Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout14 FINAL P.M. 2002-106 06-02-03AGENDA REPORT Agenda Item Reviewed: City Manager Finance Director 14 MEETING DATE: JUNE 2, 2003 TO: WILLIAM HUSTON, CITY MANAGER FROM: COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT SUBJECT: FINAL PARCEL MAP 2002-106 SUMMARY: Final Parcel Map 2002-106 is a request to subdivide a 1.62-acre site at 535 E. Main Street into two (2) parcels for the purpose of conveyance. Parcel 1 will contain an existing 4,773 square foot retail building and Parcel 2 will contain an existing carwash, 1,236 square foot convenience store, and gas fueling station canopy. On August 26, 2002, the Planning Commission recommended that the City Council approve Tentative Parcel Map 2002-106 and on September 3, 2002, the City Council approved Tentative Parcel Map 2002-106 by adopting Resolution 02-81 with conditions to ensure compliance with the Subdivision Map Act. All conditions have been fulfilled and the final map may be approved and recorded. (Owners/Applicants: Tustin Auto Wash/Tom Baumgartner) RECOMMENDATION: That the City Council adopt Resolution No. 03-73 approving Final Parcel Map 2002-106. FISCAL IMPACT: Final Parcel Map 2002-106 is an applicant-initiated project. The applicants have paid applicable fees for the processing of this map. ENVIRONMENTAL: Final Parcel Map 2002-106 is Categorically Exempt pursuant to Section 15315, Class 15 of Title 14, Chapter 3 of the California Code of Regulations (Guidelines for the California Environmental Quality Act). DISCUSSION: The project site is developed with an existing 4,773 square foot retail building and a car wash, 1,236 square foot convenience store, and gas fueling station canopy at 535 E. Main Street (Attachment A - Location Map). City Council Report Final Parcel Map 2002-106 June 2, 2003 Page 2 The applicant wishes to subdivide the site into two (2) parcels for conveyance purposes as follows: Proposed Gross Area Required Provided Parcel No. (acres) Use Parking Parking Parcel 1 0.5702 Retail Building 4,773/200 = 24 29 Parcel 2 1.0496 Car Wash Retail 1,236/200 = 6 24 Convenience Store Carwash = 15 Fueling Station Service Station - 3 Total = 24 Each parcel of the subdivision would meet the development standards of the Central Commercial and Parking Overlay zoning district, including the minimum site area, lot width, setbacks, number of parking spaces, and driveway widths. However, the two parcels would maintain reciprocal ingress, egress, and parking and share a common trash enclosure and utilities (Attachment B -Submitted Map). To ensure reciprocity and continuous maintenance of the common areas, a covenant of easement with maintenance provisions has been prepared and approved by the City Attorney, which will be recorded with the final parcel map. The final parcel map is in substantial conformance with the requirements of the Tentative Parcel Map, the City's Zoning and Subdivision Codes, and the State Subdivision Map Act. Staff recommends that the City Council adopt Resolution 03-73 (Attachment- C) approving Final Map 2002-106, subject to compliance with all applicable requirements to the satisfaction of the City Engineer prior to recordation. Minoo Ashabi v Elizabeth A. Binsack Associate Planner Community Development Director Attachments: A. Location Map B. Final Parcel Map 2002-106 C. Resolution No. 03-73 S:\Cdd\CCREPOR'F~'PM 2002-106.doc ATTACHMENT A Location Map LOCATION MAP PROJECT NO. ADDRESS 535 E. Main Street TPM 2002-106 IT IT~IIT Iio ,,,, / Project Site ATTACHMENT B Submitted Final Parcel Map SHEET $. OF · ALL oF TERTATIVE PARCEL MAP NO. 2002~10G 1~3 AC~S GRO~ 2[PARGELS~ ,. PARCEL MAP N0.2'002 '106 IN THE CITY OF TOSTIN, COUNTY ORANGE ~ STATE OF CALiFORNiA CARL A MASTRO RCE 27156 CAM ENGINEERING CO. , ,JULY 2000 BASIS OF B~ARING . MO~IUMENT LEGEND ,THE I~EARING SHOWON HEREON ARE BASED ON THE BEARING BETWEEN · I~ONTROL STATION GP$ NO BOG3 ANO 8TATI~ ~I NO. 603~ KI~ S 67'~0'E ~' BET L&TAG R~ 2~15G  GO~INATE8 ~ W ~ .~ T~ ~IF~)~.~IATE~Y~ .ICES, :8~1 ~ SET I"IP TAG~D RCE 27156 Z~ VI J~ ~,, IIl~PO~ ~ ~l ~* ~ ~LL DIST~CES ~WN ~ ~, ~ OT~WI~ ~T~ TO ~TAIN ~lO 0 SET TAG RCE 27186 AS NOTED ~ 0 SET ~P~ & W TAG RCE < ( I ,PER ~- ~/40 · I ~ '.IN RECORDS OKFI~ IN T~ ~ COUNTY v~n~wle& ~ [ ~ ~SURYEYOR8 ~FI~. ' F TP~ PMB 4'1/3 I = / I.N ~1~71127 P I ~ ~CT FD ~T P~ PMB ~1/~ FD C NAIL PER P~.99-161 P~J~IS/II/I2 ~ / -I ~ 608~9~ 401 ~ I ~I ~I~/ ~ C~,T~ I~ AND ~R OCS ~ ~NE-IRV 1404 ~ I /. '-. - ' ~ nTST,. / ~~ /~J X FD PK NAIL PER CITY TIE BK 495 / /~ ,,·FD. O.C.S.~ I .P* ~ leO~O' ~ ~ ~ ~ * ORAN~ CO~Y ~l OFFI~, ~ ~ / ~/~ . ~7~6~ P/L~I ' ~ '(' G~m . N ~17814.7~3 ' ~,~. ~,r. ~ ~ / - ~ I~ b ~ ~ ~" '~ '~ ~ET 2 FOR EASEMENTS ~TES *~4g/~ X ' FST~'BLIB~ · ' ~& ~ ~ '"~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~1 LEASEMENT DEDICATED HEREON TO THE CITY OF TUSTI. ~_ '~' .4 ~ ~ i --~[ FOR FIRE AND DOMEST lC WATER SYSTEM AND APPURTENANCES ~ f'~'/~' ' ~'- ~-~:~ .~.E~-3~JE~O~%uu~u~a~ STATION GPS , - I " , ~?~,., PE~ P.. I./.-~o..o.~: ~ . ~ ' I s e9-27'06 E ~' $~7~" - REPLACED WI~ L&T ON SURFACE ~ ~ '~%~_ FDC~L NLEUN&T ~ ~ ' IF'::...'i~ ~ /":~'~::,..,.'::~;:.:' I ~ ~ ~O~.~ NnT~NGFD . ~ II /_l~O.~.~~ ~' / / ,; ~% //' ~/ I[ '4' I r~i.f ~~~'~_~_~_/ /-.~' ~ ~ 41 =: ~ ,/ ..~/.~//..~.v," ~ '~ I~'! I~' ': ' I r t ,- --- , ~t tz .l~ · H ~ ~l~ - ~oo ' ._ . ' itl/' ~1~~ : ~TA IL B ' 1 . ~~~ ~o~' · ' , ................... / x' ,~ /,' . o~.~' ~, · ." / · ':'/ / ~..~1~ - ----~ .... ~. ~ : ' · ~-z~'~ ' , .. ' . , . ~,--, -. (1194.14') ~{ 194.14' l) ~ , ~I'PM~IS/II-I2 ' P&a ~1 I T .T~E'~. 754 ' ' " ,. ~lN STREET f ~ ~STA~ISH BO~DARY B~ HOLDINGFOU~ M~N~ENTS PER eMB ~TH BOtAnY .: SHEET 2 OF 3 &LL O~ TENTATh/~ p,M~CEL IdM) 3M~-IM] iii ACRES NET i.,~ &C~ES 6ROSS DATE O~ SURLY .JULY ~ '2, pMK~LS PARCEL MAP NO. 2002-106 CAM £NGIN[ERING CO IN THE CITY OF TUSTIN. COUNTY ORANGE STATE OF CALIFORNIA ~=JNG A ~U~DIVW, ION OF LOTS t.2J.4J.~.te. AMD a PORTION OF ON A MAP RECQJ~O~D IM ~OQK ia, PAGE le OF i~7,ELLAJ~:OU~ RECC]JID~ OF LOG AN(ZELE~ COUNTY. ~~ ~C~ED Iff LA. ~ ~A~II5 ~l. ~C~S.~ ~AN~ c~y. CALIFORINA JULY 2000 CARL A M&STRO RC[ 27156 NOTARY ACKNOMIt. EOG~MENT CERTIFICATIC~I STATE OF C, AUFOJtNIA! irs COUNTY OF ) LIS ON T~as TO ~ 4~ ~ TO ~ ~ T~ ~ ~ ~T~ ~) TO ~ T~ ~T~8) 'MY STATE OF C-,,AL.IFORNIA) )SS COUNTY OF TO ~ (~ ~ TO ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~TIM~T~Y ~) TO ~ T~ ~~DTO~ ~T~ ~W 6~(~ ~T~ ~ NOT/M~Y ACKNOWI~M~NT CERTIFICATION STATE OF CALIFORNIA) )SS C.,O4.J~TY OF ) GN THIS _ BEFORE PERSONdI~LY ~O TO ME (C)~ PROVED TO ~ ~ T~ ~ ~ ~T~T~Y ~) TO M T~ ~ ( Si ~ ~( Si ~ . ~ TO T~ ~~TO~ T~T~ . - ~ ~ T~ ~8) ~O. ~ ~ ~. SIGNATURE MY Pfl~I~PAL PLACE OF 8USINESS IS NOTARY PUeLIC IN ,MdO FOR S~JD STATE iN ~ COUNTY EASEMENT NOTES ,~ 6.5' EASEMENT FOR THE SANTA ANA VALLEY IRRIGATION COMPANY FOR PiPE UNE ~ ~ES PER R/.S 31/35 ':B~ SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA EDISON COMPANY EASEMENT FOR UNDER GROUND LINES ,,~ AND INCIDENT'AL PURPOSES F~R BK 7680 PG 2~4 OF OFFICIAL. RECCX~6. ~:)UTHERN CALIFORNIA EDISON COMPANY ~ENT FOR PUBLIC UTILITIES ~ SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA ED$1ON COMPANY EASEMENT FOR PUBLIC UTILITIES ~AND INCIDENTAL P~S PER iNSTRUMENT NO. 200101354.11 OF OF OFFICIAL RECOILS. (~ ~MENT RESERVED FOR INGRESS~ ~SS, SEWER AND WATER LINES PURPOSES FOR ADJACENT OWNER AS SHOWN ON THIS MAP AND ALSO AN ~NT FOR FIRE LANE D~DICATED HEREON TO THE CITY OF TUSTIN O EASEMENT FOR FIRE AND DOMESTIC WATER SYSTEM ANO APPURTENANCES AS CEDICATED HEREON TO THE CITY OF TU~TIN. (J~ EASEMENT FOR FIRE ~S PURPOSES AS D~DICATEO HEREON TO THE ClT~ OF TUSTIN Ist STREET FIRE LAN[ EAM[MIrNT DEdiCATED H~R[ON TO TH[ CiTY Mr T~TIN ,,...'E. O~ "" '~- ""' "'' /.:..~ IDEAIT/cA~ # zIs.$o· # '/ MAIN STREET // -- '-~'---~&w ncEe,442 ~ P.M.B. ~1Ml1-12 GJ~,L TIE, FIIIE UUIIE AND APPROVED ACCESS L~CATI. Oll M'TAIIJ ·NEET 1OF 3 ALL OF ~NTATNE PMK::EL MM' alCZ-IM 1.41 AC~ES IA-T LSS AC~J MIOI$ ~IA~ OF ~UI~rY AJLY ~00 PARCEL MAP NO. 2002-106 IN THE CITY OF TUSTIN. COUNTY ORANGE, STATE OF CALIFORNIA BEM~ ASUIDMSN3N OP LOTS 1,2.3,4,1,S,1O, ANDA PoffrK)N OF ABANDONED bd ~IREET, IN BLOCK FOF YOII~AI~UBOIVISION OF A MAP RE(XINDED IN BOOK ~ll, IIAGE 10 OF MIBCELJ.ANE(X~ RECORDS CAM I:'NGIN£1rRiNG CO. CALIFCNqMiA. JULY 2000 OWNERSHIP cERTIFICATE W1E HEI~E~Y DEDICATE 'l'O TH~ PtHIUC FO~ ~I'REET IqJg~PO~.~ NI~N ~'~R~T, C~NNIT:NIAL WAY ANO N~Wgq3NT AVP. NUE o WE~MJO HB~:~Y D~DICATE TO THE C~'YOFTU~TIN AN ~FO~ FtRE/i~D DOMFJTi¢ WATER IBY~TEM ~ND ~qJRTEN~M~E$ A8 ~NOWN ON THI~ MAP . WEAL~O HEREBYD~XCATETOTHECtTYOFTUIFriNN4EA~IMENT FO~ FIRE L~NEPURPO~ES WE JMJ~ HEREBY ~ ~ND REUNQUi~4 TO THE CITY OF TU~TIN ALL VEI~'C~JI. AA ACCE6$ ~ TO N~IW~)~T AW~IUE~.XC~PT AT APPff~O~D ACCE~ LOCATION~. HOWARD FARRAND, TRUSTEE OF THE FARRAND FAMILY TRUST DATED JANUARY I~OU[ST air OA~[: D[PUI¥ CARL A MASTRO RC£ 271['G ENGINEER' STATEMENT: THIS WAP NAS P]~L:)AR~D BY ME OR U~DER HY DIRECTION AND TS BASBD UPON A ~'I~LD SURVEY IN CONFORMANC~ WITH RA~UIP,~I~T~S OP THE SUBDIVISION MAP ACTAND LOCAL ORDINANCE AT THE R~UEST OF P,]~ESH ~JARIA ~N MAY2000. Z H~R~y ~TATE THAT ALL HONUNL~TS ARE OF TH~ (~ARACTER AND OCCTJPy THE POSITIONS INDICATED, OR THeY WILL B~ ~ET IN SUCH POSITIONS ON OR BBFORE ~E 1. 2003; AND THAT S~[D MONUM~S AR~ SUFFICT~NT TO ENABI~ SURVEY TO B~ RE~RACHD I H~P~BY STATE PARCEL MAP SUBSTANTIALLy CONI~RMS TO TH~ APPROVED OR CONDITIONALLY APPROVED TBNTATIVE MAP, IF ANY. ~.~/'~~',4~y~ Ret 2715~ EXPIRATION ]-S~-05 ~/,.., .,/,, ',~:~,: -, COUNTY SURVEYOR'S STATEMENT ! HEREBY ITATE THAT I HAVE ~ THIS MAP AND FOUND THAT ALL MAPPING ~ATISFIED ~,AIO MAP IS TECHllCAU. Y CORRECT RF. LATNE TO THE P'AJ~CEL MAP REKHA BAJAR/A, SOLE TRUSTEE OF THE RAMESH BAJARIA AND REKHA BAJARIA RE VOCABLE TRUST DATED MAY 6, 2000 REKHA BA.M,R:IA TRUSTEE SOUTH BAY/I}ANK, BENEFICIARY UNDER A DEED OF TRUST RECORDED MARCH 30, wee P~ESiDENT Aifl. ~C~TARY . HOWARD W FARRAND, TRUSTEE OF THE FARRAND FAMILY TRUST DATED JUNUARY t6,1~6 UNDER A DEED OF TRUST RECORDED FEBUARY 7,1~96 AS /__~,~gENT NO. 19~119E OF OFFICIAL RECORDS HOWARD W FA~RAND I TRUSTEE .... NOTARY ACKNOWLEDGEMENT CERTIFICATION STATE OF CALIFoMA) )SS PE~C)N( S) W~C~(8)~'~ .. mJ~CRmED TO THE w~r~N NSmUMENT ~AJ~D_ ACKNOW. E[X)ED TO ME TH*T INE~B)F./mEy, F. XECUT~D ~E SAME m ~N~TWT~T~I~ ALJTHC)R~D CAPAC~Y.(IE$), AND THAT BY~I&~Mi/TNEIR LMm) o. THE mmLMNT T,E PF.W~S). ON T.E Em~'Y UP~ BEW~F ~TNESS MY~,M~. NOTARY ~ CERTIFIC~TION STATE OF CALIFGRNIA~ ANC) '~K~M.E(X3EO TO .E THaT NL,~HFJI~y DATE~ ~ DAY OF COUNTY TREASURER-TAX COtLECTOR'8 CERTIFICATE STAI~ OF CALFORNIA ) COUNTy OF ORANGE ) I hMeby c. ed~ ti'mt iccordin0 to ihe recon~ M my office. ~lem lira no ikml W the I~d cewrecl by I/~ map or any pa~t thereof for u~paM SIMO. Cow~, n.alicipld M loc/ MSP Ac~ h~o boen Gor~)lMd ultA mgan:iing deposb to socum peymeM of Mxos or · oecM L~enmenb colied~d it laxel on the lind (~wed by this i~p. DMod tNs doy of. (Men,h) John M.W. Momlach By: County Tma~um~-Tax Collector Deputy Treasurer-Tax CMle~or CITY ENGINEER STATEMENT; I HEREBY STATE THAT I HAVE EXAMINED THIS MAP AND HAVE FOUND I T TO SE SUBSTANTIALLy IN CONFORMANC~ W1TH THE 'r~NTATIVE MAP. IF REQUIRED, AS FILED WlI~-I AMENDED ANO APPROVED BYTHE CI'I~ PLANNING C, OMMISSlON; THAT ALL PROVISION8 OF THE SUBDIVISION MAP ACT AND CITY SUBDIVISION REGULATIONS HAVE BEEN ~ WWH AND THE MAP IS TECHNICAU_y CORRECT IN AL/. RESPECTS NOT STATED TO BY THE COUNTY SURVEYOR. DATED THIS DAY OF , ,2003 TIM D. SERLET RCE 28738 LICENSE EX,RES g 1 30 1 06 CITY ENGINEER, CITY OF TUSTIN CITY CLERK'S CERTIFICATE STATE OF CALIFORNIA ) ) SS COUNTY OF ORANGE ) I HEREBY CERTIFY THAT THIS MAP WAS PRESENTED FOR APPROVAL TO THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF TU~TiN AT A REGLk. AR MEETING ~F HF. LD ON THE AND THAT T"-R _ ~A.y OF .... ,2003 HE EUPON SAJDCOUNClLDID. BY AN ORDER DULY PASSED ANO ENTERED. A/v~ROVE SAID MAP AND DID ACCEPT ON BEHALF OF THE PUBUC. St~JECT TO IMPROVEMENTS ~ DEDICATION FOR STREET F'URFO~ES OF: MNN STREET. C~CNTENNIAL WAY AND NEWPI~T AVENUE. AND DIOALSO ACCEPT ON BI~HALF OF THE CITY OF TUS~qN. THE EA~-MENT FOR FIRE AND DOMESTIC WATER SYSI~=M ANO APPURTENANCES THE EASEMENT~ FOR FIRE LANE PURPOSES. ~ VEHICULAR ACCESS RIGHTS TO NEWPORT AVENUE AS RELEASED ANO RELINQUISHED. WE ALSO HEREBy ASANOON, PIJRSUANT TO SECTION ~6499 20 1/2 OF THE SUS~VION MAPACT. THEPUSUC EA~-MENTWlTHINBOOK 11811 PAGE 73. NOT SHOINN OR THIS MAP. AND DiD AL~O APPROVE SUBJECT MAP RIJR~UAJ~/T TO THE PROVISIONS OF S~CTION (a) (3) (A) OF 1HE SUEOMSION MAP ACT. DATED THIS__ DAy OF 2003 PAMELA STOKER. CITY CLERK CITY OF TUSTIN SIGNATURE OMISSIONS PURSUANT TO THE PROVISIONS OF SECTION 86436 ia (3) (A). 'THE FOLLOWING SIGNATURES HAVE BEEN OMI~rED." 1 SANTA ANA VALLEY IRRIGATION COMPANy. HOLDER OF AN EASEMENT FOR PIPELINE PURPOSES SHOWN IN BOOK 31, PAGE 35 OF RECORD OF SURVEYS. 2. SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA E[NSON COMPANY. HOLDER OF EASEMENTS FOR PUBLIC UTILITIES . INCIDENTAL AND UNOER GROUNO PtJRPO~ES RECORDED IN BOOK 7890, PAGE 294 ANO A~ INSTRUMENT NOR. 20010135431 AND 20010487896 ALL OF OFFICIAL RECORDS. 3. THE CITY OF TUSTIN. HOLDER OF AN EASEMENT RECORDED IN BOOK 11Sll, PAGE 173 OF OFFICIAL RECORDS. FOR STREET. HIGI-flNAY AND INCIDENTAL PURPOSES 4. NEWPORT-TUSTIN ASSOCIATES, HOLDER OF AN EASEMENT FOR INGRESS. EGRESS 5. LARWIN SQUARE TUSTIN, LLC, HOLDER OF AN EASEMENT FOR INGRESS. EGRESS AND INCIDENTAL PURPOSES RECORDED AS INSTRUMENT NO 1~0107283 OF OFFICIAL RECORDS. ATTACHMENT C Resolution No. 03-073 RESOLUTION NO. 03-73 A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF TUSTIN APPROVING FINAL PARCEL MAP 2002-106 TO SUBDIVIDE A 1.62 ACRE PARCEL CURRENTLY DEVELOPED WITH A CAR WASH, CONVENIENCE STORE, AND FUELING STATION CANOPY AND A RETAIL BUILDING INTO TWO (2) PARCELS FOR CONVEYANCE PURPOSES. The City Council of the City of Tustin does hereby resolve as follows: I. The City Council finds and determines as follows: A. Final Parcel Map 2002-106 to subdivide a 1.62 acre parcel with existing development into two (2) parcels of 0.57 and 1.05 acres located at 535 E. Main Street, for conveyance purposes, was submitted by Tom Baumgartner on behalf of Tustin Car Wash for consideration. The 0.57 parcel (Parcel 1) will contain a 4,773 square foot retail building and the 1.05 parcel (Parcel 2) will contain the carwash, 1,236 square foot convenience store, and fueling station canopy; B, The Planning Commission recommended that the City Council approve Tentative Parcel Map 2002-106 on August 26, 2002, and the City Council approved Tentative Parcel Map 2002-106 on September 3, 2002; C, The proposed subdivision is in conformance with the Tustin Area General Plan, Tustin Zoning Code, State Subdivision Map Act, the City's Subdivision Code, and has been determined to be consistent or has been conditioned to be consistent with the Air Quality Sub-Element; D. The site is physically suitable for the type of development proposed; E. The site is physically suitable for the proposed density of development; Fo The design of the proposed improvements is not likely to cause substantial environmental damage or substantially and avoidably injure fish or wildlife in their habitat; Go The types of improvements proposed are not likely to cause public health problems; H. Reciprocal access for parking, ingress, egress, common trash and utilities and continuous maintenance of the common areas will be ensured through a covenant of easement with maintenance provisions City Council Resolution No. 03-73 Final Parcel Map 2002-106 June 2, 2003 Page 2 approved by the City Attorney, which will be recorded with the final map; All necessary easements and dedications have been shown on the map and associated improvements have been installed; and, J, Final Parcel Map 2002-106 is Categorically Exempt (Class 15) from the provisions of the California Environmental Quality Act pursuant to Section 15315 of Title 14, Chapter 3 of the California Code of Regulations (Guidelines for the California Environmental Quality Act). II. The City Council hereby approves Final Parcel Map 2002-106 to subdivide a 1.62 acre parcel into two (2) parcels that are 0.57 and 1.05 acres located at 535 E. Main Street for conveyance purposes. PASSED AND ADOPTED at a regular meeting of the Tustin City Council, held on the 2nd day of June 2003. Tracy Wills Worley MAYOR PAMELA STOKER CITY CLERK City Council Resolution No. 03-73 Final Parcel Map 2002-106 June 2, 2003 Page 3 STATE OF CALIFORNIA ) COUNTY OF ORANGE ) CITY OF TUSTIN ) SS I, Pamela Stoker, City Clerk and ex-officio Clerk of the City Council of the City of Tustin, California, do hereby certify that the whole number of the members of the City Council of the City of Tustin is five; that the above and foregoing Resolution No. 03-73 was duly passed and adopted at a regular meeting of the Tustin City Council, held on the 2nd day of June, 2003 by the following vote: COUNCILMEMBER AYES: COUNCILMEMBER NOES: COUNCILMEMBER ABSTAINED: COUNCILMEMBER ABSENT: PAMELA STOKER CITY CLERK