Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutORD 1080 (1991) ORDINANCE NO. 1080 3 AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF TUSTIN, CALIFORNIA AMENDING ARTICLE 5, CHAPTER 5, 4 OF THE TUSTIN CITY CODE IN ITS ENTIRETY RELATING TO THE ESTABLISHMENT OF MINIMUM PROPERTY MAINTENANCE 5 STANDARDS The City COuncil of the City of Tustin hereby ordains as 7 follows: 8 Section 1: Legislative Findings 9 WHEREAS, the City council finds that areas of the City of Tustin are undergoing social, economic and physical ]0 deterioration; and ]] WHEREAS, this deterioration is resulting in the following community problems: An increase in crime, noise pollution, ]2 lack of adequate parking, trash and debris buildup, physical deterioration of the city's housing stock, visual blight, ]3 dying landscaping, rodent infestation and graffiti buildup; and ]4 WHEREAS, the City Council finds that an example is the ]5 southwest neighborhood of the city bounded generally bythe I- ... ~. ... .5, Newport, Walnut', Edinger,~..McFadden,.and Red Hill,-.Which ]O neighborhood is characterized by: ]7 1. An aging housing stock where two-thirds of all units in the area are more than 21 years old; I8 2. A densely populated area with a total of 4,220 19 multi-family units which comprise 56% percent of all such units in the City; 3. A higher than average vacancy rate (5% to 8%, 2] compared to a 3-3/4% county average); 4. An increased crime pattern consuming one-third of the total of police time spent on all police calls; 5. Increase in graffiti activity; 6. Accumulation of debris and trash near and along the front and sides of residential properties open to public view; 7. Structural dwelling defects consisting of broken roof coverings, windows, walls, stucco, broken driveways and pathways; Ordinance No. 1080 Page 2 8. Increase in nuisance complaints relating to parking noise and trash and debris buildup; 9. Higher unemployment rate versus the city-at-large rate; and WHEREAS, the City Council further determines that it is necessary to enact minimum property maintenance standards to address the physical deterioration of this and other areas of the City; and WHEREAS, the City Council finds that such standards will promote the public health and safety by preventing further deterioration and the achievement of a potential enhancement of the physical condition of real properties; NOW, THEREFORE, the City Council proposes to add comprehensive revisions to Article 5, Chapter 5 of the Tustin City Code by the enactment of minimum property maintenance standards to address the above-described community problems. Section 2. Article 5, Chapter 5 of the Tustin City Code is hereby.amended in. its entirety to read as follows: CHAPTER' 5 PROPERTY MAINTENANCE AND NUISANCE ABATEMENT REGULATIONS STANDARDS. 5500 PURPOSE AND FINDINGS The purpose of this chapter is to provide for the abatement of conditions which are offensive or annoying to the senses, detrimental to property values and community appearance, an obstruction to or interference with the comfortable enjoyment of adjacent property, or hazardous or injurious to the health, safety or welfare of the general public in such ways as to constitute a nuisance. The Council finds and determines as follows: (a) The City has a history and reputation for well kept properties and the property values and the general welfare of the community are founded, in part, upon the appearance and maintenance of private properties- (b) There is a need for further emphasis on property maintenance and sanitation in that certain conditions, as described in this chapter, have been found from place to place throughout the City- Ordinance No. 1080 Page 3 (c) The existence of such conditions as described in this chapter, is injurious and inimical to the public health, safety, and welfare of the residents of the City and contributes substantially and increasingly to the deterioration of neighborhoods. (d) Abatement of such conditions is in the best interests of the health, safety and welfare of the residents of the City because maximum use and enjoyment of property in proximity to one another depends upon maintenance of those properties at or above a minimum standard. (e) Unless corrective measures are undertaken to alleviate such existing'conditions and assure the avoidance of future problems in this regard, the public health, ~afety, and general welfare, and specifically the social and economic standards of the community, will be depreciated. (f) The abatement of such conditions will improve the general welfare and image of the City. 550l DEFINITIONS For the purposes ~f this'Chapter, the ~011owin -Words and" phrases shall have the meaning a~cribed thereto: "Abandoned": In addition to those definitions provided by state codes, local ordinances and case law, the term "abandoned" neans and refers to any item which has ceased to be used for its designed and intended purpose. The following factors, among others, will be considered in determining whether or not an item has been abandoned: (1) Present operability and functional utility; (2) The date of last effective use; (3) The condition of disrepair or damage; (4) The last time an effort was made to repair or rehabilitate the item; (5) The status of registration or licensing of the item; (6) The age and degree of obsolescence; (7)' The cost of rehabilitation or repair of the item versus its market value; Ordinance No. 1080 Page 4 (8) The nature of the area and location of the item. "Abate" means to repair, replace, remove, destroy or otherwise remedy the condition in question by such means and in such manner and to such an extent as the Enforcement officer in his or her judgment shall determine is necessary in the interest of the general health, safety and welfare of the community. "Attractive nuisance" shall mean any condition, instrument or machine which is unsafe and unprotected and thereby dangerous to young children by reason of their inability to appreciate the peril therein, and which may be reasonably expected to attract children to a property and thus risk injury by playing with, in or on it. "Dismantled" means that from which essential equipment, parts or contents have been removed or stripped and the outward appearance verifies the removal. "Enforcement officer" means that person or other City officer or employee as may be designated in writing by the City Manager to. enforce property maintenance, zoning and ~ther City violations-. "Graffiti" means City unauthorized inscribing, spraying of paint, or making of symbols using paint, spray paint, ink, chalk, dye· or similar materials on public or private structures, buildings, places or other surfaces. "Inoperative" means incapable of functioning or producing activity for mechanical or other reasons. "Person" means person, partnership, corporation, or any other entity. "Property Owner" means the person(s) or entity to whom property tax is assessed, as shown on the last equalized assessment roll of the County. "Owner" means the registered owner of a vehicle which includes but shall no be limited to the property owner, renter, lessor and/or other residents or guests residing permanently or temporarily on a residential property. "Premises" means any building, lot, parcel, real estate, or land or portion of land whether improved or unimproved, including adjacent streets, sidewalks, parkways and parking strips. Ordinance No. 1080 Page 5 "Property" means any lot or parcel of land and shall include any alley, sidewalk, parkway or_unimproved public easement abutting such lot or parcel of land. "Wrecked" means that which has an outward manifestation or appearance of damage to parts and contents which is essential to operation. 5502 PROPERTY MAINTENANCE NUISANCES It is hereby declared to be a public nuisance for any property owner or other person in control of said property to keep or maintain said property, including adjacent parkways, sidewalks or streets under fee ownership by said person, in such manner that any of the following conditions are found to exist: (a) Any abandoned, dismantled, wrecked, inoperable, discarded objects or equipment such as, but not limited to automobiles, trucks, trailers, boats, appliances, water heaters, refrigerators, furniture, fixtures, miscellaneous machinery and equipments, cans or containers standing or stored on property or on adjacent '-- parkway sidewalks or.streets .Which ca~.be..vie~e~.frQm a pUbli~ h~ghway~ walkway, or from private or 'public property, or which items are readily accessible from such places, or which are stored on private property in violation of any other law or ordinance; (b) Any condition which exists upon any premises that is dangerous to human life or is detrimental to health as determined by an appropriate city official; (c) Any alteration of land, the topography or configuration of which in any man-made state, whether as a result of grading operations, excavations, fill or other alteration, interferes with the established drainage pattern over the property or from adjoining or other property which does or may result in erosion, subsidence or surface water drainage problems of such magnitude as to be injurious to public health, Safety and welfare of any real property; (d) Disposal or presence of oil, grease, other petroleum products, noxious chemicals, pesticides, or any gaseous, liquid or solid waste in such a manner to consist a health or fire hazard or degrade the appearance of or detract from the aesthetic and property values of neighboring properties; Ordinance No. 1080 Page 6 (e) Lumber (excluding stacked firewood not visible from a public street, alley or adjoining property for use on the property or lumber for a construction project on the property with a valid permit), junk, trash, salvage materials (including but not limited to auto parts, scrap metals, tires, tin cans and bottles), or packing boxes or other debris stored on premises in excess of 72 hours; (f) Any performance of work on motor vehicles, vehicle engines or parts, or household fixtures, on a public right-of-way or performance of such work in yard areas of residential properties so as to be visible from a public right-of-way or neighboring properties other than emergency repairs or minor maintenance being performedby the owner of the vehicle or fixture; (g) Any swimming, pool, pond, spa or other body of water or excavation which is abandoned, unattended, or unfiltered; (h) Trailers not within established mobilehome parks, dumpsters or similar vehicles or equipment used for sleeping purposes; ...-(.~) AccumulatiQns. 9~.asPha~t',.concrete-,.Pla~ter,.'tile-,-r°cks~ bricks, building materials and fill dirt resulting from excavations on or off the property; (j) 'Use of-a parked or stored vehicle, boat, camper shell, trailer or other similar item as temporary or permanent living space; (k) Any vehicle, boat, camper shell or other similar item parked or stored on an unpaved surface or which blocks access to a required parking space; (1) Presence of graffiti, that is, City unauthorized inscribing, spraying of paint, or making of symbolsusing paint, spray paint, ink, chalk, dye, or similar materials on public or private structures, buildings, or places. (m) Property failing to meet minimum levels of maintenance and care as set forth as follows: (1) Landscapinq. All landscaping shall be maintained in ahealthy condition free of dead, decayed, overgrown or discarded plant material; (2') Landscape Irriqation. Landscape irrigation pipes and sprinkler heads shall be maintained in good working order Ordinance No. 1080 Page 7 so as to cover all landscaped areas; (3) Walls, Fences and Other Structures. All walls, fences and trash enclosures and other structures shall be maintained free of significant surface cracks, dryrot, warping, missing panels or blocks which either (i) threaten structural integrity, or (ii) results in a dilapidated, decaying, disfigured, partially ruined, appearance; (4) Parkinq and Related Surfaces. Parking surfaces and pedestrian walkways shall be maintained in a safe condition such that any concrete, asphalt or other driving or walking surfaces are free of potholes, buckled or cracked surfaces or raised areas; (5) Buitdinq Elevations and Roofs. Exterior building surfaces and roofs shall be maintained free of significant surface cracks, missing materials, warping, dryrot or blocks, which either (i) threatens structural integrity, or (ii) results in a dilapidated, decaying, disfigured, partially ruined, appearance. .- (6)-.Trash and D~bris. ~he..~rope~ty--'Shall, be.main~ained free of the'accumulation of trash-and debris. Trash and debris associated with permitted uses are to be stored solely in designated trash enclosures. Any violation of subsection 5502(m)(5) is hereby declared to-be a misdemeanor. 5503 PUBLIC NUISANCE (a) Authority to Abate and Impose Sanctions Enforcement of this chapter may be accomplished by the enforcement officer in any manner authorized by law. The procedures set forth ~n this chapter shall not be exclusive and shall not in any manner limit or restrict the city from enforcing other city ordinances or abating public nuisances in any other manner provided by law. Whenever an enforcement officer determines that any condition exists in violation of Section 5502, he or she may take enforcement action pursuant to this section. Notwithstanding the public nuisance abatement pr6cedures, criminal and/or civil remedies may be employed as provided under law. Ordinance No. 1080 Page 8 (b) Written Notice Whenever the enforcement officer has inspected the location of the alleged violation and it has been found or determined that conditions constituting a nuisance exists on any property located in the city, the enforcement officer may prepare a notice and order and cause the owner of the property and the person, if other than the landowner occupying or otherwise in charge or control of property to be notified in writing of the existence of said condition and/or require an appearance before the enforcement officer at a stated time and place to show why such condition should not be abated by the City at such person's expense. The notice and order to abate the determined public nuisance shall contain the following: (1) The street address and a legal description sufficient for identification of the property on which the condition exists. (2) A statement that the enforcement officer has determined that a -public nuisance is being maintainedoon-.the prope~ty.'~ith a.brie.fdesc~iptiQn~ of the conditions' which render .the' property a public nuisance. (3) An order to secure all appropriate permits and to physically commence, within a certain time from the date of service of the notice and order, and to complete within that reasonable and established ~' time and date, the abatement of the described conditions. (4) A statement advising that the disposal of any material involved in public nuisances shall be carried forth in a legal manner. ('5) A statement advising that if the required work is not commenced within the time specified, the enforcement officer will proceed to cause the work to be done, and bill the persons named in the notice for the abatement costs and/or assess the costs against the property. (6) A statement advising that any person having any interest or record title in the property may request consideration of the notice and order or any action of the enforcement within ten (10) days Ordinance No. 1080 Page 9 from the date of service of the notice and order. (7) A statement advising that the notice and order will be recorded against the property in the Office of the County Recorder. (c) Manner of Notice The notice and order, and any amended notice and order, shall be mailed by first class mail, postage prepaid, to each person as required pursuant to the provisions of subsection (b) of this section at the address of the violation as it appears on the last equalized assessment roll of the County or as known to the enforcement officer. The address of owners shown on the assessment roll shall be conclusively deemed to be the property address for the purpose of mailing such notice. The failure of the enforcement officer to make or attempt service on any person required in this section to be served shall not invalidate any proceedings hereunder as to any other person duly served. Service by mail in the manner herein provided shall be effective on the date of mailing. .The failure of any such person entitled' to -.receive Su~ch'nOtice-shall not'affect ~he.~alidity of any.. proceedings t~en°'under this arti~le.-Proof of Service of the notice and order shall be documented at the time Of service by a declaration under penalty of perjury executed .by the person effecting service, declaring the time and manner in which service was made. At the time the notice and order is served, the enforcement officer shall file in the Office of the County Recorder a certificate legally describing the property and certifying that a public nuisance exists on the property and that the owner has been so notified. The enforcement officer shall file a new certificate with the County Recorder that the nuisance has been abated whenever the corrections ordered shall have been completed so that there no longer exists a public nuisance on the property described in the certificate; or the notice and order is rescinded upon appeal; or whenever the City abates the nuisance and the abatement costs have been paid. (d) Extension of Time to Perform Work. Upon receipt of a written request from any person required to comply with the order, the enforcement officer may grant an extension of time within which to complete said abatement, if the enforcement officer determines that such an extension of time will not create Ordinance No. 1080 Page 10 or perpetuate a situation imminently dangerous to life or property. The enforcement officer. shall have the authority to place reasonable conditions on any such extensions. (e) Hearing The enforcement officer may set a date, time and place to hear any relevant evidence concerning the existence of the alleged public nuisance and the question of whether the expense of abating said public nuisance, if determined to exist, should be made a lien on the property. If, at the conclusion of such hearing, the enforcement officer is Satisfied that said condition exists and concludes that it should be abated at the expense of the landowner, he or she shall advise such person in writing in the same manner as provided in subsection C of this section. Such notice shall also inform the landowner of the right of appeal as provided in Section 5504. In the event any person given notice of hearing, as shown by the evidence of mailing, should fail to appear at said hearing,' then such evidence available to'the-enforcement.- ~fficer shall be Sufficient evidence of the ex'istenCe'of facts in supportof said conclusion. (f) Request for Reconsideration Any person aggrieved by the action of the enforcement officer in issuing a notice and order pursuant to the provisions of this chapter may appealin accordance with provisions of Section 5504 of this chapter. If no appeal is filed within the time prescribed, the action of the enforcement officer shall be final. 5504 APPEALS. (a) Appeal of Enforcement Officer Decision Any person entitled who is dissatisfied with a public nuisance determination of the enforcement officer shall have the right to appeal to the Planning Commission within seven (7) days from the date of mailing of the decision of the enforcement officer. Such appeal shall be in writing and filed with the Community Development Department, together with a filing fee in an amount as may be prescribed by the City Council by resolution. The notice of appeal shall specify: Ordinance No. 1080 Page 11 1. The legal description and street address of the property; 2. The determination being appealed; 3. The owner's or appealing party's legal interest in the property; 4. A statement of disputed and undisputed facts; 5. A statement specifying that portion of decision or hearing proceedings that are being appealed together with any evidentiary and supporting materials that would support the appeal; 6. 'A signed verification of the truth of all matters. Upon the timely filing of a notice of appeal in the proper form, the Community Development Department shall place said appeal upon regular meeting of the Planning Commission scheduled to be held not less than thirty (30) days after said appeal is received. "The-'-Community-. Development Department shall. provide written notice of the appeal, including the time, place and date of the hearing on the appeal., to the appellant and any other person to w~om notice of the enforcement officer's order was sent. Said notice shall be sent in the same manner as notice of the enforcement officer's notice and order. The Planning Commission may limit the issues on appeal to those set forth in the appellant's notice of appeal, may consider the record produced before the enforcement officer, and may allow additional evidence to be produced. Notice of the Planning Commission's determination shall be in substantially the same form as that sent by the enforcement officer and shall be sent to all persons to whom notice of the enforcement officer's order was sent as well as to all persons requesting such notice, in writing, at the time the appeal is heard. (b) Appeal of Planning Commission Decision Any person who is entitled to notice of hearing, who participated in the Planning Commission hearing and who is dissatisfied with a public nuisance decision of the Ordinance No. 1080 Page 12 Planning Commission may appeal any order, requirement, decision or determination to the City Council in the same manner set forth for enforcement officer appeals. Appeals shall be made in writing and filed with the City Clerk prior to 5:00 p.m. of the day of the first regular meeting of the City Council following the Planning Commission action to be appealed, together with a filing fee in the amount as prescribed by the City Council resolution which may be amended from time to time. Upon any appeal being duly filed or requested by the City Council, a time for hearing shall be a date set within- thirty (30) days of the filing of the appeal. Notice of the appeal shall be sent in the same manner as notice of the Planning Commission's decision. At the close of the hearing on an appeal, the City Council may reverse or modify the decision' of the Planning Commission and/or remand the matter to the Planning Commission for further proceedings in accordance with directions of the City Council. If the City Council does not take any action r~versing, modifying and/or remanding of the decision of the Planning Commission -within..~thirty ~30) 'days af.ter--th~-~il~n~. of.--appeal? thereon, ~he Planning Cbmmission's action on the matter shall be final and conclusive. Notice of a final determination shall be sent in the same manner as after the Planning Commission's determination. 5505 ABATEMENT OF NUISANCE BY CITY If such nuisance is not completely abated by the owner as directed within the abatement period, the City shall immediately cause the same to be abated by City personnel or private contract and such personnel or persons under contract are expressly authorized to enter upon said premises for such purposes. The owner of said premises shall be liable to the City for all costs of such abatement, including all administrative and inspection costs. 5506 PROCEEDINGS FOR ABATEMENT OF IMMINENTLY DANGEROUS PUBLIC NUISANCES Whenever the enforcement officer determines that a public nuisance is so imminently dangerous to life or adjacent property that such condition must be immediately corrected, or isolated, the following procedures may be instituted. (a) The enforcement officer shall attempt to make contact ] Ordinance No. 1080 2 Page 13 4 through. a personal interview, or by telephone with the landowner or the person, if any, occupying or otherwise 5 in real or apparent charge and control thereof. In the event contact is made, the enforcement officer shall 6 notify such person, or persons, of the danger involved and require that such condition be immediately removed, 7 repaired or isolated so as to preclude harm to any person or property. 8 (b) In the event the enforcement officer is unable to make 9 contact as hereinabove noted, or if the appropriate persons, after notification by the enforcement officer, ]0 do not take action as specified by such official, within the time frame requested, then the enforcement officer ~ may, with the approval of the City Manager, take all steps deemed necessary to remove or isolate such ]2 dangerous condition, or conditions, with the use of City forces or a contractor retained pursuant to the ~3 provisions of this Code. ]4 (c) The enforcement officer shall keep an itemized account of the costs incurred by the City in removing or isolating ]5 such condition, or conditions. Such costs may be ~ recovered in the same-manner. that abatement costs are ]G recovered pursuant:to this chapterS' ]7 5507 COSTS OF INSPECTION ]8 Whenever a public nuisance as defined in this chapter is found to exist as a result of said inspection, the reasonable ~9 costs for said inspection as set by City Council resolution shall be paid by the landowner- 20 5508 ASSESSMENT OF COSTS AGAINST PROPERTY (a) Cost Assessment The enforcement officer, personnel or persons who abate 23 the nuisance shall keep an account of the cost of abatement. Such personnel or persons shall submit an 24 itemized written report showing such costs to the Community Development Department for transmittal to the 25 City Clerk for City Council- 26 (b) Hearing on Assessment 27 The City Clerk shall thereupon set the report and account for hearing by the City Council at the first regular 28 meeting which will be held at least seven calendar days Ordinance No. 1080 Page 14 after the date of filing, and shall post a copy of said report and account and notice of the-time and place of hearing in a conspicuous place in or near the entrance of the Tustin City Hall. The owner who is affected by such report and account shall be sent a notice advising him of the date, time and place of the hearing and said notice shall be served. (c) Tax Lien The City Council shall consider the report and account at the time set for hearing, together with any objections or protests by any interested parties. Any owner of land or person interested therein may present a written or oral protest or objection to the report and account. The City Council may modify the report if it is deemed necessary, and shall then confirm the report by motion or resolution. Pursuant to appropriate sections of the Government Code and in particular Section 38773.5 and Section 25845, the total costs of abatement including all administrative costs, shall constitute a special assessment against that parcel. After the assessment is made and confirmed, it shall be a lien on the property. (d) Cost Report After confirmation of the report, a certified copy shall be .filed with the Orange County Auditor on or before August 10 of each year and the auditor shall be requested to enter the amounts of the respective assessments on the county tax roll. (e) Special Assessment Such special assessment shall be collected at the same time and in the same manner as ordinary municipal taxes are collected and shall be subject to the same penalties and the same procedures and sale in case of delinquency as provided for ordinary municipal taxes. (f) Refunds The City Council may order refunded all or part of an assessment paid pursuant to this chapter if it finds that all or part of the assessment has been erroneously levied. An assessment or any part thereof shall not be refunded unless a claim is filed with the City Clerk on or before December 1st after the assessment becomes due and payable. The claim shall be verified by the person ] Ordinance No. 1080 2 Page 15 4 who paid the assessment, or his guardian, executor, or administrator. 5509 GENERAL PENALTY AND CONTINUING VIOLATIONS 6 (a) Any person violating or failing to comply with any 7 provision or mandatory requirement of this code shall be guilty of a misdemeanor unless charged as an infraction 8 by the enforcement officer. 9 (b) Each person guilty of a misdemeanor or infraction shall be guilty of a separate offense for each and every day ]0 during any portion of which any violation or any provision of this code is committed, continued or ~] permitted by such person and shall be punished accordingly. (c) Any person who removes any notice or order posted as ]3 required in this chapter, for the purpose of interfering with the enforcement of the provisions of this chapter, ]4 is guilty of a misdemeanor unless charged as an infraction by the enforcement officer. (d) Any person who obstructs, impedes or interferes with any ]6 representative of a City department or with any person who owns or holds an estate or interest in a building ]7 which has been ordered to be vacated, repaired, rehabilitated,'or demolished or with any person to whom ~8 any such building has been lawfully sold pursuant to the provisions of this chapter when any of the aforementioned ~9 individuals are lawfully engaged in proceedings involving the abatement of a nuisance iS guilty of a misdemeanor 20 unless charged as an infraction by the enforcement officer. (e) The penalties and procedures provided in this chapter 22 shall be cumulative and in addition to any other procedure or procedures provided in this Code or by state 23 law for the abatement of any of the conditions described herein, and abatement hereunder shall not prejudice or 24 affect any other action, civil or criminal, for the maintenance of any such condition. 5510 SEVERABILITY It is declared to be the intention of the City Council 27 that the sections, paragraphs, sentences, clauses and phrases of this chapter form interrelated regulations for dealing with 28 the problem of property maintenance and public nuisances Ordinance No. 1080 Page 16 within the city, but that such sections, paragraphs, sentences, clauses and phrases are distinct. and severable and, in the event that any sections, paragraphs, clauses and phrases are declared unconstitutional, invalid or unenforceable by any court of competent jurisdiction, such unconstitutionality, invalidity or unenforceability shall not affect any of the remaining sections, paragraphs, clauses or phrases of this chapter. meeting of the stin City PASSED and ADOPTED at a regular ~e~lh.~/ Council held on the 18th day of November 1991. CHARLES E. PUCKETT Mayor STATE OF CALIFORNIA ) COUNTY OF ORANGE ) ss. CITY OF TUSTIN CERTIFICATION FOR ORDINANCE NO. 1080 MARY E. WYNN, City Clerk and ex-officio Clerk of the City Council of the City of Tustin, California, does hereby certify that the whole number of the members of the City Council of the City of Tustin is 5; that the above and foregoing Ordinance No. 1080 was duly and regularly introduced and read at a regular meeting 0f the City Council held on the 4th day of November, 1991, and was given its second reading, passed and adopted at a regular meeting of the City Council held on the 18th day Of November, 1991, by the following vote: COUNCILMEMBER AYES: Puckett, Pontious, Edgar, Potts, Prescott COUNCILMEMBER NOES: None COUNCILMEMBER ABSTAINED: None COUNCILMEMBER ABSENT: None OO:~\lOaO.ord