations, guarantees or warranties with respect to any future dam Buyer bitials! ! _ j S_ 2544-332531CLP42901SCLSM 609965.3 6/13/06 inundation zone determinations. The Community is downstream from the Santiago Creek Dam, an earthfill dam approximately one hundred and thirty-six (136) feet high which has a capacity of 25,000 acre feet of water. Santiago Creek Dam is jointly owned and maintained by the Serrano Irrigation District and the Irvine Ranch Water District. Information about the Santiago Creek Dam can be found on the California Department of Water Resources website: http://cdec.water.ca.gov/misc/resinfo.htjnl. Please contact the Office of Emergency Services for further information concerning Areas of Potential Flooding. 30. Soil Conditions. In purchasing your Home, you should review soils reports for the Community, available for review at the City, and take into consideration the following: (a) Expansive Soil. According to the soils report, soil in the Community is highly expansive in nature. Expansive soil expands when it becomes wet and it contracts when it dries out. Expansion and contraction of soils may cause movement, lifting, cracking and distress in slabs, patios, sidewalks and other flatwork improvements. Some cracking is normal in all flatwork improvements, with or without expansive soils. However, some expansion damage may be reduced by use of appropriate design and construction techniques. When designing flatwork and other Improvements, you should advise your consultants that designs must accommodate soils with expansion potential. In addition, you should consider the following information and recommendations before making or modifying any Improvements. (b) Concrete and Masonry Improvements. Special attention is required in designing and constructing concrete and masonry Improvements such as masonry walls and planters, concrete slabs and decking. For example, steel reinforcing bars may be required in lieu of steel mesh in concrete patio slabs. Block walls may require extra horizontal and vertical steel reinforcing bars. (c) Drainage and Irrigation. Owners must use adequate drainage and irrigation control. Drainage devices installed in the Community by the Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders should not be altered in any manner that will redirect or obstruct drainage through these devices. The construction or modification of Improvements should not result in ponding of water. Drainage devices, including, but not limited to, concrete ditches, area drain lines and gutters should be carefully designed and installed with professional assistance and then maintained in an unobstructed condition. Drainage devices installed by the Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders designed to serve more than the (1) Home should not be altered in a manner that will redirect or obstruct the drainage through these drainage devices. The landscape irrigation system should be designed, constructed and operated to prevent excessive saturation of soils. Water must drain away from the Home footings and other Improvements. Obstructions such as walls should not be constructed across swales unless adequate replacement drainage Improvements have been installed or created. Planters should be lined with an impervious surface and should contain outlets to drain excess water. (d) Fill Sail. Homes in the Community may be constructed on fill soil in accordance with the recommendations and inspection of licensed civil and soils engineers. A soils report certifying the compaction of fill soils is available for review at the City. Buyer Initials: / -16- 2544-33253TLP428WISCLSM 609965.3 6/1310* (e) Corrosive Soil. Soils in some areas of the Community are potentially severely corrosive to buried concrete and ferrous metals. Soluble sulfates and acidic soils are highly corrosive to buried metals and concrete and should be taken into account in the construction of below grade structures and hardscape. Sulfates may chemically and physically attack concrete that is not sulfate resistant, causing the concrete to break down. Thus, you must use the proper type of cement and water -to -cement ratio for the level of sulfates or acidity that exists on your Homesite. Overwatering soil will exacerbate the corrosivity of the soil. You should inform contractors of this potential condition to allow them to use appropriate measures to combat the effects of corrosive soil on buried metals, below grade structures and hardscape. M Groundwater. Groundwater has been encountered in portions of the Community at depths of six (6) to twenty-five (25) feet below the ground surface. You may not dig or drill on any Homesite to a depth that would disturb or otherwise come in contact with the groundwater. Groundwater may rise during the rainy season. (g) Pools/Spas. Prior to designing any pool, spa, or other similar amenity, it is recommended you consult with a licensed civil engineer to determine the depth of the water table under your Homesite to insure that your Improvements are compatible with the depth of the water table and that they will not disturb or come in contact with the groundwater during a rainy season. The Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders make no guarantee that any Homesite has the ability for pool or spa installation. Homesites 242 through 245, inclusive, of Tract No. 16581, which are located within the LIFOC Property, have been determined to be unsuitable for installation of pools, spas or other similar amenity. The deeds for these Lots will contain deed restrictions that prohibit the use of the Lots for such purposes. (h) Soils Professionals. Before starting a pool or spa or any patio, concrete or other flatwork on the Homesite, you should consult with a licensed soils engineer to ensure that such work is constructed correctly in light of current soils conditions. Although consulting with a soils professional may add substantially to the cost of installation of improvements, failure to do so may result in significant breaking, lifting, separating, tilting or cracking in improvements. (i) Interior Gases and Other Contaminants. The aging process of soil and natural soil elements, as well as the aging of man-made building materials, may create unwanted and undesired gases and other contaminants in homes, both new and previously occupied. In addition, a lower rate of air exchange between outdoor and indoor environments has resulted from modern construction techniques which comply with energy conservation requirements enacted by the State of California. A lower air exchange rate can result in the build-up of unwanted gases and other contaminants in varying degrees. As the quality of the air we breathe can affect our health, you should frequently air out your Home by opening the windows. 31. Post -Tension Concrete System. Your Horne may have been built using a post - tension concrete system ("System'). If any portion of your Home has been constructed using the System, a placard or stamp will be placed in the garage signifying the existence of such System. The System involves placing steel cables under high tension in the concrete slab located beneath the Home. Therefore, any attempt to alter or pierce the foundation (for example, sawing, cutting or drilling) could damage the integrity of the System and cause serious injury or damage to persons and property. The Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders shall not be Buyer Initials: / -17. 2544-33253%CLP42MISCLSR\ 609965.3 6113/06 responsible for any damage or injury resulting from or arising in connection with the alteration of the slab or foundation of any Horne. By acceptance of a deed to a Home, you agree that: (i) you shall not cut into or otherwise tamper with the System; (ii) you shall not knowingly permit or allow any other person to out into or tamper with the System so long as you own any interest in the Home; (iii) you shall disclose the existence of the System to any person who rents, leases or purchases your Home; and (iv) you shall indemnify and hold the Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders and all of their affiliated entities, officers, directors, agents and assigns free and harmless from any and all claims, damages, losses or other liability (including attorneys' fees and costs) arising from any breach of this covenant. 32. Reclaimed Water. In its efforts to conserve water, the Irvine Ranch Water District (the "Water District") requires the use of reclaimed water (treated wastewater) to irrigate parks, school yards, golf courses, greenbelt areas and common areas. The Water District may require the use of reclaimed water to irrigate landscaping in private yards. The water used in the Homes and outside in the patio and yard areas through hose bibs will be domestic potable water. The water used to irrigate the Association Property may include reclaimed water. Reclaimed water is not potable and therefore not suitable for human consumption. As with any water overspray, the repeated spray of reclaimed water may stain or discolor personal property, fencing and structural Improvements. According to the Water District, the Water District's reclaimed water is disinfected with chlorine and its clarity to the human eye is indistinguishable from domestic water. The standards imposed on the Water District for reclaimed water quality are established by governmental regulatory agencies, and these. standards are subject to change. The Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders and Community Association and their agents are not liable for any property damage or personal injury by reclaimed water. You are subject to Water District rules and regulations, one of which prohibits the use of self -generating water softeners connected to Water District sewer facilities. Further information regarding Water District regulations is available at the Water District's headquarters. 33. Air Quality. Southern California is subject to Stage I smog alerts. You should take advantage of the Air Quality Management District's forecasts to plan your outdoor activities to avoid peak pollution by checking your television, radio or daily newspapers to find out if unhealthful air quality is expected. For more information, you can also call A.Q.M.D. at 1 -800 -CUT -SMOG (1-800-288-7664) or check their website at www.agmd.gov. By acceptance of a deed to a Home, you (for and on your behalf, and the members of your family, tenants, lessees, guests and invitees) expressly acknowledge and accept the existing and possible future impacts of smog on yourself and your family and forever waive any and all causes of actions against the Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders and their respective directors, officers, employees, agents,, representatives and consultants for any damages or injuries which may arise from or relate to any such conditions or risks. 34. Wind. All of Southern California is subject to periods of high winds. Wind speeds in the Community may exceed that experienced in other areas of the surrounding region. You must ensure that any structures or other Improvements you install on your Homesite are constructed or designed to withstand high winds. You are advised to consult with experienced Buyer initials: 1 _ j $. 2544-33253TU428WISCLSM 604465.3 6!13/06 architects and engineers in the design and specification of any structures or Improvements that you plan to add. 35. Private Streets. All of the streets within the Community are private streets. Maintenance and repair of the private streets is the responsibility of the Community Association or the Neighborhood Associations, as applicable. 36. Building Setbacks. Construction of Improvements in the.yard of any Homesite such as pools, spas, patio covers, BBQ, fountains, trellises and water features are subject to minimum setback and height restrictions and may not be permitted. You should refer to the Community Association Governing Documents and applicable City ordinances for any restrictions concerning the construction of any Improvements to your Homesite. 37. Boundaries. You may not rely on any written or oral statements by Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders or their agents regarding the exact boundaries of your Homesite or Home or whether any wall or fence has been or will be constructed exactly on the boundaries of your Homesite. 38. Square Footage Representations. Representations of square footage are approximate only. You may not rely on any written (brochures and other sales documents) or verbal statements by Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders or their agents regarding the exact square footage of your Homesite or Home. The computation of square footage varies based on the criteria used. You agree by acceptance of a deed to a Home to hold the Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders harmless in any dispute arising over any representations concerning the square footage of your Homesite or Home. TAXES AND ASSESSMENTS 39. Supplemental Real Property Taxes. The California law requires real property to be revalued whenever it changes ownership or when improvements are newly constructed. After the Close of Escrow for your Home, the County of Orange Tax Assessor ("Assessor") will determine a new taxable value for your Home based' on current market values. The property tax will increase and you will receive one or more supplemental tax bills depending upon the time of the year in which Escrow closed for the purchase of your Home. Master Developers and Neighborhood Builders have no control over the valuation, timing or the amount of the supplemental bill resulting from the reassessment. You are solely responsible for the payment of any supplemental tax bills. The following notice is given pursuant to Section 1142.6c of the California Civil Code: "California property tax law requires the Assessor to revalue real property at the time the ownership of the property changes. Because of this law, you may receive one or two supplemental tax bills, depending on when your loan closes. The supplemental tax bills are not mailed to your lender. If you have arranged for your property tax payments to be paid through an impound account, the supplemental tax bills will not be paid by your lender. It is your responsibility to pay these supplemental bills directly to the Tax Collector. If Buyer Initials: 1 —19_ 2541-332531CLP429\D1SCLSR1609965.3 6/13/06 you have any. question concerning this matter, please call your local Tax Collector's Office." Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders have no control over the valuation, timing or the amount of the supplemental bill resulting from the reassessment. You are solely responsible for the payment of the supplemental tax bill. You hereby acknowledge, accept and agree that neither Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders nor any of their authorized agents, representatives, employees or sales ale have made any representations or warranties respecting the amount of the supplemental assessment or the assessed value. Should you have any questions or concerns relating to the supplem mtal assessment, you agree, prior to the CIose of Escrow, to consult with the County Assessor or your legal or other advisors to satisfy such questions or concerns. 40. Estimated Taxes. You have been provided with an estimate of your assessments. THE AMOUNT OF ASSESSMENTS ARE ESTIMATES ONLY, and are based on current information provided by the City, County or those public or private agencies responsible for the administration for the districts. These assessments may INCREASE or DECREASE, based upon changes in real property tax law; the district(s) may dissolve; formation of new districts may occur, an extension of the districts or the services to the districts and other factors NOT IN MASTER DEVELOPER'S OR NEIGHBORHOOD BUILDER'S CONTROL may transpire. The amount of special taxes may appear on your property tax bill or may be billed separately. 41. Special Tax Assessment Districts. All or a portion of the Community lies within the boundaries of the following Special Tax and Assessment Districts: (a) Proposed Tustin LLD. Master Developer currently intends to form a landscape and lighting maintenance assessment district with the City of Tustin ("Proposed City LLD'. The Proposed City LLD is expected to be formed to pay for the maintenance of public street lighting, landscaping and park maintenance within the Proposed City LLD area. (b) Proposed Tustin CFD. Master Developer currently intends to form a community facilities district with the City of Tustin ("Proposed City CFD 'I which would pay for the maintenance of City park improvements, biking and hiking trails, road improvements, dry and wet utilities and the MCAS Tustin Master infrastructure -backbone improvement items. Please contact the City of Tustin (City Clerk), telephone (714) 573-3025 for additional information. `Ch1h "C h er►ti At le 6 d five% /0%* p VetwJtb �. (c) Recreation and Improvement Maintenance District. The Irvine Unified School District has formed a recreation and improvement maintenance district which is an annual assessment for maintenance of public sports/playfields. Please contact David Taussig & Associates, telephone (949) 955-1500 for additional information. The Neighborhood Builder will provide you with disclosures entitled "Notice of Special Tax" ("Notice") prior to entering into a contract to purchase a Home. These Notices will inform you of the special tax and assessment districts that apply to your Home. The Notices will also contain a detailed description of the special tax calculation, important information about functions and rights of the special tax and assessment districts, your obligations, and who to Buyer Initials: ,1 _20- 2544-33253TI-P428\131SC7_S12\ 6499M 3 6113/06 contact for additional information about the special tax and assessment districts. You should thoroughly understand the information contained in the Notices prior to entering into a contract to purchase a Home. You will have five days after the Notice is delivered by mail, or three days after its delivery in person, to terminate the contract to purchase by giving written notice of that termination. All Homes will be subject to annual special taxes levied by one or more of the special tax and assessment districts listed above. Not all special tax or assessment districts listed above will apply to your Home. These special taxes will be a continuing lien on your Home and will be billed to you with the annual real property tax bill issued by the County Assessor. The lien of these special taxes will continue until the obligation is satisfied. If you fail to pay a special tax when due, the assessment districts may exercise their right to foreclose on your Home. Information concerning the estimated amount of the annual special tax on your Home for the special tax and assessment districts is available from the City and County. 42. Changes in Special Taxes. The amount of any special taxes disclosed to you are estimates only, and are based on current information provided by the City, County or other public or private agencies responsible for the administration of special tax districts. Special taxes may increase or decrease, based upon the terms of the special tax lien, changes in real property tax law, the dissolution of special tax districts, the formation of new special tax districts, extension of special tax district(s), changes in services by the districts and other facts not in Master Developer's or Neighborhood Builders' control. The amount of special taxes may appear on your real property tax bill or may be billed separately. ADJACENT AREA DISCLOSURES 43. Adjacent Property Disclosures. The land adjacent to the Community within the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan has a variety of land use designations. The land use designations are subject to change. Therefore, the type of future development adjacent to the Community cannot be predicted with accuracy. 44. WAS Specific Plan. MCAS Tustin was realigned and closed on July 2, 1999, in accordance with Base Realignment and Closure Act. The Department of Defense recognized the City of Tustin as the Lead Agency or Local Redevelopment Authority ("LRA') for preparation of the required reuse planning documents in late 1991. The WAS Tustin Specific Plan/Reuse Plan (the "Plan') includes detailed planning, policies, regulations, implementation strategies and procedures necessary to guide the reuse and development of the site into the next century. Since implementation of the Plan will be a long- term process and there are unique circumstances associated with converting military bases to civilian uses, the Plan is intended to be practical in economic terms and visionary in terms of its ability to create and respond to future market opportunities. This means that it must provide sufficient guidance to provide investors with a high confidence level that their investments will be protected. At the same time, it must offer sufficient flexibility to respond to changing market conditions. A careful balance between certainty and flexibility underlies the provisions of this Plan. Buyer Initials: / -21- 2544-332331CLP4281DISCLSR160M.3 6/13/06 The Plan is intended to serve as both a policy -oriented and regulatory document. The Plan has been submitted to the Department of Defense as a policy guide outlining the intended reuse for the Community. Subsequently, the Plan will be adopted by the Tustin City Council as the zoning for the Community. The Plan may also be amended one or more times by the City of Tustin. The Plan is one device for implementing goals and policies of the Tustin General Plan. The Plan also contains the development and reuse regulations that constitute the zoning for the Community. As a federal installation, MCAS Tustin was not subject to local zoning and planning requirements. Upon conversion to civilian use, the former MCAS Tustin property will be under the jurisdictional authority of either the City of Tustin or the City of Irvine, as applicable, and will be subject to local codes and ordinances. The City of Irvine has assigned responsibility for preparation of the Plan (and accompanying joint Environmental Impact Statement/Environmental Impact Report) to Tustin for that portion of the Plan area within Irvine. However, the City of Irvine will have to adopt any General Plan and zoning changes necessary to implement the provisions of the Plan within the City of Irvine. The land uses described in the Plan for the area covered by the Plan include, but are not limited to, Low -High Density Residential, Transitional and Affordable Housing, Golf Resort Living, Commercial Business and Retail, and Institutional/R.ecreational designations such as Parks, Trails and Schools. Also recommended were applications by the Orange County Sheriffs Department, City of Tustin and County of Orange Social Service Agency. The Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders have no control over the Plan, changes to the Plan, or development of the area covered by the Plan in accordance with the Plan. For further information, you should review the Plan. The Plan and information regarding the development of the Plan is available for review at the office of the Local Redevelopment Agency, City of Tustin. 45. The District. The District is a proposed one million square foot outdoor shopping center to be located approximately one and one-half (1 %s) miles southwest of the Community, at the corner of Jamboree Road and Barmnca Parkway. The District is planned to include, among other businesses, several retail stores, a grocery store and a movie theater. The District will result in increased noise and traffic in and around the Community, particularly along Jamboree Road and Barranca Parkway. Neither Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders nor the Community Association have any control over the use or maintenance of the District or its impact on the Community. 46. Rail Corridor/ Metrolink Station. As disclosed in the Homebuyer Notification, there is a rail corridor ("Corridor') located to the north of the Community. There is also a Metrolink station ("Station') located to the north of the Community at 2975 Edinger Avenue, Tustin, CA 92780. The impact of the Corridor and Station may include, without limitation, increased noise, light and vibration levels in the vicinity of the Community. The Corridor and Station could be an attractive nuisance to children and animals who may wish to play in the vicinity of the rail corridor. The Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders and the Community Association have no control over the use, maintenance or care of the Corridor or Station. You acknowledge and understand that you are responsible for keeping your children and animals Buyer Initials: / -22- 2544.33253\CLP42MDISCLSR\ 6499453 &I V06 away from the Corridor and Station and the danger that is inherent around the Corridor and Station. You should evaluate the impact of the Corridor and Station on your decision to purchase a Home in the Community. 47. Temporary Sewer Lift Station. A temporary sewer lift station will be constructed within the vicinity of the Community at the northeast corner of West Connector and Valencia North Loop Road to serve the Community. The lift station will be installed below - grade and will be constructed, owned and maintained by the Master Developer. Owners of Homes near the lift station may experience an increase in noise and dust levels in the area of the lift station during the construction period and less significant noise levels after completion. Owners may encounter some odors in the areas near the lift station. You acknowledge, understand and agree that neither the Community Association nor the Neighborhood Builders will have any control over the use, maintenance or care of the lift station. 48. Areas Outside the Specific Plan. The MCAS Tustin Specific Plan, which is bounded by Edinger Avenue, Redhill Avenue, Barranca Parkway and Harvard Avenue has the following surrounding uses. (a) A rail corridor and Metrolink station (described above) are located along Edinger Avenue; (b) A business park, commercial and industrial areas, sports park and utility power lines are located along Barranca Parkway; (c) Adjacent to the west side of Warner Avenue exists a Southern California Edison easement with high voltage transmission lines and usages by a wholesale plant nursery and public storage facility; and (d) A Southern California Edison easement area with high voltage transmission lines, landscaped areas available for public access and residential neighborhoods are located along Harvard Avenue. The Master Developer, Neighborhood Builder and the Community Association have no control over development outside of the Community. 49. Airport Proximity Disclosure. The Community is located within what is known as an airport influence area (as defined in California Civil Code Section 1353) surrounding John Wayne Airport. John Wayne Airport is located approximately 3.6 miles southwest of the Community at the (405) San Diego Freeway and MacArthur Boulevard in the City of Santa Ana. For that reason, the Community may be subject to some of the annoyances or inconveniences associated with proximity to airport operations (for example; noise, vibration or odors). Individual sensitivities to those annoyances can vary from person to person. You,may wish to consider what airport annoyances, if any, are associated with the, Community before you complete your purchase and determine whether they are acceptable to ydu. John Wayne Airport has noise abatement procedures in place, but there is no guarantee that these procedures will lessen the impacts on the Community of noise and vibrations caused by aircraft using this airport or that these noise abatement procedures will continue in the future. Further information is Boyer initials:. ! -23- 2544.3325ACLP428MISCLSM 609965.3 6!13/46 available from the airport website: www.ocair.com. Your Neighborhood Builder will provide you with a separate airport proximity notice required by California Civil Code Section 1353. 50. Avigation Easement. An avigation easement has been recorded against the Community. The avigation easement establishes a permanent right to travel through the air space over the Community for the benefit of John Wayne Airport. You may notice noise and vibration from overflying aircraft approaching or leaving the airstrip. By accepting a deed to a Home in the Community, you understand that the avigation easement gives the users of the airstrip a perpetual legal right to fly over the Community without interference from the occupants of the Community. 51. Residential Developments. There are existing single-family residential developments adjacent to the northern, eastern and western boundaries of the Community. In addition to increased automobile and pedestrian traffic resulting from the proximity of these residential developments to the Community, the solitude of a Home's yard area may be significantly impacted by the proximity, height and design of multi -story, residential buildings constructed on property adjacent to the Community. The Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders have no control over the proximity, height and design of such nearby buildings and make no representation on the future impacts that these residential developments will have on residents of the Community. 52. Commercial/Industrial Property. The Community is located within the vicinity of property zoned for commercial and heavy industrial uses. This area consists of, among others, a Waste Management Public Recycling/ Transferring Station, asphalt recycling, trucking facilities and multiple concrete companies, all with product deliveries. These commercial and industrial properties may generate dust, offensive odor, noise and other effects. The Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders have no control over the existing or potential uses of this property. These uses may create light, noise and other nuisances twenty-four (24) hours a day, seven (7) days a week. 53. Elementary School. The Tustin Unified School District owns an elementary school site located to the southeast of the Community. Owners and other residents within the Community may experience, among other things, glare from bright lights, noise and increased traffic and parking congestion in connection with the use of this site. There are no assurances if or when any school will be completed on the site, nor the type of facilities that may be included as part of the school. You should contact the Tustin Unified School District at (714) 730-7301 for more information. Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders and the Community Association make no representations as to the future use of this school site. 54. Development Area. The Community lies in a rapidly expanding area. As future commercial and residential developments are built in and around MCAS Tustin, you may expect attendant limitations on solitude and inconveniences. For example, you can expect to hear noise from the development of future adjacent residential and commercial• areas and the machinery used to develop these areas. You can also expect increased traffic and rerouting of traffic as new residential and commercial developments are constructed, nearby streets and major thoroughfares are widened and new streets are built. As the area around the Community develops, you may experience light entering your Horne from exterior sources including Buyer Initials: / -24- 2544-33253\CLP428\DISCLSR\ 649965,3 6/13/46 er streetlights, parking lot lighting and nearby residential and commercial buildings. The Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders and the Community Association have no control over the transmission of noise, light, vibration, odor and other impacts or their potential effects on Homes in the Community, including any which may be a direct result of current and future construction activity. 55. MCAS Tustin Airship Hangars. Two (2) airship hangars ("Hangars'l are located within MCAS Tustin southwest of the Community. The hangars are each approximately one thousand (1,000) feet long, three hundred (300) feet wide, and one hundred and seventy (170) feet tall. The view from your Home may be effected by the nearby presence of the Hangars. It has not been determined whether these Hangars will remain or be demolished, or what uses might be made of them. For further information regarding the Hangars, please contact the City of Tustin. 56. Future Fire Station Site. The Community is located adjacent to a future fire station site at the corner of Edinger Avenue and West Connector Road. The fire station will operate twenty four (24) hours a day and seven (7) days a week. Owners whose Homes are located in the vicinity of the fire station will notice noise, sirens, light, glare and other impacts from the operation of the fire station and emergency vehicles. You are advise that Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders have no control over the operation or use of the fire station. You should carefully evaluate the impact of the fire station on your decision to purchase a Homesite or Home in the Community. 57. Village Services. The Community is located northwest of an area designated in the Pian as the Village Services area. When and if built, this area is intended to be accessible to both vehicle and pedestrian traffic, and to provide localized commercial retail and service uses to adjacent residential areas within the Plan area. 58. Learning Village/Transitional and Emergency Housing. The Community is located east of an area designated in the Plan as the Learning Village area. When and if built, this area is intended to provide a specialized educational environment with a variety of public - serving uses. GENERAL DISCLOSURES 59. Neighborhood Model Homes. Neighborhood model homes reflect typical exterior elevations, floor plans and methods of construction, and also illustrate possibilities for future interior decoration and exterior landscaping and hardscape improvements. Your Home will not necessarily conform to any model shown. The exterior elevations, architectural treatments, floor plans and colors shown on the master plot plans on display at the office of each Neighborhood Builder may be different than those both displayed in the models and those actually constructed by the Neighborhood Builder. Additionally, window locations, window types, roof lines, architectural projections and other similar features vary by elevation and Home location, and not all of the features displayed in the models may be ineldded in your Home. The models have also been professionally decorated to show various decor ideas. Decoration items such as furnishings, draperies and other window treatments, any window tinting, wallpaper, custom carpet, coordinated paint, built-in shelves, beams, certain lighting fixtures (including Buyer initials: / _25_ 2544-33253TU4281131SCLSM609965.3 6/13/06 halogen lighting), special ceiling treatments and some mirrors are for display purposes only, and are not included in the purchase price for your Home. Entries, walkways and driveways are shown in a variety of materials to show design ideas; however, for your Horne, they will be constructed using only standard concrete. The hardscape shown in the model complex may not depict what may be constructed in all locations. Additionally, landscaping for the models is greater in density and type than any landscape package offered by a Neighborhood Builder. If not expressly included in the purchase price for your Home in writing by a Neighborhood Builder, the rear, side and front yard landscaping is your responsibility. The type of plants, and the size and density of the landscaping in the yards of the models are merely intended to suggest ideas to you. Certain models may also include hardscape items (patio slabs, patio covers, pools, spas, etc.) which are not included in the purchase price of your Home. All such options and upgrades displayed in the models (including decorator items, landscaping and hardscape) are not included in the purchase price for your Home unless expressly agreed to in writing by the Neighborhood Builder. You should consult your sales representative for additional information regarding non-standard items used in the model homes. 64. Extended Use of the Model Complex. Each Neighborhood Builder reserves the right to use one or more Homes in a Neighborhood as a sales office and model home complex, and to display signs and banners, in connection with its program of marketing and selling Homes in the Neighborhood as well as other Homes owned by Neighborhood Builders, even if they are located in separate and unrelated Neighborhoods. 61. Grading Variations. Your Homesite has been graded to City specifications and may vary significantly from other Homesites. Variations may include slopes, swales, drains, flood control channels and retaining walls as required. Any changes made to the grading of the Hon which your Home is located may significantly affect you or your neighbor's drainage pattern and cause significant property damage to your Home or a neighbor's Home. 62, Wall/Ceiling Heights. Wail and ceiling heights and configurations may vary significantly by elevation. Your Home's walls and ceiling heights may be different from those used in the model homes. You are encouraged to speak to a sales representative if you have any questions. 63. Right of Substitution. From time to time due to unavailability and other production considerations, it is necessary for a Neighborhood Builder to make substitutions of materials and other items used in construction of the Homes from those materials and items displayed in the models. Therefore, each Neighborhood Builder reserves the right to make any changes or substitutions as the Neighborhood Builder deems necessary or desirable to the color schemes, building materials, fixtures, appliances and other components of the Homes. The foregoing substitutions may include, without limitation, kitchen appliances, household fixtures, electrical outlets and switches, hardware, wall surfaces, painting and other similar items. Each Neighborhood Builder shall have the right to make the substitutions described above without adjustment to the purchase price of your Home. 64. Changes in Construction Plans. The construction, grading, drainage and improvement plans (collectively, the "Construction Plans') for Homesites and Homes within each Neighborhood all contain dimensions that are approximate. They are not intended to be Buyer Initials: 1 -26- 2544-3325MCLP42811DISCLSM 609965,3 6113106 precise dimensions with regard to the Neighborhood. Room dimensions and electrical outlet placement will vary slightly from models and from printed information. Construction will be performed in substantial conformance with the Construction Plans, but dimensions may change slightly from them. If there is a discrepancy between the Construction Plans and the actual as - built conditions of your Homesite or Horne, the as -built conditions will control. The usable or buildable area, location and configuration of the Homesite and all improvements located thereon may fluctuate from that shown or displayed to you in the Construction Plans or any other drawings, topographic maps or models based upon a Neighborhood Builder's construction of final improvements including, without limitation, fencing and slopes, which shall be constructed in a Neighborhood Builder's sole and absolute discretion. The location, size, height and composition of all walls and fences to be constructed on your Homesite or Home or adjacent to your it shall be determined by the Neighborhood Builder in its sole and absolute discretion and despite the Construction Plans or any other models, drawings or topographic maps displayed to you. The Neighborhood Builder makes no representations, warranties or assurances as to the size, height, location or composition of any wall or fence to be constructed on or adjacent to your Homesite or Home. The Construction Plans are subject to change at any time without notice or obligation. 65. Non -Standard Construction. You may not personally perform any changes of any kind to your Home (such as alarm systems, home intercoms, stereo wiring, etc.) during construction and prior to the Close of Escrow. Such changes may void your warranty. Only those options and upgrades specifically agreed to by the Neighborhood Builder will be made. Any other changes and unapproved options found in a Home during the construction period will be removed by the Neighborhood Builder and the cost of removal and any repairs shall be your responsibility. 66. Changes In Development Plan and Prices. The residential real estate market continually fluctuates due to changes in economic, social and political conditions that directly affect the supply of and demand for housing. As a result, the development plan for the Neighborhood and the Community, and home prices and the terms and conditions of sale are also subject to change. Therefore: (a) With the exception of your Home, each Neighborhood Builder reserves the right at any time prior to or after the Close of Escrow for the sale of a Home and without notice, (i) to increase or decrease the sale price, adjust incentives or otherwise adjust the terms and conditions of sale for Homes in the Neighborhood or in the Community, and (ii) change the number, size, location, elevation, design or type of homes constructed in current or future phases of development of the Neighborhood; (b) No Neighborhood Builder is obligated to offer you the same price, incentives or other terms and conditions of sale that the Neighborhood Builder has previously offered or may subsequently offer to another purchaser; (c) No Neighborhood Builder has either offered or agreed to any price protection or other similar commitment to you regarding the value or resale value of your Home (or any other property), and no Neighborhood Builder shall not have any obligation or liability Buyer lnitials: / -27- 2544-33253TI.P429MISCLSM 609965.3 6/13/06 whatsoever to you in the event any price changes directly or indirectly affect the value of your Home; (d) When you entered into a Purchase Agreement, the Neighborhood Builder may have owned other properties which may have been off the market and may not have been shown to or otherwise made available for purchase by you. No Neighborhood Builder has any obligation to notify you if any of such properties come on the market or are otherwise available for purchase or any obligation to notify you of any future properties the Neighborhood Builder may develop and make available for purchase. (e) You shall not hold a Neighborhood Builder responsible for any fluctuations in the purchase price of Homes within the Neighborhood or the Community. in consideration of a Neighborhood Builder's agreement to sell a Home to you, you agree that you shall have no claims against the Master Developer or the Neighborhood Builder for any possible change (decrease or increase) in the purchase price of Homes within the Neighborhood or any other terms of purchase, including, without limitation, upgrades or other concessions or incentives offered by a Neighborhood Builder to other purchasers of Homes within the Neighborhood and the construction of any additional floor plans on any of the Homes in the Neighborhood. 67. Use of Subcontractors. Neighborhood Builders generally perform construction through the use of subcontractors, and may not employ construction trades or workers. A Neighborhood Builder is not permitted to change its subcontracts without approval of the respective subcontractor; therefore, you may not request interior or exterior construction changes or alterations not otherwise offered to other purchasers in the sales office. 68. Elevation/Floor Plan Specifications. In order to provide architectural diversity in the street scene, each Neighborhood Builder's architect has produced more than one exterior design (elevation) for each floor plan. Consequently, differences may be noticed between the model home for your floor plan and the elevation of your Home. You acknowledge that you have received a description of the exterior configuration for the elevation and the exterior color scheme number for your Home. You also acknowledge that your Home's elevation and floor plan may vary from the configuration of the model home for your Home in terms of layout, sizes of certain rooms, exterior elevation features and other items such as sloped ceilings, veneer treatments, window locations and sizes, roof lines and color schemes. 69. Upper Floor Weight Limits. The upper floors of Homes are designed to support weight limits as outlined in the Uniform Building Code ("UBC"). If you currently own or are planning to purchase a waterbed, pool table or other heavy furniture you must confirm with the manufacturer that the weight introduced by these items does not exceed the UBC weight limit. Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders shall not be responsible for damage caused by anything you place on the upper floors that exceeds the UBC weight limit. 70. Air 'Conditioning. The air conditioning system and equipment specifications installed in the model homes may vary and operate at a higher capacity than those provided in your Home. You are encouraged to speak with your sales representative to determine the exact equipment specifications that will be provided with your Home. The location of the air Buyer Initials; / _28_ 2544.332531CLP42801SCLSk1609%5.3 6113/06 conditioning compressor may vary between the model and your Horne and between your Home and other Homes in your Neighborhood. 71. Alarm System. If you purchase an alarm system from a Neighborhood Builder, you specifically waive any claims against Master Developer, the Neighborhood Builder and the Community Association as a result of any failure of the alarm system to warn, frighten off, or alert anyone about intruders or any other problems. The sale of such system to you by the Neighborhood Builder is not a guarantee or warranty against criminal acts. Master Developer, the Neighborhood Builders and the Community Association are not insurers against criminal acts. 72. Energy Conservation. Homes in the Community meet or exceed the energy conservation standards that are a part of Title 24 of the California Administrative Code. Each Neighborhood Builder is required to design and install heating and cooling units that meet strict guidelines in Title 24. This is an energy conservation law that is designed to help reduce the overall use of energy in your Home. Title 24 describes the amount of cooling capacity as well as the minimum efficiency ratings for each geographic location in the state. In complying with Title 24, the cooling units installed in your Home are designed for maximum efficiency. Due to the Title 24 geographic requirements, on extremely warm days your inside room temperature may be warmer than your thermostat selection. This is due to design restrictions imposed by Title 24, not any design or installation defect by the Neighborhood Builder or its contractor. 73. Water Conservation. Each Home in the Community is equipped with low flow fixtures and other equipment to aid in water conservation in compliance with the City's Conditions of Approval for the Neighborhood. 74. Gas Barbecue Stub. If a natural gas service line is stubbed -out to an exterior backyard wall of your Home, it is suitable only for use in connection with a gas barbecue. Any other use may result in a serious fire hazard. The Neighborhood Builder and Master Developer are not responsible for any damage resulting from your use of the exterior gas stub. 75. Stain Grade Material Discoloration. Natural hardwoods used for cabinets, doors, stair systems, moldings, etc., are finished with stain and lacquer finish products which will change color over time. Color change may be the result of exposure to sunlight or weather, or simply the consequence of aging. Discoloration is not a defect. 76. Paint Discoloration. Certain portions of your Home, such as paint -grade cabinets, casework, moldings and interior doors, may be painted with oil-based enamel paint. Yellowing is common with oil-based enamel paints. Additionally, if your Home has white oil- based enamel paint -grade cabinets, yellowing will occur. 77. Variations In Natural Materials. Your Horne may include various natural materials (e.g., wood products and/or stone products). Wood products vary in dimension, grain, color, moisture content, and performance when subjected to high inoisture environments. Dimensional variations in the wood framing members (studs, plates, joists, rafters, and beams) or the required structural hardware connectors may show through the drywall and stucco finishes under certain lighting conditions. Wood panels and trim, exposed timbers, rafters, and posts will Buyer Initials: 1 -29- 2544-332531CLP428U715CI.SR1609965.3 6/13/06 require periodic painting. Wood exposed to weather will require more frequent painting. Consult the maintenance schedule included in your Homeowners Manual. Some of the natural characteristics of wood will show through the painted or stained finish. For example, there may be shades of white, red, black, grey or even green in areas. Mineral streaks may also be visible. This is caused by the irregularity of mineral absorption from one part of the tree to another. Grain patterns or texture will vary from even to irregular throughout your cabinetry. Similarly, granite and natural stone products are composed of various mineral contents. Marble is less dense and more porous than granite. Great care must be taken to prevent damage to marble and other stone products. You should follow the manufacturers' recommendations for cleaning and maintenance. Because these are natural products, they are subject to variation in color, veining, spotting, holes, cloudiness, texture and cracking. Some may vary significantly in filler and sheen. The samples in the sales office are actual pieces of natural stone which indicate general color and character; however, no two (2) pieces can be expected to match, even when taken from the same box. You should view the stone prior to purchase, and any questions regarding these materials must be resolved prior to installation. If replacement of natural material tile or carpet is required, you understand and agree that a match with existing material cannot be guaranteed. 78. Brass Plumbing/Light Fixtures/Hardware. Brass, bronze or other finishes have their limitations. In time, the protective lacquer may deteriorate from exposure to weather, perspiration, cleaning agents, frequency of use and other factors. Tarnishing or excessive wear of these finishes is, therefore, not a defect, but a normal process which is unavoidable. Under the circumstances, these finishes cannot be guaranteed and products will not be repaired or replaced under the manufacturer's warranties for tarnishing or wear of finishes. 79. Drywall Panels and Finishes. Drywall panels are placed over the wall studs, joists, rafters and beams. Drywall is typically used to finish window openings. Drywall panels will not completely eliminate variations in the dimension and plane of wood framing members. Metal trim (i.e., corner bead) is used at corners, window edges, soffits and ceilings. They are designed to be filled with finish compounds. These trim metals provide a durable finish but cause the wall plane to "flare" at the metal edge. Panel joints and seams are taped and coated with finish compounds. Fasteners are coated with finish compounds to cover the small "dimple" in the surface of the drywall panel. Progressive applications of finish compounds are required to cover the joints, fasteners, and seams. In some cases, the normal finishing of these joints, fasteners, and seams will cause a subtle "bulge". When the finishing process is complete, the walls and ceilings receive a texture coat. In certain lighting conditions (up -lights placed close to the walls), irregularities and variations in the wall plane or intersection of vertical and horizontal panels may be evident. These variations are normal. 80. View. Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders, the Community Association and their counselors, agents, representatives or employees make no representations, warranties or promises concerning any view, present or future, that may be enjoyed from all or any portion of your Homesite or Home. The view from your Homesite or Home may change or may be fully or partially obstructed by (a) the construction of other homes, Improvements, structures, fences, walls and/or landscaping by Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders or other Owners within the Community, (b) activities and Improvements on real property outside the Community, and/or (c) the growth of trees and/or other vegetation within or outside the Community. You are advised that trees installed in the Community are generally smaller than they will be once mature Buyer Initials: / _30- 2544-332531CLP428\D1SCLSR\ 609965.3 6113106 and trees that do not block views when you purchase your Home may obstruct views as they grow. Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders make no representations or warranties with respect to any open space on property adjacent to your Homesite or Home, or the Community as a whole, whether this property is owned or controlled by Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders, government agencies or private property owners. 81. Warranties for Consumer Products. The manufacturers' warranties for the consumer products included in your Home (e.g., water heater, air conditioning system, dishwasher, garbage disposal and other household appliances) are available for review in the sales office of your Neighborhood Builder. 82. Financing. This paragraph only applies if you are purchasing your Home from a Neighborhood Builder who is also a Lennar Family Builder and you are financing the purchase with Universal American Mortgage Corporation ("UAMC'). You will be required to provide UAMC with all documents necessary to obtain loan approval. UAMC may be affiliated with the Neighborhood Builder. You are not obligated to accept a loan from UAMC, but you may be required to submit documentation to UAMC to permit the Neighborhood Builder to determine whether it is likely that you will qualify to purchase the Home you desire. You may select your lender independently; however, if you select a lender other than UAMC, you must ensure that the lender can meet the time limitations and requirements imposed on lenders in the Purchase Agreement. Master Developer and Neighborhood Builder have not reviewed or approved any lender's sales or marketing materials, and does not make any representations or warranties whatsoever regarding any matters set forth therein or your ability to obtain any financing under any particular terms. You are strongly encouraged to make your own independent evaluation of the rates and loan programs offered by all lenders, including UAMC. You understand that the interest. rate and loan fees for the loan applied for will be determined at the time of the Close of Escrow and may be higher or lower than on the date you signed a purchase agreement for your Home. You also acknowledge that the interest rate and loan fees referenced on the loan application are approximate only and do not constitute a binding commitment. 83. Schools. The Community is currently located in the Tustin Unified School District, telephone: (714) 730-7301 (the "School District'j. To obtain further information about the schools serving the Community, including transportation to and from the schools, please contact the School District. You should investigate this matter to your satisfaction prior to purchasing a Home in the Community. Due to the rate of population change, the school district may find it necessary to change boundaries and designated schools periodically, prior to or after your close of escrow. In addition, it is possible that school district boundaries may change and your children will be required to attend a different school district in the future. Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders have no control or responsibility for such changes should they occur. The Community is currently expected to be served by the following schools: Marjorie Veeh Elementary School (K-6) 1701 San Juan Street Tustin, California (714) 730-7544 Buyer Initials: / -31- 2544-3325MCLP42ADISCLSM 609965.3 6/!3/06 A.G. Currie Middle School (7-8) 1402 Sycamore Avenue Tustin, California (714) 730-7352 Tustin High School (9-12) 4321 1171 El Camino Real Tustin, California (714) 730-7414 To obtain further information about the schools serving the Community, including transportation to and from the schools, please contact the applicable school referenced above or the School District, or you can visit the School District's website at www.tustin.kl2,ea.us. You should investigate this matter to your satisfaction prior to purchasing a Home in the Community. 84. Mailboxes. Mailboxes in the Community may be clustered in groups as required by the United States Postal Service. The location of mailboxes and above -ground utility structures are determined by governmental agencies or utility companies, or both. You may not change the type of mailbox being used or the location. Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders reserve the right to modify such locations as may be dictated by field conditions without prior notice. 85. Residential Construction Legislation, California Civil Code Sections 895 through 945.5 ("Construction Claims Statute'l, went into effect on January 1, 2003. The Construction Claims Statute (a) delineates standards for how various components of your Home should be constructed and function, (b) limits the time frames for bringing various claims against the Neighborhood Builder to anywhere from one year to ten years (as listed in the Construction Claims Statute) after the Close of Escrow, (c) imposes an obligation on all Owners and their successors in interest to follow Neighborhood Builder's maintenance recommendations and schedules or other applicable maintenance guidelines, and (d) establishes a non -adversarial claims resolution procedure. Pursuant to Section 914 of the Construction Claims Statute, the Neighborhood Builder is permitted to elect to utilize the procedure in the Construction Claims Statute or its own alternate contractual pre -litigation procedures. The applicable claims handling procedures are outlined in the Purchase Documents you receive from the Neighborhood Builder, including the "Dispute Resolution" provision in Section 13.5 of the Master Declaration. A separate notice further describing claims handling procedures may have been recorded against the title to Homes by the Neighborhood Builder in some Neighborhoods. You should review any such notice and your Purchase Documents carefully concerning these issues. YOU ARE ADVISED THAT THE CONSTRUCTION CLAIMS STATUTE AFFECTS YOUR LEGAL RIGHTS. YOU ARE ADVISED TO READ THE STATUTE CAREFULLY AND SEEK LEGAL ADVICE IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS REGARDING ITS EFFECT ON YOUR LEGAL RIGHTS. Buyer Initials; ! -32- 2544-33253\C1.P428\D1SCL.SR\ 609965.3 6/13/06 Buyer Initials Buyer Initials 86. Duty to Follow Maintenance Guidelines. An Owner is obligated by Section 907 of the Construction Claims Statute to follow any maintenance recommendations and schedules from the Neighborhood Builder, including the maintenance recommendations and schedules for manufactured products and appliances included with the Home, as well as all commonly accepted maintenance practices (collectively, "Maintenance Guidelines'). Pursuant to Section 945.5 of the Construction Claims Statute, failure to follow any such Maintenance Guidelines may reduce or preclude an Owner's right to recover damages relating to an Owner's Home which could have been prevented or mitigated had the Maintenance Guidelines been followed. Buyer Initials Buyer Initials 87. Obligation to Retain Purchase Documents. The Purchase Documents that you receive through escrow in conjunction with the purchase of a Home may include Maintenance Guidelines, a written limited warranty, claim forms, and other documentation relating to the Construction Claims Statute. All Owners are required by the Construction Claims Statute to retain these documents and provide copies of such documents to an Owner's successors in interest upon the sale or transfer of the Owner's Home. Buyer Initials Buyer Initials 88. Warranty and Limitations on Liability. A Neighborhood Builder may provide a written limited warranty for the Homesite or Home covering certain defects for a limited period after the date the limited warranty commences. Warranty periods for items will vary as set forth in the written limited warranty. During the written limited warranty period, if any, the Neighborhood Builder will repair or replace,. at the Neighborhood Builder's sole discretion, certain components of your Homesite or Home, as set forth in the written limited warranty. A written limited warranty generally does not cover defects resulting from the failure of an Owner to perform commonly- accepted maintenance. Minor expansion, contraction, settlement cracks normal to home construction, and secondary damage, are generally not covered under the terms of a written limited warranty. Please refer to the written limited warranty you may receive for additional information. No other warranties or guarantees, whether expressed or implied, are provided, unless stated in writing and signed by a Neighborhood Builder. The manufacturers' warranties for the manufactured consumer products included in your Home (for example, water heater, air conditioning system, dishwasher, garbage, disposal and other household appliances) are available for review in the Neighborhood Builder's sales office. 89. Notice of Sexual Offenders. Section 2079.10a of the California Civil Code: Buyer Initials: The following notice is given pursuant to -33- 2544-33253\CLP428\DISCLSR160M5.3 6/13/06 Pursuant to Section 290.46 of the Penal Code, information about specified registered sex offenders is made available to the public via an Internet Web site maintained by the Department of Justice at www.meeauslaw.ca.aoy. Depending on an offender's criminal history, this information will include either the address at which the offender resides or the community of residence and ZIP Code in which he or she resides. 90. Prior to the purchase of a Home in the Community, you may research the database to determine whether there are sex offenders in the area. Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders, the Community Association and their respective directors, officers, employees, agents, representatives and consultants make no representations, warranties, or guarantees regarding the presence or absence of registered sex offenders within the Community or in the surrounding area. In addition, Master Developer, Neighborhood Builder, the Community Association and their respective directors, officers, employees, agents, representatives and consultants have no obligation or duty to investigate existing residents or buyers to determine whether they are sex offenders. You are solely responsible for making your own investigation. For further information, please contact your local law enforcement agency. Most law enforcement agencies have special stations to view the Megan's Law database. 91. Benefit of Home Ownership. Although the purchase of a new home has traditionally been considered a wise decision, Master Developer and Neighborhood Builder have _ made no representations, guarantees or warranties to you regarding the tax benefits, investment benefits or other benefits of home ownership, regarding appreciation or depreciation in the value or equity accrual in your Home, and regarding future price adjustments. 92. Assumption of Risk and Liability. By acceptance of this Disclosure, you assume all risk and liability for injuries to persons and property that may be sustained by you, your family members and your social and business guests by reason of all conditions or circumstances disclosed in this Disclosure. VISITING THE COMMUNITY BEFORE MOVE -IN If you wish to visit the Community, the Neighborhood and your Home before your move in, please be aware that your Home is located within a construction area and that construction sites are potentially dangerous. The Neighborhood Builder will permit you to enter your Home and the construction area surrounding your Home provided that you are fully aware of the risks of such entry and are willing to comply with the procedures and requirements imposed on such visit by the Neighborhood Builder. You must be accompanied by your sales representative, or another representative of the Neighborhood Builder on any and all visits to your Home. Each Neighborhood Builder further requests that such visits be limited to non -construction hours. By signing this Disclosure you acknowledge that there are numerous risks associated with visiting your Home during construction, including without limitation, open trenches, construction traffic, potential falling debris, exposed nails and electrical wiring, incomplete construction and certain other potential hazards. You further agree to use due care while visiting your Home. In addition, prior to visiting any construction area you may be required to sign a waiver and release form provided by the Neighborhood Builder ("Waiver') in which you agree to comply with the provisons of the Waiver. Whether or not you have signed a Waiver, by signing this Disclosure, Buyer Initials: / _34� 2544-33253\CLF428\DISCLSR1609965.3 6113106 you agree that you shall proceed at your own risk and you release and waive any claims against Master DeveloRer, Neighborhood Builders, all of their affiliated entities, officers, directors, agents and assigns, and all other Rersons or entities potentially liable to you as a result of an injury which may occur duringyourvisit to your Home, to the Neighborhood and to the Community. ENTIRE DISCLOSURE; NO OTHER REPRESENTATIONS No sales representative, employee or agent of any Neighborhood Builder or the Master Developer has the authority to make any representation to you which contradicts or modifies the matters and information set forth in this Disclosure, the purchase agreement or any other written disclosure provided by the Master Developer or Neighborhood Builders in connection with the purchase of a Home in a Neighborhood (collectively, the "Disclosure Documents'). You acknowledge that no representations have been made to you by such persons other than as set forth in the Disclosure Documents and upon which you have relied in connection with the purchase of the Home. Please indicate below if any representations have been made by any such person which contradict or modify the matters and information set forth in the Disclosure Documents: RELEASE AND INDRNMTY REGARDING DISCLOSURES With respect to items of information disclosed to you in this Disclosure or in any Disclosure Documents provided by Master Developer or Neighborhood Builders (collectively, "Disclosure Items"), you agree that you and your family members release, waive and will not make any claims against Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders for (a) nondisclosure of Disclosure Items, (b) for alleged improper or incomplete Disclosure Items, and (c) personal injury, property damage, expenses (including attorney fees and costs) and other liability you, your family members and others experience from the nondisclosure, improper disclosure or incomplete disclosure of Disclosure Items. You also agree that you will indemnify and hold the Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders and all of their affiliated entities, officers, directors, agents and assigns, harmless from all such claims by you, your family members and your social and business guests. Buyer Initials Buyer Initials [Buyer Acknowledgment on following page) Buyer Initials: / _35_ 254433253TU428WISCLSM609965.3 6/13/06 Columbus Square HOMEBUYER DISCLOSURE STATEMENT BUYER ACKNOWLEDGMENT By the signatures below, you acknowledge that you will close escrow with full knowledge, understanding and agreement as to all of the information contained in this Disclosure, and that this Disclosure constitutes a part of the terms of your Home purchase. Buyer: Date: Homesite or Condominium No: Tract No: Street Address: Buyer Initials: ! -36- 2544-3325ACLP428WISCLSM 60M5.3 6/13!06 Columbus Square HOMEBUYER DISCLOSURE STATEMENT Meriwether • Camden Place Tire Gables • Astoria a Coventry Court Cambridge Lane • Kensiuldon Court • Verandas August 2006 Welcome to Columbus Square. We are pleased you are considering the purchase of a new home in Columbus Square. We want you (the `Buyer") to be an extremely satisfied customer. Part of your satisfaction is in knowing as much as possible about your new home in the master -planned community of Columbus Square ("Community'), located in the City of Tustin. We offer this Homeowner Disclosure Statement ("Disclosure") as a service to describe to you various matters which might affect your decision to purchase. Please read it carefully. Be aware, however, that (a) much of the information in this Disclosure has been obtained from other sources (public agencies, public records, etc.), and (b) the information contained in this Disclosure is not comprehensive. This means that we cannot guarantee the accuracy or completeness of the information disclosed. Because this information is subject to change without notice to us, it also means that we cannot commit to advise you of any changes affecting the information in this Disclosure. In addition to this Disclosure, the City of Tustin has required that the Master Developer provide you with a Columbus Square Homebuyer Notification (the "Homebuyer Noti,Jlcation"). The Master Developer prepared the Homebuyer Notification with information provided by the City of Tustin, at the direction of the City of Tustin and do not have the right to alter or update the Homebuyer Notification. To the extent any of the information provided in the Homebuyer Notification is inconsistent with the information provided in this Disclosure, this Disclosure shall supersede that portion of the Homebuyer Notification. By signing this Disclosure, you agree to independently verify all information regarding matters of concern to you before the Close of Escrow for your home purchase. As a part of your pre -purchase investigation, we strongly recommend that you visit the Community and the general vicinity surrounding the Community on several different days at several different times to familiarize yourself with the Community, its location and its surroundings. You will receive many documents in addition to this Disclosure to review, complete and sign before the Close of Escrow for the purchase of your home. These other documents are called the "Purchase Documents" in this Disclosure, and they include documents pertaining to the Community, defined below as the "Community Association Governing Documents". This Disclosure is not intended as a substitute for your review of the Community Association Governing Documents. This Disclosure does not amend, modify or supersede the Community Buyer 6rilials: __ _ 2544-33253TIP42801SCLM 600%5.4 9!1 UOn Association Governing Documents. If the Community Association Governing Documents are inconsistent with this Disclosure, the Community Association Governing Documents will supersede this Disclosure. Unless defined in this Disclosure, capitalized terms used in this Disclosure have the meanings given them in the Master Declaration of Covenants, Conditions, Restrictions and Reservation of Easements for Columbus Square ("Community Declaration'). If the Community Declaration gives the same capitalized term a different meaning than this Disclosure, the meaning given in the Community Declaration shall apply. INTRODUCTION TO THE MASTER DEVELOPER Moffett Meadows Partners, LLC, a Delaware limited liability company, is the initial Master Developer of the Columbus Square master -punned community ("Master Developer'). INTRODUCTION TO COLUMBUS SQUARE 1. Location and Master Ptah. The Community is east of Interstate 55 near the intersection of Edinger Avenue and Redhill Avenue, in the City of Tustin (the "City'l. The master land -use plan approved by the City of Tustin for the Community is called the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan (the "Specific Plan") and it contains numerous design standards and development conditions. Such conditions establish, among other things, the number of single family dwellings and condominiums and other development requirements. if developed as approved by the City, Columbus Square will encompass approximately 1075 Homes, which are planned to consist of 283 single family dwellings, 552 condominiums and 240 senior housing condominiums. The actual number of Homes built may increase or decrease subject to approval by the City. All Homes in the Community are planned to be subject to the jurisdiction of the Columbus Square Community Association, a California nonprofit mutual benefit corporation ("Community Association'), as described in the Community Declaration. INTRODUCTION TO COLUMBUS SQUARE'S NEIGHBORHOODS AND NEIGHBORHOOD BUILDERS 2. Neighborhoods. The Community is being developed with Homes in numerous distinct neighborhoods ("Neighborhoods') constructed by various homebuilders ("Neighborhood Builders'). Neighborhood Builders may have owner occupancy restrictions, rental Homesites and Homes (each of which is defined below), and investor-owned Homesites and Homes. You are advised to read the individual Neighborhood Builder disclosures and any other documentation relating to the Neighborhood in which you choose to purchase a Homesite or Home thoroughly. Neighborhood Builder policies may differ from those described in this Disclosure and the Community Declaration and are enforceable by the applicable Neighborhood Builders. The following is a list of the different Neighborhoods to be developed by the Neighborhood Builders in the Community and the approximate • number of Homes to be constructed in each Neighborhood; provided that that any product may be renamed or sold by the Neighborhood Builder currently listed below and the Neighborhood Builders reserve the right not to build the Neighborhoods listed below at all: New Buys Initials: i _'7.. 2544.33253WTP428\D1SCLSR\ 609965.4 BM/06 (a) Lennar Homes of California, Inc. • Meiiwether 114 Homes • Camden Place 222 Homes • The Gables 84 Homes • Coventry Court 240 Homes (b) William Lyon Homes, Inc. + Astoria 102 Homes • Cambridge Lane 156 Homes • Kensington Court 60 Homes • Verandas 97 Homes 3. Ownership. A residential Lot in the Community is referred to as a "Homesite" in this Disclosure. If you are purchasing a residential Lot in the Community, upon the Close of Escrow, you will receive fee title to a Homesite, which will be improved with a single family dwelling (a "Hoare'). If you are purchasing a Condominium in the Community, upon the Close of Escrow, you will receive fee title to a Unit and you will also receive easements for maintenance and use over Exclusive Use Areas (collectively, a "Home'l. If you purchase a Homesite, you will not own the mineral, oil, and gas rights under the land below a depth of five hundred (500) feet, or the water rights. The holder of these rights has no right of surface entry. COMMUNITY ASSOCIATION GOVERNING DOCUMENTS Your Home will be subject to the following documents ("Community Association Governing Documents"): (a) The Community Declaration, and any amendments or modifications thereto; (b) The Articles of Incorporation of the Columbus Square Community Association ("Community Association"); (c) The Bylaws of the Community Association; (d) The Supplemental Declaration of Covenants, Conditions and Restrictions ("Supplemental Declaration') that is applicable to the Neighborhood in which your Home is located, and may annex that Neighborhood to the coverage of the Community Declaration; and (e) Any Community Guidelines or Design Guidelines which_ may be adopted from time to time, respectively, by the Community Association's Board of Directors or the Design Review Committee ("Committee") pursuant to the Community Declaration. You should carefully review the Community Association Governing Documents in order to understand your specific rights and obligations as an Owner in the Community. The Community Association Governing Documents establish limits and restrictions on the use of the Buyer Initials: / _3_ 254433253\CLP428UDISCLSRI609965A 8/11/06 Home you are purchasing. You will also be provided with a preliminary title report. The title report will list other recorded documents affecting the use of the Home you are purchasing. You should review the title report and the documents referenced in the report closely prior to your purchase of a Home. SPECIFIC PROVISIONS OF THE COMMUNITY DECLARATION 4. Assessment Obligation. The Community Declaration authorizes the Community Association's Board of Directors to levy a Common Assessment against each Home to meet the Community Association's Common Expenses, The Board of Directors is also authorized to levy various special assessments for specific purposes, in conformance with Articles I and VIII of the Community Declaration. The monthly installment of the Common Assessment will vary as each Phase of the Community is developed. You should review the Budget approved by the California Department of Real Estate and provided to you with the Final Subdivision Public Report for your Horne. The Board of Directors' ability to increase the Common Assessments and improve additional special assessments without a vote of the Members is subject to certain limitations set forth in Sections 8.5 and 8.6 of the Community Declaration. The Community Association is obligated to provide you with an annual budget and other financial statements for the Community Association. 5. Use Restrictions. You must comply with all the various use restrictions set forth in the Community Declaration. These restrictions include, among other things, restrictions on non-residential uses of your Home, keeping of animals, improvements to your Homesite and Home, parking of vehicles, etc. The Community Association has the power to enforce the use restrictions set forth in the Community Declaration, as well as the Community Guidelines and the Design Guidelines. 6. Prohibited Dwelling Structures. You may not use your garage as a living area. Further, in accordance with Section 2.7 of the Community Declaration, you may not erect or use any outbuilding, tent; shack, storage shed, trailer, camper, motor home, recreational vehicle or any other vehicle on your Homesite for a living area. 7. Use of Garages. All vehicles owned or operated by or within the control of an Owner and kept in the Community must be parked in the assigned parking space or garage of that Owner; provided that, although storage of personal items may occur in the garage, all Authorized Vehicles must be parked in the garage, in accordance with Section 2.4.3 of the Community Declaration and Exhibit PC-] attached thereto. Notwithstanding the foregoing, Owners may not park any Authorized Vehicle in the street or in any guest parking spaces. No repair, maintenance or restoration of any vehicle may be conducted within the Community except in an enclosed garage when the garage door is closed; provided, however, that such activity may not be undertaken as a business, and provided further that such. activity may be prohibited entirely by the Board if the Board determines that it constitutes a nuisance. 8. Parking of Recreational and Commercial Vehicles. Sections 2.4.1, 2.4.2 and 2.4.3 of. the Community Declaration impose limitations and prohibitions on the parking of: Authorized Vehicles and Prohibited Vehicles within the Community. In accordance with Section 2.4.6 of the Community Declaration, an Owner may park any Authorized Vehicle that Buyer Initials; ! _4- 2544-33253\CLP428\DISCLSR\ 609905.4 8111/06 exceeds seven (7) feet high, seven (7) feet wide, and nineteen (19) feet long in the Owner's garage or driveway (as long as the Authorized Vehicle does not extend onto the sidewalk or - drive approach area). In addition, no delivery and/or moving trucks larger than forty (40) feet are permitted on any private drive having less than a twenty-five (25) foot radius that is located within a Neighborhood in the Community. You further acknowledge that it is your responsibility to determine whether the parking provided in the Community and your Neighborhood is satisfactory for your purposes and to verify that the standard height and depth of the garage will provide adequate clearance for your vehicles before the Close of Escrow on your Horne. 9. Owner Maintenance Guidelines. As set forth in Section 9. 1.1 of the Community Declaration, each Owner must maintain his Home and Homesite in a neat and attractive condition at all times. The maintenance of all areas located within the boundaries of a Homesite is the responsibility of each Owner. The Neighborhood Builders will provide you with important guidelines on the proper maintenance of improvements in your Homesite. Failure to properly maintain interior improvements may cause premature deterioration of important features, finishes or equipment. The Neighborhood Builders are not responsible for failure of equipment or other improvements caused by your failure to properly maintain such improvements. In addition, you acknowledge that some upgraded materials, if any are selected by you, may have specific maintenance requirements. The Neighborhood Builders are not responsible for any damages that may occur to such materials due to your failure to properly maintain them. 10. Insurance. In accordance with Article IX of the Community Declaration, you are solely responsible for determining the type and quality of insurance required to adequately insure your Homesite and Home, your personal property, and your personal liability for ownership of your Homesite and Home.. You are solely responsible for determining if natural disaster insurance is required for your Homesite and Home. If any insurance is required by your lender, you are responsible for obtaining that insurance prior to Close of Escrow. 11. Design Review of Improvements and Alterations. You may not build, construct, install or plant any improvements on your Homesite (or alter any improvements located on your Homesite, including your Home), until you have submitted plans and specifications and obtained approval from the Design Review Committee, as set forth in Article V of the Community Declaration. The Design Review Committee will establish Design Guidelines containing rules and guidelines for the submission of plans and specifications. The Design Review Committee may collect a fee to review the plans. All Improvements must comply with any applicable restrictions in the Community Declaration and the Design Guidelines, as well as with all requirements imposed by the City and any other local governmental agency. The Design Guidelines and City and other local governmental agency regulations may change from time to time, and you will be subject to the regulations in effect at the time plans are submitted. After obtaining written approval of the Design Review Committee, you must submit the plans and specifications to the appropriate local governmental agencies for any proposed improvements that require the issuance of a building permit, or other approval by the City or any other local governmental agencies, as applicable. You should read Article V of Buyer Initials; / _5_ 2544-332531CLP428\UISCLSR\009965A 8/11/06 the Community Declaration before constructing any Improvements. You may be subject to a Neighborhood Association Design Review Committee if you live in a Condominium project. (a) Landscaping and Irrigation Improvements. All landscape materials and irrigation systems installed by Owners must comply with plans and specifications approved by the Design Review Committee. You may need to install yard drains when installing landscaping and patios. Your landscaping plans are required to conform with the original drainage plan of the Homesite. Changes to drainage and grading require approval of the Design Review Committee and generally require you to obtain a permit from the City, as applicable. The slope areas, if any, located on a Homesite may include drainage facilities and temporary erosion control measures. No modifications to the slope areas shall be undertaken without the prior approval of the Design Review Committee and the City, as applicable. (b) Landscaping Completion Deadline. Section 2.18 of the Community Declaration requires you to install landscaping on any portions of your Homesite that have not been landscaped by a Neighborhood Builder. Landscaping in the front yard of a Homesite must be completed within six (6) months after the Close of Escrow for the purchase of the Homesite and landscaping in the back yard of a Homesite must be completed within one (1) year after the Close of Escrow for the purchase of the Homesite. The time period for the completion of such improvements is set forth in the Community Declaration. (c) Owner Liability. Any alterations or Improvements made by you to your Homesite, to its drainage pattern or to the Home shall be made at your sole risk. The Neighborhood Builders assume no responsibility for any damage caused by the design, construction, installation, alteration or maintenance by you of any Improvement on the Homesite, or caused by the impact of such an Improvement on the Homesite's drainage pattern. (d) Licensed Professionals. if you wish to alter or install any Improvement on your Homesite, you should obtain the advice of a licensed architect or civil, soil or structural engineer, as applicable, and should design and complete the alteration or installation of the Improvement in accordance with such licensed professional's advice and specifications. 12. Drainage. Section 2.14 of the Community Declaration contains important restrictions concerning drainage of water and water pollution. (a) Surface Water. The Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders have provided for surface and underground drainage of water from all Homesites and Homes in the Community. Your Homesite may have surface "swales" or area drains to carry the water from the rear and sides of the Home to the street or other designated outlet points. The Homesites and Homes are graded in accordance with plans approved by the City and certified by a registered civil engineer. In connection with the preparation of landscape plans for your yard, it is important that you consider any possible harmful effects that such landscaping and associated Improvements may have on adjacent property and structures as well as your Homesite and Home. Because the Community and your Homesite are located in an area which may contain expansive soils as more particularly explained in the Paragraph below entitled "Soil Conditions," water may have a detrimental impact upon such soils and the soils of surrounding Homesites and Buyer Initials: / _6_ 2544-33253\CLP428\DISCLSR\ 609965.4 8/11/06 slopes. Existing drainage patterns must be maintained and all drainage systems must be kept free of debris and free flowing. (b) Effect of Improvements and Alterations. Raising the existing grade, constructing planters, changing the drainage pattern and other similar activities may cause damage to your Homesite, adjacent property (including, without limitation, your neighbor's Homesite, adjacent slopes and lower Homesites) and Improvements located thereon, including the Home. It is recommended that you consult with a licensed professional on landscaping and drainage, such as a qualified landscape architect and soils engineer, geotechnical engineer, geologist, civil engineer or other similar specialist, before making any alterations. Any Improvements must be designed and constructed in a manner to prevent any possible damage to your Homesite and to adjacent property. If any obstruction occurs to the drainage on your yard, it may result in obstruction of drainage from adjacent property or cause major problems such as trapped water or flooding which may undermine the foundation of your Home and surrounding Homes or create moisture intrusion or mold and mildew problems. You are solely responsible for any damage to your Homesite and Home or surrounding property and the Improvements located thereon as a result of any alterations you make to the approved existing drainage pattern or failure to maintain proper drainage. The Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders and Community Association shall have no liability or responsibility for any such damage. Any grading or drainage modifications are subject to applicable codes of the City, approval by the Design Review Committee, and the terms of any drainage easements that may be of record. You acknowledge and understand that if your Homesite or Home does not include area drains, you shall be responsible for installing area drains on your Homesite or Home when installing your landscaping. Your responsibilities for maintaining all grading and other drainage -related features on your Homesite and Home are set forth in Section 2.14.1 of the Community Declaration. (c) Water Quality Management Requirements. The Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders are developing the Community and Neighborhoods in accordance with a water quality management plan ("Plan 11 required by the California State Water Quality Control Board. The Plan imposes requirements for the design, implementation and maintenance of Best Management Practices ("BMPs') to eliminate or mitigate all non -storm water discharges into storm drains during and after construction of the Community and Neighborhoods. The requirements imposed by the Plan are in addition to any local ordinances with regard to discharge of non -storm water into storm drains. The Plan imposes post -construction requirements. This means that after the Close of Escrow, you and your sub -contractors and other agents, are required to comply with all BMPs which are necessary to prevent, without limitation, run-off of soil, sand, sediment, oil, gasoline or other hydrocarbons, paint, fertilizers, pool chemicals and other household chemicals into the storm drains located in your Neighborhood. For example, when fertilizing landscaping, measures must be taken to prevent over -watering the landscaping to ensure 'that fertilizer and other lawn chemicals do not run into the storm drains. Your Neighborhood Builder will provide you with a Best Management Practices Handbook containing BMP recommendations for the prevention of run-off into storm drains from your Homesite and Home. The Plan affirmatively obligates all Owners to take immediate corrective action whenever there is a violation of the Plan as to an Owner's Homesite or Home. Penalties include Buyer initials: / -7_ 2544-33253\CLP428\DiSCLSRk &"%5.4 8/11/00 significant fines that may be imposed against an Owner for failing to comply with BMPs necessary to prevent non -storm water run-off into storm drains, in violation of the Plan. 13. Utility and Other Easements. Article VII of the Community Declaration contains provisions pertaining to easements which may affect Owners and Homes. Your Homesite and Horne may be subject to easements or other rights in favor of utility companies, local governmental agencies and other parties. These easements and rights may include access onto your Homesite or to exterior portions of the Home for purposes of installing, constructing, inspecting, maintaining and repairing facilities which are customary for residential developments (including, but not limited to, water lines, sewer lines, electrical lines and facilities, transformer boxes, natural gas pipelines, street lights, telephone lines and facilities, cable television lines, mailboxes, traffic signs, fire hydrants, etc.). These facilities and structures may be located above ground or below ground. In either case, the foregoing easements, rights and facilities may restrict the use and type of improvements you can make to your Homesite and Home, and the utility company, local government agency or other parties benefited by such easement or right may have the right to remove improvements made by you on the easement area without any obligation to repair or restore them. You should review the policy of title insurance, the tract map for your Homesite, Article VII of the Community Declaration, and the Supplemental Declaration to determine what easements and other rights, if any, affect your Homesite and Horne. Such easements may preclude construction of structures or other improvements or may require an encroachment permit to be obtained. You should not excavate or construct an improvement on any portion of your Homesite, as applicable, until you have consulted with an applicable licensed design professional (for example, an engineer) and located all easements and .facilities. A copy of the tract map depicting your Homesite is available for review in the sales office. The location of gas and electric meters, telephone and cable access panels may change from the locations shown in the models. Please ask your sales representative for information concerning the proposed location of utility facilities and structures for your Home. The Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders make no representations or warranties concerning the final location of these facilities or structures for your Home. 14. Pets. Household pets, such as dogs or cats, are limited to reasonable quantities as established in Section 2.5 of the Community Declaration. Buyers shall be liable for any unreasonable noise or damage (including, but not limited to, clean up after such animal(s)) caused by any animal brought or kept upon the Community and Neighborhoods as more fully described in the Community Declaration. 15. Window Coverings. In accordance with Section 2.10 of the Community Declaration, the Design Guidelines and Community Guidelines may prohibit or restrict certain types of window coverings such as paint, foil, reflective tint or other similar materials or substances, and may permit certain types of temporary window coverings pending installation of permanent window coverings. 16. Walls and Fences. Wall and fence heights may vary'throughout the Community and your Neighborhood. Walls and fences are subject to change, at any time and without notice to you, from any depiction that may have been provided or shown to you. Section 9.1.4 of the Community Declaration sets forth Owner's wall maintenance responsibilities. Owners are responsible for maintenance of all portions of the walls and fences that border the perimeter of Buyer Initials: ! _$_ 2544-33253NUP428W1sCLSM 609965.4 8/1l/06 the Homesite, including any pilasters located on an Owner's Homesite, except for those portions that are designated for maintenance by the Community Association or a Neighborhood. Association. You should review the Community Association Governing Documents for further information. Community Walls, Neighborhood Walls and/or Party Walls (all as defined in the Community Declaration) may be installed on the property line(s) of your Homesite (collectively, the "Walls', as shown as Exhibit WWM attached to the Community Declaration, Neighborhood Declaration or a Supplemental Declaration. Owners must maintain any portion of the Walls not otherwise maintained by the Community Association or a Neighborhood Association. Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders and the Community Association are not responsible for damage to any Wall on. the Homesite if such damage results from your failure to properly maintain the Walls. 17. Solar Energy Systems. Pursuant to Section 2.17 of the Community Declaration, you and all other Owners of Homesites in the Community have the right to place and maintain equipment and facilities related to the installation and maintenance of individual solar energy systems ("System -'I. The installation and maintenance of any System by you shall be subject to all applicable ordinances and zoning regulations of the City, the Uniform Building Code and associated ordinances. California has a strong public policy in favor of solar energy needs of a neighbor, including but not limited to the location and height of trees on your Homesite. You must obtain written approval from the Design Review Committee prior to installation of a System and you must comply with reasonable restrictions placed on the System by the Design Review Committee, subject to California Civil Code Sections 714 and 714. 1, as the same may be amended from time to time. 18. Satellite Dishes. Satellite dish antennas (or Authorized Antennae, as defined in the Community Declaration) may be installed and used in the Community in accordance with Section 2.11 of the Community Declaration. However, Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders have provided no assurances or guarantees that ,any satellite dish or other antenna installed within the Community will remain unobstructed or that satellite service will be provided to an Owner after installation of an Authorized Antennae. You should understand that broadcast signals may be obstructed by the installation of additional improvements within and outside of the Community including, without limitation, homes, walls, fences, trees and other landscaping and such obstructions may not allow for acceptable satellite reception. You should also understand that Neighborhood Associations may impose additional restrictions. 19. Amendments to the Community Declaration. Notwithstanding the fact that you have received a copy of the Community Declaration and the Supplemental Declaration for your Phase of Development, these documents may be amended in accordance with their amendment provisions. 20. Additional Provisions. There may be provisions of various laws, including the Davis -Stirling Common Interest Development Act codified at Sections 1350 et seq. of the California Civil Code and the Federal Fair Housing Act codified at Title 42 United States Code, Section 3601 et seq., which may supplement or override the Community Association Governing Documents. The Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders and Community Association make Buyer Initials: / -9- 2544-33253\CLP428\01SCLSM 609965.4 8/11/06 no representations or warranties regarding the future enforceability of any portion of the Community Association Governing Documents. COLUMBUS SQUARE DISCLOSURES 21. Charitable Endowment Fee. A recorded Charitable Housing Agreement Imposing Endowment Fee On Transfer ("Agreement') affects your Home and the other Homes in the Community. The Agreement requires that an "Endoxlment Fee" equal to one -twentieth of one percent (0.05%) of the total sales price (0.0005 x total sales price) be paid each time a Home in the Community is transferred to a new owner. The Endowment Fee will be paid to Lennar Charitable Housing Foundation, a California nonprofit public benefit corporation ("Foundation'), to be used for the purposes described in the Agreement. When you close escrow for the purchase of your Home, you will pay the Endowment Fee to the Foundation. Thereafter, each time your Home is resold, the Endowment Fee must be paid at the close of escrow, but it may be paid either by the new buyer or the then current seller. The Agreement will be in effect for an indefinite period of time. 22. Affordable Housing/Transitional Housing. The -City of Tustin has required the Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders to provide two hundred sixty-six (266) units of affordable housing ("Affordable Housing Units') within the Community. Sixty-three (63) Affordable Housing Units will be located in the Camden Place Neighborhood, fifty (50) Affordable Housing Units will be located in the Cambridge Lane Neighborhood, and one hundred fifty-three (153) Affordable Housing Units will be located in an area of the Community that will be designated as housing for seniors (Coventry Court). Certain of these Affordable Housing Units will be offered to persons who _ qualify as very low, low and moderate income buyers pursuant to guidelines established by the United States Department of Housing and Urban Development for the City. Buyers who qualify as very low, low and moderate income will purchase their Homes subject to resale restrictions, as reflected in a recorded covenant agreement, for a period of forty-five (45) years. If you are interested in the Affordable Housing Units you should consult your sales representative for further information. 23. "Active Adult" Neighborhood. An "Active Adult Neighborhood," the Coventry Court, consists of age restricted residences located within the Community. In Coventry Court, each Home must be occupied by at least one resident who is at least 55 years of age. Coventry Court is a community consisting of approximately 240 Homes and has its own recreational facilities and activities. All assessments for the maintenance of these recreation facilities are the exclusive responsibility of the Coventry Court residents. As a result, the recreational facilities located within Coventry Court are not open to other Owners in the Community; provided, however, Coventry Court residents will have the right to use the recreational facilities located throughout the Community. Master Developer reserves the right to construct other age restricted communities in other locations in the Community. 24. Home Business Use. Any Home within the Community may be used for home. based business purposes, provided that such use is subject to the City of Tustin's Home Occupation Ordinance (if applicable), the provisions in Section 2.1 of the Community Declaration and the Community Guidelines. You are advised that the Community Declaration and the Community Guidelines may contain stricter restrictions than those in the City Ordinance Buyer Initials: _10- 2544.33253\CLP428\D1SCLSR\ 609965.4 8/11106 and that such use may require zoning clearance and a business license. You should contact the City for more information regarding business uses in your Horne. 25. MCAS Tustin. (a) Prior Use as MCAS Tustin. You are advised that the Community was previously used as the Tustin Marine Corps Air Station ("MCAS Tustin"). The Marine Corps and the Department of the Navy (11DON11 are the responsible agencies for the Installation Restoration Program (`IRP"). The IRP is a comprehensive environmental investigation and cleanup program formed to identify, investigate and clean up chemical and nuclear contamination that has resulted from past land use operations. When MCAS Tustin was an active base, it received a permit from the California Department of Toxic Substances Control ("DTSC'j pursuant to the Federal Resources Conservation and Recovery Act ("RCRA'1(42 U.S.C. 6901 et seq.) to store hazardous waste on portions of the base. One of the conditions of that permit was to perform "corrective action" to clean-up releases of hazardous waste constituents throughout the base. Although the permit has expired, these corrective action obligations continue, and the DON is undertaking environmental investigation and cleanup activities on portions of the former base that are within the Community. (b) Asbestos Containing Material. Hazardous material in the form of asbestos or asbestos -containing materials ("ACM") have been found and are otherwise presumed to exist in buildings and structures previously located in the Community. At such time as demolition of the prior existing buildings on the Community containing ACM was completed, the appropriate governmental regulatory agency confirmed that ACM had been removed from the buildings and any necessary soil remediation had been conducted in accordance with all applicable federal, state and local laws and regulations. (c) Easement for Environmental Remediation. An easement over the Community granted to the United States of America, acting by and through the Department of the Navy ("DON11 in a document entitled "Quitclaim Deed for Marble Mountain Parcel and Environmental Restriction Pursuant to Civil Code Section 1471," was recorded on March 11, 2003, as Document No. 200300263521. In connection with ongoing remediation on the DON's property within the Community, it was agreed, as a covenant running with the land, that the DON and its officers, agents, employees, contractors and subcontractors shall have the right, upon reasonable notice, to enter the Community when a response or corrective action is found to be necessary or when such access is necessary to carry out a response action or corrective action. The right for the DON to enter the Community shall include the right to conduct tests, investigations and surveys, including, where necessary, drilling, test -pitting, boring and other similar activities. Such right shall also include the right to construct, operate, maintain or undertake any other response or corrective action as required or necessary, including, but not limited to, monitoring wells, pumping wells, treatment facilities, and the installing of associated utilities. In exercising these rights of access, except in the case of imminent and substantial endangerment to human health or the environment, the DON shall give reasonable notice of any action to be taken related to such Buyer Initials: / _] J _ 2544-332531CLP4281131SCLSM 609965.4 8/11/06 remedial or corrective actions on the Community. Further, the DON will make reasonable efforts to minimize interference with the on going use of the Community and act in good faith to minimize any conflict between the necessary environmental investigation and remediation activities and the use of the Community. The DON is not required to restore or repair any hnprovements in the Community damaged as a result of this right to access the Community. If any Improvements on Association Property are damaged as a result of the DON's access to the Community, you are advised that any such damaged Improvement may be repaired or replaced by the Community Association and you may be charged a Reconstruction Assessment or Extraordinary Assessment (if applicable). (d) Groundwater Plume. The City Environmental Impact Report (1999) ("EIR'J indicates the presence of subsurface plumes of chlorinated volatile organic compounds ("VOCs'), dissolved trichloroethene ("TCE") and methyl tertiary -butyl ether ("MTBE") at ground water level in portions of MCAS Tustin located outside the Community. It is presently unknown whether and to what extent these contaminants will migrate towards the Community. According to the EIR, estimated human health risks associated with residential use of groundwater from the plumes are above the acceptable limits of the United States Environmental Protection Agency. Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders make no representations or warranties with respect to the plumes described above or whether such plumes will migrate into the groundwater under Community. 26. LIFOC PROPERTY/ENVIRONMENTAL CONDITIONS. Due to its prior use as a military base, certain areas within the Community, designated on the map for Tract No. 16581 as "IRP -13S" and "IRP -13W" (collectively, the "LIFOC Property"), are owned by the United States of America ("U.S Government" j and will ultimately be annexed into the Covered Property pursuant to Section 16.6 of the Community Declaration. (a) Prior Use of the LIFOC Property. That portion of the LIFOC Property identified as IRP -13S is approximately 0.7 acres and was previously used as a "Temporary Storage Area" ("TSA") and as a "Miscellaneous Wash Area" ("AMA"). The TSA consisted of two (2) buildings that were used for vehicle maintenance. Cleaning solvents were reportedly used to wash down floors in the buildings and waste solvent was likely released to storm drains, or to the ground outside the building. The MWA includes an inactive wash pad formerly used for cleaning small generators and other field equipment. Solvents were used in this area and may have been released to the subsurface through cracks in the concrete pad. That portion of the LIFOC Property identified as IRP 13W was previously used as a former disposal area where hydraulic fluid, diesel fuel, leaded gasoline, oil, paint stripper, batter acid and solvent were stored. (b) Release of Volatile Organic Compounds. As a result of the historic use of the LIFOC Property, hazardous substances have been released into the groundwater at the LIFOC Property. Volatile Organic Compounds (11VOCs1% including trichloroethylene ("?SCE") and 1,2,3 Trichloropropane (111,2,3 TCP'j, were found in groundwater at concentrations that could result in adverse effect to human health if this water was extracted from the ground and directly used for domestic purposes such as drinking or bathing. However, groundwater at this location is currently not used for such purposes. Buyer Initials; / -12- 2544-3325ACLP428WISCLSM609965A 8/11/06 (c) Remedial Action Plan. As a result of the release of hazardous substances at the LIFOC Property, various remedial activities have occurred at the LIFOC Property and will continue to occur until remediation goals have been achieved. In October 2004, the Department of Navy issued a report entitled "Final Record of Decision/Remedial Action Plan, Operable Unit IA, Former Marine Corps Air Station, Tustin, California", which describes the specific remedial action plan (V,4P' } that has been approved for IRP 13S to address groundwater contamination. In August 2005, the Department of Navy published a report entitled "Draft Feasibility Study Report for Operable Unit 4B [includes IRP 13W), Former Marine Corps Air Station, Tustin, California," ("Feasibility Study') which addresses a range of remedial alternatives to address the VOCs in groundwater. As documented in the Feasibility Study, "no further action was recommended for soil a OU -4B sites... therefore, soil remediation..." was not addressed in the Feasibility Study. A final groundwater remedial action plan has not yet been selected for IRP 13W. (d) Deed Restrictions. Deed restrictions will ultimately be recorded on all or a portion of the Homesites or Homes in the Community lying within the LIFOC Property, and will limit certain activities on such Homesites or Homes. These deed restrictions will identify specific land use restrictions to prevent exposure of future landowners and/or users of the LIFOC Property to hazardous substances and to maintain the integrity of the remedial action until remediation is complete and remediation goals have been achieved. (e) Documentation Relating to the Release and Remediation Activities. Extensive documentation has been prepared that describes the nature and extent of the release of hazardous substances that has occurred at the LIFOC Property. The following reports are available for public review and document the investigation and remediation work that has been or will be performed at the LIFOC Property: (i) Draft Feasibility Study Report For Operable Unit 4B, Former Marine Corps Air Station, Tustin, California, August 2005 (Bechtel Environmental, Inc., August 2005); (ii) Final Record of Decision/Remedial Action Plan Operable Unit 1A, Former Marine Corps Air Station, Tustin, California (Department of Navy, October 2004); (iii) Final Feasibility Study Report, OU-lA, Marine Corps Air Station, Tustin, California (Bechtel Environmental, Inc., August 2003); and (iv) Final Environmental Impact Statement/Environmental Impact Report, Disposal and Reuse of MCAS Tustin, California (Department of Navy and City of Tustin, December 1999). You should carefully review these reports before making a decision to buy a Home in the Community. Copies of the reports are available for review at either.(1) BRACS Environmental Coordinator's Office, Library Building 307, WAS El Toro, telephone (949) 726-5398 or (2) City of Tustin, Department of Community Development, 300 Centennial Way, Tustin, CA 92780, telephone (714) 573-3100. The Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders make no representations or warranties with respect to the LIFOC Property and the Buyer Initials: / -13- 2544-33253\CLP42WISCL8R\ 609965.4 8/11106 environmental conditions described above or in the reports. Due to the fact that groundwater in the Community has been found at depths of six (6) to twenty-five (25) feet below the ground surface, as described below, you are advised to avoid eating any fruit. from trees with deep root systems in the Community or drinking any groundwater, and to keep your children and animals away fi-om such fruit and groundwater. (f) The following items have been indicated in the EIR. as affecting portions of MCAS Tustin that are outside of the Community. These items are not expected to impact the Community, and are listed in this Disclosure for your information only. Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders make no representations or warranties as to any future impact these items may have on the Community or Residents using public parks and other areas outside the Community. (i) Former crash drill site area; (ii) Former skeet ranges; (iii) Transformers containing polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs); (iv) Buildings formerly on property containing lead based paint, (v) Moffit Meadow fire fighting trenches and crash crew burn pits; (vi) JP -5 pipeline, currently classified as out of service; and (vii) Petroleum hydrocarbons in subsurface soil. If you have any questions or concerns about environmental activities at MCAS Tustin or the Community, please contact the Local Redevelopment Authority at the City of Tustin or visit the United States Naval Facilities Engineering Command's internet website at www..e.fdsw.navfac.navy.inil/F,,nvitoninentaVT-ustin.btin- 27. Prior Agricultural Use. The Community is located on or near lands that are or were previously used for agricultural purposes, including farming operations. By reason of such agricultural use, you may be subject to dust, noise and odors and may be exposed to pesticides, herbicides, insecticides and other chemicals. By acceptance of a deed to a Home, you on your own behalf, and on behalf of the members of your family, tenants, lessees, guests and invitees) expressly acknowledge and accept these existing and future impacts and forever waive any and all causes of actions against the Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders and Community Association and their respective directors, officers, employees, agents, representatives and consultants for any damages or injuries which may arise from or relate to any such conditions or risks. 28. Private Recreational Center. The Community is planned to include a private recreational center (the "Center'). The Center is planned to include swimming and wading pools, spas and recreational building and other recreational facilities. While the Center is planned to be private and only open to owners and guests in the Community, the public will have access to the open space areas surrounding the Center and some outdoor recreational Buyer Initials: 1 _ 11�_ 2544-33253\C 609965.4 8111706 facilities in the Open Space/Park Areas. All persons using the Center are required to use caution and to watch their children at all times to prevent drowning and other injuries. The Community Association may, from time to time, promulgate rules for use and operation of the Center, including reasonable hours of operation. Owners and other residents living in the area of the Center will most likely experience and otherwise be subject to or inconvenienced by noise and pedestrian and vehicular traffic in the areas surrounding the Center. 29. Natural Hazard Zone Disclosures. Your Neighborhood Builder will provide you with a Natural Hazard Disclosure Statement in compliance with Section 1103 of the California Civil Code that discloses whether your Home is located in a seismic hazard zone. (a) Earthquakes. California is subject to a wide range of earthquake activity. California has many known earthquake faults as well as yet undiscovered faults. While the Community is not located in an Alquist Priolo Earthquake Zone, earthquakes are always a possibility. You must evaluate the potential for future seismic activity that may seriously damage your Homesite and Home. A major earthquake, which some have predicted will occur in our lifetimes, could cause very serious damage to Homes located even many miles from the epicenter of the earthquake. A more moderate earthquake occurring on a more minor fault, or on an as yet undiscovered fault, could also cause substantial damage. For more information, read "The Homeowners Guide to Earthquake Safety" which explains the various geological hazards associated with earthquakes and contains information on planning ahead for earthquakes, as well as what to do during and after an earthquake. Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders make no representations or warranties as to the degree of earthquake risk in the Community. You are advised to consult with the City, County, other public agencies and appropriate experts to evaluate the potential risk. (b) Seismic Hazard Zones. Many portions of California are subject to risks associated with seismic activity. Areas that meet the definition of "Seismic Hazard Zone" in the Seismic Hazards Mapping Act (California Public Resources Code Section 2690, et seq.) are shown on maps that are prepared and released by the California Department of Conservation, Division of Mines and Geology. Such zones may pose an increased risk of damage to property from earthquakes and liquefaction. "Liquefaction" is the process by which water -saturated soils become unstable under heaving shaking and thereby jeopardize foundations and other structures. The Master Developer has been informed that all or a portion of the Community is located within a Seismic Hazard Zone. You are advised to consult with the City, County, other public agencies and appropriate experts to evaluate the potential risk. For more information concerning seismic activity and risks, read "The Homeowner's Guide to Earthquake Safety." (c) Area of Potential Flooding. The Master Developer has been informed that the Community is located within an Area of Potential Flooding (or Dam Inundation Zone) pursuant to applicable maps. The Office of Emergency Services is required to designate areas within which personal injury or death would, in its determination, result from the partial or total failure of any dam. These areas of potential flooding, as defined in the California Emergency Services Act (California Government Code Section 8984.4, et seq.), are shown on maps released by the Office of Emergency Services, copies of which are also on file with the City. These maps are updated periodically, and the Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders and Community Association make no representations, guarantees or warranties with respect to any future dam Buyer Initials: / -15- 2544-33253\CLP428MISCLSM 609965A 8/11/06 inundation zone determinations. The Community is downstream from the Santiago Creek Dam, an earthfll dam approximately one hundred and thirty-six (136) feet high which has a capacity of 25,000 acre feet of water. Santiago Creek Dam is jointly owned and maintained by the Serrano Irrigation District and the Irvine Ranch Water District. Information about the Santiago Creek Dam can be found on the California Department of Water Resources website: littp://cdee.water.ca.gov/misc/resinfo.httnl. Please contact the Office of Emergency Services for further information concerning Areas of Potential Flooding, 30. Soil Conditions. In purchasing your Home, you should review soils reports for the Community, available for review at the City, and take into consideration the following: (a) Expansive Sail. According to the soils report, soil in the Community is highly expansive in nature. Expansive soil expands when it becomes wet and it contracts when it dries out. Expansion and contraction of soils may cause movement, lifting, cracking and distress in slabs, patios, sidewalks and other flatwork improvements. Some cracking is normal in all flatwork improvements, with or without expansive soils. However, some expansion damage may be reduced by use of appropriate design and construction techniques. When designing flatwork and other Improvements, you should advise your consultants that designs must accommodate soils with expansion potential. In addition, you should consider the following information and recommendations before making or modifying any Improvements. (b) Concrete and Masonry Improvements. Special attention is required in designing and constructing concrete and masonry Improvements such as masonry walls and planters, concrete slabs and decking. For example, steel reinforcing bars may be required in lieu of steel mesh in concrete patio slabs. Block walls may require extra horizontal and vertical steel reinforcing bars. (c) Drainage and Irrigation. Owners must use adequate drainage and irrigation control. Drainage devices installed in the Community by the Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders should not be altered in any manner that will redirect or obstruct drainage through these devices. The construction or modification of Improvements should not result in ponding of water, Drainage devices, including, but not limited to, concrete ditches, area drain lines and gutters should be carefully designed and installed with professional assistance and then maintained in an unobstructed condition. Drainage devices installed by the Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders designed to serve more than the (1) Home should not be altered in a manner that will redirect or obstruct the drainage through these drainage devices. The landscape irrigation system should be designed, constructed and operated to prevent excessive saturation of soils. Water must drain away from the Home footings and other Improvements. Obstructions such as walls should not be constructed across swales unless adequate replacement drainage Improvements have been installed or created. Planters should be lined with an impervious surface and should contain outlets to drain excess water. , (d) Fill Soil. Homes in the Community may be constructed on fill soil in accordance with the recommendations and inspection of licensed civil and soils engineers. A soils report certifying the compaction of fill soils is available for review at the City. Buyer Initials: J _ 1(�_ 2544-33253TIP42SUSCLSM 609965.4 $/11/06 (e) Corrosive Soil. Soils in some areas of the Community are potentially severely corrosive to buried concrete and ferrous metals. Soluble sulfates and acidic soils are highly corrosive to buried metals and concrete and should be taken into account in the construction of below grade structures and hardscape. Sulfates may chemically and physically attack concrete that is not sulfate resistant, causing the concrete to break down. Thus, you must use the proper type of cement and water -to -cement ratio for the level of sulfates or acidity that exists on your Homesite. Overwatering soil will exacerbate the corrosivity of the soil. You should inform contractors of this potential condition to allow them to use appropriate measures to combat the effects of corrosive soil on buried metals, below grade structures and hardscape. (f) Groundwater. Groundwater has been encountered in portions of the Community at depths of six (6) to twenty-five (25) feet below the ground surface. You may not dig or drill on any Homesite to a depth that would disturb or otherwise come in contact with the groundwater. Groundwater may rise during the rainy season. (g) Pools/Spas. Prior to designing any pool, spa, or other similar amenity, it is recommended you consult with a licensed civil engineer to determine the depth of the water table under your Homesite to insure that your Improvements are compatible with the depth of the water table and that they will not disturb or come in contact with the groundwater during a rainy season. The Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders make no guarantee that any Homesite has the ability for pool or spa installation. Homesites 242 through 245, inclusive, of Tract No. 16581, which are located within the LIFOC Property, have been determined to be unsuitable for installation of pools, spas or other similar amenity. The deeds for these Lots will contain deed restrictions that prohibit the use of the Lots for such purposes. (h) Soils Professionals. Before starting a pool or spa or any patio, concrete or other flatwork on the Homesite, you should consult with a licensed soils engineer to ensure that such work is constructed correctly in light of current soils conditions. Although consulting with a soils professional may add substantially to the cost of installation of improvements, failure to do so may result in significant breaking, lifting, separating, tilting or cracking in improvements. (i) Interior Gases and Other Contaminants. The aging process of soil and natural soil elements, as well as the aging of man-made building materials, may create unwanted and undesired gases and other contaminants in Homes, both new and previously occupied. In addition, a lower rate of air exchange between outdoor and indoor environments has resulted from modern construction techniques which comply with energy conservation requirements enacted by the State of California. A lower air exchange rate can result in the build-up of unwanted gases and other contaminants in varying degrees. As the quality of the air we breathe can affect our health, you should frequently air out your Home by opening the windows. 31. Post -Tension Concrete System. Your Home may have been built using a post - tension concrete system ("System'). If any portion of your Home has been constructed using the System, a placard or stamp will be placed in the garage signifying the existence of such System. The System involves placing steel cables under high tension in the concrete slab located beneath the Home. Therefore, any attempt to alter or pierce the foundation (for example, sawing, cutting or drilling) could damage the integrity of the System and cause serious injury or damage to persons and property. The Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders shall not be Buyer Initials: 1 -17- 2544-3325ACLP42MISCLSM 609465.4 8111/06 responsible for any damage or injury resulting from or arising in connection with the alteration of the slab or foundation of any Home. By acceptance of a deed to a Home, you agree that: (i) you shall not cut into or otherwise tamper with the System; (ii) you shall not knowingly permit or allow any other person to cut into or tamper with the System so long as you own any interest in the Home; (iii) you shall disclose the existence of the System to any person who rents, leases or purchases your Home; and (iv) you shall indemnify and hold the Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders and all of their affiliated entities, officers, directors, agents and assigns free and harmless from any and all claims, damages, losses or other liability (including attorneys' fees and costs) arising from any breach of this covenant. 32. Reclaimed Water. In its efforts to conserve water, the Irvine Ranch Water District (the "Water District") requires the use of reclaimed water (treated wastewater) to irrigate parks, school yards, golf courses, greenbelt areas and common areas. The Water District may require the use of reclaimed water to irrigate landscaping in private yards. The water used in the Homes and outside in the patio and yard areas through hose bibs will be domestic potable water. The water used to irrigate the Association Property may include reclaimed water. Reclaimed water is not potable and therefore not suitable for human consumption. As with any water overspray, the repeated spray of reclaimed water may stain or discolor personal property, fencing and structural Improvements. According to the Water District, the Water District's reclaimed water is disinfected with chlorine and its clarity to the human eye is indistinguishable from domestic water. The standards imposed on the Water District for reclaimed water quality are established by governmental regulatory agencies, and these standards are subject to change. The Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders and Community Association and their agents are not liable for any property damage or personal injury by reclaimed water. You are subject to Water District rules and regulations, one of which prohibits the use of self -generating water softeners connected to Water District sewer facilities. Further information regarding Water District regulations is available at the Water District's headquarters. 33. Air Quality. Southern California is subject to Stage I smog alerts. You should take advantage of the Air Quality Management District's ("A. Q.M.D. 11 forecasts to plan your outdoor activities to avoid peak pollution by checking your television, radio or daily newspapers to find out if unhealthful air quality is expected. For more information, you can also call A.Q.M.D. at 1-800-CUT-SMOO (1-800-288-7664) or check their website at www.ag)nd.aov. By acceptance of a deed to a Home, you (for and on your behalf, and the members of your family, tenants, lessees, guests and invitees) expressly acknowledge and accept the existing and possible future impacts of smog on yourself and your family and forever waive any and all causes of actions against the Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders and their respective directors, officers, employees, agents, representatives and consultants for any damages or injuries which may arise from or relate to any such conditions or risks. 34. Wind. All of Southern California is subject to periods of high winds. Wind speeds in the Community may exceed that experienced in other areas of the surrounding region. You must ensure that any structures or other Improvements you install on your Homesite are constructed or designed to withstand high winds. You are advised to consult with experienced Guyer initials: 1 _18_ 2544-33253TI_P42MISCLSM 604465.4 8t11106 architects and engineers in the design and specification of any structures or Improvements that you plan to add. 35. Private Streets. All of the streets within the Community are private streets. Maintenance and repair of the private streets is the responsibility of the Community Association or the Neighborhood Associations, as applicable. 36. Building Setbacks. Construction of Improvements in the yard of any Homesite such as pools, spas, patio covers, BBQ, fountains, trellises and water features are subject to minimum setback and height restrictions and may not be permitted. You should refer to the Community Association Governing Documents and applicable City ordinances for any restrictions concerning the construction of any Improvements to your Homesite. 37, Boundaries. You may not rely on any written or oral statements by Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders or their agents regarding the exact boundaries of your Homesite or Home or whether any wall or fence has been or will be constructed exactly on the boundaries of your Homesite. 38. Square Footage Representations. Representations of square footage are approximate only. You may not rely on any written (brochures and other sales documents) or verbal statements by Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders or their agents regarding the exact square footage of your Homesite or Home. The computation of square footage varies based on the criteria used. You agree by acceptance of a deed to a Home to hold the Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders harmless in any dispute arising over any representations concerning the square footage of your Homesite or Home. TAXES AND ASSESSMENTS 39. Supplemental Real Property Taxes. The California law requires real property to be revalued whenever it changes ownership or when improvements are newly constructed. After the Close of Escrow for your Home, the County of Orange Tax Assessor ("Assessor") will determine a new taxable value for your Home based on current market values. The property tax will increase and you will receive one or more supplemental tax bills depending upon the time of the year in which Escrow closed for the purchase of your Home. Master Developers and Neighborhood Builders have no control over the valuation, timing or the amount of the supplemental bill resulting from the reassessment. You are solely responsible for the payment of any supplemental tax bills. The following notice is given pursuant: to Section 1102.6c of the California Civil Code: "California property tax law requires the Assessor to revalue real property, at the time the ownership of the property changes. Because of this law, ,you may receive one or two supplemental tax bills, depending on when your loan closes. The supplemental tax bills are not mailed to ,your lender. If you have arranged for your property tax payments to be paid through an impound account, the supplemental tax bills will not be paid by your lender. It is your responsibility to pay these supplemental bills directly to the Tax Collector. If BuyeInitiate: _ -19_ 2544-33253\CLP42M1SCLSR\609%5.4 8/11/06 you have any question concerning this matter, please call your local Tax Collector's Office--' Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders have no control over the valuation, timing or the amount of the supplemental bill resulting from the reassessment. You are solely responsible for the payment of the supplemental tax bill. You hereby acknowledge, accept and agree that neither Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders nor any of their authorized agents, representatives, employees or sales people have made any representations or warranties respecting the amount of the supplemental assessment or the assessed value. Should you have any questions or concerns relating to the supplemental assessment, you agree, prior to the Close of Escrow, to consult with the County Assessor or your legal or other advisors to satisfy such questions or concerns. 40. Estimated Taxes. You have been provided with an estimate of your assessments. THE AMOUNT OF ASSESSMENTS ARE ESTIMATES ONLY, and are based on current information provided by the City, County or those public or private agencies responsible for the administration for the districts. These assessments may INCREASE or DECREASE, based upon changes in real property tax law; the district(s) may dissolve; formation of new districts may occur, an extension of the districts or the services to the districts and other factors NOT IN MASTER DEVELOPER'S OR NEIGHBORHOOD BUILDER'S CONTROL may transpire. The amount of special taxes may appear on your property tax bill or may be billed separately. t{- 41. Special Tax Assessment Districts. All or a portion of the Community lies within (1 the boundaries of the following Special Tax and Assessment Districts: v (a) Community Facilities District No. 06-1. Several Neighborhoods in the 41 Community are located within the boundaries of City of Tustin Community Facility District No. h 06-1 ("CFD No. 06-1'l which was formed for the construction and maintenance of public improvements, including, but not limited to, street improvements, parkway and landscaping, storm drains, utilities, public parks, public libraries and fire protection facilities. If your Home is located within CFD No. 06-1, your Home will be subject to any taxes, assessments and 3 obligations associated with CFD No. 06-1. You will be provided with a Notice of Special Tax y for CFD No. 06-1. This Notice contains important information about district functions, your obligations, rights of the district, and information on how to contact the district for additional information materials. You should carefully read and understand the information contained in j the Notice. Master Developers and Neighborhood Builders have no control over the amount of -� tax assessments levied or imposed against your Home or any increase or decrease in the amount of such assessments. Please contact the City of Tustin (City Clerk), telephone (714) 573-3025 for additional information. (b) Tustin Unifred School District Community Facilities District No. 06-1. Several Neighborhoods in the Community are located within the boundaries of Tustin Unified School District Community Facility District No. 06-1 ("TUSDCFD No. 06-1') which was forrned for the construction and maintenance of elementary, middle and high school facilities and any improvements in connection with such facilities. If your Home is located within TUSDCFD No. 06-1, your Home will be subject to any taxes, assessments and obligations associated with TUSDCFD No. 06-1. You will be provided with a Notice of Special Tax for Buyerhiirials! i _20_ 2544-3325\TP4281D15C' M609%5.4 R/l 1/06 TUSDCFD No. 06-1. This Notice contains important information about district functions, your obligations, rights of the district, and information on how to contact the district for additional information materials. You should carefully read and understand the information contained in the Notice. Master Developers and Neighborhood Builders have no control over the amount of tax assessments levied or imposed against your Home or any increase or decrease in the amount of such assessments. Please contact the City of Tustin (City Clerk), telephone (714) 573-3025 for additional information. 4446AT"M (JVVVVA't(CA) (c) Proposed Tustin LLD. Master Developer currently intends to form a MAV-dn landscape and lighting maintenance assessment district with the City of Tustin ("Proposed City ekep%T LLD'J. The Proposed City LLD is expected to be formed to pay for the maintenance of public �ILYYI street lighting, landscaping and park maintenance within the Proposed City LLD area. (d) Recreation and Inprovemurt Maintenance District. The Irvine Unified School Dlsirict has formed a recreation and improvement maintenance district which is an annual assessment for maintenance of public sports/playfields. Please contact David Taussig & Associates, telephone (949) 955-1500 for additional information. The Neighborhood Builder will provide you with disclosures entitled "Notice of Special Tax" ("Notice") prior to entering into a contract to purchase a Home. These Notices will inform you of the special tax and assessment districts that apply to your Home. The Notices will also contain a detailed description of the special tax calculation, important information about functions and rights of the special tax and assessment districts, your obligations, and who to contact for additional information about the special tax and assessment districts. You should thoroughly understand the information contained in the Notices prior to entering into a contract to purchase a Home. You will have five days after the Notice is delivered by mail, or three days atter its delivery in person, to terminate the contract to purchase by giving written notice of that termination. All Homes will be subject to annual special taxes levied by one or more of the special tax and assessment districts listed above. Not all special tax or assessment districts listed above will apply to your Home. These special taxes will be a continuing lien on your Home and will be billed to you with the annual real property tax bill issued by the County Assessor. The lien of these special taxes will continue until the obligation is satisfied. If you fail to pay a special tax when due, the assessment districts may exercise their right to foreclose on your Home. Information concerning the estimated amount of the annual special tax on your Home for the special tax and assessment districts is available from the City and County. 42. Changes in Special Taxes. The amount of any special taxes disclosed to you are estimates only, and are based on current information provided by the City, County or other public or private agencies responsible for the administration of special tax districts. Special taxes may increase or decrease, based upon the terms of the special tax lien, changes in real property tax law, the dissolution of special tax districts, the formation of new special tax districts, extension of special tax district(s), changes in services by the districts and other facts not in Master Developer's or Neighborhood Builders' control. The amount of special taxes may appear on your real property tax bill or may be billed separately. Buylm Initials -21- 2544-3325NIP428018CLSM 6OM5.4 Ell U06 ADJACENT AREA DISCLOSURES 43. Adjacent Property Disclosures. The land adjacent to the Community within the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan has a variety of land use designations. The land use designations are subject to change. Therefore, the type of future development adjacent to the Community cannot be predicted with accuracy. 44. MCAS Specific Plan, MCAS Tustin was realigned and closed on July 2, 1999, in accordance with Base Realignment and Closure Act. The Department of Defense recognized the City of Tustin as the Lead Agency or Local Redevelopment Authority ("LRA") for preparation of the required reuse planning documents in late 1991. The MCAS Tustin Specific Plan/Reuse Plan (the "Plan") includes detailed planning, policies, regulations, implementation strategies and procedures necessary to guide the reuse and development of the site into the next century. Since implementation of the Plan will be a long- term process and there are unique circumstances associated with converting military bases to civilian uses, the Plan is intended to be practical in economic terms and visionary in terms of its ability to create and respond to future market opportunities. This means that it must provide sufficient guidance to provide investors with a high confidence level that their investments will be protected. At the same time, it must offer sufficient flexibility to respond to changing market conditions. A careful balance between certainty and flexibility underlies the provisions of this Plan. The Plan is intended to serve as both a policy -oriented and regulatory document. The Plan has been submitted to the Department of Defense as a policy guide outlining the intended reuse for the Community. Subsequently, the Plan will be adopted by the Tustin City Council as the zoning for the Community. The Plan may also be amended one or more times by the City of Tustin. The Plan is one device for implementing goals and policies of the Tustin General Plan. The Plan also contains the development and reuse regulations that constitute the zoning for the Community. As a federal installation, MCAS Tustin was not subject to local zoning and planning requirements. Upon conversion to civilian use, the former MCAS Tustin property will be under the jurisdictional authority of either the City of Tustin or the City of Irvine, as applicable, and will be subject to local codes and ordinances. The City of Irvine has assigned responsibility for preparation of the Plan (and accompanying joint Environmental Impact Statement/Environmental Impact Report) to Tustin for that portion of the Plan area within Irvine. However, the City of Irvine will have to adopt any General Plan and zoning changes necessary to implement the provisions of the Plan within the City of Irvine. The land uses described in the Plan for the area covered by the Plan include, but are not limited to, Low -High Density Residential, Transitional and Affordable Housing, Golf Resort Living, Commercial Business and Retail, and Institutional/Recreational designations such as Parks, Trails and Schools. Also recommended were applications by the Orange County Sheriffs Department, City of Tustin and County of Orange Social Service Agency. 2544-33253TU428U11SCI-M 609165.4 Huyer]nitials: / -22' 8!11106 The Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders have no control over the Plan, changes to the Plan, or development of the area covered by the Plan in accordance with the Plan. For further information, you should review the Plan. The Plan and information regarding the development of the Plan is available for review at the office of the Local Redevelopment Agency, City of Tustin. 45. The District. The District is a proposed one million square foot outdoor shopping center to be located approximately one and one-half (1'/,) miles southwest of the Community, at the corner of Jamboree Road and Barranca Parkway. The District is planned to include, among other businesses, several retail stores, a grocery store and a movie theater. The District will result in increased noise and traffic in and around the Community, particularly along Jamboree Road and Barranca Parkway. Neither Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders nor the Community Association have any control over the use or maintenance of the District or its impact on the Community. 46. Rail Corridor/ Metrolink Station. As disclosed in the Homebuyer Notification, there is a rail corridor ("Corridor") located to the north of the Community. There is also a Metrolink station ("Sla don") located to the north of the Community at 2975 Edinger Avenue, Tustin, CA 92780. The impact of the Corridor and Station may include, without limitation, increased noise, light and vibration levels in the vicinity of the Community. The Corridor and Station could be an attractive nuisance to children and animals who may wish to play in the vicinity of the rail corridor. The Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders and the Community Association have no control over the use, maintenance or care of the Corridor or Station. You acknowledge and understand that you are responsible for keeping your children and animals away from the Corridor and Station and the danger that is inherent around the Corridor and Station. You should evaluate the impact of the Corridor and Station on your decision to purchase a Horne in the Community. 47. Temporary Sewer Lift Station. A temporary sewer lift station will be constructed within the vicinity of the Community. It is located at the northeast corner of p�"�• Kensington Drive and Valencia North Loop Road and will serve a portion of the Community Y�rb until such time the master infrastructure is completed to connect your Homesite or Home to the �ot�d - ,� � main sewer lines. The lift station will be installed below -grade and will be owned and —ftc-y CotAtiw�bYr maintained by the Irvine Ranch Water District. Owners of Homes near the lift station may g6Vk otn experience an increase in noise and dust leve s in the area of the lift station during the IWIU&4( �n,�`n• construction period and less significant noise le els after completion. Owners may encounter , •� some odors in the areas near the lift station. You cknowledge, understand and agree that neither "Gott n" the Community Association nor the Neighborho Builders will have any control over the use, maintenance or care of the lift station. Fret Ve ; eh re�re.,c«9 M s,f« bz%ref i0t` 48. Areas Outside the Specific Plan. The MCAS Tustin Specific Plan, which is bounded by Edinger Avenue, Redhill Avenue, Barranca Parkway and Harvard Avenue has the following surrounding uses. (a) Edinger Avenue; Buyer biitials: A rail corridor and Metrolink station (described above) are located along -23- 2544-33253\CLP429\DISCLSR160W5A MIft (b) A business park, commercial and industrial areas, sports park and utility power lines are located -along Banana Parkway; (c) Adjacent to the west side of Warner Avenue exists a Southern California Edison easement with high voltage transmission lines and usages by a wholesale plant nursery and public storage facility; and (d) A Southern California Edison easement area with high voltage transmission lines, landscaped areas available for public access and residential neighborhoods are located along Harvard Avenue. The Master Developer, Neighborhood Builder and the Community Association have no control over development outside of the Community. 49. Airport Proximity Disclosure. The Community is located within what is known as an airport influence area (as defined in California Civil Code Section 1353) surrounding John Wayne Airport. John Wayne Airport is located approximately 3.6 miles southwest of the Community at the (405) San Diego Freeway and MacArthur Boulevard in the City of Santa Ana. For that reason, the Community may be subject to some of the annoyances or inconveniences associated with proximity to airport operations (for example: noise, vibration or odors). Individual sensitivities to those annoyances can vary from person to person. You may wish to consider what airport annoyances, if any, are associated with the Community before you complete your purchase and determine whether they are acceptable to you. John Wayne Airport has noise abatement procedures in place, but there is no guarantee that these procedures will lessen the impacts on the Community of noise and vibrations caused by aircraft using this airport or that these noise abatement procedures will continue in the future. Further information is available from the airport website: www.o aair.coni. Your Neighborhood Builder will provide you with a separate airport proximity notice required by California Civil Code Section 1353. 50. Avigation Easement. An avigation easement has been recorded against the Community. The avigation easement establishes a permanent right to travel through the air space over the Community for the benefit of John Wayne Airport. You may notice noise and vibration from overflying aircraft approaching or leaving the airstrip. By accepting a deed to a Home in the Community, you understand that the avigation easement gives the users of the airstrip a perpetual legal right to fly over the Community without interference from the occupants of the Community. 51. Residential Developments. There are existing single-family residential developments adjacent to the northern, eastern and western boundaries of the Community. In addition to increased automobile and pedestrian traffic resulting from the proximity of these residential developments to the Community, the solitude of a Home's yard area may be significantly impacted by the proximity, height and design of multi -story, residential buildings constructed on property adjacent to the Community. The Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders have no control over the proximity, height and design of such nearby buildings and make no representation on the future impacts that these residential developments will have on residents of the Community. Buyer Initials: / _7Q_ 2544-33253\CLP428\D1SCL.SR\609965.4 911 1/06 52. Commercial/Industrial Property. The Community is located within the vicinity of property zoned for commercial and heavy industrial uses. This area consists of, among others, a Waste Management Public Recycling/Transferring Station, asphalt recycling, trucking facilities and multiple concrete companies, all with product deliveries. These commercial and industrial properties may generate dust, offensive odor, noise and other effects. The Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders have no control over the existing or potential uses of this property. These uses may create light, noise and other nuisances twenty-four (24) hours a day, seven (7) days a week. 53. Elementary School. The Tustin Unified School District owns an elementary school site located to the southeast of the Community. Owners and other residents within the Community may experience, among other things, glare from bright lights, noise and increased traffic and parking congestion in connection with the use of this site. There are no assurances if or when any school will be completed on the site, nor the type of facilities that may be included as part of the school. You should contact the Tustin Unified School District at (714) 730-7301 for more information. Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders and the Community Association make no representations as to the future use of this school site. 54. Development Area. The Community lies in a rapidly expanding area. As future commercial and residential developments are built in and around MCAS Tustin, you may expect attendant limitations on solitude and inconveniences. For example, you can expect to hear noise from the development of future adjacent residential and commercial areas and the machinery used to develop these areas. You can also expect increased traffic and rerouting of traffic as new residential and commercial developments are constructed, nearby streets and major thoroughfares are widened and new streets are built. As the area around the Community develops, you may experience light entering your Home from exterior sources including streetlights, parking lot lighting and nearby residential and commercial buildings. The Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders and the Community Association have no control over the transmission of noise, light, vibration, odor and other impacts or their potential effects on Homes in the Community, including any which may be a direct result of current and future construction activity. 55. MCAS Tustin Airship Hangars. Two (2) airship hangars ("Hangars') are located within MCAS Tustin southwest of the Community. The hangars are each approximately one thousand (1,000) feet long, three hundred (300) feet wide, and one hundred and seventy (170) feet tall. The view from your Home may be effected by the nearby presence of the Hangars. It has not been determined whether these Hangars will remain or be demolished, or what uses might be made of them. For further information regarding the Hangars, please contact the City of Tustin. 56. Future Fire Station Site. The Community is located adjacent to a future fire station site at the corner of Edinger Avenue and West Connector Road. The Are station will operate twenty four (24) hours a day and seven (7) days a week. Owners whose Homes are located in the vicinity of the fire station will notice noise, sirens, light, glare and other impacts from the operation of the fire station and emergency vehicles. You are advise that Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders have no control over the operation or use of the fire Buyer1"Wak: �/ _25- 2544-332531CLP42$1DISCLSR�609965.4 8(11/06 station. You should carefully evaluate the impact of the fire station on your decision to purchase a Homesite or Home in the Community. 57. Village Services. The Community is located northwest of an area designated in the Plan as the Village Services area. When and if built, this area is intended to be accessible to both vehicle and pedestrian traffic, and to provide localized commercial retail and service uses to adjacent residential areas within the Plan area. 58. Learning Village/Transitional and Emergency Housing. The Community is located east of an area designated in the Plan as the Learning Village area. When and if built, this area is intended to provide a specialized educational environment with a variety of public - serving uses. GENERAL DISCLOSURES 59. Neighborhood Model Homes. Neighborhood model homes reflect typical exterior elevations, floor plans and methods of construction, and also illustrate possibilities for future interior decoration and exterior landscaping and hardscape improvements. Your Home will not necessarily conform to any model shown. The exterior elevations, architectural treatments, floor plans and colors shown on the master plot plans on display at the office of each Neighborhood Builder may be different than those both displayed in the models and those actually constructed by the Neighborhood Builder. Additionally, window locations, window types, roof lines, architectural projections and other similar features vary by elevation and Home location, and not all of the features displayed in the models may be included in your Home. The models have also been professionally decorated to show various decor ideas. Decoration items such as furnishings, draperies and other window treatments, any window tinting, wallpaper, custom carpet, coordinated paint, built-in shelves, beams, certain lighting fixtures (including halogen lighting), special ceiling treatments and some mirrors are for display purposes only, and are not included in the purchase price for your Home. Entries, walkways and driveways are shown in a variety of materials to show design ideas; however, for your Home, they will be constructed using only standard concrete. The hardscape shown in the model complex may not depict what may be constructed in all locations. Additionally, landscaping for the models is greater in density and type than any landscape package offered by a Neighborhood Builder. If not expressly included in the purchase price for your Home in writing by a Neighborhood Builder, the rear, side and front yard landscaping is your responsibility. The type of plants, and the size and density of the landscaping in the yards of the models are merely intended to suggest ideas to you. Certain models may also include hardscape items (patio slabs, patio covers, pools, spas, etc.) which are not included in the purchase price of your Home. All such options and upgrades displayed in the models (including decorator items, landscaping and hardscape) are not included in the purchase price for your Home unless expressly agreed to in writing by the Neighborhood Builder. You should consult your sales representative for additional information regarding non-standard items used in the model homes. 60. Extended Use of the Model Complex. Each Neighborhood Builder reserves the right to use one or more Homes in a Neighborhood as a sales office and model home complex, and to display signs and banners, in connection with its program of marketing and selling Homes Buyer Initials: / -26- 9/1 609965.4 R/1 It0O in the Neighborhood as well as other Homes owned by Neighborhood Builders, even if they are located in separate and unrelated Neighborhoods. 61. Grading Variations. Your Homesite has been graded to City specifications and may vary significantly from other Homesites. Variations may include slopes, swales, drains, flood control channels and retaining walls as required. Any changes made to the grading of the Hon which your Home is located may significantly affect you or your neighbor's drainage pattern and cause significant property damage to your Home or a neighbor's Home. 62. Wall/Ceiling Heights. Wall and ceiling heights and configurations may vary significantly by elevation. Your Home's walls and ceiling heights may be different from those used in the model homes. You are encouraged to speak to a sales representative if you have any questions. 63. Right of Substitution. From time to time due to unavailability and other production considerations, it is necessary for a Neighborhood Builder to make substitutions of materials and other items used in construction of the Homes from. those materials and items displayed in the models. Therefore, each Neighborhood Builder reserves the right to make any changes or substitutions as the Neighborhood Builder deems necessary or desirable to the color schemes, building materials, fixtures, appliances and other components of the Homes. The foregoing substitutions may include, without limitation, kitchen appliances, household fixtures, electrical outlets and switches, hardware, wall surfaces, painting and other similar items. Each Neighborhood Builder shall have the right to make the substitutions described above without adjustment to the purchase price of your Home. 64. Changes in Construction Plans. The construction, grading, drainage and improvement plans (collectively, the "Construction Plans"j for Homesites and Homes within each Neighborhood all contain dimensions that are approximate. They are not intended to be precise dimensions with regard to the Neighborhood. Room dimensions and electrical outlet placement will vary slightly from models and from printed information. Construction will be performed in substantial conformance with the Construction Plans, but dimensions may change slightly from them. If there is a discrepancy between the Construction Plans and the actual as - built conditions of your Homesite or Home, the as -built conditions will control. The usable or buildable area, location and configuration of the Homesite and all improvements located thereon may fluctuate from that shown or displayed to you in the Construction Plans or any other drawings, topographic maps or models based upon a Neighborhood Builder's construction of final improvements including, without limitation, fencing and slopes, which shall be constructed in a Neighborhood Builder's sole and absolute discretion. The location, size, height and composition of all walls and fences to be constructed on your Homesite or Home or adjacent to your it shall be determined by the Neighborhood Builder in its sole and absolute discretion and despite the Construction Plans or any other models, drawings or topographic maps displayed to you. The Neighborhood Builder makes no representations, warranties or assurances as to the size, height, location or composition of any wall or fence to be constructed on or adjacent to your Homesite or Home. The Construction Plans are subject to change at any time without notice or obligation. Buyer lnitiaW / -27- 2544.33253W1.1142MISCLSM 609965.4 8/1 U)6 65. Non -Standard Construction. You may not personally perform any changes of any kind to your Home (such as alarm systems, home intercoms, stereo wiring, etc.) during construction and prior to the Close of Escrow. Such changes may void your warranty. Only those options and upgrades specifically agreed to by the Neighborhood Builder will be made. Any other changes and unapproved options found in a Home during the construction period will be removed by the Neighborhood Builder and the cost of removal and any repairs shall be your responsibility. 66. Changes In Development Plan and Prices. The residential real estate market continually fluctuates due to changes in economic, social and political conditions that directly affect the supply of and demand for housing. As a result, the development plan for the Neighborhood and the Community, and home prices and the terms and conditions of sale are also subject to change. Therefore: (a) With the exception of your Home, each Neighborhood Builder reserves the right at any time prior to or after the Close of Escrow for the sale of a Home and without notice, (i) to increase or decrease the sale price, adjust incentives or otherwise adjust the terms and conditions of sale for Homes in the Neighborhood or in the Community, and (ii) change the number, size, location, elevation, design or type of homes constructed in current or future phases of development of the Neighborhood; (b) No Neighborhood Builder is obligated to offer you the same price, incentives or other terms and conditions of sale that the Neighborhood Builder has previously offered or may subsequently offer to another purchaser; (c) No Neighborhood Builder has either offered or agreed to any price protection or other similar commitment to you regarding the value or resale value of your Home (or any other property), and no Neighborhood Builder shall not have any obligation or liability whatsoever to you in the event any price changes directly or indirectly affect the value of your Home; (d) When you entered into a Purchase Agreement, the Neighborhood Builder may have owned other properties which may have been off the market and may not have been shown to or otherwise made available for purchase by you. No Neighborhood Builder has any obligation to notify you if any of such properties come on the market or are otherwise available for purchase or any obligation to notify you of any future properties the Neighborhood Builder may develop and make available for purchase. (e) You shall not hold a Neighborhood Builder responsible for any fluctuations in the purchase price of Homes within the Neighborhood or the Community. ay you consideration of a Neighborhood Builder's agreement to sell a Horne to you, you agree shall have no claims against the Master Developer or the Neighborhood Builder for any possible change (decrease or increase) in the purchase price of Homes within the Neighborhood or any other terms of purchase, including, without limitation, upgrades or other concessions or incentives offered by a Neighborhood Builder to other purchasers of Homes within the Neighborhood and the construction of any additional floor plans on any of the Homes in the Neighborhood. -is- 2541-33253\CLPd28\DISCLSR\ 609965A Buyer initials: !�� 8111/06 67. Use of Subcontractors. Neighborhood Builders generally perform construction through the use of subcontractors, and may not employ construction trades or workers. A Neighborhood Builder is not permitted to change its subcontracts without approval of the respective subcontractor; therefore, you may not request interior or exterior construction changes or alterations not otherwise offered to other purchasers in the sales office. 68. Elevation/Floor Plan Specifications. In order to provide architectural diversity in the street scene, each Neighborhood Builder's architect has produced more than one exterior design (elevation) for each floor plan. Consequently, differences may be noticed between the model home for your floor plan and the elevation of your Home. You acknowledge that you have received a description of the exterior configuration for the elevation and the exterior color scheme number for your Home. You also acknowledge that your Home's elevation and floor plan may vary from the configuration of the model home for your Horne in terms of layout, sizes of certain rooms, exterior elevation features and other items such as sloped ceilings, veneer treatments, window locations and sizes, roof lines and color schemes. 69. Upper Floor Weight Limits. The upper floors of Homes are designed to support weight limits as outlined in the Uniform Building Code ("UBC'). If you currently own or are planning to purchase a waterbed, pool table or other heavy furniture you must confirm with the manufacturer that the weight introduced by these items does not exceed the UBC weight limit. Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders shall not be responsible for damage caused by anything you place on the upper floors that exceeds the UBC weight limit. 70. Air Conditioning. The air conditioning system and equipment specifications installed in the model homes may vary and operate at a higher capacity than those provided in your Home. You are encouraged to speak with your sales representative to determine the exact equipment specifications that will be provided with your Home. The location of the air conditioning compressor may vary between the model and your Horne and between your Home and other Homes in your Neighborhood. 71. Alarm System. If you purchase an alarm system from a Neighborhood Builder, you specifically waive any claims against Master Developer, the Neighborhood Builder and the Community Association as a result of any failure of the alarm system to warn, frighten off, or alert anyone about intruders or any other problems. The sale of such system to you by the Neighborhood Builder is not a guarantee or warranty against criminal acts. Master Developer, the Neighborhood Builders and the Community Association are not insurers against criminal acts. 72. Energy Conservation. Homes in the Community meet or exceed the energy conservation standards that are a part of Title 24 of the California Administrative Code. Each Neighborhood Builder is required to design and install heating and cooling units that meet strict guidelines in Title 24. This is an energy conservation law that is designed to help reduce the overall use of energy in your Home. Title 24 describes the amount of cooling capacity as well as the minimum efficiency ratings for each geographic location in the state. In complying with Title 24, the cooling units installed in your Home are designed for maximum efficiency. Due to the Title 24 geographic requirements, on extremely warm days your inside room temperature Buyer Initials: i _29- 2544-3325MCLP42801SCLSM 609965.4 81111% inay be wanner than your thermostat selection. This is due to design restrictions imposed by Title 24, not any design or installation defect by the Neighborhood Builder or its contractor. 73. Water Conservation. Each Home in the Community is equipped with low flow fixtures and other equipment to aid in water conservation in compliance with the City's Conditions of Approval for the Neighborhood. 74. Gas Barbecue Stub. If a natural gas service line is stubbed -out to an exterior backyard wall of your Home, it is suitable only for use in connection with a gas barbecue. Any other use may result in a serious fire hazard. The Neighborhood Builder and Master Developer are not responsible for any damage resulting from your use of the exterior gas stub. ds used for 75. Stain Grade Material Discoloration, with staff ral and lacquerofinish productswhich doors, stair systems, moldings, etc., are will change color over time. Color change may be the result of exposure to sunlight or weather, or simply the consequence of aging. Discoloration is not a defect. 76. Paint Discoloration. Certain portions of your Home, such as paint -grade cabinets, casework, moldings and interior doors, may be painted with oil-based enamel paint. Yellowing is common with oil-based enamel paints. Additionally, if your Home has white oil- based enamel paint -grade cabinets, yellowing will occur. 77. Variations In Natural Materials. Your Home may include various natural materials (e.g., wood products and/or stone products). Wood products vary in dimension, grain, color, moisture content, and performance when subjected to high moisture environments. Dimensional variations in the wood framing members (studs, plates, joists, rafters, and beams) or the required structural hardware connectors may show through the drywall and stucco finishes under certain lighting conditions. Wood panels and trim, exposed timbers, rafters, and posts will require periodic painting. Wood exposed to weather will require more frequent painting. Consult the maintenance schedule included in your Homeowners Manual. Some of the natural characteristics of wood will show through the painted or stained finish. For example, there may be shades of white, red, black, grey or even green in areas. Mineral streaks may also be visible. This is caused by the irregularity of mineral absorption from one part of the tree to another. Grain patterns or texture will vary from even to irregular throughout your cabinetry. Similarly, granite and natural stone products are composed of various mineral contents. Marble is less dense and more porous than granite. Great care must be taken to prevent damage to marble and other stone products. You should follow the manufacturers' recommendations for cleaning and maintenance. Because these are natural products, they are subject to variation in color, veining, spotting, holes, cloudiness, texture and cracking. Some may vary significantly in fiUer and sheen. The samples in the sales office are actual pieces of natural stone which indicate general color and character; however, no two (2) pieces can be expected to match, even when taken from the same box. You should view the stone prior to purchase, and any questions regarding these materials must be resolved prior to installation. If replacement of natural material the or carpet is required, you understand and agree that a match with existing material cannot be guaranteed. 78. Brass Plumbing/Light Fixtures/Hardware, Brass, bronze or other finishes have their limitations. In time, the protective lacquer may deteriorate from exposure to weather, —��_ 2544-33253\CLP428\DISCLSR\ 609965.4 Buyer Initials: ��_-- -- 8J11/00 perspiration, cleaning agents, frequency of use and other factors. Tarnishing or excessive wear of these finishes is, therefore, not a defect, but a normal process which is unavoidable. Under the circumstances, these finishes cannot be guaranteed and products will not be repaired or replaced under the manufacturer's warranties for tarnishing or wear of finishes. 79. Drywall Panels and Finishes. Drywall panels are placed over the wall studs, .joists, rafters and beams. Drywall is typically used to finish window openings. Drywall panels will not completely eliminate variations in the dimension and plane of wood framing members. Metal trim (i.e., corner bead) is used at corners, window edges, soffits and ceilings. They are designed to be filled with finish compounds. These trim metals provide a durable finish but cause the wall plane to "flare" at the metal edge. Panel joints and seams are taped and coated with finish compounds. Fasteners are coated with finish compounds to cover the small "dimple" in the surface of the drywall panel. Progressive applications of finish compounds are required to cover the joints, fasteners, and seams. In some cases, the normal finishing of these joints, fasteners, and seams will cause a subtle "bulge". When the finishing process is complete, the walls and ceilings receive a texture coat. In certain lighting conditions (up -lights placed close to the walls), irregularities and variations in the wall plane or intersection of vertical and horizontal panels may be evident. These variations are normal. 80. View. Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders, the Community Association and their counselors, agents, representatives or employees make no representations, warranties or promises concerning any view, present or future, that may be enjoyed from all or any portion of your Homesite or Home. The view from your Homesite or Home may change or may be fully or partially obstructed by (a) the construction of other homes, Improvements, structures, fences, walls and/or landscaping by Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders or other Owners within the Community, (b) activities and Improvements on real property outside the Community, and/or (c) the growth of trees and/or other vegetation within or outside the Community. You are advised that trees installed in the Community are generally smaller than they will be once mature and trees that do not block views when you purchase your Home may obstruct views as they grow. Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders make no representations or warranties with respect to any open space on property adjacent to your Homesite or Home, or the Community as a whole, whether this property is owned or controlled by Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders, government agencies or private property owners. 81. Warranties for Consumer Products. The manufacturers' warranties for the consumer products included in your Home (e.g., water heater, air conditioning system, dishwasher, garbage disposal and other household appliances) are available for review in the sales office of your Neighborhood Builder. 82. Financing. This paragraph only applies if you are purchasing your Home from a Neighborhood Builder who is also a Lennar Family Builder and you are financing the purchase with Universal American Mortgage Corporation ("UAMC"). You will be required to provide UAMC with all documents necessary to obtain loan approval. UAMC may be affiliated with the Neighborhood Builder. You are not obligated to accept a loan from UAMC, but you may be required to submit documentation to UAMC to permit the Neighborhood Builder to determine whether it is Iikely that you will qualify to purchase the Horne you desire. You may select your lender independently; however, if you select a lender other than UAMC, you must ensure that Buyer Initials: / -31- 2544-3325ACLA428USCLSM (M965.4 8/11/06 the lender can meet the time limitations and requirements imposed on lenders in the Purchase Agreement. Master Developer and Neighborhood Builder have not reviewed or approved any lender's sales or marketing materials, and does not make any representations or warranties whatsoever regarding any matters set forth therein or your ability to obtain any financing under any particular terms. You are strongly encouraged to make your own independent evaluation of the rates and loan programs offered by all lenders, including VAMC. You understand that the interest rate and loan fees for the loan applied for will be determined at the time of the Close of Escrow and may be higher or lower than on the date you signed a purchase agreement for your Home. You also acknowledge that the interest rate and loan fees referenced on the loan application are approximate only and do not constitute a binding commitment. 83. Schools. The Community is currently located in the Tustin Unified School District, telephone: (714) 730-7301 (the 'School District). To obtain further information about the schools serving the Community, including transportation to and from the schools, please contact the School District. You should investigate this matter to your satisfaction prior to purchasing a Horne in the Community. Due to the rate of population change, the school district may find it necessary to change boundaries and designated schools periodically, prior to or after your close of escrow. In addition, it is possible that school district boundaries may change and your children will be required to attend a different school district in the future. Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders have no control or responsibility for such changes should they occur. The Community is currently expected to be served by the following schools: Marjorie Veeh Elementary School (K-6) 1701 San Juan Street Tustin, California (714) 730-7544 A.G. Currie Middle School (7-8) 1402 Sycamore Avenue Tustin, California (714) 730-7352 Tustin High School (9-12) 4321 1171 El Camino Real Tustin, California (714) 730-7414 To obtain further information about the schools serving the Community, including transportation to and from the schools, please contact the applicable school referenced above or the School District, or you can visit the School District's website at www.tustin.k12.ca.us. You should investigate this matter to your satisfaction prior to purchasing a Home in the Community. 84. Mailboxes. Mailboxes in the Community may be clustered in groups as required by the United States Postal Service. The location of mailboxes and above -ground utility structures are determined by governmental agencies or utility companies, or both. You may not change the type of mailbox being used or the location. Master Developer and Neighborhood Auger Liitials; ! _2- 2544-33253\CLP42R\!7[SCLSR\ 609265.4 8/11/06 Builders reserve the right to modify such locations as may be dictated by field conditions without prior notice. - 85. Residential Construction Legislation. California Civil Code Sections 895 through 945.5 ("Construction Claims Statute'% went into effect on January 1, 2003. The Construction Claims Statute (a) delineates standards for how various components of your Horne should be constructed and function, (b) limits the time frames for bringing various claims against the Neighborhood Builder to anywhere from one year to ten years (as listed in the Construction Claims Statute) after the Close of Escrow, (c) imposes an obligation on all Owners and their successors in interest to follow Neighborhood Builder's maintenance recommendations and schedules or other applicable maintenance guidelines, and (d) establishes a non -adversarial claims resolution procedure. Pursuant to Section 914 of the Construction Claims Statute, the Neighborhood Builder is permitted to elect to utilize the procedure in the Construction Claims Statute or its own alternate contractual pre -litigation procedures. The applicable claims handling procedures are outlined in the Purchase Documents you receive from the Neighborhood Builder, including the "Dispute Resolution" provision in Section 13.5 of the Master Declaration. A separate notice further describing claims handling procedures may have been recorded against the title to Homes by the Neighborhood Builder in some Neighborhoods. You should review any such notice and your Purchase Documents carefully concerning these issues. YOU ARE ADVISED THAT THE CONSTRUCTION CLAIMS STATUTE AFFECTS YOUR LEGAL RIGHTS. YOU ARE ADVISED TO READ THE STATUTE CAREFULLY AND SEEK LEGAL ADVICE IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS REGARDING ITS EFFECT ON YOUR LEGAL RIGHTS. Buyer Initials Buyer Initials 86. Duty to Follow Maintenance Guidelines. An Owner is obligated by Section 907 of the Construction Claims Statute to follow any maintenance recommendations and schedules from the Neighborhood Builder, including the maintenance recommendations and schedules for manufactured products and appliances included with the Home, as well as all commonly accepted maintenance practices (collectively, "Maintenance Guidelines"). Pursuant to Section 945.5 of the Construction Claims Statute, failure to follow any such Maintenance Guidelines may reduce or preclude an Owner's right to recover damages relating to an Owner's Home which could have been prevented or mitigated had the Maintenance Guidelines been followed. Buyer Initials Buyer Initials 87. Obligation to Retain Purchase Documents. The Purchase Documents that you receive through escrow in conjunction with the purchase of a Home may include Maintenance Guidelines, a written limited warranty, claim forms, and other documentation relating to the Buyer Initials: / -33- 2544-33253\CLP428\DISCLSR\ 609965.4 8/11/06 ners e required ms Statute to Construction Claims Statute. All lidew copies rof such docunilents to Construction Owne �s 1 successors in retain these document,, p interest upon the sale or transfer of the Owner's Home. Buyer Initials Buyer initials 88. Warranty and Limitations on Liability. A Neighborhood Builder may provide a written limited warranty for the Homesite or Home covering certain defects for a limited period after the date the limited warranty commences. Warranty periods for items will vary as set forth in the written limited warranty. During the written limited warranty period, if any, the Neighborhood Builder will repair or replace, at the Neighborhood Builder's sole discretion, certain components of your Homesite or Home, as set forth in the written limited warranty.. A written limited warranty generally does not cover defects resulting from the failure of an Owner to perform commonly- accepted maintenance. Minor expansion, contraction, settlement cracks normal to home construction, and secondary damage, are generally not covered under the terms of a written limited warranty. Please refer to the written limited warranty you may receive for additional information. No other warranties or guarantees, whether expressed or implied, are provided, unless stated in writing and signed by a Neighborhood Builder. The manufacturers' warranties for the manufactured consumer products included in your Home (for example, water heater, air conditioning system, dishwasher, garbage disposal and other household appliances) are available for review in the Neighborhood Builder's sales office. 89. Notice of Sexual Offenders. The following notice is given pursuant to Section 2079.10a of the California Civil Code: Pursuant to Section 290.46 of the Penal Code, information about Specified registered sex offenders is made available to the public via an Internet Web site maintained by the Department of Justice at www meeanslaw.ca.aov. Depending on an offender's criminal history, this Information will include either the address at which the offender resides or the community of residence and ZIP Code in which he or she resides. 90. Prior to the purchase of a Home in the Community, you may research the database to determine whether there are sex offenders in the area. Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders, the Community Association and their respective directors, officers, employees, agents, representatives and consultants make no representations, warranties, or guarantees regarding the presence or absence of registered sex offenders within the Community or in the surrounding area. In addition, Master Developer, Neighborhood Builder, the Community Association and their respective directors, officers, employees, agents, representatives and consultants have no obligation or duty to investigate existing residents or buyers to determine whether they are sex offenders. You are solely responsible for making your own investigation. For further information, please contact your local law enforcement agency. Most law enforcement agencies have special stations to view the Megan's Law database. -34. 2544.332531C'LP428TISCLSM 609)65.4 Buyer initials: / _ __ 8111106 91. Benefit of Home Ownership. Although the purchase of a new home has traditionally been considered a wise decision, Master Developer and Neighborhood Builder have made no representations, guarantees or warranties to you regarding the tax benefits, investment benefits or other benefits of home ownership, regarding appreciation or depreciation in the value or equity accrual in your Horne, and regarding future price adjustments. 92. Assumption of Risk and Liability. By acceptance of this Disclosure, you assume all risk and liability for injuries to persons and property that may be sustained by you, your family members and your social and business guests by reason of all conditions or circumstances disclosed in this Disclosure. VISITING THE COMMUNITY BEFORE MOVE -IN If you wish to visit the Community, the Neighborhood and your Home before your move in, please be aware that your Home is located within a construction area and that construction sites are potentially dangerous. The Neighborhood Builder will permit you to enter your Horne and the construction area surrounding your Home provided that you are fully aware of the risks of such entry and are willing to comply with the procedures and requirements imposed on such visit by the Neighborhood Builder. You must be accompanied by your sales representative, or another representative of the Neighborhood Builder on any and all visits to your Horne. Each Neighborhood Builder further requests that such visits be limited to non -construction hours. By signing this Disclosure you acknowledge that there are numerous risks associated with visiting your Home during construction, including without limitation, open trenches, construction traffic, potential falling debris, exposed nails and electrical wiring, incomplete construction and certain other potential hazards. You further agree to use due care while visiting your Home. In addition, prior to visiting any construction area you may be required to sign a waiver and release form provided by the Neighborhood Builder ("Waiver l in which you agree to comply with the provisons of the Waiver. Whether or not you have signed a Waiver, by signing this Disclosure, you agree that you shall proceed at your own risk and you release and waive any claims against Master Developer Neighborhood Builders all of their affiliated entities, officers, directors, agents and assigns and all other persons or entities potentially liable to you as a result of an injury which may occur during your visit to your Home, to the Neighborhood and to the Community. ENTIRE DISCLOSURE; NO OTHER REPRESENTATIONS No sales representative, employee or agent of any Neighborhood Builder or the Master Developer has the authority to make any representation to you which contradicts or modifies the matters and information set forth in this Disclosure, the purchase agreement or any other written disclosure provided by the Master Developer or Neighborhood Builders in connection with the purchase of a Home in a Neighborhood (collectively, the "Disclosure Documents"). You acknowledge that no representations have been made to you by such persons other than as set forth in the Disclosure Documents and upon which you have relied in connection with the purchase of the Home. Please indicate below if any representations have been made by any such person which contradict or modify the matters and information set forth in the Disclosure Documents: Buyer Initials: ! -35- 2544-332531CLP42MISCLSM 609965.4 8/11!06 RELEASE AND INDEMNITY REGARDING DISCLOSURES With respect to items of information disclosed to you in this Disclosure or in any Disclosure Documents provided by Master Developer or Neighborhood Builders (collectively, "Disclosure Items"), you agree that you and your family members release, waive and will not make any claims against Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders for (a) nondisclosure of Disclosure Items, (b) for alleged improper or incomplete Disclosure Items, and (c) personal injury, property damage, expenses (including attorney fees and costs) and other liability you, your family members and others experience from the nondisclosure, improper disclosure or incomplete disclosure of Disclosure Items. You also agree that you will indemnify and hold the Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders and all of their affiliated entities, officers, directors, agents and assigns, harmless from all such claims by you, your family members and your social and business guests. Buyer Initials Buyer Initials [Buyer•Acknowledgment on following page] 2544-3325::ACLP42STISCLSM 609965.4 Duyerluitiuls: 1 -36- 8/11/06 Columbus Square HOMEBUYER DISCLOSURE STATEMENT BUYER ACKNOWLEDGMENT By the signatures below, you acknowledge that you will close escrow with full knowledge, understanding and agreement as to all of the infonnation contained in this Disclosure, and that this Disclosure constitutes a part of the terns of your Home purchase. Buyer: Date: Homesite or Condominium No: Tract No: Street Address: DuyerInitials: / -37_ 2544-33253\CLP428\DISCL.SR\609965.4 8/I 1/06 Association Governing Documents. I.f the Community Association Governing Documents are inconsistent with this Disclosure, the Community Association Governing Documents will supersede this Disclosure. Unless defined in this Disclosure, capitalized terns used in this Disclosure have the meanings given them in the Master Declaration of Covenants, Conditions, Restrictions and Reservation of Easements for Columbus Square ("Community Declaration"). If the Community Declaration gives the same capitalized tenn a different meaning than this Disclosure, the meaning given in the Community Declaration shall apply. INTRODUCTION TO THE MASTER DEVELOPER Moffett Meadows Partnbeus,LLC, �Dter-planned claware ornmunityt("Master Developerany, is the "). - Master Developer of the Colum q INTRODUCTION TO COLUMBUS SQUARE 1. Location and Master Plan. The Community is east of Interstate 55 near the intersection of Edinger Avenue and Redhill Avenue, in the City of Tustin (the "City'. The master land -use plan approved by the City of Tustin for the Community is called the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan (the "Specific plan") and it contains numerous design standards and development conditions. Such conditions establish, among other things, the number of single family dwellings and condominiums and other development requirements. If developed as approved by the City, Columbus Square will encompass approximately 1075 Homes, which are planned to consist of 283 single family dwellings, 552 condominiums and 240 senior housing condominiums. The actual number of Homes built may increase or decrease subject to approval by the City. All Homes in the Community are planned to be subject to the jurisdiction of the Columbus Square Community Association, a California nonprofit mutual benefit corporation ("Community Association"), as described in the Community Declaration. INTRODUCTION TO COLUMBUS SQUARE'S NEIGHBORHOODS AND NEIGHBORHOOD BUILDERS 2. Neighborhoods. The Community is being developed with Homes in numerous distinct neighborhoods ("Neighborhoods'l constructed by various homebuilders ("Neighborhood Builders"). Neighborhood Builders may have owner occupancy restrictions, rental Homesites and Homes (each of which is defined below), and investor-owned Homesites and Homes. You are advised to read the individual Neighborhood Builder disclosures and any other documentation relating to the Neighborhood in which you choose to purchase a Homesite or Home thoroughly. Neighborhood Builder policies may differ from those described in this Disclosure and the Community Declaration and are enforceable by the applicable Neighborhood Builders. The following is a list of the different Neighborhoods to be developed by the Neighborhood Builders in the Community and the approximate' number of Homes to be constructed in each Neighborhood; provided that that any product may be renamed or sold by the Neighborhood Builder currently listed below and the Neighborhood Builders reserve the right not to build the Neighborhoods listed below at all: -�- 2544-33253\CLP428\DISCLSR\ X65.6 Buyer Initials: �--- HOMEBUYER DISCLOSURE STATEMENT Aferiwether * Camden PWe The gables * Astoria e Corenirp Court Cambridge Lame * Mirabella * Verandas March 2007 Welcome to Columbus Square. We are pleased you are considering the purchase of a new home in Columbus Square. We want you (the "Buyer" j to be an extremely satisfied customer. Part of your satisfaction is in knowing as much as possible about your new home in the master -planned community of Columbus Square ("Community"), located in the City of Tustin. We offer this Homeowner Disclosure Statement (KDiselosure") as a service to describe to you various matters which might affect your decision to purchase. Please read it carefully. Be aware, however, that (a) much of the information in. this Disclosure has been obtained from other sources (public agencies, public records, etc.), and (b) the information contained in this Disclosure is not comprehensive. This means that we cannot guarantee the accuracy or completeness of the information disclosed. Because this information is subject to change without notice to us, it also means that we cannot commit to advise you of any changes affecting the information in this Disclosure. In addition to this Disclosure, the City of Tustin has required that the Master Developer provide you with a Columbus Square Homebuyer Notification (the "Homebuyer Nodfieation" j. The Master Developer prepared the Homebuyer Notification with information provided by the City of Tustin, at the direction of the City of Tustin and do not have the right to alter or update the Homebuyer Notification. To the extent any of the information provided in the Homebuyer Notification is inconsistent with the information provided in this Disclosure, this Disclosure shall supersede that portion of the Homebuyer Notification. By signing this Disclosure, you agree to independently verify all information regarding matters of concern to you before the Close of Escrow for your home purchase. As a part of your pre -purchase investigation, we strongly recommend that you visit the Community and the general vicinity surrounding the Community on several different days at several different times to familiarize yourself with the Community, its location and its surroundings. You will receive many documents in addition to this Disclosure to review, complete and sign before the Close of Escrow for the purchase of your home. These other documents are called the "Purchase Documents" in this Disclosure, and they include documents pertaining to the Community, defined below as the "Comnunity Association Governing Documents". This Disclosure is not intended as a substitute for your review of the Community association Governing Documents. This Disclosure does not amend, modify or supersede the Community Buyer initials: 2544-332531,CLP428%DISCLSK1609965.t; _,/61/07 (a) Lennar Homes of California, Inc. Meriwether 114 Homes Camden Place 222 Homes The Gables 84 Homes Coventry Court 240 Homes (b) William Lyon Hames, Inc. Astoria 102 Homes Cambridge Lane 156 Homes Mirabella 60 Homes Verandas 97 Homes 3, Ownership. A residential Lot in the Community is referred touas n the Close of in this Disclosure. If you are purchasingHomesitenwhich owilltbe he Community, ed with a single family Escrow, you will receive fee dwelling (a "Home'). If you are purchasing a Condominium in the Community, upon the Close of Escrow, you will receive fee title to a Unit and you will also receive If easementsfor oa maintenance and use over Exclusive mineralSoil and gas eas lrights eunder the la d below a depth of five - Homesite, you will not own hundred of these rights has no right of surface en (500) feet, or the water rights. The ho COMMUNITY ASSOCIATION GOVERNING DOCUMENTS Your Home will be subject to the following documents (,,Community Association Governing Documents': ty Declaration, and any amendments or modifications (a) The Communi thereto; (b) The Articles of Incorporation of the Columbus Square Community Association ("Community Association'); (c) The Bylaws of the Community Association; (d) The Supplemental Declaration of Covenants, Conditions and Restrictions eighborhood in which your Hme (" Supplemental Declaration") that is apptile veha a of tl a CommunityDeclaration;and is located, and may annex that Neighborhood to the g (e) Any Community Guidelines or Design Guidelines which may be adapted from time to time, respectively, by the Community Association's Board of Directors or the Design Review Committee ("Committee") pursuant to the Community Declaration. You should carefully review the Community Association Governing Documents in order to understand your specific rights and obligations as an Owner in the Community. The Community Association Governing Documents establish limits and restrictions an the use of the _�_ 2544-3325MCI.F4280ISCI.SM 609965.6 OU07 Buyer Initials: ,_ 1---- Home you are purchasing. You will also be provided with a preliminary title report. The title report will list other recorded documents affecting the use of the Home you are purchasing. You should review the title report and the documents referenced in the report closely prior to your purchase of a Horne. SPECIFIC PROVISIONS OF THE COMMUNITY DECLARATION 4. Assessment Obligation. The Community Declaration authorizes the Community Association's Board of Directors to levy a Common Assessment against each Home to meet the Community Association's Common Expenses. The Board of Directors is also authorized to levy various special assessments for specific purposes, in conformance with Articles I and VIII of the Community Declaration. The monthly installment of the Common Assessment will vary as each Phase of the Community is developed. You should review the Budget approved by the California Department of Real Estate and provided to you with the Final Subdivision Public Report for your Home. The Board of Directors' ability to increase the Common Assessments and improve additional special assessments without a vote of the Members is subject to certain limitations set forth in Sections 8.5 and 8.6 of the Community Declaration. The Community Association is obligated to provide you with an annual budget and other financial statements for the Community Association. 5. Use Restrictions. You must comply with all the various use restrictions set forth in the Community Declaration. These restrictions include, among other things, restrictions on non-residential uses of your Home, keeping of animals, improvements to your Homesite and Home, parking of vehicles, etc. The Community Association has the power to enforce the use restrictions set forth in the Community Declaration, as well as the Community Guidelines and the Design Guidelines. 6. Prohibited Dwelling Structures. You may not use your garage as a living area. Further, in accordance with Section 2.7 of the Community Declaration, you may not erect or use any outbuilding, tent, shack, storage shed, trailer, camper, motor home, recreational vehicle or any other vehicle on your Homesite for a living area. 7. Use of Garages. All vehicles owned or operated by or within the control of an Owner and kept in the Community must be parked in the assigned parking space or garage of that Owner; provided that, although storage of personal items may occur in the garage, all Authorized Vehicles must be parked in the garage, in accordance with Section 2.4.3 of the Community Declaration and Exl:ibU PC -1 attached thereto. Notwithstanding the foregoing, Owners may not park any Authorized Vehicle in the street or in any guest parking spaces. No repair, maintenance or restoration of any vehicle may be conducted within the Community except in an enclosed garage when the garage door is closed; provided, however, that such activity may not be undertaken as a business, and provided further that such, activity may be prohibited entirely by the Board if the Board determines that it constitutes a nuisance. 8. Parking of Recreational and Commercial Vehicles, Sections 2.4.1, 2.4.2 and 2.4.3 of the Community Declaration impose limitations and prohibitions on the parking of. Authorized Vehicles and Prohibited Vehicles within the Community. In accordance with Section 2.4.6 of the Community Declaration, an Owner may park any Authorized Vehicle that Buyer Initials: ( _G,- 2544-33253\CLP428\D1SCL,5R\ (09965.6 3/01/07 exceeds seven (7) feet high, seven (7) feerized Vehicle nineteen notlextend onto thethe s deOwalkror garage or driveway (as long as the Authorized drive approach area). In addition, no deli es�than/a twenty-five or moving u(2 )lfoot radius that is located are permitted on any private drive having 1 within a Neighborhood in the Community. You further acknowledge that it is your responsibility to determine whether the parkin tg provided in the Community and your Neighborhood is satisfactory for your purposes verify that the standard height and depth of the garage will provide adequate clearance for your vehicles before the Close of Escrow on your Home. 9. Owner Maintenance Guidelines. As set forth in Section 9.1.1 of the Community Declaration, each Owner rnust maintain his as located within the rnHomesite boundaries of a attractive condition at all times. The maintenance of all are Homesite is the responsibility of each OwnerTh fNghborhood $ilders will yaur Homesite. provide tailureyou ito important guidelines on the proper maintenanceimprovements in properly maintain interior improvementsmay cause Builderpres are not re ponsible for faature deterioration of ilure of features, finishes or equipment. The Neighborhood our failure to properly maintain such equipment or other improvements caused by y improvements. In addition, you acknowledge uhaat om u gr Neighbo hood Builders ared materials, if any are not by you, may have specific maintenance req ts. The responsible for any damages that may occur to such materials due to your failure to properly maintain them. 10. Insurance. In accordance with Article IX of the Community Declaration, you are solely responsible for determining the type and quality of insurance required to adequately insure your Homesite and Home, your personal property, and your personal liabilitynaor ownership d caster your Homesite and Home. You are solely responsible for determining our lender, insurance is required for your Homesite and Home. If any insurance is required by y you are responsible for obtaining that insurance prior to Close of Escrow. 11, Design Review of Improvements and Alterations. You may not build, construct, install or plant any improvements on your Homesite (or alter any improvements Home), until you have submitted plans and located on your Homesite, including your specifications and obtained approval from the DesignvReview ere �C °mmi7ritt a will establish Design mittee, as set forth in V of the Community Declaration. Th Design Guidelines containing rules and guidelines feet to reviewsion of il a plans. All Improvements m st Design Review Committee may collect applicable restrictions in the Community Declaration and the Design comply with any app and any other local Guidelines, as well as with all requirements imposed by the City governmtal agency governmental agency. The Design Guidela regulations may change from time to time, d you d be subject to thety and otherlregulatt'ons in effect at of the Design the time plans are submitted. After obtaining written ppropriate local governmental agencies tfor you must submit the plans and specification p permit, or other approval by any proposed improvements that require the issuance of a building p the City or any other local governmental agencies, as applicable. You should read Article V of 2544-33253\CLP428\DISCLSK\ 6OM5.6 Buyer initials: —� "5 the Community Declaration before constructing any Improvements. You may be subject to a Neighborhood Association Design Review Committee if you live in a Condominium project. (a) Landscaping and Irrigation Improvements. All landscape materials and irrigation systems installed by Owners must comply with plans and specifications approved by the Design Review Committee. You may need to install yard drains when installing landscaping and patios. Your landscaping plans are required to conform with the original drainage plan of the Homesite. Changes to drainage and grading require approval of the Design Review Committee and generally require you to obtain a permit from the City, as applicable. The slope areas, if any, located on a Homesite may include drainage facilities and temporary erosion control measures. No modifications to the slope areas shall be undertaken without the prior approval of the Design Review Committee and the City, as applicable. (b) Landscaping Completion Deadline. Section 2.18 of the Community Declaration requires you to install landscaping on any portions of your Homesite that have not been landscaped by a Neighborhood Builder. Landscaping in the front yard of a Homesite must be completed within six (6) months after the Close of Escrow for the purchase of the Homesite and landscaping in the back yard of a Homesite must be completed within one (1) year after the Close of Escrow for the purchase of the Homesite. The time period for the completion of such improvements is set forth in the Community Declaration. (c) Owner Liability. Any alterations or Improvements made by you to your Homesite, to its drainage pattern or to the Home shall be made at your sole risk. The Neighborhood Builders assume no responsibility for any damage caused by the design, construction, installation, alteration or maintenance by you of any Improvement on the Homesite, or caused by the impact of such an Improvement on the Homesite's drainage pattern. (d) Licensed Professionals. If you wish to alter or install any Improvement on your Homesite, you should obtain the advice of a licensed architect or civil, soil or structural engineer, as applicable, and should design and complete the alteration or installation of the Improvement in accordance with such licensed professional's advice and specifications. 12. Drainage. Section 2.14 of the Community Declaration contains important restrictions concerning drainage of water and water pollution. (a) Surface Water. The Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders have provided for surface and underground drainage of water from all Homesites and Homes in the Community. Your Homesite may have surface "swales" or area drains to carry the water from the rear and sides of the Home to the street or other designated outlet points. The Homesites and Homes are graded in accordance with plans approved by the City and certified by a registered civil engineer. In connection with the preparation of landscape plans for your yard, it is important that you consider any possible harmful effects that such landscaping hnd associated Improvements may have on adjacent property and structures as well as your Homesite and Home. Because the Community and your Homesite are located in an area which may contain expansive soils as more particularly explained in the Paragraph below entitled "Soil Conditions," water may have a detrimental impact upon such soils and the soils of surrounding Homesites and Buyer Initials: ! _6_ 2544-33253\CLP428\DISCLSR\ 609965.6 3/01/07 slopes. Existing drainage patterns must be maintained and all drainage systems must be kept fi•ee of debris and free flowing. (b) Effect of Improvements and Alterations. Raising the existing grade, constructing planters, changing the drainage pattern and other similar activities may cause damage to your Homesite, adjacent property (including, without limitation, your neighbor's Homesite, adjacent slopes and lower Homesites) and Improvements located thereon, including the Home. It is recommended that you consult with a licensed professional on landscaping and drainage, such as a qualified landscape architect and soils engineer, geotechnical engineer, geologist, civil engineer or other similar specialist, before making any alterations. .Any Improvements must be designed and constructed in a manner to prevent any possible damage to your Homesite and to adjacent property. If any obstruction occurs to the drainage on your yard, it may result in obstruction of drainage from adjacent property or cause major problems such as trapped water or flooding which may undermine the foundation of your Home and surrounding Homes or create moisture intrusion or mold and mildew problems. You are solely responsible for any damage to your Homesite and Home or surrounding property the P nts located thereon as a result of any alterations you make to the approved existing drainage pattern or failure to maintain proper drainage. The Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders and Community Association shall have no liability or responsibility for any such damage.val by Any grading or drainage modifications are subject to applicable codes of the City, app Design Review Committee, and the terms of any drainage easements that may be of record. You acknowledge and understand that if your Homesite or Home does not include area drains, you shall be responsible for installing area drains on your Homesite or Home when installing your landscaping. Your responsibilities for maintaining all grading and other drainage -related features on your Homesite and Home are set forth in Section 2.14.1 of the Community Declaration. (c) Water Quality Management Requirements. The Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders are developing the Community and Neighborhoods in accordance with a water quality management plan ("Plan") required by the California State Water Quality Control Board. The Plan imposes requirements for the design, implementation and maintenance of Best Management Practices ("BMPs") to eliminate or mitigate all non -storm water discharges into storm drains during and after construction of the Community and Neighborhoods. The requirements imposed by the Plan are in addition to any local ordinances with regard to discharge of non -storm water into storm drains. The Plan imposes post -construction requirements. This means that atter the Close of Escrow, you and your sub -contractors and other agents, are required to comply with all BMPs which are necessary to prevent, without limitation, run-offsoil,househo dsediment, oil, l gasoline or other hydrocarbons, paint, fertilizers, pool chemicals and storm drains located in your Neighborhood. For example, when fertilizing landscaping, measures must be taken to prevent over -watering the landscaping to ensure that fertilizer and other lawn chemicals do not run into the storm drains. Your ontaining Neighborhood reconBuilder endations forvtle you with a Best Management Practices Handbook prevention of run-off into storm drains fiom your Homesite and Home. The Plan affirmatively obligates all Owners to take immediate corrective action whenever there is a violation of the Plan as to an Owner's Homesite or Home. Penalties include -7- 2544-33253\CLP428\D1SCISX\ 609965.6 Buyer Initials: 3101107 significant fines that may be imposed against an Owner for failing to comply with BMPs necessary to prevent non -storm water run-off into storni drains, in violation of the Plan. 13. Utility and Other Easements. Article VR of the Community Declaration contains provisions pertaining to easements which may affect Owners and Homes. Your Homesite and Home may be subject to easements or other rights in favor of utility companies, local governmental agencies and other parties. These easements and rights may include access onto your Homesite or to exterior portions of the Home for purposes of installing, constructing, inspecting, maintaining and repairing facilities which are customary for residential developments (including, but not limited to, water lines, sewer lines, electrical lines and facilities, transformer boxes, natural gas pipelines, street lights, telephone lines and facilities, cable television lines, mailboxes, traffic signs, fire hydrants, etc.). These facilities and structures may be located above ground or below ground. In either case, the foregoing easements, rights and facilities may restrict the use and type of improvements you can make to your Homesite and Home, and the utility company, local government agency or other parties benefited by such easement or right may have the right to remove improvements made by you on the easement area without any obligation to repair or restore them. You should review the policy of title insurance, the tract map for your Hornesite, Article VR of the Community Declaration, and the Supplemental Declaration to determine what easements and other rights, if any, affect your Homesite and Home. Such easements may preclude construction of structures or other improvements or may require an encroachment permit to be obtained. You should not excavate or construct an improvement on any portion of your Homesite, as applicable, until you have consulted with an applicable licensed design professional (for example, an engineer) and located all easements and facilities. A copy of the tract map depicting your Homesite is available for review in the sales office. The location of gas and electric meters, telephone and cable access panels may change from the locations shown in the models. Please ask your sales representative for information concerning the proposed location of utility facilities and structures for your Home. The Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders make no representations or warranties concerning the final location of these facilities or structures for your Home. 14. Pets. Household pets, such as dogs or cats, are limited to reasonable quantities as established in Section 2.5 of the Community Declaration. Buyers shall be liable for any unreasonable noise or damage (including, but not limited to, clean up after such animal(s)) caused by any animal brought or kept upon the Community and Neighborhoods as more fully described in the Community Declaration. 15. Window Coverings. In accordance with Section 2.10 of the Community Declaration, the Design Guidelines and Community Guidelines may prohibit or restrict certain types of window coverings such as paint, foil, reflective tint or other similar materials or substances, and may permit certain types of temporary window coverings pending installation of permanent window coverings. 16. Walls and Fences. Wall and fence heights may vary throughout the Community and your Neighborhood. Walls and fences are subject to change, at any time and without notice to you, from any depiction that may have been provided or shown to you. Section 9.1.4 of the Community Declaration sets forth Owner's wall maintenance responsibilities. Owners are responsible for maintenance of all portions of the walls and fences that border the perimeter of Buyer Initials: / 2544-332$3\CLP428\LIISCLSR\ 604965.6 3/01/07 those portions the Homesite, including any pilasters located m Community (Association or arNeighbo Neighborhood that are designated for maintenance y he C Association. You should review the Community Association Governing Documents for further information. Community Walls, Neighborhood Walls and/or Party Walls (all as defined in the on the property line(s) of your Community Declaration) may be installedattached to the Community Declaration, Neighborhood e (collectively, the "Walls', as shown as ExhibitWM portion of the Walls not Declaration or a Supplemental Declaration. Owners must maintain any per otherwise maintained by the Communntdy thesociation or CanununityaAssocotion are not responsible od Association. for Developer, Neighborhood Builders a damage to any Wall on the Homesite if such damage results from your failure to properly maintain the Walls. 17. Solar Energy Systems. Pursuant to Section 2.17 of the Community Declaration, you and all other Owners of Hamesitesin the Community have .ns /lotion and maintenance of indive right to idual solace lar energy aintain equipment and facilities related to the i you shall be subject to systems ("System"). The installation and maintenance of any System by y all applicable ordinances and zoning regulations of the City, the Uniform Building Code and associated ordinances. California has a strong public policy in favor of solar energy needs of a neighbor, including but not limited to the location and n eweCorrunitteeeight of son your Homesite. You prior to installation of a must obtain written approval from the Design Review System and you must comply with reasonable aiil Code Sections/aced on the 714 and 714. y stem as the same may by the Design Review Committee, subject to California amended from time to time. 18. Satellite Dishes. Satellite dish antennas (or Authorized Antennae, as defined in the Community Declaration) may be installed H weve ,'Master, DCommunity elope and Neighborhood Section 2.11 of the Community Declare Builders have provided no assurances or guarantees that any satellite dish or other antenna installed within the Community will of remain uthorized Antennae. at satellite service will be You should understand that provided to an Owner after installation broadcast signals may be obstructed by the installation of additional improvementsrees within other and outside of the Community including, without limitation, homes, walls, fences, landscaping and such obstructions may not allow for acceptable satellite reception. You should also understand that Neighborhood Associations may impose additional restrictions. 19. Amendments to the Community Declaration. Notwithstanding the fact that you have received a copy of the Community Declaration nabeand the o Supplementaldii�Deelar tion for their your Phase of Development, these documentsY amendment provisions. 20. Additional Provisions. There may be provisions of' arious laws, including the Davis -Stirling Common Interest DevelopmentAct codified codiSed at Title 42ons Uniteded States Code, et seq. of the California Civil Code and the Federal Fair Housing Section 3601.et seq., which may supplement or override the Community Association Governing Documents, The Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders and Community Association make _9- 2544-33253\CLP428\DISGLSR\6090 and Buyer Initials; —f-- no representations or warranties regarding the future enforceability of any portion of the Community Association Governing Documents. COLUMBUS SQUARE DISCLOSURES 21. Charitable Endowment Fee. A recorded Charitable Housing Agreement Imposing Endowment Fee On Transfer (`Agreement') affects your Home and the other Homes in the Community. The Agreement requires that an "Endowment Fee" equal to one -twentieth of one percent (0.05%) of the total sales price (0.0005 x total sales price) be paid each time a Home in the Community is transferred to a new owner. The Endowment Fee will be paid to Lennar Charitable Housing Foundation, a California nonprofit public benefit corporation ("Foundation's, to be used for the purposes described in the Agreement. When you close escrow for the purchase of your Home, you will pay the Endowment Fee to the Foundation. Thereafter, each time your Home is resold, the Endowment Fee must be paid at the close of escrow, but it may be paid either by the new buyer or the then current seller. The Agreement will be in effect for an indefinite period of time. 22. Affordable Housing/Transitional Housing. The City of Tustin has required the Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders to provide two hundred sixty-six (266) units of affordable housing ("Affordable Housing Units") within the Community, Sixty-three (63) Affordable Housing Units will be located in the Camden Place Neighborhood, fifty (50) Affordable Housing Units will be located in the Cambridge Lane Neighborhood, and one hundred fifty-three (153) Affordable Housing Units will be located in an area of the Community that will be designated as housing for seniors (Coventry Court). Certain of these Affordable Housing Units will be offered to persons who qualify as very low, low and moderate income buyers pursuant to guidelines established by the United States Department of Housing and Urban Development for the City. Buyers who qualify as very low, low and moderate income will purchase their Homes subject to resale restrictions, as reflected in a recorded covenant agreement, for a period of forty-five (45) years. If you are interested in the Affordable Housing Units you should consult your sales representative for further information. 23. "Active Adult" Neighborhood. An "Active Adult Neighborhood," the Coventry Court„ consists of age restricted residences located within the Community. In Coventry Court, each Home must be occupied by at least one resident who is at least 55 years of age. Coventry Court is a community consisting of approximately 240 Homes and has its own recreational facilities and activities. All assessments for the maintenance of these recreation facilities are the exclusive responsibility of the Coventry Court residents. As a result, the recreational facilities located within Coventry Court are not open to other Owners in the Community; provided, however, Coventry Court residents will have the right to use the recreational facilities located throughout the Community. Master Developer reserves the right to construct other age restricted communities in other locations in the Community. . , 24. Home Business Use. Any Home within the Community may be used for home based business purposes, provided that such use is subject to the City of Tustin's Home Occupation Ordinance (if applicable), the provisions in Section 2.1 of the Community Declaration and the Community Guidelines. You are advised that the Community Declaration and the Community Guidelines may contain stricter restrictions than those in the City Ordinance Buyer Initials! / _10_ 2544-33253\CLP428NDISCLM609965.6 3/01/07 and that such use may require zoning clearance and a business license. You should contact the City for more information regarding business uses in your Home. 25. MCAS Tustin. (a) Prior Use as MCAS Tustin. You are advised that the Community was previously used as the Tustin Marine Corps Air Station ("MCAS Tustin"). The Marine Corps and the Department of the Navy ("DON") are the responsible agencies for the Installation Restoration Program ("IRP"), The IRP is a comprehensive environmental investigation and cleanup program formed to identify, investigate and clean up chemical and nuclear contamination that has resulted from past land use operations. When MCAS Tustin was an active base, it received a permit from the California Department of Toxic Substances Control ("DTSC"} pursuant to the Federal Resources Conservation and Recovery Act ("RCRAI (42 U.S.C. 6901 et seq.) to store hazardous waste on portions of the base. One of the conditions of that permit was to perform "corrective action" to clean-up releases of hazardous waste constituents throughout the base. Although the permit has expired, these corrective action obligations continue, and the DON is undertaking environmental investigation and cleanup activities on portions of the former base that are within the Corrununity. _ (b) Asbestos Containing Material. Hazardous material in the form of asbestos or asbestos -containing materials ("ACM'J have been found and are otherwise presumed to exist in buildings and structures previously located in the Community. At such time as demolition of the prior existing buildings on the Community containing ACM was completed, the appropriate governmental regulatory agency confirmed that ACM had been removed from the buildings and any necessary soil remediation had been conducted in accordance with all applicable federal, state and local laws and regulations. (c) Easement for Environmental Remediation. An easement over the Community granted to the United States of America, acting by and through the Department of the Navy ("DON") in a document entitled "Quitclaim Deed for Marble Mountain Parcel and Environmental Restriction Pursuant to Civil Code Section 1471," was recorded on March 11, 2003, as Document No. 200300263521. In connection with ongoing remedi tion on ehat0 hes property DON and itsithin the officers, Community, it was agreed, as a covenant running with the landt agents, employees, contractors and subcontractors shall have the right, upon reasonable notice, to enter the Community when a response or corrective action is found to be necessary or when such access is necessary to carry out a response action or corrective action. The right for the DON to enter the Community shall include the right to conduct tests, investigations and surveys, including, where necessary, drilling, test -pitting, boring and other similar activities. Such right shall also include the right to construct, operate, maintain or undertake any other response or corrective action as required or necessary, including, but not limited to, monitoring wells, pumping wells, treatment facilities, and the installing of associated utilities. In exercising these rights of access, except in the case of imminent and substantial endangerment to human health or the environment, the DON shall give reasonable notice of any action to be taken related to such -I 1- 2544.33253\CLp429\DISCLSR\ 6)9965.6 Hger Initials: 1 3!)1/17 remedial or corrective actions on the Community. Further, the DON will make reasonable efforts to minimize interference with the on going use of the Community and act in good faith to minimize any conflict between the necessary environmental investigation and remediation activities and the use of the Community. The DON is not required to restore or repair any Improvements in the Community damaged as a result of this right to access the Community. If any Improvements on Association Property are damaged as a result of the DON's access to the Community, you are advised that any such damaged Improvement may be repaired or replaced by the Community Association and you may be charged a Reconstruction Assessment or Extraordinary Assessment (if applicable). (d) Groundwater Plume. The City Environmental Impact Report (1999) ("EIRI indicates the presence of subsurface plumes of chlorinated volatile organic compounds ("V00'1, dissolved trichloroethene ("TCE") and methyl tertiary -butyl ether ("MTBE") at ground water level in portions of MCAS Tustin located outside the Community. It is presently unknown whether and to what extent these contaminants will migrate towards the Community. According to the EIR, estimated human health risks associated with residential use of groundwater from the plumes are above the acceptable limits of the United States Environmental Protection Agency. Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders make no representations or warranties with respect to the plumes described above or whether such plumes will migrate into the groundwater under Community. 26. LIFOC PROPERTY/ENVIRONMENTAL CONDITIONS. Due to its prior use as a military base, certain areas within the Community, designated on the map for Tract No. 16581 as "IRP -13S" and "IRP -13W" (collectively, the `LIFOC Properly'), are owned by the United States of America ("U.S. Government') and will ultimately be annexed into the Covered Property pursuant to Section 16.6 of the Community Declaration. (a) Prior Use of the LIFOC Property. That portion of the LIFOC Property identified as IRP -13S is approximately 0.7 acres and was previously used as a "Temporary Storage Area" ("TSA' and as a "Miscellaneous Wash Area" ("MWA'J. The TSA consisted of two (2) buildings that were used for vehicle maintenance. Cleaning solvents were reportedly used to wash down floors in the buildings and waste solvent was likely released to storm drains, or to the ground outside the building. The MWA includes an inactive wash pad formerly used for cleaning small generators and other field equipment. Solvents were used in this area and may have been released to the subsurface through cracks in the concrete pad. That portion of the LIFOC Property identified as IRP 13W was previously used as a former disposal area where hydraulic fluid, diesel fuel, leaded gasoline, oil, paint stripper, batter acid and solvent were stored. (b) Release of Volatile Organic Compounds. As a result of the historic use of the LIFOC Property, hazardous substances have been released into the groundwater at the LIFOC Property. Volatile Organic Compounds ("VOCs"), including, trichloroethylene ("TCE") and 1,2,3 Triehloropropane (111,2,3 TCP"), were found in groundwater at concentrations that could result in adverse effect to human health if this water was extracted from the ground and directly used for domestic purposes such as drinking or bathing. However, groundwater at this location is currently not used for such purposes. 1luyerinitials. ! -12- 2544-33253\CLP428\D18CLSR\609965.6 3/01/07 (c) Remedial Action Plan. As a result of the release of hazardous substances at the LIFOC Property, various remedial activities have occurred at the LIFOC Property and will continue to occur until remediation goals ion/Remedihave been achieved. In October al Action Plan Operable Unit he Department of Navy issued a report entitled final Record of Dec IA, Former Marine Corps Air Station, Tustin, IRP113S', which to address groundwateribes the r contamination. action plan ("RAP") that has been approved f In August 2005, the Department of Navy published a report entitled "Draft Feasibility Study Report for Operable Unit 4B [includes IRP 13W), Former Marine Corps Air Station, Tustin, California," ("Feasibility Study?A) which addresses a range of remedial alternatives to address the VOCs in groundwater. As documented re or thhe erefore, reimediationeasibility �.tay, ,no further w s not addressed nn the was recommended for soil a OU -4B sites ... t Feasibility Study. A final groundwater remedial action plan has not yet been selected for IRP 13W. (d) Deed Restrictions. Deed restrictions will ultimately be recorded on all or a portion of the Homesites or Homes in the Community lying within the LIFOC Property, will limit certain activities on such Hamesites oFfutmure landowners and/ordeed ictions will users oftheldentify LIFOC specific land use restrictions to prevent exposureof the remedial action until Property to hazardous substances and to maintain the integrity remediation is complete and remediation goals have been achieved. (e) Documentation Relating to the Retemt nt of the reeaseediation eof s. Extensive documentation has been prepared that describes the nature and i The following reports are hazardous substances that has occurred at the LIFOC Property. available for public review and document the investigation and remediation work that has been or will be performed at the LIFOC Property: (i) Draft Feasibility Study Report For Operable Unit 4B, Former Marine Corps Air Station, Tustin, California, August 2005 (Bechtel Environmental, Inc., August 2005); (ii) Final Record of Decision/Remedial Action Plan Operable Unit IA, Former Marine Corps Air Station, Tustin, California (Department ofNavy, October 2004); (iii) Final Feasibility Study Report, OU -1A, Marine Corps Air Station, Tustin, California (Bechtel Environmental, Inc., August 2003); and (iv) Final Environmental Impact Statement/Enviromnenatald Carp of Report, Disposal and Reuse of MCAS Tustin, California (Department of Navy ity Tustin, December 1999). You should carefully review these reports before making a decision t buyBRAa are availabe for reiew at either (1)Home in the Community. Copies of the rapo Building 307,1 MCASvElToro, telephone (949) Environmental Coordinator's Office, Library 726-5398 or (2) City of Tustin, Department of Community Development, 300 Centennial Way, Tustin, GA 92780, telephone (714) 573-3100 The Master respect t Dhe LIFOC Propeeveloper and rghborhood ty and the Builders make no representations or warrants withrep 2543-3325MCLP42801SCLSM 609%5.6 -1 3- 3/01/07 Buyer Initials: ---J-----" environmental conditions described above or in the reports. Due to the fact that groundwater in the Community has been found at depths of six (6) to twenty-five (25) feet below the ground - surface, as described below, you are advised to avoid eating any fruit from trees with deep root systems in the Cormnunity or drinking any groundwater, and to keep your children and animals away from such fruit and groundwater. (f) The following items have been indicated in the ETR as affecting portions of MCAS Tustin that are outside of the Community. These items are not expected to impact the Community, and are listed in this Disclosure for your information only. Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders make no representations or warranties as to any future impact these items may have on the Community or Residents using public parks and other areas outside the Community. (i) Former crash drill site area; (ii) Former skeet ranges; (iii) Transformers containing polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs); (iv) Buildings formerly on property containing lead based paint; (v) Moffit Meadow fire fighting trenches and crash crew burn pits; (vi) JP -5 pipeline, currently classified as out of service; and (vii) Petroleum hydrocarbons in subsurface soil. If you have any questions or concerns about environmental activities at MCAS Tustin or the Community, please contact the Local Redevelopment Authority at the City of Tustin or visit the United States Naval Facilities Engineering Command's internet website at www.efdsw.nav-fac,navy.mil/F,.uviroiiinental/Tustin.htin. 27. Prior Agricultural Use. The Community is located on or near lands that are or were previously used for agricultural purposes, including farming operations. By reason of such agricultural use, you may be subject to dust, noise and odors and may be exposed to pesticides, herbicides, insecticides and other chemicals. By acceptance of a deed to a Home, you on your own behalf, and on behalf of the members of your family, tenants, lessees, guests and invitees) expressly acknowledge and accept these existing and future impacts and forever waive any and all causes of actions against the Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders and Community Association and their respective directors, officers, employees, agents, representatives and consultants for any damages or injuries which may arise from or relate to any such conditions or risks. 28. Private Recreational Center. The Community is planned to include a private recreational center (the "Center"). The Center is planned to include swimming and wading pools, spas and recreational building and other recreational facilities. While the Center is planned to be private and only open to Owners and guests in the Community, the public will have access to the open space areas surrounding the Center and some outdoor recreational Buyer Initials: / _Iq•_ 2544.33253TI-I'428\131SCLSM 609965.6 3/01107 facilities in the Open Space/Park Areas. All persons using the Center are required to use caution and to watch their children at all times to prevent drowning and other injuries. The Community mulgate rules for use and operation of the Center, Association may, from time to time, pro including reasonable hours of operation. Owners and other residents living in the area of the Center will most likely experience and otherwise be subject to or inconvenienced by noise and pedestrian and vehicular traffic in the areas surrounding the Center. 29. Natural Hazard Zone Disclosures. Your Neighborhood Builder will provide you with a Natural Hazard Disclosure Statement in compliance with Section 1103 of the California Civil Code that discloses whether your Home is located in a seismic hazard zone. (a) Earthquakes. California is subject to a wide range of earthquake activity. California has many known earthquake faults as well as yet undiscovered faults. While the Community is not located in an Alquist Priolo Earthquake Zone, earthquakes are always a possibility. You must evaluate the potential for future seismic activity that may seriously damage your Homesite and Home. A major earthquake, which some have predicted will occur in our lifetimes, could cause very serious damage to Homes located even many miles from the epicenter of the earthquake. A more moderate earthquake occurring on a more minor fault, or on an as yet undiscovered fault, could also cause substantial damage. For more information, read "The Homeowners Guide to Earthquake Safety" which explains the various geological hazards associated with earthquakes and contains information on planning ahead for earthquakes, as well as what to do during and after an earthquake. Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders make no representations or warranties as to the degree of earthquake risk in Community. You are advised to consult with the City, County, other public agencies and appropriate experts to evaluate the potential risk. (b) Seismic Hazard Zones. Many portions of California are subject to risks associated with seismic activity. Areas that meet the definition of "Seismic Hazard Zone" in the Seismic Hazards Mapping Act (California Public Resources Code Section 2690, et seq.) are shown on maps that are prepared and released by the California Department of Conservation, Division of Mines and Geology. Such zones may pose an increased risk of damage to property from earthquakes and liquefaction. "Liquefaction" is the process by which water -saturated soils become unstable under heaving shaking and thereby jeopardize foundations and other structures. The Master Developer has been informed that all or a portion of the Communityther public within a Seismic Hazard Zone. You are advised to consult with the City, County, agencies and appropriate experts to evaluate the potential risk. For more information concerning seismic activity and risks, read "The Homeowner's Guide to Earthquake Safety." (c) Area of Potential Flooding. The Master Developer has been informed that the Community is located within an Area of Potential Flooding (or Dam Inundation Zone) pursuant to applicable maps. The Office of Emergency Services is required to designate areas within which personal injury or death would, in its determination, result from the partial or total failure of any darn. These areas of potential flooding, as defined in the California Emergency Services Act (California Government Code Section 8984.4, et seq.), are shown on maps released by the Office of Emergency Services, copies of which are also on file with the City. These maps are updated periodically, and the Master Developer, Neighborhood tB Community Association make no representations, guarteesarwarantiewl pest to any future dam -15- 2544-33253\CLP428\DI8CLSx\ 609965.6 Buyer Initials: 1_ ___ _-- — -- 3101107 inundation zone determinations. The Community is downstream from the Santiago Creek Dam, an earthfill dam approximately one hundred and thirty-six (136) feet high which has a capacity of 25,000 acre feet of water. Santiago Creek Dam is jointly owned and maintained by the Serrano Irrigation District and the Irvine Ranch Water District. Information about the Santiago Creek Dam can be found on the California Department of Water Resources website: littp://cdee.water.ca.gov/mise/resinfo.html. Please contact the Office of Emergency Services for further information concerning Areas of Potential Flooding. 30. Soil Conditions. In purchasing your Home, you should review soils reports for the Community, available for review at the City, and take into consideration the following: (a) Expansive Soil. According to the soils report, soil in the Community is highly expansive in nature. Expansive soil expands when it becomes wet and it contracts when it dries out. Expansion and contraction of soils may cause movement, lifting, cracking and distress in slabs, patios, sidewalks and other flatwork improvements. Some cracking is normal in all flatwork improvements, with or without expansive soils. However, some expansion damage may be reduced by use of appropriate design and construction techniques. When designing flatwork and other Improvements, you should advise your consultants that designs must accommodate soils with expansion potential. In addition, you should consider the following information and recommendations before making or modifying any Improvements. (b) Concrete and Masonry Improvements. Special attention is required in designing and constructing concrete and masonry Improvements such as masonry walls and planters, concrete slabs and decking. For example, steel reinforcing bars may be required in lieu of steel mesh in concrete patio slabs. Block walls may require extra horizontal and vertical steel reinforcing bars. (c) Drainage and Irrigation. Owners must use adequate drainage and irrigation control. Drainage devices installed in the Community by the Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders should not be altered in any manner that will redirect or obstruct drainage through these devices. The construction or modification of Improvements should not result in ponding of water. Drainage devices, including, but not limited to, concrete ditches, area drain lines and gutters should be carefully designed and installed with professional assistance and then maintained in an unobstructed condition. Drainage devices installed by the Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders designed to serve more than the (1) Home should not be altered in a manner that will redirect or obstruct. the drainage through these drainage devices. The landscape irrigation system should be designed, constructed and operated to prevent excessive saturation of soils. Water must drain away from the Home footings and other Improvements. Obstructions such as walls should not be constructed across swales unless adequate replacement drainage Improvements have been installed or created. Planters should be lined with an impervious surface and should contain outlets to drain excess water. , (d) Fill Soil. Homes in the Community may be' constructed on fill soil in accordance with the recommendations and inspection of licensed civil and soils engineers. A soils report certifying the compaction of fill soils is available for review at the City. Buyer Initials. / _16_ 2544-33253TI-P428\13ISCLSM 609965.6 3!01/07 (e) Corrosive Soil. Soils in some areas of the Community are potentially severely corrosive to buried concrete and ferrous metals. Soluble sulfates and acidic soils are highly corrosive to buried metals and concrete and should be taken into account in the construction of below grade structures and hardscape. Sulfates may chemically and physically attack concrete that is not sulfate resistant, causing the concrete to break down. Thus, you must use the proper type of cement and water -to -cement ratio for the level of sulfates or acidity that exists on your Homesite. Overwatering soil will exacerbate the corrosivity of the soil. You should inform contractors of this potential condition to allow them to use appropriate measures to combat the effects of corrosive soil on buried metals, below grade structures and hardscape. (f) Groundwater. Groundwater has been encountered in portions of the Community at depths of six (6) to twenty-five (25) feet below the ground surface. You may not dig or drill on any Homesite to a depth that would disturb or otherwise come in contact with the groundwater. Groundwater may rise during the rainy season. (g) PoolslSpas. Prior to designing any pool, spa, or other similar amenity, it is recommended you consult with a licensed civil engineer to determine the depth of the water table under your Homesite to insure that your Improvements are compatible with the depth of the water table and that they will not disturb or come in contact with the groundwater during a rainy season. The Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders make no guarantee that any Homesite has the ability for pool or spa installation. Hornesites 242 through 245, inclusive, of Tract No. 16581, which are located within the LIFOC Property, have been determined to be unsuitable for installation of pools, spas or other similar amenity. The deeds for these Lots will contain deed restrictions that prohibit the use of the Lots for such purposes. (h) Soils Professionals. Before starting a pool or spa or any patio, concrete or other flatwork on the Homesite, you should consult with a licensed soils engineer to ensure that such work is constructed correctly in light of current soils conditions. Although consulting with a soils professional may add substantially to the cost of installation of improvements, failure to do so may result in significant breaking, lifting, separating, tilting or cracking in improvements. (i) Interior Gases and Other Contaminants. The aging process of soil and natural soil elements, as well as the aging of man-made building materials, may create unwanted and undesired gases and other contaminants in Homes, both new and previously occupied. In addition, a lower rate of air exchange between outdoor and indoor environments has resulted from modem construction techniques which comply with energy conservation requirements enacted by the State of California. A lower air exchange rate can result in the build-up of unwanted gases and other contaminants in varying degrees. As the quality of the air we breathe can affect our health, you should frequently air out your Home by opening the windows. 31. Post -Tension Concrete System. Your Home may have been built using a post - tension concrete system ("Svstem'o. If any portion of your Home has been constructed using the System, a placard or stamp will be placed in the garage signifying the existence of such System. The System involves placing steel cables under high tension in the concrete slab located beneath the Home. Therefore, any attempt to alter or pierce the foundation (for example, sawing, cutting or drilling) could damage the integrity of the System and cause serious injury or damage to persons and property. The Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders shall not be Buyer Initials: ! -17- 2544-332531CLP42MISCLSR\ 609965.6 3/01/07 responsible for any damage or injury resulting from or arising in comuaection with the alteration of the slab or foundation of any Home. By acceptance of a deed to a }tome, you agree that: (i) you shall not cut into or otherwise tamper with the System; (ii) you shall not knowingly permit or allow any other person to cut into or tamper with the System so long as you own any interest in the Home; (iii) you shall disclose the existence of the System to any person who rents, leases or purchases your Home; and (iv) you shall indemnify and hold the Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders and all of their affiliated entities, officers, directors, agents and assigns free and harmless from any and all claims, damages, losses or other liability (including attorneys' fees and costs) arising from any breach of this covenant. 32. Reclaimed Water. In its efforts to conserve water, the Irvine Ranch Water District (the "Water District") requires the use of reclaimed water (treated wastewater) to irrigate parks, school yards, golf courses, greenbelt areas and common areas. The Water District may require the use of reclaimed water to irrigate landscaping in private yards. The water used in the Homes and outside in the patio and yard areas through hose bibs will be domestic potable water. The water used to irrigate the Association Property may include reclaimed water. Reclaimed water is not potable and therefore not suitable for human consumption. As with any water overspray, the repeated spray of reclaimed water may stain or discolor personal property, fencing and structural Improvements. According to the Water District, the Water District's reclaimed water is disinfected with chlorine and its clarity to the human eye is indistinguishable from domestic water. The standards imposed on the Water District for reclaimed water duality are established by governmental regulatory agencies, and these standards are subject to change. The Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders and Conrnlunit-y Association and their agents are not liable for any property damage or personal injury by reclaimed water. You are subject to Water District rules and regulations, one ol'which prohibits the use of self -generating water softeners connected to Water District sewer facilities. Further information regarding Water District regulations is available at the Water District's headquarters. 33. Electric Power Lines. Underground or overhead electric transmission and distribution lines and transformners are located in and around the Community. Two (2) 220 Kv and one (I) 66 Kv overhead transmission and distribution lines, which are located along Harvard and Warner Avenues and around other perimeter boundaries of the Community, and other lines and transformers are owned and maintained by Southern California Edison Company. Southern California Edison may increase the number of transmission and distribution lines and the electric current through such lines. Power lines and transformers produce extremely low-fi•equency electromagnetic fields ("ELF -EMF") when operating. For some time, there has been speculation in the scientific community about health risks associated with living near ELF -EMF sources. In 1992, the United States Congress authorized the Electric and Magnetic Fields Research and Public Information Dissemination Program to perforin research on these issues and to analyze the existing scientific evidence in order to clarify the potential for health risks from exposure to ELF -EMF. In May of 1999, the National institute of Environmental Health Sciences (-NIERS') issued a report to Congress summarizing its review of scientific data from over three hundred (300) studies on ELF -EMF health risks. The ELF -EMF studies consist of both epidemiological studies (studies of exposure in human populations) and controlled laboratory Oexperiments on animal and cell models. While some epidemiological studies suggested some liuyerinitials: 25+34-33253K11'428013CURN609965.6 3.101/07 link between certain health effects and exposure to ELF -EMF, the laboratory experiments did not support such a link. According to the N1EHS report, the scientific evidence shows no clear pattern of health hazards from ELF -EMF exposure, and the NIEHS report did not find evidence of any link sufficient to recommend widespread changes in the design or use of electrical transmission equipment. However, because the evidence does not clearly rule out any effect; MEHS advocated continuing inexpensive and safe reductions in exposure to ELF -EMF and 01 endorsed current utility practices regarding design and siting of new transmission and distribution lines. Further information on this subject is available from the Regional EMF Manager, Southern California Edison Company, 1851 West Valencia Drive, Fullerton, California 92833. Additional information on ELF -EMF and copies of the NIEHS report are available from the EMF -RAPID website at www.nichs.nih.gov/emfrapid/home.htm. 34. Air Quality. Southern California is subject to Stage I smog alerts. You should take advantage of the Air Quality Management District's ("AOMA") forecasts to plan your outdoor activities to avoid peak pollution by checking your television, radio or daily newspapers to find out if unhealthful air quality is expected. For more information, you can also call A.Q.M.D. at 1 -800 -CUT -SMOG (1-800-288-7664) or check their website at www.agrnd.lrov. By acceptance of a deed to a Home, you (for and on your behalf, and the members of your family, tenants, lessees, guests and invitees) expressly acknowledge and accept the existing and possible future impacts of smog on yourself and your family and forever waive any and all causes of actions against the Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders and their respective directors, officers, employees, agents, representatives and consultants for any damages or injuries which may arise from or relate to any such conditions or risks. 35. Wind. All of Southern California is subject to periods of high winds. Wind speeds in the Community may exceed that experienced in other areas of the surrounding region. You must ensure that any structures or other Improvements you install on your Homesite are constructed or designed to withstand high winds. You are advised to consult with experienced architects and engineers in the design and specification of any structures or Improvements that you plan to add. 36. Private Streets. All of the streets within the Community are private streets. Maintenance and repair of the private streets is the responsibility of the Community Association or the Neighborhood Associations, as applicable. 37. Building Setbacks. Construction of Improvements in the yard of any Homesite such as pools, spas, patio covers, BBQ, fountains, trellises and water features are subject to minimum setback and height restrictions and may not be permitted. You should refer to the Community Association Governing Documents and applicable City ordinances for any restrictions concerning the construction of any Improvements to your Homesite. 38. Boundaries. You may not rely on any written or oral statements by Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders or their agents regarding the exact boundaries of your Homesite or Home or whether any wall or fence has been or will be constructed exactly on the boundaries of your Homesite. Quyei Initials: _19- 2544-33253\C1.P428\IASCL9R\609965.6 3/01to? 39, Square Footage Representations. Representations of square footage are approximate only. You may not rely on any written (brochures and other sales documents) or verbal statements by Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders or their agents regarding the exact square footage of your Homesite or Home. The computation of square footage varies based on the criteria used. You agree by acceptance of a deed, to a Home to hold the Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders harmless in any dispute arising over any representations concerning the square footage of your Homesite or Home. TAXES AND ASSESSMENTS 40. Supplemental Real Property Taxes. The California law requires real property to be revalued whenever it changes ownership or when improvements are newly constructed. After the Close of Escrow for your Home, the County of Orange Tax Assessor ("Assessor") will determine a new taxable value for your Home based on current market values. The property tax will increase and you will receive one or more supplemental tax bills depending upon the time of the year in which Escrow closed for the purchase of your Home. Master Developers and Neighborhood Builders have no control over the valuation, timing or the amount of the supplemental bill resulting from the reassessment. You are solely responsible for the payment of any supplemental tax bills. The following notice is given pursuant to Section 1102.6c of the California Civil Code: "California property tax law requires the Assessor to revalue real property at the time the ownership of the property changes. Because of this law, you may receive one or two supplemental tax bills, depending on when your loan closes. The supplemental tax bills are not mailed to your lender. 1f ,you have arranged for your property tax payments to be paid through an impound account, the supplemental tax bills will not be paid by ,your lender. It is ,your responsibility to pay these supplemental bills directly to the Tax Collector. If you have any question concerning this matter, please call ,your local Tax Collector's Office." Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders have no control over the valuation, timing or the amount of the supplemental bill resulting from the reassessment. You are solely responsible for the payment of the supplemental tax bill. You hereby acknowledge, accept and agree that neither Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders nor any of their authorized agents, representatives, employees or sales people have made any representations or warranties respecting the amount of the supplemental assessment or the assessed value. Should you have any questions or concerns relating to the supplemental assessment, you agree, prior to the Close of Escrow, to consult with the County Assessor or your legal or other advisors to satisfy such questions or concerns. 41. Estimated Taxes. You have been provided with an estimate of your assessments. THE AMOUNT OF ASSESSMENTS ARE ESTIMATES ONLY, and are based on current information provided by the City, County or those public or private agencies responsible for the administration for the districts. These assessments may INCREASE or DECREASE, based upon changes in real property tax law; the district(s) may dissolve; formation of new districts may riuyar6iiiiuls: / _ZQ.. 2544.332531CLP4281D1SCLSR1609965.6 3/01/07 occur, an extension of the districts or the services to the districts and other factors NOT IN MASTER DEVELOPER`S OR NEIGHBORHOOD BUILDER'S CONTROL may transpire. The amount of special taxes may appear on your property tax bill or may be billed separately. 42. Special Tax Assessment Districts. All or a portion of the Community Iies within the boundaries of the following Special Tax and Assessment Districts: (a) Communitp Fnriiftfes District No. 06-1. Several Neighborhoods in the Community are located within the boundaries of City of Tustin Community Facility District No. 0(3-1 ("CFD No. 06-Il which was formed for the construction and maintenance of public improvements, including, but not limited to, street improvements, parkway and landscaping, storm drains, utilities, public parks, public libraries and fire protection facilities. If your Home is located within CFD No. 06-1, your Home will be subject to any taxes, assessments and obligations associated with CFD No. 06-1. You will be provided with a Nonce of Special Tax for CFD No. 06-1. This Notice contains important information about district functions, your obligations, rights of the district, and information on how to contact the district for additional information materials. You should carefully read and understand the information contained in the Notice. Master Developers and Neighborhood Builders have no control over the amount of tax assessments levied or imposed against your Home or any increase or decrease in the amount of such assessments. Please contact the City of Tustin (City Clerk), telephone (714) 573-3025 for additional information. (b) Tustin Unfed School District Community Facilities District No. 06-1. Several Neighborhoods in the Community are located within the boundaries of Tustin Unified School District Community Facility District No. 06-1 ("TUSDCFD No. 06-1") which was formed for the construction and maintenance of elementary, middle and high school facilities and any improvements in connection with such facilities. If your Home is located within TUSDCFD No. 06-1, your Horne will be subject to any taxes, assessments and obligations associated with TUSDCFD No. 06-1. You will be provided with a Notice of Special Tax for TUSDCFD No. 06-1. This Notice contains important information about district functions, your obligations, rights of the district, and information on how to contact the district for additional information materials. You should carefully read and understand the information contained in the Notice. Master Developers and Neighborhood Builders have no control over the amount of tax assessments levied or imposed against your Home or any increase or decrease in the amount of such assessments. Please contact the City of Tustin (City Clerk), telephone (714) 573-3025 for additionalinformation. ((c) ecreatian and Inrprwement Maintenance District. The Irvine Unified School District has formed a recreation and improvement maintenance district which is an annual assessment for maintenance of public sports/playfrelds. Please contact David Taussig & Associates, telephone (949) 955-1500 for additional information. d 616 lora d T4--v lv1 u-D 0(c) The eighborhood Builder will provide you with disclosures entitled "Notice of Special Tax" ("Notice") prior to entering into a contract to purchase a Home. These Notices will inform you of the special tax and assessment districts that apply to your Home. The Notices will also contain a detailed description of the special tax calculation, important information about functions and rights of the special tax and assessment districts, your obligations, and who to 7 i 2544.33253',CLP428\D1SCL.SR\ 609965.6 Buyer Initials: 3/011117 contact for additional information about the special tax and assessment districts. You should thoroughly understand the information contained in the Notices prior to entering into a contract to purchase a Home. You will have five days after the Notice is delivered by mail, or three days after its delivery in person, to terminate the contract to purchase by giving written notice of that termination. All Homes will be subject to annual special taxes levied by one or more of the special tax and assessment districts listed above. Not all special tax. or assessment districts listed above will apply to your Home. These special taxes will be a continuing lien on your Horne and will be billed to you with the annual real property tax bill issued by the County Assessor. The lien of these special taxes will continue until the obligation is satisfied. If you fail to pay a special tax when due, the assessment districts may exercise their right to foreclose on your Home. Information concerning the estimated amount of the annual special tax on your ]'Tome for the special tax and assessment districts is available from the City and County. 43. Changes in Special Taxes. The amount of any special taxes disclosed to you are estimates only, and are based on current information provided by the City, County or other public or private agencies responsible for the administration of special tax districts. Special taxes may increase or decrease, based upon the terms of the special tax lien, changes in real property tax law, the dissolution of special tax districts, the formation of new special tax districts, extension of special tax district(s), changes in services by the districts and other facts not in Master Developer's or Neighborhood Builders' control. The amount of special taxes may appear on your real property tax bill or may be billed separately. ADJACENT AREA DISCLOSURES 44, Adjacent Property Disclosures. The land adjacent to the Community within the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan has a variety of land use designations. The land use designations are subject to change. Therefore, the type of future development adjacent to the Community cannot be predicted with accuracy. 45. MCAS Specific Plan. MCAS Tustin was realigned and closed on July 2, 1999, in accordance with Base Realignment and Closure Act. The Department of Defense recognized the City of Tustin as the Lead Agency or Local Redevelopment Authority (`LRA") for preparation of the required reuse planning documents in late 1991. The MCAS Tustin Specific Plan/Reuse Plan (the "Plan") includes detailed planning, policies, regulations, implementation strategies and procedures necessary to guide the reuse and development of the site into the next century. Since implementation of the Plan will be a long- term process and there are unique circumstances associated with converting military bases to civilian uses, the Plan is intended to be practical in economic terms and visionary in terns of its ability to create and respond to future market opportunities. This means that it must provide sufficient guidance to provide investors with a high confidence level that their investments will be protected. At the same time, it must offer sufficient flexibility to respond to changing market conditions. A careful balance between certainty and flexibility underlies the provisions of this Plan. Buyei Initials: ! -22- 2544-33253\CLP428\DISCLSR\ 609965.6 3/01!07 The Plan is intended to serve as both a policy -oriented and regulatory document. The Plan has been submitted to the Department of Defense as a policy guide outlining the intended reuse for the Community. Subsequently, the Plan will be adopted by the Tustin City Council as the zoning for the Community. The Plan may also be amended one or more times by the City of Tustin. The Plan is one device for implementing goals and policies of the Tustin General Plan. The Plan also contains the development and reuse regulations that constitute the zoning for the Community. As a federal installation, MCAS Tustin was not subject to local zoning and planning requirements. Upon conversion to civilian use, the former MCAS Tustin property will be under the jurisdictional authority of either the City of Tustin or the City of Irvine, as applicable, and will be subject to local codes and ordinances. The City of Irvine has assigned responsibility for preparation of the Plan (and accompanying joint Environmental Impact Statement/Environmental Impact Report) to Tustin for that portion of the Plan area within Irvine. However, the City of Irvine will have to adopt any General Plan and zoning changes necessary to implement the provisions of the Plan within the City of Irvine. The land uses described in the Plan for the area covered by the Plan include, but are not limited to, Low -High Density Residential, Transitional and Affordable Housing, Golf Resort Living, Commercial Business and Retail, and Institutional/Recreational designations such as Parks, Trails and Schools. Also recommended were applications by the Orange County Sheriffs Department, City of Tustin and County of Orange Social Service Agency. The Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders have no control over the Plan, changes to the Plan, or development of the area covered by the Plan in accordance with the Plan. For further information, you should review the Plan. The Plan and information regarding the development of the Plan is available for review at the office of the Local Redevelopment Agency, City of Tustin. 46. The District. The District is a proposed one million square foot outdoor shopping center to be located approximately one and one-half (1'/z) miles southwest of the Community, at the corner of Jamboree Road and Barranca Parkway. The District is planned to include, among other businesses, several retail stores, a grocery store and a movie theater. The District will result in increased noise and traffic in and around the Community, particularly along Jamboree Road and Barranca Parkway. Neither Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders nor the Community Association have any control over the use or maintenance of the District or its impact on the Community. 47. Rail Corridor/ Metrolink Station. As disclosed in the Homebuyer Notification, there is a rail corridor ("Corridor'l located to the north of the Community. There is also a Metrolink station ("Station") located to the north of the Community at 2975 Edinger Avenue, Tustin, CA 92780. The impact of the Corridor and Station may include, without limitation, increased noise, light and vibration levels in the vicinity of the Community. The Corridor and Station could be an attractive nuisance to children and animals who may wish to play in the vicinity of the rail corridor. The Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders and the Community Association have no control over the use, maintenance or care of the Corridor or Station. You acknowledge and understand that you are responsible for keeping your children and animals Buyer Initials: / -23- 2544-33253\CLP428\1)JSC1SR\ 6119965.6 3101107 away from the Corridor and Station and the danger that is inherent around the Corridor and Station. You should evaluate the impact of the Corridor and Station on your decision to purchase a Home in the Community. 48, Temporary Sewer Lift Station. A temporary sewer lift station will be constructed within the vicinity of the Community. It is located at the northeast coiner of Kensington Drive and Valencia North Loop Road and will seine a portion of the Community until such time the master infrastructure is completed to connect your Homesite or Horne to the main sewer lines. The lift station will be installed below -grade and will be owned and maintained by the Irvine Ranch Water District. Owners of Homes near the lift station may experience an increase in noise and dust levels in the area of the lift station during the construction period and less significant noise levels after completion. Owners may encounter some odors in the areas near the lift station. You acknowledge, understand and agree that neither the Community Association nor the Neighborhood Builders will have any control over the use, maintenance or care of the lift station. 49. Areas Outside the Specific Plan. The MCAS Tustin Specific Plan, which is bounded by Edinger Avenue, Redhill Avenue, Barranca Parkway and Harvard Avenue has the following surrounding uses. (a) A rail corridor and Metrolink station (described above) are located along Edinger Avenue; (b) A business park, commercial and industrial areas, sports park and utility power lines are located along Barranca Parkway; (c) Adjacent to the west side of Warner Avenue exists a Southern California Edison easement with high voltage transmission lines and usages by a wholesale plant nursery and public storage facility; and (d) A Southern California Edison easement area with high voltage transmission Iines, landscaped areas available for public access and residential neighborhoods are located along Harvard Avenue. The Master Developer, Neighborhood Builder and the Community Association have no control over development outside of the Community. 50. Airport Proximity Disclosure. The Community is located within what is known as an airport influence area (as defined in California Civil Code Section 1353) surrounding John Wayne Airport. John Wayne Airport is located approximately 3.6 miles southwest of the Community at the (405) San Diego Freeway and MacArthur Boulevard in the City of Santa Ana. For that reason, the Community may be subject to some of the annoyances or inconveniences associated with proximity to airport operations (for example: noise, vibration or odors). Individual sensitivities to those annoyances can vary from person to person. You may wish to consider what airport annoyances, if any, are associated with the Community before you complete your purchase and determine whether they are acceptable to you. John Wayne Airport has noise abatement procedures in place, but there is no guarantee that these procedures will Buyer initieis: / -24- 2544-33253\CLP426\DISCLSR\ 609965.6 3/01/07 lessen the impacts on the Community of noise and vibrations caused by aircraft using this airport or that these noise abatement procedures will continue in the future. Further information is available from the airport website: www.ocair.com. Your Neighborhood Builder will provide you with a separate airport proximity notice required by California Civil Code Section 1353. 51. Avigation Easement. An avigation easement has been recorded against the Community. The avigation easement establishes a permanent right to travel through the air space over the Community for the benefit of John Wayne Airport. You may notice noise and vibration from overflying aircraft approaching or leaving the airstrip. By accepting a deed to a Home in the Community, you understand that the avigation easement gives the users of the airstrip a perpetual legal right to fly over the Community without interference from the occupants of the Community. 52. Residential Developments. There are existing single-family residential developments adjacent to the northern, eastern and western boundaries of the Community. In addition to increased automobile and pedestrian traffic resulting from the proximity of these residential developments to the Community, the solitude of a Home's yard area may be significantly impacted by the proximity, height and design of multi -story, residential buildings constructed on property adjacent to the Community. The Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders have no control over the proximity, height and design of such nearby buildings and make no representation on the future impacts that these residential developments will have on _. residents of the Community. 53. Commercial/Industrial Property. The Community is located within the vicinity of property zoned for commercial and heavy industrial uses. This area consists of, among others, a Waste Management Public Recycling/Transferring Station, asphalt recycling, trucking facilities and multiple concrete companies, all with product deliveries. These commercial and industrial properties may generate dust, offensive odor, noise and other effects. The Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders have no control over the existing, or potential uses of this property. These uses may create light, noise and other nuisances twenty-four (24) hours a day, seven (7) days a week. 54. Elementary School. The Tustin Unified School District owns an elementary school site located to the southeast of the Community. Owners and other residents within the Community may experience, among other things, glare from bright lights, noise and increased traffic and parking congestion in connection with the use of this site. There are no assurances if or when any school will be completed on the site, nor the type of facilities that may be included as part of the school. You should contact the Tustin Unified School District at (714) 730-7301 for more information. Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders and the Community Association make no representations as to the future use of this school site. 55. Development Area. The Community lies in a rapidly expanding area. As future commercial and residential developments are built in and around MCAS Tustin, you may expect attendant limitations on solitude and inconveniences. For example, you can expect to hear noise from the development of future adjacent residential and commercial areas and the machinery used to develop these areas. You can also expect increased traffic and rerouting of traffic as new residential and commercial developments are constructed, nearby streets and major Buyer Initials: / -25- 2544-33253\CLP423\D[SCLSR\ 609965.6 3/01/07 thoroughfares are widened and new streets are built. As the area around the Community develops, you may experience light entering your Home from exterior sources including streetlights, parking lot lighting and nearby residential and commercial buildings. The Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders and the Community Association have no control over the transmission of noise, light, vibration, odor and other impacts or their potential effects on Homes in the Community, including any which may be a direct result of current and fitture construction activity. 56. MCAS Tustin Airship Hangars. Two (2) airship hangars ("Hangars") are located within MCAS Tustin southwest of the Community. The hangars are each approximately one thousand (1,000) feet long, three hundred (300) feet wide, and one hundred and seventy (170) feet tall. The view from your Home may be effected by the nearby presence of the Hangars. It has not been determined whether these Hangars will remain or be demolished, or what uses might be made of them. For further information regarding the Hangars, please contact the City of Tustin. 57. Future Fire Station Site. The Community is located adjacent to a future fire station site at the corner of Edinger Avenue and West Connector Road. The fire station will operate twenty four (24) hours a day and seven (7) days a week. Owners whose Homes are located in the vicinity of the fire station will notice noise, sirens, light, glare and other impacts from the operation of the fire station and emergency vehicles. You are advise that Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders have no control over the operation or use of the fire station. You should carefully evaluate the impact of the fire station on your decision to purchase a Homesite or Horne in the Community. 58. Village Services. The Community is located northwest of an area designated in the Plan as the Village Services area. When and if built, this area is intended to be accessible to both vehicle and pedestrian traffic, and to provide localized commercial retail and service uses to adjacent residential areas within the Plan area. 59. Learning Village/Transitional and Emergency Housing. The Community is located east of an area designated in the Plan as the Learning Village area. When and if built, this area is intended to provide a specialized educational environment with a variety of public - serving uses. GENERAL DISCLOSURES 60. Neighborhood Model Homes. Neighborhood model homes reflect typical exterior elevations, floor plans and methods of construction, and also illustrate possibilities for future interior decoration and exterior landscaping and hardscape improvements. Your Home will not necessarily conform to any model shown. The exterior elevations, architectural treatments, floor plans and colors shown on the master plot plans on display at the office of each Neighborhood Builder may be different than those both displayed in the models and those actually constructed by the Neighborhood Builder. Additionally, window locations, window types, roof lines, architectural projections and other similar features vary by elevation and Home location, and not all of the features displayed in the models may be included in your Horne. The models have also been professionally decorated to show various decor ideas. Decoration items Buyer Initials; / _26_ 2544-332531CLA4281DISCLSR\ 609965.6 3101/01 such as furnishings, draperies and other window treatments, any window tinting, wallpaper, custom carpet, coordinated paint, built-in shelves, beams, certain lighting fixtures (including halogen lighting), special ceiling treatments and some mirrors are for display purposes ol>ay, and are not included in the purchase price for your Home. Entries, walkways and driveways are shown in a variety of materials to show design ideas; however, for your Horne, they will be constructed using only standard concrete. The hardscape shown in the model complex may not depict what may be constructed in all locations. Additionally, landscaping for the models is greater in density and type than any landscape package offered by a Neighborhood Builder. If not expressly included in the purchase price for your Home in writing by a Neighborhood Builder, the rear, side and front yard landscaping is your responsibility. The type of plants, and the size and density of the landscaping in the yards of the models are merely intended to suggest ideas to you. Certain models may also include hardscape items (patio slabs, patio covers, pools, spas, etc.) which are not included in the purchase price of your Home. All such options and upgrades displayed in the models (including decorator items, landscaping and hardscape) are not included in the purchase price for your Home unless expressly agreed to in writing by the Neighborhood Budder. You should consult your sales representative for additional information regarding non-standard items used in the model homes. 61. Extended Use of the Model Complex. Each Neighborhood Builder reserves the right to use one or more Homes in a Neighborhood as a sales office and model home complex, and to display signs and banners, in connection with its program of marketing and selling Homes in the Neighborhocid as well as other Homes owned by Neighborhood Builders, even if they are located in separate :and unrelated Neighborhoods. 62. Grading Variations. Your Homesite has been graded to City specifications and may vary significantly from other Homesites. Variations may include slopes, swales, drains, flood control chanlnels and retaining walls as required. Any changes made to the grading of the Hon which your ]Rome is located may significantly affect you or your neighbor's drainage pattern and cause significant property damage to your Home or a neighbor's Home. 63. WaWCeiling Heights. Wall and ceiling heights and configurations may vary significantly by elevation. Your Home's walls and ceiling heights may be different from those used in the model domes. You are encouraged to speak to a sales representative if you have any questions. 64. Right of Substitution. From time to time due to unavailability and other production considerations, it is necessary for a Neighborhood Builder to make substitutions of materials and other items used in construction of the Homes from those materials and items displayed in the models. Therefore, each Neighborhood Builder reserves the right to make any changes or substitutions as the Neighborhood Builder deems necessary or desirable to the color schemes, building materials, fixtures, appliances and other components of 'the. Homes. The foregoing substitutions may include, without limitation, kitchen appliances, household fixtures, electrical outlets and switches, hardware, wall surfaces, painting and other similar items. Each Neighborhood Builder shall have the right to make the substitutions described above without adjustment to the purchase price of your Home. Buyer Initials: J -27- 2544-312$3\CLF429\DISCLSR\ 609965,6 3101/07 65. Changes in Construction Plans. The construction, grading, drainage and improvement plans (collectively, the "Construction Plans") for Homesites and Homes within each Neighborhood all contain dimensions that are approximate.. They are not intended to be precise dimensions with regard to the Neighborhood. Room dimensions and electrical outlet placement will vary slightly from models and from printed information. Construction will be performed in substantial conformance with the Construction Plans, but dimensions may change slightly from them. If there is a discrepancy between the Construction Plans and the actual as - built conditions of your Homesite or Home, the as -built conditions will control. The usable or buildable area, location and configuration of the Homesite and all improvements located thereon may fluctuate from that shown or displayed to you in the Construction Plans or any other drawings, topographic maps or models based upon a Neighborhood Builder's construction of final improvements including, without limitation, fencing and slopes, which shall be constructed in a Neighborhood Builder's sole and absolute discretion. The location, size, height and composition of all walls and fences to be constructed on your Homesite or Home or adjacent to your it shall be determined by the Neighborhood Builder in its sole and absolute discretion and despite the Construction Plans or any other models, drawings or topographic maps displayed to you. The Neighborhood Builder makes no representations, warranties or assurances as to the size, height, location or composition of any wall or fence to be constructed on or adjacent to your Homesite or Home. The Construction Plans are subject to change at any time without notice or obligation. 66. Non -Standard Construction. You may not personally perform any changes of any kind to your Home (such as alarm systems, home intercoms, stereo wiring, etc.) during construction and prior to the Close of Escrow. Such changes may void your warranty. Only those options and upgrades specifically agreed to by the Neighborhood Builder will be made. Any other changes and unapproved options found in a Home during the construction period will be removed by the Neighborhood Builder and the cost of removal and any repairs shall be your responsibility. 67. Changes In Development Plan and Prices. The residential real estate market continually fluctuates due to changes in economic, social and political conditions that directly affect the supply of and demand for housing. As a result, the development plan for the Neighborhood and the Community, and home prices and the terms and conditions of sale. are also subject to change. Therefore: (a) With the exception of your Horne, each Neighborhood Builder reserves the right at any time prior to or after the Close of Escrow for the sale of a Home and without notice, (i) to increase or decrease the sale price, adjust incentives or otherwise adjust the terms and conditions of sale for Homes in the Neighborhood or in the Community, and (ii) change the number, size, location, elevation, design or type of homes constructed in current or future phases of development of the Neighborhood; (b) No Neighborhood Builder is obligated to offer you the same price, incentives or other terms and conditions of sale that the Neighborhood Builder has previously offered or may subsequently offer to another purchaser; Buyer Initials: / -2$- 2544-33253\CLP428\171SC:LSR\ 609965.6 3/0I/1)7 (c) No Neighborhood Builder has either offered or agreed to any price protection or other similar commitment to you regarding the value or resale value of your Home (or any other property), and no Neighborhood Builder shall not have any obligation or liability whatsoever to you in the event any price changes directly or indirectly affect the value of your Home; (d) When you entered into a Purchase Agreement, the Neighborhood Builder may have owned other properties which may have been off the market and may not have been shown to or otherwise made available for purchase by you. No Neighborhood Builder has any obligation to notify you if any of such properties come on the market or are otherwise available for purchase or any obligation to notify you of any future properties the Neighborhood Builder may develop and make available for purchase. (e) You shall not hold a Neighborhood Builder responsible for any fluctuations in the purchase price of Homes within the Neighborhood or the Community. In consideration of a Neighborhood Builder's agreement to sell a Home to you, you agree that you shall have no claims against the Master Developer or the Neighborhood Builder for any possible change (decrease or increase) in the purchase price of Homes within the Neighborhood or any other terms of purchase, including, without limitation, upgrades or other concessions or incentives offered by a Neighborhood Builder to other purchasers of Homes within the Neighborhood and the construction of any additional floor plans on any of the Homes in the Neighborhood. 68. Use of Subcontractors. Neighborhood Builders generally perform construction through the use of subcontractors, and may not employ construction trades or workers. A Neighborhood Builder is not permitted to change its subcontracts without approval of the respective subcontractor; therefore, you may not request interior or exterior construction changes or alterations not otherwise offered to other purchasers in the sales office. 69. Elevation/Floor Plan Specifications. In order to provide architectural diversity in the street scene, each Neighborhood Builder's architect has produced more than one exterior design (elevation) for each floor plan. Consequently, differences may be noticed between the model home for your floor plan and the elevation of your Home. You acknowledge that you have received a description of the exterior configuration for the elevation and the exterior color scheme number for your Home. You also acknowledge that your Home's elevation and floor plan may vary from the configuration of the model home for your Home in terms of layout, sizes of certain rooms, exterior elevation features and other items such as sloped ceilings, veneer treatments, window locations and sizes, roof lines and color schemes. 70. Upper Floor Weight Limits. The upper floors of Homes are designed to support weight limits as outlined in the Uniform Building Code ("UBC"). If you currently own or are planning to purchase a waterbed, pool table or other heavy furniture you must confirm with the manufacturer that the weight introduced by these items does not exceed the UBC weight limit. Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders shall not be responsible for damage caused by anything you place on the upper floors that exceeds the UBC weight limit. Buyer Initials: / _29. 2544.33253\CLP428\DISCLSR\ 609965.6 3/01/07 71. Air Conditioning. The air conditioning system and equipment specifications installed in the model -homes may vary and operate at a higher capacity than those provided in your Home. You are encouraged to speak with your sales representative to determine the exact equipment specifications that will be provided with your Home. The location of the air conditioning compressor may vary between the model and your Home and between your Home and other Homes in your Neighborhood. 72. Alarm System. If you purchase an alarm system from a Neighborhood Builder, you specifically waive any claims against Master Developer, the Neighborhood Builder and the Community Association as a result of any failure of the alarm system to warn, frighten off, or alert anyone about intruders or any other problems. The sale of such system to you by the Neighborhood Builder is not a guarantee or warranty against criminal acts. Master Developer, the Neighborhood Builders and the Community Association are not insurers against criminal acts. 73. Energy Conservation. Homes in the Community meet or exceed the energy conservation standards that are a part of Title 24 of the California Administrative Code. Each Neighborhood Builder is required to design and install heating and cooling units that meet strict guidelines in Title 24. This is an energy conservation law that is designed to help reduce the overall use of energy in your Home. Title 24 describes the amount of cooling capacity as well as the minimum efficiency ratings for each geographic location in the state. In complying with Title 24, the cooling units installed in your Home are designed for maximum efficiency. Due to the Title 24 geographic requirements, on extremely warm days your inside room temperature may be warmer than your thermostat selection. This is due to design restrictions imposed by Title 24, not any design or installation defect by the Neighborhood Builder or its contractor. 74. Water Conservation. Each Home in the Community is equipped with low flow fixtures and other equipment to aid in water conservation in compliance with the City's Conditions of Approval for the Neighborhood. 75. Gas Barbecue Stub. If a natural gas service line is stubbed -out to an exterior backyard wall of your Home, it is suitable only for use in connection with a gas barbecue. Any other use may result in a serious fire hazard. The Neighborhood Builder and Master Developer are not responsible for any damage resulting from your use of the exterior gas stub. 76. Stain Grade Material Discoloration. Natural hardwoods used for cabinets, doors, stair systems, moldings, etc., are finished with stain and lacquer finish products which will change color over time. Color change may be the result of exposure to sunlight or weather, or simply the consequence of aging. Discoloration is not a defect. 77. Paint Discoloration. Certain portions of your Home, such as paint -grade cabinets, casework, moldings and interior doors, may be painted with oil-based' enamel paint. Yellowing is common with oil-based enamel paints. Additionally, if your Home has white oil- based enamel paint -grade cabinets, yellowing will occur. 78. Variations In Natural Materials. Your Home may include various natural materials (e.g., wood products and/or stone products). Wood products vary in dimension, grain, Buyer Initials: ! -30- 2544-332531CLP428WISCLM 609965.6 3101107 color, moisture content, and performance when subjected to high moisture environments. Dimensional variations in the wood framing members (studs, plates, joists, rafters, and beams) or the required structural hardware connectors may show through the drywall and stucco finishes under certain lighting conditions. Wood panels and trim, exposed timbers, rafters, and posts will require periodic painting. Wood exposed to weather will require more frequent painting. Consult the maintenance schedule included in your Homeowners Manual. Some of the natural characteristics of wood will show through the painted or stained finish. For example, there may be shades of white, red, black, grey or even green in areas. Mineral streaks may also be visible. This is caused by the irregularity of mineral absorption from one part of the tree to another. Grain patterns or texture will vary from even to irregular throughout your cabinetry. Similarly, granite and natural stone products are composed of various mineral contents. Marble is less dense and more porous than granite. Great care must be taken to prevent damage to marble and other stone products. You should follow the manufacturers' recommendations for cleaning and maintenance. Because these are natural products, they are subject to variation in color, veining, spotting, holes, cloudiness, texture and cracking. Some may vary significantly in filler and sheen. The samples in the sales office are actual pieces of natural stone which indicate general color and character; however, no two (2) pieces can be expected to match, even when taken from the same box. You should view the stone prior to purchase, and any questions regarding these materials must be resolved prior to installation. If replacement of natural material tile or carpet is required, you understand and agree that a match with existing material cannot be guaranteed. 79. Brass Plumbing/Light Fixtures/Hardware. Brass, bronze or other finishes have their limitations. In time, the protective lacquer may deteriorate from exposure to weather, perspiration, cleaning agents, frequency of use and other factors. Tarnishing or excessive wear of these finishes is, therefore, not a defect, but a normal process which is unavoidable. Under the circumstances, these finishes cannot be guaranteed and products will not be repaired or replaced under the manufacturer's warranties for tarnishing or wear of finishes. 80. Drywall Panels and Finishes. Drywall panels are placed over the wall studs, joists, rafters and beams. Drywall is typically used to finish window openings. Drywall panels will not completely eliminate variations in the dimension and plane of wood framing members. Metal trim (i.e., comer bead) is used at corners, window edges, soffits and ceilings. They are designed to be filled with finish compounds. These trim metals provide a durable finish but cause the wall plane to "flare" at the metal edge. Panel joints and seams are taped and coated with finish compounds. Fasteners are coated with finish compounds to cover the small "dimple" in the surface of the drywall panel. Progressive applications of finish compounds are required to cover the joints, fasteners, and seams. In some cases, the normal. finishing of these joints, fasteners, and seams will cause a subtle "bulge". When the finishing process is complete, the walls and ceilings receive a texture coat. In certain lighting conditions (up -lights placed close to the walls), irregularities and variations in the wall plane or intersection of vertical and horizontal panels may be evident. These variations are normal. 81. View, Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders, the, Community Association and their counselors, agents, representatives or employees make no representations, warranties or promises concerning any view, present or future, that may be enjoyed from all or any portion of your Homesite or Home. The view from your Hornesite or Home may change or may be fully or partially obstructed by (a) the construction of other homes, Improvements, structures, fences, Buyer Initials: / -31- 2544-33253TI-P42801SCLSM 609965.6 3/01107 walls and/or landscaping by Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders or other Owners within the Community, (b) activities and Improvements on real property outside the Community, and/or (c) the growth of trees and/or other vegetation within or outside the Community. You are advised that trees installed in the Community are generally smaller than they will be once mature and trees that do not: block views when you purchase your Home may obstruct views as they grow. Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders make no representations or warranties with respect to any open space on property adjacent to your Homesite or Home, or the Community as a whole, whether this property is owned or controlled by Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders, government agencies or private property owners. 82. Warranties for Consumer Products. The manufacturers' warranties for the consumer products included in your Home (e.g., water heater, air conditioning system, dishwasher, garbage disposal and other household appliances) are available for review in the sales office of your Neighborhood Builder. 83. Financing. This paragraph only applies if you are purchasing your Home from a Neighborhood Builder who is also a Lemiar Family Builder and you are financing the purchase with Universal American Mortgage Corporation ("UAMC'). You will be required to provide VAMC with all documents necessary to obtain loan approval. UAMC may be affiliated with the Neighborhood Builder. You are not obligated to accept a loan from UAMC, but you may be required to submit documentation to UAMC to permit the Neighborhood Builder to determine whether it is likely that you will qualify to purchase the Home you desire. You may select your lender independently; however, if you select a lender other than UAMC, you must ensure that the lender can meet the time limitations and requirements imposed on lenders in the Purchase Agreement. Master Developer and Neighborhood Builder have not reviewed or approved any lender's sales or marketing materials, and does not make any representations or warranties whatsoever regarding any matters set forth therein or your ability to obtain any financing under any particular terms. You are strongly encouraged to make your own independent evaluation of the rates and loan programs offered by all lenders, including UAMC. You understand that the interest rate and loan fees for the loan applied for will be determined at the time of the Close of Escrow and may be higher or lower than on the date you signed a purchase agreement for your Home. You also acknowledge that the interest rate and loan fees referenced on the loan application are approximate only and do not constitute a binding commitment. 84. Schools. The Community is currently located in the Tustin Unified School District, telephone: (714) 730-7301 (the "School District"). To obtain further information about the schools serving the Community, including transportation to and from the schools, please contact the School District. You should investigate this matter to your satisfaction prior to purchasing a Home in the Community. Due to the rate of population change, the school district may find it necessary to change boundaries and designated schools periodically, prior to or after your close of escrow. In addition, it is possible that school district• bpundaries may change and your children will be required to attend a different school district in the future. Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders have no control or respoftsibility for such changes should they occur. The Community is currently expected to be served by the following schools: Buyer bihials: / _32- 2544-3325ACLl1421MISCLSM 609965.6 3/01/07 Marjorie Veeh Elementary School (K-6) 1701 San Tuan Street Tustin, California (714) 730-7544 A.G. Currie Middle School (7-8) 1402 Sycamore Avenue Tustin, California (714)730-7352 Tustin High School (9-12) 4321 1171 El Camino Real Tustin, California (714) 730-7414 To obtain further information about the schools serving the Community, including transportation to and from the schools, please contact the applicable school referenced above or the School District, or you can visit the School District's website at www.tusti 2.ca.us. You should investigate this matter to your satisfaction prior to purchasing a Home in the Community. 85. Mailboxes. Mailboxes in the Community may be clustered in groups as required by the United States Postal Service. The location of mailboxes and above -ground utility structures are determined by governmental agencies or utility companies, or both. You may not change the type of mailbox being used or the location. Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders reserve the right to modify such locations as may be dictated by field conditions without prior notice. 86. Residential Construction Legislation. California Civil Code Sections 895 through 945.5 ("Construction Claims Statute'!, went into effect on January 1, 2003. The Construction Claims Statute (a) delineates standards for how various components of your Home should be constructed and function, (b) limits the time frames for bringing various claims against the Neighborhood Builder to anywhere from one year to ten years (as listed in the Construction Claims Statute) after the Close of Escrow, (c) imposes an obligation on all Owners and their successors in interest. to follow Neighborhood Builder's maintenance recommendations and schedules or other applicable maintenance guidelines, and (d) establishes a non -adversarial claims resolution procedure. Pursuant to Section 914 of the Construction Claims Statute, the Neighborhood Builder is permitted to elect to utilize the procedure in the Construction Claims Statute or its own alternate contractual pre -litigation procedures. The applicable claims handling procedures are outlined in the Purchase Documents you receive from the Neighborhood Builder, including the "Dispute Resolution" provision in Section 13.5 of the Master Declaration. A separate notice further describing claims handling procedures may have been recorded against the title to Homes by the Neighborhood Builder in some Neighborhoods. You should review any such notice and your Purchase Documents carefully concerning these issues. YOU ARE ADVISED THAT THE CONSTRUCTION CLAIMS STATUTE AFFECTS YOUR LEGAL RIGHTS. YOU ARE ADVISED TO READ THE STATUTE 2544-13253\C.LP429W1SCLSM 6119965.6 Buyer bitials: -- -33- 3101/07 CAREFULLY AND SEED LEGAL ADVICE IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS REGARDING ITS EFFECT ON YOUR LEGAL RIGHTS. Buyer Initials Buyer Initials 87. Duty to Follow Maintenance Guidelines. An Owner is obligated by Section 907 of the Construction Claims Statute to follow any maintenance recommendations and schedules from the Neighborhood Builder, including the maintenance recommendations and schedules for manufactured products and appliances included with the Home, as well as all commonly accepted maintenance practices (collectively, "Maintenance Guidelines'. Pursuant to Section 945.5 of the Construction Claims Statute, failure to follow any such Maintenance Guidelines may reduce or preclude an Owner's right to recover damages relating to an Owner's Home which could have been prevented or mitigated had the Maintenance Guidelines been followed. Buyer Initials Buyer Initials 88. Obligation to Retain Purchase Documents. The Purchase Documents that you receive through escrow in conjunction with the purchase of a Home may include Maintenance Guidelines, a written limited warranty, claim forms, and other documentation relating to the Construction Claims Statute. All Owners are required by the Construction Claims Statute to retain these documents and provide copies of such documents to an Owner's successors in interest upon the sale or transfer of the Owner's Home. Buyer Initials Buyer Initials 89. Warranty and Limitations on Liability. A Neighborhood Builder may provide a written limited warranty for the Homesite or Horne covering certain defects for a limited period after the date the limited warranty commences. Warranty periods for items will vary as set forth in the written limited warranty. During the written limited warranty period, if any, the Neighborhood Builder will repair or replace, at the Neighborhood Builder's sole discretion, certain components of your Homesite or Home, as set forth in the written limited warranty. A written limited warranty generally does not cover defects resulting from the failure of an Owner to perform commonly- accepted maintenance. Minor expansion, contraction, settlement cracks normal to home construction, and secondary damage, are generally not covered under the terms of a written limited warranty. Please refer to the written Iimited warranty you may receive for additional information. No other warranties or guarantees, whether expressed or implied, are provided, unless stated in writing and signed by a Neighborhood Builder. The manufacturers' warranties for the manufactured consumer products included in your Home (for example, water heater, air conditioning system, dishwasher, garbage disposal and other household appliances) are available for review in the Neighborhood Builder's sales office. Buyer Initials; 1 -34- 2544-33253\CLY42$\D1SCL8k\ 609965.6 am1r07 90. Notice of Sexual Offenders. The following notice is given pursuant to Section 2079.10a of the California Civil Code: Pursuant to Section 290.46 of the Penal Code, information about specified registered sex offenders is made available to the public via an Internet Web site maintained by the Department of Justice at www megansl ft)y.ea.-,oy. Depending on an offender's criminal history, this information will include either the address at which the offender resides or the community of residence and ZIP Code in which he or she resides. Prior to the purchase of a Home in the Community, you may research the database to determine whether there are sex of in the area. Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders, the Community Association and their respective directors, officers, employees, agents, representatives and consultants make no representations, warranties, or guarantees regarding the presence or absence of registered sex offenders within the Community or in the surrounding area. In addition, Master Developer, Neighborhood Builder, the Community Association and their respective directors, officers, employees, agents, representatives and consultants have no obligation or duty to investigate existing residents or buyers to determine whether they are sex offenders. You are solely responsible for making your own investigation. For further information, please contact your local law enforcement agency. Most law enforcement agencies have special stations to view the Megan's Law database. - 91. Benefit of Home Ownership. Although the purchase of a new home has traditionally been considered a wise decision, Master Developer and Neighborhood Builder have made no representations, guarantees or warranties to you regarding the tax benefits, investment benefits or other benefits of home ownership, regarding appreciation or depreciation in the value or equity accrual in your Horne, and regarding future price adjustments. 92. Assumption of Risk and Liability. By acceptance of this Disclosure, you assume all risk and liability for injuries to persons and property that may be sustained by you, your family members and your social and business guests by reason of all conditions or circumstances disclosed in this Disclosure. VISITING THE COMMUNITY BEFORE MOVE -IN If you wish to visit the Community, the Neighborhood and your Horne before your move in, please be aware that your Home is located within a construction area and that construction sites are potentially dangerous. The Neighborhood Builder will permit you to enter your Home and the construction area surrounding your Home provided that you are fully aware of the risks of such entry and are willing to comply with the procedures and requirements imposed on such visit by the Neighborhood Builder. You must be accompanied by your sales representative, or another representative of the Neighborhood Builder on any and all visits to your Home. Each ests that such visits be limited to non -construction hours. By Neighborhood Builder further requ signing this Disclosure you acknowledge that there are numerous risks associated with visiting your Home during construction, including without limitation, open trenches, construction traffic, potential falling debris, exposed nails and electrical wiring, incomplete construction and certain other potential hazards. You further agree to use due care while visiting your Home. In Buyer Initials: / � �_ 2544-332531CLP428TISCLSM 609965.6 3/01/07 addition, prior to visiting any construction area you may be required to sign a waiver and release form provided by the Neighborhood Builder ("Waiver") in which you agree to comply with the provisoes of the Waiver. Whether or not you have signed a Waiver, by signing this Disclosure, you agree that you shall proceed at your own risk and you release and waive any claims against Master Developer Neighborhood Builders, all of their affiliated entities, officers, directors, agents and assigns and all other persons or entities potentially liable to you as a result of an injury which may occur during Your visit. to your Home, to the Neighborhood and to the community. ENTIRE DISCLOSURE; NO OTHER REPRESENTATIONS No sales representative, employee or agent of any Neighborhood Builder or the Master Developer has the authority to make any representation to you which contradicts or modifies the matters and information set forth in this Disclosure, the purchase agreement or any other written disclosure provided by the Master Developer or Neighborhood Builders in connection with the purchase of a Home in a Neighborhood (collectively, the "Disclosure Documents"). You acknowledge that no representations have been made to you by such persons other than as set forth in the Disclosure Documents and upon which you have relied in connection with the purchase of the Home. Please indicate below if any representations have been made by any such person which contradict or modify the matters and information set forth in the Disclosure Documents: RELEASE AND INDEMNITY REGARDING DISCLOSURES With respect to items of information disclosed to you in this Disclosure or in any Disclosure Documents provided by Master Developer or Neighborhood Builders (collectively, "Disclosure Items"), you agree that you and your family members release, waive and will not make any claims against Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders for (a) nondisclosure of Disclosure Items, (b) for alleged improper or incomplete Disclosure Items, and (c) personal injury, property damage, expenses (including attorney fees and costs) and other liability you, your family members and others experience from the nondisclosure, improper disclosure or incomplete disclosure of Disclosure Items. You also agree that you will indemnify and hold the Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders and all of their affiliated entities, officers, directors, agents and assigns, harmless from all such claims by you, your family members and your social and business guests. Buyer initials Buyer Initials [Buyer Acknowledgment on following page] Buyer Initials: / _36_ 2544-33253TLf4281DISCLSR\ 609965.6 3/01/07 Columbus Square HOMEBUYER DISCLOSURE STATEMENT BUYER ACKNOWLEDGMENT By the signatures below, you acknowledge that you will close escrow with full knowledge, understanding and agreement as to all of the information contained in this Disclosure, and that this Disclosure constitutes a part of the terms of your Home purchase. Buyer: Date: Homesite or Condominium No: Tract No: Street Address: Buyer Initials; -37- 2544-33253\CLA42WISCLSR\ 609965.6 3101/0? Columbus Square HOMEBUYER DISCLOSURE STATEMENT MeriweAer + Carty ko Place The tables + Ashnia • Corm urry Court Cam brake Lame * .M kabelle + Vererxdas September 2008 Welcome to Columbus Square. We are pleased you are considering the purchase of a new home in Columbus Square. We want you (the "Buyer") to be an extremely satisfied cesumer. Part of your satisfaction is in knowing as much as possible about your new home in the master -planned community of Columbus Square ("Commmuolly"), located in the City of Tustin. We offer this Homeowner Disclosure Statement ("Disclosure") as a service to describe to you various matters which might affect your decision to purchase. Plow read it carefully. Be aware, however, that (a) much of the information in this Disclosure has been obtained from other sources (public agencies, public records, etc.), and (b) the information contained in this Disclosure is not comprehensive. This means that we cannot guarantee the accuracy or completeness of the information disclosed. Because this information is subject to change without notice to us, it also means that we cannot commit to advise you of any changes affecting the information in this Disclosure. In addition to this Disclosure, the City of Tustin has required that the Master Developer provide you with a Columbus Square Homebuyer Notification (the "Homebuyer NoliJleation"). The Master Developer prepared the Homebuyer Notification with information provided by the City of Tustin, at the direction of the City of Tustin and does not have the right to alter or update the Homebuyer Notification without the express written consent of the City. To the extent any of the information provided in this Disclosure is inconsistent with the information provided in the Homebuyer Notification, the Homebuyer Notification shall supersede this Disclosure to the extent of any inconsistency; provided, however (a) the conflicting documents shall be construed to be consistent to the extent possible, and (b) the more restrictive provisions of the conflicting documents shall control. By signing this Disclosure, you agree to independently verify all information regarding matters of concern to you before the Close of Escrow for your home purchase. As a part of your pre -purchase investigation, we strongly recommend that you visit the Community and the general vicinity surrounding the Community on several different days at several different times to familiarize yourself with the Community, its location and its surroundings. You will receive many documents in addition to this Disclosure to review, complete and sign before the Close of Escrow for the purchase of your home. These other documents are called the "Purchase Documents" in this Disclosure, and they include documents pertaining to Buyer initials; i _ t _ 25114-33253\CLP428\DISCLS R\ t5("5.7 q, AIA the Community, defined below as the "Community Association Governing Documents". This Disclosure is not intended as a substitute for your review of the Community Association Governing Documents. This Disclosure does not amend, modify or supersede the Community Association Governing Documents. If the Community Association Governing Documents are inconsistent with this Disclosure, the Community Association Governing Documents will supersede this Disclosure. Unless defined in this Disclosure, capitalized terms used in this Disclosure have the meanings given them in the Master Declaration of Covenants, Conditions, Restrictions and Reservation of Easements for Columbus Square ("Community Declaration 'I. If the Community Declaration gives the same capitalized term a different meaning than this Disclosure, the meaning given in the Community Declaration shall apply. INTRODUCTION TO THE MASTER DEVELOPER Moffett Meadows Partners, LLC, a Delaware limited liability company, is the initial Master Developer of the Columbus Square master -planned community ("Master Developer'). INTRODUCTION TO COLUMBUS SQUARE 1. Location and Master Plan. The Community is east of Interstate 55 near the intersection of Edinger Avenue and Redhill Avenue, in the City of Tustin (the "City"). The master land -use plan approved by the City of Tustin for the Community is called the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan (the "Speck Plan") and it contains numerous design standards and development conditions. Such conditions establish, among other things, the number of single family dwellings and condominiums and other development requirements. If developed as approved by the City, Columbus Square will encompass approximately 1075 Homes, which are planned to consist of 283 single family dwellings, 552 condominiums and 240 senior housing condominiums. The actual number of Homes built may increase or decrease subject to approval by the City. All Homes in the Community are planned to be subject to the jurisdiction of the Columbus Square Community Association, a California nonprofit mutual benefit corporation ("Community Association 11, as described in the Community Declaration. INTRODUCTION TO COLUMBUS SQUARE'S NEIGHBORHOODS AND NEIGHBORHOOD BUILDERS 2. Neighborhoods. The Community is being developed with Homes in numerous distinct neighborhoods ("Neighborhoods') constructed by various homebuilders ("Neighborhood Builders'l. Neighborhood Builders may have owner occupancy restrictions, rental Homesites and Homes (each of which is defined below), and investor-owned Homesites and Homes. You are advised to read the individual Neighborhood Builder disclosures and any other documentation relating to the Neighborhood in which you choose to purchase a Homesite or Home thoroughly. Neighborhood Builder policies may differ from those described in this Disclosure and the Community Declaration and are enforceable by the dpplicable Neighborhood Builders. The following is a list of the different Neighborhoods to be developed by the Neighborhood Builders in the Community and the approximate number of Homes to be constructed in each Neighborhood; provided that that any product may be renamed or sold by the Buyer Initials: / -2- 2544-33253TU428\13ISCLSM 604965.7 9125108 Neighborhood Builder currently listed below and the Neighborhood Builders reserve the right not to build the Neighborhoods listed below at all: (a) Lennar Homes of California, Inc. • Meriwether 114 Homes • Camden Place 222 Homes • The Gables 84 Homes • Coventry Court 240 Homes (b) William Lyon Homes, Inc. and/or Resmark Equity Partners, LLC • Astoria 102 Homes • Cambridge Lane 156 Homes • Mirabella 60 Homes • Verandas 97 Homes 3. Ownership. A residential Lot in the Community is referred to as a "Homesite" in this Disclosure. If you are purchasing a residential Lot in the Community, upon the Close of Escrow, you will receive fee title to a Homesite, which will be improved with a single family dwelling (a "Home'). If you are purchasing a Condominium in the Community, upon the Close of Escrow, you will receive fee title to a Unit and you will also receive easements for maintenance and use over Exclusive Use Area's (collectively, a "Home'). If you purchase a Homesite, you will not own the mineral, oil, and gas rights under the land below a depth of five hundred (500) feet, or the water rights. The holder of these rights has no right of surface entry. COMMUNITY ASSOCIATION GOVERNING DOCUMENTS Your Horne will be subject to the following documents ("Community Association Governing Documents"): (a) The Community Declaration, and any amendments or modifications thereto; (b) The Articles of Incorporation of the Columbus Square Community Association ("Community Association'); (c) The Bylaws of the Community Association; (d) The Supplemental Declaration of Covenants, Conditions and Restrictions ("Supplemental Declaration 'I that is applicable to the Neighborhood in which your Home is located, and may annex that Neighborhood to the coverage of the Community Declaration; and (e) Any Community Guidelines or Design Guidelines; which may be adopted from time to time, respectively, by the Community Association's Board of Directors or the Design Review Committee ("Committee') pursuant to the Community Declaration. Buyer initials: / _3_ 2544-33253TU42MISCLSM 609965.7 9/25/08 You should carefully review the Community Association Governing Documents in order to understand your specific rights and obligations as an Owner in the Community. The Community Association Governing Documents establish limits and restrictions on the use of the Home you are purchasing. You will also be provided with a preliminary title report. The title report will list other recorded documents affecting the use of the Horne you are purchasing. You should review the title report and the documents referenced in the report closely prior to your purchase of a Home. SPECIFIC PROVISIONS OF THE COMMUNITY DECLARATION 4. Assessment Obligation. The Community Declaration authorizes the Community Association's Board of Directors to levy a Common Assessment against each Home to meet the Community Association's Common Expenses. The Board of Directors is also authorized to levy various special assessments for specific purposes, in conformance with Articles I and VIII of the Community Declaration. The monthly installment of the Common Assessment will vary as each Phase of the Community is developed. You should review the Budget approved by the California Department of Real Estate and provided to you with the Final Subdivision Public Report for your Home. The Board of Directors' ability to increase the Common Assessments and improve additional special assessments without a vote of the Members is subject to certain limitations set forth in Sections 8.5 and 8.6 of the Community Declaration. The Community Association is obligated to provide you with an annual budget and other financial statements for the Community Association. 5. Use Restrictions. You must comply with all the various use restrictions set forth in the Community Declaration. These restrictions include, among other things, restrictions on non-residential uses of your Home, keeping of animals, improvements to your Homesite and Home, parking of vehicles, etc. The Community Association has the power to enforce the use restrictions set forth in the Community Declaration, as well as the Community Guidelines and the Design Guidelines. 6. Prohibited Dwelling Structures. You may not use your garage as a living area. Further, in accordance with Section 2.7 of the Community Declaration, you may not erect or use any outbuilding, tent, shack, storage shed, trailer, camper, motor home, recreational vehicle or any other vehicle on your Homesite for a living area. 7. Use of Garages. All vehicles owned or operated by or within the control of an Owner and kept in the Community must be parked in the assigned parking space or garage of that Owner; provided that, although storage of personal items may occur in the garage, all Authorized Vehicles must be parked in the garage, in accordance with Section 2.4.3 of the Community Declaration and Exhibit PC -1 attached thereto. Notwithstanding the foregoing, Owners may not park any Authorized Vehicle in the street or in any guest parking spaces. No repair, maintenance or restoration of any vehicle may be conducted within the Community except in an enclosed garage when the garage door is closed; provided, however, that such activity may not be undertaken as a business, and provided further that such activity may be prohibited entirely by the Board if the Board determines that it constitutes a nuisance. Buyer initials: ! -4_ 2544-3325MUP4281131SCLSM 609965.7 9/25A)8 8. Parking of Recreational and Commercial Vehicles. Sections 2.4.1, 2.4.2 and 2.43 of the Community Declaration impose limitations and prohibitions on the parking of. Authorized Vehicles and Prohibited Vehicles within the Community. In accordance with Section 2.4.6 of the Community Declaration, an Owner may park any Authorized Vehicle that exceeds seven (7) feet high, seven (7) feet wide, and nineteen (19) feet long in the Owner's garage or driveway (as long as the Authorized Vehicle does not extend onto the sidewalk or drive approach area). In addition, no delivery and/or moving trucks larger than forty (40) feet are permitted on any private drive having less than a twenty-five (25) foot radius that is located within a Neighborhood in the Community. You further acknowledge that it is your responsibility to determine whether the parking provided in the Community and your Neighborhood is satisfactory for your purposes and to verify that the standard height and depth of the garage will provide adequate clearance for your vehicles before the Close of Escrow on your Home. 9. Owner Maintenance Guidelines. As set forth in Section 9.1.1 of the Community Declaration, each Owner must maintain his Home and Homesite in a neat and attractive condition at all times. The maintenance of -all areas located within the boundaries of a Homesite is the responsibility of each Owner. The Neighborhood Builders will provide you with important guidelines on the proper maintenance of improvements in your Homesite. Failure to properly maintain interior improvements may cause premature deterioration of important features, finishes or equipment. The Neighborhood Builders are not responsible for failure of equipment or other improvements caused by your failure to properly maintain such improvements. In addition, you acknowledge that some upgraded materials, if any are selected by you, may have specific maintenance requirements. The Neighborhood Builders are not responsible for any damages that may occur to such materials due to your failure to properly maintain them. 10. Insurance. In accordance with Article IX of the Community Declaration, you are solely responsible for determining the type and quality of insurance required to adequately insure your Homesite and Home, your personal property, and your personal liability for ownership of your Homesite and Home. You are solely responsible for determining if natural disaster insurance is required for your Homesite and Home. If any insurance is required by your lender, you are responsible for obtaining that insurance prior to Close of Escrow. 11. Design Review of Improvements and Alterations. You may not build, construct, install or plant any improvements on your Homesite (or alter any improvements located on your Homesite, including your Home), until you have submitted plans and specifications and obtained approval from the Design Review Committee, as set forth in Article V of the Community Declaration. The Design Review Committee will establish Design Guidelines containing rules and guidelines for the submission of plans and specifications. The Design Review Committee- may collect a fee to review the plans. All Improvements must comply with any applicable restrictions in the Community Declaration and the Design Guidelines, as well as with all requirements imposed by the City and any other local governmental agency. The Design Guidelines and City and other local governmental agency regulations may change from time to time, and you will be subject to the regulations in effect at the time plans are submitted. After obtaining written approval of the Design Review Committee, Buyer Initials: / -5_ 2544-3325MLP428WISCLM 6OM5.7 9/25/08 you must submit the plans and specifications to the appropriate local governmental agencies for any proposed improvements that require the issuance of a building permit, or other approval by the City or any other local governmental agencies, as applicable. You should read Article V of the Community Declaration before constructing any Improvements. You may be subject to a Neighborhood Association Design Review Committee if you live in a Condominium project. (a) Landscaping and Irrigation Improvements. All landscape materials and irrigation systems installed by Owners must comply with plans and specifications approved by the Design Review Committee. You may need to install yard drains when installing landscaping and patios. Your landscaping plans are required to conform with the original drainage plan of the Homesite. Changes to drainage and grading require approval of the Design Review Committee and generally require you to obtain a permit from the City, as applicable. The slope areas, if any, located on a Homesite may include drainage facilities and temporary erosion control measures. No modifications to the slope areas shall be undertaken without the prior approval of the Design Review Committee and the City, as applicable. (b) Landscaping Completion Deadline. Section 2.18 of the Community Declaration requires you to install landscaping on any portions of your Homesite that have not been landscaped by a Neighborhood Builder. Landscaping in the front yard of a Homesite must be completed within six (6) months after the Close of Escrow for the purchase of the Homesite and landscaping in the back yard of a Homesite must be completed within one (1) year after the Close of Escrow for the purchase of the Homesite. The time period for the completion of such improvements is set forth in the Community Declaration. (c) Owner Liability. Any alterations or Improvements made by you to your Homesite, to its drainage pattern or to the Home shall be made at your sole risk. The Neighborhood Builders assume no responsibility for any damage caused by the design, construction, installation, alteration or maintenance by you of any Improvement on the Homesite, or caused by the impact of such an Improvement on the Homesite's drainage pattern. (d) Licensed Professionals. If you wish to alter or install any Improvement on your Homesite, you should obtain the advice of a licensed architect or civil, soil or structural engineer, as applicable, and should design and complete the alteration or installation of the Improvement in accordance with such licensed professional's advice and specifications. 12. Drainage. Section 2.14 of the Community Declaration contains important restrictions concerning drainage of water and water pollution. (a) Surface Water. The Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders have provided for surface and underground drainage of water from all Homesites and Homes in the Community. Your Homesite may have surface "swales" or area drains to carry the water from the rear and sides of the Horne to the street or other designated outlet points. The Homesites and Homes are graded in accordance with plans approved by the City and certified by a registered civil engineer. In connection with the preparation of landscape plans for your yard, it is important that you consider any possible harmful effects that such landscaping and associated Improvements may have on adjacent property and structures as well as your Homesite and Home. Because the Community and your Homesite are located in an area which may contain Buyer Initials: ! _(_ 2544-33253\C1,1142RDiSCLSM 609965.7 9125/08 expansive soils as more particularly explained in the Paragraph below entitled "Soil Conditions," water may have a detrimental impact upon such soils and the soils of surrounding Homesites and slopes. Existing drainage patterns must be maintained and all drainage systems must be kept free of debris and free flowing. (b) Effect of Improvements and Alterations. Raising the existing grade, constructing planters, changing the drainage pattern. and other similar activities may cause damage to your Homesite, adjacent property (including, without limitation, your neighbor's Homesite, adjacent slopes and lower I-iomesites) and Improvements located thereon, including the Home. It is recommended that you consult with a licensed professional on landscaping and drainage, such as a qualified landscape architect and soils engineer, geotechnical engineer, geologist, civil engineer or other similar specialist, before making any alterations. Any Improvements must be designed and constructed in a manner to prevent any possible damage to your Homesite and to adjacent properly. If any obstruction occurs to the drainage on your yard, it may result in obstruction of drainage from adjacent property or cause major problems such as trapped water or flooding which may undermine the foundation of your Home and surrounding Homes or create moisture intrusion or mold and mildew problems. You are solely responsible for any damage to your Homesite and Home or surrounding property and the Improvements located thereon as a result of any alterations you make to the approved existing drainage pattern or failure to maintain proper drainage. The Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders and Community Association shall have no liability or responsibility for any such damage. Any grading or drainage modifications are subject to applicable codes of the City, approval by the Design Review Committee, and the terms of any drainage easements that may be of record. You acknowledge and understand that if your Homesite or Home does not include area drains, you shall be responsible for installing area drains on your Homesite or Home when installing your landscaping. Your responsibilities for maintaining all grading and other drainage -related features on your Homesite and Home are set forth in Section 2.14.1 of the Community Declaration. (c) Water Quality Management Requirements. The Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders are developing the Community and Neighborhoods in accordance with a water quality management plan ("Plan') required by the California State Water Quality Control Board. The Plan imposes requirements for the design, implementation and maintenance of Best Management Practices (11BMPs1) to eliminate or mitigate all non -storm water discharges into storm drains during and after construction of the Community and Neighborhoods. The requirements imposed by the Plan are in addition to any local ordinances with regard to discharge of non -storm water into storm drains. The Plan imposes post -construction requirements. This means that after the Close of Escrow, you and your sub -contractors and other agents, are required to comply with all BMPs which are necessary to prevent, without limitation, run-off of soil, sand, sediment, oil, gasoline or other hydrocarbons, paint, fertilizers, pool chemicals and other household chemicals into the storm drains located in your Neighborhood. For eample, when fertilizing 'landscaping, measures must be taken to prevent over -watering the landscaping to ensure that fertilizer and other lawn chemicals do not run into the storm drains. Your Neighborhood Builder will provide you with a Best Management Practices Handbook containing BMP recommendations for the prevention of run-off into storm drains from your Homesite and Home. Buyer Initials: / -7- 2544-33253TU42MISCLSM 609%5.7 9/25/08 The Plan affirmatively obligates all Owners to take immediate corrective action whenever there is a violation of the Plan as to an Owner's Homesite or Home. Penalties include significant fines that may be imposed against an Owner for failing to comply with BMPS necessary to prevent non -storm water run-off into storm drains, in violation of the Plan. 13. Utility and Other Easements. Article V11 of the Community Declaration contains provisions pertaining to easements which may affect Owners and Homes. Your Homesite and Home may be subject to easements or other rights in favor of utility companies, local governmental agencies and other parties. These easements and rights may include access onto your Homesite or to exterior portions of the Home for purposes of installing, constructing, inspecting, maintaining and repairing facilities which are customary for residential developments (including, but not limited to, water lines, sewer lines, electrical lines and facilities, transformer boxes, natural gas pipelines, street lights, telephone lines and facilities, cable television lines, mailboxes, traffic signs, fire hydrants, etc.). These facilities and structures may be located above ground or below ground. In either case, the foregoing easements, rights and facilities may restrict the use and type of improvements you can make to your Homesite and Home, and the utility company, local government agency or other parties benefited by such easement or right may have the right to remove improvements made by you on the easement area without any obligation to repair or restore them. You should review the policy of title insurance, the tract map for your Homesite, Article VII of the Community Declaration, and the Supplemental Declaration to determine what easements and other rights, if any, affect your Homesite and Home. Such easements may preclude construction of structures or other improvements or may require an encroachment permit to be obtained. You should not excavate or construct an improvement on any portion of your Homesite, as applicable, until you have consulted with an applicable licensed design professional (for example, an engineer) and located all easements and facilities. A copy of the tract map depicting your Homesite is available for review in the sales office. The location of gas and electric meters, telephone and cable access panels may change from the locations shown in the models. Please ask your sales representative for information concerning the proposed location of utility facilities and structures for your Home. The Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders make no representations or warranties concerning the final location of these facilities or structures for your Home. 14. Pets. Household pets, such as dogs or cats, are limited to reasonable quantities as established in Section 2.5 of the Community Declaration. Buyers shall be liable for any unreasonable noise or damage (including, but not limited to, clean up after such animal(s)) caused by any animal brought or kept upon the Community and Neighborhoods as more fully described in the Community Declaration. 15. Window Coverings. In accordance with Section 2.10 of the Community Declaration, the Design Guidelines and Community Guidelines may prohibit or restrict certain types of window coverings such as paint, foil, reflective tint or other similar materials or substances, and may permit certain types of temporary window coverings pending installation of permanent window coverings. 16. Walls and Fences. Wall and fence heights may vary throughout the Community and your Neighborhood. Walls and fences are subject to change, at any time and without notice to you, from any depiction that may have been provided or shown to you. Section 9.1.4 of the Buyer Initials: f -g. 2544-33253WLP42MISCLSM 609965,7 W25/08 Community Declaration sets forth Owner's wall maintenance responsibilities. Owners are responsible for maintenance of all portions of the walls and fences that border the perimeter of the Homesite, including any pilasters located on an Owner's Homesite, except for those portions that are designated for maintenance by the Comtuunity Association or a Neighborhood Association. You should review the Community Association Governing Documents for further information. Community Walls, Neighborhood Walls and/or Party Walls (all as defined in the Community Declaration) may be installed on the property line(s) of your Homesite (collectively, the "Walls"), as shown as Exhibit WM attached to the Community Declaration, Neighborhood Declaration or a Supplemental Declaration. Owners must maintain any portion of the Walls not otherwise maintained by the Community Association or a Neighborhood Association. Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders and the Community Association are not responsible for damage to any Wall on the Homesite if such damage results from your failure to properly maintain the Walls. 17. Solar Energy Systems. Pursuant to Section 2.17 of the Community Declaration, you and all other Owners of Homesites in the Community have the right to place and maintain equipment and facilities related to the installation and maintenance of individual solar energy systems ("Systeni'�. The installation and maintenance of any System by you shall be subject to all applicable ordinances and zoning regulations of the City, the Uniform Building Code and associated ordinances. California has a strong public policy in favor of solar energy needs of a neighbor, including but not limited to the location and height of trees on your Homesite. You must obtain written approval from the Design Review Committee prior to installation of a System and you must comply with reasonable restrictions placed on the System by the Design Review Committee, subject to California Civil Code Sections 714 and 714.1, as the same may be amended from time to time. 18. Satellite Dishes. Satellite dish antennas (or Authorized Antennae, as defined in the Community Declaration) may be installed and used in the Community in accordance with Section 2.11 of the Community Declaration. However, Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders have provided no assurances or guarantees that any satellite dish or other antenna installed within the Community will remain unobstructed or that satellite service will be provided to an Owner after installation of an Authorized Antennae. You should understand that broadcast signals may be obstructed by the installation of additional improvements within and outside of the Community including, without limitation, homes, walls, fences, trees and other landscaping and such obstructions may not allow for acceptable satellite reception. You should also understand that Neighborhood Associations may impose additional restrictions. 19. Amendments to the Community Declaration. Notwithstanding the fact that you have received a copy of the Community Declaration and the Supplemental Declaration for your Phase of Development, these documents may be amended in accordance with their amendment provisions. 20. Additional Provisions. There may be provisions of various laws, including the Davis -Stirling Common Interest Development Act codified at Sections 1350 et seq. of the California Civil Code and the Federal Fair Housing Act codified at Title 42 United States Code, Buyer Initials: / -y_ 2544-33253\C1.11428UNSCI-SM 609965.7 9/25/08 Section 3601 et seq., which may supplement or override the Community Association Governing Documents. The Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders and Comrnunity Association make no representations or warranties regarding the future enforceability of any portion of the Community Association Governing Documents. COLUMBUS SQUARE DISCLOSURES 2I. Charitable Endowment Fee. A recorded Charitable Housing Agreement Imposing Endowment Fee On Transfer ("Agreement") affects your Home and the other Homes in the Community. The Agreement requires that an "Endowt Fee" equal to one -twentieth of one percent (0.05%) of the total sales price (0.0005 x total sales price) be paid each time a Home in the Community is transferred to a new owner. The Endowment Fee will be paid to Lennar Charitable Housing Foundation, a California nonprofit public benefit corporation ("Foundation"), to be used for the purposes described in the Agreement. When you close escrow for the purchase of your Home, you will pay the Endowment Fee to the Foundation. Thereafter, each time your Home is resold, the Endowment Fee must be paid at the close of escrow, but it may be paid either by the new buyer or the then current seller. The Agreement will be in effect for an indefinite period of time. 22. Affordable Housingffransitional Housing. The City of Tustin has required the Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders to provide two hundred sixty-six (266) units of affordable housing ("Affordable Housing Units") within the Community. Sixty-three (63) Affordable Housing Units will be located in the Camden Place Neighborhood, fifty (50) Affordable Housing Units will be located in the Cambridge Lane Neighborhood, and one hundred fifty-three (153) Affordable Housing Units will be located in an area of the Community that will be designated as housing for seniors (Coventry Court). Certain of these Affordable Housing Units will be offered to persons who qualify as very low, low and moderate income buyers pursuant to guidelines established by the United States Department of Housing and Urban Development for the City. Buyers who qualify as very low, low and moderate income will purchase their Homes subject to resale restrictions, as reflected in a recorded covenant agreement, for a period of forty-five (45) years. If you are interested in the Affordable Housing Units you should consult your sales representative for further information. GVlavtc(e d (�vl�ua,�t� 23. "Active Adult" Neighborhood. An "Active Adult" neighborhood, is proposed �1 for the Community on Lot 265 of Tract 16581 which is located on Charleston and Cambridge Streets adjacent to Georgis Street and Keningston Park Drive,and planned to consists of approximately 240 age restricted residences.. As an Active Adult neighborhood, each Home will be required to be occupied by at least one resident who is at least 55 years of age. If the Active Adult has its own recreational facilities and activities then all assessments for the maintenance of these recreation facilities are the exclusive responsibility of the Active Adult residents. As a result, the recreational facilities located within the Active Adult neighborhood are not open to other Owners in the Community. However, Active Adult residents will have the right to use the public recreational facilities located throughout the Community and, if annexed into the Community Association and paying assessments, will have the right to use the Community Association recreational facilities, Master Developer reserves the right to construct other age restricted communities in other locations in the Community MasterDeveloper may also, plan �M_ 1111wr hidal :-- .. j ()_ 2554-.W531CLP428U)1SCLSRl609965.7 9/250% and construct other types and number of Homes, including rental, within Lot 265 with approval by the City of Tustin. 24. home Business Use. Any Home within the Community may be used for home based business purposes, provided that such use is subject to the City of Tustin's Home Occupation Ordinance (if applicable), the provisions in Section 2.1 of the Community Declaration and the Community Guidelines. You are advised that the Community Declaration and the Community Guidelines may contain stricter restrictions than those in the City Ordinance and that such use may require zoning clearance and a business license. You should contact the City for more information regarding business uses in your Home. 25. MCAS Tustin. (a) Prior Use as MCAS Tustin. You are advised that the Community was previously used as the Tustin Marine Corps Air Station ("MCAS Tustin"). The Marine Corps and the Department of the Navy ('"DON") are the responsible agencies for the Installation Restoration Program ("IRP). The IRP is a comprehensive environmental investigation and cleanup program formed to identify, investigate and clean up chemical and nuclear contamination that has resulted from past land use operations. When MCAS Tustin was an active base, it received a permit from the California Department of Toxic Substances Control ("DTSC") pursuant to the Federal Resources Conservation and Recovery Act ("RCRA") (42 U.S.C. 6901 et seq.) to store hazardous waste on portions of the base. One of the conditions of that permit was to perform "corrective action" to clean-up releases of hazardous waste constituents throughout the base. Although the permit has expired, these corrective action obligations continue, and the DON is undertaking environmental investigation and cleanup activities on portions of the former base that are within the Community. (b) Asbestos Containing Material. Hazardous material in the form of asbestos or asbestos -containing materials ("ACM') have been found and are otherwise presumed to exist in buildings and structures previously located in the Community. At such time as demolition of the prior existing buildings on the Community containing ACM was completed, the appropriate governmental regulatory agency confirmed that ACM had been removed from the buildings and any necessary soil remediation had been conducted in accordance with all applicable federal, state and local laws and regulations. (c) Easement for Environmental Remediation. An easement over the Community granted to the United States of America, acting by and through the Department of the Navy ("DON") in a document entitled "Quitclaim Deed for Marble Mountain Parcel and Environmental Restriction Pursuant to Civil Code Section 1471," was recorded on March 11, 2003, as Document No. 200300263521. In connection with ongoing remediation on the DON's property within the Community, it was agreed, as a covenant running with the land, that the DON and its officers, agents, employees, contractors and subcontractors shall have the right, upon reasonable notice, to enter the Community when a response or corrective action is found to be necessary or when such Buyer Initials: / j ; ,. 2544-33253\CLP42S1t11SCLSR16099657 9125!08 access is necessary to carry out a response action or corrective action. The right for the DON to enter the Community shall include the right to conduct tests, investigations and surveys, including, where necessary, drilling, test -pitting, being and other similar activities. Such right shall also include the right to construct, operate, maintain or undertake any other response or corrective action as required or necessary, including, but not limited to, monitoring wells, pumping wells, treatment facilities, and the installing of associated utilities. ht exercising these rights of access, except in the case of imminent and substantial endangerment to human health or the environment, the DON shall give reasonable notice of any action to be taken related to such remedial or corrective actions on the Cotnmunity. Ftirtherr, the DON will make reasonable efforts to minimize interference with the on going use of the Community and act in good faith to minimize any conflict between the necessary environmental investigation and remediation activities and the use of the Community. The DON is not required to restore or repair any Improvements in the Community damaged as a result of this right to access the Community. If any Improvements on Association Property are damaged as a result of the DON's access to the Community, you are advised that any such damaged Improvement may be repaired or replaced by the Community Association and you may be charged a Reconstruction Assessment or Extraordinary Assessment (if applicable). (d) Groundwater Plume. The City Environmental Impact Report (1999) ("EIR") indicates the presence of subsurface plumes of chlorinated volatile organic compounds ("VOCs"), dissolved trichloroethene ("TCE") and methyl tertiary -butyl ether ("MTBE") at ground water level in portions of MCAS Tustin located outside the Community. It is presently unknown whether and to what extent these contaminants will migrate towards the Community. According to the EIR, estimated human health risks associated with residential use of groundwater from the plumes are above the acceptable limits of the United States Environmental Protection Agency. Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders make no representations or warranties with respect to the plumes described above or whether such plumes will migrate into the groundwater under Community. 26. Lifoc Property/Environmental Conditions. Due to its prior use as a military base, certain areas within the Community are located within areas designated on the map for Tract No. 16581 as "IRP -1.3S" and "IRP -13W' (collectively, the "LIFOC Property'l. The LIFOC Property is owned by the United States of America acting by and through the DON and will ultimately be annexed into the Covered Property pursuant to Section 16.6 of the Community Declaration. omm(m6 (a) Prior Uses of lite LIFOC Proper(t+. me-A-101l-rz-71 (i) IRP -135. That portion of the LIFOC Property identified as IRP - 13S is approximately 0.7 acres and was previously used as a "Temporary Storage Area' ("TSA") and as a "Miscellaneous Wash Area' ("MWAI). The TSA consisted of two (2) buildings that were used for vehicle maintenance. Cleaning solvents were reportedly used as a degreaser to wash down floors in the buildings and waste solvent was likely released to storm drains, or to the ground outside the building. The MWA includes an inactive wash pad formerly used for cleaning small generators and other field equipment. Solvents were used in this area and may have been released to the subsurface through cracks in the concrete pad. That portion of the LIFOC Property identified as IRP 13W was previously used as a former disposal area where Bu erlmiials: ; .j�_ 544-33253\CLP423\DISCLSR\609%5.7 9n5rnx hydraulic fluid, diesel fuel, leaded gasolene, oil, paint stripper, batter acid and solvent were stored. (in) IRP -13W. That patios: of the LWOC Property identified as IRP - 13W was previously used as a former disposal arta where hydraulic fluid, diesel fuel, leaded gasoline, oil, paint stripper, battery acid and solvents were stored. This area was paved and cleared of stored materials. �Vpt,f� (b) Release nif Volaffle Organic Compounds. As a result of the historic use d�*� of the LIFOC Property, hazardous substances have been released into the soil an grotm water at the LIFOC Property. Volatile Organic Compounds ("VOCs"), including trichloroethene a l ("TCE"), 1,2,3-trichloropropane ('%2,3 -TCP"), and related chlorinated organic solvents, were- 1` found in soil and groundwater at concentrations that could result in adverse effect to human - health (including without limitation, cancer risks) if this water was extracted from the ground and directly used for domestic purposes such as drinking or bathing. However, groundwater at this location is currently not used for such purposes. (c) Remedial Action Plan. As a result of the release of hazardous substances at the LIFOC Property, various remedial activities have occurred or shall occur at the LiFOC Property and will continue to occur until remediation goals have been achieved. Furthermore, institutional controls will be put in place at the time of transfer of the LIFOC Property and will include restrictions consistent with the protection of human health and the envie as ..., discussed in Paragraph (d) below. t �/ (i) IRP -135. in October 2004, the DON issued a report entitled "Final Record of Decision/Remedial Action Plan, Operable Unit IA, Former Marine Corps Air Station, Tustin, California" ("ROD"), which describes a specific remedial action plan ("RAP") that has been approved for IRP -13S to address groundwater contamination. As documented in the ROD, "groundwater is the only medium that presents a risk to human health at the site. Soil, however, is also being addressed as part of the groundwater remedy because of the potential for residual contaminants in soil to act as a continuing source of groundwater contamination." Pursuant to the ROD, the selected remedy for groundwater at IRP -13S includes hydraulic containment of VOC-contaminated groundwater combined with excavation and off-site disposal of the most highly contaminated source areas ("hot spots"). Treated soil would be used for excavation backfill and treated water from the treatment system would be discharged to a city of Tustin storm drain, ultimately discharging into Peters Canyon Channel. Actual or threatened releases of hazardous substances from groundwater at IRP -13S, if not addressed by implementing the remedial action selected in the ROD/RAP, may present a potential threat to public health and welfare or to the environment. Master Developers and Neighborhood Builders make no representations, guarantees or warranties with respect to whether the remedial action selected in the ROD/RAP has been or will be implemented for IRP -13S. (ii) IRP -13W. In August 2005, the DON published a report entitled "Drab Feasibility Study Report for Operable Unit 4B [includes IRP -13W], Former Marine Corps Air Station, Tustin, California," ("Feasibilio Study') which addresses a range of remedial alternatives to address the VOCs in groundwater. As documented in the Feasibility Study, "no further action was recommended for soil at OU -4B sites... therefore, soil remediation..." was not buyer Initials. �._ -- - -1.,_ 2544-332531CLNd2$U)ISCLSR\o(*%5.7 O 9125t(Ik addressed in the Feasibility Study. As of the date of this disclosure, the Feasibility Study is currently being revised, and the DON is currently evaluating, remedial alternatives for OU -4B sites in the Feasibility Study, to he followed by a proposed plan and a final Record of Decision, No final remedy has been selected for IRP -13W. Master Developers and Neighborhood Builders make no representations, guarantees or warranties with respect to whether or when a final groundwater remedial action plan has been or will be selected or implemented for tRP-13 W. (d) Early Transfer of LIFOC Properly and Land Use Restridious. Generally, environmental remedial actions must be completed prior to property transfer. However, Section 120(h)(3)(C) of the Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation, and Liability Act ("CERCLA") allows deferral of the requirement that the United States provide a covenant in the deed conveying property. warranting that all remedial action necessary to protect human health anti the environment has been taken before the date of transfer. Specifically, CERCLA Section 120(h)(3)(C)(i)(11) requires that the deed or other agreement governing the transfer contain assurances, among other things, that provide for any necessary restrictions on the use of the property to ensure the protection of human health and the environment, as follows: (i) Any necessary restriction on the use of the property will be implemented to ensure protection of human heahh and the environment; (ii) Restrictions will be implemented on use, as necessary, to ensure that required remedial investigations (RI), response actions, and oversight activities will not be disrupted; r (iii) All necessary response actions will be taken and will identify schedules for investigation and completion of all necessary response actions, as approved by the appropriate regulatory agency; and (iv) The DON will submit a budget request to the Director of the Office of Management and Budget that adequately addresses schedules for investigation and completion of all necessary response actions, subject to congressional authorizations and appropriations. On February 13, 2007, the DON issued a "Draft Final Finding of Suitability for Early Transfer for a Portion of Parcel 24 (Early Transfer Parcel 24-1) Within Carve -Out 5, Fortner Marine Corps Air Station, Tustin, California" ("FOSET') to request transfer of the LIFOC Property prior to completion of all remedial actions pursuant to CERCLA Section 120(h)(3)(C). The FOSET presented the findings that the LIFOC Property, which is still in the remediation process, is environmentally suitable for transfer prior to completing all remedial action pursuant to the provisions of CERCLA and that the LIFOC Property has been designated as part of Early Transfer Parcel 24-1 ("ETP 24-1"). The DON has determined that there is a potential for exposure to CERCLA hazardous substances at ETP 241, and associated groundwater plumes. Restrictions on the land use of ETP 24-1 (including, without limitation, the LIFOC Property) to ensure protection of human health and the environment are set forth in one or more documents entitled "Covenant to Restrict Use of Property Environmental Restriction", more particularly defined in Section 26( )(ii) and Section 26(I:)(iii) below, VIII xhiilial, ? _ _ ?544-33253TU428USCLSM609965.7 9/25/0A �j R (collectively, the `Covenant") between the United States, acting through the DW and the State of California acting by and through the California Department of Toxic Substances Control ("DISC") through deed restrictions set forth in the FOSET. As of the date of this disclosure, the transfer of the LIFOC Property has occurred, however, environmental remedial actions at the LIFOC Property have not yet been completed. You should review the notifications and additional disclosures contained in the FOSET concerning lRP-13S and IRP -13W, as well as school site considerations, hazardous substances and petroleum products, underground storage tanks, lead based paint, asbestos - containing materials, radon, groundwater monitoring wells, polycholorinated biphenyl, indoor air quality, oil -water separators and other areas of concern within or near the vicinity of the LIFOC Property. Master Developers and Neighborhood Builders make no representations, guarantees or warranties with respect to if or when the FOSET will be finalized.. (e) Deed Restriciirrns. Deed restrictions will ultimately be recorded on all or a portion of the Homesites or Homes in the Community lying within the LIFOC Property, and will limit certain activities on such Homesites or Homes. These deed restrictions will identify specific land use restrictions to prevent exposure of future landowners and/or users of the LIFOC Property to hazardous substances and to maintain the integrity of the remedial action until remediation is complete and remediation goals have been achieved. (f) Inspection and Compliance Reporting Obligations, Indemnification. The Board of Directors of the Community Association shall be responsible for site inspections of the LIFOC Property and annual compliance reporting to address the monitoring and maintenance necessary to ensure compliance with the restrictions and terms of the Covenant. You shall not interfere with the Community Association's performance of such inspection and compliance reporting obligations. ,^/rl_�. (g) Documentation Relating to the Release and Remediation Activities. Extensive documentation has been prepared that describes the nature and extent of the release of hazardous substances that has occurred at the LIFOC Property. The following reports are available for public review and document the investigation and remediation work that has been or will be performed at the LiFOC Property: (i) Supplemental Declaration to Master Declaration of Covenants, Conditions, Restrictions and Reservation of Easements for Columbus Square (Early Transfer Parcel (ETP) 24-1A and 24-18), made by Moffett Meadows Partners, LLC, a Delaware limited liability company and consented to by the Community Association, which was re-recorded on ,lune 26, 2008, as Instrwncnt No. 2008000307660 (together with any amendment thereto, collectively, the "Stipplemental Declaration"), in the Official Records of Orange County, California (the "Official Records"). (ii) Covenant to Restrict Use of Property Environmental Restriction (Re: Former Marine Corps Air Station Tustin) Early Transfer Parcel (ETI') 24-1 A (Portion of Parcel 24) made by and between the United States, acting through the DON, and the State of California acting by and through the DISC, which was recorded on February 28, 2008, as Instrument No. 2008000090055, of Official Records. b jp/_ `/ nuyet Initials. j 2544-3.253\CLP428Ul1Sf: LSR\ "965.7 9115/Oh (iii) Covenant to Restrict Use of Property Environmental Restriction (Re: Former Marine Corps Air Station Twin) Early Transfer Parcel (ETP) 24-1 B (Portion of Parcel 24) made by and between the United Stems„ acting through the DON, and the State of California acting by and through the DISC, whish was recorded on February 28, 2008, as Instrument No. 2008000090056, and re-recorded on June 5, 2008 as Instrument No. 2008000270235 of Official Records; (iv) Drafi Final Finding of Suitability for Early Transfer for a Portion of Parcel 24 (Early Transfer Parcel 241) Within Carve -Out 5, Fortner Marine Corps Air Station, Tustin, California (Department of Navy, February 13,2007); (v) Draft (6(rDesign Submittal) Remedial Design, Hydraulic Containment with Hot Spot Removal, Operable Units IA and I B, Former Marine Corps Air Station, Tustin, California (Department of Navy, .lune 2005);� / -71VV (vi) Draft Feasibility Study Report For Operable /Unniitt 44B, Former Marine Corps Air Station, Tustin, California, August 2005 (Bechtel Environmental, Inc., August 2005): (vii) Final Record of Decision/Remedial Action Plan Operable Unit IA, Former Marine Corps Air Station, Tustin, California (Department of Navy, October 2004); (viii) Final Feasibility Study Report, OU -JA, Marine Corps Air Station, Tustin, California (Bechtel Environmental, Inc., August 2003); and (ix) Final Environmental Impact Statement/Environmental Impact Report, Disposal and Reuse of MCAS Tustin, California (Department of Navy and City of Tustin, December 1999). You should carefully review these reports before making a decision to buy a Nome in the Community. Copies of the reports are available for review at either (1) BRACS Environmental Coordinator's Office, Library Building 307, MCAS EI Toro, telephone (949) 726-5398 or (2) University of California at Irvine Langson Library, Government Publication De_ partment,Irvine, CA, (949) 824_ 7362 or 94 4-6836, or information regarding the r -um environmental documents prepared for former MCAS Tustin, p ease contact the Administrative �� + 0 Records Division by calling (619) 532-3673, located at Building 1, 937 Harbor Drive, San US Diego, California 92132, or the BRAC Information Repository Office located at 7040 Trabuco Road, Building 307 on the former MCAS EI Toro, (949) 726-5398. The Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders make no representations or warranties with respect to the LIFOC Property and the environmental conditions described above or in the reports. rbvw( m' 2 vt tte,.� Due to the fact that groundwater in the Comnmunity has been found at depths of six (6) t seventeen (17) feet below the ground surface, you are rohibited rom drinking any groundwater pursuant to covenants recorded against the Community and is advised to avoid tesla r✓ tK eating any fruit from trees with deep root systems in the Community. You are also advised to �kGen� keep children and animals away from such fruit, soil and groundwater. Should any Person come fn-vt into contact with such fruit, soil or groundwater, such Person is advised to wash thoroughly with ►1tav'cM'loc'� soap and water and seek immediate medical attention. Buyer Initials: _ ! _.)�,_ 2544.332531CLI'428\L)ISCLSR\6(19965.7 9f25M G (h) Surrounding Areas. The following items have been indicated in the EIR as affecting portions of MCAS Tustin that are outside of the Community. These items are not expected to impact the Community, and are listed in this Disclosure for your information only. Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders .make no representations or warranties as to any future impact these items may have on the Community or Residents using public parks and other areas outside the Community. (i) Former crash drill site area; (ii) Former skeet ranges. (iii) Transformers containing polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs); (iv) Buildings formerly on property containing lead based paint; (v) Moffit Meadow fire fighting trenches and crash crew bum pits; (vi) JP -5 pipeline, currently classified as out of service; and (vii) Petroleum hydrocarbons in subsurface soil. If you have any questions or concerns about environmental activities at MCAS Tustin or the Community, please contact the Local Redevelopment Authority at the City of Tustin or visit the United States Naval Facilities Engineering Command's internet website at www.eidsw.nivlac.iiavy.i-niVEiivii-oiimentai/'rustin-liti-D- 27. Prior Agricultural Use. The Community is located on or near lands that are or were previously used for agricultural purposes, including farming operations. By reason of such agricultural use, you may be subject to dust, noise and odors and may be exposed to pesticides, herbicides, insecticides and other chemicals. By acceptance of a deed to a Home, you (on your own behalf, and on behalf of the members of your family, tenants, lessees, guests and invitees) expressly acknowledge and accept these existing and future impacts and forever waive any and all causes of actions against the Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders and Community Association and their respective directors, officers, employees, agents, representatives and consultants for any damages or injuries which may arise from or relate to any such conditions or risks. NEW ytttvvt.e -' �,rmeA� r-4- - Pc�G�ut 28. The Village Conservatory. The Community includes a private recreational center (the "Conservatory'). The Conservatory includes swimming and wading pools, spa, recreational building and related facilities. While the Conservatory is planned to be private and 1% only open to Owners and guests in the Community, the public will have access to the Open Space/Park area (the "Village Green") surrounding the Conservatory and use of the outdoor recreational facilities with include an open turf area, tot lot, BBQ, and picnic area. The Village Green is maintained by the Comminity Association. All persons using the Conservatory are required to use caution and to watch their children at all times to prevent drowning and other injuries. The Community Association may, from time to time, promulgate rules for use and operation of the Conservatory, including reasonable hours of operation. Owners and other residents living in the area of the Conservatory and Village Green will most likely experience nuyei initials: g'j. 2544-33253tCLP423UiISCLSR\ 609%5.7 9r.5Ht3 and otherwise be subject to or inconvenienced by noise and pedestrian and vehicular traffic in the areas surrounding the Conservaotry and Village Green, 29. Natural Hazard Zone Disclosures. Your Neighborhood Builder will provide you with a Natural Hazard Disclosure Statement in compliance with Section 1103 of the California Civil Code that discloses whether your Home is located in a seismic hazard zone. (a) Earthquakes. California is subject to a wide range of earthquake activity. California has many known earthquake faults as well as yet undiscovered faults. While the Community is not located in an Alquist Priolo Earthquake Zone, earthquakes are always a possibility. You must evaluate the potential for future seismic activity that may seriously damage your Homesite and Home. A major earthquake, which some have predicted will occur in our lifetimes, could cause very serious damage to Homes located even many miles from the epicenter of the earthquake. A more moderate earthquake occurring on a more minor fault, or on an as yet undiscovered fault, could also cause substantial damage. For more information, read "Tire Homeowners Guide to Earthquake Safety'' which explains the various geological hazards associated with earthquakes and contains information on planning ahead for earthquakes, as well as what to do during and after an earthquake. Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders make no representations or warranties as to the degree of earthquake risk in the Community. You are advised to consult with the City, County, other public agencies and appropriate experts to evaluate the potential risk. (b) Seismic Hazard Zones. Many portions of California are subject to risks associated with seismic activity. Areas that meet the definition of "Seismic Hazard Zone" in the Seismic Hazards Mapping Act (California Public Resources Code Section 2690, et seq.) are shown on maps that are prepared and released by the California Department of Conservation, Division of Mines and Geology. Such zones may pose an increased risk of damage to property from earthquakes and liquefaction. "Liquefaction" is the process by which water -saturated soils become unstable under heaving shaking and thereby jeopardize foundations and other structures. The Master Developer has been informed that all or a portion of the Community is located within a Seismic Hazard Zone. You are advised to consult with the City, County, other public agencies and appropriate experts to evaluate the potential risk: For more information concerning seismic activity and risks, read "The Homeowner's Guide to Earthquake Safety." (c) Area of Potential Flooding. The Master Developer has been informed that the Community is located within an Area of Potential Flooding (or Dam Inundation Zone) pursuant to applicable maps. The Office of Emergency Services is required to designate areas within which personal injury or death would, in its determination, result from the partial or total failure of any dam. These areas of potential flooding, as defined in the California Emergency Services Act (California Government Code Section 8984.4, et seq.), are shown on maps released by the Office of Emergency Services, copies of which are also on file with the City. These maps are updated periodically, and the Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders and Community Association make no representations, guarantees or warranties with 'respect to any future dam inundation zone determinations. The Community is downstream from the Santiago Creek Dam, an earthf►Il dam approximately one hundred and thirty-six (136) feet high which has a capacity of 25,000 acre feet of water. Santiago Creek Dam is jointly owned and maintained by the Serrano Irrigation District and the Irvine Ranch Water District. Information about the Santiago Buyer Initials: / ,. ] �2544-33253\CLP428H71SCL8R\ 609965.7 9/2.5!08 Creek Dam can be found on the California Department of Water 'Resources website: http://cdee.water.ca.gov/mise/resinfo.html. Please contact the Office of Emergency Services for further information concerning Areas of Potential Flooding. 30. Soil Conditions. In purchasing your Home, you should review soils reports for the Community, available for review at the City, and take into consideration the following: (a) Expansive Soil. According to the soils report, soil in the Community is highly expansive in nature. Expansive soil expands when it becomes wet and it contracts when it dries out. Expansion and contraction of soils may cause movement, lifting, cracking and distress in slabs, patios, sidewalks and other flatwork improvements. Some cracking is normal in all flatwork improvements, with or without expansive soils. However, some expansion damage may be reduced by use of appropriate design and construction techniques. When designing flatwork and other improvements, you should advise your consultants that designs must accommodate soils with expansion potential. In addition, you should consider the following information and recommendations before making or modifying any improvements. (b) Concrete and Masonry Improvements. Special attention is required in designing and constructing concrete and masonry Improvements such as masonry walls and planters, concrete slabs and decking. For example, steel reinforcing bars may be required in lieu of steel mesh in concrete patio slabs. Block walls may require extra horizontal and vertical steel reinforcing bars. (c) Drainage and Irrigation. Owners must use adequate drainage and irrigation control. Drainage devices installed in the Community by the Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders should not be altered in any manner that will redirect or obstruct drainage through these devices. The construction or modification of Improvements should not result in ponding of water. Drainage devices, including, but not limited to, concrete ditches, area drain lines and gutters should be carefully designed and installed with professional assistance and then maintained in an unobstructed condition. Drainage devices installed by the Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders designed to serve more than the one (1) Home should not be altered in a manner that will redirect or obstruct the drainage through these drainage devices. The landscape irrigation system should be designed, constructed and operated to prevent excessive saturation of soils. Water must drain away from the Home footings and other Improvements. Obstructions such as walls should not be constructed across swales unless adequate replacement drainage Improvements have been installed or created. Planters should be lined with an impervious surface and should contain outlets to drain excess water. (d) Fill Soil. Homes in the Community may be constructed on fill soil in accordance with the recommendations and inspection of licensed civil and soils engineers. A soils report certifying the compaction of fill soils is available for review at the City. (e) Corrosive Soil. Soils in some areas of the Community are potentially severely corrosive to buried concrete and ferrous metals. Soluble sulfates and acidic soils are highly corrosive to buried metals and concrete and should be taken into account in the construction of below grade structures and hardscape. Sulfates may chemically and physically attack concrete that is not sulfate resistant, causing the concrete to break down. Thus, you must Buyer initials: ! -19- 2544-33253TU428WISCLSM 609965.7 9125/08 use the proper type of cement and water -to -cement ratio for the level of sulfates or acidity that exists on your Homesite. Overwatering soil will exacerbate the corrosivity of the soil. You should inform contractors of this potential condition to allow them to use appropriate measures to combat the effects of corrosive soil on buried metals, below grade structures and hardscape. (f) Groundwater. Groundwater has been encountered in portions of the Community at depths of six (6) to twenty-five (25) feet below the ground surface. You may not dig or drill on any Homesite to a depth that would disturb or otherwise come in contact with the groundwater. Groundwater may rise during the rainy season. (g) Pools/Spas. Prior to designing any pool, spa, or other similar amenity, it is recommended you consult with a licensed civil engineer to determine the depth of the water table under your Homesite to insure that your Improvements are compatible with the depth of the water table and that they will not disturb or come in contact with the groundwater during a rainy season. The Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders make no guarantee that any Homesite has the ability for pool or spa installation. Homesites 242 through 245, inclusive, of Tract No. 16581, which are located within the LIFOC Property, have been determined to be unsuitable for installation of pools, spas or other similar amenity. The deeds for these Lots will contain deed restrictions that prohibit the use of the Lots for such purposes. (h) Soils Professionals. Before starting a pool or spa or any patio, concrete or other,flatwork on the Homesite, you should consult with a licensed soils engineer to ensure that such work is constructed correctly in light of current soils conditions. Although consulting with a soils professional may add substantially to the cost of installation of improvements, failure to do so may result in significant breaking, lifting, separating, tilting or cracking in improvements. (i) Interior Gases and. Other Contaminants. The aging process of soil and natural soil elements, as well as the aging of man-made building materials, may create unwanted and undesired gases and other contaminants in Homes, both new and previously occupied. In addition, a lower rate of air exchange between outdoor and indoor environments has resulted from modern construction techniques which comply with energy conservation requirements enacted by the State of California. A lower air exchange rate can result in the build-up of unwanted gases and other contaminants in varying degrees. As the quality of the air we breathe can affect our health, you should frequently air out your Home by opening the windows. 31. Post -Tension Concrete System. Your Home may have been built using a post - tension concrete system ("System'). If any portion of your Home has been constructed using the System, a placard or stamp will be placed in the garage signifying the existence of such System. The System involves placing steel cables under high tension in the concrete slab located beneath the Home. Therefore, any attempt to alter or pierce the foundation (for example, sawing, cutting or drilling) could damage the integrity of the System and cause serious injury or damage to persons and property. The Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders shall not be responsible for any damage or injury resulting from or arising in connection with the alteration of the slab or foundation of any Home. By acceptance of a deed to a Home, you agree that: (i) you shall not cut into or otherwise tamper with the System; (ii) you shall not knowingly permit or allow any other person to cut into or tamper with the System so long as you own any interest in the Home; (iii) you shall disclose the existence of the System to any person who rents, Buyer Initials: / -20- 2544-332531CLP428\DlSCLSR1609965.7 9/25/08 leases or purchases your Home; and (iv) you shall indemnify and hold the Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders and all of their affiliated entities, officers, directors, agents and assigns free and harmless from any and all claims, damages, losses or other liability (including attorneys' fees and costs) arising from any breach of this covenant. 32. Reclaimed Water. In its efforts to conserve water, the Irvine Ranch Water District (the "Water District") requires the use of reclaimed water (treated wastewater) to irrigate parks, school yards, golf courses, greenbelt areas and common areas. The Water District may require the use of reclaimed water to irrigate landscaping in private yards. The water used in the Homes and outside in the patio and yard areas through hose bibs will be domestic potable water. The water used to irrigate the Association Property may include reclaimed water. Reclaimed water is not potable and therefore not suitable for human consumption. As with any water overspray, the repeated spray of reclaimed water may stain or discolor personal property, fencing and structural Improvements. According to the Water District, the Water District's reclaimed water.is disinfected with chlorine and its clarity to the human eye is indistinguishable from domestic water. The standards imposed on the Water District for reclaimed water quality are established by governmental regulatory agencies, and these standards are subject to change. The Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders and Community Association and their agents are not liable for any property damage or personal injury by reclaimed water. You are subject to Water District rules and regulations, one of which prohibits the use of self -generating water softeners connected to Water District sewer facilities. Further information regarding Water District regulations is available at the Water District's headquarters. 33. Electric Power Lines. Underground or overhead electric transmission and distribution lines and transformers are located in and around the Community. Two (2) 220 Kv and one (1) 66 Kv overhead transmission and distribution lines, which are located along Harvard and Warner Avenues and around other perimeter boundaries of the Community, and other lines and transformers are owned and maintained by Southern California Edison Company. Southern California Edison may increase the number of transmission and distribution lines and the electric current through such lines. Power lines and transformers produce extremely low -frequency electromagnetic fields ("ELF -EMF") when operating. For some time, there has been speculation in the scientific community about health risks associated with living near ELF -EMF sources. In 1992, the United States Congress authorized the Electric and Magnetic Fields Research and Public Information Dissemination Program to perform research on these issues and to analyze the existing scientific evidence in order to clarify the potential for health risks from exposure to ELF -EMF. In May of 1999, the National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences ("NIEHS") issued a report to Congress summarizing its review of scientific data from over three hundred (300) studies on ELF -EMF health risks. The ELF -EMF studies consist of both epidemiological studies (studies of exposure in human populations) and controlled laboratory experiments on animal and cell models. While some epidemiological studies suggested some link between certain health effects and exposure to ELF -EMF, the lahoratory experiments did not support such a link. According to the NIEHS report, the scientific evidence shows no clear pattern of health hazards from ELF -EMF exposure, and the NIEHS report did not find evidence of any link sufficient to recommend widespread changes in the design or use of electrical transmission equipment. However, because the evidence does not clearly rule out any effect, Buyerinitials: ! -21- 2544-332531CLP42W1SCLSR1609965.7 9/25/08 NIEHS advocated continuing inexpensive and safe reductions in exposure to ELF -EMF and endorsed current utility practices regarding design and siting of new transmission and distribution lines. Further information on this subject is available from the Regional EMF Manager, Southern California Edison Company, 1851 West Valencia Drive, Fullerton, California 92833. Additional information on ELF -EMF and copies of the NIEHS report are available from the EMF -RAPID website at www.niehs.nih.gov/emfrapid/home.htm. 34. Air Quality. Southern California is subject to Stage I smog alerts. You should take advantage of the Air Quality Management District's ("A.QM.D.") forecasts to plan your outdoor activities to avoid peak pollution by checking your television, radio or daily newspapers to find out if unhealthful air quality is expected. For more information, you can also call A.Q.M.D. at 1 -800 -CUT -SMOG (1-800-288-7664) or check their website at www.agmd.gov. By acceptance of a deed to a Home, you (for and on your behalf, and the members of your family, tenants, lessees, guests and invitees) expressly acknowledge and accept the existing and possible future impacts of smog on yourself and your family and forever waive any and all causes of actions against the Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders and their respective directors, officers, employees, agents, representatives and consultants for any damages or injuries which may arise from or relate to any such conditions or risks. 35. Wind. All of Southern California is subject to periods of high winds. Wind speeds in the Community may exceed that experienced in other areas of the surrounding region. You must ensure that any structures or other Improvements you install on your Homesite are constructed or designed to withstand high winds. You are advised to consult with experienced architects and engineers in the design and specification of any structures or Improvements that you plan to add. 36. Private Streets. All of the streets within the Community are private streets. Maintenance and repair of the private streets is the responsibility of the Community Association or the Neighborhood Associations, as applicable. 37. Building Setbacks. Construction of Improvements in the yard of any Homesite such as pools, spas, patio covers, BBQ, fountains, trellises and water features are subject to minimum setback and height restrictions and may not be permitted. You should refer to the Community Association Governing Documents and applicable City ordinances for any restrictions concerning the construction of any Improvements to your Homesite. 38. Boundaries. You may not rely on any written or oral statements by Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders or their agents regarding the exact boundaries of your Homesite or Home or whether any wall or fence has been or will be constructed exactly on the boundaries of your Homesite. 39. Square Footage Representations. Representations of square • footage are approximate only. You may not rely on any written (brochures and other sales documents) or verbal statements by Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders or their agents regarding the exact square footage of your Homesite or Home. The computation of square footage varies based on the criteria used. You agree by acceptance of a deed to a Home to hold the Master Buyer Initials: J -22- 2544-3325MCLI 4280I5CLSM 609965.7 9/25/08 Developer and Neighborhood Builders harmless in any dispute arising over any representations concerning the square footage of your Homesite or Home. TAXES AND ASSESSMENTS 40. Supplemental Real Property, Taxes. The California law requires real property to be revalued whenever it changes ownership or when improvements are newly constructed. After the Close of Escrow for your Home, the County of Orange Tax Assessor ("Assessor") will determine a new taxable value for your Home based on current market values. The property tax will increase and you will receive one or more supplemental tax bills depending upon the time of the year in which Escrow closed for the purchase of your Home. Master Developers and Neighborhood Builders have no control over the valuation, timing or the amount of the supplemental bill resulting from the reassessment. You are solely responsible for the payment of any supplemental tax bills. The following notice is given pursuant to Section 1102.6c of the California Civil Code: "California property tax law requires the Assessor to revalue real property at the time the ownership of the property changes. Because of this law, you may receive one or two supplemental tax bills, depending on when your loan closes. The supplemental tax bills are not mailed to your lender. If you have arranged for your property tax payments to be paid through an impound account, the supplemental tax bills will not be paid by your lender. It is your responsibility to pay these supplemental bills directly to the Tax Collector. If you have any question concerning this matter, please call your local Tax Collector's Office." Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders have no control over the valuation, timing or the amount of the supplemental bill resulting from the reassessment. You are solely responsible for the payment of the supplemental tax bill. You hereby acluiowledge, accept and agree that neither Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders nor any of their authorized agents, representatives, employees or sales people have made any representations or warranties respecting the amount of the supplemental assessment or the assessed value. Should you have any questions or concerns relating to the supplemental assessment, you agree, prior to the Close of Escrow, to consult with the County Assessor or your legal or other advisors to satisfy such questions or concerns. 41. Estimated Taxes. You have been provided with an estimate of your assessments. THE AMOUNT OF ASSESSMENTS ARE ESTIMATES ONLY, and are based on current information provided by the City, County or those public or private agencies responsible for the administration for the districts. These assessments may INCREASE or DECREASE, based upon changes in real property tax law; the district(s) may dissolve; formation of new districts may occur, an extension of the districts or the services to the districts and other factors NOT IN MASTER DEVELOPER'S OR NEIGHBORHOOD BUILDER'S CONTROL may transpire. The amount of special taxes may appear on your property tax bill or may be billed separately. \O Buyer Initials: / -23_ 2344-33253\CIT428\13I8CLSM609965.7 9/25108 42. Special Tax Assessment Districts. All or a portion of the Community lies within the boundaries of the following Special Tax and Assessment Districts. (a) Community Faeiiities District No. 0&1. Several Neighborhoods in the Community are located within the boundaries of City of Tustin Community Facility District No. 06-1 ("CFD No 06-i') which was formed for the construction and maintenance of public improvements, including, but not limited to, street improvements, parltway and landscaping storm drains, utilities, public parks, public libraries and fire protection facilities. If your Home is located within CFD No. 06-1, your Home will be subject to any taxes, assessments and obligations associated with CFD No. 06-1. You will be provided with a Notice of Special Tax for CFD No. 06-1. This Notice contains important information about district functions, your obligations, rights of the district, and information on how to contact the district for additional information materials. You should carefully read and understand the information contained in the Notice. Master Developers and Neighborhood Builders have no control over the amount of tax assessments levied or imposed against your Home or any increase or decrease in the amount of such assessments. Please contact the City of Tustin (City Clerk), telephone (714) 573-3025 for additional information. (b) Tustin Unified School District Community Facilities District No. 06-1. Several Neighborhoods in the Community are located within the boundaries of Tustin Unified School District Community Facility District No. 06-1 ("TUSDCFD No. 06-1") which was formed for the construction of elementary, middle and high school facilities and any improvements in connection with such facilities. If your Home is located within TUSDCFD No. 06-1, your Home will be subject to any taxes, assessments and obligations associated with TUSDCFD No. 06-I. You will be provided with a Notice of Special Tax for TUSDCFD No. 06- 1. This Notice contains important information about district functions, your obligations, rights of the district, and information on how to contact the district for additional information materials. You should carefully read and understand the information contained in the Notice. Master Developers and Neighborhood Builders have no control over the amount of tax assessments levied or imposed against your Home or any increase or decrease in the amount of such assessments. Please contact the City of Tustin (City Clerk), telephone (714) 573-3025 for additional information. e,14 c *12, Cc.) Rec. # Njak- T. ({purl• bt-OyLe+ The Neighborhood Builder will provide you with disclosures entitled `Notice of Special Tax" ("Notice") prior to entering into a contract to purchase a Home. These Notices will inform you of the special tax and assessment districts that apply to your Horne. The Notices will also contain a detailed description of the special tax calculation, important information about functions and rights of the special tax and assessment districts, your obligations, and who to contact for additional information about the special tax and assessment districts. You should thoroughly understand the information contained in the Notices prior to entering into a contract to purchase a Home. You will have five days after the Notice is delivered by mail, or three days after its delivery in person, to terminate the contract to purchase by giving written notice of that termination. All Homes will be subject to annual special taxes levied by one or more of the special tax and assessment districts listed above. Not all special tax or assessment districts listed above will apply to your Home. These special taxes will be a continuing lien on your Home and BUY-(hiitials: -24. 7.544-33253\CLP429\D1SCLSR\609965.7 9125/08 will be billed to you with the annual real property tax bill issued by the County Assessor. The lien of these special taxes will continue until the obligation is satisfied. If you fail to pay a special tax when due, the assessment districts may exercise their right to foreclose on your Home. Information concerning the estimated amount of the annual special tax on your Home for the special tax and assessment districts is available from the City and County. 43. Changes in Special Taxes. The amount of any special taxes disclosed to you are estimates. only, and are based on current information provided by the City, County or other public or private agencies responsible for the administration of special tax districts. Special taxes may increase or decrease, based upon the terms of the special tax lien, changes in real property tax law, the dissolution of special tax districts, the tormation of new special tax districts, extension of special tax district(s), changes in services by the districts and other facts not in Master Developer's or Neighborhood Builders' control. The amount of special taxes may appear on your real property tax bill or may be billed separately. ADJACENT AREA DISCLOSURES 44. Adjacent Property Disclosures. The land adjacent to the Community within the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan has a variety of land use designations. The land use designations are subject to change. Therefore, the type of future development adjacent to the Community cannot be predicted with accuracy. 45. MCAS Specific Plan. MCAS Tustin was realigned and closed on July 2, 1999, in accordance with Base Realignment and Closure Act. The Department of Defense recognized the City of Tustin as the Lead Agency or Local Redevelopment Authority ("LRA') for preparation of the required reuse planning documents in late 1991. The MCAS Tustin Specific Plan/Reuse Plan (the "Plait") includes detailed planning, policies, regulations, implementation strategies and procedures necessary to guide the reuse and development of the site into the next century. Since implementation of the Plan will be a long- term process and there are unique circumstances associated with converting military bases to civilian uses, the Plan is intended to be practical in economic terms and visionary in terms of its ability to create and respond to future market opportunities. This means that it must provide sufficient guidance to provide investors with a high confidence level that their investments will be protected. At the same time, it must offer sufficient flexibility to respond to changing market conditions. A careful balance between certainty and flexibility underlies the provisions of this Plan. The Plan is intended to serve as both a pol cy-oriented and regulatory document. The Plan has been submitted to the Department of Def rise as a policy guide outlining the intended reuse for the Community. Subsequently, the Plan as adopted by the Tustin City Council by City Council Ordinance No. 1257 on February 3, 2003 as the zoning for the Community. The Plan may also be amended one or more times by the City of Tustin. The Plan is one device for implementing goals and policies of the Tustin General Plan. The Plan also contains the development and reuse regulations that constitute the zoning for the Community. As a federal installation, MCAS Tustin was not subject to local zoning and ot3wcr lnirials' _ _ ��_ .'.544-33253\CLP32$\DISCt.5R\ 609965.7 9/2..WR planning requirements. Upon conversion to civilian use, the former MCAS Tustin property will be under the jurisdictional authority of either the City of Tustin or the City of Irvine, as applicable, and will be subject to local codes and ordinances. The City of Irvine has assigned responsibility for preparation of the Plan (and acco npanys►g joint Environmental Impact Statement/Environmental Impact Report) to Tustin for that portion of the Plan area within Irvine. However, the City of Irvine will have to adopt any General Plan and zoning changes necessary to implement the provisions of the Plan within the City of Irvine. The land uses described in the Plan for the area covered by the Plan include, but are not limited to, Low -High Density Residential, Transitional and Affordable Housing, Golf Resort Living, Commercial Business and Retail, and Institutional/Recreational designations such as Parks, Trails and Schools. Also recommended were applications by the Orange County Sheriffs Department, City of Tustin and County of Orange Social Service Agency. The Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders have no control over the Plan, changes to the Plan, or development of the area covered by the Plan in accordance with the Plan. For further information, you should review the Plan. The Plan and information regarding the development of the Plan is available for review at the office of the Local Redevelopment Agency, City of Tustin. Jd,64 ed q popox d u 46. The District. The District is a one million square foot outdoor shopping center under development and is located approximately one and one-half (1 %s) miles southwest of the Community, at the corner of Jamboree. Road and Barranea Parkway. The District includes, among other businesses, several retail stores, a grocery store and a movie theater. The District will result in increased noise and traffic in and around the Community, particularly along Jamboree Road and Barranca Parkway. Neither Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders nor the Community Association have any control over the use or maintenance of the District or its impact on the Community. 47. Rail Corridor/ Metrolink Station. As disclosed in the Homebuyer Notification, there is a rail corridor ("Corridor') located to the north of the Community. There is also a Metrolink station ("Station") located to the north of the Community at 2975 Edinger Avenue, Tustin, CA 92780. The impact of the Corridor and Station may include, without limitation. increased noise, light and vibration levels in the vicinity of the Community. The Corridor and Station could be an attractive nuisance to children and animals who may wish to play in the vicinity of the rail corridor. The Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders and the Community Association have no control over the use, maintenance or care of the Corridor or Station. You acknowledge and understand that you are responsible for keeping your children and animals away from the Corridor and Station and the danger that is inherent around the Corridor and Station. You should evaluate the impact of the Corridor and Station on your decision to purchase a Home in the Community. 48. Temporary Sewer Lift Station. A temporary sewer lift station has been constructed within the vicinity of the Community. It is located at the northeast corner of Kensington Drive and Valencia North Loop Road and will serve a portion of the Community until such time the master infrastructure is completed to connect your Homesite or Home to the main sewer lines. The lift station has been installed below -grade and will be owned and NKaoltrrrih /_ >��� 2544-33253\CLP428\DISCLSR\6099657 91:5/OK delAI�.y.��4 /�1nrtjj••�,`�(/j�,�, TV 6,z A u c" �= V✓� o V'VM1 i '-"V. C'4-4J�� Y. maintained by the Irvine Ranch Water District. Owners my encounter some odors in the areas near the lift station. You acknowledge, understand and agree that neither the Community Association nor the Neighborhood Builders will have any control over the use, maintenance or care of the lift station. 49. Areas Outside the Specific Plm: The MCAS Tustin Specific Plan, which is bounded by Edinger Avenue, Redhill Avenue, Barranca Parkway and Harvard Avenue has the following surrounding uses. (a) A rail corridor and Metrolink station (described above) are located along Edinger Avenue; (b) Offices, commercial and light industrial areas, are located along Edinger Avenue and adjacent to the Community at Redhill and Edinger Avenues; C'ha.v-nL4( (c) A Southern California Edison easement area with high voltage transmission lines, is located along Edinger Avenue.. GhQ r.QJecC The Master Developer, Neighborhood Builder and the Community Association have no control over development outside of the Community. 50. Airport Proximity Disclosure. The Community is located within what is known as an airport influence area (as defined in California Civil Code Section 1353) surrounding John Wayne Airport. John Wayne Airport is located approximately 3.6 miles southwest of the Community at the (405) San Diego Freeway and MacArthur Boulevard in the City of Santa Ana. For that reason, the Community may be subject to sane of the annoyances or inconveniences associated with proximity to airport operations (tor example: noise, vibration or odors). Individual sensitivities to those annoyances can vary from person to person. You may wish to consider what airport annoyances, if any, are associated with the Community before you complete your purchase and determine whether they are acceptable to you. John Wayne Airport has noise abatement procedures in place, but there is no guarantee that these procedures will lessen the impacts on the Community of noise and vibrations caused by aircraft using this airport or that these noise abatement procedures will continue in the future. Further information is available from the airport website: www.ocair.com. Your Neighborhood Builder will provide ,you with a separate airport proximity notice required by California Civil Code Section 1353. 51. Avigation Easement. An avigation easement has been recorded against the Community. The avigation easement establishes a permanent right to travel through the air space over the Community for the benefit of John Wayne Airport. You may notice noise and vibration from overflying aircraft approaching or leaving the airstrip. By accepting a deed to a Home in the Community, you understand that the avigation easement gives the users of the airstrip a perpetual legal right to fly over the Community without interference from the occupants of the Community. 52. Residential Developments. (here are existing single-family residential developments to the north of the Community across Edinger Ave. In addition to increased automobile and pedestrian traffic resulting from the proximity of these residential developments OBuyeriniIWI& ! 17_ 2 544-332531CLP42S\DISCLSM6099653 0!115/05 to the Community, the solitude of a Home`s yard area may be significantly impacted by the proximity, height and design of multi -story, residential buildings constructed on property adjacent to the Community. The Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders have no control over the proximity, height and design of such nearby buildings aid make no representation on the future impacts that these residential developments will have on residents of the Community. 53, Commercial/Industrial Property. The Community is located within the vicinity of property zoned for commercial and heavy industrial uses located in the area of Barranca and Jamboree Streets. This area consists of, among others, a Waste Management Public Recycling/Transferring Station, asphalt recycling, trucking facilities and multiple concrete �d companies, all with product deliveries. These commercial and industrial properties may generate Com. dust, offensive odor, noise and other effects. The Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders have no control over the existing or potential uses of this property. These uses may create light, noise and other nuisances twenty-four (24) hours a day, seven ('7) days a week. 54. Proposed Schools. The Tustin Unified School District owns an elementary school site located to the west of the Community on Landsdowne Road and a high school site is proposed adjacent to the Regional Park at the intersection of Kensington Park Drive and Valencia Avenue. Owners and other residents within the Community may experience, among other things, glare from bright lights, noise and increased traffic and parking congestion in connection with the use of this site. There are no assurances if or when any school will be completed on the site, nor the type of facilities that may be included as part of the school. You should contact the Tustin Unified School District at (714) 730-7301 for more information. Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders and the Community Association make no representations as to the future use of this school site. 55. Development Area. The Community lies in a rapidly expanding area. As future commercial and residential developments are built in and around MCAS Tustin, you may expect attendant limitations on solitude and inconveniences. For example, you can expect to hear noise from the development of fiiture adjacent residential and commercial areas and the machinery used to develop these areas. You can also expect increased traffic and rerouting of traffic as new residential and commercial developments are constructed, nearby streets and major thoroughfares are widened and new streets are built. As the area around the Community develops, you may experience light entering your Home from exterior sources including streetlights, parking lot lighting and nearby residential and commercial buildings. The Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders and the Community Association have no control over the transmission of noise, light, vibration, odor and other impacts or their potential effects on Homes in the Community, including any which may be a direct result of current and future construction activity. 56. MCAS 'Tustin Airship Hangars. Two (2) airship hangars ("Hangars") are located within MCAS Tustin southwest of the Community. The hangars are each approximately one thousand (1,000) feet long, three hundred (300) feet wide, and one hundred and seventy (170) feet tall. The view from vour Home may be effected by the nearby presence of the Hangars. It has not been determined whether these Hangars will remain or be demolished, or what uses might be made of them. For further information regarding the Hangars, please contact the City of Tustin. B11yerinitiZIN, _ �;;_ 2544.33253\CLP429\D1SC1JSR\tit79965.7 9125109 57. Future. Fire Station Site. The Community is located adjacent to a future fire station site at the corner of Edinger Avenue and Keningston Park Drive. The fire station will operate twenty four (24) hours a day and seven (7) days a week. Owners whose Homes are located in the vicinity of the fire station will notice noise, sirens, light, glare and other impacts from the operation of the fire station and emergency vehicles. You are advise that Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders have no control ,over the operation or use of the fare station. You should carefully evaluate the impact of the fire station on your decision to purchase a Homesite or Home in the Community. 58. Village Services. The Community is located northwest of an area designated in the Plan as the Village Services area. When and if built, this area is intended to be accessible to both vehicle and pedestrian traffic, and to provide localized commercial retail and service uses to adjacent residential areas within the Plan area. 59. Learning Village/Transitiouai and Emergency Housing. The Community is located east of an area designated in the Plan as the Learning Village area. When and if built, this area is intended to provide a specialized educational environment with a variety of public - serving uses. GENERAL DISCLOSURES 60. Neighborhood Model Homes. Neighborhood model homes reflect typical exterior elevations, floor plans and methods of construction, and also illustrate possibilities for future interior decoration and exterior landscaping and hardscape improvements. Your Home will not necessarily conform to any model shown. The exterior elevations, architectural treatments, floor plans and colors shown on the master plot plans on display at the office of each Neighborhood Builder may be different than those both displayed in the models and those actually constructed by the Neighborhood Builder. Additionally, window locations, window types, roof lines, architectural projections and other similar features vary by elevation and Home location, and not all of the features displayed in the models may be included in your Home. The models have also been professionally decorated to show various decor ideas. Decoration items such as furnishings, draperies and other window treatments, any window tinting, wallpaper, custom carpet, coordinated paint, built-in shelves, beams, certain lighting fixtures (including halogen lighting), special ceiling treatments and some mirrors are for display purposes only, and are not included in the purchase price for your Home. Entries, walkways and driveways are shown in a variety of materials to show design ideas; however, for your Home, they will be constructed using only standard concrete. The hardscape shown in the model complex may not depict what may be constructed in all locations. Additionally, landscaping for the models is greater in density and type than any landscape package offered by a Neighborhood Builder. If not expressly included in the purchase price for your Home in writing by a Neighborhood Builder, the rear, side and front yard landscaping is your responsibility. The type of plants, and the size and density of the landscaping in the yards of the models are merely intended to suggest ideas to you. Certain models may also include hardscape items (patio'slabs, patio covers, pools, spas, etc.) which are not included in the purchase price of your Home. All such options and upgrades displayed in the models (including decorator items, landscaping and hardscape) are not included in the purchase price for your Home unless expressly agreed to in writing by the Buyer Initials: / _29- 2544-33253TLP428M)ISCLSRk 604465.9 4/25/09 Neighborhood Builder. You should consult your sales representative for additional information regarding non-standard items used in the model homes. 61. Extended Use of the Model Complex. Each Neighborhood Builder reserves the right to use one or more Homes in a Neighborhood as a sales office and model home complex, and to display signs and banners, in connection with its program of marketing and selling Homes in the Neighborhood as well as other Homes owned by Neighborhood Builders, even if they are located in separate and unrelated Neighborhoods. 62. Grading Variations. Your Homesite has been graded to City specifications and may vary significantly from other Homesites. Variations may include slopes, swales, drains, flood control channels and retaining walls as required. Any changes made to the grading of the Homesite which your Home is located may significantly affect you or your neighbor's drainage pattern and cause significant property damage to your Home or a neighbor's Home. 63. Wall/Ceiling Heights. Wall and ceiling heights and configurations may vary significantly by elevation. Your Home's walls and ceiling heights may be different from those used in the model homes. You are encouraged to speak to a sales representative if you have any questions. 64. Right of Substitution. From time to time due to unavailability and other production considerations, it is necessary for a Neighborhood Builder to make substitutions of materials and other items used in construction of the Homes from those materials and items displayed in the models. Therefore, each Neighborhood Builder reserves the right to make any changes or substitutions as the Neighborhood Builder deems necessary or desirable to the color schemes, building materials, fixtures, appliances and other components of the Homes. The foregoing substitutions may include, without limitation, kitchen appliances, household fixtures, electrical outlets and switches, hardware, wall surfaces, painting and other similar items. Each Neighborhood Builder shall have the right to make the substitutions described above without adjustment to the purchase price of your Home. 65. Changes in Construction Plans. The construction, grading, drainage and improvement plans (collectively, the "Construction Plans) for Homesites and Homes within each Neighborhood all contain dimensions that are approximate. They are not intended to be precise dimensions with regard to the Neighborhood. Room dimensions and electrical outlet placement will vary slightly from models and from printed information. Construction will be performed in substantial conformance with the Construction Plans, but dimensions may change slightly from them. If there is a discrepancy between the Construction Plans and the actual as - built conditions of your Homesite or Home, the as -built conditions will control. The usable or buildable area, location and configuration of the Homesite and all improvements located thereon may fluctuate from that shown or displayed to you in the Construction Plans or any other drawings, topographic maps or models based upon a Neighborhood Builder's construction of final improvements including, without limitation, fencing and slopes, which shall be constructed in a Neighborhood Builder's sole and absolute discretion. The location, size, height and composition of all walls and fences to be constructed on your Homesite or adjacent thereto shall be determined by the Neighborhood Builder in its sole and absolute discretion and despite the Construction Plans or any other models, drawings or topographic maps displayed to you. The Buyer laidals: / -30_ 2544-3325ACLP42808CLSM 609965.7 9nsffis Neighborhood Builder .makes no representations, warranties or assurances as to the size, height, location or composition of any wall or fence to be constructed on or adjacent to your Homesite or Home. The Construction Plans are subject to change at any time without notice or obligation. 66. Non -Standard Construction. You may not personally perform any changes of any kind to your Home (such as alarm systems, home intercoms, stereo wiring, etc.) during construction and prior to the Close of Escrow. Such changes may void your warranty. Only those options and upgrades specifically agreed to by the Neighborhood Builder will be made. Any other changes and unapproved options found in a Home during the construction period will be removed by the Neighborhood Builder and the cost of removal and any repairs shall be your responsibility. 67. Changes In Development Plan and Prices. The residential real estate market continually fluctuates due to changes in economic, social and political conditions that directly affect the supply of and demand for housing. As a result, the development plan for the Neighborhood and the Community, and home prices and the terms and conditions of sale are also subject to change. Therefore: (a) With the exception of your Home, each Neighborhood Builder reserves the right at any time prior to or after the Close of Escrow for the sale of a Home and without notice, (i) to increase or decrease the sale price, adjust incentives or otherwise adjust the terms and conditions of sale for Homes in the Neighborhood or in the Community, and (ii) change the number, size, location, elevation, design or type of homes constructed in current or future phases of development of the Neighborhood; (b) No Neighborhood Builder is obligated to offer you the same price, incentives or other terms and conditions of sale that the Neighborhood Builder has previously offered or may subsequently offer to another purchaser; (c) No Neighborhood Builder has either offered or agreed to any price protection or other similar commitment to you regarding the value or resale value of your Home (or any other property), and no Neighborhood Builder shall have any obligation or liability whatsoever to you in the event any price changes directly or indirectly affect the value of your Home; (d) When you entered into a Purchase Agreement, the Neighborhood Builder may have owned other properties which may have been off the market and may not have been shown to or otherwise made available for purchase by you. No Neighborhood Builder has any obligation to notify you if any of such properties come on the market or are otherwise available for purchase or any obligation to notify you of any future properties the Neighborhood Builder may develop and make available for purchase. (e) You shall not hold a Neighborhood Builder responsible for any fluctuations in the purchase price of Homes within the Neighborhood` or the Community. In consideration of a Neighborhood Builder's agreement to sell a Home to you, you agree that you shall have no claims against the Master Developer or the Neighborhood Builder for any possible change (decrease or increase) in the purchase price of Homes within the Neighborhood or any Buyerinitiats: /_ -31- 2544-332531CLP428UISCLSM609965.7 9/25/08 other terms of purchase, including, without limitation, upgrades or other concessions or incentives offered by a Neighborhood Builder to other purchasers of Homes within the Neighborhood and the construction of any additional floor plans on any of the Homes in the Neighborhood. 68. Use of Subcontractors. Neighborhood Builders generally perform construction through the use of subcontractors, and may not employ construction trades or workers. A Neighborhood Builder is not permitted to change its subcontracts without approval of the respective subcontractor; therefore, you may not request interior or exterior construction changes or alterations not otherwise offered to other purchasers in the sales office. 69. Elevation/Floor Plan Specifications. In order to provide architectural diversity in the street scene, each Neighborhood Builder's architect has produced more than one exterior design (elevation) for each floor plan. Consequently, differences may be noticed between the model home for your floor plan and the elevation of your Home. You acknowledge that you have received a description of the exterior configuration for the elevation and the exterior color scheme number for your Home. You also acknowledge that your Home's elevation and floor plan may vary from the configuration of the model home for your Home in terms of layout, sizes of certain rooms, exterior elevation features and other items such as sloped ceilings, veneer treatments, window locations and sizes, roof lines and color schemes. 70. Upper Floor Weight Limits. The upper floors of Homes are designed to support weight limits as outlined in the Uniform Building Code ("UBC'). If you currently own or are planning to purchase a waterbed, pool table or other heavy furniture you must confirm with the manufacturer that the weight introduced by these items does not exceed the UBC weight limit. Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders shall not be responsible for damage caused by anything you place on the upper floors that exceeds the UBC weight limit. 71. Air Conditioning. The air conditioning system and equipment specifications installed in the model homes may vary and operate at a higher capacity than those provided in your Home. You are encouraged to speak with your sales representative to determine the exact equipment specifications that will be provided with your Home. The location of the air conditioning compressor may vary between the model and your Home and between your Home and other Homes in your Neighborhood. . 72. Alarm System. If you purchase an alarm system from a Neighborhood Builder, you specifically waive any claims against Master Developer, the Neighborhood Builder and the Community Association as a result of any failure of the alarm system to warn,. frighten off, or alert anyone about intruders or any other problems. The sale of such system to you by the Neighborhood Builder is not a guarantee or warranty against criminal acts. Master Developer, the Neighborhood Builders and the Community Association are not insurersagainst criminal acts. 73. Energy Conservation. Homes in the Community meet or exceed the energy conservation standards that are a part of Title 24 of the California Administrative Code. Each Neighborhood Builder is required to design and install heating and cooling units that meet strict guidelines in Title 24. This is an energy conservation law that is designed to help reduce the Buyer Initials: i _32_ 2544-33253TU42801SCLSM 609965.7 9/25/08 overall use of energy in -your Home. Title 24 describes the amount of cooling capacity as well as the minimum efficiency ratings for each geographic location in the state. In complying with Title 24, the cooling units installed in your Home are designed for maximum efficiency. Due to the Title 24 geographic requirements, on extremely warm days your inside room temperature may be warmer than your thermostat selection. This is due to design restrictions imposed by Title 24, not any design or installation defect by the Neighborhood Builder or its contractor. 74. Water Conservation. Each Horne in the Community is equipped with low flow fixtures and other equipment to aid in water conservation in compliance with the City's Conditions of Approval for the Neighborhood. 75. Gas Barbecue Stub. If a natural gas service lime is stubbed -out to an exterior backyard wall of your Home, it is suitable only for use in connection with a gas barbecue. Any other use may result in a serious fine hazard. The Neighborhood Builder and Master Developer are not responsible for any damage resulting from your use of the exterior gas stub. 76. Stain Grade Material Discoloration. Natural hardwoods used for cabinets, doors, stair systems, moldings, etc., are finished with stain and lacquer finish products which will change color over time. Color.change may be the result of exposure to sunlight or weather, or simply the consequence of aging. Discoloration is not a defect. 77. Paint Discoloration. Certain portions of your Home, such as paint -grade cabinets, casework, moldings and interior doors, may be painted with oil-based enamel paint. Yellowing is common with oil-based enamel paints. Additionally, if your Home has white oil- based enamel paint -grade cabinets, yellowing will occur. 78. Variations In Natural Materials. Your Home may include various natural materials (e.g., wood products and/or stone products). Wood products vary in dimension, grain, color, moisture content, and performance when subjected to high moisture environments. Dimensional variations in the wood framing members (studs, plates, joists, ratters, and beams) or the required structural hardware connectors may show through the drywall and stucco finishes under certain lighting conditions. Wood panels and trim, exposed timbers, rafters, and posts will require periodic painting. Wood exposed to weather will require more frequent painting. Consult the maintenance schedule included in your Homeowners Manual. Some of the natural characteristics of wood will show through the painted or stained finish. For example, there may be shades of white, red, black, grey or even green in areas. Mineral streaks may also be visible. This is caused by the irregularity of mineral absorption from one part of the tree to another. Grain patterns or texture will vary from even to irregular throughout your cabinetry. Similarly, granite and natural stone products are composed of various mineral contents. Marble is less dense and more porous than granite. Great care must be taken to prevent damage to marble and other stone products. You should follow the manufacturers' recommendations for cleaning and maintenance. Because these are natural products, they are subject to variation in eblor, veining, spotting, holes, cloudiness, texture and cracking. Some may vary significantly in filler and sheen. The samples in the sales office are actual pieces of natural stone which indicate general color and character; however, no two (2) pieces can be expected to match, even when taken from the same box. You should view the stone prior to purchase, and any questions regarding these Buyer Initials: ! -33- 2544-33253\CLP4281DISCISR%6M65.7 9/25/08 materials must be resolved prior to installation. If replacement of natural material tile or carpet is required, you understand and agree that a match with existing material cannot be guaranteed. 79. Brass Plumbing/Light Fixtures/Hardware. Brass, bronze or other finishes have their limitations. In time, the protective lacquer may deteriorate from exposure to weather, perspiration, cleaning agents, frequency of use and other factors. Tarnishing or excessive wear of these finishes is, therefore, not a defect, but a normal process which is unavoidable. Under the circumstances, these finishes cannot be guaranteed and products will not be repaired or replaced under the manufacturer's warranties for tarnishing or wear of finishes. 80. Drywall Panels and Finishes. Drywall panels are placed over the wall studs, joists, rafters and beams. Drywall is typically used to finish window openings. Drywall panels will not completely eliminate variations in the dimension and plane of wood framing members. Metal trim (i.e., corner bead) is used at corners, window edges, soffits and ceilings. They are designed to be filled with finish compounds. These trim metals provide a durable finish but cause the wall plane to "flare" at the metal edge. Panel joints and seams are taped and coated with finish compounds. Fasteners are coated with finish compounds to cover the small "dimple" in the surface of the drywall panel. Progressive applications of finish compounds are required to cover the joints, fasteners, and seams. In some cases, the normal finishing of these joints, fasteners, and seams will cause a subtle "bulge". When the finishing process is complete, the walls and ceilings receive a texture coat. In certain lighting conditions (up -lights placed close to the walls), irregularities and variations in the wall plane or intersection of vertical and horizontal panels may be evident. These variations are normal. 81. View. Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders, the Community Association and their counselors, agents, representatives or employees make no representations, warranties or promises concerning any view, present or future, that may be enjoyed from all or any portion of your Homesite or Home. The view from your Homesite or Home may change or may be fully or partially obstructed by (a) the construction of other homes, Improvements, structures, fences, walls and/or landscaping by Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders or other Owners within the Community, (b) activities and Improvements on real property outside the Community, and/or (c) the growth of trees and/or other vegetation within or outside the Community. You are advised that trees installed in the Community are generally smaller than they will be once mature and trees that do not block views when you purchase your Home may obstruct views as they grow. Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders make no representations or warranties with respect to any open space on property adjacent to your Homesite or Home, or the Community as a whole, whether this property is owned or controlled by Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders, government agencies or private property owners. 82. Warranties for Consumer Products. The manufacturers' warranties for the consumer products included in your Home (e.g., water heater, air conditioning system, dishwasher, garbage disposal and other household appliances) are available for review in the sales office of your Neighborhood Builder. 83. Financing. This paragraph only applies if you are purchasing your Home from a Neighborhood Builder who is also a Lennar Family Builder and you are financing the purchase with Universal American Mortgage Corporation ("UAMC"). You will be required to provide Buyer Initials: / -34. 2544-33253TLP429\DISCLSM 609965.7 9/25/0R UAMC with all documents necessary to obtain loan approval. UAMC may be affiliated with the Neighborhood Builder. You are not obligated to accept a loan from UAMC, but you may be required to submit documentation to UAMC to permit the Neighborhood Builder to determine whether it is likely that you will qualify to purchase the Home you desire. You may select your lender independently; however, if you select a lender other than UAMC, you must ensure that the lender can meet the time limitations and requirements imposed on lenders in the Purchase Agreement. Master Developer and Neighborhood Builder have not reviewed or approved any lender's sales or marketing materials, and does not make any representations or warranties whatsoever regarding any matters set forth therein or your ability to obtain any financing under any particular terms. You are strongly encouraged to make your own independent evaluation of the rates and loan programs offered by all lenders, including UAMC. You understand that the interest rate and loan fees for the loan applied for will be determined at the time of the Close of Escrow and may be higher or lower than on the date you signed a purchase agreement for your Home. You also acknowledge that the interest rate and loan fees referenced on the loan application are approximate only and do not constitute a binding commitment. 84. Schools. The Community is currently located in the Tustin Unified School District, telephone: (714) 730-7301 (the "School District). To obtain further information about the schools serving the Community, including transportation to and from the schools, please contact the School District. You should investigate this matter to your satisfaction prior to purchasing a Home in the Community. Due to the rate of population change, the school district may find it necessary to change boundaries and designated schools periodically, prior to or after your close of escrow. In addition, it is possible that school district boundaries may change and your children will be required to attend a different school district in the future. Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders have no control or responsibility for such changes should they occur. The Community is currently expected to be served by the following schools: Marjorie Veeh Elementary School (K-6) 1701 San Juan Street Tustin, California (714) 730-7544 . A.G. Currie Middle School (7-8) 1402 Sycamore Avenue Tustin, California (714) 730-7352 Tustin High School (9-12) 4321 1171 El Camino Real Tustin, California (714)730-7414 To obtain further information about the schools serving the- Community, including transportation to and from the schools, please contact the applicable school referenced above or the School District, or you can visit the School District's website at www.tustin.kl2.ca.us. You should investigate this matter to your satisfaction prior to purchasing a Home in the Community. Buyei Initials: / -35- 2544-33253\CLP428\D18CLSR\ 609965.7 9/25/08 85. Mailboxes. Mailboxes in the Community may be clustered in groups as required by the United States Postal Service. The location of mailboxes and above -ground utility structures are determined by governmental agencies or utility companies, or both. You may not change the type of mailbox being used or the location. Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders reserve the right to modify such locations as may be dictated by field conditions without prior notice. 86. Residential Construction Legislation. California Civil Code Sections 895 through 945.5 ("Construction Claims Statute', went into effect on January 1, 2003. The Construction Claims Statute (a) delineates standards for how various components of your Home should be constructed and function, (b) limits the time frames for bringing various claims against the Neighborhood Builder to anywhere from one year to ten years (as listed in the Construction Claims Statute) after the Close of Escrow, (c) imposes an obligation on all Owners and their successors in interest to follow Neighborhood Builder's maintenance recommendations and schedules or other applicable maintenance guidelines, and (d) establishes a non -adversarial claims resolution procedure. Pursuant to Section 914 of the Construction Claims Statute, the Neighborhood Builder is permitted to elect to utilize the procedure in the Construction Claims Statute or its own alternate contractual pre -litigation procedures. The applicable claims handling procedures are outlined in the Purchase Documents you receive from the Neighborhood Builder, including the "Dispute Resolution" provision in Section 13.5 of the Master Declaration. A separate notice further describing claims handling procedures may have been recorded against the title to Homes by the Neighborhood Builder in some Neighborhoods. You should review any such notice and your Purchase Documents carefully concerning these issues. YOU ARE ADVISED THAT THE CONSTRUCTION CLAIMS STATUTE AFFECTS YOUR LEGAL RIGHTS. YOU ARE ADVISED TO READ THE STATUTE CAREFULLY AND SEED LEGAL ADVICE IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS REGARDING ITS EFFECT ON YOUR LEGAL RIGHTS. Buyer Initials Buyer Initials 87. Duty to Follow Maintenance Guidelines. An Owner is obligated by Section 907 of the Construction Claims Statute to follow any maintenance recommendations and schedules from the Neighborhood Builder, including the maintenance recommendations and schedules for manufactured products and appliances included with the Home, as well as all commonly accepted maintenance practices (collectively, "Maintenance Guidelines'j. Pursuant to Section 945.5 of the Construction Claims Statute, failure to follow any such Maintenance Guidelines may reduce or preclude an Owner's right to recover damages relating to an Owner's Home which could have been prevented or mitigated had the Maintenance Guidelines been followed. Buyer Initials Buyer Initials Buyer Initials: / -36- 2544.33253\CLI 428\DISCLSM 609965.7 9/,25/08 88. Obligation to Retain Purchase Documents. The Purchase Documents that you receive through escrow in conjunction with the purchase of a Home may include Maintenance Guidelines, a written limited warranty, claim forms, and other documentation relating to the Construction Claims Statute. All Owners are required by the Construction Claims Statute to retain these documents and provide copies of such documents to an Owner's successors in interest upon the sale or transfer of the Owner's Home. Buyer Initials Buyer Initials 89. Warranty and Limitations on Liability. A Neighborhood Builder may provide a written limited warranty for the Homesite or Home covering certain defects for a limited period after the date the limited warranty commences. Warranty periods for items will vary as set forth in the written limited warranty. During the written limited warranty period, if any, the Neighborhood Builder will repair or replace, at the Neighborhood Builder's sole discretion, certain components of your Homesite or Home, as set forth in the written limited warranty. A written limited warranty generally does not cover defects resulting from the failure of an Owner to perform commonly- accepted maintenance. Minor expansion, contraction, settlement cracks normal to home construction, and secondary damage, are generally not covered under the terms of a written limited warranty. Please refer to the written limited warranty you may receive for additional information. No other warranties or guarantees, whether expressed or implied, are provided, unless stated in writing and signed by a Neighborhood Builder. The manufacturers' warranties for the manufactured consumer products included in your Home (for example, water heater, air conditioning system, dishwasher, garbage disposal and other household appliances) are available for review in the Neighborhood Builder's sales office. 90. Notice of Sexual Offenders. The following notice is given pursuant to Section 2079.10a of the California Civil Code: Pursuant to Section 290.46 of the Penal Code, information about specified registered sex offenders is made available to the public via an Internet Web site maintained by the Department of Justice at www.meganslaw.ca.gov. Depending on an offender's criminal history, this information will include either the address at which the offender resides or the community of residence and ZIP Code in which he or she resides. Prior to the purchase of a Home in the Community, you may research the database to determine whether there are sex offenders in the area. Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders, the Community Association and their respective directors, officers, employees, agents, representatives and consultants make no representations, warranties, or guarantees regarding the presence or absence of registered sex offenders within the Community or in the surrounding area. In addition, Master Developer, Neighborhood Builder, the Community Association and their respective directors, officers, employees, agents, representatives and consultants have no obligation or duty to investigate existing residents or buyers to determine whether they are sex offenders. You are solely responsible for making your own investigation. For further Buyer Initials,.. ! „37. 2544-33253TU42801SCLSM609965.7 925/08 information, please contact your local law enforcement agency. Most law enforcement agencies have special stations to view the Megan's Law database. 91. Benefit of Home Ownership. Although the purchase of a new home has traditionally been considered a wise decision, Master Developer and Neighborhood Builder have made no representations, guarantees or warranties to you regarding the tax benefits, investment benefits or other benefits of home ownership, regarding appreciation or depreciation in the value or equity accrual in your Home, and regarding future price adjustments. 92. Assumption of Risk and Liability. By acceptance of this Disclosure, you assume all risk and liability for injuries to persons and property that may be sustained by you, your family members and your social and business guests by reason of all conditions or circumstances disclosed in this Disclosure. VISITING THE COMMUNITY BEFORE MOVE -IN If you wish to visit the Community, the Neighborhood and your Home before your move in, please be aware that your Home is located within a construction area and that construction sites are potentially dangerous. The Neighborhood Builder will permit you to enter your Home and the construction area surrounding your Home provided that you are fully aware of the risks of such entry and are willing to comply with the procedures and requirements imposed on such visit by the Neighborhood Builder. You must be accompanied by your sales representative, or another representative of the Neighborhood Builder on any and all visits to your Home. Each Neighborhood Builder further requests that such visits be limited to non -construction hours. By signing this Disclosure you acknowledge that there are numerous risks associated with visiting your Home during construction, including without limitation, open trenches, construction traffic, potential falling debris, exposed nails and electrical wiring, incomplete construction and certain other potential hazards. You further agree to use due care while visiting your Home. In addition, prior to visiting any construction area you may be required to sign a waiver and release form provided by the Neighborhood Builder ("Waiver'l in which you agree to comply with the nrovisons of the Waiver., Whether or not you have sinned a Waiver by s>nin� t�llis_Disclosure. iniury which ma -y occur during your visit to -your Home to the Neignnornooa ana to me Community. ENTIRE DISCLOSURE; NO OTHER REPRESENTATIONS No sales representative, employee or agent of any Neighborhood Builder or the Master Developer has the authority to make any representation to you which contradicts or modifies the matters and information set forth in this Disclosure, the purchase agreement or any,other written disclosure provided by the Master Developer or Neighborhood Builders in connection with the purchase of a Horne in a Neighborhood (collectively, the "Disclosure Documents'). You acknowledge that no representations have been made to you by such persons other than as set forth in the Disclosure Documents and upon which you have relied in connection with the purchase of the Home. Please indicate below if any representations have been made by any such Buyer Initials: t -39- 2544-33253WLP42MISCLSM 609965.7 9/25!118 person which contradict or modify the matters and information set forth in the Disclosure Documents: RELEASE AND INDEMNITY REGARDING DISCLOSURES With respect to items of information disclosed to you in this Disclosure or in any Disclosure Documents provided by Master Developer or Neighborhood Builders (collectively, "Disclosure Items"), you agree that you and your family members release, waive and will not make any claims against Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders for (a) nondisclosure of Disclosure Items, (b) for alleged improper or incomplete Disclosure Items, and (c) personal injury, property damage, expenses (including attorney fees and costs) and other liability you, your family members and others experience from the nondisclosure, improper disclosure or incomplete disclosure of Disclosure Items. You also agree that you will indemnify and hold the Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders and all of their affiliated entities, officers, directors, agents and assigns, harmless from all such claims by you, your family members and your social and business guests. Buyer Initials Buyer Initials [Buyer Acknowledgment on following page] Buyer Initials; / w39_ 2544-3325ACLP428MISCLSM 609965.7 9/25/08 Columbus Square HOMEBUYER DISCLOSURE STATEMENT BUYER ACKNOWLEDGMENT By the signatures below, you acknowledge that you will close escrow with full. knowledge, understanding and agreement as to all of the information contained in this Disclosure, and that this Disclosure constitutes a part of the terms of your Home purchase. Buyer: Date: Homesite or Condominium No: Tract No: Street Address: Buyer initials: / _40_ 2544-33253T042801SGLSM 609965.7 5/25/08 Columbus Square RO EBUYER DISCLOSURE STATEMENT Merhvdher + Camden Flare The Cables + Astoria • Coventry Cour Cambridge .Lane • Mirabella + Verandas November 2009 Welcome to Columbus Square. We are pleased you are considering the purchase of a new home in Columbus Square. We want you (the "Bayer") to be an extremely satisfied customer. Part of your satisfaction is in knowing as much as possible about your new home in the master -planned community of Columbus Square ("Community"), located in the City of Tustin. We offer this Homeowner Disclosure Statement ("Disclosure") as a service to describe to you various matters which might affect your decision to purchase. Please read it carefully. Be aware, however, that (a) much of the information in this Disclosure has been obtained from other sources (public agencies, public records, etc,), and (b) the information contained in this Disclosure is not comprehensive, This means that we cannot guarantee the accuracy or completeness of the information disclosed. Because this information is subject to change without notice to us, it also means that we cannot commit to advise you of any changes affecting the information in this Disclosure. In addition to this Disclosure, the City of Tustin has required that the Master Developer provide you with a Columbus Square Homebuyer Notification (the "Homebuyer Notification'). The Master Developer prepared the Homebuyer Notification with information provided by the City of Tustin, at the direction of the City of Tustin and does not have the right to alter or update the Homebuyer Notification without the express written consent of the City. To the extent any of the .information provided in this Disclosure is inconsistent with the information provided in the Homebuyer Notification, the Homebuyer Notification shall supersede this Disclosure to the extent of any inconsistency; provided, however (a) the conflicting documents shall be construed to be consistent to the extent possible, and (b) the more restrictive provisions of the conflicting documents shall control. By signing this Disclosure, you agree to independently verify all information regarding matters of concern to you before the Close of Escrow for your home purchase. As a part of your pre -purchase investigation, we strongly recommend that you visit the Community and the general vicinity surrounding the Community on several different days at several different times to familiarize yourself with the Community, its location and its surroundings. You will receive many documents in addition to this Disclosure to review, complete and sign before the Close of Escrow for the purchase of your home. These other documents are called the "Purchase Documents" in this Disclosure, and they include documents pertaining to Guyer initials: J_ _ _ 2544-332 34CL•P4381D1SCLSR\ (x09983.10 11/16/Ci>gJ the Community, defined below as the "Community Association Governing Documents". This Disclosure is not intended as a substitute for your review of the Community Association Governing Documents. This Disclosure does not amend, modify or supersede the Community Association Governing Documents. If the Community Association Governing Documents are inconsistent with this Disclosure, the Community Association Governing Documents will supersede this Disclosure. Unless defined in this Disclosure, capitalized terms used in this Disclosure have the meanings given them in the Master Declaration of Covenants, Conditions, Restrictions and Reservation of Easements for Columbus Square ("Community Declaration"). If the Community Declaration gives the same capitalized term a different meaning than this Disclosure, the meaning given in the Community Declaration shall apply. INTRODUCTION TO THE MASTER DEVELOPER Moffett Meadows Partners, LLC, a Delaware limited liability company, is the initial Master Developer of the Columbus Square master -planned community ("Master Developer'). INTRODUCTION TO COLUMBUS SQUARE 1. Location and Master Plan. The Community is east of Interstate 55 near the intersection of Edinger Avenue and Redhill Avenue, in the City of Tustin (the "City'). The master land -use plan approved by the City of Tustin for the Community is called the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan (the "Speck Plan'l and it contains numerous design standards and development conditions. Such conditions establish, among other things, the number of single family dwellings and condominiums and other development requirements. If developed as approved by the City, Columbus Square will encompass approximately 1075 Homes, which are planned to consist of 283 single family dwellings, 552 condominiums and 240 senior housing condominiums. The actual number of Homes built may increase or decrease subject to approval by the City. All Homes in the Community are planned to be subject to the jurisdiction of the Columbus Square Community Association, a California nonprofit mutual benefit corporation ("Community Association 'I, as described in the Community Declaration. INTRODUCTION TO COLUMBUS SQUARE'S NEIGHBORHOODS AND NEIGHBORHOOD BUILDERS 2. Neighborhoods. The Community is being developed with Homes in numerous distinct neighborhoods ("Neighborhoods") constructed by various homebuilders ("Neighborhood Builders'. Neighborhood Builders may have owner occupancy restrictions, rental Homesites and Homes (each of which is defined below), and investor-owned Homesites and Homes. You are advised to read the individual Neighborhood Builder disclosures and any other documentation relating to the Neighborhood in which you choose to purchase a Homesite or Home thoroughly. Neighborhood Builder policies may differ from those described in this Disclosure and the Community Declaration and are enforceable by the applicable Neighborhood Builders. The following is a list of the different Neighborhoods to be developed by the Neighborhood Builders in the Community and the approximate number of Homes to be constructed in each Neighborhood; provided that that any product may be renamed or sold by the Buyer initials! / _Z_ 2544-33253TU429015CLSM 609965.10 11116/09 Neighborhood Builder, currently listed below and the Neighborhood Builders reserve the right not to build the Neighborhoods listed below at all: (a) Lennar Homes of California, Inc. • Meriwether 114 Homes • Camden Place 222 Homes • The Gables 84 Homes • Coventry Court 240 Homes (b) William Lyon Homes, Inc. and/or Resmark Equity Partners, LLC • Astoria 102 Homes • Cambridge Lane 156 Homes • Mirabella 60 Homes • Verandas 97 Homes 3. Ownership. A residential Lot in the Community is referred to as a "Homesite" in this Disclosure. If you are purchasing a residential Lot in the Community, upon the Close of Escrow, you will receive fee title to a Homesite, which will be improved with a single family dwelling (a "Home). If you are purchasing a Condominium in the Community, upon the Close of Escrow, you will receive fee title to a Unit and you will also receive easements for maintenance and use over Exclusive Use Areas (collectively, a "Home'!. If you purchase a Homesite, you will not own the mineral, oil, and gas rights under the land below a depth of five hundred (500) feet, or the water rights. The holder of these rights has no right of surface entry. COMMUNITY ASSOCIATION GOVERNING DOCUMENTS Your Home will be subject to the following documents ("Community Association Governing Documents'): (a) The Community Declaration, and any amendments or modifications thereto; (b) The Articles of Incorporation of the Columbus Square Community Association ("Community Association"); (c) The Bylaws of the Community Association; (d) The Supplemental Declaration of Covenants, Conditions and Restrictions ("Supplemental Declaration") that is applicable to the Neighborhood in which your Home is located, and may annex that Neighborhood to the coverage of the Community Declaration; and (e) Any Community Guidelines or Design Guidelines which may be adopted from time to time, respectively, by the Community Association's Board of Directors or the Design Review Committee ("Committee'l pursuant to the Community Declaration. Buyer Initials: / _3_ 2544-33253TU428WISCLSM 609965.10 11/16/09 You should carefully review the Community Association Governing Documents in order to understand your specific rights and obligations as an Owner in the Community. The Community Association Governing Documents establish limits and restrictions on the use of the Home you are purchasing. You will also be provided with a preliminary title report. The title report will list other recorded documents affecting the use of the Horne you are purchasing. You should review the title report and the documents referenced in the report closely prior to your purchase of a Horne. SPECIFIC PROVISIONS OF THE COMMUNITY DECLARATION 4. Assessment Obligation. The Community Declaration authorizes the Community Association's Board of Directors to levy a Common Assessment against each Home to meet the Community Association's Common Expenses. The Board of Directors is also authorized to levy various special assessments for specific purposes, in conformance with Articles I and VIII of the Community Declaration. The monthly installment of the Common Assessment will vary as each Phase of the Community is developed. You should review the Budget approved by the California Department of Real Estate and provided to you with the Final Subdivision Public Report for your Home. The Board of Directors' ability to increase the Common Assessments and improve additional special assessments without a vote of the Members is subject to certain limitations set forth in Sections 8.5 and 8.6 of the Community Declaration. The Community Association is obligated to provide you with an annual budget and other financial statements for the Community Association. 5. Use Restrictions. You must comply with all the various use restrictions set forth in the Community Declaration. These restrictions include, among other things, restrictions on non-residential uses of your Home, keeping of animals, improvements to your Homesite and Home, parking of vehicles, etc. The Community Association has the power to enforce the use restrictions set forth in the Community Declaration, as well as the Community Guidelines and the Design Guidelines. 6. Prohibited Dwelling Structures. You may not use your garage as a living area. Further, in accordance with Section 2.7 of the Community Declaration, you may not erect or use any outbuilding, tent, shack, storage shed, trailer, camper, motor home, recreational vehicle or any other vehicle on your Homesite for a living area. 7. Use of Garages. All vehicles owned or operated by or within the control of an Owner and kept in the Community must be parked in the assigned parking space or garage of that Owner; provided that, although storage of personal items may occur in the garage, all Authorized Vehicles must be parked in the garage, in accordance with Section 2.4.3 of the Community Declaration. and Exhibit PC -1 attached thereto. Notwithstanding the foregoing, Owners may not park any Authorized Vehicle in the street or in any guest parking spaces. No repair, maintenance or restoration of any vehicle may be conducted within the Community except in an enclosed garage when the garage door is closed; provided, however, that such activity may not be undertaken as a business, and provided further that such activity may be prohibited entirely by the Board if the Board determines that it constitutes a nuisance. Buyer Initials: / -4" 2544-33253\C1,I1428WISCLSM 604465.10 11/16/09 8. Parking- of Recreational and Commercial Vehicles. Sections 2.4.1, 2.4.2 and 2.4.3 of the Community Declaration impose limitations and prohibitions on the parking of Authorized Vehicles and Prohibited Vehicles within the Community. In accordance with Section 2.4.6 of the Community Declaration, an Owner may park any Authorized Vehicle that exceeds seven (7) feet high, seven .(7) feet wide, and nineteen (19) feet long in the Owner's garage or driveway (as long as the Authorized Vehicle does not extend onto the sidewalk or drive approach area). In addition, no delivery and/or moving trucks larger than forty (40) feet are permitted on any private drive having less than a twenty-five (25) foot radius that is located within a Neighborhood in the Community. You further acknowledge that it is your responsibility to determine whether the parking provided in the Community and your Neighborhood is satisfactory for your purposes and to verify that the standard height and depth of the garage will provide adequate clearance for your vehicles before the Close of Escrow on your Home. 9. Owner Maintenance Guidelines. As set forth in Section 9.1.1 of the Community Declaration, each Owner must maintain his Home and Homesite in a neat and attractive condition at all times. The maintenance of all areas located within the boundaries of a Homesite is the responsibility of each Owner. The Neighborhood Builders will provide you with important guidelines on the proper maintenance of improvements in your Homesite. Failure to properly maintain interior improvements may cause premature deterioration of important features, finishes or equipment. The Neighborhood Builders are not responsible for failure of equipment or other improvements caused by your failure to properly maintain such improvements. In addition, you acknowledge that some upgraded materials, if any are selected by you, may have specific maintenance requirements. The Neighborhood Builders are not responsible for any damages that may occur to such materials due to your failure to properly maintain them. 10. Insurance. In accordance with Article IX of the Community Declaration, you are solely responsible for determining the type and quality of insurance required to adequately insure your Homesite and Home, your personal property, and your personal liability for ownership of your Homesite and Horne. You are solely responsible for determining if natural disaster insurance is required for your Homesite and Home. If any insurance is required by your lender, you are responsible for obtaining that insurance prior to Close of Escrow. 11. Design Review of Improvements and Alterations. You may not build, construct, install or plant any improvements on your Homesite (or alter any improvements located on your Homesite, including your Home), until you have submitted plans and specifications and obtained approval from the Design Review Committee, as set forth in Article V of the Community Declaration. The Design Review Committee will establish Design Guidelines containing rules and guidelines for the submission of plans and specifications. The Design Review Committee may collect a fee to review the plans. All Improvements must comply with any applicable restrictions in the Community Declaration and the Design Guidelines, as well as with all requirements imposed by the City and any other local governmental agency. The Design Guidelines and City and other local governmental agency regulations may change from time to time, and you will be subject to the regulations in effect at the time plans are submitted. After obtaining written approval of the Design Review Committee, Buyer Initials: / _5_ 2544-33253TU42801SCLSM 609965.10 11!16/09 you must submit the plans and specifications to the appropriate local governmental agencies for any proposed improvements that require the issuance of a building permit, or other approval by the City or any other local governmental agencies, as applicable. You should read Article V of the Community Declaration before constructing any Improvements. You may be subject to a Neighborhood Association Design Review Committee if you live in a Condominium project. (a) Landscaping and Irrigation Improvements. All landscape materials and irrigation systems installed by Owners must comply with plans and specifications approved by the Design Review Committee. You may need to install yard drains when installing landscaping and patios. Your landscaping plans are required to conform with the original drainage plan of the Homesite. Changes to drainage and grading require approval of the Design Review Committee and generally require you to obtain a permit from the City, as applicable. The slope areas, if any, located on a Homesite may include drainage facilities and temporary erosion control measures. No modifications to the slope areas shall be undertaken without the prior approval of the Design Review Committee and the City, as applicable. (b) Landscaping Completion Deadline. Section 2.18 of the Community Declaration requires you to install landscaping on any portions of your Homesite that have not been landscaped by a Neighborhood Builder. Landscaping in the front yard of a Homesite must be completed within six (6) months after the Close of Escrow for the purchase of the Homesite and landscaping in the back yard of a Homesite must be completed within one (1) year after the Close of Escrow for the purchase of the Homesite. The time period for the completion of such improvements is set forth in the Community Declaration. (c) Owner Liability. Any alterations or Improvements made by you to your Homesite, to its drainage pattern or to the Home shall be made at your sole risk. The Neighborhood Builders assume no responsibility for any damage caused by the design, construction, installation, alteration or maintenance by you of any Improvement on the Homesite, or caused by the impact of such an Improvement on the Homesite's drainage pattern. (d) Licensed Professionals. If you wish to alter or install any Improvement on your Homesite, you should obtain the advice of a licensed architect or civil, soil or structural engineer, as applicable, and should design and complete the alteration or installation of the Improvement in accordance with such licensed professional's advice and specifications. 12. Drainage. Section 2.14 of the Community Declaration contains important restrictions concerning drainage of water and water pollution. (a) Surface Water. The Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders have provided for surface and underground drainage of water from all Homesites and Homes in the Community. Your Homesite may have surface "swales" or area drains to carry the water from the rear and sides of the Home to the street or other designated outlet points. The Homesites and Homes are graded in accordance with plans approved by the City and certified by a registered civil engineer. In connection with the preparation of landscape plans for your yard, it is important that you consider any possible harmful effects that such landscaping and associated Improvements may have on adjacent property and structures as well as your Homesite and Home. Because the Community and your Homesite are located in an area which may contain Buyer Initials: ! -6- 2544-33253\CLP42MISCLSM 609963.14 11/16/09 expansive soils as more particularly explained in the Paragraph below entitled "Soil Conditions," water may have a detrimental impact upon such soils and the. soils of surrounding Homesites and slopes. Existing drainage patterns must be maintained and all drainage systems must be kept free of debris and free flowing. (b) Effect of Improvements and Alterations. Raising the existing grade, constructing planters, changing the drainage pattern and other similar activities may cause damage to your Homesite, adjacent property (including, without limitation, your neighbor's Homesite, adjacent slopes and lower Homesites) and Improvements located thereon, including the Home. It is recommended that you consult with a licensed professional on landscaping and drainage, such as a qualified landscape architect and soils engineer, geotechnical engineer, geologist, civil engineer or other similar specialist, before making any alterations. Any Improvements must be designed and constructed in a manner to prevent any possible damage to your Homesite and to adjacent property. If any obstruction occurs to the drainage on your yard, it may result in obstruction of drainage from adjacent property or cause major problems such as trapped water or flooding which may undermine the foundation of your Home and surrounding Homes or create moisture intrusion or mold and mildew problems. You are solely responsible for any damage to your Homesite and Home or surrounding property and the Improvements located thereon as a result of any alterations you make to the approved existing drainage pattern or failure to maintain proper drainage. The Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders and Community Association shall have no liability or responsibility for any such damage. Any grading or drainage modifications are subject to applicable codes of the City, approval by the Design Review Committee, and the terms of any drainage easements that may be of record. You acknowledge and understand that if your Homesite or Home does not include area drains, you shall be responsible for installing area drains on your Homesite or Home when installing your landscaping. Your responsibilities for maintaining all grading and other drainage -related features on your Homesite and Home are set forth in Section 2.14.1 of the Community Declaration. (c) Water Quality Management Requirements. The Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders are developing the Community and Neighborhoods in accordance with a water quality management plan ("Plan") required by the California State Water Quality Control Board, The Plan imposes requirements for the design, implementation and maintenance of Best Management Practices ("BMPs"j to eliminate or mitigate all non -storm water discharges into storm drains during and after construction of the Community and Neighborhoods. The requirements imposed by the Plan are in addition to any local ordinances with regard to discharge of non -storm water into storm drains. The Plan imposes post -construction requirements. This means that after the Close of Escrow, you and your sub -contractors and other agents, are required to comply with all BMPs which are necessary to prevent, without limitation, run-off of soil, sand, sediment, oil, gasoline or other hydrocarbons, paint, fertilizers, pool chemicals and other household chemicals into the storm drains located in your Neighborhood. For example, when fertilizing landscaping, measures must be taken to prevent over -watering the landscaping to' epsure that fertilizer and other lawn chemicals do not run into the storm drains. Your Neighborhood Builder will provide you with a Best Management Practices Handbook containing BMP recommendations for the prevention of run-off into storm drains from your Homesite and Home. BuyerinWals: / _7- 2544-332531CLP4281DISCLSR1609965,10 11/16/09 The Plan affirmatively obligates all Owners to take immediate corrective action whenever there is a violation of the Plan as to an Owner's Homesite or Home. Penalties include significant fines that may be imposed against an Owner for failing to comply with BMPs necessary to prevent non -storm water run-off' into storm drains, in violation of the Plan. 13. Utility and Other Easements. Article VII of the Community Declaration contains provisions pertaining to easements which may affect Owners and Homes. Your Homesite and Home may be subject to easements or other rights in favor of utility companies, local governmental agencies and other parties. These easements and rights may include access onto your Homesite or to exterior portions of the Home for purposes of installing, constructing, inspecting, maintaining and repairing facilities which are customary for residential developments (including, but not limited to, water lines, sewer lines, electrical lines and facilities, transformer boxes, natural gas pipelines, street lights, telephone lines and facilities, cable television lines, mailboxes, traffic signs, fire hydrants, etc.). These facilities and structures may be located above ground or below ground. In either case, the foregoing easements, rights and facilities may restrict the use and type of improvements you can make to your Homesite and Home, and the utility company, local government agency or other parties benefited by such easement or right may have the right to remove improvements made by you on the easement area without any obligation to repair or restore them. You should review the policy of title insurance, the tract map for your Homesite, Article VII of the Community Declaration, and the Supplemental Declaration to determine what easements and other rights, if any, affect your Homesite and Home. Such easements may preclude construction of structures or other improvements or may require an encroachment permit to be obtained. You should not excavate or construct an improvement on any portion of your Homesite, as applicable, until you have consulted with an applicable licensed design professional (for example, an engineer) and located all easements and facilities. A copy of the tract map depicting your Homesite is available for review in the sales office. The location of gas and electric meters, telephone and cable access panels may change from the locations shown in the models. Please ask your sales representative for information concerning the proposed location of utility facilities and structures for your Home. The Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders make no representations or warranties concerning the final location of these facilities or structures for your Home. 14. Pets. Household pets, such as dogs or cats, are limited to reasonable quantities as established in Section 2.5 of the Community Declaration. Buyers shall be liable for any unreasonable noise or damage (including, but not limited to, clean up after such animal(s)) caused by any animal brought or kept upon the Community and Neighborhoods as more fully described in the Community Declaration. 15. Window Coverings. In accordance with Section 2.10 of the Community Declaration, the Design Guidelines and Community Guidelines may prohibit or restrict certain types of window coverings such as paint, foil, reflective tint or other similar materials or substances, and may permit certain types of temporary window coverings pending 'installation of permanent window coverings. 16. Walls and Fences. Wall and fence heights may vary throughout the Community and your Neighborhood. Walls and fences are subject to change, at any time and without notice to you, from any depiction that may have been provided or shown to you. Section 9.1.4 of the Buyer Initials: / _$_ 2544-33253\CLP428\DISCLSR\ 609965.14 11/16/09 Community Declaration sets forth Owner's wall maintenance responsibilities. Owners are responsible for maintenance of all portions of the walls and fences that border the perimeter of the Homesite, including any pilasters located on an Owner's Homesite, except for those portions that are designated for maintenance by the Community Association or a Neighborhood Association. You should review the Community Association Governing Documents for further information. Community Walls, Neighborhood Walls and/or Party Walls (all as defined in the Community Declaration) may be installed on the property lines) of your Homesite (collectively, the "Walls"), as shown as Exhibil WM attached to the Community Declaration, Neighborhood Declaration or a Supplemental Declaration. Owners must maintain any portion of the Walls not otherwise maintained by the Community Association or a Neighborhood Association. Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders and the Community Association are not responsible for damage to any Wall on the Homesite if such damage results from ,your failure to properly maintain the Walls. 17. Solar Energy Systems. Pursuant to Section 2.17 of the Community Declaration, you and all other Owners of Homesites in the Community have the right to place and maintain equipment and facilities related to the installation and maintenance of individual solar energy systems ("S)?stem's. The installation and maintenance of any System by you shall be subject to all applicable ordinances and zoning regulations of the City, the Uniform Building Code and associated ordinances, California has a strong public policy in favor of solar energy needs of a neighbor, including but not limited to the location and height of trees on your Homesite. You must obtain written approval from the Design Review Committee prior to installation of a System and you must comply with reasonable restrictions placed on the System by the Design Review Committee, subject to California Civil Code Sections 714 and 714.1, as the same may be amended from time to time. 18. Satellite Dishes. Satellite dish antennas (or Authorized Antennae, as defined in the Community Declaration) may be installed and used in the Community in accordance with Section 2.11 of the Community Declaration. However, Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders have provided no assurances or guarantees that any satellite dish or other antenna installed within the Community will remain unobstructed or that satellite service will be provided to an Owner after installation of an Authorized Antennae. You should understand that broadcast signals may be obstructed by the installation of additional improvements within and outside of the Community including, without limitation, homes, walls, fences, trees and other landscaping and such obstructions may not allow for acceptable satellite reception, You should also understand that Neighborhood Associations may impose additional restrictions. 19. Amendments to the Community Declaration. Notwithstanding the fact that you have received a copy of the Community Declaration and the Supplemental Declaration for your Phase of Development, these documents may be amended in accordande with their amendment provisions. 20. Additional Provisions. There may be provisions of various laws, including the Davis -Stirling Common Interest Development Act codified at Sections 1350 et seq. of the California Civil Code and the Federal Fair Housing Act codified at Title 42 United States Code, �® Buyer Initials: ! _o_ 2544-33253TLP42MISCLSM609965. 10 11/16/09 Section 3601 et seq., which may supplement or override the Community Association Governing Documents. The Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders and Community Association make no representations or warranties regarding the future enforceability of any portion of the Community Association Governing Documents. COLUMBUS SQUARE DISCLOSURES 21. Charitable Endowment Fee. A recorded Charitable Housing Agreement Imposing Endowment Fee On Transfer ("Agreement") affects your Horne and the other Homes in the Community. The Agreement requires that an "EndownwW Fee" equal to one -twentieth of one percent (0.05%) of the total sales price (0.0005 x total sales price) be paid each time a Home in the Community is transferred to a new owner. The Endowment Fere will be paid to Lennar Charitable Housing Foundation, a California nonprofit public benefit corporation ("Foundation"), to be used for the purposes described in the Agreement. When you close escrow for the purchase of your Home, you will pay the Endowment Fee to the Foundation. Thereafter, each time your Home is resold, the Endowment Fee must be. paid at the close of escrow, but it may be paid either by the new buyer or the then current seller. The Agreement will be in effect for an indefinite period of time. 22. Affordable Housing/Transitional Housing. The City of Tustin has required the Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders to provide two hundred sixty-six (266) units of affordable housing ("Affordable Housing Units") within the Community. Sixty-three (63) At%rdable Housing Units will be located in the Camden Place Neighborhood, fifty (50) Affordable Housing Units will be located in the Cambridge Lane Neighborhood, and one hundred fifty-three (153) Affordable Housing Units will be located in an area of the Community that will be designated as housing for seniors (Coventry Court). Certain of these Affordable Housing Units will be offered to persons who qualify as very low, low and moderate income buyers pursuant to guidelines established by the United States Department of Housing and Urban Development for the City. Buyers who qualify as very low, low and moderate income will purchase their Homes subject to resale restrictions, as reflected in a recorded covenant agreement, for a period of forty-five (45) years. If you are interested in the Affordable Housing Units you should consult your sales representative for further information. 23. "Active Adult" Neighborhood. An "Active Adult" Neighborhood is proposed for the Community on Lot 265 of Tract No. 16581, which is located on Charleston and Cambridge Streets adjacent to Georgia Street and Kensington Park Drive, and is planned to consist of approximately 240 age restricted Homes. As an Active Adult Neighborhood, each Home must be occupied by at least one resident who is at least 55 years of age. If the Active Adult Neighborhood has its own recreational facilities, then all assessments for the maintenance of these recreation facilities are the exclusive responsibility of the residents of the Active Adult Neighborhood. As a result, the recreational facilities located within the Active Adult Neighborhood are not open to other Owners in the Community; provided, however, the residents of the Active Adult Neighborhood will have the right to use the public recreational facilitiest, located throughout the Community. In addition, if the residents of the Active. Adult V__,D " Neighborhood become members of the Community Association and pay assessments to the Community Association, then the residents of the Active Adult Neighborhood, as members of a t the Community Association, will have the right to use the Community Association's private BuverInitials: i 10_ 3544.33253\CLP42MDISCLSRk6O M5.10 I 1/I6lW recreational facilities. Master Developer reserves the right to construct other age restricted communities in other locations in the Community. .Master Developer may also plan and construct other types and number of Homes, ineludhng rental, within Lot 265 of Tract No. 16581, with the approval by the City, 24. Home Business Use. Any Home within the Community may be used for home based business purposes, provided that such use is subject to the City of Tustin's Home Occupation Ordinance (if applicable), the provisions in Section 2.1 of the Community - Declaration and the Community Guidelines. You are advised that the Community Declaration and the Community Guidelines may contain stricter restrictions than those in the City Ordinance and that such use may require zoning clearance and a business license. You should contact the City for more information regarding business uses in your Home. 25. WAS Tustin. (a) Prior Use as MCAS Tustin. You are advised that the Community was previously used as the Tustin Marine Corps Air Station ("MCAS Tustin"). The Marine Corps and the Department of the Navy ("DON") are the responsible agencies for the Installation Restoration Program ("IRP'"). The IRP is a comprehensive environmental investigation and cleanup program formed to identify, investigate and clean up chemical and nuclear contamination that has resulted from past land use operations. When MCAS Tustin was an active base, it received a pennit from the California Department of Toxic Substances Control ("DTSC'I pursuant to the Federal Resources Conservation and Recovery Act ("RCRA') (42 U.S.C. 6901 et seq.) to store hazardous waste on portions of the base. One of the conditions of that permit was to perform "corrective action" to clean-up releases of hazardous waste constituents throughout the base. Although the permit has expired, these corrective action obligations continue, and the DON is undertaking environmental investigation and cleanup activities on portions of the former base that are within the Community. A ddb yl (b) Asbestos Containing Material and Lend -Based Paint. Hazardous material in the form of asbestos or asbestos -containing materials ("ACM") and lead-based paint ("LBP") have been found and are otherwise presumed to exist in buildings and structures previously located in the Community. At such time as demolition of the prior existing buildings on the Community containing ACM was completed, the appropriate governmental regulatory agency confirmed that ACM had been removed from the buildings and any necessary soil remediation had been conducted in accordance with all applicable federal, state and local laws and regulations. A state -certified lead consultant confirmed that the LBP from demolished structures was property removed and disposed of in accordance with all applicable federal, state, Q and local regulatory guidelines. &A (c) Easennent for Environmental Remediation. An easement over the Community granted to the United States of America, Acting by and through the Department of the Navy ("DON") in a document entitled "Quitclaim Deed for Marble Mountain Parcel and Environmental Restriction Pursuant to Civil Code Section 1471," was recorded on March 11, 2003, as Document No. 200300263521, OBuverinilinls. 2544.33253\CLP428\DISCLSR\609965.I0 11/16A)J In connection with ongoing remediation on the DON's property within the Community, it was agreed, as a covenant running wills the hind, that the DON and its officers, agents, employees, contractors and subcontractors shall have the right, upon reasonable notice, to enter the Community when a response or corrective scion is found to be necessary or when such access is necessary to carry out a response action or corrective action. The right for the DON to enter the Community shall include the right to conduct tests, investigations and surveys, including, where necessary, drilling, test -pitting, boring and other similar activities. Such right shall also include the right to construct, operate, naintain or undertake any other response or corrective action as required or necessary, including, but not limited to, monitoring wells, pumping wells, treatment facilities, and the installing of associated utilities. In exercising these rights of access, except in the case of imminent and substamial endangerment to human health or the environments the DON shall give reasonable notice of any action to be taken related to such remedial or corrective actions on the Community. Further, the DON will make reasonable efforts to minimize interference with the on going use of the Community and act in good faith to minimize any conflict between the necessary environmental investigation and remediation activities and the use of the Community. The DON is not required to restore or repair any Improvements in the Community damaged as a result of this right to access the Community. If any Improvements on Association Property are damaged as a result of the DON's access to the Community, you are advised that any such damaged Improvement may be repaired or replaced by the Community Association and you may be charged a Reconstruction Assessment or Extraordinary Assessment (if applicable). (d) Grouuriwater Plunw. The City Environmental Impact Report (1999) ("EIR") indicates the presence of subsurface plumes of chlorinated volatile organic compounds ("VOCs"), dissolved trichloroethene ("TCE") and methyl tertiary -butyl ether ("MTBE") at ground water level in portions of MCAS Tustin located outside the Community. It is presently unknown whether and to what extent these contaminants will migrate towards the Community. According to the EIR, estimated human health risks associated with residential use of groundwater from the plumes are above the acceptable limits of the United States Environmental Protection Agency. Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders make no representations or warranties with respect to the plumes described above or whether such plumes will migrate into the groundwater under Community. Gk&1A ltd ROM yf-DL 26. Early Transfer Property/Environmental Conditions. Due to its prior use as a military base, certain areas within the Community known in the Navy's environmental investigation programa -13S" and "IRP -13W" (collectively, the "Early Transfer �d Propertv'l. to arly Transfer Property was owned by the United States of America acting by and through the DON until February, 2008, when it was transferred to Master Developer and ply I annexed into the Covered Property pursuant to Section 16.6 of the Community Declaration. The u t S y Early Transfer Property is defined as the "LIFOC Property" in the Community Declaration. ---,A Week (a) Prior Uses of the Earp Transfer Property �h td fV011► 14 VO L' ('r) IRP -135. That portion of the Early Transfer Property identified as IRP -13S is approximately 0.7 acres and was previously used as a "Temporary Storage Area" ("TSA") and as a "Miscellaneous Wash Area" ("MICA"). The TSA consisted of two (2) buildings that were used for vehicle maintenance. Cleaning solvents were reportedly used as a Buvel billials. J ., i._ 2 44-3325g1CLI'428\DISCLSR\609"5.I0 11/ltilny degreaser to wash down boors in the buildings and waste solvent was likely released to storm drains, or to the ground outside the building. The MWA incktdes an inactive wash pad formerly used for cleaning small generators and other fireM equipment. Solvents were used in this area and may have been released to the subsurface through cracks in the concrete pad. That portion Gh(tn*d of the t..arly Transfer Property identified as IRP 13W was previously used as a former disposal area where hydraulic fluid, diesel fuel, leaded gasoline, oil, paint stripper, battery acid and solvent were stored. 11 - _ V. That portion of the Early Transfer Property identified as .,dAn# &4 IRP -13W was previously used as a former disposal area where hydraulic fluid, diesel fuel, Y' `"r % leaded gasoline, oil, paint stripper, battery acid and solvents were stored. This area was paved and cleared of stored materials. (b) Release (If Volatile Orgawir Cimrnunds. As a result of the historic use of the Early Transfer Property, hazardous substances have been released into the soil and L-woundwater at the Carly Transfer Property. Volatile Organic Compounds ("VOCs"), including trichloroethene ("TCE"), 1,2,3-tricliloropropane ("1,2,3-TCP1'), and related chlorinated organic solvents, were found in soil and groundwater at concentrations that could result in adverse effect to human health (including without limitation, cancer risks) if this water was extracted from the ground and directly used for domestic purposes such as drinking or bathing. However, groundwater at this location is currently not used for such purposes. (c) Remedial Action Plan. As a result of the release of hazardous substances 00\at the Early Transfer Property, various remedial activities have occurred or shall occur at the Carly Transfer Property and will continue to occur until remediation goals have been achieved. T ► yo Furthermore, institutional controls will be put in place at the time of transfer of the Early "-'Transfer Property and will include restrictions consistent with the protection of human health a1r 0 and the environment, as discussed in Paragraph (d) below. (i) IRP -13S. In October 2004, the DON issued a report entitled "Final Record of Decision/Remedial Action Plan, Operable Unit IA, Former Marine Corps Air Station, Tustin, California" ("ROD"), which describes a specific remedial action plan ("RAP") that has been approved for IRI' -13S to address groundwater contamination. As documented in the ROD, "[g]roundwater is the only medium that presents a risk to human health at the site. Soil, however, is also being addressed as part of the groundwater remedy because of the potential for residual contaminants in soil to act as a continuing source of groundwater contamination" Pursuant to the ROD, the selected remedy for groundwater at IRP -13S includes hydraulic containment of VOC-contaminated groundwater combined with excavation and off-site disposal of the most highly contaminated source areas ("hot spots"). Treated soil would be used for excavation backfill and treated water from the treatment system would be discharged to a city of Tustin storm drain, ultimately discharging into Peters Canyon Channel. Actual or threatened releases of hazardous substances from groundwater at IRP -13S, if not addressed by implementing the remedial action selected in the ROD/RAP, may present a potential threat to public health and welfare or to the environment. Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders make no representations, guarantees or warranties with respect to whether the remedial action selected in the ROD/RAP has been or will be implemented 11or IRP-t3S. © Duyer Initials: 2544_332531CLP42801SCLSR1609%5.10 11/16/09 ,W 'L,A ) IIfF'-1341'. In September, 2008, the DON published a report entitled "Draft Final Feasibility Study Report for Operable Unit 4B [includes IRP -13W), Former Marine Corps Air Station, Tustin, California," ('Feasibility Study') which addresses a range of remedial alternatives to address the VOCs in groundwater. As documented in the Feasibility Study, "no further action was recommended for soil at OU -40 sites... therefore, soil remediation..." was not addressed in the Feasibility Study. As ofthe datee of this disclosure, the Feasibility Study is currently being circulated for comments, and upon approval will be followed by a proposed plan and a final Record of Decision. No final remedy has been selected for IRP - QW. Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders make no representations, guarantees or warranties with respect to whether or when a final groundwater remedial action plan has been or will be selected or implemented for IRP -13W. OWN L. fty, rol " (d) Earlr Transfer of the Early Transfer Property and Land Use Restrictions. The DISC, the environmental agency responsible frff overseeing cleanup activities at MCAS Tustin, has determined that the Early Transfer Property is suitable for residential use in their current condition. Specifically, the DTSC has concluded: "!n reviewing the enviromnental investigations and human health risk assessments conducted at the site to determine what types of restrictions to impose in that land use covenant, DTSC determined that it was not necessary to impose any restrictions on residential use or any other type q/' land use at the parcels, but instead just limit certain types of activities. " Iv YJ�►U Because the surface of the Early Transfer Property lies over an area of groundwater contamination which is undergoing active remediation by the Navy, the transfer of the Early Transfer Property from the federal government was considered an "early transfer" requiring the approval of the governor after the Navy issued a Draft Final Finding of Suitability for Early Transfer for a Portion of Parcel 24 (Early Transfer Parcel 24-1) Within Carve -Out 5, Former Marine Corps Air Station, Tustin, California" ("FOSET") on February 13, 2007. The governor provided that approval upon the recommendation of the DTSC, which determined that the Early Transfer Property was suitable for residential use after review of all of the environmental data, including investigations of the potential for contamination from groundwater or soil vapor to impact indoor air. Generally, environmental remedial actions must be completed prior to property transfer. However, Section 120(h)(3)(C) of the Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation, and Liability Act ("CERCLA") allows deferral of the requirement that the United States provide a covenant in the deed conveying property, warranting that all remedial action necessary to protect human health and the environment has been taken before the date of transfer. Specifically, CERCLA Section 120(h)(3)(C)(i)(11) requires that the deed or other agreement governing the transfer contain assurances, among other things, that provide for any necessary restrictions on the use of the property to ensure the protection of human health and the environment, as follows: (i) Any necessary restriction on the use of the property will be implemented to ensure protection of human health and the environment; Buyer Initials: _. / -14- 2544-33253\C'LP428\DISCLSR\ 609W)SAI 11116M (ii) Restrictions will be implemented cat use, as necessary, to ensure that required remedial investigations (RI), response actions, and oversight activities will not be disrupted; (iii) All necessary response actions will be taken and will identify schedules for investigation and completion of all necessary response actions, as approved by the appropriate regulatory agency; and (iv) The DON will submit a budget request to the Director of the Office of Management and Budget that adequately addresses schedules for investigation and completion of all necessary response actions, subject to congressional authorizations and appropriations, yi mtei "detA -FPM LAM VOW4 On February 13, 2007, the DON issued the FOSET to request transfer of the Early Transfer Property prior to completion of all remedial actions pursuant to CERCLA Section 120(li)(3XC). The FOSET presented the findings that the Early Transfer Property, which is still in the remediation process, is environmentally suitable for transfer prior to completing all remedial action pursuant to the provisions of CERCLA and that the Early Transfer Property has been designated as part of Early Transfer Parcel 24-1 ("ETP 24-1"). The DON has determined that there is a potential for exposure to CERCLA hazardous substances at ETP 24-1, and associated groundwater plumes. Restrictions on the land use of ETP 24-1 (including, without limitation, the Early Transfer Property) to ensure protection of human health and the environment are set forth in one or more documents entitled "Covenant to Restrict Use of YV Property Environmental Restriction", more particularly defined in Paragraph 6 h ii an 'vI Paragraph 26(h)(iii) below, (collectively, the "Covenants') between the United States, actingwl through the DON, and the State of California acting by and through the California Department of�� Toxic Substances Control ("DTSC".) through deed restrictions set forth in the FOSET. As of the date of this disclosure, the transfer of the Early Transfer Property has occurred, however, environmental remedial actions at the Early Transfer Property have not yet been completed. You should review the notifications and additional disclosures contained in the FOSET concerning IRP -13S and IRP -13W, as well as school site considerations, hazardous substances and petroleum products, underground storage tanks, lead based paint, asbestos - containing materials, radon, groundwater monitoring wells, polycholorinated biphenyl, indoor air quality, oil -water separators and other areas of concern within or near the vicinity of the Early 1: eIWIN Transfer Property. Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders make no representations, LAM guarantees or warranties with respect to if or when the FOSET will be finalized.. V ro pt0l (e) DTSC Restrictions. The only restrictions DTSC determined to be necessary on the Early Transfer Property were restrictions against certain types of excavations and other activities which could disturb groundwater or disturb the groundwater remediation Nn(' systems, which restrictions are contained in the Covenants. In addition, the Master Developer 'ifu� has prepared and recorded the Supplemental Declaration (as defined in Paragraph 26(h)(i) below) in a manner satista€tory to DTSC to ensure that these activity restrictions will be monitored and enforced, Furthermore, these deed restrictions are referenced in the purchaser deeds to buyers purchasing Homes located in the Early Transfer Property. � O Buyer Inivak /.. M j. 2544.33233\CLP4281D1.SCL5R\ 609965.10 11/16/09 (t) Engineering Controls Within &ff& Transfer Property. All residential $ruetures on the Early Transfer Property will be cos>strtteted with one of the following ' engineering controls: (i) a sub -slab venting system; or (ii) a LIQUID BOOTO Gas Vapor Barrier System, (iii) or an alternative control that is determined by either the City of Tustin or the DTSC to provide equivalent protection. (g) Inspection and Compliance Reporterag Obligations,, Indemnftation. The Board of Directors of the Community Association shall be responsible for site inspections of th"arly Transfer Property and annual compliance reporting to address the monitoring and maintenance necessary to ensure compliance with the restrictions and terms of the Covenant. r !„ .�d You shall not interfere with the Community Association's performance of such inspection and U�`` compliance reporting obligations. rem (h) Documentation Relating to the Release aril Remediation Activities. Utensive documentation has been pre aced that describes the nature and extent of the release of r us su stances that has occurred at the Early Transfer Property. The following reports are lable for public review and document the investigation and remediation work that has been ill be performed at the Early Transfer Property: (i) Supplemental Declaration to Master Declaration of Covenants, Conditions, Restrictions and Reservation of Easements for Columbus Square (Early Transfer Parcel (ETP) 24-1A and 24 -IB), made by Moffett Meadows Partners, LLC, a Delaware limited liability company and consented to by the Community Association, which was recorded on Llold ec February 29, 2008, as Instrument No. 2008000093933, and re-recorded on June 26, 2008, as Instrument No. 2008000307660 (together with any amendment thereto, collectively, the "Stzpplenrental Declaration'), in the Official Records of Orange County, California (the "Q#11cial Records"). (ii) Covenant to Restrict Use of Property Environmental Restriction (Re: Former Marine Corps Air Station Tustin) Early Transfer Parcel (ETP) 24-1A (Portion of Parcel 24) made by and between the United States, acting through the DON, and the State of California acting by and through the DTSC, which was recorded on February 28, 2008, as Instrument No. 2008000090055, of Official Records; (iii) Covenant to Restrict Use of Property Environmental Restriction (Re: Former Marine Corps Air Station Tustin) Early Transfer Parcel (ETP) 24 -IB (Portion of Parcel 24) made by and between the United States, acting through the DON, and the State of California acting by and through the DTSC, which was recorded on February 28, 2008, as Instrument No. 2008000090056, and re-recorded on June 5, 2008, as Instrument No. 2008000270235, both of Official Records; (iv) Draft Final Finding of Suitability for Early Transfer for a Portion of Parcel 24 (Early Transfer Parcel 24-1) Within Carve -Out 5, Former Marine Corps Air Station, Tustin, California (Department of Navy, February 13, 2007); BuyelInitials: _._'..j{�_ 2544-33253CL142MISCLSM 609963A 0 1 iaiMN Re (v) Draft (60°10 Design Submittal) Remedial Design, Hydraulic Containment with Hot Spot Removal, Operable Units IA and 113, Former Marine Corps Air Station, Tustin:, California (Department of Navy, June 2005); (vi) Draft Feasibility Study Report For Operable Unit 4B, Former Marine Corps Air Station, Tustin, California, August 2005 (Bechtel Environmental, Inc., August 20(15); (vii) Final Record of Decision/Ranedial Action Plan Operable Unit IA, Former Marine Corps Air Station, Tustin, California (Department of Navy. October 2004); (viii) Final Feasibility Study Report, OL1-IA, Marine Corps Air Station, Tustin, California (Bechtel Environmental, Inc., August 2003), and (ix) Final Environmental Impact Statement/Environmental Impact Report, Disposal and Reuse of MCAS Tustin, California (Department of Navy and City of Tustin, December 1999). You should carefully review these reports before making a decision to buy a. Home in the Community. Copies of the reports are available for review at either (1) BRAC Environmental Coordinator's Office, Library Building 307, MCAS EI Toro, telephone (949) 726-5398 or (2) University of California at Irvine Langson Library, Government Publication Department, Irvine, CA, (949) 824-7362 or (949) 824-6836. For information regarding the environmental documents prepared for former MCAS Tustin, please contact the Administrative Records Division by calling (61.9) 532-3673, located at Building 1, 937 Harbor Drive, San Diego, California 92132, or the BRAC Information Repository Office located at 7040 Trabuco Road, Building 307 on the former WAS EI Toro, (949) 726-5398. The Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders make no representations or warranties with respect to the Early Transfer Property and the environmental conditions described above or in the reports. Due to the fact that groundwater in the Community has been found at depths of six (6) to seventeen (17) feet below the ground surface, you are prohibited from drinking any groundwater pursuant to covenants recorded against the Community and is advised to avoid eating any fruit from trees with deep root systems in the Community. You are also advised to keep children and animals away from such fruit, soil and groundwater. Should any Person come into contact with such fruit, soil or groundwater, such Person is advised to wash thoroughly with soap and water and seek immediate medical attention. (i) Surrounding Areas. The following items have been indicated in the EIR as affecting portions of MCAS Tustin that are outside of the Community. These items are not expected to impact the Community, and are listed in this Disclosure for your information only. Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders make no representations or warranties as to any future impact these items may have on the Community or Residents using public parks and other areas outside the Community. Buyer Initials: 1 (i) Former crash drill site area; (ii) Former skeet ranges; 17- 2544-33253\CLP4284)lS4ULSR\ 60()9 X5.1(1 1111 %AV) fofV"%N� Ueo!- (iii) Transformers containing polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs); (iv) Buildings formerly on property containing lead-based paint. where J� '1 l abatement or removal activities may not have been enmpleted; i'✓1 C�j (v) Moffit Meadow fire fighting ttaehs and crash crew burn pits; (vi) JP -3 pipeline, currently classified as out of service; and (vii) Petroleum hydrocarbons in subsurface soil. If you have any questions or concerns about environmental activities at MCAS Tustin or the Community, please contact the Local Redevelopment Authority at the City of Tustin or visit the United States Naval Facilities Engineering Command's internet website at www.efdsw.tiavfac.navy.iiiii/EnvironmentaUTustin.htm. 27. Prior Agricultural Use. The Community is located on or near lands that are or were previously used for agricultural purposes, including farming operations. By reason of such agricultural use, you may be subject to dust, noise and odors and may be exposed to pesticides, herbicides, insecticides and other chemicals. By acceptance of a deed to a Home, you (on your own behalf, and on behalf of the members of your family, tenants, lessees, guests and invitees) expressly acknowledge and accept these existing and future impacts and forever waive any and all causes of actions against the Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders and Community Association and their. respective directors, officers, employees, agents, representatives and consultants for any damages or injuries which may arise from or relate to any such conditions or risks. 28. The Village Conservatory. The Community includes a private recreational center (the "Conservatory"). The Conservatory includes swimming and wading pools, spa, a recreational building and related facilities. While the Conservatory is planned to be private and only open to Owners and guests in the Community, the public will have access to the Open Space/Park areas surrounding the Conservatory (the "Village Green") and use of the outdoor recreational facilities in the Village Green which include, but are not limited to, an open turf area, tot lot, BBQ and picnic areas. The Village Green is maintained by the Community Association. All persons using the Conservatory are required to use caution and to watch their children at all times to prevent drowning and other injuries. The Community Association may, n from time to time, promulgate rules for use and operation of the Conservatory, including `r , reasonable hours of operation. Owners and other residents living in the area of the Conservatory and the Village Green will most likely experience and otherwise be subject to or inconvenienced by noise and pedestrian and vehicular traffic in the areas surrounding the Conservatory and the Village Green. 29. Natural Hazard Zone Disclosures. Your Neighborhood Builder will provide you with a Natural Hazard Disclosure Statement in compliance with Section 1103 of the California Civil Code that discloses whether your Home is located in a seismic hazard :tone. (a) Earthquakes. California is subject to a wide range of earthquake activity. California has many known earthquake faults as well as yet undiscovered faults. While the 6uyerinitials. / �,�„ _tom'.. X54-3-33258\{�LPa28\DISCLSR\t'+0996910 11/160) Community is not located in an Alquist Priolo Earthquake Zone, earthquakes are always a possibility. You must evaluate the potential for future seismic activity that may seriously damage your Homesite and Home. A major earthquake, which some have predicted will occur in our lifetimes, could cause very serious damage to Homes located even many miles from the epicenter of the earthquake. A more moderate earthquake occurring on a more minor fault, or on an as yet undiscovered fault, could also cause substantial damage. For more information, read "The Homeowners Guide to Earthquake Safety" which explains the various geological hazards associated with earthquakes and contains information on planning ahead for earthquakes, as well as what to do during and after an earthquake. Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders make no representations or warranties as to the degree of earthquake risk in the Community. You are advised to consult with the City, County, other public agencies and appropriate experts to evaluate the potential risk. (b) Seismic Hazard Zones. Many portions of California are subject to risks associated with seismic activity. Areas that meet the definition of "Seismic Hazard Zone" in the Seismic Hazards Mapping Act (California Public Resources Code Section 2690, et seq.) are shown on maps that are prepared and released by the California Department of Conservation, Division of Mines and Geology. Such zones may pose an increased risk of damage to property from earthquakes and liquefaction. "Liquefaction" is the process by which water -saturated soils become unstable under heaving shaking and thereby jeopardize foundations and other structures. The Master Developer has been informed that all or a portion of the Community is located within a Seismic Hazard Zone. You are advised to consult with the City, County, other public agencies and appropriate experts to evaluate the potential risk. For more information concerning seismic activity and risks, read "The Homeowner's Guide to Earthquake Safety." (c) Area of Potential Flooding. The Master Developer has been informed that the Community is located within an Area of Potential Flooding (or Dam Inundation Zone) pursuant to applicable maps. The Office of Emergency Services is required to designate areas within which personal injuryor death would, in its determination, result from the partial or total failure of any dam. These areas of potential flooding, as defined in the California Emergency Services Act (California Government Code Section 8984.4, et seg.), are shown on maps released by the Office of Emergency Services, copies of which are also on file with the City. These maps are updated periodically, and the Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders and Community Association make no representations, guarantees or warranties with respect to any future dam inundation zone determinations. The Community is downstream from the Santiago Creek Dam, an earthfill dam approximately one hundred and thirty-six (136) feet high which has a capacity of 25,000 acre feet of water. Santiago Creek Dam is jointly owned and maintained by the Serrano Irrigation District and the Irvine Ranch Water District. Information about the Santiago Creek Dam can be found on the California Department of Water Resources website: littp://cdee.water.ca.gov/inisc/resinfo.htnil, Please contact the Office of Emergency Services for further information concerning Areas of Potential Flooding. 30, Soil Conditions. In purchasing your Home, you should. review soils reports for the Community, available for review at the City, and take into consideration the following: (a) Expansive Soil. According to the soils report, soil in the Community is highly expansive in nature. Expansive soil expands when it becomes wet and it contracts when Buyer initials: / F _19- 2544-33253\CLP428\DISCLSR\ 6119965.10 11/16/09 it dries out. Expansion and contraction of soils may cause movement, lifting, cracking and distress in slabs, patios, sidewalks and other flatwork improvements. Some cracking is normal in all flatwork improvements, with or without expansive soils. However, some expansion damage may be reduced by use of appropriate design and construction techniques. When designing flatwork and other improvements, you should advise your consultants that designs must accommodate soils with expansion potential. In addition, you should consider the following information and recommendations before making or modifying any Improvements. (b) Concrete and Masonry Improvements. Special attention is required in designing and constructing concrete and masonry Improvements such as masonry walls and planters, concrete slabs and decking. For example, steel reinforcing bars may be required in lieu of steel mesh in concrete patio slabs. Block walls may require extra horizontal and vertical steel reinforcing bars. (c) Drainage and Irrigation. Owners must use adequate drainage and irrigation control. Drainage devices installed in the Community by the Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders should not be altered in any manner that will redirect or obstruct drainage through these devices. The construction or modification of Improvements should not result in ponding of water. Drainage devices, including, but not limited to, concrete ditches, area drain lines and gutters should be carefully designed and installed with professional assistance and then maintained in an unobstructed condition. Drainage devices installed by the Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders designed to serve more than the one (1) Home should not be altered in a manner that will redirect or obstruct the drainage through these drainage devices. The landscape irrigation system should be designed, constructed and operated to prevent excessive saturation of soils. Water must drain away from the Home footings and other Improvements. Obstructions such as walls should not be constructed across swales unless adequate replacement drainage Improvements have been installed or created. Planters should be lined with an impervious surface and should contain outlets to drain excess water. (d) Fill Sail. Homes in the Community may be constructed on fill soil in accordance with the recommendations and inspection of licensed civil and soils engineers. A soils report certifying the compaction of fill soils is available for review at the City. (e) Corrosive Soil. Soils in some areas of the Community are potentially severely corrosive to buried concrete and ferrous metals. Soluble sulfates and acidic soils are highly corrosive to buried metals and concrete and should be taken into account in the construction of below grade structures and hardscape. Sulfates may chemically and physically attack concrete thatis not sulfate resistant, causing the concrete to break down. Thus, you must use the proper type of cement and water -to -cement ratio for the level of sulfates or acidity that exists on your Homesite. Overwatering soil will exacerbate the corrosivity of the soil. You should inform contractors of this potential condition to allow them to use appropriate measures to combat the effects of corrosive soil on buried metals, below grade structures and hardscape. (f) Groundwater. Groundwater has been encountered in portions of the Community at depths of six (6) to twenty-five (25) feet below the ground surface. You may not dig or drill on any Homesite to a depth that would disturb or otherwise come in contact with the groundwater. Groundwater may rise during the rainy season. littyerInitials: / -20- 2544-33253\CLP428\DiSCLSR\609965.10 11/16/09 (g) PoohOpas. Prior to designing any poiA, spa., or other similar amenity, it is recommended you consult with a licensed civil engineer to determine the depth of the water table under your Homesite to insure that your Improvements are compatible with the depth of the water table and that they will not disturb or come in contact with the groundwater during a rainy season. The Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders make no guarantee that any Homesite has the ability for pool or spa installation. Homesites 242 through 245, inclusive, ot. Tract No. 16581, which are located within the Early Transfer Property, have been determinect_to'rtw be unsuitable for installation of pools, spas or other similar amenity. The deeds for these Lots will contain deed restrictions that prohibit the use of the Lots for such purposes. i Vl (h) Soils Professionals. Before starting a pool or spa or any patio, concrete or other flatwork on the Homesitc, you should consult with a licensed soils engineer to ensure that such work is constructed correctly in light of current soils conditions. Although consulting with a soils professional may add substantially to the cost of installation of improvements, failure to do so may result in significant breaking lifting, separating, tilting or cracking in improvements. (i) Interior Gases and Olker Contaminants. The aging process of soil and natural soil elements, as well as the aging of man-made building materials, may create unwanted and undesired gases and other contaminants in Homes, both new and previously occupied. In addition, a lower rate of air exchange between outdoor and indoor environments has resulted from modern construction techniques which comply with energy conservation requirements enacted by the State of California. A lower air exchange rate can result in the build-up of ® unwanted gases and other contaminants in varying degrees. As the quality of the air we breathe can affect our health, you should frequently air out your Home by opening the windows. 31. Post -Tension Concrete System. Your Home may have been built using a post - tension concrete system ("Svstern'J. If any portion of ,your Home has been constructed using the System, a placard or stamp will be placed in the garage signifying the existence of such System. The System involves placing steel cables under high tension in the concrete slab located beneath the Home. Therefore, any attempt to alter or pierce the foundation (for example, sawing cutting or drilling) could damage the integrity of the System and cause serious injury or damage to persons and property. The Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders shall not be responsible for any damage or injury resulting from or arising in connection with the alteration of the slab or foundation of any Home. By acceptance of a deed to a Home, you agree that: (i) you shall not cut into or otherwise tamper with the System; (ii) you shall not knowingly permit or allow any other person to cut into or tamper with the System so long as you own any interest in the Home; (iii) you shall disclose the existence of the System to any person who rents, leases or purchases your Home; and (iv) you shall indemnify and hold the Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders and all of their affiliated entities, officers, directors, agents and assigns free and harmless from any and all claims, damages, losses or other liability (including attorneys' fees and costs) arising from any breach of this covenant. 32. Reclaimed Water. In its efforts to conserve water, the Irvine Ranch Water District (the "Water District") requires the use of reclaimed water (treated wastewater) to irrigate parks, school yards, golf courses, greenbelt areas and common areas. The Water District may require the use of reclaimed water to irrigate landscaping in private yards. The water used in the Homes and outside in the patio and yard areas through hose bibs will be domestic potable Buyer Initials: _. _ % _. _. _ _._ _._ _ 2:544.33253NUP42AUSCLSR\ 60996510 1116kx1 water. The water used to irrigate the Association Property may include reclaimed water. Reclaimed water is not potable and therefore not suitable for human cation. As with any water overspray, the repeated spray of reclaimed water may staim or discolor personal property, fencing and structural Improvements. According to the Water District, the Water District's reclairned water is disinfected with chlorine and its clarity to the human eye is indistinguishable from domestic water. The standards imposed on the Water District for reclaimed water quality are established by governmental regulatory agencies, and these standards are subject to change. The Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders and Community Association and their agents are not liable for any property damage or personal injury by reclaimed water. You are subject to Water District rules and regulations, one of which prohibits the use of self -generating water softeners connected to Water District sewer facilities. Further information regarding Water District regulations is available at the Water District's headquarters. 33. Electric Power Lines. Underground or overhead electric transmission and (� distribution lines and transformers are located in and around the Community, which lines and �1 transformers are owned and maintained by Southern California Edison Company. Southern California Edison may increase the number of transmission and distribution lines and the electric current through such lines. Power lines and transformers produce extremely low -frequency electromagnetic fields ( "ELF -EMF') when operating. For some time, there has been speculation in the scientific community about health risks associated with living near ELF -EMF sources. In 1992, the United States Congress authorized the Electric and Magnetic Fields Research and Public Information Dissemination Program to perform research on these issues and to analyze the existing scientific evidence in order to clarify the potential for health risks from exposure to ELF -EMF. In May of 1999, the National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences ("'NIEHS") issued a report to Congress summarizing its review of scientific data from over three hundred (300) studies on ELF -EMF health risks, The ELF -EMF studies consist of both epidemiological studies (studies of exposure in human populations) and controlled laboratory experiments on animal and cell models. While some epidemiological studies suggested some link between certain health effects and exposure to ELF -EMF, the laboratory experiments did not support such a link. According to the NIERS report, the scientific evidence shows no clear pattern of health hazards from ELF -EMF exposure, and the NIERS report did not find evidence of any link sufficient to recommend widespread changes in the design or use of electrical transmission equipment. However, because the evidence does not clearly rule out any effect, NIEHS advocated continuing inexpensive and safe reductions in exposure to ELF -EMF and endorsed current utility practices regarding design and siting of new transmission and distribution lines. Further information on this subject is available from the Regional EMF Manager, Southern California Edison Company, 1851 West Valencia Drive, Fullerton, California 92833. Additional information on ELF -EMF and copies of the NIEHS report are available from the EMF -RAPID website at www.nielis.niii.eov/enifral2id/home.htm. 34. Air Quality. Southern California is subject to Stage I smog alerts. You should take advantage of the Air Quality Management District's ("A.Q.M.D.") forecasts to plan your outdoor activities to avoid peak pollution by checking your television, radio or daily newspapers to find out if unhealthful air quality is expected. For more information, you can also call A.Q.M.D. at 1 -800 -CUT -SMUG (1-800-288-7664) or check their website at www.agni(i.gov. ntlyulmnals _?�_ 2544-33253UCLNMDISCLSM 609965.10 111160) By acceptance of a deed to a Home, you (for and on your behalf, and the members of your family, tenants, lessees, guests and invitees) expressly acknowledge and accept the existing and possible future impacts of smog on yourself and your family and forever waive any and all causes of actions against the Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders and their respective directors, officers, employees, agents, representatives and consultants for any damages or injuries which may arise from or relate to any such conditions or risks. 35. Wind. All of Southern California is subject to periods of high winds. Wind speeds in the Community may exceed that experienced in other areas of the surrounding region. You must ensure that any structures or other Improvements you install on your Homesite are constructed or designed to withstand high winds. You are advised to consult with experienced architects and engineers in the design and specification of any structures or Improvements that you plan to add. 36. Private Streets. All of the streets within the Community are private streets. Maintenance and repair of the private streets is the responsibility of the Community Association or the Neighborhood Associations, as applicable. 37. Building Setbacks. Construction of Improvements in the yard of any Homesite such as pools, spas, patio covers, BBQ, fountains, trellises and water features are subject to minimum setback and height restrictions and may not be permitted. You should refer to the Community Association Governing Documents and applicable City ordinances for any restrictions concerning the construction of any Improvements to your Homesite. 38. Boundaries. You may not rely on any written or oral statements by Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders or their agents regarding the exact boundaries of your Homesite or Home or whether any wall or fence has been or will be constructed exactly on the boundaries of your Homesite. 39. Square Footage Representations. Representations of square footage are approximate only. You may not rely on any written (brochures and other sales documents) or verbal statements by Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders or their agents regarding the exact square footage of your Homesite or Home. The computation of square footage varies based on the criteria used. You agree by acceptance of a deed to a Home to hold the Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders harmless in any dispute arising over any representations concerning the square footage of your Homesite or Home. TAXES AND ASSESSMENTS 44. Supplemental Real Property Taxes. The California law requires real property to be revalued whenever it changes ownership or when improvements are newly constructed. After the Close of Escrow for your Home, the County of Orange Tax Assessor ("Assessor") will determine a new taxable value for your Home based on current market values. The property tax will increase and you will receive one or more supplemental tax bilis depending upon the time of the year in which Escrow closed for the purchase of your Home. Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders have no control over the valuation, timing or 'the amount of the Buyer Initials: �J .23_ 2544-33253TU42MISCISM 609965.10 11/16/09 supplemental bill resulting from the reassessment, You are solely responsible for the payment of any supplemental tax bills. The following notice is given pursuant to Section 1102.6c of the California Civil Code: "California property tax law requires the Assessor to revalue real property at the time the ownership of the property changes. Because of this law, you may receive one or two supplemental tax bills, depending on when your loan closes. The supplemental tax bills are not mailed to your lender. If you have arranged for your property tax payments to be paid through an impound account, the supplemental tax bills will not be paid by your lender. It is your responsibility to pay these supplemental bills directly to the Tax Collector. If you have any question concerning this matter, please call your local Tax Collector's Office." Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders have no control over the valuation, timing or the amount of the supplemental bill resulting from the reassessment. You are solely responsible for the payment of the supplemental tax bill. You hereby acknowledge, accept and agree that neither Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders nor any of their authorized agents, representatives, employees or sales people have made any representations or warranties respecting the amount of the supplemental assessment or the assessed value. Should you have any questions or concerns relating to the supplemental assessment, you agree, prior to the Close of Escrow, to consult with the County Assessor or your legal or other advisors to satisfy such questions or concerns. 41. Estimated Taxes. You have been provided with an estimate of your assessments. THE AMOUNT OF ASSESSMENTS ARE ESTIMATES ONLY, and are based on current information provided by the City, County or those public or private agencies responsible for the administration for the districts. These assessments may INCREASE or DECREASE, based upon changes in real property tax law; the district(s) may dissolve; formation of new districts may occur, an extension of the districts or the services to the districts and other factors NOT IN MASTER DEVELOPER'S OR NEIGHBORHOOD BUILDER'S CONTROL may transpire. The amount of special taxes may appear on your property tax bill or may be billed separately. 42. Special Tax Assessment Districts. All or a portion of the Community lies within the boundaries of the following Special Tax and Assessment Districts: (a) Community Facilities District No. 06-1. Several Neighborhoods in the Community are located within the boundaries of City of Tustin Community Facility District No. 06-1 ("CFD No. 06-1' which was formed for the construction and maintenance of public improvements, including, but not limited to, street improvements, parkway and landscaping, stone drains, utilities, public parks, public libraries and fire protection facilities. If your Home is located within CFD No. 06-1, your Home will be subject to any taxes, assessments and obligations associated with CFD No. 06-1. You will be provided with *a Notice of Special Tax for CFD No. 06-1. This Notice contains important information about district functions, your obligations, rights of the district, and information on how to contact the district for additional information materials. You should carefully read and understand the information contained in Buyer Initials: / -24- 2544-33253\CLA428\DISCLSR\ 609965.10 11/16/09 the Notice. Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders have no control over the amount of tax assessments levied or imposed against your Home or any increase or decrease in the amount of such assessments. Please contact the City of Tustin (City Clerk), telephone (714) 573-3025 for additional information. (b) Tustin Unified School District Community Facilities District No. 06-1. Several Neighborhoods in the Community are located within the boundaries of Tustin Unified School District Community Facility District No. 06-1 ("TUSDCFD No. 06-111 which was formed for the construction of elementary, middle and high school facilities and any improvements in connection with such facilities. If your Home is located within TUSDCFD No. 06-1, your Home will be subject to any taxes, assessments and obligations associated with TUSDCFD No. 06-1. You will be provided with a Notice of Special Tax for TUSDCFD No. 06- 1. This Notice contains important information about district functions, your obligations, rights of the district, and information on how to contact the district for additional information materials. You should carefully read and understand the information contained in the Notice. Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders have no control over the amount of tax assessments levied or imposed against your Home or, any increase or decrease in the amount of such assessments. Please contact the City of Tustin (City Clerk), telephone (714) 573-3025 for additional information. The Neighborhood Builder will provide you with disclosures entitled "Notice of Special Tax" ("Notice'l prior to entering into a contract to purchase a Home. These Notices will inform you of the special tax and assessment districts that apply to your Home. The Notices will also contain a detailed description of the special tax calculation, important information about functions and rights of the special tax and assessment districts, your obligations, and who to contact for additional information about the special tax and assessment districts. You should thoroughly understand the information contained in the Notices prior to entering into a contract to purchase a Home. You will have five days after the Notice is delivered by mail, or three days after its delivery in person, to terminate the contract to purchase by giving written notice of that termination. All Homes will be subject to annual special taxes levied by one or more of the special tax and assessment districts listed above. Not all special tax or assessment districts listed above will apply to your Home. These special taxes will be a continuing lien on your Home and will be billed to you with the annual real property tax bill issued by the County Assessor. The lien of these special taxes will continue until the obligation is satisfied. If you fail to pay a special tax when due, the assessment districts may exercise their right to foreclose on your Home. Information concerning the estimated amount of the annual special tax on your Home for the special tax and assessment districts is available from the City and County. 43. Changes in Special Taxes. The amount of any special taxes disclosed to you are estimates only, and are based on current information provided by the City, County or other public or private agencies responsible for the administration of special tax districts. Special taxes may increase or decrease, based upon the terms of the special tax lien, changes in real property tax law, the dissolution of special tax districts, the formation of new special tax districts, extension of special tax district(s), changes in services by the districts and other facts Buyer Initials: / -25- 2544-3325ACLP428\1ASCLSRk609965.10 11/16/09 not in Master Developer's or Neighborhood Builders' control. The amount of special taxes may appear on your real property tax bill or may be billed separately. ADJACENT AREA DISCLOSURES 44. Adjacent Property Disclosures. The land adjacent to the Community within the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan has a variety of land use designations. The land use designations are subject to change. Therefore, the type of future development adjacent to the Community cannot be predicted with accuracy. 45. WAS Specific Plan. MCAS Tustin was realigned and closed on July 2, 1999, in accordance with Base Realignment and Closure Act. The Department of Defense recognized the City of Tustin as the Lead Agency or Local Redevelopment Authority ("LRA") for preparation of the required reuse planning documents in late 1991. The MCAS Tustin Specific Plan/Reuse Plan (the "P/an") includes detailed planning, policies, regulations, implementation strategies and procedures necessary to guide the reuse and development of the site into the next century. Since implementation of the Plan will be a long- term process and there are unique circumstances associated with converting military bases to civilian uses, the Plan is intended to be practical in economic terms and visionary in terms of its ability to create and respond to future market opportunities. This means that it must provide sufficient guidance to provide investors with a high confidence level that their investments will be protected. At the same time, it must offer sufficient flexibility to respond to changing market conditions. A careful balance between certainty and flexibility underlies the provisions of this Plan. The Plan is intended to serve as both a policy -oriented and regulatory document. The Plan has been submitted to the Department of Defense as a policy guide outlining the intended reuse for the Community. Subsequently, the Plan was adopted by the Tustin City Council by City Council Ordinance No. 1257 on February 3, 2003 as the zoning for the Community. The Plan may also be amended one or more times by the City of Tustin. The Plan is one device for implementing goals and policies of the Tustin General Plan. The Plan also contains the development and reuse regulations that constitute the zoning for the Community. As a federal installation, MCAS Tustin was not subject to local zoning and planning requirements. Upon conversion to civilian use, the former MCAS Tustin property will be under the jurisdictional authority of either the City of Tustin or the City of Irvine, as applicable, and will be subject to local codes and ordinances. The City of Irvine has assigned responsibility for preparation of the Plan (and accompanying joint Environmental Impact Statement/Environmental Impact Report) to Tustin for that portion of the Plan area within Irvine. However, the City of Irvine will have to adopt any General Plan and zoning changes necessary to implement the provisions of the Plan within the City of Irvine. The land uses described in the Plan for the area covered by the flan include, but are not limited to, Low -High Density Residential, Transitional and Affordable Housing, Golf Resort Living, Commercial Business and Retail, and Institutional/Recreational designations such as Buyer Initials: / _26- 2544-3325MCLI 42MISCLSR\ 609965.10 11!16104 Parks, Trails and Schools. Also recommended were applications by the Orange County Sheriffs Department, City of Tustin and County of Orange Social Service Agency. The Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders have no control over the Plan, changes to the Plan, or development of the area covered by the Plan in accordance with the Plan. For further information, you should review the Plan. The Plan and information regarding the development of the Plan is available for review at the office of the Local Redevelopment Agency, City of Tustin. 46. The District. The District is a one million square foot outdoor shopping center under development and is located approximately one and one-half (l'/:) miles southwest of the Community, at the corner of Jamboree Road and Barranca Parkway. The District includes, among other businesses, several retail stores, a grocery store and a movie theater. The District will result in increased noise and traffic in and around the Community, particularly along Jamboree Road and Barranca Parkway. Neither Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders nor the Community Association have any control over the use or maintenance of the District or its impact on the Community. 47. Rail Corridor/ Metrolink Station. As disclosed in the Homebuyer Notification, there is a rail corridor ("Corri-lor") located to the north of the Community. There is also a Metrolink station ( "Station ") located to the north of the Community at 2975 Edinger Avenue, Tustin, CA 92780. The impact of the Corridor and Station may include, without limitation, increased noise, light and vibration levels in the vicinity of the Community. The Corridor and Station could be an attractive nuisance to children and animals who may wish to play in the vicinity of the rail corridor. The Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders and the Community Association have no control over the use, maintenance or care of the Corridor or Station. You acknowledge and understand that you are responsible for keeping your children and animals away from the Corridor and Station and the danger that is inherent around the Corridor and Station. You should evaluate the impact of the Corridor and Station on your decision to purchase a Home in the Community. 48. Temporary Sewer Lift Station. A temporary sewer lift station has been constructed within the vicinity of the Community. It is located at the northeast corner of Kensington Drive and Valencia North Loop Road and will serve a portion of the Community until such time the master infrastructure is completed to connect your Homesite or Home to the main sewer lines. The lift station has been installed below -grade and will be owned and maintained by the Irvine Ranch Water District. Owners may encounter some odors in the areas near the lift station. You acknowledge, understand and agree that neither the Community Association nor the Neighborhood Builders will have any control over the use, maintenance or care of the lift station. 49. Areas Outside the Specific Plan. The MCAS Tustin Specific Plan, which is bounded by Edinger Avenue, Redhill Avenue, Barranca Parkway and Harvard Avenue has the following surrounding uses. (a) A rail corridor and Metrolink station (described above) are located along Edinger Avenue; and ® nuycr Initials: /_� -27- 2544-33253WI-11428USCLSM 60%5, 11/16/09 (b) Offices, commercial and light industrial areas are located along .Edinger Avenue and adjacent to the Community at Redhill and Edinger Avenues. The Master Developer, Neighborhood Builder and the Community Association Cr have no control over development outside of the Community. L 50. Airport Proximity Disrlosore. The Community is boated within what is known ' as an airport influence area (as defined in California Civil Code Section 1353) surrounding John Wayne Airport. John Wayne Airport is located approximately 3.6 miles southwest of the Community at the (405) San Diego Freeway and MacArthur Boulevard in the City of Santa Ana. For that reason, the Community may be subject to some of the annoyances or inconveniences associated with proximity to airport operations (for example: noise, vibration or odors). Individual sensitivities to those annoyances can vary from person to person. You may wish to consider what airport annoyances, if any, are associated with the Community before you complete your purchase and determine whether they are acceptable to you. John Wayne Airport has noise abatement procedures in place, but there is no guarantee that these procedures will lessen the impacts on the Community of noise and vibrations caged by aircraft using this airport or that these noise abatement procedures will continue in the future. Further information is available from the airport website: www.ocair.com. Your Neighborhood Builder will provide you with a separate airport proximity notice required by California Civil Code Section 1353, 51. Avigation Easement. An avigation easement has been recorded against the Community. The avigation easement establishes a permanent right to travel through the air space over the Community for the benefit of John Wayne Airport. You may notice noise and vibration from overflying aircraft approaching or leaving the airstrip. By accepting a deed to a Home in the Community, you understand that the avigation easement gives the users of the airstrip a perpetual legal right to fly over the Community without interference from the occupants of the Community. P t/ 52. Commercial/Industrial Property. The Community is located within the vicinity of property zoned for commercial and heavy industrial uses located in the area of Barranca and � Jamboree Streets. This area consists of, among others, a Waste Management Public Recycling/Transferring Station, asphalt recycling, trucking facilities and multiple concrete companies, all with product deliveries. These commercial and industrial properties may generate dust, offensive odor, noise and other effects. The Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders have no control over the existing or potential uses of this property. These uses may create light, noise and other nuisances twenty-four (24) hours a day, seven (7) days a week. 53. Proposed Schools. The Tustin Unified School District owns an elementary school site located to the west of the Community on Landsdowne Road and a high school site is >Proposed to be constructed adjacent to the Regional Park at the intersection of Kensington Park 01 Drive and Valencia Avenue. Owners and other residents within the Community may experience, among other things, glare from bright lights, noise and increased traffic and parking congestion in connection with the use of this site. There are no assurances if or when any school will be completed on the site, nor the type of facilities that may be included as part of the school, You should contact the Tustin Unified School District at (714) 730-7301 for more information. Boyer Initials ._ _ _ !., h. 2544-33233\CLI'428\UISCI.SR\609965.10 I III (AW Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders and the Community Association make no representations as to the fixture use of this school site. 54. Development Area. The Community lies in a rapidly expanding area. As future commercial and residential developments are built in and around MCAS Tustin, you may expect attendant limitations on solitude and inconveniences. For example, you can expect to hear noise from the development of future adjacent residential and commercial areas and the machinery used to develop these areas. You can also expect increased traffic and rerouting of traffic as new residential and commercial developments are constructed, nearby streets and major thoroughfares are widened and new streets are built. As the area around the Community develops, you may experience light entering your Hoine from exterior sources including streetlights, parking lot lighting and nearby residential and commercial buildings. The Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders and the Community Association have no control over the transmission of noise, light, vibration, odor and other impacts or their potential effects on Homes in the Community, including any which may be a direct result of current and fixture construction activity. 55. WAS Tustin Airship Hangars. Two (2) airship hangars ("Hangars'l are located within MCAS Tustin southwest of the Community. The hangars are each approximately one thousand (1,000) feet long, three hundred (300) feet wide, and, one hundred and seventy (170) feet tall. The view from your Home may be effected by the nearby presence of the Hangars. It has not been determined whether these Hangars will remain or be demolished, or what uses might be made of them. For further information regarding the Hangars, please contact the City of Tustin. 56. Future Fire Station Site. The Community is located adjacent to a future fire station site at the corner of Edinger Avenue and Kensington Park Drive. The fire station will operate twenty four (24) hours a day and seven (7) days a week. Owners whose Homes are located in the vicinity of the fire station will notice noise, sirens, light, glare and other impacts from the operation of the fire station and emergency vehicles. You are advise that Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders have no control over the operation or use of the fire station. You should carefully evaluate the impact of the fire station on your decision to purchase a Homesite or Home in the Community. 57. Village Services. The Community is located northwest of an area designated in the Plan as the Village Services area. When and if built, this area is intended to be accessible to both vehicle and pedestrian traffic, and to provide localized commercial retail and service uses to adjacent residential areas within the Plan area. 58. Learning Village/Transitional and Emergency Housing. The Community is located east of an area designated in the Plan as the Learning Village area. When and if built, this area is intended to provide a specialized educational environment with a variety of public - serving uses. Buyer initials; i -29- 2544-33253TLA428MISCLSM 609965.10 11/16/09 GENERAL DISCLOSURES 59. Neighborhood Model Homes. Neighborhood model homes reflect typical exterior elevations, floor plans and methods of construction, and also illustrate possibilities for future interior decoration and exterior landscaping and hardscape improvements. Your Home will not necessarily conform to any model shown. The exterior elevations, architectural treatments, floor plans and colors shown on the master plot plans on display at the office of each Neighborhood Builder may be different than those both displayed in the models and those actually constructed by the Neighborhood Builder. Additionally, window locations, window types, roof lines, architectural projections and other similar features vary by elevation and Home location, and not all of the features displayed in the models may be included in your Home. The models have also been professionally decorated to show various decor ideas. Decoration items such as furnishings, draperies and other window treatments, any window tinting, wallpaper, custom carpet, coordinated paint, built-in shelves, beams, certain lighting fixtures (including halogen lighting), special ceiling treatments and some mirrors are for display purposes only, and are not included in the purchase price for your Home. Entries, walkways and driveways are shown in a variety of materials to show design ideas; however, for your Home, they will be constructed using only standard concrete. The hardscape shown in the model complex may not depict what may be constructed in all locations. Additionally, landscaping for the models is greater in density and type than any landscape package offered by a Neighborhood Builder. If not expressly included in the purchase price for your Horne in writing by a Neighborhood Builder, the rear, side and front yard landscaping is your responsibility. The type of plants, and the size and density of the landscaping in the yards of the models are merely intended to suggest ideas to you. Certain models may also include hardscape items (patio slabs, patio covers, pools, spas, etc.) which are not included in the purchase price of your Home. All such options and upgrades displayed in the models (including decorator items, landscaping and hardscape) are not included in the purchase price for your Home unless expressly agreed to in writing by the Neighborhood Builder. You should consult your sales representative for additional information regarding non-standard items used in the model homes. 60. Extended Use of the Model Complex. Each Neighborhood Builder reserves the right to use one or more Homes in a Neighborhood as a sales office and model home complex, and to display signs and banners, in connection with its program of marketing and selling Homes in the Neighborhood as well as other Homes owned by Neighborhood Builders, even if they are located in separate and unrelated Neighborhoods. 61. Grading Variations. Your Homesite has been graded to City specifications and may vary significantly from other Homesites. Variations may include slopes, swales, drains, flood control channels and retaining walls as required. Any changes made to the grading of the Hon which your Home is located may significantly affect you or your neighbor's drainage pattern and cause significant property damage to your Home or a neighbor's Home. 62. Wall/Ceiling Heights. Wall and ceiling heights and configurations may vary significantly by elevation. Your Home's walls and ceiling heights may be different from those used in the model homes. You are encouraged to speak to a sales representative if you have any questions. Buyer Initials: / -30- 254433253\CLP428\D[SCLSR\ 609965.10 11/16/09 63. Right of Substitution. From time to time due to unavailability and other production considerations, it is necessary for a Neighborhood Builder to make substitutions of materials and other items used in construction of the Homes from those materials and items displayed in the models. Therefore, each Neighborhood Builder reserves the right to make any changes or substitutions as the Neighborhood Builder deems necessary or desirable to the color schemes, building materials, fixtures, appliances and other components of the Homes. The foregoing substitutions may include, without limitation, kitchen appliances, household fixtures, electrical outlets and switches, hardware, wall surfaces, painting and other similar items. Each Neighborhood Builder shall have the right to make the substitutions described above without adjustment to the purchase price of your Home. 64. Changes in Construction Plans. The construction, grading, drainage and improvement plans (collectively, the "Construction Plans') for Homesites and Homes within each Neighborhood all contain dimensions that are approximate. They are not intended to be precise dimensions with regard to the Neighborhood. Room dimensions and electrical outlet placement will vary slightly from models and from printed information. Construction will be performed in substantial conformance with the Construction Plans, but dimensions may change slightly from them. If there is a discrepancy between the Construction Plans and the actual as - built conditions of your Homesite or Home, the as -built conditions will control. The usable or buildable area, location and configuration of the Homesite and all improvements located thereon may fluctuate from that shown or displayed to you in the Construction Plans or any other drawings, topographic maps or models based upon a Neighborhood Builder's construction of final improvements including, without limitation, fencing and slopes, which shall be constructed in a Neighborhood Builder's sole and absolute discretion. The location, size, height and composition of all walls and fences to be constructed on your Homesite or adjacent thereto shall be determined by the Neighborhood Builder in its sole and absolute discretion and despite the Construction Plans or any other models, drawings or topographic maps displayed to you. The Neighborhood Builder makes no representations, warranties or assurances as to the size, height, location or composition of any wall or fence to be constructed on or adjacent to your Homesite or Home. The Construction Plans are subject to change at any time without notice or obligation. 65. Non -Standard Construction. You may not personally perform any changes of any kind to your Home (such as alarm systems, home intercoms, stereo wiring, etc.) during construction and prior to the Close of Escrow. Such changes may void your warranty. Only those options and upgrades specifically agreed to by the Neighborhood Builder will be made. Any other changes and unapproved options found in a Home during the construction period will be removed by the Neighborhood Builder and the cost of removal and any repairs shall be your responsibility. 66. Changes In Development Plan and Prices. The residential real estate market continually fluctuates due to changes in economic, social and political conditions that directly affect the supply of and demand for housing. As a result, the development plan for the Neighborhood and the Community, and home prices and the terms and conditions of sale are also subject to change. Therefore: (a) With the exception of your Home, each Neighborhood Builder reserves the right at any time prior to or after the Close of Escrow for the sale of a Home and without Buyer Initials: 254433253\CLP428\DISCLSR\ 609965.10 11116109 notice, (i) to increase or decrease the sale price, adjust incentives or otherwise adjust the terms and conditions of sale for Homes in the Neighborhood or in the Community, and (ii) change the number, size, location, elevation, design or type of homes constructed in current or future phases of development of the Neighborhood; (b) No Neighborhood Builder is obligated to offer you the same price, incentives or other terms and conditions of sale that the Neighborhood Builder has previously offered or may subsequently offer to another purchaser; (c) No Neighborhood Builder has either offered or agreed to any price protection or other similar commitment to you regarding the value or resale value of your Home (or any other property), and no Neighborhood Builder shall have any obligation or liability whatsoever to you in the event any price changes directly or indirectly affect the value of your Home; (d) When you entered into a Purchase Agreement, the Neighborhood Builder may have owned other properties which may have been off the market and may not have been shown to or otherwise made available for purchase by you. No Neighborhood Builder has any obligation to notify you if any of such properties come on the market or are otherwise available for purchase or any obligation to notify you of any future properties the Neighborhood Builder may develop and make available for purchase. (e) You shall not hold a Neighborhood Builder responsible for any fluctuations in the purchase price of Homes within the Neighborhood or the Community. In consideration of a Neighborhood Builder's agreement to sell a Home to you, you agree that you shall have no claims against the Master Developer or the Neighborhood Builder for any possible change (decrease or increase) in the purchase price of Homes within the Neighborhood or any other terms of purchase, including, without limitation, upgrades or other concessions or incentives offered by a Neighborhood Builder to other purchasers of Homes within the Neighborhood and the construction of any additional floor plans on any of the Homes in the Neighborhood. 67. Use of Subcontractors. Neighborhood Builders generally perform construction through the use of subcontractors, and may not employ construction trades or workers. A Neighborhood Builder is not permitted to change its subcontracts without approval of the respective subcontractor; therefore, you may not request interior or exterior construction changes or alterations not otherwise offered to other purchasers in the sales office. 68. Elevation/Floor Plan Specifications. in order to provide architectural diversity in the street scene, each Neighborhood Builder's architect has produced more than one exterior design (elevation) for each floor plan. Consequently, differences may be noticed between the model home for your floor plan and the elevation of your Home. You acknowledge that you have received a description of the exterior configuration for the elevation and the exterior color scheme number for your Home. You also acknowledge that your Home's elevation and floor plan may vary from the configuration of the model home for your Home in terms of layout, sizes of certain rooms, exterior elevation features and other items such as sloped ceilings, veneer treatments, window locations and sizes, roof lines and color schemes. Iluyer Initials: / _32.. 2544-33253TU42MISCLSM 609965.10 11/16/04 69. Upper Floor Weight Limits. The upper floors of Homes are designed to support weight limits as outlined in the Uniform Building Code ("UBC'). If you currently own or are planning to purchase a waterbed, pool table or other heavy furniture you must confirm with the manufacturer that the weight introduced by these items does not exceed the UBC weight limit. Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders shall not be responsible for damage caused by anything you place on the upper floors that exceeds the UBC weight limit. 70. Air Conditioning. The air conditioning system and equipment specifications installed in the model homes may vary and operate at a higher capacity than those provided in your Home. You are encouraged to speak with your sales representative to determine the exact equipment specifications that will be provided with your Home. The location of the air conditioning compressor may vary between the model and your Home and between your Home and other Homes in your Neighborhood. 71. Alarm System. If you purchase an alarm system from a Neighborhood Builder, you specifically waive any claims against Master Developer, the Neighborhood Builder and the Community Association as a result of any failure of the alarm system to warn, frighten off, or alert anyone about intruders or any other problems. The sale of such system to you by the Neighborhood Builder is not a guarantee or warranty against criminal acts. Master Developer, the Neighborhood Builders and the Community Association are not insurers against criminal acts. 72. Energy Conservation. Homes in the Community meet or exceed the energy conservation standards that are a part of Title 24 of the California Administrative Code. Each Neighborhood Builder is required to design and install heating and cooling units that meet strict guidelines in Title 24. This is an energy conservation law that is designed to help reduce the overall use of energy in your Home. Title 24 describes the amount of cooling capacity as well as the minimum efficiency ratings for each geographic location in the state. In complying with Title 24, the cooling units installed in your Home are designed for maximum efficiency. Due to the Title 24 geographic requirements, on extremely warm days your inside room temperature may be warmer than your thermostat selection. This is due to design restrictions imposed by Title 24, not any design or installation defect by the Neighborhood Builder or its contractor. 73. Water Conservation. Each Home in the Community is equipped with low flow fixtures and other equipment to aid in water conservation in compliance with the City's Conditions of Approval for the Neighborhood. 74. Gas Barbecue Stub. If a natural gas service line is stubbed -out to an exterior backyard wail of your Home, it is suitable only for use in connection with a gas barbecue. Any other use may result in a serious fire hazard. The Neighborhood Builder and Master Developer are not responsible for any damage resulting from your use of the exterior gas stub. 75. Stain Grade Material Discoloration. Natural hardwoods used for cabinets, doors, stair systems, moldings, etc., are finished with stain and lacquer finish products which will change color over time. Color change may be the result of exposure to sunlight or weather, or simply the consequence of aging. Discoloration is not a defect. Buyer initials: 1 -33- 2544-33253T U42801SCLSM 609965.10 11/16/41 76. Paint Discoloration. Certain portions of your Home, such as paint -grade cabinets, casework, moldings and interior doors, may be painted with oil-based enamel paint. Yellowing is common with oil-based enamel paints. Additionally, if your Home has white oil- based enamel paint -grade cabinets, yellowing will occur. 77. Variations In Natural Materials. Your Home may include various natural materials (e.g., wood products and/or stone products). Wood products vary in dimension, grain, color, moisture content, and performance when subjected to high moisture environments. Dimensional variations in the wood framing members (studs, plates, joists, rafters, and beams) or the required structural hardware connectors may show through the drywall and stucco finishes under certain lighting conditions. Wood panels and trim, exposed timbers, rafters, and posts will require periodic painting. Wood exposed to weather will require more frequent painting. Consult the maintenance schedule included in your Homeowners Manual. Some of the natural characteristics of wood will show through the painted or stained finish. For example, there may be shades of white, red, black, grey or even green in areas. Mineral streaks may also be visible. This is caused by the irregularity of mineral absorption from one part of the tree to another. Grain patterns or texture will vary from even to irregular throughout your cabinetry. Similarly, granite and natural stone products are composed of various mineral contents. Marble is less dense and more porous than granite. Great care must be taken to prevent damage to marble and other stone products. You should follow the manufacturers' recommendations for cleaning and maintenance. Because these are natural products, they are subject to variation in color, veining, spotting, holes, cloudiness, texture and cracking. Some may vary significantly in filler and sheen. The samples in the sales office are actual pieces of natural stone which indicate general color and character; however, no two (2) pieces can be expected to match, even when taken from the same box. You should view the stone prior to purchase, and any questions regarding these materials must be resolved prior to installation. If replacement of natural material tile or carpet is required, you understand and agree that a match with existing material cannot be guaranteed. 78. Brass Plumbing/Light Fixtures/Hardware. Brass, bronze or other finishes have their limitations. In time, the protective lacquer may deteriorate from exposure to weather, perspiration, cleaning agents, frequency of use and other factors. Tarnishing or excessive wear of these finishes is, therefore, not a defect, but a normal process which is unavoidable. Under the circumstances, these finishes cannot be guaranteed and products will not be repaired or replaced under the manufacturer's warranties for tarnishing or wear of finishes. 79. Drywall Panels and Finishes. Drywall panels are placed over the wall studs, joists, rafters and beams. Drywall is typically used to finish window openings. Drywall panels will not completely eliminate variations in the dimension and plane of wood framing members. Metal trim (i.e., corner bead) is used at corners, window edges, soffits and ceilings. They are designed to be filled with finish compounds. These trim metals provide a durable finish but cause the wall plane to "flare" at the metal edge. Panel joints and seams are taped and coated with finish compounds. Fasteners are coated with finish compounds to cover the small "dimple" in the surface of the drywall panel. Progressive applications of finish compounds are required to cover the joints, fasteners, and seams. in some cases, the normal finishing of these joints, fasteners, and seams will cause a subtle "bulge". When the finishing process is complete, the walls and ceilings receive a texture coat. In certain lighting conditions (up -lights placed close to Buyer Initials! / -34- 2544-33253\GLP428\DISCLSR\ 609965.10 11/16/09 the walls), irregularities and variations in the wall plane or intersection of vertical and horizontal panels may be evident. These variations are normal. 80. View. Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders, the Community Association and their counselors, agents, representatives or employees make no representations, warranties or promises concerning any view, present or fi►ture, that may be enjoyed from all or any portion of your Homesite or Home. The view from your Homesite or Home may change or may be fully or partially obstructed by (a) the construction of other homes, Improvements, structures, fences, walls and/or landscaping by Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders or other Owners within the Community, (b) activities and Improvements on real property outside the Community, and/or (c) the growth of trees and/or other vegetation within or outside the Community. You are advised that trees installed in the Community are generally smaller than they will be once mature and trees that do not block views when you purchase your Home may obstruct views as they grow. Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders make no representations or warranties with respect to any open space on property adjacent to your Homesite or Home, or the Community as a whole, whether this property is owned or controlled by Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders, government agencies or private property owners. 81. Warranties for Consumer Products. The manufacturers' warranties for the consumer products included in your Home (e.g., water heater, air conditioning system, dishwasher, garbage disposal and other household appliances) are available for review in the sales office of your Neighborhood Builder. 82. Financing. This paragraph only applies if you are purchasing your Home from a Neighborhood Builder who is also a Lennar Family Builder and you are financing the purchase with Universal American Mortgage Corporation ("UAMC"). You will be required to provide VAMC with all documents necessary to obtain loan approval. UAMC may be affiliated with the Neighborhood Builder. You are not obligated to accept a loan from UAMC, but you may be required to submit documentation to UAMC to permit the Neighborhood Builder to determine whether it is likely that you will qualify to purchase the Home you desire. You may select your lender independently; however, if you select a lender other than UAMC, you must ensure that the lender can meet the time limitations and requirements imposed on lenders in the Purchase Agreement. Master Developer and Neighborhood Builder have not reviewed or approved any lender's sales or marketing materials, and does not make any representations or warranties whatsoever regarding any matters set forth therein or your ability to obtain any financing under any particular terms. You are strongly encouraged to make your own independent evaluation of the rates and loan programs offered by all lenders, including UAMC. You understand that the interest rate and loan fees for the loan applied for will be determined at the time of the Close of Escrow and may be higher or lower than on the date you signed a purchase agreement for your Home. You also acknowledge that the interest rate and loan fees referenced on the loan application are approximate only and do not constitute a binding commitment. 83. Schools. The Community is currently located in the. Tustin Unified School District, telephone: (714) 730-7301 (the "Sekaol District"). To obtain further information about the schools serving the Community, including transportation to and from the schools, please contact the School District. You should investigate this matter to your satisfaction prior to purchasing a Home in the Community. Due to the rate of population change, the school lduyuInitials: / _35- 2.544-33253TIT42808CLSM609965, 10 11/16/09 district may find it necessary to change boundaries and designated schools periodically, prior taw or after your close of escrow. in addition, it is possible that school district boundaries may change and your children will be required to attend a differeat school district in the future. Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders have no control or responsibility for such changes should they occur. The Community is currently expected to be served by the following schools. Marjorie Veeh Elementary School (K-6) 1701 San Juan Street Tustin, California (714) 730-7544 A.G. Currie Middle School (7-8) 1402 Sycamore Avenue Tustin, California (714) 730-7352 Tustin High School (9-12) 4321 1171 EI Camino Real Tustin, California (714)730-7414 To obtain further information about the schools serving the Community, including transportation to and from the schools, please contact the applicable school referenced above or the School District, or you can visit the School District's website at www.tustin.kl2.ca.us. You should investigate this matter to your satisfaction prior to purchasing a Home in the Community. 84. Mailboxes. Mailboxes in the Community may be clustered in groups as required by the United States Postal Service. The location of mailboxes and above -ground utility structures are determined by governmental agencies or utility companies, or both. You may not change the type of mailbox being used or the location. Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders reserve the right to modify such locations as may be dictated by field conditions without prior notice. 85. Residential Construction Legislation. California Civil Code Sections 895 through 945.5 ("Construction Claims Statute"), went into effect on January 1, 2003. The Construction Claims Statute (a) delineates standards for how various components of your Home should be constructed and fimction, (b) limits the time frames for bringing various claims against the Neighborhood Builder to anywhere from one year to ten years (as listed in the Construction Claims Statute) after the Close of Escrow, (c) imposes an obligation on all Owners and their successors in interest to follow Neighborhood Builder's maintenance recommendations and schedules or other applicable maintenance guidelines, and (d) establishes a non -adversarial claims resolution procedure. Pursuant to Section 914 of the Construction Claims Statute, the Neighborhood Builder is permitted to elect to utilize the procedure in the Construction Claims Statute or its own alternate contractual pre -litigation procedures. The applicable claims handling procedures are outlined in the Purchase Documents you receive from the Neighborhood Builder, �/� t including the "Dispute Resolution" provision in Section 13.5 of the Community Dec laration_A__00 `�j separate notice further describing claims handling procedures may have been recorded against WW num Initials: �.,6.. ?.'s44.33353\CL Pd261UtSCl.5R16M94ri5.10 �� 11/IGfIM �rtl� F, the title to Homes by the Neighborhood Builder in some Neighborhoods. You should review any such notice and your Purchase Documents carefully concerning these issues. YOU ARE ADVISED THAT THE CONSTRUCTION CLAIMS STATUTE AFFECTS YOUR LEGAL RIGHTS. YOU ARE ADVISED TO READ THE STATUTE CAREFULLY AND SEEK LEGAL ADVICE IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS REGARDING ITS EFFECT ON YOUR LEGAL RIGHTS. Buyer Initials Buyer Initials 86. Duty to Follow Maintenance Guidelines. An Owner is obligated by Section 907 of the Construction Claims Statute to follow any maintenance recommendations and schedules from the Neighborhood Builder, including the maintenance recommendations and schedules for manufactured products and appliances included with the Home, as well as all commonly accepted maintenance practices (collectively, "Maintenance Guidelines'l. Pursuant to Section 945.5 of the Construction Claims Statute, failure to follow any such Maintenance Guidelines may reduce or preclude an Owner's right to recover damages relating to an Owner's Home which could have been prevented or mitigated had the Maintenance Guidelines been followed. Buyer Initials Buyer Initials 87. Obligation to Retain Purchase Documents. The Purchase Documents that you receive through escrow in conjunction with the purchase of a Home may include Maintenance Guidelines, a written limited warranty, claim forms, and other documentation relating to the Construction Claims Statute. All Owners are required by the Construction Claims Statute to retain these documents and provide copies of such documents to an Owner's successors in interest upon the sale or transfer of the Owner's Home. Buyer Initials Buyer Initials 88. Warranty and Limitations on Liability. A Neighborhood Builder may provide a written limited warranty for the Homesite or Home covering certain defects for a limited period after the date the limited warranty commences. Warranty periods for items will vary as set forth in the written limited warranty. During the written limited warranty period, if any, the Neighborhood Builder will. repair or replace, at the Neighborhood Builder's sole discretion, certain components of your Homesite or Home, as set forth in the written limited warranty. A written limited warranty generally does not cover defects resulting from the failure of an Owner to perform commonly- accepted maintenance. Minor expansion, contraction, settlement cracks normal to home construction, and secondary damage, are generally not covered under the terms of a written limited warranty. Please refer to the written limited warranty you may receive for Buyer Initials: / -37- 2544-33253\CLP428\DISCLSR\ 609%5.10 11/16/09 additional information. No other warranties or guarantees, whether expressed or implied, are provided, unless stated in writing and signed by a Neighborhood Builder. The manufacturers' warranties for the manufactured consumer products included in your Home. (for example, water heater, air conditioning system, dishwasher, garbage disposal and other household appliances) are available for review in the Neighborhood Builder's sales office. 89. Notice of Sexual Offenders. The following notice is given pursuant to Section 2079.10a of the California Civil Code: Pursuant to Section 290.46 of the Penal Code, information about specified registered sex offenders is made available to the public via an Internet Web site maintained by the Department of Justice at www.meeanslaw.ca.l?ov. Depending on an offender's criminal history, this information will include either the address at which the offender resides or the community of residence and ZIP Code in which he or she resides. Prior to the purchase of a Home in the Community, you may research the database to determine whether there are sex offenders in the area. Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders, the Community. Association and their respective directors, officers, employees, agents, representatives and consultants make no representations, warranties, or guarantees regarding the presence or absence of registered sex offenders within the Community or in the surrounding area. In addition, Master Developer, Neighborhood Builder, the Community Association and their respective directors, officers, employees, agents, represeritatives and consultants have no obligation or duty to investigate existing residents or buyers to determine whether they are sex offenders. You are solely responsible for making your own investigation. For further information, please contact your local law enforcement agency. Most law enforcement agencies have special stations to view the Megan's Law database. 90. Benefit of Home Ownership. Although the purchase of a new home has traditionally been considered a wise decision, Master Developer and Neighborhood Builder have made no representations, guarantees or warranties to you regarding the tax benefits, investment benefits or other benefits of home ownership, regarding appreciation or depreciation in the value or equity accrual in your Home, and regarding future price adjustments. 91. Assumption of Risk and Liability. By acceptance of this Disclosure, you assume all risk and liability for injuries to persons and property that may be sustained by you, your family members and your social and business guests by reason of all conditions or circumstances disclosed in this Disclosure. VISITING THE COMMUNITY BEFORE MOVE -IN If you wish to visit the Community, the Neighborhood and your Home before your move in, please be aware that your Home is located within a construction area and that construction sites are potentially dangerous. The Neighborhood Builder will permit you to enter your Home and the construction area surrounding your Home provided that you are fully aware of the risks of such entry and are willing to comply with the procedures and requirements imposed on such Buyer Initials: / _38- 2544-33253TI-P42MISCLSM 609965.10 11/16/09 visit by the Neighborhood Builder. You must be accompanied by your sales representative, or another representative of the Neighborhood Builder on any and all visits to your Home. Each Neighborhood Builder further requests that such visits be limited to non -construction hours. By signing this Disclosure you acknowledge that there are numerous risks associated with visiting your Home during construction, including without limitation, open trenches, construction traffic, potential falling debris, exposed nails and electrical wiring, incomplete construction and certain other potential hazards. You further agree to use due care while visiting your Home. In addition, prior to visiting any construction area you may be required to sign a waiver and release form provided by the Neighborhood Builder ("Waiver'l in which you agree to comply with the provisons of the Waiver. Whether or not you have signed a Waiver, by signing this Disclosure, you agree that you shall proceed at your own risk and you release and waive any claims against Master Developer. Neighborhood Builders, all of their affiliated entities, officers, directors, agents and assigns and all other persons or entities potentially liable to you as a result of an injury which may occur during your visit to your Home, to the Neighborhood and to the Community. ENTIRE DISCLOSURE; NO OTHER REPRESENTATIONS No sales representative, employee or agent of any Neighborhood Builder or the Master Developer has the authority to make any representation to you which contradicts or modifies the matters and information set forth in this Disclosure, the purchase agreement or any other written disclosure provided by the Master Developer or Neighborhood Builders in connection with the purchase of a Home in a Neighborhood (collectively, the "Disclosure Documents"). You acknowledge that no representations have been made to you by such persons other than as set forth in the Disclosure Documents and upon which you have relied in connection with the ti. purchase of the Home. Please indicate below if any representations have been made by any such person which contradict or modify the matters and information set forth in the Disclosure Documents: . RELEASE AND INDEMNITY REGARDING DISCLOSURES With respect to items of information disclosed to you in this Disclosure or in any Disclosure Documents provided by Master Developer or Neighborhood Builders (collectively, "Disclosure Items"), you agree that you and your family members release, waive and will not make any claims against Master Developer and Neighborhood Builders for (a) nondisclosure of Disclosure Items, (b) for alleged improper or incomplete Disclosure Items, and (c) personal injury, property damage, expenses (including attorney fees and costs) arid other liability you, your family members and others experience from the nondisclosure, improper disclosure or incomplete disclosure of Disclosure Items. You also agree that you will indemnify and hold the Master Developer, Neighborhood Builders and all of their affiliated entities, officers, directors, agents and assigns, harmless from all such claims by you, your family members and your social and business guests. Buyer Initials: / -39- 2544-3325MCLP42MISCLSM 609965.10 11/16/09 Buyer Initials Buyer Initials [Buyer Acknowledgment on following page] Buyer Initials: / -40- 2544-33253\CLP428\DISCLSR\ 609965.10 11/16/09 Columbus Square HOMEBUYER DISCLOSURE STATEMENT BUYER ACKNOWLEDGMENT By the signatures below, you acknowledge that you will close escrow with full knowledge, understanding and agreement as to all of the informatiori contained in this Disclosure, and that this Disclosure constitutes a part of the terms of your Home purchase. Buyer: Date: Homesite or Condominium No: Tract No: Street Address: Buyer Initials: / -41- 2544-33253\CLP428\DISCLSR\ 609965.10 11/16/09 ATTACHMENT E Master Declaration of CC&Rs and First Amendment to Master Declaration of CC&Rs RECORDING REQUESTED BY: NORTH AIb MCAN TITLE COMPANY WHEN RECORDED, MAIL TO: MOFFETT MEADOWS PARTNERS, LLC c/o Lennar Homes of California, Inc. Attn: T. Wilson 25 Enterprise, Suite 300 Aliso Viejo, CA 92656 This Document was electronically recorded by North American Recorded in Official Records, Orange County Tom Daly, Clark -Recorder ��gg 111111111111 1111438.00 2006000149773 10:35am 03/07/06 203 69 D02 R27143 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 426.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 (SpaceAboveforRecorder's Use) MASTER DECLARATION OF COVENANTS, CONDITIONS, RESTRICTIONS AND RESERVATION OF EASEMENTS FOR COLUMBUS SQUARE 2544-33253WU42MC= 591730.13 2!1/06 TABLE OF CONTENTS MASTER DECLARATION OF COVENANTS, CONDITIONS, RESTRICTIONS AND RESERVATION OF EASEMENTS FOR COLUMBUS SQUARE Page ARTICLEI DEFINITIONS..................................................................................................3 1.1 ARTICLES........................................................................................................3 1.2 ASSESSMENT, CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT................................................3 1.3 ASSESSMENT, COMMON............................................................................. 3 1.4 ASSESSMENT, COMPLIANCE..................................................................... 3 1.5 ASSESSMENT, EXTRAORDINARY.............................................................3 1.6 ASSESSMENT, RECONSTRUCTION...........:...............................................4 1.7 ASSESSMENT UNIT....................................................................................... 4 1.8 ASSOCIATION PROPERTY........................................................................... 4 1.9 BENEFICIARY................................................................................................ 4 1.10 BOARD OR BOARD OF DIRECTORS..........................................................4 1.11 BUDGET.......................................................................................................... 4 1.12 BYLAWS..........................................................................................................4 1.13 CITY................................................................................................................. 4 1.14 CLOSE OF ESCROW...................................................................................... 4 1.15 COMMON EXPENSES...................................................................................4 (, 1.16 COMMUNITY ASSOCIATION...................................................................... 5 1.17 COMMUNITY ASSOCIATION FUNDS ........................................................ 6 1.18 COMMUNITY ASSOCIATION GOVERNING DOCUMENTS ................... 6 1.19 COMMUNITY CENTER................................................................................. 6 1.20 COMMUNITY GUIDELINES......................................................................... 6 1.21 COMMUNITY MANAGER............................................................................ 6 1.22 COMMUNITY WALL..................................................................................... 6 1.23 CONDOMINIUM.............................................................................................6 1.24 COUNTY..........................................................................................................7 1.25 COVERED PROPERTY.................................................................................. 7 ' 1.26 ............................................. DECLARANT ............................................ ......... 7 1.27 DEED OF TRUST .......................... 1.28 DESIGN GUIDELINES................................................................................... 7 1.29 DESIGN REVIEW COMMITTEE...................................................................7 1.30 DRE...................................................................................................................7 1.31 FHA................................................................................................................... 7 1.32 FREDDIE MAC................................................................................................ 7 1.33 FANNIE MAE.................................................................................................. 7 1.34 FAMILY........................................................................................................... 8 1.35 FISCAL YEAR................................................................................................. 8 1.36 GINNIEMAE...................................................................................................8 1.37 HOME ............................................................................................................... 8 2544-3325AW428%CCRS% 581730.13 2/1106 TABLE OF CONTENTS (continued) Page 1.38 RAPROVEMENT.............................................................................................8 1.39 INCLUDES, INCLUDING...........................:................................................... 8 1.40 LOCAL GOVERNMENTAL AGENCY......................................................... 8 _ 1.41 LOT...................................................................................................................8 TEMPORARY BUILDINGS.........................................................................17 1.42 MAINTAIN, blAINIENANCE....................................................................... 8 1.43 MAINTENANCE AREA.................................................................................. 8 1.44 MAINTENANCE GUIDELINES..................................................................... 9 1.45 MASTERDECLARATION ION............................................................................. 9 1.46 MEMBER, MEMBERSHIP............................................................................. 9 1.47 MODEL HOMES............................................................................................. 9 1.48 NEIGHBORHOOD.......................................................................................... 9 1.49 NEIGHBORHOOD ASSOCIATION............................................................... 9 1.50 NEIGHBORHOOD BUILDER........................................................................ 9 1.51 NEIGHBORHOOD DECLARATION...........................................................10 1.52 NEIGHBORHOOD PROPERTY...................................................................10 1.53 NEIGHBORHOOD WALL............................................................................10 1.54 NOMINATING COMMITTEE......................................................................10 1.55 NOTICE AND HEARING.............................................................................10 1.56 OPEN SPACEIPARK AREAS.......................................................................10 1.57 OWNER..........................................................................................................10 1.58 PERSON.......................................................:.................................................10 1.59 PHASE OF DEVELOPMENT.......................................................................10 1.60 PUBLIC REPORT..........................................................................................10 1.61 RECORD OR FILE........................................................................................11 1.62 RESERVES.............:.......................................................................................11 1.63 RESIDENTIAL AREA...................................................................................11 1.64 SUPPLEMENTAL DECLARATION............................................................11 1.65 TELECOMMUNICATION FACILITIES......................................................11 1.66 TELECOMMUNICATION SERVICES........................................................11 1.67 VA................................:..................................................................................11 ARTICLE II USE RESTRICTIONS....................................................................................11 2.1 SINGLE FAMILY HOME .............................................................................12 2.2 NUISANCES..................................................................................................13 2.3 SIGNS.............................................................................................................13 2.4 PARKING AND VEHICULAR RESTRICTIONS........................................14 2.5 ANIMAL RESTRICTIONS...........................................................................16 2.6 EXTERIORITEMS........................................................................................16 2.7 TEMPORARY BUILDINGS.........................................................................17 2.8 ASSOCIATION PROPERTY/MAINTENANCE AREAS ............................17 2.9 OUTSIDE INSTALLATIONS.......................................................................17 2.10 INSIDE INSTALLATIONS...........................................................................17 2.11 ANTENNAE...................................................................................................17 2.12 DRILLING......................................................................................................18 -11- 2544-33253%W4=CCR81581730.13 2/1/06 TABLE OF CONTENTS (continued) Page 2.13 FURTHER SUBDIVISION............................................................................18 2.14 DRAINAGE....................................................................................................19 2.15 WATER SUPPLY SYSTEMS........................................................................ 20 2.16 VIEW OBSTRUCTIONS...............................................................................20 24 2.17 SOLAR ENERGY SYSTEMS....................................................................... 20 2.18 INSTALLATION OF LANDSCAPING........................................................ 20 2.19 POST TENSION CONCRETE SLABS ........................ :................................ 20 2.20 RIGHTS OF DISABLED............................................................................... 21 ARTICLEIII DISCLOSURES.............................................................................................. 21 3.1 SOIL CONDITIONS......................................................................................21 3.2 ENVIRONMENTAL CONDITION...............................................................22 3.3 GRADING...................................................................................................... 24 3.4 AFFORDABLE HOUSING .................................................. :........................ 24 3.5 UTILITY IMPROVEMENTS........................................................................ 24 3.6 COMMUNITY FACILITIES DISTRICT AND ASSESSMENT DISTRICTS.................................................................................................... 24 3.7 AIRPORT INFLUENCE AREA NOTICE.....................................................24 3.8 RECLAIMED WATER.................................................................................. 25 3.9 PROPERTY LINES........................................................................................ 25 3.10 OFFERS OF DEDICATION.......................................................................... 25 3.11 CHANGE INPLANS.....................................................................................25 3.12 NO ENHANCED PROTECTION AGREEMENT ........................................ 25 3.13 ADDITIONAL PROVISIONS....................................................................... 25 3.14 OTHER REPRESENTATIONS AND WARRANTIES ................................ 26 ARTICLE IV GOVERNANCE BY THE COMMUNITY ASSOCIATION ........................ 26 4.1 ORGANIZATION OF THE COMMUNITY ASSOCIATION ...................... 26 4.2 GENERAL DUTIES AND POWERS ................................................ .......26 4.3 SPECIFIC DUTIES AND POWERS.............................................................26 4.4 PERMITTED FUNCTIONS........................................................................... 30 4.5 PROHIBITED ACTIVITIES......................:...................................................30 4.6 COMMENCEMENT OF COMMUNITY ASSOCIATION MAINTENANCE......................................................................................... 31 4.7 CONVEYANCE OF ASSOCIATION PROPERTY ...................................... 31 4.8 STANDARD OF CARE, NONLIABILITY................................................... 32 ARTICLE V DESIGN REVIEW COMMITTEE ................................................................. 33 5.1 MEMBERS OF COMMITTEE ...................................................................... 33 5.2 POWERS AND DUTIES................................................................................ 34 5.3 RIGHTS OF APPOINTMENT....................................................................... 34 5.4 REVIEW OF PLANS AND SPECIFICATIONS...........................................35 5.5 MEETINGS OF THE DESIGN REVIEW COMMITTEE ............................. 37 5.6 NO WAIVER OF FUTURE APPROVALS ................................................... 37 -lll- 2544-33253%CLP428XCCRM 581730.13 2/1/06 TABLE OF CONTENTS (continued) Page 5.7 COMPENSATION OF MEMBERS............................................................... 37 5.8 INSPECTION OF WORK..............................................................................38 5.9 SCOPE OF REVIEW.......................................................................................38 . 5.10 VARIANCE....................................................................................................3 8 5.11 PRE-APPROVALS.........................................................................................39 43 5.12 APPEALS....................................................................................................... 39 ARTICLE VI OWNERS' MEMBERSHIP AND VOTING RIGHTS..................................39 44 6.1 MEMBERSHIP...............................................................................................39 6.2 TRANSFER OF MEMBERSHIPS.................................................................39 44 6.3 CLASSES OF VOTING MEMBERSHIP...................................................... 40 6.4 VOTING RIGHTS..........................................................................................41 45 6.5 DECLARANT'S VETO RIGHT....................................................................41 45 6.6 ACTIONS SUBJECT TO DECLARANT'S VETO.......................................42 ARTICLE VII OWNERS' PROPERTY RIGHTS AND PROJECT EASEMENTS .............42 7.1 OWNERS' EASEMENTS OF ENJOYMENT...............................................42 -7.2 EASEMENTS FOR VEHICULAR AND PEDESTRIAN TRAVEL ............ 43 7.3 EASEMENTS FOR PUBLIC SERVICE USE .............................. 44................. 7.4 EASEMENTS FOR WATER AND UTILITY PURPOSES .......................... 44 7.5 EASEMENT FOR DECLARANT AND NEIGHBORHOOD BUILDERS OVER ASSOCIATION PROPERTY ........................................ 44 7.6 TELECOMMUNICATIONS EASEMENT ................................................... 44 7.7 ................................... MISCELLANEOUS EASEMENTS .......................... .. 45 7.8 DELEGATION OF USE................................................................................ 45 7.9 WAIVER OF USE......................................................................................t ..45 7.10 TAXES............................................................................................................ 45 7.11 RIGHT TO GRANT ADDITIONAL EASEMENTS ..................................... 46 ARTICLE VIII OBLIGATION TO SHARE COSTS.............................................................. 46 8.1 CREATION OF ASSESSMENT OBLIGATION .......................................... 46 8.2 FUNDS OF THE COMMUNITY ASSOCIATION.......................................46 8.3 PURPOSE OF ASSESSMENT'S.................................................................... 47 8.4 ASSESSMENT COMPONENTS, RATES AND EXEMPTIONS ................ 47 . 8.5 LIMITS ON COMMON ASSESSMENT INCREASES ................................ 48 8.6 SPECIAL ASSESSMENTS............................................................................ 49 8.7 COMMENCEMENT OF COMMON ASSESSMENTS ................................ 49 8.8 COLLECTION OF COMMON ASSESSMENTS ......................................... 50 8.9 EXEMPT PROPERTY................................................................................... 50 8.10 CAPITAL CONTRIBUTIONS TO THE COMMUNITY ASSOCIATION.............................................................................................. 51 ARTICLE IX RESIDENTIAL AREA MAINTENANCE OBLIGATIONS ......................... 51 9.1 OWNER MAINTENANCE OBLIGATIONS................................................51 2544-332M%CLP429VXRM 581730.13 2/1106 12.1 TABLE OF CONTENTS 59 • (continued) 59 12.3 Page 9.2 COMMUNITY ASSOCIATION MAINTENANCE OBLIGATIONS.......... 53 93 NEIGHBORHOOD ASSOCIATION OBLIGATIONS ................................. 55 9.4 MAINTENANCE STANDARDS.................................................................. 56 ARTICLE X DAMAGE AND CONDEMNATION............................................................ 56 10.1 REPAIR AND RECONSTRUCTION............................................................ 56 10.2 OWNERS' RESPONSIBILITIES.................................................................. 56 10.3 EMINENT DOMAIN..................................................................................... 57 ARTICLEXI INSURANCE.................................................................................................. 57 11.1 PROPERTY INSURANCE............................................................................ 57 11.2 INSURANCE OBLIGATIONS OF OWNERS..............................................57 MISCELLANEOUS ......................... 11.3 WAIVER OF SUBROGATION..................................................................... 58 11.4 LIABILITY AND OTHER INSURANCE..................................................... 58 11.5 NOTICE OF EXPIRATION REQUIREMENTS ........................................... 59 ARTICLE XII RIGHTS OF BENEFICIARIES...................................................................... 59 12.1 GENERAL PROTECTIONS.......................................................................... 59 12.2 WRITTEN NOTIFICATION.....................................:................................... 59 12.3 RIGHT OF FIRST REFUSAL........................................................................ 60 12.4 RIGHTS UPON REQUEST........................................................................... 60 12.5 PAYMENTS OF DELINQUENT AMOUNTS .............................................. 60 12.6 CONTRACTS................................................................................................. 60 ARTICLE XIII ENFORCEMENT........................................................................................... 60 13.1 ENFORCEMENT OF COMMUNITY ASSOCIATION GOVERNING ARTICLE XIV GENERAL PROVISIONS............................................................................. 74 14.1 TERM..............................................................................................................74 14.2 INTERPRETATION........................................................ ................................ 74 _V_ 2544-33253%W428%CCRS%581730.13 2/1/06 DOCUMENTS................................................................................................ 60 13.2 NONPAYMENT OF ASSESSMENTS........................................................... 62 13.3 '' ENFORCEMENT OF BONDED OBLIGATIONS ........................................ 66 13A DAMAGE TO PROPERTY DISPUTES........................................................ 66 13.5 DISPUTE RESOLUTION.............................................................................. 67 13.6 CONSTRUCTION DEFECT DISPUTES...................................................... 67 13.7 OTHER DISPUTES........................................................................................ 70 13.8 ALTERNATE DISPUTE RESOLUTION PROCEDURES ........................... 70 13.9 DISPUTES RELATING TO ENFORCEMENT OF COMMUNITY ASSOCIATION GOVERNING DOCUNT NTS ........................................... 72 13.10 CIVIL CODE SECTIONS 1368.4, 1375, 1375.05 and 1375.1 ...................... 72 13.11 USE OF DAMAGE AWARD AMOUNTS .................................................... 72 13.12 MISCELLANEOUS ......................... 13.13 ENFORCEMENT BY CITY.......................................................................... 73 ARTICLE XIV GENERAL PROVISIONS............................................................................. 74 14.1 TERM..............................................................................................................74 14.2 INTERPRETATION........................................................ ................................ 74 _V_ 2544-33253%W428%CCRS%581730.13 2/1/06 TABLE OF CONTENTS (continued) Page 14.3 TERMINATION AND AMENDMENT.....................:.:................................ 75 14.4 NO PUBLIC RIGHT OR DEDICATION...................................................... 77 14.5 CONSTRUCTIVE NOTICE AND ACCEPTANCE ...................................... 77 14.6 NOTICES........................................................................................................77 14.7 ADDITIONAL PROVISIONS....................................................................... 78 14.8 MERGERS OR CONSOLIDATIONS........................................................... 78 ARTICLE XV LAND CLASSIFICATIONS.......................................................................... 78 ARTICLE XVI ANNEXATION OF ADDITIONAL PROPERTY ......................................... 79 16.1 ANNEXED TERRITORY.............................................................................. 79 16.2 SUPPLEMENTAL DECLARATION CONTENT ......................................... 79 16.3 APPROVAL OF ANNEXATIONS................................................................ 79 16.4 DEANNEXATION AND AMENDMENT .................................................... 80 16.5 RIGHTS OF ANNEXED TERRITORY MEMBERS .................................... 80 16.6 AUTOMATIC ANNEXATION OF LIFOC PROPERTY ............................. 80 ARTICLE XVII DECLARANT AND NEIGHBORHOOD BUILDER RIGHTS AND EXEMPTIONS............................................................................................... 81 17.1 INTEREST OF DECLARANT....................................................................... 81 17.2 RIGHTS.......................................................................................................... 81 17.3 EXEMPTION..................................................................................................82 1 17.4 ASSIGNMENT OF RIGHTS ......................................................................... 82 17.5 EASEMENT RELOCATION......................................................................... 83 17.6 DECLARANTS REPRESENTATIVE......................................................... 83 ARTICLE XVIII CITY REQUIRED PROVISION.................................................................... 83 18.1 ISSUANCE OF RESIDENTIAL BUILDING PERMITS WITHIN LIFOC PROPERTY ............................... EXHIBIT "CP" - DESCRIPTION OF COVERED PROPERTY EXHIBIT "AP" - ASSOCIATION PROPERTY TO BE CONVEYED IN THE COVERED PROPERTY EXHIBIT "PM" - PRIVATE PARKWAY MAINTENANCE AREAS IN THE COVERED PROPERTY EXHIBIT "SD" - STORM DRAIN MAINTENANCE AREAS IN THE COVERED PROPERTY EXHIBIT "MA' - MAINTENANCE AREAS IN THE COVERED PROPERTY EXHIBIT "WM" - WALL MAINTENANCE IN THE COVERED PROPERTY -Vi- 7544-33253%MY428%CCRS1581730.13 211106 TABLE OF CONTENTS (continued) Page EXHIBIT "OS" - OPEN SPACE/PARK AREAS IN THE COVERED PROPERTY EXHIBIT "PC" - PARKING AND CIRCULATION AREAS IN THE COVERED PROPERTY EXHIBIT "PC -1"- PARKING LIMITATIONS IN THE COVERED PROPERTY EXHIBIT "TC" - APPROVED CURBSIDE TRASH PICK-UP AREAS IN THE COVERED PROPERTY -Vll- 2544-332531CLP428\CCPM 581730.13 2/1/06 DECLARATION OF COVENANTS, CONDITIONS AND RESTRICTIONS AND RESERVATION OF EASEMENTS FOR COLUMBUS SQUARE This Master Declaration of Covenants, Conditions, Restrictions and Reservation of Easements for Columbus Square ("Master Declaration') is made by MOFFETi' MEADOWS PARTNERS, LLC, a Delaware limited liability company ("Declaranfj. PREAMBLE: A. Declarant is the Owner of real property in the City of Tustin, County of Orange, State of California, more particularly described on Exhibit "CP" ("Covered Property'). B. Declarant, the Owners and all of the Neighborhood Builders have agreed that the Residential Area and any other area added to the Covered Property will be developed with objectives designed to benefit all the property in the Covered Property, even though the areas are of different character. This common development scheme created by Declarant with the input of the Neighborhood Builders imposes reciprocal burdens and benefits on all of the Covered Property, so that each portion and the entirety of the Covered Property are both burdened and benefited by the provisions of this Master Declaration. The signatories to this Master Declaration include all of the Owners of the Covered Property as of the date of Recordation of this Master Declaration. C. Declarant deems it desirable, for the efficient preservation of the amenities in the Covered Property, to create a "master planned development" (as defined in Section 2792.32 of Title 10 of the California Code of Regulations) which is also a "common interest development" within the meaning of Section 1351(c) of the California Civil Code, pursuant to the Davis -Stirling Common Interest Development Act. The Covered Property is planned to constitute a "subdivision" as defined in Section 11000 of the California Business and Professions Code. The general plan of development of the Covered Property will include forming a corporation pursuant to the California Nonprofit Mutual Benefit Corporation Law to which will be assigned the powers of (1) owning, maintaining and administering the Association Property, (2) maintaining the Maintenance Areas, (3) administering and enforcing the Community Association Governing Documents, and (4) collecting and disbursing the assessments and charges hereinafter created. Declarant will cause such corporation, the Members of which will be the Owners of real property in the Covered Property, to be formed to exercise such powers, as required by Section 1363 of the California Civil Code. D. Declarant declares that the Covered Property will be held, conveyed, encumbered,. used, occupied and improved subject to the easements, restrictions, reservations, rights, covenants, conditions and equitable servitudes contained in this Master Declaration, all of which are for the purpose of enhancing the attractiveness and desirability of the Covered Property, in furtherance of a general plan for the protection, maintenance, subdivision, improvement and sale -1- 2544-33253WIX4281C 01581730.13 VIM of the Covered Property. The covenants, conditions, restrictions, rights, reservations, easements and equitable servitudes set forth in this Master Declaration will (1) run with and burden the Covered Property and will be binding upon all Persons having or acquiring any interest in the Covered Property or any part thereof, their heirs, successors and assigns; (2) inure to the benefit of every• portion of the Covered Property and any interest therein; (3) inure to the benefit of and be binding upon Declarant, the Neighborhood Builders, and their respective successors -in - interest, each Owner and each Owner's successors in interest; and (4) may be enforced by Declarant, any Neighborhood Builder, any Owner and the Community Association. Introduction to Covered Property Declarant is the founder and developer of the Columbus Square master planned community and the creator of Columbus Square Community Association, a California nonprofit mutual benefit corporation ("Community Association'). The primary purpose of the Community Association is to manage, maintain and govern certain real property located within the Covered Property and to enforce this Master Declaration. Declarant has established this Master Declaration to provide a governance structure and statement of the objectives of that structure for the community in the Covered Property. This community will have a flexible system of standards and procedures for its overall development, administration, and operation. This Master Declaration establishes the powers and flexibility necessary to develop the community in the Covered Property. The Community Association is a nonprofit homeowners association. The Community Association's powers are described in Sections 4.2 and 4.3 of this Master Declaration. The Master Declaration empowers the Community Association to enter into agreements with other entities to exercise its powers and ful, fill its responsibilities. The majority of the Community Association's business is overseen by its Board of Directors. Day-to-day activities are supervised by the Community Association's officers and the Community Manager. The Board is given the power of enforcing the use restrictions and other portions of the Master Declaration through administrative means. The Design Review Committee is a committee of the Community Association formed in Article V to have jurisdiction over design, development, aesthetics and the character of the Covered Propdrty. Certain issues cannot be decided by -the- Board of Directors of the Community Association. Instea4 these issues will be presented to the Members of the Community Association. Procedures for calling Member meetings are contained in the Community Association Bylaws. In addition to this Master Declaration, some Neighborhoods may also be governed by Neighborhood Declarations. These Neighborhood Declarations may impose additional restrictions on Lots or Condominiums in the affected Neighborhoods. The Neighborhood Declarations may also create Neighborhood Associdtions which will be operated pursuant to their own articles of incorporation and bylaws The Neighborhood Associations may have their own aesthetics review committees and may adopt their own aesthetics standards or rules and regulations. The Neighborhood Declarations, the management documents of Neighborhood -2- 2544-332531CLP4281CCR5\ 581730.13 2/1/06 Associations, and architectural or landscaping guidelines and standards of various Neighborhoods may supplement or be more restrictive than the Community Association Governing Documents so long as they are consistent with the scheme of governance established by the Community Association Governing Documents. ARTICLE I DEFINITIONS When the following words and phrases are used in this Master Declaration, they will have the meanings given in this Article and be subject to the limits described in this Article. 1.1 ARTICLES. Articles mean the Articles of Incorporation of the Community Association as amended or restated. 1.2 ASSESSMENT, CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT. Capital Improvement Assessment means a charge which the Board may levy against the Owners and their Lots or Condominiums representing a portion of the cost to the Community Association for installing or constructing any capital Improvements on any of the Association Property. Capital Improvement Assessments will be levied in the same proportion as Common Assessments. Capital Improvement Assessments are special assessments as described in California Civil Code Section 1366. 1.3 ASSESSMENT, COMMON. Common Assessment means a charge against the Owners and their Lots or Condominiums to be used to satisfy Common Expenses, which is to be levied as provided in this Master Declaration. The Common Assessment is a regular assessment as described in California Civil Code Section 1366. 1.4 ASSESSMENT, COMPLIANCE. Compliance Assessment means a charge against a particular Owner or Neighborhood Association directly attributable to or reimbursable by that Owner or Neighborhood Association equal to the cost incurred by the .Community Association for corrective action, or a fine or penalty assessed by the Board, plus interest and other charges on such Compliance Assessments. Compliance Assessments shall not include any late payment penalties, interest charges or costs (including attorneys' fees) incurred by the Community Association in the collection of Common, Capital Improvement or Reconstruction Assessments because these costs are added to the Common, Capital Improvement or Reconstruction Assessment for which they are incurred. Compliance Assessments may include any other collection costs, expenses and reasonable attorneys' fees. Compliance Assessments are monetary penalties described in Section 2792.26(b) of the California Code of Regulations. 1.5 ASSESSMENT, EXTRAORDINARY. Extraordinary Assessment means a charge which the Board may levy against Owners and their Lots or Condominiums representing any expense incurred or to be incurred in accordance with the Community Association Governing Documents which cannot be imposed as a Capital Improvement Assessment or Reconstruction Assessment but which qualifies as a special assessment described in California Civil Code Section 1366. Extraordinary Assessments will be levied in the same proportion as Common Assessments. -3- 2544-33253VCLP42WCRS1581730.13 211/06 1.6 ASSESSMENT, RECONSTRUCTION. Reconstruction Assessment means a charge which the Board may levy against the Owners and their Lots or Condominiums representing a portion of the Community Association's cost to reconstruct any Improvements on the Association Property or Maintenance Areas. Reconstruction Assessments will be levied in the same proportion as Common Assessments. Reconstruction Assessments are special -assessments as described in California Civil Code Section 1366. 1.7 ASSESSMENT UNIT. Assessment Unit means the value allocated to each Lot or Condominium pursuant to Section 8.4.1, for purposes of calculating the share of Common Expenses attributable to such Lot or Condominium. 1.8 ASSOCIATION PROPERTY. Association Property means all the real property and Improvements, whether annexed to the Covered Property or not, which is owned in fee simple by the Community Association. The Association Property is "common area" as defined in Section 135l(b) of the California Civil Code. The Association -Property initially encumbered by this Master Declaration is identified in Exhibit "AP" attached hereto. Additional Association Property may be identified in Supplemental Declarations and may be annexed to the Covered Property pursuant to Article XVI. 1.9 BENEFICIARY. Beneficiary means a Person to whom a mortgage is made and includes the beneficiary of a deed of trust. 1.10 BOARD OR BOARD OF DIRECTORS. Board or Board of Directors means the Community Association's Board of Directors. 1.11 BUDGET. Budget means a written, itemized estimate of the Community Association's income and Common Expenses. 1.12 BYLAWS. Bylaws means the Bylaws of the Community Association adopted by the Board as amended or restated. 1.13 CITY. City means the City of Tustin, in Orange County, California, and its various departments, divisions, employees and representatives and any joint powers authority that may exercise jurisdiction over the Covered Property. 1.14 CLOSE OF ESCROW. Close of Escrow means the date on which a deed conveying a Lot or Condominium pursuant to a transaction requiring the issuance of a Public Report is Recorded. The term "Close of Escrow" shall not include the. Recordation of a deed (a) between Deglarant and (i) any successor to any rights of the Declarant or (ii) any Neighborhood Builder, or (b) between Neighborhood Builders. 1.15 COMMON EXPENSES. Common Expenses means those expenses for which the Community Association is responsible under this Master Declaration, and may include the actual and estimated costs of the following: Maintaining, managing and operating the Association Property or Maintenance Areas; -4- 2544-3325ACLP42MCM 581730.13 2/1/06 • Unpaid Capital Improvement Assessments, Common Assessments, Compliance Assessments, Extraordinary Assessments and Reconstruction Assessments; • Any commonly metered utilities or other commonly metered charges for the Covered Property not paid for by a Neighborhood Association; • Managing and administering the Community Association; • Board, officer and committee member training and continuing education seminars or materials; • Compensation paid by the Community Association to managers, accountants, attorneys and the Community Association employees; • All utilities, landscaping, trash pickup and other services benefiting the . Association Property or Maintenance Areas; • Fire, casualty and liability insurance, worker's compensation insurance, and other insurance covering the Covered Property and the directors, officers and agents of the Community Association; • Bonding the members of the Community Association Board of Directors or its officers; • Taxes paid by the Community Association; • Amounts paid by the Community Association for discharge of any lien or encumbrance levied against the Covered Property, or portions thereof; • Reasonable Reserves; • Providing parking enforcement and site control services for the Association Property or other portions of the Covered Property; • Payments under a Mutual Benefit Agreement; • Managing, maintaining, repairing and replacing any structural improvements installed in accordance with the "Best Management Practices" (BMP's) in the Operation and Maintenance Plan for the Covered Property; • Expenses designated as Common Expenses in Supplemental Declarations; and • All other expenses incurred by the Community Association for any reason whatsoever in connection with the Covered Property, for the common benefit of the Owners. 1.16 COMMUNITY ASSOCIATION. Community Association means the Columbus Square Community Association, a California nonprofit mutual benefit corporation, formed pursuant to -5- 2544-33253 W42MOCRM 581730.13 2/1/06 the California Nonprofit Mutual Benefit Corporation Law, its successors and assigns. The Community Association is an "association" as defined in Section 1351(a) of the California Civil Code. 1.17 COMMUNITY ASSOCIATION FUNDS. The Community Association Funds means the accounts created for the Community Association receipts and disbursements pursuant to Article VIII hereof. 1.18 COMMUNITY ASSOCIATION GOVERNING DOCUMENTS. Community Association Governing Documents means this Master Declaration, all Supplemental Declarations, the Articles, Bylaws, the Community Guidelines, the Design Guidelines and the Maintenance Guidelines. 1.19 COMMUNITY CENTER Community Center means the Clubhouse of the Community Association constituting a portion of the Association Property. 1.20 COMMUNITY GUIDELINES. Community Guidelines mean the rules and regulations adopted, amended or restated by the Board. 1.21 COMMUNITY MANAGER Community Manager means the Person who provides professional community management for the Community Association and who is retained to perform functions of the Community Association as limited by the Community Association Governing Documents and the terms of the agreement between the Community Association and said Person. 1.22 COMMUNITY WALL. Community Wall means any sound wall, retaining wall, or fence in the Covered Property that is maintained entirely or partially by the Community Association. Fences or walls maintained entirely by the Owners are not Community Walls. The Community Walls in the Covered Property maintained by the Community Association are depicted on Exhibit WM; however, the obligation to maintain the Community Walls in a particular Phase of Development will not ariseuntil the commencement of Common Assessments in that Phase of Development or as otherwise directed in this Master Declaration, or in a Notice of Addition or Supplemental Declaration. Owners shall maintain the interior portion of the Community Wall while the Community Association shall maintain the structural integrity, cap and exterior surface of the Community Wall. Declarant may • designate additional Community Walls in a Notice of Addition or Supplemental Declaration. Community Walls in the Covered Property in general (a) are constructed on or along a tract boundary; or (b) separate a Lot or Condominium from Association Property, Maintenance Areas or public property; or (c) are constructed entirely within Association Property, or (d) are designated as a Community Wall by Declarant in this Master Declaration, or in a Notice of Addition or Supplemental Declaration. Party Walls are not Community Walls. 1.23 CONDOMINIUM. Condominium means a condominium as defined in Sections 783 and 1351(f) of the California Civil Code. Condominium also means the individual ownership interests in a "community apartment project" or "stock cooperative," both of which are defined in California Civil Code Section 1351, but excludes any condominium defined as a Lot for purposes of this Master Declaration. -6- 2544-33253\CLP428%CCRs1581730.13 2/1/06 1.24 COUNTY. County means the County of Orange in the State of California, and its various departments, divisions, employees and representatives. 1.25 COVERED PROPERTY. The Covered Property means all of the real property known as "Columbus Square," which is covered by this Master Declaration and subject to the jurisdiction of the Community Association, including (a) all of the real property described in Paragraph A of the Preamble of this Master Declaration, (b) the Association Property designated in this Master Declaration or a Supplemental Declaration to be owned and maintained by the Community Association, (c) any Maintenance Areas not owned in fee simple by the Community Association but maintained by the Community Association; and (d) any property annexed by a Supplemental Declaration. The Covered Property is a "common interest development" and a "planned development" as defined in Sections 1351(c) and 1351(k), respectively, of the California Civil Code. 1.26 DECLARANT. Declarant means MOFFETT MEADOWS PARTNERS, LLC, a Delaware limited liability company, its successors and any Person to which it shall have assigned any rights hereunder by express written assignment. Any such assignment may include some or all of the rights of the Declarant and may be subject to such limits as MOFFETT MEADOWS PARTNERS, LLC, a Delaware limited liability company, may impose in its sole discretion. As used in this Section, "successor" means a Person who acquires Declarant or substantially all of its assets, or who merges with Declarant, by sale, merger, reverse merger, consolidation, sale of ` stock or assets, operation of law or otherwise. Declarant is a builder as described in California Civil Code Section. 1375. 1.27 DEED OF TRUST. Deed of Trust means any Recorded mortgage or deed of trust or other conveyance of one (1) or more Lots, Condominiums, or other portions of the Covered Property to secure the performance of an obligation, which will be reconveyed upon the completion of such performance. 1.28 DESIGN GUIDELINES. Design Guidelines mean the design standards, procedures, rules and guidelines which may be adopted pursuant to Article V. 1.29 DESIGN REVIEW COAff IITTEE. Design Review Committee means the Design Review Committee created pursuant to Article V. 1.30 DRE. DRE means the California Department of Real Estate and its successors. 1.31 FHA. FHA means the Federal Housing Administration of the United States Department of Housing and Urban Development and any department or agency -of the United States government which succeeds to FHA's function of insuring notes secured by Deeds of Trust on residential real estate. 1.32 FREDDIE MAC. Freddie Mac means the Federal Home Loan Mortgage Corporation created by Title H of the Emergency Home Finance Act of 1970, and its successors. 1.33 FANNIE MAE. Fannie Mae means the Federal National Mortgage Association, a government-sponsored private corporation established pursuant to Title VIII of the Housing and Urban Development Act of 1968, and its successors. Era I 2544-33253%r_LP428=R31531730.13 211/06 1.34 FAMILY. Family means (a) one or more natural persons related to each other by blood, marriage or adoption, or (b) a group of natural persons not all so related, but who maintain a common household in a Home. 1.35 FISCAL YEAR. Fiscal Year means the fiscal accounting and reporting period of the Community Association selected by the Board. 1.36 GINNIE MAE. Ginnie Mae means the Government National Mortgage Association administered by the United States Department of Housing and Urban Development, and its successors. 1.37 HOME. Home means the dwelling intended for use and occupancy by a single Family whether a structure on a Lot in the Residential Area or a unit in a Residential Area Condominium. 1.38 IMPROVEMENT. Improvement means any structure, vegetation or appurtenance thereto including Homes, buildings, walkways, irrigation systems, parking areas, recreational facilities, pools, gazebos, roads, driveways, parking areas, fences, all types of walls, stairs, decks, landscaping, antennae, the paint on all exterior surfaces, windbreaks, patio covers, railings, poles, signs, storage areas, and exterior air conditioning. The Design Guidelines may identify additional items that are Improvements. 1.39 INCLUDES, INCLUDING. Whether capitalized or not, includes'and including mean "includes without limitation" and "including without limitation," respectively. 1.40 LOCAL GOVERNMENTAL AGENCY. Local Governmental Agency means the City and any other local governmental entity or agency and any school district, special assessment district, maintenance district or community facilities district 1.41 LOT. Lot means any lot or parcel of land shown upon any Recorded subdivision map or Recorded parcel map of any portion of the Covered Property, excluding the Association Property and the Neighborhood Property. Lot will also mean a condominium as defined in Sections 783 and 1351(f) of the California Civil Code if (a) the condominium is a volume of real property that is not located entirely within a building (a `site' condominium), and (b) the Supplemental Declaration annexing the condominium to this Master Declaration states that the condominium will be defined as a Lot for purposes of this Master Declaration. 1.42 MAINTAIN, MAINTENANCE. Whether capitalized or 'not, maintain and maintenance mean "maintain, repair and replace" and "maintenance, repair and replacement," respectively; provided, however that maintain or maintenance shall not include repair and replace(ment) where the context or specific language of this Master Declaration provides another meaning. 1.43 MAINTENANCE AREA. Maintenance Area means those areas not owned in fee simple by the Community Association, but over which the Community Association has rights or maintenance obligations by easement, lease, encroachment, permit, license or other agreement. The Maintenance Areas in the Covered Property are depicted on Exhibit "MA" attached hereto. -8- 2544-33251CLP4284CCRS\ 581730.13 vi/D6 1.44 MAINTENANCE GUIDELINES. Maintenance Guidelines means any current written guidelines, manual, or recommendations containing procedures and standards for the operation, maintenance and preservation of the Association Property Improvements and for the maintenance of Improvements or products in the Maintenance Areas and within a Residential Area Home, Lot or Condominium. Among other things, the Maintenance Guidelines specify suggested maintenance levels, recommended intervals for regularly scheduled maintenance items, and the scope of required maintenance practices and procedures. Maintenance Guidelines provided to the Community Association by Declarant may be supplemented, amended and updated by the Board. 1.45 MASTER DECLARATION. Master Declaration means this entire instrument, including the Preamble, all other provisions, and the Exhibits, as amended or restated. 1.46 MEMBER, MEMBERSHIP. Member means any Person holding a Membership and the Declarant. Membership means the property, voting and other rights and privileges of Members established in the Community Association Governing Documents, together with the correlative duties and obligations contained therein. 1.47 MODEL HOMES. Model Homes mean any Lots or Condominiums used by Declarant for model home, sales office, design center, other sales or marketing purposes, construction office or similar purposes. Commencing on the fust day of the calendar month following the sale of a Lot or Condominium being used by Declarant as a Model Home and ending on the date annual assessments commence against such Lot or Condominium, Declarant shall be responsible for the maintenance of all portions of such Phase of Development in which such Model Home Lot or Condominium is located. 1.48 NEIGBBORHOOD. Neighborhood means (a) an area covered by the jurisdiction of a Neighborhood Association, or (b) where there is no Neighborhood Association, a geographical area in the Covered Property which will be marketed under a separate marketing name. 1.49 NEIGHBORHOOD ASSOCIATION. Neighborhood Association means any California nonprofit corporation or unincorporated association, or its successor, established in connection with a Neighborhood Declaration, the membership of which is composed of Owners of Lots -or Condominiums in a portion of the Covered Property. The :Community Association is not a Neighborhood Association. 1.50 NEIGHBORHOOD BUILDER. Neighborhood Builder means (a) Lennar Homes of California, Inc., a California corporation, (b) William Lyon Homes, Inc., a California corporation, and (c) a Person designated by Declarant as a Neighborhood Builder in a Recorded document. Declarant intends to designate the following Persons as Neighborhood Builders: Persons who acquire a portion of the Covered Property for the purpose of developing Lots or Condominiums for sale to the general public. The term "Neighborhood Builder" does not include Declarant. Each Neighborhood Builder is a builder as described in California Civil Code Section 1375. -9- 2544-33253%W428\CCRM 581730.13 211106 1.51 NEIGHBORHOOD DECLARATION. Neighborhood Declaration means any declaration of covenants, conditions and restrictions, or similar document, which affects solely a portion of the Covered Property. The Master Declaration and the Supplemental Declarations are not Neighborhood Declarations. 1.52 NEIGHBORHOOD PROPERTY. Neighborhood Property means that area in any portion of the Covered Property designated in a Neighborhood Declaration as "common area" (as defined in Section 1351(b) of the California Civil Code) owned or maintained by the Neighborhood Association for the primary benefit of the Owners under the jurisdiction of the Neighborhood Association. 1.53 NEIGHBORHOOD WALL. Neighborhood Wall means any wall or fence that is (a) maintained by a Neighborhood Association, (b) not a Party Wall and (c) identified on an exhibit to a Neighborhood Declaration or a Supplemental Declaration as being a Neighborhood .Wall. 1.54 NOMINATING COIVEW1TTEE. Nominating Committee means the Nominating Committee that may be established by the Board pursuant to Section 2.15.2 of the Bylaws. 1.55 NOTICE AND HEARING. Notice and Hearing means written notice and a hearing before the Board as authorized in the Bylaws and this Master Declaration. • 1.56 OPEN SPACE/PARK AREAS. Open Space/Park Areas shall mean those portions of the Association Property over which the public has access for recreational purposes and over which no buildings or other enclosed structures are located. The Community Association or Neighborhood Association, as applicable, shall maintain the Open Space/Park Areas. Some Open Space/Park Areas may be located immediately adjacent to a Lot or Condominium within the Covered Property. The Open Space/Park Areas in the. Covered Property are located approximately as depicted on Exhibit "OS" attached hereto. 1.57 OWNER Owner means the Person or Persons, including Declarant and the Neighborhood Builders, holding fee simple interest of record to any Condominium or Lot. The term "Owner" includes a seller under an executory contract of sale but excludes Beneficiaries. 1.58 PERSON. Person means a natural individual or any entity with the legal right to hold title to real property. When the word "person" is used and is not capitalized, the word only refers to natural persons. . 1.59 PHASE OF DEVELOPMENT. Phase of Development or Phase means each of the following: (a) all or any portion of the Covered Property for which a Public Report has been issued, or (b) any portion of the Covered Property covered by a Supplemental Declaration. A Phase may consist of only Association Property with no Lots or Condominiums contained therein. 1.60 PUBLIC REPORT. Public Report means a Final Subdivision Public Report issued by DRE in compliance with Sections 11000 et seq. of the California Business and Professions Code. -10- 2544-33253%CLP4MCCRS1581730.13 211106 1.61 RECORD OR FILE. Record or File means, with respect to any document, entry of such document in the office of the County Recorder. 1.62 RESERVES. Reserves means those Common Expenses for which Community Association Funds are set aside pursuant to Article VIII and Section 1365.5 of the California Civil Code for funding the periodic maintenance of the major components of the Association Property and Maintenance Areas which would not reasonably be expected to recur on an annual or more frequent basis and for payment of deductible amounts for insurance policies which the Community Association obtains. The amount of Reserves to be maintained by the Community Association will be determined annually by the Board pursuant to reserve guidelines established in accordance with prudent property management practices generally applied for a "common interest development" (as defined in Section 1351(c) of the California Civil Code) in the City. 1.63 RESIDENTIAL AREA. Residential Area means the real property which is so classified in this Master. Declaration or a Supplemental Declaration. The Residential Area includes single-family Lots or Condominiums and may include Association Property and Neighborhood Property. 1.64 SUPPLEMENTAL DECLARATION. Supplemental Declaration means an instrument Recorded pursuant to Article XVI to annex additional real property to the Covered Property or supplementing this Master Declaration, as such instrument is amended or restated. 1.65 TELECOMMUNICATION FACILITIES. Telecommunication Facilities means equipment, cables, conduits, inner ducts, vaults, connecting hardware, wires, poles, transmitters, towers, antennae and other facilities and structures necessary for, or used in, the provisions of Telecommunication Services. 1.66 TELECOMMUNICATION SERVICES. Telecommunications Services means Telecommunication Facilities, Improvements, and services for cable television, communications, telecommunications, antenna, high-speed data, telephony and all related vertical services, intranet, internet, information transfer, transmission, video and other similar services. Declarant may expand this definition in any Supplemental Declaration. 1.67 VA. VA means the Department of Veterans Affairs of the United States of America and any department or agency of the United States government which succeeds to VA's function of issuing guarantees of notes secured by Deeds of Trust on residential meal estate. ARTICLE II USE RESTRICTIONS This Article establishes limits on the use of Homes and Lots in the Residential Area of the Covered Property. The Board has the power to enforce the use restrictions. Potential purchasers of Lots and Condominiums in the Residential Area should read these use restrictions closely to make sure they can use their property as they intends, without violating these use restrictions. For purposes of this Article Il, the term "Owner" shall be deemed to refer to an Owner or to any person residing in the Owner's Home with the Owner's permission (a "Resident'). -11- 2544-332531G7.P428XXRS% 581730.13 2/1106 The Residential Area shall be held, used and enjoyed subject to the following restrictions. Real property added to the Covered Property that is not part of the Residential Area is exempt from the restrictions established in this Article unless the Supplemental Declaration annexing the property to the Covered Property indicates that the property being annexed is subject to the restrictions in. this Article. Neighborhood Declarations may establish supplementary or more restrictive use restrictions for the property they encumber so long as the restrictions are consistent with the scheme of governance established in the Master Declaration and any applicable Supplemental Declaration. Supplemental Declarations may add use restrictions or replace the use restrictions contained in this Article for the property the Supplemental Declarations encumber. 2.1 SINGLE FAMILY HOME. Each Home shall be used only for (a) residential purposes, or (b) business or commercial activities authorized by this Section. An Owner may rent his Home to a single Family provided that the Home is rented pursuant to a lease or rental agreement which is (i) in writing, (ii) no less than thirty (30) days in duration, and (iii) subject to all of the provisions of the Community Association Governing Documents or any other requirements set forth by the Community Association. Notwithstanding the foregoing, in no event shall an Owner be permitted to rent his Home to any entity, club or other Person where the renters are multiple, unrelated Persons who pay for the right to occupy the Home for a limited period of time or who pay for the right to occupy the Home for purposes other than a primary residence (i.e., vacations). Any failure by the lessee of any Lot or Condominium to comply with the Community Association Governing Documents shall constitute a default under the lease or rental agreement Homes may be used for business or commercial activities so long as the following requirements are met: 2.1.1 Compliance With Law. The activities are conducted in conformance .ear with all applicable governmental ordinances; 2.1.2 Streets and Parking Areas. The patrons or clientele do not overburden the streets or parking areas in the Covered Property, considering the streets and parking areas are a part of a residential community, not a commercial development; 2.1.3 Exterior Effects. The existence or operation of such activities does not produce sounds, odors or materials outside the boundaries of the Home, or Neighborhood Property that are excessive or inappropriate for a residential community; 2.1.4 Insurance. The activity does not increase the Community Association's liability or casualty insurance obligation or premium; 2.1.5 No Signs. No sign, poster, billboard, balloon advertising device or other display of any kind pertaining to such activity may be displayed; and 2.1.6 Consistent. The activities are consistent with the character of the Residential Area and the Covered Property as a whole and conform to the provisions of this Master Declaration. -12- 2544-33253%CLP428TMX 581730.13 2/1!06 Offices operated by (A) the manager of a Neighborhood Association for the sole purpose of managing the Neighborhood Association, and (B) the Community Association, are exempt from the restrictions contained in this Section. Except as authorized in this Section 2. 1, no part of the Residential Area may be used for any business, commercial (including auctions or similar events), manufacturing, mercantile, storage, vending or other nonresidential purposes, including any activity for which the provider is compensated or receives any consideration, regardless of whether the activity is engaged in full or part-time, generates or does not generate a profit, or requires or does not require a license. 2.2 NUISANCES. No noxious or offensive activities may be carried on upon the Covered Property or on any public street abutting or visible from the Covered Property. The Community Association is entitled to determine if any noise, odor, or activity constitutes a nuisance. The Community Association is entitled to delegate responsibility for enforcing the restrictions on nuisances contained in this Section to the Owners or Neighborhood Associations. No Owner may permit or cause anything to be done or kept on the Covered Property or on any public street abutting the Covered Property which may (a) increase the rate of insurance in the Covered Property, (b) result in the cancellation of such insurance, or (c) obstruct or interfere with the rights of other Owners. No Owner may commit or permit any nuisance in the Covered Property. Each Owner shall comply with all requirements of the local or state health authorities and with all other applicable governmental ordinances regarding occupancy and use of a tilt - Condominium or Lot, including the Home thereon. Each Owner is accountable to the Community Association and other Owners for the conduct and behavior of Persons residing in or visiting his Home. The Community Association has the power to require that any damage to the Association Property, Maintenance Areas, personal property of the Community Association, or W, property of another Owner caused by such Persons shall be repaired at the sole expense of the Home where such Persons are residing or visiting. 2.3 SIGNS. Subject to Civil Code Sections 712, 713, and 13535, no sign, poster, billboard, balloon advertising device or other display of any kind shall be displayed in the Covered Property except the following, which must also be in accordance with the Tustin City Code or a City -approved sign program: 2.3.1 Declarant and Neighborhood Builder Signs. Signs (regardless of size or configuration) as may be used by Declarant and the Neighborhood Builders in connection with the development of the Covered Property and the sale, lease or other disposition of Homes; 2.3.2 Entry Monuments. Entry moftuinents and similar community identification signs either maintained by the Community Association or approved by the Design Review Committee and maintained by the Neighborhood Associations; 2.3.3 Lots or Condominiums. Subject to the Design Guidelines, one (1) nameplate or similar Owner name identification, and one (1) sign advising of the existence of security services protecting a Lot or Condominium; and -13- 2544332531CLP42ElCCRs1581730.13 2!1/06 2.3.4 Sale or Lease. One (1) sign which may be displayed on each Lot or Condominium advertising the Lot of Condominium for sale or lease; provided that such sign complies with the Community Guidelines. 2.4 PARKING AND VEHICULAR RESTRICTIONS. The Community Association may elect to delegate the responsibility for enforcing the restrictions contained in this Section 2.4 to any Neighborhood Association. If the Community Association notifies a Neighborhood Association that the Community Association has delegated its responsibilities, the Neighborhood Association must enforce these restrictions as they apply to the property subject to the Neighborhood Association's jurisdiction. If a Neighborhood Association fails to enforce these restrictions, the Community Association may revoke the delegation or impose a Compliance Assessment. 2.4.1 Authorized Vehicles. The following vehicles are "Authorized Vehicles": (a) standard passenger vehicles, including automobiles, vehicles designed to accommodate ten (10) or fewer people, (b) motorcycles and (c) pick-up trucks having a payload capacity of one (1) ton or less. Authorized Vehicles may be parked in any portion of the Covered Property intended for parking of motorized vehicles, subject to the restrictions in the other portions of the Community Association Governing Documents. No Owner may park any vehicle in a manner so that the Community Association determines that the vehicle unreasonably extends beyond the boundaries of a parking space or into streets or sidewalks in the Covered Property. The Community Association has the power to identify additional vehicles as Authorized Vehicles in the Community Guidelines to adapt this restriction to new types of vehicles produced by manufacturers. 2.4.2 Prohibited Vehicles. The following vehicles are "Prohibited Vehicles": (a) recreational vehicles (including motorhomes, travel trailers, camper vans and water craft), (b) commercial -type vehicles (inchiding pick-up trucks having a payload capacity in excess of one (1) ton, stakebed trucks, tank trucks, dump trucks, step .vans, concrete trucks, limousines, and other commercial purpose vehicles) or vehicles with commercial advertisements, placards or other writing on the vehicle or any equipment on a vehicle used for any commercial purpose, (c) vehicles designed to accommodate more than ten (10) people, (d) vehicles having more than two (2) axles, (e) trailers, inoperable vehicles or parts of vehicles, (f) aircraft, (g) other similar vehicles, or (h) any vehicle or vehicular equipment deemed a nuisance by the Board. Prohibited Vehicles may not be parked, stored or kept on any public or private street in, adjacent to or visible from the Covered Property or any other Association Property parking area unless (i) they are owned and used by the Community Association or a Neighborhood Association in connection with management or maintenance of a part of the Covered Property, (ii) they are parked for brief periods as may be defined in the Community Guidelines (such as loading, unloading, making deliveries or emergency repairs), or (iii) they are parked in an Owner's fully enclosed garage with the door closed. Prohibited Vehicles may be parked in an Owner's garage only if, and to the extent that, an Owner has fewer Authorized Vehicles than the number of vehicles the garage was originally designed to hold. No Owner may fill a garage with a Prohibited Vehicle or Vehicles and park an Authorized Vehicle or Vehicles on a driveway or the street. If a vehicle qualifies as both an Authorized Vehicle and a Prohibited Vehicle, then the vehicle is presumed to be a Prohibited Vehicle, unless the vehicle is expressly classified as an Authorized Vehicle in writing by the Board. The Community Association has the power to -14- 2544-33253\CLP428VCCRS\ 581730.13 identify additional vehicles as Prohibited Vehicles in the Community Guidelines to adapt this restriction to new types of vehicles produced by manufacturers. 2.4.3 General Restrictions. All vehicles owned or operated by or within the control of an Owner and kept in the Covered Property must be parked in the assigned parking space or garage of that Owner to the extent of the space available; provided that, although storage of personal items may occur in the garage, all Authorized Vehicles must be parked in the garage, in accordance with Exhibit PC -1 attached hereto. Notwithstanding the foregoing, Owners may not park any Authorized Vehicle in the street or in any guest parking .spaces. No repair, maintenance or restoration of any vehicle may be conducted on the Covered Property except in an enclosed garage when the garage door is closed, provided such activity is not undertaken as a business, and provided that such activity may be prohibited entirely by the Board if the Board determines that it constitutes a nuisance. The Community Association has the power to enforce the restrictions in this Section 2.4.3. 2.4.4 No Parking Zones. Vehicles may not be parked in "no parking zones" identified in the Supplemental Declarations. Some of these no parking zones will be identified only by signs and will not be identified with red -painted curbs. Vehicles parked in these no parking zones may be towed immediately without advance notice to vehicle owners. The parking and circulation areas in the Covered Property are located approximately as shown on Exhibit "PC" attached hereto. Notwithstanding the foregoing, a minimum of five hundred sixty- two (562) unassigned parking spaces (a portion of which shall be for use by members of the public only and shall not be available for use by Owners or their guests), shall be permanently maintained in locations shown on Exhibit "PC", and such parking spaces shall have a minimum length of twenty-two (22) feet per stall for on -street parking. 2.4.5 Parking Regulations. The Community Association may establish additional regulations regarding any parking areas not assigned to individual Lots or Condominiums, including designating "parking," "guest parking," and "no parking" areas, setting time limits for parking vehicles in the Association Property parking areas, and requiring registration of vehicles or use of parking permits. The Community Association shall develop and adopt an enforcement program for parking and traffic regulations for the Covered Property and may enforce all parking and vehicle use regulations applicable to the Covered Property through any means allowed by law, including removing violating vehicles without Notice and Hearing pursuant to California Vehicle Code Section 226582 or other applicable ordinances or statutes. If the Community Association fails to enforce any of the parking or vehicle use regulations, the City may enforce such regulations. If the City fails to enforce any of its parking ordinances on public streets in or abutting the Covered Property, including the no parking zones identified in Supplemental Declarations, the Community Association has the power to enforce such ordinances against the Covered Property Owners. No one is allowed to obstruct the fire protection apcess easements identified (a) on the Recorded Tract Maps for the Covered Property, (b) in any Supplemental Declaration or (c) as may be designated by the Community Association with the approval of the Fire Chief. The approval of the Fire Chief is required for any modifications such as speed bumps, control gates or other changes in the fire protection access easement areas. -15- 2544-332SMY42MCM 581730.13 VIM 2.4.6 Additional Restrictions. Notwithstanding any provision to the contrary in this Section 2.4, (a) no delivery and/or moving trucks larger than forty (40) feet shall be permitted on any private drive located within a Condominium Neighborhood having less than a twenty-five foot (25') radius turn, and (b) an Owner may park any Authorized Vehicle that exceeds seven (7) feet high, seven () feet wide, and nineteen (19) feet long in an Owner's garage or driveway as long as the vehicle does not extend onto the sidewalk or drive approach areas. 2.5 ANIMAL RESTRICTIONS. The only animals that may be raised, bred or kept in the Residential Area are dogs, cats, fish, birds and other usual household pets; provided that they are not kept or bred for commercial purposes, in unreasonable quantities, or in violation of the Community Association Governing Documents. As used in this Master Declaration, "unreasonable quantities" ordinarily means more than three (3) pets per household; provided, however, that the Board may determine that a reasonable number in any instance may be more or less. The Board may also change the authorized number of pets in the Community Guidelines. The Board may limit the size of pets and may prohibit maintenance of any animal which, in the Board's opinion, constitutes a nuisance. Animals in the Covered Property must be either kept in an enclosure or on a leash held by a person capable of controlling the animal. Any Person shall be liable to each and every other Person for any unreasonable noise or damage to person or property caused by any animals brought or kept upon the Covered Property by such Person. Persons shall clean up after their animals use the Covered Property or public street abutting or visible from the Covered Property. Any Person who keeps any animal, insect or reptile in the Covered Property, whether in compliance with or in violation of the Community Association Governing Documents, shall indemnify, defend and hold harmless the Community Association, its officers, directors, contractors, agents and employees from any claim brought by any Person against the Community Association, its officers, directors, agents and employees for personal injuries or property damage caused by such animal, insect or reptile. The Community Association, at its option, may elect to only enforce this Section in connection with the Association Property, leaving for the Owners and the Neighborhood Associations the power to enforce this Section as it applies to other areas of the Covered Property. 2.6 EXTERIOR ITEMS. Weeds, rubbish, debris, unsightly material or objects and trash may not be kept upon the Covered Property or on any public street abutting or visible from the Covered Property. Trashmay be kept in individual and sanitary containers in rear yards of those non -Condominium Homes located on an individual Lot in the Residential Area, -or otherwise at the designated curbside areas, located approximately as shown on Exhibit "TC" attached hereto; and in accordance with the Community Guidelines. No odor may be permitted to arise from such containers so as to render any portion of the Covered Property offensive or detrimental to any other property in the vicinity thereof or to its occupants. Owners' trash containers may be exposed to the view of neighboring Homes only when set out for a reasonable period of time (no earlier than 6:00 p.m. on the day before scheduled trash collection times and no later than midnight the day of pick up); provided, however, that the Community Guidelines may set forth more restrictive times. Trash containers owned by the Community Association or by Neighborhood Associations may be kept on Association Property or Neighborhood Property so long as they are contained in an enclosure installed by Declarant or a Neighborhood Builder or approved by the Design Review Committee. No exterior fires are permitted, except in barbeques and fire pits. -16- 2544-33253T1.P4U1C=% 581730.13 2/1/06 2.7 TEMPORARY BUILDINGS. Outbuildings, tents, storage sheds, shacks, or other temporary buildings or Improvements may not be placed on the Covered Property either temporarily or permanently, without the prior written consent of the Design Review Committee. Garages, carports, trailers, campers, motor homes, recreation vehicles or other vehicles may not be used as Homes in the Covered Property, either temporarily or permanently. 2.8 ASSOCIATION PROPERTY/MAINTENANCE AREAS. Owners and Neighborhood Associations shall not alter the Association Property or Maintenance Areas without the prior written consent of the Board. 2.9 OUTSIDE INSTALLATIONS. Projections of any type are not permitted above the roof of any building in the Covered Property, except chimneys and vent stacks originally installed, if at all, by Declarant or a Neighborhood Builder. Portable and fixed basketball backboard and other sports apparatus are subject to regulation by the Community Association. No fence or wall may be erected, altered or maintained around any Home or on any Lot except with the Design Review Committee's prior approval. No. patio cover, wiring, or air conditioning fixture, water softeners, or otherr devices may be installed on the exterior of a Home or be allowed to protrude through the walls or roof of the Home (with the exception of thbse items installed by Declarant or a Neighborhood Builder) unless the Design Review Committee's prior written approval is obtained. �- 2.10 INSIDE INSTALLATIONS. The Community Association has the power to prohibit or restrict the use of aluminum foil, newspaper, paint, reflective tint or any other material as window coverings in the Community Guidelines or Design Guidelines. The Community Association also has the power in the Design Guidelines to authorize Owners to use temporary window coverings after the Close of Escrow pending'the installation of drapes, curtains, shutters or other appropriate interior window coverings for limited periods of time. 2.11 ANTENNAE. Owners are prohibited from installing any antennae outside of or on the exterior of a Home for any purpose, except for an "Authorized Antenna," which may be installed in accordance with the Design Guidelines, the Community Guidelines and the City Code. - An "Authorized Antenna" means (a) an antenna designed to receive direct broadcast satellite service, including direct -to -home satellite service, that is one meter or less in diameter, (b) an antenna that is designed to receive video programming service, including multichannel multipoint distribution service, instructional television fixed service, and local multipoint distribution service, that is one meter or less in diameter or diagonal measurement, (c) an antenna designed to receive television broadcast signals, or (d) a mast supporting an antenna described in items (a), (b), and (e) above. So long as the Owner consents, a Resident shall have the same rights as the Owner concerning the installation or use of an Authorized Antenna under this Section. The Design Review Committee may request proof of the Owner's consent before approving a Resident's application for installation of an Authorized Antenna. -17- 2544-33=%CLP428WM% 581730.13 211106 The Community Association may adopt restrictions on the installation or use of an Authorized Antenna on an Owner's Home so long as such restrictions do not (i) unreasonably delay or prevent installation, maintenance or use of an Authorized Antenna, (ii) unreasonably increase the cost of installation maintenance or use of an Authorized Antenna, (iii) preclude acceptable quality reception, or (iv) violate applicable law. The Community Association may prohibit the installation of an Authorized Antenna if the installation, location or maintenance of such Authorized Antenna unreasonably affects the safety of managers, agents or employees of the Community Association, any Neighborhood Association and other Owners, or for any other safety related reason established by the Community Association. The Community Association may also (A) prohibit an Owner from installing an Authorized Antenna on property which such Owner does not own or is not entitled to exclusively use or control under the Community Association Governing Documents, or (B) allow an Owner to install an antenna other than an -Authorized Antenna subject to the Design Guidelines and review by the Design Review Committee. Notwithstanding- anything contained in this Master Declaration, Declarant, Neighborhood Builders and the Community Association do not warrant, represent or guarantee that satellite service will be provided to an Owner after installation of an Authorized Antenna. The location of an Owner's Home Improvements surrounding the Home or other factors over which the Declarant, Neighborhood Builders and the Community Association have no control may not allow for acceptable satellite reception. This Section is intended to be a restatement of the authority granted to the Community Association under applicable law. All amendments, modifications, restatements and interpretations of the law applicable to the installation, use or maintenance of an antenna shall be interpreted to amend, modify, restate or interpret this Section. 2.12 DRILLING. No oil drilling, oil, gas or mineral development operations, oil refining, geothermal exploration or development, quarrying or mining operations of any kind may be conducted upon the Covered Property, nor are oil wells, tanks, tunnels or mineral excavations or shafts permitted upon the surface of any Lot or within five hundred feet (500') below the surface of the Covered Property. No derrick or other structure designed for use in boring for water, oil, geothermal heat or natural gas may be erected, maintained or permitted in the Covered Property. 2.13 FURTHER SUBDIVISION. Except as otherwise provided in this Master Declaration, no Owner may further partition or subdivide his Lot or Condominium, including any division of such Owner's Lot or Condominium into time-share estates or time-share uses. This provision does not limit the right of an Owner to (a) rent or lease his entire Lot or Condominium by means of a written lease or rental agreement subject to the Community Association Governing Documents; (b) sell such Owner's Lot or Condominium; or (c) transfer or sell any Lot or Condominium to more than one (1) Person to be held by them as tenants-in- common, joint tenants, tenants by the entirety or as community property. -18- 2544.33253%W4281CCRs1581730.13 2/1/06 2.14 DRAINAGE. 2.14.1 Drainage Systems.. Rain gutters, down spouts, drainage systems or the established drainage pattern for a Lot, Condominium or Neighborhood Property originally installed or established by Declarant or the Neighborhood Builders, may not be altered or interfered with unless an adequate alternative provision is made. For the purpose hereof, "established" drainage means the pattern and drainage Improvements which exist at the time that such Lot, Condominium or Neighborhood Property is conveyed to a purchaser or Neighborhood Association (as appropriate) from Declarant or a Neighborhood Builder, and includes drainage from the Lots, Condominiums, Neighborhood Property, Association Property and Maintenance Areas onto adjacent Lots, Condominiums, Neighborhood Property and Association Property. 2.14.2 Pollutant Runoff. The Community Association, the Neighborhood Associations and the Owners shall comply with the City -approved Water Quality Management Plan for the regulation and control of pollutant run-off by using structural and non-structural "Best Management Practien," in accordance with City standards and a separate Operation and Maintenance Plan, the applicable provisions of which will be recorded separately against the Covered Property and distributed by (i) the Declarant to the Community Association and (ii) the Neighborhood Builders to any Neighborhood Association and to each Owner at the Close of Escrow for a Lot, and may include the following: (a) The Community Association and the Neighborhood Associations shall periodically provide to their members environmental awareness education materials made available by the local municipalities. These materials will describe the use of chemicals (including household types) that should be limited to the Covered Property with no discharge of specified wastes via hosing or other direct discharge to gutters, catch basins, settling basins and storm drains. The materials shall also provide a description of fertilizer and pesticide usage guidelines consistent with any City Management Guidelines for Use of Fertilizers and Pesticides. - (b) The Community Association and the Neighborhood Associations shall establish trash management and litter control procedures aimed at reducing pollution of drainage water. (c) The Community Association and the Neighborhood Associations shall have any drainage systems, streets and catch basins on property they maintain inspected and cleaned, and any streets and parking areas they maintain swept prior to the storm season (no later than October 15th each year). (d) The Community Association and the Neighborhood ' Associations will maintain the property for which they are responsible consistent with the City Water Conservation Resolution and use fertilizers and pesticides consistent with City Management Guidelines for use of fertilizers and pesticides. Owners are responsible for implementing applicable Best Management Practices for their Lots and Condominiums. (e) The Community Association and the Neighborhood Associations shall implement irrigation and landscaping practices which will include provision -19- 254433253%CLP4281C= 581730.13 211/06 of water sensors, programmable irrigation times, grouping of plants with similar water requirements in order to reduce excess irrigation runoff and to promote surface filtration. The Community Association and the Neighborhood Associations shall maintain erosion control devices -on the property they maintain until adequate vegetation coverage has been achieved following establishment of the landscape plantings. 2.15 WATER SUPPLY SYSTEMS. Individual water supply or water softener systems are prohibited on any Lot or in any Condominium unless such system is designed, located, constructed and equipped in accordance with the requirements, standards and recommendations of any applicable water district, the Design Review Committee, and all other applicable Local Governmental Agencies. 2.16 VIEW OBSTRUCTIONS. Each Owner acknowledges that (a) any construction or installation by Declarant, any Neighborhood Builder; the Community Association or any Neighborhood Association and (b) maturing plants and tree growth may impair the view of such Owner, and consents to such impairment.. Each Owner acknowledges that there are no guaranteed views in the Covered Property, and no Lot or Condominium is assured the existence or unobstructed continuation of any particular view unless a Supplemental Declaration specifically provides otherwise. 2.17 SOLAR ENERGY SYSTEMS. Each Owner may install a solar energy system which serves his Home so long as (a) the design and location of the solar energy system meet the requirements of all applicable governmental ordinances and (b) said design and location receive the prior written approval of the Design Review Committee. 2.18 INSTALLATION OF LANDSCAPING. If any landscaping on a Residential Area Lot has not been installed by Declarant or a Neighborhood Builder, .each Owner shall submit landscaping plans to the Design Review Committee within the time frame set in the Design Guidelines and complete the installation of any landscaping in accordance with a plan approved by the Design Review Committee within the time frame set in the Design Guidelines. 2.19 POST TENSION CONCRETE SLABS. The concrete slab for some or all of the Homes in the Covered Property may have been reinforced with a grid of steel cable which was installed in the concrete and then tightened to create a very high tension. This type of slab is commonly known as a "post -tension slab." Cutting into a post -tension slab for any reason (e.g., to install a floor safe, to remodel plumbing, etc.) is very hazardous and may result in serious damage to the Home and/or personal injury. Owners shall not cut into or otherwise tamper with a post -tension slab. Owners shall not knowingly permit or allow any other person to cut into or tamper with a post -tension slab, other than a licensed contractor who has been informed that the slab is post -tensioned and who has identified the location of the cables running within the slab. Owners shall disclose the existence of the post -tension slab (if any) to any tenant, subsequent purchaser or lessee of the Home. Owner shall indemnify and hold the Neighborhood Builders, Declarant, and their respective officers, employees, contractors and agents, free and harmless from and against any and all claims, damages, losses or other liability (including attorneys fees) arising from any breach of this Section. -20- 2544-3325AMY4281CCRA 581730.13 211/06 2.20 RIGHTS OF DISABLED. Subject to the provisions of Article V hereof, each Owner may modify his Home and the route leading to the front door of his Home, at his sole expense, in order to facilitate access to his Home by persons who are blind, visually impaired, deaf or physically disabled, or to alter conditions which could be hazardous to such persons, in accordance with California Civil Code Section 1360 or any other applicable law. ARTICLE III DISCLOSURES This Article describes the characteristics of certain land uses, facilities and activities within and near the Covered Property -which may have a continuing impact on the Covered Property and its residents Potential purchasers or tenants of Homes should read these descriptions closely to make sure they can use their Home as they intend subject to these potential impacts 3.1 SOIL CONDITIONS. For in-depth information regarding the geotechnical aspects of the Covered Property, Owners should review the soils report on file with the City for the Covered Property and take into consideration the following: 3.1.1 Expansive Soil. According to the soils report, soil in the Covered Property is highly exqasive in nature. Expansive soil expands when it becomes wet and it contracts when it dries out. Expansion and contraction of soils may cause movement, lifting, E cracking and distress in slabs, patios, sidewalks and other flatwork improvements. Some cracking is normal in all flatwork improvements, with or without expansive soils. However, some expansion damage may be reduced by use of appropriate design and construction techniques. When designing flatwork and other Improvements, Owners should advise their consultants that designs must accommodate soils with expansion potential. In addition, Owners should consider the following information and recommendations before making or modifying any Improvements: (a) Concrete and Masonry Improvements. Special attention is required in designing and constructing concrete and masonry Improvements such as masonry walls and planters, concrete slabs, and decking. For example, steel reinforcing bars may be required in lieu of steel mesh in concrete patio slabs. Block walls may require extra horizontal and vertical steel reinforcing bars. (b) Drainage and Irrigation. Owners must use adequate drainage and irrigation control. Drainage devices installed in the Covered Property by Declarant or a Neighborhood Builder should not be altered in any manner that will redirect or obstruct drainage through these devices. The construction or modification of Improvements should not result in ponding of water. Drainage devices, including, but not limited to, concrete ditches, area drain lines and gutters should be carefully designed and installed with professional assistance and then maintained in an unobstructed condition. Drainage devices installed by Declarant designed to serve more than the (1) Lot or Condominium should not be altered in a manner that will redirect or obstruct the drainage through these drainage devices. The landscape irrigation system should be designed, constructed and operated to prevent excessive saturation of soils. Water must drain away from the Home footings and other Improvements. Obstructions such as walls should not -21- .2544-33253%CLP42B\CCRS%581730.13 VIM be constructed across swales unless adequate replacement drainage Improvements have been installed or created. Planters should be .lined with an impervious surface and should contain outlets to drain excess water. 3.1.2 Fill Soil. Homes in the Covered Property may be constructed on fill soil in accordance with the recommendations and inspection of licensed civil and soils engineers. 3.1.3 Corrosive Soil. Soils in some areas of the Covered Property are potentially severely corrosive. Soluble sulfates and acidic soils are highly corrosive to buried metals and concrete and should be taken into account in the construction of below grade structures and hardscape. Sulfates may chemically and physically attack concrete that is not sulfate resistant, causing the concrete to break down. Thus, Owners must use the proper type of cement and water -to -cement ratio for the level of sulfates or acidity that exists on Owner's Lot or Condominium. Overwatering soil will exacerbate the corrosivity of the soil. Owners should inform contractors of this potential condition to allow them to use appropriate measures to combat the effects of corrosive soil on buried metals, below grade structures and hardscape. 3.1.4 Groundwater. Groundwater has been encountered in portions of the Covered Property at depths of six (6) to twenty-five (25) feet below the ground surface. No Person may dig or drill on any Lot or Condominium to a depth that would disturb or otherwise come in contact with the groundwater. Groundwater may rise during the rainy season. 3.1.5 Soils Experts. Before installation of a spa or any patio, concrete or other flatwork on the Lot or Condominium, Owners must consult with a licensed soils engineer to ensure that the Improvement is designed and constructed correctly in light of current soils conditions, including groundwater level determinations. Although consulting with a soils expert may add substantially to the cost of installation of Improvements, failure to do so may result in significant breaking, lifting, separating, tilting or cracking of concrete Improvements. 3.2 ENVIRONMENTAL CONDITION. Certain areas designated on the map for Tract No. 16581 as "IRP -13S" and "IRP -13W" (collectively, the "LIFOCProperty'j are owned by the United States of America ("U.S. Government') and will ultimately be annexed into the Covered Property pursuant to Section 16.6. 3.2.1 Prior Use of the LIFOC Property. That portion of the LIFOC Property identified as IRP -13S is approximately 0.7 acres and was previously used as a "Temporary Storage Area" ("TSA') and as a "Miscellaneous Wash Area" ("MWA"). The TSA consisted of two buildings that were used for vehicle maintenance. Cleaning solvents were reportedly used to wash down floors in the buildings and waste solvent was likely released to storm drains, or to the ground outside the building. The MMA includes an inactive wash pad formerly used for cleaning small generators and other field equipment. Solvents were used in this area and may have been released to the subsurface through cracks in the concrete pad. That portion of the LIFOC Property identified as IRP -13W was previously used as a former disposal area where hydraulic fluid, diesel, fuel, leaded gasoline, oil, paint stripper, batter acid and solvent were stored. -22- 2544-33253XW429%0M% 581730.13 V1106 3.2.2 Release of Volatile Organic Compounds. As a result of the historic use of the LIFOC Property, hazardous substances have been released. into the groundwater at the LIFOC Property. Volatile Organic Compounds ("VOCs'), including trichloroethylene ("TCE' ) and 1,2,3 Tricholoropropane ("1,2,3 TCP'), were found in groundwater at concentrations that could result in adverse effect to human health if this water was extracted from the ground and directly used for domestic purposes such as drinking or bathing. However, groundwater at this location is currently not used for such purposes. 3.2.3 Remedial Action Plan. As a result of the release of hazardous substances at the LIFOC Property, various remedial activities have occurred at the LIFOC Property and will continue to occur until remediation goals have been achieved. In October 2004, the Department of Navy issued a "Final Record of Decision/Remediation Plan, Operable Unit IA, Former Marine Corps Air Station, Tustin, California," which describes the specific remedial action plan "RAPn that has been approved for IRP -13S to address groundwater contamination. In August 2005, the Department of Navy published, a "Draft Feasibility Study report for Operable Unit 4B [includes IRP -13W], Former Marine Corps Air Station, Tustin, California," ("Feasibili(y Study) which addresses a range of remedial alternatives to address the VOCs in groundwater. As documented in the Feasibility Study, "no further action was recommended for soil at OU -4B sites ... therefore, soil remediation..." was not addressed in the Feasibility Study. A final groundwater remedial action plan has not been selected for IRP -13W. 3.2.4 Deed Restrictions. Deed restrictions will ultimately be recorded on all or a portion of Lots within the LIFOC Property that will limit certain activities on such Lots. These deed restrictions will identify specific land use restrictions to prevent exposure of future landowners and/or users of the LIFOC Property to hazardous substances and to maintain the integrity of the remedial action until remediation is complete and remediation goals have been achieved. 3.2.5 Documentation Relating to the Release and Remediation Activities. Extensive documentation has been prepared that describes the nature and extent of the release of hazardous substances that has occurred at the LIFOC Property. The following reports are available for public review and document the investigation and remediation work that has been or will be performed at the LIFOC Property: • Draft Feasibility Study Report for Operable Unit 4B, Former Marine Corps Air Station, Tustin, California, August 2005, Bechtel Environmental, Inc., August 2005. • Final Record of Decision/Remedial Action Plan Operable Unit 1A, Former Marine corps Air Station, Tustin, California, Department of Navy, October 2004. • Final Feasibility Study Report, OU -IA, Marine Corps Air Station, Tustin, California, Bechtel Environmental, Inc., August 2003. • Final Environmental Impact Statement/Environmental Impact Report, Disposal and Reuse of MCAS Tustin, California, Department of Navy and City of Tustin, December, 1999. -23- 2544-332531CU42MCRs1581730.13 2/1/06 3.3 GRADING. The grading design in the Covered Property should not be altered to redirect surface water flow toward the Lots or Condominiums or onto adjacent property, or to trap water so that it ponds or floods. Grading modifications are subject to law, approval by the Board, and the terms of any Recorded drainage easements. 3.4 AFFORDABLE HOUSING. The City has required Declarant to provide units of affordable housing and units of transitional housing within the Covered Property. Certain Lots or Condominiums in the Covered Property will be offered to persons .who qualify as very low, low and moderate income buyers pursuant to guidelines established by the United States Department of Housing and Urban Development for the City. Buyers who qualify as very low, low and moderate income will purchase their Lots or Condominiums subject to resale restrictions, as reflected in a recorded covenant agreement. Buyers who are interested in the affordable housing program should consult their sales counselor for further information. 3.5 UTILITY IMPROVEMENTS. All utility lines in the Covered Property shall be installed and maintained underground, however, there will be both above -ground and subterranean utility Improvements such as transformers, lift stations, water or sewer facilities, telecommunications vaults and other visible Improvements necessary for the delivery of utilities or other services either on or adjacent to each Lot or Condominium. Each Owner understands that the placement of such Improvements is dictated by the needs of the applicable utility or service provider, and the presence of such Improvements in the Covered Property is in accordance with easements created prior to or during the development of the Covered Property. 3.6 COMMUNITY FACILITIES DISTRICT AND ASSESSMENT DISTRICTS. The Covered Property lies within the boundaries of Special Assessment Districts and Mello - Roos Community Facilities Districts which require the levy of special taxes for the repayment of bonds issued for the purpose of paying the cost of services or capital improvements that have been or are being provided. The amount of the special tax and any other information pertaining to any such district can be obtained from the County Assessor's office. Owners will be obligated to pay these assessments as a part of the annual property tax bill. 3.7 AIRPORT INFLUENCE AREA. NOTICE. The following notice is included in this Master Declaration in accordance with California Civil Code Section 1353: NOTICE OF AIRPORT IN VICINITY This property is presently located in the vicinity of an airport, within what is known as an airport influence area. For that reason, the property may be subject to some of the annoyances or inconveniences associated with proximity to airport operations (for example: noise, vibration, or odors). Individual sensitivities to those annoyances can vary from person to person. You may wish to consider what airport annoyances, if any, are associated with the property before you complete your purchase and determine whether they are acceptable to you. An "airport influence area" is defined in California Civil Code Section 1353 as an area in which current or future airport-rslated noise, overflight, safety, or airspace protection factors may significantly affect land uses or necessitate restrictions on those uses as determined by an airport land use commission. -24- 2544.33253\CLP428=RS1591730.13 211/06 i i a 3.8 RECLAIMED WATER. The water used in the Homes and outside in the patio and yard areas through hose bibs will be domestic potable water. In its efforts to conserve water, the Irvine Ranch Water District (the "Water DistHd') requires the use of reclaimed water (treated wastewater) to irrigate parks, school yards, golf courses, greenbelt areas and common areas. The water used to irrigate the Association Property and Maintenance Areas may therefore include reclaimed water. Reclaimed water is not potable and therefore not suitable for pet or human consumption. As with any water overspray, the repeated spray of reclaimed water may stain or discolor personal property, fencing and structural Improvements. According to the Water District, the Water District's reclaimed water is disinfected with chlorine and its clarity to the human eye is indistinguishable from domestic water. The standards imposed on the Water District for reclaimed water quality are established by governmental regulatory agencies, and these standards are subject to change. Declarant, the Community Association and their agents are not liable for any property damage or personal injury by reclaimed water. Owners are subject to Water District rules and regulations, one of which prohibits the use of self -generating water softeners connected to Water District sewer facilities. Further information regarding Watei District regulations is available at the Water District's headquarters. 3.9 PROPERTY LINES. The boundaries of each Lot and Condominium in the Covered Property and the Association Property are delineated on subdivision (tract) maps, lot line adjustments, parcel maps, or condominium plans that are public records and are available at the County Recorder's Office. 3.10 OFFERS OF DEDICATION. Portions of the Association Property and Maintenance Areas are subject to irrevocable offers of dedication as shown on the Recorded tract maps for the Covered Property. The County or City may accept the offer of dedication and assume responsibility for maintaining these portions of the Association Property and Maintenance Areas at any time. If accepted by the City or County at a later time,. the level of maintenance provided by the City or County may not be the same as that provided by the Community Association. 3.11 CHANGE IN PLANS. Declarant and Neighborhood Builders have the right to develop the Covered Property with Improvements that may be different in design, size, character, style and price from those in any previous Phase. 3.12 NO ENHANCED PROTECTION AGREEMENT. No provisions of this Master Declaration and any Supplemental Declaration are intended, or shall be interpreted, to be an "enhanced protection agreement" as defined in Section 901 of the California Civil Code. 3.13 ADDITIONAL PROVISIONS. There may be provisions of various laws, including the Davis -Stirling Common Interest Development Act codified at Sections 1350, et seq. of the California Civil Code and the federal Fair Housing Act codified at Title 42 United States Code, Section 3601 et seq., which may supplement or override the Community Association Governing Documents. Declarant makes no representations or warranties regarding the future enforceability of any portion of the Community Association Governing Documents. -25- 2544-332531CLR428%C= 581730.13 2/1/06 3.14 OTHER REPRESENTATIONS AND WARRANTIES. No representations or warranties of any kind, express or implied, have been given or made by Declarant, the Neighborhood Builders, the Community Association or their agents or employees in connection with the Covered Property, its physical condition, zoning, compliance with laws or fitness for intended use, or in connection with the subdivision, sale, operation, maintenance, cost of maintenance, taxes or regulation thereof -as a master planned community, except as specifically and expressly set forth in the Community Association Governing Documents, as filed by Declarant or a Neighborhood Builder with the DRE, and as set forth in writing by Declarant or a Neighborhood Builder in an agreement for the purchase of a Home in the Covered Property or in an attachment thereto. ARTICLE IV GOVERNANCE BY THE COMMUNITY ASSOCIATION The success of the community is dependent upon the support and participation of each Owner in its governance and administration. This Master Declaration establishes the Community Association as the mechanism through which each Owner is able to provide that support and participation This Article describes the organization of the Community Association, its powers, duties, authorized activities and prohibited activities. This Article also spells out the standards of care used to govern the Covered Property, identifies the limits of liability of the Community Association's Board of Directors and officers and identifies the scope of indemnification the Community Association can provide to its agents and other Persons. 4.1 ORGANIZATION OF THE COMMUNITY ASSOCIATION. The homeowners association which will manage and maintain the Covered Property has or shall be incorporated by Declarant under the name of Columbus Square Community Association as a R corporation not for profit organized under the California Nonprofit Mutual Benefit Corporation Law. 4.2 GENERAL DUTIES AND POWERS. The Community Association has the duties and powers set forth in the Articles, Bylaws, this Master Declaration and the Supplemental Declarations and also has the general and implied powers of a nonprofit mutual benefit corporation, generally to do all things that a California corporation may lawfully do which are necessary or proper in operating for the general welfare of its Members, subject only to the limits upon the exercise of such powers set forth in the Articles, Bylaws, this Master Declaration and the Supplemental Declarations. All of the Community Association's powers shall be exercised by its Board of Directors except those powers reserved in specific provisions of the Articles, Bylaws, this Master Declaration or the Supplemental Declarations to the Members, Board or Design Review Committee. 4.3 SPECIFIC DUTIES AND POWERS. In addition to its general powers and duties, the Community Association has the following specific powers and duties. 4.3.1 Association Property. The power and duty to accept, maintain, inspect, modify, remove and manage the Association Property and any other real property designated for Community Association maintenance in this Master Declaration or any -26- 2544-33253\CLP428\CCRS1591730.13 211/06 Supplemental Declaration, in conformance with any Maintenance Guidelines, manufacturing recommendations and industry standards. 4.3.2 Sewers and Storm Drains. The power and duty to maintain any private sewer systems and any private storm drains or drainage facilities in the Association Property or Maintenance Areas if the drains and systems are not maintained by a Neighborhood Association, a Local Governmental Agency or a utility company. 4.3.3 Granting Rights. The power and duty to grant exclusive or nonexclusive easements, licenses, rights of way or fee interests in portions of the Association Property, to the extent any such grant is reasonably required for (a) utilities and sewer facilities to serve the Association Property, Neighborhood Property and the Lots, (b) purposes of conformity with the as -built location of Improvements, (c) purposes consistent with the intended use of the Covered Property as a master planned community, or (d) the operation of commercial concessions within Association Property for the convenience and enjoyment of the Members, subject to the provisions of the Community Association Governing Documents. The Community Association may deannex Association Property from the encumbrance of the Master Declaration in connection with any lot line adjustment. 4.3.4 Insurance. The power and duty to maintain liability and fire insurance with respect to the Association Property and personal property, if any, owned by the Community - Association as provided in this Master Declaration. 43.5 Board, Officer and Committee Member Training. The power but not the duty to make training and continuing education seminars or materials available to the Board members, officers, and committee members either before or after the persons begin their service to the Community Association. Seminars can be designed to educate the Board, officers or committee members about their duties and responsibilities. All expenses associated with these training seminars shall be a Common Expense of the Comaaunity_Association. 43.6 Right of Entry. The power, but not the duty, to enter upon any Lot, Condominium or Neighborhood Property to inspect it. The power but not the duty, after Notice and Hearing, to enter upon any Lot, Condominium or Neighborhood Property, without being liable to any Owner or Neighborhood Association except for damage caused by such entry, in order to (a) enforce by peaceful means the provisions hereof, or (b) maintain any Lot, Condominium or Neighborhood Property if for any reason the responsible Owner or Neighborhood Association fails to perform such maintenance or repair as required by the Community Association Governing Documents. The cost of such enforcement and maintenance shall be a Compliance Assessment enforceable as set forth in this Master Declaration. The Owner or Neighborhood Association shall promptly pay all amounts due for such work. The costs of collection may be added, at the option of the Board, to the amount assessed against such Owner or Neighborhood Association. If an emergency occurs, entry upon a Lot, Condominium or Neighborhood Property by or on behalf of the Community Association is permitted without Notice and Hearing. .27. 2544-3325MCLP429 CCRM 591730.13 2/1/06 4.3.7 Community Guidelines. The power but not the duty to establish, amend, restate, delete and create exceptions to the Community Guidelines for the use of the Association Property. (a) Effective Date. Any modifications to the Community Guidelines will become effective and binding fifteen (15) days after the modifications are either (i) posted in a conspicuous place in the Association Property or (ii) sent to the Members via first class mail or by any system or technology designed to record and communicate messages, facsimile, electronic mail, or other electronic means. Community Guidelines may be modified or repealed by the Board. (b) Areas of Regulation. Community Guidelines may include guidelines regarding use of the Association Property; Maintenance Areas; signs; parking restrictions; minimum standards of property maintenance; procedures for providing access to public utilities for maintenance of their facilities within the Covered Property; and any other matter within the Community Association's jurisdiction; provided, however, that such Community Guidelines are enforceable only to the -extent they are consistent with the Articles, Bylaws, Master Declaration and the Supplemental Declarations. (c) Limits on Regulation. The Community Guidelines must apply uniformly to all Owners and cannot discriminate between tenants of Owners of Residential Area Lots and Condominiums or other areas of the Covered Property. The rights of Owners to display religious and holiday signs, symbols and decorations inside their Homes of the kinds normally displayed in single family residential neighborhoods shall not be abridged, except the Community Association may adopt time, place and manner restrictions with respect to such displays if they are visible outside of the Horne. The Community Guidelines shall not regulate the content of political signs; however, they may regulate the time, place and manner of posting o of such signs. No modification to the Community Guidelines may require an Owner to dispose Of personal property that was in or on a Lot or Condominium prior to the adoption of such modification if such personal property was in compliance with all rules previously in force. This exemption shall apply only during the period of such Owner's ownership of the Lot or Condominium and shall not apply to (i) subsequent Owners who take title to the Lot or Condominium after the modification is adopted, or (ii) clarifications to the Community Guidelines. (d) Use of Facilities. The Community Guidelines may (i) specify a maximum number of guests which an Owner, tenant or other Person may admit to the Association Property facilities at one time, (ii) establish rules for allowing Owners, tenants or other Persons to use portions of Association Property facilities for groups of guests or private functions, or (iii) establish admission fees, deposit requirements or other fees for the use of any facilities on Association Property. 4.3.8 Maintenance Guidelines. The power and duty to review any Maintenance Guidelines for the Association Property and Maintenance Areas for necessary or appropriate revisions no less than annually after the Board has prepared the Budget. -28- 2544-3325MCLP428XCCRS\ 581730.13 2/1/06 4.3.9 Borrowings. The power, but not the duty, to borrow money for purposes authorized by the Articles, Bylaws, Master Declaration or any Supplemental Declaration, and in aid thereof, to mortgage, pledge, deed in trust, establish a line of credit or hypothecate any or all of its real or personal property as security for money borrowed or debts incurred. 4.3.10 Contracts and Leases. The power but not the duty to enter into contracts and leases, including the following; (a) Contracts for Services. Contracts with Owners, Neighborhood Associations or other Persons to provide services or to maintain Improvements in the Covered Property and elsewhere which the Community Association is not otherwise required to provide or maintain pursuant to the Community Association Governing Documents; provided, however, that any such contract shall provide for reimbursement of the Community Association for the costs of providing such services or maintenance; (b) Community Services. Contracts with Persons to provide various community services such as cultural programs, social services, community outreach programs, recreational programs and activities, educational programs and activities, festivals, holiday celebrations and activities, recycling programs or a community technology network to the residents of the Covered Property. The Community Association has the right to require payment of compensation for (i) making the Association Property available for events that will include Persons who are. not residents of the Covered Property or (ii) providing any other services that benefit the Persons with whom the Community Association contracts; (c) Mutual Benefit Agreements. Contracts with Neighborhood Associations. (d) Cost Sharing. Contracts to share costs with any neighboring property for, among other things, shared or mutually beneficial property or services or a higher level of Association Property or Maintenance Area maintenance; and (e) Adjacent Owners. Contracts with adjacent property owners to provide for preservation and maintenance of real property which contribute to the overall understanding, appreciation and preservation of the environment in the Covered Property and the surrounding area. 4.3.11 Indemnification. (a) For the Community Association Representatives. The Community Association has the power and the duty to indemnify Board members, the Community Association officers, Design Review Committee members, and all other Community Association committee members for all damages and pay all expenses incurred by, and satisfy any judgment or fine levied against, any Person as a result of any action or threatened action against such Person brought because of performance of acts or omissions within what the Person reasonably believed to be the scope of the Person's Community Association duties ("Oficial Acts'D to the fullest extent authorized by California law. Board members, the Community Association officers, Design Review Committee members, and all other Community Association -29- 2544-332531CLP4281CUM 581730.13 2/1/06 committee members are deemed to be agents of the Community Association when they are performing Official Acts for purposes of obtaining indemnification from the Community Association pursuant to this Section 4.3.11. The entitlement to indemnification hereunder inures to the benefit of the successors, estate, executor, administrator, heirs, legatees, or devisees of any Person entitled to such indemnification. (b) For Other Agents of the Community Association. The Community Association has the power as authorized by California law, but not the duty, to indemnify any other Person acting as an agent of the Community Association for any damages and pay all expenses incurred by, and satisfy any judgment or fine levied against, any Person as a result of any action or threatened action against such Person because of an Official Act (c) Provided by Contract. The Community Association also has the power, but not the duty, to contract with any Person to provide indemnification beyond the scope of indemnification authorized by applicable law on. such terms and subject to such conditions and the Board may impose. 4.3.12 Annexing Additional Property. The power but not the duty to annex additional property to the property encumbered by this Master Declaration pursuant to Section 16.5. 4.3.13 Vehicle Restrictions. The power granted in Section 2.4 to identify Authorized Vehicles or Prohibited Vehicles and to modify the restrictions on vehicles. 4.3.14 Cooperation with City. The power and duty to file the name, address and telephone number of at least one (1) member of the Board of Directors of the Community Association and each Neighborhood Association and the individual or entity that is the Community Manager before January I of each year with the City of Tustin Community Development Department for the purpose of contacting the Community Association in case of emergency or in those cases where the City has an interest in a violation of the Master Declaration. I 4.4 PERMT=. TI . FUNCTIONS. The CommunityAssociation is formed exclusively for those social welfare purposes and activities which are specifically and directly. related to (a) maintaining, operating and using the Association Property, including the social, recreational and other Improvements thereon, (b) collecting assessments to finance the maintenance and use of the Association Property and Maintenance Areas, and (c) administering and enforcing the Community Association Governing Documents (collectively, the "Permitted Functions"). Permitted Functions do not include those activities prohibited by Section 4.5 below. The funds and resources of the Community Association shall be used exclusively for the direct costs of Permitted Functions. This Section does not preclude the use of the Association Property facilities by Declarant or the Neighborhood Builders for promotional special events and other purposes. 4.5 PROHIBITED ACTIVITEES. The Community Association is prohibited from undertaking or performing any of the following activities ("Prohibited Activities"), or expending or using the Community Association funds or resources for any Prohibited Activities. -30- 2544-332531CLP42E\CCRS\ 531730.13 2/1M 4.5.1 Nuisances. Abating any annoyance or nuisance emanating from outside the physical boundaries of the Covered Property. This is not a limit on the Community Association's ability to enforce Sections 2.2 and 2.4 in connection with public streets in or abutting the Covered Property. 4.5.2 Political Activities. Engaging in any Federal, State or local political activities or activities intended to influence a governmental action. These activities include endorsement or support of legislative or administrative actions by a Local Governmental Agency, candidates for elected or appointed office, initiatives, recall elections or other ballot proposals. The Community Association is prohibited from conducting, sponsoring, participating in or expending funds or resources on any activity, campaign or event, including any social or political campaign, event or activity, which does not directly and exclusively pertain to a Permitted Function. 4.5.3 Abridging Rights. Taking any action which is inconsistent with, or which would abrogate, any right or exemption in Article XVII or elsewhere in the Community Association Governing Documents. 4.6 COMMENCEMENT OF COMMUNITY ASSOCIATION MAINTENANCE. For any Phase which includes a Home in the Residential Area, the Community Association's obligation to maintain the Association Property and Maintenance Areas, as applicable, shall commence on the date Common Assessments commence. For a Phase composed solely of Association Property, the Community Association's obligation to maintain the Association Property shall commence upon conveyance of such property to the Community Association. Until commencement of Common Assessments in a Phase, Declarant or the appropriate Neighborhood Builder shall maintain the Association Property or Maintenance Areas in such Phase. The nature, design, quantity, quality and all other attributes of the Association Property, and the facilities and amenities thereon, shall be determined in Declarant's sole and absolute discretion or by a Neighborhood Builder (with Declarant's written consent). 4.7 CONVEYANCE OF ASSOCIATION PROPERTY. Except as provided below in this paragraph, conveyance of Association Property in each Phase shall occur (a) for Residential Areas, before the first Close of Escrow for a Home in such Phase, or (b) for any other area (such as a Phase consisting solely of Association Property), on the first day of the first month following the month in which the Phase becomes subject to this Master Declaration unless another arrangement is proposed by Declarant and approved by the DRE. The Community Association, acting through its Board, must accept title to and maintenance responsibility for each portion of Association Property when title and maintenance responsibility is tendered by Declarant or a Neighborhood Builder, execute each deed and any accompanying escrow instructions if requested to do so by Declarant ora Neighborhood Builder, and execute any bond exonerations when presented if the bonded obligations are satisfied. Improvements on Association Property shall be deemed to be complete when they have been completed in accordance with plans approved by the City. No Owner shall interfere with the exercise of rights or performance of obligations established in this Section by the Community Association, Declarant or a Neighborhood Builder. -31- 2544-332531CLP4281CCRS1581730.13 2/1/06 4.8 STANDARD OF CARE, NONLIABILITY. 4.8.1 Scope of Powers and Standard of Care. (a) General Scope of Powers. Rights and powers conferred on the Board, the Design Review Committee or other Committees .or representatives of the Community Association by the Community Association Governing Documents are not duties and obligations charged upon those Persons unless the rights and powers are explicitly identified in the Community Association Governing Documents or in applicable law as including duties and obligations. Unless a duty to act is imposed on the Board, Design Review Committee or other Committees or the representatives of the Community Association by the Community Association Governing Documents or applicable law, the Board, and the Committees have the right to decide to act or not act. Any decision to not act is not a waiver of the right to act in the future. (b) Business Affairs. This Section 4.8.1(b) applies to Board member actions in connection with management, personnel, maintenance and operations, insurance, contracts and finances, Board member actions and Design Review Committee member actions. Each person shall perform his duties in good faith, in a manner he believes to be in the Best interests of the Community Association and with such care, including reasonable inquiry, as an ordinarily prudent person in a like position would use under similar circumstances. When performing his duties, a person is entitled to rely on information, opinions, reports or statements, including financial statements and other financial data, in each case prepared or presented by: (i) One (1) or more officers or employees of the Community Association whom the person believes to be reliable and competent in the matters presented; (ii) Counsel, independent accountants or other persons as to matters which the person believes to be in such person's professional or expert competence; or (iii) A committee of the Board upon which the person does not serve, as to matters within its designated authority, which committee the person believes to merit confidence, so long as, in any such case, the person acts in good faith, after reasonable inquiry when the need therefor is indicated by the circumstances and without knowledge that would cause such reliance to be unwarranted. (iv) This Section 4.8.1(b) is intended to be a restatement of the business judgment rule established in law applicable to the Community Association. All amendments, modifications, restatements and interpretations of the business judgment rule applicable to the Community Association shall be interpreted to amend, modify, restate or interpret this Section 4.8.1(b). (c) Community Association Governance. This Section 4.8.1(c) applies to Board actions, Design Review Committee decisions and Board decisions in connection with interpretation and enforcement of the Community Association Governing Documents, architectural and landscaping control, regulation of uses in the Covered Property, rule making and oversight of committees. Actions taken or decisions made in connection with these matters shall be reasonable, fair and nondiscriminatory. -32- 2544-332531CLP421=RS%581730.13 2/1/06 4.8.2 Nonliability. (a) General Rule. No Person is liable to any other Person (other than the Community Association or a party claiming in the name of the Community Association) for injuries or damage resulting from such Person's Official Acts, except to the extent that injuries or damage result from the Person's willful or malicious misconduct No Person is liable to the Community Association (or to any party claiming in the name of the Community Association) for injuries or damage resulting from such Person's Official Acts, except to the extent that such injuries or damage result from such Person's willful or malicious misconduct The Community Association is not liable for damage to property in the Covered Property unless caused by the negligence of the Community Association, the Board, -the Community Association's officers, the Community Manager or the Community Manager's staff. (b) Nonliability of Volunteer Board Members and Officers. A volunteer Board member or volunteer Community Association officer shall not be personally liable to any Person who suffers injury, including bodily injury, emotional distress, wrongful death or property damage or loss as a result of the tortious act or omission of the volunteer officer or Board member if all of the applicable conditions specified in Section 1365.7 of the California Civil Code are mei. ARTICLE V DESIGN REVIEW COMMITTEE Jurisdiction over design, construction and aesthetic aspects of the Covered Property is given to the Design Review Committee. The Design Review Committee is a three (3) to free (5) person committee initially appointed by the Declarant and eventually appointed by the Board of Directors of the Community Association The Design Review Committee must approve all plans for architectural or landscaping mod jications in the Covered Property before the modifications are made. The Design Review Committee also has the right to review modifications as they are constructed and give final approval of completed modifications. In addition to establishing the Design Review Committee, this Article establishes the procedures for approving Improvements, preapproving certain Improvements, granting variances and appealing decisions of the Design Review Committee and Neighborhood Associations' aesthetics review board 5.1 MEMBERS OF COMMITTEE. The Design Review Committee shall be composed of not less than three (3) nor more than five (5) members with the exact number of members set by the Board. Design Review Committee members appointed by the Board must be Members or agents of Members, but Design Review Committee members appointed by Declarant are not subject to this limit The Design Review Committee has the right and duty to promulgate Design Guidelines against which to examine any request made pursuant to this Article. Board members may also serve as,Design Review Committee members only if a reasonable effort is made to fill the positions on the Design Review Committee with persons who are not Board members and a position remains vacant No Design Review Committee member appointed by the Board may be a director or officer of a Neighborhood Association. -33- 25"4325ACLAU CCR A 581730.13 2/1/06 5.2 POWERS AND DUTIES. 5.2.1 General Powers and Duties. The Design Review Committee shall consider and act upon all plans and specifications submitted for its approval. The Design Review Committee also has the power but not the duty to inspect work in progress to assure conformance with pians approved by the Design Review Committee. The Design Review Committee shall perform such other duties as the Board assigns to it. The Design Review Committee shall not have the power to enforce the restrictions contained in the Community Association Governing Documents. This power is reserved to the Board. 5.2.2 Issuance of Design Guidelines. The Design Review Committee has the right to review its Design Guidelines and to recommend amendments to the Board. The Design Guidelines and any amendments or restatements must be approved by the Board. The Design Guidelines shall include rules or guidelines getting forth procedures for the submission of plans for approval, may require a fee to accompany each application for approval, and may identify additional factors which the Design Review Committee will consider in reviewing submissions. The Design Review. Committee may provide that fees if imposes be uniform, or that fees be determined in any other reasonable manner, such as by the reasonable cost of the construction, alterations or installations contemplated. The Design Review Committee may require such detail in plans and specifications submitted for its review as it deems proper and may require submission of landscape plans, floor plans, site plans, drainage plans, elevation drawings and descriptions or samples of exterior material and colors. In addition, the Design Guidelines may include guidelines regulating exterior finishes, roof materials, fences and walls, accessory structures such as patios, sunshades, pools, spas, fountains, water features, fireplaces, trellises, gazebos, awnings, exterior mechanical equipment, and television and radio antennae, all consistent with the City Code and the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan. The Design Review Committee shall annually issue its Design Guidelines and provide notice of any requirements for Association approval of proposed Improvements. The notice shall describe the types of proposed Improvements that require Association approval and shall include a copy of the procedure used to review and approve or disapprove any proposed Improvements. 5.2.3 Retaining Consultants. The Design Review Committee has the power but not the duty to retain Persons to advise the Design Review Committee in connection with decisions. The Design Review Committee also has the power to delegate its decision-making power to such Persons for approval of plans that are consistent with the Design Guidelines; provided, however, that such Persons may not interpret the Design Guidelines, or grant allowances or variances from the Design Guidelines. 5.3 RIGHTS OF APPOINTMENT. 5.3.1 Initial Appointment. The initial members of the Design Review Committee shall be representatives of Declarant until one (1) year after the first Close of Escrow in the Covered Property ("FirstAnniversary'J. 5.32 By Declarant. Declarant reserves the power to appoint and remove a majority of the members of the Design Review Committee until either (a) the fifteenth (151) anniversary of the fust Close of Escrow for the sale of a Lot or Condominium pursuant to the -34- 2544-33253\CLP4281CCRS% 531730.13 211/06 Final Subdivision Public Report issued for the first Phase of the Covered Property, or (b) ninety percent (90%) of the Lots and Condominiums in the overall Covered Property have been sold, whichever occurs first (the "Turnover Date'. Any person appointed to the Design Review Committee by the Declarant need not be a Member of the Community Association. Declarant may, in its discretion and at any time prior to the Turnover Date, assign to the Community Association by written instrument its powers of removal and appointment with respect to the Design Review Committee, subject to such terms and conditions regarding the exercise thereof as Declarant may impose. 5.3.3 By the Board. After one (1) year from the date of the first Close of Escrow, the member(s) of the Board who were elected by the Members, other than the Declarant and the Neighborhood Builders, shall have the power to appoint one (1) member to the Design Review Committee until the Turnover Date. From and after the Turnover Date, the Board shall have the po-uer to appoint all of the members of the Design Review Committee; provided however, if on the Turnover Date, Declarant or any Neighborhood Builder owns any Lot in the Covered Property, Declarant reserves the right to appoint one (1) member to the Design Review Committee (the "Declarant's Representative'l. Declarant's Representative shall serve on the Design Review Committee until Declarant and the Neighborhood Builders no longer own any portion of the Covered Property. All persons appointed to the Design Review Committee by the Board shall be a Member of the Community Association. 5.3.4 Liability Of Design Review Committee. No member of the Design Review Committee shall be liable to any person for the member's decisions or failure to act in malting decisions as a member of the Design Review Committee W 5.35 Notice of Appointment. Whenever a Design Review Committee member is appointed or removed while both Declarant and the Board have rights of appointment, written notice of such appointment or removal must be given by the appointing party to the other party. 5.4 REVIEW OF PLANS AND SPECIFICATIONS. 5.4.1 Improvements Requiring Approval No construction, installation or alteration of an Improvement, in the Covered Property by an Owner or a Neighborhood Association may be commenced or maintained and no permits related to such construction, installation or alteration may be requested from the City until the plans and specifications, along with all other review materials required under this Article (collectively, an "Application' showing the nature, kind, shape, height, width, color, materials and location thereof have been submitted to and approved in writing by the Design Review Committee; provided, however, that any Improvement may be repainted without Design Review Committee approval so long as the Improvement is repainted with an approved color. All plans and specifications shall conform to all City Codes and regulations. The provisions of this Article also apply to the construction, installation and alteration of solar energy systems, as defined in Section 801.5 of the California Civil Code, subject to the provisions of California Civil Code Section 714, the City Building Code, applicable zoning regulations, and associated City ordinances. -35- 2544-332531CL.P428%CCM 581730.13 2/1106 5.4.2 Application Procedure. Until changed by the Board, the address for submission of the Application is the Community Association's principal office. The form of Application used by the Design Review Committee and any Neighborhood Association shall include spaces allowing "Adjacent Owners" to sign or initial the Application confirming that they have been notified of the Application. The Design Review Committee shall establish a definition of "Adjacent Owners" in its Design Guidelines -for use by the Design Review Committee and the aesthetic review boards for all Neighborhood Associations. Applications will be complete even if all of the Adjacent Owners do not initial the Applications so long as the Owner submitting the Application ("Applicant) certifies that the Applicant requested that the Adjacent Owners sign the Applications. The requirement that the Applicant attempt to obtain the signatures of Adjacent Owners is intended only to provide notice of the pending Application to the Adjacent Owners. It does not create in the Adjacent Owners any power to approve or disapprove the Application, by signing or withholding a signature. The Design Review Committee shall deliver its written approval, disapproval or request for additional information or materials to the Applicant at the address listed in the Application within forty-five (45) calendar days after the date on which the Community Association has issued its Acknowledgement of Receipt of Complete Application to the Applicant. The Application shall not be deemed approved if the Design Review Committee fails to respond to the Applicant at the end of the forty-five (45) day approval period. If the Community Association fails to respond to the Applicant within such forty-five (45) day period of time, the Applicant must submit by United States mail, with return receipt requested, a written request for notification of the status of the Application ("Status Request'j. If the Design Review Committee fails to respond to the Applicant within forty-five (45) days of confirmed receipt by the Community Association, then the Application shall be deemed approved. Without confirmation of such receipt, the Application shall be deemed disapproved and a new �.► Application must be submitted to the Design Review Committee. 5.4.3 Standard for Approval. The Design Review Committee shall approve plans and specifications submitted for its approval only if it determines that (a) the installation, construction or alteration contemplated thereby in the locations indicated will not be detrimental to the appearance of the surrounding area of the Covered Property as a whole, (b) the appearance of any structure affected thereby will be is harmony with the surrounding structures, (c) the installation, construction or alteration thereof will not detract from the beauty, wholesomeness and attractiveness of the Association Property or Maintenance Areas or the enjoyment thereof by the Members, and, if applicable, (d) the maintenance thereof will not become a burden on the Community Association. The Design Review Committee may condition its approval of plans and specifications upon any of the following: (i) the Applicant's furnishing the Community Association with security acceptable to the Community Association against any mechanic's lien or other encumbrance which may be Recorded against the Covered Property as a result of such work, (ii) such changes therein as the Design Review Committee deems appropriate, (iii) (if applicable) the Applicant's agreement to grant appropriate easements to'thb Community Association for the maintenance of the Improvements, (iv) the Applicant's agreement to install (at its sole cost) water, gas, electrical or other utility meters to measure any increased consumption, (v) (if applicable) the Applicant's agreement to reimburse the Community Association for the cost of -36- 2544-33253TI.Y4281CCRM 581730.13 2/1/06 such maintenance, or (vi) the Applicant's agreement to complete the proposed work within a stated period of time. 5.4.4 Relationship to Neighborhood Associations. The Design Review Committee may require that all plans and specifications be approved by any Neighborhood Association having jurisdiction before the Design Review Committee reviews the plans and specifications. Conditions and requirements imposed by the Design Review Committee supersede all conflicting conditions or requirements which may be imposed by a Neighborhood Association. The Design Review Committee's determination of the existence of a conflict or discrepancy between the conditions or requirements imposed by the Design Review Committee and those imposed by a Neighborhood Association are binding and conclusive upon the Neighborhood Association and any affected Applicant. 5.4.5 Conflicts Between the City and the Design Review Committee. In the event of any conflict in the conditions of approval of any proposed Improvements imposed by the City, any City ordinances and the Design Review Committee, the mon restrictive of such conditions shall be controlling. Nothing herein shall limit the Design Review Committee from imposing conditions of approval of any proposed Improvements which are more restrictive than conditions as may be imposed by the City. 5.4.6 Exemption. Notwithstanding any other provision of the Community - Association Governing Documents, Declarant, Neighborhood Builders and any Person Declarant designates in a Supplemental Declaration need not seek Design Review Committee approval with respect to their construction or development activities. Declarant may exclude portions of the Covered Property from jurisdiction of the Design Review Committee in the applicable Supplemental Declaration. Declarant may, at its option, establish an additional architectural review committee for any area exempted from the jurisdiction of the Design Review Committee. 5.5 MEETINGS OF THE DESIGN. REVIEW COMM TTEE. The Design Review Committee shall meet as necessary to perform its duties. The vote or written consent of a majority of the Design Review Committee constitutes an act of the Design Review Committee. The Design Review Committee may, by a majority vote of the members, delegate the right to approve plans and specifications to one (1) or more duly licensed architects, who shall have full authority to act on behalf of the Design Review Committee on all matters so delegated. The Design Review Committee may not delegate the authority to approve variances as provided in Section 5.10. 5.6 NO WAIVER OF FUTURE APPROVALS. The Design Review Committee's approval does not waive any right to withhold future approvals. 5.7 COMPENSATION OF MEMBERS. The Design Review Committee's members shall receive no compensation for services rendered, other than reimbursement for expenses incurred by them in performing their duties. This Section shall not be. interpreted or construed to prohibit the Community Association from compensating any duly licensed architect who has been delegated rights and duties as provided in this Article. -37- 2544-33253NCLP428NCCM 581930.13 211106 5.8 INSPECTION OF WORK. The Design Review Committee or its duly authorized representative may inspect any work for which approval is required under the Community Association Governing Documents ("Work"). The right to inspect includes the right to require any Owner to take such action as may be necessary to remedy any noncompliance with the Design Review Committee -approved plans for the Work or with the requirements of the Community Association Governing Documents ("Noncompliance"). 5.8.1 Time Limit. The Design Review Committee's right to inspect the Work and notify the responsible Owner of any Noncompliance shall terminate sixty (60) days after the Design Review Committee has received written notice from the Owner that the Work is completed if the Work is, in fact, completed. If the Design Review Committee fails to send a notice of Noncompliance to an Owner before this time limit expires, the Work shall be deemed to comply with the approved plans. No Owner may unreasonably deny the Design Review Committee access to the Lot or Condominium to exercise its right to inspect such Work. 5.8.2 Remedy. If an Owner fails to remedy any Noncompliance within sixty (60) days from the date of notification from the Design Review Committee, the Design Review Committee may initiate the enforcement procedures established in Section 13.1.1. 5.9 SCOPE OF REVIEW. The Design Review Committee shall review and approve, conditionally approve or disapprove all plans submitted to it for any proposed construction, installation or alteration solely on the basis of aesthetic considerations, consistency with the Community Association Governing Documents, height of landscaping materials at maturity, and the overall benefit or detriment which would result to the immediate vicinity and the Covered Property generally. The Design Review Committee shall consider the aesthetic aspects.of the architectural designs, placement of buildings, landscaping, color schemes, exterior • finishes and materials and similar features. The Design Review Committee is not responsible for reviewing, nor may its approval of any plan or design be deemed approval of, any plan or design from the standpoint of structural safety or conformance with building or other codes. 5.10 VARIANCE. The Design Review Committee may authorize variances from compliance with any of the architectural and Iandscaping provisions of the Community Association Governing Documents, including restrictions upon height, size, floor area or placement of structures, or similar restrictions, when circumstances such as topography, natural obstructions, hardship, aesthetic or environmental consideration may require. Such variances must be evidenced in writing, must be signed b} a majority of the Design Review Committee. After Declarant's right to appoint a majority of the Design Review Committee's members expires, the Board must approve -any variance recommended by the Design Review Committee before any such variance becomes effective. If a variance is granted, no violation of the covenants, conditions and restrictions contained in the Community Association Governing Documents shall be deemed to have occurred with respect to the matter for which the variance was granted. The granting of such a variance does not waive any of the terms and provisions of the Community Association Governing Documents for any purpose except as to the particular property and particular provision hereof covered by the variance, nor does it affect the Owner's obligation to comply with all applicable governmental ordinances affecting the use of his Home. -38- 2544-332S3XW428\CCRS1SO] 730.13 211M 5.11 PRE -APPROVALS. The Board may authorize pre -approval of certain Improvements. 5.12 APPEALS. 5.12.1 Persons Who Have Appeal Rights. The only Person with the right to appeal an application that has been rejected is the Applicant. No Persons have the right to appeal an approved application, so long as Declarant has the right to appoint and remove Design Review Committee members, as described above. Thereafter, the. Board shall have the right, at its sole discretion, to define the adjacent Owners, if any, who may have the right to appeal an application approved by the Design Review Committee. The Persons granted appeal rights by this Section 5.12.1 are referred to in Section 5.12.2 as "Appellants." 5.12.2 Appeals of Decisions of Design Review Committee. If a proposed Improvement is disapproved, the Appellant is entitled to reconsideration by the Board of Directors at an open meeting that satisfies the requirements of Civil Code Section 1363.05. This paragraph does not require reconsideration of a decision that is made by the Board, or the Design Review Committee if the Committee has the same membership as the Board. ARTICLE VI OWNERS, MEMBERSHIP AND VOTING RIGHTS Each Person who purchases a Lot or Condominium in the Covered Property becomes a Member of the Community Association with certain rights and privileges. Methods for transferring Memberships in the Community Association, Members' voting rights and the �r Declarant's veto rights are described in this Article. 6.1 MEMBERSHIP. Every Owner shall automatically be a Member and shall remain a Member until such Owner's Lot or Condominium ownership ceases, at which time such Owner's Membership shall automatically cease. Ownership of a Lot or Condominium is the sole qualification for Membership and Membership shall be inseparable from ownership in individual Lots or Condominiums. Memberships are not assignable except to the Person to whom title to the Lot or Condominium has been transferred. 6.2 TRANSFER OF MEMBERSHIPS. The Membership of any Owner may not be transferred, pledged or alienated in any way, except upon the transfer or encumbrance of such Owner's Lot or Condominium, and then only to the transferee or Beneficiary of such Lot or . Condominium. A prohibited transfer is void and will not be reflected upon the books and records of the Community Association. A Class A Member who has sold his Lot or Condominium to a contract purchaser under an agreement to purchase may delegate his Membership rights to the contract purchaser. The delegation must be in writing and must be delivered to the Board before the contract purchaser may vote. The contractseller shall remain liable for all charges and assessments attributable to the contract seller's Lot or Condominium which accrue before fee title to the Lot or Condominium is transferred. If an Owner fails or refuses to transfer his Membership to the purchaser of such Owner's Lot or Condominium upon transfer of fee title thereto, the Board may record the transfer upon the Community Association's -39- 2544-3325T CLP428WM% 581730.13 2/1/06 books. Until satisfactory evidence of such transfer has been presented to the Board, the purchaser will not be entitled to vote at Community Association meetings. 6.3 CLASSES OF VOTING MEMBERSHIP. Members of the Community Association are Declarant, for so long as Declarant is entitled to cast a Class A or B vote or the Class C appointment right and each Owner (including any Neighborhood Builder) of at least one (1) Lot or Condominium in the Covered Property. Membership in the Community Association is subject to the Community Association Governing Documents. Except for the Class C Membership, all Memberships in the Community Association are appurtenant to the Lots and Condominiums. Ownership of a Lot or Condominium is the sole qualification for Membership in the Community Association. The Community Association classes of voting Membership are as follows: 6.3.1 Class A Class A Members are all Owners except Declarant and the Neighborhood Builders for so long as there exists a Class B Membership. Class A Members are entitled to one (1) vote for each Assessment Unit assigned pursuant to Section 8.4.1 to a Lot or Condominium owned by such Class A Members which is subject to assessment Declarant and the Neighborhood Builders shall become Class A Members upon conversion of the Class B Membership. When more than one (1) Person owns any Lot or Condominium, all such Persons are Members. The vote for such Lot or Condominium shall be exercised in accordance with Section 6.4. The Class A votes allocated to Declarant and the Neighborhood Builders shall be exercised by Declarant 6.3.2 Class B. The Class B Members are Declarant and the Neighborhood Builders. The Class B Members are entitled to three (3) votes for each Assessment Unit assigned to a Lot or Condominium owned by Declarant or a Neighborhood Builder which is subject to assessment. The Class B Membership shall be converted to Class A Membership on the first to occur of the following events: (a) The Close of Escrow for the sale of eight hundred eight (808) Lots and Condominiums in the overall development composed of the Covered Property, in accordance with the Conditions of Approval for the Covered Property; or (b) The fifth (5th) anniversary of the first Close of Escrow in the Phase for which a Public Report was most recently issued; or (c) The twenty-fifth (25th) anniversary of the fust Close of Escrow for the sale of a Lot or Condominium in the Covered Property. 6.3.3 Class C. The Class C Member shall be Declarant (whether or not Declarant is a Member). The Class C Member is not entitled to vote on any matters except the Class C Member is entitled to select a majority of the members of the Board of Directors until the Class C Termination Date. The "Class C Termination Date' shall be the earlier to occur of the following events: (a) The Close of Escrow for the sale of eight hundred eight (808) Lots and Condominiums in the overall development composed of the Covered Property, in accordance with the Conditions of Approval for the Covered Property; or -40- 2544-3325MCW428%CCRs1531730.13 7/106 (b) The fifth (5th) anniversary of the first Close of Escrow in the Phase for which a Public Report was most recently issued; or (c) The twenty-fifth (25th) anniversary of the first CIose of Escrow for the sale of a Lot or Condominium in the Covered Property. 6.4 VOTING RIGHTS. 6.4.1 General Rule. All voting rights are subject to the Community Association Governing Documents. Voting rights attributable to the Lots or Condominiums in a Phase shall be exercised only after assessments have commenced in the Phase. 6.4.2 Vote to Initiate Construction Defect Claims. Commencing on the date of the fust annual meeting of Owners, Declarant relinquishes control over the Community Association's ability to decide whether to initiate a construction defect claim under Division 2, Part 2, Title 7 (commencing with Section 895) of the California Civil Code (a "Defect Clann'l. This means that Declarant, current employees and agents of Declarant, Board members who are appointed by Declarant, Board members elected by a majority of votes cast by Declarant, and all other Persons whose vote or written consent is inconsistent with the intent of the preceding sentence, are prohibited from participating and voting in any decision of the Community Association or Owners to initiate a Defect Claim. 6.4.3 Co -Ownership. When more than one (1) Person holds an ownership interest in any Lot or Condominium ("co-owner', all such co-owners are Members and may attend any the Community Association meetings, but only one (1) such co-owner shall be entitled to exercise the vote to which the Lot or Condominium is entitled. Co-owners owning the majority interests in a Lot or Condominium may designate in writing one (1) of their number to vote. Fractional votes shall not be allowed, and the vote for each Lot or Condominium shall be exercised, if at all, as a unit. Where no voting co-owner is designated or if the designation has been revoked, the vote for the Lot or Condominium shall be exercised as the co-owners owning the majority interests in the Lot or Condominium agree. Unless the Board receives a written objection in advance from a co-owner, it shall be conclusively presumed that the corresponding voting co-owner is acting with his co-owners' consent. No vote may be cast for any Lot or Condominium if the co-owners present in person or by proxy owning the majority interests in such Lot or Condominium cannot agree to said vote or other action. The nonvoting co-owner or co-owners are jointly and severally responsible for all of the obligations imposed upon the jointly owned Lot or Condominium and are entitled to all other benefits of ownership. All agreements and determinations lawfully made by the Community Association in accordance with the voting percentages established in the Articles, Bylaws and Master Declaration are binding on all Owners and their successors in interest. 6.5 DECLARANT'S VETO RIGHT. Declarant has the right to veto the Community Association actions listed in Section 6.6. This veto right shall terminate on the date on which neither Declarant nor any Neighborhood Builder owns or has any interest in the Covered Property; provided, however, this right shall expire for all purposes twenty-five (25) years after the date on which the first Close of Escrow occurs. -41- 2544-33253XCLF428NCCRSX 581730.13 2/1/06 6.6 ACTIONS SUBJECT TO DECLARANT'S VETO. The following actions are subject to Declarant's veto: 6.6.1 Change in Design. Any change in the general, overall architectural and landscaping design of the Covered Property or the Association Property; 6.6.2 Design Review Committee. The adoption of and any supplement, amendment or restatement to the Design Guidelines, all decisions of the Design Review Committee, any decisions made on appeal to the Board, and any decision to terminate the Design Review Committee. 6.6.3 Community Guidelines. The adoption of any supplement, amendment or restatement to the Community Guidelines or the decision to terminate the Board. 6.6.4 Maintenance. Modifications to level or frequency of maintenance of Association Property or the Maintenance Areas or to the Maintenance Guidelines; 6.6.5 Reduction in Services. Any significant reduction of Association Property services, the amount of Common Assessments or entering into contracts for maintenance or other goods and services benefiting the Community Association or the Association Property at contract rates which are fifteen percent (15%) or more below the reasonable cost for such maintenance, goods or services as determined pursuant to the Maintenance Guidelines; 6.6.6 Annexations. The annexation to the Covered Property of real property pursuant to Section 16.5; 6.6.7 Amendments. Any proposed amendment to Article 11, Article IX, Article XII, Article XVI and Article XVII, and to Sections 1.25,1.26, 1.49 to 1.55, 1.59, 4.3, 4.5, 4.7,5.3,5.9,6.3,6.5,6.6,7.1,7.5,7.6,7.7,7.11,8.4,13.4,14.2and 14.3. ARTICLE VII OWNERS' PROPERTY RIGHTS AND PROJECT EASEMENTS Living or working in a master planned community involves sharing and cooperation. The various types of properties and uses in the Covered Property require the creation of special property rights and provisions to address the needs of the variety of Persons living and working in the Covered Property. The property rights acquired by Owners and other Persons in the Covered Property are described in this Article along with limits on the exercise of those rights. 7.1 OWNERS' EASEMENTS OF ENJOYMENT. Every Owner has a right and easement of ingress and egress and of enjoyment in, to and over the Association Property. Each such easement is appurtenant to and shall pass with title to every Home, subject to the following. Unless otherwise indicated, the rights of the Community Association described below may be exercised by the Board. 7.1.1 Community Association Exercise of Powers. The Community Association's exercise of its powers. -42- 2544-33253XaY428%CCRS\ 581730.13 4/1/06 7.1.2 Suspension of Privileges. The Community Association's right to enforce provisions of the Community Association Governing Documents by suspending (a) the Membership right of any Owner (and of the Persons deriving rights and easements from an Owner) to use the Association Property and to use Community Association services and facilities, and (b) other rights and easements of any Owner, in accordance with the Notice and Hearing procedure established in the Bylaws. 7.1.3 Transfer of Property. Subject to the limits established in other Sections of this Master Declaration, the Community Association's right to transfer all or a part of the Association Property for such purposes and subject to such conditions as may be approved by the Members. 7.1.4 Declarant's Right to Access. The right of Declarant, the Neighborhood Builders and their sales agents, representatives and prospective purchasers to the nonexclusive use of the Association Property, Maintenance Areas and Neighborhood Property, without cost, for access, ingress, egress, use and enjoyment, in order to market and dispose of the Covered Property, until neither Declarant nor any Neighborhood Builder owns any portion of the Covered Property; provided, however, that such use shall not unreasonably interfere with the rights of enjoyment of the other Owners established by this Master Declaration. 7.1.5 Other Declarant Rights. The rights and reservations of Declarant and the Neighborhood Builders established in Article XVII. 7.1.6 Reconstructing Improvements. The Community Association's right to reconstruct, replace or refinish any Improvement or portion thereof on the Association Property or Maintenance Areas. -- 7.1.7 Maintenance. The Community Association's right to maintain the Association Property and the Maintenance Areas. 7.1.8 Restricting Access. The Community Association's right to reasonably restrict access to slopes and other landscaped areas, maintenance facilities, Open Space/Park Areas and other areas of the Association Property designated by the Board. A Supplemental Declaration may designate exclusive use areas in portions of the Association Property for the exclusive use or maintenance by one or more Owners (such as common driveway areas). 7.1.9 Access to Public. The Community Association's right to make portions of the Association Property available for use by Persons who are not residents or Owners in the Covered Property on such terms and at such times as may be negotiated by the Community Association. 7.1.10 Other Easements. The easements reserved in the other Sections of this Article. 72 EASEMENTS FOR VEHICULAR AND PEDESTRIAN TRAVEL. Declarant reserves, for the benefit of all Owners and the Neighborhood Builders, nonexclusive easements appurtenant to all the Homes and Neighborhood Property in the Covered Property for -43- 2544-33253%CLP428%CC= 581730.13 V1/06 vehicular and pedestrian travel over the private streets and walkways in the Association Property, subject to the parking restrictions in Section 2.4. 7.3 EASEMENTS FOR PUBLIC SERVICE USE. Declarant reserves easements over the Covered Property for public services of the Local Governmental Agencies including the right of law enforcement and fire protection personnel to enter upon any part of the Covered Property for the purpose of carrying out their official duties. 7.4 EASEMENTS FOR WATER AND UTILITY PURPOSES. Declarant reserves easements over the Covered Property for public and private utility purposes including the, right of any public utility or mutual water district of ingress or egress over the Association Property for purposes of reading and maintaining meters, and using and maintaining fire hydrants located in the Covered Property. 7.5 EASEMENT FOR DECLARANT AND NEIGHBORHOOD BUILDERS OVER ASSOCIATION PROPERTY. Declarant reserves for its benefit, for the benefit of the Neighborhood Builders, and for the benefit of Declarant's and Neighborhood Builders' agents, employees, contractors, customers and invitees and for the benefit of their successors and assigns, a nonexclusive easement appurtenant to the Covered Property, in, to, and over the Association Property for access, ingress, egress, use and enjoyment, in order to show the Covered Property to its prospective purchasers, or to develop, market, sell, lease or otherwise dispose of the Covered Property. Such easement shall continue for so long as Declarant or a Neighborhood Builder owns any portion of the Covered Property. Until ten (10) years following the last Close of Escrow in the Covered Property, Declarant and Neighborhood Builders shall also have easements and right of entry to access the Association Property to repair, remove and replace all or a portion of the Association Property as may be necessary from time to time to satisfy requirements of the City or otherwise. 7.6 TELECOMMUNICATIONS EASEMENT. All of the Covered Property is subject to exclusive and nonexclusive easements reserved to Declarant for access, ingress, and egress, for purposes of installing, operating, maintaining, inspecting and removing Telecommunication Facilities for the benefit of Declarant and its subsidiaries, transferees, successors and assigns, as reserved and granted by reservations and conveyances of Record and the provisions hereof. Such easements are freely transferable by Declarant to any other individual or entity and their successive owners for the purpose of providing Telecommunication Services to the Covered Property and to other real property. All such Telecommunication Facilities shall remain the property of Declarant, its subsidiaries, successors, transferees and assigns, and transfer of all or any portion of the Covered Property does not imply the transfer of any such Telecommunication Facilities or easements located thereon. Exercise of the easements reserved in this Section shall not unreasonably interfere with the reasonable use and enjoyment of the Covered Property. However, in the event that the holder of such easements is required to excavate or remove any sidewalk, driveway or other Improvements within the Covered Property in the exercise of these easements with respect to Telecommunications Facilities, such easement holder shall restore the Improvements to their condition prior to the excavation or removal, or to a better condition, within a reasonable period of time. -44- 2%4-332n%W4281CCR31581730.13 2/1196 7.7 MISCELLANEOUS EASEMENTS. Declarant and each Neighborhood Builder reserve the following easements for the benefit of all of the real property in the Covered Property and the Owners: 7.7.1 Utilities. Reciprocal, nonexclusive easements over all Homes, Neighborhood Property and the Association Property, for maintenance and repair of utility services. 7.7.2 Drainage. Reciprocal, nonexclusive easements for drainage of water over, across and upon adjacent Homes and Association Property resulting from the normal use of adjoining Lots, Condominiums, Neighborhood Property or Association Property. 7.7.3 Maintenance and Repair. Nonexclusive easements for access to perform necessary maintenance of any Improvement constructed by Declarant or a Neighborhood Builder. 7.7.4 Easements on Maps. Easements as shown on any Recorded subdivision map or Recorded parcel map of any portion of the Covered Property. 7.7.5 Encroachments. Easements for minor encroachment and maintenance if any Improvement on a Home or Neighborhood Property encroaches upon the Association Property or if Association Property Improvements encroach upon any Lot, Condominium or Neighborhood Property as a result of construction by Declarant or a Neighborhood Builder or as a result of construction, repair or reconstruction approved by the Design Review Committee. 7.7.6 Other Accommodations. Easements for the benefit of the Homes and Neighborhood Property over adjacent Homes Neighborhood Property or Association Property for the purposes of accommodating any natural movement or settling of any Improvement, any encroachment of any Improvement due to minor engineering or construction variances, and any encroachment of eaves, roof overhangs and architectural features comprising parts of the original construction of any Home. 7.8 DELEGATION OF USE. Any Owner entitled to use and enjoyment of the Association Property may delegate his rights to such Owner's tenants, contract purchasers or subtenants who reside in such Owner's Home, subject to reasonable regulation by the Board. An Owner who has delegated his rights may not use or enjoy the recreational facilities or equipment on the Association Property for so long as such delegation remains in effect- 7.9 ffect7.9 WAIVER OF USE. No Owner may exempt himself from personal liability for assessments levied by the Community Association, nor release his Home from the liens and charges hereof, by waiving the use and enjoyment of the Association Property services and facilities, or by abandoning such Owner's Lot or Condominium. 7.10 TAXES. Each Owner shall take such action as the Community Association may reasonably require to obtain separate real estate tax assessment of each Lot or Condominium. If any taxes or assessments may, in the Community Association's opinion, become a lien on the Association Property or any part thereof, the Community Association may pay them as a -45- 2544-332SACLP42SWCM 591730.13 2/1/06 Common Expense and charge the Community Association's costs to the appropriate Owners as a Common Assessment. 7.11 RIGHT TO GRANT ADDITIONAL EASEMENTS. Declarant reserves, together with the right to grant and transfer the same, easements over the Association Property for the exclusive use by an Owner or Owners of contiguous Homes as a yard, recreational, gardening, and/or landscaping area. Any such easement may be conveyed by the Declarant prior to conveying the last Lot or Condominium in the Covered Property. Such conveyance must be approved in advance by the Board of Directors of the Community Association. The purpose of the easement, the portion of the Association Property affected, the Lot or Condominium to which the easement is appurtenant, and any restrictions on use of the easement area shall be identified in the Recorded grant of easement. ARTICLE VIII OBLIGATION TO SHARE COSTS One of the obligations of Owners in the Covered Property is to contribute financially to support the operations of the Community Association. The Community Association funds its operations through the collection of different kinds of assessments: Common Assessments, Capital Improvement Assessments, Extraordinary Assessments, Reconstruction Assessments and Compliance Assessments. This Article describes how the di„fierent types of assessments are k. collected and used by the Community Association This Article also sets limits on the amount of certain assessments that can be charged to Owners. 8.1 CREATION OF ASSESSMENT OBLIGATION. Declarant and each Neighborhood Builder, for each Lot or Condominium owned by Declarant or a Neighborhood Builder, covenants to pay, and each Owner is deemed to covenant to pay to the Community Association (a) Common Assessments, (b) Capital Improvement Assessments, (c) Compliance Assessments, (d) Extraordinary Assessments, and (e) Reconstruction Assessments. Except as provided in this Section, all assessments (other than certain Compliance Assessments), together with interest, costs and reasonable attorneys' fees for the collection thereof, are a charge and can become a lien upon the Lot or Condominium against which such assessment is made. Each assessment (including Compliance Assessments), together with interest, costs and reasonable attorneys' fees, is also the personal obligation of the Person who was the Owner of the Lot or Condominium at the time when the assessment fell due. The personal obligation for delinquent assessments may not pass to any new Owner ("Purchaser") unless expressly assumed by the Purchaser. 8.2 FUNDS OF THE COMMUNITY ASSOCIATION. The Community Association Funds may be established as trust accounts at a banking or savings institution and may be combined so long as reserve funds are not combined with operating funds and the funds are treated as separate funds for accounting purposes. The Board shall budget and keep at least the following accounts (the "Maintenance Funds') into which shall be deposited all monies paid to the Community Association, and from which disbursements shall be made in the Community Association's performance of its functions: -4Cr- 2544.33253WAY428VXM 581730.13 2/1/06 8.2.1 General Operating Fund. A General Operating Fund for current expenses of the Community Association. 8.2.2 General Reserve Fund. An adequate General Reserve Fund for the deposit of Reserves attributable to Improvements within the Assobiation Property or Maintenance Areas. 8.2.3 Miscellaneous Maintenance Funds. Any other Maintenance Funds which the Community Association may deem necessary. 8.3 PURPOSE OF. ASSESSMENTS. Assessments and any other amounts deposited into the Maintenance Funds shall be used exclusively to (a) promote the Owners' recreation and welfare, (b) improve and maintain the Association Property and Maintenance Areas, and (c) perform any other the Community Association function. Disbursements from the particular Maintenance Funds shall be limited to specific purposes as follows: 8.3.1 General Operations. Disbursements from the General Operating Fund shall be made to discharge the Community Association's responsibilities under the Community Association Governing Documents, for the common benefit of all Owners. 8.3.2 General Reserves. Disbursements from the General Reserve Fund shall be made to fund Reserve expenditures. 8.4 ASSESSMENT COMPONENTS, RATES AND EXEMPTIONS. Each annual Common Assessment is an aggregate of separate assessments for each of the Maintenance Funds, reflecting an itemization of the amounts of prospective deposits into the General Operating and Reserve Funds, and any other Maintenance Fund established by the Community Association. Common Assessments shall be assessed against the Owners of Homes as follows: 8.4.1 Assessment Units. The Common Expenses of the Community Association shall be allocated among the Owners of Homes for which Common Assessments have commenced based upon the number of Assessment Units chargeable to each Lot or Condominium. Assessment Units shall be allocated as follows: Each Residential Area Home and the Owner thereof, shall be allocated one (1) Assessment Unit 8.4.2 Excess Funds. During the term of any subsidy agreement between Declarant or any Neighborhood Builder and the Community Association approved by the DRE ("Subsidy Agreement'), all excess funds in the Maintenance Funds over and above the amounts used for payment of Common Expenses (including Reserves) shall be used by the Community Association to fund future Maintenance Fund deficits. After the termination of any Subsidy Agreement, the Board of Directors may determine that excess funds remaining in the Operating Funds, over and above the amounts used for the operation of the Covered Property, may, in the sole discretion of the Board, be used to reduce the following year's Common Assessment attributable to such Maintenance Funds. -47- 2541-33753\CL.P42rCM 581730.13 2/1/06 8.5 LIMITS ON COMMON ASSESSMENT INCREASES. 8.5.1 Increases in the General Assessment Component. For purposes of this Section 8.5 and Section 8.6, an "Increase Election" means a vote by written ballot of the Members with (i) a quorum requirement of fifty percent (5(r) of the Members, and (ii) the minimum number of Members required to approve an action being a majority of the quorum. Sections 8.5.1(a) and 8.5.1(b) do not limit increases in the General Assessment Component necessary for addressing an "Emergency Situation" as defined in Section 8.5.2(c). (a) Ma3dmum Authorized Increase for Initial Year of Operations. During the Fiscal Year in which Common Assessments commence, the Board may increase the General Assessment Component so that it exceeds one hundred twenty percent (120%) of the General Assessment Component disclosed for the Covered Property in the most current Budget approved by DRE at the time Common Assessments commence only if the Board fust obtains the approval of Members in an Increase Election. (b) Ma3dmam Authorized Increase for Subsequent Fiscal Years. After the Fiscal Year in which Common Assessments commence, the Board may increase the General Assessment Component over the General Assessment Component for the immediately preceding Fiscal Year only as follows: (i) If the increase in the General Assessment Component is less than or equal to twenty percent (20%) of the General Assessment Component for the immediately preceding Fiscal Year, then the Board must either (A) distribute the Budget for the current Fiscal Year in accordance with Section 1365(a) of the California Civil Code, or (B) obtain the approval of the Members casting a majority of votes in an Increase Election; and (ii) If the increase in the General Assessment Component is greater than twenty percent (200%) of the General Assessment Component for the immediately preceding Fiscal Year, then the Board must obtain the approval of Members casting a majority of votes in an Increase Election. 8.5.2 Provisions Applicable to All Common Assessments. (a) Supplemental Common Assessments. If the Board determines that Common Expenses may be properly paid by collection of a Common Assessment in an amount less than the maximum authorized Common Assessment, the Board may levy a Common Assessment which is less than the maximum authorized amount. If the Board determines that the Common Assessment being collected is or will become inadequate to pay all Common Expenses, the Board shall immediately determine the approximate amount of the inadequacy and levy a supplemental Common Assessment, subject to the limits described in Section 8.5.1, above. (b) Automatic Assessment Increases. Notwithstanding any other provisions of this Section 8.5, upon annexation of Annexed Territory, the Common Assessment shall be automatically increased by the additional amount, if any, necessary to maintain the Association Property and Maintenance Areas so long as the annexation of such Annexed Territory is permitted by the DRE. To minimize the need for frequent adjustments in the amount of the Common Assessments during the development of the Covered Property, the Board may -48- 2544_33253%W428%CCRM 591730.13 2/1/06 stabilize the amount of the Common Assessments invoiced to the Owners at a level amount calculated to defray the Common Expenses of the Community Association during the time that Common Assessments are fluctuating due to the periodic annexation of Lots, Condominiums and Association Property. of the following: (c) Emergency Situations. An "Emergency Situation" is any one (i) An extraordinary expense required by an order of a court; (ii) An extraordinary expense necessary to maintain any portion of the Covered Property for which the Community Association is responsible where a threat to personal safety on the Covered Property is discovered; and (iii) An extraordinary expense necessary to maintain any portion of the Covered Property for which the Community Association is responsible that could not have been reasonably foreseen by the Board when preparing the Budget. Prior to the imposition or collection of an assessment pursuant to this Subsection 8.5.2(c), the Board shall adopt a resolution containing written findings as to the necessity of the extraordinary expense involved and why the expense was not or could not have been reasonably foreseen in the budgeting process. The resolution shall be distributed to the Members with the notice of assessment increase. 8.6 SPECIAL ASSESSMENTS. 8.6.1 Authorization. The Board is authorized to levy Capital Improvement Assessments, Reconstruction Assessments and Extraordinary Assessments (each, a "Special Assessmene' for purposes of this Section 8.6) for purposes authorized in this Master Declaration or any Supplemental Declaration. 8.6.2 Limit on Special Assessments for Improvements. Special Assessments for Improvements which, if added to the Special Assessments already levied during a Fiscal Year for Improvements that exceed five percent (5%) of the Community Association's Budgeted gross expenses for such Fiscal Year may only be levied with the vote or written consent of Members casting a majority of votes at an Increase Election unless the Special Assessments are necessary for addressing Emergency Situations defined in Section 8.5.2(c). 8.7 COMMENCEMENT OF COMMON ASSESSMENTS. Common Assessments shall commence as to each Lot or Condominium in any Residential Area Phase requiring the issuance of a Public Report on the first day of the month following the first Close of Escrow in such Phase. Notwithstanding the foregoing, the conveyance of any Lot or Condominium in the Covered Property which is being used by Declarant or any Neighborhood Builder as a Model Home shall not serve to commence the levy of Common Assessments against such Model Home. Common Assessments shall be suspended against such Model Home until the first day of the month following the earlier of the following events: (a) Declarant or the respective Neighborhood Builder discontinue using such Lot or Condominium as a Model Home; or (b) any other Lot or Condominium in the same Phase of Development as such Model Home has been sold to a member of the homebuying public pursuant to a transaction requiring -49- 2544-332531CU429=01581730.13 211/06 the issuance of a Public Report and such Lot or Condominium is occupied by a member of the general public. During the period of time a Model Home is not subject to the levy of Common Assessments as provided herein, Declarant or the respective Neighborhood Builder shall maintain such Model Home at its sole cost and expense and shall keep same in an as -new condition. Common Assessments shall commence on each Lot in a Phase in an area other than the Residential Area on the first day that such Phase becomes subject to this Master Declaration. The first Common Assessment shall be adjusted according to the number of months remaining in the Fiscal Year. 8.8 COLLECTION OF COMMON ASSESSMENTS. The Board shall fix the amount of the Common Assessment against each Lot at least thirty (30) days in advance of each Common Assessment period. Written notice of any change in the amount of any Common Assessment, Capital Improvement Assessment or Reconstruction Assessment shall be sent via fust -class mail to every Owner subject thereto not less than thirty '30) nor more than ninety (90) days prior to the increased assessment becoming due. The due dates shall be established by the Board. The Community Association shall, upon demand and for a reasonable charge, furnish a certificate setting forth whether the assessments on a specified Lot or Condominium have been paid. A properly completed certificate as to the status of assessments against a Lot or Condominium is binding upon the Community Association as of the date of its issuance. The Community Association may use any method of collecting assessments allowed by law including charging credit cards or electronic transfers. At the Community Association's discretion, the additional cost of any method of collection can be collected from the Owner electing the method of collection and does not have to be divided equally among all Owners. Each installment of Common Assessments may be paid by the ' Member to the Community Association in one (1) check or payment or in separate checks as payments attributable to specified the Community Association Funds. If any payment of a Common Assessment installment is less than the amount assessed and the payment does not specify the Maintenance Fund or Funds into which it should be deposited, the payment received by the Community Association from that Owner shall be credited in the order of priority set forth in the collection policy of the Community Guidelines. 8.9 EXEMPT PROPERTY. The following property is exempt from all assessments imposed pursuant to this Master Declaration: 8.9.1 Public Property. All portions of the Covered Property dedicated to and accepted by a Local Governmental Agency. 8.7, above. 8.9.2 Maintenance Areas. The Maintenance Areas. 8.9.3 Association Property. The Association Property. 8.9.4 Neighborhood Property. All Neighborhood Property. 8.9.5 Model Homes. Any Model Homes, subject to the provisions of Section -50- 254433253%W42VC= 511730.13 2/1/06 8.9.6 Other. Any areas exempted from assessments in a Supplemental Declaration, including those areas governed by Regulation 2792.16(c)(2) of the Regulations of the Real Estate Commissioner as contained in Title 10, California Code of Regulations, and Civil Code 1366.1 (regarding temporary exemption from assessment the amounts necessary to defray the costs for maintenance of Association until a notice of completion has been recorded and the Community Association has accepted the Association Property). 8.10 CAPITAL CONTRIBUTIONS TO THE COMMUNITY ASSOCIATION. On the acquisition of record title to a Lot or Condominium from Declarant or Neighborhood Builders, each Owner of a Lot or Condominium shall contribute to the capital of the Community Association an amount equal to One Hundred Fifty and No/100 Dollars ($150.00). This amount shall be deposited by the buyer into the purchase and sale escrow and disbursed therefrom to the Community Association or to Declarant if Declarant has previously advanced such funds to the Community Association. ARTICLE ICK RESIDENTIAL AREA MAINTENANCE OBLIGATIONS To protect the aesthetics of the Covered Property, the Declarant has established standards for maintaining the various types of property in the Residential Area This Article describes these standards. 9.1 OWNER MAINTENANCE OBLIGATIONS. Each Owner of a Lot in the Residential Area shall maintain his Home and Lot in accordance with this Section unless this Section is explicitly superseded in a Supplemental Declaration. 9.1.1 General Responsibilities. Each Owner, at the Owner's sole expense, shall maintain and restore all Improvements located on the Owner's Lot and the Lot itself, excluding any Parkway Improvements described below, in a neat, sanitary and attractive condition, and in conformance with any Maintenance Guidelines. Such maintenance responsibilities include the maintenance of the entire Home on the Lot, as well as any fence or wall constructed on the Lot along the Lot Line abutting any Association Property or Maintenance Area Each Owner whose Lot uses a private drainage system installed by Declarant or a Neighborhood Builder is responsible for its maintenance. Each Owner whose Lot uses a sewer system lateral is responsible for the maintenance of that portion of the lateral which exclusively serves such Owner's Lot. If any Owner permits any Improvement which such Owner is responsible for maintaining to fall into disrepair or to become unsafe, unsightly or unattractive, or to otherwise violate the Community Association Governing Documents, the Board may seek any remedies at law or in equity which it may have. In addition, the Board may, after Notice and Hearing, enter upon such Owner's Lot to perform such maintenance and charge the cost thereof to the Owner. Said cost shall be a Compliance Assessment enforceable as set forth in this Master Declaration. 9.1.2 Insurance Obligations. Each Owner is also responsible for carrying public liability insurance in the amount such Owner deems desirable to cover such Owner's individual liability for damage to person or property occurring inside such Owner's Home or elsewhere upon such Owner's Lot. -51- 2544-332531CL.P429%CCRS% 581730.13 2/1/06 9.1.3 Damage to Homes -Reconstruction. If all or any portion of any Lot or Home is damaged or destroyed by fire or other casualty, the Owner of such Lot shall either (a) rebuild, repair or reconstruct the Lot and the Home thereon in a manner which will restore them substantially to their appearance and condition immediately prior to the casualty or as otherwise approved by the Design Review Committee, or (b) install landscaping on the Lot without rebuilding the Home as approved by the Design Review Committee. The Owner of any damaged Lot or Home and the Design Review Committee shall proceed with all due diligence. The Owner shall cause construction or landscaping to commence within six (6) months after the damage occurs and to be completed within twelve (12) - months after damage occurs, unless prevented by causes beyond such Owner's reasonable control. A transferee of the Lot which is damaged or upon which is located a damaged Home shall commence and complete construction or landscaping in the respective periods which would have remained for the performance of such obligations if the Owner of the Lot at the time of the damage still held title to the Lot. However, no such transferee may be required to commence or complete such construction in less than thirty (30) days from the date such transferee acquired title to the Lot. 9.1.4 Walls. The walls in the Covered Property located on or within one (1) foot of a property line of a Lot are divided into the categories listed in this Section and shall be maintained as required by this Section. (a) Party Walls. Each wall or fence which is placed on the dividing line between the Lots (the "Party Wall") is a party wall. The cost of reasonable maintenance of a Party Wall shall be shared equally by the Owners of the Lots divided by the Party Wall. However, each Owner is responsible for repainting the side of any Party Wall facing his Lot. If a Party Wall is destroyed or damaged, any Owner whose Lot is affected thereby may restore it, and the Owner of the other Lot which is affected thereby shall contribute equally to the cost of restoration. An Owner who by his negligent or willful act causes a Party Wall to require repair or replacement shall bear the whole cost of the necessary repairs or replacement. The right of any Owner to contribution from any other Owner under this Subsection is appurtenant to each Owner's Lot and passes to such Owner's successors in title. (b) Community Walls. The Community Association shall maintain the structural integrity, cap and exterior surface of the Community Walls in the Covered Property as shown on Exhibit "MM' attached hereto. The Owners shall maintain the interior portion of any Community Walls which face their Lot or Condominium. If a portion of a Community Wall is damaged or destroyed, the Owner of the damaged portion shall promptly repair or reconstruct the damaged their portion of the Community Wall using the same design and identical or substantially equivalent materials as used in the original construction. Additional Community Walls may be identified in Supplemental Declarations. (c) Neighborhood Walls. Neighborhood Walls maintained by the Neighborhood Association, in the Covered Property are located approximately as shown on Exhibit 'IRV" attached to a Neighborhood Declaration or to any Supplemental Declaration. Additional Neighborhood Walls may be identified in Supplemental Declarations. The Neighborhood Association shall maintain all portions of any Neighborhood Walls identified on Exhibit "WWI attached to a Neighborhood Declaration or to any Supplemental Declaration. -52- 2544-33253V-U42MCCRS% 581730.13 2/1/06 Any Neighborhood Wall not shown on Exhibit "WM" shall be maintained by the Owner of the Lot or Condominium which abuts such Neighborhood Wall. 9.2 COMMUNITY ASSOCIATION MAINTENANCE OBLIGATIONS. 9.2.1 Responsibilities. After completion of the construction or installation of the Improvements on the Association Property by Declarant or a Neighborhood Builder, no Improvement, excavation or work which in any way alters the Association Property or Maintenance Areas may be made or done by any Person other than the Community Association, its authorized agents, Declarant or the Neighborhood Builders. Unless otherwise expressly provided in this Master Declaration or a Supplementary Declaration, upon commencement of Common Assessments on the Lots or Condominiums in a Phase, the Community Association shall maintain all completed Improvements on the Association Property and Maintenance Areas it is obligated to maintain in such Phase (including the Parkways described below, public and private park areas, streets, alleys, paseos and storm drain areas as depicted on Exhibit "SD" attached hereto) in perpetuity, in conformance with any Maintenance Guidelines. In addition, the Community Association will maintain the Open Space/Park Areas to be constructed in the Covered Property and any associated access or use easements for the benefit of the public in connection with the use of such Open Space/Park Areas. The Open Space/Park Areas in the Covered Property are located approximately as shown on Exhibit "OS" attached hereto. Pursuant to requirements imposed by the City, upon commencement of Common Assessments on Lots or Condominiums in a Phase, the Community Association shall also maintain all completed Improvements on real property in the Phases (a) owned by the Community Association and designated for maintenance by the Community Association as shown on Exhibit "AP" attached hereto or any Exhibit "AP" attached to any Supplemental Declaration, and (b) owned by others which is designated for Community Association maintenance on Exhibit "MA" attached hereto or any Exhibit "MA" attached to any Supplemental Declaration. Unless otherwise provided in any Maintenance Guidelines, the Board shall determine, in its sole discretion, the level and frequency of maintenance of the Association Property and Maintenance Areas the Community Association is obligated to maintain. The Community Association may add or remove any landscaping Improvements to or from the Association Property or Maintenance Areas it is obligated to maintain and shall keep the landscaping thereon free of weeds and disease. 9.22 Parkway Maintenance Areas. The following areas will be maintained by the Community Association: (a) landscaped portions of the private streets adjacent to certain Lots identified as "Private Parkways" on Exhibit "PM" attached hereto or as identified in any Supplemental Declaration; and (b) portions of public streets not owned by the Community Association but maintained by the Community Association identified as "Public Parkways" on Exhibit "MA" attached hereto or as identified in any Supplemental Declaration. The Private Parkways (including sidewalks) and Public Parkways (collectively, "Parkways"), are to be maintained by the Community Association, commencing not more than thirty (30) days after both a Notice of Completion for the Parkway Improvements has been filed and the City has performed a Final Inspection or provided other written acknowledgement of the approval of the completed Parkway Improvements. Improvements on Parkways adjacent to Lots in any Phase shall be maintained by the Neighborhood Builder until Community Association maintenance commences. Sidewalks within Public Parkways will be maintained by the City. Driveways in -53- 2544-33253CU428%CCRs1581730.13 2/1/06 multi -family Neighborhoods in the Covered Property shall be maintained by the applicable Neighborhood Association. Otherwise, each Owner shall be responsible for maintenance of the driveway of such Owner's Lot. The Community Association will be responsible for trimming and pruning the street trees and maintaining turf, shrubs, irrigation systems and any mailbox kiosks in the Parkways. Neighborhood Builders will plant street trees in the Parkways and in the front yard areas of some Lots, adjacent to the street Each Owner of a Lot and each Neighborhood Association Owner of Neighborhood Property (as the case may be), on which no portion is identified as a "Private Parkway" on Exhibit "PM" or a "Public Parkway" on Exhibit "MA" attached hereto shall maintain all portions of the Lot or Neighborhood Property (as applicable), including any trees originally planted by Neighborhood Builders. Neither the Neighborhood Association nor Owners may remove or relocate the street trees originally planted by the Neighborhood Builder in the Parkways or the front yard of the Lot or on Neighborhood Property without the prior written consent of the Community Association. 9.2.3 Damage to Association Property or Maintenance Areas. The Board may levy the cost of any maintenance by the Community Association in the Association Property or Maintenance Areas caused by the willful or negligent act of an Owner, other Person or any Neighborhood Association as a Compliance Assessment against the responsible Owner, Person or Neighborhood Association after Notice and Hearing. 92.4 Community Association Maintenance Obligations. Except as otherwise provided in this Master Declaration, from and after the date .of conveyance of fee ti e or appropriate easements thereto to the Community Association, the Community Association will be responsible for the maintenance, repair, replacement, irrigation, drainage facilities, brush clearance, landscaping and preservation of the appearance of the Association Property and Maintenance Areas in strict compliance with the Maintenance Manual provided to the Board by Declarant or a Neighborhood Builder ("Maintenance Manual"), the Best Management Practices, and in accordance with all commonly accepted maintenance practices. To ensure compliance with the requirements of the Maintenance Manual, for a period of ten (10) years after the last Close of Escrow in the Covered Property, Declarant shall have the right, but not the obligation, at its own cost and expense, to retain the services of appropriate consultant(s) to (a) prepare, update and keep current the Maintenance Manual for the Community Association maintenance of the Association Property and Maintenance Areas, (b) conduct annual inspections of all elements of the Association Property and Maintenance Areas covered by the Maintenance Manual, and (c) prepare a report covering the results of such inspections and deliver such report to Declarant and to the Community Association. Declarant hereby reserves non-exclusive easements on, over, under, across and through all Association Property and Maintenance Areas within the Covered Property, for the purpose of such inspections and activities related thereto. The Community Association shall provide Declarants' consultant(s) with copies of its maintenance log, and related records reasonably requested by such consultant(s), at least thirty (30) days prior to the date scheduled for the Declarant's annual inspection. Declarant shall provide any updates to the Maintenance Manual to the Community Association. The Community Association shall cause such Association Property and Maintenance Areas to be regularly maintained and painted in accordance with the requirements and recommendations of the Maintenance Manual, as revised from time to time, and shall perform all remedial maintenance in accordance with the recommendations of the annual inspection reports prepared -54- 2544-3325AaY42l1C= 581730.13 VI/06 by DeclaranVs consultant(s). The provisions of this Section shall not be amended without the prior written consent of Declarant. 9.2.5 Maintenance Manual Compliance. The Community Association has the duty and obligation, along with the attendant rights and power to carry out the Declarants and its consultant(s)' required maintenance of the Association Property and Maintenance Areas in perpetuity, as set forth in the Maintenance Manual. The Board shall regularly determine whether the recommended inspections and maintenance activities have been followed, and, if any such recommendations have not been followed, what corrective steps need to be taken to assure proper inspections and maintenance of the Association Property and the Maintenance Areas. The Board shall keep a record of such determinations in the Board's minutes. The Board shall review the Maintenance Manual for any needed appropriate revisions at appropriate intervals, but in no event less frequently than annually. 9.2.6 Community Association Inspections. If in any year Declarant elects not to perform an annual maintenance inspection as provided for in Section 92.4 above, the Board shall have the duty and obligation to cause an inspection and report to be made in accordance with the provisions hereof. The Board's annual inspections shall (a) determine whether the Association Property and Maintenance Areas is being maintained adequately in accordance with the standards of maintenance established herein and by the Maintenance Manual, (b) identify the condition of the Association Property and the Maintenance Areas, including the existence of any hazards or defects, and the need for performing additional maintenance or refurbishing, and (c) recommend preventative actions, which may be taken to reduce potential maintenance costs to be incurred in the future. The Community Association . may employ such experts and consultants as necessary to perform such inspections. With thirty (30) days after the Board's annual inspection, the Board shall have a report of the results of the �- inspection prepared, and such report shall include the following: (i) a description of the condition of the Association Property and the Maintenance Areas, including a list of items inspected and the status of maintenance, repair and need for replacement of such items; (ii) a description of all maintenance planned for the ensuing Fiscal Year and included in the Budget; (iii) if any maintenance is to be deferred, an explanation must be given for such deferral; (iv) a summary of all reports of inspections performed by any expert or consultant employed by the Board to perform inspections; (v) a report of the status of compliance with the maintenance needs set forth in all inspection reports for preceding years and identified in any applicable Maintenance Guidelines; and (vi) such other matters as the Board deems appropriate. The Board shall promptly cause a copy of each inspection report prepared in accordance with this Section to be delivered to Declarant The Community Association's obligations under this Section shall continue until the expiration of the ten (10) -year period following the last Close of Escrow in the Covered Property. The requirements of this Section are in addition to the Board's obligations to perform ongoing reserve studies as required by Section 2.12 of the Bylaws. The provisions of this Section shall not be amended without the prior written consent of Declarant 9.3 NEIGHBORHOOD ASSOCIATION OBLIGATIONS. Each Neighborhood Association, at its expense shall maintain and restore all Improvements located on its Neighborhood Property in a neat, sanitary and attractive condition. If any Neighborhood Association permits any Improvement which such Neighborhood Association is responsible for maintaining, to fall into disrepair or to become unsafe, unsightly or unattractive, to reasonably be -55- 2544-33253%W42r CCas1591730.13 211/06 deemed by a duly authorized City official that a public nuisance has been created by the absence of adequate maintenance such as to be detrimental to public health, safety or general welfare, or to otherwise violate this Master Declaration, the Board may seek any remedies at .law or in equity which it may have. In addition, the Board may, after Notice and Hearing, enter upon such Neighborhood Property to make such repairs or to perform such maintenance and charge the cost thereof to the Neighborhood Association. Said cost shall be a Compliance Assessment enforceable as set forth in this Master Declaration. 9.4 MAINTENANCE STANDARDS. Notwithstanding any other provision of this Article 1X, the Declarant, the Community Association, Neighborhood Builders, Neighborhood Associations and all Owners shall maintain everything they are required to maintain in a neat, safe and attractive condition, which maintenance shall include: (a) maintenance of all landscaping such that all landscaping is evenly cut, evenly edged, free of bare or brown spots, debris and weeds, (b) trimming of trees and shrubs so that they do not impede vehicular or pedestrian traffic, (c) pruning of trees so that they do not intnide, have droppings on or are another nuisance on neighboring Lots, Condominiums or other properties, (d) pruning of trees so as to eliminate exposed surface roots and damage to sidewalks, driveways and structures, (e) maintenance of all private roadways, sidewalks and Open Space/Park Areas so that they are safe for users, and (f) repair and removal of any significant pavement cracks, pavement distress, excessive slab settlement, abrupt vertical variations and debris on travelways. ARTICLE X DAMAGE AND CONDEMNATION This Article establishes the procedure for repairing or reconstructing damaged Association Property or Maintenance Areas and for obtaining funds from condemnation of Association Property. Damage to or destruction of the Association Property or Maintenance Areas and condemnation of the Association Property shall be handled in the following manner: 10.1 REPAIR AND RECONSTRUCTION. If the Association Property or any Maintenance Area is damaged or destroyed, the Community Association shall cause the Association Property or Maintenance Area to be repaired and reconstructed substantially in accordance with the original plans and specifications, and any restoration or repair of the Association Property or Maintenance Area shall be performed substantially in accordance with the original plans and specifications. If the cost of effecting total restoration of the Association Properly or Maintenance Area exceeds the amount of insurance proceeds, then the Community Association shall levy a Reconstruction Assessment against the Lots and Condominiums and their respective Owners equal to the difference between the total restoration cost and the insurance proceeds. 10.2 OWNERS' RESPONSIBILITIES. Each Owner is liable to the Community Association for all expenses of repairing the Association Property and Maintenance Areas not fully reimbursed to the Community Association by insurance proceeds (including any deductible amounts under any insurance policies against which the Community Association files a claim for such damage) which may be sustained due to the negligence or willful misconduct of said Owner -56- 2544-33253NCLP4281CM 581730.13 2/1/06 or the Persons deriving their right and easement of use and enjoyment of the Association Property or Maintenance Area from said Owner. The Community Association may, after Notice and Hearing, (a) determine whether any claim shall be made upon the insurance kept by the Community Association and (b) levy against such Owner a charge equal to any deductible paid and the increase, if any, in the insurance premium directly attributable to the damage caused by such Owner or the Persons for whom such Owner may be liable as described in this Master Declaration, as a Common Assessment. If a Lot or Condominium is jointly owned, the liability of its Owners is joint and several, except to the extent that the Community Association has previously contracted in writing with such joint Owners to the contrary. After Notice and Hearing, the cost of correcting such damage, to the extent not reimbursed to the Community Association by insurance, shall be a Compliance Assessment against such Owner. 10.3 EMINENT DOMAIN. If any portion of the Association Property is taken by right of eminent domain or by private purchase in lieu of eminent domain, the award in condemnation shall be paid to the Community Association and deposited in the Operating Fund. No Owner may participate as a party, or otherwise, in any proceedings relating to such condemnation. ARTICLE XI INSURANCE This Article establishes minimum requirements for insurance kept by the Community Association and the Owners in the Covered Property. 11.1 PROPERTY INSURANCE. The Board shall obtain and keep all such property insurance for loss or damage to all insurable Improvements installed by Declarant, any Neighborhood Builder or by the Community Association on the Association Property and Maintenance Areas with an agreed amount endorsement for no less than one hundred percent (100%) of the full replacement cost (new without deduction for depreciation) of the cost of Improvements, fixtures and other property without deduction for coinsurance, and may obtain insurance against such other hazards and casualties as the Community Association may deem desirable if commercially reasonable and kept by reasonably prudent owners of similar properties. The Community Association may also insure any other real or personal property it owns against loss or damage by fire and such other hazards as the Community Association may deem desirable, with the Community Association as the owner and beneficiary of such insurance. The policies insuring -the Association Property and Maintenance Areas must be written in the name of, and the proceeds thereof must be payable to, the Community Association. Unless the applicable insurance policy provides for a different procedure for filing claims, all claims made under such policy must be sent to the insurance carrier or agent, as applicable, by certified mail and be clearly identified as a claim. The Community Association shall keep a record of all claims made. The Community Association shall use insurance proceeds to repair or replace the property for which the insurance was carried. Premiums for all insurance carried by the Community Association are a Common Expense. 11.2 INSURANCE OBLIGATIONS OF OWNERS. Each Owner is responsible for insuring his personal property and all other property and Improvements in his Lot or Condominium as required by either Section 9.12, the applicable Supplemental Declaration or -57- 2544332531CLP428%CCRM 581730.13 2/1/06 Neighborhood Declaration. Such policies shall not adversely affect or diminish any coverage under any insurance obtained by or on behalf of the Community Association. Duplicate copies of such other policies shall be deposited with the Board upon the Board's request. If any loss intended to be covered by insurance carried by or on behalf of the Community Association occurs and the proceeds payable thereunder are reduced due to insurance carried by any Owner, such Owner shall assign the proceeds of such insurance to the Community Association, to the extent of such reduction, for application by the Board to the same purposes as the reduced proceeds are to be applied. 11.3 WAIVER OF SUBROGATION. All policies of insurance the Community Association keeps must provide, if available on commercially reasonable terms, for waiver of: (a) any defense based on coinsurance, and (b) any claim for subrogation. and other rights of recovery that the Community Association and the Owners might have against each other and their respective agents, employees, entities and insurers with respect to all parties covered by whatever casualty insurance is in effect. As to each policy of insurance the Community Association keeps which will not be voided or impaired thereby, the Community Association waives and releases all claims against the Board, the Owners, the Community Manager, Declarant, the Neighborhood Builders and the agents and employees of each of the foregoing, with respect to any loss covered by such insurance, whether or not caused by negligence or breach of any agreement by such Persons, but only to the extent that insurance proceeds are received in compensation for such loss. 11.4 LIABILITY AND OTHER INSURANCE. The Community Association shall obtain commercial general liability insurance, including coverage for medical payments and malicious mischief, in such limits as it deems desirable with such minimum limits as are set forth in Section 1365.9 of the California Civil Code, insuring against liability for bodily injury, death and property damage arising from the Community Association's activities or with respect to property the Community Association maintains or is required to maintain including, if obtainable, a cross -liability endorsement insuring each insured against liability to each other insured. The Community Association may also obtain Worker's Compensation insurance and other liability insurance as it may deem desirable, insuring each Owner, the Community Association, the Board and Community Manager, against liability in connection with the Association Property and Maintenance Areas, the premiums for which are a Common Expense. The Board shall review all insurance policies at least annually and adjust the limits in its discretion. The Board may also obtain such errors and omissions insurance, indemnity bonds, fidelity insurance and other insurance as it deems advisable, insuring the Board, the Community Association's officers and the Community Manager against any liability for any act or omission in carrying out their obligations hereunder, or resulting from their membership on the Board or on any committee thereof. However, fidelity insurance coverage which names the Community Association as an obligee must be obtained by or on behalf of the Community Association for any Person handling the Community Association funds, including the Community Association officers, directors, employees and agents and Community Manager employees, whether or not such Persons are compensated for their services, in an amount not less than the estimated maximum of funds, including reserve funds, in the Community Association's or Community Manager's custody during the term of the insurance. The aggregate amount of such insurance coverage may not be less than one-fourth (1/4) of the annual Common Assessments on all Lots and Condominiums in the Covered Property, plus reserve funds. In addition, the Community -58- 2544-33253CU429 CCRM 581730.13 2/1/06 Association shall continuously keep in effect such casualty, flood and liability insurance and fidelity insurance coverage meeting the requirements for planned unit developments established by Fannie Mae, Ginnie Mae and Freddie Mac, so long as any of them is a Beneficiary or an Owner of a Lot or Condominium in the Covered Property, except to the extent such coverage is not reasonably available or has been waived in writing by Fannie Mae, Ginnie Mae and Freddie Mac, as applicable. For a period of ten (10) years following the last Close of Escrow in the Covered Property, the Board shall provide summaries of insurance, notices of significant changes in insurance coverage and notice if a policy of insurance is not renewed to the Members and to Declarant. 11.5 NOTICE OF EXPIRATION REQUUMMENTS. If available, each insurance policy the Community Association keeps must contain a provision that said policy may not be canceled, terminated, materially modified or allowed to expire by its terms, without ten (10) to thirty (30) days' prior written notice to the Board, Declarant, and to each Owner and Beneficiary, insurer and guarantor of a first Deed of Trust who has filed a written request with the carrier for such notice, and every other Person in interest who requests such notice of the insurer. ARTICLE XII RIGHTS OF BENEFICIARIES This Article gives various rights to lenders. 12.1 GENERAL PROTECTIONS. Notwithstanding any other provision of this Master Declaration, no amendment or violation of the Master Declaration defeats or renders invalid the rights of the Beneficiary under any Deed of Trust upon one (1) or more Lots or Condominiums made in good faith and for value, provided that after the foreclosure of any such Deed of Trust such Lot or Condominium will remain subject to this Master Declaration. For purposes of the Community Association Governing Documents, "first Deed of Trust" means a Deed of Trust with first priority over other Deeds of Trust on a Lot or Condominium. 122 WRITTEN NOTIFICATION. Each Beneficiary, insurer and guarantor of a first Deed of Trust encumbering at least one (1) Home, upon filing a written request for notification with the Board, is entitled to written notification from the Community Association of. (a) any condemnation or casualty loss which affects either a material portion of the Covered Property or the Homes securing the respective first Deed of Trust; and (b) any delinquency of ninety (90) days or more in the performance of any obligation under the Community Association Governing Documents, including the payment of assessments or charges owed by the Members, which notice each Member consents to and authorizes; and (c) a lapse, cancellation, or material modification of any policy of insurance or fidelity insurance kept by the Community Association; and (d) any abandonment or termination of the Community Association. -59- 2544-33253%CLP428T= 591730.13 2/1106 12.3 RIGHT OF FIRST REFUSAL. Each Owner, including each first Beneficiary of a first Deed of Trust which obtains title to such Home pursuant to the remedies provided in such Deed of Trust, or by foreclosure of such Deed of Trust, or by deed or assignment in lieu of foreclosure, shall be exempt from any "right of first refusal" created or purported to be created by the Community Association Governing Documents. . - 12.4 RIGHTS UPON REQUEST. All Beneficiaries, insurers and guarantors of first Deeds of Trust, upon written request to the Community Association, shall have the right to: (a) examine current copies of the Community Association's books, records and financial statements and the Community Association Governing Documents during normal business hours; and (b) receive writter notice of all meetings of Members; and (c) designate in writing a representative who shall be authorized to attend all meetings of Members. 12.5 PAYMENTS OF DELINQUENT AMOUNTS. Beneficiaries of First Deeds of Trust may, jointly or singly, pay taxes or other charges which are in default and which may or have become a charge against any Association Property and may pay any overdue premiums on hazard insurance policies, or secure new hazard insurance coverage on the lapse of a policy, for Association Property or Maintenance Areas and shall be owed immediate reimbursement therefor from the Community Association. 12.6 CONTRACTS. The Board may enter into such contracts or agreements on behalf of the Community Association as are required in order to satisfy the guidelines of VA, FHA, Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, Ginnie Mae or any similar entity, so as to allow for the purchase, insurance or guaranty, as the case may be, by such entities of first Deeds of Trust encumbering Lots and Condominiums. Each Owner agrees that it will benefit the Community Association and its Members, as a class of potential borrowers and potential sellers of their Homes, if such agencies approve the Covered Property as a qualifying subdivision under their respective policies, rules and regulations. Each Owner authorizes his Beneficiary to furnish information to the Board concerning the status of any Deed of Trust encumbering a Home. ARTICLE XIII ENFORCEMENT This Article establishes procedures for enforcing the provisions of the Community Association Governing Documents, collecting delinquent assessments, enforcing certain bonded obligations and resolving disputes with the Declarant. 13.1 ENFORCEMENT OF COMMUNITY ASSOCIATION GOVERNING DOCUMENTS. All disputes arising under the Community Association Governing Documents, other than those described in Section 13.2, Section 13.4 or regulated by Civil Code Section 1375, et seq., shall be resolved as follows: -60- 2544-3325ACLP428TCRM 581730.13 2/1/06 13.1.1 Violations Identified by the Community Association. If, the Design Review Committee or the Board determines that there is a violation of the Community Association Governing Documents, then the Board shall give written notice to the responsible Owner or Neighborhood Association identifying (a) the condition or violation complained of, and (b) the length of time the Owner or Neighborhood Association has to remedy the violation including, if applicable, the length of time the Owner or Neighborhood Association has to submit plans to the Design Review Committee and the length of time the Owner or Neighborhood Association has to complete the work proposed in the plans submitted to the Design Review Committee. If an Owner or Neighborhood Association does not perform such corrective action as is required by the Board within the allotted time, the Board, after Notice and Hearing, may remedy such condition or violation complained of, and the cost thereof shall be charged to the Owner or Neighborhood Association as a Compliance Assessment. If the violation involves nonpayment of any type of assessment, then the Board may collect such delinquent assessment pursuant to the procedures set forth in Section 13.2. 13.1.2 Violations Identified by an Owner or Neighborhood Association. If an Owner or Neighborhood Association alleges that another Owner, other Person, or Neighborhood Association is violating the Community Association Governing Documents (other than nonpayment of any type of assessment), .the complaining Owner or Neighborhood Association must first submit the matter to the Board for Notice and Hearing before the complaining Owner or Neighborhood Association may resort to alternative dispute resolution, as required by Section 1369.510, et seq., of the California Civil Code, or litigation for relief. 13.1.3 Legal Proceedings. Failure to comply with any of the terms of the Community Association Governing Documents by a Neighborhood Association or an Owner, or any other Person, is grounds for relief which may include an action to recover sums due for damages, injunctive relied foreclosure of any lien, or any combination thereof; provided, however, that the procedures established in Sections 1363.810, et seq. and 1369.510, et seq., of the California Civil Code and in Sections 13.1.1 and 13.1.2 above must first be followed, if they are applicable. 13.1.4 Limit on Expenditures. The Community Association may not incur litigation expenses, including attorneys' fees, or borrow money to fund litigation, where the Community Association initiates legal proceedings or is joined as a plaintiff in legal proceedings, unless the Community Association first obtains the consent of the Members (excluding the voting power of any Owner who would be a defendant in such proceedings), and, if applicable, complies with the requirements of Sections 1363.810, et seq., and 1369510, et seq., of the California Civil Code. Such approval is not necessary if the legal proceedings are initiated (a) to enforce the use restrictions contained in Article II, (b) to enforce the architectural and landscaping control provisions contained in Article V, (c) to collect any unpaid assessments levied pursuant to the Community Association Governing Documents, (d) for a claim, the total value of which is less than five hundred thousand dollars ($500,000), or (e) as a cross-complaint in litigation to which the Community Association is already a party. If the Community Association decides to use or transfer reserve funds or borrow funds to pay for any litigation, the -61- 2544.33253CU 428=0%591730.13 2/1106 Community Association must notify its Members of the decision by mail. Such notice shall provide an explanation of why the litigation is being initiated or defended, why operating funds cannot be used, how and when the reserve fimds will be replaced or the loan will be repaid, and a proposed budget for the litigation. The notice must slate that the Members have a right to review an accounting for the litigation which will be available at the Community Association's office. The accounting shall be updated monthly. If the Association action to incur litigation expenses or borrow money to fund litigation concerns a Defect Claim defined in Section 6.4.2, then the voting requirements of both Sections 6.4.2 and 13.1.4 must be met 13.1.5 Additional Remedies. The Board may adopt a schedule of reasonable fines or penalties which, in its reasonable discretion, it may assess against an Owner -or Neighborhood Association for the failure of such Owner, or of a resident of or visitor to such Owner's Home, or Neighborhood Association to comply with the Community Association Governing Documents. The Board may Record a Notice of Noncompliance for any violation of the Community Association Governing Documents if permitted by law. Such fines or penalties may only be assessed after Notice and Hearing. 13.1.6 No Waiver. Failure to enforce any provision hereof does not waive the right to enforce that provision, or any other provision hereof. 13.1.7 Right to Enforce. The Board or 'any Owner (not at the time in default hereunder) may enforce the Community Association Governing Documents as described in this Article, subject to Sections 1363.810, et seq., and 1369.510, et seq., of the California Civil Code. Each remedy provided for in the Community Association Governing Documents is cumulative and not exclusive or exhaustive. 132 NONPAYMENT OF ASSESSMENTS. 13.2.1 Delinquency. Assessments are delinquent if not paid within fifteen (15) days after the due date established by the Community Association. Assessments not paid within fifteen (15) days after the due date, plus all reasonable costs of collection (including attorneys' fees) and late charges bear interest at the maximum rate permitted by law commencing thirty (30) days after the due date until paid. The Community Association may also require the delinquent Owner to pay a late charge in accordance with California Civil Code Section 1366(d)(2). The Community Association need not accept any tender of a partial payment of an assessment and all costs and attorneys' fees attributable thereto. Acceptance of any such tender does not waive the Community Association's right to demand and receive full payment. 13.2.2 Creation and Release of Lien. (a) Priority of Lien. All liens levied in accordance with this Master Declaration shall be prior and superior to (i) any declaration of homestead Recorded after the Recordation of this Master Declaration, and (ii) all other liens, except (1) all taxes, bonds, assessments and other levies which, by law, would be superior thereto, and (2) the lien or charge of any first Deed of Trust of Record (meaning any Recorded Deed of Trust with fust priority or seniority over other Deeds of Trust) made in good faith and for value and Recorded before the -62- 2544-33253\CU428%CC M 591730.13 211M date on which the "Notice of Delinquent Assessment" (described in this Section) against the assessed Lot or Condominium was Recorded. (b) Prerequisite to Creating Lien. Before the Community Association may place a lien on an Owner's Lot or Condominium to collect a past due assessment, the Community Association shall send written notice ("Notice oflntent to Lien"), at least thirty (30) days prior to recording of such lien, to the Owner by certified mail which contains the following information: (i) the fee and penalty procedure of the Community Association, (ii) an itemized statement of the charges owed by the Owner, including the principal owed, any late charges, any interest, and the method of calculation, any attorneys' fees, iii) the collection practices used by the Community Association, (iv) a statement that the Community Association may recover the reasonable costs of collecting past due assessments, (v) a statement that the Owner has the right to inspect the Community Association's records, pursuant to California Corporations Code Section 8333, (vi) the following statement in 14 -point boldface type or all capital letters: "IMPORTANT NOTICE: IF YOUR SEPARATE INTEREST IS PLACED IN FORECLOSURE BECAUSE YOU ARE BEHIND IN YOUR ASSESSMENTS, IT MAY BE SOLD WITHOUT COURT ACTION," (vii) a statement that the Owner shall not be liable to pay the charges, interest and costs of collection if it is determined the assessment was paid on time to the Community Association, and (viii) a statement that the Owner has the right to request a meeting with the Board, as provided by California Civil Code Section 1367.1(c) and Section 13.22(d) below. (c) Dispute by Owner. An Owner may dispute the Notice of Intent to Lien by submitting to the Board a written explanation of the reasons for the Owner's dispute. The Board shall respond in writing to the Owner within fifteen (15) days of the date of the postmark of the explanation, if the explanation is mailed within fifteen (15) days of the postmark of the Notice of Intent to Lien. (d) Owner's Right to Request Meeting. An Owner may submit a written request to meet with the Board to discuss a payment plan for the debt noticed in Section 13.2.2(b) above. The Community Association shall provide the Owner with the standards for payment plans, if any exist. The Board shall meet with the Owner in executive session within forty-five (45) days of the postmark of the request, if the request is mailed within fifteen (15) days of the date of the postmark of the Notice of Intent to Lien, unless there is no regularly scheduled Board meeting within that period, in which case the Board may designate a committee of one (1) or more members to meet with the Owner. (e) Notice of Delinquent Assessment. The lien becomes effective on Recordation by the Board or its authorized agent of a Notice of Delinquent Assessment ("Notice of Delinquent Assessment") as provided in Section 1367 or 1367.1 of the California Civil Code. The Notice of Delinquent Assessment must identify (i) the amount of the assessment and other authorized charges and interest, including the cost of preparing and Recording the Notice of Delinquent Assessment, (ii) the amount of collection costs incurred, including reasonable attorneys' fees, (iii) a sufficient description of the Lot or Condominium that has been assessed, (iv) the Community Association's name and address, (v) the name of the Owner of the Lot or Condominium that has been assessed, and (vi) if the lien is to be enforced by nonjudicial foreclosure, the name and address of the trustee authorized by the Community -63- 2544-33253TLP428%CCRS%581730.13 2/1/06 Association to enforce the lien by sale. The Notice of Delinquent Assessment must be signed by an authorized Community Association officer or agent and must be mailed in the manner required by Section 2924b of the California Civil Code to the Owner of record of the Lot or Condominium no later than ten (10) calendar days after Recordation. The lien relates only to the individual Lot or Condominium against which the assessment was levied and not to the Covered Property as a whole. (f) Exceptions. Assessments described in Section 1367.1(e) of the California Civil Code and Section 2792.26(c) of the California Code of Regulations may not become a lien against an Owner's Lot or Condominium enforceable by the sale of the Lot or Condominium under Sections 2924, 2924(b) and 2924(c) of the California Civil Code. (g) Release of Lien. Within twenty-one (21) days of payment of the full amount claimed in the Notice of Delinquent Assessment, or other satisfaction thereot the Board shall cause to be Recorded a Notice of Satisfaction and Release of Lien ("Nod ee of Release'l stating the satisfaction and release of the amount claimed. The Community Association shall provide the Owner with a copy of the Notice of Release or any other notice that the full amount claimed in the Notice of Delinquent Assessment has been satisfied. The Board may require the Owner to pay a reasonable charge for preparing and Recording the Notice of Release. Any purchaser or encumbrancer who has acted in good faith and extended value may rely on the Notice of Release as conclusive evidence of the full satisfaction of the sums identified as owed in the Notice of Delinquent Assessment. 132.3 Enforcement of Liens. The Board shall enforce the collection of amounts due under this Master Declaration by one (1) or more of the alternative means of relief afforded by this Master Declaration. The lien on a Lot or Condominium may be enforced by foreclosure and sale of the Lot or Condominium after failure of the Owner to pay any assessment or installment thereof as provided in this Master Declaration. The sale shall be conducted in accordance with the provisions of the California Civil Code applicable to the exercise of powers of sale in Deeds of Trust, or in any manner permitted by law. The Community Association (or any Owner if the Community Association refuses to act) may sue to foreclose the lien if (a) at least thirty (30) days have elapsed since the date on which the Notice of Delinquent Assessment was Recorded and (b) at least ten (10) days have elapsed since a copy of the Notice of Delinquent Assessment was mailed to the Owner affected thereby. The Community Association may bid on the Lot or Condominium at the foreclosure sale, and acquire and hold, lease, mortgage and convey the same. On completion of the foreclosure sale, the Community Association or the purchaser at the sale may file suit to secure occupancy of the defaulting Owner's Lot or Condominium, and the defaulting Owner shall be required to pay the reasonable rental value for the Lot or Condominium during any period of continued occupancy by the defaulting'Owner or any persons claiming under the defaulting Owner. A suit to recover a money judgment for unpaid assessments may be brought without foreclosing or waiving any lien securing the same, but this provision or any suit to recover a money judgment does not affirm the adequacy of money damages. Any recovery resulting from a suit at law or in equity initiated pursuant to this Section may include reasonable attorneys' fees as fixed by the court. 13.2.4 Priority of Assessment Lien. Deeds of Trust Recorded before a Notice of Delinquent Assessment have lien priority over the Notice of Delinquent Assessment. Sale or -64- 2544-33253%W429=RS1581730.13 2/1/06 transfer of any Lot or Condominium does not affect the assessment lien, except that the sale or transfer of any Lot or Condominium pursuant to judicial or nonjudicial foreclosure of a first Deed of Trust extinguishes the lien of such assessments as to payments which became due before such sale or transfer. No sale or transfer relieves such Lot or Condominium from liens for any assessments thereafter becoming due. No Person who obtains title to a Lot or Condominium pursuant to a judicial or nonjudicial foreclosure of the fust Deed of Trust is liable for the share of the Common Expenses or assessments chargeable to such Lot or Condominium which became due before the acquisition of title to the Lot or Condominium by such Person. Such unpaid share of Common Expenses or assessments is a Common Expense collectible from all Owners including such Person. The Community Association may take such action as is necessary to make any assessment lien subordinate to the interests of the Department Veterans Affairs of the State of California under its Cal -Vet loan contracts as if the Cal -Vet loan contracts were first Deeds of Trust of record. 13.2.5 Receivers. In addition to the foreclosure and other remedies granted to the Community Association in this Master Declaration, each Owner conveys to the Community Association all of such Owner's right, title and interest in all rents, issues and profits derived from and appurtenant to such Lot or Condominium, subject to the right, power and authority of the Community Association to collect and apply such rents, issues and profiis to any delinquent assessments owed by such Owner, reserving to the Owner the right, prior to any default by the Owner in the payment of assessments, to collect and retain such rents, issues and profits as they may become due and payable. Upon any such default the Community Association may, upon the expiration of thirty (30) days following delivery to the Owner of the "Notice of Delinquent Assessment" described in this Master Declaration, either in person, by agent or by receiver to be appointed by a court, and without regard to the adequacy of any security for the indebtedness secured by the lien described in this Master Declaration, (a) enter in or upon and take possession of the Lot or Condominium or any part thereof, (b) in the Community Association's name sue for or otherwise collect such rents, issues and profits, including those past due and unpaid, and (c) apply the same, less allowable expenses of operation, to any delinquencies of the Owner hereunder, and in such order as the Community Association may determine. The entering upon, and taking possession of the Lot or Condominium, the collection of rents, issues and profits and the application thereof, shall not cure or waive any default or notice of default hereunder or invalidate any act done pursuant to such notice. 13.2.6 Alternative Dispute Resolution of Assessment Disputes. Disputes between an Owner and the Community Association regarding the assessments imposed by the Community Association may be submitted to alternative dispute resolution in accordance with Civil Code Sections 1363.810, et seq., and 1369.510, et seq., if such Owner pays in full (a) the amount of the assessment in dispute, (b) any late charges, (c) any interest, and (d) all fees and costs associated with the preparation and filing of a Notice of Delinquent Assessment (including mailing costs and attorneys' fees not to exceed the maximum amount allowed by law), and states by written notice that such amount is paid under protest, and the written notice is mailed by certified mail to the Community Association not more than thirty (30) days from the Recording of a Notice of Delinquent Assessment. Upon receipt of such written notice, the Community Association shall inform the Owner in writing that the dispute may be resolved through alternative dispute resolution as set forth in Civil Code Sections 1363.810, et seq., and 1369.510, et seq. -65- 2544-3325ACLP428kCRS\ 581730.13 2/1/06 The right of any Owner to utilize alternative dispute resolution under this Section may not be exercised more than two (2) times in any single calendar year, and not more than three times within any five (5) calendar years. Nothing in this Section shall preclude any Owner and the Community Association, upon mutual agreement, from entering into alternative dispute resolution in excess of the limits set forth in this Master Declaration. An Owner may request and be awarded through alternative dispute resolution reasonable interest to be paid by the Community Association in the total amount paid under items (a) through (d) above, if it is determined that the assessment levied by the Community Association was not correctly levied. 13.3 ENFORCEMENT OF BONDED OBLIGATIONS. If (a) the Association Property and Improvements in any Phase are not completed prior to the issuance of a Public Report for such Phase by the DRE, and (b) the Community Association is obligee under a bond or other arrangement (" Bond'j required by the DRE to secure performance of Declarant's or a Neighborhood Builder's commitment to complete such Improvements, then the following provisions of this Section will be applicable: 13.3.1 Board Action. The Board shall consider and vote on the question of action by the Community Association to enforce the obligations under the Bond with respect to any such Improvement for which a Notice of Completion has not been filed within sixty (60) days after the completion date specified for that Improvement in the Planned Construction Statement appended to the Bond. If the Community Association has given an extension in writing for the completion of any Association Property Improvement, then the Board shall be directed to consider and vote on the aforesaid question if a Notice of Completion has not been filed within thirty (30) days after the expiration of the extension. 13.3.2 Member Action. A vote by written ballot of Members to override a decision by the Board not to enforce the obligations under the Bond or on the Board's failure to consider and vote on the question shall be held no fewer than thirty-five (35) nor more than forty-five (45) days after the Board receives a petition for such a vote signed by Members representing at least five percent (51%) of the Community Association's voting power_ A vote of a majority of the Community Association's voting power composed of Members other than Declarant or the Neighborhood Builders to enforce the obligations under the Bond shall be deemed to be the decision of the Community Association, and the Board shall thereafter implement such decision by initiating and pursuing appropriate action. 13.4 DAMAGE TO PROPERTY DISPUTES. Not later than thirty (30) days prior to the filing of any civil action by the Community Association against Declarant or any Neighborhood Builder for alleged damage to Association Property or Maintenance Areas, alleged damage to a Home Lot or Condominium that the Community Association is obligated to maintain or repair, or alleged damage to a Home, Lot or Condominium that arises out of, or is integrally related, to damage to the Association Property, Maintenance Areas or a Home, Lot or Condominium that the Community Association is obligated to maintain or repair, the Board shall provide written notice to each Member who appears on the records of the Community Association at the time notice is given, specifying (a) that a meeting of Members will be held to discuss problems that may lead to the filing of a civil action, (b) the options, including civil actions, that are available to address the problems, and (c) the time and place of the meeting. If the Community Association has .reason to believe that the applicable statute of limitations will -66- 2544-33253%CL.P429%CCRS% 591730.13 VIM expire before the Community Association files the civil action, the Community Association may give the foregoing notice not later than thirty (30) days after the filing of the action. .13.5 DISPUTE RESOLUTION. Any disputes between all or any of the Community Association, Owner(s), Declarant, any Neighborhood Builder, or any director, officer, partner, employee, contractor, design professional, consultant, subcontractor or agent of Declarant (collectively Declarant Parties'), arising under this Master Declaration or relating to the Covered Property, shall be subject to this Section 13.5 and the following Sections 13.6, 13.7 and 13.8. 13.6 CONSTRUCTION DEFECT DISPUTES. 13.6.1 Notice of Construction Claims Statute. California Civil Code Section 895 et seq., as hereafter amended ("Construction Claims Statute'), delineates standards for how various components of residential dwelling units should be constructed and function, limits the time frames for bringing various claims against the builder to anywhere from one (1) year to ten (10) years (as listed in the Construction Claims Statute) from the close of escrow for the residential dwelling unit, imposes an obligation on all Owner's to follow Declarant's or any Neighborhood Builder's maintenance recommendations and schedules, or other applicable maintenance guidelines, and establishes a non -adversarial claims resolution procedure that must be followed by an Owner before the Owner can initiate an adversarial claim and proceed to judicial reference or binding arbitration, as described in Section 13.8 below. THE CONSTRUCTION CLAIMS STATUTE AFFECTS EACH OWNER'S LEGAL RIGHTS. OWNERS ARE ADVISED TO READ THE STATUTE CAREFULLY AND SEEK LEGAL ADVICE IF OWNER HAS ANY QUESTIONS REGARDING ITS AFFECT ON OWNER'S LEGAL RIGHTS. PURSUANT TO CALIFORNIA CIVIL CODE SECTION 914, DECLARANT AND NEIGHBORHOOD BUILDERS ARE PERMITTED TO ELECT TO USE ALTERNATE CONTRACTUAL NON ADVERSARIAL PROCEDURES INSTEAD OF USING THE STATUTORY PRE -LITIGATION PROCEDURES PROVIDED IN THE CONSTRUCTION CLAIMS STATUTE. DECLARANT AND NEIGHBORHOOD BUILDERS HAVE ELECTED TO USE THEIR OWN CONTRACTUAL NON - ADVERSARIAL PROCEDURES. AS PROVIDED BELOW. Notwithstanding the above election, a Neighborhood Builder may in a Supplemental Declaration or a Notice of Election affecting a Phase of Development being developed by such Neighborhood Builder, make an alternative election pursuant to Civil Code Section 914 only as to construction defect claims which do not concern Association Property and which are not directed to Declarant or Declarant's directors, officers, partners, employees, contractors, design professionals, consultants, subcontractors or agents. 13.6.2 Owners' Construction Defect Claims. Prior to the commencement of any legal proceeding by any Owner against Declarant or any Declarant Party based upon a claim for defects in the design or construction of any Home, Lot or Condominium, Association Property or any Improvements thereon, the Owner must fust comply with the provisions of this Section. If at any time during the ten (10) year period following the Close of Escrow for the original Owner's purchase of such Owner's Home from Declarant or a Neighborhood Builder, as such period may be extended by any applicable tolling statute or provision, or any shorter period as provided by applicable law, such Owner believes Declarant or a Neighborhood Builder has -67- 2344-33253KC.P428\C= 531730.13 2/1106 violated any of the standards set forth in the Construction Claims Statute ("Claimed Defect"), which such Owner feels may be the responsibility of Declarant or a Neighborhood Builder, such Owner shall promptly notify Declarant at Lennar Corporation, 700 NW 107 Avenue, 4th Floor, Miami, FL 33172, attention General Counsel, in writing, with a copy thereof to MOFFETT MEADOWS PARTNERS, LLC, c% Lennar Homes of California, Inc., Attention: Western Region Corporate Legal Counsel, 25 Enterprise, Aliso Viejo, CA 92656, and shall promptly notify the Neighborhood Builder at such other address as has been provided to the Owner pursuant to the Construction Claims Statute. Such notice shall be deemed a notice of intention to commence a legal proceeding and shall include: (a) a detailed description of the Claimed Defect, (b) the date upon which the Claimed Defect was first discovered, and (c) dates and times when Owner or Owner's agent will be available during ordinary business hours, so that service calls or inspections by Declarant or a Neighborhood Builder can be scheduled. Declarant and any Neighborhood Builder shall, in their sole discretion, be entitled to inspect the applicable property regarding the reported Claimed Defect and, within their sole discretion, shall be entitled to cure such Claimed Defect Nothing contained in this Article shall obligate Declarant and any Neighborhood Builder to perform any such inspection or repair, nor shall this Section be deemed to increase Declamat's and any Neighborhood Builder's legal obligations to Owner. Owner's written notice delivered to Declarant and any Neighborhood Builder shall be a condition precedent to Owner's right to institute any legal proceeding and to proceed to judicial reference or binding arbitration as set forth Section 13.8 below, and Owner shall not pursue any other remedies available to it, at law or otherwise, including the filing of any legal proceeding or action, until Declarant and any Neighborhood Builder has had the reasonable opportunity to inspect and cure the Claimed Defect During the term of any written limited warranty ("Limited Warranty") provided to the original Owner of the Home by Declarant or a Neighborhood Builder, any conflict between the provisions of this Section and the Limited Warranty shall be e�► resolved in favor of the Limited Warranty. Declarant and Neighborhood Builders shall not be liable for any general, special or consequential damage, cost, diminution in value or other loss which Owner may suffer as a result of any Claimed Defect in the Home, which reasonably might have been avoided had Owner given Declarant and Neighborhood Builder the notice and opportunity to cure as described above within a reasonable time of discovering the Claimed Defect Except as otherwise provided in the written Limited Warranty, if any, provided to Owner, nothing contained herein shall establish any contractual duty or obligation on the part of Declarant or a Neighborhood Builder to repair, replace or cure any Claimed Defect. If an Owner sells or otherwise transfers ownership of such Owner's Home to any other person during such ten (10) year period, as such period may be extended by any applicable tolling statute or provision, Owner covenants and agrees to give such other person written notice of these procedures by personal delivery. Owner's continuing obligation under this covenant shall be binding upon Owner and Owner's successors and assigns. (a) Owner Document Obligations. All Owners, who originally purchased a Home from Declarant or a Neighborhood Builder, were provided copies of certain documents through escrow in conjunction with the purchase of the Home, including copies of this Master Declaration, maintenance recommendations from Declarant or a Neighborhood Builder, maintenance recommendations for manufactured products or appliances included with the Home, a limited warranty, claim forms, and other documentation relating to the Construction Claims Statute. All Owners are required by the Construction Claims Statute to retain these -68- 2544-332531CLP428NCCRM 591730.13 2/1/06 documents and provide copies of such documents to Owner's successors in interest upon the sale or transfer of such Owner's Home. (b) Owner Maintenance Obligations. All Owners are obligated by Section 907 of the Construction Claims Statute to follow Declarant's or a Neighborhood Builder's maintenance recommendations and schedules, including the maintenance recommendations and schedules for manufactured products and applianbes provided with the Lot or Condominium, as well as all commonly accepted maintenance practices (collectively, "Maintenance Recommendations'). Pursuant to Section 945.5 of the Construction Claims Statute, failure to follow the Maintenance Recommendations may reduce or preclude Owner's right to recover damages relating to such Owner's Lot or Condominium, which could have been prevented or mitigated had the Maintenance Recommendations been followed. 13.6.3 Community Association's Construction Defect Claims. DECLARANT ELECTS TO USE THE ALTERNATE CONTRACTUAL NON - ADVERSARIAL PROCEDURES CONTAINED IN CIVIL CODE SECTION 1375, EXCEPT AS OTHERWISE PROVIDED' HEREIN, RATHER THAN THE STATUTORY PRE- LITIGATION PROCEDURES OF THE CONSTRUCTION CLAIMS STATUTE, WITH RESPECT TO CLAIMS BY THE COMMUNITY ASSOCIATION. Prior to the commencement of any legal proceeding by the Community Association against Declarant or any Declarant Party based upon a claim for defects in the design or construction of the, Association Property, or any Improvements thereon, or any other area within the Covered Property which the Community Association has standing to make a claim for defects in design or construction, the Community Association must first comply with all of the applicable requirements of Civil Code Section 1375, as the same may be amended from time to time, or any successor statute thereto. In addition to the requirements of said Section 1375, Declarant and any Neighborhood Builder shall have an absolute right, but not an obligation, to repair any alleged defect or condition claimed by the Community Association to be in violation of the standards set forth in the Construction Claims Statute, within a reasonable period of time after completion of the inspection and testing provided for in such Section and prior to submission of Neighborhood Builder's settlement offer under such Section. If the parties to such dispute are unable to resolve their dispute in accordance with the procedures established under Civil Code Section 1375, as the same may be amended from time to time, or any successor statute, the dispute shall be resolved in accordance with the judicial reference or binding arbitration provisions • of Section 13.8 below and the parties to the dispute shall each be responsible for their own attorneys' fees. The Community Association shall have the power to initiate claims against a Declarant Party for violations of the Construction Claims Statute, as soon as the Community Association has one (1) Class A Member other than Declarant. Upon the written request of any Class A Member to the Board of Directors, the Board shall establish a committee consisting exclusively of Class A Member(s), other than Declarant's or any Neighborhood Builder's agents or employees to investigate claimed violations of the standards of the Construction Claims Statute. Upon the committee's determination that cause exists to initiate a claim, the decision of whether to initiate a claim shall be made by a vote of the Class A Members, other than Declarant's or any Neighborhood Builder's agents or employees. A majority of the votes cast shall be deemed to be the decision of the Community Association, which the Board shall carry out by submitting the necessary claim to Declarant or the appropriate Declarant Party; provided, however, that the vote is either conducted at a properly convened meeting with the requisite quorum in accordance with -69- 2544-33253XCLP42IRCCRM 591730.13 2/1/06 the provisions of the Bylaws relating to meetings and voting, or the vote was conducted without a meeting in accordance with California Corporations Code Section 7513, as authorized by the Bylaws. 13.7 OTHER DISPUTES. Any other disputes arising under this Master Declaration, or otherwise, between the Community Association or any Owner and Declarant or any Declarant Party (except for any action taken by the Community Association against Declarant or a Neighborhood Builder for delinquent assessments, any action involving enforcement of any completion bonds or any action described in Civil Code Section 1369.520) shall be resolved in accordance with the alternate dispute resolution provisions of Section 13.8 below. The dispute resolution procedure in Section 13.8, as it applies solely to disputes under this Section 13.7, shall be deemed to satisfy the alternative dispute requirements of Civil Code Section 1363.810, et seq. and 1369.510, et seq.,or any successor statute, as applicable. 13.8 ALTERNATE DISPUTE RESOLUTION PROCEDURES. 13.8.1 Judicial Reference. Subject to compliance with the provisions of Sections 13.5 through 13.7 above, to the extent applicable, it is the intention of Declarant and Neighborhood Builders that, except as otherwise expressly provided herein, any and all disputes upon which litigation is filed, shall be resolved by judicial reference under California law. Accordingly, except as otherwise expressly provided in this Master Declaration (such as the collection of delinquent assessments), any dispute between the Community. Association or any Owner(s) and the Declarant or any Neighborhood Builder, or between the Community Association and any Owner with respect to the interpretation of any of the provisions of this Master Declaration, or with respect to any alleged breach hereof, or with respect to any other ' claim related to the Association Property, including, without limitation, any alleged latent or patent construction or design defect in the Association Property, or any part thereof, any alleged violation of the standards set forth in the Construction Claims Statute, any judicial determination to be made under California Civil Code Section 1375(h), or for alleged damage to the Association Property, alleged damage to Homes, Lots or Condominiums that arises out of, or is integrally related to the Association Property, or Homes, Lots or Condominiums that the Community Association is obligated to maintain or repair, shall be heard by a referee pursuant to the provisions of California Code of Civil Procedure Sections 638(a) and 641 through 645.1. Notwithstanding any other provision of this Master Declaration, this Article shall not be amended without the written consent of Declarant. In the event litigation is filed based upon any such dispute, the following shall apply: (a) The proceeding shall be brought and held in the County, unless the parties agree to an alternative venue. (b) The parties shall use the procedures adopted by JAMS for judicial reference and selection of a referee (or any other entity offering judicial reference dispute resolution procedures as may be mutually acceptable to the parties). (c) The referee must be a retired judge or a licensed attorney with substantial experience in relevant real estate matters. -70 2544-33253%CLP428%C= 581730.13 2/1/06 (d) The parties to the litigation shall agree upon a single referee who shall have the power to try any and all of the issues raised, whether of fact or of law, which may be pertinent to the matters in dispute, and to issue a statement of decision thereon to the court. Any dispute regarding the selection of the referee shall be resolved by JAMS or the entity providing the reference services, or, if no entity is involved, by the court with appropriate jurisdiction in accordance with California Code of Civil Procedure Sections 638 and 640. (e) The referee shall be authorized to provide all remedies available in law or equity appropriate under the circumstances of the controversy. (f) The referee may require one (1) or more pre -hearing conferences. (g) The parties shall be entitled to discovery, and the referee shall oversee discovery and may enforce all discovery orders in the same manner as any trial court judge. (h) A stenographic record of the trial shall be made. (i) The referee's statement of decision shall contain findings of fact and conclusions of law to the extent applicable. 0) The referee shall have the authority to rule on all post -hearing motions in the same manner as a trial judge. (k) The parties shall promptly and diligently cooperate with each other and the referee and perform such acts, as may be necessary for an expeditious resolution of the dispute. 0) Except as otherwise agreed by the parties or as required by applicable law, neither the Community Association nor any Owner shall be required to pay any fee of the judicial reference proceeding except to the extent of the cost that would be imposed upon the Community Association or Owner if the dispute had been resolved as a dispute in court. The referee may not award against the Community Association or any Owner any expenses in excess of those that would be recoverable as costs if the dispute had been litigated to final judgment in court. Each party to the judicial reference proceeding shall bear its own attorney fees and costs in connection with such proceeding. (m) The statement of decision of the referee upon all of the issues considered by the referee shall be binding upon the parties, and upon filing of the statement of decision with the clerk of the court, or with the judge where there is no clerk, judgment may be entered thereon. The decision of the referee shall be appealable as if rendered by the court. This provision shall in no way be construed to limit any valid cause of action that may be brought by any of the parties. DECLARANT, NEIGHBORHOOD BUILDERS AND OWNERS, BY ACCEPTING A DEED TO A HOME WITHIN THE COVERED PROPERTY, ACKNOWLEDGE AND ACCEPT THAT THEY ARE WAIVING THEIR RIGHT TO A JURY TRIAL. -71- 2544-332531CLP428=RS%581730.13 2/1/06 13.8.2 Binding Arbitration. If for any reason the judicial reference procedures in Section 13.8.1 are legally unavailable at the time a dispute would otherwise be referred to judicial reference, then such dispute shall be submitted to binding arbitration under the rules and procedures in this Section. Any dispute submitted to binding arbitration shall be administered by the AAA in accordance with the AAA's Construction Industry Arbitration Rules in effect on the date of the submission. If such entity is not then in existence, then the dispute shall be submitted to JAMS, and administered in accordance with the Comprehensive Arbitration Rules of JAMS. Any judgment upon the award rendered by the arbitrator may be entered in and enforced by any court having jurisdiction over such dispute. If the claimed amount exceeds $250,000.00 or includes a demand for punitive damages, the dispute shall be heard and determined by three arbitrators. Otherwise, unless mutually agreed to by the parties, there shall be one arbitrator. Arbitrators shall have expertise in the area(s) of dispute, which may include legal expertise if legal issues are involved. All decisions concerning the arbitrability of any dispute shall be decided by the arbitrator(s). At the request of any party, the award of the arbitrator(s) shall be accompanied by detailed written findings of fact and conclusions of law. Except as may be required by law or for confirmation of an award, neither party nor the arbitrators) may disclose the existence, content, or results of any arbitration hereunder without the prior written consent of both parties. 13.8.3 Interpretation. The binding arbitration procedures contained in Section 13.8.2 are implemented for the Covered Property in accordance with the philosophy and intent of the Federal Arbitration Act (9 U.S.C. Section 1 et seq.) ("FAA'), which is designed to encourage the use of alternative methods of dispute resolution and avoid costly and potentially lengthy traditional court proceedings. The binding arbitration procedures in said Section are to be interpreted and enforced as authorized by the FAA. Parties interpreting this Section shall follow wf the federal court rulings, which provide among other things that: (a) the FAA is a congressional declaration of liberal federal policy favoring alternate dispute resolution notwithstanding substantive or procedural state policies or laws to the contrary, (b) alternate dispute resolution agreements are to be rigorously enforced by state courts; and (c) the scope of.issues subject to alternate dispute resolution are to be interpreted in favor of alternate dispute resolution. 13.9 DISPUTES RELATING TO ENFORCEMENT OF COMMUNITY ASSOCIATION GOVERNING DOCUMENTS. In the event of a dispute between the Community Association and an Owner, or between an Owner and another Owner, relating to the enforcement of the governing documents of the Community Association, the parties shall comply with the provisions of California Civil Code Section 1354(b) through 0), prior to filing of any civil action: 13.10 CIVIL. CODE SECTIONS 1368.4, 1375, 1375.05 AND 1375.1. Nothing contained herein shall be deemed a waiver or limitation of the provisions of California Civil Code Sections 1368.4, 1375, 1375.05, or 1375.1. 13.11 USE OF DAMAGE AWARD AMOUNTS. Any and all amounts awarded to a claimant on account of a claimed construction or design defect in the Association Community, or damage suffered as a result thereof, shall be expended by such claimant for the attorney fees and costs of the proceeding and the repair, rehabilitation, or remediation of the claimed defect or damage. -72- 2544-33253W-U4281CCM 581730.13 2/1/06 13.12 MISCELLANEOUS. Nothing in Sections 13.4 through 13.12 shall constitute a waiver of any. of the benefits of statutes of limitations or equitable defenses of any party. Furthermore, notwithstanding any other provision of this Master Declaration, Sections 13.4 through 13.12 may not be amended without the prior written consent of the Declarant. 13.13 ENFORCEMENT By CITY. 13.13.1 Enforcement of Maintenance Obligation. The City shall have the right, but not the obligation, to enforce the performance of any Community Association obligations set forth herein and in the City's conditions of approval for the Covered Property contained in City Council Resolution No. 05-40, passed and adopted at a regular meeting of the Tustin City Council held on February 22, 2005, by notifying the Community Association in writing of the need to perform such maintenance. The Community Association shall promptly maintain the subject Improvements. Such maintenance shall be commenced by the Community Association within thirty (30) days after receipt by the Community Association of the City's notice, and thereafter pursued to completion as soon as reasonably possible 13.13.2 Failure to Perform. In the event that the Community Association does not commence the maintenance described in the City notice within the time permitted, or diligently pursue the work to completion, the City may undertake the necessary maintenance or other reasonable actions to ensure compliance. The City may then impose an assessment upon the Community Association in an amount sufficient to cover the actual costs of City maintenance and costs of other City actions to ensure compliance, including reasonable attorneys' fees, and other reasonable expenses. 13.13.3 Assessment and Lien. Declarant, for each Lot it owns, covenants to pay, and each Owner, by acceptance of a deed to a Lot, whether or not it shall be so expressed in such deed, is deemed to covenant to pay, to the City any assessment imposed pursuant to this Section. All such assessments, together with interest, costs and reasonable attorneys' fees for the collection thereof, are a charge and continuing lien upon the Lot against which assessment is made. In addition to the lien upon the Lot, each such assessment, together with interest, costs and reasonable attorneys' fees, is also the personal obligation of the Person who was the Owner of the Lot at the time when the assessment was due. The personal obligation for delinquent assessments, but not the lien, shall not pass to any new Owner C Purchaser'o unless expressly assumed by the Purchaser. 13.13.4 Assessment Payment. Any assessment pursuant to this Section is delinquent if not paid within thirty (30) days of the due date established by the City. Any assessment not paid within forty-five (45) days after the due date, plus all reasonable costs of collection (including attorneys' fees), bears interest at the legal rate commencing thirty (30) days from the date the assessment becomes due until paid. The City may bring an action at law against the Owner personally obligated to pay the same, or foreclose the lien against the Lot. The city need not accept any tender of a partial payment of an assessment and all costs and attorneys' fees attributable thereto, and any acceptance of any such tender does not waive the City's right to demand and receive full payment thereafter. -73- 2544-33253XC1.P4281C= 581730.13 VIM 13.13.5 Enforcement of Lien. The lien created bythis this Section shall be enforced and perfected pursuant to Civil Code Sections 1366, et seq., as they now exist or may hereafter be amended. ARTICLE XIV GENERAL PROVISIONS Communities are dynamic and constantly evolving as circumstances, technology, needs, desires and laws change, and as the surrounding area changes. The Covered Property and the Community Association Governing Documents must be able to adapt to these changes while protecting the things that make the Covered Property unique. This Article includes provisions that will allow the Covered Property to adapt to different changes. 14.1 TERM. This Master Declaration continues in full force unless a Declaration of Termination satisfying the requirements of an amendment to the Master Declaration as set forth in Section 14.3 is Recorded. 14.2 INTERPRETATION. 14.2.1 General Rules. The Community Association Governing Documents shall be liberally construed to effectuate the goal of creating a uniform plan for the development q'. of a master planned community and for the maintenance of the Association Property and Maintenance Areas. Any violation of the Community Association Governing Documents is a nuisance. The Community Association Governing Documents shall be interpreted so as to be consistent with applicable laws and regulations, including ordinances and regulations of the appropriate Local Governmental Agencies. The Article, Section and paragraph headings are inserted for convenience only, and may not be considered or referred to in resolving questions of interpretation or construction. As used in the Community Association Governing Documents, the singular includes the plural and the plural the singular, and the masculine, feminine and neuter each include the other, unless the context dictates otherwise. Except as otherwise expressly provided, any reference to time for performance of obligations or to elapsed time means consecutive calendar days, months, or years, as applicable. Exhibits "CP," "AP," "PM," "MA," "WM," "OS," "SD", "PC," W-1" and "TC" are incorporated in this Master Declaration by this reference. All references made in the Community Association Governing Documents to statutes are to those statutes as amended or restated or to subsequently enacted replacement statutes. Unless otherwise indicated, reference to Articles, Sections and Exhibits are to Articles, Sections and Exhibits of the document containing the reference. 14.2.2 Intent of Declarant. Declarant intends that the Covered Property be developed for single-family residential, and other uses defined in Supplemental Declarations, all consistent with this Master Declaration and any applicable Supplemental Declarations. In addition, Declarant, at its option, may designate areas for maintenance, recreational, institutional or other purposes. 14.2.3 Statements in Italics. The portions of the Community Association Governing Documents printed in italics are provided as simplified, general explanations of the purposes of the Articles, Sections or paragraphs of the Community Association Governing -74- 2544-33253XW428lCCRS% 581730.13 211/06 Documents and the scheme of governance for the Covered Property. The statements in italics are provided for convenience and may not be considered in resolving questions of interpretation or construction of the Community Association Governing Documents. 142.4 Relationship to Supplemental Declarations. As each Phase of the Residential Area or other area in the Covered Property is developed, Declarant or Declarant and a Neighborhood Builder may Record at least one (1) Supplemental Declaration which shall designate the use classifications in the areas affected and which may supplement this Master Declaration with such additional covenants, conditions, restrictions and land uses as Declarant may deem appropriate for the real property being annexed ("Annexed Territory"). The provisions of any Supplemental Declaration may impose such additional, different or more restrictive conditions, covenants, restrictions, land uses and limits as Declarant may deem advisable, taking into account the particular requirements of each Phase. If there is any conflict between any Supplemental Declaration and the Master Declaration, the Supplemental Declaration shall control with respect to the Annexed Territory described in such Supplemental Declaration. If there is any conflict between any Neighborhood Declaration or the Master Declaration or applicable Supplemental Declaration, the Master Declaration and applicable Supplemental Declaration shall control, although such documents shall be construed to be consistent with one another to the extent possible. A Neighborhood Declaration may, but need not, provide for the establishment of a Neighborhood Association, to be composed of Owners of Homes located within the jurisdiction of such Neighborhood Declaration. 142.5 Relationship to Other Community Association Governing Documents. if there are conflicts or inconsistencies between this Master Declaration and the Articles, Bylaws, Design Guidelines or Community Guidelines then this Master Declaration shall prevail. 14.2.6 Severability. The provisions of the Community Association Governing Documents are independent and severable. A determination of invalidity or partial invalidity or unenforceability of any one provision or portion hereof by a court of competent jurisdiction does not affect the validity or enforceability of any other provision hereof. 14.3 TFMMI KATION AND AMENDMENT. Notice of the subject matter of a proposed amendment to, or termination of, this Master Declaration in reasonably detailed form shall be included in the notice of any meeting or election of the Community Association at which a proposed amendment or termination is to be considered. 14.3.1 Member Approval. The following amendments to this Master Declaration must be approved by the Members: (a) Any amendment terminating this Master Declaration or the Community Association. (b) Amendments to Sections 4.3.10, 4.5, 6.3, 9.3, 13.1.4, 13.3, 13.4 and 14.3.1, and to Articles XVI and XVII. 14.3.2 Beneficiary Approval. In addition to the required notice and consent of Members and Declarant, the Beneficiaries of fifty-one percent (51%) of the first Deeds of -75- 2544-332531CLF4281CCRS\ 581730.13 2/1/06 Trust on all the Homes who have requested the Community Association to notify them of proposed action requiring the consent of a specified percentage of Beneficiaries of fust Deeds of Trust must approve any of the following amendments to the Community Association Governing Documents: (a) Any amendment which affects or purports to affect the validity or priority of Deeds of Trust or the rights or protection granted to Beneficiaries, insurers and guarantors of fast Deeds of Trust in this Master Declaration. (b) Any amendment which would or could result in a Deed of Trust being canceled by forfeiture. (c) Any amendment relating to the insurance provisions as set out in Article XI hereof, or to the application of insurance proceeds as set out in Article X hereof, or to the disposition of any money received in any taking under condemnation proceedings. (d) Any amendment which would subject any Owner to a right of first refusal or other such restriction if such Home is proposed to be sold, transferred or otherwise conveyed. 14.3.3 Notice to Beneficiaries. Each Beneficiary of a first Deed of Trust on a Lot or Condominium in the Covered Property which is sent written notice of a proposed amendment or termination of this Master Declaration by certified or registered mail with a return receipt requested shall be deemed to have approved the amendment or termination if the Beneficiary fails to submit a response to the notice within thirty (30) days after the date of the mailing receipt. 14.3.4 Certification of Amendments. A copy of each amendment shall be certified by at least two (2) Community Association officers, and the amendment will be effective when a Certificate of Amendment is Recorded. The Certificate, signed and sworn to by at least two (2) officers of the Community Association that the requisite number of Owners have either voted for or consented in writing to any termination or amendment adopted as provided above, when Recorded, is conclusive evidence of that fact The Community Association shall keep in its files the record of all such votes or written consents for at least four (4) years. The certificate reflecting any termination or amendment which requires the written consent of any of the Beneficiaries of first Deeds of Trust must include a certification that the requisite approval of such Beneficiary has been obtained. The certificate reflecting any termination or amendment which requires the written consent of Declarant or is subject to Declamnt's veto right must include Declarant's signature. 14.3.5 Unilateral Amendment By Declarant. Notwithstanding any other provisions of this Section 14.3, at any time prior to the first Close of Escrow in the Covered Property, Declarant may, with the City's written consent, unilaterally amend or terminate this Master Declaration by Recording a written instrument which effects the amendment or termination and is signed and acknowledged by Declarant and the Neighborhood Builder who owns a portion of the Covered Property. Notwithstanding any other provisions of this Section 14.3, Declarant (for so long as Declarant or a Neighborhood Builder owns any portion of the -76- 2544-33253XCLP428NCCRSI 581730.13 2/1/06 Covered Property) may unilaterally amend this Master Declaration or a Supplemental Declaration by Recording a written instrument signed by Declarant in order to (a) conform this Master Declaration or a Supplemental Declaration to applicable law, including supplementing this Master Declaration or a Supplemental Declaration with provisions which pertain to the rights and obligations of Declarant, the Community Association or Owners arising under Division 2, Part 2, Title 7 (commencing with Section 895) of the California Civil Code, (b) conform this Master Declaration or a Supplemental Declaration to the requirements of VA, FHA, DRE, Fannie Mae, Ginnie Mae, Freddie Mac or the City, (c) correct typographical errors, (d) change any exhibit to this Master Declaration or a Supplemental Declaration or a portion of an exhibit, depicting property that is not part of an area for which assessments have commenced, and (e) change any dxhibit to this Master Declaration or a Supplemental Declaration or portion of an exhibit to conform to as-buik conditions. 14.3.6 Amendment By the Board. Notwithstanding any other provisions of this Section 14.3, the Board may amend this Master Declaration by Recording a written instrument signed by two officers of the Community Association certifying that the Board approved the amendment in order to (a) conforin this Master Declaration to applicable law, (b) correct typographical errors, and (c) change any exhibit to this Master Declaration or portion of an exhibit to conform to as -built conditions. So long as Declarant or a Neighborhood Builder owns any portion of the Covered Property, the Board must obtain Declarant's or Neighborhood Builder's consent to any amendment the Board approves pursuant to this Section. 14.3.7 Amendments Requiring City Approval. Notwithstanding any other provisions of this Section 14.3, no amendment to alter, modify, terminate or change the Community Association's obligation to maintain the Association Property or Maintenance Areas (as set forth in Section 9.2 above) or any other provision of this Master Declaration in which the City has an interest (including the City's enforcement rights under this Master Declaration), shall be permitted without the prior written approval of the City of Tustin Community Development Department. 14.4 NO PUBLIC RIGHT OR DEDICATION. Nothing contained in this Master Declaration constitutes a gift or dedication of all or any part of the Covered Property to the public, or for any public use. 14.5 CONSTRUCTIVE NOTICE AND ACCEPTANCE. Every Person who owns, occupies or acquires any right, title, estate or interest in or to any Lot or Condominium or other portion of the Covered Property does consent and agree, and shall be conclusively deemed to have consented and agreed, to every limit, restriction, easement, reservation, condition and covenant contained in this Master Declaration, whether or not any reference to the Community Association Governing Documents is contained in the instrument by which such Person acquired ani interest in the Covered Property. 14.6 NOTICES. Except as otherwise provided in this Master Declaration, notice to be given to an Owner must be in writing and may be delivered to the Owner or Mortgagee personally or by any system or technology designed to record and cornmunicate messages, facsimile, electronic mail, or other electronic means. Delivery of such notice to one (1) or more co-owners of a Lot or Condominium, to any general partner of a partnership or to a member of a I -77- 2544-332531CLP428TCUN 581730.13 2/1/06 1 limited liability company, constitutes delivery to all co-owners, the partnership or the limited liability company. Delivery of such notice to any officer or agent for the service of process on a corporation constitutes delivery to the corporation. Alternatively, notice may be delivered by regular United States mail, postage prepaid, addressed to the Owner or Mortgagee at the most recent address furnished by such Owner or Mortgagee to the Community Association. If an Owner does not furnish an address, notice may be sent to the street address of an Owner's Lot or Condominium. Such notice is deemed delivered three (3) business days after the time of such mailing, except for notice of a meeting of Members or of the Board, in which case the notice provisions of the Bylaws control. Any notice to be given to the Community Association may be delivered personally to any member of the Board, or sent by United States mail, postage prepaid, addressed to the Community Association at such address as may be fixed from time to time and circulated to all Owners or sent by any system or technology designed to record and communicate messages, facsimile, electronic mail, or other electronic means to such address or telephone number as the Board may establish. 14.7 ADDITIONAL PROVISIONS. Notwithstanding the provisions contained in the Community Association Governing Documents, the Community Association and the Owners should be aware that there may be provisions of various laws, including the Davis -Stirling Common Interest Development Act codified at Sections 1350 et seq. of the California Civil Code and the federal Fair Housing Act codified at Title 42 United States Code, Sections 3601 et seq., which may supplement or override the Community Association Governing Documents. Declarant and the Neighborhood Builders make no representations or warranties regarding the future enforceability of the Community Association Governing Documents. 14.8 MERGERS OR CONSOLIDATIONS. Upon a merger or consolidation of the ..,. Community Association with another association, its properties, rights and obligations may, by operation of law, be transferred to another surviving or consolidated association or, alternatively, properties, rights and obligations of another association may, by operation of law, be added to the properties, rights .and obligations of the Community Association as a surviving corporation pursuant to a merger. The surviving or consolidated association may administer and enforce the covenants, conditions and restrictions established by the Community Association Governing Document, together with the covenants and -restrictions established upon any other property, as one (1) plan. ARTICLE XV LAND CLASSIFICATIONS The Covered Property is composed of marry different types of properties. Each Supplemental Declaration shall describe the different classifications of the Covered Property and land in the Covered Property that is encumbered by such Supplemental Declaration. These classifications are used to establish use restrictions and various rights and obligations of the Owners of the different types of property in the Covered Property. The Covered Property, including each portion of Annexed Territory described in a Supplemental Declaration, shall be designated according to one or more of the following land classifications: (a) Residential Area; (b) Phase of Development; (c) Association Property; -78- 2544-332531CLP428\CCRS1581730. 13 7/1/06 (d) Maintenance Areas; and (e) Neighborhood Property. The Declarant has the right to create other area designations in Supplemental Declarations. ARTICLE XVI ANNEXATION OF ADDITIONAL PROPERTY The Community Association is given the power to add additional property to the property subject to this Master Declaration. Additional real property may be annexed to the Covered Property and such additional real property may become subject to this Master Declaration by the following method.• 16.1 ANNEXED TERRITORY. Additional real property may be annexed to the Covered Property and brought within the general plan of this Master Declaration upon the approval by Members holding at least two-thirds (2/3) of the voting power of the Community Association and by Recording a Supplemental Declaration eAcumbering the real property annexed thereby ("Annexed Territory"). 16.2 SUPPLEMENTAL DECLARATION CONTENT. Each Supplemental Declaration annexing real property to the Covered Property shall contain at least the following provisions: 16.2.1 Master Declaration Reference. A reference to this . Master Declaration, which reference shall state the date of Recordation hereof and the Instrument number or other relevant Recording data of the County Recorder's office. 162.2 Extension of Comprehensive Plan. A statement that the provisions of this Master Declaration shall apply to the Annexed Territory as set forth therein. The Community Association shall commence maintaining any Association Property in any Annexed Territory containing only Association Property upon it4 completion and conveyance to the Community Association. 16.2.3 Description/Phases of Development. A description of the Annexed Territory, including any Association Property. A Supplemental Declaration may cover one (1) or more Phases of Development. 16.2.4 Land Classifications. The land classifications of the Annexed Territory, as required by Article XV. The Supplemental Declaration may create new land classifications, areas of the Association Property reserved for the exclusive use of Owners, or areas of individually owned Lots or Condominiums to be maintained by the Community Association. 16.3 APPROVAL OF ANNEXATIONS. For any annexation of property to the Covered Property, each Supplemental Declaration must be signed by the Record owner of the Annexed Territory and by an officer of the Community Association, certifying that the approval of the requisite percentage of Members has been obtained. -79- 2544-33253%CLP4281CCRS% 581730.13 v1M 16.4 DEANNEXATION AND AMENDMENT. 16.4.1 By Declarant. Declarant may unilaterally amend a Supplemental Declaration as it applies to a Phase or delete all or a portion of a Phase from coverage of this Master Declaration and the jurisdiction of the Community Association, so long as Declarant is the Owner of all of such Phase, and provided that (a) a Notice of Deletion or an amendment to the Supplemental Declaration, as applicable, is Recorded in the same manner as the applicable Supplemental Declaration was Recorded, (b) no Class A or Class B vote has been exercised with respect to any portion of such Phase, (c) Common Assessments have not yet commenced with respect to any portion of such Phase, (d) there has been no Close of Escrow for the sale of any Lot or Condominium in such Phase to a member of the home buying public, and (e) the Community Association has not made any expenditures or incurred any obligations with respect to any portion of such Phase. 16.4.2 By Neighborhood Builder. Neighborhood Builders may amend a Supplemental Declaration or delete all or any portion of a Phase from coverage of this Master Declaration and the jurisdiction of the Community Association, so long as such Neighborhood Builders or Declarant and such Neighborhood Builders together are the Owners of all of such Phase and provided further, that all requirements of items (a) through (e) set forth in Section 16.4.1 above have been satisfied, and Declarant has consented in writing to such amendment or deletion by executing the appropriate Notice of Deletion or amendment to the Supplemental Declaration, as applicable. 16.5 RIGHTS OF ANNEXED TERRITORY MEMBERS. Upon the Recording of a Supplemental Declaration containing the provisions as set forth in this Section, all provisions contained in this Master Declaration will apply to the Annexed Territory in the same manner as if it were originally covered by this Master Declaration, subject to the provisions of the applicable Supplemental Declaration. Thereafter, the rights, powers and responsibilities of the parties to this Master Declaration with respect to the Annexed Territory will be the same as with respect to the property originally covered by this Master Declaration, and the rights, powers and responsibilities of the Owners, lessees and Residents of Lots and Condominiums in the Annexed Territory, as well as within the property originally subject to this Master Declaration, will be the same as if the Annexed Territory were originally covered by this Master Declaration, subject to such restrictions as may be imposed in the Supplemental Declaration. Any Supplemental Declaration may contain such additions and modifications of the covenants, conditions, restrictions, reservation of easements and equitable servitudes contained in this Master Declaration as may be necessary to reflect the different character, if any, of the Annexed Territory, and as are consistent with the general plan of this Master Declaration. 16.6 AUTOMATIC ANNEXATION OF LIFOC PROPERTY. As of the date of recordation of this Master Declaration, certain areas designated on the map for Tract No. 16581 as "IRP -13S" and "IRP -13W' (collectively, the "LIFOC Property") are owned by the United States of America (the "U.S. Government'j, which is responsible for performing remediation work on the LIFOC Property. Immediately upon transfer of fee title interest in the LIFOC Property to Declarant, notwithstanding anything to the, contrary contained in this Master Declaration or this Article XVI, the LIFOC Property will be deemed automatically annexed to -80- 254433253\CL.P428VCCRS\ 581730. l3 2/1/06 the Covered Property. Declarant will record an instrument reflecting the fact that the LIFOC Property has been annexed to the Covered Property and will provide the City with a copy of such recorded instrument. ARTICLE XVII DECLARANT AND NEIGHBORHOOD BUILDER RIGHTS AND EXEMPTIONS Declarant reserves various rights in this Article to facilitate the smooth, orderly development of the Covered Property and to accommodate changes in the development plan that inevitably occur as a community the size of the Covered Property grows and maho-es. 17.1 INTEREST OF DECLARANT. Declarant intends to develop. the Covered Property into a master planned community. Declarant, in cooperation with the City, has created a comprehensive plan for the development of the Covered Property, which includes modern master -planning objectives which have been formulated for the common good in the community. Declarant, the Neighborhood Builders, or their successors or assigns intend, but are not obligated, to construct Homes and develop all of the Lots in the Covered Property. The completion of that work and sale, resale, rental and other disposal of Lots is essential to the establishment and welfare of the Covered Property as a quality master planned community. Each Owner acknowledges that Declarant has a substantial interest in assuring compliance with, and enforcement of, the covenants, conditions, restrictions and reservations contained in this Master Declaration and any Supplemental Declarations. 17.2 RIGHTS. The provisions of this Article XVII supersede and control over all other provisions of the Community Association Governing Documents as applied to Declarant and the Neighborhood Builders. Declarant and the Neighborhood Builders have the following rights. Nothing in the Community Association Governing Documents limits and no Owner or the Community Association will interfere with Declarant's or any Neighborhood Builder's exercise of these rights. 17.2.1 Subdivision. To subdivide and resubdivide any portion of the Covered Property - 17.2.2 Sales. To sell and rent any portion of the Covered Property directly or through agents and representatives. 17.2.3 Development. . To complete excavation, grading, construction of Improvements and other development activities on the Covered Property. 17.2.4 Construction. To alter construction plans and designs, to modify Improvements and to construct such additional Improvements as Declarant or a Neighborhood Builder deems advisable. 17.2.5 Grading. To carry on such grading work as may be approved by the Local Governmental Agency having jurisdiction. -81- 2544332531CLP42MCCRA 581730.13 7!1!06 17.2.6 Signs. To erect, construct and maintain on the Covered Property such structures, signs and displays reasonably necessary for the conduct of the business of completing the work and disposing of the Covered Property. 17.2.7 Creating Additional Easements. At any time prior to acquisition of title to a Lot or Condominium by a purchaser from Declarant or a Neighborhood Builder, to establish on that Lot, additional licenses, easements, reservations and rights-of-way to itself, to utility companies, or to others as reasonably necessary to the proper development and disposal of the Covered Property. 17.2.8 Sales and Leasing. To use the Association Property for access to the sales and leasing facilities of Declarant and Neighborhood Builders by prospective purchasers, sales agents, Declarant and Neighborhood Builders. 17.2.9 Models and Offices. To use any structures or vehicles owned or leased by Declarant or Neighborhood Builders in the Covered Property as model home complexes, or real estate sales or leasing offices. I7.2.10 Modifications. Subject to City approval, to unilaterally modify Declarant's or the Neighborhood Builders' development plan for the Covered Property, or any portion thereof, including designating and redesignating Phases of Development and constructing Homes of larger or smaller sizes, values or of different types. 17.2.11 Gated Communities. To create Neighborhoods in the Covered Property that are gated so that access to such Neighborhoods is limited. 17.2.12 Declarants Rights After Sale of all Lots and Condominiums in the Covered Property. For a period of ten (10) years following the last Close of Escrow in the Covered Property, in addition to Declarant's rights as an Owner and as a Member, Declarant shall have the following rights: (a) access to and the right to inspect the Community Association's books and financial records; (b) access to and the right to inspect the Community Association's maintenance records; (c) access to and the right to inspect the Association Property; (d) right to receive notice of, attend and speak at all regular and special meetings of the Board and meetings of the Members; and (e) right to receive copies of the minutes of Board meetings and meetings of Members, upon request and payment of the actual costs to copy and distribute such records and documents. 17.3 EXEMPTION. Declarant and the Neighborhood Builders are exempt from the restrictions contained in Article U. 17.4 ASSIGNMENT OF RIGHTS. All or any portion of the rights of Declarant or a Neighborhood Builder in the Community Association Governing Documents may be assigned by Declarant or such Neighborhood Builder (with Declarant's consent), as applicable, to any successor in interest to any portion of Declarant's or Neighborhood Builder's interest in any portion of the Covered Property (including to any Neighborhood Builder) by an express written assignment which specifies the rights of Declarant or such Neighborhood Builder so assigned. -82- 2544-3325ACLP42SYMRS1581730.13 2/1/06 17.5 EASEMENT RELOCATION. Association Property comprising easements over real property the fee title to which has not been made subject to the Master Declaration C'Interim Easement Area') may be relocated, modified or terminated by Declarant to accommodate the final plan of development for the future Phase in which the Interim Easement Area is located. Such relocation, modification or termination shall be set forth in the Recorded instrument annexing fee title to the Interim Easement Area to the Master Declaration. No such relocation, modification or termination shall prevent access to any Lot or Condominium. 17.6 DECLARAN'T'S REPRESENTATIVE. The Community Association shall provide Declarant with all notices and other documents to which a Beneficiary is entitled pursuant to this Master Declaration, provided that Declarant shall be provided such notices and other documents without making written request therefor. Commencing on the date on which Declarant no longer has an elected or appointed representative on the Board, and continuing until the date on which Declarant and the Neighborhood Builders no longer own a Lot or Condominium in the Covered Property, the Community Association shall provide Declarant with written notice of all meetings of the Board as if Declarant were an Owner and Declarant shall be entitled to have a representative present at all such Board meetings a Declarant's Representative'l. The Declarants Representative shall be present in an advisory capacity only and shall not be a Board member or have any right to vote on matters coming before the Board. ARTICLE XVIII CITY REQUIRED PROVISION This Article is included in this Master Declaration to satisfy a requirement of the City. Notwithstanding any provision in this Master Declaration to the contrary, this Article and the following section of this Master Declaration shall be enforceable by the City. 18.1 ISSUANCE OF RESIDENTIAL BUILDING PERMITS WITHIN LIFOC PROPERTY. Building permits for residential structures on the LIFOC Property will not be issued until the City of Tustin receives written confirmation from either the Declarant, Owner or Neighborhood Builder, that the LIFOC Property has been determined by the California Department of Toxic Substances Control to be suitable for residential use. In addition, all residential structures on the LIFOC Property will be constructed with one of the following engineering controls: (1) a sub -slab venting system; or (2) a LIQUID BOOT® Gas Vapor Barrier System, (3) or an alternative control that is determined by either the City of Tustin or the California Department of Toxic Substances. Control to provide equivalent protection. [Signatures on Following Page] -83- 254433253\(x.P428 =SX 581730.13 2/1/06 [SIGNATURE PAGE TO MASTER DECLARATION OF COVENANTS, CONDITIONS, RESTRICTIONS AND RESERVATION OF EASEMENTS FOR COLUMBUS SQUARE) This Master Declaration is dated for identification purposes F&MaAA �, 2006. MOFFETT MEADOWS PARTNERS, LLC, a Delaware limited liability company By: Marble Mountain Partners, LLC, a Delaware limited liability company Its: Sole Member By: Tustin Villas Partners, LLC, a Delaware limited liability company Its: Administrative Member By: Lennar Homes of California, Inc., a It B. N Ti [Signatures Continued on Following Page] -84- 2544-33253%CLP4281CCRM 581730.13 211/06 [SIGNATURE PAGE TO MASTXR DECLARATION OF . COVENANTS, CONDITIONS, RESTRICTIONS AND RESERVATION OF EASEMENTS FOR COLUMBUS SQUAREI The following parties, as Owners or Neighborhood Builders of portions of the Covered Property, hereby consent to the terms and conditions set forth in the Master Declaration. TUSTIN VILLAS PARTNERS, LLC, a Delaware limited liability company By: Lamm Homes of California, Inc.,, a California corporation, Managi By: Name: Title: '•Owner" ORA ASTORIA LLC, a California limited liability company By. ORA Residential Investments I, L.P., a California limited partnership, Its: Sole Member By: ORA California II, LLC, a Delaware limited liability company, Its: Manager By. Resmark Equity Partners, LLC, a Delaware limited liability company, Its: Manager By riz-OA&:i Name: R. Pianko Title: Executive Vice President & Chief Financial Officer "Owner" [Signatures Con dnued on Following Page] -85- 2544-33253%W42$NCCRS% $61730.13 9!11% STATE OF CALIFORNIA1-ea Ar�qeflez ss. ) COUNTY OF OFadO) On r 2006, bre me, ! 1-O //� personally appeared Q , F'i /Lo ,personally lrnown to me to be the person whose'name is subscribed to the within instrument and acknowledged to me that (he) (00l executed the same in (his) Q>te1'j authorized capacity, and that by (his) (oaf) signature on the instrument the person, or the entity upon behalf of which the person acted, executed the instrument. WITNESS my hand and official seal. vEor►o.�aMs comniNon • 14"M VW1MVCAnMEVMJM28, [SEA]LA STATE OF CALIFORNIA ) ) ss. COUNTY OF ORANGE ) � 4m2a Notary Public in and for said State personally appeared 1 persoMlly known to me (opTreve*to uWan the basoa of ce) o be the person whose name is subscribed to the within instrument and acknowledged to me that (he) (sK executed the same in (his) (h•t'f authorized capacity, and that by (his) (he* signature on the instrument the person, or the entity upon behalf of which the person acted, executed the instrument. WITNESS my hand and official seal. [SEAL] w+Kw uxMRUDEIRW WCMM*d0n 014307" Nafty "ft - Conomb C MY �JJW 18, 2a -87- and for said State 2544-332MLP42MOCRA 581730.13 ?11106 [SIGNATURE PAGE TO MASTER DECLARATION OF COVENANTS, CONDITIONS, RESTRICTIONS AND RESERVATION OF EASEMENTS FOR COLUMBUS SQUARE] WILLIAM LYON HOMES, INC., a California corporation By - Name y:Name• Title: Vim osnifia .a T;"i �11T Title:t: - -t "Owner" MW HOUSING PARTNERS III, L.P., a California limited partnership By: MW Housing Management III, LLC, a California limited liability company Its General Partner By: WRf CP Investments III, LLC, a Washington limited liability company Its Co -Manager By: Weyerhaeuser Realty Investors, Inc. a Washington corporation, Its Manager By: Name: Title By: Name: Title "Owner" -86- 2544-33253\CLP428\CCRtS\561730.13 2/1106 STATE OF CALIFORNIA ) ss. COUNTY OF ORANGE ) On 2006, before me, l,&M bAA k &&M� , WW&UCI personally appeared persdnaiiy known to rn meevidence) to 6d the person whose name is subscribed to the within instrument and acknowledged to me that (he) (ske) executed the same in (his) (he6 authorized capacity, and that by (his) (Wsignature on the instrument the person, or the entity upon behalf of which the person acted, executed the instrument. WITNESS my hand and official seal. L 4M LEM lfAlOE I AMAERR A Cam don s 1430791 ( otary Publ n and for said State Nobly Nlbo - Ccwoudo Ownp Cau * [SEAL] %FMVCam. Bq*os Jul 10.2007 STATE OF CALIFORNIA } , ) ss. COUNTY OF ORANGE ) On f It VO 2006, bri'ore me r personally appeared 0 TIADMOc, (> i personally known to me (eF-gvo-►ad #e— we an rhe haaic of-Wsfactary eyidewe) to be the person whose name is subscribed to the within instrument and acknowledged to me that (he) l4" executed the same in (his) Owr) authorized capacity, and that by (his) @w*) -signature on the instrument the person, or the entity upon behalf of which the person acted, executed the instrument. WITNESS my hand and official seal. E.OFFICIAL SER SUSANUSANI. MENARD j NOTARY PUBLIC -C/WFOtN COMMISSION # 144796E ORANGE COUNTY My Commission Exp. WoW A, 4007 j [SEAL] 4:�A-o a-& 6 kuaa Notary Public in and for said State -88- 2544-33253\CLP4281CCRS1581730.13 2/1/06 STATE OF CALIFORNIA COUNTY OF ORANGE } ss. On VYVQ c� 2006, before m , SU'Sert'j personally appeared ew R"DX115f personally known to me (or p ed to me on the basis of satisfactory evidence) to be the person whose name is subscribed to the within instrument and acknowledged to me that (he) (she) executed the same in (his) (her) authorized capacity, and that by (his) (her) signature on the instrument the person, or the entity upon behalf of which the person acted, executed the instrument. WITNESS my hand and official seal. NOTARY COMMISSIONCOUNTY *my= [SEAL] STATE OF CALIFORNIA ) ) ss. COUNTY OF ORANGE ) E ft"off Notary Public in and for said State On , 2006, before me, personally appeared 'personally known to me (or proved to me on the basis of satisfactory evidence) to be the person whose name is subscribed to the within instrument and acknowledged to me that (he) (she) executed the same in (his) (her) authorized capacity, and that by (his) (her) signature on the instrument the person, or the entity upon behalf of which the person acted, executed the instrument. WITNESS my hand and official seal. [SEAL] -89- Notary Public in and for said State 2544-33253%W42MCM 591730.13 2/1106 [SIGNATURE PAGE TO MASTER DECLARATION OF COVENANTS, CONDITIONS, RESTRICTIONS AND RESERVATION OF EASEMENTS FOR COLUMBUS SQUARE] • WILLIAM LYON HOMES, INC., a California corporation By: Name: Title: By: Name: Title: "Owner" MW HOUSING PARTNERS III, L.P., a Califbmia limited partnership By: MW Housing Management III, LLC, a California limited liability company Its General Partner By: WRI CP Investments III, LLC, a Washington limited liability company Its Co -Manager By: Weyerhaeuser Realty Investors, Inc. a Washington corporation, Its Manager By: Name: -t1�y Pr' Title Se , By: ' � Name- S Title "Owner" -86- 2544-33253\CLP428\CCRS\ 59 1730.13 2/1/06 rA S Wd5itiN &TON STATE OF GAHF9RNf2k- ) KI n1 G- ) ss. COUNTY OF 6GRz4.WQE ) On Z S 2006, before me, (A 0 A M. A 04*fW5 personally appeared MVI D t5F_CWL4 0ETE7Z-- , personally known to me (or proved to me on the basis of satisfactory evidence) to be the person whose name is subscribed to the within instrument and acknowledged to me that (he) (she) executed the same in (his) (her) authorized capacity, and that by (his) (her) signature on the instrument the person, or the entity upon behalf of which the person acted, executed the instrument. WITNESS my hand and official seal. [SEAL] LYNN M. RICHARDS STATE OF WASHING TON NOTARY -- • - PUBLIC MY COMMISSM EXPVMS 1044.06 STATE OF tLAAAF^RM e ) ss. COUNTY OF ORP& 8 K' A� /. ORM i r .� On a I -'�' , 2006, before me, tm p o M . , personally appeared &EDL4IN J. IPµe S , personally known to me (or proved to me on the basis of satisfactory evidence) to be the person whose name is subscribed to the within instrument and acknowledged to me that (he) (she) executed the same in (his) (her) authorized capacity, and that by (his) (her) signature on the instrument the person, or the entity upon behalf of which the person acted, executed the instrument. WITNESS my hand and official seal. [SEAL] LYNN M. RICHARDS STATE OF WASHINGTON NOTARY — • — PUBLIC MY COMMISSION EXPIRES 104" , (oA Notary Pu lic in and fo said State -87- 2544-332531CLP428%CCRS1581730.13 211/06 STATE OF CALIFORNIA ) ) ss. COUNTY OF ORANGE ) On , 2006, before me, , personally appeared , personally known to me (or proved to me on the basis of satisfactory evidence) to be the person whose name is subscribed to the within instrument and acknowledged to me that (he) (she) executed the same in (his) (her) authorized capacity, and that by (his) (her) signature on the instrument the person, or the entity upon behalf of which the person acted, executed the instrument. WITNESS my hand and official seal. Notary Public in and for said State [SEAL] STATE OF CALIFORNIA ) ) ss. COUNTY OF ORANGE ) On , 2006, before me, personally appeared , personally known to me (or proved to me on the basis of satisfactory evidence) to be the person whose name is subscribed to the within instrument and acknowledged to me that (he) (she) executed the same in (his) (her) authorized capacity, and that by (his) (her) signature on the instrument the person, or the entity upon behalf of which the person acted, executed the instrument [SEAL] i WITNESS my hand and official'seal. -88- Notary Public in and for said State 2541-332S31CLP428\CCRS1591730.13 2/1106 STATE OF CALIFORNIA ) ) ss. COUNTY OF ORANGE ) On , 2006, before me, personally appeared 'personally known to me (or proved to me on the basis of satisfactory evidence) to be the person whose name is subscribed to the within instrument and acknowledged to me that (he) (she) executed the same in (his) (her) authorized capacity, and that by (his) (her) signature on the instrument the person, or the entity upon behalf of which the person acted, executed the instrument. WITNESS my hand and official seal. Notary Public in and for said State [SEAL] STATE OF CALIFORNIA ) ) ss. COUNTY OF ORANGE ) On , 2006, before me, personally appeared , personally known to me (or proved to me on the basis of satisfactory evidence) to be the person whose name is subscribed to the within instrument and acknowledged to me that (he) (she) executed the same in (his) (her) authorized capacity, and that by (his) (her) signature on the instrument the person, or the entity upon behalf of which the person acted, executed the instrument. WITNESS my hand and official seal. [SEAL] Notary Public in and for said State -89- 2544-33253%CLP428%CCRs1581730.13 VIM STATE OF CALIFORNIA ) ) ss. COUNTY OF ORANGE ) On , 2006, before me, personally appeared , personally known to me (or proved to me on the basis of satisfactory evidence) to be the person whose name is subscribed to the within instrument and acknowledged to me that (he) (she) executed the same in (his) (her) authorized capacity, and that by (his) (her) signature on the instrument the person, or the entity upon behalf of which the person acted, executed the instrument. WITNESS my hand and official seal. [SEAL) Notary Public in and for said State -90- 2544-33253VCLP428WMM 581730.13 211/06 SUBORDINATION The undersigned, as Beneficiary of the beneficial interest in and under that certain Deed of Trust dated July 29, 2005, and recorded on July 29, 2005, as Instrument No. 2005000589860, in the Official Records of Orange County, California (the "Deed of Trust), ), which Deed of Trust is by and between Tustin Villas Partners, LLC, a Delaware limited liability company, as Trustor, and North American Title Company, a California corporation, as Trustee, and Moffett Meadows Partners, a Delaware limited liability company, as Beneficiary, expressly subordinates said Deed of Trust and its beneficial interest thereunder to the foregoing Master Declaration of Covenants, Conditions and Restrictions and Reservation of Easements for Columbus Square, as amended or restated ("Master Declaration"), to any Supplemental Declaration, as amended or restated, and to all easements to be conveyed to the Community Association in accordance with the Master Declaration and any Supplemental Declaration. By executing this Subordination, the undersigned agrees that should the undersigned acquire title to all or any. portion of the Properties by foreclosure (whether judicial or nonjudicial), deed -in -lieu of foreclosure or any other remedy in or relating to the Deed of Trust, the undersigned will acquire title subject to the provisions of the Master Declaration and any applicable Supplemental Declaration, which shall remain in full force and effect. Dated: 2006 MOFFETT MEADOWS PARTNERS, LLC, a Delaware limited liability company By: Marble Mountain Partners, LLC, a Delaware limited liability company Its: Sole Member By: Tustin Villas Partners, LLC, a Delaware limited liability company Its: Administrative Member By: Lennar Homes of California, Inc., a uaniom orporauon Its: Mandaiuk Member By: Name: Title: [Notarial Acknowledgment on Following Page] -9I- 2544.332531CLP4281CCRS1581730.13 2/1/06 9 STATE OF CALIFORNIA ) ) ss. COUNTY OF ORANGE ) On 0%, before me personally appeared pers6lWly known to me ( _ me donee) td be the person whose name is subscribed to the within instrument and acknowledged to me that (he) (she) executed the same in (his) (h< authorized capacity, and that by (his) @to* signature on the instrument the person, or the entity upon behalf of which the person acted, executed the instrumeaL WITNESS my hand and official seal. i Notary Public doaid State 91 pat C=* [SEAL] my 6"mj 118, SIAI 2544-332DXMP4281CCRiS% 581730.13 211106 SUBORDINATION The undersigned, as Beneficiary of the beneficial interest in and under that certain Deed of Trust dated July 29, 2005, and recorded on July 29, 2005, as Instrument No. 2005000590847, in the Official Records of Orange County, California (the "Deed of Tlrust'j, which Deed of Trust is by and between ORA Astoria LLC, a California limited liability company, as Trustor, and North American Title. Company, a California corporation, as Trustee, and Moffett Meadows Partners, LLC, a Delaware limited liability company, as Beneficiary, expressly subordinates said Deed of Trust and its beneficial interest thereunder to the foregoing Master Declaration of Covenants, Conditions and Restrictions and Reservation of Easements for Columbus Square, as amended or restated ("Master Declaration', to any Supplemental Declaration, as amended or restated, and to all easements to be conveyed to the Community Association in accordance with the Master Declaration and any Supplemental Declaration. By executing this Subordination, the undersigned agrees that should the undersigned acquire title to all or any portion of the Properties by foreclosure (whether judicial or nonjudicial), deed -in -lieu of foreclosure or any other remedy in or relating to the Deed of Trust, the undersigned will acquire title subject.to the provisions of the Master Declaration and any applicable Supplemental Declaration, which shall remain in full force and effect. Dated: &JM2LaJQA �, 2006 MOFFETT MEADOWS PARTNERS, LLC, a Delaware limited liability company By: Marble Mountain Partners, LLC, a Delaware limited liability company Its: Sole Member By: Tustin Villas Partners, LLC, a Delaware limited liability company Its: Administrative Member By: Lennar Homes of California, Inc., a It B N T. [Notarial Acknowledgment on Following Page] -93- 254433253\CLP4281CCRS1581730.13 211106 I STATE OF CALIFORNIA ) ) ss. COUNTY OF ORANGE ) On 2006, b fore me, personally appeared -----ally known to 'me (or -prered-to m ce) to the person whose name is subscribed to the within instrument and acknowledged to me that (he) (Ave) executed the same in (his) OtI6�) authorized capacity, and that by (his) (h®r signature on the instrument the person, or the entity upon behalf of which the person acted, executed the instrument. WITNESS my hand and official seal. GonMnldo 1014WM MMV mac - CAS% Ufa 0 -4p Ca.* [SEAL)MYCMM1�.E - M15,20 PMWMq -94- Publics and for said State 2544-33253%CLP429%CCRM 531730.13 2/1M SUBORDINATION The undersigned, as Beneficiary of the beneficial interest in and under that certain Deed of Trust dated July 29, 2005, and recorded on July 29, 2005, as Instrument No. 2005000591025, in the Official Records of Orange County, California (the "Deed of Trust"), which Deed of Trust is by and between William Lyon Homes, Inc., a California corporation, as Trustor, and North American Title Company, a California corporation, as Trustee, and Moffett Meadows Partners, LLC, a Delaware limited liability company, as Beneficiary, expressly subordinates. said Deed of Trust and its beneficial interest thereunder to the foregoing Master Declaration of Covenants, Conditions and Restrictions and Reservation of Easements for Columbus Square, as amended or restated ("Master Declaration"), to any Supplemental Declaration, as amended or restated, and to all easements to be conveyed to the Community Association in accordance with the Master Declaration and any Supplemental Declaration. By executing this Subordination, the undersigned agrees that should the undersigned acquire title to all or any portion of the Properties by foreclosure (whether judicial or nonjudicial), deed -in -lieu of foreclosure or any other remedy in or relating to the Deed of Trust, the undersigned will acquire title subject to the provisions of the Master Declaration and any applicable Supplemental Declaration, which shall remain in full force and effect. Dated: 1, 2006 MOFFETT MEADOWS PARTNERS, LLC, a Delaware limited liability company By: Marble Mountain Partners, LLC, a Delaware limited liability company Its: Sole Member By: Tustin Villas Partners, LLC, a Delaware limited liability company Its: Administrative Member By: Lauuw Homes of California, Inc., a Ca Its: By: Nan Title [Notarial Acknowledgment on Following Page] -95- 2544-332M%CLR42rZC= 581730.13 211/06 i I STATE OF CALIFORNIA ) ) ss. COUNTY OF ORANGE ) On , 200 , before me, personally appearedpe nally known to m vd to me e1 ce) —tbpbe the person whose name is subscribed to the within instrument and acknowledged to me that (he) (j executed the same in (his) pief) authorized capacity, and that by (his) (ber) signature on the instrument the person, or the entity upon behalf of which the person acted, executed the instrument. WITNESS my hand and official seal. -96- 0 14 2544-33253XW428UMM 5!1730.13 2/1/06 SUBORDINATION The undersigned, as Beneficiary of the beneficial interest in and under that certain Deed of Trust dated July 29, 2005, and recorded on July 29, 2005, as Instrument No. 2005000591382, in the Official Records of Orange County, California (the "Deed of nust'7, which Deed of Trust is by and between MW Housing Partners III, L.P., a California limited partnership, as Trustor, and North American Title Company, a California corporation, as Trustee, and Moffett Meadows Partners, LLC, a Delaware limited liability company, as Beneficiary, expressly subordinates said Deed of Trust and its beneficial interest thereunder to the foregoing Master Declaration of Covenants, Conditions and Restrictions and Reservation of Easements for Columbus Square, as amended or restated ("Master Declaration 'I, to any Supplemental Declaration, as amended or restated, and to all easements to be conveyed to the Community Association in accordance with the Master Declaration and any Supplemental Declaration. By executing this Subordination, the undersigned agrees that should the undersigned acquire title to all or any portion of the Properties by foreclosure (whether judicial or nonjudicial), deed -in -lieu of foreclosure or any other remedy in or relating to the Deed of Trust, the undersigned will acquire title subject to the provisions of the Master Declaration and any applicable Supplemental Declaration, which shall remain in full force and effect. Dated: 7— 2006 MOFFETT MEADOWS PARTNERS, LLC, a Delaware limited liability company By: Marble Mountain Partners, LLC, a Delaware limited liability company Its: Sole Member By: Tustin Villas Partners, LLC, a Delaware limited liability company Its: Administrative Member By: Lennar Homes of California, Inc., a It [Notarial Acknowledgment on Following Page] -97- 2544-3325ACL.P42MCM 581730.13 2/1/06 STATE OF CALIFORNIA ss. COUNTY OF ORANGE On 200 before me, j 0_11 M personally appeared pens6hal1v known to me (a to the person whose name is subscribed to the within instrument and acknowledged to me that (he) (sid' executed the same in (his) (be>t'j authorized capacity, and that by (his) (het) signature on the instrument the person, or the entity upon behalf of which the person acted, executed the instrument WITNESS my hand and official seal. tit►81 M cony+ m 01430791 0KqPC0U* [SEAL] �h COML OON M i a, zotn -98- 254433253%CLP428%CCRR.41531730.13 2/1/06 EXHIBIT "CP" DESCRIPTION OF COVERED PROPERTY All that real property located in the City of Tustin, County of Orange, State of California, more particularly described as follows: All of Tract No. 16581, as shown on a Subdivision Map recorded in Book8 7 7, pages 3 3 to 5 0 ,inclusive, of Miscellaneous Maps, in the Office of the Orange County Recorder, excepting therefrom those certain areas designated on the Subdivision Map for Tract No. 16581 as "IRP -13S" and "IRP -13W." 2544-33253%CLP428UXIM S81730.13 211/06 2544-3325AW42 ACCM 581730.13 2/1/06 EXHIBIT "AP" ASSOCIATION PROPERTY TO BE CONVEYED IN THE COVERED PROPERTY Association Property owned and maintained by the Community Association: (a) Private Street Lots A to M, P to U, X, Y, CA to CF, DA to DJ, EA to EB, FA to FD of Tract No. 16581, including parkway maintenance as shown on Exhibit "PM" attached to this Exhibit "AP" and storm drain maintenance as shown on Exhibit "SD" attached to this Exhibit "AP" (b) Landscaped and Recreation Area (1) Lots 263, 264 and 293, and 331 of Tract No. 16581 (Open Space/Park Areas shown on Exhibit "OS" available for public use). (2) Lot 365 of Tract No. 16581 (Community clubhouse and amenities are private for use by members and guests — not open to public use as shown on Exhibit "OS'). (c) Lots AAA to AAJ, BAB, BAC, BAD, BAE, and BAF Tract No. 16581, Landscaped areas for Owner use (including Community Walls as shown on i Exhibit "WM-). (d) Lots BAA, BBA to BBZ, CCA to CCO, DAA, DEA, DDA to DDZ of Tract No. 16581, Landscaped areas adjacent to streets, (including Community Walls as shown on Exhibit "WM'J. 2544-3325AW42 ACCM 581730.13 2/1/06 EXH[B7T "PM!! PRIVATE PARKWAY MAINTENANCE AREAS IN THE COVERED PROPERTY 2544-33253\024281C:CItS1581730.13 2/1106 GOVERNMENT CODE [27361-7] I certify under the penalty of perjury that the notary acknowledgement on the document to which this statement is attached reads as follows: Date commission expires: ( Commission #: \ - County where bond is filed: Manufacture/Vendor #: Place of execution: Orange Date: 3 - - •ot Signature: North American Title Company Print Name: Melissa Flores l GOVERNMENT CODE [27361-7] I certify under the penalty of perjury that the notary acknowledgement on the document to which this statement is attached reads as follows: Name of notary: Date commission expires: u '6 . Commission #: County where bond is filed: ManufactureNendor #: X\N;L Place of execution: Orange Date: S.-\ Signature; North American Title Company Print Name: Melissa Flores 5 -\ul 1003 V MATCHLRM SEE BMW s t M7 lw, 0 g C m D CO Z 13" 336 SNnHoLvn t g in oAvepaer erRtr DAVENPOW 61M a o a=o� II mOR YW1Y s ODUiiN WAY N H I ob D I > z14 �� 8 n erieeien WAY D = z 19I z- Z� a"o of i n r iUfICN WAY m co c I m co ca :2 i I D to N I I � CD 4A CAMBAMWSMWI N >3p.L?�Nl 1S3M N I D Mm D= 2m Z Z n• m D m D avow wAow AVM�wra•� 0 r AVM 3=Valn MAIN 0 AVM WMVI ` J AV /CIU1t A p cn AVM MUM � v w iD 0 AM learn AVM 3aP60Y1a1N V ai N w AVM UNUM � N N � AVM � Q Q V 91 s MMS Me 3N(*=" D M �m D= mq D-6 n� D m J 6 dl Liam ILAWSM a - - xmm MUM W r- AVIA MOM U I f n mmQ 0 m m AVM 7lVi/MI —u r T� y _. D s th AVM VTOWAMr SCS ta ! 1 AVM AYiil m > I I <I DS Z?� rt�i N � N s• N ( I � AVM Nom"Wo I r m �! D n m v N N I I D W °a 1 z _ AVM #)Op1971rJ Q V I m N Pa Z M=9 I i A-MaLaaM AWN a �'��� I AYMINOIM:�IM Zi • N � A N i 7 � ' �� o EXEaBTT "SD" STORM DRAIN MAINTENANCE AREAS IN THE COVERED PROPERTY 2544.33253UMP4211CM1511730.13 211/06 1 14) Imt tl $ $ $ 4 is, hL&Ll A Alt Y tl \ ffi g► \ i 6 ; ie 's m Irk ZU) a O It AL lO x r \ Js is c b J T Z C 0 (n n i asb! :aa sbaba = -40 c°n Ca a D 00D �'� g e v(l g i : G) Z m �'�m a b Im(n o 0 m i i i a i s Z a m i z z iilii l ml n m- m s — (5 z 36 g l m D — O � x 1ST m MAINTENANCE AREAS IN THE COVERED PROPERTY 1. Perimeter landscaping on public street rights of way as shown on Exhibit "MA" attached hereto or to a Supplemental Declaration. 2. Real property owned in fee by others but maintained by the Community Association (to be described in a Supplemental Declaration). { i i 2544-33253T-U428%CCRS1581730.13 2/1/06 $Rudma Foes W V c i <�A 4 I1N V �� Z �+8c I \ dO df i ro o j IL MATCFU NG SM $ EU Z m v_ z c m 7 m m m >X D� r D_D Z m D Z 0 m A 2LL ml m � g $Rudma Foes W V c i <�A 4 I1N V �� Z �+8c I \ dO df i ro o j IL MATCFU NG SM $ EU Z m v_ z c m 7 m m m >X D� r D_D Z m D Z 0 m ttpp i 13" aaS 3 Qia vvi • � (h � N � � z I)AVJOpam ear DAVE POW 91RW D z � (7 1ICIM" C! WIRY 1 "�� OOU�A9 WAY 11+ m m l DX S IGB7Ep WAY i 1 Z FRv VV D Z ZA Jam► c3 N D -t D ' WTTON WAY Z � � Z Z ca o � n CAMBFIDO � � m w H0103NNOO iS3M T 4w 0 w% ON � N fd CT V m m •. N co A N C! N ON � N fd CT V m m 0,vu Rojo" a AW IK1101p31� < I � y AVM 31MWA 1 I — m I AYM I'TI W W RI � o gAVM UMVI m --� AVM Nauw � co AVM AIMM vC. AVM HIM m D N D I ° C7 AVM 30NOUVOW u N CO D � ;� N H z pQ AVM 1NVyp CA CA 0 3HYIlps �'M1100 Y � 9 IS" 338 3N *=VVI a A�Wsco JWiaAVo C* wk wam o AVM NOMV0 �� f co v V � I I AVM xv w" --u -1 AVM 1R mvm et I I 1 AVM AWM I i� I II Z m vM wnnmm AVM Nonm'm f _ r I D Z 0 S • i� � N y� I 8 I WALL MAINTENANCE IN THE COVERED PROPERTY 2544-33253%W428%=S%591730.13 2/U06 9 s a m \\� a C01IIM61C11 S71�T �O Lid � E Fi. a 11 � m ZI Z6 9 s a \\� a C01IIM61C11 S71�T � :I N fAI v IA.— Cb \ V ss # 01 � O FI MATCHL14E SEE SHEEC2 0 z m 0 z r r D_ Z Dm X Z 2 ma) O -H <�' OK (_ D Cl) CO 0 i Z Z imm 338 3A7MVH W N m oAv�+Ponr srneer y 10 OONfiAf WAY l34i�3NN N ut o o m � • �n lz -0 aro Zmp Q v m I MONIR06E WAY m m 16. m afam Ar w H A W N V � Z imm 338 3A7MVH W N m oAv�+Ponr srneer y 10 OONfiAf WAY l34i�3NN N ut ro I(a 1 4► 1 c+ I th I v 0 _z D r r D Z D_m ZZ m� 0--1 co 0� c Z cn0 n Z 1 I� o �� ►�� I� I � I I C AVM 3LLiAMlY1 ;Z C4 Qm AVM I _ y v r o I AVM LVUVI 17 zm � AVM NOYAY D —gym 1 >X AVM A3MgYl = Z S co _ m co v fw w �� n �T O r D z AVM NB= nC z ni Z i I AVM BONW69ow w I A 0OCD -9 N O ig n Ao a AVD M ro O > Z ,,ioo Z p y� AVM7 f s .tee �e arrr�purw 1 A 1 cn 6 N� LEWIS iuoarenw CA ooW CA tO (AI AVM lB07V0 a m P 1:2 1 AYMAMtAI gAAl 9 A N AVM wolmokwo z a � n D Z 0 0 Z o i N m� N V � H AVM �]dWWYJ . N O m w N � AYM moro inn N ori pp O bOlJ3NN Jw EXHIBIT "OS" OPEN SPACE/PARK AREAS IN THE COVERED PROPERTY 2544-33253WU4281CCRS1581730.13 1/1106 a:tt 2 a a a I ttY Y n Y Y Y n Y I Y Y m Y v_ Z m n Y �I s z� a I ° z = m T m := z { D — n m � J— : DT 1 a D� m o'^ Vf M v_ {;m {D ml EXMIT "PC" PARIUNG AND CIRCULATION AREAS IN THE COVERED PROPERTY 2544-33253NW428\G' M 581730.13 2/1106 t o a t i i v i i t} It IL a a t A. ; s a a s It a � � e g +► ''� �* a! 9 3 9 � a 8 S t �'y �, '` s • '� a aaaa m t' a a m %1 a Z T i0 Or " * * * * * O DC *� ` n n9 -q co* a n 3 Z C t a a C O (n * . . D 0) �`� tfilllift -i -� r a r1 00 D Y . R Z i o D X t t t a a i z D a � it8t m Z a y a M a ON i m i Z M ! ! 1 + � 1 9 LS v� EXHIBIT "PC -1" PARKING lXffrATIONS IN THE COVERED PROPERTY HOUSING TYPE NUMBER OF GARAGES PER HOME Detached Single -Family 2 or more Bedroom plans have a 2 car garage 4 or more Bedroom plans have 2 or 3 car garage Condominium 1 Bedroom plans have a 1 car garage 2 or more Bedroom plans have a 2 car garage All housing types are required to park the number of cars in each garage for which the garage was designed to accommodate. Use of garage for storage of personal property shall not interfere with the ability to park the required number of cars to the extent owner owns the total number of cars for which the garage was designed. 2544-33253%W4281CCI A 531730.13 211/06 1 ENMIT "TC" APPROVED CURBSIDE TRASH PICK-UP AREAS IN THE COVERED PROPERTY 2544-33253\CLP4281CM 581730.13 2/1/06 m/ t\\\ R % moor IA All C \, 3 �\ s _ 0:2m \ \ s = C \ - \ 1 \J Nu q � r COME. ' E7 R7 J � 00000oQ�i�_: �DDODOD nn ©n ©coo Q on : ©© — ��. � u ��pp•,o op �o,, OREM �� 0 .;D v p\� • 4� ro fl0 - sopa goo , 000_oo _7.- • Ow �.� deft r r E7��E7 RECORDING REQUESTED BY: NORTH AMERICAN TITLE COMPANY WHEN RECORDED, MAIL TO: MOFFETT MEADOWS PARTNERS, LLC c/o Lennar Homes of California; Inc. Attn: T. Wilson 25 Enterprise, Suite 300 Aliso Viejo, CA 92656 This Document was electronically recorded by North American Recorded in Official Records, Orange County Tom Daly, Clerk -Recorder 11111 111 11111MW 0l1l 45.00 2006000517853 04:14pm 08/02/06 200 42 A1714 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 39.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 (Space Above for Recorder's Use) FIRST AMENDMENT TO MASTER DECLARATION OF COVENANTS, CONDITIONS, RESTRICTIONS AND RESERVATION OF EASEMENTS FOR COLUMBUS SQUARE 2544-3325MME4M 641270.4 7/15/06 1, FIRST AMENDMENT TO MASTER DECLARATION OF COVENANTS, CONDITIONS, RESTRICTIONS AND RESERVATION OF EASEMENTS FOR COLUMBUS SQUARE THIS - FIRST AMENDMENT TO MASTER DECLARATION OF COVENANTS, CONDITIONS, RESTRICTIONS AND RESERVATION OF EASEMENTS FOR COLUMBUS SQUARE ("First Amendment'l is made by MOFFETT MEADOWS PARTNERS, LLC, a Delaware limited liability company ("Declarant'). RECITALS: A. That certain Master Declaration of Covenants, Conditions, Restrictions and Reservation of Easements for Columbus Square ("Master Declaration'l was previously recorded on March 7, 2006, as Instrument No. 2006-000149773, in the Official Records of Orange County, California. B. The Master Declaration has been recorded against real property in the City of Tustin, County of Orange, State of California, described as follows ("Covered Property'): All of Tract No. 16581, as shown on a Subdivision Map recorded in Book 877, Pages 33 to 50, inclusive, of Miscellaneous Maps, in the Office of the Orange County Recorder, excepting therefrom those certain areas designated on the Subdivision Map for Tract No. 16581 as "IRP -13S" and "IRP -13W." C. Section 14.3 of the Master Declaration provides that for so long as Declarant owns any portion of the Covered Property, Declarant may unilaterally, with the consent of the City, amend the Master Declaration by Recording a written instrument signed by Declarant in order to correct any typographical errors and to conform the Declaration to applicable law. As of the date hereof, Declarant owns all or portion of the Covered Property; therefore, Declarant has the right to unilaterally amend the Master Declaration as set forth herein. D. Pursuant to Section 14.3 of the Master Declaration, Declarant desires to amend the Master Declaration to correct typographical errors in Sections 1.59, 3.2, 14.2.1 and 16.6, and to revise Sections 4.3.3, 5.4.3 and 13.2 to conform to current applicable statutory law. NOW, THEREFORE, Declarant hereby declares that the Master Declaration is amended as follows: 1. Definition of "Phase of Development" Section 1.59 of the Master Declaration is deleted in its entirety and replaced with the following: 2544-33253\AME M 641270.4 7=6 "1.59 PHASE OF DEVELOPMENT. Phase of Development or Phase means all or any portion of the Covered Property for which a Public Report has been issued, unless otherwise provided in a Supplemental Declaration covering a portion of the Covered Property. A Phase may consist of only Association Property with no Lots or Condominiums contained therein." 2. Environmental Condition. The fust sentence of Section 3.2 of the Master Declaration is deleted in its entirety and replaced with the following to include a reference to Exhibit "LIFOC" attached to the Master Declaration: "3.2 ENVIRONMENTAL CONDITION. Certain areas designated on the map for Tract No. 16581 as "IRP -13S" and "IRP -13W" (collectively, the "LIFOC Property'!, as approximately depicted on Exhibit "LIFOC" attached hereto, are owned by the United States of America ("U.S. Government'l and will ultimately be annexed into the Covered Property pursuant to Section 16.6." 3. Interpretation. The seventh sentence of Section 14.2.1 of the Master Declaration is deleted in its entirety and replaced with the following to incorporate Exhibit "LIFOC": "Exhibits "Q," "App" VM," "SD," "MA," "WX,» "OSS" "PC," ,PC J," "TC" and "LIFOC" are incorporated in this Master Declaration by this reference." 4. Automatic Annexation of LIFOC Property. The first sentence of Section 16.6 of the Master Declaration is deleted in its entirety and replaced with the following to include a reference Exhibit "LIFOC": "As of the date of recordation of this Master Declaration, certain areas designated on the map for Tract No. 16581 as "IRP -13 S" and "IRP -13W" (collectively, the "LLl*OC Property', as approximately depicted on Exhibit "LIFOC," are owned by the United States of America (the "U.S. Government'), which is responsible for performing remediation work on the LIFOC Property." 5. Specific Duties and Powers. Section 4.3.3 of the Master Declaration is deleted in its entirety and replaced with the following to conform to current applicable statutory law: "4.3.3 Granting Rights. The power and duty to grant exclusive or nonexclusive easements, licenses, rights of way or fee interests in portions of the Association Property, to the extent any such grant is reasonably required (a) for Improvements to serve the Covered Property, (b) for purposes of conformity with the as -built 2 2544-3325AAMEM 641270.4 7!25/06 location of Improvements installed or authorized by Declarant or the Community Association, (c) in connection with any lawful lot line adjustment, (d) for other purposes consistent with the intended use of the Covered Property as a master planned community, and (e) for the operation of commercial concessions within Association Property for the convenience and enjoyment of the Members, subject to the provisions of the Community Association Governing Documents. This power includes the right to create and convey easements for one or more Owners over portions of the Association Property. The Community Association may de -annex any portion of the Covered Property from the encumbrance of the Master Declaration in connection with any lawful lot line adjustment. After the Community Association acquires fee title to or any easement right over Association Property, the affirmative vote of members owning at least sixty-seven percent (67%) of the Lots and Condominiums in the Covered Property shall be required before the Board may grant exclusive use of any portion of that Association Property to any Member, except as provided in California Civil Code Section 1363.07. Any measure placed before the Members requesting that the Board grant exclusive use of any portion of the Association Property shall specify whether the Community Association will receive any monetary consideration for the grant and whether the Community Association or the transferee will be responsible for providing any insurance coverage for exclusive use of the Association Property." 6. Review of Plans and Specifications. Section 5.4.3 of the Master Declaration is deleted in its entirety and replaced with the following to conform to current applicable statutory. law: "5.4.3 Standard for Approval The Design Review Committee shall approve an application only if it determines that (a) installation, construction or alterations of the Improvements in the locations proposed will not be detrimental to the appearance of the Covered Property as a whole, (b) the appearance of the proposed Improvements will be in harmony with the existing Improvements and the overall design theme in the Covered Property, (c) installation, construction or alteration of the proposed Improvements will not detract from the beauty, wholesomeness and attractiveness of the Covered Property or the enjoyment of the Covered Property by the Owners, (d) maintenance of the proposed Improvements will not become a burden on the Community Association, and (e) the proposed Improvements are consistent with the Community Association Governing Documents. The 3 2544-33253\ANEND%641270A i 7W/06 Committee's decision on any proposed change may not violate any governing provision of law, including the Fair Employment and Housing Act, or a building code or other applicable law governing land use or public safety. The Committee may consider the impact of views from other residences, Lots or Condominiums, reasonable privacy right claims, passage of light and air, beneficial shading and other aesthetic factors in reviewing, approving or disapproving any Application. However, neither the Declarant nor the Community Association warrants that any views in the Covered Property are protected. No residence, Lot or Condominium is guaranteed the existence or unobstructed continuation of any particular view. In review of an application, the Committee shall not make any determination as to non -aesthetic factors such as general safety, fire protection, noise mitigation or compliance with building codes or applicable industry building standards." 7. Enforcement. Section 13.2 of the Master Declaration is deleted in its entirety and replaced with the following to conform to current applicable statutory law: "13.2 NONPAYMENT OF ASSESSMENTS. 13.2.1 Delinquency. Assessments are delinquent if not paid within fifteen (15) days after the due date established by the Community Association. Assessments not paid within thirty (30) days after the due date, plus all reasonable costs of collection (including attorneys' fees) and late charges bear interest at the maximum rate permitted by law commencing thirty (30) days after the due date until paid. The Community Association may also require the delinquent Owner to pay a late charge in accordance with California Civil Code Section 1366(e)(2). The Community Association need not accept any tender of a partial payment of an Assessment and all costs and attorneys' fees attributable thereto. Acceptance of any such tender does not waive the Community Association's right to demand and receive full payment. 13.2.2 Creation and Release of Lien. (a) Priority of Lien. All liens levied in accordance with this Master Declaration shall be prior and superior to (1) any declaration of homestead Recorded after the Recordation of this Master Declaration, and (2) all other liens, except (A) all taxes, bonds, Assessments and other levies which, by law, would be superior thereto, and (B) the lien or charge of any First Deed of Trust made in good faith and for value and Recorded before the date on which the "Notice of Delinquent Assessment" (described 4 2544-33253\AMESM 641270A 725/06 in this Section) against the assessed Lot or Condominium was Recorded. (b) Notice Before Creating Lien. Before the Community Association may place a lien on an Owner's Lot or Condominium to collect a past due Assessment, the Community Association shall send written notice ("Notice of Intent to Lien'), at least thirty (30) days before Recording the lien, to the Owner by certified mail which contains the following information: (1) the Community Association's fee and penalty procedure, (2) an itemized statement of the charges owed by the Owner, including the principal .owed, any late charges, any interest, the method of calculation, and any attorneys' fees, (3) the collection practices used by the Community Association, (4) a statement that the Community Association may recover reasonable costs of collecting past due Assessments, (5) a statement that the Owner has the right to inspect the Community Association's records, pursuant to California Corporations Code Section 8333, (6) the following statement in 14 -point boldface type or all capital letters: "IMPORTANT NOTICE: IF YOUR SEPARATE INTEREST IS PLACED IN FORECLOSURE BECAUSE YOU ARE BEHIND IN YOUR ASSESSMENTS, IT MAY BE SOLD WITHOUT COURT ACTION," (7) a statement that the Owner shall not be liable to pay the charges, interest and costs of collection if it is determined the Assessment was paid on time to the Community Association, (8) a statement that the Owner has the right to request a meeting with the Board, as provided by California Civil Code Section 1367.1(c)(3) and Section 13.2.2(8) below, (9) a statement concerning the Owner's right to dispute the Assessment debt by submitting a written request for dispute resolution to the Community Association pursuant to the Community Association's "meet and confer" program required in California Civil Code Section 1363.810, et seq. and (10) a statement concerning the Owner's right to request alternative dispute resolution with a neutral third party pursuant to California Civil Code Section 1369.510 before the Community Association may initiate foreclosure against the Owner's separate interest, except that binding arbitration shall not be available if the Community Association intends to initiate a judicial foreclosure. (c) Dispute Resolution Before Recording Lien. Before Recording a Notice of Delinquent Assessment, the Community Association shall offer the Owner and, if the Owner so requests, participate in dispute resolution under the Community Association's "meet and confer" program. 5 2544-332531AMEND\ 641270.4 725/06 (d) Dispute Resolution Before Foreclosure Before initiating a foreclosure for delinquent Assessments, the Community Association shall offer the Owner and, if the Owner so requests, shall participate in dispute resolution under the Community Association's "meet and confer" or alternative dispute resolution with a neutral third party. The decision to pursue resolution or a particular type of alternative dispute resolution is the Owner's choice, except that binding arbitration is not available if the Community Association intends to initiate a judicial foreclosure. (e) Board Approvab For liens recorded on or after January 1, 2006, the decision to Record a Notice of Delinquent Assessment shall be made only by the Board and may not be delegated to a Community Association agent. The Board must approve the decision by a• majority vote of the Board members in an open meeting. The Board shall record the vote in the minutes of that meeting. (f) Dispute by Owner. An Owner may dispute the Notice of Intent to Lien by submitting to the Board a written explanation of the reasons for the Owner's dispute. The Board shall respond in writing to the Owner within fifteen (15) days after the date of the postmark of the explanation, if the explanation is. . mailed within fifteen (15) days after the postmark of the Notice of Intent to Lien. (g) . Owner's Right to Request Meeting. An Owner may submit a written request to meet with the Board to, discuss a payment plan for the debt noticed in Section 13.2.2(b) above. The Community Association shall provide the Owner with the standards for payment plans, if any exist. The Board shall meet with the Owner in executive session within forty-five (45) days of the postmark of the request, if the request is mailed within fifteen (15) days after the date of the postmark of the Notice of Intent to Lien, unless there is no regularly scheduled Board meeting within that period, in which case the Board may designate a committee of one or more members to meet with the Owner. (h) Notice of Delinquent Assessment The lien becomes effective on Recordation by the Board or its authorized agent of a Notice of Delinquent Assessment ("Notice of DelinquentAssessment'l securing the payment of any Assessment or installment thereof levied by the Community Association against any Lot or Condominium Owner, as provided in California Civil Code Section 1367 or 1367.1. The Notice of Delinquent 6 2544-33253\AMENI)% 641270.4 7/25/06 Assessment must identify (1) the amount of the Assessment and other authorized charges and interest, including the cost of preparing and Recording the Notice of Delinquent Assessment, (2) the amount of collection costs incurred, including reasonable attorneys' fees, (3) a sufficient description of the Lot or Condominium that has been assessed, (4) the Community Association's name and address, (5) the name of the Owner of the Lot or Condominium that has been assessed, and (6) if the lien is to be enforced by non judicial foreclosure, the name and address of the trustee authorized by the Community Association to enforce the lien by sale. The Notice of Delinquent Assessment must be signed by an authorized Community Association officer or agent and must be mailed in the manner required by California Civil Code Section 2924b to the Owner of record of the Lot or Condominium no later than ten (10) calendar days after Recordation. The lien relates only to the individual Lot or Condominium against which the Assessment was levied and not to the Covered Property as a whole. (i) Service on Owner's Legal Representative. In addition to the requirements of California Civil Code Section 2924, a Notice of Delinquent Assessment shall be served by the Community Association on the Owner's legal representative as provided in California Code of Civil Procedure Section 415.10, et seq. 0) Secondary Addresse& Upon receipt of an Owner's written request identifying a secondary address for purposes of collection notices, the Community Association shall send an additional copy of any Notice of Intent to Lien, Notice of Delinquent Assessment or other Notice given under Section 13.2.2 to the secondary address provided. The Community Association shall notify Owners of their right to submit secondary addresses to the Community Association, when the Community Association issues its pro forma operating budget under California Civil Code Section 1365. The Owner's request must be in writing and mailed to the Community Association in a manner which indicates the Community Association has received it. The Owner may identify or change a secondary address at any time, provided that, if a secondary address is identified or changed during the collection process, the Community Association shall only be required to send Notices to the indicated secondary address from the point the Community Association receives the request. (k) Exceptions. Assessments described in California Civil Code Section 1367(c) and California Code of Regulations 7 2544-33253\AMM4M 641270.4 X25/06 Section 2792.26(c) may not become a lien against an Owner's Lot or Condominium enforceable by the sale of the Lot or Condominium under California Civil Code Sections 2924, 2924b and 2924c. (1) Release of Lien. Within twenty-one (2 1) days after payment of the full amount claimed in the Notice of Delinquent Assessment, or other satisfaction thereof, the Board shall cause to be Recorded a Notice of Satisfaction and Release of Community Lien ("Notice of Release'l stating the satisfaction and release of the amount claimed. The Community Association shall provide the Owner with a copy of the Notice of Release or any other notice that the full amount claimed in the Notice of Delinquent Assessment has been satisfied. The Board may require the Owner to pay a reasonable charge for preparing and Recording the Notice of Release. Any purchaser or encumbrancer who has acted in good faith and extended value may rely on the Notice of Release as conclusive evidence of the full satisfaction of the sums identified as owed in the Notice of Delinquent Assessment. 13.2.3 Enforcement of Liens. The Board shall enforce the collection of amounts due under this Master Declaration by one (1) or more of the alternative means of relief afforded by this Master Declaration, subject to the restrictions in California Civil Code Section 1367.4. (a) The lien on a Lot or Condominium may be enforced by foreclosure and sale of the Lot or Condominium after the Owners failure to pay any Assessment, or installment thereof, as provided in this Master Declaration. (b) The decision to initiate foreclosure after Recording a Notice of Delinquent Assessment shall be made only by the Board and may not be delegated to a Community Association agent. The Board shall approve the decision by a majority vote of the Board members in an executive session. The Board shall record the vote in the minutes of the next Board meeting open to all members. The Board shall maintain the confidentiality of the Owner or Owners by identifying the matter in the minutes by the Lot or Condominium number, rather than the name of the Owner or Owners. A Board vote to approve foreclosure of alien shall take place at least 30 days before any public sale. (c) The Board shall provide notice by personal service to an Owner who occupies the Lot or Condominium or to the Owner's legal representative, if the Board votes to foreclose on the 2544-33253\AMM4M 641270.4 725/06 Lot or Condominium. The Board shall provide written notice to an Owner who does not occupy the Lot or Condominium by first- class mail, postage prepaid, at the most current address shown on the Community Association's books. Unless the Owner provides written notification of a different mailing address to the Community Association, the address of the Owner's Lot or Condominium maybe treated as the Owner's mailing address. (d) The sale shall be conducted in accordance with the provisions of the California Civil Code applicable to the exercise of powers of sale in Deeds of Trust, or in any manner permitted by law. The Community Association (or any Owner if the Community Association refuses to act) may sue to foreclose the lien if (1) at least thirty (30) days have elapsed since the date on which the Notice of Delinquent Assessment was Recorded, and (2) at least ten (10) days have elapsed since a copy of the Notice of Delinquent Assessment was mailed to the Owner affected thereby. The Community Association may bid on the Lot or Condominium at foreclosure sale, and acquire and hold, lease, mortgage and convey the same. On completion of the foreclosure sale, the Community Association or the purchaser at the sale may file suit to secure occupancy of the defaulting Owner's Lot or Condominium, and the defaulting Owner shall be required to pay the reasonable rental value for the Lot or Condominium during any period of continued occupancy by the defaulting Owner or any persons claiming under the defaulting Owner. A nonjudicial foreclosure to collect delinquent Assessments' shall be subject to the right of redemption within 90 days after the sale, as provided in California Civil Code Section 1367.4. (e) A suit to recover a money judgment for unpaid Assessments may be brought without foreclosing or waiving any lien securing the same, subject to the provisions of California Civil Code Section 1367.1(b), but this provision or any suit to recover a money judgment does not affrm the adequacy of money damages. Any recovery resulting from a suit at law or in equity initiated pursuant to this Section may include reasonable attorneys' fees as fixed by the court. 13.2.4 Priority of Assessment Lien. Deeds of Trust Recorded before a Notice of Delinquent Assessment have lien priority over the Notice of Delinquent Assessment. Sale or transfer of any Lot or Condominium does not affect the Assessment lien, except that the sale or transfer of any Lot or Condominium pursuant to judicial or non judicial foreclosure of a First Beed of Trust extinguishes the lien of such Assessments as to payments which became due 9 2544-33253\ANIM 641270.4 725/06 before such sale or transfer. No sale or transfer relieves such Lot or Condominium from liens for any Assessments thereafter becoming due. No Person who obtains title to a Lot or Condominium pursuant to a judicial or non judicial foreclosure of the First Deed of Trust is liable for the share of the Common Expenses or Assessments chargeable to such Lot or Condominium which became due before - the acquisition of title to the Lot or Condominium by such Person. Such unpaid share of Common Expenses or Assessments is a Common Expense collectible from all Owners including such Person. The Community Association may take such action as is necessary to make any Assessment lien subordinate to the interests of the California Department of Veterans Affairs under its Cal -Vet loan contracts as if the Cal -Vet loan contracts were First Deeds of Triist. 13.2.5 Alternative Dispute Resolution. An Owner may dispute the Assessments imposed by the Community Association as provided in this Master Declaration and in California Civil Code Sections 1367.1 and 1367.4. If it is determined through dispute resolution pursuant to the Community Association's "meet and confer" program required in this Master Declaration or alternative dispute resolution with a neutral third party pursuant to California Civil Code Section 1369.510 that the Community Association Recorded a Notice of Delinquent Assessment in error, the Community Association shall promptly reverse all late charges, fees, interest, attorney's fees, costs of collection, costs imposed for the Notice prescn-W in Section 1367.1(a), and costs of Recordation and release of the lien authorized under Section 1367.4(b) and pay all costs related to the dispute resolution or alternative dispute resolution. 13.2.6 Receivers. In addition to the foreclosure and other remedies granted to the Community Association in this Master Declaration, each Owner, by acceptance of a deed to such Owner's Lot or Condominium, conveys to the Community Association all of such Owner's right, title and interest in all rents, issues and profits derived from and appurtenant to such Lot or Condominium, subject to the right of the Community Association to collect and apply such rents, issues and profits to any delinquent Assessments owed by such Owner, reserving to the Owner the right, before any default by the Owner in the payment of Assessments, to collect and retain such rents, issues and profits as they may become due and payable. On any such default, the Community Association may, on the expiration of thirty (30) days following delivery to the Owner of the "Notice of Delinquent Assessment" described in this Master Declaration, either in person, by agent or by receiver to be 1 O 2544-33253\AMEM 641270.4 725/06 appointed by a court, and without regard to the adequacy of any security for the indebtedness secured by the lien described in this Master Declaration, (a) enter in or on and take possession of the Lot or Condominium or any part thereof, (b) in the Community Association's name sue for or otherwise collect such rents, issues and profits, including those past due and unpaid, and (c) apply the same, less allowable expenses of operation, to any delinquencies of the Owner, and in such order as the Community Association may determine. The entering upon and taking possession of the Lot or Condominium, the collection of rents, issues and profits and the application thereof, shall not cure or waive any default or notice of default under this Master Declaration or invalidate any act done pursuant to such notice. 13.2.7 Compliance with Law. To the extent that any provision in this Section 13.2 conflicts with the provisions of the Davis -Stirling Act (California Civil Code Section 1350, et seq.) the statutory provisions shall control." 8. Ratification, Interpretation. Except as amended in this First Amendment, Declarant hereby ratifies and affirms the Master Declaration. Capitalized terms not defined herein shall have the meanings given to them in the Master Declaration. 9. Counterparts. This First Amendment may be executed in counterparts. [SIGNATURES INCLUDED ON FOLLOWING PAGES] 11 2544-33253WMENM 641270.4 7/ W6 [SIGNATURE PAGE TO FIRST AMENDMENT TO MASTER DECLARATION OF COVENANTS, CONDITIONS, RESTRICTIONS AND RESERVATION OF EASEMENTS FOR COLUMBUS SQUARE] Declarant has executed this First Amendment as of2006. MOFFETT MEADOWS PARTNERS, LLC, a Delaware limited liability company By: Marble Mountain Partners, LLC, a Delaware limited liability company Its: Sole Member By. Tustin Villas Partners, LLC, a Delaware limited liability company Its: Administrative Member By: Lennar Homes of California, Inc., a California corporation; Its: Managing Member By. Name: I Title: Vice President "Declarant" STATE OF CALIFORNIA COUNTY OF ORANGE On MSO before me, IL &VA 0 M V *"G • t� ae inea'tme naend title a officer) O�L(/V E personally appeared � S personally known to me ( to be the person whose name is subscribed to the within instrument and acknowledged to me that (he) (fie) executed the same in (his) (her) -authorized capacity, and that by (his) gie} signature on the instrument the person, or the entity upon behalf of which the person acted, executed the instrument. WITNESS Signature: SANJA ZMPANSia 6MyCoCommission #f 16006W rrm Notary Publo - Caffornia orange County FAT•) t xp wAug 12.2 12 2544-3325AMCDE'r 641270.4 7n-%6 GOVERNMENT CODE [27361-7] I certify under the penalty of perjury that the notary acknowledgement on the document to which this statement is attached reads as follows: Name of notary: Date commission. expires: . \Z Commission #: \\O"\a County where bond is filed: ManufactureNendor #: Place of execution: Oranize Dater • �- Signature`s-X North American Title Company Print Name: Melissa Flores ATTACHMENT F "Summary of Rental Proposal" submitted by applicant Summary of Rental ProQosal Discussed March 17, 2010 The Coventry land, approved by the City as an age -restricted apartment project with "affordable" units ("Coventry"), will not be annexed to the Columbus Square master planned community. 2. No assessments shall be levied by Columbus Square Community Association ("Master Association') against the Coventry property, votes in the Master Association shall not be exercised by the owner of Coventry, and the Coventry Owner will not be a member of the Master Association. The California Department of Real Estate has confirmed in writing that the reasonable range of assessments and votes for an annexed apartment project within a master planned community is 1 vote (and 1 assessment unit) for every 2 or 3 units in the apartment project. However, the Coventry Owner is willing to pay to the Master Association an amount equal to one assessment unit for each rented unit as outlined below. 4. The Coventry Owner will enter into a recorded, perpetual Agreement with the Master Association, which Agreement will run with the land pursuant to Sections 845 and 1468 of the Civil Code, containing the following material provisions: (a) The renters in Coventry will have access over all roads owned and maintained by the Master Association. _ (b) The renters will have nonexclusive right to park in designated areas near the Coventry project, pursuant to the same rules that pertain to homeowners in Columbus Square. (c) The renters may use the Master Association facility, on the same basis as all members of the Master Association. (d) The Coventry Owner will pay a fair fee monthly to the Master Association for the foregoing benefits for the duration of the Agreement. This fee will be equal to what any member of the Master Association is obligated to pay. In other words, the Coventry Owner will pay to the Master Association the equivalent of 240 assessment units for its 240 apartment units. RECEIVED MAR 17 2010 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT BY 2544-33253\ 947872.1 3/17/10 ATTACHMENT G First Amendment to Housing Agreement and Regulatory Agreement (draft) FIRST AMENDMENT TO HOUSING AGREEMENT FOR COLUMBUS SQUARE This First Amendment to the Housing Agreement for Columbus Square (the "First Amendment"), is entered into as of , 2010 the ("Effective Date"), by and between the City of Tustin ("City"), a municipal corporation and Moffett Meadows Partners, LLC, a Delaware Limited Liability Company ("Developer"). The Developer and City are collectively referred to herein as the "Parties." Capitalized terms used herein and not otherwise defined shall have the same meanings given to them in the Housing Agreement. RECITALS A. The City and Developer entered into that certain Housing Agreement (Columbus Square) dated as of June 20, 2005 (the "Original Housing Agreement") in order to, among other things, ensure implementation of the Affordable Housing Requirements of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan, the City's Density Bonus Ordinance, the Developer's City -approved "Affordable Housing Plan," the Developer's Density Bonus Application, the City's "Affordable Housing Policy," compliance with California Health and Safety Code Section 33413, subdivision (b)(2), and in accordance with conditions of approval for Tentative Tract Map 16581. B. The City and Developer agreed in the Housing Agreement that all 266 Affordable Housing Units at Columbus ' Square to be provided by Developer would be "for sale" units and would be owned and occupied only by Owner -Occupiers. C. Assignment Agreements were subsequently approved by the City for assignment and assumption of Developer's duties of performance under the Housing Agreement as follows, (i) an Assignment Agreement entered into by and between Moffett Meadows Partners and Tustin Villas Partners, LLC dated as of August 22, 2005 on Lot 4 of Finance and Conveyance Map No. 16857; (ii) an Assignment Agreement entered into by and between Tustin Villa Partners, LLC and Tustin Coventry, LLC dated as of October 19, 2009 on Lot 4 of Finance and Conveyance Map No. 16857; (iii) an Assignment Agreement entered into between Moffett Meadows Partners, LLC and Lennar Homes of California, Inc dated as of August 22, 2005 on Lots 8, 10 and 12 of Finance and Conveyance Map Tract 16857, and (iv) an Assignment Agreement entered into between Moffett Meadows Partners, LLC and William Lyon Homes, Inc. dated as of August 22, 2005 on Lot 7 of Finance and Conveyance Map No. 16857. D. Section 14 of the Housing Agreement provides that the Housing Agreement can be modified by written amendment if formally approved and executed by the Parties. E. Section 3.4.3 of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan also permits multi -family dwelling units (Apartments) subject to review and City approval of a Conditional Use Permit. The Tustin Planning Commission reviewed and approved Conditional Use Permit 09-024 with adoption of Resolution No. 4134 on , 2010 requiring the 240 senior citizen units in the Coventry Court product at Columbus Square to be a multi -family senior citizen se 90087986.2 1-13-09 apartment project rather than an owner occupied senior citizen multi -family condominium project. Of the 240 units in the Coventry Court project, 153 units were age and rent restricted to require occupancy by Senior Citizens who are Affordable Households, with the remaining 87 units age restricted for occupancy by Senior Citizens, but not income restricted. F. The Developer has submitted a formal request to the City to modify the Housing Agreement, consistent with the approval of Conditional Use Permit No. 09-024, to require Developer to make 153 Affordable Housing Units in Coventry Court of the total 266 Affordable Housing Units at Columbus Square identified in the Housing Agreement available as Affordable Housing Units for rental occupancy by Senior Citizens. G. The City Council has found that the conversion of 153 of the 266 Affordable Housing Units from for -sale units into rental units will not result in any adverse impacts on the public health,, safety or physical environment. H. Pursuant to Developer's request, the City and Developer hereby amend the Housing Agreement by way of this First Amendment to allow, in the Developer's discretion, for some or all of the 266 Affordable Housing Units to be made available as rental units. NOW, THEREFORE, in consideration of the foregoing Recitals, which are hereby incorporated in the operative provisions of this Amendment by this reference and mutual covenants and agreements set forth herein and other valuable consideration, the receipt and sufficiency of which is hereby acknowledged, the Parties hereto agree as follows: 1. Sections 1.1, 1.2, and 1.3. The definitions for "Affordable Housing Cost for ,Lower Income Households," "Affordable Housing Cost for Moderate Income Households" and "Affordable Housing Cost of Very Low Income Households" in Sections 1.1, 1.2, and 1.3 in the Housing Agreement are hereby amended and restated to read in their entirety as follows: "1.1 'Affordable Housing Cost' shall mean for any Affordable Housing Unit designated for sale as owner -occupied housing a price that does not exceed the Affordable Housing Cost for a Very Low Income Household, a Low Income Household, or a Moderate Income Household, as applicable. The Affordable Housing Cost for an Affordable Housing Unit shall be calculated as of the date of sale or resale of the Unit and shall take into account and include monthly payments for principal and interest on the mortgage loan, mortgage loan insurance, property taxes and assessments, fire and casualty insurance, property maintenance and repairs, homeowner association fees, and a reasonable allowance for utilities and in an amount not in excess of. (a) For'Very-Low Income Households,' as more particularly defined in Health and Safety Code Section 50052.5(b)(2) and as generally described herein as a price per unit which results in Monthly Housing Costs for the purchaser which shall not exceed one -twelfth of thirty percent (30%) times fifty percent (50%) of the annual Orange County Median Income, adjusted for family size appropriate for the unit. -2- 90087986.2 1-13-09 (b) For 'Low Income Households,' also defined as 'Lower Income Households' as more particularly defined in Health and Safety Code Section 50052.5(b)(3) and as generally described herein as a price per Unit which results in Monthly Housing Costs for the purchaser which shall not exceed one -twelfth of thirty percent (30%) times seventy percent.(70%0) of the annual Orange County Median Income, adjusted for family size appropriate for the unit. (c) For 'Moderate Income Households,' as more particularly defined in Health and Safety Code Section 50052.5(b)(4) and as generally described herein as a price per unit which results in the annual Affordable Housing Cost for the purchaser which shall not be less than twenty-eight percent (28%) of the gross annual income of the household, nor exceed the product of thirty-five percent (35%) times one hundred ten percent (110%) of the annual Orange County Median Income, adjusted for family size appropriate for the unit. Notwithstanding the foregoing, in accordance with Health and Safety Code Section 50052.5(b)(4), the City has determined and hereby agrees that, for a Moderate Income Household with annual gross income that exceeds one hundred ten percent (110%) of the annual Orange County Median Income, adjusted for family size appropriate for the unit. 1.2 'Affordable Rent' shall mean for any for -rent Affordable Housing Unit a maximum monthly rental or lease price that does not exceed the Affordable Rent for a Very Low Income Household, a Low Income Household, or a Moderate Income Household, as applicable. The Affordable Rent for a for -rent Affordable Housing Unit shall be calculated as of the date of rent of the unit and shall take into account and include a reasonable allowance for utilities and in an amount not in excess of- (a) f (a) For 'Very Low Income Households,' as more particularly defined in Health and Safety Code Section.50053(b)(2) and as generally described herein as a monthly rent which does not exceed one -twelfth of thirty percent (30%) times fifty percent (50%) of the annual Orange County Median Income, adjusted for family size appropriate for the unit. (b) For 'Low Income Households,' also defined as 'Lower Income Households,' as more particularly defined in Health and Safety Code Section 50053(b)(3) and as generally described herein as applicable to those low income households whose gross incomes exceed the maximum income for very low income households, a monthly rent which does not exceed one - twelfth of thirty percent (30%) times sixty percent (60%) of the annual Orange County Median Income, adjusted for family size appropriate for the unit. (c) For 'Moderate Income Households,' as more particularly defined in Health and Safety Code Section 50053(b)(4) and as generally described herein as a monthly rent which does not exceed one -twelfth of thirty percent (30%) times one hundred and ten percent (110%) of the annual Orange County Median Income, adjusted for family size. Notwithstanding the foregoing, in accordance with Health and Safety Code Section 50053(b)(4), the City has determined and hereby agrees that, for Moderate Income Households with annual gross incomes that exceed one hundred ten percent (110%) of the annual Orange County Median Income, adjusted for family size appropriate for the unit, a maximum monthly rent shall be calculated as not to exceed one - twelfth of thirty percent (30%) times one hundred and twenty percent (120%) of the annual -3- 90087986.2 1-13-09 Orange County Median Income, adjusted for family size. 1.3 'Affordable Regulatory Agreement' or the 'Regulatory Agreement' means the Affordable Housing Regulatory Agreement and Declaration of Restrictive Covenants in the form attached hereto as Attachment 9 to be recorded against property containing For -Rent Affordable Housing Units as described in Section 3.5." 2. Section 1.8. Section 1.8 of the Housing Agreement is hereby amended and restated to read in its entirety as follows: 1.8 'Affordable Housing Unit' means one of the one hundred thirteen (113) units to be provided by Developer for sale and to be occupied by Owner -Occupiers at an Affordable Housing Cost for Very Low, Lower or Moderate Income Households and the one hundred and fifty-three (153) Units identified .by the Developer and approved by the City for rent to Senior Citizens at an Affordable Rent to Very Low Income Households, Low Income Households, and Moderate Income Households, as more specifically set forth in Section 3, collectively the 'For - Rent Affordable Housing Units."' 3. Section 1.13. The definition of "Lower Income Households" is hereby amended and restated to read in its entirety as follows: "1.13 'Low Income Household;' also defined as 'Lower Income Household shall mean a Household occupied by persons and families whose gross annual income is greater than fifty percent (50%) but does not exceed eighty percent (80%) of the annual Orange County Median Income, as published by the California Department of Housing and Urban Development, with adjustments for smaller and larger family sizes. 4. Section 1.16. The definition of "Memorandum of Agreement" in Section 1.16 of the Housing Agreement shall be hereby amended and restated to read: "1.16 'Memorandum of Agreement' shall have the meaning set forth in Section 3.9." 5. Section 1.17. The definition of 'Moderate Income Household' in Section 1.17 of the Housing Agreement is hereby amended and restated to read in its entirety as follows: 111.17 'Moderate Income Household' shall mean a Household occupied by persons and families whose gross annual income is greater than eighty percent (80%) but does not exceed one hundred and twenty percent (120%) of the Orange County Median Income, as published.by the California Department of Housing and Urban Development, with adjustments for smaller and larger family sizes." 6. Section 1.23. The definition of "Very Low Income Household" in Section 1.23 of the Housing Agreement is hereby amended and restated to read in its entirety as follows: -4- 90087986.2 1-13-09 "1.23. 'Very Low Income Household' shall mean a Household occupied by persons and families whose gross annual income does not exceed fifty percent (50%) of the Orange County Median Income as published by the California Department of Housing and Urban Development, with adjustments for smaller and larger family sizes." 7. Section 1. Section 1 of the Housing Agreement is amended to add the following new Sections 1.24, 1.25, 1.26, 1.27 and 1.28 to read as follows: 1.24 'Business Days' shall mean any day on which Tustin City Hall is open for business. 1.25. 'City Program Administrator' shall mean the Assistant City Manager or other Redevelopment Agency staff member as designated by either the Assistant City Manager or the City Manager. 1.26. 'Qualified Project Period' shall mean the period beginning on the first day on which at least fifty percent (50%) of the residential rental Senior Citizen units in the Coventry Court project are completed and first occupied and ending on the date that is fifty-five (55) years after the date on which at least fifty percent (50%) of the residential rental Senior Citizen units are completed and first occupied. 1.27 'Senior Citizen' means persons age 55 and older. p 1.28. 'Verification of Income' shall mean the documentation by the Developer from the Very Low Income Household, Low Income Household, and Moderate Income . Households verifying income as described in Section 3.5. 10 hereof or such other form as may from time to time be provided by the City Program Administrator to the Developer." 8. Section 3. The title of Section 3 of the Housing Agreement is hereby amended and restated as follows: "3. Affordable Housing Unit Obligations and Tenure Restrictions. 9. Sections 3.1 and 3.2 of the Housing Agreement are hereby deleted in their entirety and new Sections 3.1 and 3.2 are substituted in their place. "3.1. Affordable Housing Unit Obligations 3.1.1. Developer covenants and agrees for itself, its successors, its assigns and every successor in interest of Developer that no fewer than two hundred sixty-six (266) residential units shall be constructed and available for sale to and/or rental to and occupancy by, Very Low Income Households, Low -Income Households, and Moderate Income Households (the 'Affordable Housing Units'), as identified in Attachment No. 2. Of these two hundred and sixty- six (266) Affordable Housing Units: -5- 90087986.2 1-13-09 (a) no fewer than one hundred thirteen (113) of the Affordable Housing Units shall be constructed and shall be made available as for -sale units for occupancy by qualified persons at an Affordable Housing Cost for Very Low, Lower or Moderate Income Households. All for -sale Affordable Housing Units shall be sold to and occupied by Owner -Occupiers. Of these one hundred thirteen (113) units, a minimum of twenty-five (25) units shall be sold to Very Low Income Households, a minimum of sixty-four (64) units shall be sold to Lower Income Households, and a minimum of twenty-four (24) units shall be sold to Moderate Income Households; and (b) no fewer than one hundred fifty-three (153) of the Affordable Housing Units shall be constructed and shall be made available for rental occupancy by Senior Citizens, with a minimum of thirty-six (3 6) units rented to 'Very Low Income Households', a minimum of sixty- one (61) units rented to Low Income Households, and fifty-six (56) units rented to Moderate - Income Households. For rent Affordable Housing Units may only be rented to and occupied by Senior Citizens. The proposed general locations of such Affordable Housing Units by specific parcel, tenure (rental or ownership), bedroom count by tenure which shall not be less than the bedroom mix (shown in Table 4 of the Affordable Housing Plan, as amended), shall be in accordance with conditions of approval of Resolution CC 05-40, including Conditions 2.1, 2.2, and 2.3, and in Planning Commission Resolution No.4134, including Conditions 1.8, 1.9, and 1.10. 3.2 Affordable For -Sale Housing Unit Reguirements: Marketing and Required Documents 3.2.1 Income Qualification Standards and Procedures. The Developer shall submit to the City's Program Administrator an Affordable Housing Purchaser Selection and Criteria Plan for Redevelopment Agency review and approval thirty (30) days prior to approval of a final map or issuance of a building permit. The City's Program Administrator shall approve or disapprove the Affordable Housing Purchaser Selection and Criteria Plan within twenty (20) calendar days. The Developer shall initiate marketing and sales of the Affordable Housing Units after Program Administrator's approval of Developer's Affordable Housing Purchaser Selection and Criteria Plan. Sale of Affordable Housing Units can only be after final map recordation and all necessary California Department of Real Estate approvals. Prior to execution of a sales contract for an Affordable Housing Unit, Developer shall submit to Program Administrator proposed purchaser's income certification and related income verification materials in a form acceptable to the Program Administrator and in the event that the Program Administrator finds that the provisions of the Agreement have been complied with, Program Administrator shall approve same in writing. The Developer shall submit to Program Administrator individual escrow instructions for buyers of Affordable Housing Units and all other related documents at least twenty (20) calendar days prior to close of escrow of individual Affordable Housing Units and with submission of individual escrow instructions and related items by Developer to Program Administrator. The Program Administrator shall approve or disapprove individual escrow instructions and related items for buyers of Affordable Housing Units within ten (10) calendar days of the following submission by Developer. 10 90087986.2 1-13-09 3.2.2 Housing Affordable Documents to be Recorded. At the time of closing of each sale of an Affordable Housing Unit to an Owner Occupier, the Developer shall cause to be recorded against such Affordable Housing Unit the applicable 'Affordable Housing Covenant' based on the income level for such Affordable Housing Unit (i.e., Very Low Income, Low Income, or Moderate Income), the applicable 'Affordable Housing Trust Deed, and the "Affordable Housing Option Agreement". The Developer shall also cause to be executed a promissory note executed by the applicable Owner -Occupier. In addition, Developer shall require the prospective Owner Occupier to execute a 'Reimbursement Agreement' (Exhibit 'E' to each Affordable Housing Covenant), which executed agreement shall be delivered to the City's Program Administrator as a condition of close of escrow on the Unit. In order to enable Developer to meet its continuing housing obligations under State law and as required by the Specific Plan and Housing Agreement, and because the City has facilitated the provision of the Affordable Housing Units through its adoption of the Specific Plan and housing incentives in the Density Bonus Ordinance, and provided that the Affordable Housing Covenant, Affordable Housing Trust Deed and Affordable Housing Option Agreement are recorded concurrently with the closing of the sale of an Affordable Housing Unit, the City agrees to accept the Affordable Housing Note, which Affordable Housing Note shall be in an amount equal to the difference between the appraised fair market value of the unit as if it was a Market Rate Unit and the sales price required to sell the Unit at an Affordable Housing Cost for Very Low Income Households, Low Income Households or an Affordable Housing Cost for Moderate Income Households, as applicable. The Affordable Housing Note shall be in the applicable form attached hereto as Attachment No. 3. Each Affordable Housing Note shall be assigned by the Developer to the City at the time of the closing of the sale of each Affordable Housing Unit, and shall be secured by a deed of trust executed by the purchasing Owner Occupier and recorded against the Unit at the time of the closing of such sale (the 'Affordable Housing Trust Deed') in the applicable form attached hereto as Attachment No. 4. The Affordable Housing Trust Deed shall secure the obligations of the Owner Occupier set forth in the Affordable Housing Covenant, the Reimbursement Agreement and the Affordable Housing Promissory Note and shall be subordinate in priority only to the monetary lien of a purchase money deed of trust also recorded at the time of closing of the sale securing an amount not in excess of the applicable Affordable Housing Cost of the Unit. The Affordable Housing Deed of Trust shall be subordinate in priority only to the monetary lien of a purchase money deed of trust also recorded at the time of closing." 12. Section 3.3. The title of Section 3.3 of the Housing Agreement is amended as restated to read in its entirety as follows: 1.3 Covenant: Affordable For Sale Units." 13. Sections 3.4 and 3.5 are hereby amended and restated to read in their entirety as follows: 1.4. For -Rent Affordable Housing Unit Requirements: Marketing and Required Documents. The 153 required For -Rent Senior Citizen Affordable Housing Units shall -7- 90087986.2 1-13-09 be constructed in the Coventry Court project as depicted in general location in Attachment No. 2. With respect to the Coventry Court Senior Citizen rental apartment project, 36 units shall be rent restricted and occupied by Very Low Income Senior Citizen Households, 61 units shall be rent restricted and occupied by Low Income Senior Citizen Households, and 56 units shall be rent restricted and occupied by Moderate Income Senior Citizen Households, and 87 units shall be rented at market rates. 3.5 Covenant Re: Affordable For -Rent Units. 3.5.1 The Developer covenants and agrees for itself, its successors, its assigns and every successor in interest to property designated to contain For -Rental Senior Citizen Affordable Housing Units to construct the For -Rent Senior Citizen Affordable Housing Units described in Section 3.4 and depicted as to general location on Attachment No. 2 and said units shall be restricted for a period terminating fifty-five (55) years from the issuance of a certificate of occupancy for a rental project and expiration of the Qualified Project Period and according to the following terms: (a) Affordable Housing Units designated by general parcel location in Attachment No. 2 as being For -Rent to Very Low -Income Households shall only be rented and occupied by Senior Citizens in Very Low -Income Households; (b) Affordable Housing Units designated by general parcel location in Attachment No. 2 as being For -Rent to Low -Income Households shall only be rented and occupied by Senior Citizens in Low -Income Households; and (c) Affordable Housing Units designated by general parcel location in Attachment No. 2 as being For -Rent to -Moderate Income Households shall only be rented and occupied by Senior Citizens in Moderate Income Households. 3.5.2 In order to impose upon a parcel the obligations set forth above in Section _ 3.5.1, prior to issuance by the City's Building Official of further building permits for the Coventry Court project, there shall be recorded against the Coventry Court project site an 'Affordable Housing Regulatory Agreement and Declaration of Restrictive Covenants,' (hereinafter referred to as the 'Regulatory Agreement') in the form of the Regulatory Agreement and applicable covenants attached hereto as Attachment No. 9. The Developer shall cause the Regulatory Agreement, and all amendments and supplements hereto and thereto, to be recorded and filed in the Official Records and in such other places as the Program Administrator may reasonably request. The Developer shall pay all fees and charges incurred in connection with any such recording. Written evidence of the recorded Regulatory Agreement shall be provided to the Program Administrator. 3.5.3 Renting to Affordable Households. Very Low Income Units, Low Income Units and Moderate Income Units shall be rented to eligible and qualified Senior Citizens in Very Low Income Households, Low Income Households and Moderate Income Households in accordance with the following terms: a) Developer shall use its best efforts to fill vacancies of Very Low Income, Low Income, and Moderate Income Affordable Units as soon as possible following the date the Affordable Housing Unit becomes available for renting, by renting the units to Senior Citizens in Very Low Income Households, Low Income Households, and Moderate Income -8- 90087986.2 1-13-09 Households as applicable to such units and as described in Section 3.4.1 and generally depicted on Attachment No. 2. Developer shall lease available units to eligible Affordable Households on a first-come, first-served, and non-discriminatory basis. Developer shall notify the City Program Administrator of any Affordable Housing Units that either (a) fails to have been leased to a Senior Citizen in a Very Low Income Household, Low Income Household, or Moderate Income Household, as applicable, within thirty (30) days after the issuance of a certificate of occupancy for the unit (the 'Initial Leasing Period'), or (b) becomes available as a result of tenant vacation of the premises. b) Developer shall create and maintain an 'interest list' which includes all potential tenants who have expressed an interest in leasing a unit within each rental project. The interest list shall clearly designate whether such potential tenant is a Senior Citizen in a Very Low Income Household, Low Income Household, or Moderate Income Household. The interest list shall clearly indicate whether such potential tenant will be receiving rental assistance under the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) Section 8 program (or other federal programs that may replace the Section 8 program). Developer shall use its best efforts to fill vacancies of Very Low Income Units, Low Income Units, and Moderate Income Units as soon as possible following the date the Affordable Housing Units become available for renting, by renting the units to Senior Citizens in Very Low Households, Low Income Households, and Moderate Income Households as applicable to such units. C) An Affordable Housing Unit that either (a) fails to be leased within the Initial Leasing Period to a Senior Citizen in a Very Low Income Household, Low Income Household, or Moderate Income Household, as may be applicable, or (b) becomes available as a result of tenant vacation of the premises, shall be rented to a new eligible and qualified tenant in accordance with the following procedure: (i) Developer shall make a reasonable effort to contact eligible and qualified prospective tenants in the order of priority on the interest list as set forth in this Section 3.5.3 above and, Developer shall lease available units to such eligible tenants on a first- come, first-served, basis; (ii) Each such eligible and qualified prospective tenant shall have three (3) business days to notify Developer of the prospective tenant's intent to accept the unit, and must thereafter execute a lease for the unit within seven (7) days of such acceptance; (iii) Failure of the eligible and qualified prospective tenant to timely notify Developer of accepting the unit or to thereafter timely execute a lease for the unit shall be deemed rejection of the unit, and Developer may seek other eligible tenants as set forth in this subsection (c) and following. d) In the event the 'interest list' maintained by the Developer does not include a prospective tenant that is eligible and qualified as a tenant of a vacant Affordable Housing Unit, or in the event Developer is unable to lease a vacant Affordable Housing Unit after fully complying with the procedures set forth herein, the Developer may lease the restricted 90087986.2 1-13-09 unit to any eligible and qualified Very Low Income Household, Low Income Household, or Moderate Income Household for the appropriate restricted unit. e) Senior Citizens in Low Income Households, Very Low Income Households and Moderate Income Households who occupy Low Income Units, Very Low Income Units and Moderate Income Units at the expiration of the Qualified Project Period and who qualify as Very Low Income Households, Low Income Households, or Moderate Income Households on such date shall be permitted to continue to occupy those Low Income Units, Very Low Income Units and Moderate Income Units for a period of one (1) year, beginning on the first day after the expiration of the Qualified Project Period; provided, however, that annual rent increases during such one (1) year period shall not exceed an amount equal to the existing rent for such unit plus an amount equal to the greater of (i) five percent (5%) or (ii) the percentage increase that would have been permitted had the Qualified Project Period not expired. Except as provided in the preceding sentence, upon the expiration of the Qualified Project Period, the Affordable Housing Units shall no longer be subject to the provisions of this Section 3. f) The Developer agrees to provide to Very Low Income Households, Low Income Households, and Moderate Income Households within the rental project sites notice of all rent increases pursuant to applicable Governmental Requirements, including rules and regulations of the State. 3.5.4 Rental Rates.. Rental rates for all Affordable Housing Units to which this Agreement and a Regulatory Agreement are applicable shall not exceed the higher of following: (a) The Affordable Housing Rent as defined in the California Health and Safety Code Section 50053 for Very Low Income Households (Section 50053 (b)(2)), for Low Income Households (Section 50053 (b)(3), and for Moderate Income Households (Section 50053 (b)(4), less the monthly allowance for utilities and services (excluding telephone) to be paid by the household; or (b) If an Affordable Housing Unit designated for rent to a Senior Citize in a Very Low Income Household or Low Income Household receives federal or state rental subsidy, and a Very Low or Low Income tenant pays as a contribution toward rent no more than thirty percent (30%) of the household's adjusted income, then the maximum rent (i.e., tenant contribution plus any rental subsidy) shall be the fair market rent allowable under the federal or state rental subsidy certificate or voucher program. Alternatively, the maximum monthly rent that may be charged to a qualified tenant who is subject to this limitation may be the monthly adjusted income of the qualified tenant multiplied by thirty percent (30%) and divided by 12 and, if applicable, a monthly allowance for any utilities and services (excluding telephone) to be paid by the tenant shall be subtracted. 3.5.5 Voucher Holders. No Affordable Housing Units designated for rent to a -10- 90087986.2 1-13-09 Senior Citizen in a Very Low Income Household or Low Income Income Household shall be refused for leasing to a holder of a certificate or voucher under 24 CFR Part 982 Section 8 Rental Certificate Program or Section 8 Rental Voucher Program or to the holder of a comparable document evidencing participation in a HOME tenant -based assistance program because of the status of the prospective Very Low Income Household or Low Income Household as a holder of such certificate of family participation, rental voucher, or comparable tenant -based assistance document. 3.5.6 Rent Schedule and Utility Allowances. The City Program Administrator shall annually review and approve rents proposed by the Developer for the Affordable Housing Units to determine that the Developer has properly applied the rental restrictions contained in this Section 3.5 and shall provide the Developer with a schedule establishing the monthly allowances for utilities and services to be paid by the tenants of the units. The Developer shall re-examine the income of each tenant household living in the Affordable Housing Unit at least annually. The maximum monthly rent shall be recalculated by the Developer and reviewed and approved by the City Program Administrator annually and may change as changes in .he applicable gross rent amounts, the income adjustments, or the monthly allowance for utilities and services warrant. The Developer shall not impose on a tenant an increase in rent approved by the City Program Administrator if that increase is not permitted to be imposed under the lease between Developer and the tenant. Developer shall provide not less than thirty (30) days prior written notice to affected tenants before implementing any increase in rents. 3.5.7 Increases in Income. (a) If, as a result of the annual re-examination of incomes required pursuant to Section 3.5.6, the Developer determines that a household that qualified as a Very Low Income Household for purposes of paragraph 3.5.3 above, no longer is a Very Low Income Household but instead qualifies as a Low Income Household, then the Developer may require that household to pay the Affordable Rent for Low Income Units, and the Developer shall lease the next available Low Income or Moderate Income Unit to a Senior Citizen in a Very Low Income Household at the rent permitted under Section 3.5.3. (b) If, as a result of the annual re-examination of incomes required pursuant to Section 3.5.6, the Developer determines that a household that qualified as a Very Low Income Household for purposes of paragraph 3.5.3 above, no longer is a Very Low Income Household but instead qualifies as a Moderate Income Household, then the Developer may require that household to pay the Affordable Rent for Moderate Income Units, and the Developer shall lease the next available Low Income Unit or Moderate Income Unit to a Senior Citizen in a Very Low Income Household at the rent permitted under Section 3.5.3. (c) If, as a result of the annual re-examination of incomes required pursuant to Section 3.5.6, the Developer determines that a household that qualified as a Low Income Household for purposes of paragraph 3.5.3 above, no longer is a Low Income Household but instead qualifies as a Moderate Income Household, then the Developer may require that household to pay the Affordable Rent for Moderate Income Units, and the Developer shall lease -11- 90087986.2 1-13-09 the next available Moderate Income Unit to a Senior Citizen in, a Low Income Household at the rent permitted under Section 3.5.3. (d) If, as a result of the annual re-examination of incomes required pursuant to Section 3.5.6, the Developer determines that a household that qualified as a Very Low Income Household, Low Income Household, or Moderate Income Household for purposes of paragraph 3.5.3 above, no longer is a Very Low Income Household, Low Income Household, or Moderate Income Household, then the Developer may require that household to pay fair market rent, and the Developer shall lease the next available apartment unit in the development to a Senior Citizen in a Very Low Income Household, Low Income Household, or Moderate Income Household (whichever class of household that the original Affordable Housing Units was to be leased to) at the affordable rent for such Very Low Income Unit, Low Income Unit, or Moderate Income Unit. Such next available apartment unit shall then be deemed to be a Very Low Income Unit, Low Income Unit, or Moderate Income Unit; subject to the provisions of this Section 3.5, and the previous unit shall no longer be subject to the provisions of this Section 3.5. (e) Notwithstanding the foregoing provisions, it is the intent of this Agreement and the Regulatory Agreement that the number of Very Low Income Units, Low Income Units, and Moderate Income Units be allocated as among the Affordable Housing Units as provided in Section 3.4. In the event the foregoing provisions result in an allocation of Affordable Housing Units different from that provided in Section 3.4, Developer shall lease the next available Affordable Housing Unit to a Senior Citizen in a Very Low Income Household, Low Income Household, or Moderate Income Household, as the case may be, in order to correct the allocation. 3.5.8 Minimum Rents. Notwithstanding the other provisions of this Section 3.5, Developer shall not be required to charge a rent for a Very Low Income Unit, Low Income Unit, or Moderate Income Unit that would be lower than the maximum rent Developer would have been permitted to charge for the Unit had the determination of maximum rent been made on the date the City and Developer entered into the Agreement. 3.5.9 Tenant Protections (a) Rental Agreement. The Rental Agreement (lease) between Developer and the Affordable Household must be for not less than one year, unless the City Program Administrator provides prior written approval, and may not contain any of the following provisions: (i) . Any agreement by the tenant to be sued, to admit guilt or to consent to a judgment in favor of the Developer in a lawsuit brought in connection with the lease. (ii) Any agreement by the tenant that the Developer may take, hold, or sell personal property of household members without notice to the tenant and a court -12- 90087986.2 1-13-09 decision on the rights of the parties. This prohibition, however, does not apply to an agreement by the tenant concerning disposition of personal property remaining in the Unit after the tenant has moved out of the Unit. The Developer may dispose of this personal property in accordance with applicable state law. (iii) Any agreement by the tenant not to hold the Developer or its agents legally responsible for any action or failure to act, whether intentional or negligent. (iv) Any agreement of the tenant that the Developer may evict the tenant or household members without notice to the tenant. (v) Any agreement by the tenant that the Developer may evict the tenant or household members without instituting a civil court proceeding in which the tenant has the opportunity to present a defense, or before a court decision on the rights of the parties. (vi) Any agreement by the tenant to waive any right to a trial by jury - (vii) Any agreement by the tenant to waive the tenant's right to appeal, or to otherwise challenge in court, a court decision in connection with the lease. (viii) Any agreement by the household to pay attorney's fees or other legal costs even if the tenant wins in a court proceeding by the Developer against the tenant. The tenant, however, may be obligated to pay costs if the tenant loses. (b) Termination of Tenancy. Developer may not terminate the tenancy or refuse to renew the lease of an affordable housing tenant except for violation of the terms and conditions of the lease; for violation of applicable federal, state, or local law; or for other good cause. Any termination or refusal to renew must be preceded by not less than sixty (60) days by the Developer's service upon the tenant of a written notice specifying the grounds for the action. 3.5. 10 Vely Low Income Low Income and Moderate Income Senior Citizen Tenants,• Records and Reports. The Developer hereby represents, warrants and covenants as follows: (a) Within 30 days after the date on which at least ten percent (10%) of the dwelling units in the Project are first occupied, the Developer shall execute and deliver a written notice, in the form provided by the City Program Administrator or otherwise approved by Program Administrator a copy of a certificate identifying said date and the beginning date and earliest ending date of the Qualified Project Period, which certificate shall be in the form provided by Program Administrator or otherwise approved by City's Program Administrator. The Developer shall record a copy of such certificate in the Official Records. -13- 90087986.2 1-13-09 (b) The Developer shall obtain, complete and maintain on file Verifications of Income qualification, in the form provided by City's Program Administrator or otherwise approved by City's Program Administrator, from each Very Low Income Household, Low Income Household or Moderate Income Household, including (i) a Verification of Income and age qualification dated immediately prior to the initial occupancy of such Very Low Income Household, Low Income Household or Moderate Income Household and (ii) thereafter, annual Verifications of Income and age qualifications which must be dated as of June 1st of each year, or such other date as may be mutually agreed upon by the City's Program Administrator and the Developer, and in no event less than once in every twelve-month period following each Very Low Income Household's, Low Income Household's, or Moderate Income Household's occupancy of a unit in the Project. The Developer will obtain such additional information as may be required in the future by the State or by the City's Program Administrator, due to changes in federal or state law. (c) A copy of the most recent Verification of Income and age qualification for Very Low Income Household, Low Income Household, and Moderate Income Household commencing upon occupation or continuing occupation of a. Very Low Income Unit, Low Income Unit, or Moderate Income Unit (and not previously filed) shall be attached to the Certificate of Continuing Program Compliance, in the form provided by City's Program Administrator or otherwise approved by City's Program Administrator which is to be filed with the City's Program Administrator no later than the fifteenth (15`x') day of each month following the receipt by the City's Program Administrator of the Completion Certificate to and including the month in which such report indicates that fifty percent (50%) of the units in the Coventry Court Project are occupied by Senior Citizens in Very Low Income Households, Low Income Households and Moderate Income Households and, thereafter, no later than the first (ls) day of the sixth (6t') month of each calendar year until the end of the Qualified Project Period. (d) The Developer shall make a diligent and good -faith effort to verify that theinformation provided by an applicant in the Verification of Income and Senior Citizen age qualifications is accurate by taking the following steps, as a part of the verification process: (1) obtain birth certificates for all household members; (2) obtain pay stubs for the most recent one-month period or the last three months bank statements for self-employed individuals, and (3) obtaining income W-2 Wage and Earnings Statements and tax returns for the most recent tax year; alternatively, if determined appropriate for the tenant's situation the following may be obtained: (i) obtain an income verification from the Social Security Administration and/or the California Department of Social Services if the applicant receives assistance from either of such agencies; or (ii) if the applicant is unemployed, does not have income tax returns or is otherwise unable to provide other forms of verification as required above, obtain another form of independent verification satisfactory to the Program Administrator. (e) The Developer shall maintain complete and accurate records pertaining to the Very Low Income Units, Low Income Units, and Moderate Income Units and shall permit any duly authorized representative of the City to inspect the books and records of the Developer pertaining to the Project, including those records pertaining to the occupancy of the Affordable Housing Units. -14- 90087986.2 1-13-09 (f) The Developer shall prepare and submit to the City Program Administrator no later than the first (1St) day of the sixth (6th) month of each calendar year until the end of the Qualified Project Period, a Certificate of Continuing Program Compliance executed by the Developer with the following information: (i) The number of the dwelling units of the Project which were occupied, pursuant to Section 3.4 above, by Senior Citizens in Very Low Income Households, Low Income Households, and Moderate Income Households during such period and such other tenant information as may be reasonably required as stated on the form of the Certificate of Continuing Program Compliance acceptable to the Program Administrator; and (ii) A statement either: (a) that no un -remedied default has occurred under the Regulatory Agreement or (b) a default has occurred, in which event the Certificate shall describe the nature of the default in detail and set forth the measures being taken by the Developer to remedy such default. 3.5.11 Each lease or rental agreement for an Affordable Housing Unit shall contain a provision to the effect that the Developer has relied on the Verification of Income Certification and age qualification and supporting information supplied by the Very Low Income Household, Low Income Household, or Moderate Income Household in determining qualification for occupancy of the Very Low Income Units, Low Income Units and Moderate Income Units by Senior Citizens and that any material misstatement in such verification t (whether or not intentional) will be cause for immediate termination of such lease or rental agreement. Each such lease or rental agreement shall also provide (and shall so disclose to the tenant) that the tenant's income and age qualification is subject to annual certification in accordance with the terms of the Regulatory Agreement, and that, if upon review of any such verification the tenant's income exceeds the then applicable income limit for a Very Low Income Household, Low Income Household, or Moderate Income Household, such household shall cease to qualify as a Very Low Income Household, Low Income Household, or Moderate Income Household, and, as a consequence, said household's lease shall be subject to termination on such prior notice as the City's Program Administrator deems reasonable. 3.5.12 Termination of For -Rent Affordable Housiniz Covenants. The provisions of this Section 3.5 shall remain in full force and effect for the period provided in Section 3.5.1." 14. Section 3.6 is hereby deleted in its entirety and a new Section 3.6 is substituted in its place as follows: "3.6 Purpose of Affordable Housing Provisions. The City and the Developer hereby agree that the provisions of this Agreement relating to the Affordable Housing Units are entered into in order to achieve a stabilized community of Owner -Occupied for -sale Affordable Housing Units and for -rent Affordable Housing Units. It is the intention of the City and the Developer -15- 90087986.2 1-13-09 that the City and its successors and assigns be empowered to enforce the covenants contained in this Affordable Housing Agreement and all. Affordable Housing Covenants, or Regulatory Agreements, that each of the foregoing empower the City and its successors and assigns to enforce the covenants contained herein, and that each of the foregoing should also be construed and interpreted." 15. Section 3 is hereby amended to add the following new Section 3.7: "3.7 Compliance with Density Bonus Ordinance Specific Plan and Applicable State Law. The City and the Developer hereby agree that the provisions of this Agreement comply with the Specific Plan, Density Bonus Ordinance, Government Code Section 65915, and California Health and Safety Code Sections 33413, 33334.3, and 33334.14, and that such provisions fully satisfy the requirements of such code sections." 16. Section 3 is hereby amended to add the following new Section 3.8: "3.8 Other Covenants: Developer covenants and agrees for itself, its successors, its assigns that: 3.8.1 Obligation to Refrain from Discrimination. There shall be no discrimination against or segregation of any person or group of persons, on account of race, color, creed, religion, sex, sexual orientation, marital status, national origin or ancestry in the sale, lease, sublease, transfer, use, occupancy, tenure or enjoyment of the Site or any portion thereof, nor shall Developer itself or any person claiming under or through it (including any tenant) establish or permit any such practice or practices of discrimination or segregation with reference to the selection, location, number, use or occupancy of tenants, lessees, subtenants, sublessees or vendees on the Property or any portion thereof. 3.8.4 RedeveloRment Law: Form of Nondiscrimination and Non-seare as tion Clauses. The Developer itself and any person claiming under or through it shall refrain from restricting the sale of the property on the basis of race, color, creed, religion, sex, sexual orientation, marital status, national origin or ancestry of any person. All deeds, leases or contracts shall contain or be subject to substantially the following non-discrimination or non - segregation clauses: (a) In Deeds: 'The grantee herein covenants by and for itself, its successors and assigns, and all persons claiming under or through them, that there shall be no discrimination against or segregation of, any person or group of persons on account of race, color, creed, religion, sex, sexual orientation, marital status, national origin or ancestry in the sale, lease, sublease, transfer, use, occupancy, tenure or enjoyment of the land herein conveyed, nor shall the grantee itself or any person claiming under or through it, establish or permit any such practice or practices of discrimination or segregation with reference to the selection, location, number, use or occupancy of tenants, lessees, subtenants, sublessees or vendees in the land herein conveyed. The foregoing covenants shall run with the land.' -16- 90087986.2 1-13-09 (b) In Leases: 'The lessee herein covenants ' successors and assigns, and all persons claiming under or through them, and accepted upon and subject to the following conditions: by and for itself, its and this lease is made 'That there shall be no discrimination against or segregation of, any person or group of persons on account of race, color, creed, religion, sex, sexual orientation, marital status, national origin or ancestry in the sale, lease, sublease, transfer, use, occupancy, tenure or enjoyment of the land herein conveyed, nor shall the grantee itself or any person claiming under or through it, establish or permit any such practice or practices of discrimination or segregation with reference to the selection, location, number, use or occupancy of tenants, lessees, subtenants, sublessees or vendees in the land herein leased.' (c) In Contracts: 'There shall be no discrimination against or segregation of, any person or group of persons on account of race, color, creed, religion, sex, sexual orientation, marital status, national origin or ancestry in the sale, lease, sublease, transfer, use, occupancy, tenure or enjoyment of the land herein conveyed, nor shall the grantee itself or any person claiming under or through it, establish or permit any such practice or practices of discrimination or segregation with reference to the selection, location, number, use or occupancy of tenants, lessees, subtenants, sublessees or vendees in the land.' The Developer covenants and agrees for itself, its. successors, its assigns and every successor in interest to the Site or any part thereof, there shall be no discrimination against or segregation of any person, or group of persons, on account of race, color, creed, religion, sex, sexual orientation, marital status, national origin or ancestry in the sale, transfer, rental or lease (where permitted), use, occupancy, tenure or enjoyment of the Site nor shall the Developer itself or any person claiming under or through it establish or permit any such practice or practices of discrimination or segregation with reference to the selection, location, number, use or occupancy of purchasers of the Property, or renters or lessees of the Property, or any portion thereof." 17. Section 3 of the Housing Agreement is hereby amended to add a new Section 3.9 to read: "3.9 Memorandum of Agreement. A Memorandum of Agreement, substantially in the form of Attachment No. 8, attached hereto and incorporated herein by this reference, shall be recorded against the Property upon execution of this Agreement. A Memorandum of any Amendments to the Agreement, shall also be prepared, substantially in the form of Attachment No. 10, attached hereto and incorporated herein by this reference, and shall be recorded against the Property upon execution of any Amendments to the Agreement." 18. Section 17. Section 17 is hereby amended to delete the original Attachment No. 2 and replace it in its entirety with a new Attachment No. 2, to add Attachment No. 9, and to add Attachment 10, with the Attachments included in the Agreement, as amended, to read as follows: -17- 90087986.2 1-13-09 "Attachment No. 1: Legal Description Attachment No. 2: Affordable Housing Units — Number, Location, Bedrooms Attachment No. 3: Affordable Housing Note Attachment No. 4: Affordable Housing Deed of Trust Attachment No. 5: Affordable Housing Covenant (Very Low Income) Attachment No. 6: Affordable Housing Covenant Attachment No. 7: Affordable Housing Covenant (Moderate Income) Attachment No. 8: Memorandum of Agreement Attachment No. 9: Regulatory Agreement and Declaration of Restrictive Covenants (Coventry Court Rental Project) Attachment No. 10: Memorandum of First Amendment to the Housing Agreement The new Attachment No. 2, Attachments No. 9 and Attachment No. 10 to the Housing Agreement will be in the forms attached hereto -as Exhibits 'A,' , Exhibit `B' and 'C,' respectively." 19. Counterparts. This First Amendment may be executed in counterparts. Each counterpart shall be deemed an original, and all counterparts shall be deemed the same instrument with the same effect as if all parties hereto had signed the same signature page. In addition, a copy of this First Amendment executed by a party hereto and telecopied to the other party shall be deemed to constitute delivery of an originally executed copy of this First Amendment to the other party. A facsimile signature shall be enforceable to the same extent as an original signature. -18- 90087986.2 1-13-09 IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have executed this First Amendment as of k, the date above written. In- "CITY" CITY OF TUSTIN, ATTEST: a California municipal corporation Pamela Stoker, City Clerk By: William Huston, City Manager or Christine Shingleton, Assistant City Manager APPROVED AS TO FORM: Woodruff, Spradlin & Smart Douglas Holland, City Attorney "DEVELOPER" MARBLE MOUNTAIN PARTNERS, LLC, MOFFETT MEADOWS its sole member, a Delaware limited liability company, PARTNERS, LCC, its administrative member a Delaware limited liability company By: Its: By: Its: ACKNOWLEGMENT AND CONSENT OF ASSIGNEES TO FIRST AMENDMENT The Undersigned, as assignees of portions of the property subject to the Housing Agreement in accordance with the assignment agreements referenced in Recital C hereof, consent to the foregoing amendments and agree to be bound thereby if and the extent such amendments affect the property owned by them. ASSIGNEES: For Lot 4 of Finance and Conveyance Map No. 16857 90087986.1 9/24/09 -19- TUSTIN COVENTRY, LLC, a California Delaware limited liability company By: Lennar Homes of California, Inc., a California corporation, its managing Member Name: Title: For Lots 8,10 and 12 of Finance and Conveyance Map No. 16857 Lennar Homes of California, Inc, a California corporation Name: Title: For Lot 7 of Finance and Conveyance Map No. 16857 William Lyon Homes, Inc., a California corporation Name: Title: -20- 90087986.1 9/24/09 EXHIBIT "A" ATTACHMENT 2 TO HOUSING AGREEMENT AFFORDABLE HOUSING PLAN Om OF St to LU a N4 w at M. W C4 ■ OP • n m 7 0 2 22 Z2P j 1.. J JJ JJJ a % 3C RB P I LL 9 u cq— Income Level Plan Bedrooms/Baths Units/Bldg No. of Bldgs Total Unit Very Low Income Plan 1 1 Bedroom/1 Bath 4 8 32 Low Income Plan 1 1 Bedroom/1 Bath 4 8 32 Low Income Plan 2 2 Bedroom/2 Bath 2 8 16 Moderate Income Plan 2 2 Bedroom/2 Bath 2 8 16 Moderate Income Plan 3 2 Bedroom/2 Bath 3 8 24 15 15 Total 15 120 Income Level BUILDING 2 (TOTAL OF 1 BUILDING) - B.T.-2 Plan Bedrooms/Baths Units/Bldg No. of Bldgs Total Unit Very Low Income Plan 1 1 Bedroom/1 Bath 4 1 4 Low Income Plan 1 1 Bedroom/1 Bath 4 1 4 Low Income Plan 2 2 Bedroom/2 Bath 1 1 1 Moderate Income Plan 2 2 Bedroom/2 Bath 3 1 3 Moderate Income Plan 3 2 Bedroom/2 Bath 3 1 3 Total 15 15 Income Level BUILDING 3 (TOTAL OF 1 BUILDING) - B.T.-3 Plan Bedrooms/Baths Units/Bldg No. of Bldgs Total Units Lour Income Plan 1 1 Bedroom/1 Bath 8 1 8 Moderate Income Plan 2 2 Bedroom/2 Bath 4 1 4 Moderate Income Plan 3 2 Bedroom/2 Bath 3 1 3 Moderate Income . Plan 4 2 Bedroom/2 Bath 3 1 3 Total 18 18 EXHIBIT "B" ATTACHMENT 9 TO HOUSING AGREEMENT AFFORDABLE HOUSING REGULATORY AGREEMENT AND DECLARATION OF COVENANTS CITY OF TUSTIN OFFICIAL BUSINESS REQUEST DOCUMENT BE RECORDED AND EXEMPT FROM RECORDING FEES PER GOVERNMENT CODE SECTION 6103 AND 27383 RECORDING REQUESTED BY - ) AND WHEN RECORDED MAIL TO: ) City of Tustin ) 300 Centennial Way ) Tustin, California 92780 ) Attention: Redevelopment Agency ) City Clerk COPY TO: [SPACE ABOVE LINE FOR RECORDER'S USE UNLz ] REGULATORY AGREEMENT AND DECLARATION OF RESTRICTIVE COVENANTS THIS REGULATORY AGREEMENT AND DECLARATION OF RESTRICTIVE COVENANTS (this "Regulatory Agreement" ) is made and entered into as of 2010, by and between the TUSTIN COMMUNITY REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY, a California Redevelopment Agency ("Agency") and the CITY OF TUSTIN, a municipal corporation and public body corporate and politic of the State of California (together with any successor of City, the "City") and together with the Agency collectively referred to as "CITY" and Tustin Coventry Seniors, , LLC, a California limited liability company (the "Developer"). The City and Developer are sometimes referred to herein individually as a "Party" and collectively as the "Parties". RECITALS A. Developer and City have entered into that Housing Agreement (Columbus Square) (the "Original Housing Agreement") dated as of June 20, 2005, as amended by that certain First Amendment to the Housing Agreement dated as of , 2010 (as amended, the "Housing Agreement") pursuant to which the Developer is required to construct a certain number of Affordable Housing Units and to provide for the sale and rental of these Affordable Housing Units to Senior Citizens at Affordable Rents to Very Low Income Households, Low Income Households and Moderate Income Households. Developer has also -1- obtained site plan and design review approval and a conditional use permit as approved by the Planning Commission by Resolution No. 4134. B. Conditions of the Affordable Housing Agreement, site plan and design review and conditional use permit require the Developer's agreement to enforce certain senior citizen housing and affordable senior housing restrictions. C. Developer owns, or intends to acquire, the real property legally described on Exhibit "A" attached hereto and incorporated herein (the "Property), and to construct improvements (the "Improvements") for a rental housing project on the Property (the "Project") to meet a portion of its obligations under the Housing Agreement. D. The "Developer" as used in this Agreement shall solely mean Tustin Coventry Seniors, LLC a California limited liability company, which is the Developer as of the effective date of this Agreement, or following any assignment approved by the City, any assignee of or successor of the Developer's rights, obligations, powers, and responsibilities required by this Agreement. E. In consideration of the City's agreement to support the Project pursuant to the Developer's commitments under the Housing Agreement, and for other good and valuable consideration, the receipt and sufficiency of which are hereby acknowledged, the City and the Developer now desire to enter into this Regulatory Agreement to set forth their agreement regarding the affordable housing restrictions for the Project and to cause said affordable housing restrictions to run with the land for the benefit of both the Agency and the City. AGREEMENT NOW, THEREFORE, the City and the Developer hereby agree as follows: 1. Definitions Capitalized terms used in this Regulatory Agreement, unless otherwise defined herein (including Exhibit `B" attached hereto), shall have the meanings specified in the Affordable Housing Agreement. 2. Development of the Project Site. 2.1 Permits and Governmental Approvals As part of the proposed construction of the Project, prior to any construction requiring a building permit for the Project, the Developer shall obtain all required City approvals, building permits and Design Review application approvals in accordance with the City of Tustin Municipal Code (the "City Code"), the Specific Plan, all Government Requirements and the Housing Agreement. 2.2 Local State and Federal Law. The Developer shall carry out the construction of the Project in conformity with the Housing Agreement, the City Code, the Specific Plan and all applicable Governmental Requirements. Specifically, and without limiting the foregoing, the -2- Developer shall at all times comply with all applicable federal and State labor rules including, but not limited to, any applicable prevailing wage requirements under California law. 2.3 Inspections. 2.3.1 During the construction of the Project, the City shall have the right to inspect all Improvements thereto, including but not limited to, dwelling unit interiors and the grounds of the Project for City and/or the State of California (the "State") building, housing and fire code and safety violations. Developer shall correct any such violations within a reasonable period of time after receiving written notice of a violation of any building, housing, fire or safety code applicable to the Project. 2.3.2 Upon completion of the construction work, the City shall have the right to conduct annual inspections of the Project, including the dwelling unit interiors and the grounds of the Project for City and/or. State building, housing and fire code and safety and occupancy violations. All rental agreements and contracts executed with the tenants in the Project shall include the right of the City to inspect the interior of the dwelling units upon forty- eight (48) hours notice. The City's Program Administrator ("Program Administrator") agrees to use its best efforts to cause representatives of City to coordinate annual inspections in conjunction with annual inspections by other agencies. 2.4 Time Limit for Construction. All Improvements on the Project shall be completed to the satisfaction of the Program Administrator in accordance with the Schedule of Performance which is attached as Exhibit C this Agreement, as may be modified by Program Administrator and Developer from time to time. The City may at its sole discretion, upon written request from the Developer, extend the times specified in the Schedule of Performance as evidenced by written notice and response from the Program Administrator. 3. Covenants Related to Affordable Housing. The Developer, for itself, its successors, its assigns and every successor in interest to the Property, hereby agrees, represents, warrants and covenants as follows: 3.1 Use of Very Low Income Low Income and Moderate Income Senior Citizen Units. Developer shall construct on the Property a 240 unit Senior Citizen independent living rental housing Project. The Project shall include not less than 36 Very Low Income Units, 61 Low Income Units and 56 Moderate Income Units to be rented to, occupied by, or held available only for rental to Senior Citizens in Very Low Income Households, Low Income Households and Moderate Income Households at an Affordable Rent subject to the age and occupancy restrictions contained in this Section 3 and the Housing Agreement. The remaining 88 units in the Project shall be rented at market rates to Senior Citizens with no restrictive covenants on rental rates. 3.2 Identification of Affordable Housing? Units. During the Qualified Project Period, occupancy of the Very Low Income Units, Low Income Units and Moderate Income Units shall -3- be dispersed throughout the Project in a manner approved by the City in order to avoid concentration of Very Low Income Units, Low Income Units and/or Moderate Income Units. The Very Low Income Units, Low Income Units and Moderate Income Units shall be allocated among the units as follows: Affordable Housing Unit Types Very Low Income Units Low Income Moderate Income Units Units Studio Units 1 Bedroom Units 36 44 2 Bedroom Units 17 56 3 Bedroom Units Totals 36 61 56 3.3 Renting Limited to Very Low Income Households Low Income Households and Moderate Income Households. The Affordable Housing Units shall be rented to eligible and qualified Very Low Income, Low Income and Moderate Income Households in accordance with the following terms: 3.3.1 Developer may not charge rent for an Affordable Housing Unit in excess of an Affordable Rent for such Affordable Housing Unit. 3.3.2 Only one qualified household shall be permitted to occupy and reside in a unit at any one time and said unit shall be used as the principal residence of the qualified household during the term of any lease and for no other purpose. A qualified household shall not lease or sublease the unit or its right of occupancy. 3.3.3 The number of persons permitted to occupy the Affordable Housing Unit shall not exceed the occupancy permitted pursuant to the general requirements of the United States Department of Housing and Urban Development, which as the date of this Agreement is two persons per bedroom, plus one person (i.e., for a two bedroom unit the maximum number of persons residing in the unit can be five persons). 3.3.4 Developer shall use its best efforts to fill vacancies of Very Low Income Units, Low Income Units and Moderate Income Units as soon as possible following the date the Affordable Housing Unit becomes available for renting, by renting the units to Very Low Income Households, Low Income Households and Moderate Income Households as applicable to such units. Should multiple tenants be equally eligible and qualified for a Very Low Income Unit, Low Income Unit or Moderate Income Unit, Developer shall lease available units to such eligible tenants on a first-come; first-served, and non-discriminatory basis. Developer shall notify the Program Administrator of any Affordable Housing Unit that either (a) fails to be leased within thirty (30) days after the issuance of a certificate of occupancy for the unit to a Very Low Income Household, Low Income Household or Moderate Income Household, as may -4- be applicable (the "Initial Leasing Period"), or (b) becomes available as a result of tenant vacation of the premises. 3.3.5 Developer shall create and maintain an "interest list" which includes all those potential Senior Citizen tenants who have expressed an interest in leasing a unit within the Project. The interest list shall designate whether a potential Senior Citizen tenant is in a Very Low Income Household, Low Income Household or Moderate Income Household. The interest list shall clearly designate whether such potential tenant will be receiving rental assistance under the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) Section 8 program. 3.3.6 An Affordable Housing Unit that either (a) fails to be leased within the Initial Leasing Period to a Very Low Income Household, Low Income Household or Moderate Income Household, as may be applicable, or (b) becomes available as a result of tenant vacation of the premises, shall be rented to a new eligible and qualified Senior Citizen tenant in accordance with the following procedure: 3.3.6.1 Developer shall make a reasonable effort to contact eligible and qualified prospective Senior Citizen tenants listed on the "interest list" created in Subsection 3.3.5 above, and Developer shall lease available units to such eligible tenants on a first-come, first-served, basis; 3.3.6.2 Each such eligible and qualified prospective Very Low Income ' Household(s), Low Income Household(s), or Moderate Income Household(s) shall have five (5) business days after being contacted by Developer to notify Developer of the tenant's intent to j accept the unit, and must thereafter execute a lease for the unit within seven (7) days of such acceptance; 3.3.6.3 Failure of the eligible and qualified prospective Very Low Income Household(s), Low Income Household(s), or Moderate Income Household(s) to timely notify Developer of accepting the unit or to thereafter timely execute a lease for the unit, shall be deemed a rejection of the unit, and Developer may seek other eligible tenants as set forth in Subsections 3.3.6 and 3.3.7 and following. 3.3.7 In the event the "interest list" maintained by Developer as provided in Section 3.3.5 does not include a prospective Senior Citizen tenant that is eligible and qualified as a tenant of a vacant Affordable Housing Unit, or in the event Developer is unable to lease a vacant Affordable Housing Unit after fully complying with the procedures set forth in Subsections 3.3.6, then Developer may lease the restricted unit to any eligible and qualified Very Low Income Household, Low Income Household or Moderate Income Household for the appropriate restricted unit. 3.3.8 Senior Citizens who are in Very Low Income Households, Low Income Households or Moderate Income Households who occupy Affordable Housing Units at the expiration of the Qualified Project Period and who qualify as Very Low Income Households, Low Income Households or Moderate Income Households on such date shall be permitted to continue to occupy those Affordable Housing Units for a period of one (1) year, beginning on the first day after the expiration of the Qualified Project Period; provided, however, that (i) -5- annual rent increases during such one (1) year period shall not exceed an amount equal to the existing rent for such unit plus an amount equal to the greater of five percent (5%) or (ii) the increase that would have been permitted had the Qualified Project Period not expired. Except as provided in the preceding sentence, upon the expiration of the Qualified Project Period, the Affordable Housing Units shall no longer be subject to the provisions of this Section 3. 3.3.9 The Developer agrees to provide to Very Low Income Households, Low Income Households and Moderate Income Households within the Project notice of all rent increases pursuant to all applicable Governmental Requirements, including rules and regulations of the State of California. 3.4 Rental Rates. Rental rates for all Affordable. Housing Units to which this Regulatory Agreement is applicable shall not exceed the higher of following: 3.4.1 The "Affordable Rent" for Very Low Income Households, Low Income Households and Moderate Income Households shall be as defined in Exhibit "B"; or 3.4.2 If the Senior Citizen in a Very Low Income Household or Low Income Household receives a federal or State rental subsidy and that Very Low Income Household or Low Income Household pays as a contribution toward rent no more than 30% of the household's adjusted income, then the maximum rent (i.e., tenant contribution plus any rental subsidy) is the fair market rent (FMR) allowable under the federal or State rental subsidy certificate or voucher program. To obtain the maximum monthly rent that may be charged to a qualified Tenant that is subject to this limitation, the Developer shall multiply the annual adjusted income of the qualified Tenant by 30 percent (30%) and divide by 12 and, if applicable, subtract a monthly allowance for any utilities and services (excluding telephone) to be paid by the tenant to be used in calculating the maximum rent allowed under this Subsection 3.4. 3.5 Voucher Holders. No Very Low Income Unit or Lower Income Unit shall be refused for leasing to a holder of a certificate or voucher under 24 CFR Part 982 Section 8 Rental Certificate Program or Section 8 Rental Voucher Program or to the holder of a comparable document evidencing participation in a tenant -based assistance program because of the status of the prospective Very Low Income Household or Low Income Household as a holder of such certificate of family participation, rental voucher, or comparable tenant -based assistance document. 3.6 Rent Schedule and Utility Allowances. The Program Administrator shall annually review, at Developer's sole cost, and approve rents proposed by the Developer for the Very Low Income Units, Low Income Units and Moderate Income Units to determine that the Developer has properly applied the restrictions contained in this Section 3 and shall provide the Developer with a schedule establishing the monthly allowances for utilities and services to be paid by the Very Low Income Households, Low Income Households and Moderate Income Households who occupy the Affordable Housing Units. The Developer shall re-examine the income of each tenant household living in the Affordable Housing Units at least annually. The maximum monthly rent shall be recalculated by the Developer and reviewed and approved by the Program Administrator annually, and may change as changes in the applicable gross rent -6- amounts, the income adjustments, or the monthly allowance for utilities and services warrant. The Developer shall not impose on a tenant an increase in rent approved by the Program Administrator if that increase is not permitted to be imposed under the lease between Developer and the tenant. Developer shall provide not less than sixty (60) days prior written notice to affected tenants before implementing any increase in rents. 3.7 Increases in Tenant Income. 3.7.1 If, as a result of the annual re-examination of incomes required pursuant to Subsection 3.10.2, the Developer determines that a household that qualified as a Very Low Income Household for purposes of Section 3.3 above, no longer is a Very Low Income Household but instead qualifies as a Low Income Household, then the Developer may require that household to pay the Affordable Rent for Low Income Senior Citizen Units, and the Developer shall lease the next available Lower Income Senior Citizen Unit or Moderate Income Senior Citizen Unit to a Very Low Income Household at the rent permitted under Section 3.3. 3.7.2 If, as a result of the annual re-examination of incomes required pursuant to Subsection 3.10.2, the Developer determines that a household that qualified as a Very Low Income Household for purposes of Section 3.3 above, no longer is a Very Low Income Household but instead qualifies as a Moderate Income Household, then the Developer may require that household to pay the Affordable Rent for. Moderate Income Senior Citizen Units, and the Developer shall lease the next available Moderate Income Senior Citizen Unit to a Very Low Income Household at the rent permitted under Section 3.3. �.� 3.7.3 If, as a result of the annual re-examination of incomes required pursuant to Subsection 3.10.2, the Developer determines that a household that qualified as a Low Income Household for purposes of Section 3.3 above, no longer is a Low Income Household but instead qualifies as a Moderate Income Household, then the Developer may require that household to pay the Affordable Rent for Moderate Income Households, and the Developer shall lease the next available Moderate Income Unit to a Low Income Household at the rent permitted under Section 3.3. 3.7.4 If, as a result of the annual re-examination of incomes required pursuant to Subsection 3.10.2, the Developer determines that a household that qualified as a Very Low Income Household, Low Income Household or Moderate Income Household for purposes of Section 3.3 above, no longer is a Very Low Income Household, Low Income Household or Moderate Income Household, then the Developer may require that household to pay the fair market rent, and the Developer shall lease the next available apartment unit in the Project to a VeryLow Income Household, Low Income Household or Moderate Income Household (whichever class of tenant the original Affordable Housing Unit was to be rented to) at the Affordable Rent for such Very Low Income Household, Low Income Household or Moderate Income Household. Such next available apartment unit shall then be deemed to be a Very Low Income Unit, Low Income Unit or Moderate Income Unit, as the case may be, subject to the provisions of this Section 3, and the previous unit shall no longer be subject to the provisions of this Section 3. 3.7.5 Notwithstanding the foregoing provisions, it is the intent of this Regulatory Agreement that the number of Very Low Income Units, Low Income Units and Moderate Income Units be allocated as among the Affordable Housing Units as provided in Section 3.2. In the event the foregoing provisions result in an allocation of Affordable Housing Units different from that provided in Section 3.2, Developer shall lease the next available Affordable Housing Unit to a Very Low Income Household, Low Income Household or Moderate Income Household, as the case may be, in order to correct the allocation. 3.8 Minimum Rents. Notwithstanding the other provisions of this Section 3, Developer shall not be required to charge a rent for a Very Low Income Unit, Low Income Unit or Moderate Income Unit that would be lower than the maximum rent Developer would have been permitted to charge for the Very Low Income Unit, Low Income Unit or Moderate Income Unit had the determination of maximum rent been made on the date the City and Developer entered into this Regulatory Agreement., 3.9 Tenant Protections. 3.9.1 Rental Agreement. The rental agreement between Developer and a Very Low Income Household, Low Income Household or Moderate Income Household must be for not less than one year, unless the Program Administrator provides prior written .approval, and may not contain any of the following provisions: 3.9.1.1 Any agreement by the tenant to be sued, to admit guilt, or to a judgment in favor of the Developer in a lawsuit brought in connection with the lease. 3.9.1.2 Any agreement by the tenant that the Developer may take, hold, or sell personal property of household members without notice to the tenant and a court decision on the rights of the parties. This prohibition, however, does not apply to an agreement by the tenant concerning disposition of personal property remaining in the Unit after the tenant has moved out of the Unit. The Developer may dispose of such personal property in accordance with applicable State law. 3.9.1.3 Any agreement by the tenant not to hold the Developer or its agents legally responsible for any action or failure to act, whether intentional or negligent. 3.9.1.4 Any agreement of the tenant that the Developer may evict the tenant or household members without notice to the tenant. 3.9.1.5 Any agreement by the tenant that the Developer may evict the tenant or household members without instituting a civil court proceeding in which the tenant has the opportunity to present a defense, or before a court decision on the rights of the parties. 3.9.1.6 Any agreement by the tenant to waive any right to a trial by jury. 3.9.1.7 Any agreement by the tenant to waive the tenant's right to appeal, or to otherwise challenge in court, a court decision in connection with the lease. -8- 3.9.1.8 Any agreement by the tenant to pay attorney's fees or other legal costs even if the tenant wins in a court proceeding by the Developer against the tenant. The tenant, however, may be obligated to pay costs if the tenant loses. 3.9.2 Termination of Tenancy. Developer may not terminate the tenancy or refuse to renew the lease of a Very Low Income Household, Low Income Household or Moderate Income Household except for violation of the terms and conditions of the lease; for violation of applicable federal, State, or local law; or for other good cause. Any termination or refusal to renew must. be preceded by not less than sixty (60) days by the Developer's service upon the tenant of a written notice specifying the grounds for the action. 3.10 Very Low Income Low Income and Moderate Income Senior Citizen Tenants; Records and Reports. The Developer hereby represents, warrants and covenants as follows: 3.10.1 Within thirty (3 0) days after the date on which at least fifty percent (50%) of the dwelling units in the Project are first occupied, the Developer shall execute and deliver to the Program Administrator a copy of a certificate identifying said date and the beginning date and earliest ending date of the Qualified Project Period, which certificate shall be in the form provided by Program Administrator or otherwise approved by Program Administrator. The Developer shall record a copy of such certificate in the Official Records. 3.10.2 The Developer shall obtain, complete and maintain on file Verifications of Income and age qualification, in the form provided by Program Administrator, from each Very Low Income Household, Low Income Household and Moderate Income Household, including (i) a Verification of Income and Age dated immediately prior to the initial occupancy of such Very Low Income Household, Low Income Household or Moderate Income Household and (ii) thereafter, annual Verifications of Income and Age which must be dated as of June 1 st of each year, or such other date as may be mutually agreed upon by the Program Administrator and the Developer, and in no event less than once in every twelve-month period following each Very Low Income Household's, Low Income Household's and Moderate Income Household's occupancy of a Unit in the Project. 3.10.3 A copy of the most recent Verification of Income and Senior Citizen age qualification for Very Low Income Household, Low Income Household and Moderate Income Household commencing occupation or continuing occupation of a Very Low Income Unit, Low Income Unit or Moderate Income Unit (and not previously filed) shall be attached to the Certificate of Continuing Program Compliance, in the form provided by Program Administrator, which is to be filed with the Program Administrator no later than the fifteenth (151') day of each month following the receipt by the Program Administrator of the Completion Certificate to and including the month in which such report indicates that fifty percent (50%) of the units in the Project are occupied by Senior Citizens in Very Low Income Households, Low Income Households and Moderate Income Households and, thereafter, no later than the first day of the sixth month of each calendar year until the end of the Qualified Project Period. -9- 3.10.4 The Developer shall make a diligent and good -faith effort to verify that the information provided by an applicant in the Verification of Income and Senior Citizen age qualification information is accurate by taking the following steps, as a part of the verification process: (1) obtain copy of Birth Certificate or other evidence of tenant's qualifying age acceptable to the Program Administrator; (2) obtain pay stubs for the most recent one-month period, and; (3) obtain income W-2 Wage and Earning Statements and tax returns for the most recent tax year; alternatively, if determined appropriate for the tenant's situation the following may be submitted (a) income verification from the Social Security Administration and/or the California Department of Social Services if the applicant receives assistance from either of such agencies; or (b) if the applicant is unemployed, does not have income tax returns or is otherwise unable to provide other forms of verification as required above, obtain another form of independent verification satisfactory to the Program Administrator. 3.10.5 The Developer will maintain complete and accurate records pertaining to the Very Low Income Units, Low Income Units and Moderate Income Units and will permit any duly authorized representative of the City, without limitation, to inspect the books and records of the Developer pertaining to the Project, including those records pertaining to the occupancy of the Affordable Housing Units. 3.10.6 The Developer will prepare and submit to the Program Administrator no later than the first day of the sixth month of each calendar year until the end of the Qualified Project Period, a Certificate of Continuing Program Compliance executed by the Developer with the following information: 3.10.6.1 The number of the dwelling units of the Project which were occupied, pursuant to Section 3.1 above, by Very Low Income Households, Low Income Households and Moderate Income Households during such period and such other tenant information as may be reasonably required as stated on the form of the Certificate of Continuing Program Compliance acceptable to the Program Administrator; and 3.10.6.2 A statement that either (i) no unremedied default has occurred under this Regulatory Agreement or (ii) a default has occurred, in which event the Certificate shall describe the nature of the default in detail and set forth the measures being taken by the Developer to remedy such default. 3.10.7 Each lease or rental agreement for an Affordable Housing Unit shall contain a provision to the effect that the Developer has relied on the Verification of Income and Senior Citizen age qualification and supporting information supplied by the Very Low Income Household, Low Income Household or Moderate Income Household in determining qualification for occupancy of the Very Low Income Units, Low Income Units and Moderate Income Units and that any material misstatement in such verification (whether or not intentional) will be cause for immediate termination of such lease or rental agreement. Each such lease or rental agreement shall also provide (and shall so disclose to the tenant) that the tenant's income is subject to annual verification in accordance with Section 10.2, and that, if upon review of any such verification, the tenant's income exceeds the then applicable income limit for a Very Low Income, Low Income or Moderate Income Household, such tenant shall cease to qualify as a -10- Low Income Household, Low Income Household, or Moderate Income Household and, as a consequence, said Tenant's lease shall be subject to termination on such prior notice as the Program Administrator deems reasonable. 3.10.8 Local Workforce Housing Preference Policy. In marketing and renting units to Very Low Income, Low Income and Moderate Income Senior Citizen Tenants, the Developer shall establish a priority system that ensures that prospective rental applicants who are currently employed in or currently residing in the City of Tustin have priority over an applicant that does not currently reside or is not employed in the City of Tustin (hereinafter referred to as the "Local. Preference Policy", adopted by the Tustin City Council on November 6, 2007). To qualify for the Local Preference, Developer shall require an applicant to demonstrate a minimum of six months of current employment or current residency in Tustin. The Developer shall refer to the Local Preference Policy for detailed information required to be submitted by Developer for verification of residency and local employment and to ensure Developer's compliance with the Local Preference Policy. 3.11 Termination of Affordable Housing Covenants. The provisions of this Section 3 shall terminate in their entirety at the end of one year following the expiration of the Qualified Project Period. 4. Non -Discrimination Covenants. The Developer for itself, its successors, its assigns and every successor in interest to the Project Site or any part thereof jointly and severally, hereby represents, warrants and covenants as follows: 4.1 Obligation to Refrain from Discrimination. There shall be no discrimination against or segregation of any person or group of persons, on account of race, color, creed, religion, sex, sexual orientation, marital status, national origin or ancestry in the sale, lease, sublease, transfer, use, occupancy, tenure or enjoyment of the Project Site or any portion thereof, nor shall the Developer itself or any person claiming under or through it (including any tenant) establish or permit any such practice or practices of discrimination or segregation with reference to the selection, location, number, use or occupancy of tenants, lessees, subtenants, sublessees or vendees of the Project Site or any portion thereof. All deeds, leases or contracts shall contain or be subject to substantially the following non-discrimination or non -segregation clauses: 4. 1.1 In deeds: "The grantee herein covenants by and for itself, its successors and assigns, and all persons claiming under or through them, that there shall be no discrimination against or segregation of, any person or group of persons on account of race, color, creed, religion, sex, sexual orientation, marital status, national origin or ancestry in the sale, lease, sublease, transfer, use, occupancy, tenure or enjoyment of the land herein conveyed, nor shall the grantee itself or any person claiming under or through it, establish or permit any such practice or practices of discrimination or segregation with reference to the selection, location, number, use or occupancy of tenants, lessees, subtenants, sublessees or vendees in the land herein conveyed. The foregoing covenants shall run with the land." -11- 4.1.2 In leases: "The lessee herein covenants by and for itself, its successors and assigns, and all per sons. claiming under or through them, and this lease is made and accepted upon and subject to the following conditions: "That there shall be no discrimination against or segregation of any person or group of persons, on account of race, color, creed, religion, sex, sexual orientation, marital status, national origin or ancestry in the leasing, subleasing, renting, transferring, use, occupancy, tenure or enjoyment of the land herein leased, nor shall lessee itself, or any person claiming under or through it, establish or permit such practice or practices of discrimination or segregation with reference to the selection, location, number, use or occupancy of tenants, lessees, sublessees, subtenants or vendees in the land herein leased." 4.1.3 In contracts: "There shall be no discrimination against or segregation of any person or group of persons on account of race, color, creed, religion, sex, sexual orientation, marital status, national origin or ancestry in the sale, lease, sublease, transfer, use, occupancy, tenure or enjoyment of the land, nor shall the transferee itself or any person claiming under or through it, establish or permit any such practice or practices of discrimination or segregation with reference to the selection, location, number, use or occupancy of tenants, lessees, subtenants, sublessees or vendees of the land." 5. Maintenance of the Proiect. The Developer and its successors and assigns shall maintain at their cost the Property as follows: 5.1 Minimum Standards. Prior to construction of any units on the Property, the Property shall at all times be maintained in a clean and weed -free condition, reasonably free from any debris and waste materials. 5.2 During Construction. From the date upon which construction begins of any Improvements until issuance of a completion certificate for any such Improvements, the Developer and its successors and assigns shall maintain the Property and Improvements under construction consistent with best construction industry practice. 5.3 Following Construction 5.3.1 Upon completion of construction of the Improvements, the Housing Agreement and this Agreement on the Property, the Developer, its successors and assigns shall maintain the Improvements in the same aesthetic and same condition or better as the condition of such Improvements at the time the City issues a Certificate of Compliance, reasonable wear and tear excepted. The standard for the quality of maintenance of the Project Improvements required by this Section 5.3.1 shall be met whether or not a specific item of maintenance is listed below. However, representative items of maintenance shall include: (i) maintenance, repair and replacement on a regular schedule, consistent with like developments in Orange County, of private streets, roads, drives, bike paths, alleyways, sidewalks, utilities (except to the extent owned or controlled by a utility franchisee) common areas, landscaping, hardscaped areas and fountains; (ii) frequent and regular inspection for graffiti or damage or deterioration or failure, and immediate repainting or repair or replacement of all surfaces, fencing, walls, equipment, etc., -12- as necessary; (iii) emptying of trash receptacles and removal of litter; (iv) regular sweeping of roadways and sidewalks throughout the Property; (v) fertilizing and replacing vegetation as necessary; (vi) cleaning windows on a regular basis; (vi) painting the buildings on a regular program and prior to the deterioration of the painted surfaces; (vii) conducting roof inspections on a regular basis and maintaining roofs in a leak -free and weather -tight condition. 5.3.2 Upon completion of construction of Improvements as provided in the Housing Agreement and this Agreement on the Property, Developer shall maintain, repair and replace all or any portion of the Improvements as may be required to maintain the Improvements in a high quality condition. All Improvements repaired or replaced under this Subsection 5.3.2 shall be repaired or replaced with materials, apparatus and facilities of quality at least equal to the quality of the materials, apparatus and facilities identified for the Improvements under the Regulatory Agreement. 5.3.3 Developer's obligations to maintain the Improvements as provided in this Section 5.3 shall include, but not be limited to, the following: 5.3.3.1 Maintaining all paved surfaces, including streets, drives, parking areas and curbs of the common areas in a smooth and evenly covered condition, which maintenance work shall include without limitation, cleaning, sweeping, re -striping, repairing and resurfacing of the paved surfaces using surface material of an appearance and quality equal or superior to the materials installed under the DDA and this Regulatory Agreement; 5.3.3.2 Removal of all papers, debris, filth and refuse, and washing and sweeping the common areas to the extent necessary to keep the Project Site in a first-class, clean and orderly condition, and washing down and/or cleaning all hard surfaces including brick, metal, concrete, glass, wood and other structural members as required; 5.3.3.3 Operating, keeping in repair, cleaning and replacing and/or re - ballasting all common area lighting fixtures, equipment and facilities as may be reasonably required, including all lighting necessary or appropriate for the Project Site and Project Improvements, security and exterior lights intended to illuminate the Project Site and Project Improvements; 5.3.3.4 Cleaning and maintaining all landscaped areas, including landscape planting areas, lawn areas and planters around and adjacent to exterior walls of buildings, repairing automatic sprinklers, weeding, pruning, fertilizing and making replacement of shrubs and other landscaping as required; and 5.3.3.5 Maintaining, repairing and replacing as necessary any freestanding, monument or pylon signs on the Property. 5.4 Failure to Maintain. In the event the Developer or its successors or assigns fails to maintain the Improvements in accordance with the standard for the quality of maintenance, City representatives or the Program Administrator and its designee shall have the right but not the obligation to enter the Property upon thirty (30) days notice to the Developer or its successor -13- or assigns, to correct any violation, and hold the Developer, and/or such successors or assigns, responsible for the cost thereof, and such cost, until paid, shall constitute a lien on the applicable portion of the Property. 5.5 Assignment of Obligation to Maintain. The Developer may, subject to. the prior approval of the Program Administrator, which approval shall not be unreasonably withheld, assign the maintenance responsibilities contained herein to the subsequent purchasers of the Property, a portion of the Property, or individual buildings thereon, or to any Homeowners Association to be created, through appropriate covenants, conditions and restrictions to be .recorded against one or more Parcels, upon which assignment the Developer shall have no further liability under this Section 5. 6. Sale or Transfer of the Project. The Developer hereby covenants and agrees not to voluntarily sell, transfer or otherwise dispose of th- Property, or any portion thereof (other than for individual tenant use as contemplated hereunder), without obtaining the prior written consent of the Program Administrator. It is hereby expressly stipulated and agreed that any sale, transfer or other disposition of the Property in violation of this Section 6 shall • be null, void, and shall be ineffective to relieve the Developer of its obligations under the Housing Agreement and this Regulatory. Agreement. Any transfer of the Project to any entity, whether or not affiliated with the Developer, shall be subject to the provisions of this Section 6. The provisions of this Section 6 shall terminate in their entirety at the end of one year following the expiration of the Qualified Project Period. 7. Term. This Regulatory Agreement and all and each of the provisions hereof shall become effective upon its execution and delivery and shall remain in full force and effect thereafter except as expressly provided herein. It is expressly agreed and understood that the provisions of this Regulatory Agreement are intended to survive the Housing Agreement. 8. Covenants and Restrictions to Run with the Land. 8.1 Developer States that: all covenants and restrictions contained in this Regulatory Agreement are intended to be covenants running with the land, and shall, in any event, and without regard to technical classification or designation, legal or otherwise, be, to the fullest extent permitted by law and equity, binding for the benefit and in favor of, and enforceable by the City, and its respective successors and assigns, against Developer, its successors and assigns, to or of the Property or any portion thereof or any interest therein, and any party in possession or occupancy of said Property or portion thereof. 8.2 The parties acknowledge and agree that all covenants and restrictions contained in this Regulatory Agreement are intended to be covenants running with the land of the entire Property. Without in any way limiting the foregoing, each of the parties hereto shall execute and deliver at their own cost and expense, any and all additional papers, documents, or instruments, and shall do any and all acts and things reasonably necessary or appropriate in connection with -14- the performance of their respective obligations hereunder in order to carry out the intent and purposes of this Regulatory Agreement. 8.3 In amplification and not in restriction of the provisions set forth hereinabove, Developer specifically states that it is intended and agreed that the City shall be deemed a beneficiary of the agreements, covenants and restrictions herein both for and in its own right and also for the purposes of protecting the interests of the community. All covenants and restrictions without regard to technical classification or designation shall be binding for the benefit of the City, and such covenants and restrictions shall run in favor of City for the entire period during which such covenants and restrictions shall be in force and effect, without regard to whether the City is or remains an owner of any land or interest therein to which such covenants and restrictions relate. The City shall have the independent right, in the event of any breach of this Regulatory Agreement or covenant or restriction herein, to exercise all the rights and remedies, and to maintain any action at law or suit in equity or other proper proceedings to enforce the curing of such breach of this Regulatory Agreement or covenants or restrictions. 8.4 The City and its successors and assigns, and Developer and the permitted successors and assigns of Developer in and to all or any part of the fee title to the Property and the Project, shall have the right upon written agreement signed by both parties to consent and agree to changes in, or to eliminate in whole or in part, any of the covenants or restrictions contained in this Regulatory Agreement without the consent of any tenant, lessee, easement holder, licensee, mortgagee, trustee, beneficiary under a deed of trust, or any other person or entity having any interest less than a fee in the Property or the Project. The covenants and restrictions contained in this Regulatory Agreement, without regard to technical classification shall not benefit or be enforceable by any owner of any other real property within or outside the Property or Project, or any person or entity having any interest in any other such realty. 8.5 No breach of any of the provisions of this Regulatory Agreement shall impair, defeat or render invalid the lien of any Mortgage made in good faith and for value encumbering the Property or Project or any portion thereof. 9. Burden and Benefit. The City and the Developer hereby declare their understanding and intent that the burden of the covenants and restrictions set forth herein touch and concern the Property in that the Developer's legal interest in the Property is rendered less valuable thereby. The Developer hereby further declares its understanding and intent that the benefit of such covenants and restrictions touching and concerning the land is the enhancement and enjoyment and use of the Project by Very Low Income Households, Low Income Households and Moderate Income Households, the intended beneficiaries of such covenants, reservations and restrictions, and by furthering the public purposes for which the Housing Agreement was entered into with Developer. -15- 10. Uniformity, Common Plan. The covenants, reservations and restrictions hereof shall apply uniformly to the entire Property in order to establish and carry out a common plan for the use, development and improvement of the Project Site. 11. Default Enforcement. 11.1 Default. Developer shall be in Default under this Regulatory Agreement if any of the following occur: Property; 11.1.1 A Default occurs under the Housing Agreement as it relates to the 11. 1.2 A Default occurs under any deed of trust or mortgage against the Property; 11.1.3 The Developer or its successor in interest fails to perform fully any of its obligations set forth in this Regulatory Agreement within thirty (30) days following receipt of written notice regarding such other default; provided, that if such failure is capable of being remedied but not capable of being remedied within thirty (30) days, then the defaulting party shall have an additional period of time within which to remedy such failure, not in any event to exceed sixty (60) days. The failure of a City representative or the Program Administrator to notify Developer or its successor in interest of any such default shall not be deemed a waiver of the default, and the City shall have no obligation to notify the defaulting party of the default. 11.2 Remedies. Following a Default described in Subsection 11.1, the City may pursue all of its rights and remedies set forth in the Housing Agreement or this Regulatory Agreement or otherwise available at law, in equity or by statute. The City's rights and remedies shall be cumulative and no one of such rights and remedies shall be exclusive of any of the others, or of any right or remedy at law or in equity which the City might otherwise have by virtue under this Agreement and the exercise of one such right or remedy by the City shall not impair the City's standing to exercise any other right or remedy. The parties agree that this Regulatory Agreement may be specifically enforced: 11.2.1 In the event of a Default by the Developer or its successor in interest, under any mortgage or deed of trust, the City shall have the right, but not the obligation, to perform the unperformed obligations at the expense of Developer, and all expenditures by City to cure such default shall accrue interest from the date such sums are actually spent by City at a default rate equal to the then "prime rate" specified by Wells Fargo Bank or its successor plus three percent (3%), but not in excess of such rate as may be permitted under applicable law. Payment shall be made by Developer to City within thirty (30) days after written request thereof. If payment is not made by Developer within thirty (30) days after such demand is made then City shall have the right to add such amount, to any sums then due or thereafter becoming due from Developer under the this Regulatory Agreement. In addition, the amount due to the City shall constitute a lien and charge upon the fee interest of Developer to Property and City shall have the right to record a notice (a "Delinquency Notice") against the Property, which states the amount due from the Developer. The aforesaid lien shall attach immediately upon recordation of the -16- Delinquency Notice. A copy of the Delinquency Notice shall be delivered to Developer pursuant ( to Section 14.4. The lien may be foreclosed by appropriate action in court or in the manner prescribed law. Upon such event, the Developer shall be required to pay all attorney fees and costs and expenses of City in connection with the preparation, recordation and foreclosure of such lien. Any such lien shall be prior to all encumbrances, liens, or charges on the Property except (a) taxes which are by law prior thereto; (b) the rights of tenants pursuant to bona fide leases; and (c) any permitted mortgage and advances thereunder made in good faith and for value and recorded prior to the Delinquency Notice. The transfer of the Property shall not affect the aforesaid lien. 11.2.2 Non -Complying Affordable Housing Units. In addition to and without limitation of any other rights and remedies set forth in this Regulatory Agreement or otherwise available to any party legally entitled to enforce this Regulatory Agreement, if a Default with respect to Section 3 occurs, and (i) if the Default is not cured within thirty (30) days after notice by City is provided to Developer, or (ii) if such Default cannot reasonably be cured within the thirty (30) day period and Developer has not commenced the curing of such Default, or if Developer is not otherwise diligently prosecuting such cure to completion, then City shall have the right to lease and Developer shall lease to City on demand for a rental of $1.00 per Unit per year any and all of the "Non -Complying Affordable Housing Units" at such time as the Non - Complying Affordable Housing Unit(s) is vacated. Notwithstanding any term or condition of the lease under which the City leases a Non -Complying Affordable Housing Unit pursuant to this Subsection 11.2, Developer hereby consents to and grants City the right to assign such lease or sublet such Umt(s) to a Very Low Income Household, Low Income Household or Moderate Income Household at the Affordable Rent for Very Low Income Unit(s), Low Income Unit(s) or Moderate Income Unit(s), or to any non-profit housing provider qualified as a 501 (c)(3) entity under the Internal Revenue Code (a "Provider") in the community for $1.00 per year. The assignment or sublet to a Provider shall be on the condition that such Provider subleases such Affordable Housing Unit(s), or assigns such lease(s) to a Very Low Income Household, Low Income Household or Moderate Income Senior Citizen Tenant at the Affordable Rent. If the City assigns or sublets to any Provider, notwithstanding any term or condition of the lease between the Developer and the City, the Developer hereby consents to and grants such Provider the right to assign such lease or sublet such Affordable Housing Unit to any Very Low Income Household, Low Income Household or Moderate Income Household at an Affordable Rent. If the City leases any Affordable Housing Unit(s) or a Provider subleases any Affordable Housing Unit(s) or is the assignee of any lease(s) from the City, the City or Provider, as the case may be, to the extent necessary to ensure compliance with Section 3 hereof, shall sublease such Assisted Unit(s) or assign such lease(s) to any Very Low Income Household, Low Income Household or Moderate Income Household at the Affordable Rent. Any rent paid under such a sublease or assignment shall be paid to the Developer after the City or Provider, as the case may be, has been reimbursed for any reasonable expenses incurred by it in connection with exercising the rights and remedies set forth in this Subsection 11.2.2; provided however, if the Developer is in Default under any Permitted Mortgage representing Senior Obligations, the Deeds of Trust and/or any other City approved encumbrance under the DDA in connection with the financing of the Property or any Improvements thereon, such rent shall be paid to the party legally entitled thereto under the terms of the applicable loan. -17- 12. Recording and Filing. The Developer shall cause this Regulatory Agreement, and all amendments and supplements hereto and thereto, to be recorded and filed in the Official Records and in such other places as the Program Administrator may reasonably request. The Developer shall pay all fees and charges incurred in connection with any such recording. Written evidence of the recorded Regulatory Agreement shall be provided to the Program Administrator. 13. Indemnification Developer shall defend, indemnify and hold harmless City and their respective officers, officials, agents, employees, representatives, and volunteers from and against all loss, damage, costs, expenses, liability, claim or judgment relating in any manner to Developer performance under this Agreement, except to the extent cause by the sole gross negligence or willful misconduct of City. 14. Miscellaneous. 14.1 Governing Law. This Regulatory Agreement shall be governed by, interpreted under, construed and enforced in accordance with the laws of the State of California. 14.2 Amendments This Agreement shall be amended only by written instrument executed by the parties hereto, or their successors in title and duly recorded in the Official Records. 14.3 Waiver. No waiver of any provision or consent to any action under this Regulatory Agreement shall constitute a waiver of any other provision or consent to any other action, whether or not similar. No waiver or consent shall constitute a continuing waiver or consent or commit a party to provide a waiver in the future except to the extent specifically set forth in writing. Any waiver given by a party shall be null and void if the party requesting such waiver has not provided a full and complete disclosure of all material facts relevant to the waiver requested. 14.4 Notices. All notices, demands, consents, requests and other communications required or permitted to be given under this Regulatory Agreement shall be in writing and shall be deemed conclusively to have been duly given (a) when hand delivered to the other party; (b) three (3) business days after such notice has been sent by United States mail via certified mail, return receipt requested, postage prepaid, and addressed to the other party as set forth below; or (c) the next business day after such notice has been deposited with a national overnight delivery service reasonably approved by the parties (Federal Express and Airborne Express are deemed approved by the parties), postage prepaid, addressed to the party to whom notice is being sent as set forth below with next -business -day delivery guaranteed, provided that the sending party receives a confirmation of delivery from the delivery service provider. Unless otherwise provided in writing, all notices hereunder shall be addressed as follows: -18- Developer: Tustin Coventry Seniors, LLC Attention: John Huskey 1640 Sepulveda Blvd. Suite 425 Los Angeles, CA 90025 City: City of Tustin 300 Centennial Way Tustin, CA 92780 Attn: Assistant City Manager With copy to: Clay Guntz Special Counsel Manatt, Phelps & Phillips, LLC One Embarcadero Center, 30`x' Floor San Francisco, CA 94111 Douglas HolIand City Attorney Woodruff, Spradlin & Smart 555 Anton Blvd. Suite 1200 Costa Mesa, California 92626 14.5 Severability. Any provision of this Regulatory Agreement that is deemed to be illegal, invalid or unenforceable by an arbitrator or court of competent jurisdiction shall be ineffective to the extent of the invalidity or unenforceability of such provision and shall be deemed stricken from this Regulatory Agreement. Any stricken provision shall not affect the legality, enforceability or validity of the remainder of this Regulatory Agreement. If any provision or part thereof of this Regulatory Agreement is stricken in accordance with the provisions of this Section, then the stricken provision shall be replaced, to the extent possible, with a legal, enforceable and valid provision that is as similar in tenor and intent to the stricken provision as is legally possible. Any such invalidity or unenforceability of any provision in any jurisdiction shall not invalidate or render unenforceable such provision in any other jurisdiction. 14.6 Authorityof Signatories to Regulatory Agreement. Each person executing this Regulatory Agreement represents and warrants that he or she is duly authorized and has legal capacity to execute and deliver this Regulatory Agreement on behalf of the parties for which execution is made. Each party represents and warrants to the other that the execution of this Regulatory Agreement and the performance of such party's obligations hereunder have been duly authorized and that the agreement is a valid and legal agreement binding on such party and enforceable in accordance with its terms. -19- 14.7 Consent to Jurisdiction. The parties hereto agree that all actions or proceedings arising in connection with this Regulatory Agreement shall be tried and litigated exclusively in the state and federal courts located in the County of Orange, State of California. This choice of venue is intended by the parties to be mandatory and not permissive in nature, thereby precluding the possibility of litigation between or among the parties with respect to or arising out of this Regulatory Agreement in any jurisdiction other than that specified in this Section. Each party hereto waives any right that it may have to assert the doctrine forum non conveniens or similar doctrine or to object to venue with respect to any proceeding brought in accordance with this section, and stipulates that the state and federal courts located in the County of Orange, State of California, shall have in personam jurisdiction and venue over each of them for the purpose of litigating any dispute, controversy or proceeding arising out of this Regulatory Agreement. Each party hereby authorizes and accepts service of process sufficient for personal jurisdiction in any action against it as contemplated by this section by means of registered or certified mail, return receipt requested, postage prepaid, to its address for the giving of notices as set forth in this Regulatory Agreement, or in the manner set forth in the section of this Regulatory Agreement pertaining to notice. Any final judgment rendered against the party in any action or proceeding shall be conclusive as to the subject of such final judgment and may be enforced in other jurisdictions in any manner provided by law. 14.8 Recitals. The recitals set forth at the beginning of this Regulatory Agreement of any matters or facts shall be conclusive proof of the truthfulness thereof and the terms and conditions set forth in the recitals, if any, shall be deemed a part of this Regulatory Agreement. 14. 9 Captions. All captions, titles or headings of the articles, sections, paragraphs or subparagraphs of this Regulatory Agreement are inserted solely as a matter of convenience of the parties hereto, and for reference, shall not be deemed to be a part of this Regulatory Agreement, and shall not define, limit, extend or describe the scope of this Regulatory Agreement nor be used or construed in the interpretation or determination of the validity of this Regulatory Agreement or any provision hereof. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the City of Tustin and the Developer have executed this Regulatory Agreement and Declaration of Restrictive Covenants by duly authorized representatives, all as of the date first written above. -20- Dated: APPROVED AS TO FORM By: By: Doug Holland, City Attorney Clay Gantz, Special Tustin Counsel CITY OF TUSTIN: William A. Huston, City Manager TUSTIN• COMMUNITY REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY -21- William A. Huston Executive Director DEVELOPER: TUSTIN COVENTRY SENIORS, LLC By: Its Managing Partner By: Title: By: Title: -22- John M. Huskey EXHIBIT A LEGAL DESCRIPTION PROJECT SITE That certain real property located in the City of Tustin, County of Orange, State of California, and legally described as follows: Lot 265 of Tract No. 16581, in the City of Tustin, County of Orange, State of California, as shown on the map recorded in Book 877 Pages 33 through 50 inclusive Miscellaneous Maps, in the office of the county recorder of Orange County. Excepting therefrom all oil, oil rights, mineral rights, natural gas rights, and other hydrocarbons by whatsoever name known, geothermal steam and all products derived from any of the foregoing, that may be within or under the parcel of land hereinabove described, together with the perpetual right of drilling, mining or expldring and operating therefore and storing in and removing same from said land or any other land, including the right to whipstock or directionally drill or mine from lands other than those hereinafter described, oil or gas wells, tunnels and shafts into, through or across the subsurface of the land hereinabove described, and to bottom such whipstocked or directionally drilled wells, tunnels and shafts under and beneath or beyond the exterior limits thereof, and to redrill, retunnel, equip, maintain, repair, deepen and operate any such wells or mines without, however, the right to drill, mine, store, explore or operate through the surface or the upper 500 feet of the subsurface of the land, as reserved by Moffett Meadows Partners, LLC, by deed recorded July 25, 2005 as Instrument Nos. 2005000590846, 2005000591024 and 2005000591381, all of Official Records. EXHIBIT B GLOSSARY.OF DEFINED TERMS For purposes of this Regulatory Agreement, the following initially capitalized terms shall mean the following: "Act" means Chapter 8 (commencing with Section 33750) of Part 1 of Division 24 of the Health and Safety Code of the State of California, as amended. "Affordable Housing Agreement" shall mean the agreement entered into between the Developer and City as required by the Housing Agreement which identified specific restrictions to insure affordability of rental and for -sale Affordable Housing Units at Tustin Legacy and as required by the Regulatory Agreement. "Affordable Housing Units" means the units to be rented to, occupied by or held available for Very Low, Lower or Moderate Income Households at an Affordable Rent as described in Section 3 and in the Regulatory Agreement. "Affordable Rent" shall mean for any for -rent Affordable Housing Unit, a maximum monthly rent or lease price that does not exceed the Affordable Rent for a Very Low Income Household, a Low or Lower Income Household, or a Moderate Income Household, as specifically applicable. The Affordable Rent shall be calculated as of the date of rent of the unit and shall take into account and include a reasonable allowance for utilities and in an amount not in excess of: (a) For "Very Low Income Units," as more particularly defined in Health and Safety Code Section 50053 (b)(2) and as generally described herein as a monthly rent which does not exceed one -twelfth of the product of thirty percent (30%) times fifty percent (50%) of the annual Orange County Median Income, adjusted for family size appropriate for the unit, including a reasonable utility allowance. (b) For "Low or Lower Income Units," as more particularly defined in Health and Safety Code Section 50053 (b)(3) and as generally described herein as applicable to those low income or Lower Income Households whose gross incomes exceed the maximum income for Very Low Income Households as the product of thirty percent (30%) times sixty percent (60%) of the annual Orange County Median Income, adjusted for family size appropriate for the units, including a reasonable utility allowance. (c) For "Moderate Income Units," as more particularly defined in Health and Safety Code Section 50053 (b)(4), and as generally described herein as the product of thirty percent (30%) times one hundred and ten percent (110%) of the annual Orange County Median Income adjusted for family size appropriate for the units, including a reasonable utility allowance Notwithstanding the foregoing, in accordance with Health and Safety Code Section 50053 (b) (4), the City has determined and hereby agrees that, for a Moderate Income Household with annual gross incomes that exceed one hundred and ten percent (110%) of the annual Orange County Median Income, adjusted for family size appropriate for the unit, a maximum monthly (; rent shall be calculated as not to exceed one twelfth of thirty percent (30%) times one hundred and twenty percent (120%) of the annual Orange County Median Income, adjusted for family size. "Certificate of Continuing Program Compliance" means the annual report of occupancy for the Affordable Housing Units including the verification of income provided by Developer to Agency as described in Section 3.10.6 hereof or such other form as may be prescribed by the Agency. "Completion Certificate" means the notice of completion of construction filed by Developer, a copy of which shall also be concurrently delivered to the City and Agency by the Developer. "Developer" means Marble Mountain Partners, LLC, and its permitted successors and assigns. "Gross Income" means as it is defined by California Code of Regulations Title 25, §6914 as the anticipated income of a person or family for the twelve-month period following the date of determination of income. To make the projection, "a 'snapshot' of the household's current circumstances is used to project future income. Today's circumstances should be assumed to continue for the next 12 months unless there is verifiable evidence to the contrary. Income, as defined in §6914, shall include, but not be limited to: 1) The gross amount, before any payroll deductions, of wages and salaries, overtime pay, commissions, fees, tips and bonuses: 2) The net income from operation of a business or profession or from rental or real or personal property (for this purpose, expenditures for business expansion or amortization of capital indebtedness shall not be ' deducted to determine the net income from a business); 3) Interest and dividends; 4) The full amount of periodic payments received from social security, annuities, insurance policies, retirement funds, pensions, disability or death benefits and other similar types of periodic receipts; 5) Payments in lieu of earnings, such as unemployment and disability compensation, worker's compensation and severance pay (but see subdivision (b)(3)). 6) Public Assistance. If the public assistance payment includes an amount specifically designated for shelter and utilities which is subject to adjustment by the public assistance agency in accordance with the actual cost of shelter and utilities, the amount of public assistance income to be included as income shall consist of: a. The amount of the allowance or grant exclusive of the amount specifically designated for shelter and utilities, plus b. The maximum amount which the public assistance agency could in fact allow for the family for shelter and utilities, 7) Periodic and determinable allowances such as alimony and child support payments, and regular contributions or gifts received from persons not residing in the dwelling; and 8) All regular pay, special pay and allowances of a member of the Armed Forces (whether or not living in the dwelling) who is head of the family or spouse (but see subdivision (b)(5)). The following items, asdefined in §6914, shall not be considered as gross income: 1) Casual, sporadic and irregular gifts (includes casual, sporadic and irregular income under this exclusion); 2) Amounts which are specifically for or in reimbursement of the cost of medical expenses; 3) Lump -sum additions to family assets, such as inheritances, insurance payments (including payments under health and accident insurance' and worker's compensation), capital gains and settlement for personal or property losses; 4) Amounts of educational scholarships paid directly to the student or to the educational institution, and amounts paid by the government to a veteran for use in meeting the costs of tuition, fees, books and equipment. Any amounts of such scholarships, or payments to veterans not used for the above purposes of which are available for subsistence are to included in income; 5) The special pay to a serviceman head of a family away from home and exposed to hostile fire; 6) Relocation payments made pursuant to federal, state, or local relocation law; 7) Foster child care payments 8) The value of coupon allotments for the purchase of food pursuant to the Food Stamp Act of 1964 which is in excess of the amount actually charged the eligible household; and 9) Payments received pursuant to participation in the following volunteer programs under the ACTION Agency: a. National Volunteer Antipoverty Programs which include VISTA, Service Learning Programs and Special Volunteer Programs. b. National Older American Volunteer Programs for persons aged 60 and over which include Retired Senior Volunteer Programs, Foster Grandparent Program, Older American Community Services Program, and National Volunteer Program to Assist Small Business Experience, Service Corps of Retired Executive (SCORE) and Active Corps of Executives (ACE). "Low Income or Lower Income Household" means Senior Citizen households whose annual gross incomes do not exceed eighty percent (80%) of the annual Orange Median Income with adjustments for smaller and larger families. The determination of a tenant's status as a Low or Lower Income Household shall be made by the Developer upon initial occupancy of a unit in the Project by such tenant and annually thereafter on the basis of a Verification of Income executed by the tenant. "Improvements" means those Project Improvements described in Housing Agreement on the Project Site and included in Approved Plans (the Scope of Development). "Low or Lower Income Units" means the units in the Project required to be rented to, occupied by, and held available for Low or Lower Income Tenants in accordance with the Affordable Housing Agreement and this Regulatory Agreement. "Moderate Income Household" means Senior Citizen households whose annual gross incomes do not exceed one hundred and twenty percent (120%) of the annual Orange County Median Income with adjustments for smaller and larger families. The determination of a tenant's status as a Moderate Income Household shall be made by the Developer upon initial occupancy of a unit in the Project by such tenant and annually thereafter, on the basis of a Verification of Income executed by the tenant. "Moderate Income Units" means the units in the Project required to be rented to, occupied by, or held available for Moderate Income Households in accordance with the Affordable Housing Agreement and this Regulatory Agreement. "Non -Complying Assisted Units" shall mean an Affordable Housing Unit which is occupied and/or leased in violation of Section 3 of the Restriction (excluding the units leased by any Eligible Tenant who loses eligibility between certification dates). Determination of such a violation may be based on information provided in the Annual . Report or determined by City in its reasonable discretion based on information otherwise available to it. "Orange County Median Income and AMI" means the median family income for the Orange. County Primary Metropolitan Statistical Area as most recently established by official annual publication of the Federal Department of Housing and Urban Development as published, modified and released by the State Department of Housing and Community Development. "Permitted Mortgage (Permitted Mortgagee)" means Developer's interim and permanent financing loan(s) for acquisition, development, and construction, as may be approved by the City for the entire property and secured by a First Deed of Trust(s). "Project" means Project Site and Improvements including structures and related buildings and other Improvements to be constructed on the Project Site and all fixtures and other property owned by the Developer and located on, or used in connection with, such buildings, structures as described in the Scope of Development. "Project Site" means the real property legally described on Exhibit "A", which is attached hereto and by this reference incorporated herein, and all rights and appurtenances thereunto appertaining. "Senior Citizen" means persons age 55 and older. "Qualified Project Period" means the period beginning on the first day on which at least 50% of the residential units in the Project are completed and first occupied and ending on the date which is fifty-five (55) years after the date on which at least 50% of the residential units in the Project are completed and first occupied. "Verification of Income and Age Qualification" means the documentation obtained by the Developer from the Very Low Income Households, Lower Income Households and Moderate Income Households of the Verification of Income and age qualification described in Section 3.10 hereof or such other form as may from time to time be provided by the City to the Developer. "Very Low Income Household" means very low income Senior Citizen households whose gross annual incomes do not exceed fifty percent (50%) of the Orange County Median Income with adjustments for smaller and larger families. The determination of a tenant's status as a Very Low Income Household shall be made by the Developer upon initial occupancy of a unit in the Project by such tenant and annually thereafter, on the basis of a Verification of Income executed by the tenant. "Very Low Income Senior Citizen Units" means the units in the Project required to be rented to, occupied by, or held available for Very Low Income Households in accordance with the Housing Agreement and this Regulatory Agreement. t EXHIBIT C SCHEDULE OF PERFORMANCE Milestones Date Site Acquisition Jan. 2010 General Contractor Selection Jan. 2010 Planning Hearing May 2010 Building Permit Issued June 2010 Construction Start June 2010 Construction Completion Dec. 2011 Placed In Service Jan. 12 Occupancy of All Affordable Units July 2012 Occupancy of All Market Rate Dec. 2012 Units STATE OF CALIFORNIA ) )ss. COUNTY OF ORANGE ) On ,2010 before me, notary public, personally appeared who proved to me on the basis of satisfactory evidence to be the person(s) whose name(s) is/are subscribed to the within instrument and acknowledged to me that he/she/they executed the same in his/her/their authorized capacity(ies), and that by his/her/their signature(s) on the instrument the person(s), or the entity upon behalf of which the person(s) acted, executed the instrument. I certify under PENALTY OF PERJURY under the laws of the State of California that the foregoing paragraph is true and correct. WITNESS my hand and official seal. Signature (Seal) EXHIBIT "C" ATTACHMENT 10 TO HOUSING AGREEMENT MEMORANDUM OF AGREEMENT FOR FIRST AMENDMENT TO THE HOUSING AGREEMENT MEMORANDUM OF AGREEMENT RECORDING REQUESTED BY AND WHEN RECORDED MAIL TO: City of Tustin 300 Centennial Way Tustin, California 92780 Attention: Assistant City Manager No fee for recording requested pursuant to Government Code Sections 6103 and 27383 MEMORANDUM OF FIRST AMENDMENT TO THE HOUSING AGREEMENT THIS MEMORANDUM OF THE FIRST AMENDMENT TO THE HOUSING AGREEMENT ("Memorandum of Agreement") is made as of 2010 by and between the CITY OF TUSTIN, a municipal corporation (together with its successors and assigned, the "City"), and MARBLE MOUNTAIN PARTNERS, LLC a Delaware limited liability company (the "Developer") to confirm that the City and the Developer have entered into that certain FIRST AMENDMENT TO THE HOUSING AGREEMENT dated as of , 2009 (the "Amended Agreement") affecting the real property described below. The City and the Developer are sometimes referred to herein individually as a "Party" and collectively as the "Parties." Initially capitalized terms used herein and not otherwise defined shall have the meanings ascribed to such terms in the Agreement. 1. Property Affected by the Agreement. The following described land is subject to the terms, covenants, conditions and restrictions set forth in the Amended Agreement effective as to such land upon the date of acquisition thereof by the Developer: 1.1 The "Property" consisting as of the date hereof of that certain land at the former MCAS Tustin site, legally described on EXHIBIT A attached hereto and incorporated herein by this reference. 1.2 This Memorandum of Agreement has been executed and shall be recorded immediately following the recordation of the Amended Agreement for the Site and the Amended Agreement and this Memorandum of Agreement shall each be binding upon the Site in accordance with its terms. 2. Effect of Agreement. The Amended Agreement imposes certain obligations, agreements, covenants, conditions and restrictions with respect to the Property and Developer's development, use, operation and ultimate disposition thereof of required Affordable Units, that run with the land as further set forth below, including, but not limited to without limitation: (a) The covenants for the development and sale and rent of Affordable Units contained in Sections 31, 3.2, and 3.2 of the Amended Agreement; that remain in effect until execution and recordation by the City of a Certificate of Compliance on the Property and certain covenants and restrictions which continue on sold and rented Affordable Units under the terms of Section 3.3 of the Amended Agreement; (b) Certain restrictions on the sale or transfer of the Property contained in Section 6. 1, 6.2, and 7 and the assignment of the Amended Agreement contained in Section 3.3 of the Agreement, that terminate upon execution and recordation by the City of a Certificate of Compliance on the Property; (c) The non-discrimination covenants contained in Section 3.4 of the Amended Agreement that remain in effect in perpetuity; (f) The affordable housing covenants contained in Section 3.3 on for -sale Affordable Units and in Section 3.5 on for -rent Affordable Units, that remain in effect for the period specified in the Amended Agreement; 3. Amended Agreement and Memorandum of Agreement Run with the Land. The Amended Agreement and this Memorandum of Agreement, including, without limitation, the provisions recited and set forth above, and all other obligations, agreements, covenants, conditions and restrictions set forth in the Amended Agreement and this Memorandum of Agreement, are hereby agreed by the Developer and the City to be covenants running with the land and enforceable as equitable servitudes against the Site, and are hereby declared to be and shall be binding upon the Property and the Developer and the successors and assigns of the Developer owning all or any portion of the Property for the benefit. of the City, except that a City approved written assignment by the Vertical Builder/Purchaser shall relieve Developer of its obligations under the Amended Agreement for that portion of the Property. 4. Acknowledgement and Assumption by Developer. The Developer hereby acknowledges and assumes all responsibilities placed upon the Developer under the terms of the Amended Agreement. Public Documents. The documents constituting the Amended Agreement are public documents and may be reviewed at the official offices of the City. 6. Interpretation; Notice. This Memorandum of Agreement is prepared for recordation and notice purposes only and in no way modifies the terms, conditions, provisions and covenants of the Amended Aureement. In the event of any inconsistency between the terms, conditions, provisions and covenants of this Memorandum of Agreement and the Amended Agreement, the terms, conditions, provisions and covenants of the Agreement shall prevail. 7. Attaclunents. Exhibit A to this Memorandum of Agreement is hereby incorporated by this reference as though fully set forth in this Section. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties have signed this Memorandum of Agreement as of the date first set forth above CITY: CITY OF TUSTIN Dated: Bv: ATTEST: Pamela Stoker, City Clerk APPROVED AS TO FORM Doug Holland, City Attorney Clay Gantz, Special Counsel William A. Huston, City Manager < Additional Signatures follow> "DEVELOPER" MARBLE MOUNTAIN PARTNERS, LLC, MOFFETT MEADOWS its sole member, a Delaware limited liability company, its PARTNERS, LCC, administrative member a Delaware limited liability company By: Its: By:, Its: ACKNOWLEGMENT AND CONSENT OF ASSIGNEES TO MEMORANDUM OF FIRST AMENDMENT The Undersigned, as assignees of portions of the property subject to the Housing Agreement, as amended by the First Amendment to the Housing Agreement, in accordance with the assignment agreements referenced in Recital C hereof of the First Amendment to the Housing Agreement, have consented to the Amended Agreement and this Memorandum of Agreement and agree to be bound thereby if and the extent such amendments affect the property owned by them. ASSIGNEES: For Lot 4 of Finance and Conveyance Map No. 16857 TUSTIN COVENTRY, LLC, a California Delaware limited liability company By: Lennar Homes of California, Inc., a California corporation, its managing Member Name: Title: <See additional signature page which follows> For Lots 8, 10 and 12 of Finance and Conveyance Map No. 16857 Lennar Homes of California, Inc, a California corporation Name: Title: For Lot 7 of Finance and Conveyance Map No. 16857 William Lyon Homes, Inc., a California corporation Name: Title: Dated: STATE OF CALIFORNIA ) )ss. COUNTY OF ORANGE ) On before me, a Notary Public, personally appeared ' who proved to me on the basis of satisfactory evidence to be the person(s) whose name(s) is/are subscribed to the within instrument and acknowledged to me that he/she/they executed the same in his/her/their authorized capacity(ies), and that by his/her/their signature(s) on the instrument the person(s), or the entity upon behalf of which the person(s) acted, executed the instrument. I certify under PENALTY OF PERJURY under the laws of the State of California that the foregoing paragraph is true and correct. WITNESS my hand and official seal. �, Signature (Seal) ATTACHMENT H Planning Commission Resolution Nos. 4134, 4136, and 4137 RESOLUTION NO. 4134 A RESOLUTION OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF TUSTIN RECOMMENDING THAT THE CITY COUNCIL APPROVE DESIGN REVIEW 09-024 AND CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT 09-024, AUTHORIZING THE DEVELOPMENT OF A 240 -UNIT SENIOR APARTMENT RESIDENTIAL COMPLEX, AGE RESTRICTED TO PERSONS OF 55 YEARS OR OLDER, INCLUDING 153 AFFORDABLE UNITS, WITH A PARKING STANDARD OF 1.7 SPACES PER UNIT, RECREATION . CENTER, AND ASSOCIATED INFRASTRUCTURE AND SITE IMPROVEMENTS ON LOT 265 OF TRACT 16581 WITHIN PLANNING AREA 4 AND PLANNING AREA 5 OF THE MCAS TUSTIN SPECIFIC PLAN, ALSO REFERRED TO AS COVENTRY COURT IN COLUMBUS SQUARE AT TUSTIN LEGACY The Planning Commission of the City of Tustin does hereby resolve as follows: The Planning Commission finds and determines as follows: A. That a proper application . for Design Review 09-024 and Conditional Use Permit 09-024, Amendment to Tract Map 16581 and Amendment to Concept Plan 03-003 was submitted by Lennar Corporation for the development of a 240 -unit senior apartment housing project for rental tenure on a nine (9) acre site within Columbus Square within Planning Area 4 and Planning Area 5 of the MCAS -Tustin Specific Plan (Lot 265 of Tract 16581); B. That the site is located in the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan land use designation of the General Plan, which provides for residential development, and on Reuse Disposition Parcels 23 and 24 in Planning Areas 4 and 5 of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan, which is designated for low and medium density residential; C. That a public hearing on the matter was duly called, noticed, and held for said application on December 8, 2009, by the Planning Commission; D. That at the December 8, 2009, meeting, the Planning Commission continued the project to the January 26, 2010, meeting to allow the -project proponent to meet directly with the Community Association and any interested members of the community; E. That on January 26, 2010, the Planning Commission held a continued public hearing on the item and continued the item for sixty (60) days to allow staff, the applicant, and residents to conduct further research and report back on subjects raised at the hearing; F. That on March 23, 2010, the Planning Commission conducted a second PC Resolution No. 4134 DR 09-024 and CUP 09-024 Page 2 G. continued public hearing on the item; That the site is located with Council Resolution No. 05 Planning Commission Resolu within Planning Areas 4 and purpose of developing 1,075 units for ownership tenure .of units; in Tract -40 and tion No. 5 of the residential which 15 16581 previously approved by Concept Plan 03-003 approved 3951 for subdivision of 105.5 a MCAS Tustin Specific Plan for units including 240 senior hou 3 units are designate as afford City by cres the sing able H. That pursuant to Condition 2.2 of Resolution No. 05-40 approving TTM 16581, a Design Review is required for the overall design of the senior housing project and a Conditional Use Permit is required to permit a reduction in the number of on-site parking spaces; I. That the senior housing project was originally approved by Planning Commission Resolution No. 4014 as Design Review 05-019 and Conditional Use Permit 05-037 authorizing development of 240 age -restricted senior housing units for ownership tenure and a parking ratio of 1.7 spaces per unit; I That pursuant to Condition 1.2 of Resolution No. 4014, permits must be obtained and substantial construction underway within 24 months; K. That some building permits were applied for, approved, and issued; and one (1) of the ten (10) buildings was constructed but the developer chose not to obtain additional permits or continue construction at Coventry Court; L. That since development at Coventry Court was discontinued, Design Review 05-019 and Conditional Use Permit 05-037 for Coventry Court are considered null; M. That new applications (DR 09-024, CUP 09-024, and Amendments to TM 16581 and CP 03-003) for continued development of the project and change in tenure type from ownership to rental are proposed; N. That the submitted plans are consistent with the plans that were previously approved by the Planning Commission and Community Development Department except for tenure type which is proposed to change from ownership to rental. Pursuant to Sections 3.4.2.A and 3.4.5.A of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan, development in Planning Area 4 and 5 of apartments is a discretionary action requiring approval of a conditional use permit; O. That the proposed project is part of Tract 16581; thus all applicable conditions from City Council Resolution No. 05-40 for approval of Tentative Tract Map PC Resolution No. 4134 DR 09-024 and CUP 09-024 Page 3 16581 and Resolution No. 06-17 for approval of Final Tract Map 16581 remain applicable to proposed project; P. That the City's Traffic Engineer re -reviewed the parking demand analysis approved under CUP 05-037 in conjunction with the proposed project for the development of 240 senior rental apartments and determined that the difference in parking demand between a senior condominium (for sale) and senior apartment (for lease) project would be negligible. Accordingly, the parking ratio of 1.7 spaces per unit approved under CUP 05-037 remains valid and applicable to the subject project (CUP 09-024); Q. That pursuant to the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan and Section 9272 of the Tustin City Code, the location, size, architectural features, and general appearance of the proposed development will not impair the orderly and harmonious development of the area, the present or future development therein, or the occupancy as a whole, in that: The proposed senior residential apartment development is a permitted use in Planning Areas 4 and 5 of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan, subject to approval of a conditional use permit, 2. As conditioned, the proposed project is consistent with the development standards and design guidelines of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan, 3. As conditioned, conformance with all other applicable development standards, including current California building codes, will be verified by staff during plan check review, 4. The proposed site and building improvements are substantially consistent with plans previously approved by the Planning Commission and Community Development Department, 5. The location, size, architectural features and general appearance of the proposed development are consistent with and will not impair the orderly and harmonious development of the area, the present or future development therein, the occupancy thereof, or the community as a whole. In making such findings, the Commission has considered at least the following items: a) Height, bulk, and area of buildings. b) Setbacks and site planning. c) Exterior materials and colors. d) Type and pitch of roofs. e) Size and spacing of windows, doors, and other openings. 0 Towers, chimneys, roof structures, flagpoles, radio and television PC Resolution No. 4134 DR 09-024 and CUP 09-024 Page 4 antennae. g) Location, height, and standards of exterior illumination. h) Landscaping, parking area design, and traffic circulation. i) Location and appearance of equipment located outside an enclosed structure. j) Location and method of refuse storage. k) Physical relationship of proposed structures to existing structures in the neighborhood. 1) Appearance and design relationship of proposed structures to existing structures and possible future structures in the neighborhood and public thoroughfares. m) Proposed signage. n) Development Guidelines and criteria as adopted by the City Council. R. That pursuant to Tustin City Code Section 9291, the proposed senior apartment housing development with a parking ratio of 1.7 spaces per unit will not be detrimental to the health, safety, morals, comfort, or general welfare of the persons residing or working in the neighborhood, nor be injurious or detrimental to the property and improvements in the neighborhood of the subject property, or to the general welfare of the City of Tustin, in that: 1. Multi -family residential apartment housing is a permitted use in Planning Areas 4 and 5 of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan, subject to approval of a conditional use permit; 2. The 240 -unit senior apartment project is in conformance with the MCAS Specific Plan, including the limitation of rental units to a maximum 25 percent of the total number of units permitted in the Tustin portion of the Specific Plan; 3. The change from ownership to rental tenure will not result in a change in the design, operational characteristics, or intent of the project as previously considered and approved; 4. The aging and elderly are identified in the Housing Element of the City's General Plan as a growing special needs population in the City. The Housing Element identified Coventry Court as an implementation project to meet the City's housing projections and goals; 5. The project as proposed remains an age -restricted senior project and will benefit the target population as originally intended; 6. The 153 affordable housing units will be provided just as originally approved in terms of number, location, size, bedroom counts and income level, in PC Resolution No. 4134 DR 09-024 and CUP 09-024 Page 5 conformance with the approved Housing Agreement and Affordable Housing Plan for Columbus Square; 7. Approval of the project for rental tenure will allow for the project to progress and deliver the affordable housing units to the market in a more timely manner and in conformance with the requirement for reasonable proportionality in development of market -rate and affordable housing units; 8. A parking demand analysis utilizing a parking ratio of 1.7 spaces per unit was previously approved for senior condominiums as CUP 05-037 by Resolution No. 4014, has been re -reviewed by the Citys Traffic Engineer in conjunction with the subject project, and has been determined to be satisfactory, adequate and applicable to the project as proposed for senior apartments. S. That the multiple family senior housing complex for ownership tenure was part of the subdivision of 105.5 acres and development of 1,075 residential units at the Columbus Square site, including was approved under Concept Plan (CP) 03-003 by Planning Commission Resolution No. 3951, under Tentative Tract Map (TTM) 16581 by City Council Resolution No. 05-40, and Final Tract Map (FTM) 16581 by City Council Resolution No. 06-17. The project proposed as rental units necessitates text amendments to CP 03-003, and TTM 16581 and FTM 16581 to ensure consistency of the approved housing tenure type from ownership to rental senior units, and that the necessary amendments are determined to be consistent with the intent of the approved Concept Plan and Tract Map; T. That should the proposed rental tenure not be carried out or instituted, the project approval shall remain valid for the development of 240 age -restricted senior condominium units, as was originally intended and approved for the project site; U. That this project is determined to be exempt from additional CEQA review pursuant to California Government Code Section 65457, which provides that once the EIR has been certified and the specific plan adopted, any residential development project that is undertaken to implement and is consistent with the speck plan is exempt from additional CEQA review. On January 16, 2001, the City of Tustin certified the Program Final Environmental Impact Statement/Environmental Impact Report for the Reuse and Disposal of MCAS Tustin (FEIS/EIR), which evaluated the environmental impacts of the reuse and disposal of MCAS -Tustin, in conjunction with the adoption of a Specific Plan. On February 3, 2003, the Tustin City Council adopted Ordinance No. 1257, which adopted the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan. PC Resolution No. 4134 DR 09-024 and CUP 09-024 Page 6 On April 3, 2006, the City Council adopted Resolution No. 06-43 approving an Addendum to the FEIS/EIR for the Disposal and Reuse of MCAS Tustin. The FEIS/EIR and its Addendum considered the potential environmental impacts associated with development on the former Marine Corps Air Station, Tustin. The development of Coventry Court at Columbus Square is a residential development project that is being undertaken to implement and is consistent with the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan, as amended. No substantial changes in the project or circumstances under which it is being undertaken have occurred and no new information which was not known at the time the EIR was certified (or amended) has become available. Therefore, the proposed project is exempt from additional environmental review under CEQA. II. The Planning Commission hereby recommends that the City Council approve Design Review 09-024 and Conditional Use Permit 09-024 for development of a 240 -unit senior housing project age restricted for persons of 55 years or older for rental tenure utilizing a parking standard of 1.7 spaces per unit on Lot 265 of Tract 16581, including 153 affordable housing units, recreation center, and associated infrastructure and site improvements, subject to the recommended conditions contained in Exhibit A attached hereto. PASSED AND ADOPTED at a regular meeting of the Tustin Planning Commission held on the 23`d day of March, 2010. ELWYN A. "AL". MURRAY Chairperson ELIZABETH A. BINSACK Planning Commission Secretary STATE OF CALIFORNIA ) COUNTY OF ORANGE ) CITY OF TUSTIN ) I, ELIZABETH A. BINSACK, the undersigned, hereby certify that I am the Planning Commission Secretary of the Planning Commission of the City of Tustin, California; that Resolution No. 4134 duly passed and adopted at a regular meeting of the Tustin Planning Commission, held on the 23`d day of March, 2010. PC Resolution No. 4134 DR 09-024 and CUP 09-024 Page 7 ELIZABETH A. BINSACK Planning Commission Secretary rkm M EXHIBIT A RESOLUTION NO. 4134 DESIGN REVIEW 09-024 AND CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT 09-024 RECOMMENDED CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL GE_ The proposed project shall coriform with the Tustin City Code and Tustin guidelines and standards and be consistent with submitted plans for the project date stamped [date of approval], on file with the Community Development Department, except as herein modified, or as modified by the Director of Community Development in accordance with this Exhibit. The Director of Community Development may also approve minor modifications to plans during plan check if such modifications are consistent with the provisions of the Tustin City Code, and other applicable codes. (1) 1.2 Unless otherwise specified, the conditions contained in this Exhibit shall be complied with as specified or prior tQ the issuance of any building permits for the project, subject to review and approval by the Community Development Department. (1) 1.3 The subject project approval shall become null and void unless permits for the proposed project are issued and substantial construction is underway within twelve (12) months. All time extensions may be. considered if a written request is received within thirty (30) days prior to expiration date. Should this approval become null and void, the obligation that existed (prior to this approval) to develop 240 age -restricted senior condominium units, as was originally intended and approved for the project site, shall continue to apply. Associated conditions shall be applied accordingly. (1) 1.4 Approval of Design Review 09-024, Conditional Use Permit 09-024, Amendment to Tract Map 16581, and Amendment to Concept Plan 03-003 is contingent upon the applicant returning to the Community Development Department a notarized "Agreement to Conditions Imposed" form and the property owner signing and recording with the County Clerk -Recorder a notarized "Notice of Discretionary Permit Approval and Conditions of Approval' form. The forms shall be established by the Director of Community Development, and evidence of recordation shall be provided to the Community Development Department. SOURCE CODES (1) STANDARD CONDITION (5) RESPONSIBLE AGENCY REQUIREMENT (2) CEQA MITIGATION (6) LANDSCAPING GUIDELINES (3) UNIFORM BUILDING CODE/S (7) PC/CC POLICY (4) DESIGN REVIEW "* EXCEPTION PC Resolution No. 4134 DR 09-024 and CUP 09-024 Page 2 (1) 1.5 As a condition of approval of Design Review 09-024, Conditional Use Permit 09-024, Amendment to Tract Map 16581, and Amendment to Concept Plan 03-003, the applicant shall agree, at its sole cost and expense, to defend, indemnify, and hold harmless the City, its officers, employees, agents, and consultants, from any claim, action, or proceeding brought by a third party against the City, its officers, agents, and employees, which seeks to attack, set aside, challenge, void, or annul an approval of or conditions imposed by the City Council, the Planning Commission, or any other decision-making body, including staff, concerning this project. The City agrees to promptly notify the applicant of any such claim or action filed against the City and to fully cooperate in the defense of any such action. The City may, at its sole cost and expense, elect to participate in defense of any such action under this condition. (1) 1.6 Any violation of any of the conditions imposed is subject to issuance of an Administrative Citation pursuant to Tustin City Code Section 1162(a). (1) 1.7 The applicant shall be responsible for costs associated with any necessary code enforcement action, including attorney fees, subject to the applicable notice, hearing, and appeal process as established by the City Council by ordinance. (1) 1.8 The project approval is for. 240 senior housing units age restricted to persons of 55 years or older for rental tenure utilizing a parking ratio of 1.7 spaces per unit, including 153 affordable units, recreation center, and infrastructure and site improvements. Any changes to the project description, scope, or affordable housing plan shall require further review and approval by the City. (***) 1.9 The subject project approval requires the approval and execution of an amendment to the Housing Agreement and Affordable Housing Plan by the City Council in form and content approved by the Redevelopment Agency, City Attorney, and City's Special Real Estate Counsel. The Amendment shall be approved and executed by all current parties to the Housing Agreement and all successors and assigns of each of the parties. Should amendments to the Housing Agreement and Affordable Housing Plan not be approved by the City Council, the subject approval shall become null and void. (***) 1.10 All applicable conditions of City Council Resolution Nos. 05-40 approving TTM 16581, density bonus, and affordable housing transfer and 06-17 approving FTM 16581, and Planning Commission Resolution No. 3953 approving DR 04-006 for the Columbus Square community shall remain applicable to Design Review 09-024, Conditional Use Permit 09-024, Amendment to Tract Map 16581, and Amendment to Concept Plan 03-003 as may be modified herein or in Planning Commission Resolution Nos. 4136 and/or 4137. PC Resolution No. 4134 DR 09-024 and CUP 09-024 Page 3 (***) 1.11 The senior apartment development is proposed to be developed strictly as a senior complex with parking concession of 1.7 parking ratio per unit. Accordingly the senior apartment development shall be restricted to seniors of 55 years or older for the life of the project. An age restricted covenant running with the land shall be reviewed and approved by the Community Development Director and shall be recorded by the applicant prior to issuance of a building permit. PROJECT APPROVALS (***) 2.1 The subject project shall not be annexed into the Columbus Square Master Community Association (CSMCA). Instead, the applicant shall be responsible for drafting and obtaining from the CSMCA a written agreement regarding the use and maintenance of CSMCA community facilities, including but not limited to • private streets and drives, common areas, recreational facilities, parking facilities (on- and off-street), parks, etc, and the payments to CSMCA of amounts equivalent to 240 units CSMCA assessments for the life of the project. The agreement shall be subject to review and approval by the City, and the provisions required by these Conditions of Approval may not be amended without the approval of the City. The agreement shall be recorded on and burden run with the property, and shall benefit the CSMCA property. The agreement shall provide that the subject lot and units shall not receive any voting rights within the CSMCA unless and until voting rights are required by the City or by operation of law. _ The applicant shall obtain agreements from all lenders and others possessing deeds of trust or other security interests secured by the property subordinating their interests to the agreement with CSMCA required by this Condition. Should the applicant be unable to fulfill this condition for any reason, the subject approval for the project for rental tenure shall be considered null and void. Should this project approval become null and void, the obligation that existed (prior to this approval) to develop 240 age -restricted senior condominium units, as was originally intended and approved for the project site, shall continue to apply. (***) 2.2 Should the project as proposed for rental tenure not be instituted or carried out, the subject approval shall be considered valid for ownership tenure (240 condominium units) as originally intended and approved for the project site. However, notwithstanding such an obligation to develop condominiums for ownership tenure, non condominium unit shall be sold except with the approval of the City. DESIGN REVIEW (4) 3.1 The applicant shall clearly demonstrate compliance with all applicable development standards of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan and the Tustin PC Resolution No. 4134 DR 09-024 and CUP 09-024 Page 4 City Code on construction drawings at the time of plan check submittal. (4) 3.2 Architecturally compatible roof screening shall be incorporated into the building design similar and comparable to the roof screens that have been provided at the constructed model building on site. Details of proposed roof screens shall be provided in the construction drawings at the time of plan check submittal. (4) 3.3 Production plans shall incorporate additional chimneys as necessary to be consistent with the approved conceptual roof plans. GRADING PLAN SUBMITTAL (1) 4.1 Four (4) sets of final grading plans, including a site plan, and consistent with the landscaping plans, as prepared by a registered civil engineer, shall be submitted and shall include the following: A. Technical details and plans for all utility installations including telephone, gas, water, and electricity. B. Three (3) copies of a precise soils report provided by a civil engineer and less than one (1) year old. Expanded information regarding the levels of hydrocarbons and ground water contamination found on-site shall be provided in the soil report. All pavement "R" values shall be in accordance with applicable City of Tustin standards. C. Information demonstrating that all site drainage shall be handled on-site and shall not be permitted to drain onto adjacent properties. D. Information demonstrating that drainage, vegetation, circulation, street sections, curbs, gutters, sidewalks, and storm drains shall comply with the City of Tustin's "Construction Standards for Private Streets, Storm Drain and On -Site Private Improvements," revised April 1989. E. Two (2) copies of a hydrology report. F. Information demonstrating that vehicle parking, primary entrance to the building, primary paths of travel, sanitary facilities, drinking fountain, and public telephones for the recreation building shall be accessible to persons with disabilities. G. Building and landscape setback dimensions and dimensions for all drive aisles, back up areas, each covered parking stall, and open parking stalls. (1) 2.2 The engineer of record must submit a final compaction report to the Building Division for review and approval prior to the issuance of a building permit. (1) 2.3 The engineer of record must submit a pad certification to the Building Division for review and approval prior to the issuance of a building permit. PC Resolution No. 4134 DR 09-024 and CUP 09-024 Page 5 (1) 2.4 Prior to issuance of a grading permit, the applicant shall be required to provide a performance bond to assure grading work is completed in accordance with approved plans. The engineer's estimated cost shall be submitted to the Building Oficial for determination of the bond amount. (1) 2.5 A note shall be provided on the final plans indicating that a six (6) foot high chain link fence shall be installed around the site prior to grading. A nylon fabric or mesh shall be attached to the temporary construction fencing. Gated entrances shall be permitted along the perimeter of the site for construction vehicles. BUILDING PLAN SUBMITTAL (3) 3.1 At the time of building permit application, the plans shall comply with the latest applicable codes, City Ordinances, State, Federal laws, and regulations as adopted by the City Council of the City of Tustin. . (3) 3.2 Building plan check submittal shall include the following: e Seven (7) sets of construction plans, including drawings for mechanical, plumbing, and electrical. e Structural calculations, two (2) copies. e Title 24 energy calculations, two (2) copies. e Elevations that include all proposed dimensions, materials, colors, finishes, and partial outlines of adjacent buildings on-site and off-site where applicable e Details for the proposed windows and doors. e Roofing material shall be fire rated class "B" or better. e The location of any utility vents or other equipment shall be provided on the roof plan. . e Details of all proposed lighting fixtures and a photometric study showing the location and anticipated pattern of light distribution of all proposed fixtures. All new light fixtures shall be consistent with the architecture of the building. All exterior lighting shall be designed and arranged as not to direct light or glare onto adjacent properties, including the adjacent streets. Wall- mounted fixtures shall be directed at a 90 -degree angle directly toward the ground. All lighting shall be developed to provide a minimum of one (1) foot-candle of light coverage, in accordance with the City's Security Ordinance. e A note shall be provided on the plans that "All parking areas shall be illuminated with a minimum of one (1) foot-candle of light, and lighting shall not produce light, glare, or have a negative impact on adjacent properties." e Cross-section details showing the installation of the proposed rooftop equipment. Rooftop equipment shall be installed and maintained so as not to be visible from the public right-of-way. An elevation showing rooftop equipment installation related to the height of the parapet and k PC Resolution No. 4134 DR 09-024 and CUP 09-024 Page 6 proposed equipment must be identified at plan check submittal and all equipment must be six (6) inches below the top of the parapet, subject to the approval of the Community Development Director. • Noise attenuation features as required under the "Noise" section of this Resolution. Note on plans that no field changes shall be made without prior approval from the Building Official and architect or engineer of record. (1) 3.3 Sufficiently sized concrete pad in front of mailbox structures shall be provided to allow mail carrier to place mail and homeowner to retrieve mail without standing in the street or landscape area. (3) 3.4 Vehicle parking, primary entrance to the pool and recreational building, the primary path of travel, sanitary facilities, drinking fountains, and public telephones shall be accessible to persons with disabilities as per State of California Accessibility Standards (Title 24). Parking for disabled persons shall be provided with an additional five (5) foot loading area with striping and ramp; disabled persons shall be able to park and access the building without passing behind another car. At least one (1) accessible space shall be van accessible served by a minimum 96 inch wide loading area. C (3) 3.5 The clear and unobstructed interior garage dimensions for each parking space shall be a minimum of ten (10) feet in width and twenty (20) feet in length and shall be shown on the plans. (4) 3.6 Information to ensure compliance with requirements of the Orange County Fire Authority shall be submitted including fire flow and installation of fire hydrants subject. to approval of the City of Tustin Public Works and/or Irvine Ranch Water District. (1) 3.7 If determined feasible by the Building Official, the applicant shall implement one or more of the following control measures, if not already required by the SCAQMD under Rule 403 during construction as follows: a) Apply water twice daily, or chemical soil stabilizers according to manufacturers' specifications, to all unpaved parking or staging areas or unpaved road surfaces at all actively disturbed sites. b) Develop a construction traffic management plan that includes, but is not limited to, rerouting construction trucks off congested streets, consolidating truck deliveries, and providing dedicated tum lanes for movement of construction trucks and equipment on-site and off-site. c) Use electricity from power poles rather than temporary diesel or gasoline -powered generators. d) Reduce traffic speeds on all unpaved roads to 15 mph or less. PC Resolution No. 4134 DR 09-024 and CUP 09-024 Page 7 e) Pave construction roads that have a traffic volume of more than 50 daily trips by construction equipment or 150 total daily trips for all vehicles. f) Apply approved chemical soil stabilizers according to manufacturers' specifications to all inactive construction areas (previously graded areas inactive for four days or more). g) Enclose, cover, water twice daily, or apply approved soil binders according to manufacturers' specifications to exposed piles of gravel, sand, or dirt. h) Cover all trucks hauling dirt, sand, soil, or other loose materials, and maintain at least two (2) feet of freeboard (i.e., minimum vertical distance between top of the load and top of the trailer). i) Sweep streets at the end of the day if Visible soil material is carried over to adjacent roads (use water sweepers with reclaimed water when feasible). j) Install wheel washers where vehicles enter and exit unpaved roads onto paved roads or wash off trucks and any equipment leaving the site each trip. k) Use low VOC architectural coatings for all interior and exterior painting operations. PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT (1) 4.1 A separate 24" x 36" street improvement plan, as prepared by a California Registered Civil Engineer, shall be required for all construction within the public right-of-way along Edinger Avenue and West Connector Road. Construction and/or replacement of any missing or damaged public improvements will be required adjacent to this development. Said plan shall include, but not be limited to the following: a) Curb and Gutter b) Sidewalk c) Drive aprons d) Catch basin/storm drain laterals/ connection to existing storm drain system e) Domestic water facilities f) Reclaimed water facilities g) Sanitary sewer facilities h) Underground utility connections In addition, a 24" x 36" reproducible construction area traffic control plan, as prepared by a California Registered Traffic Engineer or Civil Engineer experienced in this type of plan preparation may be required. PC Resolution No. 4134 DR 09-024 and CUP 09-024 Page 8 (1) 4.2 Preparation of plans for and construction of: a. All sanitary sewer facilities shall be submitted as required by the City Engineer and Irvine Ranch Water District. b. A domestic water system shall be designed and installed to the standards of the Irvine Ranch Water District. The adequacy and reliability of the water system design and the distribution of fire hydrants shall be evaluated. The water distribution system and appurtenances shall also conform to the applicable laws and adopted regulations. enforced by the Orange County Health Department. Any required reclaimed water system shall meet the standards as required by the Irvine Ranch Water District. (1) 4.3 The applicant shall comply and meet all conditions of Tract Map 16581. (1) 4.4 Prior to any work in the public right-of-way, an Encroachment Permit shall be obtained from and applicable fees paid to the Public Works Department. (1) 4.5 Any damage done to existing street improvements and utilities shall be repaired before issuance of a certificate of Occupancy. ...w (1) 4.6 A complete hydrology study and hydraulic calculations shall be submitted for review and approval by the City. (1) 4.7 In addition to the normal full size map and plan submittal process, all final maps and development plans including, but not limited to: tract maps, parcel maps, right-of-way maps, records of survey, public works improvements, private infrastructure improvements, final grading plans, and site plans are also required to be submitted to the Public Works Department/Engineering Division in computer aided design and drafting (CADD) format. The standard file format is AutoCAD Release 2007, or latest version, having the extension "DWG." All layering and linotype conventions are AutoCAD -based (latest version available upon request from the Public Works Department). The CADD files shall be submitted to the City at the time the plans are approved and updated CADD files reflecting "as built" conditions shall be submitted once all construction has been completed. No project bonds will be released until acceptable "as built" CADD files have been submitted to the City. (1) 4.8 Facility Solid Waste Collection and Recycling Plan a. Prior to approval of a site plan or the issuance of a building permit, whichever occurs first, a Facility Solid Waste Collection and Recycling PC Resolution No. 4134 DR 09-024 and CUP 09-024 Page 9 Plan and a site plan covering the planned use o the facility shall be submitted utilizing the applicable from and approved by the City of Tustin Public Works Department. b. The applicant, property owner, and/or tenant(s) are required to participate in the City's recycling program. c. Waste and Recycling collection facilities shall be equally and readily accessible by the property owner(s) or tenant(s). d. Waste and Recycling collection facilities must be placed in a location that can be easily and safely accessed by the solid waste hauler which utilizing either front loader or side loading equipment. e. Adequate collection capability shall be provided to ensure that collection frequency shall not exceed four times per week for commercial customers. f. All trash enclosures shall utilize the City's standard enclosure designed to accommodate at least two (2) 4 -cubic yard bins, with at least one (1) bin reserved for recyclable materials. g. Prior to the issuance of a building permit, the Public Works Department shall review and approve the number of trash enclosures required to service the project site. (***) 4.9 Condition of approval 4.1 of Resolution 05-40 approving Tentative Tract Map16581, which is incorporated into this approval, requires that the applicant fund its Fair Share Contribution to the Tustin Legacy Backbone Infrastructure Program. The applicant shall fund and provide security for its Fair Share Contribution to the Tustin Legacy Backbone Infrastructure Program as required by Condition of approval 4.1 of Resolution 05-40, including its Fair Share Contribution of the cost estimates of the Tustin Legacy Backbone Infrastructure as adjusted by the Tustin City Council on April 3, 2006, and September 2, 2008, and subject to future increases in the Backbone Infrastructure Program costs and applicant's Fair Share Contribution thereto. WATER QUALITY (1) 5.1 This development shall comply with all applicable provisions of the City of Tustin Water Quality Ordinance and all Federal, State and Regional Water Quality Control Board rules and regulations. (1) 5.2 An updated Water Quality Management Plan (WQMP) shall be submitted and approved prior to issuance of grading permit. The WQMP shall be prepared using the City's WQMP Guidelines. The applicant shall submit a deposit of $2,700.00 for the estimated cost for reviewing WQMP to the City. PC Resolution No. 4134 DR 09-024 and CUP 09-024 Page 10 The actual costs will be deducted from the deposit, and the applicant shall be responsible for any additional review cost that exceeded the deposit prior to issuance of grading permits. Any unused portion of the deposit will be refunded to the applicant. CONSTRUCTION PHASING AND MODEL UNIT PLAN (1) 6.1 The developer shall close and convert the model units (constructed units) to occupancy within 90 days from the last unit rented. (***) 6.2 No further building permits shall be issued for any portion of Tract 16581 until the balance of market -rate and affordable units within the entirety of Tract 16581 is reasonably in proportion, as determined by the Director of Community Development. The applicant shall submit a revised phasing plan, for review and approval by the Community Development Department, reflecting phasing in conformance with this condition, prior to the issuance of any further building permits in Tract 16581. LANDSCAPING/HARDSCAPE (1) 7.1 Submit at plan check complete detailed landscaping and irrigation plans for all landscaping areas, including the model complex, consistent with adopted City of Tustin Landscaping requirements. The plans shall include the following: ■ Include a summary table identifying plan materials. The plant table shall list botanical and common names, sizes, spacing, location, and quantity of the plant materials proposed. ■ Show planting and berming details, soil preparation, staking, etc. The irrigation plan shall show location and control of backflow prevention devices, pipe size, sprinkler type, spacing, and coverage. Details for all equipment must be provided. ■ Show all property lines on the landscaping and irrigation plans, public right-of-way areas, sidewalk widths, parkway areas, and wall locations. ■ The Community Development Department may request minor substitutions of plant materials or request additional sizing or quantity of materials during plan check. ■ Add a note that coverage of landscaping and irrigation materials is subject to inspection at project completion by the Community Development Department. ■ Turf is unacceptable for grades over 25 percent. A combination of PC Resolution No. 4134 DR 09-024 and CUP 09-024 Page 11 planting materials shall be used: On large areas, ground cover alone is not acceptable. ■ Shrubs shall be a minimum of five (5) gallon size and shall be placed a maximum of five (5) feet on center. Fences, wall, and equipment areas shall be screened with walls, vines, and/or trees. All plant materials shall be installed in a healthy vigorous condition typical to the species and shall be maintained in a neat and healthy condition. Maintenance includes, but is not limited to, trimming, weeding, removal of litter, fertilizing, regular watering, and replacement of diseased or dead plants. Landscape adjacent to the right-of-way shall be in compliance with the requirements of MCAS Tustin Specific Plan. Perimeter walls should be treated with vines to relieve large expanse walls with greenery and color. Vines shall be informally grouped and installed with training devices. (4) 7.2 On-site walls and fences shall be noted on the plans with specific materials, colors, and decorative treatments. Interior wall/fences shall be made of durable materials subject to review and approval of the Community Development Department. PARKING (***) 8.1 The approved parking ratio of 1.7 parking spaces per unit is exclusive to the senior community and is contingent on the property remaining a senior housing complex for persons of 55 years and older. The project shall provide a minimum of 409 parking spaces including a minimum of 200 one -car garage spaces and 40 carports, 130 open guest parking stalls, 28 parallel street parking, 10 ADA accessible parking spaces and 1 ADA van accessible parking space. (***) 8.2 The applicant shall submit a Parking Management Plan for review and approval by the Community Development Department prior to issuance of any building permit. The Parking Management Plan shall include, but not be limited to, the following: • Of the 409 parking spaces, thirty-six (36) spaces (0.15 space per unit as recommended by the ULI Shared Parking Study) shall be set aside for guests, six (6) spaces shall be set aside for employees and a maximum of 367 spaces shall be available for residents. In any event, the owner and/or operator of the facility shall not permit residents to own and maintain any more than a total of 367 vehicles on-site at any given time. These restrictions shall be incorporated in any lease and/or PC Resolution No. 4134 DR 09-024 and CUP 09-024 Page 12 rental agreement. • The owner and/or operator of the facility shall ensure that required parking is provided to tenants, employees, and visitors such that off- site or surrounding properties parking are not negatively impacted. This could be accomplished using a decal systems, on-site security and/or manager parking enforcement, etc. • The owner and/or operator shall be responsible for monitoring and enforcing all parking and traffic regulations on the project site. • Any revision to the Parking Management Plan shall be reviewed and approved by the Community Development Department. ("**) 8.3 If in the future the City determines that parking or traffic problems exist on the site or in the vicinity, the Community Development Director may require that the property owner prepare an analysis and bear all associated costs. If the study indicates that there is a parking or traffic impact, the applicantiproperty owner shall provide interim and permanent mitigation measures to alleviate the problem. RENTER NOTIFICATION (1) 9.1 The applicant shall submit to the Community Development Department for review and approval a renter notification document that includes the notifications listed below. The notification document shall be signed by each renter(s) prior to occupancy, and a copy of the signed notification shall be provided to the Community Development Department prior to final inspection and/or issuance of each Certificate of Occupancy. A. A notice for roadway, trail, and train noise that may impact the project, including roadway noise associated with, Edinger Avenue, North Loop Road, Kensington Park Drive, and train noise associated with the rail corridor north of the project. The notice shall indicate the current number of trains per day (59) and the estimated to increase to over 100 trains on a 24 hour basis by the year 2020. The notice shall indicate that additional building upgrades may be necessary for noise attenuation. This determination is to be made as architectural drawings become available and/or where field-testing determines inadequate noise insulation. B. A notice, to be reviewed by the City of Tustin and the Tustin Unified School District, regarding the location of existing and proposed elementary, middle, and high schools which will serve the subdivision (text and map) and advice to renters that proposed school sites may never be constructed. C. A notice regarding units that are adjacent to aboveground utilities or structures (such as light standards and fire hydrants) identifying the type of structure and their locations.. PC Resolution No. 4134 DR 09-024 and CUP 09-024 Page 13 D. A notice indicating that any use of a residence for. a business shall be subject to the City's Home Occupation Ordinance and may require zoning clearance and a business license. E. A notice indicating that public use of a minimum one (1) acre or more portion of the park site, to be maintained by the CSMCA homeowners association, will be allowed and noting public ingress and egress through the subdivision will be provided for access to the park. F. A notice explaining the easements, facilities, amenities, and dedications that will be provided on lettered lots and indicating all on- site streets, alleys, paseos, and common areas are to be maintained by the CSMCA. The notice shall notify the renter that renters are not members of the CSMCA, and will not vote in CSMCA matters. The notice shall also identify any easements, facilities, amenities, and dedications that will be maintained by the owner or operator of the apartment complex. G. A notice, to be approved by the City Attorney, indicating that neither the site, nor the project nor any part thereof any street or sidewalk, alleyway, or paseo thereon shall be privately gated, provided however that any swimming pool and/or spa facility within the common area and any indoor common area improvements, including any clubhouse and bathrooms, may be gated or locked and made available solely to members of the CSMCA, to the residents of the project, and to their guests. H. A notice indicating that surrounding properties may be developed in accordance with City ordinances in a manner which may partially or totally obstruct views from the renter's unit and that the City of Tustin makes no claim, warranty, or guarantee that views from any unit will be preserved as development of surrounding properties occurs. I. A notice explaining that 153 affordable housing units -will be dispersed throughout the project site. These units will remain affordable for a period of fifty-five (55) years or longer. J. A notice explaining the phasing of construction within the project site and surrounding subdivison and that activity may be disruptive. K. A notice that the project is located adjacent to a future fire station site at the southwest comer of Edinger Avenue and Kensington Park Drive and that the station will be operating 24 hours a day. PC Resolution No. 4134 DR 09-024 and CUP 09-024 Page 14 ORANGE COUNTY FIRE AUTHORITY (5)' 10.1 Prior to the issuance of any grading, the applicant shall submit a fire hydrant location plan to the Fire Chief for review and approval. (5) 10.2 Prior to the issuance of a building permit, the applicant shall submit evidence of the on-site fire hydrant system to the Fire Chief and indicate whether it is public or private. If the system is private, it shall be reviewed and approved by the Fire Chief prior to building permit issuance, and the applicant shall make provisions for the repair and maintenance of the system in a manner meeting the approval of the Fire Chief. Please contact the OCFA at (714) 573-6100 or visit the OCFA website for a copy of the "Guidelines for Private Fire Hydrant Wor Sprinkler Underground Piping." (5) 10.3 Prior to the issuance of any certificate of occupancy, all fire hydrants shall have a blue reflective pavement marker indicating the hydrant location on the street as approved by the Fire Chief, and must be maintained in good condition by the property owner. Please contact the OCFA at (714) 573- 6100 or visit the OCFA website for a copy of the "Guideline for Installation of Blue Dot Hydrant Markers." `m*p" (5) 10.4 Prior to the issuance of any grading, the applicant shall provide evidence of adequate fire flow. The "Orange County Fire Authority Water Availability for Fire Protection" form shall be signed by the applicable water district and submitted to the Fire Chief for approval. If sufficient water to meet fire flow requirements is not available an automatic fire extinguishing system may be required in each structure affected. (5) 10.5 Prior to the issuance of building permits, a note shall be placed on the plans stating that all residential structures (R-1 occupancies) and any structure exceeding 6,0.00 square feet (per amendment) shall be protected by an automatic fire sprinkler system in a manner meeting the approval of the Fire Chief. (5) 10.6 Prior to the issuance of a building permit, the applicant shall submit plans for any required automatic fire sprinkler system in any structure to the Fire Chief for review and approval. Please contact the OCFA at (714) 573- 6100 for additional information. (5) 10.7 Prior to the issuance of a certificate of occupancy, this system shall be operational in a manner meeting the approval of the Fire Chief. (5) 10.8 Prior to the issuance of any grading or building permits, the applicant shall obtain approval of the Fire Chief for all fire protection access roads to within 150 feet of all portions of the exterior of every structure on site. Please contact the OCFA at (714) 573-6100 or visit the OCFA website to PC Resolution No. 4134 DR 09-024 and CUP 09-024 Page 15 obtain a copy of the "Guidelines for Emergency Access, or Bulletin number 08-99, "Fire Department Access Requirements for A Single Family Residence." (5) 10.9 Prior to the issuance of a precise grading permit or building permit, the applicant shall submit and obtain approval of the Fire Chief and City Staff of plans for all public or private access roads, streets and courts. The plans shall include plan and sectional views and indicate the grade and width of the access road measured flow -line to flow -line. When a dead- end street exceeds 150 feet or when otherwise required, a clearly marked fire apparatus access turnaround must be provided and approved by the Fire Chief. Applicable CC&R'S or other approved documents shall contain provisions which prohibit obstructions such as speed bumps/humps, control gates or other modifications within said easement or access road unless prior approval of the Fire Chief is granted. Please contact the OCFA at (714) 573-6100 or visit the OCFA website to obtain a copy of the "Guidelines for Emergency Access." (5) 10.10 A note shall be placed on the fire protection access easement plan indicating that all street/road signs shall be designed and maintained to be either internally or externally illuminated in a manner meeting approval of the Fire Chief. (5) 10.11 Prior to the issuance of any grading or building permits, the applicant shall submit plans and obtain approval from the Fire Chief for fire lanes on required fire access roads less than 36 feet in width. The plans shall indicate the locations of red curbs and signage and include a detail of the proposed signage including the height, stroke and colors of the lettering and its contrasting background. Please contact the OCFA at (714) 573- 6100 or visit the OCFA website to obtain a copy of the "Guidelines for Emergency Access Roadways and Fire Lane Requirements," or Bulletin 06-99, "Fire Lane Requirements on Private & Public Streets Within Residential Developments.' . (5) 10.12 Prior to the issuance of any certificate of occupancy, the fire lanes shall be installed in accordance with the approved fire lane plan. The CC&R'S or other approved documents shall contain a fire lane map, provisions prohibiting parking in the fire lanes, and an enforcement method. (5) 10.13 Prior to the issuance of any grading permits, the applicant shall obtain the approval, from the Fire Chief for the construction of any gate across required fire department access roads. Please contact the OCFA at (714) 573-6100 or visit the OCFA website to obtain a copy of the "Guidelines for Design and Installation of Emergency Access Gates and Barriers." (5) 10.14 Prior to the issuance of a building permit for combustible construction, the builder shall submit a letter on company letterhead stating that water for PC Resolution No. 4134 DR 09-024 and CUP 09-024 Page 16 fire -fighting purposes and all-weather fire protection access roads shall be in place and operational before any combustible material is placed on site. Building permits will not be issued without OCFA approval obtained as a result of an on-site inspection. Please contact the OCFA at (714) 573- 6100 to obtain a copy of the standard combustible construction letter. (5) 10.15 Prior to the issuance of a building permit, the applicant shall submit architectural plans for the review and approval of the Fire Chief if required per the "Orange County Fire Authority Plan Submittal Criteria Form." Please contact the OCFA at (714) 573-6100 for a copy of the Site/Architectural Notes to be placed on the plans prior to submittal. (5) 10.16 Prior to the issuance of a building permit, plans for the fire alarm system shall be submitted to the Fire Chief for review and approval. Please contact the OCFA at (714) 573-6100 or visit the OCFA website to obtain a copy of the "Guideline for New and Existing Fire Alarm Systems." (5) 10.17 This system shall be operational prior to the issuance of a certificate of occupancy. , NOISE (1) 11.1 Noise attenuation measures as recommended by the noise analysis shall �..� be included with the construction drawings for plan check, which ensure a minimum outdoor -indoor transmission class (OITC) of 37. The interior and exterior noise levels (including balconies of six feet in width) shall comply with City of Tustin noise requirements. (1) 11.2 In accordance with the noise analysis, all units are required to include air conditioning units or fresh air intake systems to achieve the minimum interior noise level standards shall have these units installed prior to issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy. Prior to final inspection and issuance of certificates of use and occupancy, the developer shall provide an independent noise analysis verifying that interior noise levels comply with Title 25 and City noise requirements. (1) 11.3 The perimeter sound walls, are included as part of the master wall plans for Columbus Square currently under review. PUBLIC SAFETY (4) 12.1 Required lighting shall be installed so as not to be in conflict with landscaping and possible reduced lighting output. Evidence of such shall be shown on lighting. and landscape plans at the time of plan check submittal. PC Resolution No. 4134 DR 09-024 and CUP 09-024 Page 17 ENVIRONMENTAL (1) 13.1 Additional measures related to development of this project as noted in the adopted EIS/EIR including, but not limited to the following: A. Prior to issuance of a grading permit, the developer shall retain a County -certified archaeologist. If buried resources are found during grading within the reuse plan area, a qualified archaeologist would need to assess the site significance and perform the appropriate mitigation. The Native American viewpoint shall be considered during this process. This could include testing or data recovery. Native American consultation shall also be initiated during this process. B. The developer shall comply with the requirements established in a Palentological Resource Management Plan (PRMP) prepared for the site, which details the methods to be used for surveillance of construction grading, assessing finds, and actions to be taken in the event that unique paleontological resources are found. C. Prior to the issuance of a grading permit, the applicant shall provide written evidence to the Community Development Department that a County -certified paleontologist has been retained to conduct salvage excavation of unique paleontological resources if they are found. D. Prior to issuance of any permit, the developer shall provide traffic operations and control plans that would minimize the traffic impacts of proposed- construction activity. The plans shall address roadway and lane closures, truck hours and routes, and notification procedures for planned short-term or interim changes in traffic patterns. Such plans shall minimize anticipated delays at major intersections. Prior to approval, the City of Tustin or the City of Irvine, as applicable, shall review the proposed traffic control and operations plans with any affected jurisdiction. FEES (1)(5) 14.1 Prior to issuance of any building permits, payment shall be made of all applicable fees, including but not limited to, the following. Payment shall be required based upon those rates in effect at the time of payment and are subject to change. a. Building plan check and permit fees to the Community Development Department based on the most current schedule at the time of permit PC Resolution No. 4134 DR 09-024 and CUP 09-024 Page 18 issuance. b. Engineering plan check and permit fees to the Public Works Department based on the most current schedule at the time of permit issuance. C. Orange County Fire Authority plan check and inspection fees to the Community Development .Department based upon the most current schedule at the time of permit issuance. d. Major Thoroughfare and Bridge Fees to the Tustin Public Works Department based on the most current schedule at the time of permit issuance. e. Transportation System Improvement Program (TSIP), Benefit Area "B" fees in the amount of $3.31 per square foot of new or added gross square floor area of construction or improvements to the Community Development Department. f. Water and sewer connection fees to the Irvine Ranch Water District. t New development tax in the amount of $350.00 per unit, plus �.. g, p $100.00 per bedroom over one (1) bedroom in each unit. h. School facilities fee in the amount as required by Tustin Unified School District. i. Other applicable parkland in -lieu fees and Tustin Legacy Backbone Infrastructure Program fees as required by Resolution No. 05-40. (1) 14.2- Within forty-eight (48) hours of final approval of the project, the applicant shall deliver to the Community Development Department, a CASHIER'S CHECK payable to the County Clerk in the amount of fifty dollars ($50.00) to enable the City to file the appropriate environmental documentation for the project. If within such forty-eight (48) hour period that applicant has not delivered to the Community Development Department the above -noted check, the statute of limitations for any interested party to challenge the environmental determination under the provisions of the California Environmental Quality Act could be significantly lengthened. RESOLUTION NO. 4136 A RESOLUTION OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION RECOMMENDING THAT THE CITY COUNCIL APPROVE AMENDMENT TO CONCEPT PLAN 03-003 TO REFLECT A CHANGE IN TENURE FROM OWNERSHIP TO RENTAL FOR THE PROPOSED 240 -UNIT AGE -RESTRICTED SENIOR HOUSING COMPLEX ON LOT 265 OF TRACT 16581 (COVENTRY COURT IN COLUMBUS SQUARE AT TUSTIN LEGACY) The Planning Commission of the City of Tustin does hereby resolve as follows: I. The Planning Commission finds and determines as follows: A. That a proper application for Design Review 09-024 and Conditional Use Permit 09-024, Amendment to Resolution No, 05-40 which approved Tract Map 16581 and Amendment to Resolution No. 3951 which approved Concept Plan 03-003 was submitted by Lennar Corporation for the development of a 240 -unit senior apartment housing project for rental tenure on a nine (9) acre site within Columbus Square within Planning Area 4 and Planning Area 5 of the MCAS -Tustin Specific Plan (Lot 265 of Tract 16581); B. That the site is located is located within Tract 16581 previously approved by City Council Resolution No. 05-40 in the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan land use designation of the General Plan, which provides for residential development, and on Reuse Disposition Parcels 23 and 24 in Planning Areas 4 and 5 of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan, which is designated for low and medium density residential; C. That a public hearing on the matter was duly called, noticed, and held for said application on December 8, 2009, by the Planning Commission; D. That at the December 8, 2009, meeting, the Planning Commission continued the project to the January 26, 2010, meeting to allow the project proponent to meet directly with the Community Association and any interested members of the community; E. That on January 26, 2010, the Planning Commission held a continued public hearing on the item and continued the item for sixty (60) days to allow staff, the applicant, and residents to conduct further research and report back on subject raised at the hearing; F. That on March 23, 2010, the Planning Commission conducted a second continued public hearing on the item; G. That on February 14, 2005, the Planning Commission adopted Resolution No. 3951 approving Concept Plan 03-003 to subdivide 105.5 acres for the Resolution No. 4136 Amendment to Concept Plan 03-003 Page 2 purpose of developing 1,077 residential units including 84 Single Family Detached (SFD), 181 Carriage Way SFD, 72 Multiple Family Attached (senior housing - for ownership tenure) for a total of 337 units at an average density of 8.62 du/acre in Planning Area 4 (Parcel 23) and 18 carriage way units, 552 Multiple Family Attached (MFR), 170 Multiple Family Attached (senior housing -- for ownership tenure) for a total of 740 units at an Average density 17.53 du/acre for Planning Area 5 (Parcel 24) of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan; H. That the submitted plans are consistent with the plans that were previously approved by the Planning Commission and Community Development Department except for tenure type which is proposed to change from ownership to rental; That the proposed project necessitates text amendments to Resolution 3951 which approved Concept Plan 03-003; I That the amendment to Concept Plan 03-003 is in conformance with the Tustin Area General Plan and MCAS Tustin Specific Plan and approval of Concept Plan 03-003, subject to conditions contained in Resolution Nos. 4134 and 4137, would achieve the development concepts set forth by the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan, including: 1. Ensuring the continuity and adequacy of all circulation systems, such as: roadways, access points, trails, pedestrian ways, and other infrastructure systems needed to serve the project; 2. Ensuring the continuity and design quality of architecture, landscape, and hardscape themes and treatments; 3. Providing urban design features as per Chapters 2 and 3 of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan; 4. Ensuring conformity with the Non -Residential Land Use Trip Budget; and, 5. Ensuring compliance with all applicable provisions of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan. II. The Planning Commission hereby recommends that the City Council approve amendment to Concept Plan 03-003 to reflect a change in tenure from ownership to rental for the proposed 240 -unit age -restricted senior apartment housing project on a nine (9) acre site within Columbus Square within Planning Area 4 and Planning Area 5 of the MCAS -Tustin Specific Plan (Lot 265 of Tract 16581), subject to the conditions of approval attached hereto. Resolution No. 4136 Amendment to Concept Plan 03-003 Page 3 PASSED AND ADOPTED at a regular meeting of the Tustin Planning Commission held on the 23d day of March, 2010. ELWYN A. "AL" MURRAY Chairperson ELIZABETH A. BINSACK Planning Commission Secretary STATE OF CALIFORNIA ) COUNTY OF ORANGE ) CITY OF TUSTIN ) I, ELIZABETH A. BINSACK, the undersigned, hereby certify that I am the Planning Commission Secretary of the Planning Commission of the City of Tustin, California; that Resolution No. 4136 was duly passed and adopted at a regular meeting of the Tustin Planning Commission, held on the 23`d day March, 2010. ELIZABETH A. BINSACK Planning Commission Secretary EXHIBIT A RESOLUTION NO. 4136 AMENDMENT TO CONCEPT PLAN 03-003 RECOMMENDED CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL Concept Plan 03-003 is approved for development of 1,075 residential units in Planning Area 4 and Planning Area 5 as follows: Planning Area 4 (Parcel 23) 84 Single Family Detached (SFD) 181 Carriage Way SFD 72 Multiple Family Attached (Senior Housing) Total: 337 units Average density of 8.62 du/acre Planning Area 5 (Parcel 24) 18 Carriage Way units 552 Multiple Family Attached (MFR) 170 Multiple Family Attached (Senior Housing) Total: 740 units Average density 17.53 du/acre (***) 1.2 The amendment to the approved Concept Plan is subject to execution of the First Amendment to the Housing Agreement and Regulatory Agreement in conformance with the requirements of the density bonus application as approved by the City Council, ,- Condition 1.9 and 1.10 of Planning Commission Resolution No. 4134, and Condition 2.2 of Resolution No. 4137. (***) 1.3 Resolution No. 4136 shall become null and void in the event that Resolution Nos. 4134 approving Design Review 09-024 and Conditional Use Permit 09-024 and Resolution No. 4137 approving Amendment to the Tract Map 16581 are not approved by the City Council. (***) 1.4 Resolution No. 4136 shall become null and void in the event that the subject project is not approved or instituted as a rental project. In such event, Concept Plan 03-003 shall remain unchanged and the original approval (Resolution No. 3951, which approved the subject senior units for ownership tenure), shall remain valid. (1) 1.5 Approval of Amendment to Concept Plan 03-003 shall be contingent upon all conditions of approval contained within Resolution Nos. 4134 and 4137. (***) 1.6 Condition of Approval 4.1 of Resolution No. 05-40 approving Tentative Tract Map 16581, which is incorporated into this approval, requires that the applicant fund its Fair Share Contribution to the Tustin Legacy Backbone Infrastructure Program. The applicant shall fund and provide security for its Fair Share Contribution to the Tustin Legacy Backbone Infrastructure Program as required by Condition of Approval 4.1 of Resolution No. 05-40, Resolution No. 4136 Amendment to Concept Plan 03-003 Page 2 including its Fair Share Contribution of the cost estimates of the Tustin Legacy Backbone Infrastructure as adjusted by the Tustin City Council on April 3, 2006 and September 2, 2008, and subject to future increases in the Backbone Infrastructure Program costs and applicant's Fair Share Contribution thereto. RESOLUTION NO. 4137 A RESOLUTION OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF TUSTIN RECOMMENDING THAT THE CITY COUNCIL APPROVE AMENDMENT TO RESOLUTION NOS. 05-40 AND 06-17, WHICH APPROVED TENTATIVE TRACT MAP AND FINAL TRACT MAP 16581 RESPECTIVELY, TO REFLECT A CHANGE IN TENURE FROM OWNERSHIP TO RENTAL FOR THE PROPOSED 240 -UNIT AGE -RESTRICTED SENIOR HOUSING COMPLEX ON LOT 265 OF TRACT 16581 (COVENTRY COURT IN COLUMBUS SQUARE AT TUSTIN LEGACY) The Planning Commission of the City of Tustin does hereby resolve as follows: I. The Planning Commission finds and determines as follows: A. That a proper application for Design Review 09-024 and Conditional Use Permit 09-024, Amendment to Resolution No. 05-40, which approved Tract Map 16581, and Amendment to Resolution No. 3951, which approved Concept Plan 03-003, was submitted by Lennar Corporation for 'the development of a 240 -unit senior apartment housing project for rental tenure on a nine (9) acre site within Columbus Square within Planning Area 4 and Planning Area 5 of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan (Lot 265 of Tract 16581); B. That the site is located in the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan land use designation of the General Plan, which provides for residential development, and on Reuse Disposition Parcels 23 and 24 in Planning Areas 4 and 5 of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan, which is designated for low and medium density residential uses; C. That a public hearing on the matter was duly called, noticed, and held for said application on December 8, 2009, by the Planning Commission; D. That at the December 8, 2009, meeting, the Planning Commission continued the project to the January 26, 2010, meeting to allow the project proponent to meet directly with the Community Association and any interested members of the community; E. That on January 26, 2010, the Planning Commission held a continued public hearing on the item and continued the item for sixty (60) days to allow staff, the applicant, and residents to conduct further research and report back on subjects raised at the hearing; F. That on March 23, 2010, the Planning Commission conducted a second continued public hearing on the item; Resolution No. 4137 Amendment to TTM 16581 Page 2 G. That the site is located within Tract 16581 previously approved by City Council Resolution Nos. 05-40 and 06-17 for subdivision of 105.5 acres within Planning Areas 4 and 5 of the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan for the purpose of developing 1,075 residential units including 240 senior housing units for ownership tenure; H. That the applicant submitted a request to allow a change in tenure from ownership to rental for the proposed 240 -unit age restricted. senior housing complex; I. That the request is consistent with the previously -approved project and the text changes are for consistency purposes and do not constitute a significant change from the intent of the original approvals; J. That the proposed project necessitates text amendments to Resolution No. 05-40 which approved Tentative Tract Map 16581; K. That pursuant to the previously -approved Tract Map 16581, density bonus, and transfer of affordable housing units for Columbus Square, the Columbus Square Housing Agreement, and the Affordable Housing Plan for Villages of Columbus, the senior housing project includes 153 affordable housing units (36 Very Low, 61 Low, and 56 Moderate Income units). The proposed project includes the prescribed number of affordable units identical in size, location, bedroom counts, and income levels as to the previously approved plans with the exception of the type of tenure; L. That should the proposed rental tenure not be carried out or instituted, the project approval shall remain valid for the development of 240 age -restricted senior condominium units, as was originally intended and approved for the project site; M. That this project is determined to be exempt from additional CEQA review pursuant to California Government Code Section 65457, which provides that once the EIR has been certified and the specific plan adopted, any residential development project that is undertaken to implement and is consistent with the specific plan is exempt from additional CEQA review; On January 16, 2001, the City of Tustin certified the Program Final Environmental Impact Statement/Environmental Impact Report for the Reuse and Disposal of MCAS Tustin (FEIS/EIR), which evaluated the environmental impacts of the reuse and disposal of MCAS -Tustin, in conjunction with the adoption of a Specific Plan. On February 3, 2003, the Tustin City Council adopted Ordinance No. 1257, which adopted the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan. On April 3, 2006, the City Council adopted Resolution No. 06-43 approving an Addendum to the FEIS/EIR for the Disposal and Reuse of MCAS Tustin. The Resolution No. 4137 Amendment to TTM 16581 Page 3 FEIS/EIR and its Addendum considered the potential environmental impacts associated with development on the former Marine Corps Air Station, Tustin. The development of Coventry Court at Columbus Square is a residential development project that is being undertaken to implement and is consistent with the MCAS Tustin Specific Plan, as amended. No substantial changes in the project or circumstances under which it is being undertaken have occurred and no new information which was not known at the time the EIR was certified (or amended) has become available. Therefore, the proposed project is exempt from additional environmental review under CEQA. II. The Planning Commission hereby recommends that the City Council approve amendment to Resolution Nos. 05-40 and 06-17, which approved Tentative Tract Map 16581, to reflect a change in tenure from ownership to rental for the proposed 240 -unit age -restricted senior housing complex on Lot 265 of Tract 16581, subject to the conditions contained in Exhibit A attached hereto. PASSED AND ADOPTED at a regular meeting of the Tustin Planning Commission held on the 23`d day of March, 2010. ELWYN A. "AL" MURRAY Chairperson ELIZABETH A. BINSACK Planning Commission Secretary STATE OF CALIFORNIA ) COUNTY OF ORANGE ) CITY OF TUSTIN ) I, ELIZABETH A. BINSACK, the undersigned, hereby certify that I am the Planning Commission Secretary of the Planning Commission of the City of Tustin, California; that Resolution No. 4137 duly passed and adopted at a regular meeting of the Tustin Planning Commission, held on the 23rd day of March, 2010. ELIZABETH A. BINSACK Planning Commission Secretary EXHIBIT A RESOLUTION NO. 4137 AMENDMENT TO TENTATIVE TRACT MAP 16581 CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL GENERAL (1) 1.1 All applicable conditions -of City Council Resolution Nos. 05-40 approving TTM 16581, a density bonus, and affordable housing transfer and Resolution No. 06-17 approving FTM 16581 for the Columbus Square community shall remain applicable, as herein modified. (1) 1.2 Approval of Resolution No. 4137 is contingent upon the applicant returning to the Community Development Department a notarized "Agreement to Conditions Imposed" form and the property owner signing and recording with the County Clerk -Recorder a notarized "Notice of Discretionary Permit Approval and Conditions of Approval" form. The forms shall be established by the Director of Community Development, and evidence of recordation shall be provided to the Community Development Department. (***) 1.3 The senior apartment development shall be restricted to seniors of 55 years or older for the life of the project. An age -restrictive covenant running with the land shall be reviewed and approved by the Community Development Director and shall be recorded by the applicant prior to issuance of a building permit. (***) 1.4 Prior to issuance of a building permit, the applicant shall submit an Addendum to Homebuyer Notification for Columbus Square and a letter that will be sent to all existing homeowners explaining the change in Coventry Court. Proof of mailing of the Addendum to Homebuyer Notification and the letter to existing homeowners shall be submitted to the Community Development prior to final inspection and occupancy. (1) 1.5 The applicant shall submit an amendment to Final Tract Map 16581 or a Certificate of Correction to reflect the change from condominium to apartment units, for review and approval. The amended Final Tract Map or Certificate of Correction shall be recorded prior to issuance of a building permit. SOURCE CODES (1) STANDARD CONDITION (5) RESPONSIBLE AGENCY REQUIREMENT (2) CEQA MITIGATION (6) LANDSCAPING GUIDELINES (3) UNIFORM BUILDING CODE/S (7) PC/CC POLICY (4) DESIGN REVIEW *** EXCEPTION Exhibit A Resolution No. 4137 TTM 16581 Page 2 (1) 1.6 Resolution No. 4137 shall become null and void in the event that Resolution No. 4134 approving Conditional Use Permit 09-024 and Design Review 09-024 and Resolution No. 4136 approving amendment to Resolution No. 3951 which approved Concept Plan 03-003 are not approved by the City Council. (***) 1.7 Condition of Approval 4.1 of Resolution No. 05-40 approving Tentative Tract Map16581,which is incorporated into this approval, requires that the applicant fund its Fair Share Contribution to the Tustin Legacy Backbone Infrastructure Program. The applicant shall fund and provide security for its Fair Share Contribution to the Tustin Legacy Backbone Infrastructure Program as required by Condition of Approval 4.1 of Resolution No. 05-40, including its Fair Share Contribution of the cost estimates of the Tustin Legacy Backbone Infrastructure as adjusted by the Tustin City Council on April 3, 2006, and September 2, 2008, and subject to future increases in the Backbone Infrastructure Program costs and applicant's Fair Share Contribution thereto. 1.8 Should the project as proposed for rental tenure not be instituted or carried out, the subject approval shall be considered valid for ownership tenure (240 condominium units) as originally intended and approved for the project site. However, notwithstanding such an obligation to develop condominiums for ownership tenure, non condominium unit shall be sold except with the approval of the City. (***) 1.9 No further building permits shall be issued for any portion of Tract 16581 until the balance of market -rate and affordable units within the entirety of Tract 16581 is reasonably in proportion, as determined by the Director of Community Development. The applicant shall submit a revised phasing plan, for review and approval of the Community Development Department, reflecting phasing in conformance with this condition, prior to the issuance of any further building permit in Tract 16581. AFFORDABLE HOUSING (***) 2.1 The developer shall comply with the obligations contained in Resolution No. 05-40 regarding affordable housing units. The senior housing project shall contain a minimum of 153 affordable units including 36 Very Low, 61 Low, and 56 Moderate Income units and at locations depicted on the previously approved Affordable Housing Plan. Exhibit A Resolution No. 4137 TTM 16581 Page 3 (***) 2.2 The First Amendment to the Housing Agreement shall include a Regulatory Agreement as an exhibit to reflect rental tenure which will be required to be executed by Tustin Coventry Seniors, LLC. (the proposed owner of the project). The First Amendment to the Housing Agreement shall be subject to approval of the Redevelopment Agency, City Attorney, and City's Special Real Estate Counsel as to form and content and shall be executed and recorded prior to issuance of any building permits. Should the First Amendment to the Housing Agreement and Affordable Housing Plan not be approved by the City Council, the subject approval shall become null and void. (***) 2.3 Prior to issuance of any building permits, an Assignment and Assumption Agreement of Tustin Coventry, LLC's duties of performance under the Housing Agreement, as amended, shall be executed between Tustin Villas Partners, LLC and Tustin Coventry Seniors, LLC on Lot 265 of Tract 16581 in a form and content approved by the Redevelopment Agency, Community Development Department, City•Attomey, and City's Special Real Estate Counsel and the Community Development Department (***) 2.4 The "Affordable Housing Plan and Density Bonus Application" document approved for the Columbus Square shall be amended to reflect the rental tenure and a clean copy of the document shall be provided to the City and Redevelopment Agency for final review and approval, prior to issuance of a building permit. (***) 2.5 The 240 -unit project shall not feature a mix of housing tenure (i.e. ownership and rental) during the term of affordability outlined in the First Amendment to the Housing Agreement and any executed Regulatory Agreement. (***) 2.6 The affordable units in the project shall be available during the qualified project period outlined in the First Amendment to the Housing Agreement which shall be not less than 55 years. (***) 2.7 The affordable units shall comply with the City's adopted Local Workforce Housing Preference Policy by granting current Tustin residents or individuals employed within the city of Tustin preference over an applicant who does not currently reside or is not employed in the City of Tustin. FEES (***) 3.1 The applicant shall submit all fees required by the City and other agencies as identified in Resolution No. 4134 including all Attorney and Special Counsel fees associated with the review of the project.