Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout13 REVISION TO THE DRAFT HOUSING ELEMENT DocuSign Envelope ID: 1329BDA6-63C6-4222-8A36-123CE92404B2 13 ms9Agenda Item DS-- t9 N Reviewed: AGENDA REPORT City Manager1W �� Finance Director N/A MEETING DATE: AUGUST 17, 2021 TO: MATTHEW S. WEST, CITY MANAGER FROM: JUSTINA L. WILLKOM, COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DIRECTOR SUBJECT: REVISION TO THE DRAFT HOUSING ELEMENT SUMMARY: The proposed draft has been amended to include additional areas such as the Tustin Market Place and the Enderle Center that could potentially be developed with residential units. The redistribution of units throughout the City is intended to further facilitate the equitable dispersion of housing units of various income levels. FISCAL IMPACT Housing Element Update is a City-initiated project. There are no direct fiscal impacts anticipated as a result of adopting the Housing Element Update. However, the implementation of the policies within the Housing Element may result in fiscal impacts to the City. CORRELATION TO THE STRATEGIC PLAN The proposal supports the implementation of Goal A within the City's Strategic Plan: Goal A: Economic and Neighborhood Development: Enable business opportunities and job development and to enhance the vibrancy and quality of life in all neighborhoods and areas of the community. RECOMMENDATION That the City Council receive and file this report. BACKGROUND The California Government Code requires that each City adopt a Housing Element as a mandatory part of its General Plan. Of the mandated General Plan Elements, the Housing Element is the only one that is required to be updated on a specific schedule. The Housing Element is also subject to review by the State Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD). State Planning Law mandates that jurisdictions within the Southern California Association of Governments (SCAG) region adopt revisions to their Housing Elements by October 15, 2021. DocuSign Envelope ID: 1329BDA6-63C6-4222-8A36-123CE92404B2 City Council Report August 17, 2021 Revision to the Draft Housing Element Page 2 For the 2021-2029 Housing Element Planning Period, the City was assigned a Regional Housing Needs Assessment (RHNA) allocation of 6,782 housing units, see Table 1. As shown below, approximately half of the RHNA units are market rate, or above market rate. TABLE 1 INCOMER• PFr Of Very Low 31-50% 1,724 25% Low 51-80% 1,046 15% Moderate 81-120% 1,132 17% Above Moderate 120% 2,880 42% Total 6,782 100% A Housing Element Community survey was first opened from January 28-February 28, 2021 . That survey received 194 responses, including two in Spanish. Following the May 11 , 2021 City Council/Planning Commission Housing Element Workshop, the survey was reopened again from July 1 — July 31 , 2021 . An additional 119 responses, 4 of those were responses to the Spanish language survey were recieved. The re-opening of the survey in July 2021 coincided with the draft Housing Element document public comment period. The attached PowerPoint provides an overview of all survey responses and a summary of the responses received for the opening ended question seeking additional ideas about where housing could be added in the City and best methods to produce more affordable housing. Respondents indicated the following preferences when asked where it would be appropriate to add more residential units within the City: ANSWER CHOICES RESPONSES In the Tustin Legacy Specific Plan(rLSP)area(refer to link above) 62.750/c, 192 Red bill Avenue Specific Plan(P.HASP)area(refer to rink above) 31.37% 96 Downtown Commercial Core Specific Plan(DCCSP)area(refer to link above) 20.92% 64 Tustin Marketplace(bounded by Jamboree Poad, Bryan Avenue,Myford Poad.and the 15 Freeway) 32.03% 98 17th Street commercial corridor(between the 1-55 Freeway and Prospect Avenue) 29.41% 90 Pacific Center East Specific Plan(PCESP)area(refer to rink above) 16.670K, 51 Other(please specify) 12.75% 39 Total Respondents:306 DocuSign Envelope ID: 1329BDA6-63C6-4222-8A36-123CE92404B2 City Council Report August 17, 2021 Revision to the Draft Housing Element Page 3 DISCUSSION Table 2 provides a revised Site Inventory summary. Specifically, the revision reallocates just over half of the 1,461 "Additional" units previously allocated to Tustin Legacy, by redistributing those units to the Tustin Market Place (431 units) and the Enderle Center (300 units). In addition, the units have been further distributed within Tustin Legacy to additional neighborhoods. TABLE 2 Sites Remaining Additional Total N Units/ Units to Units Entitled Units meet RHNA Tustin Legacy 4,055 Neighborhood D North 430 105 42 86 197 Neighborhood D South 1,296 100 314 154 263 665 Neighborhood G 2,029 200 526 245 404 1,054 Enderle Center 300 300 76 33 50 141 Tustin Market Place 431 431 98 43 95 195 Red Hill Ave 500 500 127 55 83 235 Downtown Comm.Core 747 747 190 82 125 350 ADUs/JADUs 100 100 25 15 17 43 Transitional Housing 132 132 132 0 0 0 Preservation of At-Risk Units 517 517 131 377 9 0 TOTAL 5,221 1,561 6,782 1,724 1,046 1,132 2,880 Public Outreach As part of the Housing Element Update, community engagement has included paid social media ads, dedicated website, postcard mailings and multiple online housing surveys. Details of these efforts are further described in the City's Community Engagement Plan (see attachment). The City continues to encourage stakeholder input on the draft Housing Element. For more information or questions about the Housing Element Update process, please email us at housingelement(u-)tustinca.or.1 or call city staff, Erica H. Demkowicz, AICP, Senior Planner, at (714) 573-3127. Next Steps • HCD review period ends —August 30, 2021 • Planning Commission — September 14, 2021 • City Council — October 5, 2021 DocuSigned by, C�. INiR,Q, oo- ED45DA2623854A5... Justina L. Willkom Community Development Director Attachments: 1. Community Engagement Plan 2. Community Survey Results Summary DocuSign Envelope ID: 1329BDA6-63C6-4222-8A36-123CE92404B2 - A V V x �Y_ + - ISP �l 11 City of 1 1 • Housing Element Update Community Engagement Plan Tustin y: 2021-2029 Housing Element DocuSign Envelope ID: 1329BDA6-63C6-4222-8A36-123CE92404B2 Contents Background .........................................................................................................................................3 ProjectPurpose...................................................................................................................................3 Goals & Objectives ...........................................................................................................................3 TargetedStakeholders .....................................................................................................................4 Outreach & Engagement Strategies...............................................................................................7 Education & Awareness Strategies...................................................................9 City of Tustin 1 2021 — 2029 Housing Element Update I Community Engagement Plan P a g e 1 2 DocuSign Envelope ID: 1329BDA6-63C6-4222-8A36-123CE92404B2 Purpose This COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT PLAN is for the City of Tustin's 61"Cycle Housing Element (2021-2029). This Plan describes strategies for engaging with residents and stakeholders through an online survey, education and awareness campaigns, and public meetings. Due to COVID-1 9 restrictions on in-person meetings,this outreach plan focused on alternatives such as virtual meetings, targeted email blasts, mailings to stakeholders, unpaid and paid social media postings, posters at community facilities, distribution of flyers, dedicated project website, and newspaper advertisements. Background The City of Tustin is preparing the 2021 — 2029 HOUSING ELEMENT UPDATE to evaluate current and future housing conditions, and identify housing sites and programs to meet the community's needs. While updating the housing element is a State requirement, it is also an opportunity to assess its accomplishments and progress toward meeting housing goals put forth in the previous Housing Element in 2013. The 2021- 2029 Housing Element will outline the goals, policies and programs needed to promote the development and preservation of safe, accessible, and diverse housing in the City. Goals and Objectives The GOAL of the COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT PLAN for the 2021 — 2029 Housing Element Update is to guide the City's community and stakeholder engagement efforts and to provide information about the importance in participating in the Housing Element Update. The OBJECTIVES of the Community Engagement Plan include: Building public awareness of the Housing Element Update, its requirements, and the City's vision and goals to adequately plan to meet housing needs to all of its residents; Educating the Tustin community on the requirements of the Housing Element Update, and progress since the previous Housing Element; Engaging community members and key stakeholder groups to provide input on potential policies and programs that will align with Tustin resident's housing needs; Facilitating discussions with community members and decision makers to identify how and where additional housing could be located within the City; and, Providing a concise document to the Tustin City Council and Planning Commission for adoption, with input and updates from public outreach and engagement activities during the Housing Element Update. 4 City of Tustin 2021 — 2029 Housing Element Update Community Engagement Plan Pa g e 3 DocuSign Envelope ID: 1329BDA6-63C6-4222-8A36-123CE92404B2 Targeted Stakeholders To meet the OBJECTIVES of the City of Tustin's COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT PLAN, the City requested feedback from a diverse set of stakeholders within the community who represent multiple interests and experiences related to housing.This section of the Community Engagement Plan includes the various organizations and agencies that were included in the City's outreach efforts. A database was maintained and updated with stakeholder contact information throughout the outreach process. The various stakeholders include, but are not limited to: RESIDENTS, APARTMENT OWNERS, SERVICE PROVIDERS, ORGANIZATIONS, and AGENGIES. so, Affordable Housing Advocates Rai& Organizations and agencies that advocate for safe and affordable housing opportunities for residents of all ages and abilities within the City of Tustin. This includes but is not limited to: - Kennedy Commission - University of Irvine - Tustin Planning - Habitat for Humanity Partnership - Jamboree Housing - OC Community - Linc Housing Corp. Housing Corp. Apartment/HOA Managers and Owners The TEAM (Tustin Effective Apartment Managers) group, which is a problem-solving community organization comprised of apartment managers, apartment owners, police, school officials, and service providers, and additionally outreached to 99 Home Owner Association property management groups throughout the Tustin area. Community Service Groups Community-based organizations that provide services to historically under-represented community members as well as youth and seniors. This includes but is not limited to: - St. Joseph Hospital - Alzheimer's of OC -Community Health - Lestonnac Free Clinic Initiative of OC - Meals on Wheels -Neighborworks OC -Tustin Community - Tustin Public Schools OC Foundation Foundation Disability Advocates Organizations and agencies that advocate or provide assistance to people with disabilities who rely on safe and accessible housing opportunities. This includes but is not limited to: - Assistance League of - Dayle McIntosh - Learning Disabilities - The Blind Children's Tustin Center Assoc. of Southern Learning Center CA - Regional Center of OC City of Tustin 1 2021 — 2029 Housing Element Update I Community Engagement Plan P a g e 4 DocuSign Envelope ID: 1329BDA6-63C6-4222-8A36-123CE92404B2 Economic Development Organizations that represent or advocate for business and employers in Tustin. This includes but is not limited to: - Tustin Chamber of Commerce - Tustin Economic - BIA Orange County - Orange County Development Division Chapter Business Council Environmental Advocates Commissions, agencies, or organizations that advocate for sustainable land use and environmental protection in the Tustin or Orange County area. This includes but is not limited to: - Southern California - Southern California - Southern California Air -OC Fire Authority Gas Edison Quality Management - Regional Water - OC Environmental - Airport Land Use -East Orange Quality Control Health Commission County Water Board District Low-Income Communities Organizations or agencies that represent low-income communities in Tustin. This includes but is not limited to: - Boys & Girls Clubs of - Big Brothers and Big - Goodwill of OC - Legal Aid Society of Tustin Sisters of OC OC - MOMS OC - OC Food Access - Patriots & Paws - Second Harvest Food Coalition Bank of OC - Veterans Legal - YMCA of OC - Community Action - Public Law Center Institute Partnership of OC - Orange County Finance Trust People Experiencing Homelessness Organizations, groups, or agencies that provide services to people experiencing homelessness in Tustin. This includes but is not limited to: - Housing and Homeless - City Net - Families Forward - Family Promise of OC Prevention Unit - Human Options - Olive Crest - OC Gateway to - Second Chance OC Housing - The Eli Home - American Family - OC Social Services - OC Rescue Mission Housing Tustin Family Campus -Orange County Housing Finance Trust Real Estate Affiliated Businesses or agencies that are affiliated with real estate transactions in Tustin. This includes but is not limited to: - Affordable Housing - Consumer Credit -Orange County Clearinghouse Counseling Realtors Association of Professionals City of Tustin 1 2021 — 2029 Housing Element Update I Community Engagement Plan Pa g e 15 DocuSign Envelope ID: 1329BDA6-63C6-4222-8A36-123CE92404B2 Residential Developers Residential or property developers that develop housing sites in Tustin, including affordable housing developers. This includes but is not limited to: - Intracorp Homes -City Ventures -Greystar -Curt Pringle & Assoc. - Century Housing - Civic Center Barrio - William Lyon Homes, -HomeAid Orange County Housing Corp. Inc. - Lennar Corp. - Taylor Morrison - Brookfield Residential - Shea Homes Southern CA Senior Housing and Advocates Agencies or organizations that provide senior housing in Tustin, and agencies that advocate for safe, affordable, and accessible housing options for senior residents living in Tustin. This includes but is not limited to: - Council on Aging - OC Office on -Tustin Housing -Senior Rental OC Aging Authority Properties in Tustin -Community Action -Orange County -County of Orange Partnership of Health Care Agency Senior Services Orange County Religious Institutions Faith-based organizations who provide supportive services to residents living in Tustin. This includes but is not limited to: - St. Paul's Episcopal - Grace Harbor - The Salvation Army -Orange County Church Church & School Rescue Mission Underrepresented Groups Cultural organizations or groups who advocate for the traditionally underrepresented groups in the Tustin area.The City has reached out to these organizations to encourage feedback. This includes but is not limited to: - AIDS Services - Fair Housing - Fair Housing Council of - Tustin Unified Foundation Foundation OC School District City of Tustin 1 2021 — 2029 Housing Element Update I Community Engagement Plan P a g e 1 6 DocuSign Envelope ID: 1329BDA6-63C6-4222-8A36-123CE92404B2 Outreach & Engagement Strategies The chart below provides a summary of the scheduled activities, community outreach and engagement strategies that the City implemented to obtain input and build awareness throughout the Housing Element Update. Each strategy encourages participation, facilitates meaningful dialogue with the community, and builds awareness of the challenges and opportunities of implementing housing strategies that meet the State's requirements. Schedule of Activities ► Housing Element Update Community ► Joint Community Workshop with Workshop with the Planning Commission the City Council and Planning ► Draft Document- Public Hearing with the Commission Planning Commission rj-une/JuIV 16Septernberl'L October November 116' Jan/Feb 1 kp=W 14 , 2020 A 2021 2021 2021 110� 2021 Ar A0, ► Community Survey open ► June 30-Reopened the ► Finalize Document- for 30 days Community Survey for 30 days Public Hearing with the ► Draft Housing Element City Council Document available for public review(30 days) and HCD review(60 days) Online Community Survey An online community survey was made available from January 21, 2021 through February 28, 2021, in English and Spanish, to help city staff better understand the communities housing needs and priorities. In total, there were 193 survey respondents, with a majority of the respondents being Tustin residents. The online survey re-opened for another 30 days from June 30, 2021 through July 30, 2021. Planning Commission and Council Meetings and Workshops A total of four community/public meetings are planned with the Planning Commission and City Council as part of the Housing Element preparation process. These virtual workshops and in-person hearings, serve as a method for community members to provide input on the progress of the Housing Element update as well as a venue to inform the Council and Commission on the state requirements, discuss housing needs, and to provide a progress update. November 10, 2020 — Planning Commission Workshop (Via Zoom) - City staff provided an overview of the housing element preparation process, including plans for community outreach. May 11, 2021- City Council and Planning Commission Workshop (via Zoom) - City staff presented its findings from the community outreach and engagement activities, and solicited input on future housing needs. Key topics covered at the meetings included: ■ Survey results ■ Reviewed existing housing policies ■ Potential new housing programs ■ Opportunity sites for meeting housing requirements ■ Project timeline City of Tustin 1 2021 — 2029 Housing Element Update I Community Engagement Plan P a g e 1 7 DocuSign Envelope ID: 1329BDA6-63C6-4222-8A36-123CE92404B2 Public Review Period The City is available to the public for a 30-day public review period, from June 30, 2021 through July 30, 2021. During this time, stakeholders and the general public are provided with the opportunity to review and comment on the Draft Housing Element document before it is finalized. The document has also been transmitted to the Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD) on June 30, 2021 for a 60-day review period. The HCD review period concludes on August 30, 2021. Planning Commission and Council Adoption Public Hearings After the final Draft Housing Element is developed, and reviewed by HCD,the City will hold public hearings with the Planning Commission and City Council before submitting the final draft to HCD for certification. Tentative — Planning Commission Hearing on September 14, 2021 Tentative — City Council Hearing on October 5, 2021 City of Tustin 1 2021 — 2029 Housing Element Update I Community Engagement Plan P a g e 1 8 DocuSign Envelope ID: 1329BDA6-63C6-4222-8A36-123CE92404B2 Education & Awareness Strategies The City is using many strategies to build education and awareness of the Housing Element Update, and increase participation among community members. The following strategies were implemented to ensure public awareness and to solicit feedback from residents and stakeholders. -CITY WEBSITE SPOTLIGHT FEATURE - Outreach and project information was •SOCIAL MEDIA POSTS- UNPAID posted as a spotlight feature on the City's website and sent to the web's AND PAID -Social media posts subscriber list in English and in Spanish were made containing information -POSTED FLYERS - Notifications in English and in Spanish were posted on the on public participation City's e-notice board, Library,Senior Center,Tustin Family Youth Center (TFYC), opportunities regarding the and Boys & Girls Club. Additional bundles of flyers were distributed at the Housing Element Update survey, Senior Center (200 flyers),TFYC (200 flyers), and Boys & Girls Club (100 and multiple workshops meetings, flyers). Additional flyer distribution was offered to individual apartment on all of the City's social meda locations part of the TEAM (Tustin Effective Apartment Managers) group platforms -CITY CALENDAR - Meeting information was posted on the City's Calendar -PRESS RELEASE-A press release •TUSTIN CHAMBER - Tustin Chamber of Commerce advertised meeting dates on was distributed in English and their website. Flyer graphics shared were in English and in Spanish. Spanish, inviting the public to review the Draft Housing Element -EMAIL BLASTS - Multiple email notifications were sent to 268 stakeholders and Update (97 subscribers) interested parties. The City Manager's Office utilized their Community Outreach •VIDEO OUTREACH -Mayor ListSery to e-mail notifications to over 10,000 subsribers. Graphics included and Clark's Corner video advertised attached to email blasts were in English and in Spanish. review of the Draft HEU. Video -POSTCARD MAILINGS - Postcards containing workshop and public participation was posted on all Social Media information in English and in Spanish were mailed to 396 interested parties outlets including YouTube including residents, businesses, property managers,housing advocacy groups, *The Tustin Chamber of Commerce non-profits, religious institutions and others. Information regarding workshop shared workshop/meeting participation was included within the City of Tustin's Strategic Plan postcards information on each of their social which were distributed to 29,885 Tustin residents and 3,457 Tustin businesses. media platforms Notification Methods U *WEBSITE- City developed a -NEWSPAPER ADVERTISEMENTS-To build widespread awareness of the dedicated Housing Element Update Housing Element Update,the City has made publications in local and regional webpage, hosted on the City's news resources in both printed and digital formats website *Website includes a project *Tustin News - distributed to over 7,000 Tustin residents overview, schedule of activities, *Irvine Weekly - distributed to over 8,200 Tustin residents, including a digital and information on how the public distribution, reaching over 33,000 individuals can get involved -PAID SOCIA MEDIA ADS - Paid advertisements on the City's social media *Website updated regularly with platfroms which enabled notification to a larger population than traditional timeline, meeting updates and postings survey information City of Tustin 1 2021 — 2029 Housing Element Update I Community Engagement Plan P a g e 1 9 DocuSign Envelope ID: 1329BDA6-63C6-4222-8A36-123CE92404B2 Appendix B Index of Interested Parties DocuSign Envelope ID: 1329BDA6-63C6-4222-8A36-123CE92404B2 Index of Interested Parties Housing Element Survey Respondents DocuSign Envelope ID: 1329BDA6-63C6-4222-8A36-123CE92404B2 u1 n r-I r' o rn O O O O O O N O N O O N N N O O O O N O N O l0 O Q N O O O 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 oo U M oo oo oo I- n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n N nQ n n n N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N0) N " u N N N U U U U U U U U U U U U U U U U U U U U U U U Q U U U 4 J 4 J 4 J v7 cn cn v7 v7 cn cn cn cn cn cn cn cn cn cn cn cn cn cn cn cn cn l0 cn � C cn cn cn 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 7 L 7 (p 7 7 7 O > m a L O a) N O N L +J O aJ LJ cu (0 N 0 a) L 0 Q N 4, W L U •� (� i L L Z N aJ O t M O N > N N L � a) L O O U O N U aJ U Q aJ 3 +J .L aJ Ln — O N N O O WD N N cn x n3 3 c �_ O +_ J +J t N L.L C l0 C Z0 2i O J _ = Z +J O Z L aJ Q (0 J Z _ aJ l0 C cn J cu CU z l0 aJ l0 w / C v (0 w v C C V_1 L L •� C C +J �. m w l0 l0 C l0 ' � 'cn N aJ X aJ +J co c o0 a� coo co coo f° p t ai _ �° a� O a� .� t T o t z Q } 0 — w a z m 0 � — � � z � Q •m � o � LL 0 = c7 Q u � DocuSign Envelope ID: 1329BDA6-63C6-4222-8A36-123CE92404B2 0 1.01.0N Q U O O O O O N N N N N N N N O O O O O W 00 00 W W 00 00 00 00 co 00 00 00 00 W W W W t I, n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n n Cu O N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N m m m 61 61 61 61 61 61 61 61 61 61 61 61 61 61 61 M N N Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q m U U U U U U U U U U U U U U U U U U t C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C O 41 Q L V1 (n V7 N N N N N N N N N N (n N N V7 N O (� N O U_ L (0 L � 5O •L N LQ J Q L �` L L C �` L Q m i c o o v� 2 E ao v c an v v v v 'c t N NC J 0 2 i TO 2 O O N N 4J O s — O N O O io � co N co co O O Q — an V- Wan �1 -1 of W > Q -T A Q U � J a cn J �1 0 A DocuSign Envelope ID: 1329BDA6-63C6-4222-8A36-123CE92404B2 Index of Interested Parties Community Development Block Grant Interested Parties List DocuSign Envelope ID: 1329BDA6-63C6-4222-8A36-123CE92404B2 MM -A 0000 0 0000 0 0 0 0 0 0 D-' o ONO 0 0 -A 00 o Ln o 0 0000 0 D-' D-' D-' o -A 0 �D �D r, r, r, 00 r, 00 00 00 r, 00 r, �D I'D 00 r, r, 00 �D 00 �D r, r, r, r, 1.0 1.0 1.0 00 �D r, N N N N N N N N N O N N N N N N N N N O N N N N N N N N N N O N N dl dl dl dl dl dl dl dl dl dl dl dl dl dl dl dl dl dl dl dl dl dl dl dl dl dl dl dl dl dl dl dl dl U U U U U U U U U U U U U U U U U U U U U U U U U U U U U U U U U > > U N f6 f6 U cc cc f6 U w m m (6 U (6 C C (o C C C (0 CD C C C (o C O Q Q •� C Q •� Q Q � E (0 Q Q Q Q (o > > (0 7 (o O O f0 co O co > > O D M O > O (moo cO0 cO0 7 cO0 > > > 0 > J N H U N Q J U N Q N Q H N J Q J N N Ln L L L J L N O r` a-+ N OJ O O N N N N L O O N NO MM +-+ +-+ h0 N N Nco VI OJ OJ N 7C) Z3C) U Ln Lf) �+ VIVI C VI o U Q °' ° 00 > °o m i L t > L U > Of Y �' Q +' 3 �° �' m 3 i Ln Ln Ln Q L O w ° b4 }' L E U L N r t L +-+ N O � � � U C OJ L C C (/I C N .+.+ L O i U Ln Y W N M (6 Ln LCL CL >- ^ r, r, m (p >- H > �i E > t � o ° > > � °o M ° � t t 3 Ln Ln Ln a 3 0 in � m w tD L > co M Y L > C a + C) u O CAM N U co C +, *' L('1 coo m x i i z t.+ x x x (o U (o iJ N w w C7 w Q Q O w Z w U x0 Z w O m Z Z `� O O iD 00 L('1 > L('1 00 r` L('1 O O > cocco co w w M °' Ln � M 00 O O 00 O O N w 0 0 4 O O 0 0 00 O O O O O N Q N c-I N .4 c-I Ln r, c-I Ln � c-I c-I c-I —A N a Ln —A N M 00 M a � .4 c-I N a- 0 O C U -5 C) O pO U OC) >- " b4 C N O � o O O > > U p O Ufl C C U t O — ° D E 7 o ° OJ b4 >. C C — Ln OJ O m O U b4 •L C C vii O U U OJro 'LO b4 OJ O C C C (% .z o Z C O i .+-+ b4 L 0 c cv O O � O u (6 U N I— O N (6 C (6 a C C) ° 'a-.+ C U U L >- O °c° 0 V) Ln ago ao ° a°i � •°U' O U c ago ago ( tLO � o � m `° o o' W " •c Ln 1-- o 0 o m 0 i i u E c c c 0 = O J N a � D Q = t V) Q o o } 3 " O O o = o 0 0 o u ° m 'E o5 c cj c c O o a O O "M C) o a a a o 0 N i c c +� o (n o' Z3 , a t = _ (0 O O O = aOo bo o •N >- — — — >. E E m E S E > fl L L o o E E E i N Ln — O L L L }' O O c� O O 'L (o E '(o '(o (o (o 'i O O i (0 7 7 7 +-' E W O Q Q Q Q co co U U u u U U C U U U w w w w w w (f (7 (7 O OJ m m C N E OD C)C Q 7 -0 OD Q C N m .� N •L O to � C N Y Q O Vl O O L C LL = ate-+ (6 OC E O _ U L O C C E i (6 (6 1_ i C Q � N > OJ OJ O cn 2 C) C U > _0 N -0 t (O0 i E N °' - O 7 = C b4 (o � U +�-+ LL U Q + (Eo - M m M ° c i to O N Y i O = o f0 > � = E C7 U Q Q U C U 4J to 4J M C N ° >. GO > :c� -0 to C w Ln Q m m U t U C C L Y GO 'L (6 GO L L (6 W m C ci 4J C •L +_+ 5 L 4J (o U E (o b4 � o ° N i a o U m (0 C) Z co 2 9 2 - 2 (n 3 0 0 z 2 = a w C7 v) 00 U U - a 2 2 �! U _3 0- DocuSign Envelope ID: 1329BDA6-63C6-4222-8A36-123CE92404B2 Ln M 'tt V) n N M M V) n O V) V) V) V) V) O V) lD M 00 N lD 00 lD O V) V) 00 -A lD rl O O O iD 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 iD M O O O O O iD -AIct u1 O 00 N -A N -A 0 0 -A O N 00 00 00 I, 00 lD I, n r� n n n 00 lD I, n n n n lD lD lD lD I, n �D lD lD 00 I, 00 I'D I, I'D I, n n N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N O N N N N N N N N dl dl dl dl dl dl dl dl dl dl dl dl dl dl dl dl dl dl dl dl dl dl dl dl dl dl dl dl dl dl dl dl dl dl a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a U U U U U U U U U U U U U U U U U U U U U U U U U U U U U U U U U U u u t (0 (0 > u 4) 41 4J (0 00 00 — OJ N (10 (6 (6 L (0 (0 (0 (0 (0 (0 (0 (0 (0 (0 (0 (0 (0 m O O 1- C C C C C C C C C C L C C C C C a a, a a a a a a w O a a a a a o (� (� 2 m a a C (0 C C C C C C (0 Y C C C C C 3 C C b4 7 C C (0 Vii Vii Vii Vii (0 > (0 (0 (0 (0 (0 (0 (0 (0 (0 (0 (0 (0 4J 7 7 f0 O 7 O > O ° (0 � > (0 O 7 7 7 (n O (n (n (n (n (n (n O J (n V, LA �, �, z = = J L U U J (n a (� U O O N Lr) � � ) N N N O n cn _ O U VI }+ +-+ > +-+ CD CD 7 VI VI VI -0 4J z 4J .- +� 7 7 N VI +�-+ 4J VI Q 4J +-+ (0 +_+ a-+ 7 Q VI VI Yk +-+ +-+ VI 7 — 4J 4J n3 +-+ +-+ +-+ O +-+ QJ 4J QJ (0 +-+ > C i � 4J > O W W W of (n 4J Y N °> Of > C) C) � 4J C) 4J C: E u1 1° 19 N m O +� +� +� w +� (i a f t O (n (n O a O +� +� a +� '+' o c c t L (n (n (n > (n O (o u - - L �i >- °_ (n '^ (0 I� '^ dl (0 (0 +' QJ O t t t M t O Ln }' O •L C N QJ +' '^ (0 t VI VI n a-+ H +� +� +� +, +� N iD 11 = O ° t0 •L w C ate-+ 3 +' ~ U i w ~ x A m � � x + Y w LM L m n- 7 O O i O U Z w O Z 0 > > w w w w w w m m Q O m io � w Z E O Q OD O —A u1 �Ln N 00 00 O W iD O O O O -A O N O Y O Ln � Z w m N 00 O .N-I —A 00 rIJ -AONO m —A —A —A N 001 OM N M 00 O m O V) lDD OLn —A I, OA Ln -A m n -A N N N N c-I c-I c-I O_ 01 N N 00 -A -A -A -A N M M O_ M -A +�+ C C O 7 0O (}0 E > L ° U _ 7 CL c C i C: Ln > 4J Ln UO O O C t U N � N N 0 H b4 Q >. O U � °J i o2S 0 U — ° c c p p :> a O 0 ° Y °' °�° c u m c Q u ° _ &- C i U 00 E m c W C — o ao a m � c O L (°n E .+� w N 0 U O O °' U u � — ° U O c O O O = o ° O D- �n L O z O L o > c� o (moo U U O u _u Ln C) (n 3 E O W •c (o i coo uC Ln 0 E.2 N ago OD .� o c U c o O C > a EcL -0 W N c c v Ln u C) cc cc D L L Q � t " O a o t m � v w w m O o o = O O o ° U _0 C) U N (aoo o c u = o p C) _ (o o L L t a v, a (n (n m a U U u C) o +� E .� ago m c - _ °c° c c c b4 (10 up m 0 -0 i m u 2 o C) C) C) c ° U O •° •L o o > u > w V) > E •+ +� �i > > > M (o +� ao O ? u u L W L Ln Ln Ln 3 z z 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 a a a (n (n (n (n Ln (CL }n H H H H H c � Y a b4 J Z3 O 4J -0 > Ln C C C 4J (0 1_ N 4J 4J E D 4J L >� m Y i i -0 � ° L O U C (0 4J N aJ W - O LL u c 0 °; oNE -i uoE w w m (o � c Ln E C7 '> � ^ > -0 c u 0 o u c N -0 c L L (o (0 (0 = O = (0 c (0 O t (0 (0 •� O z f>6 p '� p o W 0 a Q Z U U O J J W O_ CD J > co J J V) co mes)nEm¥ope gg£gBo Eeac-2 aA3 E1SCSm«& 0 0 o m / o 0 \ f % f / z f f @ @ @ @ ? @ @ @ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ 0 Ln@ § § § 2 c 5 § \ \ \ \ \ \ / \ 9 \ \ \ \ \ § � z z V) o ( _ ( \ \ . < 0 < ® � E ± » \ a \ / $ \ } 0 / 2 / / /co z z o ƒ \ m Ln @ @ \\ \ \ \ \ _ _ 0 2 \ % _ 2 0 c [ » » 0 L § E § § > \ g / / / \ \ \ � \ / S S E 2 G E E 5 5 § \ E n k / / U = 0 § _ = 0 0 § § � » / E \ \ \ \ \ \ \ \ 7 / _ \ / @ E \ \ \ \& Ln L > 3 \ < / \ \ \ ƒ / \ \ / DocuSign Envelope ID: 1329BDA6-63C6-4222-8A36-123CE92404B2 Index of Interested Parties Outside Agencies and Developers List DocuSign Envelope ID: 1329BDA6-63C6-4222-8A36-123CE92404B2 0 o 0 £ O v o o E v 00p LO N L H - O - W E O - 0 M. O O Q E Y O O E 1102 0 O Q v o L 3 v 9 - 3 0o - m � u u L W r0 y, 00 00 i O - `� O O O OO 1-00 n N X O T tp 00 O 00 of O O 01 Ol V O T T 00 O 01 O tp vt O .ti T tp 00 O Ol O O 00 00 O O 00 � N I� n T N O 01 O h N N N O 00 M N 1p I� N V 1p O VI N 1p I� M Ol N N O 1p O N N N 00 M I� n VI VI O M N 00 VI O 1p I� N l0 l0 l0 V 00 V N M VI V 00 W N T O T I� Ol T N T V�1 RO^1 T T M M M lmp lip Ol M V n Z l0 l0 VI VI n VI N M I� � W VI VI N 00 VI 1p V V 00 1p N Ol VI 00 00 VI VI O N V N N N N V N V N N N N N N V V 333 V N O3 33 N a 00 v n N 00 t0 V N VI VI � � VI VI 1p N VI N VI N VI N01 I (,1 m l.1 N m Q (.1 Ol (.1 m l,1 l.1 l,1 01 01 l.1 H U U (ro 01 01 01 Ol Y i0 i0 0 01 01 l.1 Y @ t6 t6 t6 t6 t6 t6 t6 w t6 t6 O �6 („) t6 N N N Ul d @ 5a` 5a` `� o a` `� a` a a a U z ¢ v H H H �n �n �n c7 �n n n v O O v �n N O Y 00 O � N O � O Y d > Ul n <> , > N > N v v ¢ ¢ sN a+ m m ¢ L @ L ¢ N a m T m H 0 ¢ N It N N N > d N o _O _O - T > -w N U m N d w O d h U O N r N n V1 '� ¢ 2 R in 00 O m p O O 0 -O L 0 m m m c 0 m LL O � m E L 01 N o — v E E o a O N o w 3 v o z E t7 0 ¢ LL x N > ; @ w m m z U U m o 2i C7 x �j g x a i� r U x 0 C7 Y in x m U x E Q O Z T N W W Z .-i N L O of Z N m N N W o vi lrt m 0 0 W T z O m p 0 tp W O m vl T ¢ N m , O Q tp tp W of of O N tp O O N O O 00 O O N O O t0 O I� b O of N Q V VI � M N N VI d Ol N N N N d N Ol d N N N VI d M d T T to O c 2 O 10 C d E uw 0 00 T v m@ @ i U O u ¢ — O =O L O 11 o u O O 2 O U N s O 0 N ry YQ{ p O O r 10 2 000 O O " O m U — to uo w EU f jM. _ Io °° a� O p m o Y o v H m a O o N O O r O N O LLO N 2 H 0 '^ O v C O v w o u 0 Eo m '.n — x a o = Y a v o r t u N .� v 'o v i v - 0 01 £ o 'o - o 2� o otl _ oo �o x v o v ._ o z Y d L d 10 T O +-' 00 2 2 C 'i H O m N d d -O T T 30 1 Y.� 0Z{ an d T £ N d H Q ' N @ d U Y N N d d 2 0 m x �n a '^ - v m ¢ 'a E _ -o o v £ T v E .. v v 3 T v x ¢ w v v °� a o v v 1 -o a O a v Qa @ v o ¢ Q E a ¢ v m o o s o@ a' m v ¢ x Y m m '... — E > Y m v u �^ £ v -o , m > a s v ._ v O v T m .n .n v o 0 o m v '� w v o m00 o v > a m v E v > o U > 0 O T Q H v a v O O H v J v is 2i LL �n x H O H O J O ¢ O v v W -O J - H N H a` v 3 2 — O o i E N o o o m 0 1 E 1 J O F U N O r i tOi6 T > d O d Q v -o a E ¢ i x -o �^ Z m m — v o v v _ > Q v v @ v v v 3 m v m v - DocuSign Envelope ID: 1329BDA6-63C6-4222-8A36-123CE92404B2 0 o 0`o a L o 0 0 0 0 3 o u v E o £ a w E "> - E v v — o v o v 9 v - � o f L o£ 0 M. E O � w L N m o a ^ a a N a N 0 N tp 01 tp O � O 01 01 L � � O 00 O 01 01 � N O Q NN QON QON O QO 0Q1 O 00 0Q1 QO N QON OQl Q u l7 m @ Q E x v o"oo 0a 5 5 @ @ m atta@o 0aa % % ¢ 0 p ` mv ai ai o0 ai ai _ 00 m ¢ to 2 m Z to ¢ �n H m U m m m H �m m ¢ m _ H m 0 u N O O O O O Y O ry ry N Z N v v 0 Nai ai > v D vi ai °�' ai v ¢ 3 v >; Q 3 v it N > ; 3 Q T Q L =' Q U Q a+ H d d D ? N m Q N N U j o t ry ry O N O O N U L 1 >@ L E - L U lryll d 01 o m O N > v " ip 'c N ¢ L in a Q > g w N o w o@ r r Y U 3@@ ^Y� fl- U O ~ O p 6 Io U 0 U Y Z W o f N W Q Q W o > w ii .^ti m vii m v m voi m ^ vix d x o 0 vii O o m o d vryi voi o o m in o0 o voi voi "' O v o N N d N M I� 01 V M N N N N N N 1p d VI 00 d N N N N N N M V N N N N Vf V N N d N N M 2 (j T T T o LL C d YE N T o Y @ o �E o v v o v m -° o 'O w Q v -o m ¢ N @ N H H to N N E T > o m m v o z - �^i v v `�° 01 v c °° o '^ m O 0 11 N v - o o ` v L v o 'o �° o ~ o ff m > O v v - o U' o 'u O E s v m a o tcc c c m@ - p - L T U _T ry EO N J In H d m m vi -O x m O O 2 H m N LL C '—.' a+ E 2 T T 00 E T c O E H E T Y U m T 'O u @ }T, N N �' O O 10 ai E � -' = v = v@ 0 3 T E o E E °� v E = z - v v O � x Q o T m o0 O EO O N H U U T O O y 01 o N m N O @ O- LL uo 2 do O /J c� w o 00 YO N i+ m yT, '1 N c c U x 2 00 y, — u J e x = N N N U U O T U T U @ in U w N d C O N H H 0010 w > E x :: @ @ 0°10 M. -o -o m u v v v v v m 'o 0°10 °1 0 v°1i £ t� v v = �^ 3 'o 'o v v o - m o i v o O `o a E E n u N N N -o v z E v n x x u z z O H O a 2i H H a Q v v v v v tv w LL LL v m `o v p o o v vim- > m O O m 0 > 01 3 3 o 3 3 d d E d d d U w w v01i w m w m o N o0 E v o v 01 o @ 01 a a o o T@ - m m @ Y Y v o v v o >�.' o o n o0 x Y v L N o Y v > v w = c m LL 'o v x @ m L@ ro u O o c o v m m o Y m' Jo u m m in ° m in Y �n z x v w z a �'n C7 c7 x a U' in DocuSign Envelope ID: 1329BDA6-63C6-4222-8A36-123CE92404B2 E 0 v v v 0 0 3 n � Y 0 0 v1 0 VOI V O N V � V1 V1 1p N V1 � M v1 tp h h 00 M N N V N llM1 N O tip N � W M M V1 N M M V1 M V1 V1 V1 V1 (} N tO O a1 O 5c5 � � 55555 � `�y5555 vm `� aNONON � c5 � � 55 � � 5 QQ � o � d � 2 - v z O 0 0 M 0o m o v N O O a+ N m V O O O R O N S m vl V1 N m N m Ul 00 N 00 N N a ; U W N N U @ @ 3 r+ a+ a+ Y Z w 3 N r+ m N U a m > m N 3 3 > -0 1'n �'n �'n - �^ N >w o N m > m - w v 3 .i .i Q. m Q Q v Q v v v �^ v > a T > v > 3 .. v o d a ` Q Q �° `v `v m Q ^ T O m N - Vl Vl Vl Q O O -O o 00 m d d - N o -m -m 3 M o L v o L L L L o - a1 c7 L 0 3 m a+ u v fl- c a v V1 N N r+ H @ ry 3] M Y ry m L 3 3 m _ _ m m p u m LL F v m uj o o z o 0 3 3 w " w w m ¢ ' E z z w `n 3 m O q W O .-i O m m O m 00 M M M O O N O O W M Q v1 O 00 Ol M O U V O M O vt O O v N N m N M 01 M N 01 1p h I� O M M O tp O O M ifl ifl ifl ifl m T m w c c vv w T T L o o m m p w 1 m v m uw E m o m m y E c c m +' N m _o o L vi 5i o O m m E '� o m o o m s v - 0 1n > v o o ' m vo coy m O = c) = 3 O .. > _ v > v o o w x N `° `° '^ w m m � Y °' o u o v E — m v ;� O Y O O o o N @ @ ro o T m N °� @ £ - m N m m m v o V o a c 0 0 o a Q o @ 2� .. .. .. Q o .•3• E v .'� a = = m = 0 0 0 o v v v -o v '" u m a. o f - � a ._ y o u a Q tv tv tv LL o 0 0 o O o o o@ E 0 0 o m c.i > > > c7 o f v :: a �n Y Y m Y Q =' Q �, x m LL col col c7 = z z 0 0 0 0 0 0 a v01i O vmi > > u v1 o v v O v o > O x ¢ O 0 v 0 o m u -O o m - o 9 N iU c o ._ o w . Q .L• n m H O > 003o ww a` JEw N � m w v @ o £ N a z w 3 m vE v > u _ m `m c m `g m m ` v v N T N r+ w o > U m m E m m m Z - > L L2 O 2 U Y Y } m Q D Q Z D U U m W 1 D W Y Y W E DocuSign Envelope ID: 1329BDA6-63C6-4222-8A36-123CE92404B2 Index of Interested Parties Adjacent Jurisdictions, Utilities, and College Districts List DocuSign Envelope ID: 1329BDA6-63C6-4222-8A36-123CE92404B2 E v L O w O- U W u N v c N N ++ N 3 L OC O N + N C O E m - m v Y u oo m y 3 m v N r > ° v E Zy� a � ° 3 v0 a: o o 2 n a i Y E �, �° v 3T 0 v 3@ 12 o V C O! m N m W m>, C @ N N ~ N m N N m U O! _ O C t6 N t6 r6 �' � C @ @ m to O L C N U ¢ Y U Y N Q J J ¢ N D m H N U Y Q J U U U O E O E L O N O o 0 0 ` p `O E j E "O a o u o 3 0 o 0 m O v o O um 3 N um "3 O UE L u O mE O! Oxu> pu v mm3 OEU OU O O OOO �O Ou u m U?: OOu U _ O OO -p O Eo! O Eu m ai v ._ 0 0 = v E •R m y v m - - ° 3c E Y u °uou ° tvE oro -a o ovw -2 212 Y w ° 0o 0o ID N U m V IO m N D V O a,o @ e-I a, ¢ ¢ p M V Ol � N C ¢ of o N ¢ @ N tp tub O U N t0 C U O N NO o� V r tU W NO ` E O r M of m N I� E L N ¢ M tp C ¢ `N° E u °i o N L U m ¢ ai o u o^ tO m rn a, a U p ¢ 6 0 C p m U 00 N c m W e-I C tp U N 'p) tp 0 0Nm ¢ K O C X Ol Q LL C ¢ m U V o 3 m O of L N N V V U t0 C O ¢ O L O ¢ 0 U tT O ¢ 2 Q rC ¢ O C O M ¢ 0 0 0 O tT O m m U LL m LL C Qj to N O^ U ry @ p U ¢ U oro ¢ m N U - r r m LL ¢ � c Q c "O L > to e-I �° to N to ^ N Ln ¢ m ai m -a N w m m m v '° to a ¢ c � ?m N N o > m m ¢ v U c c > @ m C C ai m N o y o X N C ¢ ¢ U ro aNi u @ U v u u E N `�° ti @ v v af6 o m 0 3 v o 5 o > >. E w C p to to to m > - N m ° c m v-o v Q C C C > O o N 3 u ro v 3 .� m c v ¢ Q Q m -d m ¢ v N 0 ._ a N 'O LL m N ~ O) to o > m u c > m m m ai m o a C v m t^ v m c v - > m N v ¢ a Q v to - c m m m E �, 3 'n c o m v v to m e to ` ww > o i N C u V N 'p ^ to N N N D (7 +_ -° U L O N N j Ip L O ¢ m N -O U C M N C N E oo o0 op N j o@ r O N t6 N N >'Q 'O L r6 M L t`6 Gl Q oo V V Q C L O 'O H U c C L C C O Vl E to @ d a - _ L U M 3 L e�-I ° R J ccN m N N t6 V ccm 'r6 - 'T -0 @ 3 O) cc 3 N X O X U U C N r6 r6 U N C c N W X m G tO W m m N N m W O O O N 3 O Z O W W ^ r W N C W -zr m j w ¢ H O m N m m m tO c-I O M O O of I, N O I� H V 16 0 �D o m m 0 0 0 0 .M-i '� 0000 m Ln N m n o n o n N o 4 o m .tO-i o oo M H N d H e-I a M ti tZ tZ N N H N N e-I N M rl M e-I N M CO >> Q C L w 6 O N o = N O m - YJ N +m+ N m O` N Q C O .7 T E - c E p O N o 0 O C a c .`p t E o c c � � v `v o o o T o L o O U o o O 22 E r m m >„ v 0 '^ o > c Y m v E o v ooNuzo .mmw vL C C C C U U p 0 3 N N O! O! N U U u '6 m o ii o m c °� 0 m N m m- w o N 'E N o 0 o v ¢c C ° m 3 E 3 Y °° v m m m 'm_' � v evcv = = - m t6 c = C C :, c c v ° w m °' u u u tca c o u u o m u u o E 0 c 0 o H c c c E E E ° o 0 o E u o N to E U E m 6 o U o o = 3 c v 12 C t6 N L r L o o o C LLL 0 L C V U N Yui H U R ¢ O C C C C C r O oq C C J 3 3 J 3 t` U C C N oZf @ X b0 3 t`6 J O H N N N N U U U U O N V 0 ° m N ¢ u u U O s u 0 u u H ¢ w DocuSign Envelope ID: 1329BDA6-63C6-4222-8A36-123CE92404B2 Index of Interested Parties Orange County Housing Developers List DocuSign Envelope ID: 1329BDA6-63C6-4222-8A36-123CE92404B2 E . o � E u O ° m E a m o ° °� E L O E a E n o v °u E o ° R y u O O - U m u " E u E u ` ra ° L O c O .. O E ra E '= c v v c O L E ". L "O CO E 3 0 N > E O C x N C m ar v 2 E L v ° E 3 m > 'u v c m v E u L v v m c o o v Y v 3 Y m o a v > o m m c m c v E 0 Q -0E ._ m E to O E ra ¢ c t'i c m Y 0 0 D o v o 3 o E m 0 0 c W c c c u w c v c a 1 c c o ci 3 m 00 o� ID mo 000 ^ r o°io v m 0000 coo ao tOo tOo N t°O t°O tco °O N r t°O t°O � ta0 to to M ^ M V V Ln N N N N �n �p Ln 4 N N a � 0p N Q ^ �p p N N m e-I e-I 0p Ol Ol r W N N N Ol Ol e-I N W m U M M V Ol Ol 'C V1 to to M Q Q V a to �o M O Q Q ^ n Q N O r Q Q O N u1 N 00 U U N W W U U W Q t0 U u pp I� U U O N n3 00 n1 e-I r r rl ei Q e-I Q r r ,y U O t m 00 r r r t6 m N t0 u u l0 N l0 U l0 U u u � 'D U N - - Q u u U Q C m C N m m N o N N m m N N m 'o N N U m m 6 U O Q O � m m a, Q a m a, O) m m N o, m C Ol M L m m w U !� U p p U v U U C p p U O U p C U U m tf O O Q U ,a U c_ 3 z z O u ° z z z = v0 z z i v ¢ Oo O o N O O O N O O p M N O e-I in rl p 0 N M rl to 0 N O O N in M O � O/ O > > O O O N > m N N > v ` m O M N m to > 0 V M j tf m > m ? > O N m O 6 N 0 3 M N N V N 3 U N � O m 0` -O N O! C in o V N > j m to o N o E u Y v m v v m c ai p` Q a m Q U > 3 U N m S u m ab m 0 `1 U u u o o of O/ L m u a O o c c v « v c m v o o 3 m u `O `O ¢ min m m o a E o y a a a m 0 3 o m m v a `0 ° 0 u ° m o o a o m m O m s u 0 a .--� w N m Ln Z a Ln m o 6 m z z m 0 D O o o Ln Ln z o oo m Ln o Ln m N o Q o Ln Lo Ln� n a m Ln m .^-i o 0 0 o o n n C rl V Ln H I� e-I M N e-I V t0 H N Ln m Ln 00 Ln M N V V Ln rl ei rl m C O c N .@ E u v m m v c c L m U � C y m 'o E c Q y � ° Li U ° C x O E n3 N c � O�U � C m U U u, O_ o a o m o E E E E E v c E o E 3 o o u u ° _ x a o m o o o v o o m m Q E o x x o ° o o u m L a ° E m x x x E m xa o 6 °tS u x > m ° ¢ m a c oc m = E m m x° m o x o um`o x M c > a m o ami x c v ._ m m E c 3 3 'o > v Z E v v u m ° °c E —' u u � H � HHumvL Y r - rad � m° 2KOmu ¢ = '-4 > � DocuSign Envelope ID: 1329BDA6-63C6-4222-8A36-123CE92404B2 Index of Interested Parties Tustin Home Owners Association/Property Management Companies List DocuSign Envelope ID: 1329BDA6-63C6-4222-8A36-123CE92404B2 C a, C N NEm NxE m E :° o ° O Ov Q0 O O N O O >Cm —lm > oo O > p E ° vo mm v `1 u Y cC N N J x m O 0 = 2LZ' O K Y 0>/ 3m O O t0 10 M Ln O N tN0 ONi N tN0 O N N N 110 110 N < N e^-I O^ W ONj ¢ O^ ONi e^-I O N O^ Ol ONi ONi N U Ol N W Ol e-I W W N W Q U W W ONi W W W Q O W ONi e ONi N Q r O N W W O O O w N O W W O O O U W W W Q 'y 'y Q W W W N < L W 'D rl ¢ ONl U N U Ol ONl ONlONl ONl U ONl ONl ONl vi ONl U ONl U Q UONl v M M N ONl ONl ONl ONl ONl M U N ONl ONl ONl U N N V U Q C U U V U x U U 16 C U U U x U U C t6 C U C U U U x U U x U U U U c m U U U > w o r m E ai r E E m c E E E o 9 m c m ai E E E ai ai E'F- E E m o- ai ai o C C m o C C m C o c C :- '- '- O 3 C C m e m o " c m c v m m m O 3 ` J ttou 0 3 3 m 3 3 3 ttou 3 L 3 m m m > 0 3 3 t�op ttoo 3 3 3 0 m N 3 f0 N U H — H J LL H Vm H H H J H U H N > $ E c E v v c v v > a` v o v > v E c w c m m m c v m v E E a > o v v ° C m r c m . c 0 m — E '�° c m c m E m 3 v a 8 E o v v c w v m m m u p c v m m E > a m w a m c m O o - v m a v w v 3 c m v m ami wu m m o E a ami v .'�'' o f °- m c m v0/i o c 0 aci E > aa' a `?° Y `c° aa, v a° m '° o. c m c o w a u o ° m C a `u E m o o v " v m >' m o a v u m u >!� o v Q c v u pp >' m e c u o o m v v c v c v o ra m e p Q m Mc o = w'1 v `° a ^`°' `° ¢ a` ^ o c o o C .w° a° ¢ m o ' ° ° E E o¢ o o c °°° ° u '� m 0 � o o .@ > o o >o ¢ >Ow O — o m m c v m ° m m a m y ¢ o o Q� > m o u � 0 a — � v L o > u D v m E m 'u .0 O v O ° ° �? 3 O h m v v ° ¢ o \ E ¢ v v u a ° u u v = -u o-2 o o v N E m 0 0 ° Q c > E E o O - LL Q 5 2 ¢ a` Q c m u ¢ E z o 0 2 E > -E L m ` E c m U m E a1' 2 Q Q w c E o c c > O v o 0 . Q „ 'E s 0 .Q p E E LL O o -0 � E ww o cc E u Q u m u v o u u o u v c- ¢ v g ¢ - O m $ u m E u o u Q 3 L u E a u > m Q O u O v '�'' QO m o 3 0 0 c E 2O E E 3 u p w Q c" Z m ¢ v O c 0 m E O '� '6 Q 6 0 xO 0 p Q 2 m O ¢ 2 6 u H v w E u O c u 0 C u Y O m 0 0 x E o x u a a > C7 N u m 0 =_ a 2 0 N m p > p E@ v J v V Q a v Q u c@ O m = x y p F N u H o m u x x O — c 0 0 0 O — o > > m a o �, a = v m U ¢ c , O j j — �/ c V` 2 O c > O m O U u U — m — C : a� a� L O m 0 3 m c 3 `_ o E@ n n > U m o v m m a Y 3 c c 3 3 v m v o 6 o v v v 0 am 4 v aui C= v ¢ m 3 v E E v c m c v o v m m a E p 3 '> H v_ a s m o m x v m m m 3 3 0/ ° v a' Y �' m v o v g u v m c m c C c E o ` v c� E E L u Q m 01 O m 0 0 0 ria E C *' O z m m m m m m 0 0 0 m C v O O Q Q Q ¢` ¢` m CO CO CO CO` CO` CO` U U U U w w w w LL C7 C7 C7 H a a a 'a a a a DocuSign Envelope ID: 1329BDA6-63C6-4222-8A36-123CE92404B2 o - O C m m ° H E E " 3 v °- N m o E c a' c ` E o v E o 0 o m m o c m ° ai v t ° m N m = o O E m U m c m = 'n tT6 r U N U v C_ 6 N = L x C C C = N N N _ E N N m r p 2 m r to O -O p c N m O N c O — y -o = -O N u 2 O! N -o ,� v` m m m m o m r m >U 2 m c C C m m 0 L C C Q O! Y — U =CL 3 L L N O c .— a! O m C U .— R C J U -O L > C C R N 2 a/ L fp K D m m Z x -_, m U 0 Y Y ¢ D U ¢ H Y N Y in 2 W p e NO � W O N W U N U O N to ° ° a, ^ N N N U a, U N N O N W t^O W O ID a, V ^ O oo ^ O 'o Q ^ oo ^ n oo O N L o0 L o0 O O Q W O O O L Q O - a0 rn eo Q a0 �y I� O Q �y Ol 00 �y Ol 00 O U Ol N Ol W 00 to ¢ tU6 N tU6 N N N N N U N N N m U = N u N Q N U N N N U N U N N U N N u Q u U m Ol m Ol Ol Ol ++ Q Ol Ol Ol m = = Ol U Ol = Q Ol Ol = m Ol Ol N U ¢ ONi E p u p u u u u u p @ L L u p m E L Q u `° v m v u u V m v Q V V Q V V Q E Q m V V V L a a N N C LL = N N N a C L N m C a=j N C oa N C N C N m C N m C N m r m = N C N m 3 3 c c .- v o c c c 3 = m c +- u c = = c +- c = c +- c +- c m o c v J v = > ` _ = y O ` 5 N m c ` m 3 m @ ` _ m 3 ` m 3 ` m = m e a z r z r _ _ r r U _ _ _ z ¢ _ N r a _ O _ c m a " U E E c v m vE Y w .2 LE c v o v o U o v m E E m aL m v c c m E v o 0 0 > a` v m �U m o o ova Q o E E c E m a E O m m a o N m c U N m 2 U c m m � m v E � ova u 'c _o <m ; o 2 m '° m � m .5 .0 w 2 o m w v ova +• v ua m ° a m y ova v c m ° E E E N > m m o v vv o ° \ u �u 0aEi v ova m y ova D- o c Q a m a` m c m 2 E 0 0 5 U g v>� Q o a o ami o �' " _ = u v u m o E c 2 w c o m v o °- E c v m 2 a > m v m o s >ao o m E .r- a p- = c c c m o = m o w m N m m m - a a ° o = m a t a a o \ o v t a` .G v v u > O O O O m m 2 v c 2 'u o a o a a o > >' E m ¢ o o u u E a > o a o a m a o m m m c a '6 u c >. v m > o u t c a o a a` v a E o c a Q o c ova o v Q ao` a 0 a3 o v 'u 'u 'u $ v 'u = o ° v m O Q D E E .0 O > a O a c E 'm o c a o @ o v u = w ¢ E o o O n o = Q a m -0 _ ° ` = m v o �- c = ' im m v . C7 c = O m u N� v E m o N v v u o E a a o c a O o o va 'c p m o c o m o >> ¢ v m Q Q Q Y Q a E c v o p a u 3 m u a° c a x v 3 E u "' E o = o u 3 '" o- m Y o � m m � - ---u..- am w o C u o = E m - ^ O - o = y" 0 E Q .Q \°� o ¢ � v m Q O v c .0 o u ¢ E E E u Q 3 a o v a o o u 'c o m v v v ¢ 3 m O \ o v E m o Q w °"uo >' _ -6 E w a° O E = c o o Ox o a u ¢O O u r E E E v O E o v v v c m o Y E ° E ° c - tf m u c c o o c c E ° o ¢ O x = o o 0 0 'a °- o - ¢ °u 3 > E o O E ` u O o u Q v c v 3 \\ v O E u `�' v 2 m 3 — U U U w t U c O v p_Q 3 ? m u m \ O a O \ y v u u O — O c o_ O C t`6 N u U O \ U Q U > ° Q m C O U E O — = Y C N -O > L L L L C ova bva x O O ° m ° m m v 2 c v x O ¢O v o .m m p v o E v v v v o a v c c c c c 3 u u am N N > c _ 'u u n` ' 2 > x u = o o v v o E m '6 m m m m o - - - m m c u v L L = L `° b° =o m c c m o o ` E E = x o c E E E E c E E c E E E E E E c m 3@ > N � m - .m c c c c c c c c c v > m m u u m v v '+ •� •� •� •� •� '+ •� •� '+ •� •� •� •� •� •� •� •� •� •� •� 0/ > > > > > mes)nEm¥ope gg£gBo Eeac-2 aA3 E1SCSm«& { � 0E u � ) « } 3 /) & 5 ) \ LD LDLO [ \/ / / / / / } $ ) ) ®222222 2a « \{{{}{} ) ) ) ) ) / E � \\ \} } 77*o E » [ ! } E 000 cm : / ef i § } 5 ){{ƒƒ/\ 2 EE / + / wEtL - c � k \ & \\\\\® a § ±2 ® 23222 » \ o > t � ƒ\) 3 / ) G \ ( { }\ \ j (D } \ ) \ $f ± / / / / DocuSign Envelope ID:1329BDA6-63C6-4222-&436-123CE92404B2 Tustin City of Tustin i2021-2029 2021-2029 Housing Element Housing Element Update Community Survey Results Summary Survey Open: January 21— February 28, 2021 July 1—July 30, 2021 DocuSign Envelope ID:1329BDA6-63C6-4222-a436-123CE92404B2 Q1 Do you live and/or work in the City of Tustin? (Choose one) Q2 If a resident,select those that apply to you. (Choose up to two) Answered:306 Skipped:0 Answered:295 Skipped:11 I tbut. RESPONSES l awn a home Tustin,but.. RESPONSES rent ahem 71.53% 211 I work 51.31% 157 Tustin,but.. 15.93% 47 MMM 111-with _ 3.59% 11 anomer... 5.08% 15 I live and 27.45% 84 do ne� work in Tustin 2'37/0 7 currently ha 11.76% 36 1898% 56 live i I have been 5.88% 18 esitlent for.. 12.54% 37 Tustin and d.. r I have mun 44.07% 130 Other(pleas 306 reeidem for. specify I have been resident(or.. O% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90%100% 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90%100% Additional Spanish Reponses Additional Spanish Reponses 25.00% 1 WSP ES 25.00% 1 25.00% 1 0.009h 0 25.00% 1 Tustin 50.00% 2 0.00% u a Dow o 0.wi6 0 0 0mc a o 0ot5 0 4 25O 1 7500% 3 DocuSign Envelope ID:1329BDA6-63C6-4222-8A36-123CE92404B2 Q3 Which best describes your current living situation? (Choose one) A nswered:306 Skipped:0 ANSWER CHOICES RESPONSES A A single-family home 57.84% 177 single-fgmil,. A duplexlNplexfiowpiex 327% 10 A condomimumil—Trrome 22.80% 70 duplexltripl� An apartment 11 44% 35 condaminlum/ Accessory d—thrig snit(ADII) 000% 0 A room rental 229% 7 An apartrnenm A mobile home 0.33% 1 Accessory Group h—.I-mated living 900% 0 d_111 ng u m... 000% 0 Fransi0onal housing and shelter A ream rent Do not currently have a permanent home O 65% 2 I Other(please specify) 1.31% 4 A mobile hom1 TOTAL 30fi Group Additional Spanish Reponses homelassiste.. o.ro% e Transitions! 1 ha using and.,. — o.00ss o Ib not �0°* 2 current ly he orow a Other(pleas specify 000ss a Tustin Gl 10% 20% 309'e 40% 50% 60% 70% 60% 90%100% — oo o 0.00% a s.ro% o I DocuSign Envelope ID:1329BDA6-63C6-4222-8436-123CE92404B2 Q4 What are some barriers to the production/ creation of affordable housing in the City of Tustin? (Choose up to three) .Answered:306 Skipped:0 ANSWER CHOICES RESPONSES Limited availability of ren?-restricted affordable units 24.18% 74 Limit Cost of quality housing is too high 48.37% 148 availability ._ Cost of housing is too high in areas with good jobs and services 23.53°h 72 Costa Cost of land is#vo high 24.84°h 76 qua!¢y haus. Cost of construction labor is too high 11.44°h 35 Ca St 9 housing is t.. Developers make more profit building market-fate housing 26.14% 80 Cost of Lan Elimination of redevelopment agencies 523% 16 is too h- Low supply of housing 27.12% 83 Cost Not enough well-paid jobs 13.07% 40 construction Resident opposition 25.160/o 77 Developers Other(please specify) 10.78% 33 make more.. Total Respondents:306 Elimination o redevelvpmenAdditional Spanish Reponses zs oar r Low supply❑ hvusin is oo3s a s omt a Not enoug 21aws r weLl-paid job - - omvc a Res i.,.o - oomc a o ppad, oaovc a Tustin ether ipleas - oaoss a sple `o 000% a 046 1045 20% 3046 4046 504i, 6096 704n 60% 904610096 ooass a DocuSign Envelope ID:1329BDA6-63C6-4222-&436-123CE92404B2 Q5 When you consider all housing issues in the City of Tustin, what do you believe is the most urgent issue? (Choose up to three) Answered:306 Skipped:0 ANSWER CHOICES RESPONSES Affordability 61.441K 188 Affordability Availability 31.37% 96 Homelessness 31.370K 96 AvadabiL Housing proximity new transit 1269% 37 Homeownership 18.3W/c 56 HomOlessn08 Overcrowding 32.35% 99 Housirl Displacement 1.96% 6 proximity ne.� Housing quality 16.34% 56 Hgmepwnershi� Types of housing(i.e.,single-family,multi family,ADU's) ,.. 18.95% 5H Other(please specify) 8.56% 26 Overcrowdin Total P.espondents:306 Additional Spanish Reponses Displace -I 7500% 3 iocr 4 Houvrigqualit zsno% i owes a Typos oM housing[i.e.. o ww a Other(ple 0D a Tustin sp-ol 1 o.ws a 090 to% 20% 30% iOWe 5096 6044 70% 80% 90%1pD% DocuSign Envelope ID:1329BDA6-63C6-4222-8A36-123CE92404B2 Q6 As the economy and population grow, more housing is generally needed to accommodate this growth. What do you think is the hest strategy to produce more housing? (Choose up to three) Answered:306 Skipped:0 ANSWER CHOICES RESPONSES Improve City processes(further streamlined application process and checklists,preapplication meetings,handouts, 34.64% 106 improve city improved website design&navigation to find needed materials,etc.) processes... Increase housing opportunities near trans it 24.18% 74 Increase 21.900/c 67 h9usin Allow more housing in single-family neighborhoods g... AEEow more Increase opportunities for backyard units(accessory dwelling units or AEU's) 23.53% 72 housing in... 18.63%. 57 Increase housing opportunities near jobs and schools Inereas Approve new housing`by nghf"(no public hearing) 10.78% 33 opportunitie. _ Waive.ceitein development tees(i.e.,park andfor.Luer) 16.67% 51 In�ease _ housing... P.educe parking requirements 12.09% 37 Approve new Allow buildings with more housing unitsl greater density 21.57% 66 housing"by... Waive certai. Other(please specify) 21.57% 66 d—Lopment. Total Respondents:306 Additional Spanish Reponses Reduce parkin 25 doss r requirement Allow_ bvikdings wi... oxas o 2500% 1 Other{pleas 5o Doss 2 speci€y — 5o Doss z Tustin 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90%100% oao% o corns i a doss � o Doss o DocuSign Envelope ID:1329BDA6-63C6-4222-&436-123CE92404B2 Q7 What do you believe is the best way to help people who are experiencing homelessness? (Choose up to three) Answered: 306 Skipped: 0 Prand. housing and.. ANSWER CHO]CES RESPONSES Provide housing and supportive services(i.e.assistance with addiction,mental health,recovery,displacement ardor 60.46% 185 1 mare transitionallemergency housing) Increase th 29.41% 90 Increase the affordable housing supply affordable.. Better connect people to assistance and services 62.7`'% 192 Increase outreach from highly trained specialists 49.02% 150 Better connect Other(please specify) 16.67% 51 people to... Total P.espondents:306 Additional Spanish Reponses Increas RESPONSES outreach fro. 50.00% z Other(pleas 50.00% 2 Sp"; 75LDD% 3 Tustin mom 1 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% 0.00% 0 DocuSign Envelope ID:1329BDA6-63C6-4222-&A36-123CE92404B2 Q8 Where do you think more housing units would be appropriate in the City (Choose up to three)? Refer to this link to view the City of Tustin Map. Answered: 306 Skipped: 0 In the Tustin Legacy Speci... ANSWER CHOICES RESPONSES Red Hill A Venue Speci... In the Tustin Legacy Specific Plan(TLSP)area(refer to link above) 6275% 192 Ped Hill Avenue Specific Plan(PHI area(refer to fink above) 31.37% 96 Downtown — Commercial C... Downtown Commercial Core Specific Plan(DCCSP)area(iefer to link above) 20.92% 64 TTuStin Marketplace(bounded by Jamboree Poad,Bryan Avenue,Mytord Road.and the 1-5 Freeway) 32.03% 98 17th Street commercial corridor(between the I-55 Freeway and Prospect Avenue) 29.41% 90 Marketplaaceco.. Pacific Center East Specific Plan(PCESP)area(refer to link above) 16.67% 51 77th Stree Other(please specify) 12.751/b 39 commercial.. Total P.espondents:306 Pacific Cen". Additional Spanish Reponses East Specifl.. r£SPqLSES 5000°h 2 Other(pleas wc�v z specify 75.00% 3 Tustin zsao% � 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% SO% 600/a 701/0 60% 90% 100% saose i o aaw a � oaaw o DocuSigo Envelope ID:1329BDA6-63C6-4222-8436-123CE92404B2 Q9 Do you have additional ideas about where more housing units could be added in the City? (Refer to link of City of Tustin Zoning Map) and/or do you have additional ideas about the best methods to produce more affordable housing? Please share with us here. Answered:151 Skipped:155 R RESPONSES 1 No,for the most part we are built out leaving this once great city. 2 Don't 11 No more apartments.Build single family dwellings 3 I hate that the city is looking at more housing dmwft n,we already have a traffic issue,only to have more once the Santa Ana apartments fill up m 1st.No more apartments-we have so 12 Tustin Legacy many in the city.We need businesses to fill our empty Lox stores.17th street is anighunam now,and you want housing there.Redo the base development:plan and put housing 9h -tum 13 Tustin the empty Flight into condos since business occupancy is new zero.Mone emplvymem opportunities near base than anywhere else in city,with target roads to handle traffic. 14 It would be nice for the community more near the high school of Tustin to have more affordable housing for the local families 4 No 5 Affordable housing should be.dispersed throughtut the city. 15 Please stop dumping all very low income units in the legacy.This is creating lack of equity and will create transportation issues.Marry very low income residents have limited transportation 6 I do not.I would however like to know how you plan m ensure Mere is ample infrastructure to so these units should be dispersed in various areas of the city and on public transit routes so support[his?Police,schools,shopping centers? _ residents can get to Jobs,schods,grocery store etcdumping an extra 1900 affordable un as in 7 No. the legacy will not solve your problem 8 Streamline review of ADlls.;encourage development of ADlls on multiple family sites; 16 1 believe that redeveloping parking Ids at the Tustin Marketplace or other shopping centers encourage density bonus development;up zone transportation corridors;eliminate minimum could provide the sWpty of housing Urri needed, parking standards and establish maximums instead. 9 Single famify homes,Tustin meadows I rid town Tustin 10 Tustin already has more affordable housing then it's neighboring cities.Push some of this housing on cities such as Irvine that has way more land to develop on.Why is Tustin having to deal with the homeless in Irvine that are pushed ever to our city?Why doesn't Imine has a homeless sheter`2 Why are we responsible for dealing with their issues?My family has lived in Tustin for my entire life and it's gotten so bad.The crime the homeless the drugs etcliterally if something isnt bolted dorm it rill be stolen.You can't even leave your shoes m your doorstep because they Wit be stolen.If a child leaves his hike or scooter at a park wrrile they are playing it's stolen.Can't even have plaids on your from parch because guess wrrat....they are stolen_It's very discouraging for hard working homeowners_Pio wander so many are leaving this once great city. DocuSign Envelope ID:1329BDA6-63C6-4222-&436-123CE92404B2 17 How about Cowan heights?Pioneer road north is good.Browning and Simon P.anch is good Why not Peter's Canyon? 18 No 19 Na 20 nla 21 Make all new multi family construction include 15%-201%low income housing.See Irvine. 32 Considering the limited space within Tustin city limits more multi family development will compromise our qualify of life making it a less desirable place to live This is already seen with 22 Industrial area near 55 the overflow from east Santa Ana.The huge complex erected at 1st and Tustin vnll accommodate need of affordable housing,understanding that is within Santa Ana city limitss. 23 As young adults reach a age limit we are looking for a place to rent but most places in Tustin There has been recent overhuildi ng in Orange County giving the feel of metropolitan. are extremely over priced due to the fact that boomers are holding property's and renting them 33 Sycamore and Redhill-PI zone out for profit we can work for jobs that make 17$an hour but yet we can't afford a place because of inflammation 34 Encourage commercial building owners with low occupancy to convert their properties the residential units 24 1 bought in Tustin because the homes were not on top of each other.I am fine with a the city 35 No having higher density near transit centers,but I am opposed with recent push by the state to do infill housing and smaller lots in areas designed for less density.We paid for these 36 Really want to see less crowding and more single family houses to improve quality of living properties based on these zoning laws.I live in an area where development,such as the tustin 37 No low income housing in Tustin Legacy.we have enough and crime is up.v+nll fight against it. racquet club,can vastly change the quality of the area of condos or apartments are allowed to be built there in violation of the deed in that land.Not every part of every city needs to be 38 New Irvine or by railroad station. treated like a major city such as LA.Some people like city living and some do not,whatever 39 Na the plan is here for more units should not come at the expense of the city allowing other people — their desire for quieter spaces. 40 Not sure that more housing units is in the hest interest for the residents that are already here and the city's long term plan.Tustin has been a small city with a Main Street and old town 25 Old town tustin charm when compared to other cities in Orange County and to over populate through density will lead to challenges with parking,increased crime and lack of community spirit. 26 P.educe population,no need to grow!!!! 41 Consult with developers of permanent supportive housing about its many financial and social benefits;partner with existing expert organizations in Orange County like Illumination 27 Build out pacific center,old town and legacy.P.edevelop red hill and 17th areas Foundation and Mercy House 28 YES...DONT EVEN THINK ABOUT IT. 29 East Tustin 36 Everywhere 31 Get a list of democratic voters.Let them house the homeless. DocuSign Envelope ID:1329BDA6-63C6-4222-&A36-123CE92404B2 42 Farmer WAS land 43 Not Tustin Legacy.The City already views this area as a dumping ground and I'm afraid that an up and coming area will be saddled with all of the city's problems. 44 Do we really need more housing in Tustin?The traffic keeps getting worse and parking near your house or apt is getting crazy.Perhaps we should fix these problems before we have more 55 None people moving into Our city. 56 Leave Tustin alone. 45 Place affordable housing near commerciailbusiness centers.Tustin Legacy is good opportunity 57 There is plenty of space around the Tustin Air Base.We are opposed to adding multiple for this.Ped Hill Area Specific Plan is area I'd like t0 see prioritized for development! housing units in SFP.areas.This depresses values and hurts the community as awhole. 46 Near the train station both north(industrial park south of Edinger)and south(existing 58 Tustin should not be responsible for providing housing or anything else forthese people.It just commercial center on Edinger)of The tracks.New housing should be equitably distributed encourages more of them to migrate here.Make them prove a connection to Tustin. through the entire city.The Legacy already has over 3,000 units zoned.The P.edhill and Old 59 Map is not very helpful.Affordability always improves with distance away from existing high Town specific plans were steps in the right direction. cost areas.If you can't afford to live in Tustin then go somewhere else.I couldn't afford to live in a mansion in Newport Beach,so I bought a house In Tustin in 1983.1 didn't expect Newport 47 You can not force 20 lbs.of stuff in a 2 Ib.bag!!!!!!!!!!!l! to provide me with affordable housing.I couldn't afford a Ferrari so I bought a Honda.Only tiny houses will ever be affordable in O.C.,and nobody wants to live in them.Let the market of 48 HERE IS AN IDEA-DO NOT BUILD ANY MORE HOUSi NG IN TUSTIN! supply and demand take care of itself. 49 Not at this time 60 Higher density but make them townhomes with individual rooftop terrace such as these at the . —..- Legacy(a little enclosed patio would be nice too),people may settle for this type of housing 50 Multiuse commerciallresidential buildings along Ped Hill Avenue and within Tustin instead of single family as it is more affordable and offers playgrounds,community pool etc... Marketplace. 61 The city should chose not to accept state or federal money if it requires that the property 51 None owners to change the character of Tustin. fit Mixed use.Ist street and Irvine Boulevard both have tons of offices or shops(medical offices, 52 if families who have kids can have a safe and healthy affordable place to live near schools it bike shops...)on one or two stories at most.I would love it it it used vertical space with would help a lot.help for families who are trying but have a mental health disability extra help retailloffices on the first floor or two and apartments above.Instead of the weekend ghost town is needed for them. it currently is. 53 Any area where parking will not have a negative impact an streets and or community. 63 Affordable housing should be located new shoppinglretail centers,public transit,public schools and parks and within a few miles of quality jobs.Affordable housing should be located 54 No.We have no room for mu€tlple unit dwellings.Our streets are overcrowded.People within walkable communities.Because of the abundance of land available,the most obvious crammed into one apartment with several cars now line up and use parking in single family location is Tustin Legacy The city should work with—profit lousing devel pars and donate home areas.Bring the hammer drnm on landlords that allow over capacity and help Tustin get land to be developed into affo table housing. its aid town feeling back. DocuSign Envelope ID:1329BDA6-63C6-4222-&436-123CE92404B2 64 171h street,red hill,and dtwn area are already crowded as it is.By building in those areas will further congest those areas.Would like Tustin to remain a small town feel. 65 If you cannot afford the housing,live somewhere else. 66 r11a 75 No more housing unless single family homes. 67 No 76 No 68 By the hangars by Tustin District 77 More housing units could he added to Tustin Legacy. 69 Not in residential single family neighhorhoods We do not need more homes used as rooming 78 Tear dawn key inn houses and rehab facilities New housing should he built where there is previous commercial 79 There appears to he no plan to accommodate the older population in Tustin in providing gated buildings that are now empty or in areas that have not been previously built on Not in already retirement communities.Why? dense neighborhoods 80 Mixed use housing.Look it up.Learn it.Do it. 70 Tustin Legacy 81 By the district,stop putting apartments that are way loo expensive for the average family. 71 When offering new areas for residential development Specific Plans and Overlays or Rezoning People are loosing jobs and jobs are taking advantage of that so they're paying minimum wage for jobs that should be paying more.Don't charge$2101}+for atwo bedroom apartment.The require a minimum of 15%to 20 V.affordable at low and very low. cost of goads is also going up,how can w afford to pay for utilities and necessities when all 72 Oust leave it alone our money goes to rent? 82 No 73 Mixed use low rises in the old town core and continued development of legacy 83 In need of community liaison,low housing/vouchers funding distribution to single moms, 74 Looking at the current situation in my area there's lack of parking for mini apartment domestic violence survivors(not only adultichildren with disabilities,mental health and or complexes so that Hass to be considered when you build any more apartments.Design is very elderly... important specially when apartments 50 years old and he has nothing but plenty plumbing problems such as the one t live in.Hopefully any new apartments built are going to he more 84 We could construct transit-oriented housing in concert with expanding public transportation.As efficient when it comes to maintenance and gardening.Small yard patio size is preferable a place to stall,we could construct more high-density housing near the Tustin railway.Looking forward,we should consider collaborating with OC Streetcar and establishing several stops in since nowadays people want a pet and has some value in their life to have a pet.Size and Tustin,especially but not limited to Old Town.Housing affordability increases when people storage in the apartment is also highly prized.No high-rise that's fine for young people but for have access to low-cost transportation methods that can connect them with high-paying jobs. people middle-aged seniors who don't want to be in a senior home that cost more than renting Finally,1 also believe that Tustin could partner with community land trusts to help low-income an apartment.So an apartment is my only option and quality of life is very important to me.I want to take elevators I don't feel so sate in elevators apartments with upstairs downstairs people secure and maintain affordable housing long-term.Especially Tustin continues to grow economically and attract more young and professional Milkers,we warn to mitigate would be great because to be less complaints t0 the management about noise. against gentntication and housing displacement,which will not only evict beloved members at our community but also increase rates of homelessness.CLTs can offer affordable housing options and a pathway to homeownership for people experiencing poverty. DocuSign Envelope ID:1329BDA6-63C6-4222-&436-123CE92404B2 94 Reduce dependence an personal automobiles Improvedlcheaper public transit Walkable, 85 P.ezone industrial area around Metrolink Station with high-density residential.Peduce the bikable City(see Bogota or Curitiba)Higher density,housing Environmental design to reduce amount of land used for surface parking in the Tustin Legacy public benefit areas and use for likelihood of crime Green roots,drought-resistant plants,vertical walls,energy independence, housing instead. solar panels,recycle water(see Freiburg)Puhlic bank(cheaper interest rate for housing development)Guwanteecilbasic income(prevent homelessness,keep people in homes) 86 The downtown core and additional ADU units could help the Missing Middle gap in our city but Community gardens(produce can he sold for profit,vacantlpoorly utilized lots can be used, must be done with respect to the existing character of the city.exceeding 16DUlAC is probably help food insecuritylfoad deserts,food can be used foriood banks)Zero waste,reduce p g y 9 p y trashllitter,compost,use compost in community gardens,ban single-use plastics Encourage not what we want in these more traditional parts of the city that have developed character and entrepreneurship,people can live and work in the same place not blight. 95 South 5 freeway.More luxury lownhomes to displace gangs out of the city.Housing should not 87 rVa be affordable in this city.If they can't afford living in here they should look in to the Inland Empire.Affordable housing and section 8 brings problems. 88 If building more housing in Tustin legacy would also like more greenlpatk space.Don't like 96 f think more housing units could be added in the Tustin Legacy area with more multi-family overcrowding and with at these homes with small backyards need more space for dogs and housing and allordable units available.I think a good method for producing more affordable kids In be outside housing is to increase partnerships with the private sector to help build these projects. 89 Housing units need to be close to public transportation because people needing affordable 97 units may not have reliable personal transportation to jobs,shopping,etc..Ask the people 98 Commercial areas off Tustin ranch Rd close to 5 and behindlaround Market Place who are currently in affordable housing what they believe is needed in locations,units, 99 Stop building it in Tustin go somewhere else transportation,etc.How can we determine what is needed if we do not talk to the people who actually need and use It? too We do not need more affordable housing. 90 Bring back the first time Homebuyer program.More home ownership instead of dense rental. 181 Villa park 102 1 would like public servants to take a stand on the human rights issue of housing.I think 91 Single family housing residents would benefit from being educated about housing being a basic human right rather — than a reward for earning more than the AMI.The NIMBYism can be reduced through empathy 92 rent control!iong term leases that lock in affordable rates.that encourages people to put in activation and education.Thank you for your service.Stay loud. roots and pay into Tustin taxes long-term. – 103 More multi-unit projects 93 no DocuSign Envelope ID:1329BDA6-63C6-4222-&A36-123CE92404B2 104 Obtain public participation from diverse communities.Make efforts to engage those without access or with limited access to technology.Father than allowing developers to buy their way out of providing affordable housing.create more strict requirements to provide those much needed units.Ensure your count of ADUs as applied to the P.HNA are reasonable and 114 Create atax on international purchases of houses of 30%and use those funds to subsidize supported by SCAG's accepted methodologylaffordability assumptions or your own detailed cityawned low income rental units to provide affordable housing to qualified occupants.Also,.a version.Encourage creative ways to provide housing sites and types of housing.Distribute general question,if housing is not affordable.who is affording to buy all this housing? affordable housing in various areas of the city to discourage socioeconomic segregation. Affordable seems like a pretty malleable term. 105 Establish and inclusionary housing ordinance. 215 Affordable housing overlay over andenrtirized commercial centers that allows increased density,height limits,etc for projects that incorporate a minimum percentage of allordable 106 Not at this time housing mixed with market rate rental units. 107 Housing is a human right. 116 Close to transitlfreeway i06 I dont five In Tustin because Of affordable housing.If you cant afford to live here,dont. 117 You have all that land at the hale that can be used for all types of housing.Amend the Legacy Specific plan to address the needs.That is the start point. 109 The single biggest obstacle to affordable housing in tustin specifically(as opposed to generic 118 Build in Santa Ana Issues within orange county)Is the haphazard city and neighborhood geometries.I consistently fail to understand how North tustin and orange can treat and isolate our communities the way 119 no they do with no contribution to neighborhood building Or family development support.It's elitist 120 1.Lure more high-tech and disruptive-technology jobs here(thus increasing incomes for locals) and mind-boggling. 2.Require more parking for condos and single-family units,thus encouraging multi-generational single-family housing.(beffer usage of single-family homes)3.Lure minodty-owned lenders to 110 Multigenerational families are more common nowadays due to economical hardships,culture, the area(hetterfinancing for minodty and low-income families).4.Transitional housing for etc however overt discriminatory practices such as parking permits can bring financial those coming out of homelessness new public transportation(access to more jobs)5.Cover hardships on multigen families(due to paying parking ticket fees).Also no matter where you closing costs for fav-income families buying condominiums as their first home.6.Build put the housing units,i fear that they won't be affordable.Or they will raise the prices of the condominiums,not rentals,so that people have a stake in the community.Check out Boston area surrounding them. Capital-they build low-income housing and often sell the units back to the renters after 10 yrs. 111 No 121 NIA 122 Increase areas in which affordable multifamily units can be built,not segregated but throughout 112 1 am glad to see that this is being address.As a longtime advocate for homeless people.I the city.This provides housing in more high opportunity areas and decreases class and race would like to see an education element incorporated into a proposal-how does low segregation. Incomelpermanent supportive housing affect the city and neighborhood - 113 Suspend CEQA.If the state wants something then they have to give up something,they need to have some skin in the game. DocuSign Envelope ID:1329BDA6-63C6-4222-&436-123CE92404B2 123 1 think the area around the Tustin Metrolink station is an opportunity for more housing where residents can use transit. 124 None 125 Please build normal homes single and 2 story.Nat like levity the 3 stories 140 Larwin Square ideal since buses bring homeless there.Build a high nse short term housing there and use other areas for more long term uses.Possibly at old grocery store location.Arry 126 No location where housing does not exist or current use has degraded of is abandoned should be used for this purpose.Cause as little disruptions to viable commercial and residential as 127 Tustin doesn't have to meet the demand of all housing needs.Some people will need to move possible. inland or our of state.The jobs are not here to support. 141 Get S for affordable housing from business donors who would have a personal interest in getting some of the homeless rehabilitated,and for the ones mentally able,possibly for 128 East and around the Tustin Metrolink Station.P.epeal the Voluntary Workforce Housing eventual work experience. Incentive Program;approve the PSH development within Legacy;incentivize redevelopment of the Old Town by limiting city staffs discretionary power. 142 Young adults are struggling to afford apartment costs but are limited on having roommates.A common saying is"I work in[vine to afford Tustin".Neighborhoods can be judgmental to 129 Tustin neighbors that conserve water or that cant afford landscapers...more education on conserving resources 130 No 143 Along thoroughfares such as freeways and major streets,the train station,etc. 131 N/A _ 144 1.A plan for increasing housing in Multiple locations is optimal 2.Allow addition of granny 132 Do not over populate an area.No low income housing in affluent neighborhoods units to single family homes 3.Increase housing in single family developments(one duplex — _ every other block).We need multiple strategies as its a huge problem. 133 Empty Industrial Areas because there will be lots of available parking and area to build 145 No 134 Single family zones 146 central city 135 Hire more staff to get the hall rolling.Do not do home building one at a time.Look at Mission 147 Tustin Legacy Viejo back in the 70's.They built 3 levels of housing at the same.Barceicnas low income, 148 Ped hill and EI Camino strip mail needs to be removed(lots of drugs,homelessness)and Castillos middle income,Madnds high income. convened.Area around there has what appears to be open land space for multi unit. 136 n1a 149 Make sure there are enough parking places. 137 Make sure that there is adequate on site parking for all new construction. 150 Need more single family homes with big back yards. 138 By the airplane hangers by Justin legacy 151 Everywhere 139 Pent determined by income;sliding scale;