HomeMy WebLinkAboutActions Memo Planning Commission 1-28-14Inter -Com
DATE: JANUARY 30, 2014
TO: DIS RIBUTION
FROM: 9ETH A. BINSACK, DIRECTOR OF COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT
SUBJECT: ACTIONS: PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING, JANUARY 28, 2014
TUSTIN
a
xn '
BUILDING OUR FUTURE
HONORING OUR PAST
Pursuant to Tustin City Code Section 9294b, any person may appeal any decision of the
Planning Commission by filing a written notice within ten (10) calendar days of the Planning
Commission's action, or February 7, 2014. This notice of actions taken by the Planning
Commission is being transmitted to the City Council prior to the end of the appeal period.
On January 28, 2014, the Planning Commission took the following actions:
Agenda Item
Action
Vote
1. Approval of Minutes — January 14, 2014, Planning
Approved, as amended, the
5 -0
Commission.
Minutes of the January 14, 2014
RECOMMENDATION:
meeting as provided. (Attached).
That the Planning Commission approve the minutes of the
January 14, 2014 meeting as provided.
2. Conditional Use Permit 2013 -07 8 Design Review 2013-
Adopted, as amended, Resolution
5 -0
09 Wireless Mono - Eucalyptus
No. 4246 as provided. (Unsigned
A request to construct and operate an unmanned wireless
copy attached.)
telecommunications facility consisting of a fifty -five (55)
foot tall mono - eucalyptus faux tree with twelve (12) panel
antennas and associated equipment.
APPLICANT: Verizon Wireless
15505 Sand Canyon Avenue,
Building D
Irvine, CA 92618
PROPERTY
OWNER: LBA Realty Fund II- WBPII, LLC
17981 Skypark Circle, Suite H
Irvine, CA 92614
LOCATION: 3002 Dow Avenue
PC Action Memo 1 -28 -14
Page 2
Agenda Item
Action
Vote
RECOMMENDATION:
That the Planning Commission adopt Resolution No. 4246
approving Conditional Use Permit (CUP) 2013 -07 and
Design Review 2013 -09 to construct and operate an
unmanned wireless telecommunications facility consisting
of a fifty -five (55) foot tall mono - eucalyptus faux tree,
twelve (12) panel antennas and associated equipment
located within the parking lot of 3002 Dow Avenue.
3. Appeal of Denial of Massage Establishment Application —
Adopted Resolution No. 4252 as
5 -0
Tustin Day Spa
provided. (Unsigned copy
APPELLANT: Lisa Huynh
attached.)
14892 Stranyan Cir.
Westminster, CA 92683
LOCATION: 18121 Irvine Blvd., Suites A & B
Tustin, CA 92780
Ms. Lisa Huynh ( "Appellant ") appeals from and requests
reconsideration of the Director of Finance's denial of a
massage establishment permit application for Tustin Day
Spa (18121 Irvine Blvd., Suites A & B, Tustin, CA).
RECOMMENDATION:
Based on the foregoing, City staff recommends that the
Planning Commission uphold the denial of the Appellant's
massage establishment permit application.
4. Appeal of Denial of Massage Establishment Application —
Adopted Resolution No. 4253 as
5 -0
Le Petite Spa
provided. (Unsigned copy
APPELLANT: Garrett Biggs
attached.)
26447 Basswood Ave
Rancho Palos Verdes, CA 90275
LOCATION: 13762 Newport Ave, Suite C
Tustin, CA 92780
Mr. Garrett Biggs ( "Appellant ") appeals from and requests
reconsideration of the Director of Finance's denial of a
massage establishment permit application for Le Petite
Spa (13762 Newport Ave, Suite C, Tustin, CA).
RECOMMENDATION:
Based on the foregoing, City staff recommends that the
Planning Commission uphold the denial of the Appellant's
massage establishment permit application.
5. Design Review 2013 -12 — AT &T Utility Cabinets
Action denied. A new resolution to
3 -2'
A request to install 25 aboveground utility cabinets in, or
be prepared and submitted at the
adjacent to, the public right -of -way in various locations
next scheduled meeting for
throughout Tustin to house and operate Lightspeed
consideration.
equipment for U -Verse service.
PC Action Memo 1 -28 -14
Page 3
Agenda Item
Action
Vote
APPLICANT: AT &T California
1265 N. Van Buren Street, Room 180
Anaheim, CA 92807
PROPERTY
OWNERS: City of Tustin (23 locations)
Venturanza Del Verde HOA (one
location)
Laurelwood HOA (one location)
LOCATION: Citywide
RECOMMENDATION:
The Planning Commission may take one of the following
options:
1. Should the Commission desire to approve all 25
proposed cabinets, as conditioned:
• Adopt Resolution No. 4235 approving Design
Review 2013 -12 to install and operate 25 utility
cabinets (combination of aboveground and
flush - mounted underground), located at various
locations within or adjacent to the public right -of-
way;
2. Should the Commission desire to require that all 25
proposed cabinets be underground and flush -
mounted, as conditioned:
• Adopt Resolution No. 4235A approving the
installation and operation of 25 flush - mounted
underground utility cabinets, located at various
locations within or adjacent to the public right -of-
way; or
3. Should the Commission desire to deny Design Review
2013 -12:
Direct staff to prepare a resolution of denial with
associated findings for consideration by the
Commission at the next regularly scheduled Planning
Commission meeting.
6. Minor Adjustment 2013 -006 — Enderle Gardens
Adopted Resolution No. 4247 as
4 -1
A request for a minor adjustment to increase and remodel
provided. (Attached.)
the existing community entry wall to a height of forty -three
(43) inches, finish with stucco and pilasters. The existing
walls are 36 inches high and located within the private
property front yard setback area.
PC Action Memo 1 -28 -14
Page 4
Agenda Item
Action
Vote
APPLICANT: Vince Feehan
Enderle Gardens Property Owner
Association
14241 Acacia Dr.
Tustin, CA 92780
PROPERTY Robert Clark & Donna Hopson
OWNERS: 17331 Jacaranda Ave.
17332 Jacaranda Ave.
Tustin, CA 92780
LOCATION: 17331 Jacaranda Ave.
17332 Jacaranda Ave.
Tustin, CA 92780
RECOMMENDATION:
That the Planning Commission Adopt Resolution No.
4247, denying Minor Adjustment 2013 -006 to allow block
walls taller than three (3) feet within the front yard setback
of single family residences located at 17331 & 17332
Jacaranda Avenue.
Commissioners Thompson and Smith dissented'
Chairperson Pro Tem Thompson dissented"
Please contact me at 714 - 573 -3031 if you have any questions regarding this matter.
Distribution: Tustin City Council
Planning Commission
City Manager
City Clerk Services Supervisor
City Attorney