HomeMy WebLinkAboutPC Minutes 09-13-65MINUTES OF A REGULAR MEETING
TUSTIN PLANNING COMMISSION
SEPTEMBER 13, 1965
I ·
CAi. L
TO
0 ilDER
II.
ROLL
CALL
III.
OF
IV.
PUBI..I C
H LA2I NGS
Me=:tlng w.ns c,~lled to order at 7:32 :.M. by Chairman
Hafner.
PRES'-"NT: Commissioners: Hefner, Bacon, M~r.zters, Halus,
Oster·
--
ABS NT Co ..... i ssioners: ~r,'~nd.
OTHE RS .:~HE 5 ENT:
Harry Gill, City Administrator
J..~mes R~urke, City Attorney
" Pl~nnln~ Director
Edward nov.'orth, .
Planni~ Pechnlcian
J,'~mes Taylor, ,.~ ~'
Lois A. Ault, Secretary
Moved by Bacon, secc'cded by O~ter that the minutes of
Au:lust 23, 1965 be a?proved as mailed. C~r'"ied by roll
call. Ayes: Hafner, B~con, Marsters, Halus, Sharp,
Oster· Noes: None. Absent: Brand· C;~rried.
./.,~ 6~-146 St.nnville Development ~om any
A cha~~= of zone from PD (Pl:-~.ned Dcvelooment) to R-1
(Sln:~le Family Residential), located on the North side
of San Juan Street at l~0l Sar.. Juan Street, ..~st of
RedH[ll Avenue, Tustln.
Hearing ozened ~t 7:3~ P.M.
Staff Re~rort w'~s '~resented by Mr. Taylor, recommending
ao.oroval of ZC 65-146. It was the feeling of the Staff
that this would be consistent with the development
trend in the general loc']tion.
There being no further comments or objections, the hearing
w'.'~s declared closed at 7:37 P.E.
Moved by Sharp, seconded by Halus that RESOLUTION N0. 793
be oassed and ado:~ted reco ...... e.,ding to the City Council
that ZC 65-1~6 be gr;anted as submitted by the Avo]ic~nt.
. . B~ con M~rsters,
Carried by ~oll call Ayes: Hafner, ,
Halus, SharE, Oster· Noes: None. Absent: Brand, Carried.
2. ZC 6~-lZ~ - Associates Funding - (continued from
Auuust 23, 196~)
To oermlt a change of zone from R-3 to C-1 on the property
~,,.:.w,..ort Av ~ue and Sycamore (~o:~,:~, off-ramr~)
located at 'T~, ~ ~
He'.~ring ocened at 7:40 P.M.
Staff reFort w':s 'eraser:ted by ~.~r. Haworth, recommending
denial. The -:~nnin~ Stnff felt that a:..artment zor. ing
would be .~.',,.ore lo~ic;~! for the ares as oresent!y zoned.
Mr. Art Nisson seoke in behalf of ApTli. cant. He
oresented s letLer from Mr. Bob J. McCord of the West~orter
Apartments, 14771 New'oort Avenue, T..vstin w'~'ich stated
that he felt that a neiw.~borhood tyy~e shopping center
would be beneficial to the area.
There being no further comments or obj.-~ctions, the hearing
w-~s declared closed at 8:02 P.?.
B.'~ccn moved".~hnt ZC 65-1~3 be ~?~nted chan~~.:ng the zone
from R-3 to C-l, however, the r~cti, or, d.ted for ~.ack of a
· -~'~ M . ,. ros he a~]
Mr Hefner ao:~,~,d r Ar.~zy if .~lt that it w., .d be
beneficial, to have ~-~nother worksho.v with the County
PI.':~ ar. i ~g De .'..artment.
~..r. Art ~i:~-on.~ st,~ted "Yes, if a ,~.~."-oo~*'~lve~,.. ~,~,,~:.~, from
Ac'~c~:~s Fun~im~ could b,~ ~res~nt to ~ '~ ~ ~
o~inions to the County."
City Attor.,~ey, J~mes Rour.ke said theft a re~re, sent~tive
of the aof !c~nt cm~ld be entitled to be ~res~.nt at
the m~.t in,I
Moved by .Oster, secouded by Sh-~rp that ZC 65-1~.3 be
continued u~t~ the r~:t ~eetl,,,~ ~, October of the
Pla~ui. ng CommLssion at which time the Tust!n P!ann!r~
Comm~.sslon could ~et to,~th~r..~ ........ For a workshom om the ~'.,ort
recently com'~)leted by the Clty and County Plan,ting St:--affi.
by . Ay ' ~.~ t~,~
Carried roll c,.~l
'"~m lus, Shar~-.., O,~ter. ........
To'a,,.~nd~. ..... "us~ Permit ':~,..,., 65-1°4,. ,:~rant~n~.~ ., , an ext~s~on, ,~,,, _ of
time to submit :r.~e~ise.. .~ ~'~,'~s., .. on ,~n exis~ing~ build~',', g
~35 ~ Ea~n Stre t, Tustl~
].oc'~ted at ~ ~. ~ .e .
Heo, rin~ o~.ened at 8:a5 P.E.
St~ff retort w~s ,vresented by M~. Taylor, recom~'~nd~....., , ~n,~,~ a
90 day extens.ion to subm!t '.'.]ans on the old existing
buYldln~. It was the recommendatlcn of the St'.~ff that
fin.sl occu~.ancy of the 'newly constructed car wash not
be held u~:. nending the remov'.~l or imzrov£.ment of the
subject building.
Er. M.:.:.I Shubin, Co-owner of the Tustln Car Wash sr.'oke in
f;~vor of a,_..r,.: i cat !on.
There bein~ no further com'~,zents or obJect lons, the
he~rin~ w?s declgr.ad closed at 8:4.8 P.M.
Moved by' Sh!:~~' s~cor!d~d by ?.,'ius thot R!':S'~''~'':~.~.~.,.~ ~ ...... .~, .,~,'~
~ , ~ ._, _ x ~ ·
794 be oa::.~.~:ed '~ ~ ~,ted ~
~n~, r~:~c ~runt!..r~ an A~endm~nt to
UP 65-194 a!lowin~ for the ooening of the Cgr Wash in
two weeks, sad allow!n5 a n!nety (9C) d:~y extension for
the old exi. stin~ buil~in~ to be brought uo to the
st'.~r'd'~rds of the Bui. ldln5 Code, or be re:~:oved from the
.-, ~ . : ~- .. ~fl
premises. C'~.ried by roll c~i! Ay~:s nefmer, con,
M.~rsters, H,'~].us, Shar~, Oster· Noes: Notre. Absent:
Brand. Carried.
65-1oo A R ~u: ~ders
To ~:erF,,]t the est?,~"llshmcnt of a P].~nned Res~denti~.~l
Dovel"~ment in the PD (Planned ~:sldential District),
loc'~ted ..... '~ the ~,,~-~h:,.',?~t,: cc. rn~r cf '",.,:.:" ',. i::~,.v.s ~r,d Mcfadden, .
H.~'.-~Ing ooened at .P:5° '~.M.
r~'~ ;~ ..... ~-*h ~.~'orted t~ the '.~'~
...... ,-~ ..................
A. ~. Bu~lJ~:,rs b. ave re.,:uested a co~tinu~nce of their
h~-':~ ~ [~g~ u~til,_ the next~-~-'.'~-~ q rl y, .,.~ ~.,. scheduled
of the ~l~ntn~ Comziss!on on o..n~ember ~?, ].~.
There beln.'.ff ~.o fur~.her com"tents or ob,! ?.,'-;t ions , the
he'.-:rtng was declared closed at 9:04 P.M.
Moved by Bacon, seconded by Sharu~ that UP 65-199 be
continued until the next regularly scheduled meet!nE of
the ?ianuing Commission on Ser>tember 27, 1965. Ca~ried
by roll c~.~i!. Ayes: Hefrer, Bacon, Msrst¢,rs, Ha!us,
Shar~,, Oster. Need: ~,~one. Abe .... t: Brand. Carried·
5- V 6.5-161 DE" ' ~ ~,
- ~.~ ELS C~R!-:.2RATION
· ,,
To allow th~ com:~tructi
exist in~f lot
~. ~ to ~.e~it ~ reduction in th~
re.~uired f'~ont y:.~rd setbnck, ~nd tc ~ermit a ~r~:~'csed
structure ht~her th~n the ul!cwed hel.~ht in the
front ,~,,~rd ..... ~tbnck '~ea, ]oc'~ted at 16012 .and 160~1.
Bliss Lane, Tustln.
Heqrin,,~ o~ened at 9:~5 o M
St~_~ff ret. orr w~s .':resented by ~<r. Haworth, reco:.~.mending
,'a"','~rov'o] of the sub jo. ct v~rJauce subject to the fo].lowin~
cond ~ t ] OhS:
1. T?:~:.t ~ .'lanter stn!:'~ be ~-r:.':v.~ded betwe':n the slda. w'~lk
:~'~d the ero~osed f~nce su~.~ to the a"'~:,rov~] cf thc
. ~ _ ~ ~) ,~ ~ ~ ~, .
Architecturnl ~o~-'i~t~e.~ ....... : .... .visions should be made
to insure the r~nlntennnce of this stri.~.
Theft a dec].~r..-~t!on cf coven'~r'..ts, conditions snd
restrictions be execut,d as ,"er the recom~:end~tions
of the ~uildin~ Der~:~rtment.
That a ferce be construct,ad to com,:'!etely surr".;und
the oool lsolatin~ ':~ny arart.~:ent doors ~rom
Fo":l area.
No cne s~oke in favor or in .~c-oos~bion.. . to ax~o].ic.'~"1on.,.
. a ....~,'~ ob ~ct the
There b.elng no further .. .... · .... ~ts or j.. ions,
hearing w'-~.s declared closed at 9:20 P.M.
Moved by Sharp, seconded by B~con that
795 be 'r~ss'~d ° ~ ed 1~ .... ut V 65[161 subject
,.. =n,~ ado~:t '~'.'~
to the conditions ~s outlined in the St,~ff Re~:ort.
C:~rried by roi.~ c~'~ll. Ayes: Hefn.~r, B~con, ~,,~rsters,
H~:~lus, Sh~]rp, Oster. Noes: [',~oue. Absent: Brsnd. Carried.
6. V 6~-162 - Saddleb':~ck X~' lonal Bsnk
'fo -'.erm~.t reduction of front '-..~nd side setback lines snd
a reduction in off-site recuired varkinE sr..aces, loc.~ted
at the .':~orth-?:nst cc. rr:er of First St. and New"ort, Tustin.
Hearing ozened at 9:25
St x~,~ ,..,
' .. re ort was resent=d...~ .. by Mr. T!~y].or, recommend_~.~.~_.~ that
the ..... minu".um ~u'~b:::,~ of osrk~...: ~......~aces be .:'rovlded either
on-~ite or on ad~ ........ ty
'~ kine in e'.-:,,vor of ae::.!~c:~tion was ?r.
o~es .... Leu H'.ardy,
Board Chairman - Sa~leb.~ck N':~t!o~al B':r:k, Mr. Bob
..... ~ M 2.:~ y ..
Schoeffl~r, Bsnk ~si.,d..nt, r. Chermak, Arc'~itect,
~nd Mr. Cec%l Suddaby, Pronerty Owner.
Mr. Coc!l ,Su~aby,~ L,~nd O',~.~r,.__ ...a=~':ed;... to ~ive two
.-, . .. "f ~ "', -,- . ~ ....
a.fi'-~tional ~,'~rP.~n~ s~:eces to Sa "~ fi .. .. b,~ ck ,...st~onal ~:-~k ~n~
s.t'~ted thnt he did .not know :.,'h~t thc, future uses of the
surroundlnz rro~:~rty is .~'~in:'t to b,~
There betn!~ no further com:ents or obj~'.ctions, the
hc-'~r~'r~, ;,:~-~s ~.,~1-'.~.,~ c:.,-'~.~ at o:~0 o_ .K.
F;ow~d by Ost<-r, sec:;uled by u,-, - "_
,,.~.us l',h"': t ";~'
.",T '",nT ."'.,T ~ UC~ ~ ,-~[~e~.~d
~r,~nt~*:~ V ~5 1~'~ ~h~
th3t thc A,tr].tcant obt'.'~~n a written
merit .?or two, addit~c~a]. "~2.p~.'1z:~ st.. n!$ from
~ ....... j,2,~cnt lunfi owner to
of the ~y A''~:~-,,-,,~ Co~.'i,~d by roll c::~l
Ayes: I-{cf fieF, Becon, Ivl'f~z~.~'-~.~s u.. ].us 3h2pF..
~ ~',"~ ~ ~- N',' ~ Aba ,
,J S ;"] 0 .. ~:: .
.... . .... ~ nd Ca i
Thc.:re 'c:..:'~ ~ ,r --. ..... ,. .~ .
_.l.::., no further c ~'"-':n s or ol-.j"~t".o~'s,
ti''~-' :~,:';'~r'i~',..~ ..,:as d,.¢cl'~-ed c] ~'s,'d a+ lC :q, 2 TM :"
Eov.,.:.d by Shat::, s,:c:)i'fied by H.'_:!us :hat subject
' ", ' "b:~ c3_ntinu..."d 'J~'~ ~ .3co~ .... ~-,-' "~ lo6.
t..o ",r.:".','.?!c the ?%:'~:':r:"..%i~ 3t3f£ to m3ke th~ nec-
,."',~";"P~::'~:3rl'.~"'S ~:2~'?~ed '.?y ~,'~1" O:':]].~'
.. ~, ..~. ~~ . = ...... ·
· .,, , , .... ~ ;'.. ~ us 3',,'.'~
,..: 7; ... ~.l S · ]'!0 '~ '=
..., ~\ ,~ _ .- ...
..,
c. ar',:ln;; '.z",'~c,-'s ........ inst~.'.d, of two s'.'~-~c,.'-s. .. ~ _.
two '-" :.,.i :"~o:r: t)~ its.
['ir. Bom WinJ o]. :.'h '-il'so s':o',-:,¢. ir! f3',:.t.r ,,.,~ .,
''.r].rir::- ?:.'"c.¢:'.'s i"'3L.:.:'.;fi :'~¢ t~,,'~ fo~ two b?d
P .D :";fi', !., :l" t S .
.... by oh..rr .
Vov,-,'~ by E.;,1.~"on, s,'-c.. }nded ° ~ th":t
('.rd~n3nce Az; r. dr..:~nts be "ost'. o~:ed untLl the
....,':~xt re.'~larly, scheiul, ed meet'...n%-of t'¢¢ ..... n].an:q~-,%..
Co ...... ~ss on o~ 'Se~ t~.~',':,r 27, , ~ ....
~.,- : ~ e'. ut "'~' ich ~!.~'~:
........ · ...... I. O } .....
~;¢ :',.~nr~'~ ''-S. 3t'-,F *. ,""- ch¢:ck ' ~ hh .... o ce
, ~ ., .... ~ ~ ..
.~ -. -
10:~-'3 !t. :; Cu, P,~'~'':~ t;..:.':S ~' :'P.i ..... ~ !-Q' P.ll
!{"i"" ~ ' rri ed
Vi.
VII.
OTHER
BUSI X ~SS
Tc) permit a ~riv:~te sc?:ec, 1 in the American Legion
War Memorial Suildi. nS at First Street and ?roar cci
Ave., Tustin.
Nr. Haworth uolnted out th'?.t this was not a ~Isted
use in. the C-2 zor:e ~nJ that the Plann[.ng Commission
was to det~>r~ine whether it was a s]mll.~r use as
.. - ~r~ v..'hether ~ Use =~"~it
allowed .!~ the C 2 zone, ........
si~uld be re,~uired if it were an allowed use.
Er. H:~lus felt th:~t this F, srticu]nr loc:-~tion is
very bad for children w~:~!king to and from school.
'~ ' ~ H:-~us that the h~.ari~g
r. oved oy C.'st r, s~cordod by ' '.
be continued until Sertc..mb~r 27, 196~ at which time
the A".'r,].ic~nt must submit an a,:...~'ication for a Use
Permit. Carried by roll c?~ll. Ayes: Hefner, Bacon,
:.~rsters,~'-. n"..lus, Shar~,, Oster. Noes: None. Absent:
Brand. Carried.
C:~r.~sideration of Zone Change to be initiated by the
City of Tu:.~tln to hermit a cha~.~ of zsne From C-]
(t-'.c~,vy Commercial) to Pr(i~esidentiai Profess'.onal),
on a'~rrox!mntcly o.2 acres located on the Easterly
-and Westerly sid~s~ .of :'~c~<'?rt Avenue, ~"'~"'ox~ot~, .. _.,.~ ~y
2~0 feet South of Main Street.
?<oved by Halus, s.~'~c:~nded by Sharr that consideration
of chan~e of zone b:.: m-~d.e by the City .of Tustin on
New:;ort Avenue,.. to come before th~ ~'~lan~i-~=...~ ~omm ~ is:'ion
~ ~o65. Carried by rol~ call
Ayes:, Hefner, Bacon, Earsters, ~{alus, Sharn., 0ster.
Noes: None. Absent: B~nd. Carried.
Z,~i~E CU
3 · CCXSIDE.~ATION .iF ..... A~=E
Mr. Sharp asked th".,t we initi.'--~te another zone change
to oermit a chan~e of zone on the oroperty located
at the o..'_utheast corner of New orr Avenue and
Layuna Road, changing the zone from C-2 b~ck to the
original C-1 zone. Carried by roll call· Ayes:
, w.-. ~ - ' Oster
uo~ner, B..con, Esrsters, ...~!us,
,~'o~'s:~ None. Absent'. ~':nd.., . Carrled.
Z~ 2 -,.-, r,.:I IVE T:'; ": :'
· __zo · _.7[
Staff rez, ort was :'.resented by Mr. Haworth.
Moved by Ha!us, sec '~ded by X:~,r:.'.ters that Tentative
Tr~t.. ~,v'o. 57'-~.e,,: be a:"~roved sub~ect~ to the conditions
_'~ ~"- ~"':,ff Re.~.ort Carried by roll
as st~..ul~.~ed in the ~ ,
call Ayes: Hefner, Bacon, Msrsters, Share
Halus, Oster. Noes: None. Absent: Brand. Carrie~
1. Mr. Hefner directed Mr. Haworth to exulore the
f~cets of~::re-zori~.-. to ~.%~s~dor~,..._ _ ,_ the ~ossibility
of making th~s a ~.nrt of the '" ' ~
.._ , ~on ng Ord!~nce.
2 ']?he Planni:~ Staff recommended that t~.e Arch-
it,~ct:~r~;] Comm.:it. tee establish a reT,~]..qr tl.~e, t~,:ice
a.,,-:,'.~n~.b,~ , for "~'~iew~r~, ._. r'!"~ns.
Viii.
.-- OQ-
3:..iiC'E
l X
· ah,.urc :';u:V:ve:st,'~4 t'~.'.~,'t ',,'~ .... :c.]ic!'='-~ the date's
so t.h~.~t th,:: r~blic '.'ould be uw'~re cf the ~ates
';~nd ~zat their nlans in o.n t~me.
'?he A, rc~., tect"ra'i Co?::'ittee will ;~::t to~ether
r~nd decide on the days th.:.~t the Committee w~i~'
meet,
3, Mr Hn~'~orth ir:formed the Plannln~ Commission
that there would be a meeting of the General
Co..mmitte~. on W~d~esday, Se~,te...b,,r 2': 1965 to b,~
held at th~ Tustin ~'
,.~_,-.s Youth Center at 7:30 o.M.
4. the Pl~n.~ing Commission declded on Seotember
co ~065 as the d':~t= ?o~ a t~mt:-~tiv~ worksh'~ with
the .Piannin~ Staff·
5 The P].~n~".. r,g Commissi.~? ,4,:c",d~-~d '-~" '"etcher ~
1905 9s a tentg, t~ve d:'::te For a Joint Workshor
betw~:e',: the "P:~stin ?lan'.':~n~ Commission and County
of Orgn.:~e /'19,~,,~-~ Commissinr.
'?o r:erm~:t the ~,oc.-~t~.on of ,~ subdiv~..s~'on di-,~ctiona]~,..
s~'~'~ ~or '-~' + me not tn ~xce.:~d ~ " ',.~:,rs
on a ':'~rcel of land in the Ail Agricu].t~ral Res~denti.~l
Dlstrict.
Moved by Halus, sec nded my .~.~ ....
.... tar th'~t C'~.untv C~se
UV ~611 be d,en'~ed because of the fcllowi, ng re':~son:-~
"-~',.~',~ented~ ..... by th~, l-'i,nnr:.i n~ St~ff:
1. Such a Use as r:rooosed is not allowed ir~ the
AR (Agr".cultu~':~l ~.~,sl~n.nt~a~ ~ ~
o~ther the ,City or the County.
2. Directional si'~ns are al. lowed in the City of
Tusti~ only if they are to be erected within
one mile of the subject subdlv'~slon.
Dlrect]onsl :';i~ns in the City are restr'ct~'~d
to one hundred sou2re feet in
Directional si.~,'~s are oermltted to bc erected
in the City of Tustin for '.a ,ver~od of o~!y or:e
(l) ye?~r.
"?;" ~-~, ,. .. ..,'~:st"~nce~ of the _r:rot-:osed s lsn from
.n ......... ~.]aces it w~tbin the
S¢ ta Ana ¢~.w,:.y ~...
~ro~.o~ed:. ~ by th~.~ ~etate of Cai~forr~i~'~. ,.. as landscu'~d
,, m,, ?'[.~ -~.,,~
Ca tied by roll c:-:il. Ayes: F. cfner, .... con, r~o rs,
' '~:~ "~ster ?'.~-,,~: None Ab.tent: Brand
~'~'.:].US, o..:,r?,, . . .
Mov,.',d '~ Sh~r~:, seconded bV..,, L'";'] blS:.;' ...... t'~.'~t m=:etln~
be ad ~'our¥~e.d. Carried.
Cha i r~a n
Secretary