HomeMy WebLinkAbout01 Presentation Historical IntegrityAGENDA REPORT
MEETING DATE: JULY 12, 2011
TO: PLANNING COMMISSION
FROM: SCOTT REEKSTIN, SENIOR PLANNER
SUBJECT: PRESENTATION ON HISTORICAL INTEGRITY
ITEM # 1
On June 2, 2011, City staff attended a workshop sponsored by the California Preservation
Foundation on the subject of historical integrity. In an effort to provide the Planning
Commission with additional historic preservation training, staff will be giving a PowerPoint
Presentation and will be available to answer the Commissioners' questions regarding
historical integrity. A copy of the PowerPoint Presentation is attached for your review in
advance of the July 12, 2011, meeting.
The presentation will focus on 'the seven (7) aspects of integrity and will provide
illustrative examples of each aspect of integrity.
Scott Reekstin
Senior Planner
Elizabeth A. Binsack
Community Development Director
Attachment: PowerPoint Presentation
06/28/2011
HIS {
NTEGRITY
~,
,_
~' '> ~ .. ,.'OMMISSION
,r ULY 12, 2011
PKESENTA'rION CRI?UI'r
TF.KESA GRIMES
GALVIN PRESEKVA'I'ION r'1SSOCIA'I'F.S
The Concept of Integrity
._ _ - .. __- - _. _ .. n ..
National Register of Historic Places
California Register of Historic Resources
Local Landmark Ordinances
1
06/28/2011
fnificance + Integrity =Eligibility
_ . _ __ _ _ ._ _ CO __.. _ - - .. ----
~,
nificancc
Criterion A/1-Association with events that have made
a significant contribution to the broad patterns of
history.
Criterion B/2 -Association with the lives of persons
significant in ottr past.
Criterion C/3 -Embody the distinctive characteristics
of a type, period, or method of construction;
representative of the work of a master; possessing high
artistic value; or contribttting to a historic district.
Criterion D/4 -Yielded or likely to yield information
important in prehistory or history.
2
06/28/2011
p/
i~.er~~~
_... 1 ......_ --___
The ability of a property to
convey its significance.
Seve~l~ 1--_ ~~~ ~ L ~~ ~. _ _i .._t
. __ __ _ _ . _ __ _ ... _. _ __ . o _ ._ _..~ _ _ __ _. _ , . _.
Location
Setting
Design
Materials
Workmanship
Feeling
Association
3
06/28/2011
Location is the place where the historic property
was constructed or the place where the historic
event occurred.
4
06/28/2011
i iii:--
Setting is the physical environment of a historic
property.
'I'<~Ex>~;ra~~liical Feahu~~~,;
I)Ctil~lle(,~811C~VE'PI1~1CU1~t1'L.~1llC~SCE1~)l` ~~~';;~iil'~'~_ ;i~ii'i!.,~: l', .,~~
~~aths, trees, gardens, retaining walls, and ~~~~~~~~,~~~
Rclati<m~hil~s hc~t~~ren Btiildin~~ and S~r~c~~~~
5
06/28/2011
sign
Design is the combination of elements that create
the form, plan, space, structure, and style of a
property.
Or;~anir.ati~m of Space
I'r~~portiou
`gale
;.wilding Technolog~~
t)1'IlaI11eI1tat10I1
6
06/28/2011
Materials are the physical elements that were
combined or deposited during a particular period
of time and in a particular pattern or configuration
to form a historic property.
S
~ ~S
,~R
u ii
~•~
\ / ~
~ \ u1'1
~ ~ I[t:~~
?~
=.1r
~,
r
-tf'1'1 ~? ~ ~
Ini b.
. ~ ~~
__~
7
06/28/2011
"~
,:~ ~!i ItG CfF f~~ ~~F ~~1
rr~ ~,rG ~~~ lil Il~~gi{
~ ~~'q
p -, 1
~` ° ~ N 1E ,
o:i
_.
vx.Sll.I~CAY1s~~JL-~..
r-
Workmanship is the physical evidence of the crafts
of a particular culture or people during any given
period in history or prehistory.
s
06/28/2011
9
06/28/2011
Feeling
Feeling is a property's expression of the aesthetic
or historic sense of a particular period of time.
10
- ~~~
~~
06/28/2011
____. _
%~~
,~ r v'
.°~~ ~;
~ ;i ,~~
i % a` ,~
~+ v a ~ .,
^,..,~A~1 ieY~.
Ns ' ~ 1:4:^'s
~Ni ^a
" ¢¢!!!!
-~:~ r R!!7 ! ! i LC a _ _- __
xtW8P4\A _
~M!!•
T.
~~"p
t _
~.tL1I' ~. ..,1
11
06/28/2011
_ ilk.J i`3 v iii d.i Lx :.9 ~.. _:.
Association is the direct link between an important
historic event or person and a historic property.
12
06/28/2011
~~;.
Because feeling and association depend on
individual perceptions, their retention alone is
never sufficient to support eligibility for listing in
the National Register.
i
.~
The evaluation of integrity includes interiors as well
as exteriors.
13
06/28/2011
14
06/28/2011
Ii
~~.-~
_ `~
h _ .
_._ ~. ~. :.. +.,~ a.~ V` .~. A,. 'yi V ~ a ~~a..~ ~.l*~A'~JL L1'~.+' Ji.A
f lJ
Integrity and condition are different concepts that
only sometimes cross paths.
i
15
06/28/2011
How do you evaluate integrity?
Determine ,and the property is
significant.
Determine the essential factors of integrity it needs
to convey it's significance.
Determine if it has those aspects of integrity.
Properties either retain integrity or they do not.
16